analyzthis_design 2.4.1 → 2.5.0

package/README.md

@@ -4,6 +4,37 @@ A set of AI design personas and a task-first evaluation framework that plugs int
 
 Install once. Run structured UX critiques, multi-phase ideation, and task-grounded screen reviews — directly inside your AI chat. **No external LLM API keys required** for CLI orchestrator runs: **`/devi`** voices each persona from your host IDE (Cursor, Claude, etc.).
 
+## v2.5.0 — personas earn or lose trust
+
+Marking a note now moves a score. Previously a rejection *raised* a persona's score by
+15 — `accept.fix()` recorded `outcome: 'revised'` and scoring counted outcomes without
+reading their value. Punishment was a reward. Fixed.
+
+- **Signed, rate-based scoring.** A persona starts at 50 and moves both ways:
+  `shipped` +15, `blocked_correctly` +10, `revised` −5, `missed` −15, plus
+  `(rating − 3) x 4` per rating. Scored as a **rate per signal**, not a running total,
+  so early wins can never make a persona immune to later failures.
+- **Evidence gating.** Under 5 signals a persona reads `Baseline (insufficient
+  evidence)`. One bad note does not brand anyone.
+- **Bands:** At risk · Developing · Baseline · Reliable · Trusted.
+- **Devi gets a scoreboard** in every pending prompt and weights its synthesis,
+  saying the lean in one line. Advisory only — **no persona is ever dropped from a run.**
+- **Feedback works with no terminal.** New `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool in the
+  **lite** catalog, so Claude Desktop can record keep/skip. Same shared core as the
+  CLI — both transports write identical state.
+- **The persona asks.** Every note ends with one host-neutral line: *"Was this right?
+  Say yes, or no plus one sentence."* The designer answers in plain language; the
+  agent picks the transport. No flags, ever.
+- **Lessons learn from rejections too**, tagged `polarity`, and de-duplicated so
+  re-marking a note cannot inflate a score.
+
+```bash
+npx analyzthis_design scores                  # the whole team
+npx analyzthis_design scores --persona arjun  # one persona, with the breakdown
+```
+
+Scores are derived on read — changing the weights re-scores history with no migration.
+
 ## v2.4.1 — `/accept` and `/share` (designer keep / skip / send)
 
 After `/zara` (or any persona), type `/accept yes` or `/accept no` plus one sentence. No CLI flags. Writes keep or skip for **local** evolution. Slash-only notes still count.
@@ -54,7 +85,7 @@ Pass `--global` to opt into the legacy merged behavior (read `config.sources` an
 
 Use `npx analyzthis_design run-unchunked` for the legacy single-pass orchestrator.
 
-**npm:** [analyzthis_design](https://www.npmjs.com/package/analyzthis_design) · **Current version:** 2.4.1 · **Step-by-step guide:** [HOW-TO-USE.md](./HOW-TO-USE.md)
+**npm:** [analyzthis_design](https://www.npmjs.com/package/analyzthis_design) · **Current version:** 2.5.0 · **Step-by-step guide:** [HOW-TO-USE.md](./HOW-TO-USE.md)
 
 ---
 
@@ -80,7 +111,7 @@ npx analyzthis_design run-unchunked --task "Review invoice approval screen" --pr
 
 > **Security:** This package publishes **plain source** — no obfuscation, no minification, no dynamic require. Every file in `dist/` is readable and auditable. The `postinstall` script only prints a welcome message; it does **not** write to any AI-agent directories. Skill installation requires an explicit `npx analyzthis_design install --target <ide>` (or `npx analyzthis_design --target <ide>`).
 >
-> **MCP (universal):** `npx analyzthis_design mcp` starts a local MCP server. Default catalog is **lite** (router + retrieve + session + receipt). Full 19 named tools: `ANALYZTHIS_MCP_CATALOG=full` or `mcp --catalog full`. Auto-configures for Cursor, Claude Desktop, **Claude Code**, and Windsurf during install. For Lovable, v0, Bolt, Replit, ChatGPT: run `npx analyzthis_design mcp --configure <tool>` for a config snippet.
+> **MCP (universal):** `npx analyzthis_design mcp` starts a local MCP server. Default catalog is **lite** (router + retrieve + session + receipt). Full 19 named tools: `ANALYZTHIS_MCP_CATALOG=full` or `mcp --catalog full`. Auto-configures for Cursor, Claude Desktop, **Claude Code**, and Windsurf during install. **Browser-only tools (Lovable, v0, Bolt, Replit, ChatGPT) cannot use MCP here** — our server speaks stdio, and a cloud-hosted tool cannot spawn a process on your machine. Paste the team in instead: `npx analyzthis_design system-prompt --mode both`, or copy it with one click from [the tool picker](https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app/design#install-lovable). Note the paste path gives you the personas but no `/accept`, lessons, or trust scores — those need local state.
 
 ### Install by target IDE
 
@@ -893,7 +924,7 @@ skills/
 |---------|-------------|
 | **MCP server** | `npx analyzthis_design mcp` starts a local MCP server exposing 19 tools — all 8 individual personas + 6 combination passes + 5 utilities. Any MCP-compatible client can discover and call them. |
 | **Auto-configure MCP** | `npx analyzthis_design mcp --configure cursor` (or `claude`, `windsurf`) writes the MCP config automatically. `--target all` now auto-configures MCP during install. |
-| **Universal IDE support** | Cursor, Claude Desktop, Windsurf auto-configured. Lovable, v0, Bolt, Replit, ChatGPT: run `mcp --configure <tool>` for a copy-paste config snippet. |
+| **Universal IDE support** | Cursor, Claude Code, Claude Desktop, Windsurf auto-configured via MCP. Lovable, v0, Bolt, Replit, ChatGPT install nothing — paste `system-prompt` output into the tool's instructions. |
 | **MCP lite + full** | Default: router (`analyzthis_design`) + retrieve + session + receipt. Full 19 named tools behind `--catalog full`. |
 | **System prompt fallback** | `analyzthis_system_prompt` tool generates a consolidated prompt for tools that don't support MCP yet |
 
@@ -958,7 +989,7 @@ skills/
 
 ## Marketing site
 
-The public lab site lives in `website/` and is deployed on Vercel as **analyzthis-lab** (site only — not the npm package). Copy now names two doors: lab products for people who already use Cursor or Claude, and custom teams that arrive in a firm’s existing tools. The Vercel project root is `website/` with no build step — do not set Output Directory to `public`.
+The public lab site lives in `website/` and is deployed on Vercel as **analyzthis-lab** (site only — not the npm package). The home page keeps the packet story and offers three paths: designers (`design.html`), Dev/PMs (three jobs + workspace warning), and firm owners (map one workflow). The Vercel project root is `website/` with no build step — do not set Output Directory to `public`.
 
 - Live: [https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app](https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app)
 - Design team deep-dive: [https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app/design](https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app/design) (`website/design.html`)

package/agents/cards/anuj.md

@@ -26,3 +26,16 @@ Full Concept B text wireframe (hierarchy check, primary action, nav level, visib
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/agents/cards/arjun.md

@@ -27,3 +27,16 @@ Full UX Critique + Visual Design Audit blocks with per-dimension reasons — see
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/agents/cards/devi.md

@@ -13,3 +13,25 @@ run --task "..."  →  pending/001-arjun.json  →  /devi  →  responses/001-ar
 ```
 
 See `skills/devi/SKILL.md` for the full protocol.
+
+## Team scoreboard (advisory)
+
+Every pending prompt you pick up may open with a **Team scoreboard** — trust bands
+earned from designer feedback on past runs (`shipped` / `revised` / `missed` plus
+ratings). It is advisory input for synthesis, not an instruction.
+
+**Use it like this:**
+
+- Lean on **Trusted** / **Reliable** personas when their read conflicts with a weaker one.
+- Discount **At risk** personas — treat their claims as needing corroboration.
+- Say the lean in **one line**, e.g. "Weighted toward Meera (Trusted, 6 shipped) over Priya (At risk) on the effort call."
+
+**Never:**
+
+- Drop a persona from the run, or skip writing their output. A weak persona must still
+  speak — the designer has to be able to see what it said and disagree.
+- Treat a band as a verdict. It reflects past runs, not this screen.
+- Show the scoreboard to the designer unless they ask. It is context, not output.
+
+Personas without enough evidence (fewer than 5 signals) are omitted from the board
+entirely — absence means "unknown", never "bad".

package/agents/cards/kavi.md

@@ -24,3 +24,16 @@ Next: run /persona-orchestrator or any critique persona — they read this bank
 ```
 
 Consult `skills/kavi/SKILL.md` for the host workflow. Prefer running `npx analyzthis_design collect` over re-scanning files in chat. Invoke as **`/kavi`** (alias: `/collect-knowledge`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/agents/cards/meera.md

@@ -25,3 +25,16 @@ Full Business Impact block (metric impact, hierarchy check, segment, GTM lever,
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/agents/cards/noor.md

@@ -26,3 +26,16 @@ Full Concept A text wireframe (hierarchy, primary action, nav level, visible-on-
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/agents/cards/priya.md

@@ -25,3 +25,16 @@ Full Feasibility Analysis block (score, blockers, ranked risks, effort, simpler
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/agents/cards/raj.md

@@ -27,3 +27,16 @@ What [losing agent] gives up: [named]
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/agents/cards/zara.md

@@ -28,3 +28,16 @@ Full Delight Pass block (surface, moment, type, specific addition, why-this-one,
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/dist/README.md

@@ -4,6 +4,37 @@ A set of AI design personas and a task-first evaluation framework that plugs int
 
 Install once. Run structured UX critiques, multi-phase ideation, and task-grounded screen reviews — directly inside your AI chat. **No external LLM API keys required** for CLI orchestrator runs: **`/devi`** voices each persona from your host IDE (Cursor, Claude, etc.).
 
+## v2.5.0 — personas earn or lose trust
+
+Marking a note now moves a score. Previously a rejection *raised* a persona's score by
+15 — `accept.fix()` recorded `outcome: 'revised'` and scoring counted outcomes without
+reading their value. Punishment was a reward. Fixed.
+
+- **Signed, rate-based scoring.** A persona starts at 50 and moves both ways:
+  `shipped` +15, `blocked_correctly` +10, `revised` −5, `missed` −15, plus
+  `(rating − 3) x 4` per rating. Scored as a **rate per signal**, not a running total,
+  so early wins can never make a persona immune to later failures.
+- **Evidence gating.** Under 5 signals a persona reads `Baseline (insufficient
+  evidence)`. One bad note does not brand anyone.
+- **Bands:** At risk · Developing · Baseline · Reliable · Trusted.
+- **Devi gets a scoreboard** in every pending prompt and weights its synthesis,
+  saying the lean in one line. Advisory only — **no persona is ever dropped from a run.**
+- **Feedback works with no terminal.** New `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool in the
+  **lite** catalog, so Claude Desktop can record keep/skip. Same shared core as the
+  CLI — both transports write identical state.
+- **The persona asks.** Every note ends with one host-neutral line: *"Was this right?
+  Say yes, or no plus one sentence."* The designer answers in plain language; the
+  agent picks the transport. No flags, ever.
+- **Lessons learn from rejections too**, tagged `polarity`, and de-duplicated so
+  re-marking a note cannot inflate a score.
+
+```bash
+npx analyzthis_design scores                  # the whole team
+npx analyzthis_design scores --persona arjun  # one persona, with the breakdown
+```
+
+Scores are derived on read — changing the weights re-scores history with no migration.
+
 ## v2.4.1 — `/accept` and `/share` (designer keep / skip / send)
 
 After `/zara` (or any persona), type `/accept yes` or `/accept no` plus one sentence. No CLI flags. Writes keep or skip for **local** evolution. Slash-only notes still count.
@@ -54,7 +85,7 @@ Pass `--global` to opt into the legacy merged behavior (read `config.sources` an
 
 Use `npx analyzthis_design run-unchunked` for the legacy single-pass orchestrator.
 
-**npm:** [analyzthis_design](https://www.npmjs.com/package/analyzthis_design) · **Current version:** 2.4.1 · **Step-by-step guide:** [HOW-TO-USE.md](./HOW-TO-USE.md)
+**npm:** [analyzthis_design](https://www.npmjs.com/package/analyzthis_design) · **Current version:** 2.5.0 · **Step-by-step guide:** [HOW-TO-USE.md](./HOW-TO-USE.md)
 
 ---
 
@@ -80,7 +111,7 @@ npx analyzthis_design run-unchunked --task "Review invoice approval screen" --pr
 
 > **Security:** This package publishes **plain source** — no obfuscation, no minification, no dynamic require. Every file in `dist/` is readable and auditable. The `postinstall` script only prints a welcome message; it does **not** write to any AI-agent directories. Skill installation requires an explicit `npx analyzthis_design install --target <ide>` (or `npx analyzthis_design --target <ide>`).
 >
-> **MCP (universal):** `npx analyzthis_design mcp` starts a local MCP server. Default catalog is **lite** (router + retrieve + session + receipt). Full 19 named tools: `ANALYZTHIS_MCP_CATALOG=full` or `mcp --catalog full`. Auto-configures for Cursor, Claude Desktop, **Claude Code**, and Windsurf during install. For Lovable, v0, Bolt, Replit, ChatGPT: run `npx analyzthis_design mcp --configure <tool>` for a config snippet.
+> **MCP (universal):** `npx analyzthis_design mcp` starts a local MCP server. Default catalog is **lite** (router + retrieve + session + receipt). Full 19 named tools: `ANALYZTHIS_MCP_CATALOG=full` or `mcp --catalog full`. Auto-configures for Cursor, Claude Desktop, **Claude Code**, and Windsurf during install. **Browser-only tools (Lovable, v0, Bolt, Replit, ChatGPT) cannot use MCP here** — our server speaks stdio, and a cloud-hosted tool cannot spawn a process on your machine. Paste the team in instead: `npx analyzthis_design system-prompt --mode both`, or copy it with one click from [the tool picker](https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app/design#install-lovable). Note the paste path gives you the personas but no `/accept`, lessons, or trust scores — those need local state.
 
 ### Install by target IDE
 
@@ -893,7 +924,7 @@ skills/
 |---------|-------------|
 | **MCP server** | `npx analyzthis_design mcp` starts a local MCP server exposing 19 tools — all 8 individual personas + 6 combination passes + 5 utilities. Any MCP-compatible client can discover and call them. |
 | **Auto-configure MCP** | `npx analyzthis_design mcp --configure cursor` (or `claude`, `windsurf`) writes the MCP config automatically. `--target all` now auto-configures MCP during install. |
-| **Universal IDE support** | Cursor, Claude Desktop, Windsurf auto-configured. Lovable, v0, Bolt, Replit, ChatGPT: run `mcp --configure <tool>` for a copy-paste config snippet. |
+| **Universal IDE support** | Cursor, Claude Code, Claude Desktop, Windsurf auto-configured via MCP. Lovable, v0, Bolt, Replit, ChatGPT install nothing — paste `system-prompt` output into the tool's instructions. |
 | **MCP lite + full** | Default: router (`analyzthis_design`) + retrieve + session + receipt. Full 19 named tools behind `--catalog full`. |
 | **System prompt fallback** | `analyzthis_system_prompt` tool generates a consolidated prompt for tools that don't support MCP yet |
 
@@ -958,7 +989,7 @@ skills/
 
 ## Marketing site
 
-The public lab site lives in `website/` and is deployed on Vercel as **analyzthis-lab** (site only — not the npm package). Copy now names two doors: lab products for people who already use Cursor or Claude, and custom teams that arrive in a firm’s existing tools. The Vercel project root is `website/` with no build step — do not set Output Directory to `public`.
+The public lab site lives in `website/` and is deployed on Vercel as **analyzthis-lab** (site only — not the npm package). The home page keeps the packet story and offers three paths: designers (`design.html`), Dev/PMs (three jobs + workspace warning), and firm owners (map one workflow). The Vercel project root is `website/` with no build step — do not set Output Directory to `public`.
 
 - Live: [https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app](https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app)
 - Design team deep-dive: [https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app/design](https://analyzthis-lab.vercel.app/design) (`website/design.html`)

package/dist/agents/cards/anuj.md

@@ -26,3 +26,16 @@ Full Concept B text wireframe (hierarchy check, primary action, nav level, visib
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/dist/agents/cards/arjun.md

@@ -27,3 +27,16 @@ Full UX Critique + Visual Design Audit blocks with per-dimension reasons — see
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/dist/agents/cards/devi.md

@@ -13,3 +13,25 @@ run --task "..."  →  pending/001-arjun.json  →  /devi  →  responses/001-ar
 ```
 
 See `skills/devi/SKILL.md` for the full protocol.
+
+## Team scoreboard (advisory)
+
+Every pending prompt you pick up may open with a **Team scoreboard** — trust bands
+earned from designer feedback on past runs (`shipped` / `revised` / `missed` plus
+ratings). It is advisory input for synthesis, not an instruction.
+
+**Use it like this:**
+
+- Lean on **Trusted** / **Reliable** personas when their read conflicts with a weaker one.
+- Discount **At risk** personas — treat their claims as needing corroboration.
+- Say the lean in **one line**, e.g. "Weighted toward Meera (Trusted, 6 shipped) over Priya (At risk) on the effort call."
+
+**Never:**
+
+- Drop a persona from the run, or skip writing their output. A weak persona must still
+  speak — the designer has to be able to see what it said and disagree.
+- Treat a band as a verdict. It reflects past runs, not this screen.
+- Show the scoreboard to the designer unless they ask. It is context, not output.
+
+Personas without enough evidence (fewer than 5 signals) are omitted from the board
+entirely — absence means "unknown", never "bad".

package/dist/agents/cards/kavi.md

@@ -24,3 +24,16 @@ Next: run /persona-orchestrator or any critique persona — they read this bank
 ```
 
 Consult `skills/kavi/SKILL.md` for the host workflow. Prefer running `npx analyzthis_design collect` over re-scanning files in chat. Invoke as **`/kavi`** (alias: `/collect-knowledge`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/dist/agents/cards/meera.md

@@ -25,3 +25,16 @@ Full Business Impact block (metric impact, hierarchy check, segment, GTM lever,
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/dist/agents/cards/noor.md

@@ -26,3 +26,16 @@ Full Concept A text wireframe (hierarchy, primary action, nav level, visible-on-
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/dist/agents/cards/priya.md

@@ -25,3 +25,16 @@ Full Feasibility Analysis block (score, blockers, ranked risks, effort, simpler
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/dist/agents/cards/raj.md

@@ -27,3 +27,16 @@ What [losing agent] gives up: [named]
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/dist/agents/cards/zara.md

@@ -28,3 +28,16 @@ Full Delight Pass block (surface, moment, type, specific addition, why-this-one,
 **Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
 
 **Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `deliberation-protocol` in your host skills dir (e.g. `~/.claude/skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md` or `~/.claude/commands/deliberation-protocol.md`).
+
+## Closing line (always)
+
+End every reply with this line, exactly:
+
+```
+—
+Was this right? Say yes, or no plus one sentence. I'll record it.
+```
+
+If the designer answers, record it with whatever path you have — Bash
+(`npx analyzthis_design accept …`) or the `analyzthis_accept` MCP tool. Never ask
+them to type a command, and never mention flags.

package/dist/bin/cli.js

@@ -1000,6 +1000,60 @@ switch (cmd) {
     break;
   }
 
+  case 'scores': {
+    const em = require('../lib/evolution-metrics');
+    if (flags.includes('--submit') || flags.includes('--submit-dry-run')) {
+      const submitter = require('../lib/feedback-submit');
+      const dry = flags.includes('--submit-dry-run');
+      submitter.submitScores({ dryRun: dry })
+        .then((r) => {
+          if (r.skipped) console.log(`\n  Not sent: ${r.skipped}\n`);
+          else if (r.dryRun) console.log(`\n  Would send ${r.rows.length} persona score row(s). Counts only — no note text.\n`);
+          else console.log(`\n  Sent ${r.sent} persona score row(s).\n`);
+        })
+        .catch((e) => console.log(`\n  Submit failed: ${e.message}\n`));
+      break;
+    }
+    const metrics = em.computeEvolutionMetrics(projectVal ? { project: projectVal } : undefined);
+    if (personaVal) {
+      const m = metrics.personas[personaVal];
+      if (!m) {
+        console.log(`\n  Unknown persona "${personaVal}". Use: ${em.PERSONAS.join(', ')}\n`);
+        break;
+      }
+      console.log(`\n  ${personaVal}: ${m.score}/100 ${m.level}` +
+        (m.sufficient_evidence ? '' : ' (insufficient evidence)'));
+      console.log(`  ${m.evidence_count} signal(s) · shipped ${m.outcome_breakdown.shipped}` +
+        ` · revised ${m.outcome_breakdown.revised} · missed ${m.outcome_breakdown.missed}` +
+        (m.avg_rating != null ? ` · avg rating ${m.avg_rating}` : ''));
+      console.log(`  contributions: ${JSON.stringify(m.contributions)}\n`);
+      break;
+    }
+    console.log('\n' + em.formatEvolutionSummary(metrics));
+    break;
+  }
+
+  case 'system-prompt': {
+    // The only path into the personas for browser-only tools (Lovable, v0, Bolt,
+    // Replit, ChatGPT). They cannot reach the MCP server — it speaks stdio, and a
+    // cloud-hosted tool cannot spawn a process on the user's machine.
+    const builder = require('../lib/system-prompt');
+    const mode = getFlag('mode') || 'both';
+    if (!['create', 'critique', 'both'].includes(mode)) {
+      console.log(`\n  Unknown mode "${mode}". Use: create, critique, or both.\n`);
+      break;
+    }
+    const prompt = builder.buildPrompt({ mode });
+    const out = getFlag('out');
+    if (out) {
+      require('fs').writeFileSync(out, prompt);
+      console.log(`\n  Wrote ${prompt.length} chars to ${out}\n  Paste it into your tool's system instructions.\n`);
+    } else {
+      console.log(prompt);
+    }
+    break;
+  }
+
   case 'receipt': {
     const receipt = require('../lib/receipt');
     console.log('\n' + receipt.report({ project: projectVal }) + '\n');

package/dist/lib/accept.js

@@ -8,6 +8,7 @@
 var session = require('./session');
 var feedback = require('./feedback');
 var outcome = require('./outcome');
+var lessons = require('./lessons');
 
 var PERSONA_IDS = session.PERSONA_IDS;
 
@@ -27,6 +28,16 @@ function resolvePersona(opts) {
   return id;
 }
 
+// Lesson extraction must never break a designer's keep/skip.
+function safeExtract(project, persona) {
+  try {
+    var r = lessons.extractLessons({ project: project, persona: persona });
+    return (r && r.extracted) || 0;
+  } catch (e) {
+    return 0;
+  }
+}
+
 function keep(opts) {
   opts = opts || {};
   var persona = resolvePersona(opts);
@@ -36,22 +47,23 @@ function keep(opts) {
     text: opts.note,
   });
   session.markAccepted({ project: opts.project, persona: persona, accepted: true });
-  if (opts.comment) {
-    feedback.recordFeedback({
-      project: opts.project,
-      persona: persona,
-      satisfied: true,
-      rating: 5,
-      comment: opts.comment,
-      correction: '',
-      markRejected: false,
-    });
-  }
+  // Always record — a bare "/accept yes" is still a rating, and scoring reads it.
+  feedback.recordFeedback({
+    project: opts.project,
+    persona: persona,
+    satisfied: true,
+    rating: opts.rating != null ? Number(opts.rating) : 5,
+    comment: opts.comment || '',
+    correction: '',
+    tags: ['positive'],
+    markRejected: false,
+  });
   var shipped = opts.shipped !== false;
   if (shipped) {
     outcome.confirmOutcome({ project: opts.project, persona: persona, outcome: 'shipped' });
   }
-  return { persona: persona, kept: true, shipped: shipped };
+  var learned = safeExtract(opts.project, persona);
+  return { persona: persona, kept: true, shipped: shipped, lessons: learned };
 }
 
 function fix(opts) {
@@ -80,7 +92,8 @@ function fix(opts) {
     markRejected: true,
   });
   outcome.confirmOutcome({ project: opts.project, persona: persona, outcome: 'revised' });
-  return { persona: persona, kept: false, because: because };
+  var learnedFix = safeExtract(opts.project, persona);
+  return { persona: persona, kept: false, because: because, lessons: learnedFix };
 }
 
 function preview(opts) {