akm-cli 0.9.0-beta.57 → 0.9.0-beta.59

package/dist/commands/improve/distill/quality-gate.js

@@ -107,14 +107,17 @@ export function buildJudgePrompt(lessonContent, sourceContent, similarLessons) {
  * `profiles.improve.default.processes.distill.qualityGate.enabled` (and the
  * corresponding `.reflect.qualityGate.enabled` for proposals).
  *
- * Fail-open: returns `pass: true` on timeout, parse failure, or missing LLM.
+ * Fail-CLOSED (07 P0-2): returns `pass: false` (score -1) on timeout, parse
+ * failure, or missing LLM. Minted content that cannot be judged is rejected,
+ * not passed through — an unverifiable judge must never wave content into the
+ * stash. The rejection is `quality_rejected`, not `review_needed`.
  */
 export async function runLessonQualityJudge(config, lessonContent, sourceContent, chat, 
 /** D-4 / #390: top-3 similar existing lessons for dedup check. */
 similarLessons) {
     const llmConfig = getDefaultLlmConfig(config);
     if (!llmConfig) {
-        return { pass: true, score: -1, reason: "no LLM configured — passing through" };
+        return { pass: false, score: -1, reason: "no LLM configured — cannot judge, failing closed" };
     }
     const judgeLlmConfig = llmConfig.judgeModel ? { ...llmConfig, model: llmConfig.judgeModel } : llmConfig;
     const JUDGE_TIMEOUT_MS = 8_000;
@@ -128,7 +131,7 @@ similarLessons) {
         ]);
         const parsed = parseEmbeddedJsonResponse(raw);
         if (!parsed || typeof parsed.score !== "number") {
-            return { pass: true, score: -1, reason: "judge parse failed — passing through" };
+            return { pass: false, score: -1, reason: "judge parse failed — cannot judge, failing closed" };
         }
         // D-5 / #388: Three-band system (MT-Bench arXiv:2306.05685 — ~±0.5 judge variance).
         //   >= 3.5: auto-queue as pending (pass: true)
@@ -146,7 +149,7 @@ similarLessons) {
         return { pass: false, score, reason };
     }
     catch {
-        return { pass: true, score: -1, reason: "judge failed — passing through" };
+        return { pass: false, score: -1, reason: "judge timeout/error — cannot judge, failing closed" };
     }
 }
 // ── Quality-rejection helper ─────────────────────────────────────────────────