dsh-vibe-math 2.8.2 → 2.8.3

package/docs/final-paper.md

@@ -121,6 +121,10 @@
   **所办必须先与全所交流、商讨、优化、审查**：至少 1 条所办消息（`vibe_v5_message`）**且**至少 1 次会议
   （`vibe_v5_meeting`），结论写进定稿说明，然后调用 `vibe_v5_finalize_paper`。
   两个计数记在 `paper.meta.json`；缺一即 `V5_PAPER_CONSULT_REQUIRED`（不是静默跳过）。
+- **`force` ＝ 一张新论文**：`/vN paper … force` **重写**已定稿的论文 ⇒ 新的 `paper` 状态以
+  `consult = {messages: 0, meetings: 0}` 开始，**重启前的消息与会议不再计入**（这是设计，不是丢状态 ✗）。
+  因此 `paperEditor="office"` 在 `force` 之后必须**重新**征询；`V5_PAPER_CONSULT_REQUIRED` 的响应会**具名**说明
+  这一点（`restarted: true` ＋ `forceReason`），不再让人靠猜。
 
 ## 8. LaTeX 检测、编译与降级
 

package/docs/release-notes/README.en.md

@@ -8,6 +8,7 @@ Chinese counterpart of this index is [`README.md`](./README.md) (中文索引).
 
 | Version | Key change | Notes |
 |---|---|---|
+| 2.8.3 | Patch: a speech arriving **after the meeting closed** is no longer dropped silently (it becomes a named "late note" in the minutes, which stay append-only); an office finalisation refused after a `force` restart now **explains why** (`restarted: true` + `forceReason`, stating that the counters restarted with the new paper and that a fresh consultation is required); the docs now state "`force` = a new paper". | [中文](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.3.md) · [English](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.3.en.md) |
 | 2.8.2 | Patch: an explicit `paperLatexCommand` is now probed **alone**, so `triedPaths` no longer reports impossible paths of the form "known TeX root + absolute path"; v5's delivered `paper.md` / `paper.tex` now also **each state** the compile outcome (no engine detected / compilation failed), exactly once and without duplication on re-entry — matching v4 since 2.8.1. Both have real-host reproductions and named-red guards. | [中文](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.2.md) · [English](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.2.en.md) |
 | 2.8.1 | Patch: v4's delivered `paper.md` and `paper.tex` now each state the compile outcome (no engine detected → tex+md only, or PDF compilation failed with tex/md kept), **exactly once** and idempotently — resolving known limitation #3 of the 2.8.0 notes; added `scripts/release-check.mjs`, which runs the pre-release checks as one command (version triple, section order of both notes, manifest registration, declared-but-missing = 0, repository-only files not shipped, no CRLF in the package). | [中文](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.1.md) · [English](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.1.en.md) |
 | 2.8.0 | Feature: an explicit `paperLatexCommand` now means "use only this" (v4/v5 no longer fall back silently), the missing-engine warning is actionable and `triedPaths` is recorded, and all four presets share one byte-identical missing-engine guidance block; the test gate is steadier (default concurrency 2, stale scratch swept at start-up, read-only warning for suspected leftover processes); repository line endings are unified on LF (byte-reproducible npm package). | [中文](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.0.md) · [English](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.0.en.md) |

package/docs/release-notes/README.md

@@ -7,6 +7,7 @@
 
 | 版本 | 关键变化 | 说明 |
 |---|---|---|
+| 2.8.3 | 补丁：会议**收束后到达的发言**不再静默丢弃（作为具名「会后补记」写入纪要、只增不覆盖）；`force` 重启后 `paperEditor="office"` 的定稿拒绝**说明原因**（新增 `restarted:true` ＋ `forceReason`，并写明"计数随新论文重置、需重新征询"）；文档明确「`force` ＝ 一张新论文」。 | [中文](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.3.md) · [English](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.3.en.md) |
 | 2.8.2 | 补丁：显式 `paperLatexCommand` 改为**单独探测** ⇒ `triedPaths` 不再出现「已知 TeX 根 ＋ 绝对路径」这类**不可能路径**；v5 交付的 `paper.md`／`paper.tex` 也**各自写明**编译结果（未检测到引擎／编译失败），恰好一次且重入不重复 ⇒ 与 2.8.1 的 v4 对齐。两处均有真机复现读数与具名红守卫。 | [中文](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.2.md) · [English](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.2.en.md) |
 | 2.8.1 | 补丁：v4 交付的 `paper.md`／`paper.tex` 现在各自写明编译结果（未检测到引擎 ⇒ 只产出 tex+md，或 PDF 编译失败并保留 tex/md），**恰好一次**且幂等 ⇒ 2.8.0 说明里的「已知限制」第 3 条已解决；新增 `scripts/release-check.mjs` 把发布前逐项核对做成一条命令（版本三处一致／两份说明章节顺序／清单登记／声明缺失=0／开发专用文件不随包／包内无 CRLF）。 | [中文](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.1.md) · [English](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.1.en.md) |
 | 2.8.0 | 功能版：显式 `paperLatexCommand` 改为「指定即只用它」（v4/v5 不再静默回落）、检测不到引擎的警告可行动并新增 `triedPaths`、四套预设新增逐字一致的引擎缺失指引；测试门禁更稳（默认并发 2、自动清扫陈旧临时目录、疑似遗留进程只读告警）；仓库行尾统一为 LF（npm 包逐字节可复现）。 | [中文](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.0.md) · [English](./RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.0.en.md) |

package/docs/release-notes/RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.3.en.md

@@ -0,0 +1,50 @@
+# dsh-vibe-math 2.8.3 — Release Notes
+
+> Previous release: 2.8.2. This is a **patch release** fixing two v5 issues around meetings and finalisation: a speech that arrives **after the meeting closed** is no longer dropped silently (it becomes a clearly-marked late note), and an office finalisation refused after a `force` restart now **explains why** (the counters restarted with the new paper, so a fresh consultation is required). Parameter names and defaults, data formats and the directory layout are **unchanged**, the DSH support window is unchanged, and **no migration is needed**.
+
+## Overview
+
+- A member's meeting speech **no longer disappears silently**: even when it arrives **after** the meeting closed (the watchdog abandons a stalled meeting; the office may finalise early) it is written into the minutes as a clearly-marked "late note", with one named line in the group chat.
+- Meeting minutes are **append-only**: earlier speakers are always preserved.
+- A refusal after a `force` restart is now **explainable**: the response carries `restarted: true` plus the `forceReason`, and the message states that the counters restarted with the new paper, that earlier messages/meetings no longer count, and that a fresh consultation is required.
+- The documentation now states it plainly: **`force` means a new paper** (both `consult` counters start at 0), so a restart requires a **new** consultation.
+
+## Added
+
+- When `vibe_v5_finalize_paper` is refused for insufficient consultation, the response now carries **`restarted`** (boolean: was this paper started by a `force` restart?).
+
+## Changed
+
+- Meeting minutes gained one kind of entry: `### <member>（会后补记：该发言到达时会议已收束）` — used for speeches that arrive **after** the meeting closed; identical text submitted again is recorded only once.
+- The `V5_PAPER_CONSULT_REQUIRED` message appends the reset explanation when `restarted` (**behaviour is unchanged**; it only states the cause).
+- `docs/final-paper.md` §7 gained the "`force` = a new paper" rule.
+
+## Fixed
+
+- Symptom: a member's speech — on a real host, the **convener's own** speech — never appeared in the minutes: the header said `- 发言顺序: r-1 → acad` while the body contained only `### r-1`; the paper's `consult.meetings` stayed 0 and finalisation was refused repeatedly. Cause: a member's end-block `input` was only consumed when a meeting was **live**, and a stalled meeting is closed by the watchdog — speeches arriving later had nowhere to go and were **dropped silently**. Such speeches are now appended as "late notes" (named, de-duplicated, appended rather than overwritten). Guards: `tests/e2e-v5-round2.test.mjs` (`★ [real1004-minutes]`), `tests/v5-institute-fixes.mutants.mjs`.
+- Symptom: after a `force` restart of the paper, the office's usual finalisation was refused by `V5_PAPER_CONSULT_REQUIRED` with **no hint** that the restart had reset the counters (on a real host: **11** consecutive refusals, leaving the members to infer it). Cause: that semantics existed **only in the code** — neither the docs nor the refusal message said it. The refusal now names the reset and asks for a fresh consultation, and the docs state "`force` = a new paper". Guards: `tests/e2e-v5-round2.test.mjs` (`★ [real1004-consult]`), `tests/v5-institute-fixes.mutants.mjs` (**18/18** named reds).
+
+## Compatibility & Migration
+
+- Breaking changes: **none**.
+- Additive only: the `restarted` response field; one new kind of minutes entry.
+- Migration: none needed; existing `paper.meta.json` files, meeting minutes and the directory layout are unchanged.
+- The DSH support window is unchanged (see `engines.dsh` in `package.json`).
+
+## Known Limitations
+
+- **TeX installed in a non-standard location is still not auto-discovered**: the default probe covers PATH and the documented common install roots; use an absolute path in `paperLatexCommand` otherwise.
+- The shipped suites **do not cover host-level behaviour** (for example "the caller is dropped after an interrupt"); that needs a real host.
+- **A root-agent question blocks the whole institute** (operational note, product unchanged): nothing else proceeds until the answer arrives — state the problem and acceptance criteria up front for unattended runs. See [`slv-playbook.md`](./slv-playbook.md) §5.
+- After a meeting is abandoned by the watchdog, the minutes keep the abandonment marker and **all earlier speeches**; speeches that arrive later land in the "late note" section.
+
+## Verification
+
+- `node tests/run-tests.mjs` — all green (**106** items: 44 suites + 62 probes).
+- `node scripts/release-check.mjs` — exits 0 (version triple, section order of both notes, `files[]` registration, no CRLF in the package); after publishing, add `--registry` to compare the registry shasum with the local tarball.
+- The two fixes in this release: `node tests/e2e-v5-round2.test.mjs` (`★ [real1004-minutes]`, `★ [real1004-consult]`) and `node tests/v5-institute-fixes.mutants.mjs` (**18/18** named reds).
+- Real-host re-check recipe: install the exact published version (`-Pin <version>`) and run a **trimmed** meeting + paper task (no research), then check that the minutes contain both speakers and that a refusal after a `force` restart is named.
+
+## Dependencies
+
+- No new runtime dependencies; the DSH support window is unchanged.

package/docs/release-notes/RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.3.md

@@ -0,0 +1,50 @@
+# dsh-vibe-math 2.8.3 — 发布说明
+
+> 上一版本：2.8.2。本版是**补丁版**，修两处 v5 的会议与定稿问题：**会议收束后到达的发言不再被静默丢弃**（改成具名的"会后补记"）；`force` 重启后 `paperEditor="office"` 的定稿拒绝会**说明原因**（计数已随新论文重置、需重新征询）。参数名与默认值、数据格式与目录结构**未变**，DSH 支撑窗口不变，**无需迁移**。
+
+## 概述
+
+- 成员的会议发言**不会再无声消失**：即使发言在会议收束（看门狗放弃停滞会议，或所办提前定稿）**之后**才到达，也会作为「**会后补记**」写进会议纪要，并在群聊里具名说明一次。
+- 会议纪要**只增不覆盖**：先前发言者的内容一律保留。
+- `force` 重启后的定稿拒绝**可解释**：响应新增 `restarted: true` 并写明 `forceReason`，消息直接告诉你"计数随新论文重置、重启前的消息/会议不再计入、请重新征询"。
+- 文档明确：**`force` ＝ 一张新论文**（`consult` 的两个计数随之从 0 开始），因此重启后必须**重新**征询。
+
+## 新增
+
+- `vibe_v5_finalize_paper` 在因征询不足被拒时，响应新增 **`restarted`** 字段（布尔；该论文是否由 `force` 重启而来）。
+
+## 变更
+
+- 会议纪要新增一种条目：「会后补记」（`### <成员>（会后补记：该发言到达时会议已收束）`）——针对**会议已收束后**到达的发言；同一段文本重复提交只记一次。
+- `V5_PAPER_CONSULT_REQUIRED` 的文案在 `restarted` 时追加重置说明（**行为逻辑不变**，只是把原因说清）。
+- `docs/final-paper.md` §7 增补一条「`force` ＝ 一张新论文」的口径。
+
+## 修复
+
+- 症状：某位成员（真机实测中正是**会议的召集人**）的发言没有出现在会议纪要里——纪要在头部写着 `- 发言顺序: r-1 → acad`，正文却**只有 `### r-1`**；同一张论文的 `consult.meetings` 一直为 0，定稿被连续拒绝。原因：成员结束块里的 `input` 只认「**有活会议**」这一条路径，而会议一旦停滞会被看门狗收束，之后到达的发言**无处可去、静默丢弃**。现在这类发言会作为「会后补记」写入纪要（具名、去重、追加而非覆盖）。守卫：`tests/e2e-v5-round2.test.mjs`（`★ [real1004-minutes]`）、`tests/v5-institute-fixes.mutants.mjs`。
+- 症状：`force` 重启论文后，所办按老流程定稿会被 `V5_PAPER_CONSULT_REQUIRED` 反复拒绝，而**提示里没有任何线索**说明"刚刚重启导致计数清零"（真机实测连续 **11** 次、只能靠成员自行推断）。原因：这一语义**只存在于代码里**，文档与拒绝文案都没写。现在拒绝会具名说明重置与"请重新征询"，文档也把「`force` ＝ 新论文」写清楚。守卫：`tests/e2e-v5-round2.test.mjs`（`★ [real1004-consult]`）、`tests/v5-institute-fixes.mutants.mjs`（**18/18** 具名红）。
+
+## 兼容性与迁移
+
+- 破坏性变更：**无**。
+- 纯新增：`restarted` 响应字段；纪要里一种新的条目类型。
+- 迁移：无需迁移；既有 `paper.meta.json`、会议纪要与目录结构不变。
+- DSH 支撑窗口不变（见 `package.json` 的 `engines.dsh`）。
+
+## 已知限制
+
+- **非标准位置的 TeX 仍不会被自动发现**：默认探测只覆盖 PATH 与文档化的常见安装根；装在其它目录请用 `paperLatexCommand` 指绝对路径。
+- 随包套件**不覆盖宿主层行为**（例如「中断后调用方被丢弃」），这类行为需要真机才能观察。
+- **根代理提问会阻塞整所流程**（运维注意项，不改产品）：答复到达前其余流程停摆；长跑时请把问题与验收条件一次说清。详见 [`slv-playbook.md`](./slv-playbook.md) §5。
+- 会议「因长时间无新发言被看门狗放弃」之后，纪要里会留下放弃标记；**放弃前的发言仍保留**，之后到达的发言进「会后补记」。
+
+## 验证方式
+
+- `node tests/run-tests.mjs` —— 全部通过（**106** 项：44 套件 + 62 探针）。
+- `node scripts/release-check.mjs` —— 退出 0（版本三处一致／两份说明章节顺序／`files[]` 登记／包内无 CRLF）；发布后加 `--registry` 比对线上 shasum 与本地 tarball。
+- 本版两处修复：`node tests/e2e-v5-round2.test.mjs`（`★ [real1004-minutes]`、`★ [real1004-consult]`）与 `node tests/v5-institute-fixes.mutants.mjs`（**18/18** 具名红）。
+- 真机复测方式：用 registry 上的精确版本（`-Pin <version>`）跑一个**精简**会议＋论文任务（跳过研究），核对纪要是否含两位发言人、以及 force 重启后拒绝是否具名。
+
+## 依赖
+
+- 无新增运行时依赖；DSH 支撑窗口不变。

package/package.json

@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
 {
   "name": "dsh-vibe-math",
   "description": "Multi-agent mathematical problem-solving & verification frameworks for DeepSeek Harness — FOUR agent presets in one install: vibe-math-v2 (probability-driven, classic: qs.json + Propos knowledge base + explorer→solver→review/debate verdict), vibe-math-v3 (THIRD-generation, classic: paper-style Markdown knowledge base with Problems/Progress/Propos/Methods/Verified + planner-agent scheduling that decides the next N actions + universal theory/method invention library + agents write their own Markdown directly via a per-file write lock), and vibe-math-v4 (FOURTH-generation: persistent self-organizing resident subagents that message & meet to decide all tasks, verify only by unanimous consensus, /compact at a context threshold, and stop only when all agree the problem is solved), and vibe-math-v5 (FIFTH-generation research institute: an academician as the organizational centre who decomposes and ASSIGNS work and chairs meetings; permanent researchers who hold the vote and may hire/fire their own temp workers; temp workers with no vote; a group chat and meetings; a durable per-recipient mailbox; a compare-and-set task DAG; and a boolean m-vote consensus rule where an object enters Verified/ only when at least m voting members agree AND every one of them returns exactly 1 or exactly 0). Installing this bundle auto-installs all four presets (v1 was removed at v2.0.0). Each preset also writes a FINAL PAPER by default when its run concludes — and does so BEFORE the run is marked complete: on v4/v5 the team co-authors its parts, merges them, cross-reviews, and the editor named by paperEditor finalises; the output is Paper/<run or institute id>/{paper.md,paper.tex,paper.pdf when a LaTeX engine is detected,paper.meta.json,paper.log.md} (params finalPaper/paperFormat/paperLanguage/paperCompilePdf/paperLatexCommand, plus paperEditor on v4/v5; see docs/final-paper.md).",
-  "version": "2.8.2",
+  "version": "2.8.3",
   "type": "module",
   "engines": {
     "node": "^22.19.0 || >=24.0.0",
@@ -209,7 +209,9 @@
     "docs/release-notes/RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.1.md",
     "docs/release-notes/RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.1.en.md",
     "docs/release-notes/RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.2.md",
-    "docs/release-notes/RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.2.en.md"
+    "docs/release-notes/RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.2.en.md",
+    "docs/release-notes/RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.3.md",
+    "docs/release-notes/RELEASE-NOTES-2.8.3.en.md"
   ],
   "license": "MIT",
   "keywords": [
@@ -239,7 +241,7 @@
     },
     "minVersion": "0.1.2-alpha.4",
     "testedVersion": "0.2.0-rc.2",
-    "compatNote": "v2.8.2 补丁版：修 v5 的「诊断与交付物」两处。① 显式 paperLatexCommand 改为**单独探测** ⇒ paper.meta.json 的 compile.triedPaths 不再出现「已知 TeX 根 ＋ 你的绝对路径」这类不可能路径（此前该值被当命令名去和已知安装根拼候选），真机实测：坏路径 ⇒ not-detected ＋ triedPaths=[\"Z:/…\"]；真引擎 ⇒ compiled ＋ 真产出 paper.pdf。② v5 交付的 paper.md／paper.tex 现在各自写明编译结果（未检测到引擎 ⇒ 只产出 tex+md；编译失败 ⇒ 已保留 tex/md），恰好一次且定稿重入不重复 ⇒ 与 2.8.1 的 v4 对齐。参数名与默认值、数据格式与目录结构均未变；DSH 支撑窗口不变；无需迁移。",
+    "compatNote": "v2.8.3 补丁版：修 v5 的会议与定稿两处。① 会议收束后到达的成员发言不再静默丢弃 —— 看门狗放弃停滞会议（或所办提前定稿）后到达的 input 现在作为具名「会后补记」追加进纪要（按文本去重、先前发言只增不覆盖）；真机实测原症状是纪要在头部写着「发言顺序: r-1 → acad」而正文只有 ### r-1。② force 重启后 paperEditor=\"office\" 的定稿拒绝现在说明原因：响应新增 restarted 字段并在文案里写明 forceReason 与「计数随新论文重置、重启前的消息/会议不再计入、请重新征询」；docs/final-paper.md §7 明确「force ＝ 一张新论文」。参数名与默认值、数据格式与目录结构均未变；DSH 支撑窗口不变；无需迁移。",
     "compatibility": {
       "dshReleases": {
         "0.1.2-alpha.4": "compatible",

package/tests/e2e-v5-round2.test.mjs

@@ -1350,6 +1350,20 @@ console.log('\n[25] paper idempotency: repeated triggers only fill missing artif
   const stF = await h.callTool('vibe_v5_status', {})
   assert(stF.paper.status === 'writing' && stF.paper.round === 1, 'the forced run restarted at round 1')
 }
+// real1004-consult (found on a real host with 2.8.2): `force` rewrites the paper, so the NEW paper starts with
+// consult={0,0} — intended — but the office was rejected ELEVEN times with no hint that its earlier meeting had
+// stopped counting (only the members could infer it). The refusal must NAME the reset and say what to do.
+{
+  const hq = makeHost({ pluginModule })
+  await hq.callTool('vibe_v5_start', { problem: PROBLEM, researcherCount: 1 })
+  await hq.settleSpawns()
+  const fq = await hq.callTool('vibe_v5_paper', { force: true, editor: 'office', reason: 'real1004 复测' })
+  assert(fq.ok === true && fq.started === true, 'precondition: a forced office-editor paper starts (' + JSON.stringify(fq).slice(0, 130) + ')')
+  await drivePaper(hq)   // parts + cross-reviews land, so the office's finalisation reaches the CONSULT gate
+  const rq = await hq.callTool('vibe_v5_finalize_paper', { decision: 'deliverable', note: 'real1004：未重新征询，预期被具名拒绝' })
+  assert(rq.ok === false && rq.code === 'V5_PAPER_CONSULT_REQUIRED' && rq.restarted === true && /force/.test(String(rq.message)) && /重置/.test(String(rq.message)) && /重新/.test(String(rq.message)),
+    '★ [real1004-consult] an office finalisation after a force restart NAMES the reset (restarted=true, message explains the required re-consultation): ' + JSON.stringify(rq).slice(0, 300))
+}
 
 // ---------- 26. fake LaTeX: the success path produces paper.pdf ----------
 console.log('\n[26] fake LaTeX compiler: success path produces paper.pdf')
@@ -1452,6 +1466,35 @@ console.log('\n[27] fake LaTeX compiler: repair path and persistent-failure degr
   assert(tp.length >= 1 && joined.length === 0,
     '★ [task-17/v5] an ABSOLUTE explicit paperLatexCommand is probed ALONE — triedPaths never joins it onto a known TeX root (triedPaths=' + JSON.stringify(tp) + ')')
 }
+// real1004-minutes (found on a real host with 2.8.2): a speech that arrives AFTER the meeting closed — the
+// watchdog abandons a stalled meeting and the office may finalise early — used to be dropped SILENTLY, so the
+// minutes declared a speaking order ("r-1 → acad") that never appeared in the file (only "### r-1"). It must
+// be appended as a clearly-marked late note, and the earlier speeches must survive (append-only).
+{
+  const hm = makeHost({ pluginModule })
+  await hm.callTool('vibe_v5_start', { problem: PROBLEM, researcherCount: 1 })
+  await hm.settleSpawns()
+  const mt = await hm.callTool('vibe_v5_meeting', { agenda: 'real1004 晚到发言：会议收束后仍有人发言', kind: 'sync' })
+  const mid = mt && mt.meeting
+  assert(!!mid, 'precondition: the meeting is convened (' + JSON.stringify(mt).slice(0, 120) + ')')
+  await hm.drain(40)                                  // everyone speaks -> the meeting finalises, meeting = null
+  const mpath = join(hm.WS, 'VibeMath', 'Projects', 'default', 'Institutes', 'institute', 'Shared', 'Meetings', mid + '.md')
+  const before = readFileSync(mpath, 'utf8')
+  assert(/### /.test(before), 'precondition: the closed minutes already contain at least one speech: ' + before.slice(0, 140))
+  const stc = await hm.callTool('vibe_v5_status', {})
+  assert(!stc.meeting, 'precondition: the meeting is CLOSED (meeting=' + JSON.stringify(stc.meeting) + ') so a later speech has no live meeting')
+  // A LATE speech: the member submits `input` on a LATER wake while no meeting is running (exactly what a
+  // real host showed — the member kept submitting after the meeting was already closed).
+  await hm.callTool('vibe_v5_message', { to: 'acad', content: 'real1004：请再确认一次你的意见。' })
+  const wlate = await hm.peekWakeOf('acad', 8000)
+  assert(!!wlate, 'precondition: a member is woken again after the meeting closed (so the end block is processed)')
+  hm.fireEnd(wlate.childId, { input: 'real1004 晚到发言：会议收束之后我仍提交了意见。', contextPct: 20 })
+  await sleep(200)
+  const after = readFileSync(mpath, 'utf8')
+  assert(after.includes('real1004 晚到发言') && after.includes('会后补记'),
+    '★ [real1004-minutes] a speech arriving after the meeting closed is appended as a late note, never dropped silently')
+  assert(after.includes('### '), 'the earlier speeches are still in the minutes (append-only, never clobbered)')
+}
 
 // ---------- 28. office-only surface + id normalisation ----------
 console.log('\n[28] the final-paper surface is office-only and its directory id cannot escape Paper/')

package/tests/v5-institute-fixes.mutants.mjs

@@ -219,6 +219,22 @@ const FAMILIES = [
     to: ": ''",
     expect: /\[task-18\/v5\] the DELIVERED paper.md and paper.tex/,
   },
+  {
+    // real1004-minutes: a speech arriving after the meeting closed must be appended as a late note; dropping
+    // it silently is exactly what a real host showed (minutes declared "r-1 → acad" with only "### r-1").
+    name: 'real1004-minutes: a speech arriving after the meeting closed is dropped silently again',
+    from: "} else if (lastMeetingId && typeof p.input === 'string' && p.input.trim()) {",
+    to: '} else if (false) {',
+    expect: /\[real1004-minutes\] a speech arriving after the meeting closed/,
+  },
+  {
+    // real1004-consult: the office refusal must NAME the force reset (observed: 11 unnamed rejections on a real
+    // host). Dropping the clause must redden the guarding assertion by name.
+    name: 'real1004-consult: the office refusal stops naming the force restart',
+    from: 'const restarted = p.forced === true',
+    to: 'const restarted = false',
+    expect: /\[real1004-consult\] an office finalisation after a force restart NAMES the reset/,
+  },
 ]
 let red = 0
 for (const f of FAMILIES) { const ok = runFamily(f); if (ok) red++ }

package/vibe-math-v5/vibe-math-v5.js

@@ -990,6 +990,11 @@ export function apply(ctx) {
     const inflight = new Map()        // childId -> turn token (dedupes duplicate subagent/end)
     let heartbeatDisposer = null
     let meeting = null                // in-flight meeting round state
+    // real1004-minutes: the id of the MOST RECENT meeting. A speech can arrive AFTER the meeting was
+    // closed (the watchdog abandons a stalled meeting, and the office may finalise early); such a late
+    // submission used to be dropped SILENTLY, so the minutes claimed a speaking order that never appeared
+    // in the file. Keep the pointer so a late speech can still be appended as a clearly-marked note.
+    let lastMeetingId = ''
     let pendingMeeting = null          // parked meeting (never preempts verification)
     let digestTimer = null
     let lastProgressAt = now()
@@ -4971,6 +4976,7 @@ export function apply(ctx) {
         return idx
       } })
       const id = idx.id
+      lastMeetingId = id   // real1004-minutes: late speeches are appended to the most recent minutes
       meeting = {
         id, agenda: opts.agenda, kind: opts.kind || 'sync', target: opts.target || '',
         by: opts.by || 'office', order, inputs: {}, extras: {}, lastInputAt: now(), startedAt: now(),
@@ -5623,11 +5629,20 @@ export function apply(ctx) {
       }
       const consult = Object.assign({ messages: 0, meetings: 0 }, p.consult || {})
       if (!(Number(consult.messages) > 0) || !(Number(consult.meetings) > 0)) {
+        // real1004-consult: `force` REWRITES the paper (docs/final-paper.md: "force 重写已定稿的论文"), so the
+        // new paper starts with consult={0,0}. That is intended — but the refusal used to say nothing about it:
+        // on a real host the office was rejected ELEVEN times and only the members could infer why their
+        // earlier meeting had stopped counting. Name the reset, its reason, and what to do about it.
+        const restarted = p.forced === true
         return {
           ok: false, code: 'V5_PAPER_CONSULT_REQUIRED',
           message: 'paperEditor="office" 要求所办先与全所交流、商讨、优化、审查：至少 1 条所办消息（vibe_v5_message）+ 至少 1 次会议（vibe_v5_meeting），然后才能定稿。当前：messages=' +
-            Number(consult.messages || 0) + ', meetings=' + Number(consult.meetings || 0),
+            Number(consult.messages || 0) + ', meetings=' + Number(consult.meetings || 0) +
+            (restarted
+              ? '。注意：本论文由 force 重启（forceReason=' + String(p.forceReason || '') + '）⇒ consult 计数随新论文重置为 0，重启前的消息/会议不再计入，请**重新**征询（两个计数记录在 paper.meta.json）'
+              : ''),
           consult: { messages: Number(consult.messages || 0), meetings: Number(consult.meetings || 0) },
+          restarted,
         }
       }
       const fin = {
@@ -6808,6 +6823,20 @@ export function apply(ctx) {
         const rel = 'Shared/Meetings/' + meeting.id + '.md'
         const prev = (await readTextRel(rel)) || ('# 会议纪要｜' + meeting.id + '\n\n')
         await writeTextRel(rel, prev + '### ' + member.id + '\n' + (text || '（无发言）') + '\n\n')
+      } else if (lastMeetingId && typeof p.input === 'string' && p.input.trim()) {
+        // real1004-minutes: no live meeting, yet the member submitted a speech (a real host showed exactly
+        // this: `input` kept arriving after the meeting had been closed/abandoned). It used to be dropped
+        // SILENTLY — the minutes then declared a speaking order that never appeared in the file (`- 发言顺序:
+        // r-1 → acad` with only `### r-1` present). Append it as a clearly marked late note instead, keyed on
+        // ANY wake (not only meeting wakes: the observed submissions arrived on later rounds), de-duplicated by
+        // text so repeated submissions do not pile up.
+        const late = String(p.input).trim()
+        const rel = 'Shared/Meetings/' + lastMeetingId + '.md'
+        const prev = (await readTextRel(rel)) || ('# 会议纪要｜' + lastMeetingId + '\n\n')
+        if (prev.indexOf(late) === -1) {
+          await writeTextRel(rel, prev + '### ' + member.id + '（会后补记：该发言到达时会议已收束）\n' + late + '\n\n')
+          await saveChatLine('【会议 ' + lastMeetingId + '】' + member.id + ' 的发言在会议收束后到达，已作为补记写入纪要（不再静默丢弃）。')
+        }
       }
       if (p.solved !== undefined) {
         await writeTextRel('Shared/State-of-institute.md', [