amsd-pipeline-shared 0.5.10 → 0.5.12

package/README.md

@@ -9,6 +9,9 @@ workflows (`amsd-pipeline-workflow`). A fix lands here, once, and both run the s
 |---|---|---|
 | The model-call gateway | `orchestrations/scripts/llm-handler.sh` and the 34 libraries it runs (`docs/gateway-files.txt`) | Every model call: retry up to `EPAM_CALL_MAX_ATTEMPTS`, the agent's ladder (next rung on a failure), the previous-refusal block, the KB episode for self-heal, cost and Langfuse |
 | The Writer's reviewer | `orchestrations/scripts/team-lead-review.sh` | A failed review call is no verdict — retried up its ladder, then *review incomplete*, never approved |
+| The reviewer's instructions and model policy | `orchestrations/prompts/templates/{team-lead-review,blocker-discipline,review-shared,code-review-cycle}.json`, `config/reviewer-policy.json`, `lib/reviewer-model.js` | The reviewer rates the work 0 to 10 and approves at 8.5 or higher; an unmet criterion the implementer can meet is a blocker. The review runs on the model the policy names (`top-of-ladder` by default: the top of the active provider set's highest ladder), read by the bash reviewer and the Claude workflow alike. Evidence: run 11, real tokens — Sonnet rated a thin and a rich delivery 9 and 9, Opus 6 and 7.5 |
+| The failure analysts' templates, the seam output contracts | `prompts/templates/{failure-analyst,agent-failure-analyst,gate-finding-analyst,lint-finding-analyst,story-recovery-analyst,post-failure-analyst}.json`, `config/seam-output-contracts.json` | Moved into the component byte-identical to the 2.0.80 release (the analysts' instructions are unchanged) |
+| Every app-level prompt template | `orchestrations/prompts/templates/*` (141) | The one source of the pipeline's prompt templates for both pipelines (operator, 2026-10-21). Moved in byte-identical to the released copies; a test fails if an install carries a template this package does not own. A project's own prompts are generated from these by the pipeline's prompt builder |
 | The Spec runner | `orchestrations/scripts/spec-mode-runner.js` | A failed mint re-proposal keeps the accepted roles and says so |
 | The KB synthesiser | `orchestrations/scripts/lib/kb-synthesizer.js` | Runs on its own seam's model |
 | Agent-to-agent messages | `orchestrations/scripts/lib/agent-messages.js` | send / receive / list / route on the pipeline's own bus format (`logs/messages/`, `agent-messages.jsonl`); "router" goes to the stage's router |

package/docs/gateway-baseline-2.0.80.md5

@@ -92,3 +92,143 @@ a01137cb36b65a3b80a8327404f4ed7a  scripts/lib/story-acs-block.sh
 043b6c85d1505ebc5da6c6b158000330  scripts/lib/plan-of-record.sh
 1cc1978d614fca875ad1117e9ac42f93  scripts/lib/render-engine-prompt.sh
 bad91b18bf546145a58423c770ba1a3a  prompts/templates/criterion-origin.json
+8c3bd8f0b375b047b8f85909f43cf4f5  config/seam-output-contracts.json
+a8c558184595777b8f2f7c62f313f622  prompts/templates/agent-failure-analyst.json
+583b47885d69f2c917db6514eef09d8e  prompts/templates/code-review-cycle.json
+d9cd85a83389a52a09477573a33fa314  prompts/templates/failure-analyst.json
+8142977265d30ecfae6128b09a3584c5  prompts/templates/gate-finding-analyst.json
+7e605cada6c96d1591811434251605d5  prompts/templates/lint-finding-analyst.json
+9ba265eb3db0d8329276856a3a006814  prompts/templates/post-failure-analyst.json
+089b704c8a96cacd0b929d8078432796  prompts/templates/review-shared.json
+7785cb19d58eb65321df380839accf85  prompts/templates/story-recovery-analyst.json
+71db8785df56a99c694b2447f45bd0a7  prompts/templates/team-lead-review.json
+271ec0ed7881aeb741758c3b79f3e77b  prompts/templates/blocker-discipline.json
+d8ab5a65203994059759a0b0aafcc8d9  prompts/templates/ac-classification.json
+46f635c2fd583a6acecd72b9fb42e280  prompts/templates/ac-elaboration.json
+4517af7c7a190826dc93f63ff71e282a  prompts/templates/ac-gate-codeline-assignment.json
+88545faf059ecfc1d33b34da47ddcbd7  prompts/templates/agent-name-refusal.json
+af6902e975ab7d26fe4fa87dc2cdd23e  prompts/templates/agent-plan-mode.json
+3f997f3b60cb46ca57bacd3e24641abb  prompts/templates/agent-proposal.json
+8bfeedf6be435dbb9f76372b5d777c08  prompts/templates/agent-retry-prefix.json
+3e630bd87bae6261d690d0b40513a68b  prompts/templates/assign-agent-roles.json
+f243819cc6a8b3313be761ff79aad4bc  prompts/templates/bug-fix-story.json
+069f31e37f04580a3a61a50c5be65add  prompts/templates/change-reviewer.json
+db5f4f4ccc7a79f8b75dc7fb635d5c12  prompts/templates/code-graph-detective.json
+af80eb699d37de3c33f8142ff14e867a  prompts/templates/codeline-bridge.json
+182ebe94aa6b76ff9db10e329a7022e7  prompts/templates/content-retry-correction.json
+878b65729afde7a948954aabded84c5f  prompts/templates/coordinator-amendment.json
+4cbae58080502113f6fff7b64afa486c  prompts/templates/corrective-note.json
+e889148a825a143e34713e7dbf0dae0c  prompts/templates/cpa-inference.json
+4ef6492508aa11814c620f18785b8386  prompts/templates/cpa-system.json
+f3c3d0a43684c96d7b887a892ee30c63  prompts/templates/declared-packages.json
+e7e5bf7e6537dec96490b0b12e84e933  prompts/templates/detective-extract.json
+5b8b2d28c37fc9036a84d3e6e69ace7d  prompts/templates/detective-overall-plan-given.json
+56fde9372f409fd4e2f0d950e954c03e  prompts/templates/detective-overall-plan.json
+772440b500616fc437f47f323cb090c6  prompts/templates/detective-prescription.json
+fcc4c33796a8ff84f0ffb1009f327b74  prompts/templates/detective-retry-note.json
+1fdd4baef69a17e71e48315a5ba69269  prompts/templates/detective-shared-package.json
+0334da922969979a77c5b530ed926fd1  prompts/templates/discovery-vocabulary.json
+ae151e94855a15014923ca6a0aa223d3  prompts/templates/e2e-route-check.json
+8602bc0209f4c9b8239edac4e1d630d5  prompts/templates/estate-survey.json
+8d95f4dda8282fe2ed1a2eaa181cf521  prompts/templates/estimation-assessment.json
+88dfed65505f1615723850c4324026ee  prompts/templates/fix-plan-shared.json
+a5902db0a2e1d57c6949bdff3a6551e6  prompts/templates/guard-vocabulary-codegraph.json
+5cffde4c531a86c79b6ffdf2dd1f4302  prompts/templates/guard-vocabulary-documentation.json
+b317a40599807d01bf56a4fd4d058994  prompts/templates/guard-vocabulary.json
+b1ef16b460745d6280173218a5ae4f10  prompts/templates/hybrid-prephase-coordinator.json
+0e30d94da41020b2f7fa4f00492d5d53  prompts/templates/inference-ladder-coordinator.json
+89623ba94a972ddebb1d202e83448190  prompts/templates/kb-enforcement-synthesis.json
+f546ef09cf91f202e08fa7fc97be9159  prompts/templates/lint-ac-remediator.json
+c032d2b3a57987f364208f475af194ec  prompts/templates/lint-fixer.json
+2fd5ae994275fa976eeb638705cd1b0b  prompts/templates/manifest-analysis.json
+c183693ce3900d3a5b23f6d910f271b4  prompts/templates/mint-existing-roster.json
+c46d01e7d248b28800c15be28442c97c  prompts/templates/new-dependency-directive.json
+0a739165f57a7abd51795fcd950b80ce  prompts/templates/new-dependency-lockfile-note.json
+fcaa89f4f128d9508b7b3f01df3f3263  prompts/templates/phase-assessment-header.json
+f168d08528b5b99d4f1dc8f77c1f44d6  prompts/templates/pipeline-tools-command.json
+2d37b0176958cf139f623e8bb2acad02  prompts/templates/pipeline-tools-hosted.json
+c49b84f8826b8ebeca2a9d08ed2b4a03  prompts/templates/plan-corrective.json
+3a4fa3a6a29d3017e7e3b379a271719e  prompts/templates/plan-producer.json
+1067f45335c3046c942a918a561007df  prompts/templates/plan-reviewer.json
+39ec1495af887178b8fcabbe9e84d640  prompts/templates/prd-change-reviewer-mode-rules.json
+0e0ca79a70b196eb850f664f51e185b5  prompts/templates/prd-change-reviewer-spec.json
+cd5909d25efae77b5507d50791fd5782  prompts/templates/prd-change-reviewer.json
+3cf8196127c9ef9d02576b52105d85f1  prompts/templates/prd-change-summarizer-text.json
+164b856ded730148c6e3609368345e9c  prompts/templates/prd-change-summarizer-tool.json
+d5be51f84cd58f9be71c9b109e926d98  prompts/templates/prd-configuration-block.json
+cbda184a2fc8d9d26fee32788ac131a1  prompts/templates/prd-generation.json
+c3c99c7d7937450c7c22e10f9f8d8451  prompts/templates/prd-model-coordinator.json
+4ba780cb0fe68f3f984e4fbf0d299402  prompts/templates/previous-refusal.json
+36a5bbe3c02f38ffe364207126cd68ac  prompts/templates/profile-augmentor.json
+3b6d4e1ca5c6527c9c23b03028b71ccc  prompts/templates/project-prompt-generation.json
+6011c046dace5c6d4e542f56b88749d5  prompts/templates/project-roster-review.json
+e982082353d77d51d767eff996081420  prompts/templates/prompt-claim-adjudication.json
+1013d2645b5c41e6503d11cdc263bc61  prompts/templates/prompt-review.json
+ebe778ef783cf200abf8abcd99257e42  prompts/templates/qa-brownfield-scope.json
+890580ee8027ef6e9ab8ac8164306f73  prompts/templates/qa-evidence-labels.json
+67fd07cef64f644212ee786e034dbff1  prompts/templates/qa-fuzz-weaver.json
+2267438237186805ddec69ac9e2418e0  prompts/templates/qa-mutant-hunter.json
+75df110e18bd9a178d705900e2d9dc95  prompts/templates/qa-oracle-evidence.json
+8b8d01b3aa44cf97bdcea423fa9bc74a  prompts/templates/qa-perf-sentinel.json
+5d5e25225b973842b2c51ac5999d08e2  prompts/templates/qa-review-ranger.json
+d3a71e6a003fed3a674470889bfe647b  prompts/templates/qa-sast-sentinel.json
+9a12ffffa1a2acd5f4e6cc4d75a7cd4c  prompts/templates/qa-spec-validator.json
+a307132612f2d84b09c6ebb2bae6aab0  prompts/templates/release-line-port.json
+31587776b57bff68f865ee511d523a6f  prompts/templates/repro-feedback.json
+2f6e16b9c22fb7c19d98e2f98dd1e66c  prompts/templates/repro-role.json
+bdb83759d6a60f7820f5ad428b40611d  prompts/templates/repro-test-writer.json
+05eb04b4c706f16e59670c7d5e3da411  prompts/templates/retry-extension-coordinator.json
+7aa968f99abc2f24e3578e1c1e258716  prompts/templates/review-ac-remediator.json
+c43d37501d2b66052764d28877a35b55  prompts/templates/review-finding-routing.json
+af929616ab538f96587765bdc6994aa6  prompts/templates/review-scope-block.json
+3310af2ce49b0e0888e6c77b233a58ab  prompts/templates/roster-review.json
+bf71a718e7a9a76b6b97bb3b34f4f441  prompts/templates/roster-specialisation-one.json
+14735ac00e0f6d1c8d1b7f515f16ac76  prompts/templates/roster-specialisation-plan.json
+3ccec07880d358148b411b9ccc31c46c  prompts/templates/roster-specialisation.json
+73786c3d9a9e6af39d0f5878a2a9af4b  prompts/templates/roster-tool-grant.json
+df46fd81ae6b150e366cbd92e4938241  prompts/templates/runtime-boundary-review.json
+1cd4572cc6f60f4aded3615989a9c850  prompts/templates/shared-file-ownership.json
+f6cc6a8ae600a698c95243c28dc4d122  prompts/templates/skill-assessment-postphase.json
+02589c86fd6824a55538861acad1d4b1  prompts/templates/skill-assessment-prephase.json
+4e029a1b41337bb96c52f43a93319396  prompts/templates/skills-coordinator.json
+dfad8d083117d651006d5ddf8fd4c4ff  prompts/templates/spec-agent-openspec.brownfield.json
+41b4ca56677d921af53cc7d224d735c9  prompts/templates/spec-agent-openspec.json
+148d5a5a7e638f3c4e010a0c084477c5  prompts/templates/spec-agent-speckit-refine.json
+6ed26e0f074838b5fec169619e954ce1  prompts/templates/spec-agent-speckit.json
+2fca7774140bfc3c2c61829dc384ba7f  prompts/templates/spec-authoring-rules.json
+84c52a75a7315043285c6da047bcc2c0  prompts/templates/spec-brownfield-mode.json
+9c95bfc346c2d05cf738f78cd5ecc411  prompts/templates/spec-context-fragments.json
+0f8e962ba283d319dbc10b1cbfe63df9  prompts/templates/spec-coordinator-review.json
+d2195b624515824c662d6547e1deae1d  prompts/templates/spec-coordinator.json
+b4168e7ccceb68fe0dfe8c2933e6783b  prompts/templates/spec-model-review.json
+782195903b013897b02551156c7ed4f8  prompts/templates/spec-review-criteria.json
+f7d2b85b76b4770d276c11565e418117  prompts/templates/spec-shared-consumer.json
+d84a5395c719ef1022945b5e16831fc7  prompts/templates/spec-story-block.json
+40a71ac5df666257a9bccde9e79cc8ae  prompts/templates/speckit-split-rules.json
+5bf372eb630bb4aa638ca44ee50bb615  prompts/templates/squad-coder.json
+d4a9592bfc667b3cde488a54481ca066  prompts/templates/squad-leader.json
+0687020fbc6dba6c435a6a55a9724418  prompts/templates/squad-security-auditor.json
+9fa13890fe876853051cb0b74343c0f2  prompts/templates/squad-tester.json
+6ab52a0b0b1b7fe2340cac9e6ff1cbd1  prompts/templates/story-ac-remediator.json
+02d537ae30e95e545d043ff25362780d  prompts/templates/story-diff-not-inlined.json
+ebda59bad7d4f91f6354bb6f604eb4ea  prompts/templates/story-file-generation.json
+f33e2ce53d6daf2193ba48b83ae54435  prompts/templates/story-implementation.json
+b828065ae7498d3d06650d29d1ee8b3f  prompts/templates/story-kind-hint-defect.json
+119a924912788c1af9b41c62e3627c48  prompts/templates/story-kind-hint-other.json
+717120953b6041234d88fae0f9f259d5  prompts/templates/story-plan-agent.json
+81ee6cb6917b662bf490b30f367b83c0  prompts/templates/story-writer-main.json
+7a0a6ae6a01bfa17b46e8617b6fd4b37  prompts/templates/story-writer.json
+3a41ad7338a29ef6542682f13541e5a9  prompts/templates/survey-review.json
+1a6fff953ed9759136eb56ff30d69558  prompts/templates/tc-writer.json
+98da28419b07a58bd6873e2600a17627  prompts/templates/test-gate-finding.json
+2248138ed57dfdaed076d20315fcaabd  prompts/templates/test-ownership.json
+dcf4f6d925125da08fd7fe9361404f9f  prompts/templates/tools-coordinator.json
+9c8bbde2f765ef773d20577ca25fa670  prompts/templates/topology-router.json
+e33482e86be747344873cea13b3c6d71  prompts/templates/update-invalidated-tests.json
+5ced1c1a88e878930920f994636058e3  prompts/templates/vc-coverage.json
+93ab935ce02104774e0196735b54960c  prompts/templates/vc-regenerate.json
+e902dfbf9802f60b06b7cd8ef48deaf5  prompts/templates/vc-review.json
+58655fbe526dfb4ec90a9994d9dd666d  prompts/templates/worktree-autocommit-message.json
+7e82a5b7d9ea0dd04f7dd4db5300e2c0  prompts/templates/writer-codegraph-block.json
+ff9ea38d594f181363c40295ea42012a  prompts/templates/writer-plan-section.json
+8e18f7be6b28fa94c8dbbc723a23dc57  prompts/templates/writer-string-invariants.json

package/docs/gateway-files.txt

@@ -3,10 +3,151 @@ config/doctor-signatures.json
 config/model-pricing.json
 config/repo-artifacts.json
 config/resume-preserves.json
+config/reviewer-policy.json
 config/run-modes.json
+config/seam-output-contracts.json
 prompts/doctor-repair.md
+prompts/templates/ac-classification.json
+prompts/templates/ac-elaboration.json
+prompts/templates/ac-gate-codeline-assignment.json
+prompts/templates/agent-failure-analyst.json
+prompts/templates/agent-name-refusal.json
+prompts/templates/agent-plan-mode.json
+prompts/templates/agent-proposal.json
+prompts/templates/agent-retry-prefix.json
+prompts/templates/assign-agent-roles.json
+prompts/templates/blocker-discipline.json
+prompts/templates/bug-fix-story.json
+prompts/templates/change-reviewer.json
+prompts/templates/code-graph-detective.json
+prompts/templates/code-review-cycle.json
+prompts/templates/codeline-bridge.json
 prompts/templates/codeline-discovery.json
+prompts/templates/content-retry-correction.json
+prompts/templates/coordinator-amendment.json
+prompts/templates/corrective-note.json
+prompts/templates/cpa-inference.json
+prompts/templates/cpa-system.json
 prompts/templates/criterion-origin.json
+prompts/templates/declared-packages.json
+prompts/templates/detective-extract.json
+prompts/templates/detective-overall-plan-given.json
+prompts/templates/detective-overall-plan.json
+prompts/templates/detective-prescription.json
+prompts/templates/detective-retry-note.json
+prompts/templates/detective-shared-package.json
+prompts/templates/discovery-vocabulary.json
+prompts/templates/e2e-route-check.json
+prompts/templates/estate-survey.json
+prompts/templates/estimation-assessment.json
+prompts/templates/failure-analyst.json
+prompts/templates/fix-plan-shared.json
+prompts/templates/gate-finding-analyst.json
+prompts/templates/guard-vocabulary-codegraph.json
+prompts/templates/guard-vocabulary-documentation.json
+prompts/templates/guard-vocabulary.json
+prompts/templates/hybrid-prephase-coordinator.json
+prompts/templates/inference-ladder-coordinator.json
+prompts/templates/kb-enforcement-synthesis.json
+prompts/templates/lint-ac-remediator.json
+prompts/templates/lint-finding-analyst.json
+prompts/templates/lint-fixer.json
+prompts/templates/manifest-analysis.json
+prompts/templates/mint-existing-roster.json
+prompts/templates/new-dependency-directive.json
+prompts/templates/new-dependency-lockfile-note.json
+prompts/templates/phase-assessment-header.json
+prompts/templates/pipeline-tools-command.json
+prompts/templates/pipeline-tools-hosted.json
+prompts/templates/plan-corrective.json
+prompts/templates/plan-producer.json
+prompts/templates/plan-reviewer.json
+prompts/templates/post-failure-analyst.json
+prompts/templates/prd-change-reviewer-mode-rules.json
+prompts/templates/prd-change-reviewer-spec.json
+prompts/templates/prd-change-reviewer.json
+prompts/templates/prd-change-summarizer-text.json
+prompts/templates/prd-change-summarizer-tool.json
+prompts/templates/prd-configuration-block.json
+prompts/templates/prd-generation.json
+prompts/templates/prd-model-coordinator.json
+prompts/templates/previous-refusal.json
+prompts/templates/profile-augmentor.json
+prompts/templates/project-prompt-generation.json
+prompts/templates/project-roster-review.json
+prompts/templates/prompt-claim-adjudication.json
+prompts/templates/prompt-review.json
+prompts/templates/qa-brownfield-scope.json
+prompts/templates/qa-evidence-labels.json
+prompts/templates/qa-fuzz-weaver.json
+prompts/templates/qa-mutant-hunter.json
+prompts/templates/qa-oracle-evidence.json
+prompts/templates/qa-perf-sentinel.json
+prompts/templates/qa-review-ranger.json
+prompts/templates/qa-sast-sentinel.json
+prompts/templates/qa-spec-validator.json
+prompts/templates/release-line-port.json
+prompts/templates/repro-feedback.json
+prompts/templates/repro-role.json
+prompts/templates/repro-test-writer.json
+prompts/templates/retry-extension-coordinator.json
+prompts/templates/review-ac-remediator.json
+prompts/templates/review-finding-routing.json
+prompts/templates/review-scope-block.json
+prompts/templates/review-shared.json
+prompts/templates/roster-review.json
+prompts/templates/roster-specialisation-one.json
+prompts/templates/roster-specialisation-plan.json
+prompts/templates/roster-specialisation.json
+prompts/templates/roster-tool-grant.json
+prompts/templates/runtime-boundary-review.json
+prompts/templates/shared-file-ownership.json
+prompts/templates/skill-assessment-postphase.json
+prompts/templates/skill-assessment-prephase.json
+prompts/templates/skills-coordinator.json
+prompts/templates/spec-agent-openspec.brownfield.json
+prompts/templates/spec-agent-openspec.json
+prompts/templates/spec-agent-speckit-refine.json
+prompts/templates/spec-agent-speckit.json
+prompts/templates/spec-authoring-rules.json
+prompts/templates/spec-brownfield-mode.json
+prompts/templates/spec-context-fragments.json
+prompts/templates/spec-coordinator-review.json
+prompts/templates/spec-coordinator.json
+prompts/templates/spec-model-review.json
+prompts/templates/spec-review-criteria.json
+prompts/templates/spec-shared-consumer.json
+prompts/templates/spec-story-block.json
+prompts/templates/speckit-split-rules.json
+prompts/templates/squad-coder.json
+prompts/templates/squad-leader.json
+prompts/templates/squad-security-auditor.json
+prompts/templates/squad-tester.json
+prompts/templates/story-ac-remediator.json
+prompts/templates/story-diff-not-inlined.json
+prompts/templates/story-file-generation.json
+prompts/templates/story-implementation.json
+prompts/templates/story-kind-hint-defect.json
+prompts/templates/story-kind-hint-other.json
+prompts/templates/story-plan-agent.json
+prompts/templates/story-recovery-analyst.json
+prompts/templates/story-writer-main.json
+prompts/templates/story-writer.json
+prompts/templates/survey-review.json
+prompts/templates/tc-writer.json
+prompts/templates/team-lead-review.json
+prompts/templates/test-gate-finding.json
+prompts/templates/test-ownership.json
+prompts/templates/tools-coordinator.json
+prompts/templates/topology-router.json
+prompts/templates/update-invalidated-tests.json
+prompts/templates/vc-coverage.json
+prompts/templates/vc-regenerate.json
+prompts/templates/vc-review.json
+prompts/templates/worktree-autocommit-message.json
+prompts/templates/writer-codegraph-block.json
+prompts/templates/writer-plan-section.json
+prompts/templates/writer-string-invariants.json
 scripts/agent-attempt-analyst.sh
 scripts/lib/agent-contract.js
 scripts/lib/agent-ladder.sh
@@ -88,6 +229,7 @@ scripts/lib/release-lines.sh
 scripts/lib/render-engine-prompt.sh
 scripts/lib/render-prompt-section.js
 scripts/lib/resume-semantics.sh
+scripts/lib/reviewer-model.js
 scripts/lib/run-checkpoint.sh
 scripts/lib/run-modes.sh
 scripts/lib/seam-invocation.js

package/orchestrations/config/reviewer-policy.json

@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+{
+  "$comment": "WHICH MODEL THE WRITER'S REVIEW RUNS ON — one declared policy, read by the bash reviewer (scripts/team-lead-review.sh reviewer_model_for) and by the Claude workflow's generator, through scripts/lib/reviewer-model.js, so the two pipelines can never differ. 'writer-rung': the review runs on the model that produced the work (the rule since 2026-08-22). 'top-of-ladder': the review runs on the top of the active provider set's highest ladder, derived from the set's own file (no model name is written here).",
+  "$why": "Run 11 (AMSD-2974, 2026-10-21): the same reviewer prompt on the Writer's rung model (Sonnet 5) rated a thin delivery and a richer delivery 9 and 9 and approved both; on Opus 5.5 it rated them 6 and 7.5 and sent both back (about $0.25 more per review). A reviewer that is no stronger than the work it judges cannot see what that rung gets wrong.",
+  "model": "top-of-ladder"
+}