ai-foreman 1.7.25 → 1.7.26

package/dist/tickets/reset.js

@@ -61,82 +61,93 @@ export function resetTickets(projectDir, target, actor = "user", now = new Date(
     if (ids.length === 0)
         return { resetId: randomUUID(), tickets: [] };
     const { config, paths, tickets, db } = open(projectDir);
-    const workflow = new WorkflowDb(projectDir);
-    const resetId = hooks.resetId ?? randomUUID();
-    if (ids.every((id) => db.getTicketEvents(id).some((event) => event.event_type === "ticket_reset" && event.payload_json?.includes(resetId)))) {
-        workflow.close();
-        db.close();
-        return { resetId, tickets: ids };
-    }
-    const stagePath = join(projectDir, ".rafi", "reset-stage", resetId, "progress.md");
-    const oldStates = new Map(ids.map((id) => [id, db.getState(id)]));
-    const oldRecentCompleted = db.getRecentCompleted().filter((row) => ids.includes(row.ticket_id));
-    const insertedEventIds = [];
-    const progressBefore = existsSync(paths.progressDoc) ? readFileSync(paths.progressDoc) : undefined;
-    const run = workflow.createRun({
-        kind: "recovery",
-        checkpoint: "ticket-reset-intent",
-        originalWork: { resetId, scope: preview.scope, tickets: ids, states: Object.fromEntries(oldStates) },
-        remainingWork: { tickets: ids },
-        state: { operation: "ticket-reset", progressDigest: digest(progressBefore) },
-    }, now);
-    const publication = workflow.beginPublication(run.runId, { operation: "ticket-reset", resetId, tickets: ids, stagePath, targetPath: paths.progressDoc }, { progressDigest: digest(progressBefore) }, now);
+    let workflowHandle;
     try {
-        const stamp = now.toISOString();
-        db.transaction(() => {
-            for (const row of preview.tickets) {
-                db.upsertState(row.id, pristineTicketState(row.id, stamp, actor), stamp);
-                db.deleteRecentCompleted(row.id);
-                insertedEventIds.push(db.insertEvent({
-                    timestamp: stamp,
-                    actor,
-                    ticket_id: row.id,
-                    event_type: "ticket_reset",
-                    old_status: row.status,
-                    new_status: "planned",
-                    summary: `Reset ${row.id} to pristine active state`,
-                    validation: null,
-                    evidence: null,
-                    payload_json: JSON.stringify({ reset_id: resetId, scope: preview.scope, cleared: row.cleared }),
-                }));
+        const workflow = workflowHandle = new WorkflowDb(projectDir);
+        const resetId = hooks.resetId ?? randomUUID();
+        if (ids.every((id) => db.getTicketEvents(id).some((event) => event.event_type === "ticket_reset" && event.payload_json?.includes(resetId)))) {
+            return { resetId, tickets: ids };
+        }
+        return workflow.withTrackerMutationAuthority(() => {
+            if (JSON.stringify(loadTickets(paths.tickets)) !== JSON.stringify(tickets))
+                throw new Error("Ticket definitions changed before reset authority was acquired; preview again");
+            const stagePath = join(projectDir, ".rafi", "reset-stage", resetId, "progress.md");
+            const oldStates = new Map(ids.map((id) => [id, db.getState(id)]));
+            const oldRecentCompleted = db.getRecentCompleted().filter((row) => ids.includes(row.ticket_id));
+            const insertedEventIds = [];
+            const progressBefore = existsSync(paths.progressDoc) ? readFileSync(paths.progressDoc) : undefined;
+            const run = workflow.createRun({
+                kind: "recovery",
+                checkpoint: "ticket-reset-intent",
+                originalWork: { resetId, scope: preview.scope, tickets: ids, states: Object.fromEntries(oldStates) },
+                remainingWork: { tickets: ids },
+                state: { operation: "ticket-reset", progressDigest: digest(progressBefore) },
+            }, now);
+            let publication;
+            try {
+                publication = workflow.beginPublication(run.runId, { operation: "ticket-reset", resetId, tickets: ids, stagePath, targetPath: paths.progressDoc }, { progressDigest: digest(progressBefore) }, now);
+                const stamp = now.toISOString();
+                db.transaction(() => {
+                    for (const row of preview.tickets) {
+                        db.upsertState(row.id, pristineTicketState(row.id, stamp, actor), stamp);
+                        db.deleteRecentCompleted(row.id);
+                        insertedEventIds.push(db.insertEvent({
+                            timestamp: stamp,
+                            actor,
+                            ticket_id: row.id,
+                            event_type: "ticket_reset",
+                            old_status: oldStates.get(row.id)?.status ?? row.status,
+                            new_status: "planned",
+                            summary: `Reset ${row.id} to pristine active state`,
+                            validation: null,
+                            evidence: null,
+                            payload_json: JSON.stringify({ reset_id: resetId, scope: preview.scope, cleared: row.cleared }),
+                        }));
+                    }
+                });
+                mkdirSync(dirname(stagePath), { recursive: true });
+                writeFileSync(stagePath, renderProgressDoc({ config, projectDir, ticketDefs: tickets, states: db.getAllStates(), db, now: stamp }), "utf8");
+                workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "staged", now);
+                workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "tracker_committed", now);
+                hooks.beforePublish?.();
+                writeProgressDoc(paths.progressDoc, readFileSync(stagePath, "utf8"), true);
+                workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "published", now);
+                workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "committed", now);
+                workflow.transition(run.runId, { status: "completed", checkpoint: "ticket-reset-committed", remainingWork: {}, state: { operation: "ticket-reset", resetId, tickets: ids } }, now);
+                rmSync(dirname(stagePath), { recursive: true, force: true });
+                return { resetId, tickets: ids };
             }
-        });
-        mkdirSync(dirname(stagePath), { recursive: true });
-        writeFileSync(stagePath, renderProgressDoc({ config, projectDir, ticketDefs: tickets, states: db.getAllStates(), db, now: stamp }), "utf8");
-        workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "staged", now);
-        workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "tracker_committed", now);
-        hooks.beforePublish?.();
-        writeProgressDoc(paths.progressDoc, readFileSync(stagePath, "utf8"), true);
-        workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "published", now);
-        workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "committed", now);
-        workflow.transition(run.runId, { status: "completed", checkpoint: "ticket-reset-committed", remainingWork: {}, state: { operation: "ticket-reset", resetId, tickets: ids } }, now);
-        rmSync(dirname(stagePath), { recursive: true, force: true });
-        return { resetId, tickets: ids };
-    }
-    catch (error) {
-        db.transaction(() => {
-            db.deleteEvents(insertedEventIds);
-            for (const [id, state] of oldStates) {
-                if (state)
-                    db.upsertState(id, state, state.updated_at);
+            catch (error) {
+                db.transaction(() => {
+                    db.deleteEvents(insertedEventIds);
+                    for (const [id, state] of oldStates) {
+                        if (state)
+                            db.upsertState(id, state, state.updated_at);
+                        else
+                            db.deleteState(id);
+                    }
+                    for (const row of oldRecentCompleted)
+                        db.upsertRecentCompleted(row);
+                });
+                if (progressBefore)
+                    writeProgressDoc(paths.progressDoc, progressBefore.toString("utf8"), true);
                 else
-                    db.deleteState(id);
+                    rmSync(paths.progressDoc, { force: true });
+                rmSync(dirname(stagePath), { recursive: true, force: true });
+                if (publication)
+                    workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "rolled_back", now);
+                workflow.transition(run.runId, { status: "failed", checkpoint: "ticket-reset-rolled-back", state: { operation: "ticket-reset", resetId, error: error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error) } }, now);
+                throw error;
             }
-            for (const row of oldRecentCompleted)
-                db.upsertRecentCompleted(row);
         });
-        if (progressBefore)
-            writeProgressDoc(paths.progressDoc, progressBefore.toString("utf8"), true);
-        else
-            rmSync(paths.progressDoc, { force: true });
-        rmSync(dirname(stagePath), { recursive: true, force: true });
-        workflow.updatePublication(publication.transactionId, "rolled_back", now);
-        workflow.transition(run.runId, { status: "failed", checkpoint: "ticket-reset-rolled-back", state: { operation: "ticket-reset", resetId, error: error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error) } }, now);
-        throw error;
     }
     finally {
-        workflow.close();
-        db.close();
+        try {
+            workflowHandle?.close();
+        }
+        finally {
+            db.close();
+        }
     }
 }
 /** Finish or roll back a reset publication left incomplete by process interruption. */

package/dist/workflowDb.d.ts

@@ -201,7 +201,6 @@ export interface QaReportRecordV2 {
     createdAt: string;
     updatedAt: string;
 }
-/** Authoritative persistence for every resumable workflow in a project. */
 export declare class WorkflowDb {
     readonly projectDir: string;
     private readonly readinessAccess?;
@@ -212,6 +211,7 @@ export declare class WorkflowDb {
     private coordinatorTransition;
     private lineageTransition;
     private workAuthority;
+    private readonly createdRecoveryIntents;
     constructor(projectDir: string, path?: string, readinessAccess?: {
         probeId: string;
     } | {
@@ -254,6 +254,9 @@ export declare class WorkflowDb {
     /** Atomic local changes only; never await provider or filesystem work here. */
     atomic<T>(work: () => T): T;
     buildAdmission(): BuildAdmission | undefined;
+    /** Short synchronous tracker mutations share the build fence without retiring
+     * provider receipts or granting authority to resume implementation. */
+    withTrackerMutationAuthority<T>(work: () => T): T;
     private assertNoLegacyBuildOwner;
     private assertExecutionProtocol;
     acquireBuildAdmission(runId: string, phase: BuildAdmission["phase"]): BuildAdmission;
@@ -270,6 +273,10 @@ export declare class WorkflowDb {
     acknowledgeBuildLaunchChild(authority: BuildAdmission, token: string, pid: number): void;
     reconcileBuildLaunches(runId: string, original?: BuildAdmission): "retired" | "claimed" | "unknown";
     buildLaunch(token: string): BuildLaunch | undefined;
+    /** A supervisor's waiting exit may represent a successful partial QA boundary.
+     * Require this launch's clean worker exit and verified cleanup, never just QA. */
+    successfulPartialQaRecovery(runId: string, ticketId: string, launchToken: string): boolean;
+    waitForSuccessfulPartialQaRecovery(runId: string, ticketId: string, launchToken: string): Promise<boolean>;
     preparationSuccessor(runId: string): string;
     reservePreparationRetry(predecessor: string, args: string[], expectedStartArgs?: string): {
         runId: string;
@@ -310,6 +317,9 @@ export declare class WorkflowDb {
         state?: Record<string, unknown>;
         legacy?: boolean;
     }, now?: Date): WorkflowRunSnapshot;
+    /** Record failure of an intent this connection just created, before recovery
+     * authority was acquired. This cannot write build execution or publications. */
+    pauseOwnStartOverIntent(runId: string, error: unknown): void;
     getRun(runId: string): WorkflowRunSnapshot | undefined;
     /** Publication intents are immutable; mutable tracker snapshots are not approval evidence. */
     approvedPopulationDefinitions(): unknown[];
@@ -347,6 +357,7 @@ export declare class WorkflowDb {
     sessionUsageSamples(runId: string, role?: "builder" | "qa"): SessionUsageSample[];
     acknowledgeSettings(ack: LiveSettingsAcknowledgment): void;
     settingsAcknowledgments(revision: number): LiveSettingsAcknowledgment[];
+    settingsAdoptionState(runId: string, role: "builder" | "qa"): "active" | "deferred" | "unknown";
     appendContinuityEvent(input: {
         runId: string;
         role: "builder" | "qa" | "host";
@@ -494,6 +505,9 @@ export declare class WorkflowDb {
     recordQaHandoffReceipt(receipt: HandoffAcceptanceReceiptV2): void;
     qaHandoffReceipt(operationId: string): HandoffAcceptanceReceiptV2 | undefined;
     beginQaTurn(intent: QaTurnIntentV2): void;
+    /** Retire an interrupted, proven read-only review transport, never a QA pass
+     * or Builder remediation. A fresh immutable review must still run afterward. */
+    reconcileInterruptedQaDispatch(runId: string, ticketId: string): boolean;
     commitQaTurnIntent(intent: QaTurnIntentV2, expectedRevision: number): QaReducerStateV2;
     finishQaTurn(receipt: QaTurnReceiptV2): void;
     recordQaReport(input: Omit<QaReportRecordV2, "reportOccurrenceId" | "disposition" | "createdAt" | "updatedAt">, findingIds: string[], now?: Date): QaReportRecordV2;
@@ -521,6 +535,7 @@ export declare class WorkflowDb {
     authorizeContractQaWaiver(runId: string, workId: string, decisionId: string): string;
     commitQaWaiver(runId: string, ticketId: string, expectedRevision: number, reason: string, now?: Date, authorizationRef?: string): QaReducerStateV2;
     builderRemediationReceipt(operationId: string): BuilderRemediationReceiptV2 | BuilderRemediationReceiptV3 | undefined;
+    hasConfirmedQaRemediationForRecheck(runId: string, ticketId: string): boolean;
     recordBuilderRemediationReceipt(receipt: BuilderRemediationReceiptV2 | BuilderRemediationReceiptV3): void;
     commitBuilderRemediationSuccess(receipt: BuilderRemediationReceiptV2 | BuilderRemediationReceiptV3, expectedRevision: number, now?: Date): QaReducerStateV2;
     commitQaRemediationOutcome(input: {

package/dist/workflowDb.js

@@ -15,11 +15,15 @@ import { createHash, randomUUID } from "node:crypto";
 import { appendFileSync, existsSync, mkdirSync, readFileSync, readdirSync, statSync } from "node:fs";
 import { hostname } from "node:os";
 import { dirname, join, resolve } from "node:path";
+import { execFileSync } from "node:child_process";
 import Database from "better-sqlite3";
 import { validateQaFailureReport } from "rafi-spec";
 import { migrateQaHandback, registerHandbackWriter, reportOccurrenceId } from "./qaHandbackMigration.js";
 import { providerSessionKey } from "./sessionIdentity.js";
-import { taggedProcesses, classifyProcess, processStartIdentity } from "./processIdentity.js";
+import { captureFrozenQaSource } from "./qaSnapshot.js";
+import { loadTicketsConfig, resolveTicketPaths } from "./tickets/config.js";
+import { loadTickets } from "./tickets/ticketLoader.js";
+import { processGroupQuiescent, taggedProcesses, classifyProcess, processStartIdentity } from "./processIdentity.js";
 import { initialQaReducerState, qaDigest, reduceQaState, } from "./qaProtocolV2.js";
 export const WORKFLOW_DB_FILE = ".rafi/recovery.sqlite3";
 /** Read the current project lease without creating or migrating recovery state. */
@@ -63,6 +67,41 @@ export function heartbeatCurrentWorkflowLease(projectDir, lease, now = new Date(
     }
 }
 /** Authoritative persistence for every resumable workflow in a project. */
+function partialQaRecoveryProcessProof(db, runId, ticketId, launchToken) {
+    const run = db.getRun(runId);
+    const launch = db.buildLaunch(launchToken);
+    const supervisor = db.supervisorState(runId);
+    if (!run || run.status !== "paused" || run.state.status !== "recoverable" || run.checkpoint !== "qa-recovery-complete"
+        || !launch || launch.runId !== runId || launch.state !== "claimed" || !launch.claimant
+        || !supervisor || supervisor.status !== "waiting_for_human" || supervisor.workerPid
+        || launch.role !== "coordinator" || launch.claimant.pid !== supervisor.pid || launch.claimant.processStart !== supervisor.processStart
+        || !["completed", "waived"].includes(db.qaTicketHead(runId, ticketId).state)
+        || !(run.state.progress?.completedTickets?.includes(ticketId))
+        || db.pendingHumanDecisions(runId).length || db.readinessProcesses(runId).length
+        || db.unresolvedRoleDispatches(runId, "builder").length || db.unresolvedRoleDispatches(runId, "qa").length)
+        return undefined;
+    const events = db.events(runId);
+    const exit = events.filter(event => event.type === "worker_exit").at(-1);
+    const started = events.filter(event => event.type === "worker_started").at(-1);
+    const exitProof = exit?.payload;
+    const startProof = started?.payload;
+    if (!exit || !started || exit.at < launch.createdAt || started.at < launch.createdAt
+        || !exitProof || !startProof || exitProof.code !== 0 || exitProof.signal != null || exitProof.stopRequested !== false
+        || exitProof.generation !== supervisor.workerGeneration || startProof.generation !== exitProof.generation)
+        return undefined;
+    const worker = started.payload;
+    if (!worker.workerPid || !worker.processStart || !worker.host)
+        return undefined;
+    return { worker: { pid: worker.workerPid, processStart: worker.processStart, host: worker.host }, claimant: launch.claimant,
+        launchToken, checkpoint: run.checkpoint, supervisorGeneration: supervisor.generation,
+        workerGeneration: supervisor.workerGeneration, startedAt: started.at, exitedAt: exit.at,
+        startedSequence: started.sequence, exitedSequence: exit.sequence };
+}
+function partialQaProcessesSettled(proof) {
+    return classifyProcess(proof.worker.pid, proof.worker.processStart, proof.worker.host).state === "dead"
+        && processGroupQuiescent(proof.worker.pid)
+        && classifyProcess(proof.claimant.pid, proof.claimant.processStart, proof.claimant.host).state === "dead";
+}
 export class WorkflowDb {
     projectDir;
     readinessAccess;
@@ -73,6 +112,7 @@ export class WorkflowDb {
     coordinatorTransition = 0;
     lineageTransition = 0;
     workAuthority = 0;
+    createdRecoveryIntents = new Set();
     constructor(projectDir, path = join(resolve(projectDir), WORKFLOW_DB_FILE), readinessAccess) {
         this.projectDir = projectDir;
         this.readinessAccess = readinessAccess;
@@ -290,6 +330,70 @@ export class WorkflowDb {
     /** Atomic local changes only; never await provider or filesystem work here. */
     atomic(work) { return this.db.transaction(work).immediate(); }
     buildAdmission() { return readAdmission(this.db); }
+    /** Short synchronous tracker mutations share the build fence without retiring
+     * provider receipts or granting authority to resume implementation. */
+    withTrackerMutationAuthority(work) {
+        if (this.writerAuthority) {
+            this.assertBuildAdmission(this.writerAuthority);
+            return work();
+        }
+        let authority;
+        let lease;
+        let intent;
+        try {
+            const prior = this.buildAdmission();
+            if (prior) {
+                authority = this.acquireBuildRecoveryAdmission(prior.runId);
+                lease = this.acquireLease(prior.runId);
+            }
+            else {
+                this.atomic(() => {
+                    this.assertNoLegacyBuildOwner();
+                    for (const owner of this.runningSupervisors()) {
+                        if (owner.state.pid && classifyProcess(owner.state.pid, owner.state.processStart).state !== "dead")
+                            throw new Error("A live or unverified supervisor must stop before tracker reset");
+                    }
+                    for (const row of this.db.prepare("SELECT DISTINCT run_id FROM build_owned_processes WHERE state<>'quiescent'").all()) {
+                        if (this.unresolvedPreparationProcesses(row.run_id).length)
+                            throw new Error("Owned preparation descendants require reconciliation before tracker reset");
+                    }
+                    intent = this.createRun({ kind: "recovery", checkpoint: "tracker-mutation-intent", state: { operation: "tracker-mutation" } });
+                    lease = this.acquireLease(intent.runId);
+                    authority = this.admitLeasedBuild(lease);
+                });
+            }
+            const result = work();
+            if (intent)
+                this.transition(intent.runId, { status: "completed", checkpoint: "tracker-mutation-completed" });
+            return result;
+        }
+        catch (error) {
+            if (intent && this.getRun(intent.runId) && authority && this.buildAdmission()?.token === authority.token) {
+                this.transition(intent.runId, { status: "failed", checkpoint: "tracker-mutation-failed", payload: { error: error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error) } });
+            }
+            throw error;
+        }
+        finally {
+            try {
+                if (lease) {
+                    this.releaseLease(lease);
+                    // Acquisition can have been rolled back by the outer transaction.
+                    // Drop only this invocation's cached token, never a replacement owner.
+                    if (this.currentLease()?.owner !== lease.owner)
+                        forgetOriginalLease(this.projectDir, lease);
+                }
+            }
+            finally {
+                if (authority && this.buildAdmission()?.token === authority.token)
+                    this.releaseBuildAdmission(authority);
+                else if (authority) {
+                    forgetBuildAuthority(authority);
+                    if (this.writerAuthority?.token === authority.token)
+                        this.writerAuthority = undefined;
+                }
+            }
+        }
+    }
     assertNoLegacyBuildOwner() {
         for (const row of this.db.prepare("SELECT run_id,state_json FROM workflow_runs WHERE kind='build' AND legacy=1").all()) {
             const state = parseJson(row.state_json);
@@ -419,6 +523,29 @@ export class WorkflowDb {
         });
     }
     buildLaunch(token) { return readLaunch(this.db, token); }
+    /** A supervisor's waiting exit may represent a successful partial QA boundary.
+     * Require this launch's clean worker exit and verified cleanup, never just QA. */
+    successfulPartialQaRecovery(runId, ticketId, launchToken) {
+        const proof = partialQaRecoveryProcessProof(this, runId, ticketId, launchToken);
+        return Boolean(proof && partialQaProcessesSettled(proof));
+    }
+    async waitForSuccessfulPartialQaRecovery(runId, ticketId, launchToken) {
+        // Clean exits can precede native descendant/inventory settlement. Recheck
+        // only an already validated exact boundary; never kill or relax ownership.
+        const initial = partialQaRecoveryProcessProof(this, runId, ticketId, launchToken);
+        if (!initial || process.platform === "win32")
+            return false;
+        const deadline = Date.now() + 3000;
+        do {
+            const proof = partialQaRecoveryProcessProof(this, runId, ticketId, launchToken);
+            if (!proof || JSON.stringify(proof) !== JSON.stringify(initial))
+                return false;
+            if (partialQaProcessesSettled(proof))
+                return true;
+            await new Promise(resolve => setTimeout(resolve, 100));
+        } while (Date.now() < deadline);
+        return false;
+    }
     preparationSuccessor(runId) {
         const seen = new Set();
         let current = runId;
@@ -714,8 +841,26 @@ export class WorkflowDb {
             }
             this.insertEvent(run.runId, "run_created", run.checkpoint, { kind: run.kind }, at);
         })();
+        if (run.kind === "recovery")
+            this.createdRecoveryIntents.add(run.runId);
         return run;
     }
+    /** Record failure of an intent this connection just created, before recovery
+     * authority was acquired. This cannot write build execution or publications. */
+    pauseOwnStartOverIntent(runId, error) {
+        const run = this.getRun(runId);
+        if (!this.createdRecoveryIntents.has(runId) || run?.kind !== "recovery" || run.state.operation !== "build-start-over"
+            || run.checkpoint !== "start-over-inventory" || run.state.gitPreserved || this.operations(runId).length
+            || this.incompletePublications().some(publication => publication.runId === runId))
+            throw new Error("Recovery intent is outside this connection's unstarted setup scope");
+        this.coordinatorTransition++;
+        try {
+            this.transition(runId, { status: "paused", checkpoint: "start-over-setup-paused", state: { ...run.state, error: error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error) } });
+        }
+        finally {
+            this.coordinatorTransition--;
+        }
+    }
     getRun(runId) {
         const row = this.db.prepare("SELECT * FROM workflow_runs WHERE run_id=?").get(runId);
         return row ? rowToRun(row) : undefined;
@@ -849,6 +994,21 @@ export class WorkflowDb {
         const rows = this.db.prepare("SELECT * FROM live_settings_acknowledgments WHERE revision=? ORDER BY acknowledged_at").all(revision);
         return rows.map((row) => ({ runId: row.run_id, role: row.role, ...(row.provider_session_id ? { providerSessionId: row.provider_session_id } : {}), ...(row.session_key ? { sessionKey: row.session_key } : {}), ...(row.session_ref_json ? { sessionRef: parseJson(row.session_ref_json) } : {}), revision: row.revision, acknowledgedAt: row.acknowledged_at }));
     }
+    settingsAdoptionState(runId, role) {
+        const admission = this.buildAdmission();
+        const lease = this.currentLease();
+        const owner = admission?.runId === runId ? admission : lease?.runId === runId ? lease : undefined;
+        if (!owner)
+            return "deferred";
+        const liveness = classifyProcess(owner.pid, owner.processStart, owner.host).state;
+        if (liveness === "unknown")
+            return "unknown";
+        if (liveness !== "live" || this.getRun(runId)?.status !== "running" || this.pendingHumanDecisions(runId).length)
+            return "deferred";
+        // Historical role/session records are not proof of an active role. A
+        // submitted turn can adopt saved settings at its next safe boundary.
+        return this.unresolvedRoleDispatches(runId, role).some(operation => operation.status === "in_progress") ? "active" : "deferred";
+    }
     appendContinuityEvent(input, now = new Date()) {
         this.ensureRun(input.runId, "build", now);
         const at = now.toISOString();
@@ -893,7 +1053,7 @@ export class WorkflowDb {
             this.refreshRunContinuityHead(input.runId, input.authoritativeStateRevision, at);
             this.insertEvent(input.runId, "continuity_checkpoint", `continuity:${input.role}`, { checkpointId: checkpoint.checkpointId, digest, state: checkpoint.state }, at);
             return checkpoint;
-        })();
+        }).immediate();
     }
     continuityCheckpoints(runId, role) {
         const rows = role
@@ -1578,6 +1738,90 @@ export class WorkflowDb {
                 .run(intent.runId, intent.ticketId, intent.reviewNumber, intent.sessionGeneration, intent.slot, intent.operationId, at);
         })();
     }
+    /** Retire an interrupted, proven read-only review transport, never a QA pass
+     * or Builder remediation. A fresh immutable review must still run afterward. */
+    reconcileInterruptedQaDispatch(runId, ticketId) {
+        const dispatches = this.unresolvedRoleDispatches(runId, "qa");
+        if (!dispatches.length)
+            return false;
+        const lease = this.currentLease();
+        if (lease?.runId !== runId || lease.pid !== process.pid)
+            throw new Error("QA reconciliation requires the original build recovery lease");
+        const worker = this.events(runId).filter(event => event.type === "worker_started").at(-1)?.payload;
+        if (!worker?.workerPid || classifyProcess(worker.workerPid, worker.processStart, worker.host).state !== "dead" || !processGroupQuiescent(worker.workerPid)
+            || this.readinessProcesses().length || this.unresolvedRoleDispatches(runId, "builder").length)
+            throw new Error("Interrupted QA and all owned provider processes must be verified stopped before a fresh review");
+        const head = this.qaTicketHead(runId, ticketId);
+        if (!["turn-intended", "turn-uncertain", "operator-menu"].includes(head.state))
+            throw new Error("QA dispatch is not an interrupted review boundary");
+        const run = this.getRun(runId)?.state;
+        if (!run?.tickets?.includes(ticketId) || run.progress?.completedTickets?.includes(ticketId))
+            throw new Error("QA recovery cannot reopen completed or unapproved tickets");
+        const definition = loadTickets(resolveTicketPaths(loadTicketsConfig(this.projectDir), this.projectDir).tickets).find(ticket => ticket.id === ticketId);
+        if (!definition || qaDigest("admitted-requirements", definition) !== this.assertAdmittedWork(runId, ticketId).requirementsDigest)
+            throw new Error("QA recovery requirements changed; approval is required");
+        const owner = this.roleMutationLease(runId, "qa");
+        // A cancellation can have a durable host terminal receipt while the
+        // provider dispatch is still unknown. Exact frozen-turn bindings remain
+        // required; the old receipt is never promoted to an accepted QA result.
+        const rows = this.db.prepare("SELECT status,intent_json FROM qa_turns WHERE run_id=? AND ticket_id=? AND status IN ('intended','uncertain','unknown','completed')").all(runId, ticketId);
+        const turns = rows.flatMap(row => {
+            const turn = parseJson(row.intent_json);
+            if (row.status === "completed" && !dispatches.some(dispatch => {
+                const result = dispatch.result;
+                return result?.isError === true && result.failure?.dispatchState === "unknown"
+                    && dispatch.intent.instructionDigest === turn.instructionDigest;
+            }))
+                return [];
+            return [turn];
+        });
+        const bindings = dispatches.map(dispatch => {
+            const intent = dispatch.intent;
+            const ref = intent.sessionRef;
+            if (!ref || !owner?.sessionKey || ref.role !== "qa" || ref.stream !== "qa" || !Number.isSafeInteger(ref.generation) || ref.generation < 0
+                || !ref.configRoot || canonicalProject(ref.configRoot) !== canonicalProject(this.projectDir) || !ref.validatedAt || Number.isNaN(Date.parse(ref.validatedAt))
+                || ref.source !== "observed" || providerSessionKey(ref) !== owner.sessionKey)
+                throw new Error("QA dispatch has no validated owner binding");
+            const turn = turns.find(turn => turn.reviewNumber === head.reviewNumber && turn.instructionDigest === intent.instructionDigest
+                && turn.providerSession.sessionId === ref.sessionId && turn.providerSession.provider === ref.provider && turn.providerSession.generation === ref.generation
+                && turn.providerSession.cwd === ref.cwd && turn.providerSession.configRoot === ref.configRoot);
+            if (!turn || turn.sourceStateDigest !== head.sourceStateDigest || turn.reviewBasisDigest !== head.reviewBasisDigest)
+                throw new Error("QA dispatch does not match the frozen review turn");
+            const sessions = this.db.prepare("SELECT session_json FROM qa_sessions WHERE run_id=? AND ticket_id=? AND generation=? AND source_state_digest=? AND review_basis_digest=?").all(runId, ticketId, ref.generation, turn.sourceStateDigest, turn.reviewBasisDigest);
+            const session = sessions.map(row => parseJson(row.session_json)).find(session => providerSessionKey(session.session) === owner.sessionKey && session.confinement);
+            const confinement = session?.confinement;
+            if (!confinement)
+                throw new Error("Interrupted QA lacks a retained read-only confinement proof");
+            const { digest, ...fields } = confinement;
+            if (fields.version !== 2 || fields.sourceMode !== "read-only" || fields.scratchMode !== "isolated" || !["none", "user"].includes(String(fields.settingsSources))
+                || !["disabled", "provider-required"].includes(String(fields.networkMode)) || !/^[a-f0-9]{64}$/.test(String(fields.environmentDigest)) || !/^[a-f0-9]{64}$/.test(String(fields.policyDigest)) || digest !== qaDigest("qa-confinement", fields))
+                throw new Error("Interrupted QA confinement is invalid");
+            const sourceRow = this.db.prepare("SELECT state_json FROM qa_source_states WHERE run_id=? AND ticket_id=? AND digest=?").get(runId, ticketId, turn.sourceStateDigest);
+            const frozen = sourceRow ? parseJson(sourceRow.state_json) : undefined;
+            if (!frozen || frozen.version !== 2 || frozen.runId !== runId || frozen.ticketId !== ticketId || frozen.digest !== turn.sourceStateDigest || !/^[a-f0-9]{64}$/.test(frozen.contentDigest) || !/^[a-f0-9]{64}$/.test(frozen.originDigest) || !Array.isArray(frozen.paths))
+                throw new Error("Interrupted QA frozen source binding is missing or invalid");
+            const basisRow = this.db.prepare("SELECT basis_json FROM qa_review_bases WHERE run_id=? AND ticket_id=? AND digest=?").get(runId, ticketId, turn.reviewBasisDigest);
+            if (!basisRow)
+                throw new Error("Interrupted QA review basis is missing");
+            const basis = parseJson(basisRow.basis_json);
+            const { digest: basisDigest, ...basisFields } = basis;
+            if (basisDigest !== qaDigest("review-basis-fields", basisFields) || basis.confinementDigest !== digest || basis.ticketDigest !== qaDigest("ticket", definition))
+                throw new Error("Interrupted QA review basis is invalid");
+            return { dispatch, turn, confinementDigest: digest };
+        });
+        const source = captureFrozenQaSource(this.projectDir);
+        if (run.repository?.branch && execFileSync("git", ["branch", "--show-current"], { cwd: this.projectDir, encoding: "utf8" }).trim() !== run.repository.branch)
+            throw new Error("Return to the build's owning branch before QA recovery");
+        this.atomic(() => {
+            if (captureFrozenQaSource(this.projectDir).digest !== source.digest)
+                throw new Error("QA source changed during recovery inspection; retry");
+            const reconciliationId = `qa-review-resume:${runId}:${randomUUID()}`;
+            for (const { dispatch, turn, confinementDigest } of bindings)
+                this.updateOperation(dispatch.idempotencyKey, "failed", { result: { recovery: "interrupted-read-only-qa", reconciliationId, outcomeUnknown: true, providerReplayAuthorized: false, priorResult: dispatch.result, qaTurnId: turn.operationId, reviewedSourceDigest: turn.sourceStateDigest, currentSourceDigest: source.digest, confinementDigest }, error: "Interrupted read-only QA outcome remains unknown; replaced by a fresh immutable full review, never replayed or treated as a pass" });
+            this.appendContinuityEvent({ runId, role: "host", kind: "interrupted_qa_reconciled", payload: { reconciliationId, ticketId, dispatchIds: dispatches.map(dispatch => dispatch.idempotencyKey), currentSourceDigest: source.digest, outcomeUnknown: true, providerReplayAuthorized: false }, authoritativeStateRevision: this.continuityHead(runId, "run")?.authoritativeStateRevision ?? 0 });
+        });
+        return true;
+    }
     commitQaTurnIntent(intent, expectedRevision) {
         return this.db.transaction(() => {
             const next = this.transitionQa(intent.runId, intent.ticketId, expectedRevision, { type: "turn-intended", slot: intent.slot }, new Date(intent.intendedAt));
@@ -1748,6 +1992,21 @@ export class WorkflowDb {
         const row = this.db.prepare("SELECT receipt_json FROM qa_remediation_receipts WHERE operation_id=?").get(operationId);
         return row ? parseJson(row.receipt_json) : undefined;
     }
+    hasConfirmedQaRemediationForRecheck(runId, ticketId) {
+        const head = this.qaTicketHead(runId, ticketId);
+        const attempt = this.qaRemediationAttempts(runId, ticketId).at(-1);
+        if (head.state !== "recheck-required" || !attempt || attempt.status !== "succeeded"
+            || attempt.generation !== head.remediationGeneration || this.unresolvedRoleDispatches(runId, "builder").length)
+            return false;
+        const receipt = this.builderRemediationReceipt(attempt.attemptId);
+        const review = this.qaReviewAttempt(attempt.reviewAttemptId);
+        const transition = this.db.prepare("SELECT to_revision,event_json FROM qa_transitions WHERE run_id=? AND ticket_id=? ORDER BY to_revision DESC LIMIT 1").get(runId, ticketId);
+        return Boolean(receipt && review && review.status === "failed" && receipt.runId === runId && receipt.ticketId === ticketId
+            && receipt.operationId === attempt.attemptId && receipt.requestDigest === attempt.requestDigest
+            && receipt.responseDigest === attempt.responseDigest && receipt.summaryDigest === attempt.summaryDigest
+            && receipt.sourceStateDigest === review.sourceDigest && receipt.reportDigest === review.reportDigest && receipt.providerTurnId
+            && transition?.to_revision === head.revision && parseJson(transition.event_json).type === "remediation-received");
+    }
     recordBuilderRemediationReceipt(receipt) {
         const text = json(receipt);
         const existing = this.db.prepare("SELECT receipt_json FROM qa_remediation_receipts WHERE operation_id=?").get(receipt.operationId);
@@ -2268,17 +2527,26 @@ export class WorkflowDb {
      */
     hasUncheckpointedRoleTurn(runId, role) {
         const events = this.continuityEvents(runId);
-        let startSequence = 0;
+        const pending = new Map();
         for (const event of events) {
             if (event.kind === "turn_started" && event.role === "host" && event.payload.role === role) {
-                startSequence = event.sequence;
+                const dispatchId = event.payload.dispatchId;
+                pending.set(event.sequence, typeof dispatchId === "string" ? dispatchId : undefined);
+            }
+            else if (event.role === role && event.kind === "turn_not_sent") {
+                const dispatchId = event.payload.dispatchId;
+                if (typeof dispatchId === "string")
+                    for (const [sequence, id] of pending) {
+                        if (id === dispatchId)
+                            pending.delete(sequence);
+                    }
             }
-            else if (startSequence && event.sequence > startSequence && event.role === role
-                && (event.kind === "turn_completed" || event.kind === "turn_completed_after_repair" || event.kind === "handback_turn_completed" || event.kind === "fresh_successor_accepted")) {
-                startSequence = 0;
+            else if (event.role === role
+                && (event.kind === "turn_completed" || event.kind === "turn_completed_after_repair" || event.kind === "handback_turn_completed" || event.kind === "fresh_successor_accepted" || event.kind === "handoff_successor_accepted")) {
+                pending.clear();
             }
         }
-        return startSequence > 0;
+        return pending.size > 0;
     }
     beginPublication(runId, intent, previousDigests, now = new Date()) {
         const transactionId = randomUUID();

package/package.json

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 {
   "name": "ai-foreman",
-  "version": "1.7.25",
+  "version": "1.7.26",
   "description": "An orchestrator that keeps Codex CLI / Claude Code builders moving through their step list unattended. Part of Rafi.",
   "license": "Apache-2.0",
   "type": "module",