botholomew 0.8.3 → 0.8.5

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
package/README.md CHANGED
@@ -8,15 +8,17 @@
8
8
 
9
9
  ![Botholomew chat TUI](docs/assets/chat-happy-path.gif)
10
10
 
11
- **A local AI agent for knowledge work.** Botholomew is an autonomous agent
11
+ **An AI agent for knowledge work.** Botholomew is an autonomous agent
12
12
  that works its way through a task queue — reading email, summarizing
13
13
  documents, researching topics, organizing notes, and maintaining context
14
14
  over time — while you sleep, work, or chat with it.
15
15
 
16
- Unlike coding agents, Botholomew has **no shell, no filesystem, and no network
17
- tools** by default. Everything it touches lives inside a single DuckDB database
18
- at `.botholomew/data.duckdb` and a handful of markdown files. External access
19
- is granted deliberately, per project, through MCP servers.
16
+ Unlike coding agents, Botholomew has **no shell and no direct access to
17
+ your filesystem**. It can't edit files on disk instead, it ingests local
18
+ files, folders, and URLs into a DuckDB-backed context store that it can
19
+ read, search, and summarize. External capabilities (email, Slack, the web,
20
+ and hundreds of other services) are granted deliberately, per project,
21
+ through MCP servers wired up via [MCPX](https://github.com/evantahler/mcpx).
20
22
 
21
23
  ---
22
24
 
@@ -27,19 +29,19 @@ is granted deliberately, per project, through MCP servers.
27
29
  long-running `--persist` worker, or point cron at `botholomew worker run`.
28
30
  - **Portable.** Each project is a `.botholomew/` directory — markdown +
29
31
  DuckDB. Copy it, share it, check it in (or `.gitignore` it).
30
- - **Local.** All data stays on your machine. Embeddings are indexed in
31
- DuckDB's native vector store with HNSW. Model calls go direct to Anthropic
32
- and OpenAI.
32
+ - **Your data, your disk.** Project state tasks, threads, ingested
33
+ context, embeddings lives in `.botholomew/`, indexed in DuckDB with
34
+ HNSW for vector search. Model calls go direct to Anthropic and OpenAI;
35
+ any further reach is scoped to the MCP servers you add.
33
36
  - **Extensible.** External tools come from MCP servers via
34
37
  [MCPX](https://github.com/evantahler/mcpx) — run them locally (Gmail,
35
38
  Slack, GitHub) or connect through an MCP gateway like
36
39
  [Arcade.dev](https://www.arcade.dev/) to reach hundreds of
37
40
  authenticated services without managing each server yourself.
38
41
  Reusable workflows are defined as markdown "skills" (slash commands).
39
- - **Safe by default.** The agent has no shell, no network, and no
40
- filesystem access of its own. Everything it can touch lives in
41
- `.botholomew/` — and every external capability is something you
42
- explicitly add.
42
+ - **Safe by default.** The agent has no shell and no direct filesystem
43
+ access. Out of the box, everything it can touch lives in `.botholomew/`;
44
+ every external capability is a MCP server you explicitly add.
43
45
  - **Concurrent.** Many workers can run at once. Each registers itself in
44
46
  the DB and heartbeats; crashed workers get reaped and their tasks go
45
47
  back into the queue automatically.
@@ -49,6 +51,15 @@ is granted deliberately, per project, through MCP servers.
49
51
 
50
52
  ---
51
53
 
54
+ ## Demo
55
+
56
+ A full tour of the chat TUI — every tab, slash-command autocomplete,
57
+ the message queue, tool-call visualization, and the live workers panel:
58
+
59
+ ![Tour of every tab in the chat TUI](docs/assets/full-tour.gif)
60
+
61
+ ---
62
+
52
63
  ## Install
53
64
 
54
65
  Requires [Bun](https://bun.sh) 1.1+.
package/package.json CHANGED
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
1
1
  {
2
2
  "name": "botholomew",
3
- "version": "0.8.3",
4
- "description": "Local, autonomous AI agent for knowledge work — works your task queue while you sleep.",
3
+ "version": "0.8.5",
4
+ "description": "An autonomous AI agent for knowledge work — works your task queue while you sleep.",
5
5
  "type": "module",
6
6
  "bin": {
7
7
  "botholomew": "./src/cli.ts"
@@ -1,4 +1,5 @@
1
1
  import { getConfigPath } from "../constants.ts";
2
+ import { setLogLevel } from "../utils/logger.ts";
2
3
  import { type BotholomewConfig, DEFAULT_CONFIG } from "./schemas.ts";
3
4
 
4
5
  export async function loadConfig(
@@ -22,6 +23,8 @@ export async function loadConfig(
22
23
  config.openai_api_key = process.env.OPENAI_API_KEY;
23
24
  }
24
25
 
26
+ setLogLevel(config.log_level);
27
+
25
28
  return config;
26
29
  }
27
30
 
@@ -15,6 +15,7 @@ export interface BotholomewConfig {
15
15
  worker_stopped_retention_seconds?: number;
16
16
  schedule_min_interval_seconds?: number;
17
17
  schedule_claim_stale_seconds?: number;
18
+ log_level?: string;
18
19
  }
19
20
 
20
21
  export const DEFAULT_CONFIG: Required<BotholomewConfig> = {
@@ -34,4 +35,5 @@ export const DEFAULT_CONFIG: Required<BotholomewConfig> = {
34
35
  worker_stopped_retention_seconds: 3600,
35
36
  schedule_min_interval_seconds: 60,
36
37
  schedule_claim_stale_seconds: 300,
38
+ log_level: "",
37
39
  };
@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ import {
6
6
  listContextItemsByPrefix,
7
7
  resolveContextItem,
8
8
  } from "../../db/context.ts";
9
+ import { buildContextTree } from "../dir/tree.ts";
9
10
  import type { ToolDefinition } from "../tool.ts";
10
11
 
11
12
  const inputSchema = z.object({
@@ -43,6 +44,12 @@ const outputSchema = z.object({
43
44
  ),
44
45
  message: z.string(),
45
46
  is_error: z.boolean(),
47
+ tree: z
48
+ .string()
49
+ .optional()
50
+ .describe(
51
+ "Snapshot of the context filesystem after the refresh so you can see what's currently stored.",
52
+ ),
46
53
  });
47
54
 
48
55
  const empty = {
@@ -54,6 +61,7 @@ const empty = {
54
61
  chunks: 0,
55
62
  embeddings_skipped: false,
56
63
  items: [],
64
+ tree: undefined as string | undefined,
57
65
  };
58
66
 
59
67
  export const contextRefreshTool = {
@@ -127,10 +135,13 @@ export const contextRefreshTool = {
127
135
  parts.push("embeddings skipped (no OpenAI API key configured)");
128
136
  }
129
137
 
138
+ const { tree } = await buildContextTree(ctx.conn);
139
+
130
140
  return {
131
141
  ...result,
132
142
  message: parts.join(", "),
133
143
  is_error: false,
144
+ tree,
134
145
  };
135
146
  },
136
147
  } satisfies ToolDefinition<typeof inputSchema, typeof outputSchema>;
@@ -1,4 +1,5 @@
1
1
  import { z } from "zod";
2
+ import type { DbConnection } from "../../db/connection.ts";
2
3
  import {
3
4
  countContextItemsByPrefix,
4
5
  listContextItemsByPrefix,
@@ -9,6 +10,185 @@ const DEFAULT_MAX_DEPTH = 3;
9
10
  const DEFAULT_ITEMS_PER_DIR = 15;
10
11
  const HARD_FETCH_CAP = 1000;
11
12
 
13
+ export interface BuildContextTreeOptions {
14
+ path?: string;
15
+ maxDepth?: number;
16
+ itemsPerDir?: number;
17
+ }
18
+
19
+ export interface BuildContextTreeResult {
20
+ tree: string;
21
+ total_items: number;
22
+ truncated_dirs: Array<{ path: string; shown: number; total: number }>;
23
+ hint: string;
24
+ }
25
+
26
+ interface DirNode {
27
+ name: string;
28
+ fullPath: string;
29
+ isDir: true;
30
+ children: TreeEntry[];
31
+ }
32
+
33
+ interface FileNode {
34
+ name: string;
35
+ fullPath: string;
36
+ isDir: false;
37
+ }
38
+
39
+ type TreeEntry = DirNode | FileNode;
40
+
41
+ export async function buildContextTree(
42
+ conn: DbConnection,
43
+ options: BuildContextTreeOptions = {},
44
+ ): Promise<BuildContextTreeResult> {
45
+ const path = options.path ?? "/";
46
+ const maxDepth = options.maxDepth ?? DEFAULT_MAX_DEPTH;
47
+ const itemsPerDir = options.itemsPerDir ?? DEFAULT_ITEMS_PER_DIR;
48
+ const normalizedPath = path.endsWith("/") ? path : `${path}/`;
49
+
50
+ const totalItems = await countContextItemsByPrefix(conn, path, {
51
+ recursive: true,
52
+ });
53
+
54
+ if (totalItems === 0) {
55
+ return {
56
+ tree: `${path}\n (empty)`,
57
+ total_items: 0,
58
+ truncated_dirs: [],
59
+ hint: "Directory is empty.",
60
+ };
61
+ }
62
+
63
+ const items = await listContextItemsByPrefix(conn, path, {
64
+ recursive: true,
65
+ limit: HARD_FETCH_CAP,
66
+ });
67
+
68
+ // Build tree structure: dirs map child name -> child node
69
+ const root: DirNode = {
70
+ name: path,
71
+ fullPath: path,
72
+ isDir: true,
73
+ children: [],
74
+ };
75
+ const dirIndex = new Map<string, DirNode>();
76
+ dirIndex.set(stripTrailingSlash(path), root);
77
+
78
+ for (const item of items) {
79
+ const relative = item.context_path.slice(normalizedPath.length);
80
+ if (relative.length === 0) continue; // root itself, skip
81
+ const parts = relative.split("/").filter((p) => p.length > 0);
82
+ const isExplicitDir = item.mime_type === "inode/directory";
83
+
84
+ // Walk segments, creating intermediate directories as needed
85
+ let parentDir = root;
86
+ let currentRel = "";
87
+ for (let i = 0; i < parts.length; i++) {
88
+ const segment = parts[i];
89
+ if (!segment) continue;
90
+ currentRel = currentRel ? `${currentRel}/${segment}` : segment;
91
+ const fullPath = `${normalizedPath}${currentRel}`;
92
+ const isLeaf = i === parts.length - 1;
93
+ const isDirHere = !isLeaf || isExplicitDir;
94
+
95
+ if (isDirHere) {
96
+ const key = stripTrailingSlash(fullPath);
97
+ let dir = dirIndex.get(key);
98
+ if (!dir) {
99
+ dir = {
100
+ name: segment,
101
+ fullPath,
102
+ isDir: true,
103
+ children: [],
104
+ };
105
+ dirIndex.set(key, dir);
106
+ parentDir.children.push(dir);
107
+ }
108
+ parentDir = dir;
109
+ } else {
110
+ parentDir.children.push({
111
+ name: segment,
112
+ fullPath,
113
+ isDir: false,
114
+ });
115
+ }
116
+ }
117
+ }
118
+
119
+ // Sort each directory's children: dirs first, then alphabetical
120
+ for (const dir of dirIndex.values()) {
121
+ dir.children.sort((a, b) => {
122
+ if (a.isDir !== b.isDir) return a.isDir ? -1 : 1;
123
+ return a.name.localeCompare(b.name);
124
+ });
125
+ }
126
+
127
+ const truncatedDirs: Array<{
128
+ path: string;
129
+ shown: number;
130
+ total: number;
131
+ }> = [];
132
+ const depthLimitedDirs: string[] = [];
133
+
134
+ const lines: string[] = [path];
135
+
136
+ const render = (dir: DirNode, indent: string, currentDepth: number): void => {
137
+ const children = dir.children;
138
+ const total = children.length;
139
+ const shown = Math.min(total, itemsPerDir);
140
+ const visible = children.slice(0, shown);
141
+ const overflow = total - shown;
142
+
143
+ if (overflow > 0) {
144
+ truncatedDirs.push({
145
+ path: stripTrailingSlash(dir.fullPath),
146
+ shown,
147
+ total,
148
+ });
149
+ }
150
+
151
+ for (let i = 0; i < visible.length; i++) {
152
+ const child = visible[i];
153
+ if (!child) continue;
154
+ const isLastVisible = i === visible.length - 1 && overflow === 0;
155
+ const connector = isLastVisible ? "└── " : "├── ";
156
+ const childIndent = isLastVisible ? " " : "│ ";
157
+
158
+ if (child.isDir) {
159
+ const atDepthLimit = currentDepth + 1 >= maxDepth;
160
+ if (atDepthLimit && child.children.length > 0) {
161
+ depthLimitedDirs.push(stripTrailingSlash(child.fullPath));
162
+ const subCount = countDescendants(child);
163
+ lines.push(
164
+ `${indent}${connector}${child.name}/ (${subCount} ${
165
+ subCount === 1 ? "item" : "items"
166
+ }, drill in)`,
167
+ );
168
+ } else {
169
+ lines.push(`${indent}${connector}${child.name}/`);
170
+ render(child, indent + childIndent, currentDepth + 1);
171
+ }
172
+ } else {
173
+ lines.push(`${indent}${connector}${child.name}`);
174
+ }
175
+ }
176
+
177
+ if (overflow > 0) {
178
+ lines.push(`${indent}└── ... (+${overflow} more)`);
179
+ }
180
+ };
181
+
182
+ render(root, "", 0);
183
+
184
+ return {
185
+ tree: lines.join("\n"),
186
+ total_items: totalItems,
187
+ truncated_dirs: truncatedDirs,
188
+ hint: buildHint({ truncatedDirs, depthLimitedDirs, totalItems }),
189
+ };
190
+ }
191
+
12
192
  const inputSchema = z.object({
13
193
  path: z
14
194
  .string()
@@ -48,21 +228,6 @@ const outputSchema = z.object({
48
228
  hint: z.string(),
49
229
  });
50
230
 
51
- interface DirNode {
52
- name: string;
53
- fullPath: string;
54
- isDir: true;
55
- children: TreeEntry[];
56
- }
57
-
58
- interface FileNode {
59
- name: string;
60
- fullPath: string;
61
- isDir: false;
62
- }
63
-
64
- type TreeEntry = DirNode | FileNode;
65
-
66
231
  export const contextTreeTool = {
67
232
  name: "context_tree",
68
233
  description:
@@ -71,163 +236,12 @@ export const contextTreeTool = {
71
236
  inputSchema,
72
237
  outputSchema,
73
238
  execute: async (input, ctx) => {
74
- const path = input.path ?? "/";
75
- const maxDepth = input.max_depth ?? DEFAULT_MAX_DEPTH;
76
- const itemsPerDir = input.items_per_dir ?? DEFAULT_ITEMS_PER_DIR;
77
- const normalizedPath = path.endsWith("/") ? path : `${path}/`;
78
-
79
- const totalItems = await countContextItemsByPrefix(ctx.conn, path, {
80
- recursive: true,
81
- });
82
-
83
- if (totalItems === 0) {
84
- return {
85
- tree: `${path}\n (empty)`,
86
- is_error: false,
87
- total_items: 0,
88
- truncated_dirs: [],
89
- hint: "Directory is empty.",
90
- };
91
- }
92
-
93
- const items = await listContextItemsByPrefix(ctx.conn, path, {
94
- recursive: true,
95
- limit: HARD_FETCH_CAP,
96
- });
97
-
98
- // Build tree structure: dirs map child name -> child node
99
- const root: DirNode = {
100
- name: path,
101
- fullPath: path,
102
- isDir: true,
103
- children: [],
104
- };
105
- const dirIndex = new Map<string, DirNode>();
106
- dirIndex.set(stripTrailingSlash(path), root);
107
-
108
- for (const item of items) {
109
- const relative = item.context_path.slice(normalizedPath.length);
110
- if (relative.length === 0) continue; // root itself, skip
111
- const parts = relative.split("/").filter((p) => p.length > 0);
112
- const isExplicitDir = item.mime_type === "inode/directory";
113
-
114
- // Walk segments, creating intermediate directories as needed
115
- let parentDir = root;
116
- let currentRel = "";
117
- for (let i = 0; i < parts.length; i++) {
118
- const segment = parts[i];
119
- if (!segment) continue;
120
- currentRel = currentRel ? `${currentRel}/${segment}` : segment;
121
- const fullPath = `${normalizedPath}${currentRel}`;
122
- const isLeaf = i === parts.length - 1;
123
- const isDirHere = !isLeaf || isExplicitDir;
124
-
125
- if (isDirHere) {
126
- const key = stripTrailingSlash(fullPath);
127
- let dir = dirIndex.get(key);
128
- if (!dir) {
129
- dir = {
130
- name: segment,
131
- fullPath,
132
- isDir: true,
133
- children: [],
134
- };
135
- dirIndex.set(key, dir);
136
- parentDir.children.push(dir);
137
- }
138
- parentDir = dir;
139
- } else {
140
- parentDir.children.push({
141
- name: segment,
142
- fullPath,
143
- isDir: false,
144
- });
145
- }
146
- }
147
- }
148
-
149
- // Sort each directory's children: dirs first, then alphabetical
150
- for (const dir of dirIndex.values()) {
151
- dir.children.sort((a, b) => {
152
- if (a.isDir !== b.isDir) return a.isDir ? -1 : 1;
153
- return a.name.localeCompare(b.name);
154
- });
155
- }
156
-
157
- const truncatedDirs: Array<{
158
- path: string;
159
- shown: number;
160
- total: number;
161
- }> = [];
162
- const depthLimitedDirs: string[] = [];
163
-
164
- const lines: string[] = [path];
165
-
166
- const render = (
167
- dir: DirNode,
168
- indent: string,
169
- currentDepth: number,
170
- ): void => {
171
- const children = dir.children;
172
- const total = children.length;
173
- const shown = Math.min(total, itemsPerDir);
174
- const visible = children.slice(0, shown);
175
- const overflow = total - shown;
176
-
177
- if (overflow > 0) {
178
- truncatedDirs.push({
179
- path: stripTrailingSlash(dir.fullPath),
180
- shown,
181
- total,
182
- });
183
- }
184
-
185
- for (let i = 0; i < visible.length; i++) {
186
- const child = visible[i];
187
- if (!child) continue;
188
- const isLastVisible = i === visible.length - 1 && overflow === 0;
189
- const connector = isLastVisible ? "└── " : "├── ";
190
- const childIndent = isLastVisible ? " " : "│ ";
191
-
192
- if (child.isDir) {
193
- const atDepthLimit = currentDepth + 1 >= maxDepth;
194
- if (atDepthLimit && child.children.length > 0) {
195
- depthLimitedDirs.push(stripTrailingSlash(child.fullPath));
196
- const subCount = countDescendants(child);
197
- lines.push(
198
- `${indent}${connector}${child.name}/ (${subCount} ${
199
- subCount === 1 ? "item" : "items"
200
- }, drill in)`,
201
- );
202
- } else {
203
- lines.push(`${indent}${connector}${child.name}/`);
204
- render(child, indent + childIndent, currentDepth + 1);
205
- }
206
- } else {
207
- lines.push(`${indent}${connector}${child.name}`);
208
- }
209
- }
210
-
211
- if (overflow > 0) {
212
- lines.push(`${indent}└── ... (+${overflow} more)`);
213
- }
214
- };
215
-
216
- render(root, "", 0);
217
-
218
- const hint = buildHint({
219
- truncatedDirs,
220
- depthLimitedDirs,
221
- totalItems,
239
+ const result = await buildContextTree(ctx.conn, {
240
+ path: input.path,
241
+ maxDepth: input.max_depth,
242
+ itemsPerDir: input.items_per_dir,
222
243
  });
223
-
224
- return {
225
- tree: lines.join("\n"),
226
- is_error: false,
227
- total_items: totalItems,
228
- truncated_dirs: truncatedDirs,
229
- hint,
230
- };
244
+ return { ...result, is_error: false };
231
245
  },
232
246
  } satisfies ToolDefinition<typeof inputSchema, typeof outputSchema>;
233
247
 
@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ import {
6
6
  PathConflictError,
7
7
  upsertContextItem,
8
8
  } from "../../db/context.ts";
9
+ import { buildContextTree } from "../dir/tree.ts";
9
10
  import type { ToolDefinition } from "../tool.ts";
10
11
 
11
12
  function mimeFromPath(path: string): string {
@@ -49,6 +50,12 @@ const outputSchema = z.object({
49
50
  error_type: z.string().optional(),
50
51
  message: z.string().optional(),
51
52
  next_action_hint: z.string().optional(),
53
+ tree: z
54
+ .string()
55
+ .optional()
56
+ .describe(
57
+ "Snapshot of the context filesystem after the write so you can see the surrounding files.",
58
+ ),
52
59
  });
53
60
 
54
61
  export const contextWriteTool = {
@@ -86,7 +93,13 @@ export const contextWriteTool = {
86
93
  });
87
94
 
88
95
  await ingestByPath(ctx.conn, input.path, ctx.config);
89
- return { id: item.id, path: item.context_path, is_error: false };
96
+ const { tree } = await buildContextTree(ctx.conn);
97
+ return {
98
+ id: item.id,
99
+ path: item.context_path,
100
+ is_error: false,
101
+ tree,
102
+ };
90
103
  } catch (err) {
91
104
  if (err instanceof PathConflictError) {
92
105
  return {
@@ -4,34 +4,78 @@ function ts(): string {
4
4
  return ansis.gray(new Date().toTimeString().slice(0, 8));
5
5
  }
6
6
 
7
+ const LEVELS = {
8
+ silent: 0,
9
+ error: 1,
10
+ warn: 2,
11
+ info: 3,
12
+ debug: 4,
13
+ } as const;
14
+
15
+ type LogLevel = keyof typeof LEVELS;
16
+
17
+ function parseLevel(raw: string | undefined): number | undefined {
18
+ const key = raw?.toLowerCase();
19
+ if (key && key in LEVELS) return LEVELS[key as LogLevel];
20
+ return undefined;
21
+ }
22
+
23
+ const envPinned = parseLevel(process.env.BOTHOLOMEW_LOG_LEVEL) !== undefined;
24
+
25
+ function defaultLevel(): number {
26
+ const explicit = parseLevel(process.env.BOTHOLOMEW_LOG_LEVEL);
27
+ if (explicit !== undefined) return explicit;
28
+ if (process.env.NODE_ENV === "test") return LEVELS.error;
29
+ return LEVELS.info;
30
+ }
31
+
32
+ let currentLevel = defaultLevel();
33
+
34
+ /**
35
+ * Apply a log level from config. `BOTHOLOMEW_LOG_LEVEL` always wins, so
36
+ * this is a no-op when that env var is set. Empty/invalid values are
37
+ * ignored — callers can pass `config.log_level` directly without checking.
38
+ */
39
+ export function setLogLevel(level: string | undefined): void {
40
+ if (envPinned) return;
41
+ const parsed = parseLevel(level);
42
+ if (parsed === undefined) return;
43
+ currentLevel = parsed;
44
+ }
45
+
7
46
  export const logger = {
8
47
  info(msg: string) {
48
+ if (currentLevel < LEVELS.info) return;
9
49
  console.log(ts(), ansis.blue("ℹ"), msg);
10
50
  },
11
51
 
12
52
  success(msg: string) {
53
+ if (currentLevel < LEVELS.info) return;
13
54
  console.log(ts(), ansis.green("✓"), msg);
14
55
  },
15
56
 
16
57
  warn(msg: string) {
58
+ if (currentLevel < LEVELS.warn) return;
17
59
  console.log(ts(), ansis.yellow("⚠"), msg);
18
60
  },
19
61
 
20
62
  error(msg: string) {
63
+ if (currentLevel < LEVELS.error) return;
21
64
  console.error(ts(), ansis.red("✗"), msg);
22
65
  },
23
66
 
24
67
  debug(msg: string) {
25
- if (process.env.BOTHOLOMEW_DEBUG) {
26
- console.log(ts(), ansis.gray("·"), ansis.gray(msg));
27
- }
68
+ if (currentLevel < LEVELS.debug) return;
69
+ console.log(ts(), ansis.gray("·"), ansis.gray(msg));
28
70
  },
29
71
 
30
72
  dim(msg: string) {
73
+ if (currentLevel < LEVELS.info) return;
31
74
  console.log(ts(), ansis.dim(msg));
32
75
  },
33
76
 
34
77
  phase(name: string, detail?: string) {
78
+ if (currentLevel < LEVELS.info) return;
35
79
  const tag = ansis.magenta.bold(`[[${name}]]`);
36
80
  if (detail) {
37
81
  console.log(ts(), tag, ansis.dim(detail));