crewforth 3.2.0-rc.1 → 3.2.0-rc.10

package/kit/eval/smoke-test.sh

@@ -1674,8 +1674,8 @@ if [ "$IS_KIT" = 1 ]; then
   _ch4_t="$(printf '%s\n' "all fo""ur channels carry it" "Dö""rt kanal da taşıyor" "of fo""ur distribution channels" "three channels" "four channel types of RGB" | grep -ciE "$_ch4_re")"
   if [ "$_ch4_t" != 3 ]; then fail "channel-count check cannot tell its twins apart (caught $_ch4_t of the 3 planted, want 3 and none of the 2 clean)"
   elif git -C "$KR" rev-parse --git-dir >/dev/null 2>&1; then
-    _ch4_hits="$(git -C "$KR" grep -niIE "$_ch4_re" -- . ':!CHANGELOG.md' ':!site/src/content/docs/changelog.md' ':!site/src/content/docs/tr/changelog.md' 2>/dev/null)"
-    [ -z "$_ch4_hits" ] && pass "no tracked file gives the old channel count — three ship Crewforth (CHANGELOG exempt; twins 3/3 caught, 0/2 flagged)" \
+    _ch4_hits="$(git -C "$KR" grep -niIE "$_ch4_re" -- . ':!CHANGELOG.md' ':!site/src/content/docs/changelog.md' ':!site/src/content/docs/tr/changelog.md' ':!packaging/review-bench/cases' 2>/dev/null)"
+    [ -z "$_ch4_hits" ] && pass "no tracked file gives the old channel count — three ship Crewforth (CHANGELOG and the review bench's past-version cases exempt; twins 3/3 caught, 0/2 flagged)" \
       || fail "a tracked file still gives the old channel count (there are three): $(printf '%s\n' "$_ch4_hits" | head -3 | tr '\n' ' ')"
   else skip scope "channel-count check not run — not a git checkout of Crewforth's source"; fi
   # THE CLIENT SIDE IS STACK-NEUTRAL (3.0.1): the install summary, the help and the install page named the scope as
@@ -3407,6 +3407,46 @@ pass|rm -f file.txt
 pass|rm file.txt
 pass|rmdir empty/
 RMCASES
+# V4: a stopped or asked command says what it would have touched (eval/lib/preview.sh): the changes a reset discards,
+# the paths a clean deletes, the files under an rm target inside the project, what a commit takes and a push sends.
+# Read only, and after the decision: a preview library that fails or ends its shell leaves the decision as it was.
+PVR="$(mktemp -d)"; PVR="$(cd -P "$PVR" && pwd)"; PVO="$(mktemp)"; PVE="$(mktemp)"; PVX="$(mktemp -d)"
+( cd "$PVR" && git init -q . && git -c user.email=a@b -c user.name=a commit -q --allow-empty -m base \
+  && printf '1\n' > a.txt && printf '2\n' > b.txt && git add . && git -c user.email=a@b -c user.name=a commit -q -m two \
+  && printf 'x\n' >> a.txt && printf 'y\n' >> b.txt && mkdir -p out/sub && : > out/sub/1 && : > out/2 && : > junk.log ) >/dev/null 2>&1
+_pvrun(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","permission_mode":"default","hook_event_name":"PreToolUse","tool_name":"Bash","tool_input":{"command":"%s"},"cwd":"%s"}' "$1" "$PVR" \
+  | ( cd "$PVR" && CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR="$PVR" CREW_GATE_LOG=/dev/null bash "${2:-$HOOKS}/guard-bash.sh" ) > "$PVO" 2> "$PVE"; _pvrc=$?; }
+_pvb=""
+_pvrun "git reset --hard"; { [ "$_pvrc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'Preview: it would discard 2 uncommitted change' "$PVE"; } || _pvb="$_pvb [reset: rc $_pvrc · $(grep Preview "$PVE")]"
+_pvrun "git reset --hard HEAD~1"; grep -q 'and drop 1 commit(s) from the branch' "$PVE" || _pvb="$_pvb [reset HEAD~1: $(grep Preview "$PVE")]"
+_pvrun "git clean -fd"; { [ "$_pvrc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'lists 2 path(s) it would delete' "$PVE"; } || _pvb="$_pvb [clean: $(grep Preview "$PVE")]"
+_pvrun "rm -rf out/"; { [ "$_pvrc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'Preview: out/: 2 file(s)' "$PVE"; } || _pvb="$_pvb [rm inside: $(grep Preview "$PVE")]"
+_pvrun "rm -rf $PVX/"; { [ "$_pvrc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'outside the project, not counted' "$PVE"; } || _pvb="$_pvb [rm outside: $(grep Preview "$PVE")]"
+# The asked ones: a commit (past §4.6, with the review record) and a push to a remote of its own.
+( cd "$PVR" && git add a.txt && mkdir -p .claude && D=$(git diff --cached --no-ext-diff --no-textconv | git hash-object --stdin) && H=$(git rev-parse HEAD) \
+  && printf '{"diff_oid":"%s","head":"%s","ts":"%s"}\n' "$D" "$H" "2026-01-01T00:00:00Z" > .claude/review-pass.json ) >/dev/null 2>&1
+_pvrun "git commit -m wip"; { [ "$_pvrc" = 0 ] && grep -q 'Preview: 1 file changed, 1 insertion' "$PVO"; } || _pvb="$_pvb [commit ask: rc $_pvrc · $(grep -o 'Preview[^\\]*' "$PVO")]"
+( cd "$PVR" && git init -q --bare "$PVX/r.git" && git remote add origin "$PVX/r.git" && git push -q -u origin HEAD:main && git branch -q -u origin/main \
+  && git -c user.email=a@b -c user.name=a commit -q --allow-empty -m "one ahead" ) >/dev/null 2>&1
+_pvrun "git push"; { [ "$_pvrc" = 0 ] && grep -q 'Preview: it sends 1 commit(s) to origin/main' "$PVO"; } || _pvb="$_pvb [push ask: rc $_pvrc · $(grep -o 'Preview[^\\]*' "$PVO")]"
+# A push that names its branch sends to that one: an existing one is counted, an unknown one would be created.
+_pvrun "git push origin main"; grep -q 'Preview: it sends 1 commit(s) to origin/main' "$PVO" || _pvb="$_pvb [named push: $(grep -o 'Preview[^\\]*' "$PVO")]"
+_pvrun "git push origin feat/new"; grep -q 'Preview: origin/feat/new is not known here; the push would create it' "$PVO" || _pvb="$_pvb [push to a new branch: $(grep -o 'Preview[^\\]*' "$PVO")]"
+# A push of another local branch counts that branch's commits, not the current one's (current: 1 ahead; side: 3).
+( cd "$PVR" && _cur="$(git rev-parse --abbrev-ref HEAD)" && git checkout -q -b side && git -c user.email=a@b -c user.name=a commit -q --allow-empty -m s1 \
+  && git -c user.email=a@b -c user.name=a commit -q --allow-empty -m s2 && git checkout -q "$_cur" ) >/dev/null 2>&1
+_pvrun "git push origin side:main"; grep -q 'Preview: it sends 3 commit(s) to origin/main' "$PVO" || _pvb="$_pvb [push of another branch: $(grep -o 'Preview[^\\]*' "$PVO")]"
+# A pattern is said, not expanded by the hook's own shell into the files it matches.
+_pvrun "rm -rf out/*"; { [ "$_pvrc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'Preview: out/\*: a pattern, not counted' "$PVE"; } || _pvb="$_pvb [rm pattern: rc $_pvrc · $(grep Preview "$PVE")]"
+# A broken preview library: one that exits, one that does not parse. The decision stays rc 2 and nothing is said.
+_pvh="$(mktemp -d)"; cp -R "$HOOKS" "$_pvh/hooks"; mkdir -p "$_pvh/eval"; cp -R "$ROOT/eval/lib" "$_pvh/eval/lib"
+printf 'crew_preview(){ exit 0; }\n' > "$_pvh/eval/lib/preview.sh"; _pvrun "git reset --hard" "$_pvh/hooks"
+{ [ "$_pvrc" = 2 ] && ! grep -q Preview "$PVE"; } || _pvb="$_pvb [a preview that exits changed the decision: rc $_pvrc]"
+printf 'crew_preview(){ ( \n' > "$_pvh/eval/lib/preview.sh"; _pvrun "rm -rf out/" "$_pvh/hooks"
+[ "$_pvrc" = 2 ] || _pvb="$_pvb [a preview that does not parse changed the decision: rc $_pvrc]"
+[ -z "$_pvb" ] && pass "a stopped command says what it would have touched: reset (2 changes, and 1 commit for HEAD~1), clean (2 paths, dry run), rm (2 files inside the project; a target outside it not counted); an asked commit and push say what they take and send (a push that names a new branch says it would create it, one of another local branch counts that branch's commits); a pattern is said, not expanded; a preview library that exits or does not parse leaves the decision at rc 2" \
+  || fail "risk preview:$_pvb"
+rm -rf "$PVR" "$PVX" "$_pvh"; rm -f "$PVO" "$PVE"
 # §4.5 whole-tree revert. `reset --hard` was gated from the start; `git checkout -- .` does the same damage and
 # was not — a verification subagent used it over uncommitted work in this repo and the tree went with it. The
 # single-file form stays allowed (everyday, recoverable), and the two ways around a naive matcher — `git -C`
@@ -3625,6 +3665,8 @@ if [ "$_gc1" != 5 ] || [ "$_gc2" != 7 ]; then
 else
   gcj(){ printf '{"tool_name":"%s","permission_mode":"default","tool_input":{"command":"%s"},"cwd":"%s"}' "$1" "$2" "$_gcp"; }
   gwj(){ printf '{"tool_name":"Write","permission_mode":"default","tool_input":{"file_path":"%s/%s","content":"x"},"cwd":"%s"}' "$_gcp" "$1" "$_gcp"; }
+  # commit-msg 15 -> 16 (2026-10-18): one more line in trace-blocklist.txt, the session-link trailer that reached
+  # pushed commits; each line is one grep on every commit.
   GCT='guard-bash @@ 0 @@ 0 @@ Bash @@ git status --short
 guard-bash @@ 0 @@ 0 @@ Bash @@ ls -la
 guard-bash @@ 0 @@ 0 @@ Bash @@ git log --oneline -2 && git status --short | head; ls; cat CHANGELOG.md
@@ -3646,7 +3688,7 @@ guard-write @@ 0 @@ 0 @@ Write @@ .env
 guard-write @@ 2 @@ 0 @@ Write @@ .claude/hooks/guard-bash.sh
 guard-powershell @@ 0 @@ 0 @@ PowerShell @@ Get-ChildItem -Recurse src
 pre-commit @@ 0 @@ 22 @@ Script @@ -
-commit-msg @@ 0 @@ 15 @@ Script @@ msg'
+commit-msg @@ 0 @@ 16 @@ Script @@ msg'
   _gcn=0; _gcbad=""; _gcrow=""
   while IFS= read -r _gl; do [ -z "$_gl" ] && continue
     _gh="${_gl%% @@ *}"; _gl="${_gl#* @@ }"; _gr="${_gl%% @@ *}"; _gl="${_gl#* @@ }"; _gb="${_gl%% @@ *}"; _gl="${_gl#* @@ }"; _gt="${_gl%% @@ *}"; _gc="${_gl#* @@ }"
@@ -4492,6 +4534,41 @@ else fail "session-rehydrate git-hooks states read '$_got' (want '--UO---': no h
 rm -rf "$RHG"
 _rj=0; for _o in "$_o1" "$_o2" "$_o4" "$_o6"; do printf '%s' "$_o" > "$RHD/o.json"; awk -v op=validate -f "$ROOT/eval/lib/settings-json.awk" "$RHD/o.json" 2>/dev/null || _rj=$((_rj+1)); done
 [ "$_rj" = 0 ] && pass "each language/handover output is valid JSON (Crewforth's reader, 4 of 4)" || fail "$_rj session-rehydrate output(s) are not valid JSON"
+# V3: just before a compaction, precompact-snapshot.sh writes the state of the work from the files and the gates;
+# after it, session-rehydrate gives that state back, to the same session only. The snapshot never blocks the
+# compaction (PreCompact exit 2 would): rc 0 and silent in every case, a broken one included.
+PCS="$HOOKS/precompact-snapshot.sh"
+if [ ! -x "$PCS" ]; then fail "precompact-snapshot.sh missing/not executable"
+else
+  PCD="$(mktemp -d)"; PCD="$(cd -P "$PCD" && pwd)"; _pco="$(mktemp)"; _pcr="$(mktemp)"   # outside the repository: a file there is uncommitted
+  ( cd "$PCD" && git init -q . && git -c user.email=a@b -c user.name=a commit -q --allow-empty -m base ) >/dev/null 2>&1
+  mkdir -p "$PCD/.claude" "$PCD/.crewforth" "$PCD/docs"
+  printf 'x\n' > "$PCD/plain.txt"; printf 'x\n' > "$PCD/odd\"na	me.txt"; printf 'x\n' > "$PCD/ıİşğü.txt"
+  printf '{\n  "findings": [\n    {\n      "rule": "a"\n    },\n    {\n      "rule": "b"\n    }\n  ]\n}\n' > "$PCD/.crewforth/review.json"
+  printf 'BLOCK\t§4.2\tvendor name\t\n' > "$PCD/.git/crewforth-gate-log.tsv"
+  printf '{"session_id":"s-1","cwd":"%s","hook_event_name":"PreCompact","trigger":"auto","custom_instructions":null}' "$PCD" | CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR="$PCD" bash "$PCS" > "$_pco" 2>&1; _pcrc=$?
+  _snap="$PCD/.git/crewforth-session-snapshot.json"; _sb=""
+  [ -f "$_snap" ] && IFS= read -r _sb < "$_snap"
+  _rs(){ printf '{"session_id":"%s","source":"%s","cwd":"%s"}' "$1" "$2" "$PCD" | CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR="$PCD" bash "$HOOKS/session-rehydrate.sh" 2>/dev/null; }
+  _same="$(_rs s-1 compact)"; _other="$(_rs s-2 compact)"; _start="$(_rs s-1 startup)"
+  printf '%s' "$_same" > "$_pcr"
+  _b=""
+  [ "$_pcrc" = 0 ] && [ ! -s "$_pco" ] || _b="$_b [rc $_pcrc, printed: $(head -c 120 "$_pco")]"
+  awk -v op=validate -f "$ROOT/eval/lib/settings-json.awk" "$_snap" 2>/dev/null || _b="$_b [the snapshot is not valid JSON: ${_sb:0:160}]"
+  case "$_sb" in *'"session_id":"s-1"'*'"trigger":"auto"'*'branch '*'4 uncommitted file(s)'*'ıİşğü.txt'*'§4.2 vendor name'*'review 2'*) ;; *) _b="$_b [snapshot: ${_sb:0:200}]" ;; esac
+  case "$_same" in *'Before this context was compacted'*'review 2'*) ;; *) _b="$_b [not given back after compaction: ${_same:0:120}]" ;; esac
+  awk -v op=validate -f "$ROOT/eval/lib/settings-json.awk" "$_pcr" 2>/dev/null || _b="$_b [the SessionStart output with an odd file name is not valid JSON]"
+  case "$_other$_start" in *'Before this context was compacted'*) _b="$_b [given to another session or on a plain start]" ;; esac
+  # Fail-open: no repository, a cwd that is not there, no JSON at all, and the hook alone without eval/lib.
+  _nr="$(mktemp -d)"; _alone="$(mktemp -d)"; cp "$PCS" "$_alone/precompact-snapshot.sh"
+  printf '{"session_id":"s-9","cwd":"%s","trigger":"manual"}' "$_nr" | CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR="$_nr" bash "$PCS" >/dev/null 2>&1 || _b="$_b [non-repo rc $?]"
+  printf '{"session_id":"s-9","cwd":"/nonexistent/x"}' | CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR= bash "$PCS" >/dev/null 2>&1 || _b="$_b [missing cwd rc $?]"
+  printf 'not json' | CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR="$_nr" bash "$PCS" >/dev/null 2>&1 || _b="$_b [garbage rc $?]"
+  printf '{"session_id":"s-9","cwd":"%s"}' "$PCD" | CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR="$PCD" bash "$_alone/precompact-snapshot.sh" >/dev/null 2>&1 || _b="$_b [no eval/lib rc $?]"
+  [ -z "$_b" ] && pass "PreCompact writes the state of the work (branch, uncommitted files, the last gate refusal, the findings on record) as valid JSON, even for a file name with a quote and a tab, and names a Turkish file name as written; SessionStart gives it back after a compaction to the same session only, never to another or on a plain start; the hook is rc 0 and silent outside a repository, with no cwd, with no JSON and without eval/lib" \
+    || fail "precompact snapshot:$_b"
+  rm -rf "$PCD" "$_nr" "$_alone" "$_pco" "$_pcr"
+fi
 # Asked of the entry that carries session-rehydrate, not of the file: skill-trust's entry has the same matcher.
 _rw(){ _n="$(awk -v op=len -v path=hooks.SessionStart -f "$ROOT/eval/lib/settings-json.awk" "$1" 2>/dev/null)"; _i=0
        while [ "$_i" -lt "${_n:-0}" ]; do _e="$(awk -v op=get -v path="hooks.SessionStart.$_i" -f "$ROOT/eval/lib/settings-json.awk" "$1" 2>/dev/null)"
@@ -4971,6 +5048,8 @@ sec "== 7u) update prompt: ASKS about a release, never installs one, never spend
 UPD="$(mktemp -d)"; mkdir -p "$UPD/.claude/.state" "$UPD/.claude/hooks"
 printf '3.0.0\n' > "$UPD/.claude/VERSION"
 UH="$HOOKS/session-update-check.sh"; cp "$UH" "$UPD/.claude/hooks/"
+# The hook reads and orders the install's version through eval/lib/version.sh, beside it in an install.
+mkdir -p "$UPD/.claude/eval/lib"; cp "$ROOT/eval/lib/version.sh" "$UPD/.claude/eval/lib/"
 uc(){ ( printf '{"hook_event_name":"SessionStart","source":"startup","cwd":"%s"}' "$UPD" \
         | env -u CI -u CREW_NO_UPDATE_CHECK -u CREW_LANG CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ATTENDED=1 LANG=C LC_ALL= LC_MESSAGES= \
           CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR="$UPD" CREW_UPDATE_URL="${1:-http://10.255.255.1/blackhole}" bash "$UH" 2>/dev/null ); }
@@ -5099,10 +5178,25 @@ cp "$UH" "$UPD/uh-twin.sh"; printf 'npx --yes crewforth@latest update --here --y
 if [ "$_ni" = 0 ] && [ "$(_noinst "$UPD/uh-twin.sh")" -ge 1 ]; then pass "the update hook runs no installer (npx, npm, adopt.sh, start.sh): 0 lines; the twin with one is caught"
 else fail "the update hook contains an installer call ($_ni line(s)) — it must only ask, or the twin was not caught"; fi
 
+# 12b) AN INSTALLED RC IS OFFERED ITS FINAL. The installer copies VERSION into the project, and an rc's says
+#      X.Y.Z-rc.N: 3.2.0 published over an installed 3.2.0-rc.1 is newer (it used to read as the same 3.2.0, and the
+#      rc's user was never told the final shipped). An older final is not offered, and what the network answers is
+#      still held to X.Y.Z: an rc off the network is no version.
+printf '3.2.0-rc.1\n' > "$UPD/.claude/VERSION"
+ucache 3.2.0
+case "$(uc)" in *'"Crewforth v3.2.0 is out (installed: v3.2.0-rc.1). Update now?"'*) pass "an installed 3.2.0-rc.1 is offered the final 3.2.0" ;;
+                *) fail "an installed 3.2.0-rc.1 was not offered the final 3.2.0 (got: $(uc | head -c 120))" ;; esac
+ucache 3.1.1
+[ -z "$(uc)" ] && pass "an installed rc is not offered an older final (3.1.1 under 3.2.0-rc.1)" || fail "3.1.1 was offered over an installed 3.2.0-rc.1"
+ucache 3.2.0-rc.2
+[ -z "$(uc)" ] && pass "an rc answered off the network is no version: nothing asked" || fail "a pre-release from the network was put in a question"
+printf '3.0.0\n' > "$UPD/.claude/VERSION"; ustate
+
 # 13) THE PLUGIN EDITION. Its version is its own manifest, its release is the marketplace repo's copy, its state is
 #     user-level (a plugin serves every project), and its Update path is the plugin command — measured to work from
 #     inside a session, applying on restart.
-PLG="$UPD/plugin"; mkdir -p "$PLG/.claude-plugin" "$PLG/hooks"; cp "$UH" "$PLG/hooks/"
+PLG="$UPD/plugin"; mkdir -p "$PLG/.claude-plugin" "$PLG/hooks" "$PLG/eval/lib"; cp "$UH" "$PLG/hooks/"
+cp "$ROOT/eval/lib/version.sh" "$PLG/eval/lib/"
 printf '{"name":"crewforth","version":"3.0.0"}\n' > "$PLG/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
 XDG="$UPD/xdg"; mkdir -p "$XDG/crewforth"
 printf '3.1.0 %s\n' "$(date +%s)" > "$XDG/crewforth/update-check"
@@ -5478,6 +5572,20 @@ $TRFX\""; then pass "multi-line AI trace in the commit message BLOCKED (§4.1)"
   if csblk "git commit -F $MFX"; then pass "-F <file> carrying an AI trace BLOCKED (§4.1)"
   else fail "-F <file> AI trace not blocked with rc=2 (§4.1 hole or the hook died)"; fi
   rm -f "$MFX"
+  # Both halves in ONE refusal: a staged secret and a session-link trailer in the message. The message used to be
+  # scanned only when the staged content was clean, so the refusal named the first problem and the commit was
+  # retried with the trailer still in it (a real project, 2026-10-21). Assembled at run time, as above.
+  STFX="Claude-""Session: https://claude.ai/code/""session_""0123456789abcdef"
+  ( cd "$CS" && printf 'k = "%s"\n' "$SKFX" > c.txt && git add c.txt ) >/dev/null 2>&1
+  _cso="$( cd "$CS" && printf '%s' "$(csj "git commit -m \"feat: z
+
+$STFX\"")" | bash .claude/hooks/guard-commit-scan.sh 2>&1 >/dev/null )"; _csr=$?
+  ( cd "$CS" && git rm -q --cached c.txt && rm -f c.txt ) >/dev/null 2>&1
+  case "$_cso" in *SECRET-SCANNER*'TRACE-SCANNER (message)'*'does not override'*)
+    [ "$_csr" = 2 ] && pass "a staged secret and a trailer in the message are named in ONE refusal, with the harness-reminder line (§4.1)" \
+                    || fail "both problems named but rc=$_csr, not 2" ;;
+    *) fail "the refusal did not name both the staged secret and the message trailer (rc=$_csr): $(printf '%s' "$_cso" | tr '\n' ' ' | cut -c1-200)" ;;
+  esac
   # A QUOTED -F path with a space. The sed extraction that ran wherever python3 did not stopped at the space, read
   # `-F "my msg.txt"` as `my`, found no such file and refused the commit — a clean one. The awk tokenizer is now
   # the only path; both directions are asserted so an extraction that reads NOTHING cannot pass as "clean".
@@ -6363,6 +6471,14 @@ GNI="$(mktemp -d)"; ( cd "$GNI" && git init -q . && mkdir -p .claude )
 ( cd "$GNI" && gjson 'git reset --hard' | bash "$ROOT/hooks/guard-bash.sh" >/dev/null 2>&1 )
 [ -e "$GNI/.claude/gate-log.tsv" ] && fail "gate log wrote into a repo where the path is not gitignored" \
                                    || pass "gate log declines a path git would track"
+# ...and since 3.2.0 writes inside the repository's .git instead, which is never committed: a project that tracks
+# .claude/ had no record of a refusal at all (seen on a real project: no 🛡, no note of a lowered model).
+# The readers find it there (eval/lib/gate-log.sh, the one rule), and `git status` stays clean.
+_gni_read="$( cd "$GNI" && . "$ROOT/eval/lib/gate-log.sh" && crew_gate_log_read && printf '%s' "$_CREW_GL" )"
+_gni_st="$( cd "$GNI" && git status --porcelain --untracked-files=all 2>/dev/null | grep -c gate-log )"
+{ [ -s "$GNI/.git/crewforth-gate-log.tsv" ] && grep -q '^BLOCK' "$GNI/.git/crewforth-gate-log.tsv" && [ "$_gni_st" = 0 ] && [ "$_gni_read" = ./.git/crewforth-gate-log.tsv ]; } \
+  && pass "where git would track it, the gate log goes inside .git: written, found by the readers, and git status stays clean" \
+  || fail "gate log inside .git: file $([ -s "$GNI/.git/crewforth-gate-log.tsv" ] && echo written || echo MISSING), git status shows it ${_gni_st}x, reader found '${_gni_read}'"
 ( cd "$GNI" && echo '.claude/' > .gitignore && gjson 'git reset --hard' | bash "$ROOT/hooks/guard-bash.sh" >/dev/null 2>&1 )
 [ -s "$GNI/.claude/gate-log.tsv" ] && pass "gate log writes once the path is gitignored" \
                                    || fail "gate log stayed silent even though the path is ignored"
@@ -7587,6 +7703,25 @@ _pa_say auto 'approve: push' >/dev/null; ( cd "$_paw" && git checkout -q -b othe
 _pa_run auto 'git push origin feat/x'; [ "$_par" = 2 ] || _pabad="$_pabad other-branch-checked-out:rc=$_par"
 [ -z "$_pabad" ] && pass "a push approval is for the commit HEAD was on and the branch that was checked out: one more commit, or another branch, and it is refused" \
                  || fail "push binding:$_pabad"
+# A tag on the approved commit is part of that push (a release: `/crew-approve push`, then `git push origin v2.0.0`
+# was refused on a real project). A tag elsewhere, a name that is also a branch, or a full ref is not.
+_pa_new; _pabad=""; ( cd "$_paw" && git commit -qm second && git tag old HEAD^ && git tag v1 && git tag -a v1a -m v1a && git tag both && git branch both ) >/dev/null 2>&1
+_pa_say auto 'approve: commit' >/dev/null
+_pa_run auto 'git push origin v1'; [ "$_par" = 2 ] || _pabad="$_pabad [a commit approval pushed a tag: rc=$_par]"
+_pa_say auto 'approve: push' >/dev/null
+for _pc in 'git push origin v1' 'git push origin v1a' 'git push -q origin v1'; do
+  _pa_run auto "$_pc"; [ "$_par" = 0 ] || _pabad="$_pabad [$_pc → $_par $(head -c 120 "$_PA/err")]"
+done
+_pa_run auto 'git push origin old'; { [ "$_par" = 2 ] && grep -q 'the tag old is on' "$_PA/err"; } || _pabad="$_pabad [a tag on another commit → $_par]"
+for _pc in 'git push origin both' 'git push origin refs/tags/v1' 'git push origin nosuch' 'git push origin v1:v2' 'git push other v1'; do
+  _pa_run auto "$_pc"; [ "$_par" = 2 ] || _pabad="$_pabad [$_pc → $_par]"
+done
+_pa_new; ( cd "$_paw" && git tag before ) >/dev/null 2>&1; _pa_say auto 'approve: commit+push' >/dev/null
+_pa_run auto 'git commit -m x' >/dev/null; ( cd "$_paw" && git commit -qm approved && git tag after ) >/dev/null 2>&1
+_pa_run auto 'git push origin after'; [ "$_par" = 0 ] || _pabad="$_pabad [commit+push: a tag on the new commit → $_par $(head -c 120 "$_PA/err")]"
+_pa_run auto 'git push origin before'; { [ "$_par" = 2 ] && grep -q 'the tag before is on' "$_PA/err"; } || _pabad="$_pabad [commit+push: a tag on the old commit → $_par]"
+[ -z "$_pabad" ] && pass "a push approval covers a tag on the approved commit (lightweight or annotated; after commit+push, on the new commit): a tag on another commit, a name that is also a branch, a full ref, a refspec, another remote or a commit-only approval is refused" \
+                 || fail "tag push:$_pabad"
 
 # ---- commit+push: the push is for the commit the approved diff became -----------------------------------------
 _pa_new; _pabad=""
@@ -7892,8 +8027,8 @@ _paq_text="$(bash -c '. "$1"; printf "%s" "$_CREW_Q_TEXT"' _ "$HOOKS/prompt-appr
 _paq_pre(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","transcript_path":"%s","cwd":"%s","permission_mode":"%s","hook_event_name":"PreToolUse","tool_name":"AskUserQuestion","tool_input":{"questions":[%s]%s},"tool_use_id":"%s"}' "$_patr" "$_paw" "$1" "$2" "${3:-}" "${4:-tu1}" > "$_PA/q.json"
   if [ -n "$JSONQ" ]; then json_ok < "$_PA/q.json" || _paqbad="$_paqbad [pre payload is not JSON]"; fi
   _pao="$( cd "$_paw" && env -u CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ATTENDED $_PAQ_ENV ${_PAQ_X:-} bash "$HOOKS/guard-question.sh" < "$_PA/q.json" 2>"$_PA/qerr" )"; _par=$?; }
-# $1 = mode, $2 = the answer, $3 = tool_use_id
-_paq_post(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","transcript_path":"%s","cwd":"%s","permission_mode":"%s","hook_event_name":"PostToolUse","tool_name":"AskUserQuestion","tool_input":{"questions":[%s],"answers":{"%s":"%s"}},"tool_response":{"questions":[%s],"answers":{"%s":"%s"}},"tool_use_id":"%s"}' "$_patr" "$_paw" "$1" "$_paq_canon" "$_paq_text" "$2" "$_paq_canon" "$_paq_text" "$2" "${3:-tu1}" > "$_PA/q.json"
+# $1 = mode, $2 = the answer, $3 = tool_use_id, $4 = the questions array's content as Claude Code hands it back (default: as asked)
+_paq_post(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","transcript_path":"%s","cwd":"%s","permission_mode":"%s","hook_event_name":"PostToolUse","tool_name":"AskUserQuestion","tool_input":{"questions":[%s],"answers":{"%s":"%s"}},"tool_response":{"questions":[%s],"answers":{"%s":"%s"}},"tool_use_id":"%s"}' "$_patr" "$_paw" "$1" "${4:-$_paq_canon}" "$_paq_text" "$2" "${4:-$_paq_canon}" "$_paq_text" "$2" "${3:-tu1}" > "$_PA/q.json"
   if [ -n "$JSONQ" ]; then json_ok < "$_PA/q.json" || _paqbad="$_paqbad [post payload is not JSON]"; fi
   _pao="$( cd "$_paw" && env -u CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ATTENDED $_PAQ_ENV ${_PAQ_X:-} bash "$HOOKS/prompt-approval.sh" < "$_PA/q.json" 2>"$_PA/qerr" )"; _par=$?; }
 _paq_gate(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","cwd":"%s","permission_mode":"%s","tool_name":"Bash","tool_input":{"command":"%s"}}' "$_paw" "$1" "$2" > "$_PA/pl.json"
@@ -7906,6 +8041,11 @@ _paq_is(){ _paqn=$((_paqn+1)); [ "$2" = "$3" ] || _paqbad="$_paqbad [$1: got '$2
 _paq_post auto 'Commit only';                             _paq_is 'its answer is recorded' "$(_paq_rec)" commit
 _paq_gate auto 'git commit -m x';                         _paq_is 'the recorded click allows the commit' "$_par" 0
 _pa_new; : > "$_pa_rec"; _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" '' tu2; _paq_post auto 'Commit + push' tu2; _paq_is 'commit + push' "$(_paq_rec)" commit+push
+# Claude Code may hand the answered question back with its keys sorted and multiSelect gone: 7 of 7 such answers were
+# refused on a byte match (real `auto` sessions, 2026-10-18). This is that shape, as it was handed back.
+_paq_sorted="{\"header\":\"Approval\",\"options\":[{\"description\":\"Commit exactly what is staged now. No push.\",\"label\":\"Commit only\"},{\"description\":\"Commit what is staged now, then push that commit on this branch.\",\"label\":\"Commit + push\"},{\"description\":\"Push this branch as it is now. No new commit.\",\"label\":\"Push only\"},{\"description\":\"Neither commit nor push.\",\"label\":\"No\"}],\"question\":\"$_paq_text\"}"
+_pa_new; : > "$_pa_rec"; _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" '' tu10; _paq_post auto 'Commit + push' tu10 "$_paq_sorted"
+                                                          _paq_is 'the answered question handed back with its keys sorted' "$(_paq_rec)" commit+push
 # must-fail twins: each differs from the round trip in one thing
 _pa_new; : > "$_pa_rec"; _paq_post auto 'Commit only' tu3;  _paq_is 'an answer no PreToolUse asked for' "$(_paq_rec)" none
 _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" '' tu4; _paq_post auto 'Commit only' tu5; _paq_is 'an answer to another call' "$(_paq_rec)" none
@@ -7914,6 +8054,8 @@ _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" '' tu6; _paq_post auto 'Commit only' tu6; : > "$_pa_
 _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" '' tu7; _paq_post auto 'HOOK-CHOSE-Commit only' tu7; _paq_is 'an answer that is none of the four' "$(_paq_rec)" none
 _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" '' tu8; _paq_post auto 'No' tu8; _paq_is 'No' "$(_paq_rec)" none
 _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" '' tu9; _paq_post default 'Commit only' tu9; _paq_is 'an answer recorded outside auto' "$(_paq_rec)" none
+_paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" '' tu11; _paq_post auto 'Commit only' tu11 "${_paq_sorted/No new commit./Then force-push.}"
+                                                          _paq_is 'sorted, with one text of the question changed' "$(_paq_rec)" none
 _paq_pre auto '{"question":"Crewforth approval: commit?","header":"Approval","options":[{"label":"Commit only","description":"x"}],"multiSelect":false}'
                                                           _paq_is 'another wording is refused' "$_par" 2
 _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" ',"answers":{"x":"Commit only"}'; _paq_is 'a call with answers is refused' "$_par" 2
@@ -7924,9 +8066,93 @@ _paq_pre bypassPermissions "$_paq_canon";                 _paq_is 'bypassPermiss
 _PAQ_X="CLAUDE_CODE_SESSION_ATTENDED=0"; _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon"; unset _PAQ_X; _paq_is 'a headless session: refused' "$_par" 2
 _paq_pre auto '{"question":"Which colour?","header":"Colour","options":[{"label":"Red","description":"r"}],"multiSelect":false}'
                                                           _paq_is 'any other question: no decision' "$_par/$_pao" "0/"
-if [ "$_paqn" != 18 ]; then fail "FIXTURE: the approval-question table ran $_paqn cases, not 18"
-elif [ -z "$_paqbad" ]; then pass "the approval question: asked (ask) only as the fixed text, in auto, attended, with no answers; its answer recorded only for the call that was asked, once, and only as one of the four; the record allows the commit (18 cases, 13 must-fail)"
+if [ "$_paqn" != 20 ]; then fail "FIXTURE: the approval-question table ran $_paqn cases, not 20"
+elif [ -z "$_paqbad" ]; then pass "the approval question: asked (ask) only as the fixed text, in auto, attended, with no answers; its answer recorded only for the call that was asked, once, and only as one of the four, in whatever key order Claude Code hands it back; the record allows the commit (20 cases, 14 must-fail)"
 else fail "the approval question:$_paqbad"; fi
+# ...and the way to it. B-2 (a real `auto` session, 2026-10-17): /crew-ship asked for /crew-approve before any commit
+# was refused, so the refusal that prints the question never came and the click was never offered; telling the agent
+# to try the commit first did not help either (§4.4 says not to, and it did not). agent-outcome.sh now hands the
+# question over when crew-commit-agent is called; the text pinned here only says to ask it.
+_cqa="$AGENTS/crew-commit-agent.md"; _cqs="$SKILLS/crew-ship/SKILL.md"
+if [ ! -f "$_cqa" ] || [ ! -f "$_cqs" ]; then skip scope "the way to the approval question: crew-commit-agent or crew-ship is not installed here"
+elif grep -q 'question (below): ask it, with the message, instead of' "$_cqa" && grep -q 'one-click approval question when crew-commit-agent is called' "$_cqs"; then
+  pass "in auto the commit agent and /crew-ship ask the one-click question Crewforth hands over, before asking for /crew-approve"
+else fail "the commit agent or /crew-ship asks for /crew-approve before the one-click question Crewforth hands over (B-2)"; fi
+# The hand-over itself, run: agent-outcome.sh on PostToolUse of an Agent call. In `auto`, for crew-commit-agent, with
+# both halves of the question wired and no PermissionRequest hook, it adds the fixed question (_CREW_Q_JSON, read from
+# prompt-approval.sh) to the session's context; in any other mode, for any other agent, or with such a hook, nothing.
+_aq="$(mktemp -d)"; _aq="$(cd -P "$_aq" && pwd)"; mkdir -p "$_aq/p/.claude/state" "$_aq/ccd" "$_aq/home"
+printf '%s' '{"hooks":{"PreToolUse":[{"matcher":"AskUserQuestion","hooks":[{"type":"command","command":"bash .claude/hooks/guard-question.sh"}]}],"PostToolUse":[{"matcher":"AskUserQuestion","hooks":[{"type":"command","command":"bash .claude/hooks/prompt-approval.sh"}]}]}}' > "$_aq/p/.claude/settings.json"
+_aq_run(){ printf '{"hook_event_name":"PostToolUse","tool_name":"Agent","permission_mode":"%s","session_id":"s","tool_use_id":"toolu_aq1","cwd":"%s","tool_input":{"subagent_type":"%s","description":"d","prompt":"p"},"tool_response":{"status":"async_launched","agentId":"aq123abc"}}' "$1" "$_aq/p" "$2" > "$_aq/pl.json"
+  ( cd "$_aq/p" && env -u CREW_MODEL_ROUTING CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR="$_aq/p" CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR="$_aq/ccd" HOME="$_aq/home" CREW_GATE_LOG=/dev/null bash "$HOOKS/agent-outcome.sh" < "$_aq/pl.json" 2>/dev/null ); }
+_aqbad=""; _aqo="$(_aq_run auto crew-commit-agent)"
+case "$_aqo" in *"$_paq_text"*) ;; *) _aqbad="$_aqbad [auto, crew-commit-agent: the question was not handed over]" ;; esac
+if [ -n "$JSONQ" ] && [ -n "$_aqo" ]; then printf '%s' "$_aqo" | json_ok || _aqbad="$_aqbad [its output is not JSON]"; fi
+for _aqc in default:crew-commit-agent dontAsk:crew-commit-agent acceptEdits:crew-commit-agent auto:crew-review-agent; do
+  [ -z "$(_aq_run "${_aqc%%:*}" "${_aqc#*:}")" ] || _aqbad="$_aqbad [${_aqc%%:*}, ${_aqc#*:}: handed the question over]"
+done
+printf '%s' '{"hooks":{"PermissionRequest":[{"hooks":[{"type":"command","command":"x"}]}]}}' > "$_aq/ccd/settings.json"
+[ -z "$(_aq_run auto crew-commit-agent)" ] || _aqbad="$_aqbad [a PermissionRequest hook is wired: the question was still handed over]"
+rm -rf "$_aq"
+[ -z "$_aqbad" ] && pass "in auto, calling crew-commit-agent hands the session the fixed one-click question; not in default, acceptEdits or dontAsk, not for another agent, not with a PermissionRequest hook" \
+  || fail "the one-click question hand-over:$_aqbad"
+# THE CLICK BEFORE THE TYPED WAY, at the turn's end (2026-10-18: 9 of 18 typed asks in two real `auto` sessions on rc.4
+# came in a turn where no commit was tried, so neither the refusal nor the commit agent's hand-over offered the click).
+# prompt-approval.sh on Stop: the reply names /crew-approve, auto, the question open, not asked since the user's last
+# message -> the session is told once to ask the click. Every other case is a twin that differs in one thing.
+_sq="$(mktemp -d)"; _sq="$(cd -P "$_sq" && pwd)"; mkdir -p "$_sq/p/.claude/state" "$_sq/ccd" "$_sq/home"
+printf '%s' '{"hooks":{"PreToolUse":[{"matcher":"AskUserQuestion","hooks":[{"type":"command","command":"bash .claude/hooks/guard-question.sh"}]}],"PostToolUse":[{"matcher":"AskUserQuestion","hooks":[{"type":"command","command":"bash .claude/hooks/prompt-approval.sh"}]}]}}' > "$_sq/p/.claude/settings.json"
+_SQ_ENV="CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR=$_sq/p CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR=$_sq/ccd HOME=$_sq/home CREW_GATE_LOG=/dev/null"
+# $1 = mode, $2 = the reply, $3 = stop_hook_active, $4 = session id
+_sq_stop(){ printf '{"session_id":"%s","transcript_path":"%s/t.jsonl","cwd":"%s","permission_mode":"%s","hook_event_name":"Stop","stop_hook_active":%s,"last_assistant_message":"%s"}' "${4:-s1}" "$_sq" "$_sq/p" "$1" "${3:-false}" "$2" > "$_sq/pl.json"
+  ( cd "$_sq/p" && env $_SQ_ENV bash "$HOOKS/prompt-approval.sh" < "$_sq/pl.json" 2>/dev/null ); }
+_sq_ask='Review is clean. If you approve, send only this:\n/crew-approve commit+push'
+_sqbad=""; _sqn=0
+_sq_says(){ _sqn=$((_sqn+1)); case "$2" in *'ASK THE USER WITH ONE CLICK'*"$_paq_text"*) ;; *) _sqbad="$_sqbad [$1: the click was not asked for]" ;; esac
+  if [ -n "$JSONQ" ]; then printf '%s' "$2" | json_ok || _sqbad="$_sqbad [$1: the output is not JSON]"; fi; }
+_sq_quiet(){ _sqn=$((_sqn+1)); [ -z "$2" ] || _sqbad="$_sqbad [$1: said something: ${2:0:80}]"; }
+_sq_says  'auto, a typed ask, not asked this turn' "$(_sq_stop auto "$_sq_ask")"
+_sq_quiet 'stop_hook_active'                       "$(_sq_stop auto "$_sq_ask" true)"
+_sq_quiet 'dontAsk'                                "$(_sq_stop dontAsk "$_sq_ask")"
+_sq_quiet 'default'                                "$(_sq_stop default "$_sq_ask")"
+_sq_quiet 'a reply that names no /crew-approve'    "$(_sq_stop auto 'Done: the tests pass.')"
+# asked this turn: the PreToolUse half writes it down, even when it refuses the question
+printf '{"session_id":"s1","cwd":"%s","permission_mode":"dontAsk","hook_event_name":"PreToolUse","tool_name":"AskUserQuestion","tool_input":{"questions":[%s]},"tool_use_id":"tq1"}' "$_sq/p" "$_paq_canon" > "$_sq/pre.json"
+( cd "$_sq/p" && env $_SQ_ENV bash "$HOOKS/guard-question.sh" < "$_sq/pre.json" >/dev/null 2>&1 ); _sqr=$?
+[ "$_sqr" = 2 ] || _sqbad="$_sqbad [FIXTURE: the dontAsk question was not refused (rc $_sqr), so 'refused but asked' is not what runs]"
+_sq_quiet 'asked this turn (and refused)'          "$(_sq_stop auto "$_sq_ask")"
+_sq_says  'asked in another session'               "$(_sq_stop auto "$_sq_ask" false s2)"
+# the user's next message starts a new turn
+printf '{"session_id":"s1","cwd":"%s","permission_mode":"auto","hook_event_name":"UserPromptSubmit","prompt":"next"}' "$_sq/p" > "$_sq/ups.json"
+( cd "$_sq/p" && env $_SQ_ENV bash "$HOOKS/prompt-approval.sh" < "$_sq/ups.json" >/dev/null 2>&1 )
+_sq_says  'the user wrote since it was asked'      "$(_sq_stop auto "$_sq_ask")"
+printf '%s' '{"hooks":{"PermissionRequest":[{"hooks":[{"type":"command","command":"x"}]}]}}' > "$_sq/ccd/settings.json"
+_sq_quiet 'a PermissionRequest hook is wired'      "$(_sq_stop auto "$_sq_ask")"
+rm -rf "$_sq"
+# A Stop is not the user's next message: an approval recorded by a click survives the turn's end, even when the reply
+# quotes the tool's name (which sends the payload past the AskUserQuestion test).
+_pa_new; : > "$_pa_rec"; _paq_pre auto "$_paq_canon" '' ts1; _paq_post auto 'Commit only' ts1
+printf '{"session_id":"s","transcript_path":"%s","cwd":"%s","permission_mode":"auto","hook_event_name":"Stop","stop_hook_active":false,"last_assistant_message":"I asked with \\"AskUserQuestion\\"; run /crew-approve if not."}' "$_patr" "$_paw" > "$_PA/st.json"
+( cd "$_paw" && env $_PAQ_ENV bash "$HOOKS/prompt-approval.sh" < "$_PA/st.json" >/dev/null 2>&1 )
+_sqn=$((_sqn+1)); [ "$(_paq_rec)" = commit ] || _sqbad="$_sqbad [a Stop ended the recorded approval: '$(_paq_rec)']"
+if [ "$_sqn" != 10 ]; then fail "FIXTURE: the Stop-half table ran $_sqn cases, not 10"
+elif [ -z "$_sqbad" ]; then pass "at the turn's end a reply asking for /crew-approve, in auto with the question open and not asked since the user's last message, is sent back once to ask the click; not after a Stop continuation, outside auto, without the command, once asked (even refused), or with a PermissionRequest hook; a Stop leaves a recorded approval alone (10 cases, 6 must-stay-quiet)"
+else fail "the Stop half of the approval question:$_sqbad"; fi
+# ONE WAY TO ASK in the refusal (2026-10-18, a real `auto` session on rc.3: the refusal offered the question and the
+# typed command as equals, and the session told the user to type 7 times in 9). With the question open the typed way is
+# printed only as the fallback for a question that cannot be asked; with it closed (dontAsk), only the typed way.
+_pa_new
+( cd "$_paw" && printf '%s' '{"hooks":{"UserPromptSubmit":[{"hooks":[{"type":"command","command":"bash .claude/hooks/prompt-approval.sh"}]}],"PreToolUse":[{"matcher":"AskUserQuestion","hooks":[{"type":"command","command":"bash .claude/hooks/guard-question.sh"}]}],"PostToolUse":[{"matcher":"AskUserQuestion","hooks":[{"type":"command","command":"bash .claude/hooks/prompt-approval.sh"}]}]}}' > .claude/settings.json )
+_oabad=""
+_paq_gate auto 'git commit -m x'
+case "$_pae" in *'"questions":['*'do not also give the user a command to type.'*'ONLY IF THAT QUESTION CANNOT BE ASKED'*) ;; *) _oabad="$_oabad [auto, question open: not the click first and the typed way as its fallback]" ;; esac
+case "$_pae" in *'ASK THE USER NOW'*|*'the way below works as well'*) _oabad="$_oabad [auto, question open: the typed way is still offered as an equal]" ;; esac
+_paq_gate dontAsk 'git commit -m x'
+case "$_pae" in *'ASK THE USER NOW'*'/crew-approve'*) ;; *) _oabad="$_oabad [dontAsk: the typed way is not asked for]" ;; esac
+case "$_pae" in *'"questions":['*|*'ONLY IF THAT QUESTION'*) _oabad="$_oabad [dontAsk: the question is offered]" ;; esac
+_pa_new
+[ -z "$_oabad" ] && pass "a refused commit in auto offers the click and only falls back to the typed /crew-approve when the question cannot be asked; in dontAsk only the typed way" \
+  || fail "one way to ask:$_oabad"
 
 # A PermissionRequest HOOK, wherever this can read one, closes the question AND the gate's own prompt. Each source is
 # planted alone in an otherwise clean fixture; the clean fixture itself must answer "none" (calibration).
@@ -8218,7 +8444,7 @@ _v2new(){ rm -rf "$_v2p" "$_v2/home"; mkdir -p "$_v2/home" "$_v2p/.claude" "$_v2
 _v2e(){ env -u CREW_MODEL_ROUTING -u CREW_ALLOW_FABLE -u CREW_MODEL_CAL_N -u CREW_MODEL_CAL_PCT -u CREW_VERIFY_NO_SETSID -u CREW_VERIFY_TIMEOUT -u CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR -u CREW_MANAGED_SETTINGS HOME="$_v2/home" CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR="$_v2p" CREW_GATE_LOG=/dev/null ${_V2ENV:-} "$@"; }
 # $1 agent, $2 model, $3 files, $4 change, $5 verify, $6 extra fields -> _v2rc, stderr in $_v2/err
 _v2call(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","permission_mode":"auto","hook_event_name":"PreToolUse","tool_name":"Agent","tool_input":{"description":"d","prompt":"files: %s\\nchange: %s\\nverify: %s\\n\\nDo the work.","subagent_type":"%s","model":"%s"%s},"tool_use_id":"tu%s"}' "$3" "$4" "$5" "$1" "$2" "${6:-}" "$RANDOM$RANDOM" > "$_v2/c.json"
-  ( cd "$_v2p" && _v2e bash "$_V2G" < "$_v2/c.json" >/dev/null 2>"$_v2/err" ); _v2rc=$?; }
+  ( cd "$_v2p" && _v2e bash "$_V2G" < "$_v2/c.json" >"$_v2/out" 2>"$_v2/err" ); _v2rc=$?; }
 _v2start(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","hook_event_name":"SubagentStart","agent_id":"%s","agent_type":"%s"}' "$1" "${2:-crew-backend-expert}" | ( cd "$_v2p" && _v2e bash "$_V2O" >/dev/null 2>&1 ); }
 _v2stop(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","permission_mode":"%s","hook_event_name":"SubagentStop","agent_id":"%s","agent_type":"x","stop_hook_active":false,"agent_transcript_path":"%s/none.jsonl","last_assistant_message":"did it\\n%s"}' "${_V2PM:-auto}" "$1" "$_v2" "${2:-confidence: high}" | ( cd "$_v2p" && _v2e bash "$_V2O" 2>/dev/null ); }
 _v2post(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","hook_event_name":"PostToolUse","tool_name":"Agent","tool_input":{"prompt":"p"},"tool_response":{"status":"completed","agentId":"%s","content":"x"}}' "$1" | ( cd "$_v2p" && _v2e bash "$_V2O" 2>/dev/null ); }
@@ -8251,21 +8477,26 @@ done <<'V2'
 2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|prisma/schema.prisma|feature|none|
 2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|config/SECRETS_local.env|text|none|
 0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|docs/author.md, src/cryptography/hash.ts|feature|none|
-2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|legal/terms-of-service.md|text|none|
-2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|docs/privacy-policy.md|text|none|
+0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|legal/terms-of-service.md|text|none|
+0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|docs/privacy-policy.md|text|none|
 2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|src/PrivacyController.cs|feature|none|
 2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|src/consent/banner.ts|feature|none|
-2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|content/terms/index.md|text|none|
-2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|fastlane/metadata/en-US/description.txt|text|none|
-2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|store/listing.md|text|none|
-2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|metadata/android/en-US/full_description.txt|text|none|
+0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|content/terms/index.md|text|none|
+0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|fastlane/metadata/en-US/description.txt|text|none|
+0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|store/listing.md|text|none|
+0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|metadata/android/en-US/full_description.txt|text|none|
 0|crew-backend-expert|opus|legal/terms-of-service.md|text|none|
+2|crew-backend-expert|haiku|legal/terms-of-service.md|text|none|
+2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|legal/terms-of-service.md, src/legal/consent.ts|text|none|
+2|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|legal/terms-of-service.md|feature|none|
 0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|src/searchTerms.ts|feature|none|
 0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|src/store/index.ts|feature|none|
 0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|fastlane/metadata/en-US/images/icon.png|text|none|
 0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|docs/legalese.md|text|none|
 0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|src/ui/a.ts|feature|none|
-2|crew-backend-expert|haiku|src/ui/a.ts|text|none|
+0|crew-backend-expert|haiku|src/ui/a.ts|text|none|
+2|crew-backend-expert|haiku|src/ui/a.ts|fix-known|none|
+0|crew-commit-agent|haiku|src/ui/a.ts|fix-known|none|
 0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|src/ui/a.ts|text|none|
 0|crew-backend-expert|haiku|src/ui/a.ts|text|true|
 0|crew-test-expert|haiku|src/ui/**|test-run|true|
@@ -8297,9 +8528,48 @@ done <<'V2'
 0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|src/ui/a.ts|feature|git commit -m x|
 0|crew-backend-expert|sonnet|src/ui/a.ts|feature|rm -rf /|
 V2
-if [ "$_v2n" != 60 ]; then fail "FIXTURE: the card table has $_v2n rows, not 60"
-elif [ -z "$_v2b" ]; then pass "the card decides the model: critical work (payments/, migrations, a .sql file, AuthController, userAuth, schema.prisma, and the four critical kinds of change) is refused below opus and passes on opus; verify none is refused on haiku; test-run passes on haiku, also on a critical path; test-write, audit and review are held to sonnet in normal work and to opus in critical work; critical work with a verify command is refused when the call says run_in_background true, and passes with false and with the field left out (a session whose Agent tool has no such field cannot send it); a card that is not one is refused; a verify command never refuses the call, whatever it is (the hook decides whether to run it) (47 rows)"
+if [ "$_v2n" != 65 ]; then fail "FIXTURE: the card table has $_v2n rows, not 65"
+elif [ -z "$_v2b" ]; then pass "the card decides the model: critical work (payments/, migrations, a .sql file, AuthController, userAuth, schema.prisma, and the four critical kinds of change) is refused below opus and passes on opus; a text change whose every file is prose (legal, privacy, terms, a store listing) passes on sonnet and is refused on haiku, and one card file that is not prose holds it to opus; verify none is refused on haiku, except for a text change and the commit agent; test-run passes on haiku, also on a critical path; test-write, audit and review are held to sonnet in normal work and to opus in critical work; critical work with a verify command is refused when the call says run_in_background true, and passes with false and with the field left out (a session whose Agent tool has no such field cannot send it); a card that is not one is refused; a verify command never refuses the call, whatever it is (the hook decides whether to run it) ($_v2n rows)"
 else fail "card table:$_v2b"; fi
+# The card's floor is also the default: a call above it runs ON it (the gate hands back the same input with `model`
+# replaced, PreToolUse updatedInput), unless the card's next line says `above: <why>`. Measured on a real project:
+# 73 of 186 crew tasks ran above their floor and none on haiku; measured on Claude Code 2.1.299: the rewrite holds.
+_v2new; _v2b=""
+_v2last(){ ls -t "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/pending/"* 2>/dev/null | head -1; }
+_v2call crew-review-agent opus 'src/ui/a.ts' audit none ',"run_in_background":true,"isolation":"worktree"'
+_o="$(cat "$_v2/out" 2>/dev/null)"; _r="$(_v2last)"
+case "$_o" in *'"permissionDecision":"allow"'*'"updatedInput":'*) ;; *) _v2b="$_v2b [above the floor, no above: -> no rewrite: rc=$_v2rc ${_o:0:80}]" ;; esac
+_u="$(printf '%s' "$_o" | awk -v op=get -v path=hookSpecificOutput.updatedInput -f "$ROOT/eval/lib/settings-json.awk" - 2>/dev/null | tr -d ' \n')"
+case "$_u" in *'"model":"sonnet"'*'"run_in_background":true'*'"isolation":"worktree"'*|*'"run_in_background":true'*'"isolation":"worktree"'*) ;; *) _v2b="$_v2b [the rewrite lost a field: ${_u:0:120}]" ;; esac
+case "$_u" in *'"model":"sonnet"'*) ;; *) _v2b="$_v2b [the rewrite is not to the floor: ${_u:0:120}]" ;; esac
+{ grep -q '^tier=sonnet$' "$_r" && grep -q '^lowered=opus$' "$_r"; } 2>/dev/null || _v2b="$_v2b [record: $(tr '\n' ' ' < "$_r" 2>/dev/null | cut -c1-80)]"
+rm -f "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/pending/"*
+_v2call crew-review-agent opus 'src/ui/a.ts' audit 'none\nabove: the audit covers the whole session layer'
+{ [ "$_v2rc" = 0 ] && [ ! -s "$_v2/out" ] && grep -q '^tier=opus$' "$(_v2last)"; } 2>/dev/null || _v2b="$_v2b [above: did not keep opus: rc=$_v2rc $(head -c 60 "$_v2/out")]"
+rm -f "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/pending/"*
+_v2call crew-review-agent sonnet 'src/ui/a.ts' audit none
+{ [ "$_v2rc" = 0 ] && [ ! -s "$_v2/out" ]; } || _v2b="$_v2b [a call on its floor was rewritten: $(head -c 60 "$_v2/out")]"
+_v2call crew-frontend-expert sonnet 'src/ui/a.ts' text 'test -d src'
+case "$(tr -d ' ' < "$_v2/out")" in *'"model":"haiku"'*) ;; *) _v2b="$_v2b [work a command checks did not go to haiku: $(head -c 80 "$_v2/out")]" ;; esac
+rm -f "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/pending/"*
+# Not a crew agent: no card and no floor, only the expensive end is held. opus or fable with no `above:` line in the
+# task runs on sonnet; with one it stays; a call that names no model, or sonnet, is not touched.
+_v2o(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","permission_mode":"auto","hook_event_name":"PreToolUse","tool_name":"Agent","tool_input":{"description":"d","prompt":"Find where X is defined.%s","subagent_type":"general-purpose"%s},"tool_use_id":"tu%s"}' "$1" "$2" "$RANDOM" | ( cd "$_v2p" && _v2e bash "$_V2G" 2>/dev/null ) | tr -d ' '; }
+case "$(_v2o '' ',"model":"opus"')" in *'"updatedInput":'*'"model":"sonnet"'*) ;; *) _v2b="$_v2b [general-purpose on opus was not run on sonnet]" ;; esac
+[ -z "$(_v2o '\nabove: a design question across the codebase' ',"model":"opus"')" ] || _v2b="$_v2b [above: did not keep opus for general-purpose]"
+[ -z "$(_v2o '' ',"model":"sonnet"')" ] || _v2b="$_v2b [a call naming sonnet was rewritten]"
+# Naming no model: general-purpose takes the session's model, so it is given sonnet (CLAUDE_CODE_SUBAGENT_MODEL in
+# the project's settings env did not do it, measured on 2.1.299), unless the session is on haiku; an agent whose
+# definition names its own model is left to it; a project agent with no model line is treated like general-purpose.
+_v2ot(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","permission_mode":"auto","hook_event_name":"PreToolUse","tool_name":"Agent","transcript_path":"%s","tool_input":{"description":"d","prompt":"Find X.","subagent_type":"%s"},"tool_use_id":"tu%s"}' "$2" "$1" "$RANDOM" | ( cd "$_v2p" && _v2e bash "$_V2G" 2>/dev/null ) | tr -d ' '; }
+printf '{"type":"assistant","message":{"model":"claude-opus-5-5"}}\n' > "$_v2/tr-opus.jsonl"; printf '{"type":"assistant","message":{"model":"claude-haiku-5-5"}}\n' > "$_v2/tr-haiku.jsonl"
+mkdir -p "$_v2p/.claude/agents"; printf -- '---\nname: mine\ndescription: x\n---\nDo it.\n' > "$_v2p/.claude/agents/mine.md"; printf -- '---\nname: cheap\nmodel: haiku\n---\nDo it.\n' > "$_v2p/.claude/agents/cheap.md"
+case "$(_v2ot general-purpose "$_v2/tr-opus.jsonl")" in *'"updatedInput":'*'"model":"sonnet"'*) ;; *) _v2b="$_v2b [general-purpose naming no model under opus was not given sonnet]" ;; esac
+[ -z "$(_v2ot general-purpose "$_v2/tr-haiku.jsonl")" ] || _v2b="$_v2b [a haiku session's general-purpose was raised to sonnet]"
+[ -z "$(_v2ot Explore "$_v2/tr-opus.jsonl")$(_v2ot cheap "$_v2/tr-opus.jsonl")" ] || _v2b="$_v2b [an agent with a model of its own was given one]"
+case "$(_v2ot mine "$_v2/tr-opus.jsonl")" in *'"model":"sonnet"'*) ;; *) _v2b="$_v2b [a project agent with no model line was not given sonnet]" ;; esac
+[ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "above the floor runs on the floor: opus for a sonnet card is rewritten to sonnet with every other field kept and recorded as lowered; 'above: <why>' keeps opus; a call on its floor is untouched; checkable text work goes to haiku; an agent outside the crew asking for opus, or inheriting an opus session's model, runs on sonnet unless its task says why; a haiku session and an agent with its own model are left alone" \
+               || fail "model on the floor:$_v2b"
 # The refusal names the way forward that exists (the field was sent, so it can be sent as false), and a call that
 # left the field out and was launched in the background is told so when the launch comes back.
 _v2new; _v2b=""
@@ -8340,20 +8610,67 @@ for _pr in 'Do the work.' 'Please do this:\nfiles: a\nchange: feature\nverify: t
 done
 [ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "a crew call with no card, a card that is not at the top, a card with a line missing or one named twice is refused, with the three lines to write" \
                || fail "a task without a proper card passed:$_v2b"
+# The card on one line (2026-10-18: 17 of 39 card refusals on this machine were `files: … · change: … · verify: …`). It is
+# read by its labels and held to the same rules: what passes on three lines passes on one, and what fails there fails.
+_v2b=""; _v2one(){ printf '{"hook_event_name":"PreToolUse","tool_name":"Agent","tool_input":{"prompt":"%s\\n\\nDo it.","subagent_type":"crew-backend-expert","model":"%s"}}' "$1" "$2" > "$_v2/one.json"
+  ( cd "$_v2p" && _v2e bash "$_V2G" < "$_v2/one.json" >"$_v2/oneout" 2>"$_v2/err" ); _rc=$?; }
+for _pr in 'files: src/ui/a.ts · change: feature · verify: true' 'files: src/ui/a.ts; change: feature; verify: true' 'files: src/ui/a.ts | change: feature | verify: true' \
+           'Card: files: src/ui/a.ts, src/ui/b.ts · change: feature · verify: true.' 'Card — files: src/ui/a.ts · change: text · verify: none' \
+           'Kart — files: src/ui/a.ts · change: text · verify: none' 'Kart: files: src/ui/a.ts · change: feature · verify: true'; do
+  _v2one "$_pr" sonnet; [ "$_rc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b [refused: $_pr → $_rc $(head -c 120 "$_v2/err")]"
+done
+_v2one 'files: src/payments/p.ts · change: feature · verify: true' sonnet
+{ [ "$_rc" = 2 ] && ! grep -q 'opens with its task card' "$_v2/err"; } || _v2b="$_v2b [a one-line card on a critical path was not read as one (rc $_rc)]"
+_v2one 'files: src/ui/a.ts · change: feature · verify: true · above: the parser is subtle' opus
+{ [ "$_rc" = 0 ] && ! grep -q 'runs on sonnet' "$_v2/oneout"; } || _v2b="$_v2b [above: on the same line was not read (rc $_rc)]"
+_v2one 'files: src/ui/a.ts · change: feature (a small one) · verify: true' sonnet; [ "$_rc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b [a kind with a note in parentheses, one line → $_rc]"
+_v2one 'files: src/ui/a.ts · change: architecture (planning only) · verify: none' sonnet
+{ [ "$_rc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'runs on opus' "$_v2/err"; } || _v2b="$_v2b [architecture (planning only) was not read as architecture, which runs on opus (rc $_rc)]"
+_v2one 'files: src/ui/a.ts\nchange: refactor (no behaviour change)\nverify: true' sonnet; [ "$_rc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b [a kind with a note in parentheses, three lines → $_rc]"
+for _pr in 'files: a · change: archi (planning only) · verify: none' 'files: a · change: feature extra · verify: none' 'files: a · verify: true · change: text' 'files: a · change: feature' 'Do this. files: a · change: feature · verify: true' 'Kartal files: a · change: feature · verify: true'; do
+  _v2one "$_pr" sonnet; { [ "$_rc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'opens with its task card' "$_v2/err"; } || _v2b="$_v2b [passed: $_pr → $_rc]"
+done
+[ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "a card on one line (· ; | separators, a Card: or Kart: lead, above: on the line) is read by its labels and held to the three-line rules: a critical path still needs opus; a kind with a note in parentheses is the kind, on one line or three; a bad change, labels out of order, a missing verify or prose first are refused" \
+               || fail "the one-line card:$_v2b"
+# `above:` among the three lines, not only after them (2026-10-19: 2 of 19 line refusals had it between change: and
+# verify:; the retry moved it down and passed). It keeps the model the same way; the three are still all required.
+_v2b=""
+for _pr in 'files: src/ui/a.ts\nchange: feature\nabove: the parser is subtle\nverify: true' 'above: the parser is subtle\nfiles: src/ui/a.ts\nchange: feature\nverify: true'; do
+  _v2one "$_pr" opus; { [ "$_rc" = 0 ] && [ ! -s "$_v2/oneout" ]; } || _v2b="$_v2b [above: among the three did not keep opus: $_pr → $_rc $(head -c 100 "$_v2/oneout")]"
+done
+_v2one 'files: src/ui/c.ts\nchange: feature\nverify: true' opus
+grep -q '"updatedInput":' "$_v2/oneout" || _v2b="$_v2b [without above: opus was not lowered (rc $_rc)]"
+for _pr in 'files: src/ui/a.ts\nchange: feature\nabove: x\nDo it.' 'files: src/ui/a.ts\nabove: x\nabove: y\nverify: true'; do
+  _v2one "$_pr" sonnet; { [ "$_rc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'opens with its task card' "$_v2/err"; } || _v2b="$_v2b [passed: $_pr → $_rc]"
+done
+# `change: review` is an audit (the discipline's table lists it with them): same floor, a near miss still refused.
+_v2one 'files: src/ui/a.ts\nchange: review\nverify: none' haiku; { [ "$_rc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'runs on sonnet' "$_v2/err"; } || _v2b="$_v2b [review on haiku was not held to sonnet as audit (rc $_rc)]"
+for _pr in 'files: src/ui/a.ts\nchange: review\nverify: none' 'files: src/ui/a.ts · change: review (the staged diff) · verify: none'; do
+  _v2one "$_pr" sonnet; [ "$_rc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b [refused: $_pr → $_rc $(head -c 100 "$_v2/err")]"
+done
+_v2one 'files: src/payments/p.ts\nchange: review\nverify: none' sonnet; { [ "$_rc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'runs on opus' "$_v2/err"; } || _v2b="$_v2b [review on a critical path was not held to opus (rc $_rc)]"
+_v2one 'files: src/ui/a.ts\nchange: reviews\nverify: none' sonnet; { [ "$_rc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'opens with its task card' "$_v2/err"; } || _v2b="$_v2b [change: reviews passed (rc $_rc)]"
+[ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "above: may stand anywhere among the three card lines and keeps the model; without it the model is lowered; above: does not stand in for files:, change: or verify:; change: review is an audit, held to the same floors, and a near miss is still refused" \
+               || fail "above: in the card:$_v2b"
 
 # ---- at write time: the card can leave a file out --------------------------------------------------------------
 _v2new; _v2b=""
 _v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'src/ui/a.ts' refactor true; _v2start ag-son
 _v2call crew-backend-expert opus 'src/payments/p.ts' feature none; _v2start ag-op
+_v2call crew-docs-agent sonnet 'legal/terms.md' text none; _v2start ag-txt crew-docs-agent
 _v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts" ',"agent_id":"ag-son","agent_type":"crew-backend-expert"'; { [ "$_v2wrc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'escalate: src/payments/p.ts' "$_v2/werr" && grep -q '^GUARD (agent model): ' "$_v2/werr"; } || _v2b="$_v2b sonnet-agent-wrote-payments:$_v2wrc"
 _v2write "$_v2p/src/ui/a.ts"        ',"agent_id":"ag-son","agent_type":"crew-backend-expert"'; [ "$_v2wrc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b sonnet-agent-refused-on-ui:$_v2wrc"
 _v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts" ',"agent_id":"ag-op","agent_type":"crew-backend-expert"';  [ "$_v2wrc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b opus-agent-refused:$_v2wrc"
 _v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts" ',"agent_id":"ag-unknown","agent_type":"general-purpose"'; [ "$_v2wrc" = 2 ] || _v2b="$_v2b unknown-model-wrote-payments:$_v2wrc"
 _v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts"; [ "$_v2wrc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b the-session-refused:$_v2wrc"
+# A text change on sonnet writes prose on a critical path; not code there, and not prose for any other change.
+_v2write "$_v2p/legal/terms.md"     ',"agent_id":"ag-txt","agent_type":"crew-docs-agent"';     [ "$_v2wrc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b sonnet-text-refused-legal-prose:$_v2wrc"
+_v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts" ',"agent_id":"ag-txt","agent_type":"crew-docs-agent"';     [ "$_v2wrc" = 2 ] || _v2b="$_v2b sonnet-text-wrote-payments-code:$_v2wrc"
+_v2write "$_v2p/legal/terms.md"     ',"agent_id":"ag-son","agent_type":"crew-backend-expert"'; [ "$_v2wrc" = 2 ] || _v2b="$_v2b sonnet-refactor-wrote-legal-prose:$_v2wrc"
 mkdir -p "$_v2/t/subagents"; printf '{"type":"assistant","message":{"model":"claude-opus-5-5"}}\n' > "$_v2/t/subagents/agent-ag-gp.jsonl"
 _v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts" ',"agent_id":"ag-gp","agent_type":"general-purpose"'; [ "$_v2wrc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b opus-by-its-transcript-refused:$_v2wrc"
 _V2ENV="CREW_MODEL_ROUTING=off" _v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts" ',"agent_id":"ag-son","agent_type":"crew-backend-expert"'; [ "$_v2wrc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b routing-off-refused:$_v2wrc"
-[ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "an agent on sonnet is refused a write to a critical path its card did not name, and told to report escalate; the same agent writes elsewhere; an agent on opus (by its call, or by its own transcript) writes there; an agent whose model cannot be read does not; the session's own write is not asked; routing off asks nothing" \
+[ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "an agent on sonnet is refused a write to a critical path its card did not name, and told to report escalate; the same agent writes elsewhere; an agent on opus (by its call, or by its own transcript) writes there; an agent whose model cannot be read does not; the session's own write is not asked; routing off asks nothing; an agent on sonnet with a text card writes prose there (legal/terms.md) and not code, and one with any other card writes neither" \
                || fail "write-time check:$_v2b"
 # B2 (K7): the session's own write to a critical path is not refused, and it is recorded: one NOTE line in the gate
 # log naming the path and the rule. A write elsewhere, one outside the project, and one with routing off add none.
@@ -8387,6 +8704,32 @@ _v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'docs/security.md' text none; [ "$_v2rc" = 0
 _v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'Api/Services/AuthorService.cs' feature none; [ "$_v2rc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b AuthorService-read-as-auth"
 [ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "with no settings file the scan finds the critical paths of a Flutter app and a .NET service (a folder once, not per file; AuthorService and author.md are not auth); crew-model-rules adds and removes paths, at SessionStart too, and the gate follows it" \
                || fail "critical paths:$_v2b"
+# V5: an organisation preset (eval/lib/preset.sh) is a block at the top of crew-model-rules. The project's own lines
+# stay below it and win where the file's rule lets them; applying again changes nothing; an invalid one writes nothing.
+_v2new; _v2b=""; PSH="$ROOT/eval/lib/preset.sh"; _psr="$_v2p/.claude/crew-model-rules"; _psx="$(mktemp -d)"
+printf '# ours\n- infra\n' > "$_psr"
+( cd "$_v2p" && bash "$PSH" --apply strict ) >/dev/null 2>&1 || _v2b="$_v2b [strict did not apply]"
+{ IFS= read -r _l1 < "$_psr"; case "$_l1" in '# ---- preset: strict '*) ;; *) false ;; esac; } || _v2b="$_v2b [first line: ${_l1:-none}]"
+grep -qx '+ deploy' "$_psr" && grep -qx 'floor crew-review-agent \* \* opus' "$_psr" && grep -qx -- '- infra' "$_psr" && grep -qx '# ours' "$_psr" || _v2b="$_v2b [block or own lines missing]"
+[ "$(grep -n -- '^- infra$' "$_psr" | cut -d: -f1)" -gt "$(grep -n '^+ infra$' "$_psr" | cut -d: -f1)" ] || _v2b="$_v2b [the project's own line is not below the block]"
+cp "$_psr" "$_psx/a"; ( cd "$_v2p" && bash "$PSH" --apply strict ) >/dev/null 2>&1; cmp -s "$_psr" "$_psx/a" || _v2b="$_v2b [a second apply changed the file]"
+[ "$( cd "$_v2p" && bash "$PSH" --show )" = strict ] || _v2b="$_v2b [--show]"
+# The gate follows it: review on sonnet is refused under strict, and the project's `- infra` undoes the preset's `+ infra`.
+_v2call crew-review-agent sonnet 'src/ui/a.ts' audit none; { [ "$_v2rc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'floor crew-review-agent \* \* opus' "$_v2/err"; } || _v2b="$_v2b [review on sonnet under strict: rc $_v2rc]"
+_v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'infra/main.tf' feature 'test -d src'; [ "$_v2rc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b [infra stayed critical though the project removed it: rc $_v2rc]"
+_v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'deploy/run.sh' feature 'test -d src'; [ "$_v2rc" = 2 ] || _v2b="$_v2b [deploy is not critical under strict: rc $_v2rc]"
+( cd "$_v2p" && bash "$PSH" --apply solo ) >/dev/null 2>&1; ! grep -q '^+ deploy' "$_psr" && grep -qx 'verify npm test' "$_psr" && grep -qx -- '- infra' "$_psr" || _v2b="$_v2b [switching to solo left the old block or lost the own line]"
+# Invalid presets: each refused with rc 1, the file untouched.
+cp "$_psr" "$_psx/b"; _bad=0
+for _bj in '{"name":"x","oops":1}' '{"name":"x","floors":[["a","b","c","gpt"]]}' '{"name":"x","verify":["npm test; rm -rf /"]}' '{"name":"X Y"}' 'not json'; do
+  printf '%s' "$_bj" > "$_psx/bad.json"; ( cd "$_v2p" && bash "$PSH" --apply "$_psx/bad.json" ) >/dev/null 2>&1; _rc=$?
+  { [ "$_rc" = 1 ] && cmp -s "$_psr" "$_psx/b"; } || { _bad=$((_bad+1)); _v2b="$_v2b [accepted or wrote: $_bj rc $_rc]"; }
+done
+( cd "$_v2p" && bash "$PSH" --apply no-such-preset ) >/dev/null 2>&1 && _v2b="$_v2b [a preset that is not there applied]"
+_dl="$(cd "$_v2p" && bash "$ROOT/eval/doctor.sh" . 2>/dev/null | grep -c 'organisation preset: solo')"; [ "$_dl" = 1 ] || _v2b="$_v2b [doctor did not name the preset: $_dl]"
+[ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "an organisation preset is a block at the top of crew-model-rules: the project's own lines stay below it and win (its '- infra' undoes the preset's), the gate follows it (review held to opus under strict), applying again changes no byte, switching replaces the block, five invalid presets and a missing one write nothing, and doctor names the one in force" \
+               || fail "presets:$_v2b"
+rm -rf "$_psx"
 
 # ---- 3. verify, one fix inside the agent, then one model up, then the user -----------------------------------
 _v2new; _v2b=""
@@ -8699,12 +9042,41 @@ if command -v iconv >/dev/null 2>&1; then printf '%s' "$_o" | iconv -f UTF-8 -t
 [ "${#_o}" -le 2600 ] || _v2b="$_v2b [the reason is ${#_o} bytes]"
 [ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "the one fix is asked once and only where it can be counted: a red verify under stop_hook_active ends as fail with no block, and so does one whose counter cannot be written (both recorded as fail with no fix); the output handed to the agent is cut at 1500 bytes without splitting a character" \
                || fail "the stop hook's one fix:$_v2b"
+# A verify command in a sub-folder, `cd <folder> && <command>` (41 of 71 refusals on one project): judged as the
+# command and run in the folder with no chain. A folder outside the project, one that does not exist, or a second
+# chain after it stays refused. A card that says `none (why)` is none.
+_v2new; _v2b=""; mkdir -p "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/agents" "$_v2p/sub"; : > "$_v2p/sub/ok.flag"
+printf 'verify test -f ok.flag\n' > "$_v2p/.claude/crew-model-rules"
+_v2plant c1 'cd sub && test -f ok.flag'; _v2stop c1 >/dev/null
+[ "$(_v2row c1 | cut -d/ -f2)" = pass ] || _v2b="$_v2b [cd sub && test: $(_v2row c1)]"
+for _cc in 'c2:cd ../sub && test -f ok.flag' 'c3:cd nowhere && test -f ok.flag' 'c4:cd sub && test -f ok.flag && touch x' 'c5:cd /tmp && test -f ok.flag'; do
+  _v2plant "${_cc%%:*}" "${_cc#*:}"; _v2stop "${_cc%%:*}" >/dev/null
+  [ "$(_v2row "${_cc%%:*}" | cut -d/ -f2)" = blocked ] || _v2b="$_v2b [${_cc#*:} was not refused: $(_v2row "${_cc%%:*}")]"
+done
+[ ! -e "$_v2p/sub/x" ] || _v2b="$_v2b [a chain after the folder ran]"
+_v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'src/ui/a.ts' text 'none (the author ran it)'
+grep -q '^verify=none$' "$(ls -t "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/pending/"* 2>/dev/null | head -1)" 2>/dev/null || _v2b="$_v2b [none (why) was not none]"
+# doctor lists the commands refused for not being allowed, with the line that allows them, and not a sentence
+mkdir -p "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/results"
+printf 'verify=blocked\nwhynot=it is not a test or build command on this hook'"'"'s list, and no rule names it\ncmd=node tools/build.mjs --check\n' > "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/results/r1"
+printf 'verify=blocked\nwhynot=it is not a test or build command on this hook'"'"'s list, and no rule names it\ncmd=actionlint (if installed)\n' > "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/results/r2"
+# The other way of saying "nothing allows it" (default mode), for a command in a sub-folder: counted, and offered as
+# the rule that matches it, the command without its `cd` (measured on Windows: the line with the cd in it did not).
+printf "verify=blocked\nwhynot=in 'default' mode Claude Code does not run a command the user has not allowed, so neither does a hook\ncmd=cd sub && ./check.sh\n" > "$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model/results/r3"
+if [ -f "$ROOT/eval/doctor.sh" ]; then
+  mkdir -p "$_v2p/.claude/eval"; cp -R "$ROOT/eval/." "$_v2p/.claude/eval/" 2>/dev/null
+  _dd="$( cd "$_v2p" && env -u CLAUDE_CODE_SUBAGENT_MODEL CREW_NO_STAR=1 CREW_LANG=en CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR="$_v2/home" bash .claude/eval/doctor.sh 2>/dev/null | grep 'verify commands never run' )"
+  case "$_dd" in *'3 time(s)'*'verify node tools/build.mjs --check'*'verify ./check.sh'*) case "$_dd" in *actionlint*|*'verify cd '*) _v2b="$_v2b [doctor offered a sentence, or a rule with its cd, as a rule: ${_dd}]" ;; esac ;;
+    *) _v2b="$_v2b [doctor: ${_dd:-no line}]" ;; esac
+fi
+[ -z "$_v2b" ] && pass "a verify command in a sub-folder runs there: 'cd sub && <command>' passes, judged as the command alone; a folder outside the project or missing, an absolute one, and a chain after it stay refused; 'none (why)' is none; doctor offers the refused commands, in either mode, as the rule that matches them (no cd prefix), not a sentence" \
+               || fail "verify in a sub-folder:$_v2b"
 # Which record is whose. Two calls of one type made together are matched by order, which can be wrong; the card in
 # the agent's own transcript settles it.
 _v2new; _v2b=""; _v2st="$_v2p/.claude/state/crew-model"
 _v2tr(){ printf '{"type":"user","message":{"role":"user","content":"files: %s\\nchange: %s\\nverify: %s\\n\\nDo the work."}}\n' "$2" "$3" "$4" > "$_v2/tr-$1.jsonl"; }
 _v2stopt(){ printf '{"session_id":"s","permission_mode":"auto","hook_event_name":"SubagentStop","agent_id":"%s","agent_type":"x","stop_hook_active":false,"agent_transcript_path":"%s/tr-%s.jsonl","last_assistant_message":"did it\\nconfidence: high"}' "$1" "$_v2" "$1" | ( cd "$_v2p" && _v2e bash "$_V2O" 2>/dev/null ); }
-_v2call crew-backend-expert haiku 'src/ui/one.ts' text 'test -f one.ok'; _v2call crew-backend-expert opus 'src/ui/two.ts' feature 'test -f two.ok'
+_v2call crew-backend-expert haiku 'src/ui/one.ts' text 'test -f one.ok'; _v2call crew-backend-expert opus 'src/ui/two.ts' feature 'test -f two.ok\nabove: two models pending for one agent type'
 # The order the two records are taken in is made known: the haiku call's first, so each agent gets the OTHER's below.
 for _pf in "$_v2st/pending"/*; do if grep -q 'one.ok' "$_pf"; then mv "$_pf" "$_v2st/pending/1-a"; else mv "$_pf" "$_v2st/pending/2-b"; fi; done
 _pt="$(date +%s)"; mv "$_v2st/pending/1-a" "$_v2st/pending/$_pt-a"; mv "$_v2st/pending/2-b" "$_v2st/pending/$_pt-b"
@@ -8739,6 +9111,16 @@ rm -f "$_v2st"/pending/*
 _v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'src/ui/race.ts' text true
 _v2start r1 & _v2start r2 & wait
 _rn=0; [ -f "$_v2st/agents/r1" ] && _rn=$((_rn+1)); [ -f "$_v2st/agents/r2" ] && _rn=$((_rn+1)); [ "$_rn" = 1 ] || _v2b="$_v2b [one record, two agents: $_rn got it]"
+ls "$_v2st/agents" 2>/dev/null | grep -qE '\.(take|claim)$' && _v2b="$_v2b a-lock-or-claim-left-behind"
+# A record another hook holds the lock on is not taken: the agent goes on to the next one (the lock is what keeps
+# two agents off one record where a rename alone did not, on Windows).
+rm -rf "$_v2st/agents"; rm -f "$_v2st"/pending/*
+_v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'src/ui/l1.ts' text 'test -f l1'; _pl1="$(ls "$_v2st/pending")"
+sleep 1; _v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'src/ui/l2.ts' text 'test -f l2'
+mkdir -p "$_v2st/agents"; : > "$_v2st/agents/$_pl1.take"
+_v2start k1
+{ grep -q '^verify=test -f l2' "$_v2st/agents/k1" 2>/dev/null && [ -f "$_v2st/pending/$_pl1" ]; } || _v2b="$_v2b a-locked-record-was-taken-or-the-next-one-was-not"
+rm -f "$_v2st/agents/$_pl1.take" "$_v2st"/pending/*
 # A record nothing claimed within five minutes is nobody's.
 mkdir -p "$_v2st/pending"; printf 'agent=crew-backend-expert\ntier=opus\nchange=text\nrisk=normal\ncard=old\nbg=unset\nesc=-\nverify=none\n' > "$_v2st/pending/1000000000-tuold"
 _v2start o1; { [ ! -f "$_v2st/agents/o1" ] && [ ! -f "$_v2st/pending/1000000000-tuold" ]; } || _v2b="$_v2b a-stale-record-was-given-to-an-agent-or-kept"
@@ -8761,7 +9143,7 @@ _kn="$(awk -F'\t' '$2 == "k2" { print $5 "/" $13 }' "$_v2st/../model-outcomes.ts
 # The gate's and the write-time check's refusals are in the gate log; an agent id that cannot be read does not open
 # the write-time check; run_in_background named twice is refused.
 _v2new; _v2b=""; _V2ENV="CREW_GATE_LOG=$_v2/gl.tsv"; : > "$_v2/gl.tsv"
-_v2call crew-database-expert sonnet 'src/payments/p.ts' feature none; _v2call crew-backend-expert haiku 'src/ui/a.ts' text none
+_v2call crew-database-expert sonnet 'src/payments/p.ts' feature none; _v2call crew-backend-expert haiku 'src/ui/a.ts' fix-known none
 _v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts" ',"agent_id":"nobody-known","agent_type":"x"'
 _v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts" ',"agent_id":"","agent_type":"x"'; [ "$_v2wrc" = 2 ] || _v2b="$_v2b an-empty-agent-id-opened-the-check:$_v2wrc"
 _v2write "$_v2p/src/payments/p.ts" ',"agent_id":"a b/../c","agent_type":"x"'; [ "$_v2wrc" = 2 ] || _v2b="$_v2b an-unreadable-agent-id-opened-the-check:$_v2wrc"
@@ -8905,11 +9287,11 @@ _v2call crew-backend-expert sonnet 'src/payments/p.ts' feature none; [ "$_v2rc"
 # What a lowering cannot reach: the floors the card and the agent carry. Two raised floors are planted and lowered;
 # the model below still fails where another rule holds it, and passes where only the lowered floor did.
 _v2new; _v2b=""; mkdir -p "$_v2p/.claude/state"
-printf 'crew-backend-expert\ttext\tnormal\tsonnet\t6\t3\t2026-01-01T00:00:00Z\ncrew-database-expert\tfeature\tnormal\topus\t6\t3\t2026-01-01T00:00:00Z\n' > "$_v2fl"
-_o="$(_v2say '/crew-loosen crew-backend-expert text normal')$(_v2say '/crew-loosen crew-database-expert feature normal')"
+printf 'crew-backend-expert\tfix-known\tnormal\tsonnet\t6\t3\t2026-01-01T00:00:00Z\ncrew-database-expert\tfeature\tnormal\topus\t6\t3\t2026-01-01T00:00:00Z\n' > "$_v2fl"
+_o="$(_v2say '/crew-loosen crew-backend-expert fix-known normal')$(_v2say '/crew-loosen crew-database-expert feature normal')"
 case "$_o" in *'from sonnet to haiku'*'from opus to sonnet'*) ;; *) _v2b="$_v2b FIXTURE:the-two-floors-were-not-lowered" ;; esac
-_v2call crew-backend-expert haiku 'src/ui/f1.ts' text true;   [ "$_v2rc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b the-lowered-class-is-still-refused-on-haiku:$_v2rc"
-_v2call crew-backend-expert haiku 'src/ui/f1.ts' text none;   [ "$_v2rc" = 2 ] || _v2b="$_v2b verify-none-went-to-haiku-after-a-lowering"
+_v2call crew-backend-expert haiku 'src/ui/f1.ts' fix-known true;   [ "$_v2rc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b the-lowered-class-is-still-refused-on-haiku:$_v2rc"
+_v2call crew-backend-expert haiku 'src/ui/f1.ts' fix-known none;   [ "$_v2rc" = 2 ] || _v2b="$_v2b verify-none-went-to-haiku-after-a-lowering"
 _v2call crew-database-expert sonnet 'src/ui/f2.ts' feature true; [ "$_v2rc" = 0 ] || _v2b="$_v2b the-lowered-class-is-still-refused-on-sonnet:$_v2rc"
 _v2call crew-database-expert haiku 'src/ui/f2.ts' feature true;  { [ "$_v2rc" = 2 ] && grep -q 'runs on sonnet or above' "$_v2/err"; } || _v2b="$_v2b an-agents-own-floor-was-lowered"
 _v2call crew-database-expert sonnet 'db/migrations/1.sql' feature true ',"run_in_background":false'; [ "$_v2rc" = 2 ] || _v2b="$_v2b critical-work-went-below-opus-after-a-lowering"
@@ -11155,7 +11537,7 @@ sec "== 14c) the 3.0 rename left no old name behind — outside history and the
 if [ -n "$SGR" ] && [ -d "$SGR/packaging" ] && [ -f "$SGR/VERSION" ] && [ -d "$SGR/kit" ] && [ -f "$SGR/packaging/build-plugin.sh" ]; then
   RN_ALLOW='CHANGELOG.md	196	history: every entry before 3.0 keeps the name it shipped under
 README*.md site/content/*/install.md	4	migration: the 2.x plugin note names the plugin to uninstall — one line in each README and install page, EN + TR
-evals/results/*	6	history: recorded eval runs stay byte-for-byte
+evals/results/* packaging/review-bench/cases/* packaging/review-bench/results/* packaging/advisor-bench/results/*	729	history: recorded eval runs, and the review bench'"'"'s cases (past versions of Crewforth'"'"'s own files) and results, and the advisor bench'"'"'s results on them, stay byte-for-byte
 adopt.sh kit/legacy-blobs.tsv	347	migration: finds and moves 2.x names (components, CLAUDE.md, board, auto-mode rules, variables), and the generated list of the 1.x/2.x files it may move
 bin/cli.js	4	migration: add accepts a typed <x>-csk and moves an add record written under the old names
 evals/run.sh	4	compat: reads the 2.x trusted eval parent when the 3.0 one is absent — removed in 4.0
@@ -11375,6 +11757,22 @@ $(printf '%s\n%s\n%s\n' "$_ka" "$_kb" "$_kc" | grep . | head -n 6 | sed "s|$KR/|
     [ -n "$(_dn "$_kd/done-twin.sh")" ] && pass "the installers' closing lines name no kit (EN key and TR value); a planted 'kit/ deleted' is caught" \
       || fail "twin: the closing-line check missed a planted 'kit/ deleted' — it reads nothing"
   fi
+  # adopt.sh --help answers before it reads anything. An unknown flag is ignored further down, so --help used to run
+  # the detection (seen on Windows in the 3.2.0-rc.1 trial). Read in a git repo holding only adopt.sh: no kit/, both
+  # languages, and nothing written. Twin: the same script without its --help branch must not print the usage.
+  _ah_run(){ ( cd "$1" && CREW_LANG=en bash adopt.sh --help; echo "rc=$?"; bash adopt.sh -h --lang tr; echo "rc=$?" ) 2>&1; }
+  mkdir -p "$_kd/ah" "$_kd/ah-twin"; git init -q "$_kd/ah" 2>/dev/null; git init -q "$_kd/ah-twin" 2>/dev/null
+  cp "$KR/adopt.sh" "$_kd/ah/"; sed 's/-h|--help) _hh=1 ;;//' "$KR/adopt.sh" > "$_kd/ah-twin/adopt.sh"
+  _ah="$(_ah_run "$_kd/ah")"; _aht="$(_ah_run "$_kd/ah-twin")"
+  _ahw="$(git -C "$_kd/ah" status --porcelain 2>/dev/null | grep -vx '?? adopt.sh')"
+  case "$_ah" in
+    *'Usage: bash adopt.sh'*'rc=0'*'Kullanım: bash adopt.sh'*'rc=0'*)
+      if [ -n "$_ahw" ]; then fail "adopt.sh --help wrote into the project: $(printf '%s' "$_ahw" | head -n 2 | tr '\n' ' ')"
+      else case "$_aht" in *'Usage: bash adopt.sh'*) fail "twin: adopt.sh without its --help branch still printed the usage — the check reads nothing" ;;
+             *) pass "adopt.sh --help prints its usage in English and Turkish, rc 0, with no kit/ and nothing written (a twin without it does not)" ;; esac
+      fi ;;
+    *) fail "adopt.sh --help did not print its usage in both languages with rc 0: $(printf '%s' "$_ah" | head -n 3 | tr '\n' ' ')" ;;
+  esac
   rm -rf "$_kd"
 else
   skip scope "printed-text wording check skipped (installed project — the installers live in the source repository)"