dflow-sdd-ddd 0.7.0 → 0.9.0

package/templates/brownfield/references/init-project-flow.md

@@ -0,0 +1,430 @@
+# Init Project Flow — Brownfield Track
+
+Internal flow spec for `npx dflow-sdd-ddd init` after the CLI selects the
+Brownfield track. It also serves as the manual reference for environments
+where Node.js/npm is unavailable.
+
+This is not a skill slash command. Do not describe or invoke it as one.
+
+This is a **one-time project bootstrap** flow. It sets up the `dflow/specs/`
+directory structure, seeds project-level governance files from the packaged
+`scaffolding/` template set, and points the developer at `/dflow:new-feature`
+as the natural next command.
+
+The V1 CLI clean cut does not migrate or dual-read a legacy root `specs/`
+directory. If root `specs/` exists, warn that new Dflow files will be created
+under `dflow/specs/`.
+
+**Confirmations** in this flow:
+- Step 2 → Step 3: information collected → present file-list preview
+- Step 3 → Step 4: file-list confirmed → write
+
+In the CLI, use ordinary yes/no confirmation. In the manual AI fallback,
+ask for explicit confirmation in natural language; do not require
+the workflow next command for init.
+
+**Ceremony**: this flow is **meta-level** — it sets up the infrastructure
+that subsequent T1 / T2 / T3 work will live in. It does not itself produce
+a SPEC-ID, feature directory, or branch. It does not count against Ceremony
+Scaling.
+
+---
+
+## Step 1: Current-State Inventory
+
+The CLI inspects the project root before prompting.
+
+**Read** (using the Read / Glob / LS tools):
+- Is there a `.git` directory? → repo exists
+- Is there an existing non-empty `dflow/specs/` directory? → Dflow already initialized; abort
+- Is there an empty `dflow/specs/` directory? → continue with existing-file protection
+- Is there an existing root `specs/` directory? → legacy / other-tool warning only; do not read, copy, move, or rewrite it
+- Is there an existing `CLAUDE.md` at the repo root? → project already
+  has AI-collab rules
+
+Report findings plainly:
+
+> "Repo inventory:
+>  - `.git`: present
+>  - `dflow/specs/`: not yet present → greenfield Dflow setup
+>  - `specs/`: present → legacy / other-tool directory; Dflow V1 will not
+>    migrate or modify it
+>  - `CLAUDE.md`: present → will not overwrite; I'll offer a snippet
+>    to merge into it"
+
+Or:
+
+> "Repo inventory:
+>  - `dflow/specs/`: already contains files
+>  - `CLAUDE.md`: not present
+>
+>  Dflow already appears initialized here. I will stop rather than risk
+>  mixing bootstrap versions."
+
+Classify the scenario:
+- **Greenfield**: no `dflow/specs/` at all → create full baseline
+- **Empty Dflow namespace**: `dflow/specs/` exists but contains no files → continue
+- **Already initialized**: non-empty `dflow/specs/` exists → abort cleanly
+
+**→ Transition (step-internal)**: Step 1 complete. Announce
+> "Step 1 complete (current-state inventory). Entering Step 2: Project
+> Information."
+
+and continue.
+
+---
+
+## Step 2: Project Information (track-specific intake)
+
+Ask these questions naturally — not as a checklist dump. Skip any
+question where Step 1 already gave a confident answer.
+
+### Q1. Project type
+
+> "Is this project greenfield (fresh start with Dflow) or brownfield
+> (existing code, now adopting Dflow)?"
+
+Used to seed `_overview.md`'s "現有問題" section (brownfield typically
+has backlog issues to document).
+
+### Q2. Tech stack confirmation
+
+> "Confirm the tech stack so I populate the right scaffolding
+> variables: current presentation framework or entrypoint stack?
+> language? database / ORM / persistence approach?"
+
+Used to substitute `{Framework}` / `{Framework version}` / `{Language}` /
+`{ORM / persistence}` / `{ORM version}` placeholders in `_overview.md`.
+
+### Q3. Migration plan
+
+> "Is there an existing plan to migrate this Brownfield project to
+> a target architecture?"
+
+If yes → `_overview.md` "Target Architecture Strategy" section is emphasised and
+`migration/tech-debt.md` is prioritised. If no → the scaffolding still
+mentions the principles (Migration Awareness / Domain Extraction /
+Dual-Track Parallel / Pragmatic First) but framed as forward-option.
+
+### Q4. Project prose language
+
+> "Project prose language for generated spec content? Choose an explicit
+> language tag: `zh-TW`, `en`, `ja-JP`, or another BCP-47 tag."
+
+Used to write `dflow/specs/shared/_conventions.md` under `## Prose
+Language`. This value is required. Do not accept `any`, `skip`, `later`,
+blank input, or prose descriptions such as "Traditional Chinese". Dflow
+templates keep canonical English structural language; this setting controls
+free prose inside generated spec sections.
+
+### Q5. Git policy (mandatory — pick one)
+
+> "Which Git policy does the team follow? This drives the runtime branch gate
+> and the finish-stage merge guidance, so it is required:
+>
+>   1. GitFlow — long-lived develop / release branches
+>   2. Trunk / GitHub Flow — short-lived feature branches (lightest; the
+>      default for most GitHub / GitLab teams)"
+
+Required — do not accept a skip. Both policies use feature branches; the choice
+only changes finish-stage merge guidance. The selected policy seeds exactly one
+`dflow/specs/shared/Git-principles-{gitflow|trunk}.md` (**mandatory, not
+optional**) and is recorded in `_conventions.md` under `## Git Policy`.
+
+### Q6. AI commit marker (mandatory — default None)
+
+> "How should AI-made commits be marked? The AI offers to commit at lifecycle
+> checkpoints (you can always decline); this sets how those commits are tagged:
+>
+>   1. None (default) — AI commits look like any other commit
+>   2. Co-Authored-By trailer (`dflow-ai <noreply@dflow.local>`) — filterable
+>   3. `[ai-assisted]` commit-subject prefix — visible at a glance"
+
+Recorded in `_conventions.md` under `## AI Commit Policy`; the runtime does not
+re-ask.
+
+### Q7. Optional starter files (multi-select)
+
+> "Besides the mandatory baseline, which optional starter files do you want me
+> to seed?
+>
+>   - [ ] `dflow/specs/shared/_overview.md` — system overview template"
+
+Wait for answers.
+
+### Q8. AI coding agents (multi-select)
+
+> "Which AI coding agents should Dflow configure?
+>
+>   - [ ] `AGENTS.md` — Codex / Copilot coding agent
+>   - [ ] `CLAUDE.md` — Claude Code
+>   - [ ] `.github/copilot-instructions.md` — GitHub Copilot
+>
+> If you select any agent, Dflow will create
+> `dflow/specs/shared/AI-AGENT-GUIDE.md` as the canonical guide. Root-level
+> tool files stay thin and point back to that guide. Existing tool files are
+> never overwritten; Dflow writes merge snippets under `dflow/specs/shared/`
+> instead."
+
+**→ Transition (step-internal)**: Step 2 complete. Announce
+> "Step 2 complete (project information captured). Entering Step 3:
+> File-list preview."
+
+and continue.
+
+---
+
+## Step 3: File-list Preview
+
+Compute the full list of files that will be created / skipped, based on
+Step 1 (current state) + Step 2 (developer choices).
+
+### 3.1 Mandatory baseline (Brownfield track)
+
+These files / directories are **always part of the baseline** — they
+are what every Dflow-adopting Brownfield project is expected to have
+before `/dflow:new-feature` runs cleanly:
+
+```
+dflow/specs/
+├── features/
+│   ├── active/               # directory (empty)
+│   ├── completed/            # directory (empty)
+│   └── backlog/              # directory (empty)
+├── domain/
+│   └── glossary.md           # ← templates/glossary.md
+├── shared/
+│   └── _conventions.md       # ← scaffolding/_conventions.md (mandatory)
+└── migration/
+    └── tech-debt.md          # ← templates/tech-debt.md
+```
+
+Key Brownfield-track notes:
+- `dflow/specs/migration/tech-debt.md` (not `dflow/specs/architecture/tech-debt.md`)
+  — Brownfield projects use `migration/` as the cross-cutting directory
+  for migration-era concerns. The Greenfield track uses `architecture/`
+  instead; this split is an F-05 decision from R7 review.
+- **`behavior.md` is NOT generated here.** Per F-05, per-context
+  `behavior.md` files are created by `/dflow:new-feature` Step 8.3
+  (completion flow) or by the P007a baseline-capture flow at the moment
+  the first bounded context is established. Creating empty
+  `behavior.md` files here would create stale placeholders.
+- `domain/context-map.md` is **not** mandatory in the Brownfield track
+  (contexts emerge organically during domain extraction; the Greenfield
+  track makes this file mandatory because BCs are usually planned
+  up-front).
+
+### 3.2 Optional files (from Step 2 Q7)
+
+Use the packaged scaffolding templates listed below; their project-local
+outputs are under `dflow/specs/shared/` (the scaffolding root, not the
+vendored workflow bundle). Compute the destination path:
+
+| Scaffolding source | Destination in project |
+|---|---|
+| `scaffolding/_overview.md` | `dflow/specs/shared/_overview.md` |
+| `scaffolding/_conventions.md` | `dflow/specs/shared/_conventions.md` (mandatory baseline) |
+| `scaffolding/Git-principles-gitflow.md` | `dflow/specs/shared/Git-principles-gitflow.md` |
+| `scaffolding/Git-principles-trunk.md` | `dflow/specs/shared/Git-principles-trunk.md` |
+| `scaffolding/AI-AGENT-GUIDE.md` | `dflow/specs/shared/AI-AGENT-GUIDE.md` when at least one AI agent is selected |
+| generated tool shim | `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, or `.github/copilot-instructions.md` when selected and missing |
+| generated merge snippet | `dflow/specs/shared/*-snippet.md` when the selected tool file already exists |
+
+### 3.3 Present the preview
+
+Present the complete file list as two tables, separating create vs
+skip, and wait for developer confirmation:
+
+> "Based on Step 1 inventory + Step 2 answers, here is what I'll do:
+>
+> **Will create ({N} files):**
+>
+> | Path | Source |
+> |---|---|
+> | `dflow/specs/features/active/.gitkeep` | (directory placeholder) |
+> | `dflow/specs/features/completed/.gitkeep` | (directory placeholder) |
+> | `dflow/specs/features/backlog/.gitkeep` | (directory placeholder) |
+> | `dflow/specs/domain/glossary.md` | `templates/glossary.md` (mandatory baseline) |
+> | `dflow/specs/shared/_conventions.md` | `scaffolding/_conventions.md` (mandatory baseline) |
+> | `dflow/specs/migration/tech-debt.md` | `templates/tech-debt.md` (mandatory baseline) |
+> | `dflow/specs/shared/_overview.md` | optional (you picked it) |
+> | `dflow/specs/shared/Git-principles-trunk.md` | mandatory (selected Git policy) |
+> | `dflow/specs/shared/AI-AGENT-GUIDE.md` | selected AI agent guide |
+> | `CLAUDE.md` | selected tool shim because repo has no CLAUDE.md |
+>
+> **Will skip ({M} files — already present):**
+>
+> | Path | Reason |
+> |---|---|
+> | `dflow/specs/domain/glossary.md` | already exists (47 lines) |
+>
+> **Not creating** (per F-05 decision):
+> - No `dflow/specs/domain/{context}/behavior.md` files. These are created
+>   later by `/dflow:new-feature` Step 8.3 or P007a when the first
+>   bounded context is established.
+> - No `dflow/specs/domain/context-map.md`. Brownfield track treats BCs as
+>   emergent from domain extraction; this file becomes relevant later,
+>   typically when 2+ contexts coexist.
+>
+> Looks good? Reply 'yes' to proceed with the writes, or tell me what to
+> adjust."
+
+**→ Step Gate: Step 3 → Step 4**
+
+Wait for explicit confirmation. If the developer asks to change the
+selection, go back to the relevant Step 2 question (Q5–Q8) and re-run Step 3.
+
+---
+
+## Step 4: Write Files (placeholder fill-in + existing-file protection)
+
+Execute the write plan agreed in Step 3. Use the Write tool (or
+mkdir-equivalent for directories).
+
+### 4.1 Existing-file protection (strict)
+
+Before every single write, re-check: does the target path already
+exist? If yes, **skip** — do not overwrite. Announce the skip:
+
+> "Skipped `dflow/specs/domain/glossary.md` — already exists (unchanged)."
+
+Only overwrite if the developer said explicitly "overwrite X" in
+Step 2 (rare; usually a conscious reset during early adoption).
+
+### 4.2 Placeholder substitution
+
+When writing from `scaffolding/` sources, substitute the placeholders
+captured in Step 2:
+
+| Placeholder | Substitution source |
+|---|---|
+| `{YYYY-MM-DD}` | Today's date (ISO format) |
+| `{System Name}` / `{系統名稱}` | From Step 2 or repo folder name |
+| `{業務領域}` | From Step 2 Q1 / Q2 context |
+| `{Language}` | From Step 2 Q2 |
+| `{Framework}` | From Step 2 Q2 |
+| `{Framework version}` | From Step 2 Q2 |
+| `{ORM / persistence}` | From Step 2 Q2 |
+| `{ORM version}` | From Step 2 Q2 |
+| `{prose-language}` | From Step 2 Q4 |
+
+For placeholders the developer did not provide, keep the `{placeholder}`
+token in the emitted file and add a one-line TODO comment so they
+notice:
+
+```markdown
+<!-- TODO: fill in 業務領域 on next review -->
+```
+
+### 4.3 Special case — AI agent instruction files
+
+If the developer selected any AI coding agent in Q8, create
+`dflow/specs/shared/AI-AGENT-GUIDE.md` as the canonical Dflow project
+guide.
+
+For each selected tool-specific file (`AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`,
+`.github/copilot-instructions.md`):
+
+- if the target file does not exist, create a small shim at the target
+  path that points to `dflow/specs/shared/AI-AGENT-GUIDE.md`
+- if the target file already exists, do not overwrite it; write a merge
+  snippet under `dflow/specs/shared/` and report that the developer
+  should merge it manually
+
+### 4.4 Directory-only entries
+
+For directories that Git otherwise wouldn't track (empty `active/` /
+`completed/` / `backlog/`), seed a `.gitkeep` file so the directory
+persists across clones.
+
+**→ Transition (step-internal)**: Step 4 complete. Announce
+> "Step 4 complete (files written). Entering Step 5: Results + next
+> steps."
+
+and continue.
+
+---
+
+## Step 5: Results Report + Next-step Recommendation
+
+Summarise what actually happened and point at the next command.
+
+### 5.1 Summary report
+
+```
+Init complete. Summary:
+
+  Created ({N} files):
+    ✓ dflow/specs/features/active/.gitkeep
+    ✓ dflow/specs/features/completed/.gitkeep
+    ✓ dflow/specs/features/backlog/.gitkeep
+    ✓ dflow/specs/domain/glossary.md
+    ✓ dflow/specs/shared/_conventions.md
+    ✓ dflow/specs/migration/tech-debt.md
+    ✓ dflow/specs/shared/_overview.md
+    ✓ dflow/specs/shared/Git-principles-trunk.md
+    ✓ CLAUDE.md (seeded from scaffolding snippet)
+
+  Skipped ({M} files already present):
+    - (none this run)
+
+  Deferred (not created here by design):
+    - dflow/specs/domain/{context}/behavior.md — created by /dflow:new-feature
+      Step 8.3 or P007a baseline capture
+    - dflow/specs/domain/context-map.md — created organically when you have
+      ≥2 bounded contexts
+```
+
+### 5.2 Next-step recommendation
+
+Tailor the recommendation to the Step 1 scenario:
+
+**Greenfield**:
+
+> "Structure is ready. Recommended next step:
+>  - Run `/dflow:new-feature` to start your first feature
+>    (this will create `dflow/specs/features/active/{SPEC-ID}-{slug}/` and
+>    walk you through spec → domain concepts → implementation plan)"
+
+**Brownfield**:
+
+> "Structure is ready. Recommended next step:
+>  - First, open `dflow/specs/shared/_overview.md` and fill in the 'Current
+>    System State' and 'Known Issues' sections — this gives Dflow
+>    context when you triage existing behavior later.
+>  - Then run `/dflow:modify-existing` to work from an incoming change
+>    request (most common Brownfield entry), or `/dflow:new-feature`
+>    for a fresh piece of work.
+>  - When you touch a domain concept for the first time, the completion
+>    flow will prompt you to baseline it into
+>    `dflow/specs/domain/{context}/` — don't try to pre-fill everything
+>    up front."
+
+**Already fully set up (Step 1 showed nothing to do)**:
+
+> "Your project already has a complete Dflow layout — nothing to do.
+> If you were expecting changes, let me know which file you wanted
+> refreshed and I'll skip the safety-net."
+
+### 5.3 Optional: review project-level files
+
+Remind the developer to review files that have `{placeholder}` tokens
+still in them:
+
+> "A few files still have `{placeholder}` tokens that need your input:
+>  - `dflow/specs/shared/_overview.md`: `{業務領域}`, `{團隊}`,
+>    `{使用者規模}`
+>  - `CLAUDE.md`: `{業務領域}`
+>
+>  These are fine to leave for now; fill them in during your next
+>  review pass."
+
+---
+
+## Notes & references
+
+- Scaffolding templates: packaged in the Dflow tarball; project-local
+  outputs land under `dflow/specs/shared/`
+- `_index.md` feature template: `dflow/specs/shared/dflow-workflows/templates/_index.md`
+  (used by `/dflow:new-feature`, NOT by this flow)
+- Git integration rules: `dflow/specs/shared/dflow-workflows/references/git-integration.md`