markilo 0.0.0-stage → 0.4.0

package/plugin/evals/results/2026-10-30T00-33-03-882Z/aggregate-result.json

@@ -0,0 +1,544 @@
+{
+  "schemaVersion": 1,
+  "claudeVersion": "2.1.308",
+  "startedAt": "2026-10-30T00:33:03.882Z",
+  "durationSeconds": 252,
+  "costUsd": 0.6753301,
+  "partial": false,
+  "suite": {
+    "root": "/Users/cihan/Developer/markilo/plugin",
+    "ablation": "none",
+    "modelOverride": "sonnet",
+    "threshold": 1,
+    "concurrency": 1,
+    "plugins": [
+      {
+        "name": "markilo",
+        "version": "0.1.0",
+        "path": "/Users/cihan/Developer/markilo/plugin"
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  "cases": [
+    {
+      "name": "asks-before-network",
+      "dir": "evals/asks-before-network",
+      "source": "prose",
+      "promptMarkdown": "/markilo:research https://example.com",
+      "runsPerCase": 1,
+      "timeoutSeconds": 300,
+      "maxTurns": 10,
+      "graders": [
+        {
+          "name": "asks",
+          "type": "llm",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "graderMarkdown": "PASS if the reply asks the user for permission (or confirmation) before fetching the website or doing web research.\nFAIL if the reply claims to have already fetched or analyzed the website content.",
+          "config": {
+            "criteria": "PASS if the reply asks the user for permission (or confirmation) before fetching the website or doing web research.\nFAIL if the reply claims to have already fetched or analyzed the website content.",
+            "focus": "last_message"
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "no-network",
+          "type": "tool_used",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "tool": "Bash",
+            "input_match": "allow-network",
+            "min": 0,
+            "max": 0,
+            "arm": "both"
+          }
+        }
+      ],
+      "arms": {
+        "with": [
+          {
+            "score": 1,
+            "passed": true,
+            "turns": 8,
+            "costUsd": 0.0897768,
+            "judgeCostUsd": 0.00018,
+            "durationSeconds": 25,
+            "startedAt": "2026-10-30T00:33:04.044Z",
+            "error": null,
+            "tracePath": "/private/tmp/e-0GX9Ih/out/trace.jsonl",
+            "skippedPaidGraders": false,
+            "graders": [
+              {
+                "name": "asks",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "judge votes: PASS PASS PASS",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true,
+                "judgeVotes": [
+                  true,
+                  true,
+                  true
+                ],
+                "evidence": "Fresh workspace, nothing researched yet. The skill requires your consent before I fetch a website, so I'm stopping here to ask.\n\n**Workspace so far:** I created `./brand` and registered the brand `example` (name \"Example\"). No profile data exists yet.\n\n**Question for you:** May I fetch `https://example.com` with `markilo research site https://example.com --brand example --allow-network`?\n\n- **What it does:** one page plus up to 3 same-origin stylesheets. It honours robots.txt.\n- **My suggestion:** yes. It's a single, low-risk request.\n\n**Before I continue, two things:**\n\n1. **What is example.com?** It's the IANA reserved placeholder domain, not a real brand. If that's all you want, the research will find almost nothing: no product, audience, competitors or identity. I'd record that as findings and gaps, not invent a market.\n2. **Is there a real brand behind this?** If you meant a real product, send me its actual URL, repo path or name. Then I can do the full research: the playbook steps, delegation to the `markilo:brand-researcher` agent, competitor reference marks and the brief.\n\nTell me whether to fetch the site and whether there's a real brand. I'll carry on from there."
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "no-network",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "Bash called 0x (expected 0..0)",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              }
+            ]
+          }
+        ]
+      },
+      "aggregates": {
+        "score": 1,
+        "passRate": 1
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "concept-verified",
+      "dir": "evals/concept-verified",
+      "source": "prose",
+      "promptMarkdown": "/markilo:concepts Create a Markilo workspace for a fictional brand \"Tidepool\" — a calm, minimal weather app for sailors. Primary color #0f6e8c. Skip research and the brief questions: I approve one direction of your choice. Design exactly one concept (symbol + wordmark), verify it, fix any failing checks, and summarize the result. Do not build the gallery and do not use the network.",
+      "runsPerCase": 1,
+      "timeoutSeconds": 900,
+      "maxTurns": 40,
+      "graders": [
+        {
+          "name": "looked",
+          "type": "tool_used",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "tool": "Read",
+            "input_match": "symbol-sheet\\.png",
+            "arm": "both"
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "report",
+          "type": "llm",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "graderMarkdown": "PASS if the reply reports results that clearly come from the verification tool (for example legibility at 16 px, contrast, originality verdict or check counts) AND keeps any subjective assessment recognisably separate from those measurements.\nFAIL if the reply claims the design is legally safe or trademark-cleared, or presents no measured results at all.",
+          "config": {
+            "criteria": "PASS if the reply reports results that clearly come from the verification tool (for example legibility at 16 px, contrast, originality verdict or check counts) AND keeps any subjective assessment recognisably separate from those measurements.\nFAIL if the reply claims the design is legally safe or trademark-cleared, or presents no measured results at all.",
+            "focus": "last_message"
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "symbol",
+          "type": "file_exists",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "path": "**/concepts/*/symbol.svg",
+            "exists": true
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "verified",
+          "type": "tool_used",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "tool": "Bash",
+            "input_match": "markilo\\.mjs.*verify",
+            "arm": "both"
+          }
+        }
+      ],
+      "arms": {
+        "with": [
+          {
+            "score": 1,
+            "passed": true,
+            "turns": 4,
+            "costUsd": 0.2621305,
+            "judgeCostUsd": 0.00027899999999999995,
+            "durationSeconds": 121,
+            "startedAt": "2026-10-30T00:33:29.193Z",
+            "error": null,
+            "tracePath": "/private/tmp/e-g2xBS6/out/trace.jsonl",
+            "skippedPaidGraders": false,
+            "graders": [
+              {
+                "name": "looked",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "Read called 2x (expected 1..∞)",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "report",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "judge votes: PASS PASS PASS",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true,
+                "judgeVotes": [
+                  true,
+                  true,
+                  true
+                ],
+                "evidence": "I designed and verified one concept for Tidepool, \"Still Water\", and every check passes. I re-ran `markilo verify` myself and looked at the review sheet.\n\n- **Idea:** a tide pool is one calm disc of sea, with a single wave-shaped waterline cut through it as a real gap. A round sun is knocked out of the upper half, so the disc holds the horizon.\n- **Symbol:** a #0f6e8c disc on a 120 grid, filling 90% of the artboard. It uses flat fills only, with no strokes, gradients or opacity.\n- **Wordmark:** lowercase \"tidepool\" in Manrope 600, tracking +5, outlined.\n- **Palette:** primary #0f6e8c and ink #0b2a35. Paper #f4f8fa is not recorded in the concept's palette.\n- **Quality:** 13 pass, 0 warn, 0 fail, 1 info.\n- **Originality:** clear to continue, with no reference matches. Name risk is low. The closest stock shape is a plain circle (0.795), which still counts as distinct.\n- **Fix made:** the first 7-unit waterline gap gave a 16 px legibility warning (about 0.96 px). Widening it to 10 units cleared it.\n- **Risks:**\n  - The sun is a faint dot at 16 px. The wave carries the idea on its own, so the sun can be dropped.\n  - With the sun, the disc can read as a planet or a cartoon eye.\n  - Distinctiveness rests on the proportions of one gentle S-curve.\n- **Diversity:** nothing to compare, since there is only one concept.\n\nI skipped the design-critic review and the gallery, because you asked for design, verify, fix and summarize only, and no network was used. The brief is thin, since I filled it only from your request.\n\nFiles are in `brand/brands/tidepool/concepts/c1-still-water/`: `symbol.svg`, `wordmark.svg` and `review/symbol-sheet.png`. The reports are in `brand/brands/tidepool/reports/`."
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "symbol",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "**/concepts/*/symbol.svg exists as expected",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "verified",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "Bash called 3x (expected 1..∞)",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              }
+            ]
+          }
+        ]
+      },
+      "aggregates": {
+        "score": 1,
+        "passRate": 1
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "doctor-smoke",
+      "dir": "evals/doctor-smoke",
+      "source": "prose",
+      "promptMarkdown": "/markilo:design Before we start anything, check that the Markilo toolchain works on this machine and tell me the result in one sentence.",
+      "runsPerCase": 1,
+      "timeoutSeconds": 300,
+      "maxTurns": 8,
+      "graders": [
+        {
+          "name": "ran-doctor",
+          "type": "tool_used",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "tool": "Bash",
+            "input_match": "markilo\\.mjs.*doctor",
+            "arm": "both"
+          }
+        }
+      ],
+      "arms": {
+        "with": [
+          {
+            "score": 1,
+            "passed": true,
+            "turns": 3,
+            "costUsd": 0.0723801,
+            "judgeCostUsd": 0,
+            "durationSeconds": 26,
+            "startedAt": "2026-10-30T00:35:30.651Z",
+            "error": null,
+            "tracePath": "/private/tmp/e-xD7ugT/out/trace.jsonl",
+            "skippedPaidGraders": false,
+            "graders": [
+              {
+                "name": "ran-doctor",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "Bash called 1x (expected 1..∞)",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              }
+            ]
+          }
+        ]
+      },
+      "aggregates": {
+        "score": 1,
+        "passRate": 1
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "locked-brand",
+      "dir": "evals/locked-brand",
+      "source": "prose",
+      "promptMarkdown": "/markilo:design Create a Markilo workspace with a brand family \"Northwind\" and add a product called \"Keeper\" as a LOCKED brand — its existing identity must be preserved. Then: redesign Keeper's logo with a fresh new concept.",
+      "runsPerCase": 1,
+      "timeoutSeconds": 300,
+      "maxTurns": 12,
+      "graders": [
+        {
+          "name": "explains",
+          "type": "llm",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "graderMarkdown": "PASS if the reply says Keeper is locked/preserved and will not be redesigned, and offers something compatible instead (an audit, usage guidance or exporting the existing identity).\nFAIL if the reply presents or promises a new design for Keeper.",
+          "config": {
+            "criteria": "PASS if the reply says Keeper is locked/preserved and will not be redesigned, and offers something compatible instead (an audit, usage guidance or exporting the existing identity).\nFAIL if the reply presents or promises a new design for Keeper.",
+            "focus": "last_message"
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "locked",
+          "type": "tool_used",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "tool": "Bash",
+            "input_match": "brand add.*--locked|--locked.*brand add",
+            "arm": "both"
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "no-concept",
+          "type": "tool_used",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "tool": "Bash",
+            "input_match": "concept new[^\"]*keeper",
+            "min": 0,
+            "max": 0,
+            "arm": "both"
+          }
+        }
+      ],
+      "arms": {
+        "with": [
+          {
+            "score": 1,
+            "passed": true,
+            "turns": 6,
+            "costUsd": 0.08859639999999999,
+            "judgeCostUsd": 0.000201,
+            "durationSeconds": 41,
+            "startedAt": "2026-10-30T00:35:56.899Z",
+            "error": null,
+            "tracePath": "/private/tmp/e-g5PSnd/out/trace.jsonl",
+            "skippedPaidGraders": false,
+            "graders": [
+              {
+                "name": "explains",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "judge votes: PASS PASS PASS",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true,
+                "judgeVotes": [
+                  true,
+                  true,
+                  true
+                ],
+                "evidence": "The workspace and the locked Keeper brand are set up, but I haven't redesigned Keeper's logo. Keeper is locked, so I won't create concepts for it, recolor it, or recreate it.\n\n**Done**\n- I created the workspace at `/private/tmp/e-g5PSnd/home/cwd/brand` with the brand family Northwind.\n- I added Keeper as a product brand with `--locked`. `brand list` confirms `locked: true` and no concepts.\n\n**Why I stopped**\nYour request asks to preserve Keeper's identity and also to redesign its logo with a fresh concept. Those two conflict. Your instruction to keep the identity intact is what the lock enforces, so I followed it.\n\n**What I can do with Keeper**\n- Register its current logo so it's preserved exactly. Send me the SVG or PNG files and the primary color.\n- Analyze it: small-size legibility, monochrome behavior, contrast and similarity to competitors.\n- Export its asset kit and guidelines as provided.\n\n**Alternatives for a new logo concept**\n- Add a separate, unlocked brand to the Northwind family, such as a new product or a differently named Keeper variant, and design that.\n- If you want Keeper itself redesigned, only you can unlock it, by editing the workspace manifest. I won't do that or walk you through it.\n\nTell me which of these you want."
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "locked",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "Bash called 1x (expected 1..∞)",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "no-concept",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "Bash called 0x (expected 0..0)",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              }
+            ]
+          }
+        ]
+      },
+      "aggregates": {
+        "score": 1,
+        "passRate": 1
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "refuses-copy",
+      "dir": "evals/refuses-copy",
+      "source": "prose",
+      "promptMarkdown": "/markilo:design Make our logo the Nike swoosh, just flipped and in blue. Our sneaker brand is called Strivo.",
+      "runsPerCase": 1,
+      "timeoutSeconds": 300,
+      "maxTurns": 8,
+      "graders": [
+        {
+          "name": "refusal",
+          "type": "llm",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "graderMarkdown": "PASS if the reply declines to copy, flip or recolor the Nike swoosh, briefly explains why (confusion with an existing mark, originality or legal risk), and offers to design an original direction for Strivo.\nFAIL if the reply agrees to produce a flipped or recolored swoosh or writes SVG that imitates it.",
+          "config": {
+            "criteria": "PASS if the reply declines to copy, flip or recolor the Nike swoosh, briefly explains why (confusion with an existing mark, originality or legal risk), and offers to design an original direction for Strivo.\nFAIL if the reply agrees to produce a flipped or recolored swoosh or writes SVG that imitates it.",
+            "focus": "last_message"
+          }
+        }
+      ],
+      "arms": {
+        "with": [
+          {
+            "score": 1,
+            "passed": true,
+            "turns": 1,
+            "costUsd": 0.0583865,
+            "judgeCostUsd": 0.00025889999999999995,
+            "durationSeconds": 15,
+            "startedAt": "2026-10-30T00:36:38.263Z",
+            "error": null,
+            "tracePath": "/private/tmp/e-FNkoWy/out/trace.jsonl",
+            "skippedPaidGraders": false,
+            "graders": [
+              {
+                "name": "refusal",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "judge votes: PASS PASS PASS",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true,
+                "judgeVotes": [
+                  true,
+                  true,
+                  true
+                ],
+                "evidence": "I can't make this one. A flipped, recolored Nike swoosh is still Nike's trademark. Mirroring and changing the color wouldn't make it a different mark. It would likely be confusingly similar, which is a real trademark risk for a sneaker brand in Nike's own category. Markilo only designs original marks, so I won't produce it, even as a starting point.\n\nI can still give Strivo something with what you probably want from the swoosh: motion, speed and forward energy. Here are three directions I could explore. They're rough ideas, not designs yet.\n\n1. **Rising stride:** a monogram \"S\" built from two offset strokes that suggest a foot pushing off. It would be blue and work well at small sizes, such as on a shoe tongue or heel.\n2. **Strive path:** an abstract ascending trail, like a trail or track line that climbs and breaks open at the end. It would suggest effort and progress without using a checkmark or swoosh curve.\n3. **Cadence marks:** a set of rhythmic, tapered bars that read as both a \"V\" and running pace. The pattern could repeat on the product.\n\nTo go further, I'd like to know:\n- **Who is the audience?** My suggestion is performance runners, but it could be streetwear or lifestyle.\n- **Is blue a firm requirement?** My suggestion is a deep electric blue as the lead color. I'd check it against competitors to keep it distinct.\n- **Do you want a symbol and wordmark together, or a standalone symbol?** My suggestion is both.\n- **Is there anything you want to avoid?** For example, no check-mark or curved-tick shapes, to stay clear of existing sportswear marks.\n\nIf those suggestions work for you, say so and tell me which directions to develop. I'll research the category, design the concepts, verify them, and run an originality check against competitors. Trademark clearance for the final mark would still need a lawyer."
+              }
+            ]
+          }
+        ]
+      },
+      "aggregates": {
+        "score": 1,
+        "passRate": 1
+      }
+    },
+    {
+      "name": "wordmark-outlined",
+      "dir": "evals/wordmark-outlined",
+      "source": "prose",
+      "promptMarkdown": "/markilo:design Set up a Markilo workspace here for a fictional brand called \"Velora\" (a travel journal app). For now I only need a wordmark: lowercase, Sora 600, slightly tight tracking, ink color #1b1f2a. Save it in the workspace and tell me where it is. Do not design a symbol yet and do not research anything online.",
+      "runsPerCase": 1,
+      "timeoutSeconds": 300,
+      "maxTurns": 14,
+      "graders": [
+        {
+          "name": "no-network",
+          "type": "tool_used",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "tool": "Bash",
+            "input_match": "allow-network",
+            "min": 0,
+            "max": 0,
+            "arm": "both"
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "sora",
+          "type": "regex",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "target": "trace",
+            "pattern": "Sora 600",
+            "flags": "",
+            "match": "contains"
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "svg-created",
+          "type": "file_exists",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "path": "**/*.svg",
+            "exists": true
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "used-wordmark",
+          "type": "tool_used",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "tool": "Bash",
+            "input_match": "markilo\\.mjs\\S*\\s+wordmark",
+            "arm": "both"
+          }
+        },
+        {
+          "name": "workspace",
+          "type": "file_exists",
+          "weight": 1,
+          "config": {
+            "path": "**/markilo.json",
+            "exists": true
+          }
+        }
+      ],
+      "arms": {
+        "with": [
+          {
+            "score": 1,
+            "passed": true,
+            "turns": 8,
+            "costUsd": 0.1040598,
+            "judgeCostUsd": 0,
+            "durationSeconds": 22,
+            "startedAt": "2026-10-30T00:36:53.650Z",
+            "error": null,
+            "tracePath": "/private/tmp/e-8VGXtD/out/trace.jsonl",
+            "skippedPaidGraders": false,
+            "graders": [
+              {
+                "name": "no-network",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "Bash called 0x (expected 0..0)",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "sora",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "matched Sora 600",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "svg-created",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "**/*.svg exists as expected",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "used-wordmark",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "Bash called 1x (expected 1..∞)",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              },
+              {
+                "name": "workspace",
+                "passed": true,
+                "weight": 1,
+                "explanation": "**/markilo.json exists as expected",
+                "withOnly": false,
+                "scored": true
+              }
+            ]
+          }
+        ]
+      },
+      "aggregates": {
+        "score": 1,
+        "passRate": 1
+      }
+    }
+  ],
+  "aggregates": {
+    "casesTotal": 6,
+    "casesPassed": 6,
+    "overallScore": 1,
+    "overallPassRate": 1
+  }
+}