com.beamable 0.0.0-PREVIEW.NIGHTLY-202601071423 → 5.0.0-PREVIEW.RC10

package/Runtime/3rdParty/PubNub/Scripts/Pubnub/Helpers.cs

@@ -1,1337 +1,1337 @@
-using Beamable.Common.Dependencies;
-using System;
-using System.Collections;
-using System.Collections.Generic;
-using System.Linq;
-using System.Net;
-using System.Text;
-
-namespace PubNubMessaging.Core
-{
-	public sealed class Counter
-	{
-		private uint current = 0;
-		private object syncRoot;
-
-		public Counter()
-		{
-			syncRoot = new Object();
-			current = 0;
-		}
-
-		public uint NextValue()
-		{
-			lock (syncRoot)
-			{
-				this.current++;
-			}
-			return this.current;
-		}
-
-		public void Reset()
-		{
-			lock (syncRoot)
-			{
-				this.current = 0;
-			}
-		}
-	}
-
-	internal static class Helpers
-	{
-		#region "Helpers"
-		internal static TimetokenMetadata CreateTimetokenMetadata(object timeTokenDataObject, string whichTT)
-		{
-			IDictionary<string, object> timeTokenData = (IDictionary<string, object>)timeTokenDataObject;
-			TimetokenMetadata timetokenMetadata = new TimetokenMetadata(Utility.CheckKeyAndParseLong(timeTokenData, whichTT, "t"),
-				timeTokenData["r"].ToString());
-
-			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, TimetokenMetadata: {1} \nTimetoken: {2} \nRegion: {3}",
-				DateTime.Now.ToString(), whichTT, timetokenMetadata.Timetoken, timetokenMetadata.Region),
-				LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-			return timetokenMetadata;
-		}
-
-		internal static void AddToSubscribeMessageList(object dictObject, ref List<SubscribeMessage> subscribeMessages)
-		{
-			var dict = dictObject as IDictionary<string, object>;
-			if ((dict != null) && (dict.Count > 1))
-			{
-				string shard = (dict.ContainsKey("a")) ? dict["a"].ToString() : "";
-				string subscriptionMatch = (dict.ContainsKey("b")) ? dict["b"].ToString() : "";
-				string channel = (dict.ContainsKey("c")) ? dict["c"].ToString() : "";
-				object payload = (dict.ContainsKey("d")) ? (object)dict["d"] : null;
-				string flags = (dict.ContainsKey("f")) ? dict["f"].ToString() : "";
-				string issuingClientId = (dict.ContainsKey("i")) ? dict["i"].ToString() : "";
-				string subscribeKey = (dict.ContainsKey("k")) ? dict["k"].ToString() : "";
-				long sequenceNumber = Utility.CheckKeyAndParseLong(dict, "sequenceNumber", "s");
-
-				TimetokenMetadata originatingTimetoken = (dict.ContainsKey("o")) ? CreateTimetokenMetadata(dict["o"], "Originating TT: ") : null;
-				TimetokenMetadata publishMetadata = (dict.ContainsKey("p")) ? CreateTimetokenMetadata(dict["p"], "Publish TT: ") : null;
-				object userMetadata = (dict.ContainsKey("u")) ? (object)dict["u"] : null;
-
-				SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage = new SubscribeMessage(
-					shard,
-					subscriptionMatch,
-					channel,
-					payload,
-					flags,
-					issuingClientId,
-					subscribeKey,
-					sequenceNumber,
-					originatingTimetoken,
-					publishMetadata,
-					userMetadata
-				);
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, AddToSubscribeMessageList: \n" +
-					"shard : {1},\n" +
-					"subscriptionMatch: {2},\n" +
-					"channel: {3},\n" +
-					"payload: {4},\n" +
-					"flags: {5},\n" +
-					"issuingClientId: {6},\n" +
-					"subscribeKey: {7},\n" +
-					"sequenceNumber: {8},\n" +
-					"originatingTimetoken tt: {9},\n" +
-					"originatingTimetoken region: {10},\n" +
-					"publishMetadata tt: {11},\n" +
-					"publishMetadata region: {12},\n" +
-					"userMetadata {13} \n",
-					DateTime.Now.ToString(),
-					shard,
-					subscriptionMatch,
-					channel,
-					payload.ToString(),
-					flags,
-					issuingClientId,
-					subscribeKey,
-					sequenceNumber,
-					(originatingTimetoken != null) ? originatingTimetoken.Timetoken.ToString() : "",
-					(originatingTimetoken != null) ? originatingTimetoken.Region : "",
-					(publishMetadata != null) ? publishMetadata.Timetoken.ToString() : "",
-					(publishMetadata != null) ? publishMetadata.Region : "",
-					(userMetadata != null) ? userMetadata.ToString() : "null"),
-					LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-
-				subscribeMessages.Add(subscribeMessage);
-			}
-			else
-			{
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, AddToSubscribeMessageList: CreateListOfSubscribeMessage create " +
-					"SubscribeMessage failed. dictObject type: {1}, dict type : {2}",
-					DateTime.Now.ToString(), dictObject.ToString(), dict.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-			}
-
-		}
-
-		internal static List<SubscribeMessage> CreateListOfSubscribeMessage(object message)
-		{
-			List<SubscribeMessage> subscribeMessages = new List<SubscribeMessage>();
-			if (message != null)
-			{
-				//JSONFx
-				object[] messages = message as object[];
-
-				if (messages != null)
-				{
-					var myObjectArray = (from item in messages
-										 select item as object).ToArray();
-					if ((myObjectArray != null) && (myObjectArray.Length > 0))
-					{
-
-						foreach (object dictObject in myObjectArray)
-						{
-							AddToSubscribeMessageList(dictObject, ref subscribeMessages);
-						}
-					}
-				}
-				else
-				{
-					//MiniJSON
-					List<object> messageList = message as List<object>;
-					if ((messageList != null) && messageList.Count > 0)
-					{
-						foreach (object dictObject in messageList)
-						{
-							AddToSubscribeMessageList(dictObject, ref subscribeMessages);
-						}
-					}
-				}
-			}
-			else
-			{
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateListOfSubscribeMessage: no messages ",
-					DateTime.Now.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-			}
-
-			return subscribeMessages;
-		}
-
-		internal static string BuildJsonUserState(IDictionary<string, object> userStateDictionary)
-		{
-			StringBuilder jsonStateBuilder = new StringBuilder();
-
-			if (userStateDictionary != null)
-			{
-				string[] userStateKeys = userStateDictionary.Keys.ToArray<string>();
-
-				for (int keyIndex = 0; keyIndex < userStateKeys.Length; keyIndex++)
-				{
-					string useStateKey = userStateKeys[keyIndex];
-					object userStateValue = userStateDictionary[useStateKey];
-					if (userStateValue == null)
-					{
-						jsonStateBuilder.AppendFormat("\"{0}\":{1}", useStateKey, string.Format("\"{0}\"", "null"));
-					}
-					else
-					{
-						jsonStateBuilder.AppendFormat("\"{0}\":{1}", useStateKey, (userStateValue.GetType().ToString() == "System.String") ? string.Format("\"{0}\"", userStateValue) : userStateValue);
-					}
-					if (keyIndex < userStateKeys.Length - 1)
-					{
-						jsonStateBuilder.Append(",");
-					}
-				}
-			}
-
-			return jsonStateBuilder.ToString();
-		}
-
-		internal static string BuildJsonUserState(List<ChannelEntity> ce)
-		{
-			string retJsonUserState = "";
-
-			StringBuilder jsonStateBuilder = new StringBuilder();
-
-			if (ce != null)
-			{
-				foreach (ChannelEntity c in ce)
-				{
-					string currentJsonState = BuildJsonUserState(c.ChannelParams.UserState);
-					if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(currentJsonState))
-					{
-						currentJsonState = string.Format("\"{0}\":{{{1}}}", c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, currentJsonState);
-						if (jsonStateBuilder.Length > 0)
-						{
-							jsonStateBuilder.Append(",");
-						}
-						jsonStateBuilder.Append(currentJsonState);
-					}
-				}
-
-				if (jsonStateBuilder.Length > 0)
-				{
-					retJsonUserState = string.Format("{{{0}}}", jsonStateBuilder.ToString());
-				}
-			}
-
-			return retJsonUserState;
-		}
-
-		internal static string GetNamesFromChannelEntities(List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, bool isChannelGroup)
-		{
-
-			StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder();
-			if (channelEntities != null)
-			{
-				int count = 0;
-				foreach (ChannelEntity c in channelEntities)
-				{
-					if (isChannelGroup && c.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup)
-					{
-						if (count > 0)
-						{
-							sb.Append(",");
-						}
-
-						sb.Append(c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName);
-						count++;
-					}
-					else if (!isChannelGroup && !c.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup)
-					{
-						if (count > 0)
-						{
-							sb.Append(",");
-						}
-
-						sb.Append(c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName);
-						count++;
-					}
-				}
-			}
-			return sb.ToString();
-		}
-
-		internal static string GetNamesFromChannelEntities(List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities)
-		{
-			StringBuilder sbCh = new StringBuilder();
-			StringBuilder sbChGrp = new StringBuilder();
-			if (channelEntities != null)
-			{
-				int countCh = 0;
-				int countChGrp = 0;
-				foreach (ChannelEntity c in channelEntities)
-				{
-					if (c.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup)
-					{
-						if (countChGrp > 0)
-						{
-							sbChGrp.Append(",");
-						}
-
-						sbChGrp.Append(c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName);
-						countChGrp++;
-					}
-					else
-					{
-						if (countCh > 0)
-						{
-							sbCh.Append(",");
-						}
-
-						sbCh.Append(c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName);
-						countCh++;
-					}
-
-				}
-			}
-			return string.Format("channel(s) = {0} and channelGroups(s) = {1}", sbCh.ToString(), sbChGrp.ToString());
-		}
-
-		internal static bool UpdateOrAddUserStateOfEntity<T>(string channel, bool isChannelGroup,
-			IDictionary<string, object> userState, bool edit,
-			Action<T> userCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
-			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, ref List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, IDependencyProvider provider)
-		{
-			ChannelEntity ce = CreateChannelEntity<T>(channel, false, isChannelGroup,
-				userState, userCallback, null, errorCallback, null, null);
-			bool stateChanged = Subscription.GetSubscription(provider).UpdateOrAddUserStateOfEntity(ref ce, userState, edit);
-			if (!stateChanged)
-			{
-				string message = "No change in User State";
-
-				PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<T>(ce, message,
-					PubnubErrorCode.UserStateUnchanged, PubnubErrorSeverity.Info, errorLevel);
-			}
-			else
-			{
-				channelEntities.Add(ce);
-			}
-			return stateChanged;
-		}
-
-		internal static bool CheckAndAddExistingUserState<T>(string channel, string channelGroup, IDictionary<string, object> userState,
-			Action<T> userCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
-			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, bool edit,
-			out string returnUserState, out List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, IDependencyProvider provider
-		)
-		{
-			string[] channels = channel.Trim().Split(',');
-			string[] channelGroups = channelGroup.Trim().Split(',');
-			bool stateChanged = false;
-			channelEntities = new List<ChannelEntity>();
-
-			foreach (string ch in channels)
-			{
-				if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(ch))
-				{
-					bool changeState = UpdateOrAddUserStateOfEntity<T>(ch, false, userState, edit,
-						userCallback, errorCallback, errorLevel, ref channelEntities, provider);
-					if (changeState && !stateChanged)
-					{
-						stateChanged = true;
-					}
-				}
-			}
-
-			foreach (string ch in channelGroups)
-			{
-				if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(ch))
-				{
-					bool changeState = UpdateOrAddUserStateOfEntity<T>(ch, true, userState, edit,
-						userCallback, errorCallback, errorLevel, ref channelEntities, provider);
-					if (changeState && !stateChanged)
-					{
-						stateChanged = true;
-					}
-				}
-			}
-
-			returnUserState = BuildJsonUserState(channelEntities);
-
-			return stateChanged;
-		}
-
-		internal static ChannelEntity CreateChannelEntity<T>(string channelOrChannelGroupName2,
-			bool isAwaitingConnectCallback,
-			bool isChannelGroup, IDictionary<string, object> userState,
-			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback,
-			Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback, Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback
-		)
-		{
-			string channelOrChannelGroupName = channelOrChannelGroupName2.Trim();
-			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntity: channelOrChannelGroupName {1}, {2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(),
-				channelOrChannelGroupName.ToString(), channelOrChannelGroupName2.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-			if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(channelOrChannelGroupName))
-			{
-				ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity();
-				ci.ChannelOrChannelGroupName = channelOrChannelGroupName;
-				ci.IsPresenceChannel = Utility.IsPresenceChannel(channelOrChannelGroupName);
-				ci.IsChannelGroup = isChannelGroup;
-
-				ChannelParameters cp = new ChannelParameters();
-				cp.IsAwaitingConnectCallback = isAwaitingConnectCallback;
-				cp.UserState = userState;
-				cp.TypeParameterType = typeof(T);
-
-				cp.Callbacks = PubnubCallbacks.GetPubnubChannelCallback<T>(userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback,
-					disconnectCallback, wildcardPresenceCallback);
-
-				ChannelEntity ce = new ChannelEntity(ci, cp);
-
-				return ce;
-			}
-			else
-			{
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntity: channelOrChannelGroupName empty, is channel group {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), isChannelGroup.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-				return null;
-			}
-		}
-
-		internal static List<ChannelEntity> CreateChannelEntity<T>(string[] channelOrChannelGroupNames, bool isAwaitingConnectCallback,
-			bool isChannelGroup, IDictionary<string, object> userState,
-			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback,
-			Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback, Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback
-		)
-		{
-			List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities = null;
-			if (channelOrChannelGroupNames != null)
-			{
-				channelEntities = new List<ChannelEntity>();
-				foreach (string ch in channelOrChannelGroupNames)
-				{
-					ChannelEntity chEntity = CreateChannelEntity<T>(ch, isAwaitingConnectCallback, isChannelGroup, userState,
-						userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback, disconnectCallback, wildcardPresenceCallback
-					);
-					if (chEntity != null)
-					{
-						channelEntities.Add(chEntity);
-					}
-				}
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntity 2: channelEntities={1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelEntities.Count), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-			}
-			else
-			{
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntity 2: channelOrChannelGroupNames null, is channel group {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), isChannelGroup.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-			}
-
-			return channelEntities;
-		}
-
-		internal static IEnumerable<string> GetDuplicates(string[]
-			rawChannels)
-		{
-			var results = from string a in rawChannels
-						  group a by a into g
-						  where g.Count() > 1
-						  select g;
-			foreach (var group in results)
-				foreach (var item in group)
-					yield return item;
-		}
-
-		[System.Diagnostics.Conditional("SPEW_ALL")]
-		[System.Diagnostics.Conditional("SPEW_NOTIFICATION")]
-		internal static void LogChannelEntitiesDictionary(Subscription subscription)
-		{
-			StringBuilder sbLogs = new StringBuilder();
-			foreach (var ci in subscription.ChannelEntitiesDictionary)
-			{
-				sbLogs.AppendFormat("\nChannelEntitiesDictionary \nChannelOrChannelGroupName:{0} \nIsChannelGroup:{1} \nIsPresenceChannel:{2}\n",
-					ci.Key.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, ci.Key.IsChannelGroup.ToString(), ci.Key.IsPresenceChannel.ToString()
-				);
-			}
-			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, LogChannelEntitiesDictionary: Count: {2} \n{1}",
-				DateTime.Now.ToString(), sbLogs.ToString(), subscription.ChannelEntitiesDictionary.Count), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-		}
-
-		internal static bool CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe<T>(ResponseType type, string[] rawChannels,
-			bool isChannelGroup,
-			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
-			Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback,
-			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, bool unsubscribeCheck, ref List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, IDependencyProvider provider
-			)
-		{
-			bool bReturn = false;
-			for (int index = 0; index < rawChannels.Length; index++)
-			{
-				string channelName = rawChannels[index].Trim();
-
-				if (channelName.Length > 0)
-				{
-					if ((type == ResponseType.PresenceV2)
-						|| (type == ResponseType.PresenceUnsubscribe))
-					{
-						channelName = string.Format("{0}{1}", channelName, Utility.PresenceChannelSuffix);
-					}
-
-					Helpers.LogChannelEntitiesDictionary(Subscription.GetSubscription(provider));
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe: channel={1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelName), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-					//create channelEntity
-					ChannelEntity ce = Helpers.CreateChannelEntity(channelName, true, isChannelGroup, null,
-						userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback, disconnectCallback, wildcardPresenceCallback);
-
-					bool channelIsSubscribed = false;
-					if (Subscription.GetSubscription(provider).ChannelEntitiesDictionary.ContainsKey(ce.ChannelID))
-					{
-						channelIsSubscribed = Subscription.GetSubscription(provider).ChannelEntitiesDictionary[ce.ChannelID].IsSubscribed;
-					}
-
-					if (unsubscribeCheck)
-					{
-						if (!channelIsSubscribed)
-						{
-							string message = string.Format("{0}Channel Not Subscribed", (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? "Presence " : "");
-							PubnubErrorCode errorType = (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? PubnubErrorCode.NotPresenceSubscribed : PubnubErrorCode.NotSubscribed;
-							LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe: channel={1} response={2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelName, message), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-							PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<T>(ce, message,
-								errorType, PubnubErrorSeverity.Info, errorLevel);
-						}
-						else
-						{
-							channelEntities.Add(ce);
-							bReturn = true;
-						}
-					}
-					else
-					{
-						if (channelIsSubscribed)
-						{
-							string message = string.Format("{0}Already subscribed", (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? "Presence " : "");
-							PubnubErrorCode errorType = (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? PubnubErrorCode.AlreadyPresenceSubscribed : PubnubErrorCode.AlreadySubscribed;
-							PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<T>(ce, message,
-								errorType, PubnubErrorSeverity.Info, errorLevel);
-							LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe: channel={1} response={2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelName, message), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-						}
-						else
-						{
-							channelEntities.Add(ce);
-							bReturn = true;
-						}
-					}
-				}
-				else
-				{
-					string message = "Invalid Channel Name";
-					if (isChannelGroup)
-					{
-						message = "Invalid Channel Group Name";
-					}
-
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe: channel={1} response={2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelName, message),
-						LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-				}
-			}
-			return bReturn;
-		}
-
-		internal static bool RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon<T>(ResponseType type,
-			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
-			Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback,
-			string[] channelsOrChannelGroups, bool isChannelGroup,
-			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, bool unsubscribeCheck, ref List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
-			IDependencyProvider provider)
-		{
-			bool bReturn = false;
-			if (channelsOrChannelGroups.Length > 0)
-			{
-
-				channelsOrChannelGroups = channelsOrChannelGroups.Where(x => !string.IsNullOrEmpty(x)).ToArray();
-
-				if (channelsOrChannelGroups.Length != channelsOrChannelGroups.Distinct().Count())
-				{
-					channelsOrChannelGroups = channelsOrChannelGroups.Distinct().ToArray();
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon: distinct channelsOrChannelGroups len={1}, channelsOrChannelGroups = {2}",
-						DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelsOrChannelGroups.Length, string.Join(",", channelsOrChannelGroups)),
-						LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-					string channel = string.Join(",", GetDuplicates(channelsOrChannelGroups).Distinct<string>().ToArray<string>());
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon: duplicates channelsOrChannelGroups {1}",
-						DateTime.Now.ToString(), channel),
-						LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-					string message = string.Format("Detected and removed duplicate channels {0}", channel);
-
-					PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<T>(message, errorCallback, PubnubErrorCode.DuplicateChannel,
-						PubnubErrorSeverity.Info, errorLevel);
-				}
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon: channelsOrChannelGroups len={1}, channelsOrChannelGroups = {2}",
-					DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelsOrChannelGroups.Length, string.Join(",", channelsOrChannelGroups)),
-					LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-				bReturn = CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe<T>(type, channelsOrChannelGroups, isChannelGroup,
-					userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback, wildcardPresenceCallback, disconnectCallback, errorLevel, unsubscribeCheck, ref channelEntities, provider);
-			}
-			else
-			{
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon: channelsOrChannelGroups len <=0",
-					DateTime.Now.ToString()),
-					LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-			}
-			return bReturn;
-		}
-
-		internal static bool RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannels<T>(ResponseType type,
-			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
-			Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback,
-			string[] rawChannels, string[] rawChannelGroups,
-			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, bool unsubscribeCheck, out List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
-			IDependencyProvider provider)
-		{
-			bool bReturn = false;
-			bool channelAdded = false;
-			bool channelGroupAdded = false;
-			channelEntities = new List<ChannelEntity>();
-			if (rawChannels != null && rawChannels.Length > 0)
-			{
-				channelAdded = RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon<T>(type, userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback,
-					wildcardPresenceCallback, disconnectCallback, rawChannels, false, errorLevel, unsubscribeCheck, ref channelEntities, provider
-				);
-			}
-
-			if (rawChannelGroups != null && rawChannelGroups.Length > 0)
-			{
-				channelGroupAdded = RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon<T>(type, userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback,
-					wildcardPresenceCallback, disconnectCallback, rawChannelGroups, true, errorLevel, unsubscribeCheck, ref channelEntities, provider
-				);
-			}
-
-			bReturn = channelAdded | channelGroupAdded;
-
-			return bReturn;
-		}
-
-		internal static void ProcessResponseCallbacksV2<T>(ref SubscribeEnvelope resultSubscribeEnvelope, RequestState<T> asynchRequestState,
-			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, IDependencyProvider provider)
-		{
-
-			if (resultSubscribeEnvelope != null)
-			{
-				Helpers.ResponseToConnectCallback<T>(asynchRequestState, jsonPluggableLibrary, provider);
-				if (resultSubscribeEnvelope.Messages != null)
-				{
-					ResponseToUserCallbackForSubscribeV2<T>(resultSubscribeEnvelope.Messages, asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities,
-						cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary);
-				}
-				else
-				{
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, ProcessResponseCallbacksV2: resultSubscribeEnvelope.Messages null",
-						DateTime.Now.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelError);
-				}
-
-			}
-		}
-
-		internal static void ProcessResponseCallbacks<T>(ref List<object> result, RequestState<T> asynchRequestState,
-			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
-		{
-			if (result != null && result.Count >= 1)
-			{
-				Helpers.ResponseToUserCallback<T>(result, asynchRequestState, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary);
-			}
-		}
-		#endregion
-
-		#region "Encoding and Crypto"
-
-		internal static string JsonEncodePublishMsg(object originalMessage, string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
-		{
-			string message = jsonPluggableLibrary.SerializeToJsonString(originalMessage);
-
-			if (cipherKey.Length > 0)
-			{
-				PubnubCrypto aes = new PubnubCrypto(cipherKey);
-				string encryptMessage = aes.Encrypt(message);
-				message = jsonPluggableLibrary.SerializeToJsonString(encryptMessage);
-			}
-
-			return message;
-		}
-
-		internal static object DecodeMessage(PubnubCrypto aes, object element, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
-			IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary,
-			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel)
-		{
-			string decryptMessage = "";
-			try
-			{
-				decryptMessage = aes.Decrypt(element.ToString());
-			}
-			catch (Exception ex)
-			{
-				decryptMessage = "**DECRYPT ERROR**";
-				PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<object>(ex, channelEntities, PubnubErrorCode.None,
-					PubnubErrorSeverity.Critical, errorLevel);
-			}
-			object decodeMessage = (decryptMessage == "**DECRYPT ERROR**") ? decryptMessage : jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToObject(decryptMessage);
-			return decodeMessage;
-		}
-
-		internal static List<object> DecryptCipheredMessage(List<object> message, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
-			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary,
-			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel)
-		{
-			List<object> returnMessage = new List<object>();
-
-			PubnubCrypto aes = new PubnubCrypto(cipherKey);
-			var myObjectArray = (from item in message
-								 select item as object).ToArray();
-			IEnumerable enumerable = myObjectArray[0] as IEnumerable;
-
-			if (enumerable != null)
-			{
-				List<object> receivedMsg = new List<object>();
-				foreach (object element in enumerable)
-				{
-					receivedMsg.Add(DecodeMessage(aes, element, channelEntities, jsonPluggableLibrary, errorLevel));
-				}
-				returnMessage.Add(receivedMsg);
-			}
-			for (int index = 1; index < myObjectArray.Length; index++)
-			{
-				returnMessage.Add(myObjectArray[index]);
-			}
-			return returnMessage;
-		}
-
-		internal static List<object> DecryptNonCipheredMessage(List<object> message)
-		{
-			List<object> returnMessage = new List<object>();
-			var myObjectArray = (from item in message
-								 select item as object).ToArray();
-			IEnumerable enumerable = myObjectArray[0] as IEnumerable;
-			if (enumerable != null)
-			{
-				List<object> receivedMessage = new List<object>();
-				foreach (object element in enumerable)
-				{
-					receivedMessage.Add(element);
-				}
-				returnMessage.Add(receivedMessage);
-			}
-			for (int index = 1; index < myObjectArray.Length; index++)
-			{
-				returnMessage.Add(myObjectArray[index]);
-			}
-			return returnMessage;
-		}
-
-		internal static List<object> DecodeDecryptLoop(List<object> message, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
-			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary,
-			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel)
-		{
-			if (cipherKey.Length > 0)
-			{
-				return DecryptCipheredMessage(message, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, errorLevel);
-			}
-			else
-			{
-				return DecryptNonCipheredMessage(message);
-			}
-		}
-
-		#endregion
-
-		#region "Other Methods"
-
-		internal static void CheckSubscribedChannelsAndSendCallbacks<T>(List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
-			ResponseType type, int pubnubNetworkCheckRetries, PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel)
-		{
-			if (channelEntities != null && channelEntities.Count > 0)
-			{
-				foreach (ChannelEntity channelEntity in channelEntities)
-				{
-					string message = string.Format("Unsubscribed after {0} failed retries", pubnubNetworkCheckRetries); ;
-					PubnubErrorCode pnErrorCode = PubnubErrorCode.UnsubscribedAfterMaxRetries;
-
-					if (channelEntity.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel)
-					{
-						message = string.Format("Presence Unsubscribed after {0} failed retries", pubnubNetworkCheckRetries);
-						pnErrorCode = PubnubErrorCode.PresenceUnsubscribedAfterMaxRetries;
-					}
-
-					//TODO: Recheck
-					PubnubClientError error = Helpers.CreatePubnubClientError<T>(message, null, channelEntities, pnErrorCode,
-						PubnubErrorSeverity.Critical);
-
-					PubnubCallbacks.FireErrorCallback<T>(channelEntity,
-						errorLevel, error);
-
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CheckSubscribedChannelsAndSendCallbacks: {1} Subscribe JSON network error response={2}",
-						DateTime.Now.ToString(), (channelEntity.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? "Presence" : "", message), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-				}
-			}
-		}
-
-		public static void WrapResultBasedOnResponseType<T>(RequestState<T> pubnubRequestState, string jsonString,
-			IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, string cipherKey, ref List<object> result)
-		{
-			try
-			{
-				string multiChannel = Helpers.GetNamesFromChannelEntities(pubnubRequestState.ChannelEntities, false);
-				string multiChannelGroup = Helpers.GetNamesFromChannelEntities(pubnubRequestState.ChannelEntities, true);
-				if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(jsonString))
-				{
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, WrapResultBasedOnResponseType: jsonString = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), jsonString), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-					object deSerializedResult = jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToObject(jsonString);
-					List<object> result1 = ((IEnumerable)deSerializedResult).Cast<object>().ToList();
-
-					if (result1 != null && result1.Count > 0)
-					{
-						result = result1;
-					}
-
-					switch (pubnubRequestState.RespType)
-					{
-						case ResponseType.DetailedHistory:
-							result = DecodeDecryptLoop(result, pubnubRequestState.ChannelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, errorLevel);
-							result.Add(multiChannel);
-							break;
-						case ResponseType.Time:
-							Int64[] c = deSerializedResult as Int64[];
-							if ((c != null) && (c.Length > 0))
-							{
-								result = new List<object>();
-								result.Add(c[0]);
-							}
-							break;
-						case ResponseType.Leave:
-							if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(multiChannelGroup))
-							{
-								result.Add(multiChannelGroup);
-							}
-							if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(multiChannel))
-							{
-								result.Add(multiChannel);
-							}
-							break;
-						case ResponseType.SubscribeV2:
-						case ResponseType.PresenceV2:
-							break;
-						case ResponseType.Publish:
-						case ResponseType.PushRegister:
-						case ResponseType.PushRemove:
-						case ResponseType.PushGet:
-						case ResponseType.PushUnregister:
-							result.Add(multiChannel);
-							break;
-						case ResponseType.GrantAccess:
-						case ResponseType.AuditAccess:
-						case ResponseType.RevokeAccess:
-						case ResponseType.GetUserState:
-						case ResponseType.SetUserState:
-						case ResponseType.WhereNow:
-						case ResponseType.HereNow:
-							result = DeserializeAndAddToResult(jsonString, multiChannel, jsonPluggableLibrary, true);
-							break;
-						case ResponseType.GlobalHereNow:
-							result = DeserializeAndAddToResult(jsonString, multiChannel, jsonPluggableLibrary, false);
-							break;
-						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAdd:
-						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRemove:
-						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGet:
-							result = DeserializeAndAddToResult(jsonString, multiChannel, jsonPluggableLibrary, false);
-
-							break;
-						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGrantAccess:
-						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAuditAccess:
-						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRevokeAccess:
-							result = DeserializeAndAddToResult(jsonString, "", jsonPluggableLibrary, false);
-							result.Add(multiChannelGroup);
-							break;
-
-						default:
-							break;
-					}
-				}
-				else
-				{
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, WrapResultBasedOnResponseType: json string null ", DateTime.Now.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-				}
-			}
-			catch (Exception ex)
-			{
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, WrapResultBasedOnResponseType: exception: {1} ", DateTime.Now.ToString(), ex.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelError);
-				ProcessWrapResultBasedOnResponseTypeException<T>(pubnubRequestState, errorLevel, ex);
-			}
-		}
-
-		internal static List<object> DeserializeAndAddToResult(string jsonString, string multiChannel,
-			IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, bool addChannel)
-		{
-			IDictionary<string, object> dictionary = jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToDictionaryOfObject(jsonString);
-			List<object> result = new List<object>();
-			result.Add(dictionary);
-			if (addChannel)
-			{
-				result.Add(multiChannel);
-			}
-			return result;
-		}
-
-		internal static void ProcessWrapResultBasedOnResponseTypeException<T>(RequestState<T> pubnubRequestState,
-			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, Exception ex)
-		{
-			if (pubnubRequestState.ChannelEntities != null)
-			{
-				if (pubnubRequestState.RespType.Equals(ResponseType.SubscribeV2) || pubnubRequestState.RespType.Equals(ResponseType.PresenceV2)
-				)
-				{
-					PubnubCallbacks.FireErrorCallbacksForAllChannels<T>(ex, pubnubRequestState, PubnubErrorSeverity.Critical,
-						PubnubErrorCode.None, errorLevel);
-				}
-				else
-				{
-					PubnubCallbacks.FireErrorCallbacksForAllChannels<T>(ex, pubnubRequestState, PubnubErrorSeverity.Critical,
-						PubnubErrorCode.None, errorLevel);
-				}
-			}
-		}
-
-		internal static void CreatePNMessageResult(SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage, out PNMessageResult messageResult)
-		{
-			long timetoken = (subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata.Timetoken : 0;
-			messageResult = new PNMessageResult(
-				subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch,
-				subscribeMessage.Channel,
-				subscribeMessage.Payload,
-				timetoken,
-				subscribeMessage.UserMetadata);
-		}
-
-		internal static void AddMessageToListV2(string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary,
-			SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage, ChannelEntity ce, out List<object> itemMessage)
-		{
-			itemMessage = new List<object>();
-			if (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel)
-			{
-				itemMessage.Add(subscribeMessage.Payload);
-			}
-			else
-			{
-				//decrypt the subscriber message if cipherkey is available
-				if (cipherKey.Length > 0)
-				{
-					object decodeMessage;
-					try
-					{
-						PubnubCrypto aes = new PubnubCrypto(cipherKey);
-						string decryptMessage = aes.Decrypt(subscribeMessage.Payload.ToString());
-						decodeMessage = (decryptMessage == "**DECRYPT ERROR**") ? decryptMessage : jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToObject(decryptMessage);
-					}
-					catch (Exception decryptEx)
-					{
-						decodeMessage = subscribeMessage.Payload;
-						LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, AddMessageToListV2: decodeMessage Exception: {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), decryptEx.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelError);
-
-					}
-					itemMessage.Add(decodeMessage);
-				}
-				else
-				{
-					itemMessage.Add(subscribeMessage.Payload);
-				}
-			}
-			itemMessage.Add((subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata.Timetoken.ToString() : "");
-			if (ce.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup)
-			{
-				itemMessage.Add(ce.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName.Replace(Utility.PresenceChannelSuffix, ""));
-			}
-
-			itemMessage.Add(subscribeMessage.Channel.Replace(Utility.PresenceChannelSuffix, ""));
-		}
-
-		internal static void FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
-			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, ChannelIdentity ci)
-		{
-			ChannelEntity ce = channelEntities.Find(x => x.ChannelID.Equals(ci));
-			if (ce != null)
-			{
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, FindChannelEntityAndCallback: \n ChannelEntity : {1}  cg?={2} ispres?={3}", DateTime.Now.ToString(),
-					ce.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, ce.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup.ToString(),
-					ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel.ToString()
-				), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-				List<object> itemMessage;
-				AddMessageToListV2(cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, subscribeMessage, ce, out itemMessage);
-				PubnubChannelCallback<T> channelCallbacks = ce.ChannelParams.Callbacks as PubnubChannelCallback<T>;
-
-				if ((subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch.Contains(".*")) && Utility.IsPresenceChannel(subscribeMessage.Channel))
-				{
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, FindChannelEntityAndCallback: Wildcard match ChannelEntity : {1} ", DateTime.Now.ToString(),
-						ce.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName
-					), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-					PubnubCallbacks.GoToCallback<T>(itemMessage, channelCallbacks.WildcardPresenceCallback, jsonPluggableLibrary);
-				}
-				else
-				{
-					PubnubCallbacks.GoToCallback<T>(itemMessage, channelCallbacks.SuccessCallback, jsonPluggableLibrary);
-				}
-			}
-#if (ENABLE_PUBNUB_LOGGING)
-            else {
-                StringBuilder sbChannelEntity = new StringBuilder();
-                foreach( ChannelEntity channelEntity in channelEntities){
-                    sbChannelEntity.AppendFormat("ChannelEntity : {0} cg?={1} ispres?={2}", channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName,
-                        channelEntity.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup.ToString(),
-                        channelEntity.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel.ToString()
-                    );
-                }
-                LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, FindChannelEntityAndCallback: ChannelEntity : null ci.name {1} \nChannelEntities: \n {2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(),
-                    ci.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, sbChannelEntity.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-            }
-#endif
-
-		}
-
-		internal static void ResponseToUserCallbackForSubscribeV2<T>(List<SubscribeMessage> subscribeMessages, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
-			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
-		{
-			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, In ResponseToUserCallbackForSubscribeV2", DateTime.Now.ToString()
-				), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-			foreach (SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage in subscribeMessages)
-			{
-				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, ResponseToUserCallbackForSubscribeV2:\n SubscribeMessage:\n" +
-					"shard : {1},\n" +
-					"subscriptionMatch: {2},\n" +
-					"channel: {3},\n" +
-					"payload: {4},\n" +
-					"flags: {5},\n" +
-					"issuingClientId: {6},\n" +
-					"subscribeKey: {7},\n" +
-					"sequenceNumber: {8},\n" +
-					"originatingTimetoken tt: {9},\n" +
-					"originatingTimetoken region: {10},\n" +
-					"publishMetadata tt: {11},\n" +
-					"publishMetadata region: {12},\n" +
-					"userMetadata {13} \n",
-					DateTime.Now.ToString(),
-					subscribeMessage.Shard,
-					subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch,
-					subscribeMessage.Channel,
-					subscribeMessage.Payload.ToString(),
-					subscribeMessage.Flags,
-					subscribeMessage.IssuingClientId,
-					subscribeMessage.SubscribeKey,
-					subscribeMessage.SequenceNumber,
-					(subscribeMessage.OriginatingTimetoken != null) ? subscribeMessage.OriginatingTimetoken.Timetoken.ToString() : "",
-					(subscribeMessage.OriginatingTimetoken != null) ? subscribeMessage.OriginatingTimetoken.Region : "",
-					(subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata.Timetoken.ToString() : "",
-					(subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata.Region : "",
-					(subscribeMessage.UserMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.UserMetadata.ToString() : "null"),
-					LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-				bool isPresenceChannel = Utility.IsPresenceChannel(subscribeMessage.Channel);
-				if (string.IsNullOrEmpty(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch) || subscribeMessage.Channel.Equals(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch))
-				{
-					//channel
-
-					ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity(subscribeMessage.Channel, false, isPresenceChannel);
-					FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(subscribeMessage, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, ci);
-				}
-				else if (subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch.Contains(".*") && isPresenceChannel)
-				{
-					//wildcard presence channel
-
-					ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch, false, false);
-					FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(subscribeMessage, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, ci);
-				}
-				else if (subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch.Contains(".*"))
-				{
-					//wildcard channel
-					ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch, false, isPresenceChannel);
-					FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(subscribeMessage, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, ci);
-
-				}
-				else
-				{
-					ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch, true, isPresenceChannel);
-					FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(subscribeMessage, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, ci);
-
-					//ce will be the cg and subscriptionMatch will have the cg name
-				}
-
-			}
-		}
-
-		internal static void ResponseToUserCallback<T>(List<object> result, RequestState<T> asynchRequestState, string cipherKey,
-			IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
-		{
-			switch (asynchRequestState.RespType)
-			{
-				case ResponseType.Leave:
-					//No response to callback
-					break;
-				case ResponseType.Publish:
-				case ResponseType.DetailedHistory:
-				case ResponseType.HereNow:
-				case ResponseType.GlobalHereNow:
-				case ResponseType.WhereNow:
-				case ResponseType.GrantAccess:
-				case ResponseType.AuditAccess:
-				case ResponseType.RevokeAccess:
-				case ResponseType.GetUserState:
-				case ResponseType.SetUserState:
-				case ResponseType.Time:
-				case ResponseType.PushRegister:
-				case ResponseType.PushRemove:
-				case ResponseType.PushGet:
-				case ResponseType.PushUnregister:
-				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAdd:
-				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRemove:
-				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGet:
-				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGrantAccess:
-				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAuditAccess:
-				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRevokeAccess:
-
-					PubnubCallbacks.SendCallbacks<T>(jsonPluggableLibrary, asynchRequestState, result, CallbackType.Success, false);
-					break;
-				default:
-					break;
-			}
-		}
-
-		internal static void ResponseToConnectCallback<T>(RequestState<T> asynchRequestState,
-			 IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, IDependencyProvider provider)
-		{
-			//Check callback exists and make sure previous timetoken = 0
-			if (asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities != null)
-			{
-				bool updateIsAwaitingConnectCallback = false;
-				for (int i = 0; i < asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities.Count; i++)
-				{
-					ChannelEntity channelEntity = asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities[i];
-					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, Check ResponseToConnectCallback {1}",
-						DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-					if (channelEntity.ChannelParams.IsAwaitingConnectCallback)
-					{
-						updateIsAwaitingConnectCallback = true;
-						LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, ResponseToConnectCallback IsAwaitingConnectCallback {1}",
-							DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-
-						switch (asynchRequestState.RespType)
-						{
-							case ResponseType.SubscribeV2:
-								var connectResult = Helpers.CreateJsonResponse("Connected", channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, jsonPluggableLibrary);
-								PubnubCallbacks.SendCallbacks<T>(jsonPluggableLibrary, channelEntity, connectResult,
-									CallbackType.Connect, false);
-
-								break;
-							case ResponseType.PresenceV2:
-								var connectResult2 = Helpers.CreateJsonResponse("Presence Connected",
-													 channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName.Replace(Utility.PresenceChannelSuffix, ""), jsonPluggableLibrary);
-								PubnubCallbacks.SendCallbacks<T>(jsonPluggableLibrary, channelEntity, connectResult2,
-									CallbackType.Connect, false);
-								break;
-							default:
-								break;
-						}
-					}
-				}
-				if (updateIsAwaitingConnectCallback)
-				{
-					Subscription.GetSubscription(provider).UpdateIsAwaitingConnectCallbacksOfEntity(asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities, false);
-				}
-			}
-
-		}
-
-		internal static List<object> CreateJsonResponse(string message, string channel, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
-		{
-			string jsonString = "";
-			List<object> connectResult = new List<object>();
-			jsonString = string.Format("[1, \"{0}\"]", message);
-			connectResult = jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToListOfObject(jsonString);
-			connectResult.Add(channel);
-
-			return connectResult;
-		}
-
-		internal static PubnubErrorCode GetTimeOutErrorCode(ResponseType responseType)
-		{
-			switch (responseType)
-			{
-				case ResponseType.AuditAccess:
-				case ResponseType.GrantAccess:
-				case ResponseType.RevokeAccess:
-				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGrantAccess:
-				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAuditAccess:
-				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRevokeAccess:
-					return PubnubErrorCode.PAMAccessOperationTimeout;
-				case ResponseType.DetailedHistory:
-				case ResponseType.History:
-					return PubnubErrorCode.DetailedHistoryOperationTimeout;
-				case ResponseType.GetUserState:
-					return PubnubErrorCode.GetUserStateTimeout;
-				case ResponseType.GlobalHereNow:
-					return PubnubErrorCode.GlobalHereNowOperationTimeout;
-				case ResponseType.SetUserState:
-					return PubnubErrorCode.SetUserStateTimeout;
-				case ResponseType.HereNow:
-					return PubnubErrorCode.HereNowOperationTimeout;
-				case ResponseType.Publish:
-					return PubnubErrorCode.PublishOperationTimeout;
-				case ResponseType.Time:
-					return PubnubErrorCode.TimeOperationTimeout;
-				case ResponseType.WhereNow:
-					return PubnubErrorCode.WhereNowOperationTimeout;
-				default:
-					/*
-					 * ResponseType.Presence:
-					 * ResponseType.PresenceUnsubscribe:
-					 * ResponseType.Leave:
-					 * ResponseType.Subscribe:
-					 * ResponseType.Unsubscribe:
-					 * ResponseType.Heartbeat:
-					 * ResponseType.PresenceHeartbeat:
-					 * ResponseType.ChannelGroupAdd
-					 * ResponseType.ChannelGroupRemove
-					 * ResponseType.ChannelGroupGet
-					 */
-					return PubnubErrorCode.OperationTimeout;
-			}
-		}
-
-		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(Exception ex,
-			RequestState<T> requestState, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, PubnubErrorCode errorCode, PubnubErrorSeverity severity)
-		{
-
-			if (errorCode.Equals(PubnubErrorCode.None))
-			{
-				errorCode = PubnubErrorCodeHelper.GetErrorType(ex);
-			}
-
-			int statusCode = (int)errorCode;
-			string errorDescription = PubnubErrorCodeDescription.GetStatusCodeDescription(errorCode);
-			PubnubWebRequest request = null;
-			PubnubWebResponse response = null;
-
-			if (requestState != null)
-			{
-				request = requestState.Request;
-				response = requestState.Response;
-				if (channelEntities == null && requestState.ChannelEntities != null)
-				{
-					channelEntities = requestState.ChannelEntities;
-				}
-			}
-
-			PubnubClientError error = new PubnubClientError(statusCode, severity, true, ex.Message, ex,
-				PubnubMessageSource.Client, request, response, errorDescription,
-				channelEntities);
-
-			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, PubnubClientError = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), error.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-			return error;
-		}
-
-		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(string message,
-			RequestState<T> requestState, PubnubErrorCode errorCode, PubnubErrorSeverity severity, string channels, string channelGroups)
-		{
-
-			int statusCode = (int)errorCode;
-			string errorDescription = PubnubErrorCodeDescription.GetStatusCodeDescription(errorCode);
-
-			PubnubWebRequest request = null;
-			PubnubWebResponse response = null;
-
-			if (requestState != null)
-			{
-				request = requestState.Request;
-				response = requestState.Response;
-			}
-
-			PubnubClientError error = new PubnubClientError(statusCode, severity, message, PubnubMessageSource.Client,
-				request, response, errorDescription,
-				channels, channelGroups
-			);
-
-			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, PubnubClientError 2 = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), error.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-			return error;
-		}
-
-		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(Exception ex,
-			RequestState<T> requestState, PubnubErrorCode errorCode, PubnubErrorSeverity severity, string channels, string channelGroups)
-		{
-
-			int statusCode = (int)errorCode;
-			string errorDescription = PubnubErrorCodeDescription.GetStatusCodeDescription(errorCode);
-
-			PubnubWebRequest request = null;
-			PubnubWebResponse response = null;
-
-			if (requestState != null)
-			{
-				request = requestState.Request;
-				response = requestState.Response;
-			}
-
-			PubnubClientError error = new PubnubClientError(statusCode, severity, ex.Message, PubnubMessageSource.Client,
-				request, response, errorDescription,
-				channels, channelGroups
-			);
-
-			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, PubnubClientError 3 = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), error.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-			return error;
-		}
-
-		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(string message,
-			RequestState<T> requestState, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, PubnubErrorCode errorCode, PubnubErrorSeverity severity)
-		{
-
-			int statusCode = (int)errorCode;
-			string errorDescription = PubnubErrorCodeDescription.GetStatusCodeDescription(errorCode);
-
-			PubnubWebRequest request = null;
-			PubnubWebResponse response = null;
-
-			if (requestState != null)
-			{
-				request = requestState.Request;
-				response = requestState.Response;
-			}
-
-			PubnubClientError error = new PubnubClientError(statusCode, severity, message, PubnubMessageSource.Client,
-				request, response, errorDescription,
-				channelEntities
-			);
-
-			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, PubnubClientError 4 = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), error.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
-			return error;
-		}
-
-		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(WebException ex,
-			RequestState<T> requestState, string channel, PubnubErrorSeverity severity)
-		{
-
-			PubnubErrorCode errorCode = PubnubErrorCodeHelper.GetErrorType(ex.Status, ex.Message);
-			return CreatePubnubClientError<T>(ex, requestState, null, errorCode, severity);
-		}
-
-		#endregion
-
-	}
-}
+using Beamable.Common.Dependencies;
+using System;
+using System.Collections;
+using System.Collections.Generic;
+using System.Linq;
+using System.Net;
+using System.Text;
+
+namespace PubNubMessaging.Core
+{
+	public sealed class Counter
+	{
+		private uint current = 0;
+		private object syncRoot;
+
+		public Counter()
+		{
+			syncRoot = new Object();
+			current = 0;
+		}
+
+		public uint NextValue()
+		{
+			lock (syncRoot)
+			{
+				this.current++;
+			}
+			return this.current;
+		}
+
+		public void Reset()
+		{
+			lock (syncRoot)
+			{
+				this.current = 0;
+			}
+		}
+	}
+
+	internal static class Helpers
+	{
+		#region "Helpers"
+		internal static TimetokenMetadata CreateTimetokenMetadata(object timeTokenDataObject, string whichTT)
+		{
+			IDictionary<string, object> timeTokenData = (IDictionary<string, object>)timeTokenDataObject;
+			TimetokenMetadata timetokenMetadata = new TimetokenMetadata(Utility.CheckKeyAndParseLong(timeTokenData, whichTT, "t"),
+				timeTokenData["r"].ToString());
+
+			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, TimetokenMetadata: {1} \nTimetoken: {2} \nRegion: {3}",
+				DateTime.Now.ToString(), whichTT, timetokenMetadata.Timetoken, timetokenMetadata.Region),
+				LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+			return timetokenMetadata;
+		}
+
+		internal static void AddToSubscribeMessageList(object dictObject, ref List<SubscribeMessage> subscribeMessages)
+		{
+			var dict = dictObject as IDictionary<string, object>;
+			if ((dict != null) && (dict.Count > 1))
+			{
+				string shard = (dict.ContainsKey("a")) ? dict["a"].ToString() : "";
+				string subscriptionMatch = (dict.ContainsKey("b")) ? dict["b"].ToString() : "";
+				string channel = (dict.ContainsKey("c")) ? dict["c"].ToString() : "";
+				object payload = (dict.ContainsKey("d")) ? (object)dict["d"] : null;
+				string flags = (dict.ContainsKey("f")) ? dict["f"].ToString() : "";
+				string issuingClientId = (dict.ContainsKey("i")) ? dict["i"].ToString() : "";
+				string subscribeKey = (dict.ContainsKey("k")) ? dict["k"].ToString() : "";
+				long sequenceNumber = Utility.CheckKeyAndParseLong(dict, "sequenceNumber", "s");
+
+				TimetokenMetadata originatingTimetoken = (dict.ContainsKey("o")) ? CreateTimetokenMetadata(dict["o"], "Originating TT: ") : null;
+				TimetokenMetadata publishMetadata = (dict.ContainsKey("p")) ? CreateTimetokenMetadata(dict["p"], "Publish TT: ") : null;
+				object userMetadata = (dict.ContainsKey("u")) ? (object)dict["u"] : null;
+
+				SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage = new SubscribeMessage(
+					shard,
+					subscriptionMatch,
+					channel,
+					payload,
+					flags,
+					issuingClientId,
+					subscribeKey,
+					sequenceNumber,
+					originatingTimetoken,
+					publishMetadata,
+					userMetadata
+				);
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, AddToSubscribeMessageList: \n" +
+					"shard : {1},\n" +
+					"subscriptionMatch: {2},\n" +
+					"channel: {3},\n" +
+					"payload: {4},\n" +
+					"flags: {5},\n" +
+					"issuingClientId: {6},\n" +
+					"subscribeKey: {7},\n" +
+					"sequenceNumber: {8},\n" +
+					"originatingTimetoken tt: {9},\n" +
+					"originatingTimetoken region: {10},\n" +
+					"publishMetadata tt: {11},\n" +
+					"publishMetadata region: {12},\n" +
+					"userMetadata {13} \n",
+					DateTime.Now.ToString(),
+					shard,
+					subscriptionMatch,
+					channel,
+					payload.ToString(),
+					flags,
+					issuingClientId,
+					subscribeKey,
+					sequenceNumber,
+					(originatingTimetoken != null) ? originatingTimetoken.Timetoken.ToString() : "",
+					(originatingTimetoken != null) ? originatingTimetoken.Region : "",
+					(publishMetadata != null) ? publishMetadata.Timetoken.ToString() : "",
+					(publishMetadata != null) ? publishMetadata.Region : "",
+					(userMetadata != null) ? userMetadata.ToString() : "null"),
+					LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+
+				subscribeMessages.Add(subscribeMessage);
+			}
+			else
+			{
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, AddToSubscribeMessageList: CreateListOfSubscribeMessage create " +
+					"SubscribeMessage failed. dictObject type: {1}, dict type : {2}",
+					DateTime.Now.ToString(), dictObject.ToString(), dict.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+			}
+
+		}
+
+		internal static List<SubscribeMessage> CreateListOfSubscribeMessage(object message)
+		{
+			List<SubscribeMessage> subscribeMessages = new List<SubscribeMessage>();
+			if (message != null)
+			{
+				//JSONFx
+				object[] messages = message as object[];
+
+				if (messages != null)
+				{
+					var myObjectArray = (from item in messages
+										 select item as object).ToArray();
+					if ((myObjectArray != null) && (myObjectArray.Length > 0))
+					{
+
+						foreach (object dictObject in myObjectArray)
+						{
+							AddToSubscribeMessageList(dictObject, ref subscribeMessages);
+						}
+					}
+				}
+				else
+				{
+					//MiniJSON
+					List<object> messageList = message as List<object>;
+					if ((messageList != null) && messageList.Count > 0)
+					{
+						foreach (object dictObject in messageList)
+						{
+							AddToSubscribeMessageList(dictObject, ref subscribeMessages);
+						}
+					}
+				}
+			}
+			else
+			{
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateListOfSubscribeMessage: no messages ",
+					DateTime.Now.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+			}
+
+			return subscribeMessages;
+		}
+
+		internal static string BuildJsonUserState(IDictionary<string, object> userStateDictionary)
+		{
+			StringBuilder jsonStateBuilder = new StringBuilder();
+
+			if (userStateDictionary != null)
+			{
+				string[] userStateKeys = userStateDictionary.Keys.ToArray<string>();
+
+				for (int keyIndex = 0; keyIndex < userStateKeys.Length; keyIndex++)
+				{
+					string useStateKey = userStateKeys[keyIndex];
+					object userStateValue = userStateDictionary[useStateKey];
+					if (userStateValue == null)
+					{
+						jsonStateBuilder.AppendFormat("\"{0}\":{1}", useStateKey, string.Format("\"{0}\"", "null"));
+					}
+					else
+					{
+						jsonStateBuilder.AppendFormat("\"{0}\":{1}", useStateKey, (userStateValue.GetType().ToString() == "System.String") ? string.Format("\"{0}\"", userStateValue) : userStateValue);
+					}
+					if (keyIndex < userStateKeys.Length - 1)
+					{
+						jsonStateBuilder.Append(",");
+					}
+				}
+			}
+
+			return jsonStateBuilder.ToString();
+		}
+
+		internal static string BuildJsonUserState(List<ChannelEntity> ce)
+		{
+			string retJsonUserState = "";
+
+			StringBuilder jsonStateBuilder = new StringBuilder();
+
+			if (ce != null)
+			{
+				foreach (ChannelEntity c in ce)
+				{
+					string currentJsonState = BuildJsonUserState(c.ChannelParams.UserState);
+					if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(currentJsonState))
+					{
+						currentJsonState = string.Format("\"{0}\":{{{1}}}", c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, currentJsonState);
+						if (jsonStateBuilder.Length > 0)
+						{
+							jsonStateBuilder.Append(",");
+						}
+						jsonStateBuilder.Append(currentJsonState);
+					}
+				}
+
+				if (jsonStateBuilder.Length > 0)
+				{
+					retJsonUserState = string.Format("{{{0}}}", jsonStateBuilder.ToString());
+				}
+			}
+
+			return retJsonUserState;
+		}
+
+		internal static string GetNamesFromChannelEntities(List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, bool isChannelGroup)
+		{
+
+			StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder();
+			if (channelEntities != null)
+			{
+				int count = 0;
+				foreach (ChannelEntity c in channelEntities)
+				{
+					if (isChannelGroup && c.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup)
+					{
+						if (count > 0)
+						{
+							sb.Append(",");
+						}
+
+						sb.Append(c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName);
+						count++;
+					}
+					else if (!isChannelGroup && !c.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup)
+					{
+						if (count > 0)
+						{
+							sb.Append(",");
+						}
+
+						sb.Append(c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName);
+						count++;
+					}
+				}
+			}
+			return sb.ToString();
+		}
+
+		internal static string GetNamesFromChannelEntities(List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities)
+		{
+			StringBuilder sbCh = new StringBuilder();
+			StringBuilder sbChGrp = new StringBuilder();
+			if (channelEntities != null)
+			{
+				int countCh = 0;
+				int countChGrp = 0;
+				foreach (ChannelEntity c in channelEntities)
+				{
+					if (c.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup)
+					{
+						if (countChGrp > 0)
+						{
+							sbChGrp.Append(",");
+						}
+
+						sbChGrp.Append(c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName);
+						countChGrp++;
+					}
+					else
+					{
+						if (countCh > 0)
+						{
+							sbCh.Append(",");
+						}
+
+						sbCh.Append(c.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName);
+						countCh++;
+					}
+
+				}
+			}
+			return string.Format("channel(s) = {0} and channelGroups(s) = {1}", sbCh.ToString(), sbChGrp.ToString());
+		}
+
+		internal static bool UpdateOrAddUserStateOfEntity<T>(string channel, bool isChannelGroup,
+			IDictionary<string, object> userState, bool edit,
+			Action<T> userCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
+			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, ref List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, IDependencyProvider provider)
+		{
+			ChannelEntity ce = CreateChannelEntity<T>(channel, false, isChannelGroup,
+				userState, userCallback, null, errorCallback, null, null);
+			bool stateChanged = Subscription.GetSubscription(provider).UpdateOrAddUserStateOfEntity(ref ce, userState, edit);
+			if (!stateChanged)
+			{
+				string message = "No change in User State";
+
+				PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<T>(ce, message,
+					PubnubErrorCode.UserStateUnchanged, PubnubErrorSeverity.Info, errorLevel);
+			}
+			else
+			{
+				channelEntities.Add(ce);
+			}
+			return stateChanged;
+		}
+
+		internal static bool CheckAndAddExistingUserState<T>(string channel, string channelGroup, IDictionary<string, object> userState,
+			Action<T> userCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
+			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, bool edit,
+			out string returnUserState, out List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, IDependencyProvider provider
+		)
+		{
+			string[] channels = channel.Trim().Split(',');
+			string[] channelGroups = channelGroup.Trim().Split(',');
+			bool stateChanged = false;
+			channelEntities = new List<ChannelEntity>();
+
+			foreach (string ch in channels)
+			{
+				if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(ch))
+				{
+					bool changeState = UpdateOrAddUserStateOfEntity<T>(ch, false, userState, edit,
+						userCallback, errorCallback, errorLevel, ref channelEntities, provider);
+					if (changeState && !stateChanged)
+					{
+						stateChanged = true;
+					}
+				}
+			}
+
+			foreach (string ch in channelGroups)
+			{
+				if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(ch))
+				{
+					bool changeState = UpdateOrAddUserStateOfEntity<T>(ch, true, userState, edit,
+						userCallback, errorCallback, errorLevel, ref channelEntities, provider);
+					if (changeState && !stateChanged)
+					{
+						stateChanged = true;
+					}
+				}
+			}
+
+			returnUserState = BuildJsonUserState(channelEntities);
+
+			return stateChanged;
+		}
+
+		internal static ChannelEntity CreateChannelEntity<T>(string channelOrChannelGroupName2,
+			bool isAwaitingConnectCallback,
+			bool isChannelGroup, IDictionary<string, object> userState,
+			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback,
+			Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback, Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback
+		)
+		{
+			string channelOrChannelGroupName = channelOrChannelGroupName2.Trim();
+			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntity: channelOrChannelGroupName {1}, {2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(),
+				channelOrChannelGroupName.ToString(), channelOrChannelGroupName2.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+			if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(channelOrChannelGroupName))
+			{
+				ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity();
+				ci.ChannelOrChannelGroupName = channelOrChannelGroupName;
+				ci.IsPresenceChannel = Utility.IsPresenceChannel(channelOrChannelGroupName);
+				ci.IsChannelGroup = isChannelGroup;
+
+				ChannelParameters cp = new ChannelParameters();
+				cp.IsAwaitingConnectCallback = isAwaitingConnectCallback;
+				cp.UserState = userState;
+				cp.TypeParameterType = typeof(T);
+
+				cp.Callbacks = PubnubCallbacks.GetPubnubChannelCallback<T>(userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback,
+					disconnectCallback, wildcardPresenceCallback);
+
+				ChannelEntity ce = new ChannelEntity(ci, cp);
+
+				return ce;
+			}
+			else
+			{
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntity: channelOrChannelGroupName empty, is channel group {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), isChannelGroup.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+				return null;
+			}
+		}
+
+		internal static List<ChannelEntity> CreateChannelEntity<T>(string[] channelOrChannelGroupNames, bool isAwaitingConnectCallback,
+			bool isChannelGroup, IDictionary<string, object> userState,
+			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback,
+			Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback, Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback
+		)
+		{
+			List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities = null;
+			if (channelOrChannelGroupNames != null)
+			{
+				channelEntities = new List<ChannelEntity>();
+				foreach (string ch in channelOrChannelGroupNames)
+				{
+					ChannelEntity chEntity = CreateChannelEntity<T>(ch, isAwaitingConnectCallback, isChannelGroup, userState,
+						userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback, disconnectCallback, wildcardPresenceCallback
+					);
+					if (chEntity != null)
+					{
+						channelEntities.Add(chEntity);
+					}
+				}
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntity 2: channelEntities={1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelEntities.Count), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+			}
+			else
+			{
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntity 2: channelOrChannelGroupNames null, is channel group {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), isChannelGroup.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+			}
+
+			return channelEntities;
+		}
+
+		internal static IEnumerable<string> GetDuplicates(string[]
+			rawChannels)
+		{
+			var results = from string a in rawChannels
+						  group a by a into g
+						  where g.Count() > 1
+						  select g;
+			foreach (var group in results)
+				foreach (var item in group)
+					yield return item;
+		}
+
+		[System.Diagnostics.Conditional("SPEW_ALL")]
+		[System.Diagnostics.Conditional("SPEW_NOTIFICATION")]
+		internal static void LogChannelEntitiesDictionary(Subscription subscription)
+		{
+			StringBuilder sbLogs = new StringBuilder();
+			foreach (var ci in subscription.ChannelEntitiesDictionary)
+			{
+				sbLogs.AppendFormat("\nChannelEntitiesDictionary \nChannelOrChannelGroupName:{0} \nIsChannelGroup:{1} \nIsPresenceChannel:{2}\n",
+					ci.Key.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, ci.Key.IsChannelGroup.ToString(), ci.Key.IsPresenceChannel.ToString()
+				);
+			}
+			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, LogChannelEntitiesDictionary: Count: {2} \n{1}",
+				DateTime.Now.ToString(), sbLogs.ToString(), subscription.ChannelEntitiesDictionary.Count), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+		}
+
+		internal static bool CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe<T>(ResponseType type, string[] rawChannels,
+			bool isChannelGroup,
+			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
+			Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback,
+			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, bool unsubscribeCheck, ref List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, IDependencyProvider provider
+			)
+		{
+			bool bReturn = false;
+			for (int index = 0; index < rawChannels.Length; index++)
+			{
+				string channelName = rawChannels[index].Trim();
+
+				if (channelName.Length > 0)
+				{
+					if ((type == ResponseType.PresenceV2)
+						|| (type == ResponseType.PresenceUnsubscribe))
+					{
+						channelName = string.Format("{0}{1}", channelName, Utility.PresenceChannelSuffix);
+					}
+
+					Helpers.LogChannelEntitiesDictionary(Subscription.GetSubscription(provider));
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe: channel={1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelName), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+					//create channelEntity
+					ChannelEntity ce = Helpers.CreateChannelEntity(channelName, true, isChannelGroup, null,
+						userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback, disconnectCallback, wildcardPresenceCallback);
+
+					bool channelIsSubscribed = false;
+					if (Subscription.GetSubscription(provider).ChannelEntitiesDictionary.ContainsKey(ce.ChannelID))
+					{
+						channelIsSubscribed = Subscription.GetSubscription(provider).ChannelEntitiesDictionary[ce.ChannelID].IsSubscribed;
+					}
+
+					if (unsubscribeCheck)
+					{
+						if (!channelIsSubscribed)
+						{
+							string message = string.Format("{0}Channel Not Subscribed", (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? "Presence " : "");
+							PubnubErrorCode errorType = (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? PubnubErrorCode.NotPresenceSubscribed : PubnubErrorCode.NotSubscribed;
+							LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe: channel={1} response={2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelName, message), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+							PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<T>(ce, message,
+								errorType, PubnubErrorSeverity.Info, errorLevel);
+						}
+						else
+						{
+							channelEntities.Add(ce);
+							bReturn = true;
+						}
+					}
+					else
+					{
+						if (channelIsSubscribed)
+						{
+							string message = string.Format("{0}Already subscribed", (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? "Presence " : "");
+							PubnubErrorCode errorType = (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? PubnubErrorCode.AlreadyPresenceSubscribed : PubnubErrorCode.AlreadySubscribed;
+							PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<T>(ce, message,
+								errorType, PubnubErrorSeverity.Info, errorLevel);
+							LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe: channel={1} response={2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelName, message), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+						}
+						else
+						{
+							channelEntities.Add(ce);
+							bReturn = true;
+						}
+					}
+				}
+				else
+				{
+					string message = "Invalid Channel Name";
+					if (isChannelGroup)
+					{
+						message = "Invalid Channel Group Name";
+					}
+
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe: channel={1} response={2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelName, message),
+						LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+				}
+			}
+			return bReturn;
+		}
+
+		internal static bool RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon<T>(ResponseType type,
+			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
+			Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback,
+			string[] channelsOrChannelGroups, bool isChannelGroup,
+			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, bool unsubscribeCheck, ref List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
+			IDependencyProvider provider)
+		{
+			bool bReturn = false;
+			if (channelsOrChannelGroups.Length > 0)
+			{
+
+				channelsOrChannelGroups = channelsOrChannelGroups.Where(x => !string.IsNullOrEmpty(x)).ToArray();
+
+				if (channelsOrChannelGroups.Length != channelsOrChannelGroups.Distinct().Count())
+				{
+					channelsOrChannelGroups = channelsOrChannelGroups.Distinct().ToArray();
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon: distinct channelsOrChannelGroups len={1}, channelsOrChannelGroups = {2}",
+						DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelsOrChannelGroups.Length, string.Join(",", channelsOrChannelGroups)),
+						LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+					string channel = string.Join(",", GetDuplicates(channelsOrChannelGroups).Distinct<string>().ToArray<string>());
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon: duplicates channelsOrChannelGroups {1}",
+						DateTime.Now.ToString(), channel),
+						LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+					string message = string.Format("Detected and removed duplicate channels {0}", channel);
+
+					PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<T>(message, errorCallback, PubnubErrorCode.DuplicateChannel,
+						PubnubErrorSeverity.Info, errorLevel);
+				}
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon: channelsOrChannelGroups len={1}, channelsOrChannelGroups = {2}",
+					DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelsOrChannelGroups.Length, string.Join(",", channelsOrChannelGroups)),
+					LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+				bReturn = CreateChannelEntityAndAddToSubscribe<T>(type, channelsOrChannelGroups, isChannelGroup,
+					userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback, wildcardPresenceCallback, disconnectCallback, errorLevel, unsubscribeCheck, ref channelEntities, provider);
+			}
+			else
+			{
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon: channelsOrChannelGroups len <=0",
+					DateTime.Now.ToString()),
+					LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+			}
+			return bReturn;
+		}
+
+		internal static bool RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannels<T>(ResponseType type,
+			Action<T> userCallback, Action<T> connectCallback, Action<PubnubClientError> errorCallback,
+			Action<T> wildcardPresenceCallback, Action<T> disconnectCallback,
+			string[] rawChannels, string[] rawChannelGroups,
+			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, bool unsubscribeCheck, out List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
+			IDependencyProvider provider)
+		{
+			bool bReturn = false;
+			bool channelAdded = false;
+			bool channelGroupAdded = false;
+			channelEntities = new List<ChannelEntity>();
+			if (rawChannels != null && rawChannels.Length > 0)
+			{
+				channelAdded = RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon<T>(type, userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback,
+					wildcardPresenceCallback, disconnectCallback, rawChannels, false, errorLevel, unsubscribeCheck, ref channelEntities, provider
+				);
+			}
+
+			if (rawChannelGroups != null && rawChannelGroups.Length > 0)
+			{
+				channelGroupAdded = RemoveDuplicatesCheckAlreadySubscribedAndGetChannelsCommon<T>(type, userCallback, connectCallback, errorCallback,
+					wildcardPresenceCallback, disconnectCallback, rawChannelGroups, true, errorLevel, unsubscribeCheck, ref channelEntities, provider
+				);
+			}
+
+			bReturn = channelAdded | channelGroupAdded;
+
+			return bReturn;
+		}
+
+		internal static void ProcessResponseCallbacksV2<T>(ref SubscribeEnvelope resultSubscribeEnvelope, RequestState<T> asynchRequestState,
+			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, IDependencyProvider provider)
+		{
+
+			if (resultSubscribeEnvelope != null)
+			{
+				Helpers.ResponseToConnectCallback<T>(asynchRequestState, jsonPluggableLibrary, provider);
+				if (resultSubscribeEnvelope.Messages != null)
+				{
+					ResponseToUserCallbackForSubscribeV2<T>(resultSubscribeEnvelope.Messages, asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities,
+						cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary);
+				}
+				else
+				{
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, ProcessResponseCallbacksV2: resultSubscribeEnvelope.Messages null",
+						DateTime.Now.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelError);
+				}
+
+			}
+		}
+
+		internal static void ProcessResponseCallbacks<T>(ref List<object> result, RequestState<T> asynchRequestState,
+			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
+		{
+			if (result != null && result.Count >= 1)
+			{
+				Helpers.ResponseToUserCallback<T>(result, asynchRequestState, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary);
+			}
+		}
+		#endregion
+
+		#region "Encoding and Crypto"
+
+		internal static string JsonEncodePublishMsg(object originalMessage, string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
+		{
+			string message = jsonPluggableLibrary.SerializeToJsonString(originalMessage);
+
+			if (cipherKey.Length > 0)
+			{
+				PubnubCrypto aes = new PubnubCrypto(cipherKey);
+				string encryptMessage = aes.Encrypt(message);
+				message = jsonPluggableLibrary.SerializeToJsonString(encryptMessage);
+			}
+
+			return message;
+		}
+
+		internal static object DecodeMessage(PubnubCrypto aes, object element, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
+			IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary,
+			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel)
+		{
+			string decryptMessage = "";
+			try
+			{
+				decryptMessage = aes.Decrypt(element.ToString());
+			}
+			catch (Exception ex)
+			{
+				decryptMessage = "**DECRYPT ERROR**";
+				PubnubCallbacks.CallErrorCallback<object>(ex, channelEntities, PubnubErrorCode.None,
+					PubnubErrorSeverity.Critical, errorLevel);
+			}
+			object decodeMessage = (decryptMessage == "**DECRYPT ERROR**") ? decryptMessage : jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToObject(decryptMessage);
+			return decodeMessage;
+		}
+
+		internal static List<object> DecryptCipheredMessage(List<object> message, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
+			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary,
+			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel)
+		{
+			List<object> returnMessage = new List<object>();
+
+			PubnubCrypto aes = new PubnubCrypto(cipherKey);
+			var myObjectArray = (from item in message
+								 select item as object).ToArray();
+			IEnumerable enumerable = myObjectArray[0] as IEnumerable;
+
+			if (enumerable != null)
+			{
+				List<object> receivedMsg = new List<object>();
+				foreach (object element in enumerable)
+				{
+					receivedMsg.Add(DecodeMessage(aes, element, channelEntities, jsonPluggableLibrary, errorLevel));
+				}
+				returnMessage.Add(receivedMsg);
+			}
+			for (int index = 1; index < myObjectArray.Length; index++)
+			{
+				returnMessage.Add(myObjectArray[index]);
+			}
+			return returnMessage;
+		}
+
+		internal static List<object> DecryptNonCipheredMessage(List<object> message)
+		{
+			List<object> returnMessage = new List<object>();
+			var myObjectArray = (from item in message
+								 select item as object).ToArray();
+			IEnumerable enumerable = myObjectArray[0] as IEnumerable;
+			if (enumerable != null)
+			{
+				List<object> receivedMessage = new List<object>();
+				foreach (object element in enumerable)
+				{
+					receivedMessage.Add(element);
+				}
+				returnMessage.Add(receivedMessage);
+			}
+			for (int index = 1; index < myObjectArray.Length; index++)
+			{
+				returnMessage.Add(myObjectArray[index]);
+			}
+			return returnMessage;
+		}
+
+		internal static List<object> DecodeDecryptLoop(List<object> message, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
+			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary,
+			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel)
+		{
+			if (cipherKey.Length > 0)
+			{
+				return DecryptCipheredMessage(message, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, errorLevel);
+			}
+			else
+			{
+				return DecryptNonCipheredMessage(message);
+			}
+		}
+
+		#endregion
+
+		#region "Other Methods"
+
+		internal static void CheckSubscribedChannelsAndSendCallbacks<T>(List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
+			ResponseType type, int pubnubNetworkCheckRetries, PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel)
+		{
+			if (channelEntities != null && channelEntities.Count > 0)
+			{
+				foreach (ChannelEntity channelEntity in channelEntities)
+				{
+					string message = string.Format("Unsubscribed after {0} failed retries", pubnubNetworkCheckRetries); ;
+					PubnubErrorCode pnErrorCode = PubnubErrorCode.UnsubscribedAfterMaxRetries;
+
+					if (channelEntity.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel)
+					{
+						message = string.Format("Presence Unsubscribed after {0} failed retries", pubnubNetworkCheckRetries);
+						pnErrorCode = PubnubErrorCode.PresenceUnsubscribedAfterMaxRetries;
+					}
+
+					//TODO: Recheck
+					PubnubClientError error = Helpers.CreatePubnubClientError<T>(message, null, channelEntities, pnErrorCode,
+						PubnubErrorSeverity.Critical);
+
+					PubnubCallbacks.FireErrorCallback<T>(channelEntity,
+						errorLevel, error);
+
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, CheckSubscribedChannelsAndSendCallbacks: {1} Subscribe JSON network error response={2}",
+						DateTime.Now.ToString(), (channelEntity.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel) ? "Presence" : "", message), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+				}
+			}
+		}
+
+		public static void WrapResultBasedOnResponseType<T>(RequestState<T> pubnubRequestState, string jsonString,
+			IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, string cipherKey, ref List<object> result)
+		{
+			try
+			{
+				string multiChannel = Helpers.GetNamesFromChannelEntities(pubnubRequestState.ChannelEntities, false);
+				string multiChannelGroup = Helpers.GetNamesFromChannelEntities(pubnubRequestState.ChannelEntities, true);
+				if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(jsonString))
+				{
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, WrapResultBasedOnResponseType: jsonString = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), jsonString), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+					object deSerializedResult = jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToObject(jsonString);
+					List<object> result1 = ((IEnumerable)deSerializedResult).Cast<object>().ToList();
+
+					if (result1 != null && result1.Count > 0)
+					{
+						result = result1;
+					}
+
+					switch (pubnubRequestState.RespType)
+					{
+						case ResponseType.DetailedHistory:
+							result = DecodeDecryptLoop(result, pubnubRequestState.ChannelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, errorLevel);
+							result.Add(multiChannel);
+							break;
+						case ResponseType.Time:
+							Int64[] c = deSerializedResult as Int64[];
+							if ((c != null) && (c.Length > 0))
+							{
+								result = new List<object>();
+								result.Add(c[0]);
+							}
+							break;
+						case ResponseType.Leave:
+							if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(multiChannelGroup))
+							{
+								result.Add(multiChannelGroup);
+							}
+							if (!string.IsNullOrEmpty(multiChannel))
+							{
+								result.Add(multiChannel);
+							}
+							break;
+						case ResponseType.SubscribeV2:
+						case ResponseType.PresenceV2:
+							break;
+						case ResponseType.Publish:
+						case ResponseType.PushRegister:
+						case ResponseType.PushRemove:
+						case ResponseType.PushGet:
+						case ResponseType.PushUnregister:
+							result.Add(multiChannel);
+							break;
+						case ResponseType.GrantAccess:
+						case ResponseType.AuditAccess:
+						case ResponseType.RevokeAccess:
+						case ResponseType.GetUserState:
+						case ResponseType.SetUserState:
+						case ResponseType.WhereNow:
+						case ResponseType.HereNow:
+							result = DeserializeAndAddToResult(jsonString, multiChannel, jsonPluggableLibrary, true);
+							break;
+						case ResponseType.GlobalHereNow:
+							result = DeserializeAndAddToResult(jsonString, multiChannel, jsonPluggableLibrary, false);
+							break;
+						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAdd:
+						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRemove:
+						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGet:
+							result = DeserializeAndAddToResult(jsonString, multiChannel, jsonPluggableLibrary, false);
+
+							break;
+						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGrantAccess:
+						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAuditAccess:
+						case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRevokeAccess:
+							result = DeserializeAndAddToResult(jsonString, "", jsonPluggableLibrary, false);
+							result.Add(multiChannelGroup);
+							break;
+
+						default:
+							break;
+					}
+				}
+				else
+				{
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, WrapResultBasedOnResponseType: json string null ", DateTime.Now.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+				}
+			}
+			catch (Exception ex)
+			{
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, WrapResultBasedOnResponseType: exception: {1} ", DateTime.Now.ToString(), ex.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelError);
+				ProcessWrapResultBasedOnResponseTypeException<T>(pubnubRequestState, errorLevel, ex);
+			}
+		}
+
+		internal static List<object> DeserializeAndAddToResult(string jsonString, string multiChannel,
+			IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, bool addChannel)
+		{
+			IDictionary<string, object> dictionary = jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToDictionaryOfObject(jsonString);
+			List<object> result = new List<object>();
+			result.Add(dictionary);
+			if (addChannel)
+			{
+				result.Add(multiChannel);
+			}
+			return result;
+		}
+
+		internal static void ProcessWrapResultBasedOnResponseTypeException<T>(RequestState<T> pubnubRequestState,
+			PubnubErrorFilter.Level errorLevel, Exception ex)
+		{
+			if (pubnubRequestState.ChannelEntities != null)
+			{
+				if (pubnubRequestState.RespType.Equals(ResponseType.SubscribeV2) || pubnubRequestState.RespType.Equals(ResponseType.PresenceV2)
+				)
+				{
+					PubnubCallbacks.FireErrorCallbacksForAllChannels<T>(ex, pubnubRequestState, PubnubErrorSeverity.Critical,
+						PubnubErrorCode.None, errorLevel);
+				}
+				else
+				{
+					PubnubCallbacks.FireErrorCallbacksForAllChannels<T>(ex, pubnubRequestState, PubnubErrorSeverity.Critical,
+						PubnubErrorCode.None, errorLevel);
+				}
+			}
+		}
+
+		internal static void CreatePNMessageResult(SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage, out PNMessageResult messageResult)
+		{
+			long timetoken = (subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata.Timetoken : 0;
+			messageResult = new PNMessageResult(
+				subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch,
+				subscribeMessage.Channel,
+				subscribeMessage.Payload,
+				timetoken,
+				subscribeMessage.UserMetadata);
+		}
+
+		internal static void AddMessageToListV2(string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary,
+			SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage, ChannelEntity ce, out List<object> itemMessage)
+		{
+			itemMessage = new List<object>();
+			if (ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel)
+			{
+				itemMessage.Add(subscribeMessage.Payload);
+			}
+			else
+			{
+				//decrypt the subscriber message if cipherkey is available
+				if (cipherKey.Length > 0)
+				{
+					object decodeMessage;
+					try
+					{
+						PubnubCrypto aes = new PubnubCrypto(cipherKey);
+						string decryptMessage = aes.Decrypt(subscribeMessage.Payload.ToString());
+						decodeMessage = (decryptMessage == "**DECRYPT ERROR**") ? decryptMessage : jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToObject(decryptMessage);
+					}
+					catch (Exception decryptEx)
+					{
+						decodeMessage = subscribeMessage.Payload;
+						LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, AddMessageToListV2: decodeMessage Exception: {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), decryptEx.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelError);
+
+					}
+					itemMessage.Add(decodeMessage);
+				}
+				else
+				{
+					itemMessage.Add(subscribeMessage.Payload);
+				}
+			}
+			itemMessage.Add((subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata.Timetoken.ToString() : "");
+			if (ce.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup)
+			{
+				itemMessage.Add(ce.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName.Replace(Utility.PresenceChannelSuffix, ""));
+			}
+
+			itemMessage.Add(subscribeMessage.Channel.Replace(Utility.PresenceChannelSuffix, ""));
+		}
+
+		internal static void FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
+			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, ChannelIdentity ci)
+		{
+			ChannelEntity ce = channelEntities.Find(x => x.ChannelID.Equals(ci));
+			if (ce != null)
+			{
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, FindChannelEntityAndCallback: \n ChannelEntity : {1}  cg?={2} ispres?={3}", DateTime.Now.ToString(),
+					ce.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, ce.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup.ToString(),
+					ce.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel.ToString()
+				), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+				List<object> itemMessage;
+				AddMessageToListV2(cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, subscribeMessage, ce, out itemMessage);
+				PubnubChannelCallback<T> channelCallbacks = ce.ChannelParams.Callbacks as PubnubChannelCallback<T>;
+
+				if ((subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch.Contains(".*")) && Utility.IsPresenceChannel(subscribeMessage.Channel))
+				{
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, FindChannelEntityAndCallback: Wildcard match ChannelEntity : {1} ", DateTime.Now.ToString(),
+						ce.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName
+					), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+					PubnubCallbacks.GoToCallback<T>(itemMessage, channelCallbacks.WildcardPresenceCallback, jsonPluggableLibrary);
+				}
+				else
+				{
+					PubnubCallbacks.GoToCallback<T>(itemMessage, channelCallbacks.SuccessCallback, jsonPluggableLibrary);
+				}
+			}
+#if (ENABLE_PUBNUB_LOGGING)
+            else {
+                StringBuilder sbChannelEntity = new StringBuilder();
+                foreach( ChannelEntity channelEntity in channelEntities){
+                    sbChannelEntity.AppendFormat("ChannelEntity : {0} cg?={1} ispres?={2}", channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName,
+                        channelEntity.ChannelID.IsChannelGroup.ToString(),
+                        channelEntity.ChannelID.IsPresenceChannel.ToString()
+                    );
+                }
+                LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, FindChannelEntityAndCallback: ChannelEntity : null ci.name {1} \nChannelEntities: \n {2}", DateTime.Now.ToString(),
+                    ci.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, sbChannelEntity.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+            }
+#endif
+
+		}
+
+		internal static void ResponseToUserCallbackForSubscribeV2<T>(List<SubscribeMessage> subscribeMessages, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities,
+			string cipherKey, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
+		{
+			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, In ResponseToUserCallbackForSubscribeV2", DateTime.Now.ToString()
+				), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+			foreach (SubscribeMessage subscribeMessage in subscribeMessages)
+			{
+				LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, ResponseToUserCallbackForSubscribeV2:\n SubscribeMessage:\n" +
+					"shard : {1},\n" +
+					"subscriptionMatch: {2},\n" +
+					"channel: {3},\n" +
+					"payload: {4},\n" +
+					"flags: {5},\n" +
+					"issuingClientId: {6},\n" +
+					"subscribeKey: {7},\n" +
+					"sequenceNumber: {8},\n" +
+					"originatingTimetoken tt: {9},\n" +
+					"originatingTimetoken region: {10},\n" +
+					"publishMetadata tt: {11},\n" +
+					"publishMetadata region: {12},\n" +
+					"userMetadata {13} \n",
+					DateTime.Now.ToString(),
+					subscribeMessage.Shard,
+					subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch,
+					subscribeMessage.Channel,
+					subscribeMessage.Payload.ToString(),
+					subscribeMessage.Flags,
+					subscribeMessage.IssuingClientId,
+					subscribeMessage.SubscribeKey,
+					subscribeMessage.SequenceNumber,
+					(subscribeMessage.OriginatingTimetoken != null) ? subscribeMessage.OriginatingTimetoken.Timetoken.ToString() : "",
+					(subscribeMessage.OriginatingTimetoken != null) ? subscribeMessage.OriginatingTimetoken.Region : "",
+					(subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata.Timetoken.ToString() : "",
+					(subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.PublishTimetokenMetadata.Region : "",
+					(subscribeMessage.UserMetadata != null) ? subscribeMessage.UserMetadata.ToString() : "null"),
+					LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+				bool isPresenceChannel = Utility.IsPresenceChannel(subscribeMessage.Channel);
+				if (string.IsNullOrEmpty(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch) || subscribeMessage.Channel.Equals(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch))
+				{
+					//channel
+
+					ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity(subscribeMessage.Channel, false, isPresenceChannel);
+					FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(subscribeMessage, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, ci);
+				}
+				else if (subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch.Contains(".*") && isPresenceChannel)
+				{
+					//wildcard presence channel
+
+					ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch, false, false);
+					FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(subscribeMessage, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, ci);
+				}
+				else if (subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch.Contains(".*"))
+				{
+					//wildcard channel
+					ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch, false, isPresenceChannel);
+					FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(subscribeMessage, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, ci);
+
+				}
+				else
+				{
+					ChannelIdentity ci = new ChannelIdentity(subscribeMessage.SubscriptionMatch, true, isPresenceChannel);
+					FindChannelEntityAndCallback<T>(subscribeMessage, channelEntities, cipherKey, jsonPluggableLibrary, ci);
+
+					//ce will be the cg and subscriptionMatch will have the cg name
+				}
+
+			}
+		}
+
+		internal static void ResponseToUserCallback<T>(List<object> result, RequestState<T> asynchRequestState, string cipherKey,
+			IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
+		{
+			switch (asynchRequestState.RespType)
+			{
+				case ResponseType.Leave:
+					//No response to callback
+					break;
+				case ResponseType.Publish:
+				case ResponseType.DetailedHistory:
+				case ResponseType.HereNow:
+				case ResponseType.GlobalHereNow:
+				case ResponseType.WhereNow:
+				case ResponseType.GrantAccess:
+				case ResponseType.AuditAccess:
+				case ResponseType.RevokeAccess:
+				case ResponseType.GetUserState:
+				case ResponseType.SetUserState:
+				case ResponseType.Time:
+				case ResponseType.PushRegister:
+				case ResponseType.PushRemove:
+				case ResponseType.PushGet:
+				case ResponseType.PushUnregister:
+				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAdd:
+				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRemove:
+				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGet:
+				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGrantAccess:
+				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAuditAccess:
+				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRevokeAccess:
+
+					PubnubCallbacks.SendCallbacks<T>(jsonPluggableLibrary, asynchRequestState, result, CallbackType.Success, false);
+					break;
+				default:
+					break;
+			}
+		}
+
+		internal static void ResponseToConnectCallback<T>(RequestState<T> asynchRequestState,
+			 IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary, IDependencyProvider provider)
+		{
+			//Check callback exists and make sure previous timetoken = 0
+			if (asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities != null)
+			{
+				bool updateIsAwaitingConnectCallback = false;
+				for (int i = 0; i < asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities.Count; i++)
+				{
+					ChannelEntity channelEntity = asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities[i];
+					LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, Check ResponseToConnectCallback {1}",
+						DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+					if (channelEntity.ChannelParams.IsAwaitingConnectCallback)
+					{
+						updateIsAwaitingConnectCallback = true;
+						LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, ResponseToConnectCallback IsAwaitingConnectCallback {1}",
+							DateTime.Now.ToString(), channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+
+						switch (asynchRequestState.RespType)
+						{
+							case ResponseType.SubscribeV2:
+								var connectResult = Helpers.CreateJsonResponse("Connected", channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName, jsonPluggableLibrary);
+								PubnubCallbacks.SendCallbacks<T>(jsonPluggableLibrary, channelEntity, connectResult,
+									CallbackType.Connect, false);
+
+								break;
+							case ResponseType.PresenceV2:
+								var connectResult2 = Helpers.CreateJsonResponse("Presence Connected",
+													 channelEntity.ChannelID.ChannelOrChannelGroupName.Replace(Utility.PresenceChannelSuffix, ""), jsonPluggableLibrary);
+								PubnubCallbacks.SendCallbacks<T>(jsonPluggableLibrary, channelEntity, connectResult2,
+									CallbackType.Connect, false);
+								break;
+							default:
+								break;
+						}
+					}
+				}
+				if (updateIsAwaitingConnectCallback)
+				{
+					Subscription.GetSubscription(provider).UpdateIsAwaitingConnectCallbacksOfEntity(asynchRequestState.ChannelEntities, false);
+				}
+			}
+
+		}
+
+		internal static List<object> CreateJsonResponse(string message, string channel, IJsonPluggableLibrary jsonPluggableLibrary)
+		{
+			string jsonString = "";
+			List<object> connectResult = new List<object>();
+			jsonString = string.Format("[1, \"{0}\"]", message);
+			connectResult = jsonPluggableLibrary.DeserializeToListOfObject(jsonString);
+			connectResult.Add(channel);
+
+			return connectResult;
+		}
+
+		internal static PubnubErrorCode GetTimeOutErrorCode(ResponseType responseType)
+		{
+			switch (responseType)
+			{
+				case ResponseType.AuditAccess:
+				case ResponseType.GrantAccess:
+				case ResponseType.RevokeAccess:
+				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupGrantAccess:
+				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupAuditAccess:
+				case ResponseType.ChannelGroupRevokeAccess:
+					return PubnubErrorCode.PAMAccessOperationTimeout;
+				case ResponseType.DetailedHistory:
+				case ResponseType.History:
+					return PubnubErrorCode.DetailedHistoryOperationTimeout;
+				case ResponseType.GetUserState:
+					return PubnubErrorCode.GetUserStateTimeout;
+				case ResponseType.GlobalHereNow:
+					return PubnubErrorCode.GlobalHereNowOperationTimeout;
+				case ResponseType.SetUserState:
+					return PubnubErrorCode.SetUserStateTimeout;
+				case ResponseType.HereNow:
+					return PubnubErrorCode.HereNowOperationTimeout;
+				case ResponseType.Publish:
+					return PubnubErrorCode.PublishOperationTimeout;
+				case ResponseType.Time:
+					return PubnubErrorCode.TimeOperationTimeout;
+				case ResponseType.WhereNow:
+					return PubnubErrorCode.WhereNowOperationTimeout;
+				default:
+					/*
+					 * ResponseType.Presence:
+					 * ResponseType.PresenceUnsubscribe:
+					 * ResponseType.Leave:
+					 * ResponseType.Subscribe:
+					 * ResponseType.Unsubscribe:
+					 * ResponseType.Heartbeat:
+					 * ResponseType.PresenceHeartbeat:
+					 * ResponseType.ChannelGroupAdd
+					 * ResponseType.ChannelGroupRemove
+					 * ResponseType.ChannelGroupGet
+					 */
+					return PubnubErrorCode.OperationTimeout;
+			}
+		}
+
+		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(Exception ex,
+			RequestState<T> requestState, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, PubnubErrorCode errorCode, PubnubErrorSeverity severity)
+		{
+
+			if (errorCode.Equals(PubnubErrorCode.None))
+			{
+				errorCode = PubnubErrorCodeHelper.GetErrorType(ex);
+			}
+
+			int statusCode = (int)errorCode;
+			string errorDescription = PubnubErrorCodeDescription.GetStatusCodeDescription(errorCode);
+			PubnubWebRequest request = null;
+			PubnubWebResponse response = null;
+
+			if (requestState != null)
+			{
+				request = requestState.Request;
+				response = requestState.Response;
+				if (channelEntities == null && requestState.ChannelEntities != null)
+				{
+					channelEntities = requestState.ChannelEntities;
+				}
+			}
+
+			PubnubClientError error = new PubnubClientError(statusCode, severity, true, ex.Message, ex,
+				PubnubMessageSource.Client, request, response, errorDescription,
+				channelEntities);
+
+			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, PubnubClientError = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), error.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+			return error;
+		}
+
+		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(string message,
+			RequestState<T> requestState, PubnubErrorCode errorCode, PubnubErrorSeverity severity, string channels, string channelGroups)
+		{
+
+			int statusCode = (int)errorCode;
+			string errorDescription = PubnubErrorCodeDescription.GetStatusCodeDescription(errorCode);
+
+			PubnubWebRequest request = null;
+			PubnubWebResponse response = null;
+
+			if (requestState != null)
+			{
+				request = requestState.Request;
+				response = requestState.Response;
+			}
+
+			PubnubClientError error = new PubnubClientError(statusCode, severity, message, PubnubMessageSource.Client,
+				request, response, errorDescription,
+				channels, channelGroups
+			);
+
+			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, PubnubClientError 2 = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), error.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+			return error;
+		}
+
+		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(Exception ex,
+			RequestState<T> requestState, PubnubErrorCode errorCode, PubnubErrorSeverity severity, string channels, string channelGroups)
+		{
+
+			int statusCode = (int)errorCode;
+			string errorDescription = PubnubErrorCodeDescription.GetStatusCodeDescription(errorCode);
+
+			PubnubWebRequest request = null;
+			PubnubWebResponse response = null;
+
+			if (requestState != null)
+			{
+				request = requestState.Request;
+				response = requestState.Response;
+			}
+
+			PubnubClientError error = new PubnubClientError(statusCode, severity, ex.Message, PubnubMessageSource.Client,
+				request, response, errorDescription,
+				channels, channelGroups
+			);
+
+			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, PubnubClientError 3 = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), error.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+			return error;
+		}
+
+		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(string message,
+			RequestState<T> requestState, List<ChannelEntity> channelEntities, PubnubErrorCode errorCode, PubnubErrorSeverity severity)
+		{
+
+			int statusCode = (int)errorCode;
+			string errorDescription = PubnubErrorCodeDescription.GetStatusCodeDescription(errorCode);
+
+			PubnubWebRequest request = null;
+			PubnubWebResponse response = null;
+
+			if (requestState != null)
+			{
+				request = requestState.Request;
+				response = requestState.Response;
+			}
+
+			PubnubClientError error = new PubnubClientError(statusCode, severity, message, PubnubMessageSource.Client,
+				request, response, errorDescription,
+				channelEntities
+			);
+
+			LoggingMethod.WriteToLog(string.Format("DateTime {0}, PubnubClientError 4 = {1}", DateTime.Now.ToString(), error.ToString()), LoggingMethod.LevelInfo);
+			return error;
+		}
+
+		internal static PubnubClientError CreatePubnubClientError<T>(WebException ex,
+			RequestState<T> requestState, string channel, PubnubErrorSeverity severity)
+		{
+
+			PubnubErrorCode errorCode = PubnubErrorCodeHelper.GetErrorType(ex.Status, ex.Message);
+			return CreatePubnubClientError<T>(ex, requestState, null, errorCode, severity);
+		}
+
+		#endregion
+
+	}
+}