maestro-flow 0.5.3 → 0.5.31

package/.agents/skills/odyssey-review-test-fix/SKILL.md

@@ -14,416 +14,403 @@ allowed-tools:
 ---
 <!-- Open-standard mirror generated by scripts/build-agents-standard.mjs — do not edit; re-run after editing .claude/ source. -->
 
-<purpose>
-Deep code review with exhaustive fix and generalization: archaeology → explore → multi-dimensional
-review → fix ALL findings → confirm → generalize (举一反三) → discover → persist.
-
-Unlike `quality-review` (pipeline gate verdict), this goes deeper: exhaustive documentation,
-automated fix, codebase-wide generalization, decision journal. Use `--skip-fix` for review-only.
-
-**三句哲学约束（穷尽迭代）:**
-1. **零遗留** — 每个 finding 必须是 action item（修复 / issue / 决策），不允许只报告不处理
-2. **穷尽迭代** — 按 severity 从高到低逐轮修复，直到 0 remaining actionable findings 才退出 fix loop
-3. **改进即标准** — 每次修复后重审同区域，发现新问题继续修，直到该区域无可改善
-
-Core behaviors:
-- **Find one, fix one, find all** — every finding triggers fix + codebase-wide scan
-- **Record everything** — ambiguous items → decision journal, never silent skip
-- **CLI-assisted** — delegate for multi-angle analysis and verification
-</purpose>
-
-<boundary>
-**范围内:** 目标代码的多维度深度审查 → 穷尽修复 ALL 发现（按 severity 递降）→ 泛化 pattern 到全项目
-**范围外:** 深度根因调查（根因不明时）→ `/odyssey-debug` | 需求实现 → `/odyssey-planex` | UI 视觉优化 → `/odyssey-ui`
-**探索自由度:** 边界内自由探索 — 可跨维度关联发现、追溯 git 历史、泛化扫描全项目。修复仅限 critical/high findings。
-</boundary>
-
-<execution_discipline>
-**三条铁律（所有阶段适用）:**
-
-1. **Phase auto-commit** — 每个阶段完成后**自动** `git commit`，无需用户确认
-   - 代码变更 + understanding.md → `git add` → `git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): {phase} — {摘要}"`
-   - session.json / evidence.ndjson 为运行时状态，不纳入 commit
-
-2. **有把握才改** — 仅修改自己有把握的内容；不确定的记录决策等人判断
-   - 有把握 → 直接修改代码，commit
-   - 需要决策 → 记录 `evidence.ndjson {"phase":"decision","status":"pending"}` 不改代码
-   - 禁止猜测性修改
-
-3. **多 CLI 辅助** — 利用 `maestro delegate` 调用多个 CLI 工具交叉验证
-   - 关键判断用不同 `--role`（analyze / review / explore）获取多视角
-   - 修复前后各做一次 CLI review 确认
-</execution_discipline>
-
-<context>
-$ARGUMENTS — target and optional flags.
-
-**Target resolution:**
-| Input | Resolution |
-|-------|-----------|
-| File/dir path | Review those files |
-| `HEAD` / `staged` | `git diff HEAD` / `git diff --staged` |
-| Phase number | Resolve via state.json → changed files |
-| PR number | `git diff main...HEAD` |
-
-**Flags:**
-| Flag | Effect | Default |
-|------|--------|---------|
-| `--dimensions <list>` | Comma-separated subset | correctness,security,performance,architecture |
-| `--fix-threshold <severity>` | 修复到哪个 severity 为止（all = 全部修复）| `all` |
-| `--skip-fix` | Review-only — skip S_FIX and S_CONFIRM | false |
-| `--skip-generalize` | Skip S_GENERALIZE and S_DISCOVER | false |
-| `--auto` | CLI delegates without confirmation | false |
-| `-y` | Auto-confirm at decision points (see appendix) | false |
-| `-c` | Resume most recent session | — |
-
-**Session**: `SESSION_DIR = .workflow/scratch/{YYYYMMDD}-review-odyssey-{slug}/`
-
-**Output — 4 files:**
-```
-SESSION_DIR/
-  ├── session.json       # state + review_result + confirmation + patterns + phase_goals
-  ├── evidence.ndjson    # ALL evidence (phase: archaeology|explore|review|fix|discovery|decision)
-  ├── explore.json       # CLI exploration snapshot
-  └── understanding.md   # 8-section evolving narrative (§1-§8, one per major phase)
-```
-
-**session.json schema:**
-```json
-{
-  "session_id": "review-odyssey-{YYYYMMDD-HHmmss}",
-  "target": "", "dimensions": [],
-  "flags": { "skip_fix": false, "skip_generalize": false, "fix_threshold": "all", "auto": false, "auto_confirm": false },
-  "current_state": "S_INTAKE",
-  "review_result": { "dimensions_reviewed": [], "finding_count": 0, "severity_distribution": { "critical": 0, "high": 0, "medium": 0, "low": 0 }, "remaining_actionable": 0 },
-  "patterns": [{ "id": "P1", "source_finding": "F1", "layer": "syntax|semantic|structural", "signature": "", "description": "", "risk": "", "fix_template": "", "confidence": "high|medium|low" }],
-  "confirmation": { "test_result": {}, "cli_review": {}, "overall": "confirmed|needs_rework" },
-  "generalization_stats": { "patterns_extracted": 0, "total_hits": 0, "true_positives": 0, "false_positives": 0, "uncertain": 0, "cross_layer_confirmed": 0, "regression_risks": 0, "by_layer": {}, "deepening_triggered": false, "self_iteration_rounds": 0 },
-  "phase_goals": [], "phase_goals_all_done": false,
-  "self_iteration_log": [],
-  "cross_phase_loops": 0, "max_loops": 3,
-  "created_at": "", "updated_at": ""
-}
-```
-
-**evidence.ndjson unified schema:** `{"ts":"","phase":"<phase>","type":"<type>","dimension":"","title":"","severity":"","file":"","line":0,"description":"","suggestion":"","files_modified":[]}`
-
-**phase_goals[]:**
-| ID | Goal | Done When | Phase | skip_when |
-|----|------|-----------|-------|-----------|
-| G1 | Review completed | all dimensions reviewed, findings logged | S_REVIEW | — |
-| G2 | Explore context gathered | explore.json populated | S_EXPLORE | — |
-| G3 | Zero remaining: all findings fixed | `remaining_actionable == 0` within fix_threshold | S_CONFIRM | skip_fix |
-| G4 | Pattern generalized | patterns[] ≥1 entry | S_GENERALIZE | skip_generalize |
-| G5 | Discoveries triaged | all scan hits classified | S_DISCOVER | skip_generalize |
-| G6 | Learnings persisted | spec entries created OR no actionable | S_RECORD | — |
-
-Lifecycle: `pending → done | skipped | failed` (all set `completion_confirmed`)
-
-### Pre-load（可选，缺失不阻塞）
-
-| 层级 | 命令 | 作用 |
-|------|------|------|
-| Codebase docs | Read `.workflow/codebase/ARCHITECTURE.md` | 模块边界，架构约束 |
-| Wiki search | `maestro search "<target keywords>" --json` | 先前 review、已知问题（取 top 5） |
-| Specs | `maestro spec load --category review` | review 标准、checklist、knowhow 工具 |
-| Role knowledge | `maestro search --category review` → 选相关 → `maestro wiki load <id>` | 累积 review 领域知识 |
-| Prior sessions | `find_files(".workflow/scratch/*-review-odyssey-*")` | 相关 odyssey 会话 |
-
-### Knowledge Persistence（S_RECORD 中写入产出文件）
-
-S_RECORD 阶段将可沉淀知识 **写入 understanding.md §8 Learnings**，按以下分类结构化：
-
-| 分类 | 写入内容 | 后续建议命令 |
-|------|---------|-------------|
-| 跨维度反复 pattern | 模式描述 + 出现维度 + 建议规范 | `/spec-add review "..."` |
-| 安全发现 | 漏洞类型 + 触发条件 + 修复方案 | `/spec-add debug "..."` |
-| 架构违反 pattern | 违反描述 + 正确边界 + 检查方法 | `/spec-add arch "..."` |
-| 可复用泛化 pattern | pattern 签名 + 风险说明 + fix 模板 | `/spec-add coding "..."` |
-
-**两步模式：** 执行中写入产出文件（临时记录）→ 任务完成后用户通过 next_step_routing 沉淀为永久知识。执行过程中不调用外部 Skill。
-</context>
-
-<self_iteration>
-**Quality Gate** — auto-evaluate after each analytical phase. Insufficient → re-enter (max 2 rounds).
-
-| Dimension | Sufficient | Insufficient |
-|-----------|-----------|-------------|
-| Coverage | All known related files analyzed | Missed targets discoverable via grep/git log |
-| Depth | ≥80% findings have file:line evidence | Most findings lack specifics |
-| Actionability | Each conclusion has concrete next action | "Consider reviewing" without action |
-
-**Expansion:** Round 1 = widen scope (more dirs, deeper git log, extra delegate angles). Round 2 = shift perspective (different CLI tool, reverse trace, manual reading).
-
-**Log:** `evidence.ndjson ← {"phase":"self-iteration","type":"quality-gate","stage":"S_XXX","round":N,"assessment":{},"expansion":""}`
-
-**Applicable stages:** S_ARCHAEOLOGY, S_EXPLORE, S_REVIEW, S_FIX, S_GENERALIZE
-</self_iteration>
-
-<state_machine>
-
-<states>
-S_INTAKE       — Parse target, load context, resume session            PERSIST: session.json + understanding.md §1
-S_ARCHAEOLOGY  — Git history of target files                           PERSIST: evidence.ndjson (archaeology) + understanding.md §2
-S_EXPLORE      — CLI-assisted structure/call-chain exploration         PERSIST: explore.json + evidence.ndjson (explore) + understanding.md §3
-S_REVIEW       — Parallel multi-dimension review (4 Agents)            PERSIST: evidence.ndjson (review) + understanding.md §4
-S_FIX          — Targeted fix for critical/high (skip if --skip-fix)   PERSIST: code changes + evidence.ndjson (fix)
-S_CONFIRM      — Test + CLI review confirmation (skip if --skip-fix)   PERSIST: session.json.confirmation + understanding.md §5
-S_GENERALIZE   — Pattern extraction + 4-agent scan (skip if --skip-generalize) PERSIST: session.json.patterns + understanding.md §6
-S_DISCOVER     — Classify hits, create issues (skip if --skip-generalize)      PERSIST: evidence.ndjson (discovery|decision) + understanding.md §7
-S_RECORD       — Knowledge persistence + final report                  PERSIST: understanding.md §8 + spec entries
-</states>
-
-<transitions>
-S_INTAKE:
-  → S_INTAKE        WHEN -c + session found        DO A_RESUME
-  → S_ARCHAEOLOGY   WHEN target resolved            DO A_INTAKE
-  → S_INTAKE        WHEN no target                  DO ask_user
-
-S_ARCHAEOLOGY  → S_EXPLORE      DO A_ARCHAEOLOGY
-S_EXPLORE      → S_REVIEW       DO A_EXPLORE
-
-S_REVIEW:
-  → S_FIX           WHEN !skip_fix AND any findings within fix_threshold   DO A_REVIEW
-  → S_GENERALIZE    WHEN (skip_fix OR no findings) AND !skip_gen           DO A_REVIEW
-  → S_RECORD        WHEN (skip_fix OR no findings) AND skip_gen            DO A_REVIEW
-
-S_FIX          → S_CONFIRM      DO A_FIX
-
-S_CONFIRM:
-  → S_GENERALIZE    WHEN confirmed AND !skip_gen    DO A_CONFIRM
-  → S_RECORD        WHEN confirmed AND skip_gen     DO A_CONFIRM
-  → S_FIX           WHEN needs_rework               DO A_CONFIRM
-
-S_GENERALIZE:
-  → S_DISCOVER      WHEN hits found                 DO A_GENERALIZE
-  → S_RECORD        WHEN no hits                    DO A_GENERALIZE
-
-S_DISCOVER → S_FIX          : discovery finds fixable sibling, !skip_fix, loops < max_loops → cross_phase_loops++
-S_DISCOVER → S_REVIEW       : discovery opens new review target, loops < max_loops → cross_phase_loops++
-S_DISCOVER → S_RECORD       : triage complete OR loops >= max_loops (剩余项 → issue/decision)
-
-S_RECORD   → END            DO A_RECORD
-</transitions>
-
-<actions>
-
-### A_INTAKE
-Parse target + flags → file list. Create `SESSION_DIR`, derive `phase_goals[]` from flags.
-Search prior knowledge: `maestro search`, prior sessions, ARCHITECTURE.md.
-Write `session.json` + `understanding.md` §1. Display Goal Prompt (appendix).
-
-📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): INTAKE — 目标解析与上下文加载"`
-
-### A_ARCHAEOLOGY
-`git log --oneline -20 -- {target_files}` + `git blame` on key regions.
-CLI delegate `--role analyze --mode analysis` to review past changes.
-Append evidence.ndjson (phase: "archaeology"). Update `understanding.md` §2.
-
-📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): ARCHAEOLOGY — git 考古分析"`
-
-### A_EXPLORE
-CLI delegate `--role explore --mode analysis` — call chains, error gaps, similar patterns.
-Write `explore.json`, append evidence.ndjson (phase: "explore").
-Update `understanding.md` §3. Mark G2 done.
-
-📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): EXPLORE — 代码探索完成"`
-
-### A_REVIEW
-Spawn N parallel Agents (one per dimension, default 4):
-
-| Agent | Dimension | Focus |
-|-------|-----------|-------|
-| Correctness | correctness | Logic errors, boundary conditions, null/undefined, race conditions |
-| Security | security | Injection, XSS, CSRF, data exposure, auth bypass |
-| Performance | performance | Hot paths, N+1, memory leaks, unnecessary recomputation |
-| Architecture | architecture | Layer violations, circular deps, interface contracts, SoC |
-
-Each returns `[{title, severity, file, line, description, suggestion, cwe}]`.
-Merge → evidence.ndjson (phase: "review"). Write `session.json.review_result`.
-Update `understanding.md` §4 (findings by dimension + severity matrix). Mark G1 done.
-
-📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): REVIEW — 多维度审查完成"`
-
-### A_FIX
-
-**穷尽迭代修复** — 按 severity 递降逐轮修复，直到 `remaining_actionable == 0`。
-
-#### Fix Loop (severity tiers)
-
-```
-fix_tiers = [critical, high, medium, low].filter(s => severity_order(s) >= severity_order(fix_threshold))
-for tier in fix_tiers:
-  candidates = evidence.filter(phase=="review" AND severity==tier AND status!="fixed")
-  if candidates.empty: continue
-  for each candidate:
-    read context (file:line ±20) → implement fix → append evidence (phase: "fix")
-  run local re-review on modified area ("改进即标准"):
-    new_findings in same region? → append to current tier, continue loop
-  tier complete → auto-commit
-```
-
-**Re-review gate** ("改进即标准"): 每轮修复后，对修改区域执行轻量 re-review（同维度）。若发现新问题，追加到当前轮继续修复。单轮最多 re-review 2 次，防止无限循环。
-
-**Normal**: ask_user 确认每个 tier 的 candidates。**`-y`**: auto-fix all, record `deferred`.
-
-**Remaining check**: 所有 tiers 完成后，count unfixed findings within fix_threshold → 写入 `review_result.remaining_actionable`。若 > 0 且未超 max_loops → 回到 tier 1 重试。
-
-📌 **Auto-commit per tier**: `git add -A && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): FIX-{tier} — {N}项修复"`
-
-### A_CONFIRM
-Run tests covering modified files. CLI delegate fix review:
-```
-maestro delegate "PURPOSE: Verify ALL fixes and confirm zero remaining improvements
-TASK: Verify fix correctness | Check regressions | Count remaining unfixed findings | Confirm zero-residual
-MODE: analysis
-CONTEXT: @{modified_files} | Findings: {all_findings_summary} | Diff: {git_diff}
-EXPECTED: JSON {verdict, findings_addressed, remaining_unfixed, regression_risk, new_findings_in_modified_area}
-CONSTRAINTS: Focus on correctness AND completeness — flag ANY remaining actionable improvement
-" --role review --mode analysis
-```
-Run_in_background, STOP, wait.
-
-**Zero-residual gate:**
-- `remaining_unfixed == 0 AND new_findings == 0` → `confirmed`, mark G3 done
-- `remaining_unfixed > 0 OR new_findings > 0` → `needs_rework` → S_FIX（追加新发现）
-- Regression detected → `needs_rework` → S_FIX
-
-Write `session.json.confirmation` + update `review_result.remaining_actionable`.
-Update `understanding.md` §5.
-
-📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): CONFIRM — 零遗留验证"`
-
-### A_GENERALIZE
-**Multi-layer pattern extraction** from findings (severity >= medium):
-
-| Layer | Method | Example |
-|-------|--------|---------|
-| Syntax | Regex → direct Grep | `eval(`, `innerHTML =` |
-| Semantic | Agent understands anti-pattern → scans | Missing error handling on async |
-| Structural | File/module structure similarity | Same base class missing override |
-
-Write `session.json.patterns[]`.
-
-**4-agent parallel scan** (single message):
-1. **Syntax grep** — Grep syntax-layer signatures across project
-2. **Semantic scan** — Check related modules for same anti-patterns
-3. **Structural match** — Find structurally similar files, check for same issues
-4. **Historical grep** — `git log -S "{pattern}"` for introduction/fix history
-
-**Cross-layer dedup**: Multi-layer hit → boost confidence. Single-layer → `needs_review`. Historical match on fixed code → `regression_risk`.
-
-**Iterative deepening** (conditional): High-density cluster (≥3 hits in same module) → targeted deep scan on that module. Max 1 round.
-
-**CLI validation** (optional): Delegate to validate true/false positives.
-
-Update `understanding.md` §6 (per-pattern summary, cross-layer matrix, risk heatmap).
-Write `session.json.generalization_stats`. Mark G4 done.
-
-📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): GENERALIZE — 泛化扫描完成"`
-
-### A_DISCOVER
-Classify each hit: `bug` / `risk` / `safe`.
-**Normal**: ask_user for bug routing. **`-y`**: auto create issue, `deferred`.
-Append evidence (phase: discovery + decision). Update `understanding.md` §7. Mark G5 done.
-
-📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): DISCOVER — 发现分类完成"`
-
-### A_RECORD
-Finalize `understanding.md` §8: per-dimension summary, top findings with file:line, generalization results, open decisions.
-Write learnings to understanding.md §8: 按 Knowledge Persistence 表分类记录（临时），completion summary 列出建议的 `/spec-add` 命令。
-Pending decisions: **Normal** → ask_user. **`-y`** → skip, display deferred count.
-Goal audit: check all `phase_goals[*].completion_confirmed`. Mark G6 done.
-
-Completion summary:
-```
---- REVIEW-TEST-FIX ODYSSEY COMPLETE ---
-Target:     {target}
-Dimensions: {dimensions_reviewed}
-Findings:   {C}C {H}H {M}M {L}L
-Fix:        {fixed} applied, confirmed={confirmed|skipped}
-Patterns:   {extracted} ({by_layer} distribution)
-Scan hits:  {total} ({cross_layer} cross-layer confirmed)
-Issues:     {N} created
-Decisions:  {N} resolved, {M} pending, {K} deferred
-Learnings:  {N} spec entries
-Self-iter:  {N} rounds across {M} stages
-Goals:      {done}/{total} ({skipped} skipped)
----
-```
-
-📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): RECORD — 会话总结与知识沉淀"`
-
-</actions>
-
-<appendix>
-
-### Goal Prompt Template
-**⚠️ 时机守卫：仅在 A_INTAKE 完成后显示一次（session 创建后、开始考古前）。A_RECORD 完成时禁止重新显示。**
-
-```
-📋 Review-Test-Fix Odyssey 会话已创建。可随时复制以下 /goal 设定终止条件（执行过程中输入即可）：
-
-/goal 穷尽迭代：直到 session.json 的 review_result.remaining_actionable == 0
-且 confirmation.verdict == "confirmed" 且 phase_goals_all_done == true 才停。
-修复按 severity 逐轮迭代（critical→high→medium→low），每轮修复后 re-review 修改区域。
-发现新问题追加到当前轮继续。遇到 phase=decision 的 pending 必须 ask_user。
-不允许"只报告不处理"，每个 finding 必须有 action（fix/issue/decision）。
-```
-
-完成时仅输出 completion summary，不重复此提示。
-
-### `-y` Auto-Confirm (6 decision points)
-| Decision Point | Normal | `-y` |
-|----------------|--------|------|
-| S_FIX tier candidates | ask_user per tier | auto-fix ALL tiers, `deferred` |
-| S_FIX re-review new findings | ask_user | auto-append and fix |
-| S_CONFIRM needs_rework | Display, proceed to S_FIX | auto proceed |
-| S_DISCOVER bug routing | ask_user | auto create issue, `deferred` |
-| S_DISCOVER ambiguous | ask_user | all `deferred` |
-| S_RECORD pending decisions | ask_user | skip |
-| S_RECORD goal audit | ask_user | auto accept |
-
-</appendix>
-
-</state_machine>
-
-<error_codes>
-| Code | Severity | Condition | Recovery |
-|------|----------|-----------|----------|
-| E001 | error | No target specified | Provide target |
-| E002 | error | Target path not found | Check path |
-| E003 | error | Resume but no session | Start new |
-| W001 | warning | No git history for target | Proceed |
-| W002 | warning | Some dimension agents failed | Partial coverage |
-| W003 | warning | Generalization 0 hits | Skip discovery |
-| W004 | warning | Delegate parse failed | Raw output |
-</error_codes>
-
-<success_criteria>
-- [ ] Target resolved and session created
-- [ ] Git archaeology on target files
-- [ ] CLI exploration executed, explore.json written
-- [ ] All dimensions reviewed with structured findings
-- [ ] Severity matrix produced
-- [ ] **ALL findings within fix_threshold fixed** — remaining_actionable == 0 (unless --skip-fix)
-- [ ] Per-tier fix with re-review gate: modified area re-reviewed, new findings appended
-- [ ] Zero-residual confirmed by CLI external model
-- [ ] Pattern generalized with multi-layer scan + deepening (unless --skip-generalize)
-- [ ] Quality Gate self-iteration triggered when insufficient
-- [ ] Discoveries classified and routed
-- [ ] understanding.md §8 finalized
-- [ ] phase_goals G1-G6 tracked and audited (G3 = zero remaining)
-- [ ] Goal Prompt displayed once
-- [ ] `-y`: no blocking prompts, deferred counted
-- [ ] Session resumable via -c
-</success_criteria>
-
-<next_step_routing>
-| Condition | Next step |
-|-----------|-----------|
-| Finding needs deeper debug | `/odyssey-debug "<finding>"` |
-| Issues created | `/manage-issue list --source review-odyssey` |
-| Pattern to document | `/learn-decompose <module>` |
-| Plan fixes for findings | `/maestro-plan --gaps` |
-</next_step_routing>
+<purpose>
+Deep code review with exhaustive fix: archaeology → explore → multi-dimensional review →
+fix ALL findings → confirm → generalize → discover → persist. Zero-residual philosophy.
+</purpose>
+
+<boundary>
+**范围内:** 目标代码的多维度深度审查 → 穷尽修复 ALL 发现（按 severity 递降）→ 泛化 pattern 到全项目
+**范围外:** 深度根因调查（根因不明时）→ `/odyssey-debug` | 需求实现 → `/odyssey-planex` | UI 视觉优化 → `/odyssey-ui`
+**探索自由度:** 边界内自由探索 — 可跨维度关联发现、追溯 git 历史、泛化扫描全项目。修复仅限 critical/high findings。
+</boundary>
+
+<execution_discipline>
+**三条铁律（所有阶段适用）:**
+
+1. **Phase auto-commit** — 每个阶段完成后**自动** `git commit`，无需用户确认
+   - 代码变更 + understanding.md → `git add` → `git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): {phase} — {摘要}"`
+   - session.json / evidence.ndjson 为运行时状态，不纳入 commit
+
+2. **有把握才改** — 仅修改自己有把握的内容；不确定的记录决策等人判断
+   - 有把握 → 直接修改代码，commit
+   - 需要决策 → 记录 `evidence.ndjson {"phase":"decision","status":"pending"}` 不改代码
+   - 禁止猜测性修改
+
+3. **多 CLI 辅助** — 利用 `maestro delegate` 调用多个 CLI 工具交叉验证
+   - 关键判断用不同 `--role`（analyze / review / explore）获取多视角
+   - 修复前后各做一次 CLI review 确认
+</execution_discipline>
+
+<context>
+$ARGUMENTS — target and optional flags.
+
+**Target resolution:**
+| Input | Resolution |
+|-------|-----------|
+| File/dir path | Review those files |
+| `HEAD` / `staged` | `git diff HEAD` / `git diff --staged` |
+| Phase number | Resolve via state.json → changed files |
+| PR number | `git diff main...HEAD` |
+
+**Flags:**
+| Flag | Effect | Default |
+|------|--------|---------|
+| `--dimensions <list>` | Comma-separated subset | correctness,security,performance,architecture |
+| `--fix-threshold <severity>` | 修复到哪个 severity 为止（all = 全部修复）| `all` |
+| `--skip-fix` | Review-only — skip S_FIX and S_CONFIRM | false |
+| `--skip-generalize` | Skip S_GENERALIZE and S_DISCOVER | false |
+| `--auto` | CLI delegates without confirmation | false |
+| `-y` | Auto-confirm at decision points (see appendix) | false |
+| `-c` | Resume most recent session | — |
+
+**Session**: `SESSION_DIR = .workflow/scratch/{YYYYMMDD}-review-odyssey-{slug}/`
+
+**Output — 4 files:**
+```
+SESSION_DIR/
+  ├── session.json       # state + review_result + confirmation + patterns + phase_goals
+  ├── evidence.ndjson    # ALL evidence (phase: archaeology|explore|review|fix|discovery|decision)
+  ├── explore.json       # CLI exploration snapshot
+  └── understanding.md   # 8-section evolving narrative (§1-§8, one per major phase)
+```
+
+**session.json schema:**
+```json
+{
+  "session_id": "review-odyssey-{YYYYMMDD-HHmmss}",
+  "target": "", "dimensions": [],
+  "flags": { "skip_fix": false, "skip_generalize": false, "fix_threshold": "all", "auto": false, "auto_confirm": false },
+  "current_state": "S_INTAKE",
+  "review_result": { "dimensions_reviewed": [], "finding_count": 0, "severity_distribution": { "critical": 0, "high": 0, "medium": 0, "low": 0 }, "remaining_actionable": 0 },
+  "patterns": [{ "id": "P1", "source_finding": "F1", "layer": "syntax|semantic|structural", "signature": "", "description": "", "risk": "", "fix_template": "", "confidence": "high|medium|low" }],
+  "confirmation": { "test_result": {}, "cli_review": {}, "overall": "confirmed|needs_rework" },
+  "generalization_stats": { "patterns_extracted": 0, "total_hits": 0, "true_positives": 0, "false_positives": 0, "uncertain": 0, "cross_layer_confirmed": 0, "regression_risks": 0, "by_layer": {}, "deepening_triggered": false, "self_iteration_rounds": 0 },
+  "phase_goals": [], "phase_goals_all_done": false,
+  "self_iteration_log": [],
+  "cross_phase_loops": 0, "max_loops": 3,
+  "created_at": "", "updated_at": ""
+}
+```
+
+**evidence.ndjson unified schema:** `{"ts":"","phase":"<phase>","type":"<type>","dimension":"","title":"","severity":"","file":"","line":0,"description":"","suggestion":"","files_modified":[]}`
+
+**phase_goals[]:**
+| ID | Goal | Done When | Phase | skip_when |
+|----|------|-----------|-------|-----------|
+| G1 | Review completed | all dimensions reviewed, findings logged | S_REVIEW | — |
+| G2 | Explore context gathered | explore.json populated | S_EXPLORE | — |
+| G3 | Zero remaining: all findings fixed | `remaining_actionable == 0` within fix_threshold | S_CONFIRM | skip_fix |
+| G4 | Pattern generalized | patterns[] ≥1 entry | S_GENERALIZE | skip_generalize |
+| G5 | Discoveries triaged | all scan hits classified | S_DISCOVER | skip_generalize |
+| G6 | Learnings persisted | spec entries created OR no actionable | S_RECORD | — |
+
+Lifecycle: `pending → done | skipped | failed` (all set `completion_confirmed`)
+
+### Pre-load（可选，缺失不阻塞）
+
+| 层级 | 命令 | 作用 |
+|------|------|------|
+| Codebase docs | Read `.workflow/codebase/ARCHITECTURE.md` | 模块边界，架构约束 |
+| Wiki search | `maestro search "<target keywords>" --json` | 先前 review、已知问题（取 top 5） |
+| Specs | `maestro spec load --category review` | review 标准、checklist、knowhow 工具 |
+| Role knowledge | `maestro search --category review` → 选相关 → `maestro wiki load <id>` | 累积 review 领域知识 |
+| Prior sessions | `find_files(".workflow/scratch/*-review-odyssey-*")` | 相关 odyssey 会话 |
+
+### Knowledge Persistence（S_RECORD 中写入产出文件）
+
+S_RECORD 阶段将可沉淀知识 **写入 understanding.md §8 Learnings**，按以下分类结构化：
+
+| 分类 | 写入内容 | 后续建议命令 |
+|------|---------|-------------|
+| 跨维度反复 pattern | 模式描述 + 出现维度 + 建议规范 | `/spec-add review "..."` |
+| 安全发现 | 漏洞类型 + 触发条件 + 修复方案 | `/spec-add debug "..."` |
+| 架构违反 pattern | 违反描述 + 正确边界 + 检查方法 | `/spec-add arch "..."` |
+| 可复用泛化 pattern | pattern 签名 + 风险说明 + fix 模板 | `/spec-add coding "..."` |
+
+**两步模式：** 执行中写入产出文件（临时记录）→ 任务完成后用户通过 next_step_routing 沉淀为永久知识。执行过程中不调用外部 Skill。
+</context>
+
+<self_iteration>
+**Quality Gate** — auto-evaluate after each analytical phase. Insufficient → re-enter (max 2 rounds).
+
+| Dimension | Sufficient | Insufficient |
+|-----------|-----------|-------------|
+| Coverage | All known related files analyzed | Missed targets discoverable via grep/git log |
+| Depth | ≥80% findings have file:line evidence | Most findings lack specifics |
+| Actionability | Each conclusion has concrete next action | "Consider reviewing" without action |
+
+**Expansion:** Round 1 = widen scope (more dirs, deeper git log, extra delegate angles). Round 2 = shift perspective (different CLI tool, reverse trace, manual reading).
+
+**Log:** `evidence.ndjson ← {"phase":"self-iteration","type":"quality-gate","stage":"S_XXX","round":N,"assessment":{},"expansion":""}`
+
+**Applicable stages:** S_ARCHAEOLOGY, S_EXPLORE, S_REVIEW, S_FIX, S_GENERALIZE
+</self_iteration>
+
+<state_machine>
+
+<states>
+S_INTAKE       — Parse target, load context, resume session            PERSIST: session.json + understanding.md §1
+S_ARCHAEOLOGY  — Git history of target files                           PERSIST: evidence.ndjson (archaeology) + understanding.md §2
+S_EXPLORE      — CLI-assisted structure/call-chain exploration         PERSIST: explore.json + evidence.ndjson (explore) + understanding.md §3
+S_REVIEW       — Parallel multi-dimension review (4 Agents)            PERSIST: evidence.ndjson (review) + understanding.md §4
+S_FIX          — Targeted fix for critical/high (skip if --skip-fix)   PERSIST: code changes + evidence.ndjson (fix)
+S_CONFIRM      — Test + CLI review confirmation (skip if --skip-fix)   PERSIST: session.json.confirmation + understanding.md §5
+S_GENERALIZE   — Pattern extraction + 4-agent scan (skip if --skip-generalize) PERSIST: session.json.patterns + understanding.md §6
+S_DISCOVER     — Classify hits, create issues (skip if --skip-generalize)      PERSIST: evidence.ndjson (discovery|decision) + understanding.md §7
+S_RECORD       — Knowledge persistence + final report                  PERSIST: understanding.md §8 + spec entries
+</states>
+
+<transitions>
+S_INTAKE:
+  → S_INTAKE        WHEN -c + session found        DO A_RESUME
+  → S_ARCHAEOLOGY   WHEN target resolved            DO A_INTAKE
+  → S_INTAKE        WHEN no target                  DO ask_user
+
+S_ARCHAEOLOGY  → S_EXPLORE      DO A_ARCHAEOLOGY
+S_EXPLORE      → S_REVIEW       DO A_EXPLORE
+
+S_REVIEW:
+  → S_FIX           WHEN !skip_fix AND any findings within fix_threshold   DO A_REVIEW
+  → S_GENERALIZE    WHEN (skip_fix OR no findings) AND !skip_gen           DO A_REVIEW
+  → S_RECORD        WHEN (skip_fix OR no findings) AND skip_gen            DO A_REVIEW
+
+S_FIX          → S_CONFIRM      DO A_FIX
+
+S_CONFIRM:
+  → S_GENERALIZE    WHEN confirmed AND !skip_gen    DO A_CONFIRM
+  → S_RECORD        WHEN confirmed AND skip_gen     DO A_CONFIRM
+  → S_FIX           WHEN needs_rework               DO A_CONFIRM
+
+S_GENERALIZE:
+  → S_DISCOVER      WHEN hits found                 DO A_GENERALIZE
+  → S_RECORD        WHEN no hits                    DO A_GENERALIZE
+
+S_DISCOVER → S_FIX          : discovery finds fixable sibling, !skip_fix, loops < max_loops → cross_phase_loops++
+S_DISCOVER → S_REVIEW       : discovery opens new review target, loops < max_loops → cross_phase_loops++
+S_DISCOVER → S_RECORD       : triage complete OR loops >= max_loops (剩余项 → issue/decision)
+
+S_RECORD   → END            DO A_RECORD
+</transitions>
+
+<actions>
+
+### A_INTAKE
+Parse target + flags → file list. Create `SESSION_DIR`, derive `phase_goals[]` from flags.
+Search prior knowledge: `maestro search`, prior sessions, ARCHITECTURE.md.
+Write `session.json` + `understanding.md` §1. Display Goal Prompt (appendix).
+
+📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): INTAKE — 目标解析与上下文加载"`
+
+### A_ARCHAEOLOGY
+`git log --oneline -20 -- {target_files}` + `git blame` on key regions.
+CLI delegate `--role analyze --mode analysis` to review past changes.
+Append evidence.ndjson (phase: "archaeology"). Update `understanding.md` §2.
+
+📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): ARCHAEOLOGY — git 考古分析"`
+
+### A_EXPLORE
+CLI delegate `--role explore --mode analysis` — call chains, error gaps, similar patterns.
+Write `explore.json`, append evidence.ndjson (phase: "explore").
+Update `understanding.md` §3. Mark G2 done.
+
+📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): EXPLORE — 代码探索完成"`
+
+### A_REVIEW
+Spawn N parallel Agents (one per dimension, default 4):
+
+| Agent | Dimension | Focus |
+|-------|-----------|-------|
+| Correctness | correctness | Logic errors, boundary conditions, null/undefined, race conditions |
+| Security | security | Injection, XSS, CSRF, data exposure, auth bypass |
+| Performance | performance | Hot paths, N+1, memory leaks, unnecessary recomputation |
+| Architecture | architecture | Layer violations, circular deps, interface contracts, SoC |
+
+Each returns `[{title, severity, file, line, description, suggestion, cwe}]`.
+Merge → evidence.ndjson (phase: "review"). Write `session.json.review_result`.
+Update `understanding.md` §4 (findings by dimension + severity matrix). Mark G1 done.
+
+📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): REVIEW — 多维度审查完成"`
+
+### A_FIX
+
+**穷尽迭代修复** — 按 severity 递降逐轮修复，直到 `remaining_actionable == 0`。
+
+#### Fix Loop (severity tiers)
+
+```
+fix_tiers = [critical, high, medium, low].filter(s => severity_order(s) >= severity_order(fix_threshold))
+for tier in fix_tiers:
+  candidates = evidence.filter(phase=="review" AND severity==tier AND status!="fixed")
+  if candidates.empty: continue
+  for each candidate:
+    read context (file:line ±20) → implement fix → append evidence (phase: "fix")
+  run local re-review on modified area ("改进即标准"):
+    new_findings in same region? → append to current tier, continue loop
+  tier complete → auto-commit
+```
+
+**Re-review gate** ("改进即标准"): 每轮修复后，对修改区域执行轻量 re-review（同维度）。若发现新问题，追加到当前轮继续修复。单轮最多 re-review 2 次，防止无限循环。
+
+**Normal**: ask_user 确认每个 tier 的 candidates。**`-y`**: auto-fix all, record `deferred`.
+
+**Remaining check**: 所有 tiers 完成后，count unfixed findings within fix_threshold → 写入 `review_result.remaining_actionable`。若 > 0 且未超 max_loops → 回到 tier 1 重试。
+
+📌 **Auto-commit per tier**: `git add -A && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): FIX-{tier} — {N}项修复"`
+
+### A_CONFIRM
+Run tests covering modified files. CLI delegate fix review:
+```
+maestro delegate "PURPOSE: Verify ALL fixes and confirm zero remaining improvements
+TASK: Verify fix correctness | Check regressions | Count remaining unfixed findings | Confirm zero-residual
+MODE: analysis
+CONTEXT: @{modified_files} | Findings: {all_findings_summary} | Diff: {git_diff}
+EXPECTED: JSON {verdict, findings_addressed, remaining_unfixed, regression_risk, new_findings_in_modified_area}
+CONSTRAINTS: Focus on correctness AND completeness — flag ANY remaining actionable improvement
+" --role review --mode analysis
+```
+Run_in_background, STOP, wait.
+
+**Zero-residual gate:**
+- `remaining_unfixed == 0 AND new_findings == 0` → `confirmed`, mark G3 done
+- `remaining_unfixed > 0 OR new_findings > 0` → `needs_rework` → S_FIX（追加新发现）
+- Regression detected → `needs_rework` → S_FIX
+
+Write `session.json.confirmation` + update `review_result.remaining_actionable`.
+Update `understanding.md` §5.
+
+📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): CONFIRM — 零遗留验证"`
+
+### A_GENERALIZE
+**Multi-layer pattern extraction** from findings (severity >= medium):
+
+| Layer | Method | Example |
+|-------|--------|---------|
+| Syntax | Regex → direct Grep | `eval(`, `innerHTML =` |
+| Semantic | Agent understands anti-pattern → scans | Missing error handling on async |
+| Structural | File/module structure similarity | Same base class missing override |
+
+Write `session.json.patterns[]`.
+
+**4-agent parallel scan** (single message):
+1. **Syntax grep** — Grep syntax-layer signatures across project
+2. **Semantic scan** — Check related modules for same anti-patterns
+3. **Structural match** — Find structurally similar files, check for same issues
+4. **Historical grep** — `git log -S "{pattern}"` for introduction/fix history
+
+**Cross-layer dedup**: Multi-layer hit → boost confidence. Single-layer → `needs_review`. Historical match on fixed code → `regression_risk`.
+
+**Iterative deepening** (conditional): High-density cluster (≥3 hits in same module) → targeted deep scan on that module. Max 1 round.
+
+**CLI validation** (optional): Delegate to validate true/false positives.
+
+Update `understanding.md` §6 (per-pattern summary, cross-layer matrix, risk heatmap).
+Write `session.json.generalization_stats`. Mark G4 done.
+
+📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): GENERALIZE — 泛化扫描完成"`
+
+### A_DISCOVER
+Classify each hit: `bug` / `risk` / `safe`.
+**Normal**: ask_user for bug routing. **`-y`**: auto create issue, `deferred`.
+Append evidence (phase: discovery + decision). Update `understanding.md` §7. Mark G5 done.
+
+📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): DISCOVER — 发现分类完成"`
+
+### A_RECORD
+Finalize `understanding.md` §8: per-dimension summary, top findings with file:line, generalization results, open decisions.
+Write learnings to understanding.md §8: 按 Knowledge Persistence 表分类记录（临时），completion summary 列出建议的 `/spec-add` 命令。
+Pending decisions: **Normal** → ask_user. **`-y`** → skip, display deferred count.
+Goal audit: check all `phase_goals[*].completion_confirmed`. Mark G6 done.
+
+Completion summary:
+```
+--- REVIEW-TEST-FIX ODYSSEY COMPLETE ---
+Target:     {target}
+Dimensions: {dimensions_reviewed}
+Findings:   {C}C {H}H {M}M {L}L
+Fix:        {fixed} applied, confirmed={confirmed|skipped}
+Patterns:   {extracted} ({by_layer} distribution)
+Scan hits:  {total} ({cross_layer} cross-layer confirmed)
+Issues:     {N} created
+Decisions:  {N} resolved, {M} pending, {K} deferred
+Learnings:  {N} spec entries
+Self-iter:  {N} rounds across {M} stages
+Goals:      {done}/{total} ({skipped} skipped)
+---
+```
+
+📌 **Auto-commit**: `git add understanding.md && git commit -m "odyssey-review({slug}): RECORD — 会话总结与知识沉淀"`
+
+</actions>
+
+<appendix>
+
+### Goal Prompt Template
+**⚠️ 时机守卫：仅在 A_INTAKE 完成后显示一次（session 创建后、开始考古前）。A_RECORD 完成时禁止重新显示。**
+
+```
+📋 Review-Test-Fix Odyssey 会话已创建。可随时复制以下 /goal 设定终止条件（执行过程中输入即可）：
+
+/goal 穷尽迭代：直到 session.json 的 review_result.remaining_actionable == 0
+且 confirmation.verdict == "confirmed" 且 phase_goals_all_done == true 才停。
+修复按 severity 逐轮迭代（critical→high→medium→low），每轮修复后 re-review 修改区域。
+发现新问题追加到当前轮继续。遇到 phase=decision 的 pending 必须 ask_user。
+不允许"只报告不处理"，每个 finding 必须有 action（fix/issue/decision）。
+```
+
+完成时仅输出 completion summary，不重复此提示。
+
+### `-y` Auto-Confirm (6 decision points)
+| Decision Point | Normal | `-y` |
+|----------------|--------|------|
+| S_FIX tier candidates | ask_user per tier | auto-fix ALL tiers, `deferred` |
+| S_FIX re-review new findings | ask_user | auto-append and fix |
+| S_CONFIRM needs_rework | Display, proceed to S_FIX | auto proceed |
+| S_DISCOVER bug routing | ask_user | auto create issue, `deferred` |
+| S_DISCOVER ambiguous | ask_user | all `deferred` |
+| S_RECORD pending decisions | ask_user | skip |
+| S_RECORD goal audit | ask_user | auto accept |
+
+</appendix>
+
+</state_machine>
+
+<error_codes>
+| Code | Severity | Condition | Recovery |
+|------|----------|-----------|----------|
+| E001 | error | No target specified | Provide target |
+| E002 | error | Target path not found | Check path |
+| E003 | error | Resume but no session | Start new |
+| W001 | warning | No git history for target | Proceed |
+| W002 | warning | Some dimension agents failed | Partial coverage |
+| W003 | warning | Generalization 0 hits | Skip discovery |
+| W004 | warning | Delegate parse failed | Raw output |
+</error_codes>
+
+<success_criteria>
+- [ ] Target resolved and session created
+- [ ] Git archaeology on target files
+- [ ] CLI exploration executed, explore.json written
+- [ ] All dimensions reviewed with structured findings
+- [ ] Severity matrix produced
+- [ ] **ALL findings within fix_threshold fixed** — remaining_actionable == 0 (unless --skip-fix)
+- [ ] Per-tier fix with re-review gate: modified area re-reviewed, new findings appended
+- [ ] Zero-residual confirmed by CLI external model
+- [ ] Pattern generalized with multi-layer scan + deepening (unless --skip-generalize)
+- [ ] Quality Gate self-iteration triggered when insufficient
+- [ ] Discoveries classified and routed
+- [ ] understanding.md §8 finalized
+- [ ] phase_goals G1-G6 tracked and audited (G3 = zero remaining)
+- [ ] Goal Prompt displayed once
+- [ ] `-y`: no blocking prompts, deferred counted
+- [ ] Session resumable via -c
+</success_criteria>
+
+<next_step_routing>
+| Condition | Next step |
+|-----------|-----------|
+| Finding needs deeper debug | `/odyssey-debug "<finding>"` |
+| Issues created | `/manage-issue list --source review-odyssey` |
+| Pattern to document | `/learn-decompose <module>` |
+| Plan fixes for findings | `/maestro-plan --gaps` |
+</next_step_routing>