agent-bios 0.9.9 → 0.10.0

package/compose/check-domains.py

@@ -13,9 +13,13 @@ Blocking checks (any violation exits 1, all violations listed):
      in claude/CLAUDE.md, and every bullet is claimed by exactly ONE entry
   3. file coverage: every file in claude/guides|hooks|agents claimed exactly
      once; every claimed file exists on disk
-  4. router-guide co-package: a bullet referencing guides/<g>.md must have an
-     audience covered by that guide's audience (universal bullet -> universal
-     guide; domain bullet -> guide covering all its domains)
+  4. router-guide co-package, both directions: a bullet or guide referencing a
+     guide must have an audience covered by that guide's audience, and the target
+     must be one an install actually receives; every guide must be pointed at by
+     something — a bullet, a parent guide, or a launch preset — or it ships and is
+     read by nobody. This gate assumes references take PATH form; the rule that
+     makes that true is author-side, in gates/check-lexicon.py — it needs LEXICON
+     and the ko/ tree, neither of which a packaged install has
   5. hook source_guide: a hook naming its source guide must carry the same
      tier + domain set as that guide
   6. non-vacuity: every subject set this gate judges is non-empty, so a green
@@ -34,6 +38,7 @@ import sys
 
 sys.path.insert(0, str(pathlib.Path(__file__).resolve().parent))
 import pkgid  # noqa: E402  (sibling module in compose/)
+from assemble import author_only, hook_command_matches  # noqa: E402  THE readers: audience frontmatter, and the settings-merge token rule the gate must agree with
 
 REPO = pathlib.Path(__file__).resolve().parent.parent
 MANIFEST = REPO / "compose" / "domains.json"
@@ -75,6 +80,20 @@ def audience(entry, errors, ctx):
     return "NEVER"
 
 
+def delivered(name, repo=None):
+    """Does an install actually receive this guide?
+
+    Manifest audience says who NEEDS it; `audience: author` says who can act on it, and
+    compose/assemble.py withholds the second from every packaged install. A reference whose
+    target is withheld is unresolvable for every installed reader no matter how universal its
+    tier looks, so audience coverage alone is the wrong question to ask about it."""
+    base = (repo or REPO) / "claude" / "guides" / name
+    try:
+        return not author_only(base)
+    except Exception:
+        return True   # unreadable frontmatter is check-package's call, not this one
+
+
 def covers(guide_aud, bullet_aud):
     if guide_aud == "UNIVERSAL":
         return True
@@ -83,6 +102,75 @@ def covers(guide_aud, bullet_aud):
     return isinstance(guide_aud, frozenset) and guide_aud >= bullet_aud
 
 
+def prose_handles(name):
+    """Prose forms of a guide name, DERIVED from the filename rather than declared.
+
+    Multi-token runs of the stem only — `coding-staged-workflow` yields "staged-workflow"
+    and "coding-staged", never the bare "workflow" or "coding", because a single generic
+    token matches unrelated sentences and a gate that cries wolf gets routed around. The
+    hyphen is what makes a run distinctive enough to mean the guide.
+
+    Derivation rather than declaration because declaring is a step someone forgets: two
+    prose references were already caught this way after their instances were patched, and
+    a third and fourth were found by the derivation itself. `handles` stays for a phrasing
+    that shares no token run with the filename."""
+    toks = name[:-3].split("-")
+    return sorted({"-".join(toks[i:j]) for i in range(len(toks))
+                   for j in range(i + 2, len(toks) + 1)}, key=len, reverse=True)
+
+
+# The words that make a prose mention a REFERENCE ("read the X guide/doc/..."). One list,
+# owned here because this file ships and gates/ may import shipped, never the reverse.
+# refs_from hard-coded "guide" while check-lexicon knew four words, so "read the
+# staged-workflow document" resolved for the author-side gate and not for this one — a
+# universal bullet could carry that pointer past rule 4 undetected.
+REFERRING_WORDS = ("guide", "guidance", "document", "doc")
+
+
+def referring_alternation():
+    """The regex alternation for referring words, plurals included — "read the concept
+    economy guideS" was a reference the singular-only pattern let through. One builder,
+    because two gates consume this and a plural added in one drifted from the other."""
+    return "|".join(w if w == "guidance" else w + "s?" for w in REFERRING_WORDS)
+
+
+def refs_from(text, guides):
+    """Which guides this text sends the reader to — by path, by declared handle, or by a
+    derived prose form. Stable order, so one guide named twice is judged once.
+
+    A derived run counts only when it identifies ONE guide — or is a guide's entire stem,
+    since naming the whole filename is not ambiguous even where it prefixes a sibling's.
+    Without that, "the llm-capability-boundary guide" marked the base AND both of its
+    children as consumed, so an unrelated mention of the parent kept an unreachable child
+    out of the orphan report."""
+    found = list(dict.fromkeys(re.findall(r"guides/([a-z0-9-]+\.md)", text)))
+    lowered = text.lower()
+
+    def loose(run):
+        # Prose renders filenames as plain words: a bullet saying "the concept economy
+        # guide" is a promise refs_from could not see while it required the hyphen, so a
+        # universal bullet could point at a domain guide undetected. Safe to relax here
+        # because this branch already requires the word "guide" after the run — a bare
+        # dehyphenated mention never reaches it.
+        return r"[-\s]+".join(re.escape(tok) for tok in run.split("-"))
+
+    owner = {}
+    for name in guides:
+        for r in prose_handles(name):
+            owner.setdefault(r, set()).add(name)
+    for name, entry in guides.items():
+        if name in found:
+            continue
+        stem = name[:-3]
+        runs = [h for h in prose_handles(name) if owner.get(h) == {name} or h == stem]
+        if any(re.search(rf"(?<![0-9A-Za-z_]){re.escape(h.lower())}(?![0-9A-Za-z_])",
+                         lowered) for h in entry.get("handles", [])) or \
+           any(re.search(rf"\b{loose(h)}\s+(?:{referring_alternation()})\b", lowered)
+               for h in runs):
+            found.append(name)
+    return found
+
+
 def run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=REPO):
     errors = []
     tiers = set(manifest.get("tiers", []))
@@ -154,18 +242,69 @@ def run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=REPO):
             errors.append(f"{key}: file {name} in {rel} not claimed by the manifest")
 
     # -- 4. router-guide co-package ----------------------------------------
+    # Path form AND declared prose handles. Naming a guide in prose is still a router — the
+    # reader is sent somewhere — and a path-only scan reports clean on it, so a rule can ship to
+    # an audience that cannot hold what it names. Prose is decidable once the mapping exists, so
+    # the mapping is DATA on the guide entry (`handles`) and the check stays structural. A
+    # handle is only as good as its declaration: this catches phrasings someone wrote down, not
+    # every paraphrase.
     guide_aud = {n: audience(e, errors, f"guides/{n}") for n, e in entries["guides"].items()}
+    # A declared handle is a NAME, and a name resolving to two guides routes the reader
+    # nowhere: refs_from() would credit both targets from one prose router, falsely
+    # rooting and co-packaging a guide the sentence never meant. Duplicates fail here
+    # so resolution below can trust that a declared handle has one owner.
+    hdl_owner = {}
+    for n, e in entries["guides"].items():
+        for h in e.get("handles", []):
+            # Indexed by the SAME normalized form resolution uses — refs_from
+            # lowercases before matching, so "Case Alias" and "case alias" are one
+            # name, and indexing raw text passed the pair as distinct.
+            hdl_owner.setdefault(h.lower(), []).append(n)
+    for h, owners in sorted(hdl_owner.items()):
+        if len(owners) > 1:
+            errors.append(f"guides: handle {h!r} is declared by {', '.join(sorted(owners))}"
+                          f" — one name, one target; make the handle unique")
+    # Declared×derived is the remaining collision pair (declared×declared above,
+    # derived×derived resolves to nobody inside refs_from): a handle like "concept
+    # economy guide" declared on another guide double-resolves with concept-economy.md's
+    # DERIVED form, one prose pointer rooting and co-packaging two targets. Normalized —
+    # lowercased, one trailing referring word stripped, spaces to hyphens — a declared
+    # handle may not carry a different guide's run or stem at a hyphen boundary.
+    ref_tail = re.compile(rf"[-\s]+(?:{referring_alternation()})$")
+    for n, e in entries["guides"].items():
+        for h in e.get("handles", []):
+            norm = re.sub(r"\s+", "-", ref_tail.sub("", h.lower()).strip())
+            for other in entries["guides"]:
+                if other == n:
+                    continue
+                runs = set(prose_handles(other)) | {other[:-3]}
+                if any(re.search(rf"(?:^|-){re.escape(r)}(?:-|$)", norm) for r in runs):
+                    errors.append(
+                        f"guides: handle {h!r} on {n} collides with {other}'s derived "
+                        f"name — one prose pointer would resolve both; reword the handle")
+                    break
     anchor_of = {id(e): e.get("anchor", "?") for e in mb}
     ref_checks = 0
+    undelivered = set()
     for entry in mb:
         hits = [b for b in bullets if entry.get("anchor", "\0") in b]
         if len(hits) != 1:
             continue  # already reported by bijection
         b_aud = audience(entry, errors, f"bullet {entry.get('anchor', '')!r:.40}")
-        for g in re.findall(r"guides/([a-z0-9-]+\.md)", hits[0]):
+        if b_aud == "NEVER":
+            # env-personal is never assembled (assemble.py maps the tier to NEVER),
+            # so this bullet's references reach no reader — remembered here so the
+            # orphan check below does not let it root a guide.
+            undelivered.add(hits[0])
+        for g in refs_from(hits[0], entries["guides"]):
             ref_checks += 1
             if g not in guide_aud:
                 errors.append(f"router: bullet {entry['anchor']!r:.40} references unclaimed guide {g}")
+            elif not delivered(g, repo):
+                errors.append(
+                    f"router: bullet {entry['anchor']!r:.40} references {g}, which declares "
+                    f"audience: author and is withheld from every install — no reader can open it"
+                )
             elif not covers(guide_aud[g], b_aud):
                 errors.append(
                     f"router: bullet {entry['anchor']!r:.40} (audience {b_aud}) references guide {g} "
@@ -174,6 +313,233 @@ def run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=REPO):
     if ref_checks == 0:
         errors.append("non-vacuity: no router->guide references were checked")
 
+    # The same relation, read the other way. Rule 4 asks whether the reader of a pointer has
+    # the guide; this asks whether a guide has a pointer at all. Without it a guide can be
+    # written, packaged, and delivered while nothing reaches it, and every other check is green.
+    #
+    # Three consumer kinds exist and each is a real delivery path, so none of them is an
+    # exemption: a corpus bullet (by path or declared handle), a parent guide citing a child
+    # as a depth chain, and a launch preset's mission. An exemption list would be the fourth,
+    # and it is the one that lets a genuinely orphaned guide through.
+    guide_dir = repo / "claude" / "guides"
+    launch = repo / "launch" / "agent-launch.toml"
+    launch_text, launch_missions = "", []
+    if launch.is_file():
+        # PARSED string values, not the raw file: a guide named in a TOML comment reaches
+        # no agent, but refs_from over raw text credited it as a consumer and an orphan
+        # slipped past. The parser drops comments and keys; what remains is exactly the
+        # text a mission can put in front of a model. A config that does not parse is a
+        # loud error — silently falling back to raw text would re-open the comment hole.
+        import tomllib
+        # Instruction-bearing fields ONLY — `mission` is what the launcher appends to the
+        # system prompt, so it is the one field whose text reaches a model. Walking every
+        # string value credited a guide named in an unused key as consumed, hiding an
+        # orphan; and classified-or-loud closes the other direction too: a guides/
+        # reference in any NON-instruction field fails outright, because text no agent
+        # reads is either a mistake or belongs in a mission.
+        def _fields(v, path=()):
+            if isinstance(v, str):
+                yield path, v
+            elif isinstance(v, dict):
+                for k, x in v.items():
+                    yield from _fields(x, path + (k,))
+            elif isinstance(v, list):
+                for x in v:
+                    yield from _fields(x, path)
+
+        def _is_mission(path):
+            # presets.*.mission ONLY — the launcher reads mission from presets alone
+            # (launch/agent-launch.py, load_config -> presets), so a `mission` key under
+            # any other table is inert text no model receives. Filtering by leaf key
+            # credited exactly such a value as a consumer.
+            return len(path) == 3 and path[0] == "presets" and path[2] == "mission"
+        try:
+            pairs = list(_fields(tomllib.loads(launch.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))))
+            launch_missions = [v for k, v in pairs if _is_mission(k)]
+            launch_text = "\n".join(launch_missions)
+            for k, v in pairs:
+                # Path form OR prose form — refs_from covers both (its path regex is
+                # this test's old one): a `mission` under the wrong table saying
+                # "read the concept economy guide first" is the same inert text as a
+                # guides/ path there, and the path-only test let the prose form
+                # masquerade as instructions no launcher delivers.
+                if not _is_mission(k) and refs_from(v, entries["guides"]):
+                    errors.append(
+                        f"launch: field {'.'.join(k)!r} names a guide but is not "
+                        f"instruction-bearing — no agent reads it there; move it into a "
+                        f"preset mission or drop it")
+        except tomllib.TOMLDecodeError as exc:
+            errors.append(f"launch: agent-launch.toml does not parse ({exc}) — mission "
+                          f"consumers cannot be judged")
+    # install.sh deploys the launch config regardless of domain selection, so a mission's
+    # DEPLOYED-form reference (a CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR / ~/.claude path) must resolve for every
+    # user: universal tier and delivered. A CHECKOUT-form reference (bare claude/guides/...,
+    # as the distill mission uses on purpose) names the author's repo; its guard is
+    # check-package's RUNTIME_GUARDED leg, not audience math — but it still counts as a
+    # consumer below, or the guide it points at reads as an orphan.
+    # Judged PER MISSION, never over the concatenated text: one preset's guarded
+    # checkout reference must not exempt another preset's prose reference to the same
+    # guide — collapsing by name did exactly that, and review reproduced it with both
+    # forms of concept-economy in one config.
+    launch_flagged = set()
+    for mtext in launch_missions:
+        # Occurrences are classified separately even inside ONE mission: refs_from
+        # collapses a checkout path and a prose pointer to the same guide, and the
+        # mission-wide checkout match exempted the prose — review reproduced both forms
+        # in a single mission. Stripping every path first leaves exactly the prose
+        # occurrences, so what still resolves afterwards was said in words.
+        pathless_m = re.sub(r"\S*guides/[a-z0-9-]+\.md\S*", "", mtext)
+        prose_refs = set(refs_from(pathless_m, entries["guides"]))
+        for lg in refs_from(mtext, entries["guides"]):
+            if lg in launch_flagged:
+                continue
+            # The EXEMPTION is the narrow case: a checkout-form path (bare
+            # claude/guides/..., the distill mission's deliberate shape, guarded by
+            # check-package's RUNTIME_GUARDED) names the author's repo. A deployed-home
+            # path or a PROSE occurrence reaches every selection, because presets deploy
+            # unconditionally.
+            checkout_form = re.search(
+                r"(?<![\w$}])claude/guides/" + re.escape(lg), mtext)
+            deployed_form = re.search(
+                r"(?:CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR|CODEX_HOME|\.claude|\.codex)[^\n\"']*guides/"
+                + re.escape(lg), mtext)
+            if (deployed_form or lg in prose_refs or not checkout_form) and (
+                    not delivered(lg, repo) or guide_aud.get(lg) != "UNIVERSAL"):
+                launch_flagged.add(lg)
+                errors.append(
+                    f"launch: a mission references {lg}, the launch config deploys to "
+                    f"every selection, and {lg} is "
+                    f"{'withheld (audience: author)' if not delivered(lg, repo) else 'domain-scoped'}"
+                    f" — a non-matching selection receives the mission without the guide")
+    def _defenced(text):
+        # Fenced code blocks are EXAMPLES: a fenced `guides/x.md` shows the reader what a
+        # reference looks like without sending anyone anywhere, and counting it as a
+        # consumer let a fenced sample conceal an orphan after its real router was
+        # removed. ALL Markdown fence forms — ``` and ~~~ at any length >= 3, closed by
+        # the same character at >= the opening length — because the first version knew
+        # only triple backticks and review moved the sample to ~~~. Inline code spans
+        # stay: real references are written as backticked deploy paths.
+        out, fence = [], None
+        prev_blank, last_nonblank, in_indent = True, "", False
+        for line in text.splitlines():
+            # Blockquote markers are containers, not content: `> ```` opens a fence as
+            # surely as ``` does, and the prefixed form escaped the opener match. The
+            # marker is normalized off for the whole pipeline — blockquoted PROSE still
+            # renders and its real references still count.
+            # A list marker is a container the same way when a blockquote rides it:
+            # `- > ```` renders as code inside a list-carried blockquote, and the
+            # leading marker hid the `>` from the normalization — the fence never
+            # opened and the quoted example read as prose. Stripped only when a
+            # blockquote follows; a plain list item is content, not a wrapper.
+            line = re.sub(r"^\s*(?:[-*+]|\d+\.)\s+(?=>)", "", line)
+            line = re.sub(r"^(\s*>)+ ?", "", line)
+            s = line.strip()
+            m = re.match(r"(`{3,}|~{3,})", s)
+            if fence is not None:
+                if m and m.group(1)[0] == fence[0] and len(m.group(1)) >= fence[1] \
+                        and not s[len(m.group(1)):].strip():
+                    # A CLOSING fence carries nothing but whitespace — ```python inside
+                    # an open block is a nested opener in real Markdown, and treating it
+                    # as the close exposed the rest of the example as prose.
+                    fence = None
+                continue
+            if m:
+                fence = (m.group(1)[0], len(m.group(1)))
+                continue
+            # Markdown's INDENTED code form: four spaces (or a tab) after a blank line
+            # opens a code block unless the preceding block is a list item, whose
+            # continuation lines are legitimately indented prose. The fenced repairs
+            # left this fourth example syntax crediting consumers.
+            # The code threshold is RELATIVE to the enclosing block: four columns past
+            # the text of a list item (whose continuations are legitimately indented
+            # prose), four from the margin otherwise. A blanket list exemption kept an
+            # eight-space sample nested under a list item as prose.
+            lm = re.match(r"(\s*(?:[-*+]|\d+\.)\s+)", last_nonblank.expandtabs(4))
+            base = len(lm.group(1)) if lm else 0
+            # Tabs expand to columns (CommonMark: a tab advances to the next 4-column
+            # stop); counting a tab as one character kept tab-indented code as prose.
+            exp = line.expandtabs(4)
+            ind = len(exp) - len(exp.lstrip())
+            indented = bool(s) and ind >= base + 4
+            if in_indent:
+                if (bool(s) and ind >= base + 4) or not s:
+                    continue
+                in_indent = False
+            elif indented and prev_blank:
+                in_indent = True
+                continue
+            if s:
+                last_nonblank = line
+            prev_blank = not s
+            out.append(line)
+        prose = "\n".join(out)
+        # HTML comments are stripped from RENDERED PROSE, after the fence pass: a literal
+        # <!-- inside a fenced sample is code, and subbing comments first let it swallow
+        # everything through EOF — including a real router after the fence, which then
+        # read as an orphan. Closed comments first, then an unterminated one through EOF
+        # (rendered Markdown hides the remainder either way).
+        prose = re.sub(r"<!--.*?-->", "", prose, flags=re.S)
+        return re.sub(r"<!--.*", "", prose, flags=re.S)
+
+    bodies = {p.name: _defenced(p.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
+              for p in sorted(guide_dir.glob("*.md"))}
+    if not bodies:
+        errors.append("non-vacuity: no guide bodies read, so consumers were not checked")
+    # Reachability is TRANSITIVE FROM ROOTS (bullets and launch missions), not "any
+    # incoming edge": two unrooted guides citing each other kept each other alive as an
+    # inert island — the same lesson the pre-commit reach scan learned about seeding.
+    # And a root must be DELIVERED: an undelivered (env-personal) bullet exists in the
+    # monolith but ships to nobody, and routing a guide's only pointer through one
+    # concealed the orphan behind a tier change.
+    reachable, frontier = set(), [
+        g for g in entries["guides"]
+        if any(g in refs_from(b, entries["guides"])
+               for b in bullets if b not in undelivered)
+        or g in refs_from(launch_text, entries["guides"])]
+    while frontier:
+        g = frontier.pop()
+        if g in reachable:
+            continue
+        reachable.add(g)
+        frontier.extend(n for n in refs_from(bodies.get(g, ""), entries["guides"])
+                        if n != g and n not in reachable)
+    for name in entries["guides"]:
+        if name not in reachable:
+            errors.append(
+                f"orphan: guide {name} is claimed by the manifest and delivered, but no bullet, "
+                f"no other guide, and no launch preset points at it — it is inert"
+            )
+
+    # A guide citing another guide is a router with the same failure mode, so it needs the
+    # same audience check. Miss it and an install can deliver the citing guide while withholding
+    # the cited one, which reads to the gate as two independently legal packages.
+    body_checks = 0
+    for name, body in bodies.items():
+        if name not in entries["guides"]:
+            continue                                # unclaimed file: rule 3 owns that
+        src_aud = audience(entries["guides"][name], errors, f"guides/{name}")
+        for cited in refs_from(body, entries["guides"]):
+            if cited == name:
+                continue
+            body_checks += 1
+            if delivered(name, repo) and not delivered(cited, repo):
+                errors.append(
+                    f"router: guide {name} is delivered but points at {cited}, which declares "
+                    f"audience: author and is withheld — the citation cannot resolve for a reader"
+                )
+            elif delivered(name, repo) and not covers(guide_aud.get(cited, "NEVER"), src_aud):
+                # Coverage is asked only of citations a packaged reader can follow. An
+                # audience:author guide never reaches an install, and a checkout has the whole
+                # tree regardless of domains — so its citation of a narrow-domain child is a
+                # gap for nobody, and failing it would force author docs to carry universal
+                # audiences they do not have.
+                errors.append(
+                    f"router: guide {name} (audience {src_aud}) points at {cited} "
+                    f"(audience {guide_aud.get(cited)}) — reader can hold {name} without it"
+                )
+    if body_checks == 0:
+        errors.append("non-vacuity: no guide->guide references were checked")
+
     # -- 5. hook source_guide -----------------------------------------------
     for name, entry in entries["hooks"].items():
         src = entry.get("source_guide")
@@ -219,7 +585,10 @@ def check_settings_template(manifest, repo=REPO):
     if not entries:
         errors.append("non-vacuity: settings template registers no hooks")
     for ev, cmd in entries:
-        if not any(("/hooks/" + n) in cmd for n in names):
+        # The assembler's matcher, not a substring: `.disabled` after the name satisfied
+        # `in` while merge_settings skipped the entry, so the gate blessed a template the
+        # install silently dropped. One matcher, imported, so they cannot drift apart.
+        if not any(hook_command_matches(cmd, n) for n in names):
             errors.append(f"settings: {ev} hook {cmd!r} names no manifest hook "
                           f"(known: {sorted(names)}) — it would never deploy")
     return errors
@@ -252,6 +621,173 @@ def self_test(manifest, bullets):
     m7["hooks"] = {"renamed-hook.py": {"tier": "core", "domains": []}}
     muts.append(("settings registers a hook the manifest does not declare", m7, bullets))
 
+    # A bullet that names a cross-domain guide in PROSE. This shipped for real: the reader
+    # held the rule and could not hold the guide, and a path-only scan reported clean. The
+    # control plants the handle rather than a path, so it fails only while handle detection
+    # is live — deleting `handles` or reverting refs_from() to the path regex brings it back.
+    handled = [(n, e) for n, e in manifest["guides"].items()
+               if e.get("handles") and e.get("tier") == "domain"]
+    if not handled:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: no guide declares `handles` — the prose-router control "
+                         "has no subject and would pass vacuously")
+    gname, gentry = handled[0]
+    victim = next(b for b in manifest["bullets"]
+                  if b.get("tier") == "domain"
+                  and not set(b.get("domains") or []) & set(gentry["domains"]))
+    hits = [b for b in bullets if victim["anchor"] in b]
+    assert len(hits) == 1, "self-test: prose-router control could not locate its bullet"
+    b8 = [b + f" (see the {gentry['handles'][0]})" if b is hits[0] else b for b in bullets]
+    muts.append((f"bullet names {gname} in prose across a domain boundary",
+                 copy.deepcopy(manifest), b8))
+    # The dehyphenated PLURAL of the same promise: "the concept economy guides" resolved
+    # to nothing while the singular was caught — the referring pattern must own plurals.
+    spoken8 = gname[:-3].replace("-", " ")
+    b8p = [b + f" — read the {spoken8} guides first" if b is hits[0] else b for b in bullets]
+    muts.append((f"bullet names {gname} as a dehyphenated PLURAL prose reference",
+                 copy.deepcopy(manifest), b8p))
+
+    # The orphan control removes a guide's ONLY pointer. It picks that guide by looking, not
+    # from a name typed here: a typed name stops being the right subject the moment that guide
+    # gains a second consumer, and the control would go quiet without saying so.
+    only_bullet = []
+    for name in manifest["guides"]:
+        cited = f"guides/{name}"
+        handles = manifest["guides"][name].get("handles", [])
+        refs = [b for b in bullets
+                if cited in b or any(h.lower() in b.lower() for h in handles)]
+        elsewhere = any(cited in (REPO / "claude" / "guides" / o).read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                        for o in manifest["guides"] if o != name)
+        if len(refs) == 1 and not elsewhere:
+            only_bullet.append((name, refs[0]))
+    if not only_bullet:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: no guide is reachable through exactly one bullet, so the "
+                         "orphan control has no subject and would pass vacuously")
+    o_name, o_line = only_bullet[0]
+    if len(only_bullet) < 2:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: fewer than two single-pointer guides, so the island "
+                         "control has no subject and would pass vacuously")
+    i_name, i_line = only_bullet[1]
+    # The manifest entry goes with the line. Dropping the line alone breaks the bijection in
+    # rule 2, which fails first — the control would then pass without the orphan check being
+    # consulted at all.
+    m_orphan = copy.deepcopy(manifest)
+    m_orphan["bullets"] = [e for e in m_orphan["bullets"] if e["anchor"] not in o_line]
+    if len(m_orphan["bullets"]) != len(manifest["bullets"]) - 1:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: the orphan control could not drop exactly one manifest "
+                         "entry with its bullet, so the mutation is not the one it claims")
+    muts.append((f"guide {o_name} left with no pointer at all",
+                 m_orphan, [b for b in bullets if b != o_line]))
+
+    # A bullet that exists but ships to NOBODY cannot root a guide: reclassify the
+    # orphan guide's only router bullet as env-personal (assemble maps the tier to
+    # NEVER) and the guide must be reported as an orphan. The monolith line survives,
+    # so the bijection stays intact and the orphan leg itself is the one judged —
+    # which is why this control requires the orphan error by name instead of joining
+    # the generic any-error mutation list.
+    m_never = copy.deepcopy(manifest)
+    tgt = [e for e in m_never["bullets"] if e["anchor"] in o_line]
+    if len(tgt) != 1:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: the never-delivered control could not target exactly "
+                         "one manifest entry, so the mutation is not the one it claims")
+    tgt[0]["tier"] = "env-personal"
+    tgt[0].pop("domains", None)
+    errs_nv, _ = run_gate(m_never, bullets)
+    never_ok = any(o_name in e and "orphan" in e for e in errs_nv)
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if never_ok else 'MISSED'}] an env-personal (never-"
+          f"delivered) router bullet leaves {o_name} an orphan")
+
+    # One handle, one guide: copying a declared handle onto a second guide must fail as
+    # a duplicate declaration, not silently resolve one prose router to both targets.
+    m_dup = copy.deepcopy(manifest)
+    donor = next((n for n in m_dup["guides"] if m_dup["guides"][n].get("handles")), None)
+    if donor is None:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: no guide declares a handle, so the duplicate-handle "
+                         "control has no subject and would pass vacuously")
+    other = next(n for n in m_dup["guides"] if n != donor)
+    m_dup["guides"][other].setdefault("handles", []).append(
+        m_dup["guides"][donor]["handles"][0])
+    errs_dup, _ = run_gate(m_dup, bullets)
+    dup_ok = any("handle" in e and "declared by" in e for e in errs_dup)
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if dup_ok else 'MISSED'}] a handle declared by two "
+          f"guides fails as a duplicate declaration")
+
+    # Case is not identity: resolution lowercases, so the uniqueness index must too —
+    # a case variant of a declared handle is the same name and must fail the same way.
+    m_case = copy.deepcopy(manifest)
+    variant = m_case["guides"][donor]["handles"][0].upper()
+    if variant == m_case["guides"][donor]["handles"][0]:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: the case-variant control is vacuous — the donor "
+                         "handle has no case to vary")
+    other2 = next(n for n in m_case["guides"] if n != donor)
+    m_case["guides"][other2].setdefault("handles", []).append(variant)
+    errs_case, _ = run_gate(m_case, bullets)
+    case_ok = any("handle" in e and "declared by" in e for e in errs_case)
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if case_ok else 'MISSED'}] a case-variant duplicate "
+          f"handle fails as the same name")
+
+    # Declared×derived: a handle spelling ANOTHER guide's spoken name (plus a referring
+    # word) must fail as a collision — refs_from would resolve both targets from one
+    # prose pointer, the declared branch for the handle's owner and the derived branch
+    # for the guide the words actually name.
+    m_xd = copy.deepcopy(manifest)
+    target_g = next((n for n in m_xd["guides"] if "-" in n[:-3]), None)
+    if target_g is None:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: no guide has a hyphenated stem, so the declared× "
+                         "derived collision control has no subject and would pass vacuously")
+    victim_g = next(n for n in m_xd["guides"] if n != target_g)
+    m_xd["guides"][victim_g].setdefault("handles", []).append(
+        target_g[:-3].replace("-", " ") + " guide")
+    errs_xd, _ = run_gate(m_xd, bullets)
+    xd_ok = any("collides with" in e and target_g in e for e in errs_xd)
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if xd_ok else 'MISSED'}] a declared handle spelling "
+          f"another guide's derived name fails as a collision")
+
+    # Guide-to-guide audience. The mutation is a manifest narrowing, not a corpus edit, so it
+    # cannot trip the bijection the way the orphan control first did: take a guide that some
+    # OTHER guide cites and shrink its domain set to one the citing guide does not hold.
+    # The cited guide must be one NO bullet points at — a depth-chain child. Pick one a bullet
+    # also names and the forward leg fails on the same mutation, so the control would pass
+    # without this leg being consulted.
+    citers = []
+    for name in manifest["guides"]:
+        body = (REPO / "claude" / "guides" / name).read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+        for cited in re.findall(r"guides/([a-z0-9-]+\.md)", body):
+            if cited == name or cited not in manifest["guides"]:
+                continue
+            handles = manifest["guides"][cited].get("handles", [])
+            if any(f"guides/{cited}" in b or any(h.lower() in b.lower() for h in handles)
+                   for b in bullets):
+                continue                       # a bullet names it too; forward leg would fire
+            citers.append((name, cited))
+    if not citers:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: no guide cites another that no bullet names, so the "
+                         "guide->guide control cannot be isolated from the forward leg")
+    c_from, c_to = citers[0]
+    m_cross = copy.deepcopy(manifest)
+    m_cross["guides"][c_to] = {"tier": "domain", "domains": ["office-work"]}
+    muts.append((f"guide {c_from} cites {c_to} after {c_to} moves to a domain it does not hold",
+                 m_cross, bullets))
+
+    # Targeted: the settings leg must use the assembler's TOKEN rule, not a substring.
+    # `.disabled` appended after the hook name is the reviewer-verified shape: substring
+    # said deployed, merge_settings skipped it, the install carried no hook. Planted in a
+    # copy because the leg reads the template from disk.
+    import shutil as _sh, tempfile as _tf, json as _json
+    with _tf.TemporaryDirectory() as _td:
+        tmpl_tmp = pathlib.Path(_td)
+        _sh.copytree(REPO / "claude", tmpl_tmp / "claude")
+        sp = tmpl_tmp / "claude" / "settings.template.json"
+        data = _json.loads(sp.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
+        for evs in data.get("hooks", {}).values():
+            for en in evs:
+                for h in en.get("hooks", []):
+                    h["command"] = h.get("command", "") + ".disabled"
+        sp.write_text(_json.dumps(data), encoding="utf-8")
+        dis_errs = [e for e in check_settings_template(manifest, tmpl_tmp)
+                    if e.startswith("settings:")]
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if dis_errs else 'MISSED'}] a '.disabled'-suffixed hook "
+          f"command fails the settings leg instead of passing as a substring")
+
     # Targeted: the settings rule itself must speak, not just some neighbouring
     # check tripping on the same mutation.
     import copy as _c
@@ -260,7 +796,347 @@ def self_test(manifest, bullets):
     settings_errs = [e for e in check_settings_template(m_off) if e.startswith("settings:")]
     print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if settings_errs else 'MISSED'}] settings rule fires on its own")
 
+    # Targeted: an ambiguous derived run must resolve to nothing, and a full stem to exactly
+    # its own guide. Without the restriction, "the llm-capability-boundary guide" marked the
+    # base and both children consumed, so an unrelated mention of a parent could keep an
+    # unreachable child out of the orphan report.
+    owner_st = {}
+    for n in manifest["guides"]:
+        for r in prose_handles(n):
+            owner_st.setdefault(r, set()).add(n)
+    shared = next((r for r, o in sorted(owner_st.items())
+                   if len(o) > 1 and all(r != g[:-3] for g in o)), None)
+    if shared is None:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: no derived run is shared between guides, so the "
+                         "ambiguity control has no subject and would pass vacuously")
+    amb = refs_from(f"see the {shared} guide", manifest["guides"])
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if not amb else 'MISSED'}] shared run {shared!r} "
+          f"resolves to no guide (got {amb})")
+    stem_owner = next((g for r, o in owner_st.items() if len(o) > 1
+                       for g in o if r == g[:-3]), None)
+    stem_ok = True
+    if stem_owner is not None:
+        got = refs_from(f"see the {stem_owner[:-3]} guide", manifest["guides"])
+        stem_ok = got == [stem_owner]
+        print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if stem_ok else 'MISSED'}] full stem resolves to "
+              f"{stem_owner} alone (got {got})")
+
+    # Targeted: a withheld guide's citation of a narrower child is a gap for nobody — the
+    # packaged reader never holds the citing guide, and a checkout has the whole tree. The
+    # firing side of this leg is the m_cross mutation above; this is the exemption side,
+    # planted in a throwaway copy because the leg reads bodies from disk.
+    import shutil, tempfile
+    withheld = next((n for n in manifest["guides"] if not delivered(n)), None)
+    narrow = next((n for n, e in manifest["guides"].items() if e.get("tier") == "domain"), None)
+    if withheld is None or narrow is None:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: no withheld guide or no domain guide, so the "
+                         "author-citation exemption has no subject and would pass vacuously")
+    with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as td:
+        tmp2 = pathlib.Path(td)
+        for sub in ("claude", "ko", "launch"):
+            if (REPO / sub).is_dir():
+                shutil.copytree(REPO / sub, tmp2 / sub)
+        gf = tmp2 / "claude" / "guides" / withheld
+        gf.write_text(gf.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                      + f"\n\nSee `guides/{narrow}` for the workflow.\n", encoding="utf-8")
+        errs2, _ = run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=tmp2)
+        false_hits = [e for e in errs2 if withheld in e and narrow in e]
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if not false_hits else 'MISSED'}] withheld {withheld} citing "
+          f"{narrow} is exempt from audience coverage")
+
+    # Launch missions: a deployed-form reference to a non-universal or withheld guide must
+    # fail; the real checkout-form reference must stay clean (it is the distill mission's
+    # deliberate shape, guarded by check-package instead).
+    with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as td:
+        tmp3 = pathlib.Path(td)
+        for sub in ("claude", "ko", "launch"):
+            if (REPO / sub).is_dir():
+                shutil.copytree(REPO / sub, tmp3 / sub)
+        lt = tmp3 / "launch" / "agent-launch.toml"
+        lt.write_text(lt.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                      + f'\n[presets.zz-probe]\nmission = "read '
+                        f'${{CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR:-$HOME/.claude}}/guides/{narrow} first"\n',
+                      encoding="utf-8")
+        errs3, _ = run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=tmp3)
+        launch_hits = [e for e in errs3 if e.startswith("launch:") and narrow in e]
+        # The same plant in Codex-home form: the config drives both hosts, and the regex
+        # knowing only Claude homes was review's next find.
+        lt.write_text(lt.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                      + f'\n[presets.zz-probe-cx]\nmission = "read '
+                        f'${{CODEX_HOME}}/guides/{narrow} first"\n',
+                      encoding="utf-8")
+        errs3c, _ = run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=tmp3)
+        launch_hits_cx = [e for e in errs3c if e.startswith("launch:") and narrow in e]
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if launch_hits else 'MISSED'}] a deployed-form mission "
+          f"reference to domain-scoped {narrow} fails the launch leg")
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if launch_hits_cx else 'MISSED'}] the CODEX_HOME form "
+          f"of the same reference fails too")
+
+    # A TOML comment naming a guide reaches no agent: planting the orphaned guide's ONLY
+    # pointer as a comment must leave the orphan error standing.
+    with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as td:
+        tmp4 = pathlib.Path(td)
+        for sub in ("claude", "ko", "launch"):
+            if (REPO / sub).is_dir():
+                shutil.copytree(REPO / sub, tmp4 / sub)
+        lt4 = tmp4 / "launch" / "agent-launch.toml"
+        lt4.write_text(lt4.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                       + f'\n# a comment mentioning guides/{o_name} reaches nobody\n',
+                       encoding="utf-8")
+        errs4, _ = run_gate(m_orphan, [b for b in bullets if b != o_line], repo=tmp4)
+        still_orphan = any(o_name in e for e in errs4)
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if still_orphan else 'MISSED'}] a TOML comment naming "
+          f"{o_name} does not resurrect it as consumed")
+
+    # A fenced code sample in another guide is an example, not a router: with the real
+    # pointer dropped, the sample alone must leave the orphan error standing.
+    with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as td:
+        tmp7 = pathlib.Path(td)
+        for sub in ("claude", "ko", "launch"):
+            if (REPO / sub).is_dir():
+                shutil.copytree(REPO / sub, tmp7 / sub)
+        host7 = next(n for n in manifest["guides"] if n != o_name)
+        g7 = tmp7 / "claude" / "guides" / host7
+        fenced_orphan = True
+        for fence_open, fence_close, label in (
+                ("```", "```", "triple backtick"),
+                ("~~~", "~~~", "tilde"),
+                ("````", "````", "four backtick"),
+                ("```", "```python\nstill inside\n```", "info-string non-close"),
+                ("<!--", "-->", "HTML comment"),
+                ("<!--", "", "unclosed HTML comment"),
+                ("", "", "four-space indented"),
+                ("", "", "list-nested indented"),
+                ("", "", "tab indented"),
+                ("> ```", "> ```", "blockquoted fence"),
+                ("- > ```", "  > ```", "list-blockquoted fence")):
+            base7 = g7.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+            if label == "four-space indented":
+                sample7 = f"\n\n    read guides/{o_name} for the flow\n"
+            elif label == "list-nested indented":
+                sample7 = (f"\n\n- a list item\n\n"
+                           f"        read guides/{o_name} for the flow\n")
+            elif label == "tab indented":
+                sample7 = f"\n\n\tread guides/{o_name} for the flow\n"
+            elif label == "blockquoted fence":
+                sample7 = (f"\n\n> ```\n> read guides/{o_name} for the flow\n> ```\n")
+            elif label == "list-blockquoted fence":
+                sample7 = (f"\n\n- > ```\n  > read guides/{o_name} for the "
+                           f"flow\n  > ```\n")
+            else:
+                sample7 = (f"\n\n{fence_open}\nread guides/{o_name} for the "
+                           f"flow\n{fence_close}\n")
+            g7.write_text(base7 + sample7, encoding="utf-8")
+            errs7, _ = run_gate(m_orphan, [b for b in bullets if b != o_line], repo=tmp7)
+            ok7 = any(o_name in e for e in errs7)
+            fenced_orphan = fenced_orphan and ok7
+            print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if ok7 else 'MISSED'}] a {label} fenced sample "
+                  f"naming {o_name} does not resurrect it as consumed")
+            g7.write_text(base7, encoding="utf-8")
+
+        # Two unrooted guides citing each other must BOTH stay orphans: reciprocal
+        # references are edges, not roots.
+        m_isl = copy.deepcopy(manifest)
+        m_isl["bullets"] = [e for e in m_isl["bullets"]
+                            if e["anchor"] not in o_line and e["anchor"] not in i_line]
+        b_isl = [b for b in bullets if b not in (o_line, i_line)]
+        ga = tmp7 / "claude" / "guides" / o_name
+        gb = tmp7 / "claude" / "guides" / i_name
+        base_a, base_b = ga.read_text(encoding="utf-8"), gb.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+        ga.write_text(base_a + f"\n\nSee `guides/{i_name}` too.\n", encoding="utf-8")
+        gb.write_text(base_b + f"\n\nSee `guides/{o_name}` too.\n", encoding="utf-8")
+        errs_isl, _ = run_gate(m_isl, b_isl, repo=tmp7)
+        island_ok = (any(o_name in e and "orphan" in e for e in errs_isl)
+                     and any(i_name in e and "orphan" in e for e in errs_isl))
+        print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if island_ok else 'MISSED'}] a reciprocal island "
+              f"({o_name} <-> {i_name}) is still orphaned — edges are not roots")
+        ga.write_text(base_a, encoding="utf-8")
+        gb.write_text(base_b, encoding="utf-8")
+
+        # The other direction: a REAL router placed after a fence whose sample contains
+        # a literal <!-- must still count — comments-before-fences deleted it through
+        # EOF and reported a false orphan.
+        g7.write_text(base7 + f"\n\n```\n<!-- a literal in an example\n```\n\n"
+                      f"See `guides/{o_name}` for the flow.\n", encoding="utf-8")
+        errs7b, _ = run_gate(m_orphan, [b for b in bullets if b != o_line], repo=tmp7)
+        post_fence_ok = not any(o_name in e for e in errs7b)
+        print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if post_fence_ok else 'MISSED'}] a real router after "
+              f"a fence containing a literal <!-- still counts as a consumer")
+
+        # And blockquoted prose riding a list marker still RENDERS: stripping the
+        # combined container must not delete a real router written as `- > see ...`.
+        g7.write_text(base7 + f"\n\n- > See `guides/{o_name}` for the flow.\n",
+                      encoding="utf-8")
+        errs7c, _ = run_gate(m_orphan, [b for b in bullets if b != o_line], repo=tmp7)
+        listquote_prose_ok = not any(o_name in e for e in errs7c)
+        print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if listquote_prose_ok else 'MISSED'}] a real router "
+              f"in list-blockquoted prose still counts as a consumer")
+        g7.write_text(base7, encoding="utf-8")
+
+    # A guides/ reference in a non-instruction field must fail loudly, not quietly count.
+    with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as td:
+        tmp5 = pathlib.Path(td)
+        for sub in ("claude", "ko", "launch"):
+            if (REPO / sub).is_dir():
+                shutil.copytree(REPO / sub, tmp5 / sub)
+        lt5 = tmp5 / "launch" / "agent-launch.toml"
+        lt5.write_text(lt5.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                       + f'\nzz_inert = "see guides/{narrow} for details"\n',
+                       encoding="utf-8")
+        # And the reviewer's sharper shape: a `mission` key OUTSIDE presets is equally
+        # inert — the leaf name does not make it instruction-bearing.
+        lt5.write_text(lt5.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                       + f'\n[capabilities.zz-cap]\nmission = "read guides/{narrow}"\n',
+                       encoding="utf-8")
+        # And the PROSE form of that shape: an inert field needs no guides/ path to
+        # send the reader somewhere — the spoken name is the same masquerade.
+        spoken5 = narrow[:-3].replace("-", " ")
+        lt5.write_text(lt5.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                       + f'\n[capabilities.zz-cap2]\nmission = "Read the {spoken5} guide '
+                       f'first."\n',
+                       encoding="utf-8")
+        errs5, _ = run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=tmp5)
+        inert_hits = [e for e in errs5 if "not instruction-bearing" in e]
+        cap_hits = [e for e in errs5 if "capabilities.zz-cap.mission" in e]
+        cap2_hits = [e for e in errs5 if "capabilities.zz-cap2.mission" in e]
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if inert_hits else 'MISSED'}] a guide named in a "
+          f"non-instruction TOML field fails loudly")
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if cap_hits else 'MISSED'}] a mission key outside "
+          f"presets is inert and fails loudly too")
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if cap2_hits else 'MISSED'}] a PROSE reference in an "
+          f"inert field fails loudly without a path form")
+
+    # PROSE form of the same promise: "Read the <spoken> guide" in a mission must fail
+    # for a domain guide exactly as the deployed path does — form must not be a bypass.
+    with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as td:
+        tmp6 = pathlib.Path(td)
+        for sub in ("claude", "ko", "launch"):
+            if (REPO / sub).is_dir():
+                shutil.copytree(REPO / sub, tmp6 / sub)
+        lt6 = tmp6 / "launch" / "agent-launch.toml"
+        spoken6 = narrow[:-3].replace("-", " ")
+        lt6.write_text(lt6.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                       + f'\n[presets.zz-prose]\nmission = "Read the {spoken6} guide first."\n',
+                       encoding="utf-8")
+        errs6, _ = run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=tmp6)
+        prose_hits = [e for e in errs6 if e.startswith("launch:") and narrow in e]
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if prose_hits else 'MISSED'}] a PROSE mission reference "
+          f"to domain-scoped {narrow} fails without needing a path form")
+
+    # One preset's guarded checkout reference must not launder another preset's prose
+    # reference to the same guide.
+    with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as td:
+        tmp8 = pathlib.Path(td)
+        for sub in ("claude", "ko", "launch"):
+            if (REPO / sub).is_dir():
+                shutil.copytree(REPO / sub, tmp8 / sub)
+        lt8 = tmp8 / "launch" / "agent-launch.toml"
+        spoken8b = narrow[:-3].replace("-", " ")
+        lt8.write_text(lt8.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                       + f'\n[presets.zz-ck]\nmission = "read claude/guides/{narrow} in '
+                         f'the agent-bios checkout"\n'
+                         f'[presets.zz-pr]\nmission = "Read the {spoken8b} guide first."\n',
+                       encoding="utf-8")
+        errs8, _ = run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=tmp8)
+        mixed_hits = [e for e in errs8 if e.startswith("launch:") and narrow in e]
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if mixed_hits else 'MISSED'}] a checkout reference in one "
+          f"preset does not exempt a prose reference in another")
+
+    # Both forms in ONE mission: the checkout path must not exempt the prose pointer
+    # standing beside it.
+    with tempfile.TemporaryDirectory() as td:
+        tmp9 = pathlib.Path(td)
+        for sub in ("claude", "ko", "launch"):
+            if (REPO / sub).is_dir():
+                shutil.copytree(REPO / sub, tmp9 / sub)
+        lt9 = tmp9 / "launch" / "agent-launch.toml"
+        spoken9 = narrow[:-3].replace("-", " ")
+        lt9.write_text(lt9.read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+                       + f'\n[presets.zz-both]\nmission = "read claude/guides/{narrow} in '
+                         f'the agent-bios checkout, or just read the {spoken9} guide."\n',
+                       encoding="utf-8")
+        errs9, _ = run_gate(manifest, bullets, repo=tmp9)
+        same_hits = [e for e in errs9 if e.startswith("launch:") and narrow in e]
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if same_hits else 'MISSED'}] a checkout path does not "
+          f"exempt a prose pointer in the SAME mission")
+
+    # Targeted: the consumer legs resolve handles, not only paths. All three call refs_from,
+    # so proving the resolver sees a handle-only mention proves the legs do. Without it a child
+    # cited only in prose reads as inert while rule 4 validates that same reference.
+    handled = next((n for n, e in manifest["guides"].items() if e.get("handles")), None)
+    if handled is None:
+        raise SystemExit("self-test: no guide declares handles, so the handle-resolution "
+                         "assertion has no subject and would pass vacuously")
+    probe = f"see the {manifest['guides'][handled]['handles'][0]} for the rest"
+    handle_ok = handled in refs_from(probe, manifest["guides"])
+    # A handle must match as a complete phrase: "multi-model guidelines" contains the
+    # handle "multi-model guide" and is ordinary prose, not a router.
+    hprefix = f"note the {manifest['guides'][handled]['handles'][0]}lines here"
+    handle_bounded = handled not in refs_from(hprefix, manifest["guides"])
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if handle_bounded else 'MISSED'}] a handle embedded in a "
+          f"longer word does not resolve")
+    dehy = next((n for n in manifest["guides"] if "-" in n[:-3]
+                 and prose_handles(n) and n[:-3] in
+                 [r for r in prose_handles(n)]), None)
+    dehy_ok = True
+    if dehy is not None:
+        spoken = dehy[:-3].replace("-", " ")
+        dehy_ok = (dehy in refs_from(f"read the {spoken} guide", manifest["guides"])
+                   and dehy in refs_from(f"read the {spoken} document", manifest["guides"]))
+        print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if dehy_ok else 'MISSED'}] a dehyphenated reference "
+              f"('the {spoken} guide') resolves to {dehy}")
+    print(f"self-test [{'CAUGHT' if handle_ok else 'MISSED'}] a handle-only reference "
+          f"resolves to {handled}")
+
     failed = [] if settings_errs else ["settings rule fires on its own"]
+    if amb:
+        failed.append("shared run resolves to no guide")
+    if not stem_ok:
+        failed.append("full stem resolves uniquely")
+    if false_hits:
+        failed.append("withheld-guide citation exempt from coverage")
+    if not dehy_ok:
+        failed.append("dehyphenated reference resolves")
+    if not dis_errs:
+        failed.append("disabled-suffixed hook command fails the settings leg")
+    if not launch_hits:
+        failed.append("deployed-form launch reference to a domain guide fails")
+    if not launch_hits_cx:
+        failed.append("CODEX_HOME-form launch reference fails")
+    if not still_orphan:
+        failed.append("comment mention does not count as a consumer")
+    if not fenced_orphan:
+        failed.append("fenced sample does not count as a consumer")
+    if not post_fence_ok:
+        failed.append("real router after a <!--bearing fence still counts")
+    if not listquote_prose_ok:
+        failed.append("real router in list-blockquoted prose still counts")
+    if not never_ok:
+        failed.append("never-delivered bullet does not root a guide")
+    if not island_ok:
+        failed.append("reciprocal island stays orphaned")
+    if not inert_hits:
+        failed.append("non-instruction field naming a guide fails loudly")
+    if not cap_hits:
+        failed.append("mission outside presets is inert")
+    if not cap2_hits:
+        failed.append("prose reference in an inert field fails loudly")
+    if not dup_ok:
+        failed.append("duplicate declared handle fails as a duplicate declaration")
+    if not xd_ok:
+        failed.append("declared handle colliding with a derived name fails")
+    if not case_ok:
+        failed.append("case-variant duplicate handle fails as the same name")
+    if not prose_hits:
+        failed.append("prose mission reference validated like a path")
+    if not mixed_hits:
+        failed.append("checkout occurrence does not launder a prose occurrence")
+    if not same_hits:
+        failed.append("checkout path does not exempt prose in the same mission")
+    if not handle_ok:
+        failed.append("handle-only reference resolves")
+    if not handle_bounded:
+        failed.append("handle embedded in a longer word must not resolve")
     for name, mm, bb in muts:
         errs, _ = run_gate(mm, bb)
         if not errs:
@@ -294,7 +1170,7 @@ def main():
     if errors:
         print(f"DOMAINS GATE FAIL: {len(errors)} violation(s)")
         return 1
-    print(f"DOMAINS GATE OK: {len(bullets)} bullets bijective, all files claimed, routers co-packaged")
+    print(f"DOMAINS GATE OK: {len(bullets)} bullets bijective, all files claimed, routers co-packaged and delivered, no orphan guides")
     return 0