analyzthis_design 1.18.0 → 1.19.0

package/README.md

@@ -92,7 +92,7 @@ Invoke critique personas for targeted, already-grounded questions. For **wirefra
 
 ---
 
-## Agentic system (v1.15)
+## Agentic system (v1.19)
 
 ```
 User ask / Figma URL
@@ -101,14 +101,43 @@ User ask / Figma URL
         ↓
   ux-story-gate Phases 0–1.5 (PRD + DS/Figma + MoE router)
         ↓
-  MoE subset (default, 1–2 experts) OR design-critic / ideation chain (explicit "full")
+  Adversarial deliberation (parallel objection rounds, low satisfaction default)
         ↓
-  Hard gates: DS tokens → Information Hierarchy → Browser verify (skipped if assess_only + no URL)
+  MoE subset (default) OR full chain (explicit "full")
         ↓
-  Session state + cost metrics persisted  →  SHIP / REVISE / BLOCK
+  Raj on stalemate (2+ blocking objections)
+        ↓
+  Hard gates: DS → Hierarchy → Verify
+        ↓
+  SHIP / REVISE / BLOCK
 ```
 
-**Shared session state** lives at `~/.analyzthis_design/sessions/{project-id}/session-state.json` so Ask→Agent turns do not re-derive the task map, DS checklist, or routing decision.
+### Adversarial deliberation (v1.19)
+
+Personas **debate** grounded in real task_map, PRD, and UI context — they do not pass generic handoff documents.
+
+| Knob | Default | Meaning |
+|------|---------|---------|
+| `satisfaction_threshold` | 0.4 | Personas hard to please — must see evidence before `accepts_prior: true` |
+| `max_rounds` | 3 | Cap on objection rounds (token-bounded) |
+| `parallel_pairs` | Noor∥Anuj, Meera∥Priya | Adversarial critique in parallel |
+
+```bash
+npx analyzthis_design run --task "Review onboarding" --full --dry-run   # see deliberation groups
+npx analyzthis_design run --task "..." --satisfaction 0.3               # even harder to satisfy
+npx analyzthis_design run --task "..." --no-deliberate                  # legacy sequential mode
+npx analyzthis_design metrics                                           # deliberation_rounds, objections
+```
+
+Config: `~/.analyzthis_design/config.json` → `deliberation` block (see `supabase/deliberation-config.example.json`).
+
+Skill: `/deliberation-protocol` | Schema: `agents/deliberation-schema.json`
+
+**Low satisfaction ≠ unlimited tokens.** Objection rounds use lite schema + 600-token cap; synthesis and Raj use full models.
+
+---
+
+**Shared session state** lives at `~/.analyzthis_design/sessions/{project-id}/session-state.json` (includes `deliberation.round_log` after adversarial runs).
 
 ```bash
 npx analyzthis_design session init
@@ -139,6 +168,7 @@ npx analyzthis_design run --task "Review this screen" --figma https://figma.com/
 # Force the full design-critic chain, or bypass the router entirely
 npx analyzthis_design run --task "Full critique of onboarding" --full
 npx analyzthis_design run --task "Just check spacing" --experts arjun
+npx analyzthis_design run --task "..." --max-rounds 2 --satisfaction 0.5 --no-deliberate
 ```
 
 Provider defaults live in `~/.analyzthis_design/config.json`:
@@ -521,7 +551,7 @@ npx analyzthis_design retrieve --file <csv> --column <col> --keywords a,b [--lim
 
 # Standalone orchestrator
 npx analyzthis_design run --task "..." [--figma URL] [--provider anthropic|openai|google|zai] [--dry-run] [--output path]
-npx analyzthis_design run --task "..." [--lite | --full] [--experts a,b]
+npx analyzthis_design run --task "..." [--lite | --full] [--experts a,b] [--deliberate | --no-deliberate] [--max-rounds N] [--satisfaction 0.4]
 
 # Efficiency / cost
 npx analyzthis_design metrics [--project id] [--all]
@@ -551,6 +581,7 @@ lib/
   export.js             LoRA training-pair export hook
   feedback.js           Persona unhappiness + correction logging (session + global JSONL)
   feedback-submit.js    Opt-in anonymized submit to Supabase (community feedback)
+  deliberation.js       Adversarial satisfaction loops, context pack, Raj escalation
   cost.js               $-cost report from metrics × config.pricing
   orchestrator/run.js   Standalone LLM runtime (v2) — MoE, effort-graded tiers, caps, cache-aware
 scripts/obfuscate.js    Build step → dist/
@@ -558,6 +589,7 @@ skills/
   kavi/                 Kavi — Knowledge Archivist (/kavi)
   collect-knowledge/    Alias for Kavi (backward compatible)
   persona-orchestrator/ Agentic critique entry point
+  deliberation-protocol/ Adversarial review rules (v1.19)
   ux-story-gate/        Task-first gate + DS/MoE/verify/assess phases
   design-critic/        4-persona critique + hierarchy gate
   ux-ideator/           6-phase ideation

package/agents/cards/anuj.md

@@ -20,3 +20,9 @@ Top fix: [one line]
 Full Concept B text wireframe (hierarchy check, primary action, nav level, visible-on-load at full density, keyboard shortcuts, progressive disclosure, rationale) — see `skills/anuj/SKILL.md` "Output — Concept B". Use deep mode for ideation runs or full/deep critiques.
 
 **Citation:** `[filename, row N: "exact quoted value"]` — e.g. `[ux-guidelines.csv, row 22: "..."]`. Only run this persona when task Frequency = daily/weekly.
+
+## Deliberation modes (v1.19)
+
+**Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
+
+**Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md`.

package/agents/cards/arjun.md

@@ -21,3 +21,9 @@ Combined score: [X/5]
 Full UX Critique + Visual Design Audit blocks with per-dimension reasons — see `skills/arjun/SKILL.md` "Output format". Use deep mode when the user asks for a full/deep critique, any dimension scores C or below and needs the full rubric quoted, or `default_chain` is running.
 
 **Citation:** `[filename, row N: "exact quoted value"]`. Consult `skills/arjun/SKILL.md` Grade Rubric tables when scoring C or below and rubric detail is needed.
+
+## Deliberation modes (v1.19)
+
+**Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
+
+**Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md`.

package/agents/cards/meera.md

@@ -19,3 +19,9 @@ Score: [1-5]
 Full Business Impact block (metric impact, hierarchy check, segment, GTM lever, retention hook, adoption risk, verdict) — see `skills/meera/SKILL.md` "Output format". Use deep mode for full/deep critiques or when `default_chain` is running.
 
 **Citation:** `[filename, row N: "exact quoted value"]` — e.g. `[products.csv, row 6: "..."]`. Consult `skills/meera/SKILL.md` for the full reference-data table when a specific product-type match is needed.
+
+## Deliberation modes (v1.19)
+
+**Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
+
+**Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md`.

package/agents/cards/noor.md

@@ -20,3 +20,9 @@ Rationale: [one line, Hick's Law / progressive disclosure]
 Full Concept A text wireframe (hierarchy, primary action, nav level, visible-on-load, progressive disclosure, nav path, rationale) — see `skills/noor/SKILL.md` "Output — Concept A". Use deep mode for ideation runs or full/deep critiques.
 
 **Citation:** `[filename, row N: "exact quoted value"]` — e.g. `[stacks/shadcn.csv, row 8: "..."]`. Consult `skills/noor/SKILL.md` when naming specific components.
+
+## Deliberation modes (v1.19)
+
+**Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
+
+**Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md`.

package/agents/cards/priya.md

@@ -19,3 +19,9 @@ Score: [1-5]
 Full Feasibility Analysis block (score, blockers, ranked risks, effort, simpler alternative) — see `skills/priya/SKILL.md` "Output format". Use deep mode for full/deep critiques or when `default_chain` is running.
 
 **Citation:** `[filename, row N: "exact quoted value"]` — e.g. `[stacks/nextjs.csv, row 12: "..."]`. Consult `skills/priya/SKILL.md` for the stack-file table matching the session's tech stack.
+
+## Deliberation modes (v1.19)
+
+**Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
+
+**Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md`.

package/agents/cards/raj.md

@@ -21,3 +21,9 @@ What [losing agent] gives up: [named]
 ```
 
 **Citation:** `[filename, row N: "exact quoted value"]`. Consult `skills/raj/SKILL.md` for the ranked product-principles list (Owner governs, Data honesty, Intentionality over automation, Persona density split, PRD scope boundary) and their worked examples before deciding.
+
+## Deliberation modes (v1.19)
+
+**Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
+
+**Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md`.

package/agents/cards/zara.md

@@ -22,3 +22,9 @@ If high-frequency working surface: output only "no delight needed here — speed
 Full Delight Pass block (surface, moment, type, specific addition, why-this-one, cost, design-system pointer) — see `skills/zara/SKILL.md` "Output format". Use deep mode for full/deep critiques or when `default_chain` is running.
 
 **Citation:** `[filename, row N: "exact quoted value"]`. Apply the `styles.csv` 5-step filter in `skills/zara/SKILL.md` before citing — never read the full file.
+
+## Deliberation modes (v1.19)
+
+**Review mode (rounds 0–N-1):** Critique prior output with grounded objections. Default `accepts_prior: false`. Include deliberation JSON block.
+
+**Produce mode (final round):** Full output schema after consensus or Raj. See `skills/deliberation-protocol/SKILL.md`.

package/agents/chain.json

@@ -1,20 +1,26 @@
 {
   "description": "Default sequential graph for a full multi-persona critique (design-critic). The MoE router in router.json selects a smaller subset of this chain by default; only run this full chain for an explicit full-screen review.",
   "default_expert_budget": 2,
+  "deliberation_mode": "adversarial",
+  "objection_token_cap": 600,
   "default_chain": [
     { "step": 1, "persona": "arjun",  "handoff_from": null,     "handoff_to": "meera",  "parallel_safe_with": [] },
     { "step": 2, "persona": "meera",  "handoff_from": "arjun",  "handoff_to": "priya",  "parallel_safe_with": ["priya"] },
     { "step": 3, "persona": "priya",  "handoff_from": "meera",  "handoff_to": "zara",   "parallel_safe_with": ["meera"] },
     { "step": 4, "persona": "zara",   "handoff_from": "priya",  "handoff_to": null,     "parallel_safe_with": [] }
   ],
+  "deliberation_groups": {
+    "critique": [["arjun"], ["meera", "priya"], ["zara"]],
+    "ideation": [["meera"], ["noor", "anuj"], ["arjun"], ["zara", "priya"]],
+    "lite": [["arjun"], ["meera"]]
+  },
   "ideation_chain": [
     { "step": 1, "persona": "meera", "handoff_to": ["noor", "anuj"], "parallel_safe_with": [] },
     { "step": 2, "persona": "noor",  "handoff_from": "meera", "handoff_to": "arjun", "parallel_safe_with": ["anuj"] },
     { "step": 2, "persona": "anuj",  "handoff_from": "meera", "handoff_to": "arjun", "parallel_safe_with": ["noor"] },
     { "step": 3, "persona": "arjun", "handoff_from": ["noor", "anuj"], "handoff_to": "zara", "parallel_safe_with": [] },
     { "step": 4, "persona": "zara",  "handoff_from": "arjun", "handoff_to": "priya", "parallel_safe_with": [] },
-    { "step": 5, "persona": "priya", "handoff_from": "zara",  "handoff_to": "raj", "parallel_safe_with": [] },
-    { "step": 6, "persona": "raj",   "handoff_from": "priya", "handoff_to": null, "parallel_safe_with": [] }
+    { "step": 5, "persona": "priya", "handoff_from": "zara",  "handoff_to": null, "parallel_safe_with": [] }
   ],
   "tiers": {
     "router": null,

package/agents/deliberation-schema.json

@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
+{
+  "description": "Structured output every persona emits during adversarial deliberation rounds (v1.19).",
+  "persona_output_block": {
+    "grounding": [
+      {
+        "type": "task_map | prd | ui_region | ds_token | figma",
+        "ref": "string — e.g. task_map[0], PRD line, header/CTA, --color-primary",
+        "note": "string — why this citation matters"
+      }
+    ],
+    "satisfaction_with_prior": "number 0.0–1.0 — how satisfied with prior persona output",
+    "accepts_prior": "boolean — true only if satisfaction >= threshold",
+    "objections": [
+      {
+        "target_persona": "string — persona id being challenged",
+        "claim": "string — specific claim being contested",
+        "evidence_required": "string — what would resolve this",
+        "blocking": "boolean — must resolve before synthesis",
+        "grounded_in": "string — citation to task/PRD/UI"
+      }
+    ],
+    "questions": ["string — contextual questions about UI, PRD, task, JTBD"],
+    "revisions": ["string — concrete changes required in prior output"],
+    "verdict": "SHIP | REVISE | BLOCK | CONTEST | ACCEPT",
+    "synthesis": "string — optional; full produce-mode output on final round only"
+  },
+  "session_deliberation": {
+    "round": "number — current round index",
+    "max_rounds": "number",
+    "satisfaction_threshold": "number 0.0–1.0",
+    "open_objections": ["object — unresolved objections from round_log"],
+    "round_log": [
+      {
+        "round": "number",
+        "persona": "string",
+        "parsed": "object — parsed deliberation block",
+        "raw_length": "number"
+      }
+    ],
+    "consensus_reached": "boolean",
+    "raj_escalated": "boolean",
+    "mode": "adversarial | legacy"
+  }
+}

package/agents/session-schema.json

@@ -69,6 +69,16 @@
     ],
     "vault_path": "string — Obsidian vault written by Kavi collect (empty until first collect)",
     "last_collect_at": "ISO 8601 timestamp — last successful collect run",
+    "deliberation": {
+      "round": "number — current deliberation round",
+      "max_rounds": "number",
+      "satisfaction_threshold": "number 0.0–1.0",
+      "open_objections": ["object — unresolved blocking objections"],
+      "round_log": ["object — per-persona per-round parsed output"],
+      "consensus_reached": "boolean",
+      "raj_escalated": "boolean",
+      "mode": "adversarial | legacy"
+    },
     "digest": {
       "task_map_summary": "string — short summary passed to persona calls instead of the full task_map/persona_outputs history",
       "hierarchy_top3": ["string — top 3 ranked hierarchy items, if declared"],
@@ -86,7 +96,11 @@
       "cache_hits": "number — retrieve/cache hits during the last run",
       "mode": "lite | full",
       "effort_log": [{ "persona": "string", "effort": "trivial|standard|hard", "model": "string|null", "scoped_mode": "string|null" }],
-      "cost_usd": "number — estimated $ cost of the run from config.pricing (0 when pricing missing)"
+      "cost_usd": "number — estimated $ cost of the run from config.pricing (0 when pricing missing)",
+      "deliberation_rounds": "number — adversarial rounds executed in last run",
+      "objections_raised": "number",
+      "objections_resolved": "number",
+      "raj_escalations": "number"
     }
   }
 }