delegation-layer 0.1.30 → 0.1.37

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
package/README.md CHANGED
@@ -301,6 +301,14 @@ reference](skills/agent-integration/references/workspaces.md) for attachment,
301
301
  continuation, verification, review scope, release, and forgetting. This
302
302
  feature does not automatically apply, commit, branch, or merge worker changes.
303
303
 
304
+ To fork a worker from current uncommitted work, first record a Git checkpoint
305
+ with `delegate checkpoint create --cwd ABS` (or `--workspace ID`). It stores a
306
+ synthetic commit under a Delegate-owned ref without moving `HEAD` or touching
307
+ the real index. After `checkpoint status` reports it `checkpointed` and
308
+ `usable`, pass its commit to `dispatch --isolation git-worktree --base`.
309
+ Checkpoints stay until `checkpoint remove`; see the [checkpoint
310
+ guidance](skills/agent-integration/references/workspaces.md#git-checkpoints).
311
+
304
312
  ## Documentation
305
313
 
306
314
  - [Getting started](docs/getting-started.md) — install and run a first task.
package/package.json CHANGED
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
1
1
  {
2
2
  "name": "delegation-layer",
3
- "version": "0.1.30",
3
+ "version": "0.1.37",
4
4
  "description": "Multi-provider AI agent delegation CLI and Agent Skill for running bounded coding tasks across provider CLIs.",
5
5
  "keywords": [
6
6
  "ai-agents",
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
1
1
  {
2
2
  "name": "delegation-layer",
3
3
  "displayName": "Delegation Layer",
4
- "version": "0.1.30",
4
+ "version": "0.1.37",
5
5
  "description": "Consult external AI harnesses and CCR-configured models for reviews, research, implementation, and debate through the resumable Delegate CLI.",
6
6
  "author": {
7
7
  "name": "Hesham Karam",
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
1
1
  {
2
2
  "name": "delegation-layer",
3
- "version": "0.1.30",
3
+ "version": "0.1.37",
4
4
  "description": "Consult external AI harnesses and CCR-configured models for reviews, research, implementation, and debate through the resumable Delegate CLI.",
5
5
  "author": {
6
6
  "name": "Hesham Karam",
@@ -112,7 +112,13 @@ tasks may proceed; the failed attempt must remain reported as failed or blocked.
112
112
  output as an answer.
113
113
  7. If a task is timed out and its JSON says `continuation.resumable: true`, use
114
114
  `continue --task TASK_ID`, optionally with a new `--brief`. Do not create a
115
- fresh unrelated dispatch to replace a resumable task.
115
+ fresh unrelated dispatch to replace a resumable task. The one other automatic
116
+ route is an `interrupted` task from `status` or `collect`, and only when
117
+ `failure.code` is `"task_interrupted"`, `failure.next_action` is
118
+ `"continue_task"`, and `continuation.resumable` is `true`; see
119
+ [interrupted turn](references/continuation.md#interrupted-turn). A
120
+ cancellation, `stop_and_report`, or failed admission always takes precedence
121
+ over `resumable: true`.
116
122
  8. Treat `blocked` authentication as unresolved. Do not call it compatible,
117
123
  successful, or failed provider behavior, and do not invent login commands.
118
124
  9. Never put credentials, tokens, or unrestricted provider output in a brief,
@@ -127,7 +133,12 @@ tasks may proceed; the failed attempt must remain reported as failed or blocked.
127
133
  or provider comparison. For independent parallel writes, choose
128
134
  `--isolation git-worktree` automatically unless the user explicitly chooses
129
135
  shared coordination; the model chooses fan-out and task scope. A read-only
130
- review may attach a retained workspace with `--workspace ID`.
136
+ review may attach a retained workspace with `--workspace ID`. To fork a
137
+ worker from current uncommitted content, follow
138
+ [checkpoint before fork](references/workspaces.md#checkpoint-before-fork):
139
+ fork only from a `checkpointed`, `usable` checkpoint commit. If your own
140
+ turn holds the workspace, do not wait or retry through `--cwd`; report so
141
+ the Lead checkpoints after your turn closes.
131
142
 
132
143
  For an explicit Codex code review, use the discoverable `codex:review` profile
133
144
  with one persisted target: `--review-target uncommitted`,
@@ -321,8 +332,8 @@ delegate --root "${DELEGATE_ROOT:-$HOME/delegation-state}" status TASK_ID --json
321
332
  delegate --root "${DELEGATE_ROOT:-$HOME/delegation-state}" collect TASK_ID --watch 5s --json
322
333
  ```
323
334
 
324
- Check `status` first: if it is `timed_out`, follow step 6 even when publication
325
- is pending and no outcome is present. If `interaction.pending_requests` is
335
+ Check `status` first: if it is `timed_out` or `interrupted`, follow step 6 even
336
+ when publication is pending or unknown and no outcome is present. If `interaction.pending_requests` is
326
337
  nonempty and the interaction is not closed, answer the questions using
327
338
  [active-task interaction](references/interaction.md) before collecting again.
328
339
  Otherwise, if `collect` exits with code `3` because publication is still
@@ -336,14 +347,19 @@ is committed. A rejected outcome is terminal evidence and must be reported as
336
347
  rejected. Payload and raw output are returned as validated descriptors; do not
337
348
  copy unrestricted provider output into the control response.
338
349
 
339
- ### 6. Continue a timed out turn
350
+ ### 6. Continue a timed out or interrupted turn
340
351
 
341
- When `status` or `collect` reports `timed_out`, read
342
- [continuation and timeout recovery](references/continuation.md). If
343
- `continuation.resumable` is true, use `continue --task TASK_ID` with the original
344
- state root and a finite budget, then observe the returned successor ID. Do not
352
+ When `status` or `collect` reports `timed_out` or `interrupted`, read
353
+ [continuation and timeout recovery](references/continuation.md). Unless a
354
+ cancellation or `stop_and_report` applies, a `timed_out` task with
355
+ `continuation.resumable: true` may use `continue --task TASK_ID`. An
356
+ `interrupted` task may use it only under all three conditions in rule 7;
357
+ otherwise report it. When continuing, use the original state root and a finite
358
+ budget, then observe the returned successor ID. Do not
345
359
  wait indefinitely for pending publication or restart the task as an unrelated
346
- dispatch. If continuation is unavailable, report its reason. Apply the same
360
+ dispatch. If continuation is unavailable, report its reason, except the busy
361
+ managed-workspace case in [continuation and timeout
362
+ recovery](references/continuation.md). Apply the same
347
363
  `failure` and `task_record` decisions as for dispatch; never repeat an uncertain
348
364
  successor creation.
349
365
 
@@ -365,10 +381,12 @@ recruit more agents unless that is explicitly part of the task.
365
381
  model/effort options or another public command.
366
382
  - Read [result handling](references/result-handling.md) when interpreting
367
383
  admission, publication, authentication, errors, or exit codes.
368
- - Read [continuation](references/continuation.md) for timeout recovery or an
369
- exact-session follow-up.
384
+ - Read [continuation](references/continuation.md) for timeout or interruption
385
+ recovery or an exact-session follow-up.
370
386
  - Read [managed workspaces](references/workspaces.md) for optional Git
371
- worktrees, capture, review scope, release, and forgetting.
387
+ worktrees, capture, review scope, release, and forgetting, and
388
+ [Git checkpoints](references/workspaces.md#git-checkpoints) before creating,
389
+ observing, forking from, or removing a checkpoint.
372
390
  - Use [read-only example](examples/read-only-task.md),
373
391
  [write example](examples/workspace-write-task.md),
374
392
  [JSON examples](examples/json-results.md), and
@@ -11,3 +11,45 @@ own the decision order for task creation, failures, timeout continuation,
11
11
  terminal outcomes, pending interaction, and bounded collection. Read them
12
12
  before interpreting these commands; pending publication alone is not a reason
13
13
  to wait when the task needs an answer or timeout recovery.
14
+
15
+ ## Checkpoint responses
16
+
17
+ These abbreviated shapes use the delivered field names; `…` marks omitted
18
+ values. Apply [checkpoint results](../references/result-handling.md#checkpoint-results)
19
+ to the whole response and its exit code.
20
+
21
+ Accepted creation, exit `3`:
22
+
23
+ ```json
24
+ {"schema_version":1,"command":"checkpoint","root_id":"…","admission":"unknown","liveness":"undetermined","publication":"unknown",
25
+ "checkpoint":{"id":"CHECKPOINT_ID","next_action":"watch_checkpoint"}}
26
+ ```
27
+
28
+ Busy refusal, exit `3`, with no accepted ID:
29
+
30
+ ```json
31
+ {"checkpoint":{"reason_code":"requested_action_not_authorized","next_action":"retry_create"}}
32
+ ```
33
+
34
+ Qualified checkpoint from `status`, exit `0`; only this state may be forked:
35
+
36
+ ```json
37
+ {"checkpoint":{"id":"CHECKPOINT_ID","current":{"id":"CHECKPOINT_ID","selection":"ordinary","cwd":"/abs/source",
38
+ "state":"checkpointed","snapshot_ref":"refs/delegate/ROOT_ID/checkpoints/CHECKPOINT_ID","commit_oid":"…","usable":true}}}
39
+ ```
40
+
41
+ Exact removal attempt from `status CHECKPOINT_ID --operation OPERATION_ID`,
42
+ exit `0`. Creation history stays `checkpointed`, but `usable` is now `false`:
43
+
44
+ ```json
45
+ {"checkpoint":{"id":"CHECKPOINT_ID","operation_id":"OPERATION_ID",
46
+ "current":{"id":"CHECKPOINT_ID","selection":"ordinary","state":"checkpointed","usable":false,
47
+ "removal":{"operation_id":"OPERATION_ID","attempts":1,"state":"removed"}},
48
+ "operation":{"operation_id":"OPERATION_ID","attempts":1,"state":"removed"}}}
49
+ ```
50
+
51
+ An empty `list` page, exit `0`, still has the array:
52
+
53
+ ```json
54
+ {"schema_version":1,"command":"checkpoint","root_id":"…","admission":"unknown","liveness":"undetermined","publication":"unknown","checkpoints":[]}
55
+ ```
@@ -66,3 +66,64 @@ Save each response and exit code once. A created task is observed with
66
66
  success; continue observing the same task. The Lead reviews the capture and
67
67
  owns landing any changes. `workspace release` is explicit; no automatic
68
68
  apply, commit, branch merge, TTL eviction, or provider-CLI fallback occurs.
69
+
70
+ ## Fork from a checkpoint
71
+
72
+ Use this sequence when the worker must start from current uncommitted content
73
+ instead of a committed base. Run it from the Lead, not from inside a worker
74
+ that uses the same workspace. The [checkpoint guidance](../references/workspaces.md#checkpoint-before-fork)
75
+ owns the rules; [checkpoint results](../references/result-handling.md#checkpoint-results)
76
+ owns every response decision.
77
+
78
+ ```sh
79
+ SOURCE="$PWD"
80
+ RESPONSE="$(mktemp)"
81
+ if delegate --root "${DELEGATE_ROOT:-$HOME/delegation-state}" checkpoint create \
82
+ --cwd "$SOURCE" --budget 5m --json >"$RESPONSE.checkpoint"; then
83
+ checkpoint_exit=0
84
+ else
85
+ checkpoint_exit=$?
86
+ fi
87
+ printf '%s\n' "$checkpoint_exit" >"$RESPONSE.checkpoint.exit"
88
+ cat "$RESPONSE.checkpoint"
89
+ ```
90
+
91
+ Exit `3` with `checkpoint.id` and `next_action: "watch_checkpoint"` means the
92
+ request was accepted, not captured. Use that `checkpoint.id` as
93
+ `CHECKPOINT_ID`. Do not run `create` again.
94
+
95
+ ```sh
96
+ if delegate --root "${DELEGATE_ROOT:-$HOME/delegation-state}" checkpoint status CHECKPOINT_ID \
97
+ --watch 30s --json >"$RESPONSE.checkpoint.status"; then
98
+ checkpoint_status_exit=0
99
+ else
100
+ checkpoint_status_exit=$?
101
+ fi
102
+ printf '%s\n' "$checkpoint_status_exit" >"$RESPONSE.checkpoint.status.exit"
103
+ cat "$RESPONSE.checkpoint.status"
104
+ ```
105
+
106
+ Repeat that status command while it exits `3`. Fork only when it exits `0`,
107
+ `checkpoint.current.state` is `checkpointed`, and `checkpoint.current.usable`
108
+ is `true`. Use `checkpoint.current.commit_oid` as `COMMIT_OID` in the first
109
+ dispatch example, replacing `--base HEAD` with `--base COMMIT_OID`. Report a
110
+ `stop_and_report` result instead of forking.
111
+
112
+ When the Lead no longer needs the checkpoint, remove it explicitly:
113
+
114
+ ```sh
115
+ if delegate --root "${DELEGATE_ROOT:-$HOME/delegation-state}" checkpoint remove CHECKPOINT_ID \
116
+ --budget 5m --json >"$RESPONSE.checkpoint.remove"; then
117
+ checkpoint_remove_exit=0
118
+ else
119
+ checkpoint_remove_exit=$?
120
+ fi
121
+ printf '%s\n' "$checkpoint_remove_exit" >"$RESPONSE.checkpoint.remove.exit"
122
+ cat "$RESPONSE.checkpoint.remove"
123
+ ```
124
+
125
+ Exit `3` with `checkpoint.operation_id` and `watch_checkpoint` means removal
126
+ attempt `OPERATION_ID` was accepted. Observe that exact attempt with
127
+ `checkpoint status CHECKPOINT_ID --operation OPERATION_ID --watch 30s --json`,
128
+ saving its response and exit the same way. A `retry_remove` response has no
129
+ `operation_id` and accepted nothing.
@@ -8,6 +8,22 @@ cap or TTL eviction. A read-only review may attach a retained workspace with
8
8
  release rules live in [managed workspace guidance](workspaces.md); do not
9
9
  restate them in each collaboration brief.
10
10
 
11
+ Give each participant a bounded deliverable, explicit write ownership, and the
12
+ inputs it depends on. Run independent assignments in parallel; dependent work
13
+ begins only after the required results are collected and any prerequisite
14
+ changes are applied and verified in the consuming worker's workspace, without
15
+ requiring a merge. Combine the relevant completed results in the verification
16
+ workspace before running checks that depend on their interaction. A worker's
17
+ terminal outcome establishes that assignment's result, not completion of the
18
+ user's full objective; keep remaining integration, verification and unresolved
19
+ work explicit.
20
+
21
+ When a participant must start from the Lead's current uncommitted work, the
22
+ Lead checkpoints that content first and forks each worker from the qualified
23
+ checkpoint commit with `--base`. Follow
24
+ [checkpoint before fork](workspaces.md#checkpoint-before-fork); a worker never
25
+ checkpoints a workspace its own turn is using.
26
+
11
27
  ## Keep each request identifiable
12
28
 
13
29
  Choose the fan-out needed for the user's task. Each participant needs its own
@@ -6,7 +6,8 @@ All paths passed to `--root`, `--cwd`, and `--brief` must be absolute. Add
6
6
  Pass the intended workspace directly. Delegate handles provider launch options;
7
7
  do not initialize Git, change trust settings, or call a provider CLI as a
8
8
  workspace workaround. Ordinary tasks support non-Git directories. Git is
9
- required for managed worktree creation/attachment only; native review retains
9
+ required for managed worktree creation/attachment and checkpoint creation or
10
+ removal only; native review retains
10
11
  its separate explicit review-target contract. See [managed workspace guidance](workspaces.md)
11
12
  for the policy owner.
12
13
 
@@ -52,8 +53,8 @@ Dispatch flags:
52
53
  - `--model MODEL` and `--effort VALUE`: provider-advertised choices (CCR requires a model alias);
53
54
  Codex maps effort to TOML `model_reasoning_effort` for ordinary turns or a native
54
55
  turn parameter for interactive turns, while Claude and AGY
55
- pass native effort flags; Pi maps effort to `--thinking`; OpenCode maps it to
56
- `--variant`; CCR forwards effort to Claude and uses `--model` as a CCR alias; `default` is omitted;
56
+ pass native effort flags; Pi maps effort to `--thinking`; OpenCode sends model
57
+ and effort as acknowledged ACP session options; CCR forwards effort to Claude and uses `--model` as a CCR alias; `default` is omitted;
57
58
  - `--interactive`: enable advertised native clarification and steering; see [interaction](interaction.md);
58
59
  - `--native-timeout DURATION`: optional provider-native timeout where advertised.
59
60
 
@@ -101,6 +102,27 @@ Continuation flags:
101
102
  - `--budget DURATION`, `--model MODEL`, and `--effort VALUE`: optional overrides;
102
103
  - `--interactive`: enable interaction when supported; already-interactive predecessors keep it.
103
104
 
105
+ ## Checkpoint commands
106
+
107
+ Git checkpoints are optional and launch no provider work. Use them to fork a
108
+ worker from current uncommitted content; the canonical
109
+ [checkpoint guidance](workspaces.md#git-checkpoints) owns targets, limits, and
110
+ the checkpoint-before-fork sequence, and
111
+ [checkpoint results](result-handling.md#checkpoint-results) owns the decisions.
112
+
113
+ ```sh
114
+ delegate --root ROOT checkpoint create --cwd ABS [--budget DURATION] --json
115
+ delegate --root ROOT checkpoint create --workspace ID [--budget DURATION] --json
116
+ delegate --root ROOT checkpoint status CHECKPOINT_ID [--operation OP] [--watch DURATION] --json
117
+ delegate --root ROOT checkpoint list [--after CHECKPOINT_ID] [--limit 1..50] --json
118
+ delegate --root ROOT checkpoint remove CHECKPOINT_ID [--budget DURATION] --json
119
+ ```
120
+
121
+ `create` takes exactly one of `--cwd` or `--workspace`. `--operation` selects a
122
+ removal attempt ID returned by `remove`; without it, `status` observes the
123
+ creation and its latest removal. `list` pages with the returned
124
+ `checkpoint_cursor` as `--after`.
125
+
104
126
  ## Choosing models and effort
105
127
 
106
128
  Pass an explicitly supplied model ID and effort unchanged, even if discovery
@@ -135,7 +157,9 @@ enumeration, not effort metadata. `null` means effort metadata is unknown;
135
157
  `[]` means the provider explicitly reported no choices. Discovery exits `0`
136
158
  for `available` or `partial`, `2` for `blocked` or `unavailable`, and `1` for
137
159
  `failed`. Preserve a blocked or unavailable discovery result as unresolved;
138
- defaults remain allowed.
160
+ defaults remain allowed. An operational discovery failure also includes an
161
+ optional `failure` object and a fixed `error` message; keep both fields and
162
+ follow `failure.next_action`.
139
163
 
140
164
  ## Checking readiness
141
165
 
@@ -53,6 +53,42 @@ Then retry the exact `continue --task PREDECESSOR_ID` after it becomes retained.
53
53
  Keep the original predecessor, brief, and budget; do not replace continuation
54
54
  with a fresh dispatch. A created successor is only observed.
55
55
 
56
+ **Busy managed workspace after a timeout.** This is the only case where an
57
+ unavailable continuation may be waited for instead of reported. It applies
58
+ only when a `timed_out` task reports all of `continuation.resumable: false`,
59
+ `continuation.reason` exactly `"managed workspace is busy"`,
60
+ `workspace.state: "busy"`, and `workspace.next_action: "watch_workspace"`.
61
+ Another reservation may still hold the workspace; do not infer which use. Wait
62
+ only when further work needs to continue this task, and return a committed
63
+ result normally. Do not wait when a cancellation (`failure.code:
64
+ "task_cancelled"`), a concrete fault, or `stop_and_report` applies to the task
65
+ or the workspace. If a successor from this predecessor was already created,
66
+ observe that successor instead; if its creation is uncertain, follow the
67
+ `task_record` stop rule in [result handling](result-handling.md).
68
+
69
+ 1. Watch the workspace with the same root and a finite duration, using
70
+ `workspace.id` from the task response; never guess an ID or path:
71
+
72
+ ```sh
73
+ delegate --root "${DELEGATE_ROOT:-$HOME/delegation-state}" workspace status \
74
+ WORKSPACE_ID --watch 30s --json
75
+ ```
76
+
77
+ Repeat the watch only while it reports `state: "busy"`.
78
+ 2. When it reports `state: "retained"`, run a fresh `status` for the same
79
+ predecessor task ID.
80
+ 3. Only if that status now reports `continuation.resumable: true` and the task
81
+ rules above still permit it, run the exact `continue --task PREDECESSOR_ID`
82
+ once. Otherwise report its reason and stop.
83
+
84
+ Never run `continue` while `resumable` is `false`. Report any other reason,
85
+ workspace state, or fault under the existing guidance; do not reactivate a
86
+ `released` or `forgotten` workspace. An `undetermined` workspace view is
87
+ unobserved and follows [managed workspace results](result-handling.md#managed-workspace-results);
88
+ it is neither a terminal failure nor permission to continue. Do not dispatch,
89
+ fall back to another provider, repair the environment, or mutate the workspace
90
+ to free it. Availability is not guaranteed; do not wait indefinitely.
91
+
56
92
  `mode` describes the provider contract:
57
93
 
58
94
  - `native` uses the provider’s exact persisted conversation/session ID;
@@ -61,11 +97,14 @@ with a fresh dispatch. A created successor is only observed.
61
97
  - `unsupported` cannot be continued safely.
62
98
 
63
99
  Do not use a guessed session ID, a provider-specific resume command, or a new
64
- independent dispatch to recover a timeout. The CLI accepts either a validated
65
- terminal outcome or a durable Pueue-ended observation backed by a guardian
66
- lifetime-termination record with independently proven empty scope for the
67
- session handoff; without one of those proofs it refuses continuation. Inspect
68
- the predecessor again rather than bypassing that boundary.
100
+ independent dispatch to recover a timeout. The CLI accepts a validated
101
+ terminal outcome, a durable Pueue-ended budget stop backed by a guardian
102
+ lifetime-termination record with independently proven empty scope, or canonical
103
+ closed lifetime evidence of any closure kind together with a free runner lease
104
+ for a turn with no seal or outcome. A sealed predecessor must be collected
105
+ first. A queue-row end or a timestamp alone never qualifies; without one of those
106
+ proofs it refuses continuation. Inspect the predecessor again rather than
107
+ bypassing that boundary.
69
108
 
70
109
  For a managed workspace timeout, capture is a new finite auxiliary operation
71
110
  after canonical closure. The normal path proves the provider scope empty and
@@ -76,6 +115,56 @@ unavailable capture can still preserve continuation evidence; it does not
76
115
  change the provider outcome.
77
116
 
78
117
 
118
+ ## Interrupted turn
119
+
120
+ A host restart can end a provider turn before it publishes anything. Delegate
121
+ reports an interruption only when the task's stored publication state is still
122
+ unknown, with no provider exit or outcome, its canonical lifetime closure is
123
+ proven, and its runner lease is released. A terminated budget stop is checked
124
+ first and reports `timed_out` instead, as does a closure whose recorded
125
+ termination cause is the budget. Closure proves only that the provider
126
+ scope is gone; it is not provider success, and no answer or output from that
127
+ turn is accepted. Do not check these facts yourself or infer eligibility from
128
+ missing files: obey the returned `status`, `failure`, `continuation`, and
129
+ `pending` fields. For an eligible task, after real outcomes and concrete errors
130
+ are checked, `status` and `collect` report `status: "interrupted"` with
131
+ `publication: "unknown"`, no `outcome`, and
132
+ `failure.code: "task_interrupted"`. `status` exits `0`; `collect` exits `1`.
133
+ An interruption may also carry `pending.kind: "supervisor-command"`; that
134
+ independent observation means only that a supervisor command has not
135
+ finished, so follow the interruption's `failure` and `continuation` as usual.
136
+ Do not infer an interruption from `publication: "unknown"` alone: a response
137
+ with `pending.kind: "publication"` is still pending publication and carries no
138
+ interrupted resume offer, so handle it as pending under
139
+ [result handling](result-handling.md). Outcomes, `timed_out`, interaction,
140
+ `lifetime-finalization`, and ordinary pending exit `3` keep their meaning.
141
+
142
+ | Response | Action |
143
+ |---|---|
144
+ | `failure.code: "task_interrupted"`, `failure.next_action: "continue_task"`, and `continuation.resumable: true` (all three) | Run the `continue` above for that predecessor with the original root and a finite budget, then observe the successor. |
145
+ | `interrupted` with any other combination, including `failure.next_action: "stop_and_report"` or `continuation.resumable: false` | Report the reason and stop. |
146
+ | `timed_out` with `failure.code: "task_cancelled"` (user stop and budget stop, no outcome) | `stop_and_report`; `continuation.resumable` is `false` and no `continue_command` is returned. Report it. `collect` exit `3` here is a finite watch, not success and not a reason to keep waiting. |
147
+ | Any other operational error | It is not an interruption; apply [result handling](result-handling.md). |
148
+
149
+ `continuation.resumable: true` alone never revives an attempt that returned
150
+ `stop_and_report`, and a failed admission keeps its `task_record` rules.
151
+ Never continue a cancelled task automatically or start a fresh provider
152
+ fallback. A user stop keeps `interrupted` / `task_interrupted` for a closed
153
+ interrupted task, now with `stop_and_report` and `resumable: false`. A
154
+ committed or rejected outcome stays authoritative and is never replaced by
155
+ `task_cancelled`. A later, explicit user request to `continue` is a separate
156
+ action and still validated against real closure and the recorded session.
157
+
158
+ The successor uses the predecessor's observed provider session from
159
+ `provider.ref`. Only when `provider.ref` is genuinely absent, for any eligible
160
+ predecessor and not only an interrupted one, does `continue` fall back to the
161
+ validated immutable session that turn was asked to resume. The response reports
162
+ the source in `continuation.session_source`: `observed` means `provider.ref`
163
+ supplied the identity, and `recorded_input` means the requested session supplied
164
+ it. Neither value is evidence the provider saved any message or resumed
165
+ successfully. A missing task reference, or an unreadable, malformed, or mismatched
166
+ record, refuses. Never search ancestors or rerun the original task.
167
+
79
168
  ## Follow up after normal completion
80
169
 
81
170
  A validated terminal outcome, committed or rejected, can also support a new
@@ -3,7 +3,11 @@
3
3
  Use the response fields independently. A successful control command is not
4
4
  the same as a successful provider result.
5
5
 
6
- 1. Save `task_id` immediately after dispatch or continue.
6
+ 1. Save `task_id` immediately after dispatch or continue. It is the durable
7
+ Delegate identity. `supervisor.numeric_task_id` and a stop's
8
+ `numeric_task_id` are private, ephemeral queue addresses. The queue can
9
+ reuse a number for a later task, so a repeated number is not a binding
10
+ error; never use it as a task handle.
7
11
  2. For a dispatch or continue error, inspect `task_record` first. When it is
8
12
  `created`, observe the returned ID with `status`. Before applying the generic
9
13
  `not_created` stop rule, handle the sole migration exception: when
@@ -24,7 +28,13 @@ the same as a successful provider result.
24
28
  evidence for an existing task.
25
29
  3. If `status` is `timed_out`, follow the continuation procedure before treating
26
30
  pending publication as a reason to wait. `continuation.resumable: true`
27
- permits a linked successor even when no outcome has been published.
31
+ permits a linked successor even when no outcome has been published. An
32
+ `interrupted` task (`failure.code: "task_interrupted"`) follows the table in
33
+ [interrupted turn](continuation.md#interrupted-turn): continue only when
34
+ `failure.next_action` is `continue_task` and `continuation.resumable` is
35
+ `true`, otherwise report it. A `timed_out` task whose `failure.code` is
36
+ `task_cancelled` is `stop_and_report`: report it and stop, even though
37
+ `collect` exits `3`; that exit is not success.
28
38
  4. If `publication` is committed and `outcome.verdict` is committed, return
29
39
  the result and its payload/evidence descriptors.
30
40
  5. If `outcome.verdict` is rejected and `failure.next_action` is `recheck`,
@@ -51,7 +61,13 @@ from an inspection-worker or supervisor-observation failure.
51
61
  For `delegate models`, validate the complete JSON envelope before using any
52
62
  fact. Treat `available` and `partial` with exit `0` as observations, preserve
53
63
  `blocked` and `unavailable` with exit `2` as unresolved prerequisites, and
54
- preserve `failed` with exit `1` as a discovery failure. `complete` refers to
64
+ preserve `failed` as a discovery failure. Exit `1` with `failed` is an
65
+ operational failure; exit `2` with `failed` is an invalid or unsupported
66
+ request, not an authentication block. Status and exit are separate
67
+ observations. When the response
68
+ includes the optional `failure` object and `error` message, keep both in the
69
+ report and follow `failure.next_action`; report and stop on
70
+ `stop_and_report`. `complete` refers to
55
71
  model enumeration. Keep `efforts: null` distinct from `efforts: []`, and do not
56
72
  apply harness-wide effort choices to every model. Discovery is advisory and
57
73
  never an admission allowlist; a provider default remains valid and a listed
@@ -79,6 +95,18 @@ The provider outcome is immutable and the workspace `CaptureReceipt` is a
79
95
  separate immutable fact; a failed or unavailable capture must not be reported
80
96
  as a provider failure when native closure is already proven.
81
97
 
98
+ In task `status` or `collect`, a workspace with `state: "undetermined"`,
99
+ `evidence_state: "unknown"`, and `next_action: "watch_workspace"` means that
100
+ observer's bounded view expired before it read the workspace. It is an
101
+ unobserved view only. It does not imply corruption, change the task fields, or
102
+ revoke an eligible continuation, and it does not turn a committed task into a
103
+ failure. Follow the task fields above: return a committed result, handle a
104
+ rejection using its reported guidance, and keep observing only while the task
105
+ fields are pending. When useful, watch the same workspace with the same root.
106
+ Do not dispatch again, retry the provider, fall back to another integration,
107
+ or repair the environment because of it. A workspace view with `stop_and_report` remains a
108
+ concrete failure to report.
109
+
82
110
  Before a task record exists, a pending workspace provision returns
83
111
  `task_record: "not_created"` with
84
112
  `failure.code: "workspace_provision_pending"` and
@@ -112,6 +140,42 @@ Lead has terminal task/capture evidence and explicitly releases it. Read
112
140
  [managed workspace guidance](workspaces.md) for the exact command surface and
113
141
  review/capture/forgetting boundaries.
114
142
 
143
+ ## Checkpoint results
144
+
145
+ A `checkpoint` response has `command: "checkpoint"` and no `task_id` or
146
+ `outcome`. A checkpoint receipt is Git-content evidence; it never replaces a
147
+ provider outcome, and a provider outcome never proves a checkpoint. Read
148
+ `checkpoint.id`, `checkpoint.operation_id`, `checkpoint.current`,
149
+ `checkpoint.operation`, `checkpoint.reason_code`, `checkpoint.next_action`, and
150
+ `error` separately, together with the exit code. Exit `0` alone is not enough.
151
+
152
+ | Command and response | Meaning and next action |
153
+ | --- | --- |
154
+ | `create`: exit `3`, `id` C, `next_action: "watch_checkpoint"` | Accepted, not yet captured. Watch `status C`; never repeat `create`. |
155
+ | `create`: exit `3`, `requested_action_not_authorized`, `retry_create`, no `id` | Busy refusal; nothing was accepted. Apply the [busy rule](workspaces.md#checkpoint-before-fork). Never wait for your own turn or switch to `--cwd`. |
156
+ | `remove C`: exit `3`, `id` C, `operation_id` R, `watch_checkpoint` | Removal attempt R is accepted. Watch `status C --operation R`; never repeat `remove` to observe it. |
157
+ | `remove C`: exit `3`, `requested_action_not_authorized`, `retry_remove`, no `operation_id` | Not accepted, usually because creation is still pending. The `id` in your command is not a removal ID. Watch `status C` until it settles, then retry `remove C` once. |
158
+ | `remove C`: exit `0` with `operation_id` R | R already succeeded. No new attempt was registered. |
159
+ | `status C`: exit `0` | Successful observation. Fork only when `current.state` is `checkpointed` and `current.usable` is `true`. With `next_action: "stop_and_report"`, report the unavailable creation or latest removal; do not fork. |
160
+ | `status C`: exit `3`, `watch_checkpoint` | Creation or latest removal is still pending. Keep watching the same C. |
161
+ | `status C --operation R`: exit `0`, `1`, or `3` | R's own result: `removed` or `nothing_to_remove` is `0`; `unavailable` is `1` with `stop_and_report`; pending is `3`. A newer attempt in `current.removal` never replaces R's outcome. Keep watching R, not the newer head. |
162
+ | `list`: exit `0` | One metadata page. Entries may be pending, unavailable, or removed. Run `status C` for a reconciled verdict. |
163
+ | Exit `1` with `stop_and_report` | Concrete failure. Report `error` and every ID already returned; do not repeat the mutation. |
164
+ | Exit `2` | Invalid request. Parse errors print usage on stderr without guaranteed JSON; correct the request. |
165
+
166
+ Take `C` only from `checkpoint.id` and `R` only from `checkpoint.operation_id`
167
+ of a response that returned them. Never invent an operation ID or reuse a
168
+ creation ID as `--operation`. Returned IDs stay valid after a later read
169
+ fault; an unreadable `current` or `operation` is omitted rather than shown as
170
+ empty availability.
171
+
172
+ `status --watch` repeats the same observation of the same IDs until a settled
173
+ or failed result or the bound ends. It never begins another action, renews a
174
+ helper deadline, or cancels accepted work. The latest observation chooses the
175
+ exit. A watch that ends at exit `3` means keep observing; it is not a failure.
176
+ If writing the response itself fails (exit `1`), accepted work stays accepted;
177
+ observe it with `status` instead of repeating the mutation.
178
+
115
179
  ## Offline recovery
116
180
 
117
181
  When Delegate returns `failure.next_action: "recheck"`, use the same root and