claude-evolve 1.0.0

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
@@ -0,0 +1,248 @@
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+
3
+ set -e
4
+
5
+ # Parse arguments
6
+ timeout_seconds=""
7
+
8
+ while [[ $# -gt 0 ]]; do
9
+ case $1 in
10
+ --timeout)
11
+ if [[ -z ${2:-} ]] || [[ ! $2 =~ ^[0-9]+$ ]] || [[ $2 -eq 0 ]]; then
12
+ echo "[ERROR] --timeout requires a positive integer (seconds)" >&2
13
+ exit 1
14
+ fi
15
+ timeout_seconds="$2"
16
+ shift 2
17
+ ;;
18
+ --help)
19
+ cat <<EOF
20
+ claude-evolve run - Execute evolution candidates
21
+
22
+ USAGE:
23
+ claude-evolve run [OPTIONS]
24
+
25
+ OPTIONS:
26
+ --timeout <sec> Kill evaluator after specified seconds (default: no timeout)
27
+ --help Show this help message
28
+
29
+ DESCRIPTION:
30
+ Processes the oldest pending candidate from evolution.csv by:
31
+ 1. Generating algorithm mutation using Claude
32
+ 2. Running evaluator.py on the generated algorithm
33
+ 3. Updating CSV with performance score and completion status
34
+
35
+ Use --timeout to prevent runaway evaluations from blocking progress.
36
+ EOF
37
+ exit 0
38
+ ;;
39
+ *)
40
+ echo "[ERROR] Unknown option: $1" >&2
41
+ exit 1
42
+ ;;
43
+ esac
44
+ done
45
+
46
+ echo "[INFO] Starting evolution run..."
47
+ [[ -n $timeout_seconds ]] && echo "[INFO] Using timeout: ${timeout_seconds} seconds"
48
+
49
+ # Validate workspace
50
+ if [[ ! -d evolution ]]; then
51
+ echo "[ERROR] Evolution directory not found. Run 'claude-evolve setup' first." >&2
52
+ exit 1
53
+ fi
54
+
55
+ for file in evolution.csv evaluator.py; do
56
+ if [[ ! -f evolution/$file ]]; then
57
+ echo "[ERROR] $file not found. Run 'claude-evolve setup' first." >&2
58
+ exit 1
59
+ fi
60
+ done
61
+
62
+ # Find oldest empty row (pure shell)
63
+ find_empty_row() {
64
+ local row_num=2 # Start after header
65
+ while IFS=, read -r id based_on desc perf status; do
66
+ if [[ -z $perf && -z $status ]]; then
67
+ echo $row_num
68
+ return 0
69
+ fi
70
+ ((row_num++))
71
+ done < <(tail -n +2 evolution/evolution.csv)
72
+ return 1
73
+ }
74
+
75
+ # Get CSV row (pure shell)
76
+ get_csv_row() {
77
+ sed -n "${1}p" evolution/evolution.csv
78
+ }
79
+
80
+ # Update CSV row (pure shell with temp file)
81
+ update_csv_row() {
82
+ local row_num="$1"
83
+ local performance="$2"
84
+ local status="$3"
85
+
86
+ # Read CSV and update specific row
87
+ local temp_file="evolution/evolution.csv.tmp"
88
+ local current_row=1
89
+
90
+ while IFS=, read -r id based_on desc perf stat; do
91
+ if [[ $current_row -eq $row_num ]]; then
92
+ # Update this row
93
+ echo "$id,$based_on,$desc,$performance,$status"
94
+ else
95
+ # Keep original row
96
+ echo "$id,$based_on,$desc,$perf,$stat"
97
+ fi
98
+ ((current_row++))
99
+ done <evolution/evolution.csv >"$temp_file"
100
+
101
+ mv "$temp_file" evolution/evolution.csv
102
+ }
103
+
104
+ # Find next candidate
105
+ if ! row_num=$(find_empty_row); then
106
+ echo "[ERROR] No empty rows found in CSV. Run 'claude-evolve ideate' to add candidates." >&2
107
+ exit 1
108
+ fi
109
+
110
+ # Get row data
111
+ row_data=$(get_csv_row "$row_num")
112
+ IFS=, read -r id based_on_id description performance status <<<"$row_data"
113
+
114
+ # Clean up description (remove quotes)
115
+ description=${description#\"}
116
+ description=${description%\"}
117
+
118
+ echo "[INFO] Processing candidate ID: $id"
119
+ echo "[INFO] Description: $description"
120
+ echo "[INFO] Based on ID: $based_on_id"
121
+
122
+ # Set interrupt handler
123
+ trap 'update_csv_row "$row_num" "" "interrupted"; echo "[INFO] Evolution interrupted"; exit 130' INT
124
+
125
+ # Mark as running
126
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "" "running"
127
+
128
+ # Determine parent algorithm
129
+ parent_file="evolution/algorithm.py"
130
+ if [[ -n $based_on_id && $based_on_id != "0" ]]; then
131
+ parent_file="evolution/evolution_id${based_on_id}.py"
132
+ if [[ ! -f $parent_file ]]; then
133
+ echo "[ERROR] Parent algorithm file not found: $parent_file" >&2
134
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "" "failed"
135
+ exit 1
136
+ fi
137
+ fi
138
+
139
+ echo "[INFO] Using parent algorithm: $parent_file"
140
+
141
+ # Generate mutation
142
+ output_file="evolution/evolution_id${id}.py"
143
+ echo "[INFO] Generating algorithm mutation..."
144
+
145
+ # Copy parent algorithm to output file first
146
+ cp "$parent_file" "$output_file"
147
+ echo "[INFO] Copied parent algorithm to: $output_file"
148
+
149
+ # Check for claude CLI
150
+ claude_cmd="${CLAUDE_CMD:-claude}"
151
+ if ! command -v "$claude_cmd" >/dev/null 2>&1; then
152
+ echo "[ERROR] Claude CLI not found. Please install claude-cli." >&2
153
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "" "failed"
154
+ exit 1
155
+ fi
156
+
157
+ # Create mutation prompt
158
+ prompt="You are an AI assistant helping to evolve algorithms through mutations. Please modify the Python algorithm file at $output_file based on the requested modification.
159
+
160
+ CONTEXT:
161
+ $(cat evolution/BRIEF.md 2>/dev/null || echo "No brief available")
162
+
163
+ ALGORITHM FILE TO MODIFY: $output_file
164
+
165
+ REQUESTED MODIFICATION:
166
+ $description
167
+
168
+ INSTRUCTIONS:
169
+ 1. Read the existing algorithm file at $output_file
170
+ 2. Apply the requested modification while preserving the core structure
171
+ 3. Ensure the modified algorithm maintains the same interface (function signatures)
172
+ 4. Include proper error handling and documentation
173
+ 5. Overwrite the file with your improved version
174
+ 6. Return ONLY the complete Python code without explanation
175
+
176
+ The output should be a complete, executable Python file that builds upon the existing algorithm."
177
+
178
+ # Generate mutation
179
+ if ! generated_code=$(echo "$prompt" | "$claude_cmd"); then
180
+ echo "[ERROR] Claude failed to generate algorithm mutation" >&2
181
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "" "failed"
182
+ exit 1
183
+ fi
184
+
185
+ # Save generated algorithm (overwrite the copied file)
186
+ echo "$generated_code" >"$output_file"
187
+ echo "[INFO] Updated algorithm: $output_file"
188
+
189
+ # Run evaluator
190
+ echo "[INFO] Running evaluation..."
191
+ eval_output=""
192
+ eval_exit_code=0
193
+
194
+ if [[ -n $timeout_seconds ]]; then
195
+ echo "[INFO] Starting evaluation with ${timeout_seconds}s timeout..."
196
+ if eval_output=$(timeout "$timeout_seconds" python3 evolution/evaluator.py "$output_file" 2>&1); then
197
+ eval_exit_code=0
198
+ else
199
+ eval_exit_code=$?
200
+ if [[ $eval_exit_code -eq 124 ]]; then
201
+ echo "[ERROR] Evaluation timed out after ${timeout_seconds} seconds" >&2
202
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "" "timeout"
203
+ exit 1
204
+ fi
205
+ fi
206
+ else
207
+ if eval_output=$(python3 evolution/evaluator.py "$output_file" 2>&1); then
208
+ eval_exit_code=0
209
+ else
210
+ eval_exit_code=$?
211
+ fi
212
+ fi
213
+
214
+ # Process results
215
+ if [[ $eval_exit_code -eq 0 ]]; then
216
+ # Extract score from JSON (simple grep approach)
217
+ if score=$(echo "$eval_output" | grep -o '"score"[[:space:]]*:[[:space:]]*[0-9.]*' | cut -d: -f2 | tr -d ' '); then
218
+ if [[ -n $score ]]; then
219
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "$score" "completed"
220
+ echo "[INFO] ✓ Evaluation completed successfully"
221
+ echo "[INFO] Performance score: $score"
222
+ else
223
+ # Try "performance" field
224
+ if score=$(echo "$eval_output" | grep -o '"performance"[[:space:]]*:[[:space:]]*[0-9.]*' | cut -d: -f2 | tr -d ' '); then
225
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "$score" "completed"
226
+ echo "[INFO] ✓ Evaluation completed successfully"
227
+ echo "[INFO] Performance score: $score"
228
+ else
229
+ echo "[ERROR] No score found in evaluator output" >&2
230
+ echo "[ERROR] Output: $eval_output" >&2
231
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "" "failed"
232
+ exit 1
233
+ fi
234
+ fi
235
+ else
236
+ echo "[ERROR] Failed to parse evaluator output" >&2
237
+ echo "[ERROR] Output: $eval_output" >&2
238
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "" "failed"
239
+ exit 1
240
+ fi
241
+ else
242
+ echo "[ERROR] Evaluator failed with exit code $eval_exit_code" >&2
243
+ echo "[ERROR] Output: $eval_output" >&2
244
+ update_csv_row "$row_num" "" "failed"
245
+ exit 1
246
+ fi
247
+
248
+ echo "[INFO] Evolution cycle completed successfully!"
@@ -0,0 +1,55 @@
1
+ #!/bin/bash
2
+
3
+ set -e
4
+
5
+ # Get script directory
6
+ SCRIPT_DIR="$(cd "$(dirname "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")" && pwd)"
7
+ PROJECT_ROOT="$(dirname "$SCRIPT_DIR")"
8
+
9
+ # Source shared editor functions
10
+ source "$PROJECT_ROOT/lib/editor.sh"
11
+
12
+ echo "[INFO] Initializing evolution workspace..."
13
+
14
+ # Create evolution directory
15
+ if [[ ! -d evolution ]]; then
16
+ echo "[INFO] Creating evolution/ directory..."
17
+ mkdir -p evolution
18
+ else
19
+ echo "[INFO] evolution/ directory already exists"
20
+ fi
21
+
22
+ # Copy template files
23
+ for file in BRIEF.md algorithm.py evaluator.py; do
24
+ if [[ ! -f evolution/$file ]]; then
25
+ if [[ -f "$PROJECT_ROOT/templates/$file" ]]; then
26
+ echo "[INFO] Copying $file from templates..."
27
+ cp "$PROJECT_ROOT/templates/$file" "evolution/$file"
28
+ else
29
+ echo "[ERROR] Template file not found: $PROJECT_ROOT/templates/$file"
30
+ exit 1
31
+ fi
32
+ else
33
+ echo "[INFO] $file already exists, skipping"
34
+ fi
35
+ done
36
+
37
+ # Create CSV with header
38
+ if [[ ! -f evolution/evolution.csv ]]; then
39
+ echo "[INFO] Creating evolution.csv with header..."
40
+ echo "id,basedOnId,description,performance,status" >evolution/evolution.csv
41
+ else
42
+ echo "[INFO] evolution.csv already exists, skipping"
43
+ fi
44
+
45
+ # Open editor for BRIEF.md if interactive and file is new or empty
46
+ if [[ -t 1 ]] && [[ ! -s evolution/BRIEF.md ]]; then
47
+ echo "[INFO] Opening BRIEF.md for editing..."
48
+ open_with_editor evolution/BRIEF.md
49
+ fi
50
+
51
+ echo "[INFO] Evolution workspace setup complete!"
52
+ echo "[INFO] Next steps:"
53
+ echo "[INFO] 1. Edit evolution/BRIEF.md to describe your optimization problem"
54
+ echo "[INFO] 2. Customize evolution/evaluator.py for your evaluation criteria"
55
+ echo "[INFO] 3. Run 'claude-evolve ideate' to generate initial candidates"
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
1
+ # Claude-Evolve – AI Working Notes
2
+
3
+ These notes capture my current understanding of the project, the major design choices already fixed in the brief / Q&A, and the open items that still require clarification. They are **living notes** – feel free to edit or extend them during the implementation.
4
+
5
+ ## 1. Project Understanding
6
+
7
+ 1. **Purpose** – Provide a lightweight command-line tool (`claude-evolve`) that orchestrates an _algorithm-evolution_ workflow driven by Claude AI. The tool repeatedly:
8
+ • plans → develops a candidate → runs the evaluator → records the result → lets the user/AI propose the next mutation.
9
+
10
+ 2. **Inspiration** – It mirrors the successful `claude-fsd` package (software delivery), but targets algorithm R&D. The entire CLI is implemented as simple **Bourne-compatible shell scripts** published as an **npm** package – no compiled binaries, no extra runtime besides POSIX sh and Node.
11
+
12
+ 3. **Artifacts produced**
13
+ • `evolution/BRIEF.md`  – high-level goal of the algorithm being optimised
14
+ • `evolution/evolution.csv` – log of all candidates (ID,basedOnID,description,performance,status)
15
+ • `evolution/evolution_details.md` – free-form explanation / commentary per candidate
16
+ • `evolution/evolution_idNNN.<ext>` – snapshot of the concrete algorithm evaluated
17
+
18
+ 4. **Evaluator contract** – An _executable_ (often Python, but not required) that receives the candidate file path as its sole argument and prints a **single-line JSON dict** to stdout, e.g. `{"score": 0.87}`. Claude-evolve treats the first numeric value in that dict as "performance" (higher is better).
19
+
20
+ ## 2. Key Technical Decisions & Rationale
21
+
22
+ • **Shell scripts in an npm package** – keeps the runtime guarantees identical to `claude-fsd`, leverages cross-platform Node installer, and avoids the overhead of compiling/packaging native binaries.
23
+
24
+ • **LLM-driven search** – instead of classic genetic algorithms, we rely on Claude to suggest mutations based on the project history and metrics. The human operator can inject ideas at any point (`claude-evolve ideate`).
25
+
26
+ • **File-system persistence** – CSV + Markdown files are trivial to diff and review in Git. Snap-shooting each algorithm version guarantees perfect reproducibility.
27
+
28
+ • **Single-metric MVP** – Start with exactly one performance number to keep the loop simple; extend to multi-metric later (post-MVP roadmap).
29
+
30
+ • **Menu _and_ sub-commands** – An interactive menu for exploratory use, plus explicit sub-commands for CI automation, following `claude-fsd` precedent.
31
+
32
+ • **Visualization as PNG via Node** – Node libraries (e.g. `chartjs-node-canvas`) generate a static PNG for `claude-evolve analyze`, sidestepping browser dependencies.
33
+
34
+ • **Git-first workflow** – All artifacts (except large training artefacts / checkpoints) tracked in Git. Users work on feature branches; PRs reviewed like any other code change.
35
+
36
+ • **Strict YAGNI** – Avoid prematurely implementing fancy features (branching selection strategies, cloud storage, etc.) until a real need emerges.
37
+
38
+ ## 3. Assumptions & Constraints
39
+
40
+ 1. `claude` CLI is installed and authenticated in the user’s environment.
41
+ 2. Users have a POSIX-style shell environment (bash/zsh/sh) and Node ≥16.
42
+ 3. Evaluations may be _slow_ and resource-intensive; scheduling and cost control are left to the evaluator implementation.
43
+ 4. The repository **should not** store large binary artefacts – evaluator is responsible for external storage if needed.
44
+ 5. Concurrency: MVP evaluates _one_ candidate at a time; optional parallelism (max-N background processes) is documented as a stretch goal.
45
+
46
+ ## 4. Areas Requiring Future Clarification
47
+
48
+ • **Charting implementation** – exact Node library and minimum PNG spec (size, axis labels).
49
+ • **Pre-commit policy** – exactly which linters (shellcheck, shfmt, prettier-markdown, …) are required.
50
+ • **Timeout/Resource limits** – default wall-clock limit for an evaluation and how to surface that to the user.
51
+ • **Multi-metric support** – data model changes (`evolution.csv`) once we decide to support >1 metric.
52
+ • **Security/PII** – explicit organisational policy might evolve (currently "no constraints").
53
+ • **Distribution** – npm org name, versioning scheme, release cadence.
54
+
55
+ ---
56
+
57
+ These notes should evolve alongside the code. When a decision is implemented, reflect it here so future contributors can quickly understand the rationale.
package/docs/IDEAS.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,168 @@
1
+ # Claude-Evolve Future Ideas
2
+
3
+ This file tracks potential enhancements and features that could be added to claude-evolve in the future.
4
+
5
+ ## CLI Enhancements
6
+
7
+ ### Interactive Menu Improvements
8
+
9
+ - Add keyboard shortcuts (arrow keys) for menu navigation
10
+ - Implement command search/filtering in interactive mode
11
+ - Add history of recent commands in interactive menu
12
+
13
+ ### CLI Usability
14
+
15
+ - Add shell completion support (bash, zsh, fish)
16
+ - Implement command aliases (e.g., `claude-evolve i` for `ideate`)
17
+ - Add progress bars for long-running operations
18
+ - Colorized output with configurable themes
19
+ - Implement timeout presets (--timeout-short, --timeout-medium, --timeout-long) for common use cases
20
+ - Add timeout estimation based on historical evaluator performance
21
+ - Create timeout warnings when approaching the limit during evaluation
22
+ - Add configurable default timeout in project configuration file
23
+
24
+ ### Ideation Enhancements
25
+
26
+ - Add a `--from-file` option to ideate command for bulk importing ideas
27
+ - Implement idea similarity detection using embeddings or simple text comparison
28
+ - Add progress bar for multi-idea generation
29
+ - Create idea templates for common algorithm patterns
30
+ - Add support for idea categories or tags for better organization
31
+ - Implement idea rating/scoring before evaluation
32
+ - Add interactive mode for refining AI-generated ideas
33
+ - Cache BRIEF.md content to improve performance
34
+
35
+ ## Testing Framework Enhancements
36
+
37
+ ### Test Coverage
38
+
39
+ - Add integration tests for template copying functionality
40
+ - Implement test mocks for Claude API calls
41
+ - Add performance/benchmark tests for CLI operations
42
+ - Create end-to-end workflow tests
43
+ - Add comprehensive unit tests for CSV manipulation functions in lib/common.sh
44
+ - Fix run command implementation to resolve test failures (prioritize over environment blame)
45
+ - Add tests for concurrent execution scenarios when parallel mode is implemented
46
+ - Create stress tests for large CSV files and many candidates
47
+ - Implement proper error handling in cmd_run to prevent silent failures
48
+ - Add debugging output to understand why tests are failing in npm test environment
49
+
50
+ ### Test Infrastructure
51
+
52
+ - Add test coverage reporting
53
+ - Implement parallel test execution
54
+ - Add visual regression testing for generated charts
55
+ - Create test data generators and fixtures
56
+
57
+ ## Development Workflow
58
+
59
+ ### Code Quality
60
+
61
+ - Add more sophisticated pre-commit hooks
62
+ - Add pre-commit hook to run shellcheck and catch linting issues before commits
63
+ - Implement automated dependency vulnerability scanning
64
+ - Add code complexity analysis
65
+ - Create automated documentation generation
66
+ - Add automatic changelog generation from conventional commits
67
+ - Implement semantic versioning based on conventional commit types
68
+ - Consider adding commit message linting for conventional commit standards (✅ COMPLETED)
69
+ - Add git hook integrity checks to prevent legacy hook conflicts
70
+ - Implement automated commit message template generation for consistency
71
+
72
+ ### Build System
73
+
74
+ - Add Docker containerization for consistent development environment
75
+ - Implement cross-platform build verification
76
+ - Add automated changelog generation
77
+ - Create release automation workflows
78
+
79
+ ## Future Phase Ideas
80
+
81
+ ### Enhanced Error Handling
82
+
83
+ - Implement structured error codes and recovery suggestions
84
+ - Add error telemetry collection (with privacy controls)
85
+ - Create error reproduction scripts for debugging
86
+ - Add graceful degradation modes
87
+
88
+ ### Configuration System
89
+
90
+ - Add configuration file support (.claude-evolve.json)
91
+ - Implement environment-specific configurations
92
+ - Add configuration validation and migration tools
93
+ - Create configuration templates for common scenarios
94
+
95
+ ### Monitoring and Observability
96
+
97
+ - Add execution time tracking and optimization suggestions
98
+ - Implement resource usage monitoring (memory, CPU)
99
+ - Create performance regression detection
100
+
101
+ ### Testing Infrastructure Improvements
102
+
103
+ - **Automated Testing Matrix**: Set up GitHub Actions CI pipeline with multiple OS testing (Ubuntu, macOS, Windows WSL)
104
+ - **Shell Script Coverage**: Implement code coverage reporting for shell scripts using tools like bashcov or kcov
105
+ - **Performance Benchmarking**: Add automated performance tests to detect CLI execution speed regressions
106
+ - **Integration Test Environments**: Create Docker-based test environments for consistent testing across platforms
107
+ - **Test Data Management**: Implement test fixture management for reproducible testing scenarios
108
+ - **Parallel Test Execution**: Optimize test suite execution time through parallel test running
109
+ - **Test Result Reporting**: Add comprehensive test result reporting with trend analysis
110
+ - **Mock Service Improvements**: Enhance Claude API mocking with more realistic response scenarios and error conditions
111
+ - **Bats Environment Documentation**: Document the TMPDIR requirements for Bats tests in the README
112
+ - **Cross-platform Test Compatibility**: Verify TMPDIR solution works across different platforms
113
+ - **Test Runner Consolidation**: Consider whether to maintain both Bats and shell-based test runners
114
+
115
+ ### Enhanced Timeout Management
116
+
117
+ - **Granular Timeout Controls**: Support timeout specification in minutes/hours (e.g., `--timeout 5m`, `--timeout 2h`)
118
+ - **Process Group Management**: Implement proper process group cleanup to handle evaluators that spawn subprocesses
119
+ - **Timeout Recovery Strategies**: Add automatic retry mechanisms for timeout scenarios with backoff logic
120
+ - **Cross-platform Timeout**: Ensure consistent timeout behavior across Linux, macOS, and Windows WSL environments
121
+ - **Timeout Monitoring**: Add real-time timeout countdown display during evaluation execution
122
+ - **Smart Timeout Recommendations**: Analyze historical evaluation times to suggest optimal timeout values
123
+ - Add execution analytics and insights
124
+ - Implement CSV schema validation to catch column mismatch issues at runtime
125
+ - Consider using a more robust CSV parsing library or approach to prevent manual column indexing errors
126
+
127
+ ## Architecture Improvements
128
+
129
+ ### Modularity
130
+
131
+ - Extract common CLI patterns into reusable library
132
+ - Implement plugin architecture for extensibility
133
+ - Add support for custom command extensions
134
+ - Create standardized interfaces for evaluators
135
+
136
+ ### Performance
137
+
138
+ - Implement caching for frequently accessed data
139
+ - Add lazy loading for heavy operations
140
+ - Optimize JSON parsing and file operations
141
+ - Create efficient batch processing modes
142
+
143
+ ## Documentation and User Experience
144
+
145
+ ### Documentation
146
+
147
+ - Add man page generation
148
+ - Create interactive tutorial mode
149
+ - Implement contextual help system
150
+ - Add troubleshooting guides and FAQ
151
+
152
+ ### User Experience
153
+
154
+ - Add onboarding wizard for new projects
155
+ - Implement project templates and examples
156
+ - Create guided workflow suggestions
157
+ - Add undo/rollback functionality for destructive operations
158
+
159
+ ## Repository Management
160
+
161
+ ### Branch Protection Enhancements
162
+
163
+ - Consider adding required status checks once CI/CD is implemented in Phase 7
164
+ - Evaluate enabling linear history requirement to simplify merge scenarios
165
+ - Add automated branch protection rule updates when new CI checks are added
166
+ - Implement branch protection rule validation/testing to ensure proper configuration
167
+ - Consider adding protection for other important branches (develop, release branches)
168
+ - Add monitoring/alerting for branch protection rule changes