eval-quality 0.2.0 → 0.3.0

package/corpus/dev/contracts/satisfied-declarations.json

@@ -1 +1 @@
-{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"satisfied-declarations","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":3,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}
+{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"satisfied-declarations","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":4,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}

package/corpus/dev/contracts/single-required-response-key.json

@@ -1 +1 @@
-{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"single-required-response-key","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":3,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}
+{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"single-required-response-key","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":4,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}

package/corpus/dev/contracts/split-indicator-oracle.json

@@ -1 +1 @@
-{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"split-indicator-oracle","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok"],"negativeDomain":"A create response carrying no indicator at all.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"existence","scope":"The create response indicator, read on its own."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":3,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}
+{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"split-indicator-oracle","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok"],"negativeDomain":"A create response carrying no indicator at all.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"existence","scope":"The create response indicator, read on its own."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":4,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}

package/corpus/dev/contracts/unaddressed-parameter-sibling.json

@@ -1 +1 @@
-{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"unaddressed-parameter-sibling","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":3,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","offset"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}
+{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"unaddressed-parameter-sibling","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":4,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","offset"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}

package/corpus/dev/contracts/unnamed-reference-set.json

@@ -1 +1 @@
-{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"unnamed-reference-set","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":null}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":3,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}
+{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"unnamed-reference-set","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"count":3,"mode":"exact"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":null}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":4,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}

package/corpus/dev/contracts/wrong-cardinality-form.json

@@ -1 +1 @@
-{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"wrong-cardinality-form","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"max":20,"mode":"page-bounded"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":3,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}
+{"behaviors":[{"description":"A created thing is readable back in the list of things.","id":"B-001","observableSuccessCriterion":"A list call after a create returns one element per seeded thing, carrying the name the create call sent.","oracles":["O-001","O-002","O-003","O-004","O-005","O-006","O-007"],"requirementLinks":[{"id":"REQ-1","scheme":"local"}],"riskLinks":[{"id":"RISK-1","scheme":"local-risk"}],"severity":"critical"}],"budgets":{"maxCostUsd":"0.25","maxToolCalls":20,"maxWallClockMinutes":5},"contractId":"wrong-cardinality-form","fixtureReset":null,"forbiddenInputs":["original-spec","source-code","repository","builder-transcript","implementation-logs","comparator-results","human-labels"],"interactionPlan":[{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"any"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"create"},{"after":"create","cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"literal":10}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"list"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":{"name":{"matcher":"type-violating"}},"header":null,"path":null,"query":null},"operationId":"create-thing","stepId":"malformed-create"},{"after":null,"cardinality":"exactly-one","inputBinding":{"body":null,"header":null,"path":null,"query":{"limit":{"matcher":"type-violating"}}},"operationId":"list-things","stepId":"malformed-list"}],"oracles":[{"check":{"actualKey":"id","expectedKey":"id","op":"covers-by-key","operands":[{"referenceSet":"expected-things"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},"commentary":"Reconciles the whole list against the declared set.","direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list omitting a seeded thing, or repeating one.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"covers-by-key","scope":"One list call over the seeded set."},"id":"O-001","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/ok"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/id"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/response-body/ok","/interactions/create/response-body/id","/interactions/create/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success with no identifier, or with a diagnostic beside it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The whole create response."},"id":"O-002","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"}]},{"op":"absence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"A list carrying items alongside a diagnostic field.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The list response taken as a whole."},"id":"O-003","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/malformed-create/response-body/error","/interactions/malformed-list/response-body/error"],"negativeDomain":"One sibling rejecting the malformed input while the other accepts it.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"Both sibling operations, each given an input that violates its declared type."},"id":"O-004","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"all","operands":[{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"}]}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name","/interactions/list/call-inputs/query/limit"],"negativeDomain":"One parameter carried and the other dropped.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"all","scope":"The two sibling parameters, as sent."},"id":"O-005","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"op":"containment","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"}]},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items","/interactions/create/call-inputs/body/name"],"negativeDomain":"A create reporting success whose thing never appears in a later list.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"containment","scope":"The list read after the create, against the name the create sent."},"id":"O-006","polarity":"expects-hold"},{"check":{"collection":{"pointer":"/interactions/list/response-body/items"},"op":"for-all","predicate":{"op":"existence","operands":[{"pointer":"@/id"}]}},"commentary":null,"direction":{"evidenceTargets":["/interactions/list/response-body/items"],"negativeDomain":"A list whose first element carries an identifier and whose later elements do not.","polarity":"expects-hold","relation":"for-all","scope":"Every element of the returned list."},"id":"O-007","polarity":"expects-hold"}],"parentDigest":null,"permittedInterfaces":[{"kind":"api","logicalId":"thing-api","operations":[{"method":"POST","operationId":"create-thing","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":["name"],"requiredKeys":["name"],"types":{"name":"string"}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/id":"payload","/ok":"success-indicator"},"collectionLocations":[],"permittedKeys":["id","ok","error"],"requiredKeys":["id","ok"],"successIndicator":"/ok","types":{"error":"string","id":"string","ok":"boolean"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"body","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"alpha"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"json","value":{"name":"beta"}},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{}},"legId":"create-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/create-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"create-thing-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":true,"volatilePointers":["/id"]},{"method":"GET","operationId":"list-things","pathTemplate":"/things","requestShape":{"body":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"header":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"path":{"permittedKeys":[],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{}},"query":{"permittedKeys":["limit"],"requiredKeys":[],"types":{"limit":"number"}}},"responseDescriptor":{"channelRoles":{"/error":"diagnostic","/items":"collection"},"collectionLocations":[{"expectedCardinality":{"max":20,"mode":"page-bounded"},"pointer":"/items","referenceSet":"expected-things"}],"permittedKeys":["items","error"],"requiredKeys":["items"],"successIndicator":"/items","types":{"error":"string","items":"array"}},"sensitivityWitness":{"channel":"query","legs":[{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":1}},"legId":"list-witness-a"},{"inputs":{"body":{"kind":"absent"},"header":{},"path":{},"query":{"limit":2}},"legId":"list-witness-b"}],"relation":{"op":"not","operands":[{"op":"deep-equality","operands":[{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-a/response-body"},{"pointer":"/interactions/list-witness-b/response-body"}]}]},"witnessId":"list-things-sensitivity"},"stateChangeMarker":false,"volatilePointers":[]}]}],"probeStepBound":8,"referenceSets":{"expected-things":{"commentary":null,"keys":["id"],"members":[{"id":"t-1"},{"id":"t-2"},{"id":"t-3"}]}},"requiredEvidence":["Request and response pair for every call, in order."],"revisionCount":0,"rubrics":[{"criteria":[{"evidence":"/interactions/list/response-body/items","id":"RC-001","text":"Does the returned list carry every expected identifier?"}],"failureModePenalties":[{"description":"An expected thing is missing.","name":"omission"}],"id":"R-001","maxLength":400,"scaleLevels":[{"anchor":"Every expected thing is present.","level":1}]}],"safetyLimits":["No request to any host other than the mapped thing-api target."],"schemaVersion":4,"scopedResources":null,"siblingGroups":{"operations":[["create-thing","list-things"]],"parameters":[["limit","name"]]},"sourceSpecDigest":null,"testData":{"cleanup":"Delete every thing created during the run.","principals":null,"resources":null,"setup":"Seed exactly three things with identifiers t-1, t-2, t-3."},"waivers":[{"approval":"gate-c-reviewer","condition":null,"expiresAt":"2027-01-01T00:00:00Z","id":"W-001","rationale":"The upstream seed is unavailable in the sandbox environment.","rule":"omission-and-completeness"}]}

package/corpus/dev/index.json

@@ -1 +1 @@
-{"entries":[{"digest":"sha256:274261155b7b22ebc72e02c72615b65496534fc028e85d4203c8bffcb64a25ad","kind":"readme","path":"corpus/dev/README.md"},{"digest":"sha256:bb80ec73156236762e38485febcb7d0e2e1d6c1f6752cc3b8fbece8da2cacd93","kind":"sealed-evaluator-brief","path":"corpus/dev/compile-seal-example/brief.json"},{"digest":"sha256:df768e15f3fbc46dc8f196ef40738eb00efe51f102defe1b115419e0669acd15","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/compile-seal-example/contract.json"},{"digest":"sha256:920132358c6de060d04a601a25103fce863c01ac5ef7f518d937307d16fc592a","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/absent-collection-locations.json"},{"digest":"sha256:9aa0271bd7b101f359d8c5fbe9abd25bf828781e12bbc7830f8ae5590037fcf2","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/absent-sibling-groups.json"},{"digest":"sha256:3567b94883b4df964660f498447e0cc6c6f4104b0591976e19e8d6b11747a715","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/absent-success-indicator.json"},{"digest":"sha256:c2aab07d2d2569041c563ed25f6f166e2340dfeac526727fe0041beb9529c6be","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/empty-channel-roles.json"},{"digest":"sha256:8ae55e5678a092053bc0beb01174a059fdeec8afe52d1a26af05417d259f08e1","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/empty-collection-locations.json"},{"digest":"sha256:1910b4a104e257f68e1a3dc5c9ecd8aa11d2a3406b9361757129bec18bd49c17","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/empty-request-shapes.json","structuralFailure":"unreachable-check-evidence"},{"digest":"sha256:aa87fed1298ff2af5683df0c6e867c243ad2a0a57c49e20e0d53848fa694147b","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/empty-sibling-groups.json"},{"digest":"sha256:ad6939d036d96993d8d3907d82de2174913a5bedfae0c6b9affd9fd99f3a415f","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-collection-quantifier.json"},{"digest":"sha256:c0b3257397926508dff837e519d872c6b12a881a79484c78ad49e444323e62d7","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-operation-inventory.json","structuralFailure":"unreachable-check-evidence"},{"digest":"sha256:a2f53f16c12d2a57cf20c3f46bbb7865aeb75cd0604188bb884b83c81d46bf68","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-read-back-relation.json"},{"digest":"sha256:c9d0ca24a44e2c82c30e44f7e354b419b3fd6fb35b5030c4244c6a2846c54178","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-state-change-marker.json","structuralFailure":"undeclared-mandatory-input"},{"digest":"sha256:fac4fad90a3729883b1fa653e2732e0b77f3e055e30f79d8f6efb6c34be8d420","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-type-violating-step.json"},{"digest":"sha256:c17c4ae3b2982c748c9c06657ca505339aed664f997e6a4e5a344c9e6c1c9f95","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/per-key-split-oracles.json"},{"digest":"sha256:df768e15f3fbc46dc8f196ef40738eb00efe51f102defe1b115419e0669acd15","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/satisfied-declarations.json"},{"digest":"sha256:a1fe7b1739cb25c0f02782472625f575f4c7fe0940797241cf4f8794b16945c2","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/single-required-response-key.json"},{"digest":"sha256:b0b92e9158b9c750f18307063bb1a2d965ec6eda986232029ad147ccc01115f3","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/split-indicator-oracle.json"},{"digest":"sha256:d7d4c178c1050002b8df3908bc80dc194b6416f0222cd64758b8bd98b4d69b17","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/unaddressed-parameter-sibling.json"},{"digest":"sha256:9cd3b409bb6b6556de750fd87f258d7b4cc29259b8ec438241a4f005cb91e57e","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/unnamed-reference-set.json"},{"digest":"sha256:c645b759b4eeea0f2bacfd59b0a77f75a9f4afeb4cdb3d211915af0dde0bf94d","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/wrong-cardinality-form.json"}]}
+{"entries":[{"digest":"sha256:07cb7353bf4cec88e209d6d893f4618294268b8bead9dc9e804c166038cef213","kind":"readme","path":"corpus/dev/README.md"},{"digest":"sha256:2a5a248cea57e55ba6f79eaddc5e48e156917b4b91866fa349985c8d651a94cb","kind":"sealed-evaluator-brief","path":"corpus/dev/compile-seal-example/brief.json"},{"digest":"sha256:8f9dea3220baedd8a07da83ca4dd804c943cebda99c6754734694e48b8007e1c","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/compile-seal-example/contract.json"},{"digest":"sha256:ec77b19ba1d3c8537ff74cc656f67c4ac46f0d0040e65422b3d742687a97e39c","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/absent-collection-locations.json"},{"digest":"sha256:411c6a8c074ab6e524368605812532cc932fffc1ff20e68a65b50145fc294181","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/absent-sibling-groups.json"},{"digest":"sha256:b6d22168553303903df5513da24edd01bf2f780a7f8dc3c0ed0d66a0bc6c7ba8","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/absent-success-indicator.json"},{"digest":"sha256:eca39a841b40a67595e06343119f63be471af8110139b0245d6b18d18d0be4bb","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/empty-channel-roles.json"},{"digest":"sha256:56aa60b674f70b4f96be8b982ffe384b7825caf886d1ae8107e2019beeee5d19","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/empty-collection-locations.json"},{"digest":"sha256:c6ba5efeac1e3c5dfa096375225b98fd80a6fee4f28f4546df21f18baacce663","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/empty-request-shapes.json","structuralFailure":"unreachable-check-evidence"},{"digest":"sha256:703d3e1468b6e058d728fd909d170f130d9539dc27822b16c539c5e9a3c908c1","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/empty-sibling-groups.json"},{"digest":"sha256:f7983813b294cc114c35efd3efeb1db315d40ada56ae24f22b575046e6a76a14","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/fragment-selection.json"},{"digest":"sha256:3e912f4423aa529fec21364155197334506316cdd7435ed1b59969eaab9cadf4","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-collection-quantifier.json"},{"digest":"sha256:10e142a5ea8130c83c8dbe3be1c8df67c2997e8b57da0394cccbcfc43f44326f","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-operation-inventory.json","structuralFailure":"unreachable-check-evidence"},{"digest":"sha256:8eace1550e26534eb886c9f217d4a8999891072643535b11afda44efc21d736f","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-read-back-relation.json"},{"digest":"sha256:f66980583dde3213b65d5460491fe2dc34961cc9ee44600a40a2d10ba260efed","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-state-change-marker.json","structuralFailure":"undeclared-mandatory-input"},{"digest":"sha256:deb36540d39aa99ae1d5d7e2e2808211ed40319fcc0d5519500e478659d8d232","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/no-type-violating-step.json"},{"digest":"sha256:aa0ffb76c69870798b949e2e5a6a93b0bd46507fa7124505878b45a0672bc7e5","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/per-key-split-oracles.json"},{"digest":"sha256:e4eaeb0e38357912dffb4bc7d29730797f9a1e485b4d98616fc934e83a57b732","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/review-corpus.json"},{"digest":"sha256:8f9dea3220baedd8a07da83ca4dd804c943cebda99c6754734694e48b8007e1c","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/satisfied-declarations.json"},{"digest":"sha256:951a90c269944c9e29c1b06ba4d634dbe6d2a1847308a951e7a5b6e4d271e2ff","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/single-required-response-key.json"},{"digest":"sha256:fd696c819b7e2ada4dfb821fb4bbeeb0210a7826f0dd3c845e70476e7cab6a4e","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/split-indicator-oracle.json"},{"digest":"sha256:70fa47876aa4318fb758203c77d2f234cdf26fe404d382dcc49e8f7dbf0c378e","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/unaddressed-parameter-sibling.json"},{"digest":"sha256:9a64e4c32aad92a08da1f64a7d5616b4b96b60bd7070cdeaef7afbd9723e573c","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/unnamed-reference-set.json"},{"digest":"sha256:fbb9e557e77311f8d608e003e019fe9c59fcf3e11fd737bf97cd0a3ff1e2e6b6","kind":"contract","path":"corpus/dev/contracts/wrong-cardinality-form.json"}]}

package/dist/cli/render.d.ts

@@ -1,8 +1,3 @@
-/**
- * The four shapes the binary writes, and the exit-code table two documents
- * share. Every line the CLI emits is produced here, so a format change is one
- * file.
- */
 import { type Diagnostic } from '../application/index.ts';
 /**
  * Delegates to `serializeArtifact`; the canonical bytes are not re-derived
@@ -13,6 +8,8 @@ export declare function renderArtifact(artifact: unknown, artifactPath: string):
 export declare function renderDiagnostic(diagnostic: Diagnostic): string;
 /**
  * `eval-quality: <code>: <artifactPath>: <detail>` for either error class.
+ * A fault carrying a Zod error as its cause prints that error's issues under
+ * the first line, one indented `<location>: <message>` per issue.
  * Anything else falls back to `String(error)`, which is what a defect in our
  * own code looks like from outside.
  */

package/dist/cli/render.js

@@ -3,8 +3,55 @@
  * share. Every line the CLI emits is produced here, so a format change is one
  * file.
  */
+import { z } from 'zod';
 import { RuntimeFault, StructuralFailure, serializeArtifact, } from '../application/index.js';
 const PREFIX = 'eval-quality';
+/**
+ * How many parse issues the renderer prints before it stops and counts the
+ * rest.
+ * An author fixing a contract reads the first few and edits; a wall of four
+ * hundred lines from one missing required key teaches nothing and buries the
+ * first line, which is the one that names the code.
+ */
+const ISSUE_LIMIT = 20;
+/**
+ * An RFC 6901 pointer over the failing value, so the location the renderer
+ * prints is the same spelling the contract itself uses to address evidence.
+ * A numeric segment is an array index and is printed as one.
+ */
+function issueLocation(path) {
+    if (path.length === 0)
+        return '(root)';
+    return path
+        .map((segment) => String(segment).replaceAll('~', '~0').replaceAll('/', '~1'))
+        .map((segment) => `/${segment}`)
+        .join('');
+}
+/**
+ * The issue list a failed parse already carries, which the first line of the
+ * error alone does not expose.
+ * A contract author outside this repository has the published schema and this
+ * message and nothing else, so a parse failure that names no field costs a
+ * bisect over the whole document.
+ * Issues are sorted by location so two runs over the same input print the same
+ * bytes.
+ * A Zod issue message names the expectation and never echoes the value that
+ * failed, which matters because this goes to stderr and a contract declares an
+ * environment channel; the one thing a message does quote is an unrecognized
+ * key name, which is a field name.
+ */
+function renderParseIssues(cause) {
+    if (!(cause instanceof z.ZodError))
+        return '';
+    const lines = cause.issues
+        .map((issue) => `  ${issueLocation(issue.path)}: ${issue.message}`)
+        .sort();
+    const shown = lines.slice(0, ISSUE_LIMIT);
+    const hidden = lines.length - shown.length;
+    if (hidden > 0)
+        shown.push(`  ... and ${hidden} more`);
+    return shown.length === 0 ? '' : `\n${shown.join('\n')}`;
+}
 /**
  * Delegates to `serializeArtifact`; the canonical bytes are not re-derived
  * here, so the text written to stdout is the text `digestArtifact` hashes.
@@ -18,6 +65,8 @@ export function renderDiagnostic(diagnostic) {
 }
 /**
  * `eval-quality: <code>: <artifactPath>: <detail>` for either error class.
+ * A fault carrying a Zod error as its cause prints that error's issues under
+ * the first line, one indented `<location>: <message>` per issue.
  * Anything else falls back to `String(error)`, which is what a defect in our
  * own code looks like from outside.
  */
@@ -27,7 +76,8 @@ export function renderError(error) {
         const detail = error.message.startsWith(prefix)
             ? error.message.slice(prefix.length)
             : error.message;
-        return `${PREFIX}: ${error.code}: ${error.artifactPath}: ${detail}`;
+        const issues = renderParseIssues(error.cause);
+        return `${PREFIX}: ${error.code}: ${error.artifactPath}: ${detail}${issues}`;
     }
     return `${PREFIX}: ${String(error)}`;
 }