akm-cli 0.9.17-alpha.3 → 0.9.17-alpha.5

package/dist/commands/improve/reflect-noise.js

@@ -2,288 +2,141 @@
 // License, v. 2.0. If a copy of the MPL was not distributed with this
 // file, You can obtain one at https://mozilla.org/MPL/2.0/.
 /**
- * Reflect noise gate (#580) — deterministic detection of no-op and
- * cosmetic-only reflect candidates.
- *
- * Manual review of the proposal queue (June 2026) found that 2 of 5 pending
- * reflect proposals had literally EMPTY diffs and 2 more were cosmetic-only
- * (YAML description re-folding, code-fence language hints, whitespace
- * reflow / unwrapping of hard-wrapped prose). Each wasted an LLM call AND a
- * review-queue slot. This module classifies a candidate edit against the
- * current asset BEFORE `createProposal()` so reflect can short-circuit.
- *
- * Classification is pure text comparison — no LLM involved:
- *
- *   - `"noop"`     — byte-identical after trailing-whitespace normalization.
- *   - `"cosmetic"` — identical after a conservative cosmetic normalization
- *                    of both sides (frontmatter compared as parsed YAML so
- *                    folded/literal scalar re-folding cancels out; markdown
- *                    body compared with hard-wrapped prose unwrapped,
- *                    whitespace runs collapsed, and code-fence language
- *                    hints stripped).
- *   - `"substantive"` — everything else, including every case the
- *                    normalizer is unsure about.
- *
- * The normalizer is deliberately conservative: a false NEGATIVE (letting a
- * cosmetic proposal through) costs one review-queue slot; a false POSITIVE
- * (suppressing a real fix) loses work. When in doubt, classify as
- * substantive. Concretely:
- *
- *   - Fenced code block contents are compared verbatim (whitespace inside
- *     code is significant).
- *   - Indented (4-space / tab) code lines are compared verbatim.
- *   - Headings, tables, and thematic breaks never absorb the following
- *     line, so `# Title\nprose` vs `# Title prose` stays substantive.
- *   - Prose only unwraps into the previous line when that line is itself
- *     plain prose or a list/blockquote item (CommonMark lazy continuation).
+ * The reflect noise gate (#580): classify a candidate edit against the current
+ * asset before it becomes a proposal, by text comparison alone. Empty and
+ * cosmetic-only edits (YAML re-folding, fence language hints, re-wrapped prose)
+ * each cost an LLM call and a review slot. The gate is conservative — letting a
+ * cosmetic edit through costs a review, suppressing a real fix loses work — so
+ * anything uncertain is `substantive`: code (fenced or indented) compares
+ * verbatim, and headings, tables and breaks never absorb the next line.
  */
 import { parse as yamlParse } from "yaml";
 /**
- * Classify a reflect candidate against the current asset content.
- *
- * `"noop"` and `"cosmetic"` candidates must never become proposals; only
- * `"substantive"` changes proceed to `createProposal()`.
- *
- * `"low-value"` is a tier between `"cosmetic"` and `"substantive"` (#639):
- * a small prose rewrite that changes few content-words outside fenced code,
- * without introducing new headings, list items, or code lines. The caller
- * decides whether to act on it (config-gated, DEFAULT OFF).
+ * `noop` (identical up to trailing whitespace) and `cosmetic` (identical after
+ * normalizing frontmatter as parsed YAML and prose as unwrapped text) never
+ * become proposals. `low-value` (#639) is a small prose rewrite — few changed
+ * words, nothing structural; the caller decides (off by default).
  */
 export function classifyReflectChange(sourceContent, candidateContent) {
-    if (normalizeTrailingWhitespace(sourceContent) === normalizeTrailingWhitespace(candidateContent)) {
+    if (normalizeTrailingWhitespace(sourceContent) === normalizeTrailingWhitespace(candidateContent))
         return "noop";
-    }
     try {
-        if (cosmeticNormalForm(sourceContent) === cosmeticNormalForm(candidateContent)) {
+        if (cosmeticNormalForm(sourceContent) === cosmeticNormalForm(candidateContent))
             return "cosmetic";
-        }
     }
     catch {
-        // Conservative: a normalizer error means we cannot prove the change is
-        // cosmetic — let the proposal through.
+        // unprovable → substantive
     }
-    // Low-value tier (#639): deterministic semantic-value-floor check.
     try {
-        if (isLowValueChange(sourceContent, candidateContent)) {
+        if (isLowValueChange(sourceContent, candidateContent))
             return "low-value";
-        }
     }
     catch {
-        // Conservative: treat any classifier error as substantive.
+        // unprovable → substantive
     }
     return "substantive";
 }
-// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-// Low-value tier (#639) helpers
-// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-/**
- * Threshold: the maximum number of net changed content-words in eligible prose
- * lines for a change to be classified as `"low-value"`. Conservative/low to
- * minimise false positives (substantive changes suppressed).
- */
+/** A `---` frontmatter block and the rest (`fmText: null` when there is none). */
+export function splitFrontmatter(raw) {
+    const m = raw.match(/^---\r?\n([\s\S]*?)\r?\n---\r?\n?([\s\S]*)$/);
+    return m ? { fmText: m[1] ?? "", body: m[2] ?? "" } : { fmText: null, body: raw };
+}
+/** At most this many changed words (and at least 2 — one word may be a flag flip) is low-value. */
 const LOW_VALUE_TOKEN_THRESHOLD = 4;
-/**
- * Negation / flag-correction words that make a line exempt from low-value
- * classification even when the token-change count is below the threshold.
- * A line that introduces or removes one of these words carries enough semantic
- * weight to be treated as substantive.
- */
+/** A change to any of these is never low-value. */
 const NEGATION_WORDS = new Set(["never", "not", "no", "don't", "avoid", "cannot", "can't"]);
-/**
- * Pattern for lines that contain decision / outcome markers. Changed tokens on
- * these lines are EXEMPT from the low-value token count (they are semantically
- * significant regardless of token volume).
- */
+/** Lines recording a decision or outcome are always significant; their words are not counted. */
 const DECISION_MARKER_RE = /\b(decision|outcome)\b/i;
-/**
- * Pattern for lines that start a new structural element (ATX heading, list
- * item, thematic break). A candidate that ADDS such lines is not low-value.
- */
 const STRUCTURAL_LINE_RE = /^\s*(#{1,6}\s|[-*+]\s|\d{1,9}[.)]\s|---+|===+|\|\s)/;
-/**
- * Determine whether the change from `source` to `candidate` qualifies as
- * `"low-value"`: a small prose rewrite with few changed content-words outside
- * fenced code / frontmatter / decision markers, without adding structural lines.
- *
- * Conservative / false-negative-biased: returns `false` (= substantive) when
- * any exemption condition is met or when the parser is unsure.
- */
 function isLowValueChange(source, candidate) {
-    const srcParsed = parseLowValueSections(source);
-    const cndParsed = parseLowValueSections(candidate);
-    // Any change inside a code fence → substantive (code is always significant).
-    if (srcParsed.codeFences.join("\n") !== cndParsed.codeFences.join("\n")) {
-        return false;
-    }
-    // Any change in frontmatter → substantive (description / when_to_use are semantic).
-    if (srcParsed.frontmatter !== cndParsed.frontmatter) {
+    const src = parseLowValueSections(source);
+    const cnd = parseLowValueSections(candidate);
+    // Code and frontmatter changes are always substantive.
+    if (src.codeFences.join("\n") !== cnd.codeFences.join("\n") || src.frontmatter !== cnd.frontmatter)
         return false;
-    }
-    // Check prose body lines for low-value criteria.
-    const srcLines = srcParsed.proseLines;
-    const cndLines = cndParsed.proseLines;
-    // Build a word-diff over prose lines. Align by line index (conservative: if
-    // line counts differ significantly, call it substantive).
-    if (Math.abs(srcLines.length - cndLines.length) > 2) {
+    if (Math.abs(src.proseLines.length - cnd.proseLines.length) > 2)
         return false;
-    }
-    const maxLen = Math.max(srcLines.length, cndLines.length);
     let changedTokens = 0;
-    let hasNewStructuralLine = false;
-    for (let i = 0; i < maxLen; i++) {
-        const srcLine = srcLines[i] ?? "";
-        const cndLine = cndLines[i] ?? "";
-        if (srcLine === cndLine)
-            continue;
-        // Lines with decision/outcome markers are exempt — skip their token diff.
-        if (DECISION_MARKER_RE.test(srcLine) || DECISION_MARKER_RE.test(cndLine)) {
+    for (let i = 0; i < Math.max(src.proseLines.length, cnd.proseLines.length); i++) {
+        const srcLine = src.proseLines[i] ?? "";
+        const cndLine = cnd.proseLines[i] ?? "";
+        if (srcLine === cndLine || DECISION_MARKER_RE.test(srcLine) || DECISION_MARKER_RE.test(cndLine))
             continue;
-        }
-        // Any structural line (heading, list item, thematic break) changed → not
-        // low-value. Structural changes affect document organization and are
-        // inherently significant regardless of token count.
-        if (STRUCTURAL_LINE_RE.test(cndLine) || STRUCTURAL_LINE_RE.test(srcLine)) {
-            hasNewStructuralLine = true;
-            break;
-        }
-        // Tokenise both lines into lowercase words.
+        if (STRUCTURAL_LINE_RE.test(cndLine) || STRUCTURAL_LINE_RE.test(srcLine))
+            return false;
         const srcTokens = tokenize(srcLine);
         const cndTokens = tokenize(cndLine);
-        // Check for negation / flag-correction words: if the set of negation words
-        // differs between versions → the change is semantically significant (exempt).
-        const srcNegSet = new Set(srcTokens.filter((t) => NEGATION_WORDS.has(t)));
-        const cndNegSet = new Set(cndTokens.filter((t) => NEGATION_WORDS.has(t)));
-        const negSetsEqual = srcNegSet.size === cndNegSet.size && [...srcNegSet].every((t) => cndNegSet.has(t));
-        if (!negSetsEqual) {
+        const srcNeg = new Set(srcTokens.filter((t) => NEGATION_WORDS.has(t)));
+        const cndNeg = new Set(cndTokens.filter((t) => NEGATION_WORDS.has(t)));
+        if (srcNeg.size !== cndNeg.size || [...srcNeg].some((t) => !cndNeg.has(t)))
             return false;
-        }
-        // Count changed tokens: words unique to each side (symmetric difference).
-        // Counting max(added, removed) approximates "number of substitutions" so
-        // that "is→runs" + "default→defaults" counts as 2, not 4.
+        // max(added, removed) approximates substitutions: "is→runs" counts once.
         const srcSet = new Set(srcTokens);
         const cndSet = new Set(cndTokens);
-        const addedTokens = cndTokens.filter((t) => !srcSet.has(t));
-        const removedTokens = srcTokens.filter((t) => !cndSet.has(t));
-        changedTokens += Math.max(addedTokens.length, removedTokens.length);
+        changedTokens += Math.max(cndTokens.filter((t) => !srcSet.has(t)).length, srcTokens.filter((t) => !cndSet.has(t)).length);
     }
-    if (hasNewStructuralLine)
-        return false;
-    // Must have at least 2 changed tokens to qualify as low-value:
-    //   - 0 changed tokens → noop/cosmetic (handled upstream, never reaches here)
-    //   - 1 changed token  → single-word substitution; too small to be reliably
-    //     "low-value" vs a semantically significant flag flip → treat as substantive
-    //   - 2..threshold-1   → genuine prose micro-rewrite → low-value
     return changedTokens >= 2 && changedTokens < LOW_VALUE_TOKEN_THRESHOLD;
 }
-/** Split a document into its frontmatter text, code-fence blocks, and prose lines. */
+/** Frontmatter text, fenced code blocks, and prose lines (an unclosed fence counts as prose). */
 function parseLowValueSections(text) {
-    const normalized = normalizeTrailingWhitespace(text);
-    // Split off frontmatter.
-    const fmMatch = normalized.match(/^---\n([\s\S]*?)\n---\n?([\s\S]*)$/);
-    const frontmatter = fmMatch ? (fmMatch[1] ?? "") : "";
-    const body = fmMatch ? (fmMatch[2] ?? normalized) : normalized;
-    const lines = body.split("\n");
+    const { fmText, body } = splitFrontmatter(normalizeTrailingWhitespace(text));
     const codeFences = [];
     const proseLines = [];
-    let inFence = false;
-    let currentFence = [];
-    let fenceMarker = "";
-    for (const line of lines) {
-        if (inFence) {
-            const closeMatch = line.match(/^(\s{0,3})(`{3,}|~{3,})\s*$/);
-            if (closeMatch?.[2]?.startsWith(fenceMarker)) {
-                inFence = false;
-                codeFences.push(currentFence.join("\n"));
-                currentFence = [];
-                fenceMarker = "";
-            }
-            else {
-                currentFence.push(line);
-            }
-        }
-        else {
-            const openMatch = line.match(/^(\s{0,3})(`{3,}|~{3,})/);
-            if (openMatch) {
-                inFence = true;
-                fenceMarker = openMatch[2] ?? "```";
-                currentFence = [];
+    let fence;
+    for (const line of body.split("\n")) {
+        if (fence) {
+            const close = line.match(/^(\s{0,3})(`{3,}|~{3,})\s*$/);
+            if (close?.[2]?.startsWith(fence.marker)) {
+                codeFences.push(fence.lines.join("\n"));
+                fence = undefined;
             }
             else {
-                proseLines.push(line);
+                fence.lines.push(line);
             }
+            continue;
         }
-    }
-    // Unclosed fence: treat as prose (conservative).
-    if (inFence && currentFence.length > 0) {
-        proseLines.push(...currentFence);
-    }
-    return { frontmatter, codeFences, proseLines };
+        const open = line.match(/^(\s{0,3})(`{3,}|~{3,})/);
+        if (open)
+            fence = { marker: open[2] ?? "```", lines: [] };
+        else
+            proseLines.push(line);
+    }
+    if (fence)
+        proseLines.push(...fence.lines);
+    return { frontmatter: fmText ?? "", codeFences, proseLines };
 }
-/** Split a prose line into lowercase word tokens, filtering punctuation. */
 function tokenize(line) {
-    return (line
+    return line
         .toLowerCase()
-        // Normalize the curly apostrophe (U+2019) to a straight one so negation words
-        // like "don't"/"can't" match regardless of which glyph the content uses.
-        .replace(/’/g, "'")
+        .replace(/’/g, "'") // curly apostrophes still match "don't"
         .replace(/[^a-z0-9'-]/g, " ")
         .split(/\s+/)
-        .filter((t) => t.length > 0));
+        .filter((t) => t.length > 0);
 }
-/**
- * Trailing-whitespace normalization used for the `"noop"` check: CRLF → LF,
- * strip trailing spaces/tabs per line, drop trailing newlines.
- */
+/** CRLF → LF, no trailing spaces per line, no trailing newlines. */
 export function normalizeTrailingWhitespace(text) {
     return text
         .replace(/\r\n/g, "\n")
         .replace(/[ \t]+$/gm, "")
         .replace(/\n+$/, "");
 }
-/**
- * Compute the cosmetic normal form of an asset: canonicalized frontmatter
- * (parsed YAML, keys sorted) + normalized markdown body, joined with a
- * separator that cannot occur in either part.
- *
- * Two assets with equal normal forms differ only cosmetically.
- */
+/** Canonical frontmatter (parsed YAML, keys sorted) plus the normalized body; equal forms differ only cosmetically. */
 export function cosmeticNormalForm(text) {
-    const { fmText, body } = splitFrontmatterText(normalizeTrailingWhitespace(text));
-    const fmCanonical = fmText === null ? "" : canonicalizeYamlText(fmText);
-    return `${fmCanonical}\u0000${normalizeMarkdownBody(body)}`;
-}
-/**
- * Split a normalized blob into `{ fmText, body }`. Returns `fmText: null`
- * when the blob does not start with a `---` frontmatter block. Mirrors the
- * splitter in `reflect.ts` (kept local: this module must stay dependency-light
- * and pure so the normalizer is trivially unit-testable).
- */
-function splitFrontmatterText(raw) {
-    const m = raw.match(/^---\n([\s\S]*?)\n---\n?([\s\S]*)$/);
-    if (!m)
-        return { fmText: null, body: raw };
-    return { fmText: m[1] ?? "", body: m[2] ?? "" };
-}
-/**
- * Canonicalize a YAML frontmatter block: parse and re-serialize as JSON with
- * recursively sorted object keys. Folded (`>`) and literal (`|`) scalars,
- * quoting style, and key order all cancel out; the parsed VALUES are what we
- * compare. Unparsable YAML falls back to the raw text (trailing-stripped) so
- * any real edit still registers as a difference.
- */
-function canonicalizeYamlText(fmText) {
-    try {
-        return stableStringify(yamlParse(fmText));
-    }
-    catch {
-        return fmText;
+    const { fmText, body } = splitFrontmatter(normalizeTrailingWhitespace(text));
+    let fmCanonical = "";
+    if (fmText !== null) {
+        try {
+            fmCanonical = stableStringify(yamlParse(fmText));
+        }
+        catch {
+            fmCanonical = fmText; // unparsable: any real edit still registers
+        }
     }
+    return `${fmCanonical}\u0000${normalizeMarkdownBody(body)}`;
 }
-/** JSON.stringify with recursively sorted object keys (arrays keep order). */
 function stableStringify(value) {
-    if (Array.isArray(value)) {
+    if (Array.isArray(value))
         return `[${value.map(stableStringify).join(",")}]`;
-    }
     if (value !== null && typeof value === "object") {
         const entries = Object.entries(value)
             .sort(([a], [b]) => (a < b ? -1 : a > b ? 1 : 0))
@@ -292,100 +145,71 @@ function stableStringify(value) {
     }
     return JSON.stringify(value);
 }
-/** Opening or closing fence: optional indent + ``` / ~~~ + optional info string. */
 const FENCE_LINE = /^(\s{0,3})(`{3,}|~{3,})(.*)$/;
-/**
- * Lines that terminate a logical line and never absorb a following prose
- * line: ATX headings, setext underlines, thematic breaks, table rows.
- */
+/** Headings, setext underlines, thematic breaks and table rows never absorb the next line. */
 const TERMINAL_LINE = /^\s{0,3}(#{1,6}(\s|$)|=+\s*$|(-\s*){3,}$|(\*\s*){3,}$|(_\s*){3,}$|\|)/;
-/** List items and blockquotes — start a logical line but allow lazy continuation. */
+/** List items and blockquotes allow lazy continuation. */
 const CONTINUABLE_LINE = /^\s*([-*+]\s|\d{1,9}[.)]\s|>)/;
-/** Indented code block line (outside any list context — treated verbatim). */
 const INDENTED_CODE_LINE = /^(\t| {4})/;
 /**
- * Normalize a markdown body for cosmetic comparison:
- *
- *   - code-fence language hints stripped from opening fences; fenced
- *     contents kept verbatim
- *   - indented code lines kept verbatim
- *   - hard-wrapped prose unwrapped into the preceding prose / list /
- *     blockquote line (single space join)
- *   - runs of spaces/tabs inside prose collapsed to one space
- *   - runs of blank lines collapsed to one; leading/trailing blanks dropped
+ * A markdown body for cosmetic comparison: fence language hints dropped (code
+ * kept verbatim), indented code verbatim, hard-wrapped prose joined into the
+ * preceding prose/list/quote line, inner whitespace runs collapsed, blank runs
+ * collapsed and trimmed.
  */
 export function normalizeMarkdownBody(body) {
-    const lines = normalizeTrailingWhitespace(body).split("\n");
     const logical = [];
     let lastKind = "blank";
     let fenceMarker = null;
-    for (const line of lines) {
+    const push = (line, kind) => {
+        logical.push(line);
+        lastKind = kind;
+    };
+    for (const line of normalizeTrailingWhitespace(body).split("\n")) {
         if (fenceMarker !== null) {
             const close = line.match(FENCE_LINE);
             if (close?.[2]?.startsWith(fenceMarker) && close[3]?.trim() === "") {
                 fenceMarker = null;
-                logical.push(line.trim());
-                lastKind = "terminal";
+                push(line.trim(), "terminal");
             }
             else {
-                logical.push(line); // code content: compare verbatim
-                lastKind = "verbatim";
+                push(line, "verbatim");
             }
             continue;
         }
         const fence = line.match(FENCE_LINE);
         if (fence) {
             fenceMarker = fence[2] ?? "```";
-            // Strip the info string (language hint) — ```js and ``` compare equal.
-            logical.push(fenceMarker);
-            lastKind = "terminal";
-            continue;
+            push(fenceMarker, "terminal");
         }
-        if (line.trim() === "") {
-            if (lastKind !== "blank") {
-                logical.push("");
-                lastKind = "blank";
-            }
-            continue;
+        else if (line.trim() === "") {
+            if (lastKind !== "blank")
+                push("", "blank");
         }
-        if (INDENTED_CODE_LINE.test(line)) {
-            logical.push(line);
-            lastKind = "verbatim";
-            continue;
+        else if (INDENTED_CODE_LINE.test(line)) {
+            push(line, "verbatim");
         }
-        if (TERMINAL_LINE.test(line)) {
-            logical.push(collapseInnerWhitespace(line));
-            lastKind = "terminal";
-            continue;
+        else if (TERMINAL_LINE.test(line)) {
+            push(collapseInnerWhitespace(line), "terminal");
         }
-        if (CONTINUABLE_LINE.test(line)) {
-            logical.push(collapseInnerWhitespace(line));
-            lastKind = "continuable";
-            continue;
+        else if (CONTINUABLE_LINE.test(line)) {
+            push(collapseInnerWhitespace(line), "continuable");
         }
-        // Plain prose: unwrap into the previous logical line when it can lazily
-        // continue (prose or list/blockquote); otherwise start a new logical line.
-        const collapsed = collapseInnerWhitespace(line.trim());
-        if (lastKind === "prose" || lastKind === "continuable") {
-            // lastKind stays joinable (prose continuation keeps absorbing).
-            logical[logical.length - 1] = `${logical[logical.length - 1]} ${collapsed}`;
+        else if (lastKind === "prose" || lastKind === "continuable") {
+            logical[logical.length - 1] = `${logical[logical.length - 1]} ${collapseInnerWhitespace(line.trim())}`;
         }
         else {
-            logical.push(collapsed);
-            lastKind = "prose";
+            push(collapseInnerWhitespace(line.trim()), "prose");
         }
     }
-    // Drop leading/trailing blank logical lines.
     while (logical[0] === "")
         logical.shift();
     while (logical[logical.length - 1] === "")
         logical.pop();
     return logical.join("\n");
 }
-/** Collapse internal space/tab runs to a single space, preserving leading indent. */
+/** Collapse inner space/tab runs, keeping the leading indent. */
 function collapseInnerWhitespace(line) {
     const m = line.match(/^([ \t]*)([\s\S]*)$/);
-    const indent = m?.[1] ?? "";
-    const rest = m?.[2] ?? "";
-    return indent + rest.replace(/[ \t]+/g, " ");
+    return (m?.[1] ?? "") + (m?.[2] ?? "").replace(/[ \t]+/g, " ");
 }