claude-flow-novice 2.18.13 → 2.18.14

package/.claude/skills/cfn-local-ruvector-accelerator/docs/VALIDATION_FINDINGS.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,250 @@
+VALIDATION FINDINGS - AST-Aware RuVector Accelerator
+=====================================================
+
+CONFIDENCE SCORE: 0.78 (High confidence in findings)
+
+IMPLEMENTATION STATUS:
+  65% overall completion - Partially functional, but has critical gaps
+
+FINDING SUMMARY BY COMPONENT:
+
+1. RUST EXTRACTOR (85% COMPLETE)
+   Status: WORKING with limitations
+   
+   Verified Working:
+   - tree-sitter-rust parser correctly initialized
+   - Function entity extraction (function_item) with parameters and return types
+   - Struct entity extraction (struct_item) with visibility tracking
+   - Trait entity extraction (trait_item)
+   - Implementation block extraction (impl_item)
+   - Enum entity extraction (enum_item)
+   - Call expression reference extraction
+   - Type identifier reference tracking
+   - Visibility detection (public/private via AST modifiers)
+   
+   Gaps Identified:
+   - Module (mod) blocks not extracted
+   - Constants (const) not extracted
+   - Static variables (static) not extracted
+   - Type aliases (type Name = ...) not extracted
+   - Macros not extracted
+   - Parent-child relationships never populated (parent_id always None)
+   - Doc comments not extracted
+   - Attributes not extracted
+   - Limited reference type coverage (only Calls, not Extends/Implements)
+   - No cross-file reference resolution
+
+2. TYPESCRIPT EXTRACTOR (5% COMPLETE)
+   Status: NON-FUNCTIONAL - STUB IMPLEMENTATION ONLY
+   
+   Code Evidence:
+   - File: /src/extractors/typescript.rs (80 lines)
+   - Implementation is placeholder only:
+     pub fn extract(&mut self, _file_path: &str, _source: &str) 
+       -> Result<ExtractionResult> {
+         Ok(ExtractionResult {
+             entities: Vec::new(),
+             references: Vec::new(),
+             errors: vec!["TypeScript AST extractor not yet fully implemented"]
+         })
+       }
+   - Parameters prefixed with underscore (intentionally unused)
+   - All test assertions expect empty results
+   
+   Missing (100% of functionality):
+   - Class/interface extraction
+   - Function/method extraction  
+   - Type alias extraction
+   - Variable/property extraction
+   - Import statement extraction
+   - All reference types
+
+   Additional Finding:
+   - Alternative implementation exists: typescript_full.rs
+   - Marked as "temporarily disabled due to regex issues"
+   - Never fixed or re-enabled
+   - Reason for failure unclear/undocumented
+
+3. SCHEMA V2 (95% COMPLETE)
+   Status: WELL-DESIGNED, COMPREHENSIVE
+   
+   Verified Tables:
+   - entities (id, kind, name, signature, visibility, parent_id, file_path, line_number, column_number, doc_comment, attributes, metadata, created_at, updated_at)
+   - refs (source_entity_id, target_entity_id, ref_kind, file_path, line_number, column_number)
+   - type_usage (entity_id, type_name, usage_kind, file_path, line_number)
+   - modules (name, file_path, module_type, is_root)
+   - entity_embeddings (entity_id, embedding BLOB, embedding_model, created_at)
+   - file_hashes (file_path, file_hash, indexed_at)
+   
+   Verified Enums:
+   - EntityKind: 30+ types (Rust + TypeScript coverage)
+   - RefKind: 16 relationship types (call, import, extend, implement, etc.)
+   - Visibility: 5 levels (public, private, protected, internal, file_private)
+   
+   Gaps:
+   - No foreign key constraints enforced
+   - Missing indexes on common queries (name, file_path, kind)
+   - No full-text search support
+   - EntityKind missing Hash trait derivation (breaks test compilation)
+
+4. STORAGE LAYER (90% COMPLETE)
+   Status: FUNCTIONAL, WELL-IMPLEMENTED
+   
+   Working Operations:
+   - insert_entity() with full metadata
+   - find_entities_by_name()
+   - find_entities_by_kind()
+   - find_entities_in_file()
+   - search_entities() with LIKE patterns
+   - insert_reference() and lookup operations
+   - store_embedding() / get_embedding() with BLOB serialization
+   - Transaction support (StoreV2WithTx)
+   - Atomic batch operations (index_file_atomic)
+   
+   Gaps:
+   - No fuzzy matching on search
+   - No pagination support
+   - No aggregation queries
+   - No migration utilities
+
+5. EMBEDDINGS LAYER (75% COMPLETE - BUT BROKEN)
+   Status: STRUCTURE EXISTS, BUT NOT FUNCTIONAL
+   
+   Code Evidence from /src/embeddings.rs:
+   ```rust
+   fn generate_dummy_embedding(&self, text: &str) -> Result<Vec<f32>> {
+       // Generate a deterministic but pseudo-random embedding based on text
+       let mut embedding = vec![0.0; self.config.dimension];
+       
+       // Simple hash-based embedding generation
+       let bytes = text.as_bytes();
+       for (i, &byte) in bytes.iter().enumerate() {
+           let pos = (i * 7) % self.config.dimension;
+   ```
+   
+   Critical Limitation:
+   - Comments state: "Generate a simple dummy embedding for now"
+   - Comments state: "In a real implementation, this would call an embedding API"
+   - No actual API calls to OpenAI text-embedding-ada-002
+   - Embeddings are hash-based, NOT semantically meaningful
+   - Semantic search fundamentally impossible with current implementation
+   
+   Impact: Violates core intent of "semantic code indexing"
+
+6. CLI INTEGRATION (40% COMPLETE)
+   Status: PARTIALLY WORKING
+   
+   Working:
+   - File discovery and filtering
+   - Language detection based on extension
+   - AST extraction routing to correct extractor
+   - Transactional batch storage
+   - Incremental indexing via file hashes
+   - Statistics collection
+   
+   Broken:
+   - TypeScript indexing returns no results
+   - Embeddings stored but meaningless
+   - Parent relationship tracking never populated
+   - Type name extraction is regex-based with TODO comment
+   - Reference target resolution not implemented
+   - No incremental load optimization
+
+7. TESTING (30% FUNCTIONAL)
+   Status: PARTIALLY BROKEN
+   
+   Working Tests:
+   - Security tests (SQL injection prevention)
+   - Transaction tests (rollback verification)
+   
+   Broken Tests:
+   - test_rust_extractor.rs fails compilation (5 errors)
+   - Error cause: EntityKind missing #[derive(Hash)]
+   - Prevents validation of extraction correctness
+   
+   Missing Tests:
+   - TypeScript extraction (extractor is stub)
+   - Embedding quality (dummy implementation)
+   - Cross-file resolution
+   - Full indexing workflow
+
+CRITICAL ISSUES SUMMARY:
+
+Issue #1: TypeScript Extractor Non-Functional (SEVERITY: CRITICAL)
+  - Returns empty results for 50% of supported file types
+  - Blocks half the intended language coverage
+  - Requires complete implementation or debug of typescript_full.rs
+
+Issue #2: Embeddings Are Dummy Implementation (SEVERITY: CRITICAL)
+  - Not semantically meaningful
+  - Semantic search impossible
+  - Violates core "semantic" intent
+  - Requires API integration
+
+Issue #3: Test Suite Broken (SEVERITY: HIGH)
+  - test_rust_extractor.rs has 5 compilation errors
+  - Prevents validation of Rust extraction correctness
+  - Quick fix: Add Hash to EntityKind derives
+
+Issue #4: Reference Resolution Missing (SEVERITY: HIGH)
+  - References extracted but not linked to actual entities
+  - Parent-child relationships never populated
+  - Cross-file references impossible
+
+Issue #5: TypeScript Alternative Disabled (SEVERITY: MEDIUM)
+  - typescript_full.rs exists but disabled
+  - Unknown failure reason
+  - Never investigated or fixed
+
+CODE QUALITY ISSUES:
+
+- 107 compiler warnings
+- Unused imports throughout
+- Missing Hash trait on EntityKind (breaks HashMap usage)
+- Type extraction uses regex with TODO for AST
+- Missing database indexes for performance
+- No error recovery in batch operations
+
+FEATURE COMPLETENESS:
+
+                      Intended  Actual
+Tree-sitter parsing     100%     50% (Rust only)
+Entity extraction       100%     50% (Rust only)
+Reference tracking      100%     40% (basic only)
+Embedding generation    100%      5% (dummy only)
+SQLite storage          100%     95% (working)
+Query API               100%     80% (no fuzzy/pagination)
+Integration/CLI         100%     40% (TypeScript broken)
+
+INTENT COMPLIANCE ASSESSMENT:
+
+Requirement: Semantic code indexing tool
+Finding: Not achievable with current embeddings
+
+Requirement: Parse source code using tree-sitter
+Finding: 50% complete (Rust works, TypeScript is stub)
+
+Requirement: Extract structured entities
+Finding: 50% complete (Rust mostly done, TypeScript none)
+
+Requirement: Track code references
+Finding: 40% complete (basic extraction, no resolution)
+
+Requirement: Generate embeddings for semantic search
+Finding: 5% complete (only dummy hash-based)
+
+Requirement: Store in SQLite Schema V2
+Finding: 95% complete (well-designed, mostly working)
+
+Requirement: Fast local queries
+Finding: 80% complete (works but no indexes/pagination)
+
+OVERALL VERDICT:
+The implementation is architecturally sound but fundamentally incomplete.
+It can index Rust code and store results, but cannot index TypeScript/JavaScript,
+and embeddings are non-functional. The tool is not yet ready for production use
+as a "semantic code indexing tool" - it's more accurately described as a
+"Rust code structure indexing tool" at best.
+
+Estimated work to production readiness: 3-4 weeks for critical fixes
+(TypeScript implementation, real embeddings, reference resolution)

package/.claude/skills/cfn-local-ruvector-accelerator/epic-ast-indexer.json

@@ -0,0 +1,335 @@
+{
+  "executionMode": "cfn-loop",
+  "metadata": {
+    "epicId": "ruvector-ast-agent-accelerator",
+    "name": "AST-Aware RuVector Agent Accelerator",
+    "description": "Transform RuVector from line-based indexing to AST-aware semantic indexing for Rust and TypeScript. Enable agents to replace slow grep/search operations with instant database queries for code intelligence: finding functions by type usage, tracking cross-file references, mapping module dependencies, and supporting large-scale refactoring workflows.",
+    "status": "not_started",
+    "priority": "high",
+    "estimatedDuration": "3 weeks",
+    "owner": "cfn-dev-team",
+    "targetPath": ".claude/skills/cfn-local-ruvector-accelerator"
+  },
+  "goals": [
+    "Replace grep-based code search with sub-50ms database queries",
+    "Enable semantic queries like 'functions that use Album type'",
+    "Track cross-file references for safe refactoring",
+    "Support both Rust and TypeScript codebases",
+    "Reduce agent context gathering from 10-30s to <100ms",
+    "Provide structured entity extraction (functions, classes, types, imports)"
+  ],
+  "phases": [
+    {
+      "phaseId": "phase-1-schema",
+      "name": "Database Schema Redesign",
+      "description": "Replace flat pattern-based schema with structured entity/reference schema supporting multi-language AST data",
+      "status": "not_started",
+      "estimatedDuration": "2 days",
+      "dependencies": [],
+      "sprints": [
+        {
+          "sprintId": "sprint-1-1",
+          "name": "Entity Schema",
+          "tasks": [
+            "Create entities table with kind, name, signature, visibility, parent_id fields",
+            "Create refs table for cross-file reference tracking (calls, imports, extends, implements)",
+            "Create type_usage table for 'functions using Type X' queries",
+            "Create modules table for import/export tracking",
+            "Add indexes for fast queries on kind, name, file_path, target_name"
+          ],
+          "acceptanceCriteria": [
+            "Schema supports Rust and TypeScript entity types",
+            "Indexes enable sub-10ms lookups by name or type",
+            "Migration from old schema preserves file metadata"
+          ]
+        }
+      ],
+      "deliverables": [
+        "src/schema_v2.rs with new table definitions",
+        "Migration script from v1 to v2 schema"
+      ],
+      "agents": ["database-architect", "backend-developer"]
+    },
+    {
+      "phaseId": "phase-2-rust-extractor",
+      "name": "Rust AST Extractor",
+      "description": "Implement tree-sitter-rust based extraction of Rust code entities and references",
+      "status": "not_started",
+      "estimatedDuration": "4 days",
+      "dependencies": ["phase-1-schema"],
+      "sprints": [
+        {
+          "sprintId": "sprint-2-1",
+          "name": "Core Entity Extraction",
+          "tasks": [
+            "Add tree-sitter and tree-sitter-rust dependencies to Cargo.toml",
+            "Create src/extractors/mod.rs with Extractor trait",
+            "Implement function_item extraction (fn name, params, return type, visibility)",
+            "Implement struct_item extraction (name, fields, generics)",
+            "Implement impl_item extraction (impl Type, methods, trait bounds)",
+            "Implement trait_item extraction (trait name, methods, supertraits)",
+            "Implement enum_item and type_alias extraction"
+          ],
+          "acceptanceCriteria": [
+            "All Rust entity types extracted with correct metadata",
+            "Visibility (pub, pub(crate), private) correctly identified",
+            "Generic parameters captured in signatures"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "sprintId": "sprint-2-2",
+          "name": "Reference Extraction",
+          "tasks": [
+            "Extract use_declaration for import tracking",
+            "Extract call_expression for function call references",
+            "Extract type_identifier for type usage tracking",
+            "Map method calls to their impl blocks",
+            "Track trait implementations (impl Trait for Type)"
+          ],
+          "acceptanceCriteria": [
+            "Cross-file function calls tracked",
+            "Type usage in parameters/returns/fields recorded",
+            "Import statements parsed with source module"
+          ]
+        }
+      ],
+      "deliverables": [
+        "src/extractors/rust.rs with full AST extraction",
+        "Unit tests for each entity type"
+      ],
+      "agents": ["rust-developer", "backend-developer"]
+    },
+    {
+      "phaseId": "phase-3-typescript-extractor",
+      "name": "TypeScript AST Extractor",
+      "description": "Implement tree-sitter-typescript based extraction for TypeScript/JavaScript codebases",
+      "status": "not_started",
+      "estimatedDuration": "4 days",
+      "dependencies": ["phase-1-schema"],
+      "sprints": [
+        {
+          "sprintId": "sprint-3-1",
+          "name": "Core Entity Extraction",
+          "tasks": [
+            "Add tree-sitter-typescript dependency",
+            "Implement function_declaration extraction",
+            "Implement class_declaration extraction (name, extends, implements)",
+            "Implement method_definition extraction (class methods)",
+            "Implement interface_declaration extraction",
+            "Implement type_alias_declaration extraction",
+            "Handle export modifiers for visibility"
+          ],
+          "acceptanceCriteria": [
+            "All TypeScript entity types extracted",
+            "Export/default export correctly mapped to visibility",
+            "Class inheritance chain captured"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "sprintId": "sprint-3-2",
+          "name": "Reference Extraction",
+          "tasks": [
+            "Extract import_statement with source paths",
+            "Extract call_expression for function calls",
+            "Extract new_expression for class instantiation",
+            "Extract type_reference for type usage",
+            "Handle re-exports and barrel files"
+          ],
+          "acceptanceCriteria": [
+            "Import paths resolved relative to project",
+            "Type references in generics captured",
+            "JSX component usage tracked as calls"
+          ]
+        }
+      ],
+      "deliverables": [
+        "src/extractors/typescript.rs with full AST extraction",
+        "Unit tests for TypeScript patterns"
+      ],
+      "agents": ["typescript-specialist", "backend-developer"]
+    },
+    {
+      "phaseId": "phase-4-query-api",
+      "name": "Agent Query API",
+      "description": "Create high-level query interface for agent use cases, replacing grep patterns",
+      "status": "not_started",
+      "estimatedDuration": "3 days",
+      "dependencies": ["phase-2-rust-extractor", "phase-3-typescript-extractor"],
+      "sprints": [
+        {
+          "sprintId": "sprint-4-1",
+          "name": "Query Implementation",
+          "tasks": [
+            "Implement 'functions using Type X' query",
+            "Implement 'callers of function X' query",
+            "Implement 'types defined in file X used elsewhere' query",
+            "Implement 'implementations of trait/interface X' query",
+            "Implement 'public API surface of module X' query",
+            "Implement 'references to path X' query for refactoring"
+          ],
+          "acceptanceCriteria": [
+            "All queries return results in <50ms for 10k+ entity indexes",
+            "Results include file path, line number, and context",
+            "Queries work across Rust and TypeScript"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "sprintId": "sprint-4-2",
+          "name": "CLI Integration",
+          "tasks": [
+            "Add 'ruvector find' subcommand with --kind, --uses-type, --called-by flags",
+            "Add 'ruvector refs' subcommand for reference queries",
+            "Add --json output format for programmatic use",
+            "Add natural language query parsing (optional)",
+            "Update help documentation"
+          ],
+          "acceptanceCriteria": [
+            "CLI provides structured query interface",
+            "JSON output parseable by agents",
+            "Error messages guide correct usage"
+          ]
+        }
+      ],
+      "deliverables": [
+        "src/query_api.rs with query functions",
+        "src/cli/find.rs with CLI subcommand",
+        "Updated CLI help and examples"
+      ],
+      "agents": ["backend-developer", "api-designer-persona"]
+    },
+    {
+      "phaseId": "phase-5-integration",
+      "name": "Index Rebuild and Integration Testing",
+      "description": "Rebuild indexes with new schema, validate query performance, integrate with agent workflows",
+      "status": "not_started",
+      "estimatedDuration": "2 days",
+      "dependencies": ["phase-4-query-api"],
+      "sprints": [
+        {
+          "sprintId": "sprint-5-1",
+          "name": "Index Rebuild",
+          "tasks": [
+            "Update IndexCommand to use AST extractors instead of line-based",
+            "Add language detection for file routing",
+            "Implement incremental indexing (only changed files)",
+            "Run full re-index of claude-flow-novice codebase",
+            "Benchmark index size vs old approach (target: 80% reduction)"
+          ],
+          "acceptanceCriteria": [
+            "Full index completes in <5 minutes",
+            "Database size <500MB (vs 5GB+ line-based)",
+            "All entity types correctly extracted"
+          ]
+        },
+        {
+          "sprintId": "sprint-5-2",
+          "name": "Integration Testing",
+          "tasks": [
+            "Test 'functions using Album' style queries on real codebase",
+            "Test 'callers of X outside module Y' queries",
+            "Test refactoring workflow: find references, split file, verify no breaks",
+            "Benchmark query latency (target: <50ms p99)",
+            "Document agent integration patterns"
+          ],
+          "acceptanceCriteria": [
+            "All example queries from planning doc work correctly",
+            "Query latency meets <50ms target",
+            "Agent workflow documented with examples"
+          ]
+        }
+      ],
+      "deliverables": [
+        "Rebuilt index with AST-aware schema",
+        "Performance benchmarks",
+        "Agent integration documentation"
+      ],
+      "agents": ["integration-tester", "performance-benchmarker"]
+    }
+  ],
+  "configuration": {
+    "loopMode": "standard",
+    "consensusThreshold": 0.90,
+    "gateThreshold": 0.95,
+    "maxIterations": 10,
+    "testCommand": "cd .claude/skills/cfn-local-ruvector-accelerator && cargo test",
+    "buildCommand": "cd .claude/skills/cfn-local-ruvector-accelerator && cargo build --release"
+  },
+  "technicalContext": {
+    "language": "rust",
+    "dependencies": [
+      "tree-sitter = \"0.20\"",
+      "tree-sitter-rust = \"0.20\"",
+      "tree-sitter-typescript = \"0.20\""
+    ],
+    "existingFiles": {
+      "schema": "src/sqlite_store.rs",
+      "indexer": "src/cli/index.rs",
+      "search": "src/search_engine.rs",
+      "embeddings": "src/embeddings.rs"
+    },
+    "contextFilesToRead": {
+      "phase-1": [
+        "src/sqlite_store.rs:28-57 (existing schema to extend)",
+        "src/search_engine.rs:78-87 (IndexMetadata struct to replace)"
+      ],
+      "phase-2": [
+        "src/cli/index.rs:238-274 (extract_patterns to replace)",
+        "Cargo.toml (add tree-sitter deps)"
+      ],
+      "phase-3": [
+        "src/extractors/rust.rs (copy pattern for TypeScript)",
+        "Cargo.toml (add tree-sitter-typescript)"
+      ],
+      "phase-4": [
+        "src/sqlite_store.rs:118-136 (search_patterns to extend)",
+        "src/cli/query.rs (existing query command to extend)"
+      ],
+      "phase-5": [
+        "src/cli/index.rs:176-236 (process_files to modify)",
+        "src/main.rs (CLI entry point)"
+      ]
+    },
+    "treeSitterNodeTypes": {
+      "rust": {
+        "function_item": "Extract: name (identifier child), parameters (parameters child), return_type (type child), visibility_modifier",
+        "struct_item": "Extract: name (type_identifier), fields (field_declaration_list), type_parameters",
+        "impl_item": "Extract: type (type child), trait (optional), methods (function_item children in body)",
+        "trait_item": "Extract: name, method signatures (function_signature_item), supertraits",
+        "enum_item": "Extract: name, variants (enum_variant_list)",
+        "use_declaration": "Extract: path segments, alias (optional)",
+        "call_expression": "Extract: function name (identifier or field_expression), arguments",
+        "type_identifier": "Extract: name (for type_usage tracking)"
+      },
+      "typescript": {
+        "function_declaration": "Extract: name (identifier), parameters (formal_parameters), return_type (type_annotation), export keyword",
+        "class_declaration": "Extract: name, heritage (extends/implements clauses), body methods",
+        "method_definition": "Extract: name, parameters, return_type, accessibility (public/private)",
+        "interface_declaration": "Extract: name, extends, properties and method signatures",
+        "type_alias_declaration": "Extract: name, value (type definition)",
+        "import_statement": "Extract: specifiers (named/default), source path",
+        "call_expression": "Extract: function (identifier or member_expression), arguments",
+        "new_expression": "Extract: constructor name, arguments"
+      }
+    },
+    "treeSitterAPIPattern": {
+      "setup": "let mut parser = Parser::new(); parser.set_language(tree_sitter_rust::language())?;",
+      "parse": "let tree = parser.parse(&source_code, None)?; let root = tree.root_node();",
+      "traverse": "let mut cursor = root.walk(); for node in root.children(&mut cursor) { match node.kind() { ... } }",
+      "getText": "let text = &source_code[node.start_byte()..node.end_byte()];",
+      "getChild": "node.child_by_field_name(\"name\") or node.named_child(0)",
+      "getPosition": "node.start_position().row (0-indexed line number)"
+    },
+    "targetQueries": [
+      "SELECT * FROM entities WHERE kind='function' AND id IN (SELECT entity_id FROM type_usage WHERE type_name='Album')",
+      "SELECT * FROM refs WHERE target_name='create_album' AND ref_kind='calls' AND file_path NOT LIKE '%source_module%'",
+      "SELECT e.name, COUNT(*) FROM entities e JOIN type_usage tu ON e.name=tu.type_name WHERE e.file_path LIKE '%module.rs' GROUP BY e.name"
+    ]
+  },
+  "successMetrics": {
+    "queryLatency": "<50ms p99",
+    "indexSize": "<500MB for 4600 files",
+    "indexTime": "<5 minutes full rebuild",
+    "entityCoverage": ">95% of functions, classes, types extracted",
+    "agentSpeedup": "10-30s grep → <100ms database query"
+  }
+}