dsh-vibe-math 2.2.2 → 2.3.1

package/formal-verify-v3.test.mjs

@@ -0,0 +1,1031 @@
+// ============================================================
+// V3 LEAN FORMAL VERIFICATION SUITE  (docs/formal-verification.md)
+//
+// Asserts the whole contract of the `formalVerify` knob on the v3 preset:
+//   · 'off'       is a TRUE no-op (no Lean text in ANY prompt, no Formal record, no gate)
+//   · 'encourage' injects the Lean section into the work prompts AND into both verification
+//                 prompts, and — the actual point of the feature — turns the voting prompt into
+//                 a FIDELITY review once a Lean run has passed
+//   · 'require'   withholds a true/false verdict as 未定论 until the object is Lean-passed or
+//                 carries an explicit, reasoned blocker record; then allows it, and the Verified
+//                 card records how strong the result really is
+//   · the three tools (run / archive / lib) write the right things to the right paths
+//
+// The Lean toolchain is mocked through the subprocess SERVICE, so the tests exercise the real
+// code path (resolveExecutable → spawn → collected stdout → exit code) without requiring Lean.
+//
+// V3_PLUGIN overrides the plugin under test: a sensitivity probe MUST point this suite at a
+// mutated copy, otherwise every probe would exercise the unmutated plugin and stay green.
+//
+// Run: node formal-verify-v3.test.mjs
+// ============================================================
+import { mkdtempSync, rmSync, existsSync, readFileSync, readdirSync, mkdirSync, writeFileSync } from 'node:fs'
+import { tmpdir } from 'node:os'
+import { join, dirname, isAbsolute, resolve as pathResolve } from 'node:path'
+import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url'
+
+const PLUGIN = process.env.V3_PLUGIN
+  ? new URL('file:///' + String(process.env.V3_PLUGIN).replace(/\\/g, '/'))
+  : new URL('./vibe-math-v3/vibe-math-v3.js', import.meta.url)
+const HERE = dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url))
+// AUDIT-CHECKLIST §2.4: the suite must also keep the INTERACTION TEXT it drove, so a human can
+// re-read the prompts the framework really emitted. V3_CORPUS_DIR overrides the destination.
+const CORPUS_DIR = process.env.V3_CORPUS_DIR ? pathResolve(process.env.V3_CORPUS_DIR) : join(HERE, 'prompt-corpus-v3')
+const WS = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), 'vibe-v3-lean-'))
+const VIBE = join(WS, 'VibeMath')
+const projRoot = (slug) => join(VIBE, 'Projects', slug)
+const readIf = (p) => (existsSync(p) ? readFileSync(p, 'utf8') : '')
+const reEsc = (s) => String(s).replace(/[.*+?^${}()|[\]\\]/g, '\\$&')
+const verifyRe = (target) => new RegExp('^verifier:r-' + reEsc(target) + '(?:-\\w+)?:\\d+$')
+
+let passed = 0, failed = 0
+const failures = []
+const assert = (c, m) => { if (c) { passed++; console.log('  ok - ' + m) } else { failed++; failures.push(m); console.error('  FAIL - ' + m) } }
+const sleep = (ms) => new Promise((r) => setTimeout(r, ms))
+const section = (t) => console.log('\n[' + t + ']')
+
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------
+// mock host
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------
+const listeners = {}
+const toolRegs = []
+const cmdRegs = []
+const spawns = []        // { label, childId, rootId, prompt }
+const wakes = []         // { childId, rootId, prompt }
+const interrupts = []
+const leanRuns = []      // { argv, file, cwd, graceMs }
+const terminated = []
+const roots = []
+let rootSeq = 0
+let subprocessAvailable = true
+let toolchainAvailable = true
+let spawnThrows = false
+// Interaction corpus (AUDIT-CHECKLIST §2.4): every prompt the framework actually sent, with the
+// workspace path normalised so the dump is deterministic and diffable.
+const corpus = []
+// Normalise BOTH slash forms. The VibeMath ROOT must be replaced BEFORE the workspace root,
+// otherwise `<WS>/VibeMath` would survive as a half-substituted path: the corpus would still leak
+// the machine layout and would not be diffable against another checkout.
+const scrub = (s) => String(s == null ? '' : s)
+  .split(VIBE).join('<VIBEMATH>')
+  .split(VIBE.replace(/\\/g, '/')).join('<VIBEMATH>')
+  .split(WS).join('<WS>')
+  .split(WS.replace(/\\/g, '/')).join('<WS>')
+
+// A fake Lean: a file PASSES unless it still contains `sorry` or the marker `-- FAIL`.
+// `-- HANG` simulates a toolchain that never returns (the timeout path).
+const subprocess = {
+  async resolveExecutable(cmd) {
+    if (!toolchainAvailable) throw new Error('spawn ' + cmd + ' ENOENT')
+    if (String(cmd) !== 'lean' && String(cmd) !== 'lake') throw new Error('unknown executable ' + cmd)
+    return String(cmd)
+  },
+  spawn(spec) {
+    const argv = spec.argv || []
+    const last = String(argv[argv.length - 1] || '')
+    const isShell = /powershell|cmd\.exe|\/bin\/sh|(^|\/)sh$/i.test(String(argv[0] || '')) || /New-Item|Remove-Item|Move-Item|^mkdir -p/.test(last)
+    if (isShell) {
+      // directory shim (v3's runShell: powershell New-Item / POSIX mkdir -p)
+      if (/New-Item/.test(last)) {
+        const m = last.match(/-Path\s+(?:'((?:[^']|'')*)'|"((?:[^"]|"")*)")/)
+        const raw = (m && (m[1] || m[2])) || ''
+        for (const p of raw.split(',').map((x) => x.replace(/''/g, "'"))) if (p) mkdirSync(p, { recursive: true })
+      }
+      if (/^mkdir -p/.test(last)) {
+        const re = /'((?:[^']|'\\'')*)'/g
+        let m
+        while ((m = re.exec(last)) !== null) mkdirSync(m[1].replace(/'\\''/g, "'"), { recursive: true })
+      }
+      if (/Remove-Item/.test(last)) {
+        const m = last.match(/-LiteralPath\s+'((?:[^']|'')*)'/)
+        if (m) rmSync(m[1].replace(/''/g, "'"), { force: true, recursive: true })
+      }
+      return { done: Promise.resolve({ exitCode: 0 }), collected: {} }
+    }
+    const file = last
+    const text = existsSync(file) ? readFileSync(file, 'utf8') : ''
+    leanRuns.push({ argv: argv.slice(0, -1), file, cwd: spec.cwd, graceMs: spec.graceMs })
+    if (spawnThrows) throw new Error('spawn ' + String(argv[0]) + ' EPERM')
+    if (/-- REJECT/.test(text)) {
+      return {
+        done: Promise.reject(new Error('child process died before reporting')),
+        collected: { stdout: { readFrom: () => ({ text: '', nextOffset: 0, lossy: false }) }, stderr: { readFrom: () => ({ text: '', nextOffset: 0, lossy: false }) } },
+        terminate() {},
+      }
+    }
+    if (/-- HANG/.test(text)) {
+      return {
+        done: new Promise(() => {}),
+        collected: { stdout: { readFrom: () => ({ text: '', nextOffset: 0, lossy: false }) }, stderr: { readFrom: () => ({ text: '', nextOffset: 0, lossy: false }) } },
+        terminate() { terminated.push(file) },
+      }
+    }
+    const bad = /sorry|-- FAIL/.test(text)
+    const stdout = bad ? '' : 'ok\n'
+    const stderr = bad ? 'error: declaration uses sorry\n' : ''
+    return {
+      done: Promise.resolve({ exitCode: bad ? 1 : 0, signal: null }),
+      collected: {
+        stdout: { readFrom: () => ({ text: stdout, nextOffset: stdout.length, lossy: false }) },
+        stderr: { readFrom: () => ({ text: stderr, nextOffset: stderr.length, lossy: false }) },
+      },
+      terminate() {},
+    }
+  },
+}
+
+const ctx = {
+  get(name) {
+    if (name === 'subprocess') return subprocessAvailable ? subprocess : undefined
+    if (name === 'sandboxPolicy') return { resolve() { return { workspaceRoot: WS } } }
+    return undefined
+  },
+  on(e, fn) { (listeners[e] = listeners[e] || []).push(fn) },
+  effect(fn) { const d = fn(); return () => { if (typeof d === 'function') d() } },
+  logger: { info() {}, warn() {}, error() {} },
+  tools: { register(spec) { toolRegs.push(spec); return () => {} } },
+  commands: { register(spec) { cmdRegs.push(spec); return () => {} } },
+  subagents: {
+    list() { return ['spawn'] },
+    async startContinuable({ label, request }) {
+      const childId = 'c' + (spawns.length + 1)
+      const rootId = (request && request.parent && request.parent.id) || ''
+      const prompt = (request && request.prompt && request.prompt[0] && request.prompt[0].text) || ''
+      spawns.push({ label, childId, rootId, prompt })
+      corpus.push({ kind: 'spawn', label, root: rootId, prompt: scrub(prompt) })
+      return { childId, messageId: 'm' + spawns.length }
+    },
+    async sendMessage(parent, childId, blocks) {
+      const rootId = (parent && parent.id) || ''
+      const prompt = (blocks && blocks[0] && blocks[0].text) || ''
+      wakes.push({ childId, rootId, prompt })
+      const sp = spawns.find((s) => s.childId === childId)
+      corpus.push({ kind: 'wake', label: sp ? sp.label : childId, root: rootId, prompt: scrub(prompt) })
+      return 'w' + wakes.length
+    },
+    async followup(parent, childId, blocks) { return await this.sendMessage(parent, childId, blocks) },
+    interrupt(childId) { interrupts.push(childId) },
+  },
+  agents: { roots() { return roots.slice() }, get() { return undefined } },
+  // DSH 0.1.1 fs API: resolve → { targetKey, displayPath }
+  fs: {
+    async resolve(rel, opts) {
+      const base = (opts && opts.cwd) || WS
+      const p = (typeof rel === 'string' && isAbsolute(rel)) ? rel.replace(/\//g, '\\') : join(base, ...String(rel).split('/'))
+      return { targetKey: p, displayPath: p }
+    },
+    async stat(t) { return existsSync(t.targetKey) ? { version: 'v1', type: 'file', size: 1 } : undefined },
+    async readText(t) { return readFileSync(t.targetKey, 'utf8') },
+    async writeText(t, content) { mkdirSync(dirname(t.targetKey), { recursive: true }); writeFileSync(t.targetKey, content, 'utf8') },
+    async listDir(t) { if (!existsSync(t.targetKey)) return []; return readdirSync(t.targetKey, { withFileTypes: true }).map((e) => ({ name: e.name, type: e.isDirectory() ? 'directory' : 'file' })) },
+  },
+}
+
+const mod = await import(PLUGIN.href + '?t=' + Date.now())
+;(mod.default || mod).apply(ctx)
+
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------
+// driving helpers
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------
+function makeRoot() {
+  const id = 'sess-' + String.fromCharCode(65 + rootSeq++)
+  const root = { id, options: { provider: 'mock', model: 'mock-model' }, session: { id, header: { cwd: WS, parentSession: undefined } }, followup() {}, ctx: undefined }
+  roots.push(root)
+  return root
+}
+async function callTool(name, args, agent) {
+  const spec = toolRegs.find((s) => s.name === name)
+  if (!spec) throw new Error('no tool ' + name)
+  return JSON.parse(await spec.execute(args || {}, { agent }))
+}
+function fireEnd(childId, reply) {
+  const blocks = reply === undefined ? [] : [{ type: 'text', text: '```json\n' + JSON.stringify(reply) + '\n```' }]
+  for (const h of (listeners['subagent/end'] || [])) h({ id: childId, runId: 'r', provider: 'spawn', local: true, stopReason: 'completed', lastAssistantMessage: blocks })
+}
+const firedChildren = new Set()
+// Spawns created before a restart belong to a task the restart discarded; they are never a valid
+// target for a later round (their onChildEnd has no agentRegistry entry any more). The floor keeps
+// `unfiredVerifiers` from selecting them.
+const spawnFloor = {}
+const markFloor = (root) => { spawnFloor[root.id] = spawns.length }
+const spawnOf = (root, prefix) => spawns.filter((s) => s.rootId === root.id && s.label.startsWith(prefix))
+const lastSpawn = (root, prefix) => spawnOf(root, prefix).slice(-1)[0]
+const unfiredVerifiers = (root, re) => spawns.filter((s, i) => s.rootId === root.id && (spawnFloor[root.id] || 0) <= i && re.test(s.label) && !firedChildren.has(s.childId))
+const promptText = (root) => spawns.filter((s) => s.rootId === root.id).map((s) => s.prompt).join('\n') + '\n' + wakes.filter((w) => w.rootId === root.id).map((w) => w.prompt).join('\n')
+
+/** Parameters every verification scenario uses. A high concurrency cap keeps the fallback
+ *  scheduler from starving a later object behind a pile of unfired mock verifiers. */
+const VPARAMS = { plannerEnabled: false, verifierCount: 2, debateMaxRounds: 1, maxParallelThreshold: 64, tickIntervalMs: 200 }
+
+/** Fire the one in-flight forced planner with an empty plan (an empty plan schedules a tick). */
+async function pump(root) {
+  const pending = spawns.filter((s) => s.rootId === root.id && s.label.startsWith('planner:') && !firedChildren.has(s.childId)).slice(-1)[0]
+  if (pending) { firedChildren.add(pending.childId); fireEnd(pending.childId, { summary: 'noop', plan: [] }); return }
+  try { await callTool('vibe_math_plan', { force: true }, root) } catch (e) { /* not running / gated */ }
+}
+/** Poll `pred`, nudging the scheduler along with an empty forced plan (the 1s tick timer is the fallback). */
+async function drive(root, pred, label, timeoutMs) {
+  const deadline = Date.now() + (timeoutMs || 15000)
+  while (Date.now() < deadline) {
+    if (pred()) return true
+    await pump(root)
+    await sleep(80)
+  }
+  if (pred()) return true
+  console.error('  .. drive timed out: ' + label)
+  return false
+}
+/** Fire the next `results.length` verifiers of one object (any of its candidate rIds). */
+async function runVerifyRound(root, target, results, timeoutMs) {
+  const re = verifyRe(target)
+  const ok = await drive(root, () => unfiredVerifiers(root, re).length >= results.length, 'verifiers for r-' + target, timeoutMs)
+  if (!ok) return null
+  const un = unfiredVerifiers(root, re).slice(0, results.length)
+  for (let i = 0; i < un.length; i++) { firedChildren.add(un[i].childId); fireEnd(un[i].childId, { Result: results[i], Reason: 'mock 裁决 ' + results[i] }) }
+  await sleep(220)
+  return un
+}
+/** Abort + restart: gives the next verification a FRESH task, so a prompt is guaranteed to be
+ *  constructed after whatever changed in between (mode switch, archived proof, …). */
+async function restart(root) {
+  await callTool('vibe_math_abort', {}, root)
+  await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, root)
+  markFloor(root)
+}
+
+console.log('-- V3 Lean formal verification --')
+console.log('plugin under test: ' + PLUGIN.href)
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 1. 'off' is a true no-op
+// ===============================================================
+section("1 'off' (default) is a true no-op")
+const RA = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-off' }, RA)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', Object.assign({}, VPARAMS), RA)
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-off', 概述: '关模式下的普通命题', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RA)
+await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, RA)
+const offRound = await runVerifyRound(RA, 'p-off', [1, 1])
+assert(offRound !== null && offRound.length === 2, 'off: two independent verifiers were asked (投票流程照常)')
+const offProj = projRoot('lean-off')
+assert(await drive(RA, () => existsSync(join(offProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-off.md')), 'off Verified card'), "'off' still finalizes on a unanimous boolean vote with NO Lean artifact")
+{
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RA)
+  assert(st.params.formalVerify === 'off', "the default is 'off' (got " + st.params.formalVerify + ')')
+  const all = promptText(RA)
+  assert(!/Lean/.test(all), 'no prompt mentions Lean in off mode')
+  assert(!/形式化/.test(all), 'no prompt mentions 形式化 in off mode')
+  assert(!/\[形式化\]/.test(all), 'the [形式化] announcement line is absent in off mode')
+}
+assert(!/形式化/.test(readIf(join(offProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-off.md'))), 'the Verified card carries no formal line in off mode')
+assert(!existsSync(join(offProj, 'Formal', 'Index.md')), 'no Formal/Index.md is produced in off mode (no formal record)')
+assert(!existsSync(join(offProj, 'State', 'formal.json')), 'no State/formal.json is produced in off mode')
+{
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RA)
+  assert(st.formal.mode === 'off' && st.formal.objects.length === 0, 'status reports mode=off with zero formal objects')
+}
+// the tools still EXIST in off mode (static registration), they are just never advertised
+assert(!!toolRegs.find((t) => t.name === 'vibe_math_lean_run') && !!toolRegs.find((t) => t.name === 'vibe_math_lean_archive') && !!toolRegs.find((t) => t.name === 'vibe_math_lean_lib'),
+  'the three Lean tools are registered in every mode (registration is static)')
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 2. parameter validation + runtime switching
+// ===============================================================
+section('2 parameter validation and runtime switching')
+const RB = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-params' }, RB)
+const bad = await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { formalVerify: 'banana' }, RB)
+assert(bad.params.formalVerify === 'off', "an unknown mode degrades to 'off', never to a stronger mode (got " + bad.params.formalVerify + ')')
+const bad2 = await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { formalVerify: 'REQUIRE' }, RB)
+assert(bad2.params.formalVerify === 'off', 'the mode is matched exactly (a case typo cannot force formalization)')
+const enc = await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { formalVerify: 'encourage' }, RB)
+assert(enc.params.formalVerify === 'encourage', "'encourage' is accepted")
+const req = await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { formalVerify: 'require', leanTimeoutMs: -5, leanCommand: '   ' }, RB)
+assert(req.params.formalVerify === 'require', "'require' is accepted")
+assert(req.params.leanTimeoutMs === 120000, 'a non-positive leanTimeoutMs falls back to the default (' + req.params.leanTimeoutMs + ')')
+assert((await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { leanTimeoutMs: 0 }, RB)).params.leanTimeoutMs === 120000, 'leanTimeoutMs=0 also falls back to the default')
+assert(req.params.leanCommand === 'lean', 'a blank leanCommand falls back to "lean"')
+const t5 = await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { leanTimeoutMs: 5000 }, RB)
+assert(t5.params.leanTimeoutMs === 5000, 'a positive leanTimeoutMs is accepted (got ' + t5.params.leanTimeoutMs + ')')
+const arrBad = await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { leanArgs: 'not-an-array' }, RB)
+assert(Array.isArray(arrBad.params.leanArgs) && arrBad.params.leanArgs.length === 0, 'a non-array leanArgs falls back to []')
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { leanCommand: 'lake', leanArgs: ['env', 'lean'] }, RB)
+const stL = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RB)
+assert(stL.params.leanCommand === 'lake' && stL.params.leanArgs.join(' ') === 'env lean', 'leanCommand/leanArgs are settable (lake env lean)')
+{
+  const setup = await callTool('vibe_math_setup', {}, RB)
+  const names = setup.parameters.map((p) => p.name)
+  assert(names.indexOf('formalVerify') !== -1 && names.indexOf('leanCommand') !== -1 && names.indexOf('leanArgs') !== -1 && names.indexOf('leanTimeoutMs') !== -1,
+    'the settings schema surfaces all four Lean parameters')
+  const f = setup.parameters.find((p) => p.name === 'formalVerify')
+  assert(f.default === 'off' && f.current === 'require', 'the schema carries the default (off) and the current value (require)')
+  const tmpl = await callTool('vibe_math_template', { where: 'project' }, RB)
+  const tj = readIf(join(projRoot('lean-params'), 'vibe_math_setting.json'))
+  assert(tmpl.ok === true && /"formalVerify": "off"/.test(tj) && /"leanArgs": \[\]/.test(tj), 'the generated settings template documents the Lean parameters with their defaults')
+  assert(/formalVerify — /.test(tj), 'the template carries the human-readable parameter description as a comment')
+}
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 3. 'encourage' injection into the WORK prompts
+// ===============================================================
+section("3 'encourage' injects 顺手形式化 into solver / explorer / method-keeper prompts")
+const RC = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-work' }, RC)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', Object.assign({}, VPARAMS, { formalVerify: 'encourage', methodKeepEvery: 1 }), RC)
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_problem', { id: 'qE', description: '证明 log 2 是无理数', priority: 0 }, RC)
+await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, RC)
+assert(await drive(RC, () => !!lastSpawn(RC, 'explorer:qE'), 'explorer:qE'), 'fallback scheduler spawned explorer:qE')
+{
+  const p = lastSpawn(RC, 'explorer:qE').prompt
+  assert(/【顺手形式化（鼓励）】/.test(p), 'the explorer work prompt carries the 顺手形式化 line')
+  assert(/vibe_math_lean_archive kind='def'/.test(p), 'the work prompt points at the archive tool for reusable definitions')
+  assert(/vibe_math_lean_lib 查重/.test(p), 'the work prompt tells agents to check the reuse library first')
+  assert(/形式化回执/.test(p) && /"decision":"used\|blocked\|defect"/.test(p), '★ the work-round reply contract also advertises the formal field, defect included (契约 §6.3)')
+}
+fireEnd(lastSpawn(RC, 'explorer:qE').childId, { meta: { kind: 'directions', qid: 'qE', formal: { target: 'qE', decision: 'blocked', note: '需要先形式化连分数收敛定理' }, directions: [{ id: 'd1', title: '连分数法', method: 'e 的连分数', core_assumption: '', feasibility: 0.7 }] } })
+// Answer EVERY explorer the fallback scheduler dispatches (it re-derives when a direction looks
+// unattended) until the solver for d1 appears — otherwise the retry cap can stall the project.
+for (let guard = 0; guard < 40 && !lastSpawn(RC, 'solver:qE:d1'); guard++) {
+  const ex = spawns.filter((s) => s.rootId === RC.id && s.label.startsWith('explorer:qE') && !firedChildren.has(s.childId)).slice(-1)[0]
+  if (ex) {
+    firedChildren.add(ex.childId)
+    fireEnd(ex.childId, { meta: { kind: 'directions', qid: 'qE', directions: [{ id: 'd1', title: '连分数法', method: 'e 的连分数', core_assumption: '', feasibility: 0.7 }] } })
+  }
+  await pump(RC)
+  await sleep(80)
+}
+assert(!!lastSpawn(RC, 'solver:qE:d1'), 'solver spawned for direction d1')
+assert(/【顺手形式化（鼓励）】/.test(lastSpawn(RC, 'solver:qE:d1').prompt), 'the solver work prompt carries the 顺手形式化 line')
+{
+  // the explorer's `meta.formal` judgement is recorded even though it never called a Lean tool
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RC)
+  assert(st.formal.blocked.indexOf('qE') !== -1, '★ an explorer `meta.formal` judgement is recorded (no Lean tool call needed)')
+  assert(/- 形式化: 阻塞（/.test(readIf(join(projRoot('lean-work'), 'Problems', 'qE.md'))), 'and it lands on the problem card anchor')
+}
+fireEnd(lastSpawn(RC, 'solver:qE:d1').childId, { status: 'continue', survival_probability: 0.6, formal: { target: 'd1-lemma', decision: 'used', file: 'Formal/d1-lemma.lean' }, new_inventions: [{ 类型: '工具', 标题: '连分数估值工具', 内容描述: '控制收敛速度', 是否已入库: false }] })
+await sleep(250)
+{
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RC)
+  assert(st.formal.objects.some((o) => o.target === 'd1-lemma' && o.status === 'attempted'), 'a solver top-level `formal.decision=used` reply records the object as attempted')
+}
+assert(await drive(RC, () => !!lastSpawn(RC, 'method-keeper'), 'method-keeper'), 'method keeper spawned for the pending invention')
+{
+  const p = lastSpawn(RC, 'method-keeper').prompt
+  assert(/【顺手形式化（鼓励）】/.test(p), 'the method-keeper prompt carries the 顺手形式化 line')
+  assert(/【方法沉淀 × Lean 形式化】/.test(p), '★ the method keeper is told to ALSO sediment reusable Lean definitions/lemmas')
+  assert(/kind='lemma'/.test(p) && /Proved/.test(p), 'and where the proved lemmas go')
+}
+await callTool('vibe_math_abort', {}, RC)
+assert((await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RC)).running === false, 'work-prompt scenario aborted (keeps later scenarios deterministic)')
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 4. 'encourage' injection into BOTH verification prompts + the fidelity switch
+// ===============================================================
+section("4 'encourage' reaches the review prompt and the debate prompt")
+const RD = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-verify' }, RD)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', Object.assign({}, VPARAMS, { formalVerify: 'encourage', debateMaxRounds: 2 }), RD)
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-enc', 概述: '鼓励模式下的忠实性审查', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RD)
+await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, RD)
+const encBatch = await runVerifyRound(RD, 'p-enc', [0.9, 0.95])
+assert(encBatch !== null, 'encourage: the first review round was asked')
+if (encBatch) {
+  const vp = encBatch.map((s) => s.prompt).join('\n')
+  assert(/【Lean 形式化验证（鼓励模式）】/.test(vp), 'the review prompt explains the Lean mode')
+  assert(/一旦 Lean 通过，你唯一需要确认的就是忠实性/.test(vp), 'the review prompt states that a passing Lean run shrinks the question to fidelity')
+  assert(/实现难度/.test(vp), 'the review prompt asks for the implementation-difficulty judgement')
+  assert(/可以不做，但请在回执的 formal 字段写明难度判断/.test(vp), "'encourage' explicitly allows skipping (with a recorded judgement)")
+  assert(/"formal":/.test(vp) && /"decision":"used\|blocked\|defect"/.test(vp), 'the reply contract documents the formal field (defect included)')
+  assert(/vibe_math_lean_run/.test(vp) && /vibe_math_lean_archive/.test(vp) && /vibe_math_lean_lib/.test(vp), 'the prompt names the three v3 Lean tools')
+  assert(/Formal\/（相对项目根）/.test(vp) && /VibeMath\/Formal\/Lib/.test(vp), 'the prompt states the path layout')
+}
+// a non-consensus round moves to the public debate, whose prompt must carry the same injection
+assert(await drive(RD, () => wakes.some((w) => w.rootId === RD.id && /交流群/.test(w.prompt)), 'debate prompt'), 'a non-consensus round moved to the debate')
+{
+  const dp = wakes.filter((w) => w.rootId === RD.id).map((w) => w.prompt).join('\n')
+  assert(/【Lean 形式化验证（鼓励模式）】/.test(dp), 'the debate prompt names the mode')
+  assert(/一旦 Lean 通过，你唯一需要确认的就是忠实性|你不需要重新检查推导/.test(dp), 'the debate prompt carries the Lean block too')
+  assert(/"formal":/.test(dp), 'the debate reply contract carries the formal field')
+}
+// finish the debate: a unanimous round concludes
+if (encBatch) for (const b of encBatch) fireEnd(b.childId, { Result: 1, Reason: 'mock 第二轮一致' })
+assert(await drive(RD, () => existsSync(join(projRoot('lean-verify'), 'Verified', '命题', 'p-enc.md')), 'p-enc verified'), 'the debate finished and the object was verified')
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 5. lean_run executes through the subprocess service and reports honestly
+// ===============================================================
+section('5 lean_run executes through the subprocess service and reports honestly')
+const RE = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-tools' }, RE)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { formalVerify: 'encourage' }, RE)
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-tool', 概述: '工具实验命题', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RE)
+const toolProj = projRoot('lean-tools')
+mkdirSync(join(toolProj, 'Formal'), { recursive: true })
+writeFileSync(join(toolProj, 'Formal', 'good.lean'), 'theorem t : 1 = 1 := rfl\n', 'utf8')
+writeFileSync(join(toolProj, 'Formal', 'bad.lean'), 'theorem t : 1 = 2 := by sorry\n', 'utf8')
+writeFileSync(join(toolProj, 'Formal', 'hang.lean'), '-- HANG\ntheorem t : 1 = 1 := rfl\n', 'utf8')
+{
+  const runGood = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/good.lean', target: 'p-tool' }, RE)
+  assert(runGood.ok === true && runGood.exitCode === 0, 'a file with no sorry runs green (' + JSON.stringify({ ok: runGood.ok, exitCode: runGood.exitCode }) + ')')
+  assert(/ok/.test(runGood.stdout), 'the compiler stdout is returned')
+  const last = leanRuns[leanRuns.length - 1]
+  assert(last.cwd.replace(/\\/g, '/') === toolProj.replace(/\\/g, '/'), 'the toolchain runs with the PROJECT root as cwd')
+  assert(last.argv.join(' ') === 'lean', 'by default the argv is just the executable (got ' + last.argv.join(' ') + ')')
+  assert(last.graceMs === 120000, 'the default leanTimeoutMs is passed down as graceMs (' + last.graceMs + ')')
+}
+{
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RE)
+  const o = st.formal.objects.find((x) => x.target === 'p-tool')
+  assert(!!o && o.status === 'attempted', 'lean_run with target records the object as attempted (not passed)')
+  assert(!!o.run && o.run.ok === true, 'the run result is recorded on the object')
+  const card = readIf(join(toolProj, 'Propos', '数论', 'p-tool.md'))
+  assert(/- 形式化: 已尝试未通过/.test(card), '★ the object card anchor block gains `- 形式化: <状态>` alongside 状态/概率')
+  assert(/\n- ID: p-tool\n/.test(card) && /\n- 状态: 未定论\n/.test(card) && /\n- 概率: 0.6\n/.test(card), 'the pre-existing anchors are untouched (the scheduler parser keeps working)')
+}
+{
+  const runBad = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/bad.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(runBad.ok === false && runBad.exitCode === 1, 'a file that still uses sorry reports a red run')
+  assert(/sorry/.test(runBad.stderr), 'the compiler output is returned verbatim (' + JSON.stringify(runBad.stderr).slice(0, 60) + ')')
+}
+{
+  const runMissing = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/nope.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(runMissing.ok === false && runMissing.code === 'V3_NOT_FOUND', 'a missing file is refused with a typed code')
+}
+{
+  // The guard's boundary is the VibeMath ROOT, not the project: the global reuse library
+  // deliberately lives at <VibeMath>/Formal/{Lib,Proved}, so climbing out of the project but
+  // staying inside VibeMath must remain legal (it just fails as a missing file).
+  const inside = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: '../../Formal/Lib/x.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(inside.code === 'V3_NOT_FOUND', 'climbing out of the project but staying inside VibeMath is allowed (the global library lives there)')
+  const esc1 = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: '../../../evil.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(esc1.ok === false && esc1.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', '★ a traversal that climbs ABOVE the VibeMath root is refused')
+  const esc2 = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/../../../../../../evil.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(esc2.ok === false && esc2.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'a deeper traversal is refused too')
+  const esc3 = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: '/etc/evil.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(esc3.ok === false && esc3.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'an unrelated absolute path is refused')
+  const notLean = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/good.txt' }, RE)
+  assert(notLean.ok === false && notLean.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'only .lean files can be executed')
+  const noFile = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', {}, RE)
+  assert(noFile.ok === false && noFile.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'a missing file argument is refused')
+}
+{
+  toolchainAvailable = false
+  const runNoTc = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/good.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(runNoTc.ok === false && runNoTc.code === 'LEAN_NOT_FOUND', 'a missing toolchain returns LEAN_NOT_FOUND instead of crashing')
+  assert(/仍可把形式化代码写下来归档/.test(runNoTc.message), 'the failure explains the graceful degradation')
+  toolchainAvailable = true
+}
+{
+  subprocessAvailable = false
+  const runNoSub = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/good.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(runNoSub.ok === false && runNoSub.code === 'NO_SUBPROCESS', 'a host without the subprocess service returns NO_SUBPROCESS')
+  subprocessAvailable = true
+}
+{
+  const runHang = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/hang.lean', timeout_ms: 1000 }, RE)
+  assert(runHang.ok === false && runHang.code === 'LEAN_TIMEOUT' && runHang.timedOut === true, '★ a hanging toolchain returns LEAN_TIMEOUT instead of wedging the scheduler')
+  assert(terminated.some((f) => /hang\.lean$/.test(f)), '★ the timeout path calls handle.terminate()')
+}
+{
+  spawnThrows = true
+  const runSpawn = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/good.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(runSpawn.ok === false && runSpawn.code === 'LEAN_SPAWN_FAILED', 'a spawn failure is reported as LEAN_SPAWN_FAILED instead of throwing')
+  spawnThrows = false
+  writeFileSync(join(toolProj, 'Formal', 'reject.lean'), '-- REJECT\ntheorem t : 1 = 1 := rfl\n', 'utf8')
+  const runReject = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/reject.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(runReject.ok === false && runReject.code === 'LEAN_RUN_FAILED', 'a rejecting handle.done is reported as LEAN_RUN_FAILED instead of throwing into the loop')
+}
+{
+  await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { leanCommand: 'lake', leanArgs: ['env', 'lean'] }, RE)
+  const runLake = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_run', { file: 'Formal/good.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(runLake.ok === true, 'lake env lean works through leanCommand/leanArgs')
+  assert(leanRuns[leanRuns.length - 1].argv.join(' ') === 'lake env lean', 'the argv is [exe, ...leanArgs, file] (got ' + leanRuns[leanRuns.length - 1].argv.join(' ') + ')')
+  await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { leanCommand: 'lean', leanArgs: [] }, RE)
+}
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 6. lean_archive: def / lemma / proof / blocked → the right paths + indexes
+// ===============================================================
+section('6 lean_archive writes the contract paths and rebuilds the indexes')
+const libPath = join(VIBE, 'Formal', 'Lib')
+const provedPath = join(VIBE, 'Formal', 'Proved')
+{
+  const defRes = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'def', name: 'ZMod5', content: 'def ZMod5 := Fin 5\n' }, RE)
+  assert(defRes.ok === true && defRes.file === 'Formal/Lib/ZMod5.lean', 'a reusable definition is archived to the global lib (' + defRes.file + ')')
+  assert(existsSync(join(libPath, 'ZMod5.lean')), '★ the definition exists under VibeMath/Formal/Lib/ (cross-project, NOT inside the project)')
+  assert(!existsSync(join(toolProj, 'Formal', 'Lib', 'ZMod5.lean')), 'it is NOT duplicated inside the project tree')
+  assert(defRes.run && defRes.run.ok === true, 'the reusable definition is executed on archive (run defaults to true)')
+  const libIdx = readIf(join(libPath, 'Index.md'))
+  assert(/\| 名称 \| 文件 \| 类别 \| 摘要 \| 最近运行 \|/.test(libIdx), 'Lib/Index.md uses the contract columns')
+  assert(/ZMod5/.test(libIdx) && /Lib\/ZMod5\.lean/.test(libIdx) && /\| ok \|/.test(libIdx), 'Lib/Index.md lists the new definition with its run result')
+  assert(!/ZMod5/.test(readIf(join(toolProj, 'Formal', 'Index.md'))), 'the global definition does not pollute the project formal index')
+}
+{
+  const lemRes = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'lemma', name: 'sq_odd', content: 'import Mathlib\n\ntheorem sq_odd (n : Nat) : Odd (n*n) → Odd n := by omega\n' }, RE)
+  assert(lemRes.ok === true && lemRes.file === 'Formal/Proved/sq_odd.lean', 'a lemma is archived to Proved/')
+  assert(existsSync(join(provedPath, 'sq_odd.lean')), 'the lemma exists under VibeMath/Formal/Proved/')
+  const provedIdx = readIf(join(provedPath, 'Index.md'))
+  assert(/\| 名称 \| 文件 \| 陈述 \| 依赖 \| 最近运行 \|/.test(provedIdx), 'Proved/Index.md uses the contract columns')
+  assert(/sq_odd/.test(provedIdx) && /Mathlib/.test(provedIdx), 'Proved/Index.md lists the lemma and its imports as 依赖')
+}
+{
+  const noRun = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'def', name: 'NoRun', content: 'def NoRun := 1\n', run: false }, RE)
+  assert(noRun.ok === true && noRun.run === undefined, 'run=false archives WITHOUT executing (no toolchain needed)')
+}
+{
+  const noName = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'def', content: 'def x := 1\n' }, RE)
+  assert(noName.ok === false && noName.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'archiving a definition without a name is refused')
+  const badKind = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'nonsense' }, RE)
+  assert(badKind.ok === false && badKind.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'an unknown archive kind is refused')
+  const noTarget = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', content: 'theorem x : 1 = 1 := rfl\n' }, RE)
+  assert(noTarget.ok === false && noTarget.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'kind=proof without a target is refused')
+  const noBody = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', target: 'p-x' }, RE)
+  assert(noBody.ok === false && noBody.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'kind=proof without content/from is refused')
+  const badFrom = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', target: 'p-x', from: '../../../evil.lean' }, RE)
+  assert(badFrom.ok === false && badFrom.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'kind=proof with an out-of-tree from is refused')
+}
+{
+  // a green proof → passed + Verified/Lean (the archived proof lives next to the conclusion)
+  const arc = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', target: 'p-proof', content: 'theorem p_proof : 3 * 1 ^ 2 - 2 = (1:Nat) ^ 2 := by decide\n' }, RE)
+  assert(arc.ok === true && arc.passed === true, 'the proof is archived and passes (' + JSON.stringify({ ok: arc.ok, passed: arc.passed }) + ')')
+  assert(arc.file === 'Formal/p-proof.lean', 'the working file is Formal/<target>.lean')
+  assert(arc.proof === 'Verified/Lean/p-proof.lean', 'the archived proof path is Verified/Lean/<target>.lean')
+  assert(existsSync(join(toolProj, 'Formal', 'p-proof.lean')), 'the working file exists on disk')
+  assert(existsSync(join(toolProj, 'Verified', 'Lean', 'p-proof.lean')), '★ the proof is archived under Verified/Lean/ as the proof of that object')
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RE)
+  assert(st.formal.passed.indexOf('p-proof') !== -1, 'status reports the object as Lean-passed')
+  const idx = readIf(join(toolProj, 'Formal', 'Index.md'))
+  assert(/# Lean 形式化索引/.test(idx) && /p-proof/.test(idx) && /passed/.test(idx) && /Verified\/Lean\/p-proof\.lean/.test(idx), 'Formal/Index.md indexes the object, its status and its archived proof')
+  assert(/ok（exit 0，/.test(idx), 'the index shows the run result in the contract format')
+  // a RED proof must NOT become passed
+  const red = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', target: 'p-red', content: 'theorem p_red : 1 = 2 := by sorry\n' }, RE)
+  assert(red.ok === true && red.passed === false && red.status === 'attempted', 'a red proof is archived as attempted, not passed')
+  assert(!existsSync(join(toolProj, 'Verified', 'Lean', 'p-red.lean')), '★ no archived proof is written for a red run')
+}
+{
+  const blkNoNote = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'blocked', target: 'p-blk' }, RE)
+  assert(blkNoNote.ok === false && blkNoNote.code === 'V3_INVALID_ARGUMENT', 'blocked without a note is refused')
+  const blk = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'blocked', target: 'p-blk', note: '需要外层解析数论框架，本轮工作量不可接受' }, RE)
+  assert(blk.ok === true && blk.status === 'blocked', 'a reasoned blocker is recorded')
+  const stBlk = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RE)
+  assert(stBlk.formal.blocked.indexOf('p-blk') !== -1, 'status lists the blocked object')
+  assert(/需要外层解析数论框架/.test(readIf(join(toolProj, 'Formal', 'Index.md'))), 'the blocker reason is written into the index')
+}
+{
+  const libList = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_lib', {}, RE)
+  assert(libList.ok === true && libList.counts.lib >= 2 && libList.counts.proved >= 1, 'lean_lib reports the reuse library sizes (' + JSON.stringify(libList.counts) + ')')
+  assert(libList.objects.some((o) => o.target === 'p-proof' && o.status === 'passed'), 'lean_lib lists per-object formal status')
+  assert(/复用优先/.test(libList.hint || ''), 'lean_lib tells agents to reuse before redefining')
+  assert(libList.paths && /VibeMath\/Formal\/Lib/.test(libList.paths.lib), 'lean_lib reports the cross-project path layout')
+  const ro = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_lib', { refresh: false }, RE)
+  assert(ro.rebuilt === false && ro.counts.lib === null, 'refresh:false only reads (does not rebuild the indexes)')
+}
+{
+  const ann = readIf(join(toolProj, 'Logs', '形式化.md'))
+  assert(/# 形式化公告/.test(ann) && /ZMod5/.test(ann) && /p-proof/.test(ann), 'the announcement log records what was formalized')
+}
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 7. the 'require' gate
+// ===============================================================
+section("7 'require' withholds a verdict until the formal record exists")
+const RF = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-gate' }, RF)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', Object.assign({}, VPARAMS, { formalVerify: 'require' }), RF)
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-gate', 概述: '必须形式化的命题', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RF)
+const gateProj = projRoot('lean-gate')
+await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, RF)
+{
+  const batch = await runVerifyRound(RF, 'p-gate', [1, 1])
+  assert(batch !== null, 'require: the review round was asked')
+  if (batch) {
+    const vp = batch.map((s) => s.prompt).join('\n')
+    assert(/【Lean 形式化验证（强制模式）】/.test(vp), 'the review prompt says 强制模式')
+    assert(/必须产出 Lean 形式化/.test(vp), "'require' states the formalization is mandatory")
+    assert(/本次裁定不会生效/.test(vp), 'the prompt warns that the verdict will not take effect without it')
+    assert(/formal-required/.test(vp), 'the prompt names the machine-readable reason')
+    assert(/归档可复用定义\/引理前先跑通（vibe_math_lean_archive run=true 或先 vibe_math_lean_run）；跑不通不要入库。/.test(vp),
+      '★ the verification prompt requires a GREEN run before archiving into the reuse library (§6 hard requirement 3)')
+    assert(/宿主没有 Lean 工具链（LEAN_NOT_FOUND）时：把代码写下来归档，并在回执的 note 里写明"宿主无 Lean 工具链"/.test(vp),
+      '★ and spells out the way out when the host has no Lean toolchain (§6 hard requirement 4)')
+    assert(/Result/.test(vp) && !/verdict/.test(vp) && !/(^|[^a-z_])lean_(run|archive|lib)/.test(vp),
+      '★ the voting prompt uses FULL tool names and names Result, never verdict (§6 hard requirements 1-2)')
+  }
+}
+assert(await drive(RF, () => /p-gate/.test(readIf(join(gateProj, 'Formal', 'TODO.md'))), 'p-gate in Formal/TODO.md'), '★ a unanimous TRUE verdict was withheld: the object is on the formalization TODO')
+assert(!existsSync(join(gateProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-gate.md')), 'no Verified card was written')
+{
+  const card = readIf(join(gateProj, 'Propos', '数论', 'p-gate.md'))
+  assert(/- 概率: 0.6/.test(card), '★ the object keeps its existing probability (no silent promotion to 1)')
+  assert(/- 状态: 未定论/.test(card), 'and its 状态 stays 未定论')
+  const todo = readIf(join(gateProj, 'Formal', 'TODO.md'))
+  assert(/# 形式化待办/.test(todo) && /p-gate/.test(todo) && /formal-required/.test(todo), '★ the TODO records the object with the machine-readable reason')
+  const idx = readIf(join(gateProj, 'Formal', 'Index.md'))
+  assert(/## 形式化待办/.test(idx) && /p-gate/.test(idx), 'Formal/Index.md mirrors the formalization TODO')
+  const ann = readIf(join(gateProj, 'Logs', '形式化.md'))
+  assert(/require 模式/.test(ann) && /不定论/.test(ann), '★ the withholding is announced')
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RF)
+  assert(st.formal.todo.some((t) => t.id === 'p-gate'), 'status lists the deferred object')
+  assert(/formal-required/.test(st.recentActivity.map((e) => e.detail).join('\n')), 'the activity feed shows the formal-required deferral')
+  const voteLog = readdirSync(join(gateProj, 'Logs', 'Verification')).filter((f) => /^r-p-gate_/.test(f))
+  assert(voteLog.length >= 1, 'the votes themselves are still recorded in Logs/Verification (nothing is lost)')
+}
+// runtime switch: the mode is read when the prompt is CONSTRUCTED, so a fresh round reflects it
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-mode', 概述: '模式切换观察对象', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RF)
+await restart(RF)
+assert(await drive(RF, () => unfiredVerifiers(RF, verifyRe('p-mode')).length >= 2, 'fresh verifiers in require mode'), 'a fresh object is still verified in require mode')
+{
+  const fresh = unfiredVerifiers(RF, verifyRe('p-mode'))[0]
+  assert(!!fresh && /【Lean 形式化验证（强制模式）】/.test(fresh.prompt) && /本次裁定不会生效/.test(fresh.prompt), 'a fresh round reflects the current mode (强制模式)')
+}
+// ★ anti-idle: a deferred object must NOT be re-voted while it sits on the TODO (each round would
+// just be withheld again, burning verifiers on the same rId every tick). The assertion is only
+// meaningful because the previous block proved the scheduler IS allocating verify tasks here.
+assert(unfiredVerifiers(RF, verifyRe('p-gate')).length === 0, '★ a deferred object is NOT re-voted while it sits on the formalization TODO (no verification livelock)')
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { formalVerify: 'encourage' }, RF)
+await restart(RF)
+assert(await drive(RF, () => unfiredVerifiers(RF, verifyRe('p-mode')).length >= 2, 'fresh verifiers after the mode switch'), 'the unresolved object is verified again after the mode switch')
+{
+  const fresh = unfiredVerifiers(RF, verifyRe('p-mode'))[0]
+  assert(!!fresh && /【Lean 形式化验证（鼓励模式）】/.test(fresh.prompt), '★ switching the mode at runtime immediately changes the prompt (now 鼓励模式)')
+  assert(!!fresh && !/本次裁定不会生效/.test(fresh.prompt), 'and the mandatory wording is gone in encourage mode')
+}
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', { formalVerify: 'require' }, RF)
+// formalize it, restart (so the next prompt is built AFTER the proof exists), then re-verify
+{
+  const proofNow = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', target: 'p-gate', content: 'theorem p_gate : 2 + 2 = 4 := by decide\n' }, RF)
+  assert(proofNow.ok === true && proofNow.passed === true, 'the object is now Lean-passed')
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RF)
+  assert(st.formal.passed.indexOf('p-gate') !== -1, 'status reports p-gate as passed')
+  assert(!st.formal.todo.some((t) => t.id === 'p-gate'), '★ satisfying the gate removes the object from the formalization TODO (no stale TODO)')
+  assert(!/p-gate/.test(readIf(join(gateProj, 'Formal', 'TODO.md'))), 'Formal/TODO.md no longer lists it')
+  assert(/- 形式化: Lean 通过/.test(readIf(join(gateProj, 'Propos', '数论', 'p-gate.md'))), 'the object card anchor now records Lean 通过')
+}
+await restart(RF)
+assert(await drive(RF, () => unfiredVerifiers(RF, verifyRe('p-gate')).length >= 2, 'p-gate re-eligible after passing'), '★ once the formal record satisfies the gate, the object becomes eligible for verification again')
+{
+  const batch = await runVerifyRound(RF, 'p-gate', [1, 1])
+  assert(batch !== null, 'the re-verification round was asked')
+  if (batch) {
+    const vp = batch.map((s) => s.prompt).join('\n')
+    assert(/该对象已有\*\*通过的 Lean 形式化证明\*\*/.test(vp), 'the voting prompt announces the passing proof')
+    assert(/你不需要重新检查推导/.test(vp), '★ it tells voters NOT to re-derive')
+    assert(/忠实性审查/.test(vp), '★ it tells voters the review subject is now fidelity')
+    assert(/定义 \/ 对象 \/ 条件 \/ 假设 \/ 结论是否与命题原文\*\*完全一致\*\*/.test(vp), 'it enumerates exactly what fidelity means')
+    assert(!/必须产出 Lean 形式化/.test(vp), 'and the "must formalize" wording is replaced (the object already has one)')
+  }
+}
+assert(await drive(RF, () => existsSync(join(gateProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-gate.md')), 'p-gate Verified card'), '★ with a passing Lean artifact the same vote DOES promote it')
+{
+  const card = readIf(join(gateProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-gate.md'))
+  assert(/- 形式化: Lean 通过/.test(card), '★ the Verified card records how strong the result is (Lean 通过)')
+  assert(/Verified\/Lean\/p-gate\.lean/.test(card), 'the card points at the archived proof')
+  assert(/- 结论: 真/.test(card), 'the card states the conclusion')
+}
+// the blocker escape hatch must also open the gate
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-blocked-ok', 概述: '记录阻塞后可定论', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RF)
+await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'blocked', target: 'p-blocked-ok', note: '命题涉及未形式化的分析学，本轮不做' }, RF)
+await restart(RF)
+assert(await runVerifyRound(RF, 'p-blocked-ok', [1, 1]) !== null, 'the blocked object is put to a vote')
+assert(await drive(RF, () => existsSync(join(gateProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-blocked-ok.md')), 'p-blocked-ok Verified card'), '★ an explicit reasoned blocker also lets the verdict through (decide by difficulty, but decide out loud)')
+{
+  const card = readIf(join(gateProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-blocked-ok.md'))
+  assert(/- 形式化: 阻塞（/.test(card), 'the Verified card records the blocker')
+  assert(/未形式化的分析学/.test(card), 'and quotes the reason')
+}
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 8. the reply-channel judgement (formal field in the verifier reply)
+// ===============================================================
+section('8 the per-round `formal` reply channel records the difficulty judgement')
+const RG = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-reply' }, RG)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', Object.assign({}, VPARAMS, { formalVerify: 'require' }), RG)
+const replyProj = projRoot('lean-reply')
+
+// (a) blocked WITH a note → recorded, reason reaches the index + the card anchor
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-reply', 概述: '用回执记录阻塞', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RG)
+await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, RG)
+{
+  const re = verifyRe('p-reply')
+  assert(await drive(RG, () => unfiredVerifiers(RG, re).length >= 2, 'verifiers for r-p-reply'), 'p-reply was put to a vote')
+  const vs = unfiredVerifiers(RG, re).slice(0, 2)
+  if (vs.length === 2) {
+    for (const v of vs) firedChildren.add(v.childId)
+    // A verifier that never calls a Lean tool still has to state its difficulty judgement: the
+    // JSON reply channel is the path that actually fires in practice.
+    fireEnd(vs[0].childId, { Result: 0.5, Reason: '我判断形式化不划算', formal: { target: 'p-reply', decision: 'blocked', note: '需要大量未形式化的实分析前置知识' } })
+    await sleep(150)
+    const st1 = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RG)
+    assert(st1.formal.blocked.indexOf('p-reply') !== -1, 'a `formal.decision=blocked` reply is recorded as a blocker')
+    assert(/实分析前置知识/.test(readIf(join(replyProj, 'Formal', 'Index.md'))), 'and its reason reaches the index')
+    assert(/- 形式化: 阻塞（/.test(readIf(join(replyProj, 'Propos', '数论', 'p-reply.md'))), 'the reply-recorded blocker also lands on the object card anchor')
+    fireEnd(vs[1].childId, { Result: 0.5, Reason: '同上' })
+    await sleep(200)
+  }
+}
+// (b) `used` records attempted — which does NOT open the require gate
+await restart(RG)
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-used', 概述: '写了草稿但没跑通', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RG)
+{
+  const re = verifyRe('p-used')
+  assert(await drive(RG, () => unfiredVerifiers(RG, re).length >= 2, 'verifiers for r-p-used'), 'p-used was put to a vote')
+  const vs = unfiredVerifiers(RG, re).slice(0, 2)
+  if (vs.length === 2) {
+    for (const v of vs) firedChildren.add(v.childId)
+    fireEnd(vs[0].childId, { Result: 1, Reason: '看起来对', formal: { target: 'p-used', decision: 'used', file: 'Formal/p-used.lean' } })
+    await sleep(150)
+    const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RG)
+    const o = st.formal.objects.find((x) => x.target === 'p-used')
+    assert(!!o && o.status === 'attempted' && o.file === 'Formal/p-used.lean', 'a `formal.decision=used` reply records the object as attempted with its file')
+    fireEnd(vs[1].childId, { Result: 1, Reason: '同样看起来对' })
+    await sleep(250)
+    assert(!existsSync(join(replyProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-used.md')), '★ attempted is NOT passed: the require gate still withholds the verdict')
+    assert(/p-used/.test(readIf(join(replyProj, 'Formal', 'TODO.md'))), 'and the object is on the formalization TODO')
+  }
+}
+// (c) a blocker with no note is refused (an explicit decision is required, never a silent skip)
+await restart(RG)
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-nonote', 概述: '没有理由的阻塞', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RG)
+{
+  const re = verifyRe('p-nonote')
+  assert(await drive(RG, () => unfiredVerifiers(RG, re).length >= 2, 'verifiers for r-p-nonote'), 'p-nonote was put to a vote')
+  const vs = unfiredVerifiers(RG, re).slice(0, 2)
+  if (vs.length === 2) {
+    for (const v of vs) firedChildren.add(v.childId)
+    fireEnd(vs[0].childId, { Result: 0.5, Reason: '不想做', formal: { target: 'p-nonote', decision: 'blocked' } })
+    await sleep(180)
+    assert(/未写明 note/.test(readIf(join(replyProj, 'Logs', '形式化.md'))), 'a blocked judgement without a note is refused with an explicit announcement')
+    const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RG)
+    assert(st.formal.objects.every((o) => o.target !== 'p-nonote'), 'and no blocker record is created for the refused judgement')
+    // a formal reply without a target must not invent an object (idSafe('') would fall back to 'id')
+    fireEnd(vs[1].childId, { Result: 0.5, Reason: '同上', formal: { decision: 'blocked', note: '没有写 target' } })
+    await sleep(180)
+    const st2 = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RG)
+    assert(st2.formal.objects.every((o) => o.target !== 'id' && o.target !== ''), 'a `formal` reply with no target cannot invent an object record')
+  }
+}
+await callTool('vibe_math_abort', {}, RG)
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 8b. the §4.1 `defect` channel (contract §4.1 / §6 / §10 items 8-9)
+//
+// A fidelity defect is NOT "the proposition is false". These are BEHAVIOURAL assertions: a real
+// agent reply carrying `formal:{decision:'defect', note}` is fed through the real reply path
+// (subagent/end → handleVerifier → absorbFormalReply) and the record, the archived file and the
+// formalization TODO are inspected on disk.
+// ===============================================================
+section('8b a formal.decision=defect reply withdraws the passed proof and withholds the verdict')
+const RH = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-defect' }, RH)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', Object.assign({}, VPARAMS, { formalVerify: 'require' }), RH)
+const defectProj = projRoot('lean-defect')
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-defect', 概述: '形式化写窄了的命题', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RH)
+{
+  const pass = await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', target: 'p-defect', content: 'theorem p_defect : 2 + 2 = 4 := by decide\n' }, RH)
+  assert(pass.ok === true && pass.passed === true, 'defect: the object starts out Lean-passed')
+  assert(existsSync(join(defectProj, 'Verified', 'Lean', 'p-defect.lean')), 'defect: the archived proof is on disk before the fidelity review')
+}
+await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, RH)
+{
+  const re = verifyRe('p-defect')
+  assert(await drive(RH, () => unfiredVerifiers(RH, re).length >= 2, 'verifiers for r-p-defect'), 'defect: the Lean-passed object is put to a fidelity review')
+  const vs = unfiredVerifiers(RH, re).slice(0, 2)
+  if (vs.length === 2) {
+    for (const v of vs) firedChildren.add(v.childId)
+    assert(/该对象已有\*\*通过的 Lean 形式化证明\*\*/.test(vs[0].prompt) && /不要投 0/.test(vs[0].prompt) && /formal:\{decision:'defect'/.test(vs[0].prompt),
+      'defect: the fidelity prompt asks for the defect reply and forbids recording the deviation as 0')
+    // The defect reply carries an EXTREME Result on purpose: the gate (not the vote value) has to
+    // be what withholds the verdict — a defect must never be harvested as "the proposition is false".
+    fireEnd(vs[0].childId, { Result: 1, Reason: '逐条核对后认定形式化不忠实', formal: { target: 'p-defect', decision: 'defect', note: 'Lean 代码多加了 h>0 假设，命题原文未要求' } })
+    await sleep(240)
+    const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RH)
+    const rec = st.formal.objects.find((o) => o.target === 'p-defect')
+    assert(!!rec && rec.status === 'attempted', '★ defect downgrades the formal record to attempted (observed ' + (rec && rec.status) + ')')
+    assert(st.formal.passed.indexOf('p-defect') === -1, '★ and the object is no longer reported as Lean-passed')
+    assert(!!rec && rec.proof === '', '★ defect clears the `proof` field')
+    assert(!existsSync(join(defectProj, 'Verified', 'Lean', 'p-defect.lean')), '★ defect deletes the archived proof Verified/Lean/p-defect.lean')
+    assert(existsSync(join(defectProj, 'Formal', 'p-defect.lean')), 'the WORK file Formal/p-defect.lean survives (the code itself is not lost)')
+    const persisted = JSON.parse(readIf(join(defectProj, 'State', 'formal.json')))
+    assert(persisted.records['p-defect'].decision === 'defect' && /多加了 h>0 假设/.test(persisted.records['p-defect'].note),
+      '★ the note (the concrete deviation) is recorded in the persisted formal record')
+    assert(/- 形式化: 已尝试未通过/.test(readIf(join(defectProj, 'Propos', '数论', 'p-defect.md'))), 'and the object card anchor is refreshed')
+    fireEnd(vs[1].childId, { Result: 1, Reason: '同意：形式化不忠实' })
+    await sleep(300)
+  }
+}
+{
+  const todo = readIf(join(defectProj, 'Formal', 'TODO.md'))
+  assert(/p-defect/.test(todo) && /多加了 h>0 假设/.test(todo), '★ the deviation is written into Formal/TODO.md')
+  const idx = readIf(join(defectProj, 'Formal', 'Index.md'))
+  assert(/p-defect/.test(idx) && /attempted/.test(idx) && !/Verified\/Lean\/p-defect\.lean/.test(idx), 'Formal/Index.md now shows attempted with no archived proof')
+  assert(!existsSync(join(defectProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-defect.md')), '★ require after a defect: NO Verified card is written (the verdict is withheld, not turned into "false")')
+  const card = readIf(join(defectProj, 'Propos', '数论', 'p-defect.md'))
+  assert(/- 状态: 未定论/.test(card), '★ and the object stays 未定论')
+  assert(/- 概率: 0.6/.test(card), 'the object keeps its existing probability: a defect must NOT be harvested as a refutation')
+  const ann = readIf(join(defectProj, 'Logs', '形式化.md'))
+  assert(/忠实性缺陷/.test(ann) && /多加了 h>0 假设/.test(ann), '★ the defect is announced with its concrete deviation')
+  assert(ann.indexOf('不是"命题为假"') !== -1, 'the announcement spells out that a fidelity defect is NOT "the proposition is false"')
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RH)
+  assert(st.formal.todo.some((t) => t.id === 'p-defect'), '★ the object is on the formalization TODO (undecided until the formalization is fixed and re-run)')
+}
+await callTool('vibe_math_abort', {}, RH)
+
+section('8b-2 a defect without a note is refused (the deviation must be auditable)')
+const RI = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-defect-nonote' }, RI)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', Object.assign({}, VPARAMS, { formalVerify: 'require' }), RI)
+const nonoteProj = projRoot('lean-defect-nonote')
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-nonote-defect', 概述: '没有偏差说明的缺陷回执', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RI)
+await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', target: 'p-nonote-defect', content: 'theorem p_nn_defect : 2 + 2 = 4 := by decide\n' }, RI)
+await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, RI)
+{
+  const re = verifyRe('p-nonote-defect')
+  assert(await drive(RI, () => unfiredVerifiers(RI, re).length >= 2, 'verifiers for r-p-nonote-defect'), 'defect: the passed object is put to a fidelity review')
+  const vs = unfiredVerifiers(RI, re).slice(0, 2)
+  if (vs.length === 2) {
+    for (const v of vs) firedChildren.add(v.childId)
+    fireEnd(vs[0].childId, { Result: 1, Reason: '觉得不忠实但没写清楚', formal: { target: 'p-nonote-defect', decision: 'defect' } })
+    await sleep(240)
+    const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RI)
+    const rec = st.formal.objects.find((o) => o.target === 'p-nonote-defect')
+    assert(!!rec && rec.status === 'passed', '★ a defect WITHOUT a note is refused: the object stays Lean-passed (no silent downgrade)')
+    assert(existsSync(join(nonoteProj, 'Verified', 'Lean', 'p-nonote-defect.lean')), '★ and the archived proof is NOT deleted')
+    assert(st.formal.todo.every((t) => t.id !== 'p-nonote-defect') && !/p-nonote-defect/.test(readIf(join(nonoteProj, 'Formal', 'TODO.md'))),
+      'and no bogus formalization-TODO entry is created')
+    assert(/未写明 note/.test(readIf(join(nonoteProj, 'Logs', '形式化.md'))), '★ the refusal is announced explicitly')
+    fireEnd(vs[1].childId, { Result: 1, Reason: '核对后认为一致' })
+    await sleep(300)
+  }
+}
+assert(await drive(RI, () => existsSync(join(nonoteProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-nonote-defect.md')), 'Verified card'), 'a refused defect leaves the gate open: the same vote still promotes the object')
+// §4.1: the downgrade is unconditional — a `blocked` record loses to a defect too (it needs REDOING,
+// not a free pass through the gate, which `blocked` would otherwise grant).
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-blocked-defect', 概述: '阻塞后仍被认定不忠实', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RI)
+await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'blocked', target: 'p-blocked-defect', note: '先按难度记为阻塞' }, RI)
+await restart(RI)
+{
+  const re = verifyRe('p-blocked-defect')
+  assert(await drive(RI, () => unfiredVerifiers(RI, re).length >= 2, 'verifiers for r-p-blocked-defect'), 'a blocked object is put to a vote (the gate is open for blocked)')
+  const vs = unfiredVerifiers(RI, re).slice(0, 2)
+  if (vs.length === 2) {
+    for (const v of vs) firedChildren.add(v.childId)
+    fireEnd(vs[0].childId, { Result: 1, Reason: '形式化与命题不对应', formal: { target: 'p-blocked-defect', decision: 'defect', note: '阻塞所依据的形式化本身写错了对象' } })
+    await sleep(240)
+    const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RI)
+    const rec = st.formal.objects.find((o) => o.target === 'p-blocked-defect')
+    assert(!!rec && rec.status === 'attempted', '★★ a defect ALWAYS downgrades, even from `blocked` (observed ' + (rec && rec.status) + ')')
+    assert(st.formal.blocked.indexOf('p-blocked-defect') === -1 && /阻塞所依据的形式化本身写错了对象/.test(rec.note || ''), 'and the blocked record is replaced by the concrete deviation')
+    fireEnd(vs[1].childId, { Result: 1, Reason: '同意，形式化写错了对象' })
+    await sleep(280)
+  }
+}
+assert(!existsSync(join(nonoteProj, 'Verified', '命题', 'p-blocked-defect.md')), 'require after a blocked→defect downgrade: still no Verified card (undecided, not "false")')
+await callTool('vibe_math_abort', {}, RI)
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 8c. the injected text obeys the five hard requirements of contract §6
+// ===============================================================
+section('8c the injected text uses full tool names, Result (not verdict) and the run-before-archive rule')
+const RJ = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-workline' }, RJ)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', Object.assign({}, VPARAMS, { formalVerify: 'require' }), RJ)
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_problem', { id: 'q-defect', description: '顺手形式化的对象', priority: 0 }, RJ)
+const workProj = projRoot('lean-workline')
+// a `meta.formal` defect on the WORK-round path (absorbFormalFromReply) must downgrade too
+await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', target: 'q-defect', content: 'theorem q_defect : 2 + 2 = 4 := by decide\n' }, RJ)
+await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, RJ)
+assert(await drive(RJ, () => !!lastSpawn(RJ, 'explorer:q-defect'), 'explorer:q-defect'), 'the explorer for q-defect was spawned')
+{
+  const p = lastSpawn(RJ, 'explorer:q-defect').prompt
+  assert(/归档前先跑通（vibe_math_lean_run 或 run=true）；跑不通的定义不要进可复用库。/.test(p),
+    '★ the work-round prompt requires a GREEN run before archiving a reusable definition (§6 hard requirement 3)')
+  assert(/"decision":"used\|blocked\|defect"/.test(p), 'the work-round reply contract advertises the defect decision too')
+  assert(!/verdict/.test(p) && !/(^|[^a-z_])lean_(run|archive|lib)/.test(p),
+    '★ the work-round prompt uses FULL tool names only and never the v4/v5 field name `verdict`')
+  fireEnd(lastSpawn(RJ, 'explorer:q-defect').childId, {
+    meta: { kind: 'directions', qid: 'q-defect', formal: { target: 'q-defect', decision: 'defect', note: '陈述里的自然数范围被写成了整数' },
+      directions: [{ id: 'd1', title: '直接形式化', method: 'Lean', core_assumption: '', feasibility: 0.6 }] },
+  })
+  await sleep(260)
+  const st = await callTool('vibe_math_status', {}, RJ)
+  const rec = st.formal.objects.find((o) => o.target === 'q-defect')
+  assert(!!rec && rec.status === 'attempted' && /自然数范围被写成了整数/.test(rec.note || ''),
+    '★ a `meta.formal` defect from a WORK reply downgrades the record too (absorbFormalFromReply, not just the verifier path)')
+  assert(!existsSync(join(workProj, 'Verified', 'Lean', 'q-defect.lean')), '★ and its archived proof is deleted')
+}
+await callTool('vibe_math_abort', {}, RJ)
+
+section('8c-2 the fidelity branch reaches BOTH the review and the debate prompt, and names Result')
+const RK = makeRoot()
+await callTool('vibe_math_new_project', { name: 'lean-fidelity' }, RK)
+await callTool('vibe_math_set_params', Object.assign({}, VPARAMS, { formalVerify: 'encourage', debateMaxRounds: 2 }), RK)
+await callTool('vibe_math_add_proposition', { id: 'p-fid', 概述: '忠实性审查措辞观察对象', 概率: 0.6, 分类: '数论' }, RK)
+await callTool('vibe_math_lean_archive', { kind: 'proof', target: 'p-fid', content: 'theorem p_fid : 2 + 2 = 4 := by decide\n' }, RK)
+await callTool('vibe_math_start', {}, RK)
+const fidBatch = await runVerifyRound(RK, 'p-fid', [0.9, 0.95])
+assert(fidBatch !== null, 'fidelity: the review round was asked')
+if (fidBatch) {
+  const vp = fidBatch.map((s) => s.prompt).join('\n')
+  assert(/一致 → Result = 1/.test(vp), "★ the review prompt states the faithful case as `Result = 1` (v3's REAL reply field, not v4/v5's verdict)")
+  assert(/发现任何偏差，不要投 0/.test(vp) && /形式化不合格/.test(vp), '★ and forbids expressing a fidelity defect as 0')
+  assert(/formal:\{decision:'defect', note:'<具体偏差>'\}/.test(vp), 'and points at the defect reply field to record it')
+  assert(/独立于这份 Lean 代码/.test(vp), 'only an INDEPENDENT refutation may be voted 0')
+  assert(/Result/.test(vp) && !/verdict/.test(vp), '★ the voting prompt names Result, never verdict (§6 hard requirement 2)')
+  assert(vp.indexOf('偏离 → 0') === -1, '★ no "偏离 → 0" instruction anywhere in the fidelity branch (contract §10 item 9)')
+}
+assert(await drive(RK, () => wakes.some((w) => w.rootId === RK.id && /交流群/.test(w.prompt)), 'debate prompt'), 'a non-consensus fidelity round moved to the debate')
+{
+  const dp = wakes.filter((w) => w.rootId === RK.id).map((w) => w.prompt).join('\n')
+  assert(/一致 → Result = 1/.test(dp) && /不要投 0/.test(dp), '★ the DEBATE prompt carries the same fidelity wording')
+  assert(/Result/.test(dp) && !/verdict/.test(dp), 'the debate prompt names Result, never verdict')
+  assert(dp.indexOf('偏离 → 0') === -1, 'the debate prompt also refuses "a deviation is a 0"')
+}
+await callTool('vibe_math_abort', {}, RK)
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 9. reporting + persistence
+// ===============================================================
+section('9 the office can audit formal strength')
+{
+  const rep = await callTool('vibe_math_report', {}, RF)
+  assert(rep.formal && rep.formal.mode === 'require', 'the JSON report carries the formal mode')
+  assert(rep.formal.passed.indexOf('p-gate') !== -1 && rep.formal.blocked.indexOf('p-blocked-ok') !== -1, 'the JSON report lists both passed and blocked objects')
+  assert(rep.params.formalVerify === 'require' && rep.params.leanCommand === 'lean', 'the readable parameter table carries the Lean parameters')
+  const md = readIf(join(gateProj, 'Logs', '报告.md'))
+  assert(/## Lean 形式化/.test(md), 'the human-readable report has a Lean formal-verification section')
+  assert(/已通过：.*p-gate/.test(md), 'it lists Lean-passed objects')
+  assert(/已记录阻塞：.*p-blocked-ok/.test(md), 'it lists blocked objects')
+  assert(/可复用库：VibeMath\/Formal\/\{Lib,Proved\}\//.test(md), 'it documents the path layout')
+  await callTool('vibe_math_report', {}, RA)
+  assert(/未启用（`formalVerify` = off/.test(readIf(join(offProj, 'Logs', '报告.md'))), 'in off mode the report says the feature is not enabled')
+  const offRep = await callTool('vibe_math_report', {}, RA)
+  assert(offRep.formal.mode === 'off' && /off/.test(offRep.formal.note || ''), 'and the JSON report says the same')
+}
+{
+  const before = JSON.parse(readIf(join(gateProj, 'State', 'formal.json')))
+  assert(!!before && !!before.records && before.records['p-gate'] && before.records['p-gate'].status === 'passed', 'the formal record is persisted in State/formal.json, keyed by object id')
+  assert(Array.isArray(before.todo), 'the formalization TODO is persisted alongside it')
+  assert(before.records['p-blocked-ok'].status === 'blocked' && /分析学/.test(before.records['p-blocked-ok'].note), 'a blocker record keeps its reason across sessions')
+  assert(existsSync(join(VIBE, 'Formal', 'Proved', 'Index.md')) && existsSync(join(libPath, 'Index.md')), 'both global indexes are framework-maintained')
+}
+
+// ===============================================================
+// 10. interaction corpus (AUDIT-CHECKLIST §2.4) — a HUMAN must be able to re-read
+//     every prompt the framework emitted, not just the assertions about them.
+// ===============================================================
+section('10 the captured prompt corpus is written for human review')
+{
+  mkdirSync(CORPUS_DIR, { recursive: true })
+  writeFileSync(join(CORPUS_DIR, 'formal-verify-v3.json'), JSON.stringify({ entries: corpus }, null, 2), 'utf8')
+  const md = ['# V3 形式化验证交互语料（prompt corpus）', '',
+    '> 由 `formal-verify-v3.test.mjs` 落盘：框架**真正发出**的每一条提示词原文。路径归一化：工作区 → `<WS>`，',
+    '> VibeMath 根 → `<VIBEMATH>`（两者都按正/反斜杠两种写法替换，因此语料是确定性的、可 diff 的、不泄露本机路径）。',
+    '> 覆盖：explorer / solver / method-keeper 的日常工作提示词（含「顺手形式化」与"归档前先跑通"），',
+    '> `off`（零 Lean 文本）、`encourage`、**`require`** 三档下的表决初评与辩论提示词，`passed` 之后的忠实性审查分支',
+    '> （含 `defect` 出口），以及规划提示词。', '']
+  for (let i = 0; i < corpus.length; i++) {
+    const c = corpus[i]
+    md.push('## [' + i + '] ' + c.kind + ' · ' + c.label)
+    md.push('')
+    md.push('```text')
+    md.push(c.prompt)
+    md.push('```')
+    md.push('')
+  }
+  writeFileSync(join(CORPUS_DIR, 'formal-verify-v3.md'), md.join('\n'), 'utf8')
+  assert(existsSync(join(CORPUS_DIR, 'formal-verify-v3.json')) && existsSync(join(CORPUS_DIR, 'formal-verify-v3.md')), 'the prompt corpus was written (JSON + Markdown)')
+  assert(corpus.length >= 25, 'the corpus covers the whole run (' + corpus.length + ' prompts)')
+  assert(corpus.some((c) => c.label.startsWith('explorer:')) && corpus.some((c) => c.label.startsWith('solver:')) && corpus.some((c) => c.label.startsWith('method-keeper')) && corpus.some((c) => c.label.startsWith('verifier:')), 'the corpus covers every interaction type this suite drives')
+  assert(corpus.some((c) => c.kind === 'wake'), 'the corpus also keeps the continuation prompts (debate rounds)')
+  // generic sweep over EVERY captured prompt, not spot checks (AUDIT §2.1)
+  const dirty = corpus.filter((c) => /\[object Object\]|\bNaN\b|:\s*undefined|["']undefined["']|undefined\s*[,}\]]/.test(c.prompt))
+  assert(dirty.length === 0, 'no captured prompt contains placeholder garbage (' + dirty.map((d) => d.label).join(',') + ')')
+  const joined = corpus.map((c) => c.prompt).join('\n')
+  assert(joined.indexOf(WS) === -1 && joined.indexOf(WS.replace(/\\/g, '/')) === -1, 'every captured prompt normalises the workspace path to <WS> (the corpus stays diffable)')
+  assert(joined.indexOf(VIBE) === -1 && joined.indexOf(VIBE.replace(/\\/g, '/')) === -1 && joined.indexOf('<VIBEMATH>') !== -1,
+    '★ every captured prompt normalises the VibeMath root to <VIBEMATH> (no machine path leaks into the shipped corpus, contract §10 item 10)')
+  assert(!corpus.some((c) => c.root === RA.id && /Lean|形式化/.test(c.prompt)),
+    '★ the off-mode prompts captured in the corpus contain ZERO Lean text (off stays a true no-op)')
+  // contract §10 item 10: the corpus must cover require AND the work round (not just encourage + fidelity)
+  assert(corpus.some((c) => /【Lean 形式化验证（鼓励模式）】/.test(c.prompt)), '★ the corpus covers the encourage-mode verification prompt')
+  assert(corpus.some((c) => /【Lean 形式化验证（强制模式）】/.test(c.prompt)), '★ the corpus covers the REQUIRE-mode verification prompt')
+  assert(corpus.some((c) => /【顺手形式化（鼓励）】/.test(c.prompt)) && corpus.some((c) => /【顺手形式化（强制）】/.test(c.prompt)), '★ the corpus covers the work-round 顺手形式化 prompt in both modes')
+  assert(corpus.some((c) => /一致 → Result = 1/.test(c.prompt)), '★ the corpus keeps the passed/fidelity branch verbatim for human review')
+  // contract §6 hard requirements 1-2 + §10 item 9, swept over EVERY captured prompt
+  const verifier = corpus.filter((c) => c.label.startsWith('verifier:'))
+  assert(verifier.length >= 5 && verifier.every((c) => /Result/.test(c.prompt) && !/verdict/.test(c.prompt)),
+    '★ every captured voting prompt names Result and never verdict (§6 hard requirement 2)')
+  const bareTools = corpus.filter((c) => /(^|[^a-z_])lean_(run|archive|lib)/.test(c.prompt))
+  assert(bareTools.length === 0, '★ no captured prompt abbreviates a Lean tool name (§6 hard requirement 1): ' + bareTools.map((b) => b.label).join(','))
+  const zeroDeviation = corpus.filter((c) => c.prompt.indexOf('偏离 → 0') !== -1)
+  assert(zeroDeviation.length === 0, '★ no captured prompt turns a fidelity defect into a 0 vote (§6 hard requirement 5 / §10 item 9): ' + zeroDeviation.map((b) => b.label).join(','))
+}
+
+console.log('')
+console.log('passed=' + passed + ' failed=' + failed)
+if (failed) { console.error('FAILURES:'); for (const f of failures) console.error('  - ' + f) }
+rmSync(WS, { recursive: true, force: true })
+if (failed) process.exit(1)
+console.log('ALL GREEN')
+process.exit(0)