crewly 1.20.197 → 1.20.198

package/dist/cli/backend/src/services/agent/agent-registration.service.js

@@ -11,7 +11,9 @@ import { RuntimeServiceFactory } from './runtime-service.factory.js';
 import { OrcReplyRouteService } from '../orc/orc-reply-route.service.js';
 import { registerInProcessRuntime, unregisterInProcessRuntime, } from './crewly-agent/in-process-runtime-registry.js';
 import { getCrewlyHomePath } from '../core/crewly-home.utils.js';
-import { CREWLY_CONSTANTS, ENV_CONSTANTS, OWNER_AUTH_CONSTANTS, AGENT_TIMEOUTS, ORCHESTRATOR_SESSION_NAME, ORCHESTRATOR_ROLE, RUNTIME_TYPES, SESSION_COMMAND_DELAYS, SESSION_RECREATION_CONSTANTS, EVENT_DELIVERY_CONSTANTS, TERMINAL_PATTERNS, GEMINI_SHELL_MODE_CONSTANTS, GEMINI_STUCK_CONNECTIVITY_PATTERN, GEMINI_ERROR_STATE_CONSTANTS, REGISTRATION_DELIVERY_CONSTANTS, ORC_CONVERSATION_CONSTANTS, SLACK_THREAD_KEY_CONSTANTS, OPEN_ITEMS_CONSTANTS, SPEND_CAP_CONSTANTS, } from '../../constants.js';
+import { CREWLY_CONSTANTS, ENV_CONSTANTS, OWNER_AUTH_CONSTANTS, AGENT_TIMEOUTS, ORCHESTRATOR_SESSION_NAME, ORCHESTRATOR_ROLE, RUNTIME_TYPES, SESSION_COMMAND_DELAYS, SESSION_RECREATION_CONSTANTS, EVENT_DELIVERY_CONSTANTS, TERMINAL_PATTERNS, GEMINI_SHELL_MODE_CONSTANTS, GEMINI_STUCK_CONNECTIVITY_PATTERN, GEMINI_ERROR_STATE_CONSTANTS, REGISTRATION_DELIVERY_CONSTANTS, ORC_CONVERSATION_CONSTANTS, SLACK_THREAD_KEY_CONSTANTS, OPEN_ITEMS_CONSTANTS, SPEND_CAP_CONSTANTS, RUNTIME_INPUT_SAFETY, TUI_INPUT_GUARD, } from '../../constants.js';
+import { TuiInputGuardError } from '../session/tui-input-guard.js';
+import { InputBlockedRetryService } from '../messaging/input-blocked-retry.service.js';
 import { extractSlackThreadKeys, formatSlackThreadKey } from '../slack/slack-thread-key.js';
 import { delay } from '../../utils/async.utils.js';
 import { buildRuntimeModelFlags } from '../../utils/runtime-model-flags.utils.js';
@@ -31,7 +33,6 @@ import { InFlightTurnTracker } from '../restart/in-flight-turn-tracker.service.j
 import { AgentTurnStateService } from '../monitoring/agent-turn-state.js';
 import { FreshTaskConversationService } from './fresh-task-conversation.service.js';
 import { RestartDrainService } from '../restart/restart-drain.service.js';
-import { AgentSuspendService } from './agent-suspend.service.js';
 import { PromptBuilderService, buildModuleConfigFromTeamMember, memberSkillsJson, } from '../ai/prompt-builder.service.js';
 import { PromptAssemblyService } from '../ai/prompt-modules/prompt-assembly.service.js';
 import { renderActiveWorkSection } from '../ai/prompt-modules/active-work.module.js';
@@ -157,6 +158,12 @@ export class AgentRegistrationService {
     // Per-session hash of last sent message to prevent duplicate writes (#128).
     // Key: sessionName, Value: { hash, sentAt }
     lastSentMessageHash = new Map();
+    // Last input-guard refusal per session during the current delivery: the
+    // box was unreadable or held text we did not write. Such a message is
+    // kept queued and retried, never dropped (2026-10-03 review).
+    lastGuardRefusal = new Map();
+    // Consecutive guard refusals per session, for escalation.
+    guardRefusalCount = new Map();
     // In-process Crewly Agent runtimes (sessionName → runtime instance).
     // Used for crewly-agent runtimeType agents that run without PTY sessions.
     inProcessRuntimes = new Map();
@@ -178,12 +185,14 @@ export class AgentRegistrationService {
         RuntimeExitMonitorService.getInstance().setOnExitDetectedCallback((sessionName) => {
             this.cancelPendingRegistration(sessionName);
             this.unregisterTuiSession(sessionName);
-            // Preserve queued messages for suspended agents (they'll be delivered on rehydrate)
-            // and during shutdown: runtimes exit because the backend is stopping,
-            // and messages held back by the restart drain must survive it.
-            if (!AgentSuspendService.getInstance().isSuspended(sessionName) &&
-                !RestartDrainService.getInstance().isDeliveryPaused()) {
-                SubAgentMessageQueue.getInstance().clear(sessionName);
+            // Queued messages are kept when the runtime exits (crewly#1014
+            // review #4): they are someone's undelivered words. They go out
+            // when the agent is started again (registration flushes the
+            // queue; an agent that went down with messages queued is woken
+            // for them), and the queue reports anything it drops.
+            const pending = SubAgentMessageQueue.getInstance().getQueueSize(sessionName);
+            if (pending > 0) {
+                this.logger.warn('Runtime exited with messages still queued — keeping them for its next start', { sessionName, pending });
             }
             InFlightTurnTracker.getInstance().markTurnComplete(sessionName, 'runtime exited');
             // Its hook state belonged to the process that just exited.
@@ -1279,8 +1288,16 @@ export class AgentRegistrationService {
      * Tries to reset the runtime session and start fresh
      */
     async tryCleanupAndReinit(sessionName, role, timeout, projectPath, memberId, runtimeType = RUNTIME_TYPES.CLAUDE_CODE, runtimeFlags, additionalAllowlistPaths) {
-        // Clear Commandline
-        await (await this.getSessionHelper()).clearCurrentCommandLine(sessionName);
+        // Clear the shell's command line before the launch command is typed —
+        // only when no runtime input box is on screen (a plain shell), and with
+        // Ctrl+U alone: never Ctrl+C into a live runtime, never wipe an agent
+        // box the harness cannot prove is its own (crewly#1014 review #3).
+        {
+            const helper = await this.getSessionHelper();
+            if (helper.readInputBox(sessionName, '', 'before-write').state === 'unknown') {
+                await helper.sendKey(sessionName, 'C-u');
+            }
+        }
         // Conversation id: preset for Claude Code (--session-id), resumed on
         // restore (--resume / `codex resume`), discovered after launch for Codex.
         const effectiveFlags = runtimeFlags ? [...runtimeFlags] : [];
@@ -1347,15 +1364,9 @@ export class AgentRegistrationService {
             // Drain stale terminal escape sequences (e.g. DA1 [?1;2c) that may have
             // arrived during postInitialize commands, so they don't leak into the prompt input
             await delay(500);
-            // Clear any pending input after post-initialization.
-            // Claude Code: Ctrl+C + Ctrl+U (clearCurrentCommandLine) — standard cleanup.
-            // Gemini CLI: Skip cleanup entirely — the TUI just started with a clean
-            // prompt. Ctrl+C at an empty Gemini CLI prompt triggers /quit and exits
-            // the CLI. Escape defocuses the TUI. Ctrl+U is ignored. The delay(500)
-            // above is sufficient to drain stale escape sequences.
-            if (runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.CLAUDE_CODE) {
-                await (await this.getSessionHelper()).clearCurrentCommandLine(sessionName);
-            }
+            // No blind Ctrl+C / Ctrl+U after post-initialization (crewly#1014):
+            // the guarded writer types only into a box it reads as empty, so
+            // stale input is refused, never wiped unseen.
         }
         catch (postInitError) {
             this.logger.warn('Post-initialization hook failed (non-fatal)', {
@@ -1909,14 +1920,7 @@ export class AgentRegistrationService {
             // Drain stale terminal escape sequences (e.g. DA1 [?1;2c) that may have
             // arrived during postInitialize commands, so they don't leak into the prompt input
             await delay(500);
-            // Claude Code: Ctrl+C + Ctrl+U to clear any stale input.
-            // Gemini CLI (Ink TUI): Do NOT send any cleanup keystrokes.
-            // Escape defocuses the Ink TUI input permanently. Ctrl+C at empty
-            // prompt triggers /quit. Ctrl+U is ignored. The delay above is
-            // sufficient to drain stale escape sequences.
-            if (runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.CLAUDE_CODE) {
-                await (await this.getSessionHelper()).clearCurrentCommandLine(sessionName);
-            }
+            // No blind Ctrl+C / Ctrl+U (crewly#1014): see post-initialization above.
         }
         catch (postInitError) {
             this.logger.warn('Post-initialization hook failed after recreation (non-fatal)', {
@@ -2637,11 +2641,12 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                 maxRetries,
             });
             try {
-                // Step 1: Send Ctrl+C to clear any pending commands (skip on first attempt if Claude was just initialized)
+                // Step 1 (crewly#1014): no blind Ctrl+C / Ctrl+U before the
+                // registration prompt — the guarded writer refuses a box that is
+                // not empty, and only our own leftover text is ever cleared.
                 if (!skipInitialCleanup || attempt > 1) {
-                    await (await this.getSessionHelper()).clearCurrentCommandLine(sessionName);
                     await delay(500);
-                    this.logger.debug('Sent Ctrl+C to clear terminal state', {
+                    this.logger.debug('Settled before the registration prompt (no clearing keys)', {
                         sessionName,
                         attempt,
                     });
@@ -2893,6 +2898,8 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
         return {
             ...harnessEnvForAgents(process.env, runtimeType),
             ...(account ? claudeAccountEnv(account) : {}),
+            // No predicted "user" text in the input box (2026-10-03 incident).
+            ...(runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.CLAUDE_CODE ? RUNTIME_INPUT_SAFETY.CLAUDE_CODE_ENV : {}),
             [ENV_CONSTANTS.CREWLY_SESSION_NAME]: sessionName,
             // The agent's credential (#999): every skill sends it, and a request
             // carrying it is this agent — never the owner.
@@ -4079,7 +4086,45 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
             // a finished turn. After the write the echo makes it look busy.
             const turnTracker = InFlightTurnTracker.getInstance();
             turnTracker.settle(sessionName);
+            this.lastGuardRefusal.delete(sessionName);
             const delivered = await this.sendMessageWithRetry(sessionName, message, maxDeliveryAttempts, runtimeType);
+            const refusal = this.lastGuardRefusal.get(sessionName);
+            if (delivered) {
+                // Never re-send a confirmed delivery (the scanner's re-queue).
+                for (const e of this.sentMessageTracker.get(sessionName) ?? [])
+                    if (e.message === message)
+                        e.confirmed = true;
+                this.guardRefusalCount.delete(sessionName);
+                InputBlockedRetryService.getInstance().noteDelivered(sessionName);
+            }
+            if (!delivered && refusal) {
+                // The harness would not type into, or submit, the agent's input box
+                // (unreadable, or holding text it did not write). Keep the message
+                // queued — it is retried when the agent is idle — and say so.
+                SubAgentMessageQueue.getInstance().enqueue(sessionName, message);
+                // Retried on a timer with backoff, and the owner told if it stays blocked.
+                InputBlockedRetryService.getInstance().noteRefusal(sessionName, {
+                    state: refusal.reading.state,
+                    inputLength: refusal.reading.text.length,
+                    message,
+                });
+                const count = (this.guardRefusalCount.get(sessionName) ?? 0) + 1;
+                this.guardRefusalCount.set(sessionName, count);
+                const log = count >= TUI_INPUT_GUARD.ESCALATE_AFTER_REFUSALS ? this.logger.error.bind(this.logger) : this.logger.warn.bind(this.logger);
+                log('Message held: the agent input box is unreadable or holds text the harness did not write — queued for retry', {
+                    sessionName,
+                    stage: refusal.stage,
+                    state: refusal.reading.state,
+                    layout: refusal.reading.layout,
+                    inputPreview: refusal.reading.text.slice(0, 80),
+                    consecutiveRefusals: count,
+                });
+                return {
+                    success: true,
+                    queued: true,
+                    message: '[INPUT_NOT_OURS] Message queued: the agent\'s input box is unreadable or holds text the harness did not write. It will be retried.',
+                };
+            }
             if (delivered) {
                 turnTracker.recordDelivery(sessionName, message, 'pty');
                 noteTurnDelivery(sessionName, message, 'pty');
@@ -4294,6 +4339,37 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
      * @returns true if message was delivered successfully
      */
     async sendMessageWithRetry(sessionName, message, maxAttempts = 3, runtimeType = RUNTIME_TYPES.CLAUDE_CODE) {
+        const delivered = await this.sendMessageWithRetryAttempts(sessionName, message, maxAttempts, runtimeType);
+        if (!delivered)
+            return false;
+        // Whatever the checks above concluded (a fast reply, a weak output
+        // change), a collapsed paste of ours still in the box means its Enter
+        // was lost: press Enter once and look again (crewly#1014 review #4).
+        try {
+            const outcome = await (await this.getSessionHelper()).ensureOwnPasteSubmitted(sessionName);
+            if (outcome === 'stuck') {
+                this.logger.warn('Delivery looked confirmed but our paste is still in the input box — not delivered', { sessionName });
+                return false;
+            }
+            if (outcome === 'submitted') {
+                this.logger.warn('Delivery looked confirmed but its Enter was lost — submitted it now', { sessionName });
+            }
+        }
+        catch {
+            // No session helper / session gone: the checks above stand.
+        }
+        return true;
+    }
+    /**
+     * The delivery attempts behind {@link sendMessageWithRetry}.
+     *
+     * @param sessionName - Target session
+     * @param message - Message to deliver
+     * @param maxAttempts - Attempts before giving up
+     * @param runtimeType - The session's runtime
+     * @returns Whether the checks saw the message accepted
+     */
+    async sendMessageWithRetryAttempts(sessionName, message, maxAttempts = 3, runtimeType = RUNTIME_TYPES.CLAUDE_CODE) {
         const sessionHelper = await this.getSessionHelper();
         const isClaudeCode = runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.CLAUDE_CODE;
         const isCodexCli = runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.CODEX_CLI;
@@ -4395,12 +4471,9 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                 //    This may restore the internal focus state. Then Tab + Enter
                 //    for focus cycling and overlay dismissal.
                 if (isClaudeCode) {
-                    if (attempt > 1) {
-                        // On retry: Ctrl+C to cancel stale input, then PTY resize to force
-                        // TUI re-render (SIGWINCH), then Tab to cycle Ink focus.
-                        await sessionHelper.sendCtrlC(sessionName);
-                        await delay(300);
-                    }
+                    // No Ctrl+C on retry (2026-10-03 review): it wipes whatever is in
+                    // the box — possibly the owner's half-typed text — and cancels a
+                    // running turn. The guarded write only types into an empty box.
                     // PTY resize on ALL attempts to force SIGWINCH → Ink TUI re-render.
                     // Claude Code's Ink TUI can lose internal input focus after stop hooks
                     // (especially ones that error), state transitions, or idle periods.
@@ -4420,18 +4493,17 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                         }
                     }
                     catch { /* non-fatal */ }
-                    await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                    await delay(300);
+                    // No Tab here (2026-10-03): in an empty Claude Code input, Tab
+                    // ACCEPTS the faint prompt suggestion — a predicted user message —
+                    // which the paste below then got appended to and submitted as if
+                    // the owner had typed it. The resize above restores focus.
                 }
                 else if (isAntigravity) {
                     // Antigravity CLI: Ctrl+U clears stale input (verified on agy
                     // 1.2.11). No Tab/Enter nudges: Tab completes slash commands and
                     // the binary labels its spinner "Generating... (Enter/Esc to
                     // cancel)", so a stray Enter or Esc can cancel a running turn.
-                    if (attempt > 1) {
-                        await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'C-u');
-                        await delay(300);
-                    }
+                    // No blind Ctrl+U: only text proven ours is ever cleared.
                 }
                 else if (isCodexCli) {
                     // #246: Codex CLI TUI recovery — simpler than Gemini.
@@ -4449,9 +4521,7 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                             }
                         }
                         catch { /* non-fatal */ }
-                        // Ctrl+U to clear any stale input text
-                        await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'C-u');
-                        await delay(300);
+                        // No blind Ctrl+U: only text proven ours is ever cleared.
                     }
                 }
                 else {
@@ -4512,25 +4582,11 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                         // F12 to close error details panel if open
                         await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'F12');
                         await delay(300);
-                        // Enter to dismiss any remaining overlay/notification
-                        await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                        await delay(500);
                     }
-                    // Send Tab to cycle Ink focus. In Ink v6, Tab triggers
-                    // focusNext() in FocusContext, which moves focus to the next
-                    // focusable component (InputPrompt). This works even when the
-                    // input is defocused because the Tab handler runs at the Ink
-                    // framework level, not the component level.
-                    // Send two Tabs to cycle through error/notification components
-                    // that may be in the focus chain (#130).
-                    await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                    await delay(200);
-                    await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                    await delay(300);
-                    // Then Enter to dismiss any notification overlay and ensure
-                    // the input is engaged. Enter on an empty `> ` prompt is a
-                    // safe no-op (just shows a new blank prompt line).
-                    await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
+                    // No Tab/Enter focus nudges (2026-10-03): the harness never presses
+                    // Tab or Enter unless its own text is in the input box. Tab can
+                    // accept a completion/suggestion and Enter submits whatever the box
+                    // holds. The resize above re-renders the TUI to restore focus.
                     // Extra settling time after /compress or error state to let Ink TUI stabilize
                     await delay((compressDetected || errorStateDetected) ? 1000 : 500);
                 }
@@ -4547,14 +4603,15 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                     ];
                     const inInteractiveMode = interactiveModePatterns.some(p => preOutput.includes(p));
                     if (inInteractiveMode) {
-                        this.logger.warn('Gemini CLI in interactive mode, using non-destructive recovery', {
+                        // No Tab/Enter: they would pick an entry in the picker. Skip
+                        // this attempt and look again; the input guard in sendMessage
+                        // refuses to type while the box is not an empty prompt.
+                        this.logger.warn('Gemini CLI in interactive mode, skipping this delivery attempt', {
                             sessionName,
                             detectedPattern: interactiveModePatterns.find(p => preOutput.includes(p)),
                         });
-                        await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                        await delay(250);
-                        await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                        await delay(1000);
+                        await delay(SESSION_COMMAND_DELAYS.MESSAGE_RETRY_DELAY);
+                        continue;
                     }
                 }
                 // Capture output BEFORE sending to detect changes for ALL runtimes.
@@ -4651,7 +4708,8 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                 // 2. await delay(scaled)       — waits for paste processing
                 // 3. session.write('\r')       — sends Enter separately
                 // 4. await delay(KEY_DELAY)    — waits for key processing
-                await sessionHelper.sendMessage(sessionName, message);
+                // Recorded marker: this path checks the box after delivery.
+                await sessionHelper.sendMessage(sessionName, message, { recordPasteMarker: true });
                 // Register for background stuck-detection safety net (all runtimes).
                 // If progressive verification below misses an Enter drop, the
                 // background scanner will catch it within 30s.
@@ -4727,20 +4785,17 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                                 : message).replace(/\s+/g, ' ').trim();
                             const promptBottomLines = currentOutput.split('\n').slice(-10).join(' ').replace(/\s+/g, ' ');
                             if (promptBottomLines.includes(promptMsgSnippet)) {
-                                this.logger.warn('At prompt with message text at bottom — pressing Tab+Enter', {
+                                // Our text near the bottom may be the transcript echo of a
+                                // message already submitted. Press Enter only if the input
+                                // box itself holds exactly our text (never Tab: it accepts a
+                                // prompt suggestion — the 2026-10-03 phantom owner input).
+                                const pressed = (await sessionHelper.submitIfInputIsOurs(sessionName, message)).state === 'ours';
+                                this.logger.warn('At prompt with message text at bottom', {
                                     sessionName,
                                     attempt,
                                     intervalMs,
+                                    enterPressed: pressed,
                                 });
-                                // Tab restores Ink TUI focus before Enter — without this,
-                                // Enter may be consumed by the framework but not routed to
-                                // the input component if focus was lost during a re-render
-                                // (e.g., after stop hooks, state transitions).
-                                await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                                await delay(200);
-                                await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                                await delay(500);
-                                await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName); // backup
                                 await delay(SESSION_COMMAND_DELAYS.MESSAGE_PROCESSING_DELAY);
                                 // Verify recovery
                                 const postEnterOutput = sessionHelper.capturePane(sessionName);
@@ -4796,16 +4851,14 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                             // prompt is no longer in its idle form — Enter was dropped.
                             // Instead of waiting and doing a full Ctrl+C + resend retry,
                             // use Tab to restore TUI focus, then Enter to submit.
-                            this.logger.warn('Message text stuck at bottom — pressing Tab+Enter to recover', {
+                            // Enter only when the input box holds exactly our text.
+                            const pressed = (await sessionHelper.submitIfInputIsOurs(sessionName, message)).state === 'ours';
+                            this.logger.warn('Message text stuck at bottom', {
                                 sessionName,
                                 attempt,
                                 intervalMs,
+                                enterPressed: pressed,
                             });
-                            await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                            await delay(200);
-                            await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                            await delay(500);
-                            await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName); // backup Enter
                             // Give the agent a moment to start processing after Enter
                             await delay(SESSION_COMMAND_DELAYS.MESSAGE_PROCESSING_DELAY);
                             // Verify recovery: check if processing started
@@ -4849,7 +4902,7 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                     // If progressive verification didn't confirm delivery, run an
                     // extended check loop (every 3s, up to 30s total). Each iteration
                     // captures the pane, checks for spinner/working indicators, and
-                    // presses Tab+Enter if message text is still stuck at the bottom.
+                    // presses Enter if our message text is still in the input box.
                     if (!claudeDelivered) {
                         const CONFIRM_INTERVAL_MS = 3000;
                         const CONFIRM_MAX_MS = 30000;
@@ -4874,7 +4927,7 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                                 break;
                             }
                             // Text still stuck → Enter was dropped, NOT delivered. Try
-                            // Tab+Enter recovery and re-check next iteration. This is
+                            // Enter (only if the box holds our text) and re-check next iteration. This is
                             // checked BEFORE the output-change shortcut below: when our
                             // own pasted message is echoed at the prompt the output DID
                             // change vs the pre-send baseline, but that change is the
@@ -4882,14 +4935,10 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                             // is the false-positive that masked the orc 假死 (#686
                             // follow-up: a hung session looked "delivered" forever).
                             if (textStuck) {
-                                this.logger.warn('Confirmation loop: text still stuck, pressing Tab+Enter', {
-                                    sessionName, attempt, confirmAttempt,
+                                const pressed = (await sessionHelper.submitIfInputIsOurs(sessionName, message)).state === 'ours';
+                                this.logger.warn('Confirmation loop: text still stuck', {
+                                    sessionName, attempt, confirmAttempt, enterPressed: pressed,
                                 });
-                                await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                                await delay(200);
-                                await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                                await delay(500);
-                                await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName); // backup
                                 continue;
                             }
                             // Fast-response detection: output changed since send AND our
@@ -4942,8 +4991,9 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                             this.logger.debug('Antigravity: message left the prompt box — delivery trusted', { sessionName, attempt });
                             return true;
                         }
-                        this.logger.warn('Antigravity: message still in the prompt box — pressing Enter once', { sessionName, attempt });
-                        await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
+                        // Enter only when the box holds exactly our message.
+                        const pressed = (await sessionHelper.submitIfInputIsOurs(sessionName, message)).state === 'ours';
+                        this.logger.warn('Antigravity: message still in the prompt box', { sessionName, attempt, enterPressed: pressed });
                         await delay(SESSION_COMMAND_DELAYS.MESSAGE_PROCESSING_DELAY);
                         if (!isTextInAntigravityInputBox(sessionHelper.capturePane(sessionName), message)) {
                             return true;
@@ -4981,6 +5031,17 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                     }
                     else {
                         // --- Non-Gemini TUI runtimes: full verification ---
+                        // Phase 0: read the box. The guarded writer pressed Enter only
+                        // on our own text; a box that now reads empty in a verified
+                        // layout means it went in — the output-length heuristics below
+                        // miss that (Codex: "did not change" → a retry → a duplicate).
+                        {
+                            const boxAfter = sessionHelper.readInputBox(sessionName, message, 'recovery');
+                            if (boxAfter.state === 'empty' && boxAfter.verified) {
+                                this.logger.debug('Input box empty after our Enter — delivery confirmed', { sessionName, attempt, layout: boxAfter.layout });
+                                return true;
+                            }
+                        }
                         // Phase 1: Direct stuck-at-prompt detection
                         const stuckAtPrompt = this.isTextStuckAtTuiPrompt(sessionName, message);
                         if (stuckAtPrompt) {
@@ -5048,28 +5109,13 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                     sessionName,
                     attempt,
                 });
-                if (isClaudeCode) {
-                    await sessionHelper.clearCurrentCommandLine(sessionName);
-                }
-                else if (isAntigravity) {
-                    // Antigravity: clear the prompt box (Ctrl+U) so the retry types
-                    // the message into an empty box. No Ctrl+C (arms exit), no Tab.
-                    await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'C-u');
-                    await delay(300);
-                }
-                else {
-                    // Gemini CLI retry cleanup: NEVER send Ctrl+C — it triggers /quit
-                    // and kills the CLI entirely, regardless of whether text is in the
-                    // input box or not. Use Tab to cycle Ink focus back to the input
-                    // prompt, then Enter to submit any pending text.
-                    this.logger.warn('Gemini CLI message stuck — using Tab focus recovery (no Ctrl+C)', {
-                        sessionName,
-                        attempt,
-                    });
-                    await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                    await delay(300);
-                    await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                    await delay(300);
+                // Clear the box only when it holds exactly our message (2026-10-03
+                // review): never Ctrl+C (cancels a turn; twice exits Claude Code;
+                // /quit in Gemini), never wipe text we cannot prove is ours.
+                {
+                    const box = sessionHelper.readInputBox(sessionName, message, 'before-write');
+                    if (box.state === 'ours')
+                        await sessionHelper.clearInputBox(sessionName, message, box);
                 }
                 await delay(SESSION_COMMAND_DELAYS.CLEAR_COMMAND_DELAY);
                 if (attempt < maxAttempts) {
@@ -5077,6 +5123,9 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                 }
             }
             catch (error) {
+                if (error instanceof TuiInputGuardError) {
+                    this.lastGuardRefusal.set(sessionName, error);
+                }
                 this.logger.error('Error during message delivery', {
                     sessionName,
                     attempt,
@@ -5237,16 +5286,15 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
      */
     async recoverStuckTuiMessage(sessionName, message) {
         const sessionHelper = await this.getSessionHelper();
-        // Tab restores Ink TUI focus, then Enter to submit the stuck text.
-        // Without Tab, Enter may be consumed by the framework but not routed
-        // to the input component if focus was lost during a re-render.
-        this.logger.info('Pressing Tab+Enter to recover stuck TUI message', { sessionName });
-        await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-        await delay(200);
-        await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-        await delay(500);
-        // Double-tap: send a backup Enter in case the first was consumed
-        await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
+        // Enter only when the input box holds exactly our text — never Tab
+        // (accepts a suggestion) and no blind backup Enter (submits whatever
+        // the box holds once ours is gone).
+        const reading = await sessionHelper.submitIfInputIsOurs(sessionName, message);
+        // Enter only for text read as ours — never on an unreadable box.
+        const pressed = reading.state === 'ours';
+        this.logger.info('Stuck TUI message: Enter only if the box holds our text', { sessionName, enterPressed: pressed, state: reading.state });
+        if (!pressed)
+            return false;
         await delay(2000);
         // Verify text is no longer at prompt
         const stillStuck = this.isTextStuckAtTuiPrompt(sessionName, message);
@@ -5327,90 +5375,22 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                 // Non-fatal: session may have been destroyed
             }
         }
-        // --- Part 1: Existing TUI prompt-line scanning ---
-        for (const [sessionName, runtimeType] of this.tuiSessionRegistry) {
-            try {
-                // Skip Gemini CLI sessions — their TUI prompt behaves differently
-                // and false-positive stuck detection causes Tab+Enter spam.
-                // Skip Antigravity too: its idle placeholder and the `> text` echo
-                // of every submitted message sit on `>` lines, and Enter during a
-                // turn can cancel it; its deliveries are verified on the prompt box.
-                // Skip Codex: its empty composer shows a rotating suggestion
-                // ("Ask Codex to do anything", "Explain this codebase", ...) on the
-                // `›` line, indistinguishable from typed text once the dim styling is
-                // lost, so every scan of a working Codex agent pressed Tab+Enter
-                // (47 times in one turn). Tab queues input in Codex; real Enter drops
-                // are still caught by Part 2, which matches the text actually sent.
-                if (runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.GEMINI_CLI ||
-                    runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.ANTIGRAVITY_CLI ||
-                    runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.CODEX_CLI) {
-                    continue;
-                }
-                // #213: Skip orchestrator — it frequently waits for long-running
-                // agent tasks (30+ min), and false stuck detection causes disruptive
-                // Tab+Enter key injections that interrupt its workflow.
-                if (sessionName === ORCHESTRATOR_SESSION_NAME) {
-                    continue;
-                }
-                // Skip sessions that no longer exist
-                if (!sessionHelper.sessionExists(sessionName)) {
-                    this.tuiSessionRegistry.delete(sessionName);
-                    continue;
-                }
-                const output = sessionHelper.capturePane(sessionName);
-                if (!output || output.trim().length === 0)
-                    continue;
-                // Look for any text sitting on the prompt line
-                const lines = output.split('\n');
-                for (let i = lines.length - 1; i >= Math.max(0, lines.length - 25); i--) {
-                    const promptContent = matchTuiPromptLine(lines[i]);
-                    if (promptContent !== null) {
-                        const trimmedContent = stripTuiLineBorders(promptContent).trim();
-                        // Only act on substantial text (> 10 chars) to avoid false positives
-                        // from TUI rendering artifacts or short status text
-                        if (trimmedContent.length > 10) {
-                            // Skip known idle placeholder text that sits at
-                            // the `> ` prompt when no user input is present. These are
-                            // NOT stuck messages — they are TUI decoration.
-                            const lowerContent = trimmedContent.toLowerCase();
-                            const isPlaceholder = lowerContent.startsWith('type your message') ||
-                                trimmedContent.startsWith('@'); // e.g., "@path/to/file"
-                            if (isPlaceholder) {
-                                break;
-                            }
-                            this.logger.warn('Background scan: text stuck at TUI prompt, pressing Tab+Enter', {
-                                sessionName,
-                                promptContent: promptContent.slice(0, 80),
-                            });
-                            // Tab restores Ink TUI focus before Enter
-                            await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                            await delay(200);
-                            await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                            await delay(500);
-                            // Backup Enter
-                            await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                        }
-                        break; // Only check the first prompt line found from the bottom
-                    }
-                }
-            }
-            catch (error) {
-                this.logger.debug('Error scanning session for stuck messages', {
-                    sessionName,
-                    error: error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error),
-                });
-            }
-        }
+        // --- Part 1 (removed 2026-10-03) ---
+        // The old Part 1 pressed Tab+Enter on ANY text sitting on a TUI prompt
+        // line — text the harness never wrote (a prompt suggestion accepted by
+        // the Tab, or someone's half-typed input) got submitted. The harness
+        // now only submits its own tracked messages (Part 2), and only when
+        // the input box holds exactly that text.
         // --- Part 2: Tracked-message scanning (non-Gemini runtimes) ---
         const now = Date.now();
         const MIN_AGE_MS = 10000; // Check messages older than 10s
-        const MAX_RECOVERY_ATTEMPTS = 5; // Give up after 5 Tab+Enter attempts
+        const MAX_RECOVERY_ATTEMPTS = 5; // Give up after 5 Enter attempts
         for (const [sessionName, entries] of this.sentMessageTracker) {
             if (!sessionHelper.sessionExists(sessionName)) {
                 this.sentMessageTracker.delete(sessionName);
                 continue;
             }
-            // Skip Gemini CLI sessions — Tab+Enter recovery causes more harm
+            // Skip Gemini CLI sessions — Enter recovery causes more harm
             // than good because the Gemini TUI handles input differently.
             const trackedRuntime = this.tuiSessionRegistry.get(sessionName);
             if (trackedRuntime === RUNTIME_TYPES.GEMINI_CLI || trackedRuntime === RUNTIME_TYPES.ANTIGRAVITY_CLI) {
@@ -5427,9 +5407,33 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                     if (now - entry.sentAt < MIN_AGE_MS)
                         continue;
                     if (entry.recoveryAttempts >= MAX_RECOVERY_ATTEMPTS) {
-                        // Exhausted recovery attempts — mark as recovered to stop retrying
                         entry.recovered = true;
-                        this.logger.error('Background scan: max recovery attempts exhausted', {
+                        const alreadyQueued = !!entry.message && SubAgentMessageQueue.getInstance().contains(sessionName, entry.message);
+                        if (entry.unreadable && entry.message && (entry.confirmed || alreadyQueued)) {
+                            // Delivery was confirmed earlier (or the message is queued
+                            // already): re-sending would duplicate it.
+                            this.logger.warn('Background scan: input box stayed unreadable — message was already delivered or queued, not re-sending', {
+                                sessionName,
+                                snippet: entry.snippet.slice(0, 50),
+                                confirmed: !!entry.confirmed,
+                            });
+                            continue;
+                        }
+                        if (entry.unreadable && entry.message) {
+                            // The box never became readable: we cannot tell whether
+                            // the message went in. Hand it back to the queue (retried
+                            // with backoff, the owner told if it stays blocked) rather
+                            // than give up on it (review #3 of crewly#1014).
+                            SubAgentMessageQueue.getInstance().enqueue(sessionName, entry.message);
+                            InputBlockedRetryService.getInstance().noteRefusal(sessionName, { state: 'unknown', inputLength: 0, message: entry.message });
+                            this.logger.error('Background scan: input box stayed unreadable — message re-queued', {
+                                sessionName,
+                                snippet: entry.snippet.slice(0, 50),
+                                attempts: entry.recoveryAttempts,
+                            });
+                            continue;
+                        }
+                        this.logger.error('Background scan: max recovery attempts exhausted — the message may not have been delivered', {
                             sessionName,
                             snippet: entry.snippet.slice(0, 50),
                             attempts: entry.recoveryAttempts,
@@ -5437,20 +5441,74 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                         continue;
                     }
                     if (bottomText.includes(entry.snippet)) {
+                        // The text near the bottom is often only the transcript echo
+                        // of a message already submitted. Enter is pressed only when
+                        // the input box itself holds exactly this message — never on
+                        // an empty box (it may show a ghost prompt suggestion; Enter
+                        // or Tab would submit it as the owner — 2026-10-03).
+                        const reading = await sessionHelper.submitIfInputIsOurs(sessionName, entry.message);
+                        if (reading.state === 'empty') {
+                            // The box is empty: our message was submitted (the text
+                            // seen was its echo). Nothing to do.
+                            entry.recovered = true;
+                            continue;
+                        }
+                        if (reading.state === 'foreign') {
+                            const squashed = (t) => t.replace(/\s+/g, '');
+                            if (squashed(reading.text).includes(squashed(entry.snippet))) {
+                                // Our message is in the box mixed with text we did not
+                                // write. Never wipe text we cannot prove is ours: leave the
+                                // box as it is and hand the message back to delivery, which
+                                // keeps it queued until the box is empty. The entry is marked
+                                // recovered only once delivery has it (2026-10-03 review).
+                                this.logger.warn('Background scan: tracked message stuck with foreign text in the box — not touching it, re-queuing the message', {
+                                    sessionName,
+                                    snippet: entry.snippet.slice(0, 50),
+                                });
+                                this.logger.warn('Background scan: input box text (not ours)', { sessionName, inputPreview: reading.text.slice(0, 80) });
+                                try {
+                                    const result = await this.sendMessageToAgent(sessionName, entry.message);
+                                    if (result.success) {
+                                        entry.recovered = true;
+                                    }
+                                    else {
+                                        entry.recoveryAttempts++;
+                                        this.logger.error('Background scan: re-delivery failed — will try again next scan', { sessionName, error: result.error });
+                                    }
+                                }
+                                catch (err) {
+                                    entry.recoveryAttempts++;
+                                    this.logger.error('Background scan: re-delivery threw — will try again next scan', {
+                                        sessionName,
+                                        error: err instanceof Error ? err.message : String(err),
+                                    });
+                                }
+                                break;
+                            }
+                            // Our text is not in the box (someone else's is): ours was submitted.
+                            entry.recovered = true;
+                            continue;
+                        }
                         entry.recoveryAttempts++;
-                        this.logger.warn('Background scan: tracked message stuck, pressing Tab+Enter', {
+                        entry.unreadable = reading.state === 'unknown';
+                        if (reading.state === 'unknown') {
+                            // Cannot see the box: never press Enter blindly, never mark
+                            // it recovered — look again next scan; exhausting attempts
+                            // is logged as an error above.
+                            this.logger.warn('Background scan: tracked message near the bottom but the input box cannot be read — not pressing Enter', {
+                                sessionName,
+                                snippet: entry.snippet.slice(0, 50),
+                                attempt: entry.recoveryAttempts,
+                            });
+                            break;
+                        }
+                        this.logger.warn('Background scan: tracked message stuck in the input box, pressed Enter', {
                             sessionName,
                             snippet: entry.snippet.slice(0, 50),
                             ageMs: now - entry.sentAt,
                             attempt: entry.recoveryAttempts,
                             maxAttempts: MAX_RECOVERY_ATTEMPTS,
                         });
-                        // Tab restores Ink TUI focus before Enter
-                        await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'Tab');
-                        await delay(200);
-                        await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                        await delay(500);
-                        await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName); // backup
                         break; // One recovery per session per scan cycle
                     }
                 }
@@ -5501,7 +5559,7 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
         if (snippet.length < 10)
             return; // Too short to reliably match
         const entries = this.sentMessageTracker.get(sessionName) || [];
-        entries.push({ snippet, sentAt: Date.now(), recovered: false, recoveryAttempts: 0 });
+        entries.push({ snippet, message, sentAt: Date.now(), recovered: false, recoveryAttempts: 0 });
         // Keep only last 5 minutes of entries
         const cutoff = Date.now() - 5 * 60 * 1000;
         this.sentMessageTracker.set(sessionName, entries.filter(e => e.sentAt > cutoff));
@@ -5823,33 +5881,9 @@ Loop until done, blocked, or explicitly reassigned:
                     this.logger.info('Prompt delivery aborted before send (runtime exited)', { sessionName });
                     return false;
                 }
-                // Clear any pending input before sending the instruction (first attempt only).
-                if (attempt === 1) {
-                    if (isClaudeCode) {
-                        // Claude Code: Escape closes slash menus + Ctrl+U clears line.
-                        await sessionHelper.sendEscape(sessionName);
-                        await delay(200);
-                        await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'C-u');
-                        await delay(300);
-                    }
-                    else if (runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.CODEX_CLI || runtimeType === RUNTIME_TYPES.ANTIGRAVITY_CLI) {
-                        // #246: Codex CLI — Ctrl+U to clear any stale input text.
-                        // Unlike Gemini, Codex doesn't need Enter flush; its Ink TUI
-                        // handles Ctrl+U for line clear similar to Claude Code.
-                        // Antigravity clears its prompt box on Ctrl+U the same way.
-                        await sessionHelper.sendKey(sessionName, 'C-u');
-                        await delay(300);
-                    }
-                    else {
-                        // Gemini CLI (Ink TUI): After /directory add processing, the TUI
-                        // input may lose focus or have stale invisible characters.
-                        // Send Enter to flush any residual input, then wait for the
-                        // prompt to settle before sending the real instruction.
-                        this.logger.debug('Gemini CLI pre-send: flushing input with Enter', { sessionName });
-                        await sessionHelper.sendEnter(sessionName);
-                        await delay(1000);
-                    }
-                }
+                // No pre-clearing (2026-10-03 review): Escape / Ctrl+U would wipe
+                // whatever the box holds without knowing whose it is. The guarded
+                // sendMessage below types only into a box it reads as empty.
                 // Check abort right before writing instruction to terminal
                 if (this.isFlowCancelled(sessionName, abortSignal)) {
                     this.logger.info('Prompt delivery aborted before instruction send (runtime exited)', { sessionName });