imapkit 0.0.0-stage → 4.0.0

package/lib/plugins/acl.js

@@ -0,0 +1,964 @@
+'use strict';
+
+const { states } = require('../command-states');
+const { normalizeSystemFlag, checkSystemFlags } = require('../commands/handlers/flags');
+const builtinStoreHandlers = require('../commands/handlers/store');
+const { getListExtensions } = require('../list-extensions');
+const { beginSelect } = require('../commands/select');
+const { getPendingTarget } = require('../commands/append');
+const { isAstring } = require('../arguments');
+
+/**
+ * @help Adds ACL [RFC4314] capability with RIGHTS=texk
+ * @help The owner (server option "aclOwner", default "testuser")
+ * @help has all rights on every mailbox. Other users get rights
+ * @help from the "acl" property of a mailbox in storage, e.g.
+ * @help {"otheruser": "lr", "anyone": "l"}, or from SETACL. With
+ * @help LIST-EXTENDED, LIST-MYRIGHTS [RFC8440] is supported as well
+ *
+ * ACL: https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc4314
+ *
+ * LIST-MYRIGHTS: https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8440
+ *
+ * Additional commands:
+ * - SETACL, DELETEACL, GETACL, LISTRIGHTS, MYRIGHTS
+ * - the MYRIGHTS return option of LIST, when LIST-EXTENDED is loaded
+ *
+ * Users other than the owner can only do what their rights allow (RFC 4314 section 4).
+ */
+
+// RFC 4314 section 2.1, in the order they are listed in responses
+const RIGHTS = 'lrswipkxtea';
+const ALL_RIGHTS = new Set(RIGHTS);
+// RFC 4314 section 2.1.1: the obsolete "c" and "d" rights are macros. Like Dovecot, "c" is "kx"
+// ("create" for servers that used "c" for DELETE) and "d" is "et"
+const VIRTUAL_RIGHTS = { c: 'kx', d: 'et' };
+// RFC 4314 section 5.2: with none of these the mailbox is READ-ONLY. All flags are shared between
+// the users of a mailbox, so the "shared flag rights" are "s", "w" and "t"
+const WRITE_RIGHTS = ['i', 'e', 's', 'w', 't'];
+// RFC 4314 section 4: the rights for changing flags
+const FLAG_RIGHTS = ['s', 'w', 't'];
+// RFC 4314 section 4: MYRIGHTS needs any of these
+const ANY_RIGHTS = ['l', 'r', 'i', 'k', 'x', 'a'];
+const STORE_ITEMS = ['FLAGS', '+FLAGS', '-FLAGS', 'FLAGS.SILENT', '+FLAGS.SILENT', '-FLAGS.SILENT'];
+
+/**
+ * Formats an astring for a response. The compiler sends an ATOM value that is not a valid atom as a
+ * quoted string or a literal, only a leading "\\" (allowed for flags) and NIL have to be kept away from it
+ *
+ * @param {String} value
+ * @return {Object|String}
+ */
+function astring(value) {
+    // identifiers are unicode strings, sent as UTF-8 (RFC 4314 section 3)
+    value = Buffer.from(value, 'utf-8').toString('binary');
+    // an atom NIL would read back as NIL, not as an identifier
+    return value && value.charAt(0) !== '\\' && !/^NIL$/i.test(value) ? { type: 'ATOM', value } : value;
+}
+
+/**
+ * Creates an error that is answered with BAD
+ *
+ * @param {String} message Error text
+ * @return {Error}
+ */
+function badInput(message) {
+    const err = new Error(message);
+    err.imapResponse = 'BAD';
+    return err;
+}
+
+/**
+ * Parses a rights string, the virtual "c" and "d" rights are expanded (RFC 4314 section 2.1.1)
+ *
+ * @param {String} value Rights, e.g. "lrswd"
+ * @return {Set} rights
+ * @throws {Error} BAD error for unknown rights (RFC 4314 section 3.1)
+ */
+function parseRights(value) {
+    const rights = new Set();
+    for (const chr of value) {
+        if (ALL_RIGHTS.has(chr)) {
+            rights.add(chr);
+        } else if (Object.hasOwn(VIRTUAL_RIGHTS, chr)) {
+            VIRTUAL_RIGHTS[chr].split('').forEach(right => rights.add(right));
+        } else if (/^[A-Z]$/.test(chr)) {
+            throw badInput('Uppercase rights are not allowed');
+        } else {
+            throw badInput('The ' + (/^[\x21-\x7e]$/.test(chr) ? chr + ' ' : '') + 'right is not supported');
+        }
+    }
+    return rights;
+}
+
+/**
+ * Builds the attributes of an ACL, LISTRIGHTS or MYRIGHTS response. The mailbox name is a MAILBOX
+ * attribute, so each session gets it in the form it uses (modified UTF-7, or UTF-8 after ENABLE
+ * UTF8=ACCEPT)
+ *
+ * @param {Object} mailbox Mailbox object
+ * @param {Array} values Values that follow the mailbox name
+ * @return {Array} Response attributes
+ */
+function mailboxResponse(mailbox, values) {
+    return [{ type: 'MAILBOX', value: mailbox.path }].concat(values.map(astring));
+}
+
+/**
+ * Formats rights for ACL and MYRIGHTS responses. "c" and "d" are added when any of their
+ * member rights is set (RFC 4314 section 2.1.1)
+ *
+ * @param {Set} rights
+ * @return {String}
+ */
+function formatRights(rights) {
+    let result = RIGHTS.split('')
+        .filter(right => rights.has(right))
+        .join('');
+    Object.keys(VIRTUAL_RIGHTS).forEach(virtual => {
+        if (VIRTUAL_RIGHTS[virtual].split('').some(right => rights.has(right))) {
+            result += virtual;
+        }
+    });
+    return result;
+}
+
+/**
+ * Checks an identifier argument. RFC 4314 section 3 asks for SASLprep, which is not implemented,
+ * but an identifier that SASLprep would refuse (control characters, invalid UTF-8) or that is
+ * empty gets BAD, as does a lone "-" (section 2: "-" prefixes the identifier of a negative right)
+ *
+ * @param {String} identifier Identifier as a binary string
+ * @return {String|Boolean} error text, or false if the identifier is fine
+ */
+function identifierError(identifier) {
+    if (!identifier || identifier === '-') {
+        return 'Empty identifier';
+    }
+    // eslint-disable-next-line no-control-regex
+    if (/[\x00-\x1f\x7f]/.test(identifier)) {
+        return 'Identifier contains control characters';
+    }
+    const decoded = Buffer.from(identifier, 'binary').toString('utf-8');
+    if (Buffer.from(decoded, 'utf-8').toString('binary') !== identifier) {
+        return 'Identifier is not valid UTF-8';
+    }
+    return false;
+}
+
+module.exports = function (server) {
+    server.registerCapability('ACL');
+    // RFC 4314 section 5.1.1: the rights not defined in RFC 2086, MUST include "t", "e", "x" and "k"
+    server.registerCapability('RIGHTS=texk');
+
+    const owner = typeof server.options.aclOwner === 'string' ? server.options.aclOwner : 'testuser';
+
+    const isOwner = connection => connection.username === owner;
+
+    /**
+     * Returns the ACL of a mailbox as a Map of identifier to a Set of rights. The ACL from the
+     * storage (an object of identifier to rights string) is converted on first use
+     *
+     * @param {Object} mailbox Mailbox object
+     * @return {Map}
+     */
+    const getAcl = mailbox => {
+        if (!(mailbox.acl instanceof Map)) {
+            const acl = new Map();
+            const source = mailbox.acl && typeof mailbox.acl === 'object' ? mailbox.acl : {};
+            Object.keys(source).forEach(identifier => {
+                try {
+                    acl.set(identifier, parseRights(String(source[identifier])));
+                } catch (err) {
+                    // not a client error, so this is answered with NO [SERVERBUG]
+                    throw new Error('Invalid ACL in storage for ' + mailbox.path + ': ' + err.message, { cause: err });
+                }
+            });
+            mailbox.acl = acl;
+        }
+        return mailbox.acl;
+    };
+
+    /**
+     * Returns the rights a user has on a mailbox. The owner has all rights, other users get the
+     * union of the rights of their own identifier and "anyone", minus the negative rights of
+     * "-user" and "-anyone" (RFC 4314 section 2)
+     *
+     * @param {Object} connection IMAP connection of the user
+     * @param {Object} mailbox Mailbox object
+     * @param {Map} [acl] ACL to use instead of the current one of the mailbox
+     * @return {Set} rights
+     */
+    const getRights = (connection, mailbox, acl) => {
+        const username = connection.username;
+        if (username === owner) {
+            return ALL_RIGHTS;
+        }
+        acl = acl || getAcl(mailbox);
+        const identifiers = ['anyone'].concat(typeof username === 'string' && username ? username : []);
+        const rights = new Set();
+        identifiers.forEach(identifier => (acl.get(identifier) || []).forEach(right => rights.add(right)));
+        identifiers.forEach(identifier => (acl.get('-' + identifier) || []).forEach(right => rights.delete(right)));
+        return rights;
+    };
+
+    // for plugins that report only what a user may see (e.g. NOTIFY)
+    server.acl = { getRights, isOwner };
+
+    // Tells plugins that the ACL of a mailbox changed, with an `acl` event `(mailbox, previousAcl)`
+    const changeAcl = (mailbox, change) => {
+        const acl = getAcl(mailbox);
+        const previous = new Map(acl);
+        change(acl);
+        server.emit('acl', mailbox, previous);
+    };
+
+    // CATENATE (RFC 4469 section 5): reading a message through an IMAP URL needs the "r" right, a
+    // mailbox without "l" is reported like one that does not exist (RFC 4314 section 6)
+    server.urlAccessChecks.push((connection, mailbox) => {
+        const rights = getRights(connection, mailbox);
+        if (!rights.has('r')) {
+            return { text: rights.has('l') ? 'Permission denied' : 'Mailbox does not exist' };
+        }
+        return false;
+    });
+
+    // MULTISEARCH (RFC 7377 section 2.2): searching needs "r", and "l" for a mailbox that the client did not name.
+    // Other mailboxes are left out without an error
+    server.searchAccessChecks.push((connection, mailbox, named) => {
+        const rights = getRights(connection, mailbox);
+        return rights.has('r') && (named || rights.has('l'));
+    });
+
+    // Rights on the selected mailbox are taken when it is selected (RFC 4314 section 5.1.1 allows caching
+    // them), so the FLAGS and PERMANENTFLAGS a session got stay correct until the next SELECT
+    const getSelectedRights = connection => connection.aclRights || ALL_RIGHTS;
+
+    // RFC 4314 section 4: "t" for \Deleted, "s" for \Seen and "w" for all other flags
+    const flagRight = flag => {
+        flag = normalizeSystemFlag(flag);
+        if (flag === '\\Deleted') {
+            return 't';
+        }
+        if (flag === '\\Seen') {
+            return 's';
+        }
+        return 'w';
+    };
+
+    const flagValue = flag => (typeof flag === 'string' ? flag : String((flag && flag.value) || ''));
+
+    const canSetFlag = (rights, flag) => rights.has(flagRight(flagValue(flag)));
+
+    const mailboxArgument = (parsed, position) => {
+        const attr = (parsed.attributes || [])[position];
+        return isAstring(attr) ? attr.value : false;
+    };
+
+    // the mailbox named by an argument, false if there is no such mailbox or the argument is invalid
+    const argumentMailbox = (parsed, position) => {
+        const name = mailboxArgument(parsed, position);
+        return (name !== false && server.getMailbox(name)) || false;
+    };
+
+    const sendNoPerm = (connection, parsed, data, description) => connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'NO', 'Permission denied', 'NOPERM', description);
+
+    /**
+     * Refuses a command for lack of rights. Without the "l" right the user gets the same error
+     * as for a mailbox that does not exist, so the existence of the mailbox is not disclosed
+     * (RFC 4314 section 6), otherwise NO [NOPERM] (RFC 5530 section 3)
+     */
+    const sendDenied = (connection, parsed, data, rights, description, notFound) => {
+        if (rights.has('l')) {
+            sendNoPerm(connection, parsed, data, description);
+        } else if (notFound === 'TRYCREATE') {
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'NO', 'Target mailbox does not exist', 'TRYCREATE', description);
+        } else {
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'NO', 'Mailbox does not exist', 'NONEXISTENT', description);
+        }
+    };
+
+    /**
+     * Finds the nearest existing parent of a mailbox name (RFC 4314 section 4, CREATE)
+     *
+     * @param {String} path Mailbox path
+     * @return {Object|Boolean} parent mailbox or false if there is none
+     */
+    const getParent = path => {
+        for (let parent = server.getParentPath(path); parent; parent = server.getParentPath(parent)) {
+            const mailbox = server.getMailbox(parent);
+            if (mailbox) {
+                return mailbox;
+            }
+        }
+        return false;
+    };
+
+    // Checks for the ACL commands, true if the command can go ahead
+    const checkAclCommand = (connection, parsed, data, mailbox, isAllowed) => {
+        if (!mailbox) {
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'NO', 'Mailbox does not exist', 'NONEXISTENT');
+            return false;
+        }
+        const rights = getRights(connection, mailbox);
+        if (!isAllowed(rights)) {
+            sendDenied(connection, parsed, data, rights, false);
+            return false;
+        }
+        return true;
+    };
+
+    const hasAdmin = rights => rights.has('a');
+
+    /**
+     * Validates the arguments of an ACL command: `count` astrings, the first one a mailbox name and
+     * the second one (if any) an identifier
+     *
+     * @return {Boolean} true if the arguments are fine, otherwise BAD was sent
+     */
+    const checkArguments = (connection, parsed, data, count) => {
+        const args = parsed.attributes || [];
+        const command = parsed.command.toUpperCase();
+        if (args.length !== count || args.some(arg => !isAstring(arg))) {
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'BAD', command + ' expects ' + (count === 1 ? 'a mailbox name' : count + ' string arguments'));
+            return false;
+        }
+        const error = count > 1 && identifierError(args[1].value);
+        if (error) {
+            // RFC 4314 section 3: an identifier that fails preparation is refused with BAD
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'BAD', error);
+            return false;
+        }
+        if (count > 1) {
+            // user names and identifiers are unicode strings, whatever way the user logged in
+            args[1].value = Buffer.from(args[1].value, 'binary').toString('utf-8');
+        }
+        return true;
+    };
+
+    // RFC 4314 section 2: an implementation MAY force rights to always be granted to an identifier
+    const refuseOwnerIdentifier = (connection, parsed, data) => {
+        const identifier = parsed.attributes[1].value;
+        if (identifier !== owner && identifier !== '-' + owner) {
+            return false;
+        }
+        connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'NO', 'Rights of the mailbox owner can not be changed', 'CANNOT');
+        return true;
+    };
+
+    const aclCommand = (count, handler) => (connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        if (checkArguments(connection, parsed, data, count)) {
+            handler(connection, parsed, data, server.getMailbox(parsed.attributes[0].value));
+        }
+        callback();
+    };
+
+    const aclOptions = { states: states.AUTHENTICATED, mailboxArguments: [0] };
+    // RFC 4314 section 7: identifier and mod-rights are astrings
+    const identifierOptions = Object.assign({ astringArguments: [1] }, aclOptions);
+
+    // RFC 4314 section 3.8: myrights-data = "MYRIGHTS" SP mailbox SP rights
+    const sendMyRights = (connection, mailbox, parsed, data) =>
+        connection.send(
+            { tag: '*', command: 'MYRIGHTS', attributes: mailboxResponse(mailbox, [formatRights(getRights(connection, mailbox))]) },
+            'MYRIGHTS',
+            parsed,
+            data,
+            mailbox
+        );
+
+    // RFC 8440 section 3: the MYRIGHTS return option of an extended LIST. The registry is shared with
+    // LIST-EXTENDED, which accepts the option only when it is loaded, in any load order
+    const listExtensions = getListExtensions(server);
+    server.registerCapability('LIST-MYRIGHTS', () => listExtensions.enabled);
+    listExtensions.returnOptions.MYRIGHTS = {
+        // a MYRIGHTS response follows the LIST response of every listed mailbox that matches the
+        // selection criteria and exists, not the ones listed only for CHILDINFO or as \NonExistent
+        onItem: (connection, folder, value, info, parsed, data) => {
+            if (info.matched && info.exists) {
+                sendMyRights(connection, folder, parsed, data);
+            }
+        }
+    };
+
+    // RFC 4314 section 3.1
+    server.setCommandHandler(
+        'SETACL',
+        aclCommand(3, (connection, parsed, data, mailbox) => {
+            const identifier = parsed.attributes[1].value;
+            const modification = parsed.attributes[2].value;
+            const mode = /^[+-]/.test(modification) ? modification.charAt(0) : '';
+
+            // an unrecognized right MUST cause BAD, before anything else is checked
+            const rights = parseRights(modification.substr(mode.length));
+
+            if (!checkAclCommand(connection, parsed, data, mailbox, hasAdmin) || refuseOwnerIdentifier(connection, parsed, data)) {
+                return;
+            }
+
+            changeAcl(mailbox, acl => {
+                const current = new Set(acl.get(identifier) || []);
+                if (mode === '+') {
+                    rights.forEach(right => current.add(right));
+                } else if (mode === '-') {
+                    rights.forEach(right => current.delete(right));
+                }
+                const updated = mode ? current : rights;
+                if (updated.size) {
+                    acl.set(identifier, updated);
+                } else {
+                    acl.delete(identifier);
+                }
+            });
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'OK', 'Setacl complete');
+        }),
+        Object.assign({ astringArguments: [1, 2] }, aclOptions)
+    );
+
+    // RFC 4314 section 3.2
+    server.setCommandHandler(
+        'DELETEACL',
+        aclCommand(2, (connection, parsed, data, mailbox) => {
+            if (!checkAclCommand(connection, parsed, data, mailbox, hasAdmin) || refuseOwnerIdentifier(connection, parsed, data)) {
+                return;
+            }
+            changeAcl(mailbox, acl => acl.delete(parsed.attributes[1].value));
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'OK', 'Deleteacl complete');
+        }),
+        identifierOptions
+    );
+
+    // RFC 4314 sections 3.3 and 3.6
+    server.setCommandHandler(
+        'GETACL',
+        aclCommand(1, (connection, parsed, data, mailbox) => {
+            if (!checkAclCommand(connection, parsed, data, mailbox, hasAdmin)) {
+                return;
+            }
+            const attributes = [owner, formatRights(ALL_RIGHTS)];
+            getAcl(mailbox).forEach((rights, identifier) => {
+                attributes.push(identifier, formatRights(rights));
+            });
+            connection.send({ tag: '*', command: 'ACL', attributes: mailboxResponse(mailbox, attributes) }, 'ACL', parsed, data, mailbox);
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'OK', 'Getacl complete');
+        }),
+        aclOptions
+    );
+
+    // RFC 4314 sections 3.4 and 3.7
+    server.setCommandHandler(
+        'LISTRIGHTS',
+        aclCommand(2, (connection, parsed, data, mailbox) => {
+            if (!checkAclCommand(connection, parsed, data, mailbox, hasAdmin)) {
+                return;
+            }
+            // the identifier is sent back in the same form as the client used
+            const identifier = parsed.attributes[1].value;
+            let attributes;
+            if (identifier === owner) {
+                // the owner always has every right, nothing is optional
+                attributes = [identifier, formatRights(ALL_RIGHTS)];
+            } else {
+                // nothing is granted always, every right can be granted on its own, including the virtual ones
+                attributes = [identifier, ''].concat(RIGHTS.split(''), Object.keys(VIRTUAL_RIGHTS));
+            }
+            connection.send({ tag: '*', command: 'LISTRIGHTS', attributes: mailboxResponse(mailbox, attributes) }, 'LISTRIGHTS', parsed, data, mailbox);
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'OK', 'Listrights complete');
+        }),
+        identifierOptions
+    );
+
+    // RFC 4314 sections 3.5 and 3.8
+    server.setCommandHandler(
+        'MYRIGHTS',
+        aclCommand(1, (connection, parsed, data, mailbox) => {
+            if (!checkAclCommand(connection, parsed, data, mailbox, rights => ANY_RIGHTS.some(right => rights.has(right)))) {
+                return;
+            }
+            sendMyRights(connection, mailbox, parsed, data);
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, 'OK', 'Myrights complete');
+        }),
+        aclOptions
+    );
+
+    // Enforcement (RFC 4314 section 4). Commands are wrapped once every plugin is loaded, so that
+    // the commands of every plugin (MOVE, UID EXPUNGE, ...) are covered whatever the load order is
+    const wrappers = {};
+    // the handlers that the enforcement wraps
+    const prevHandlers = {};
+    const wrapCommands = () => {
+        Object.keys(wrappers).forEach(command => {
+            const prevHandler = server.getCommandHandler(command);
+            if (prevHandler) {
+                prevHandlers[command] = prevHandler;
+                server.setCommandHandler(command, (connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+                    if (isOwner(connection)) {
+                        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+                    }
+                    return wrappers[command](prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback);
+                });
+            }
+        });
+
+        // Return options of an extended LIST (LIST-STATUS, LIST-MYRIGHTS) add responses for the listed
+        // mailboxes, so they skip the mailboxes that are not listed for the user. STATUS also needs "r"
+        // (RFC 5819 section 2: the STATUS response MUST NOT be returned if the mailbox can not be selected)
+        Object.keys(listExtensions.returnOptions).forEach(name => {
+            const option = listExtensions.returnOptions[name];
+            if (typeof option.onItem !== 'function') {
+                return;
+            }
+            const onItem = option.onItem;
+            const right = name === 'STATUS' ? 'r' : 'l';
+            option.onItem = (connection, folder, ...args) => {
+                if (isOwner(connection)) {
+                    return onItem(connection, folder, ...args);
+                }
+                const rights = getRights(connection, folder);
+                if (rights.has('l') && rights.has(right)) {
+                    return onItem(connection, folder, ...args);
+                }
+            };
+        });
+
+        // RFC 4314 section 4: STORE changes only the flags the user has rights for
+        STORE_ITEMS.forEach(item => {
+            const prevHandler = server.storeHandlers[item] || builtinStoreHandlers[item];
+            server.storeHandlers[item] = (connection, message, flags, ...args) => {
+                const rights = getSelectedRights(connection);
+                if (FLAG_RIGHTS.every(right => rights.has(right))) {
+                    return prevHandler(connection, message, flags, ...args);
+                }
+                flags = [].concat(flags);
+                // invalid flags are still refused with BAD, even if the user could not set them anyway
+                flags.forEach(flag => checkSystemFlags(connection, normalizeSystemFlag(flagValue(flag))));
+                let allowed = flags.filter(flag => canSetFlag(rights, flag));
+                if (item.charAt(0) !== '+' && item.charAt(0) !== '-') {
+                    // replacing the flags keeps the ones the user can not change
+                    allowed = message.flags.filter(flag => !canSetFlag(rights, flag)).concat(allowed);
+                }
+                return prevHandler(connection, message, allowed, ...args);
+            };
+        });
+    };
+
+    server.once('pluginsLoaded', wrapCommands);
+
+    const selectWrapper = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const mailbox = argumentMailbox(parsed, 0);
+        if (!mailbox) {
+            return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+        }
+        const command = parsed.command.toUpperCase();
+        const rights = getRights(connection, mailbox);
+        if (!rights.has('r')) {
+            // a failed SELECT leaves no mailbox selected (RFC 3501 section 6.3.1)
+            beginSelect(connection, parsed, data);
+            connection.closeMailbox();
+            sendDenied(connection, parsed, data, rights, command + ' FAILED');
+            return callback();
+        }
+        connection.aclRights = rights;
+        if (command === 'SELECT' && !WRITE_RIGHTS.some(right => rights.has(right))) {
+            // RFC 4314 section 5.2: the server MUST answer READ-ONLY, so the mailbox is opened like EXAMINE does
+            return prevHandlers.EXAMINE(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+    wrappers.SELECT = selectWrapper;
+    wrappers.EXAMINE = selectWrapper;
+
+    // Checks that the user has a right on the mailbox named by an argument. Unknown mailboxes and
+    // invalid arguments are left to the command handler
+    const hasMailboxRight = (right, position, notFound) => (connection, parsed, data) => {
+        const mailbox = argumentMailbox(parsed, position);
+        const rights = mailbox && getRights(connection, mailbox);
+        if (rights && !rights.has(right)) {
+            sendDenied(connection, parsed, data, rights, false, notFound);
+            return false;
+        }
+        return true;
+    };
+
+    const requireRight = (right, position, notFound) => {
+        const check = hasMailboxRight(right, position, notFound);
+        return (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) =>
+            check(connection, parsed, data) ? prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback) : callback();
+    };
+
+    wrappers.STATUS = requireRight('r', 0);
+    // SUBSCRIBE checks that the mailbox exists, so it needs "l". UNSUBSCRIBE needs no rights
+    wrappers.SUBSCRIBE = requireRight('l', 0);
+
+    wrappers.DELETE = requireRight('x', 0);
+
+    // CREATE needs "k" on the nearest existing parent, a mailbox at the top level can not be created
+    const checkCreateRight = (connection, parsed, data, path) => {
+        const parent = getParent(path);
+        if (!parent || !getRights(connection, parent).has('k')) {
+            sendNoPerm(connection, parsed, data);
+            return false;
+        }
+        return true;
+    };
+
+    wrappers.CREATE = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const name = mailboxArgument(parsed, 0);
+        if (name !== false && !checkCreateRight(connection, parsed, data, name)) {
+            return callback();
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+
+    // RENAME needs "x" on the mailbox and "k" on the new parent
+    const hasRenameRight = hasMailboxRight('x', 0);
+    wrappers.RENAME = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        if (!hasRenameRight(connection, parsed, data)) {
+            return callback();
+        }
+        const name = mailboxArgument(parsed, 1);
+        if (name !== false && argumentMailbox(parsed, 0) && !checkCreateRight(connection, parsed, data, name)) {
+            return callback();
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+
+    // APPEND needs "i", and only the flags the user has rights for are stored
+    wrappers.APPEND = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const mailbox = argumentMailbox(parsed, 0);
+        if (!mailbox) {
+            return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+        }
+        const rights = getRights(connection, mailbox);
+        if (!rights.has('i')) {
+            sendDenied(connection, parsed, data, rights, 'APPEND FAILED', 'TRYCREATE');
+            return callback();
+        }
+        const flags = parsed.attributes[1];
+        if (Array.isArray(flags) && flags.every(flag => flag && flag.type === 'ATOM')) {
+            try {
+                flags.forEach(flag => checkSystemFlags(connection, normalizeSystemFlag(flag.value)));
+                // the server MUST NOT fail APPEND for flags the user can not set
+                parsed.attributes[1] = flags.filter(flag => canSetFlag(rights, flag));
+            } catch {
+                // invalid flags are refused with BAD by the APPEND handler
+            }
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+
+    // the refusal for a target mailbox without "i", see sendDenied
+    const insertRefusal = (connection, mailbox) => {
+        const rights = mailbox ? getRights(connection, mailbox) : false;
+        if (!rights || rights.has('i')) {
+            return false;
+        }
+        return rights.has('l')
+            ? { command: 'NO', code: 'NOPERM', text: 'Permission denied' }
+            : { command: 'NO', code: 'TRYCREATE', text: 'Target mailbox does not exist' };
+    };
+
+    // COPY and MOVE need "i" on the target, MOVE also needs what UID STORE \Deleted and UID EXPUNGE
+    // need on the source, "t" and "e" (RFC 6851 section 4.2)
+    const requireInsert = requireRight('i', 1, 'TRYCREATE');
+    const copyWrapper = isMove => (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const command = parsed.command.toUpperCase();
+        if (isMove && !connection.readOnly) {
+            const rights = getSelectedRights(connection);
+            if (!rights.has('t') || !rights.has('e')) {
+                sendNoPerm(connection, parsed, data, command + ' FAIL');
+                return callback();
+            }
+        }
+        return requireInsert(prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+    wrappers.COPY = copyWrapper(false);
+    wrappers['UID COPY'] = copyWrapper(false);
+    wrappers.MOVE = copyWrapper(true);
+    wrappers['UID MOVE'] = copyWrapper(true);
+
+    // RFC 8508 section 4.1: REPLACE needs the rights of UID STORE (\Deleted, "t") and UID EXPUNGE ("e") on the
+    // selected mailbox, and of APPEND ("i") on the target. A read-only session is refused by the command handler
+    const replaceRefusal = (connection, mailbox) => {
+        const selected = getSelectedRights(connection);
+        if (!connection.readOnly && (!selected.has('t') || !selected.has('e'))) {
+            return { command: 'NO', code: 'NOPERM', text: 'Permission denied' };
+        }
+        return insertRefusal(connection, mailbox);
+    };
+    const replaceWrapper = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const refusal = replaceRefusal(connection, argumentMailbox(parsed, 1));
+        if (refusal) {
+            connection.sendStatus(parsed, data, refusal.command, refusal.text, refusal.code, parsed.command.toUpperCase() + ' FAILED');
+            return callback();
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+    wrappers.REPLACE = replaceWrapper;
+    wrappers['UID REPLACE'] = replaceWrapper;
+
+    // The message literal of APPEND and REPLACE is refused before it is sent when the user may not add messages to the
+    // target, with the same answer as after the literal. A mailbox the user can not see ("l") is refused like a
+    // missing one, which the core literal filter refuses before the literal too, so the transcripts do not tell
+    // a hidden mailbox from a missing one (RFC 4314 section 6)
+    server.literalFilters.unshift((connection, command, line) => {
+        if (isOwner(connection) || connection.isBusy()) {
+            return false;
+        }
+        const path = getPendingTarget(connection, command, line);
+        const mailbox = path !== false && server.getMailbox(path);
+        if (!mailbox) {
+            return false;
+        }
+        return command === 'APPEND' ? insertRefusal(connection, mailbox) : replaceRefusal(connection, mailbox);
+    });
+
+    // RFC 5464 section 3.3: mailbox annotations need "l" and any of "r", "s", "w", "i" or "p". Server
+    // annotations (the empty mailbox name) are not covered by mailbox ACLs
+    const METADATA_RIGHTS = ['r', 's', 'w', 'i', 'p'];
+    const canUseMetadata = rights => rights.has('l') && METADATA_RIGHTS.some(right => rights.has(right));
+    const metadataWrapper = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const args = parsed.attributes || [];
+        // GETMETADATA takes its options before the mailbox name (RFC 5464 errata 2785)
+        const position = parsed.command.toUpperCase() === 'GETMETADATA' && Array.isArray(args[0]) ? 1 : 0;
+        const mailbox = argumentMailbox(parsed, position);
+        if (mailbox && mailboxArgument(parsed, position) !== '') {
+            const rights = getRights(connection, mailbox);
+            if (!canUseMetadata(rights)) {
+                sendDenied(connection, parsed, data, rights, false);
+                return callback();
+            }
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+    wrappers.GETMETADATA = metadataWrapper;
+    wrappers.SETMETADATA = metadataWrapper;
+
+    // Unsolicited METADATA responses (RFC 5464 section 4.4.2) only go to sessions that could read the
+    // annotations of the mailbox. Server annotations have an empty mailbox name
+    server.notifyFilters.push((connection, notification) => {
+        const command = notification.command || {};
+        if (command.command !== 'METADATA' || isOwner(connection)) {
+            return true;
+        }
+        const name = command.attributes && command.attributes[0];
+        const path = name && typeof name === 'object' ? name.value : name;
+        const mailbox = typeof path === 'string' && path !== '' && server.getMailbox(path);
+        return !mailbox || canUseMetadata(getRights(connection, mailbox));
+    });
+
+    // RFC 9208 section 6: GETQUOTA needs no rights. GETQUOTAROOT needs "r" for the MESSAGE and STORAGE
+    // resources, which tell about the messages of the mailbox, only MAILBOX needs no right. Without "r"
+    // (or for a mailbox that does not exist, so nothing is disclosed) the QUOTA responses only list MAILBOX
+    wrappers.GETQUOTAROOT = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const mailbox = argumentMailbox(parsed, 0);
+        if (!mailbox || !getRights(connection, mailbox).has('r')) {
+            parsed.aclQuotaMailboxOnly = true;
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+
+    // RFC 9208 section 6: SETQUOTA needs "a". The quota root is not a mailbox, so the user needs "a" on
+    // every mailbox the quota root applies to (all personal mailboxes)
+    wrappers.SETQUOTA = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const args = parsed.attributes || [];
+        if (args.length === 2 && Array.isArray(args[1])) {
+            const isAdmin = Object.keys(server.folderCache).every(path => {
+                const mailbox = server.folderCache[path];
+                return !server.isPersonal(mailbox) || getRights(connection, mailbox).has('a');
+            });
+            if (!isAdmin) {
+                sendNoPerm(connection, parsed, data);
+                return callback();
+            }
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+
+    // EXPUNGE needs "e". In a read-only session the command handler refuses it already
+    const expungeWrapper = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        if (!connection.readOnly && !getSelectedRights(connection).has('e')) {
+            sendNoPerm(connection, parsed, data);
+            return callback();
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+    wrappers.EXPUNGE = expungeWrapper;
+    wrappers['UID EXPUNGE'] = expungeWrapper;
+
+    // UNAUTHENTICATE (RFC 8437): rights of the previous user must not stay with the session
+    server.resetHandlers.push(connection => {
+        connection.aclRights = null;
+    });
+
+    server.connectionHandlers.push(connection => {
+        // A FETCH that implies setting \Seen MUST NOT set it without "s", and without "e" CLOSE MUST
+        // close the mailbox without expunging (RFC 4314 section 4)
+        const canSetSeen = connection.canSetSeen;
+        const canExpunge = connection.canExpunge;
+        connection.canSetSeen = () => canSetSeen.call(connection) && getSelectedRights(connection).has('s');
+        connection.canExpunge = () => canExpunge.call(connection) && getSelectedRights(connection).has('e');
+    });
+
+    // STORE needs the right of at least one of the flags it changes, it SHOULD NOT fail otherwise.
+    // The flags themselves are filtered by the store handlers
+    const storeWrapper = (prevHandler, connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const rights = getSelectedRights(connection);
+        const args = parsed.attributes || [];
+        const item = args.length >= 3 && args[args.length - 2] && args[args.length - 2].type === 'ATOM' && args[args.length - 2].value.toUpperCase();
+        if (connection.readOnly || !item) {
+            return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+        }
+        if (STORE_ITEMS.indexOf(item) < 0) {
+            // other items of plugins (e.g. X-GM-LABELS) change shared message data like keywords do, so they
+            // need "w". Unknown items are refused with BAD by the STORE handler
+            if (Object.hasOwn(server.storeHandlers, item) && !rights.has('w')) {
+                sendNoPerm(connection, parsed, data);
+                return callback();
+            }
+            return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+        }
+        const flags = [].concat(args[args.length - 1] || []);
+        try {
+            flags.forEach(flag => checkSystemFlags(connection, normalizeSystemFlag(flagValue(flag))));
+        } catch {
+            // invalid flags are refused with BAD by the STORE handler
+            return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+        }
+        let allowed;
+        if (item.charAt(0) === '+' || item.charAt(0) === '-') {
+            allowed = !flags.length || flags.some(flag => canSetFlag(rights, flag));
+        } else {
+            // replacing the flags changes every flag the user has rights for
+            allowed = FLAG_RIGHTS.some(right => rights.has(right));
+        }
+        if (!allowed) {
+            sendNoPerm(connection, parsed, data);
+            return callback();
+        }
+        return prevHandler(connection, parsed, data, callback);
+    };
+    wrappers.STORE = storeWrapper;
+    wrappers['UID STORE'] = storeWrapper;
+
+    // Checks if an extended LIST command asks for the STATUS return option (RFC 5819)
+    const hasStatusReturnOption = parsed => {
+        const args = (parsed && parsed.attributes) || [];
+        return args.some(
+            (arg, i) =>
+                arg &&
+                arg.type === 'ATOM' &&
+                /^RETURN$/i.test(arg.value) &&
+                Array.isArray(args[i + 1]) &&
+                args[i + 1].some(option => option && option.type === 'ATOM' && /^STATUS$/i.test(option.value))
+        );
+    };
+
+    // Checks if any mailbox below a mailbox is visible to the user
+    const hasVisibleChildren = (connection, mailbox) => server.hasDescendant(mailbox.path, child => getRights(connection, child).has('l'));
+
+    server.outputHandlers.push((connection, response, description, parsed, data, extra) => {
+        if (isOwner(connection)) {
+            return;
+        }
+
+        if ((description === 'LIST ITEM' || description === 'LSUB ITEM') && extra && extra.path) {
+            // LIST and LSUB need "l", the mailbox is left out without it and never answered with NO
+            if (!getRights(connection, extra).has('l')) {
+                response.skipResponse = true;
+                return;
+            }
+            const flags = response.attributes[0];
+            if (!Array.isArray(flags)) {
+                return;
+            }
+            response.attributes[0] = flags.slice();
+            const index = flags.findIndex(flag => flag && flag.value === '\\HasChildren');
+            if (index >= 0 && !hasVisibleChildren(connection, extra)) {
+                // children that the user can not see do not count (RFC 3348 section 4)
+                response.attributes[0][index] = { type: 'ATOM', value: '\\HasNoChildren' };
+            }
+            // RFC 5819 section 2: a mailbox that gets no STATUS response because it can not be selected
+            // (no "r" right) MUST be listed with \Noselect
+            const isSelectable = !flags.some(flag => flag && /^\\(Noselect|NonExistent)$/i.test(flag.value));
+            if (isSelectable && hasStatusReturnOption(parsed) && !getRights(connection, extra).has('r')) {
+                response.attributes[0].push({ type: 'ATOM', value: '\\Noselect' });
+            }
+            return;
+        }
+
+        if (description === 'QUOTA' && parsed && parsed.aclQuotaMailboxOnly && Array.isArray(response.attributes[1])) {
+            // quota-resource = resource-name SP resource-usage SP resource-limit
+            const list = response.attributes[1];
+            const filtered = [];
+            for (let i = 0; i < list.length; i += 3) {
+                if (list[i] && String(list[i].value).toUpperCase() === 'MAILBOX') {
+                    filtered.push(list[i], list[i + 1], list[i + 2]);
+                }
+            }
+            // quota-list needs at least one resource, so without a MAILBOX limit there is no QUOTA response
+            if (filtered.length) {
+                response.attributes[1] = filtered;
+            } else {
+                response.skipResponse = true;
+            }
+            return;
+        }
+
+        if (description === 'SELECT PERMANENTFLAGS') {
+            // RFC 4314 section 5.1.1: PERMANENTFLAGS MUST reflect the rights of the user
+            const section = response.attributes[0] && response.attributes[0].section;
+            const rights = getSelectedRights(connection);
+            if (section && Array.isArray(section[1])) {
+                section[1] = section[1].filter(flag => (flag.value === '\\*' ? rights.has('w') : canSetFlag(rights, flag)));
+            }
+            return;
+        }
+
+        if (extra && extra.targetUids && extra.mailbox && /^(UID )?(COPY|MOVE COPYUID)$/.test(description)) {
+            // RFC 4314 section 4: the copies only keep the flags the user has rights for in the target
+            const rights = getRights(connection, extra.mailbox);
+            const uids = new Set(extra.targetUids);
+            extra.mailbox.messages.forEach(message => {
+                if (uids.has(message.uid)) {
+                    message.flags = message.flags.filter(flag => canSetFlag(rights, flag));
+                }
+            });
+        }
+    });
+
+    // The DELETE command MUST delete the ACL of the mailbox (RFC 4314 section 4), this matters when a
+    // \Noselect placeholder stays for the children of the mailbox
+    const prevDelete = server.getCommandHandler('DELETE');
+    server.setCommandHandler('DELETE', (connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const mailbox = argumentMailbox(parsed, 0);
+        prevDelete(connection, parsed, data, () => {
+            const placeholder = argumentMailbox(parsed, 0);
+            if (placeholder && placeholder !== mailbox) {
+                delete placeholder.acl;
+            }
+            callback();
+        });
+    });
+
+    // A new mailbox inherits the ACL of its parent (RFC 4314 section 4, CREATE SHOULD)
+    const prevCreate = server.getCommandHandler('CREATE');
+    server.setCommandHandler('CREATE', (connection, parsed, data, callback) => {
+        const existing = new Set(Object.keys(server.folderCache));
+        prevCreate(connection, parsed, data, () => {
+            Object.keys(server.folderCache)
+                .filter(path => !existing.has(path))
+                .sort((a, b) => a.length - b.length)
+                .forEach(path => {
+                    const parent = getParent(path);
+                    const mailbox = server.folderCache[path];
+                    if (parent && parent !== mailbox) {
+                        const acl = new Map();
+                        getAcl(parent).forEach((rights, identifier) => acl.set(identifier, new Set(rights)));
+                        mailbox.acl = acl;
+                    }
+                });
+            callback();
+        });
+    });
+};