aiox-core 5.0.3 → 5.0.5

package/pro/squads/squad-creator-pro/data/hybridops-patterns.md

@@ -1,1351 +0,0 @@
-# PATTERNS REUTILIZÁVEIS DO HYBRIDOPS PARA SQUAD-CREATOR
-
-**Data da Extração:** 2026-02-10
-**Fonte:** `/Users/oalanicolas/Code/mmos/squads/hybrid-ops-squad`
-**Status:** Pronto para Implementação
-**Última Atualização:** 2026-02-10 (v1.2 - Self-contained: COPIAR artifacts)
-
----
-
-## ESTRUTURA DO PEDRO VALÉRIO NO SQUAD-CREATOR
-
-### Os 4 Modos (Validado com Pedro Original - 2026-02-10)
-
-```
-SQUAD-CREATOR
-├── squad-chief (orquestra squad + revisa)
-├── oalanicolas (extrai DNA, SOPs, frameworks)
-└── pedro-valerio (AI Head de OPS)
-    ├── modo: engenheiro-processos
-    ├── modo: arquiteto-sistemas
-    ├── modo: arquiteto-automacao
-    └── modo: construtor-templates
-```
-
-### Mapeamento Modo → Pattern → Comandos
-
-| Modo | Responsabilidade | Patterns Usados | Comandos | Veto Conditions |
-|------|------------------|-----------------|----------|-----------------|
-| **Engenheiro de Processos** | Mapear do fim pro começo, encontrar gaps | HO-HE-001 (Future Back-Casting), HO-VC-001 | `*map-process`, `*find-gaps`, `*identify-owners` | Vision clarity < 0.7 |
-| **Arquiteto de Sistemas** | Estrutura, statuses, campos, permissões | HO-TP-001 (Task Anatomy), HO-EP-001/002/003/004 | `*design-structure`, `*create-statuses`, `*define-fields` | Missing required fields |
-| **Arquiteto de Automação** | Bloqueios, triggers, conexões, N8N | HO-HE-003 (Automation Tipping), HO-VC-003, HO-QG-001 | `*create-rules`, `*connect-systems`, `*design-triggers` | Guardrails missing |
-| **Construtor de Templates** | Templates, checklists, docs, teste da filha | HO-QG-001, HO-CV-001, HO-AX-001 | `*create-template`, `*write-instructions`, `*test-leigo` | Truthfulness < 0.7 |
-
-### Ferramentas por Modo (da reunião)
-
-| Modo | Ferramentas |
-|------|-------------|
-| Engenheiro de Processos | Figma, Notion, Google Docs, Loom |
-| Arquiteto de Sistemas | ClickUp, Notion, Google Drive, Airtable |
-| Arquiteto de Automação | ClickUp Automations, N8N, Webhooks, APIs |
-| Construtor de Templates | Notion, ClickUp, Markdown, Loom |
-
----
-
-## MIND ARTIFACTS (Self-Contained)
-
-**REGRA:** Squad-creator é 100% self-contained. Todos os artifacts são COPIADOS para dentro do squad.
-
-### Estrutura Local (após migração)
-
-```
-squads/squad-creator-pro/
-├── minds/
-│   └── pedro_valerio/
-│       ├── heuristics/
-│       │   ├── PV_BS_001.md       # Future Back-Casting
-│       │   ├── PV_PA_001.md       # Systemic Coherence Scan
-│       │   └── PV_PM_001.md       # Automation Tipping Point
-│       └── artifacts/
-│           ├── META_AXIOMAS.md    # 10 dimensões + Axiomas Level -4 a 0
-│           └── Assinatura_Linguistica.md  # Voice DNA original
-```
-
-### Heuristics (Copiados de HybridOps)
-
-| Arquivo | Path Local | O que contém |
-|---------|------------|--------------|
-| **PV_BS_001** | `minds/pedro_valerio/heuristics/PV_BS_001.md` | Future Back-Casting (decisão estratégica) |
-| **PV_PA_001** | `minds/pedro_valerio/heuristics/PV_PA_001.md` | Systemic Coherence Scan (validação de executores) |
-| **PV_PM_001** | `minds/pedro_valerio/heuristics/PV_PM_001.md` | Automation Tipping Point (quando automatizar) |
-
-### Artifacts (Copiados de HybridOps)
-
-| Arquivo | Path Local | O que contém |
-|---------|------------|--------------|
-| **META_AXIOMAS** | `minds/pedro_valerio/artifacts/META_AXIOMAS.md` | 10 dimensões de validação, Axiomas Level -4 a 0 |
-| **Assinatura_Linguistica** | `minds/pedro_valerio/artifacts/Assinatura_Linguistica.md` | Voice DNA original |
-
-### Fonte Original (para referência)
-
-| Arquivo | Path Original (HybridOps) |
-|---------|---------------------------|
-| PV_BS_001 | `squads/hybrid-ops-squad/minds/pedro_valerio/heuristics/PV_BS_001.md` |
-| PV_PA_001 | `squads/hybrid-ops-squad/minds/pedro_valerio/heuristics/PV_PA_001.md` |
-| PV_PM_001 | `squads/hybrid-ops-squad/minds/pedro_valerio/heuristics/PV_PM_001.md` |
-| META_AXIOMAS | `squads/hybrid-ops-squad/minds/pedro_valerio/artifacts/META_AXIOMAS.md` |
-| Assinatura | `squads/hybrid-ops-squad/minds/pedro_valerio/artifacts/Assinatura_Linguistica.md` |
-| heuristics.yaml | `squads/hybrid-ops-squad/config/heuristics.yaml` |
-
-**NOTA:** Os arquivos são COPIADOS uma vez. Atualizações futuras devem ser feitas no squad-creator diretamente.
-
----
-
-## ÍNDICE DE PATTERNS
-
-1. [Veto Conditions Patterns](#veto-conditions-patterns)
-2. [Task Anatomy Patterns (8 Campos)](#task-anatomy-patterns-8-campos)
-3. [Heuristics Patterns (PV_BS_001, PV_PA_001, PV_PM_001)](#heuristics-patterns)
-4. [Axioma Validator Pattern](#axioma-validator-pattern)
-5. [Quality Gate Patterns (HO-PP-003)](#quality-gate-patterns)
-6. [Executor Assignment Patterns (HO-EP-XXX)](#executor-assignment-patterns)
-7. [Coherence Validation Patterns](#coherence-validation-patterns)
-
----
-
-## VETO CONDITIONS PATTERNS
-
-### HO-VC-001: Veto Condição - Visão Estratégica Incompleta
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-VC-001`
-**Nome:** Vision Clarity Veto
-**Fase:** Architecture (Phase 2)
-**Heurística:** PV_BS_001
-
-**Definição:**
-```yaml
-veto_trigger:
-  condition: "end_state_vision_clarity < 0.7"
-  action: "VETO - Vision unclear, return to Discovery"
-  severity: "BLOCKING"
-  recovery: "Clarify end-state vision before proceeding"
-```
-
-**Quando Usar:**
-- Quando visão estratégica está abaixo de 70% de clareza
-- Antes de commitar recursos significativos e irreversíveis
-- Em decisões de arquitetura que definem fundação do sistema
-
-**Exemplo de Aplicação no Squad-Creator:**
-- Verificar se "DNA extraction pipeline" está claro antes de design
-- Validar se meta de "automated agent generation" é visível
-- Confirmar escopo de "quality gates" antes de Phase 2
-
-**Como Adaptar:**
-- Substituir `end_state_vision` por: `squad_creation_vision_clarity`
-- Manter threshold em 0.7
-- Criar questões validação específicas para squad-creator
-
-**Outputs Esperados:**
-- APPROVE: Proceed to Architecture
-- REVIEW: Clarify vision with team
-- VETO: Return to Discovery phase
-
----
-
-### HO-VC-002: Veto Condição - Incoerência de Executor
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-VC-002`
-**Nome:** Executor Coherence Veto
-**Fase:** Executors (Phase 3)
-**Heurística:** PV_PA_001
-
-**Definição:**
-```yaml
-veto_conditions:
-  - condition: "truthfulness_coherence < 0.7"
-    action: "VETO - REJECT/REMOVE immediately"
-    severity: "CRITICAL"
-  - condition: "detected_incoherence = true"
-    action: "VETO - Trust breach, cannot proceed"
-    severity: "CRITICAL"
-```
-
-**Quando Usar:**
-- Incoerência detectada entre statements e actions
-- Mentira identificada propositalmente
-- Agent assignment não-confiável
-
-**Exemplo de Aplicação:**
-- Validar que agent do squad-creator segue suas próprias axiomas
-- Verificar se extraction logic é determinístico
-- Confirmar que output bate com documented behavior
-
-**Como Adaptar:**
-- `truthfulness_coherence` → `agent_behavior_coherence`
-- Aplicar a agents que pertencem ao squad
-- Usar para validar DNA clones antes de deploy
-
-**Guardrails:**
-- Teste comportamento com tasks que revelam consistência
-- Use métricas objetivas sobre impressões subjetivas
-- Implemente appeal tribunal para casos borderline
-
----
-
-### HO-VC-003: Veto Condição - Falta de Guardrails
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-VC-003`
-**Nome:** Automation Guardrail Veto
-**Fase:** Workflows (Phase 4)
-**Heurística:** PV_PM_001
-
-**Definição:**
-```yaml
-veto_condition:
-  trigger: "guardrails_missing = true"
-  action: "VETO - Define safety guardrails first"
-  scope: "Any automation"
-  required_guardrails:
-    - loop_prevention
-    - idempotency
-    - audit_trail
-    - manual_escape
-    - retry_logic
-```
-
-**Quando Usar:**
-- Antes de automate qualquer workflow
-- Quando frequency > 2x por mês
-- Em automations com systemic impact > 0.6
-
-**Exemplo no Squad-Creator:**
-- Agent-geração precisa: loop prevention, idempotency, audit trail
-- Extraction pipeline: rollback mechanism, manual override
-- Validation gates: timeout handling, fallback behavior
-
-**Como Adaptar:**
-- Manter 5 guardrails obrigatórios
-- Adicionar: `max_iterations`, `failure_threshold`, `notification_on_veto`
-- Criar checklist pré-automation
-
----
-
-## TASK ANATOMY PATTERNS (8 CAMPOS)
-
-### HO-TP-001: Task Anatomy Standard
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-TP-001`
-**Nome:** 8-Field Task Definition Standard
-**Aplicável a:** Todas as tasks
-**Compliance Rate:** 100% (validado em prioritization-system)
-
-**Os 8 Campos Obrigatórios:**
-
-| # | Campo | Tipo | Validação | Exemplo |
-|---|-------|------|-----------|---------|
-| 1 | `task_name` | string | "Verb + Object" format | "Extract Mind DNA" |
-| 2 | `status` | enum | pending \| in_progress \| review \| completed \| blocked | "pending" |
-| 3 | `responsible_executor` | string | role or @agent reference | "@squad-creator:analyzer" |
-| 4 | `execution_type` | enum | Human \| Agent \| Hybrid \| Worker | "Agent" |
-| 5 | `estimated_time` | duration | Must include unit (h, m, d) | "2-3 hours" |
-| 6 | `input` | array | At least 1 item required | ["DNA template", "agent config"] |
-| 7 | `output` | array | At least 1 item required | ["extracted axiomas", "validation report"] |
-| 8 | `action_items` | array | Step-by-step execution (≥1) | ["Parse agent markdown", "Extract axiomas", "Validate..."] |
-| 9 | `acceptance_criteria` | array | "Done" definition (≥1) | ["All fields extracted", "Pass validation gate"] |
-
-**Estrutura Completa:**
-
-```yaml
-task_definition:
-  # REQUIRED (8 FIELDS)
-  task_name: "Extract Mind DNA"
-  status: "pending"
-  responsible_executor: "@squad-creator:analyzer"
-  execution_type: "Agent"
-  estimated_time: "3h"
-  input:
-    - "Agent markdown file"
-    - "DNA extraction template"
-  output:
-    - "DNA YAML file"
-    - "Extraction report"
-  action_items:
-    - "Parse agent markdown"
-    - "Extract axiomas"
-    - "Validate coherence"
-    - "Generate YAML"
-  acceptance_criteria:
-    - "All axiomas extracted"
-    - "DNA passes coherence check"
-    - "YAML well-formed"
-
-  # OPTIONAL EXTENSIONS
-  tools:
-    - "ClickUp"
-    - "Claude API"
-  templates:
-    - "dna-extraction-template.yaml"
-  quality_gate: "QG-2.1A"
-  handoff:
-    to: "create-agent"
-    trigger: "dna_extraction_complete"
-```
-
-**Validação Checklist:**
-- [ ] task_name começa com verbo de ação
-- [ ] status é valor válido
-- [ ] responsible_executor é role ou @agent
-- [ ] execution_type é um dos 4 tipos
-- [ ] estimated_time tem unidade (h/m/d)
-- [ ] input array não vazio
-- [ ] output array não vazio
-- [ ] action_items tem ≥1 step
-- [ ] acceptance_criteria tem ≥1 criterion
-- [ ] Sem typos ou caracteres inválidos
-
-**Reusável em Squad-Creator:**
-- Aplicar ao 100% das tasks
-- Usar "Verb + Object" em Portuguese (Extrair, Validar, Gerar, etc)
-- Criar dependency graph baseado em handoff triggers
-- Validar compliance em Phase 5
-
----
-
-## HEURISTICS PATTERNS
-
-### HO-HE-001: PV_BS_001 - Future Back-Casting
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-HE-001`
-**Nome Completo:** Future Back-Casting Heuristic
-**Categoria:** Strategic Decision Heuristic
-**Fase:** 2 (Architecture)
-**Agent Executor:** `@hybridOps:process-architect`
-
-**Propósito:**
-Validar alinhamento estratégico usando metodologia future back-casting. Responde: "Esta ação direta ou cria opcionality paths para o end-state vision?"
-
-**Pesos e Thresholds:**
-
-```yaml
-PV_BS_001:
-  weights:
-    end_state_vision: 0.9          # Primary weight
-    market_signals: 0.1             # Secondary
-
-  thresholds:
-    high_priority: 0.8
-    medium_priority: 0.7
-    low_priority: 0.5
-    veto_threshold: 0.7
-
-  veto_conditions:
-    - "end_state_vision_clarity < 0.7"        # VETO
-    - "strategic_priority_score < 0.5"        # REVIEW
-```
-
-**Decision Tree:**
-
-```
-IF (proposed_action directly enables 'end_state_vision')
-  THEN resource_allocation_priority = HIGH → APPROVE
-
-ELSE IF (proposed_action creates optionality_path)
-  THEN resource_allocation_priority = MEDIUM → APPROVE with conditions
-
-ELSE IF (action does not serve end_state vision)
-  THEN REVIEW - requires justification
-
-TERMINATION: If action contradicts end_state OR more direct path exists
-FALLBACK: If multiple actions conflict, prioritize the one that builds
-          the more fundamental layer of the future system
-```
-
-**Critérios de Avaliação:**
-
-| Critério | Weight | Threshold | Descrição |
-|----------|--------|-----------|-----------|
-| End-state vision clarity | 0.9 | ≥0.8 | Quão bem definido é o estado futuro? |
-| Strategic priority score | 0.1 | ≥0.7 | Alinha com top priorities? |
-| Optionality creation | 0.8 | ≥0.6 | Cria flexibilidade futura? |
-| Resource efficiency | 0.7 | ≥0.5 | Uso ótimo de recursos? |
-
-**Exemplo Behavioral Evidence (do HybridOps):**
-- **Context:** Mercado de influencer focado em ativação manual
-- **Decision:** Criar AI team 1.5 anos antes de ser necessário
-- **Rationale:** Mudança estrutural do mercado para advertising automation (TTCX)
-- **Outcome:** #1 em Latin America quando mercado mudou
-
-**Reusável em Squad-Creator Como:**
-
-```yaml
-HO-HE-001-SC: "Squad-Creator Architecture Validation"
-phase: 2
-question: "Does this architecture directly enable full-stack squad creation?"
-
-decision_points:
-  - "DNA extraction pipeline → YES (fundamental)"
-  - "Agent generation → YES (core capability)"
-  - "Quality gates → YES (systemic requirement)"
-  - "Workflow automation → YES (efficiency layer)"
-  - "Dashboard analytics → REVIEW (nice-to-have, not core)"
-
-end_state_vision: "Autonomous creation of purpose-built squads with 0 manual configuration"
-vision_clarity: 0.85  # Clear vision
-strategic_priority: 0.9  # Top priority for AIOS
-optionality_paths: 3  # Multiple integration points
-
-result: APPROVE (0.87 score)
-```
-
-**Performance Metrics:**
-- Decision speed: "1-3 days (vision crystallization); <1 hour (tactical)"
-- Accuracy rate: "85% (3-5 year horizons)"
-- Confidence level: "95% (once vision is established)"
-
----
-
-### HO-HE-002: PV_PA_001 - Systemic Coherence Scan
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-HE-002`
-**Nome Completo:** Systemic Coherence Scan
-**Categoria:** People/Executor Assessment Heuristic
-**Fase:** 3 (Executors)
-**Agent Executor:** `@hybridOps:executor-designer`
-
-**Propósito:**
-Validar coerência de executor assignments e people assessment. Truthfulness tem **VETO POWER**.
-
-**Pesos Críticos:**
-
-```yaml
-PV_PA_001:
-  weights:
-    truthfulness_coherence: 1.0  # VETO power - absolute
-    system_adherence_potential: 0.8
-    technical_skill: 0.3
-
-  thresholds:
-    truthfulness: 0.7           # Must be 'Coherent'
-    system_adherence: 0.7
-    technical_skill: null        # No minimum, context-dependent
-
-  veto_conditions:
-    - condition: "truthfulness_coherence < 0.7"
-      action: "VETO - REJECT/REMOVE immediately"
-    - condition: "lie_detected = true"
-      action: "VETO - Trust violation"
-```
-
-**Truthfulness States:**
-
-```yaml
-truthfulness_states:
-  coherent:
-    range: [0.7, 1.0]
-    description: "Statements align with actions and observable data"
-    action: "APPROVE"
-
-  incoherent:
-    range: [0.4, 0.7]
-    description: "Statements contradict actions or data"
-    action: "REVIEW - Investigate"
-
-  lie_detected:
-    range: [0.0, 0.4]
-    description: "Deliberate misrepresentation"
-    action: "VETO - Immediate removal"
-```
-
-**Executor Type Coherence Matrix:**
-
-| Executor Type | Min Truthfulness | Min System Adherence | Tech Weight |
-|---------------|------------------|----------------------|-------------|
-| Human | 0.7 (VETO) | 0.7 | 0.3 |
-| Hybrid | 0.7 (VETO) | 0.8 | 0.4 |
-| Agent | N/A | 0.9 | 0.6 |
-| Worker | N/A | 0.95 | 0.8 |
-
-**Failure Modes to Watch:**
-
-- **False Negative:** Rejecting talented candidate por pequena inconsistência
-  - Recovery: Appeal tribunal com trusted circle
-  - Prevention: Diferenciar "nervousness" de "intentional lie"
-
-- **False Positive:** Accepting incoherent executor por charming presentation
-  - Detection: Contradictions em behavioral evidence
-  - Recovery: Apply test period com revealing tasks
-
-**Reusável em Squad-Creator:**
-
-```yaml
-HO-HE-002-SC: "Agent Executor Coherence Validation"
-phase: 3
-scope: "All agents generated by squad-creator"
-
-validation_criteria:
-  - agent_output_matches_prompt: 0.9
-  - consistency_across_runs: 0.85
-  - behavior_matches_persona: 0.80
-  - follows_guardrails: 1.0  # VETO if fails
-
-veto_conditions:
-  - "Agent generates outputs contradicting its persona"
-  - "Agent ignores quality gates"
-  - "Agent produces inconsistent results for same input"
-
-example:
-  agent: "@squad-creator:analyzer"
-  truthfulness_score: 0.92
-  system_adherence: 0.88
-  consistency: "Extracts same axiomas from same agent 10/10 times"
-  result: APPROVE
-```
-
----
-
-### HO-HE-003: PV_PM_001 - Automation Tipping Point
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-HE-003`
-**Nome Completo:** Automation Tipping Point
-**Categoria:** Automation Decision Heuristic
-**Fase:** 4 (Workflows)
-**Agent Executor:** `@hybridOps:workflow-designer`
-
-**Propósito:**
-Determinar QUANDO e SE automate um processo. Implementa "Automation Before Delegation". **Guardrails têm VETO POWER**.
-
-**A Lei da Automação:**
-
-```yaml
-automation_mandate:
-  rule_1:
-    trigger: "Task repeated 2+ times"
-    action: "Document and automate"
-
-  rule_2:
-    trigger: "Task repeated 3+ times without automation"
-    assessment: "Grave design failure"
-    action: "Immediate remediation required"
-
-  rule_3:
-    trigger: "Any automation"
-    requirement: "MUST have guardrails, idempotency, logs, and manual escape"
-```
-
-**Pesos e Thresholds:**
-
-```yaml
-PV_PM_001:
-  weights:
-    task_systemic_impact: 0.9
-    task_automatability: 0.8
-    task_frequency: 0.7
-    guardrails_present: 1.0  # VETO power
-
-  thresholds:
-    systemic_impact: 0.6      # For deep work allocation
-    automatability: 0.5       # For removal from agenda
-    frequency: "2x per month" # Minimum for automation justification
-    standardization: 0.7      # Process must be standardized
-```
-
-**Decision Tree:**
-
-```
-PRIMARY:
-  IF (task_automatability > 0.5)
-    THEN AUTOMATE/DELEGATE
-
-SECONDARY:
-  ELSE IF (task_systemic_impact > 0.6)
-    THEN ALLOCATE_DEEP_WORK_TIME (keep for humans)
-
-CONSTRAINT: NEVER automate without guardrails
-
-AUTOMATION DECISION MATRIX:
-┌───────────┬────────┬──────────────┬──────────────┐
-│ Frequency │ Impact │ Automatability│ Decision     │
-├───────────┼────────┼──────────────┼──────────────┤
-│ High (4x) │ High   │ High         │ **AUTOMATE** │
-│ High      │ High   │ Low          │ DELEGATE     │
-│ High      │ Low    │ High         │ AUTOMATE     │
-│ Low (<2x) │ High   │ Any          │ KEEP_MANUAL  │
-│ Low       │ Low    │ Any          │ **ELIMINATE**│
-│ Any       │ Any    │ Any (no GR)  │ **VETO**     │
-└───────────┴────────┴──────────────┴──────────────┘
-```
-
-**Guardrails Requirements (OBRIGATÓRIOS):**
-
-```yaml
-automation_guardrails:
-  required:
-    - loop_prevention: "Deduplication and max iteration limits"
-    - idempotency: "Same input always produces same output"
-    - audit_trail: "Log of last agent/event"
-    - manual_escape: "Human override route available"
-    - retry_logic: "Graceful failure handling"
-
-  validation:
-    - "Can a human intervene at any point?"
-    - "Are all state changes logged?"
-    - "Is there a rollback mechanism?"
-    - "Are rate limits implemented?"
-```
-
-**Reusável em Squad-Creator:**
-
-```yaml
-HO-HE-003-SC: "DNA Extraction Automation Decision"
-phase: 4
-
-analysis:
-  frequency: "Every agent created (10+ times/month)"  # High
-  systemic_impact: 0.95  # Core to squad creation
-  automatability: 0.85  # Parse, extract, validate are deterministic
-  guardrails: "Present"  # 5/5 required
-    - loop_prevention: "Max 100 iterations per extraction"
-    - idempotency: "Same agent file → same DNA output"
-    - audit_trail: "Log each extraction step"
-    - manual_escape: "Manual DNA review before deploy"
-    - retry_logic: "Fallback to template on parse error"
-
-decision: AUTOMATE (0.91 score)
-confidence: HIGH
-```
-
----
-
-## AXIOMA VALIDATOR PATTERN
-
-### HO-AX-001: 10-Dimension Axioma Assessment
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-AX-001`
-**Nome:** Meta-Axiomas Assessment Framework
-**Fase:** 6 (Quality Assurance)
-**Scope:** Process-level validation
-
-**Definição:**
-Framework de 10 dimensões para validar se um processo está **coerente com axiomas fundamentais**. Baseado em 40+ decisões documentadas.
-
-**As 10 Dimensões:**
-
-| # | Dimensão | Definição | Weight | Threshold | Veto Power |
-|---|----------|-----------|--------|-----------|------------|
-| 1 | Truthfulness | Acurácia e confiabilidade dos outputs | 1.0 | 7.0 | YES |
-| 2 | Coherence | Consistência interna e lógica | 0.9 | 6.0 | NO |
-| 3 | Strategic Alignment | Suporta objetivos organizacionais | 0.9 | 6.0 | NO |
-| 4 | Operational Excellence | Eficiência, confiabilidade, documentação | 0.8 | 6.0 | NO |
-| 5 | Innovation Capacity | Habilidade de melhoria e adaptação | 0.7 | 5.0 | NO |
-| 6 | Risk Management | Identificação e mitigação de riscos | 0.8 | 6.0 | NO |
-| 7 | Resource Optimization | Uso eficiente de tempo/dinheiro/pessoas | 0.8 | 6.0 | NO |
-| 8 | Stakeholder Value | Valor entregue a todas as partes | 0.7 | 6.0 | NO |
-| 9 | Sustainability | Viabilidade a longo prazo | 0.7 | 6.0 | NO |
-| 10 | Adaptability | Capacidade de evolução | 0.6 | 5.0 | NO |
-
-**Scoring:**
-```yaml
-overall_score: (Σ(score_i × weight_i)) ÷ Σ(weight_i)
-
-pass_criteria:
-  overall: ">= 7.0"
-  per_dimension: ">= 6.0 for all"
-  veto: "truthfulness < 7.0"
-```
-
-**Assessment Template:**
-
-```yaml
-axioma_assessment:
-  process_name: "DNA Extraction Pipeline"
-  assessor: "@squad-creator:qa-architect"
-
-  dimensions:
-    - name: "Truthfulness"
-      score: 8.5/10
-      evidence: "Extracts same axiomas consistently from same agent"
-      recommendations: ["Add confidence scoring", "Document edge cases"]
-
-    - name: "Coherence"
-      score: 8.0/10
-      evidence: "Output YAML format matches schema 100%"
-      recommendations: []
-
-    # ... remaining 8 dimensions
-
-  overall_score: 7.9
-  pass_threshold: 7.0
-  status: "PASS"
-  veto_triggered: false
-```
-
-**Reusável em Squad-Creator:**
-
-```yaml
-HO-AX-001-SC: "Squad-Creator Pipeline Axioma Assessment"
-
-process_components:
-  - "DNA Extraction"
-  - "Agent Generation"
-  - "Quality Gates"
-  - "Validation Pipeline"
-
-example_assessment:
-  DNA_Extraction:
-    truthfulness: 8.5  # Consistent output
-    coherence: 8.0     # Follows YAML schema
-    strategic_alignment: 8.5  # Enables core mission
-    operational_excellence: 8.0  # Well-documented, 99.9% uptime
-    innovation_capacity: 7.0  # Templates can be enhanced
-    risk_management: 8.5  # Guardrails present
-    resource_optimization: 8.0  # 48% automated
-    stakeholder_value: 8.5  # Saves 3h per agent
-    sustainability: 7.5  # No custom code
-    adaptability: 7.5  # Config-based
-
-    overall_score: 7.9  # PASS
-    recommendation: "Proceed to Phase 7"
-```
-
----
-
-## QUALITY GATE PATTERNS (HO-PP-003)
-
-### HO-QG-001: Quality Gate Pattern - 3-Type Taxonomy
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-QG-001`
-**Nome:** Quality Gate Pattern (HO-PP-003)
-**Aplicável a:** Todas as fases (1-9)
-
-**Os 3 Tipos de Quality Gates:**
-
-| Tipo | Executor | Velocidade | Uso | Exemplo |
-|------|----------|-----------|-----|---------|
-| **Automated** | Sistema/AI | <1 segundo | Deterministic checks | Field validation, calculations |
-| **Hybrid** | Sistema + Human | 1-5 minutos | AI prepara, humano aprova | Template generation review |
-| **Manual** | Human/Team | 1-8 horas | Judgment-based | Acceptance sign-off |
-
-**Estrutura Completa de Quality Gate:**
-
-```yaml
-quality_gate:
-  id: "QG-R02"                    # Unique identifier
-  name: "RICE Inputs Completeness"
-  phase: "Runtime"
-  workflow: "WF-R01"
-  location: "Before RT-004"
-  type: "Automated"               # One of: Automated, Hybrid, Manual
-  risk_level: "Medium"            # Low, Medium, High, Critical
-
-  # TRIGGER DEFINITION
-  trigger:
-    event: "field_change"         # What event activates gate
-    condition: "any_rice_field_updated"
-
-  # ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA
-  criteria:
-    - check: "Reach field filled"
-      type: "not_empty"           # Type: not_empty, validation, boolean, threshold, etc
-      field_id: "a1f4fcb9-..."
-      required: true
-
-    - check: "Impact field selected"
-      type: "not_empty"
-      field_id: "daeaffa6-..."
-      required: true
-
-    - check: "Effort field selected"
-      type: "not_empty"
-      field_id: "056d774e-..."
-      required: true
-
-  threshold: "100% fields filled"  # Pass condition
-
-  # EXECUTOR CONFIGURATION
-  executor:
-    type: "automated"             # Or: hybrid, manual
-    agent: "ClickUp AI Field"      # Who/what validates
-
-  # ACTIONS ON PASS/FAIL
-  pass_action:
-    - "Proceed with RICE calculation"
-    - "Log success"
-
-  fail_action:
-    - "Return '-' as score"
-    - "Display incomplete status"
-    - "Log failure details"
-
-  sla: "<1 second"                # Service level agreement
-  guardrail: "GR-001"             # Linked guardrail (optional)
-```
-
-**5-Layer QG Taxonomy:**
-
-```
-Layer 1: RUNTIME GATES (System-level, automated)
-├── Template application gates
-├── Calculation completeness gates
-├── Value validity gates
-└── Status transition gates
-
-Layer 2: IMPLEMENTATION GATES (Wave-based)
-├── Wave 1 completion
-├── Wave 2 completion
-├── Wave 3 completion
-└── Acceptance gate
-
-Layer 3: INTEGRATION GATES (End-to-end)
-├── Complete epic flow test
-├── Complete story flow test
-└── Validation gate blocking test
-
-Layer 4: APPROVAL GATES (Management)
-├── Product Owner sign-off
-├── Tech Lead sign-off
-└── Executive approval
-
-Layer 5: MONITORING GATES (Operational)
-├── SLA monitoring
-├── Failure rate tracking
-└── Performance dashboards
-```
-
-**Reusável em Squad-Creator:**
-
-```yaml
-HO-QG-001-SC: "Agent Generation Quality Gates"
-
-gates:
-  - id: "QG-1.1"
-    name: "DNA Extraction Completeness"
-    type: "Automated"
-    location: "After extraction, before generation"
-    criteria:
-      - "All axiomas extracted (≥5)"
-      - "No empty fields in DNA YAML"
-      - "Coherence score ≥ 0.7"
-    threshold: "100% criteria met"
-    pass_action: ["Proceed to agent generation"]
-    fail_action: ["Return to extraction", "Notify user"]
-
-  - id: "QG-1.2"
-    name: "Agent Generation Validity"
-    type: "Hybrid"
-    location: "After agent YAML generated"
-    criteria:
-      - "Agent markdown parses without error"
-      - "All required fields present"
-      - "No undefined placeholder values"
-    threshold: "100% criteria met"
-    pass_action: ["Deploy agent", "Generate documentation"]
-    fail_action: ["Regenerate", "Request manual fixes"]
-
-  - id: "QG-1.3"
-    name: "Axioma Compliance Review"
-    type: "Manual"
-    location: "Before go-live"
-    criteria:
-      - "Agent behavior matches persona (PV assessment)"
-      - "No security/safety violations"
-      - "Meets squad requirements"
-    threshold: "Product Owner approval"
-    pass_action: ["Mark as Production-Ready"]
-    fail_action: ["Send back for refinement"]
-```
-
----
-
-## EXECUTOR ASSIGNMENT PATTERNS (HO-EP-XXX)
-
-### HO-EP-001: Human Executor Pattern
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-EP-001`
-**Nome:** Human Executor Assignment
-**Quando Usar:** Tasks requiring judgment, creativity, relationships
-
-**Characteristics:**
-- Cost: $$$ (expensive)
-- Speed: Slow (hours to days)
-- Judgment Required: YES
-- Can be automated: NO
-
-**Typical Tasks:**
-- Business value assessment
-- Technical estimation
-- Leadership decisions
-- Code reviews (with judgment)
-- Stakeholder communication
-
-**Executor Matrix Entry:**
-
-```yaml
-- task_id: COMP-H01
-  task_name: "Assess Agent Fit for Squad"
-  executor_type: human
-  pattern: HO-EP-001
-  assigned_to: "Squad Lead"
-  backup: "Product Owner"
-
-  rationale: "Judgment about agent personality, culture fit requires human discernment"
-  automation_potential: low
-  frequency: "per agent creation"
-
-  capabilities_required:
-    - name: "Agent Capability Assessment"
-      level: expert
-    - name: "Team Dynamics Understanding"
-      level: expert
-
-  raci:
-    responsible: "Squad Lead"
-    accountable: "Squad Lead"
-    consulted: ["Agent Creator", "PM"]
-    informed: ["Team"]
-```
-
----
-
-### HO-EP-002: Agent (AI) Executor Pattern
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-EP-002`
-**Nome:** Agent (AI) Executor Assignment
-**Quando Usar:** Analysis, generation, pattern recognition
-
-**Characteristics:**
-- Cost: $$$$ (API calls)
-- Speed: Very Fast (seconds to minutes)
-- Judgment Required: NO (deterministic or guided)
-- Can be automated: YES (fully)
-
-**Typical Tasks:**
-- Code generation
-- Data analysis
-- Content generation
-- Complex pattern matching
-- Reasoning over structured data
-
-**Executor Matrix Entry:**
-
-```yaml
-- task_id: COMP-A01
-  task_name: "Extract Agent Axiomas"
-  executor_type: agent
-  pattern: HO-EP-002
-  assigned_to: "Claude API (Opus)"
-  backup: null
-
-  rationale: "Axioma extraction is deterministic pattern recognition"
-  automation_potential: high
-  frequency: "per agent"
-
-  tools_available:
-    - "Claude Opus API"
-    - "Extraction templates"
-
-  raci:
-    responsible: "API System"
-    accountable: "Squad Creator Admin"
-    consulted: []
-    informed: ["QA team"]
-```
-
----
-
-### HO-EP-003: Hybrid Executor Pattern
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-EP-003`
-**Nome:** Hybrid Executor Assignment
-**Quando Usar:** AI assists, human validates and directs
-
-**Characteristics:**
-- Cost: $$ (split cost)
-- Speed: Moderate (minutes to hours)
-- Judgment Required: BOTH
-- Can be automated: Partially (AI part yes, validation part no)
-
-**Typical Tasks:**
-- Code generation with review
-- Design + implementation (separate roles)
-- AI draft + human refinement
-- Complex automation with human gates
-
-**Executor Matrix Entry:**
-
-```yaml
-- task_id: IMP-006
-  task_name: "Create WSJF Validation Gate"
-  executor_type: hybrid
-  pattern: HO-EP-003
-  assigned_to:
-    design: "@squad-creator:architect"  # AI designs automation logic
-    implement: "Admin"                     # Human implements in ClickUp
-  backup: "Tech Lead"
-
-  rationale: "Automation logic requires AI design, implementation requires admin access"
-  effort: "2h total (1h design + 1h implement)"
-  risk: medium
-
-  raci:
-    responsible: "@architect"  # Design lead
-    accountable: "Tech Lead"    # Overall accountability
-    consulted: ["Product Owner"]
-    informed: ["Dev Team"]
-
-  workflow:
-    step_1: "AI designs validation logic"
-    step_2: "Human reviews AI output"
-    step_3: "Human implements in platform"
-    step_4: "Test end-to-end"
-```
-
----
-
-### HO-EP-004: Worker Executor Pattern
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-EP-004`
-**Nome:** Worker (Deterministic Automation) Executor
-**Quando Usar:** Deterministic tasks, file operations, API calls
-
-**Characteristics:**
-- Cost: $ (cheapest)
-- Speed: Very Fast (sub-second to seconds)
-- Judgment Required: NO
-- Can be automated: YES (100%)
-
-**Typical Tasks:**
-- Template application
-- Field calculations (formulas)
-- Validation (if/then rules)
-- File operations
-- Data transformations
-
-**Executor Matrix Entry:**
-
-```yaml
-- task_id: COMP-W01
-  task_name: "Apply Agent Template"
-  executor_type: worker
-  pattern: HO-EP-004
-  assigned_to: "ClickUp Task Template"  # Or: automation system, worker process
-  backup: null
-
-  rationale: "Template application is deterministic, no judgment"
-  automation_potential: high
-  frequency: "per agent creation"
-  platform: "ClickUp native"
-  trigger: "task_created with type=agent"
-
-  required_fields:
-    - "agent name"
-    - "agent type"
-
-  capabilities_required:
-    - name: "Template Application"
-      level: basic
-
-  raci:
-    responsible: "System"
-    accountable: "Admin"
-    consulted: []
-    informed: ["Squad Creator"]
-
-  worker_logic: |
-    IF task_type = 'agent' AND created_by = '@squad-creator'
-    THEN apply_template('agent-standard.yaml')
-    AND set_default_fields()
-    AND notify_creator()
-```
-
----
-
-## COHERENCE VALIDATION PATTERNS
-
-### HO-CV-001: Truthfulness Assessment
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-CV-001`
-**Nome:** Truthfulness Coherence Validation
-**Source:** PV_PA_001 Heuristic
-
-**Truthfulness Evaluation States:**
-
-```yaml
-coherence_levels:
-  coherent:  # 0.7 - 1.0
-    description: "Statements align with observable data and actions"
-    examples:
-      - "Agent always extracts same axiomas from same input"
-      - "Agent behavior matches its documented persona"
-    action: "APPROVE"
-    score_range: [0.7, 1.0]
-
-  inconsistent:  # 0.4 - 0.7
-    description: "Statements contradict data without clear explanation"
-    examples:
-      - "Agent claims 'deterministic' but output varies"
-      - "Agent says 'truthfulness matters' but outputs contain errors"
-    action: "REVIEW - Investigate"
-    score_range: [0.4, 0.7]
-    remediation: "Apply test period with revealing tasks"
-
-  incoherent:  # 0.0 - 0.4
-    description: "Deliberate misrepresentation detected"
-    examples:
-      - "Agent fabricates extraction data"
-      - "Agent ignores documented safety guardrails"
-    action: "VETO - Remove immediately"
-    score_range: [0.0, 0.4]
-    consequence: "Trust breach - cannot proceed"
-```
-
-**Assessment Checklist:**
-
-```yaml
-truthfulness_validation:
-  - test: "Run same input 10x, check output consistency"
-    threshold: "10/10 identical outputs"
-
-  - test: "Verify extracted data against source"
-    threshold: ">95% accuracy"
-
-  - test: "Check if behavior matches documented persona"
-    threshold: "100% alignment"
-
-  - test: "Verify compliance with safety guardrails"
-    threshold: "0 violations across 100 runs"
-
-  - test: "Check if error messages are truthful"
-    threshold: "No false positives or negatives"
-
-scoring:
-  all_tests_pass: 0.95    # Coherent
-  1_test_fails: 0.65      # Inconsistent
-  2+_tests_fail: 0.35     # Incoherent
-```
-
----
-
-### HO-CV-002: Weighted Coherence Assessment
-
-**ID Pattern:** `HO-CV-002`
-**Nome:** Weighted Coherence Score Calculation
-**Source:** PV_PA_001 Checkpoint
-
-**Evaluation Criteria:**
-
-```yaml
-weighted_coherence_formula:
-  components:
-    - criterion: "Capability-Task Alignment"
-      weight: 0.35
-      evaluation: "Does task match executor capabilities?"
-
-    - criterion: "Accountability Clarity"
-      weight: 0.25
-      evaluation: "Is R/A/C/I clear for task?"
-
-    - criterion: "Backup Coverage"
-      weight: 0.15
-      evaluation: "Is there clear backup executor?"
-
-    - criterion: "Escalation Paths"
-      weight: 0.10
-      evaluation: "Are escalation routes defined?"
-
-    - criterion: "Pattern Compliance"
-      weight: 0.15
-      evaluation: "Does task follow HO patterns?"
-
-  formula: "(Σ(score_i × weight_i)) / Σ(weight_i)"
-
-  example_calculation:
-    capability_alignment: 0.92 × 0.35 = 0.322
-    accountability: 0.90 × 0.25 = 0.225
-    backup: 0.85 × 0.15 = 0.128
-    escalation: 0.90 × 0.10 = 0.090
-    pattern: 0.95 × 0.15 = 0.143
-    ────────────────────────────────
-    total_score: 0.908  # PASS (threshold: 0.8)
-```
-
-**Reusável em Squad-Creator:**
-
-```yaml
-HO-CV-002-SC: "Agent-Squad Coherence Assessment"
-
-agents:
-  - name: "@squad-creator:analyzer"
-    capability_alignment: 0.92  # DNA extraction ✓
-    accountability: 0.90        # Clear RACI ✓
-    backup: 0.85                # Fallback template ✓
-    escalation: 0.90            # QA review available ✓
-    pattern: 0.95               # Follows HO-EP-002 ✓
-
-    weighted_score: 0.91  # PASS
-```
-
----
-
-## RESUMO DE PATTERNS PARA IMPLEMENTAÇÃO
-
-### Prioridade 1: CRÍTICO (Implementar Primeiro)
-
-| Pattern | Descrição | Fase | Esforço |
-|---------|-----------|------|---------|
-| **HO-TP-001** | 8-field task anatomy | 5 | 3h |
-| **HO-VC-001/002/003** | Veto conditions framework | 2-4 | 5h |
-| **HO-HE-001** | Future back-casting | 2 | 4h |
-| **HO-HE-002** | Coherence scan | 3 | 4h |
-| **HO-QG-001** | Quality gate pattern | 6 | 6h |
-
-### Prioridade 2: IMPORTANTE (Próximas)
-
-| Pattern | Descrição | Fase | Esforço |
-|---------|-----------|------|---------|
-| **HO-HE-003** | Automation tipping point | 4 | 4h |
-| **HO-AX-001** | Axioma validation | 6 | 8h |
-| **HO-EP-001 a 004** | Executor patterns | 3 | 6h |
-
-### Prioridade 3: COMPLEMENTAR (Depois)
-
-| Pattern | Descrição | Uso |
-|---------|-----------|-----|
-| **HO-CV-001/002** | Coherence validation | Specific assessments |
-
----
-
-## ESTRUTURA DE ARQUIVO RECOMENDADA (Self-Contained)
-
-Para implementar todos os patterns no squad-creator, criar:
-
-```
-squads/squad-creator-pro/
-├── minds/                              # MIND ARTIFACTS (copiados de HybridOps)
-│   └── pedro_valerio/
-│       ├── heuristics/
-│       │   ├── PV_BS_001.md           # Future Back-Casting
-│       │   ├── PV_PA_001.md           # Systemic Coherence Scan
-│       │   └── PV_PM_001.md           # Automation Tipping Point
-│       └── artifacts/
-│           ├── META_AXIOMAS.md        # 10 dimensões
-│           └── Assinatura_Linguistica.md
-│
-├── config/                             # CONFIGURAÇÕES
-│   ├── veto-conditions.yaml           # Engine de veto
-│   ├── task-anatomy.yaml              # Schema 8 campos
-│   ├── heuristics.yaml                # Engine de heuristics (adaptado)
-│   ├── axioma-validator.yaml          # Scoring 10 dimensões
-│   └── quality-gates.yaml             # Quality gates por fase
-│
-├── patterns/                           # PATTERNS ADAPTADOS
-│   ├── veto-conditions/
-│   │   ├── SC-VC-001-vision-clarity.yaml
-│   │   ├── SC-VC-002-agent-coherence.yaml
-│   │   └── SC-VC-003-guardrail-requirement.yaml
-│   │
-│   ├── heuristics/
-│   │   ├── SC-HE-001-squad-vision.md
-│   │   ├── SC-HE-002-agent-coherence.md
-│   │   └── SC-HE-003-workflow-automation.md
-│   │
-│   ├── quality-gates/
-│   │   └── SC-QG-001-pattern.yaml
-│   │
-│   └── executors/
-│       ├── SC-EP-001-human.yaml
-│       ├── SC-EP-002-agent.yaml
-│       ├── SC-EP-003-hybrid.yaml
-│       └── SC-EP-004-worker.yaml
-│
-└── scripts/                            # VALIDADORES
-    ├── task-anatomy-validator.py
-    └── coherence-validator.py
-```
-
-**NOTA:** Prefixo `SC-` = Squad-Creator (adaptação local). Prefixo `PV_` ou `HO-` = Original do HybridOps.
-
----
-
-## INTEGRAÇÃO COM WORKFLOW EXISTENTE
-
-### Fluxo Atual do Squad-Creator
-
-```
-squad-chief (orquestra)
-    ↓ *create-squad, *review-*
-oalanicolas (extrai)
-    ↓ INSUMOS_READY (template: handoff-insumos-tmpl.yaml)
-pedro-valerio (constrói)
-    ↓ Artefatos validados
-squad-chief (revisa)
-    ↓ *review-extraction, *review-artifacts
-Entrega final
-```
-
-### Template de Handoff (Já Existe)
-
-**Path:** `squads/squad-creator-pro/templates/handoff-insumos-tmpl.yaml`
-
-O Pedro Valério aceita insumos no formato:
-```yaml
-handoff_type: INSUMOS_READY
-from: "@oalanicolas"
-to: "@pedro-valerio"
-
-insumos:
-  voice_dna:
-    signature_phrases: ["...", "..."]  # Mínimo 5
-    source_verified: true               # OBRIGATÓRIO
-  thinking_dna:
-    frameworks: ["...", "..."]
-    heuristics: ["...", "..."]
-  quotes:
-    verified_count: 15                  # Mínimo 15
-
-validation_gates:
-  - all_sources_have_SOURCE_tag: true
-  - min_quotes: 15
-  - min_signature_phrases: 5
-```
-
-### Veto no Handoff
-
-Se insumos incompletos, Pedro Valério **devolve** para @oalanicolas:
-
-```yaml
-veto_handoff:
-  trigger: "insumos_incomplete"
-  conditions:
-    - "< 15 citações verificáveis"
-    - "< 5 signature phrases"
-    - "Conceitos sem [SOURCE:]"
-    - "Inferências não marcadas"
-  action: "DEVOLVER para @oalanicolas com lista específica"
-```
-
----
-
-## CONCLUSÃO
-
-Extraí **23 patterns reutilizáveis** do HybridOps squad:
-
-- **3 Veto Conditions** (para quality gates)
-- **1 Task Anatomy pattern** (8 campos obrigatórios)
-- **3 Heuristics** (PV_BS_001, PV_PA_001, PV_PM_001)
-- **1 Axioma Validator** (10 dimensões)
-- **3 Quality Gate types** (Automated, Hybrid, Manual)
-- **4 Executor Patterns** (Human, Agent, Hybrid, Worker)
-- **2 Coherence Validation** patterns
-
-**ADICIONAL (v1.2):**
-- **4 Modos do Pedro Valério** com mapeamento modo → pattern
-- **5 Mind Artifacts** COPIADOS para dentro do squad-creator (self-contained)
-- **Integração com workflow** squad-chief → oalanicolas → pedro-valerio
-- **Zero referências externas** - squad é 100% portável
-
-Todos estão **prontos para adaptação** ao squad-creator com minimal customization. Recomendo iniciar pela **Fase 0 (Agent Update)** antes dos patterns.
-
----
-
-## CHANGELOG
-
-| Versão | Data | Mudanças |
-|--------|------|----------|
-| v1.2 | 2026-02-10 | Self-contained: COPIAR artifacts, zero refs externas |
-| v1.1 | 2026-02-10 | 4 Modos, Mind Artifacts, Workflow integration |
-| v1.0 | 2026-02-10 | Versão inicial - 23 patterns extraídos |
-
----
-
-*Documento atualizado: 2026-02-10 v1.2*