interview-reps 0.0.0-stage → 0.4.0

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (285) hide show
  1. package/README.md +59 -2
  2. package/content/CLAUDE.md +131 -0
  3. package/content/LADDER.md +166 -0
  4. package/content/behavioral/QUESTIONS.md +93 -0
  5. package/content/behavioral/REVIEW.md +86 -0
  6. package/content/design/D01-short-links/README.md +20 -0
  7. package/content/design/D02-rate-limiter/README.md +21 -0
  8. package/content/design/D03-news-feed/README.md +20 -0
  9. package/content/design/D04-chat-messaging/README.md +20 -0
  10. package/content/design/D05-notification-service/README.md +20 -0
  11. package/content/design/D06-typeahead-search/README.md +20 -0
  12. package/content/design/D07-web-crawler/README.md +20 -0
  13. package/content/design/D08-file-sync/README.md +20 -0
  14. package/content/design/D09-ride-matching/README.md +20 -0
  15. package/content/design/D10-job-scheduler/README.md +20 -0
  16. package/content/design/D11-metrics-alerting/README.md +20 -0
  17. package/content/design/D12-payments-ledger/README.md +20 -0
  18. package/content/design/REVIEW.md +94 -0
  19. package/content/lib/binary-tree.ts +69 -0
  20. package/content/lib/graph.ts +50 -0
  21. package/content/lib/linked-list.ts +37 -0
  22. package/content/lib/perf.ts +9 -0
  23. package/content/problems/001-contains-duplicate/README.md +37 -0
  24. package/content/problems/001-contains-duplicate/solution.test.ts +38 -0
  25. package/content/problems/002-valid-anagram/README.md +36 -0
  26. package/content/problems/002-valid-anagram/solution.test.ts +38 -0
  27. package/content/problems/003-two-sum/README.md +40 -0
  28. package/content/problems/003-two-sum/solution.test.ts +40 -0
  29. package/content/problems/004-valid-palindrome/README.md +39 -0
  30. package/content/problems/004-valid-palindrome/solution.test.ts +38 -0
  31. package/content/problems/005-best-time-to-buy-and-sell-stock/README.md +38 -0
  32. package/content/problems/005-best-time-to-buy-and-sell-stock/solution.test.ts +39 -0
  33. package/content/problems/006-valid-parentheses/README.md +42 -0
  34. package/content/problems/006-valid-parentheses/solution.test.ts +41 -0
  35. package/content/problems/007-binary-search/README.md +39 -0
  36. package/content/problems/007-binary-search/solution.test.ts +56 -0
  37. package/content/problems/008-reverse-linked-list/README.md +39 -0
  38. package/content/problems/008-reverse-linked-list/solution.test.ts +41 -0
  39. package/content/problems/009-merge-two-sorted-lists/README.md +36 -0
  40. package/content/problems/009-merge-two-sorted-lists/solution.test.ts +43 -0
  41. package/content/problems/010-linked-list-cycle/README.md +37 -0
  42. package/content/problems/010-linked-list-cycle/solution.test.ts +39 -0
  43. package/content/problems/011-invert-binary-tree/README.md +39 -0
  44. package/content/problems/011-invert-binary-tree/solution.test.ts +32 -0
  45. package/content/problems/012-maximum-depth-of-binary-tree/README.md +37 -0
  46. package/content/problems/012-maximum-depth-of-binary-tree/solution.test.ts +29 -0
  47. package/content/problems/013-same-tree/README.md +37 -0
  48. package/content/problems/013-same-tree/solution.test.ts +38 -0
  49. package/content/problems/014-balanced-binary-tree/README.md +37 -0
  50. package/content/problems/014-balanced-binary-tree/solution.test.ts +38 -0
  51. package/content/problems/015-climbing-stairs/README.md +35 -0
  52. package/content/problems/015-climbing-stairs/solution.test.ts +27 -0
  53. package/content/problems/016-diameter-of-binary-tree/README.md +38 -0
  54. package/content/problems/016-diameter-of-binary-tree/solution.test.ts +63 -0
  55. package/content/problems/017-subtree-of-another-tree/README.md +42 -0
  56. package/content/problems/017-subtree-of-another-tree/solution.test.ts +61 -0
  57. package/content/problems/018-kth-largest-element-in-a-stream/README.md +49 -0
  58. package/content/problems/018-kth-largest-element-in-a-stream/solution.test.ts +104 -0
  59. package/content/problems/019-last-stone-weight/README.md +44 -0
  60. package/content/problems/019-last-stone-weight/solution.test.ts +67 -0
  61. package/content/problems/020-min-cost-climbing-stairs/README.md +40 -0
  62. package/content/problems/020-min-cost-climbing-stairs/solution.test.ts +44 -0
  63. package/content/problems/021-single-number/README.md +41 -0
  64. package/content/problems/021-single-number/solution.test.ts +46 -0
  65. package/content/problems/022-missing-number/README.md +40 -0
  66. package/content/problems/022-missing-number/solution.test.ts +44 -0
  67. package/content/problems/101-group-anagrams/README.md +41 -0
  68. package/content/problems/101-group-anagrams/solution.test.ts +83 -0
  69. package/content/problems/102-top-k-frequent-elements/README.md +44 -0
  70. package/content/problems/102-top-k-frequent-elements/solution.test.ts +59 -0
  71. package/content/problems/103-product-of-array-except-self/README.md +43 -0
  72. package/content/problems/103-product-of-array-except-self/solution.test.ts +59 -0
  73. package/content/problems/104-longest-consecutive-sequence/README.md +40 -0
  74. package/content/problems/104-longest-consecutive-sequence/solution.test.ts +62 -0
  75. package/content/problems/105-encode-and-decode-strings/README.md +47 -0
  76. package/content/problems/105-encode-and-decode-strings/solution.test.ts +50 -0
  77. package/content/problems/106-two-sum-ii-input-array-is-sorted/README.md +43 -0
  78. package/content/problems/106-two-sum-ii-input-array-is-sorted/solution.test.ts +47 -0
  79. package/content/problems/107-three-sum/README.md +42 -0
  80. package/content/problems/107-three-sum/solution.test.ts +79 -0
  81. package/content/problems/108-container-with-most-water/README.md +40 -0
  82. package/content/problems/108-container-with-most-water/solution.test.ts +53 -0
  83. package/content/problems/109-longest-substring-without-repeating-characters/README.md +40 -0
  84. package/content/problems/109-longest-substring-without-repeating-characters/solution.test.ts +56 -0
  85. package/content/problems/110-longest-repeating-character-replacement/README.md +41 -0
  86. package/content/problems/110-longest-repeating-character-replacement/solution.test.ts +51 -0
  87. package/content/problems/111-permutation-in-string/README.md +38 -0
  88. package/content/problems/111-permutation-in-string/solution.test.ts +54 -0
  89. package/content/problems/112-min-stack/README.md +51 -0
  90. package/content/problems/112-min-stack/solution.test.ts +123 -0
  91. package/content/problems/113-daily-temperatures/README.md +40 -0
  92. package/content/problems/113-daily-temperatures/solution.test.ts +56 -0
  93. package/content/problems/114-evaluate-reverse-polish-notation/README.md +44 -0
  94. package/content/problems/114-evaluate-reverse-polish-notation/solution.test.ts +56 -0
  95. package/content/problems/115-generate-parentheses/README.md +38 -0
  96. package/content/problems/115-generate-parentheses/solution.test.ts +59 -0
  97. package/content/problems/116-koko-eating-bananas/README.md +41 -0
  98. package/content/problems/116-koko-eating-bananas/solution.test.ts +53 -0
  99. package/content/problems/117-find-minimum-in-rotated-sorted-array/README.md +41 -0
  100. package/content/problems/117-find-minimum-in-rotated-sorted-array/solution.test.ts +69 -0
  101. package/content/problems/118-search-in-rotated-sorted-array/README.md +41 -0
  102. package/content/problems/118-search-in-rotated-sorted-array/solution.test.ts +95 -0
  103. package/content/problems/119-time-based-key-value-store/README.md +50 -0
  104. package/content/problems/119-time-based-key-value-store/solution.test.ts +107 -0
  105. package/content/problems/120-reorder-list/README.md +43 -0
  106. package/content/problems/120-reorder-list/solution.test.ts +83 -0
  107. package/content/problems/121-remove-nth-node-from-end-of-list/README.md +40 -0
  108. package/content/problems/121-remove-nth-node-from-end-of-list/solution.test.ts +55 -0
  109. package/content/problems/122-lru-cache/README.md +55 -0
  110. package/content/problems/122-lru-cache/solution.test.ts +152 -0
  111. package/content/problems/123-binary-tree-level-order-traversal/README.md +40 -0
  112. package/content/problems/123-binary-tree-level-order-traversal/solution.test.ts +42 -0
  113. package/content/problems/124-binary-tree-right-side-view/README.md +40 -0
  114. package/content/problems/124-binary-tree-right-side-view/solution.test.ts +56 -0
  115. package/content/problems/125-validate-binary-search-tree/README.md +46 -0
  116. package/content/problems/125-validate-binary-search-tree/solution.test.ts +78 -0
  117. package/content/problems/126-kth-smallest-element-in-a-bst/README.md +39 -0
  118. package/content/problems/126-kth-smallest-element-in-a-bst/solution.test.ts +61 -0
  119. package/content/problems/127-lowest-common-ancestor-of-a-bst/README.md +46 -0
  120. package/content/problems/127-lowest-common-ancestor-of-a-bst/solution.test.ts +106 -0
  121. package/content/problems/128-kth-largest-element-in-an-array/README.md +42 -0
  122. package/content/problems/128-kth-largest-element-in-an-array/solution.test.ts +67 -0
  123. package/content/problems/129-k-closest-points-to-origin/README.md +43 -0
  124. package/content/problems/129-k-closest-points-to-origin/solution.test.ts +74 -0
  125. package/content/problems/130-number-of-islands/README.md +44 -0
  126. package/content/problems/130-number-of-islands/solution.test.ts +69 -0
  127. package/content/problems/131-course-schedule/README.md +42 -0
  128. package/content/problems/131-course-schedule/solution.test.ts +82 -0
  129. package/content/problems/132-rotting-oranges/README.md +46 -0
  130. package/content/problems/132-rotting-oranges/solution.test.ts +74 -0
  131. package/content/problems/133-clone-graph/README.md +42 -0
  132. package/content/problems/133-clone-graph/solution.test.ts +58 -0
  133. package/content/problems/134-house-robber/README.md +38 -0
  134. package/content/problems/134-house-robber/solution.test.ts +45 -0
  135. package/content/problems/135-coin-change/README.md +40 -0
  136. package/content/problems/135-coin-change/solution.test.ts +45 -0
  137. package/content/problems/136-longest-increasing-subsequence/README.md +41 -0
  138. package/content/problems/136-longest-increasing-subsequence/solution.test.ts +53 -0
  139. package/content/problems/137-word-break/README.md +39 -0
  140. package/content/problems/137-word-break/solution.test.ts +49 -0
  141. package/content/problems/138-merge-intervals/README.md +40 -0
  142. package/content/problems/138-merge-intervals/solution.test.ts +84 -0
  143. package/content/problems/139-insert-interval/README.md +40 -0
  144. package/content/problems/139-insert-interval/solution.test.ts +75 -0
  145. package/content/problems/201-valid-sudoku/README.md +63 -0
  146. package/content/problems/201-valid-sudoku/solution.test.ts +104 -0
  147. package/content/problems/202-car-fleet/README.md +46 -0
  148. package/content/problems/202-car-fleet/solution.test.ts +85 -0
  149. package/content/problems/203-search-a-2d-matrix/README.md +47 -0
  150. package/content/problems/203-search-a-2d-matrix/solution.test.ts +108 -0
  151. package/content/problems/204-copy-list-with-random-pointer/README.md +46 -0
  152. package/content/problems/204-copy-list-with-random-pointer/solution.test.ts +120 -0
  153. package/content/problems/205-add-two-numbers/README.md +45 -0
  154. package/content/problems/205-add-two-numbers/solution.test.ts +74 -0
  155. package/content/problems/206-find-the-duplicate-number/README.md +47 -0
  156. package/content/problems/206-find-the-duplicate-number/solution.test.ts +72 -0
  157. package/content/problems/207-count-good-nodes/README.md +44 -0
  158. package/content/problems/207-count-good-nodes/solution.test.ts +63 -0
  159. package/content/problems/208-construct-tree-from-preorder-and-inorder/README.md +52 -0
  160. package/content/problems/208-construct-tree-from-preorder-and-inorder/solution.test.ts +126 -0
  161. package/content/problems/209-implement-trie/README.md +52 -0
  162. package/content/problems/209-implement-trie/solution.test.ts +138 -0
  163. package/content/problems/210-design-add-and-search-words/README.md +50 -0
  164. package/content/problems/210-design-add-and-search-words/solution.test.ts +127 -0
  165. package/content/problems/211-task-scheduler/README.md +47 -0
  166. package/content/problems/211-task-scheduler/solution.test.ts +64 -0
  167. package/content/problems/212-design-twitter/README.md +63 -0
  168. package/content/problems/212-design-twitter/solution.test.ts +137 -0
  169. package/content/problems/213-subsets/README.md +42 -0
  170. package/content/problems/213-subsets/solution.test.ts +63 -0
  171. package/content/problems/214-combination-sum/README.md +44 -0
  172. package/content/problems/214-combination-sum/solution.test.ts +75 -0
  173. package/content/problems/215-permutations/README.md +42 -0
  174. package/content/problems/215-permutations/solution.test.ts +70 -0
  175. package/content/problems/216-word-search/README.md +50 -0
  176. package/content/problems/216-word-search/solution.test.ts +86 -0
  177. package/content/problems/217-letter-combinations-of-a-phone-number/README.md +53 -0
  178. package/content/problems/217-letter-combinations-of-a-phone-number/solution.test.ts +57 -0
  179. package/content/problems/218-palindrome-partitioning/README.md +42 -0
  180. package/content/problems/218-palindrome-partitioning/solution.test.ts +77 -0
  181. package/content/problems/219-max-area-of-island/README.md +43 -0
  182. package/content/problems/219-max-area-of-island/solution.test.ts +78 -0
  183. package/content/problems/220-pacific-atlantic-water-flow/README.md +43 -0
  184. package/content/problems/220-pacific-atlantic-water-flow/solution.test.ts +86 -0
  185. package/content/problems/221-course-schedule-ii/README.md +42 -0
  186. package/content/problems/221-course-schedule-ii/solution.test.ts +107 -0
  187. package/content/problems/222-graph-valid-tree/README.md +42 -0
  188. package/content/problems/222-graph-valid-tree/solution.test.ts +75 -0
  189. package/content/problems/223-redundant-connection/README.md +42 -0
  190. package/content/problems/223-redundant-connection/solution.test.ts +68 -0
  191. package/content/problems/224-network-delay-time/README.md +44 -0
  192. package/content/problems/224-network-delay-time/solution.test.ts +70 -0
  193. package/content/problems/225-cheapest-flights-within-k-stops/README.md +45 -0
  194. package/content/problems/225-cheapest-flights-within-k-stops/solution.test.ts +85 -0
  195. package/content/problems/226-house-robber-ii/README.md +41 -0
  196. package/content/problems/226-house-robber-ii/solution.test.ts +51 -0
  197. package/content/problems/227-longest-palindromic-substring/README.md +41 -0
  198. package/content/problems/227-longest-palindromic-substring/solution.test.ts +69 -0
  199. package/content/problems/228-decode-ways/README.md +44 -0
  200. package/content/problems/228-decode-ways/solution.test.ts +50 -0
  201. package/content/problems/229-maximum-product-subarray/README.md +40 -0
  202. package/content/problems/229-maximum-product-subarray/solution.test.ts +55 -0
  203. package/content/problems/230-partition-equal-subset-sum/README.md +39 -0
  204. package/content/problems/230-partition-equal-subset-sum/solution.test.ts +54 -0
  205. package/content/problems/231-unique-paths/README.md +41 -0
  206. package/content/problems/231-unique-paths/solution.test.ts +45 -0
  207. package/content/problems/232-longest-common-subsequence/README.md +41 -0
  208. package/content/problems/232-longest-common-subsequence/solution.test.ts +48 -0
  209. package/content/problems/233-coin-change-ii/README.md +44 -0
  210. package/content/problems/233-coin-change-ii/solution.test.ts +45 -0
  211. package/content/problems/234-edit-distance/README.md +45 -0
  212. package/content/problems/234-edit-distance/solution.test.ts +48 -0
  213. package/content/problems/235-maximum-subarray/README.md +40 -0
  214. package/content/problems/235-maximum-subarray/solution.test.ts +63 -0
  215. package/content/problems/236-jump-game/README.md +40 -0
  216. package/content/problems/236-jump-game/solution.test.ts +68 -0
  217. package/content/problems/237-gas-station/README.md +42 -0
  218. package/content/problems/237-gas-station/solution.test.ts +56 -0
  219. package/content/problems/238-partition-labels/README.md +40 -0
  220. package/content/problems/238-partition-labels/solution.test.ts +54 -0
  221. package/content/problems/239-non-overlapping-intervals/README.md +40 -0
  222. package/content/problems/239-non-overlapping-intervals/solution.test.ts +61 -0
  223. package/content/problems/240-meeting-rooms-ii/README.md +42 -0
  224. package/content/problems/240-meeting-rooms-ii/solution.test.ts +65 -0
  225. package/content/problems/241-rotate-image/README.md +41 -0
  226. package/content/problems/241-rotate-image/solution.test.ts +72 -0
  227. package/content/problems/242-spiral-matrix/README.md +40 -0
  228. package/content/problems/242-spiral-matrix/solution.test.ts +90 -0
  229. package/content/problems/243-set-matrix-zeroes/README.md +44 -0
  230. package/content/problems/243-set-matrix-zeroes/solution.test.ts +153 -0
  231. package/content/problems/301-trapping-rain-water/README.md +42 -0
  232. package/content/problems/301-trapping-rain-water/solution.test.ts +63 -0
  233. package/content/problems/302-minimum-window-substring/README.md +43 -0
  234. package/content/problems/302-minimum-window-substring/solution.test.ts +56 -0
  235. package/content/problems/303-sliding-window-maximum/README.md +42 -0
  236. package/content/problems/303-sliding-window-maximum/solution.test.ts +63 -0
  237. package/content/problems/304-largest-rectangle-in-histogram/README.md +42 -0
  238. package/content/problems/304-largest-rectangle-in-histogram/solution.test.ts +57 -0
  239. package/content/problems/305-median-of-two-sorted-arrays/README.md +42 -0
  240. package/content/problems/305-median-of-two-sorted-arrays/solution.test.ts +84 -0
  241. package/content/problems/306-merge-k-sorted-lists/README.md +42 -0
  242. package/content/problems/306-merge-k-sorted-lists/solution.test.ts +72 -0
  243. package/content/problems/307-reverse-nodes-in-k-group/README.md +42 -0
  244. package/content/problems/307-reverse-nodes-in-k-group/solution.test.ts +86 -0
  245. package/content/problems/308-binary-tree-maximum-path-sum/README.md +44 -0
  246. package/content/problems/308-binary-tree-maximum-path-sum/solution.test.ts +91 -0
  247. package/content/problems/309-serialize-and-deserialize-binary-tree/README.md +50 -0
  248. package/content/problems/309-serialize-and-deserialize-binary-tree/solution.test.ts +120 -0
  249. package/content/problems/310-find-median-from-data-stream/README.md +47 -0
  250. package/content/problems/310-find-median-from-data-stream/solution.test.ts +102 -0
  251. package/content/problems/311-word-search-ii/README.md +51 -0
  252. package/content/problems/311-word-search-ii/solution.test.ts +144 -0
  253. package/content/problems/312-n-queens/README.md +41 -0
  254. package/content/problems/312-n-queens/solution.test.ts +91 -0
  255. package/content/problems/313-word-ladder/README.md +42 -0
  256. package/content/problems/313-word-ladder/solution.test.ts +85 -0
  257. package/content/problems/314-alien-dictionary/README.md +43 -0
  258. package/content/problems/314-alien-dictionary/solution.test.ts +127 -0
  259. package/content/problems/315-longest-increasing-path-in-a-matrix/README.md +42 -0
  260. package/content/problems/315-longest-increasing-path-in-a-matrix/solution.test.ts +118 -0
  261. package/content/problems/316-swim-in-rising-water/README.md +44 -0
  262. package/content/problems/316-swim-in-rising-water/solution.test.ts +138 -0
  263. package/content/product/P01-tool-lending/README.md +28 -0
  264. package/content/product/P02-city-bike-share/README.md +28 -0
  265. package/content/product/P03-caring-from-afar/README.md +29 -0
  266. package/content/product/P04-first-garden/README.md +28 -0
  267. package/content/product/P05-save-for-later/README.md +28 -0
  268. package/content/product/P06-ship-or-hold/README.md +28 -0
  269. package/content/product/P07-photo-backup-goals/README.md +28 -0
  270. package/content/product/P08-quarter-roadmap/README.md +28 -0
  271. package/content/product/P09-grocer-delivery/README.md +29 -0
  272. package/content/product/P10-notes-for-work/README.md +28 -0
  273. package/content/product/P11-fitness-coaching/README.md +28 -0
  274. package/content/product/P12-low-price-rival/README.md +28 -0
  275. package/content/product/P13-coffee-cups/README.md +28 -0
  276. package/content/product/P14-bike-repair-market/README.md +27 -0
  277. package/content/product/P15-scooter-rides/README.md +27 -0
  278. package/content/product/P16-school-lunch-boxes/README.md +28 -0
  279. package/content/product/P17-weekly-users-drop/README.md +28 -0
  280. package/content/product/P18-ride-cancellations/README.md +28 -0
  281. package/content/product/P19-signups-up-revenue-flat/README.md +28 -0
  282. package/content/product/P20-longer-sessions/README.md +28 -0
  283. package/content/product/REVIEW.md +107 -0
  284. package/dist/cli.mjs +4462 -0
  285. package/package.json +38 -4
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
1
+ # P03 · Caring for a parent from far away
2
+
3
+ Category: Product sense · Level: advanced · Time: 35 min
4
+
5
+ Many adults live hours away from an ageing parent who still lives alone. Design a product that helps the adult child look after their parent from a distance.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out who would pay and who would use it day to day, what the parent is willing to have in their home, and whether this is a new company or part of an existing one.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - A health insurer is exploring it; it would be offered free to members' families at first.
12
+ - Parents are 75 or older, mostly independent, many with one long-term condition.
13
+ - Some parents use a smartphone; many use only a landline and a television.
14
+ - The insurer's measure of success is fewer avoidable hospital visits within two years.
15
+ - Out of scope: medical devices that need regulatory approval.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Treats the adult child and the parent as separate users with different needs, and handles the tension between them.
20
+ - Says how privacy and dignity of the parent shape the design.
21
+ - Names concrete moments of worry or failure, not general themes, before proposing anything.
22
+ - Connects the chosen idea to the insurer's goal, not just to what users would like.
23
+ - Picks a first version small enough to learn from, and says what it would teach.
24
+ - Names the risk of the product making things worse and how it would be noticed.
25
+
26
+ ## Follow-ups
27
+
28
+ - Half the parents refuse to use it. What do you change?
29
+ - The insurer wants to use the data to set prices. How do you respond?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P04 · A product for first-time gardeners
2
+
3
+ Category: Product sense · Level: core · Time: 35 min
4
+
5
+ More people are growing vegetables and herbs at home for the first time, and many give up after one season. Design a product for them.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out what kind of company is asking, what they can already offer, and what they mean by success.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - A chain of garden centres with 200 shops; it has a loyalty card but no app.
12
+ - Its customers are mostly experienced gardeners over 50; it wants younger first-timers.
13
+ - Success means first-timers who buy a second season of plants and seeds.
14
+ - Budget for one app or web product, launching in six months.
15
+ - Out of scope: running classes in the shops.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Explains why first-timers give up, with more than one cause.
20
+ - Narrows to a group within first-timers (space, time, experience) and says why that one.
21
+ - Uses what the company already has as an advantage, or says why not.
22
+ - Chooses between distinct ideas with criteria tied to the second-season goal.
23
+ - Names a leading measure that would show progress before the second season comes round.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - Your product works, but customers buy their second season online from someone else. What changes?
28
+ - Most first-timers live in flats with a balcony at most. Does your choice still hold?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P05 · Metrics for a save-for-later list
2
+
3
+ Category: Execution · Level: core · Time: 30 min
4
+
5
+ An online clothing shop added a "save for later" button so shoppers can keep items they like without putting them in the basket. How would you decide whether the feature is working, and what would you track?
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out why the feature was built, how long it has been live, and how it fits the rest of the shopping journey.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - It was built because many baskets were abandoned with items shoppers seemed to want.
12
+ - It has been live for six weeks to all shoppers on web and app.
13
+ - Saved items show on a list page and in a reminder email after three days.
14
+ - About 8% of weekly shoppers have saved at least one item.
15
+ - Out of scope: changing prices or running discounts on saved items.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - States the goal the feature serves before choosing any metric.
20
+ - Picks one main measure and explains why it beats the obvious alternatives.
21
+ - Adds guardrails for what the feature could harm.
22
+ - Says how to tell the feature's effect apart from other changes (a comparison, not just a trend).
23
+ - Says what result would lead them to change or remove it.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - Saves are high but purchases from the list are rare. What do you do next?
28
+ - Marketing wants to email every saved item every day. How do you decide?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P06 · Ship or hold a new home feed
2
+
3
+ Category: Execution · Level: advanced · Time: 30 min
4
+
5
+ A recipe app tested a new home feed that recommends recipes instead of showing the newest ones. After two weeks the test group opens more recipes per visit, but fewer of them come back the following week. Do you launch it?
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out what the app's main goal is this year, how big the differences are and whether they are reliable, and who was in the test.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - The company goal for the year is weekly returning users.
12
+ - Recipes opened per visit: up 9%. Users returning the next week: down 1.5%. Both differences are statistically reliable.
13
+ - The test ran on 10% of new and existing users on the app only.
14
+ - Revenue comes from a subscription; subscriptions started were flat.
15
+ - A competitor launched a similar feed last month.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Ties the decision to the company's main goal rather than the metric that went up.
20
+ - Asks whether the test was long enough and fair enough before trusting it.
21
+ - Looks for which users drove each change before deciding.
22
+ - Considers options between launch and kill, and picks one.
23
+ - Says what they would watch after the decision, and what would reverse it.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - The returning-user drop only appears for existing users, not new ones. What changes?
28
+ - Leadership wants it launched because of the competitor. How do you respond?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P07 · Goals for a photo backup feature
2
+
3
+ Category: Execution · Level: core · Time: 30 min
4
+
5
+ A phone maker is adding automatic photo backup to its own cloud for the first time. You are the product manager. Set the goals for its first year and say how you would track them.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out why the company is building it, who gets it, what it costs, and what users do today.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - The company wants people to stay with its phones when they upgrade.
12
+ - Every new phone gets 15 GB free; more space is a monthly paid plan.
13
+ - Today most owners back up with another company's app or not at all.
14
+ - It launches in all markets at once in the spring.
15
+ - Out of scope: a desktop app.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Separates the company's goal from the feature's goal and links the two.
20
+ - Picks one main measure for the year and explains the choice.
21
+ - Splits the journey into steps (turning it on, first full backup, staying on) and measures each.
22
+ - Adds guardrails, for example cost or complaints, with reasons.
23
+ - Sets targets or says how they would set them, rather than leaving the numbers open.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - Six months in, many users turn backup off after the free space fills. What do you do?
28
+ - Finance asks you to raise paid plans this year. How do the goals change?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P08 · Plan a quarter for a small team
2
+
3
+ Category: Execution · Level: core · Time: 30 min
4
+
5
+ You lead product for a team of five engineers building a booking tool used by small hair salons. Next quarter you have five requests and room for about two. Decide what the team builds.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out the company's goal for the quarter, how big each request is, and who is asking for each.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - The company goal is to cut the number of salons that cancel each month.
12
+ - The requests: two-way text reminders (6 weeks), online card payments (8 weeks), a staff rota (5 weeks), a review widget for salon websites (3 weeks), and a fix for slow calendar loading on old tablets (3 weeks).
13
+ - Sales wants payments; support says slow calendars are the top complaint from salons that cancel.
14
+ - About 3% of salons cancel each month; most cancel in their first three months.
15
+ - Nothing else is committed for the quarter.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Ranks the requests against the quarter's goal with criteria stated before ranking.
20
+ - Uses the evidence in the prompt rather than opinions about which feature is best.
21
+ - Fits the plan into the team's capacity and says what happens to the rest.
22
+ - Names the stakeholders who lose out and how they would be told.
23
+ - Says how they'll know at the end of the quarter whether the choice was right.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - Halfway through, the biggest customer threatens to leave unless you build the rota. What now?
28
+ - Your first pick takes twice as long as estimated. What do you cut?
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
1
+ # P09 · Should a regional grocer deliver?
2
+
3
+ Category: Strategy · Level: advanced · Time: 40 min
4
+
5
+ A grocery chain with 120 supermarkets in one region sells only in its shops. National delivery apps are taking a growing share of its customers' spending. Should it launch its own home delivery, and if so how?
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out how the chain makes money and how healthy it is, what customers it has and what they want, and what the delivery apps are doing in its region.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - Margins are thin (about 3%) and the chain is profitable but not growing.
12
+ - Its customers are loyal, older than average, and rate its fresh food highly.
13
+ - Delivery apps already carry the chain's products from two of its competitors.
14
+ - The board would invest for three years, but wants a plan that pays back.
15
+ - Out of scope: opening new shops or selling the company.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Reasons about the market and the chain's position before deciding yes or no.
20
+ - Lays out more than one way to compete (build, partner, focus elsewhere) and compares them.
21
+ - Uses the chain's strengths and weaknesses as evidence, not generic strategy words.
22
+ - Makes the money question concrete: what has to be true for it to pay back.
23
+ - Ends on a clear recommendation, with the first step and how the board would know it's working.
24
+ - Names the biggest risk to the plan and what would be done about it.
25
+
26
+ ## Follow-ups
27
+
28
+ - A delivery app offers an exclusive deal at a low commission. Does that change your answer?
29
+ - Two years in, delivery orders grow but shop sales fall by the same amount. What now?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P10 · Take a student notes app to work
2
+
3
+ Category: Strategy · Level: core · Time: 40 min
4
+
5
+ A note-taking app is popular with university students, who use it free, and has a small paid plan. Leadership wants to sell it to companies. Should it, and how?
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out how the app makes money now, what happens to students when they graduate, and what companies already use.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - Ten million monthly users, 90% of them students; 2% pay for a personal plan.
12
+ - Most users stop within a year of graduating.
13
+ - Companies mostly use notes tools bundled with their office software.
14
+ - The company has no sales team and has never sold to businesses.
15
+ - Out of scope: building an office suite.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Explains why selling to companies could work or fail, using the prompt's facts.
20
+ - Considers who inside a company would choose, pay for and use it, and how they differ.
21
+ - Compares more than one route into companies and picks one with reasons.
22
+ - Names what the company would have to build or learn, and the cost of that.
23
+ - Says what would show, within a year, that the bet is paying off.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - A large company asks for a version that runs on its own servers. Do you take it?
28
+ - Students start to leave for a newer, free app. Does the work plan change?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P11 · A paid coaching service for a fitness tracker
2
+
3
+ Category: Strategy · Level: core · Time: 40 min
4
+
5
+ A company sells wrist fitness trackers through shops and its website, with a free app. It is considering a monthly subscription with coaching: personalised plans and check-ins. Should it launch one?
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out how the company earns money today, how many trackers are actively used, and what competitors charge for.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - Revenue is almost all from hardware; a tracker is replaced every three years on average.
12
+ - About 4 million trackers are used weekly.
13
+ - Two competitors already charge a monthly fee; one bundles it with the device.
14
+ - The company has no coaches and no health experts on staff.
15
+ - Out of scope: medical advice.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Explains what the subscription would do for the business, not just for users.
20
+ - Says which users would pay and why, with a way to estimate how many.
21
+ - Compares ways to deliver coaching (people, software, partners) with their costs.
22
+ - Considers how the move affects device sales and existing free users.
23
+ - Ends on a decision and a small first step to test the riskiest assumption.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - Only 1% of users try the subscription. Is that failure?
28
+ - A competitor drops its fee to zero. What do you do?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P12 · Answer a low-price competitor
2
+
3
+ Category: Strategy · Level: advanced · Time: 40 min
4
+
5
+ A project-planning tool for small businesses charges per user per month. A new rival offers similar features at a third of the price and is growing fast. What should the company do?
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out how much of the market each holds, which customers are leaving and why, and what the company does better or worse.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - The company has 60,000 paying businesses and grows 2% a quarter; the rival has 8,000 and doubles every two quarters.
12
+ - Customers who left for the rival were mostly teams of fewer than five people.
13
+ - Larger customers say the company's integrations and support are why they stay.
14
+ - Cutting prices to match would cost about 40% of revenue.
15
+ - Out of scope: buying the rival.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Works out whether the rival is a threat to the whole business or one segment.
20
+ - Lists several responses, not only price, and compares them on cost and effect.
21
+ - Uses the evidence about who leaves and who stays.
22
+ - Chooses, and says what is being given up by choosing it.
23
+ - Names early signals that would show the response is working or failing.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - The rival starts winning teams of 50 too. What changes?
28
+ - Your board wants a cheaper plan launched within a month. How do you shape it?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P13 · Coffee cups sold in a city each day
2
+
3
+ Category: Estimation · Level: core · Time: 20 min
4
+
5
+ Estimate how many cups of coffee are sold each day in a city of about 1.5 million people, counting cafés, kiosks and shops but not coffee made at home or at work.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out what kind of city it is, whether a working day or a weekend is meant, and what counts as a cup.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - A European city with a busy centre and many commuters.
12
+ - A typical working day.
13
+ - Any coffee drink bought ready to drink counts as one cup, whatever the size.
14
+ - About 300,000 people come into the city each day to work or study.
15
+ - Out of scope: vending machines.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - States the approach (from people, or from places that sell) before starting.
20
+ - Splits the population into groups that buy coffee differently.
21
+ - Shows each step's arithmetic and keeps units consistent.
22
+ - Checks the result with a second, different method or a sense check.
23
+ - Gives a final number with a range and says which assumption matters most.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - How would your number change on a Sunday?
28
+ - A chain wants to know how many new cafés the city could support. How would you use your estimate?
@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
1
+ # P14 · The market for bike repair
2
+
3
+ Category: Estimation · Level: core · Time: 20 min
4
+
5
+ Estimate the yearly revenue of bicycle repair and servicing in a country of about 60 million people. A company is deciding whether to start a mobile repair service.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out which country or what kind of country, what counts as repair, and whether parts are included.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - A wealthy European country where cycling is common but not dominant.
12
+ - Repair means paid work by a shop or mechanic, including the parts they fit.
13
+ - Electric bikes are about a fifth of new bikes sold.
14
+ - Out of scope: selling new bikes or accessories.
15
+
16
+ ## What a strong answer covers
17
+
18
+ - States the approach and chooses a starting point that can be reasoned about.
19
+ - Separates bikes or riders into groups that need repair differently.
20
+ - Shows the arithmetic for each step with units.
21
+ - Sanity-checks the result in a second way.
22
+ - Turns the number into what it means for the company's decision.
23
+
24
+ ## Follow-ups
25
+
26
+ - The company only cares about cities over 200,000 people. How much of your number is left?
27
+ - Electric bikes double in five years. How does your estimate move?
@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
1
+ # P15 · Scooter rides on a summer day
2
+
3
+ Category: Estimation · Level: core · Time: 20 min
4
+
5
+ Estimate how many shared electric scooter rides happen on a summer weekday in a large city.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out the city's size, how many scooters are on the street and how people use them.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - A city of 4 million people, with three scooter companies operating.
12
+ - Scooters are allowed everywhere except a few parks.
13
+ - A ride costs about the same as a bus ticket for ten minutes.
14
+ - Out of scope: privately owned scooters.
15
+
16
+ ## What a strong answer covers
17
+
18
+ - States whether the estimate is built from the riders or from the scooters, and why.
19
+ - Breaks the day or the riders into parts that behave differently.
20
+ - Shows the arithmetic and keeps units straight.
21
+ - Checks the number against a second method or a limit (how many scooters there could be).
22
+ - Gives a range and names the assumption that moves it most.
23
+
24
+ ## Follow-ups
25
+
26
+ - It rains all day. What changes, and by how much?
27
+ - The city caps each company at 2,000 scooters. Does your number change?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P16 · School lunch box subscriptions
2
+
3
+ Category: Estimation · Level: advanced · Time: 20 min
4
+
5
+ A start-up wants to deliver ready-made, healthy lunch boxes to schoolchildren's homes each morning on a weekly subscription. Estimate the yearly revenue it could reach in one country if it does well.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out the country's size, what children eat at lunch today, the price and what "doing well" means.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - A country of 50 million people; about 6 million children of school age.
12
+ - Most schools serve a hot lunch; families can opt out and send a packed lunch.
13
+ - The planned price is about twice the cost of a school lunch.
14
+ - Doing well means winning a share of families similar to what meal-kit services reach.
15
+ - Out of scope: selling to schools directly.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Separates the whole market from the part this company could realistically reach.
20
+ - Narrows families by who would plausibly pay, with reasons for each cut.
21
+ - Shows the arithmetic, with weeks in a school year and price handled carefully.
22
+ - Sanity-checks the result in another way.
23
+ - Gives a range and says which assumption the start-up should test first.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - The company wants to reach one city first. How do you size that?
28
+ - Half the families subscribe for one term only. How does revenue change?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P17 · Weekly users fell 10%
2
+
3
+ Category: Analytical · Level: core · Time: 30 min
4
+
5
+ You are the product manager of a photo-sharing app. Weekly active users fell 10% last week compared with the week before. Find out why and say what you would do.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out how weekly active users are counted, whether the drop was sudden or gradual, and what changed recently.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - A user is active if they open the app at least once in the week.
12
+ - The drop happened over two days, in the middle of last week.
13
+ - A new app version went out to Android that week; nothing changed on iPhone.
14
+ - There was a public holiday in two of the app's biggest countries.
15
+ - Out of scope: the company's other apps.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Checks whether the drop is real (counting, logging, timing) before explaining it.
20
+ - Splits the drop into parts (platform, country, user type, step in the journey).
21
+ - Separates causes inside the product from causes outside it.
22
+ - Says which data would tell the explanations apart, in what order.
23
+ - Ends on a conclusion and what to do next, including who to tell.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - The drop is only on Android, but opens are flat; only posting fell. What does that change?
28
+ - It recovers by itself the next week. Do you still need to do anything?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P18 · Cancellations rose in one city
2
+
3
+ Category: Analytical · Level: core · Time: 30 min
4
+
5
+ A ride-hailing service sees cancelled rides rise from 8% to 13% of requests in one of its cities over a month, while other cities stay flat. Investigate.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out who is cancelling (riders or drivers), when cancellations happen, and what changed in that city.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - Both riders and drivers can cancel; the data says which one did.
12
+ - The rise is mostly riders cancelling after a driver was assigned.
13
+ - The city opened a large new train line during the month.
14
+ - The company changed how it matches drivers in that city two weeks before the rise began.
15
+ - Out of scope: pricing changes.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Defines the metric and checks it is measured the same way before and after.
20
+ - Breaks the rise down by who cancels, when in the ride, and where.
21
+ - Tests each explanation against the evidence rather than picking one early.
22
+ - Names the data that would confirm the cause.
23
+ - Recommends an action and what would show it worked.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - Cancellations are fine on weekends and up only on weekday mornings. What does that suggest you check?
28
+ - Fixing it would make waits a minute longer everywhere. Do you do it?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P19 · Sign-ups up, revenue flat
2
+
3
+ Category: Analytical · Level: advanced · Time: 30 min
4
+
5
+ An online course platform's new sign-ups rose 20% over the last quarter, but revenue stayed flat. Leadership asks you to explain it and say what to do.
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out how the platform makes money, where the new sign-ups came from, and what changed in the quarter.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - Revenue comes from paying for single courses and from a yearly membership.
12
+ - Marketing launched a free-course campaign on social media this quarter.
13
+ - The share of sign-ups who ever pay fell from 12% to 9%.
14
+ - Existing members renewed at the same rate as last year.
15
+ - Out of scope: changing course prices.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Breaks revenue into its parts and checks which part didn't move.
20
+ - Compares the new sign-ups with earlier ones before judging them.
21
+ - Considers that the result may be fine or even expected, not only a problem.
22
+ - Separates what is known from what needs more data.
23
+ - Recommends what to do and how to tell within one quarter whether it worked.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - The new sign-ups do pay, but three months later than before. What does that change?
28
+ - Marketing wants to double the campaign. What do you advise?
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1
+ # P20 · Sessions doubled after a redesign
2
+
3
+ Category: Analytical · Level: advanced · Time: 30 min
4
+
5
+ After a redesign of a banking app's home screen, the average session length doubled. The design team calls it a success. Is it?
6
+
7
+ Before you answer, find out what people come to the app to do, what the redesign changed, and how sessions are measured.
8
+
9
+ ## If you ask
10
+
11
+ - Most visits are to check a balance or make a payment.
12
+ - The redesign moved payments from the home screen into a menu and added spending charts.
13
+ - A session ends after 5 minutes without a tap.
14
+ - Complaints to customer support about payments rose slightly.
15
+ - Out of scope: the website.
16
+
17
+ ## What a strong answer covers
18
+
19
+ - Asks what a longer session means for this product before calling it good or bad.
20
+ - Looks for measures closer to what users come to do.
21
+ - Splits users and tasks to see where the time went.
22
+ - Uses the other evidence in the prompt rather than ignoring it.
23
+ - Gives a verdict, and what to change or test next.
24
+
25
+ ## Follow-ups
26
+
27
+ - Payments take longer, but the charts are used daily by a fifth of users. Now what?
28
+ - Leadership wants session length as a team goal. How do you respond?
@@ -0,0 +1,107 @@
1
+ # Product review protocol
2
+
3
+ The protocol the automatic reviewer follows after each product manager practice run (and anyone
4
+ reviewing one by hand: "review product P03"). The person practises without AI help. The review
5
+ comments only on what they wrote. **Never write the answer, never name the user group, idea, metric,
6
+ market move or number that would fix a gap, and never describe what a good answer contains.** For a
7
+ weak area, name the KIND of gap and the question they should ask themselves next time.
8
+
9
+ ## Before writing
10
+
11
+ 1. Read the prompt: `product/<Pnn-slug>/README.md`, including its `## If you ask` answers and its
12
+ `## What a strong answer covers` criteria. Its Category line says which kind of question it is:
13
+ Product sense, Execution, Strategy, Estimation or Analytical.
14
+ 2. Read the person's notes and timing (the app passes them in the review request).
15
+ 3. Read earlier reviews of the same prompt in `.reps/product/reviews/<Pnn>-*.md`, if any, and note
16
+ their gaps and "Next time" lines.
17
+
18
+ Do not run commands and do not write files: print the review only.
19
+
20
+ ## Scores
21
+
22
+ Score each dimension 1 to 4, with a one-line reason that points at their own notes (quote a few
23
+ words where it helps).
24
+
25
+ | Score | Meaning |
26
+ |---|---|
27
+ | 1 | Missing, or so thin it could not guide a decision. |
28
+ | 2 | Present, but vague, generic (it would fit any prompt), or not connected to the rest of the notes. |
29
+ | 3 | Solid: specific to this prompt, complete, and consistent with the other sections. |
30
+ | 4 | Interview-ready: specific, justified with their own reasons or numbers, and explained clearly. |
31
+
32
+ The dimensions, judged on the notes as written. Every kind of question is scored on all eight; the
33
+ line under each says how to read it for the kinds where it looks different.
34
+
35
+ - **goal**: Did they ask clarifying questions, use the answers in the prompt rather than assume, and
36
+ write down the goal, the constraints and what is out of scope before answering?
37
+ - **users**: Did they say who is served (or, for estimation, who is counted; for analytical, who is
38
+ affected), split them into groups that behave differently, and pick or weight them with a reason?
39
+ - **structure**: Did they state how they would attack the problem before diving in, and did the
40
+ rest of the notes follow it? Are the branches distinct and together complete for the prompt?
41
+ - **analysis**: Is the body of the answer deep and specific to this prompt?
42
+ - Product sense: the needs and problems are concrete and the ideas are varied, not one idea dressed three ways.
43
+ - Execution: the reasoning about the product's goals, the team and the evidence is sound.
44
+ - Strategy: the market, the company's strengths and the competition are reasoned about, not asserted.
45
+ - Estimation: every step's arithmetic is shown, the units and orders of magnitude are plausible, and the result is sanity-checked another way.
46
+ - Analytical: they check that the change is real before explaining it, split it into parts, and name the data that would tell the explanations apart.
47
+ - **prioritization**: Did they compare options against criteria they stated, and choose? For
48
+ estimation, did they say which assumption moves the answer most?
49
+ - **metrics**: Is there one main measure that follows from the goal, with a guardrail and a sense of
50
+ how it would be read (time frame, comparison)? For estimation, is the final number stated with its
51
+ unit and a range?
52
+ - **trade-offs**: For their main choice, did they say what it costs, what could go wrong, and what
53
+ they gave up?
54
+ - **communication**: Are the notes ordered and readable by someone else? Do they end on a clear
55
+ recommendation or answer? Did the run fit the target time, and do the later sections show the time
56
+ reached them? Only the total time is recorded, so never guess how long each section took.
57
+
58
+ The prompt's `## What a strong answer covers` list is the checklist for this prompt: use it to judge
59
+ the dimensions, but never quote it back as the answer.
60
+
61
+ ## Verdict
62
+
63
+ - **solid** only if no dimension scores below 3 **and** the run finished within the target time.
64
+ - Otherwise **redo**.
65
+
66
+ ## Gaps
67
+
68
+ Use only these tags, comma-separated, or `none`:
69
+
70
+ | Tag | Use when |
71
+ |---|---|
72
+ | `product:goal` | goal scored 1-2, or later sections contradict or ignore the goal they set |
73
+ | `product:users` | users scored 1-2 |
74
+ | `product:structure` | structure scored 1-2 |
75
+ | `product:analysis` | analysis scored 1-2, or the arithmetic has an error that changes the answer |
76
+ | `product:prioritization` | prioritization scored 1-2: options listed but no choice, or a choice without criteria |
77
+ | `product:metrics` | metrics scored 1-2, or the main measure doesn't follow from the goal |
78
+ | `product:trade-offs` | trade-offs scored 1-2 |
79
+ | `product:recommendation` | the notes end without a clear recommendation or final answer |
80
+ | `product:pacing` | over the target time, or the early sections are full and the later ones empty or thin |
81
+ | `communication` | communication scored 1-2 |
82
+
83
+ ## The review
84
+
85
+ Print exactly these header lines first (they are parsed by the app, so keep the form):
86
+
87
+ ```
88
+ # Product review <Pnn> · <prompt name>
89
+ Prompt: <Pnn>
90
+ Date: YYYY-MM-DD
91
+ Verdict: solid | redo
92
+ Scores: goal <1-4>, users <1-4>, structure <1-4>, analysis <1-4>, prioritization <1-4>, metrics <1-4>, trade-offs <1-4>, communication <1-4>
93
+ Gaps: <tags, or none>
94
+ Next time: <one concrete habit for the next run>
95
+ ```
96
+
97
+ Then, briefly:
98
+
99
+ 1. **Scores, one line each**: the dimension, the score, the reason from their notes.
100
+ 2. **Time**: total minutes against the target, and which sections are empty or thin.
101
+ 3. **What went well**: one or two specific things worth keeping.
102
+ 4. **Weakest areas**: for each dimension below 3, the kind of gap and the question to ask
103
+ yourself (for example "the ideas stop at one: what else could solve the same problem?").
104
+ Never the answer.
105
+ 5. **Did last time's feedback stick?** Compare with the earlier reviews of this prompt: say plainly
106
+ whether their gaps came back or were fixed. Skip if this is the first run.
107
+ 6. **Next time**: one habit, the same as the header line, with a sentence on how to practise it.