deepflow 0.1.87 → 0.1.88

package/src/commands/df/execute.md

@@ -10,36 +10,26 @@ description: Execute tasks from PLAN.md with agent spawning, ratchet health chec
 You are a coordinator. Spawn agents, run ratchet checks, update PLAN.md. Never implement code yourself.
 
 **NEVER:** Read source files, edit code, use TaskOutput, use EnterPlanMode, use ExitPlanMode
-
-**ONLY:** Read PLAN.md, read specs/doing-*.md, spawn background agents, run ratchet health checks after each agent completes, update PLAN.md, write `.deepflow/decisions.md` in the main tree
+**ONLY:** Read PLAN.md, read specs/doing-*.md, spawn background agents, run ratchet health checks, update PLAN.md, write `.deepflow/decisions.md`
 
 ## Core Loop (Notification-Driven)
 
-Each task = one background agent. Completion notifications drive the loop.
-
-**NEVER use TaskOutput** — returns full transcripts (100KB+) that explode context.
+Each task = one background agent. **NEVER use TaskOutput** (100KB+ transcripts explode context).
 
 ```
 1. Spawn ALL wave agents with run_in_background=true in ONE message
-2. STOP. End your turn. Do NOT poll or monitor.
+2. STOP. End turn. Do NOT poll.
 3. On EACH notification:
-   a. Run ratchet check (section 5.5)
+   a. Ratchet check (§5.5)
    b. Passed → TaskUpdate(status: "completed"), update PLAN.md [x] + commit hash
-   c. Failed → run partial salvage protocol (section 5.5). If salvaged → treat as passed. If not → git revert, TaskUpdate(status: "pending")
-   d. Report ONE line: "✓ T1: ratchet passed (abc123)" or "⚕ T1: salvaged lint fix (abc124)" or "✗ T1: ratchet failed, reverted"
+   c. Failed → partial salvage (§5.5). Salvaged → passed. Not → git revert, TaskUpdate(status: "pending")
+   d. Report ONE line: "✓ T1: ratchet passed (abc123)" or "⚕ T1: salvaged (abc124)" or "✗ T1: reverted"
    e. NOT all done → end turn, wait | ALL done → next wave or finish
-4. Between waves: check context %. If ≥50% → checkpoint and exit.
+4. Between waves: context ≥50% → checkpoint and exit.
 5. Repeat until: all done, all blocked, or context ≥50%.
 ```
 
-## Context Threshold
-
-Statusline writes `.deepflow/context.json`: `{"percentage": 45}`
-
-| Context % | Action |
-|-----------|--------|
-| < 50% | Full parallelism (up to 5 agents) |
-| ≥ 50% | Wait for running agents, checkpoint, exit |
+**Context threshold:** Statusline writes `.deepflow/context.json`: `{"percentage": 45}`. <50% = full parallelism (up to 5). ≥50% = wait, checkpoint, exit.
 
 ---
 
@@ -47,109 +37,51 @@ Statusline writes `.deepflow/context.json`: `{"percentage": 45}`
 
 ### 1. CHECK CHECKPOINT
 
-```
---continue → Load .deepflow/checkpoint.json from worktree
-  → Verify worktree exists on disk (else error: "Use --fresh")
-  → Skip completed tasks, resume execution
---fresh → Delete checkpoint, start fresh
-checkpoint exists → Prompt: "Resume? (y/n)"
-else → Start fresh
-```
-
-Shell injection (use output directly — no manual file reads needed):
-- `` !`cat .deepflow/checkpoint.json 2>/dev/null || echo 'NOT_FOUND'` ``
-- `` !`git diff --quiet && echo 'CLEAN' || echo 'DIRTY'` ``
+`--continue` → load `.deepflow/checkpoint.json`, verify worktree exists (else error "Use --fresh"), skip completed. `--fresh` → delete checkpoint. Checkpoint exists → prompt "Resume? (y/n)".
+Shell: `` !`cat .deepflow/checkpoint.json 2>/dev/null || echo 'NOT_FOUND'` `` / `` !`git diff --quiet && echo 'CLEAN' || echo 'DIRTY'` ``
 
 ### 1.5. CREATE WORKTREE
 
-Require clean HEAD (`git diff --quiet`). Derive SPEC_NAME from `specs/doing-*.md`.
-Create worktree: `.deepflow/worktrees/{spec}` on branch `df/{spec}`.
-Reuse if exists. `--fresh` deletes first.
-
-If `worktree.sparse_paths` is non-empty in config, enable sparse checkout:
-```bash
-git worktree add --no-checkout -b df/{spec} .deepflow/worktrees/{spec}
-cd .deepflow/worktrees/{spec}
-git sparse-checkout set {sparse_paths...}
-git checkout df/{spec}
-```
+Require clean HEAD. Derive SPEC_NAME from `specs/doing-*.md`. Create `.deepflow/worktrees/{spec}` on branch `df/{spec}`. Reuse if exists; `--fresh` deletes first. If `worktree.sparse_paths` non-empty: `git worktree add --no-checkout`, `sparse-checkout set {paths}`, checkout.
 
 ### 1.6. RATCHET SNAPSHOT
 
-Snapshot pre-existing test files in worktree — only these count for ratchet (agent-created tests excluded):
-
+Snapshot pre-existing test files — only these count for ratchet (agent-created excluded):
 ```bash
-cd ${WORKTREE_PATH}
-git ls-files | grep -E '\.(test|spec)\.[^/]+$|^test_|_test\.[^/]+$|^tests/|__tests__/' \
-  > .deepflow/auto-snapshot.txt
+git -C ${WORKTREE_PATH} ls-files | grep -E '\.(test|spec)\.[^/]+$|^test_|_test\.[^/]+$|^tests/|__tests__/' > .deepflow/auto-snapshot.txt
 ```
 
 ### 1.7. NO-TESTS BOOTSTRAP
 
-If snapshot has zero test files:
-
-1. Spawn ONE bootstrap agent (section 6 Bootstrap Task) to write tests for `edit_scope` files
-2. On ratchet pass: re-snapshot, report `"bootstrap: completed"`, end cycle (no PLAN.md tasks this cycle)
-3. On ratchet fail: revert, halt with "Bootstrap failed — manual intervention required"
-
-Subsequent cycles use bootstrapped tests as ratchet baseline.
+Zero test files → spawn ONE bootstrap agent (§6 Bootstrap). Pass → re-snapshot, end cycle. Fail → revert, halt "Bootstrap failed — manual intervention required". Subsequent cycles use bootstrapped tests as baseline.
 
 ### 2. LOAD PLAN
 
-```
-Load: PLAN.md (required), specs/doing-*.md, .deepflow/config.yaml
-If missing: "No PLAN.md found. Run /df:plan first."
-```
-
-Shell injection (use output directly — no manual file reads needed):
-- `` !`cat .deepflow/checkpoint.json 2>/dev/null || echo 'NOT_FOUND'` ``
-- `` !`git diff --quiet && echo 'CLEAN' || echo 'DIRTY'` ``
+Load PLAN.md (required), specs/doing-*.md, .deepflow/config.yaml. Missing → "No PLAN.md found. Run /df:plan first."
 
 ### 2.5. REGISTER NATIVE TASKS
 
-For each `[ ]` task in PLAN.md: `TaskCreate(subject: "{task_id}: {description}", activeForm: "{gerund}", description: full block)`. Store task_id → native ID mapping. Set dependencies via `TaskUpdate(addBlockedBy: [...])`. On `--continue`: only register remaining `[ ]` items.
-
-### 3. CHECK FOR UNPLANNED SPECS
+For each `[ ]` task: `TaskCreate(subject: "{task_id}: {description}", activeForm: "{gerund}", description: full block)`. Store task_id → native ID. Set deps via `TaskUpdate(addBlockedBy: [...])`. `--continue` → only remaining `[ ]` items.
 
-Warn if `specs/*.md` (excluding doing-/done-) exist. Non-blocking.
+### 3–4. READY TASKS
 
-### 4. IDENTIFY READY TASKS
-
-Ready = TaskList where status: "pending" AND blockedBy: empty.
+Warn if unplanned `specs/*.md` (excluding doing-/done-) exist (non-blocking). Ready = TaskList where status: "pending" AND blockedBy: empty.
 
 ### 5. SPAWN AGENTS
 
-Context ≥50%: checkpoint and exit.
-
-Before spawning: `TaskUpdate(taskId: native_id, status: "in_progress")` — activates UI spinner.
-
-**Token tracking — record start:**
-```
-start_percentage = !`grep -o '"percentage":[0-9]*' .deepflow/context.json 2>/dev/null | grep -o '[0-9]*' || echo ''`
-start_timestamp  = !`date -u +%Y-%m-%dT%H:%M:%SZ`
-```
-Store both values in memory (keyed by task_id) for use after ratchet completes. Omit if context.json unavailable.
-
-**NEVER use `isolation: "worktree"` on Task calls.** Deepflow manages a shared worktree so wave 2 sees wave 1 commits.
+Context ≥50% → checkpoint and exit. Before spawning: `TaskUpdate(status: "in_progress")`.
 
-**Spawn ALL ready tasks in ONE message** — EXCEPT file conflicts (see below).
+**Token tracking start:** Store `start_percentage` (from context.json) and `start_timestamp` (ISO 8601) keyed by task_id. Omit if unavailable.
 
-**File conflict enforcement (1 file = 1 writer):**
-Before spawning, check `Files:` lists of all ready tasks. If two+ ready tasks share a file:
-1. Sort conflicting tasks by task number (T1 < T2 < T3)
-2. Spawn only the lowest-numbered task from each conflict group
-3. Remaining tasks stay `pending` — they become ready once the spawned task completes
-4. Log: `"⏳ T{N} deferred — file conflict with T{M} on {filename}"`
+**NEVER use `isolation: "worktree"`.** Deepflow manages a shared worktree so wave 2 sees wave 1 commits. **Spawn ALL ready tasks in ONE message** except file conflicts.
 
-**≥2 [SPIKE] tasks for same problem:** Follow Parallel Spike Probes (section 5.7).
+**File conflicts (1 file = 1 writer):** Check `Files:` lists. Overlap → spawn lowest-numbered only; rest stay pending. Log: `"⏳ T{N} deferred — file conflict with T{M} on {filename}"`
 
-**[OPTIMIZE] tasks:** Follow Optimize Cycle (section 5.9). Only ONE optimize task runs at a time — defer others until the active one completes.
+**≥2 [SPIKE] tasks same problem →** Parallel Spike Probes (§5.7). **[OPTIMIZE] tasks →** Optimize Cycle (§5.9), one at a time.
 
 ### 5.5. RATCHET CHECK
 
-After each agent completes, run health checks in the worktree.
-
-**Auto-detect commands:**
+Run health checks in worktree after each agent completes.
 
 | File | Build | Test | Typecheck | Lint |
 |------|-------|------|-----------|------|
@@ -158,555 +90,194 @@ After each agent completes, run health checks in the worktree.
 | `Cargo.toml` | `cargo build` | `cargo test` | — | `cargo clippy` |
 | `go.mod` | `go build ./...` | `go test ./...` | — | `go vet ./...` |
 
-Run Build → Test → Typecheck → Lint (stop on first failure).
-
-**Edit scope validation** (if spec declares `edit_scope`): check `git diff HEAD~1 --name-only` against allowed globs. Violations → `git revert HEAD --no-edit`, report "Edit scope violation: {files}".
-
-**Impact completeness check** (if task has Impact block in PLAN.md):
-Compare `git diff HEAD~1 --name-only` against Impact callers/duplicates list.
-File listed but not modified → **advisory warning**: "Impact gap: {file} listed as {caller|duplicate} but not modified — verify manually". Not auto-revert (callers sometimes don't need changes), but flags the risk.
-
-**Metric gate (Optimize tasks only):**
-
-After ratchet passes, if the current task has an `Optimize:` block, run the metric gate:
-
-1. Run the `metric` shell command in the worktree: `cd ${WORKTREE_PATH} && eval "${metric_command}"`
-2. Parse output as float. Non-numeric output → cycle failure (revert, log "metric parse error: {raw output}")
-3. Compare against previous measurement using `direction`:
-   - `direction: higher` → new value must be > previous + (previous × min_improvement_threshold)
-   - `direction: lower` → new value must be < previous - (previous × min_improvement_threshold)
-4. Both ratchet AND metric improvement required → keep commit
-5. Ratchet passes but metric did not improve → revert (log "ratchet passed but metric stagnant/regressed: {old} → {new}")
-6. Run each `secondary_metrics` command, parse as float. If regression > `regression_threshold` (default 5%) compared to baseline: append WARNING to `.deepflow/auto-report.md`: `"WARNING: {name} regressed {delta}% ({baseline_val} → {new_val}) at cycle {N}"`. Do NOT auto-revert.
+Run Build → Test → Typecheck → Lint (stop on first failure). Ratchet uses ONLY pre-existing tests from `.deepflow/auto-snapshot.txt`.
 
-**Output Truncation:**
-
-After ratchet checks complete, truncate command output for context efficiency:
-
-- **Success (all checks passed):** Suppress output entirely — do not include build/test/lint output in reports
-- **Build failure:** Include last 15 lines of build error only
-- **Test failure:** Include failed test name(s) + last 20 lines of test output
-- **Typecheck/lint failure:** Include error count + first 5 errors only
-
-**Token tracking — write result (on ratchet pass):**
-
-After all checks pass, compute and write the token block to `.deepflow/results/T{N}.yaml`:
-
-```
-end_percentage = !`grep -o '"percentage":[0-9]*' .deepflow/context.json 2>/dev/null | grep -o '[0-9]*' || echo ''`
-```
+**Edit scope validation:** `git diff HEAD~1 --name-only` vs allowed globs. Violation → revert, report.
+**Impact completeness:** diff vs Impact callers/duplicates. Gap → advisory warning (no revert).
 
-Parse `.deepflow/token-history.jsonl` to sum token fields for lines whose `timestamp` falls between `start_timestamp` and `end_timestamp` (ISO 8601 compare):
-```bash
-awk -v start="REPLACE_start_timestamp" -v end="REPLACE_end_timestamp" '
-{
-  ts=""; inp=0; cre=0; rd=0
-  if (match($0, /"timestamp":"[^"]*"/)) { ts=substr($0, RSTART+13, RLENGTH-14) }
-  if (ts >= start && ts <= end) {
-    if (match($0, /"input_tokens":[0-9]+/)) inp=substr($0, RSTART+15, RLENGTH-15)
-    if (match($0, /"cache_creation_input_tokens":[0-9]+/)) cre=substr($0, RSTART+30, RLENGTH-30)
-    if (match($0, /"cache_read_input_tokens":[0-9]+/)) rd=substr($0, RSTART+26, RLENGTH-26)
-    si+=inp; sc+=cre; sr+=rd
-  }
-}
-END { printf "{\"input_tokens\":%d,\"cache_creation_input_tokens\":%d,\"cache_read_input_tokens\":%d}\n", si+0, sc+0, sr+0 }
-' .deepflow/token-history.jsonl 2>/dev/null || echo '{}'
-```
+**Metric gate (Optimize only):** Run `eval "${metric_command}"` with cwd=`${WORKTREE_PATH}` (never `cd && eval`). Parse float (non-numeric → revert). Compare using `direction`+`min_improvement_threshold`. Both ratchet AND metric must pass → keep. Ratchet pass + metric stagnant → revert. Secondary metrics: regression > `regression_threshold` (5%) → WARNING in auto-report.md (no revert).
 
-Append (or create) `.deepflow/results/T{N}.yaml` with the following block. Use shell injection to read the existing file first:
-```
-!`cat .deepflow/results/T{N}.yaml 2>/dev/null || echo ''`
-```
+**Output truncation:** Success → suppress. Build fail → last 15 lines. Test fail → names + last 20 lines. Typecheck/lint → count + first 5 errors.
 
-Write the `tokens` block:
+**Token tracking result (on pass):** Read `end_percentage`. Sum token fields from `.deepflow/token-history.jsonl` between start/end timestamps (awk ISO 8601 compare). Write to `.deepflow/results/T{N}.yaml`:
 ```yaml
 tokens:
-  start_percentage: {start_percentage}
-  end_percentage: {end_percentage}
-  delta_percentage: {end_percentage - start_percentage}
-  input_tokens: {sum from jsonl}
-  cache_creation_input_tokens: {sum from jsonl}
-  cache_read_input_tokens: {sum from jsonl}
+  start_percentage: {val}
+  end_percentage: {val}
+  delta_percentage: {end - start}
+  input_tokens: {sum}
+  cache_creation_input_tokens: {sum}
+  cache_read_input_tokens: {sum}
 ```
+Omit if context.json/token-history.jsonl/awk unavailable. Never fail ratchet for tracking errors.
+
+**Evaluate:** All pass → commit stands. Failure → partial salvage:
+1. Lint/typecheck-only (build+tests passed): spawn `Agent(model="haiku")` to fix. Re-ratchet. Fail → revert both.
+2. Build/test failure → `git revert HEAD --no-edit` (no salvage).
 
-**Omit entirely if:** context.json was unavailable at start OR end, OR token-history.jsonl is missing, OR awk is unavailable. Never fail the ratchet due to token tracking errors.
+### 5.7. PARALLEL SPIKE PROBES
 
-**Evaluate:** All pass + no violations → commit stands. Any failure → attempt partial salvage before reverting:
+Trigger: ≥2 [SPIKE] tasks with same blocker or identical hypothesis.
 
-**Partial salvage protocol:**
-1. Run `git diff HEAD~1 --stat` to see what the agent changed
-2. If failure is lint-only or typecheck-only (build + tests passed):
-   - Spawn `Agent(model="haiku", subagent_type="general-purpose")` with prompt: `Fix the {lint|typecheck} errors in the worktree. Only fix what's broken, change nothing else. Files changed: {diff stat}. Error output: {error}`
-   - Run ratchet again on the fix commit
-   - If passes → both commits stand. If fails → `git revert HEAD --no-edit && git revert HEAD --no-edit` (revert both)
-3. If failure is build or test → `git revert HEAD --no-edit` (no salvage, too risky)
+1. `BASELINE=$(git rev-parse HEAD)` in shared worktree
+2. Sub-worktrees per spike: `git worktree add -b df/{spec}--probe-{ID} .deepflow/worktrees/{spec}/probe-{ID} ${BASELINE}`
+3. Spawn all probes in ONE message. End turn.
+4. Per notification: ratchet (§5.5). Record: ratchet_passed, regressions, coverage_delta, files_changed, commit.
+5. **Winner selection** (no LLM judge): disqualify regressions. Standard: fewer regressions > coverage > fewer files > first complete. Optimize: best metric delta > fewer regressions > fewer files. No passes → reset pending for debugger.
+6. Preserve all worktrees. Losers: branch + `-failed`. Record in checkpoint.json.
+7. Log all outcomes to `.deepflow/auto-memory.yaml` under `spike_insights`+`probe_learnings` (schema in auto-cycle.md). Both winners and losers.
+8. Cherry-pick winner into shared worktree. Winner → `[x] [PROBE_WINNER]`, losers → `[~] [PROBE_FAILED]`.
 
-Ratchet uses ONLY pre-existing test files from `.deepflow/auto-snapshot.txt`.
+#### 5.7.1. PROBE DIVERSITY (Optimize Probes)
 
-### 5.7. PARALLEL SPIKE PROBES
+Roles: **contextualizada** (refine best), **contraditoria** (opposite of best), **ingenua** (fresh, no context).
 
-Trigger: ≥2 [SPIKE] tasks with same "Blocked by:" target or identical hypothesis.
-
-1. **Baseline:** Record `BASELINE=$(git rev-parse HEAD)` in shared worktree
-2. **Sub-worktrees:** Per spike: `git worktree add -b df/{spec}--probe-{SPIKE_ID} .deepflow/worktrees/{spec}/probe-{SPIKE_ID} ${BASELINE}`
-3. **Spawn:** All probes in ONE message, each targeting its probe worktree. End turn.
-4. **Ratchet:** Per notification, run standard ratchet (5.5) in probe worktree. Record: ratchet_passed, regressions, coverage_delta, files_changed, commit
-5. **Select winner** (after ALL complete, no LLM judge):
-   - Disqualify any with regressions
-   - **Standard spikes**: Rank: fewer regressions > higher coverage_delta > fewer files_changed > first to complete
-   - **Optimize probes**: Rank: best metric improvement (absolute delta toward target) > fewer regressions > fewer files_changed
-   - No passes → reset all to pending for retry with debugger
-6. **Preserve all worktrees.** Losers: rename branch + `-failed` suffix. Record in checkpoint.json under `"spike_probes"`
-7. **Log ALL probe outcomes** to `.deepflow/auto-memory.yaml` (main tree):
-   ```yaml
-   spike_insights:
-     - date: "YYYY-MM-DD"
-       spec: "{spec_name}"
-       spike_id: "SPIKE_A"
-       hypothesis: "{from PLAN.md}"
-       outcome: "winner"
-       approach: "{one-sentence summary of what the winning probe chose}"
-       ratchet_metrics: {regressions: N, coverage_delta: N, files_changed: N}
-       branch: "df/{spec}--probe-SPIKE_A"
-     - date: "YYYY-MM-DD"
-       spec: "{spec_name}"
-       spike_id: "SPIKE_B"
-       hypothesis: "{from PLAN.md}"
-       outcome: "failed"  # or "passed-but-lost"
-       failure_reason: "{first failed check + error summary}"
-       ratchet_metrics: {regressions: N, coverage_delta: N, files_changed: N}
-       worktree: ".deepflow/worktrees/{spec}/probe-SPIKE_B-failed"
-       branch: "df/{spec}--probe-SPIKE_B-failed"
-   probe_learnings:  # read by /df:auto-cycle each start AND included in per-task preamble
-     - spike: "SPIKE_A"
-       probe: "probe-SPIKE_A"
-       insight: "{one-sentence summary of winning approach — e.g. 'Use Node.js over Bun for Playwright'}"
-     - spike: "SPIKE_B"
-       probe: "probe-SPIKE_B"
-       insight: "{one-sentence summary from failure_reason}"
-   ```
-   Create file if missing. Preserve existing keys when merging. Log BOTH winners and losers — downstream tasks need to know what was chosen, not just what failed.
-8. **Promote winner:** Cherry-pick into shared worktree. Winner → `[x] [PROBE_WINNER]`, losers → `[~] [PROBE_FAILED]`. Resume standard loop.
-
-#### 5.7.1. PROBE DIVERSITY ENFORCEMENT (Optimize Probes)
-
-When spawning probes for optimize plateau resolution, enforce diversity roles:
-
-**Role definitions:**
-- **contextualizada**: Builds on the best approach so far — refines, extends, or combines what worked. Prompt includes: "Build on the best result so far: {best_approach_summary}. Refine or extend it."
-- **contraditoria**: Tries the opposite of the current best. Prompt includes: "The best approach so far is {best_approach_summary}. Try the OPPOSITE direction — if it cached, don't cache; if it optimized hot path, optimize cold path; etc."
-- **ingenua**: No prior context — naive fresh attempt. Prompt includes: "Ignore all prior attempts. Approach this from scratch with no assumptions about what works."
-
-**Auto-scaling by probe round:**
-
-| Probe round | Count | Required roles |
-|-------------|-------|----------------|
+| Round | Count | Roles |
+|-------|-------|-------|
 | 1st plateau | 2 | 1 contraditoria + 1 ingenua |
 | 2nd plateau | 4 | 1 contextualizada + 2 contraditoria + 1 ingenua |
-| 3rd+ plateau | 6 | 2 contextualizada + 2 contraditoria + 2 ingenua |
+| 3rd+ | 6 | 2 contextualizada + 2 contraditoria + 2 ingenua |
 
-**Rules:**
-- Every probe set MUST include ≥1 contraditoria and ≥1 ingenua (minimum diversity)
-- contextualizada only added from round 2+ (needs prior data to build on)
-- Each probe prompt includes its role label and role-specific instruction
-- Probe scale persists in `optimize_state.probe_scale` in `auto-memory.yaml`
+Every set: ≥1 contraditoria + ≥1 ingenua. contextualizada from round 2+ only. Scale persists in `optimize_state.probe_scale`.
 
 ### 5.9. OPTIMIZE CYCLE
 
-Trigger: task has `Optimize:` block in PLAN.md. Runs instead of standard single-agent spawn.
-
-**Optimize is a distinct execution mode** — one optimize task at a time, spanning N cycles until a stop condition.
-
-#### 5.9.1. INITIALIZATION
-
-1. Parse `Optimize:` block from PLAN.md task: `metric`, `target`, `direction`, `max_cycles`, `secondary_metrics`
-2. Load or initialize `optimize_state` from `.deepflow/auto-memory.yaml`:
-   ```yaml
-   optimize_state:
-     task_id: "T{n}"
-     metric_command: "{shell command}"
-     target: {number}
-     direction: "higher|lower"
-     baseline: null          # set on first measure
-     current_best: null      # best metric value seen
-     best_commit: null       # commit hash of best value
-     cycles_run: 0
-     cycles_without_improvement: 0
-     consecutive_reverts: 0
-     probe_scale: 0          # 0=no probes yet, 2/4/6
-     max_cycles: {number}
-     history: []             # [{cycle, value, delta, kept, commit}]
-     failed_hypotheses: []   # ["{description}"]
-   ```
-3. **Measure baseline**: `cd ${WORKTREE_PATH} && eval "${metric_command}"` → parse float → store as `baseline` and `current_best`
-4. Measure each secondary metric → store as `secondary_baselines`
-5. Check if target already met (`direction: higher` → baseline >= target; `lower` → baseline <= target). If met → mark task `[x]`, log "target already met: {baseline}", done.
-
-#### 5.9.2. CYCLE LOOP
-
-Each cycle = one agent spawn + measure + keep/revert decision.
+Trigger: task has `Optimize:` block. One at a time, N cycles until stop condition.
+
+**Init:** Parse metric/target/direction/max_cycles/secondary_metrics. Load or init `optimize_state` in auto-memory.yaml (fields: task_id, metric_command, target, direction, baseline, current_best, best_commit, cycles_run, cycles_without_improvement, consecutive_reverts, probe_scale, max_cycles, history[], failed_hypotheses[]). Measure baseline (`eval` with cwd=worktree) → store as baseline+current_best. Measure secondaries. Target met → mark `[x]`, done.
 
+**Cycle loop:**
 ```
 REPEAT:
-  1. Check stop conditions (5.9.3) → if triggered, exit loop
-  2. Spawn ONE optimize agent (section 6, Optimize Task prompt) with run_in_background=true
-  3. STOP. End turn. Wait for notification.
-  4. On notification:
-     a. Run ratchet check (section 5.5) — build/test/lint must pass
-     b. If ratchet fails → git revert HEAD --no-edit, increment consecutive_reverts, log failed hypothesis, go to step 1
-     c. Run metric gate (section 5.5 metric gate) — measure new value
-     d. If metric parse error → git revert HEAD --no-edit, increment consecutive_reverts, log "metric parse error"
-     e. Compute improvement:
-        - direction: higher → improvement = (new - current_best) / |current_best| × 100
-        - direction: lower  → improvement = (current_best - new) / |current_best| × 100
-        - current_best == 0 → use absolute delta
-     f. If improvement >= min_improvement_threshold (default 1%):
-        → KEEP: update current_best, best_commit, reset cycles_without_improvement=0, reset consecutive_reverts=0
-     g. If improvement < min_improvement_threshold:
-        → REVERT: git revert HEAD --no-edit, increment cycles_without_improvement
-     h. Increment cycles_run
-     i. Append to history: {cycle, value, delta_pct, kept: bool, commit}
-     j. Measure secondary metrics, check regression (WARNING only, no revert)
-     k. Persist optimize_state to auto-memory.yaml
-     l. Report: "⟳ T{n} cycle {N}: {old} → {new} ({+/-delta}%) — {kept|reverted} [best: {current_best}, target: {target}]"
-     m. Check context %. If ≥50% → checkpoint and exit (auto-cycle resumes).
-```
+  1. Check stop conditions → if triggered, exit
+  2. Spawn ONE optimize agent (§6) run_in_background=true. STOP, end turn.
+  3. On notification:
+     a. Ratchet fail → revert, ++consecutive_reverts, log hypothesis, goto 1
+     b. Metric parse error → revert, ++consecutive_reverts
+     c. improvement = (new - best) / |best| × 100 (flip for lower; absolute if best==0)
+     d. >= 1% threshold → KEEP, update best, reset counters
+     e. < threshold → REVERT, ++cycles_without_improvement
+     f. ++cycles_run, append history, check secondaries, persist state
+     g. Report: "⟳ T{n} cycle {N}: {old}→{new} ({delta}%) — {kept|reverted} [best: X, target: Y]"
+     h. Context ≥50% → checkpoint, exit
+```
+
+**Stop conditions:**
+
+| Condition | Action |
+|-----------|--------|
+| Target reached | Mark `[x]` |
+| cycles_run >= max_cycles | Mark `[x]`. If best < baseline → `git reset --hard {best_commit}` |
+| 3 cycles without improvement | Launch probes (plateau) |
+| 3 consecutive reverts | Halt, task `[ ]`, requires human intervention |
 
-#### 5.9.3. STOP CONDITIONS
-
-| Condition | Detection | Action |
-|-----------|-----------|--------|
-| **Target reached** | `direction: higher` → value >= target; `lower` → value <= target | Mark task `[x]`, log "target reached: {value}" |
-| **Max cycles** | `cycles_run >= max_cycles` | Mark task `[x]` with note: "max cycles reached, best: {current_best}". If current_best worse than baseline → `git reset --hard {best_commit}`, log "reverted to best-known" |
-| **Plateau** | `cycles_without_improvement >= 3` | Pause normal cycle → launch probes (5.9.4) |
-| **Circuit breaker** | `consecutive_reverts >= 3` | Halt, task stays `[ ]`, log "circuit breaker: 3 consecutive reverts". Requires human intervention. |
-
-On **max cycles** with final value worse than baseline:
-1. `git reset --hard {best_commit}` in worktree
-2. Log: "final value {current} worse than baseline {baseline}, reverted to best-known commit {best_commit} (value: {current_best})"
-
-#### 5.9.4. PLATEAU → PROBE LAUNCH
-
-When plateau detected (3 cycles without ≥1% improvement):
-
-1. Pause normal optimize cycle
-2. Determine probe count from `probe_scale` (section 5.7.1 auto-scaling table): 0→2, 2→4, 4→6
-3. Update `probe_scale` in optimize_state
-4. Record `BASELINE=$(git rev-parse HEAD)` in shared worktree
-5. Create sub-worktrees per probe: `git worktree add -b df/{spec}--opt-probe-{N} .deepflow/worktrees/{spec}/opt-probe-{N} ${BASELINE}`
-6. Spawn ALL probes in ONE message using Optimize Probe prompt (section 6), each with its diversity role
-7. End turn. Wait for all notifications.
-8. Per notification: run ratchet + metric measurement in probe worktree
-9. Select winner (section 5.7 step 5, optimize ranking): best metric improvement toward target
-10. Winner → cherry-pick into shared worktree, update current_best, reset cycles_without_improvement=0
-11. Losers → rename branch with `-failed` suffix, preserve worktrees
-12. Log all probe outcomes to `auto-memory.yaml` under `spike_insights` (reuse existing format)
-13. Log probe learnings: winning approach summary + each loser's failure reason
-14. Resume normal optimize cycle from step 1
-
-#### 5.9.5. STATE PERSISTENCE (auto-memory.yaml)
-
-After every cycle, write `optimize_state` to `.deepflow/auto-memory.yaml` (main tree). This ensures:
-- Context exhaustion at 50% → auto-cycle resumes with full history
-- Failed hypotheses carry forward (agents won't repeat approaches)
-- Probe scale persists across context windows
-
-Also append cycle results to `.deepflow/auto-report.md`:
-```
-## Optimize: T{n} — {metric_name}
-| Cycle | Value | Delta | Kept | Commit |
-|-------|-------|-------|------|--------|
-| 1 | 72.3 | — | baseline | abc123 |
-| 2 | 74.1 | +2.5% | ✓ | def456 |
-| 3 | 73.8 | -0.4% | ✗ | (reverted) |
-...
-Best: {current_best} | Target: {target} | Status: {in_progress|reached|max_cycles|circuit_breaker}
-```
+**Plateau → probes:** Scale 0→2, 2→4, 4→6 per §5.7.1. Create sub-worktrees, spawn all with diversity roles (§6 Optimize Probe). Per notification: ratchet + metric. Winner → cherry-pick, update best, reset counters. Losers → `-failed`. Log outcomes. Resume cycle.
+
+**State persistence:** Write `optimize_state` to auto-memory.yaml after every cycle. Append results table to `.deepflow/auto-report.md`.
 
 ---
 
 ### 6. PER-TASK (agent prompt)
 
-> **Context engineering rationale:** Prompt order follows the attention U-curve (start/end = high attention, middle = low).
-> Critical instructions go at start and end. Navigable data goes in the middle.
-> See: Chroma "Context Rot" (2025) — performance degrades ~2%/100K tokens; distractors and semantic ambiguity compound degradation.
-
-**Common preamble (include in all agent prompts):**
-```
-Working directory: {worktree_absolute_path}
-All file operations MUST use this absolute path as base. Do NOT write files to the main project directory.
-Commit format: {commit_type}({spec}): {description}
-```
-
-**Standard Task** (spawn with `Agent(model="{Model from PLAN.md}", ...)`):
-
-Prompt sections in order (START = high attention, MIDDLE = navigable data, END = high attention):
-
-```
---- START (high attention zone) ---
-
-{task_id}: {description from PLAN.md}
-Files: {target files}  Spec: {spec_name}
-
-{Prior failure context — include ONLY if task was previously reverted. Read from .deepflow/auto-memory.yaml revert_history for this task_id:}
-DO NOT repeat these approaches:
-- Cycle {N}: reverted — "{reason from revert_history}"
-{Omit this entire block if task has no revert history.}
-
-{Acceptance criteria excerpt — extract 2-3 key ACs from the spec file (specs/doing-*.md). Include only the criteria relevant to THIS task, not the full spec.}
-Success criteria:
-- {AC relevant to this task}
-- {AC relevant to this task}
-{Omit if spec has no structured ACs.}
-
---- MIDDLE (navigable data zone) ---
-
-{Impact block from PLAN.md — include verbatim if present. Annotate each caller with WHY it's impacted:}
-Impact:
-  - Callers: {file} ({why — e.g. "imports validateToken which you're changing"})
-  - Duplicates:
-    - {file} [active — consolidate]
-    - {file} [dead — DELETE]
-  - Data flow: {consumers}
-{Omit if no Impact in PLAN.md.}
-
-{Dependency context — for each completed blocker task, include a one-liner summary:}
-Prior tasks:
-- {dep_task_id}: {one-line summary of what changed — e.g. "refactored validateToken to async, changed signature (string) → (string, opts)"}
-{Omit if task has no dependencies or all deps are bootstrap/spike tasks.}
-
-Steps:
-1. External APIs/SDKs → chub search "<library>" --json → chub get <id> --lang <lang> (skip if chub unavailable or internal code only)
-2. LSP freshness check: run `findReferences` on each function/type you're about to change. If callers exist beyond the Impact list, add them to your scope before implementing.
-3. Read ALL files in Impact (+ any new callers from step 2) before implementing — understand the full picture
-4. Implement the task, updating all impacted files
-5. Commit as feat({spec}): {description}
-
---- END (high attention zone) ---
-
-{If .deepflow/auto-memory.yaml exists and has probe_learnings, include:}
-Spike results (follow these approaches):
-{each probe_learning with outcome "winner" → "- {insight}"}
-{Omit this block if no probe_learnings exist.}
-
-If Impact lists duplicates: [active] → consolidate into single source of truth. [dead] → DELETE entirely.
-Your ONLY job is to write code and commit. Orchestrator runs health checks after.
-STOP after committing. Do NOT merge branches, rename spec files, remove worktrees, or run git checkout on main.
-```
-
-**Effort-aware context budget:** For `Effort: low` tasks, omit the MIDDLE section entirely (no Impact, no dependency context, no steps). For `Effort: medium`, include Impact but omit dependency context. For `Effort: high`, include everything.
-
-**Bootstrap Task:**
-```
-BOOTSTRAP: Write tests for files in edit_scope
-Files: {edit_scope files}  Spec: {spec_name}
-
-Write tests covering listed files. Do NOT change implementation files.
-Commit as test({spec}): bootstrap tests for edit_scope
-```
+**Common preamble (all):** `Working directory: {worktree_absolute_path}. All file ops use this path. Commit format: {type}({spec}): {desc}`
 
-**Spike Task:**
+**Standard Task** (`Agent(model="{Model}", ...)`):
 ```
-{task_id} [SPIKE]: {hypothesis}
-Files: {target files}  Spec: {spec_name}
-
-{Prior failure context — include ONLY if this spike was previously reverted. Read from .deepflow/auto-memory.yaml revert_history + spike_insights for this task_id:}
-DO NOT repeat these approaches:
-- Cycle {N}: reverted — "{reason}"
-{Omit this entire block if no revert history.}
-
-Implement minimal spike to validate hypothesis.
-Commit as spike({spec}): {description}
+--- START ---
+{task_id}: {description}  Files: {files}  Spec: {spec}
+{If reverted: DO NOT repeat: - Cycle {N}: "{reason}"}
+Success criteria: {ACs from spec relevant to this task}
+--- MIDDLE (omit for low effort; omit deps for medium) ---
+Impact: Callers: {file} ({why}) | Duplicates: [active→consolidate] [dead→DELETE] | Data flow: {consumers}
+Prior tasks: {dep_id}: {summary}
+Steps: 1. chub search/get for APIs 2. LSP findReferences, add unlisted callers 3. Read all Impact files 4. Implement 5. Commit
+--- END ---
+Spike results: {winner learnings}
+Duplicates: [active]→consolidate [dead]→DELETE. ONLY job: code+commit. No merge/rename/checkout.
 ```
 
-**Optimize Task** (spawn with `Agent(model="opus", subagent_type="general-purpose")`):
+**Bootstrap:** `BOOTSTRAP: Write tests for edit_scope files. Do NOT change implementation. Commit as test({spec}): bootstrap`
 
-One agent per cycle. Agent makes ONE atomic change to improve the metric.
+**Spike:** `{task_id} [SPIKE]: {hypothesis}. Files+Spec. {reverted warnings}. Minimal spike. Commit as spike({spec}): {desc}`
 
+**Optimize Task** (`Agent(model="opus")`):
 ```
---- START (high attention zone) ---
-
-{task_id} [OPTIMIZE]: Improve {metric_name} — cycle {N}/{max_cycles}
-Files: {target files}  Spec: {spec_name}
-
-Current metric: {current_value} (baseline: {baseline}, best: {current_best})
-Target: {target} ({direction})
-Improvement needed: {delta_to_target} ({direction})
-
-CONSTRAINT: Make exactly ONE atomic change. Do not refactor broadly.
-The metric is measured by: {metric_command}
-You succeed if the metric moves toward {target} after your change.
-
---- MIDDLE (navigable data zone) ---
-
-Attempt history (last 5 cycles):
-{For each recent history entry:}
-- Cycle {N}: {value} ({+/-delta}%) — {kept|reverted} — "{one-line description of what was tried}"
-{Omit if cycle 1.}
-
-DO NOT repeat these failed approaches:
-{For each failed_hypothesis in optimize_state:}
-- "{hypothesis description}"
-{Omit if no failed hypotheses.}
-
-{Impact block from PLAN.md if present}
-
-{Dependency context if present}
-
-Steps:
-1. Analyze the metric command to understand what's being measured
-2. Read the target files and identify ONE specific improvement
-3. Implement the change (ONE atomic modification)
-4. Commit as feat({spec}): optimize {metric_name} — {what you changed}
-
---- END (high attention zone) ---
-
-{Spike/probe learnings if any}
-
-Your ONLY job is to make ONE atomic change and commit. Orchestrator measures the metric after.
-Do NOT run the metric command yourself. Do NOT make multiple changes.
-STOP after committing. Do NOT merge branches, rename spec files, remove worktrees, or run git checkout on main.
+--- START ---
+{task_id} [OPTIMIZE]: {metric} — cycle {N}/{max}. Files+Spec.
+Current: {val} (baseline: {b}, best: {best}). Target: {t} ({dir}). Metric: {cmd}
+CONSTRAINT: ONE atomic change.
+--- MIDDLE ---
+Last 5 cycles + failed hypotheses + Impact/deps.
+--- END ---
+{Learnings}. ONE change + commit. No metric run, no multiple changes.
 ```
 
-**Optimize Probe Task** (spawn with `Agent(model="opus", subagent_type="general-purpose")`):
-
-Used during plateau resolution. Each probe has a diversity role.
-
+**Optimize Probe** (`Agent(model="opus")`):
 ```
---- START (high attention zone) ---
-
-{task_id} [OPTIMIZE PROBE]: {metric_name} — probe {probe_id} ({role_label})
-Files: {target files}  Spec: {spec_name}
-
-Current metric: {current_value} (baseline: {baseline}, best: {current_best})
-Target: {target} ({direction})
-
-Role: {role_label}
-{role_instruction — one of:}
-  contextualizada: "Build on the best approach so far: {best_approach_summary}. Refine, extend, or combine what worked."
-  contraditoria: "The best approach so far was: {best_approach_summary}. Try the OPPOSITE — if it optimized X, try Y instead. Challenge the current direction."
-  ingenua: "Ignore all prior attempts. Approach this metric from scratch with no assumptions about what has or hasn't worked."
-
---- MIDDLE (navigable data zone) ---
-
-Full attempt history:
-{ALL history entries from optimize_state}
-- Cycle {N}: {value} ({+/-delta}%) — {kept|reverted}
-
-All failed approaches (DO NOT repeat):
-{ALL failed_hypotheses}
-- "{hypothesis description}"
-
---- END (high attention zone) ---
-
-Make ONE atomic change that moves the metric toward {target}.
-Commit as feat({spec}): optimize probe {probe_id} — {what you changed}
-STOP after committing.
+--- START ---
+{task_id} [OPTIMIZE PROBE]: {metric} — probe {id} ({role})
+Current/Target. Role instruction:
+  contextualizada: "Build on best: {summary}. Refine."
+  contraditoria: "Best was: {summary}. Try OPPOSITE."
+  ingenua: "Ignore prior. Fresh approach."
+--- MIDDLE ---
+Full history + all failed hypotheses.
+--- END ---
+ONE atomic change. Commit. STOP.
 ```
 
 ### 8. COMPLETE SPECS
 
-When all tasks done for a `doing-*` spec:
-1. Run `/df:verify doing-{name}` via the Skill tool (`skill: "df:verify", args: "doing-{name}"`)
-   - Verify runs quality gates (L0-L4), merges worktree branch to main, cleans up worktree, renames spec `doing-*` → `done-*`, and extracts decisions
-   - If verify fails (adds fix tasks): stop here — `/df:execute --continue` will pick up the fix tasks
-   - If verify passes: proceed to step 2
-2. Remove spec's ENTIRE section from PLAN.md (header, tasks, summaries, fix tasks, separators)
-3. Recalculate Summary table at top of PLAN.md
+All tasks done for `doing-*` spec:
+1. `skill: "df:verify", args: "doing-{name}"` — runs L0-L4 gates, merges, cleans worktree, renames doing→done, extracts decisions. Fail (fix tasks added) → stop; `--continue` picks them up.
+2. Remove spec's ENTIRE section from PLAN.md. Recalculate Summary table.
 
 ---
 
 ## Usage
 
 ```
-/df:execute              # Execute all ready tasks
-/df:execute T1 T2        # Specific tasks only
-/df:execute --continue   # Resume from checkpoint
+/df:execute              # All ready tasks
+/df:execute T1 T2        # Specific tasks
+/df:execute --continue   # Resume checkpoint
 /df:execute --fresh      # Ignore checkpoint
 /df:execute --dry-run    # Show plan only
 ```
 
 ## Skills & Agents
 
-- Skill: `atomic-commits` — Clean commit protocol
-- Skill: `browse-fetch` — Fetch live web pages and external API docs via browser before coding
-
-| Agent | subagent_type | Purpose |
-|-------|---------------|---------|
-| Implementation | `general-purpose` | Task implementation |
-| Debugger | `reasoner` | Debugging failures |
-
-**Model + effort routing:** Read `Model:` and `Effort:` fields from each task block in PLAN.md. Pass `model:` parameter when spawning the agent. Prepend effort instruction to the agent prompt. Defaults: `Model: sonnet`, `Effort: medium`.
-
-| Task fields | Agent call | Prompt preamble |
-|-------------|-----------|-----------------|
-| `Model: haiku, Effort: low` | `Agent(model="haiku", ...)` | `You MUST be maximally efficient: skip explanations, minimize tool calls, go straight to implementation.` |
-| `Model: sonnet, Effort: medium` | `Agent(model="sonnet", ...)` | `Be direct and efficient. Explain only when the logic is non-obvious.` |
-| `Model: opus, Effort: high` | `Agent(model="opus", ...)` | _(no preamble — default behavior)_ |
-| (missing) | `Agent(model="sonnet", ...)` | `Be direct and efficient. Explain only when the logic is non-obvious.` |
+Skills: `atomic-commits`, `browse-fetch`. Agents: Implementation (`general-purpose`), Debugger (`reasoner`).
 
-**Effort preamble rules:**
-- `low` → Prepend efficiency instruction. Agent should make fewest possible tool calls.
-- `medium` → Prepend balanced instruction. Agent skips preamble but explains non-obvious decisions.
-- `high` → No preamble added. Agent uses full reasoning capabilities.
+**Model+effort routing** (read from PLAN.md, defaults: sonnet/medium):
 
-**Checkpoint schema:** `.deepflow/checkpoint.json` in worktree:
-```json
-{"completed_tasks": ["T1","T2"], "current_wave": 2, "worktree_path": ".deepflow/worktrees/upload", "worktree_branch": "df/upload"}
-```
+| Fields | Agent | Preamble |
+|--------|-------|----------|
+| haiku/low | `Agent(model="haiku")` | `Maximally efficient: skip explanations, minimize tool calls, straight to implementation.` |
+| sonnet/medium | `Agent(model="sonnet")` | `Direct and efficient. Explain only non-obvious logic.` |
+| opus/high | `Agent(model="opus")` | _(none)_ |
 
----
+**Checkpoint:** `.deepflow/checkpoint.json`: `{"completed_tasks":["T1"],"current_wave":2,"worktree_path":"...","worktree_branch":"df/..."}`
 
 ## Failure Handling
 
-When task fails ratchet and is reverted:
-- `TaskUpdate(taskId: native_id, status: "pending")` — dependents remain blocked
-- Repeated failure → spawn `Task(subagent_type="reasoner", prompt="Debug failure: {ratchet output}")`
-- Leave worktree intact, keep checkpoint.json
-- Output: worktree path/branch, `cd {path}` to investigate, `--continue` to resume, `--fresh` to discard
+Reverted task: `TaskUpdate(status: "pending")`, dependents stay blocked. Repeated failure → spawn reasoner debugger. Leave worktree+checkpoint intact. Output: path, `cd` command, `--continue`/`--fresh` options.
 
 ## Rules
 
 | Rule | Detail |
 |------|--------|
-| Zero test files → bootstrap first | Bootstrap is cycle's sole task when snapshot empty |
+| Zero tests → bootstrap first | Sole task when snapshot empty |
 | 1 task = 1 agent = 1 commit | `atomic-commits` skill |
-| 1 file = 1 writer | Sequential if conflict |
-| Agent writes code, orchestrator measures | Ratchet is the judge |
-| No LLM evaluates LLM work | Health checks only |
-| ≥2 spikes same problem → parallel probes | Never run competing spikes sequentially |
-| All probe worktrees preserved | Losers renamed `-failed`; never deleted |
-| Machine-selected winner | Regressions > coverage > files changed; no LLM judge |
+| 1 file = 1 writer | Sequential on conflict |
+| Agent codes, orchestrator measures | Ratchet judges |
+| No LLM evaluates LLM | Health checks only |
+| ≥2 spikes → parallel probes | Never sequential |
+| Probe worktrees preserved | Losers `-failed`, never deleted |
+| Machine-selected winner | Regressions > coverage > files; no LLM judge |
 | External APIs → chub first | Skip if unavailable |
-| 1 optimize task at a time | Inherently sequential — no parallel optimize tasks |
-| Optimize = atomic changes only | One modification per cycle for diagnosability |
-| Ratchet + metric = both required | Optimize keeps commit only if ratchet AND metric improve |
-| Plateau → probes, not more cycles | 3 cycles without ≥1% improvement triggers probe launch |
-| Circuit breaker = 3 consecutive reverts | Halts optimize loop, requires human intervention |
-| Optimize probes need diversity | Every probe set: ≥1 contraditoria + ≥1 ingenua minimum |
-
-## Example
-
-```
-/df:execute (context: 12%)
-
-Loading PLAN.md... T1 ready, T2/T3 blocked by T1
-Ratchet snapshot: 24 pre-existing test files
-
-Wave 1: TaskUpdate(T1, in_progress)
-[Agent "T1" completed]
-  Running ratchet: build ✓ | tests ✓ (24 passed) | typecheck ✓
-  ✓ T1: ratchet passed (abc1234)
-  TaskUpdate(T1, completed) → auto-unblocks T2, T3
-
-Wave 2: TaskUpdate(T2/T3, in_progress)
-[Agent "T2" completed]  ✓ T2: ratchet passed (def5678)
-[Agent "T3" completed]  ✓ T3: ratchet passed (ghi9012)
-
-Context: 35% — All tasks done for doing-upload.
-Running /df:verify doing-upload...
-  ✓ L0 | ✓ L1 (3/3 files) | ⚠ L2 (no coverage tool) | ✓ L4 (24 tests)
-  ✓ Merged df/upload to main
-  ✓ Spec complete: doing-upload → done-upload
-Complete: 3/3
-```
+| 1 optimize at a time | Sequential |
+| Optimize = atomic only | One change per cycle |
+| Ratchet + metric both required | Keep only if both pass |
+| Plateau → probes | 3 cycles <1% triggers probes |
+| Circuit breaker = 3 reverts | Halts, needs human |
+| Probe diversity | ≥1 contraditoria + ≥1 ingenua |