mindforge-cc 11.5.1 → 11.7.0

package/.agent/skills/oss-forensics/SKILL.md

@@ -0,0 +1,422 @@
+---
+name: oss-forensics
+description: |
+  Supply chain investigation, evidence recovery, and forensic analysis for GitHub repositories.
+  Covers deleted commit recovery, force-push detection, IOC extraction, multi-source evidence
+  collection, hypothesis formation/validation, and structured forensic reporting.
+  Inspired by RAPTOR's 1800+ line OSS Forensics system.
+category: security
+triggers:
+  - "investigate this repository"
+  - "investigate [owner/repo]"
+  - "check for supply chain compromise"
+  - "recover deleted commits"
+  - "forensic analysis of [owner/repo]"
+  - "was this repo compromised"
+  - "supply chain attack"
+  - "suspicious commit"
+  - "force push detected"
+  - "IOC extraction"
+toolsets:
+  - terminal
+  - web
+  - file
+  - delegation
+---
+
+# OSS Security Forensics Skill
+
+A 7-phase multi-agent investigation framework for researching open-source supply chain attacks.
+Adapted from RAPTOR's forensics system. Covers GitHub Archive, Wayback Machine, GitHub API,
+local git analysis, IOC extraction, evidence-backed hypothesis formation and validation,
+and final forensic report generation.
+
+---
+
+## ⚠️ Anti-Hallucination Guardrails
+
+Read these before every investigation step. Violating them invalidates the report.
+
+1. **Evidence-First Rule**: Every claim in any report, hypothesis, or summary MUST cite at least one evidence ID (`EV-XXXX`). Assertions without citations are forbidden.
+2. **STAY IN YOUR LANE**: Each sub-agent (investigator) has a single data source. Do NOT mix sources. The GH Archive investigator does not query the GitHub API, and vice versa. Role boundaries are hard.
+3. **Fact vs. Hypothesis Separation**: Mark all unverified inferences with `[HYPOTHESIS]`. Only statements verified against original sources may be stated as facts.
+4. **No Evidence Fabrication**: The hypothesis validator MUST mechanically check that every cited evidence ID actually exists in the evidence store before accepting a hypothesis.
+5. **Proof-Required Disproval**: A hypothesis cannot be dismissed without a specific, evidence-backed counter-argument. "No evidence found" is not sufficient to disprove—it only makes a hypothesis inconclusive.
+6. **SHA/URL Double-Verification**: Any commit SHA, URL, or external identifier cited as evidence must be independently confirmed from at least two sources before being marked as verified.
+7. **Suspicious Code Rule**: Never run code found inside the investigated repository locally. Analyze statically only, or use `execute_code` in a sandboxed environment.
+8. **Secret Redaction**: Any API keys, tokens, or credentials discovered during investigation must be redacted in the final report. Log them internally only.
+
+---
+
+## Example Scenarios
+
+- **Scenario A: Dependency Confusion**: A malicious package `internal-lib-v2` is uploaded to NPM with a higher version than the internal one. The investigator must track when this package was first seen and if any PushEvents in the target repo updated `package.json` to this version.
+- **Scenario B: Maintainer Takeover**: A long-term contributor's account is used to push a backdoored `.github/workflows/build.yml`. The investigator looks for PushEvents from this user after a long period of inactivity or from a new IP/location (if detectable via BigQuery).
+- **Scenario C: Force-Push Hide**: A developer accidentally commits a production secret, then force-pushes to "fix" it. The investigator uses `git fsck` and GH Archive to recover the original commit SHA and verify what was leaked.
+
+---
+
+> **Path convention**: Throughout this skill, `SKILL_DIR` refers to the root of this skill's
+> installation directory (the folder containing this `SKILL.md`). When the skill is loaded,
+> resolve `SKILL_DIR` to the actual path — e.g. `~/.agent/skills/security/oss-forensics/`
+> or the `optional-skills/` equivalent. All script and template references are relative to it.
+
+## Phase 0: Initialization
+
+1. Create investigation working directory:
+   ```bash
+   mkdir investigation_$(echo "REPO_NAME" | tr '/' '_')
+   cd investigation_$(echo "REPO_NAME" | tr '/' '_')
+   ```
+2. Initialize the evidence store:
+   ```bash
+   python3 SKILL_DIR/scripts/evidence-store.py --store evidence.json list
+   ```
+3. Copy the forensic report template:
+   ```bash
+   cp SKILL_DIR/templates/forensic-report.md ./investigation-report.md
+   ```
+4. Create an `iocs.md` file to track Indicators of Compromise as they are discovered.
+5. Record the investigation start time, target repository, and stated investigation goal.
+
+---
+
+## Phase 1: Prompt Parsing and IOC Extraction
+
+**Goal**: Extract all structured investigative targets from the user's request.
+
+**Actions**:
+- Parse the user prompt and extract:
+  - Target repository (`owner/repo`)
+  - Target actors (GitHub handles, email addresses)
+  - Time window of interest (commit date ranges, PR timestamps)
+  - Provided Indicators of Compromise: commit SHAs, file paths, package names, IP addresses, domains, API keys/tokens, malicious URLs
+  - Any linked vendor security reports or blog posts
+
+**Tools**: Reasoning only, or `execute_code` for regex extraction from large text blocks.
+
+**Output**: Populate `iocs.md` with extracted IOCs. Each IOC must have:
+- Type (from: COMMIT_SHA, FILE_PATH, API_KEY, SECRET, IP_ADDRESS, DOMAIN, PACKAGE_NAME, ACTOR_USERNAME, MALICIOUS_URL, OTHER)
+- Value
+- Source (user-provided, inferred)
+
+**Reference**: See [evidence-types.md](./references/evidence-types.md) for IOC taxonomy.
+
+---
+
+## Phase 2: Parallel Evidence Collection
+
+Spawn up to 5 specialist investigator sub-agents using `delegate_task` (batch mode, max 3 concurrent). Each investigator has a **single data source** and must not mix sources.
+
+> **Orchestrator note**: Pass the IOC list from Phase 1 and the investigation time window in the `context` field of each delegated task.
+
+---
+
+### Investigator 1: Local Git Investigator
+
+**ROLE BOUNDARY**: You query the LOCAL GIT REPOSITORY ONLY. Do not call any external APIs.
+
+**Actions**:
+```bash
+# Clone repository
+git clone https://github.com/OWNER/REPO.git target_repo && cd target_repo
+
+# Full commit log with stats
+git log --all --full-history --stat --format="%H|%ae|%an|%ai|%s" > ../git_log.txt
+
+# Detect force-push evidence (orphaned/dangling commits)
+git fsck --lost-found --unreachable 2>&1 | grep commit > ../dangling_commits.txt
+
+# Check reflog for rewritten history
+git reflog --all > ../reflog.txt
+
+# List ALL branches including deleted remote refs
+git branch -a -v > ../branches.txt
+
+# Find suspicious large binary additions
+git log --all --diff-filter=A --name-only --format="%H %ai" -- "*.so" "*.dll" "*.exe" "*.bin" > ../binary_additions.txt
+
+# Check for GPG signature anomalies
+git log --show-signature --format="%H %ai %aN" > ../signature_check.txt 2>&1
+```
+
+**Evidence to collect** (add via `python3 SKILL_DIR/scripts/evidence-store.py add`):
+- Each dangling commit SHA → type: `git`
+- Force-push evidence (reflog showing history rewrite) → type: `git`
+- Unsigned commits from verified contributors → type: `git`
+- Suspicious binary file additions → type: `git`
+
+**Reference**: See [recovery-techniques.md](./references/recovery-techniques.md) for accessing force-pushed commits.
+
+---
+
+### Investigator 2: GitHub API Investigator
+
+**ROLE BOUNDARY**: You query the GITHUB REST API ONLY. Do not run git commands locally.
+
+**Actions**:
+```bash
+# Commits (paginated)
+curl -s "https://api.github.com/repos/OWNER/REPO/commits?per_page=100" > api_commits.json
+
+# Pull Requests including closed/deleted
+curl -s "https://api.github.com/repos/OWNER/REPO/pulls?state=all&per_page=100" > api_prs.json
+
+# Issues
+curl -s "https://api.github.com/repos/OWNER/REPO/issues?state=all&per_page=100" > api_issues.json
+
+# Contributors and collaborator changes
+curl -s "https://api.github.com/repos/OWNER/REPO/contributors" > api_contributors.json
+
+# Repository events (last 300)
+curl -s "https://api.github.com/repos/OWNER/REPO/events?per_page=100" > api_events.json
+
+# Check specific suspicious commit SHA details
+curl -s "https://api.github.com/repos/OWNER/REPO/git/commits/SHA" > commit_detail.json
+
+# Releases
+curl -s "https://api.github.com/repos/OWNER/REPO/releases?per_page=100" > api_releases.json
+
+# Check if a specific commit exists (force-pushed commits may 404 on commits/ but succeed on git/commits/)
+curl -s "https://api.github.com/repos/OWNER/REPO/commits/SHA" | jq .sha
+```
+
+**Cross-reference targets** (flag discrepancies as evidence):
+- PR exists in archive but missing from API → evidence of deletion
+- Contributor in archive events but not in contributors list → evidence of permission revocation
+- Commit in archive PushEvents but not in API commit list → evidence of force-push/deletion
+
+**Reference**: See [evidence-types.md](./references/evidence-types.md) for GH event types.
+
+---
+
+### Investigator 3: Wayback Machine Investigator
+
+**ROLE BOUNDARY**: You query the WAYBACK MACHINE CDX API ONLY. Do not use the GitHub API.
+
+**Goal**: Recover deleted GitHub pages (READMEs, issues, PRs, releases, wiki pages).
+
+**Actions**:
+```bash
+# Search for archived snapshots of the repo main page
+curl -s "https://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=github.com/OWNER/REPO&output=json&limit=100&from=YYYYMMDD&to=YYYYMMDD" > wayback_main.json
+
+# Search for a specific deleted issue
+curl -s "https://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=github.com/OWNER/REPO/issues/NUM&output=json&limit=50" > wayback_issue_NUM.json
+
+# Search for a specific deleted PR
+curl -s "https://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=github.com/OWNER/REPO/pull/NUM&output=json&limit=50" > wayback_pr_NUM.json
+
+# Fetch the best snapshot of a page
+# Use the Wayback Machine URL: https://web.archive.org/web/TIMESTAMP/ORIGINAL_URL
+# Example: https://web.archive.org/web/20240101000000*/github.com/OWNER/REPO
+
+# Advanced: Search for deleted releases/tags
+curl -s "https://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=github.com/OWNER/REPO/releases/tag/*&output=json" > wayback_tags.json
+
+# Advanced: Search for historical wiki changes
+curl -s "https://web.archive.org/cdx/search/cdx?url=github.com/OWNER/REPO/wiki/*&output=json" > wayback_wiki.json
+```
+
+**Evidence to collect**:
+- Archived snapshots of deleted issues/PRs with their content
+- Historical README versions showing changes
+- Evidence of content present in archive but missing from current GitHub state
+
+**Reference**: See [github-archive-guide.md](./references/github-archive-guide.md) for CDX API parameters.
+
+---
+
+### Investigator 4: GH Archive / BigQuery Investigator
+
+**ROLE BOUNDARY**: You query GITHUB ARCHIVE via BIGQUERY ONLY. This is a tamper-proof record of all public GitHub events.
+
+> **Prerequisites**: Requires Google Cloud credentials with BigQuery access (`gcloud auth application-default login`). If unavailable, skip this investigator and note it in the report.
+
+**Cost Optimization Rules** (MANDATORY):
+1. ALWAYS run a `--dry_run` before every query to estimate cost.
+2. Use `_TABLE_SUFFIX` to filter by date range and minimize scanned data.
+3. Only SELECT the columns you need.
+4. Add a LIMIT unless aggregating.
+
+```bash
+# Template: safe BigQuery query for PushEvents to OWNER/REPO
+bq query --use_legacy_sql=false --dry_run "
+SELECT created_at, actor.login, payload.commits, payload.before, payload.head,
+       payload.size, payload.distinct_size
+FROM \`githubarchive.month.*\`
+WHERE _TABLE_SUFFIX BETWEEN 'YYYYMM' AND 'YYYYMM'
+  AND type = 'PushEvent'
+  AND repo.name = 'OWNER/REPO'
+LIMIT 1000
+"
+# If cost is acceptable, re-run without --dry_run
+
+# Detect force-pushes: zero-distinct_size PushEvents mean commits were force-erased
+# payload.distinct_size = 0 AND payload.size > 0 → force push indicator
+
+# Check for deleted branch events
+bq query --use_legacy_sql=false "
+SELECT created_at, actor.login, payload.ref, payload.ref_type
+FROM \`githubarchive.month.*\`
+WHERE _TABLE_SUFFIX BETWEEN 'YYYYMM' AND 'YYYYMM'
+  AND type = 'DeleteEvent'
+  AND repo.name = 'OWNER/REPO'
+LIMIT 200
+"
+```
+
+**Evidence to collect**:
+- Force-push events (payload.size > 0, payload.distinct_size = 0)
+- DeleteEvents for branches/tags
+- WorkflowRunEvents for suspicious CI/CD automation
+- PushEvents that precede a "gap" in the git log (evidence of rewrite)
+
+**Reference**: See [github-archive-guide.md](./references/github-archive-guide.md) for all 12 event types and query patterns.
+
+---
+
+### Investigator 5: IOC Enrichment Investigator
+
+**ROLE BOUNDARY**: You enrich EXISTING IOCs from Phase 1 using passive public sources ONLY. Do not execute any code from the target repository.
+
+**Actions**:
+- For each commit SHA: attempt recovery via direct GitHub URL (`github.com/OWNER/REPO/commit/SHA.patch`)
+- For each domain/IP: check passive DNS, WHOIS records (via `web_extract` on public WHOIS services)
+- For each package name: check npm/PyPI for matching malicious package reports
+- For each actor username: check GitHub profile, contribution history, account age
+- Recover force-pushed commits using 3 methods (see [recovery-techniques.md](./references/recovery-techniques.md))
+
+---
+
+## Phase 3: Evidence Consolidation
+
+After all investigators complete:
+
+1. Run `python3 SKILL_DIR/scripts/evidence-store.py --store evidence.json list` to see all collected evidence.
+2. For each piece of evidence, verify the `content_sha256` hash matches the original source.
+3. Group evidence by:
+   - **Timeline**: Sort all timestamped evidence chronologically
+   - **Actor**: Group by GitHub handle or email
+   - **IOC**: Link evidence to the IOC it relates to
+4. Identify **discrepancies**: items present in one source but absent in another (key deletion indicators).
+5. Flag evidence as `[VERIFIED]` (confirmed from 2+ independent sources) or `[UNVERIFIED]` (single source only).
+
+---
+
+## Phase 4: Hypothesis Formation
+
+A hypothesis must:
+- State a specific claim (e.g., "Actor X force-pushed to BRANCH on DATE to erase commit SHA")
+- Cite at least 2 evidence IDs that support it (`EV-XXXX`, `EV-YYYY`)
+- Identify what evidence would disprove it
+- Be labeled `[HYPOTHESIS]` until validated
+
+**Common hypothesis templates** (see [investigation-templates.md](./references/investigation-templates.md)):
+- Maintainer Compromise: legitimate account used post-takeover to inject malicious code
+- Dependency Confusion: package name squatting to intercept installs
+- CI/CD Injection: malicious workflow changes to run code during builds
+- Typosquatting: near-identical package name targeting misspellers
+- Credential Leak: token/key accidentally committed then force-pushed to erase
+
+For each hypothesis, spawn a `delegate_task` sub-agent to attempt to find disconfirming evidence before confirming.
+
+---
+
+## Phase 5: Hypothesis Validation
+
+The validator sub-agent MUST mechanically check:
+
+1. For each hypothesis, extract all cited evidence IDs.
+2. Verify each ID exists in `evidence.json` (hard failure if any ID is missing → hypothesis rejected as potentially fabricated).
+3. Verify each `[VERIFIED]` piece of evidence was confirmed from 2+ sources.
+4. Check logical consistency: does the timeline depicted by the evidence support the hypothesis?
+5. Check for alternative explanations: could the same evidence pattern arise from a benign cause?
+
+**Output**:
+- `VALIDATED`: All evidence cited, verified, logically consistent, no plausible alternative explanation.
+- `INCONCLUSIVE`: Evidence supports hypothesis but alternative explanations exist or evidence is insufficient.
+- `REJECTED`: Missing evidence IDs, unverified evidence cited as fact, logical inconsistency detected.
+
+Rejected hypotheses feed back into Phase 4 for refinement (max 3 iterations).
+
+---
+
+## Phase 6: Final Report Generation
+
+Populate `investigation-report.md` using the template in [forensic-report.md](./templates/forensic-report.md).
+
+**Mandatory sections**:
+- Executive Summary: one-paragraph verdict (Compromised / Clean / Inconclusive) with confidence level
+- Timeline: chronological reconstruction of all significant events with evidence citations
+- Validated Hypotheses: each with status and supporting evidence IDs
+- Evidence Registry: table of all `EV-XXXX` entries with source, type, and verification status
+- IOC List: all extracted and enriched Indicators of Compromise
+- Chain of Custody: how evidence was collected, from what sources, at what timestamps
+- Recommendations: immediate mitigations if compromise detected; monitoring recommendations
+
+**Report rules**:
+- Every factual claim must have at least one `[EV-XXXX]` citation
+- Executive Summary must state confidence level (High / Medium / Low)
+- All secrets/credentials must be redacted to `[REDACTED]`
+
+---
+
+## Phase 7: Completion
+
+1. Run final evidence count: `python3 SKILL_DIR/scripts/evidence-store.py --store evidence.json list`
+2. Archive the full investigation directory.
+3. If compromise is confirmed:
+   - List immediate mitigations (rotate credentials, pin dependency hashes, notify affected users)
+   - Identify affected versions/packages
+   - Note disclosure obligations (if a public package: coordinate with the package registry)
+4. Present the final `investigation-report.md` to the user.
+
+---
+
+## Ethical Use Guidelines
+
+This skill is designed for **defensive security investigation** — protecting open-source software from supply chain attacks. It must not be used for:
+
+- **Harassment or stalking** of contributors or maintainers
+- **Doxing** — correlating GitHub activity to real identities for malicious purposes
+- **Competitive intelligence** — investigating proprietary or internal repositories without authorization
+- **False accusations** — publishing investigation results without validated evidence (see anti-hallucination guardrails)
+
+Investigations should be conducted with the principle of **minimal intrusion**: collect only the evidence necessary to validate or refute the hypothesis. When publishing results, follow responsible disclosure practices and coordinate with affected maintainers before public disclosure.
+
+If the investigation reveals a genuine compromise, follow the coordinated vulnerability disclosure process:
+1. Notify the repository maintainers privately first
+2. Allow reasonable time for remediation (typically 90 days)
+3. Coordinate with package registries (npm, PyPI, etc.) if published packages are affected
+4. File a CVE if appropriate
+
+---
+
+## API Rate Limiting
+
+GitHub REST API enforces rate limits that will interrupt large investigations if not managed.
+
+**Authenticated requests**: 5,000/hour (requires `GITHUB_TOKEN` env var or `gh` CLI auth)
+**Unauthenticated requests**: 60/hour (unusable for investigations)
+
+**Best practices**:
+- Always authenticate: `export GITHUB_TOKEN=ghp_...` or use `gh` CLI (auto-authenticates)
+- Use conditional requests (`If-None-Match` / `If-Modified-Since` headers) to avoid consuming quota on unchanged data
+- For paginated endpoints, fetch all pages in sequence — don't parallelize against the same endpoint
+- Check `X-RateLimit-Remaining` header; if below 100, pause for `X-RateLimit-Reset` timestamp
+- BigQuery has its own quotas (10 TiB/day free tier) — always dry-run first
+- Wayback Machine CDX API: no formal rate limit, but be courteous (1-2 req/sec max)
+
+If rate-limited mid-investigation, record the partial results in the evidence store and note the limitation in the report.
+
+---
+
+## Reference Materials
+
+- [github-archive-guide.md](./references/github-archive-guide.md) — BigQuery queries, CDX API, 12 event types
+- [evidence-types.md](./references/evidence-types.md) — IOC taxonomy, evidence source types, observation types
+- [recovery-techniques.md](./references/recovery-techniques.md) — Recovering deleted commits, PRs, issues
+- [investigation-templates.md](./references/investigation-templates.md) — Pre-built hypothesis templates per attack type
+- [evidence-store.py](./scripts/evidence-store.py) — CLI tool for managing the evidence JSON store
+- [forensic-report.md](./templates/forensic-report.md) — Structured report template

package/.agent/skills/oss-forensics/references/evidence-types.md

@@ -0,0 +1,89 @@
+# Evidence Types Reference
+
+Taxonomy of all evidence types, IOC types, GitHub event types, and observation types
+used in OSS forensic investigations.
+
+---
+
+## Evidence Source Types
+
+| Type | Description | Example Sources |
+|------|-------------|-----------------|
+| `git` | Data from local git repository analysis | `git log`, `git fsck`, `git reflog`, `git blame` |
+| `gh_api` | Data from GitHub REST API responses | `/repos/.../commits`, `/repos/.../pulls`, `/repos/.../events` |
+| `gh_archive` | Data from GitHub Archive (BigQuery) | `githubarchive.month.*` BigQuery tables |
+| `web_archive` | Archived web pages from Wayback Machine | CDX API results, `web.archive.org/web/...` snapshots |
+| `ioc` | Indicator of Compromise from any source | Extracted from vendor reports, git history, network traces |
+| `analysis` | Derived insight from cross-source correlation | "SHA present in archive but absent from API" |
+| `vendor_report` | External security vendor or researcher report | CVE advisories, blog posts, NVD records |
+| `manual` | Manually recorded observation by investigator | Notes on behavioral patterns, timeline gaps |
+
+---
+
+## IOC Types
+
+| Type | Description | Example |
+|------|-------------|---------|
+| `COMMIT_SHA` | A git commit hash linked to malicious activity | `abc123def456...` |
+| `FILE_PATH` | A suspicious file inside the repository | `src/utils/crypto.js`, `dist/index.min.js` |
+| `API_KEY` | An API key accidentally committed | `AKIA...` (AWS), `ghp_...` (GitHub PAT) |
+| `SECRET` | A generic secret / credential | Database password, private key blob |
+| `IP_ADDRESS` | A C2 server or attacker IP | `192.0.2.1` |
+| `DOMAIN` | A malicious or suspicious domain | `evil-cdn.io`, typosquatted package registry domain |
+| `PACKAGE_NAME` | A malicious or squatted package name | `colo-rs` (typosquatting `color`), `lodash-utils` |
+| `ACTOR_USERNAME` | A GitHub handle linked to the attack | `malicious-bot-account` |
+| `MALICIOUS_URL` | A URL to a malicious resource | `https://evil.example.com/payload.sh` |
+| `WORKFLOW_FILE` | A suspicious CI/CD workflow file | `.github/workflows/release.yml` |
+| `BRANCH_NAME` | A suspicious branch | `refs/heads/temp-fix-do-not-merge` |
+| `TAG_NAME` | A suspicious git tag | `v1.0.0-security-patch` |
+| `RELEASE_NAME` | A suspicious release | Release with no associated tag or changelog |
+| `OTHER` | Catch-all for unclassified IOCs | — |
+
+---
+
+## GitHub Archive Event Types (12 Types)
+
+| Event Type | Forensic Relevance |
+|------------|-------------------|
+| `PushEvent` | Core: `payload.distinct_size=0` with `payload.size>0` → force push. `payload.before`/`payload.head` shows rewritten history. |
+| `PullRequestEvent` | Detects deleted PRs, rapid open→close patterns, PRs from new accounts |
+| `IssueEvent` | Detects deleted issues, coordinated labeling, rapid closure of vulnerability reports |
+| `IssueCommentEvent` | Deleted comments, rapid activity bursts |
+| `WatchEvent` | Star-farming campaigns (coordinated starring from new accounts) |
+| `ForkEvent` | Unusual fork patterns before malicious commit |
+| `CreateEvent` | Branch/tag creation: signals new release or code injection point |
+| `DeleteEvent` | Branch/tag deletion: critical — often used to hide traces |
+| `ReleaseEvent` | Unauthorized releases, release artifacts modified post-publish |
+| `MemberEvent` | Collaborator added/removed: maintainer compromise indicator |
+| `PublicEvent` | Repository made public (sometimes to drop malicious code briefly) |
+| `WorkflowRunEvent` | CI/CD pipeline executions: workflow injection, secret exfiltration |
+
+---
+
+## Evidence Verification States
+
+| State | Meaning |
+|-------|---------|
+| `unverified` | Collected from a single source, not cross-referenced |
+| `single_source` | The primary source has been confirmed directly (e.g., SHA resolves on GitHub), but no second source |
+| `multi_source_verified` | Confirmed from 2+ independent sources (e.g., GH Archive AND GitHub API both show the same event) |
+
+Only `multi_source_verified` evidence may be cited as fact in validated hypotheses.
+`unverified` and `single_source` evidence must be labeled `[UNVERIFIED]` or `[SINGLE-SOURCE]`.
+
+---
+
+## Observation Types (Patterned after RAPTOR)
+
+| Type | Description |
+|------|-------------|
+| `CommitObservation` | Specific commit SHA with metadata (author, date, files changed) |
+| `ForceWashObservation` | Evidence that commits were force-erased from a branch |
+| `DanglingCommitObservation` | SHA present in git object store but unreachable from any ref |
+| `IssueObservation` | A GitHub issue (current or archived) with title, body, timestamp |
+| `PRObservation` | A GitHub PR (current or archived) with diff summary, reviewers |
+| `IOC` | A single Indicator of Compromise with context |
+| `TimelineGap` | A period with unusual absence of expected activity |
+| `ActorAnomalyObservation` | Behavioral anomaly for a specific GitHub actor |
+| `WorkflowAnomalyObservation` | Suspicious CI/CD workflow change or unexpected run |
+| `CrossSourceDiscrepancy` | Item present in one source but absent in another (strong deletion indicator) |