@zat-design/sisyphus-scene 4.6.3-beta.2 → 4.6.3

package/mcp/sisyphus-react.json

@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
       "command": "npx",
       "args": [
         "-y",
-        "@zat-design/sisyphus-react-mcp@4.6.3-beta.2"
+        "@zat-design/sisyphus-react-mcp@4.6.3"
       ]
     }
   }

package/package.json

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 {
   "name": "@zat-design/sisyphus-scene",
-  "version": "4.6.3-beta.2",
+  "version": "4.6.3",
   "description": "Sisyphus 业务场景 Agent 技能，跨 Claude Code、Codex、Cursor 分发 Sisyphus 4 + Ant Design 6 场景与 MCP 配置",
   "type": "module",
   "license": "MIT",

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/SKILL.md

@@ -1,11 +1,28 @@
 ---
 name: sisyphus-scene
-description: 基于与 Scene Agent 完全同版的 @zat-design/sisyphus-react 4.x 和 Ant Design 6，从页面截图或需求描述识别保险业务场景并生成 React/TypeScript 脚手架。用于查询列表、Tab 分组列表、列表弹窗、多 Tab 详情、分区详情、列表跳转详情、步骤条分区表单、参考其他应用实现，以及无法命中既有模板时基于 MCP demo 组合新场景；支持 Claude Code、Codex、Cursor，不绑定 Umi Max。
+description: 基于与 Scene Agent 完全同版的 @zat-design/sisyphus-react 4.x 和 Ant Design 6，从页面截图或需求描述识别保险业务场景并生成 React/TypeScript 脚手架，或按用户指定文件/目录路径执行内置 Sisyphus CR 只读规范审查。用于查询列表、Tab 分组列表、列表弹窗、多 Tab 详情、分区详情、列表跳转详情、步骤条分区表单、参考其他应用实现、组合新场景和路径代码审查；支持 Claude Code、Codex、Cursor，不绑定 Umi Max。
 ---
 
 # Sisyphus 业务场景生成
 
-为保险核心系统生成可验证的页面骨架。场景模板只决定结构，组件 MCP 决定真实 API。禁止凭记忆、旧模板或 `node_modules` 推断 Sisyphus 用法。
+为保险核心系统生成可验证的页面骨架，或对指定路径执行只读 Sisyphus 规范审查。场景模板只决定结构，组件 MCP 决定真实 API；路径审查使用内置 `sisyphus-cr@1.5.0` 规则，不依赖外部 CR 技能。
+
+## 意图路由
+
+在项目探测、SceneSpec、MCP 查询和任何写入前先确定模式：
+
+- 用户明确使用“审查”“代码审查”“规范检查”或 `review`，并提供可解析的文件或目录路径时，进入 `path-review`。
+- 路径可为绝对路径、相对当前工作目录的路径或反引号包裹路径。先解析为绝对路径并验证存在、可读；缺失或无法解析时输出 CR 三段式“无法判断”，不猜测目标。
+- “参考某路径生成页面”“按某目录现有实现改造”等生成意图没有明确审查动词时，保持 `generation-gate`。
+- “审查并修复 <path>”仍进入 `path-review`，遵守只读边界，只交付问题清单和修复计划，不修改代码。
+
+### path-review
+
+读取 `references/review-guard.md` 和 `references/review-standard.md`，发现最近项目规则、依赖、TypeScript/Sisyphus 证据和必要直接调用链，再创建独立只读子代理审查目标。文件只审查自身；目录递归审查并忽略生成、依赖和缓存目录。该模式不建立 `SceneSpec`、不查询 Sisyphus 或 Ant Design MCP、不生成代码、不进入自动修复。最终只输出“规范审查 / 问题清单 / 修复计划”。
+
+### generation-gate
+
+其他 Scene 请求继续执行以下 PC 基线和生成工作流。
 
 ## PC 系统交互基线
 
@@ -23,9 +40,10 @@ description: 基于与 Scene Agent 完全同版的 @zat-design/sisyphus-react 4.
 - 仅支持 React + TypeScript、`assets/ai-contract.json` 声明的 Sisyphus 完全同版组合和 Ant Design 6。
 - 所有生成的 `.ts`、`.tsx` 运行时函数必须使用箭头函数，包括组件、事件处理、配置工厂、service 和回调。禁止函数声明/表达式、对象或类方法、getter、setter 和 constructor；目标项目已有非箭头写法也不得覆盖此规则。
 - Umi Max、React Router、请求库、权限和状态库都属于目标项目适配，不是技能依赖。
-- 无论场景是否命中模板，先查询 Sisyphus MCP 的组件列表、完整 API 和 demo。
+- `generation-gate` 无论场景是否命中模板，先查询 Sisyphus MCP 的组件列表、完整 API 和 demo。
 - 只有 Sisyphus MCP 明确给出 `missing` 的能力才可进入 Ant Design 补全；`unverified` 必须先修复 MCP 连接或版本问题。
 - Sisyphus、Ant Design 和项目公共组件都无法覆盖时停止生成，显式报告缺口。
+- 确定性脚手架校验通过后，必须按 `references/review-guard.md` 创建独立只读规范门卫子代理；平台无法创建子代理时阻断，不得降级为主 Agent 自审。
 - 不自动升级依赖、不修改全局布局、不创建新的基础组件库、不把临时场景自动写回本技能。
 - 不声称“100% 合规”；只汇报实际证据和验证结果。
 
@@ -33,12 +51,14 @@ description: 基于与 Scene Agent 完全同版的 @zat-design/sisyphus-react 4.
 
 | 阶段       | 核心动作                              | 停止条件                              |
 | ---------- | ------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------- |
+| 意图路由   | 区分路径审查与场景生成                | 审查意图没有可解析路径                |
 | 项目探测   | 读平台规则、依赖和相邻实现            | 规则冲突且无法确定优先级              |
 | 版本门禁   | 校验本地依赖、MCP 元数据和 Scene 契约 | 版本、schema、哈希或 MCP 连接不可验证 |
 | 场景建模   | 从截图/需求建立 `SceneSpec`           | 缺少会改变页面结构的关键决策          |
 | MCP 取证   | 查组件、API、类型和单个 demo          | 任一必需能力为 `unverified`           |
 | 缺口决策   | 为每项需求生成 `ComponentDecision`    | 组件体系无法覆盖必需能力              |
-| 生成与验收 | 生成最小文件集并运行项目检查          | 存在未处理的校验或影响风险            |
+| 生成与门禁 | 生成、脚手架校验、CR 门卫与自动修复   | 两轮后仍有任意问题或无法判断          |
+| 项目验收   | typecheck、测试、页面和影响检查        | 存在未处理的验证或影响风险            |
 
 ## 执行工作流
 
@@ -152,12 +172,14 @@ node scripts/resolve-versions.mjs --root <项目根目录>
 - 只有确认项目使用 React Router 时才生成对应 import。
 - 无法确认导航实现时注入 `onView`、`onEdit`、`onBack` 等回调。
 - 写代码前先按 `fileStructureAdapter.conventions` 输出“职责 → 文件路径”映射；配置、组件、services、models、assets、utils、hooks 和类型文件必须落到项目指定位置，禁止把有明确目录归属的文件平铺到页面根目录。
+- 枚举页面或组件根目录的非入口源码；纯函数工具、DTO/payload 转换、解析、克隆、布局和历史计算进入 `utils/`，类型、配置/注册表、请求、组件和 Context 分别进入责任层。React 组件、状态 Hook、请求和明确的协议/基础设施模块不机械移入 `utils/`。
+- Sisyphus columns 字段监听使用 `fieldProps.onFieldChange`；简单必填只配置 `required: true`；已有 `label` 时不重复生成默认 placeholder。直接控件 `onChange`、复杂 `rules` 和特殊业务 placeholder 保持其合理用法。
 - 页面内子组件按项目证据使用独立目录、样式文件和 `components/index.ts` barrel；类型文件严格使用 `typeConvention`，不得自行改名为 `types.ts`。
 - 请求、权限、状态和类型文件遵循目标项目证据。若 `requestAdapter` 声明全局错误拦截，不重复添加请求 `try/catch` 或 `res.status === 200` 判断。
 - 把所有适用规则中的 MUST/禁止项转换为逐文件自检清单；组件内部顺序、Hooks、导出方式、命名和样式规则没有自动校验时也必须人工核对并如实报告。
 - 无需求时不创建空 `hooks`、`models`、`utils`、`assets`、样式或菜单文件。
 
-### 9. 验证并交付
+### 9. 确定性校验与规范门卫
 
 运行：
 
@@ -169,19 +191,34 @@ node scripts/validate-scaffold.mjs \
   --profile <ProjectProfile JSON>
 ```
 
-再运行目标项目的 typecheck、lint、相关测试；有截图时启动页面做视觉核对。完成后运行 GitNexus detect changes。
+脚手架校验通过后执行以下不可跳过的闭环：
+
+1. 读取 `references/review-guard.md`，通过平台原生子代理能力创建独立只读审查子代理。
+2. 只传入用户需求与豁免摘要、本轮 `SceneSpec`、本次生成或修改的文件清单、项目根目录、目标目录、同一份 `ProjectProfile`、全部 `ComponentDecision` 和当前轮次。门卫可以读取直接依赖和项目规则取证，但不得报告清单外问题或修改文件。
+3. 门卫只能输出“规范审查 / 问题清单 / 修复计划”，并包含 `references/review-guard.md` 要求的 `reviewMode: generation-gate`、`ruleVersion: sisyphus-cr@1.5.0` 元数据。将输出保存到任务临时目录，并运行 `node scripts/evaluate-review-gate.mjs --mode generation-gate --root <项目根目录> --report-root <任务临时目录> --report <报告文件> --round <0|1|2>`。
+4. 只有门禁脚本返回 `status: passed` 才允许进入项目验证。返回 `status: repair` 时，主 Agent 按问题编号在文件清单内做最小修复，并使用 `nextRound` 进入下一轮。
+5. 每轮修复后先重新运行 `validate-scaffold.mjs`，再创建新的独立只读子代理复审。
+6. 自动修复最多 2 轮。门禁脚本返回 `status: blocked` 时立即停止；P0、P1、P2 任一遗留问题、报告格式不完整或“无法判断”都阻断交付。不得忽略 P2，也不得降级为主 Agent 自审。
+7. 修复需要改动清单外源码、公共 API、路由、权限、依赖或全局布局时立即停止并报告，不自动扩大权限。
+
+详细规则、证据要求、合理反例和输出契约见 `references/review-guard.md`。
+
+### 10. 项目验证并交付
+
+门卫通过后再运行目标项目的 typecheck、lint 和相关测试；有截图时启动页面做视觉核对。完成后运行 GitNexus detect changes。未执行的验证必须标记“未验证”。
 
 ## 输出格式
 
-按顺序输出：
+`path-review` 只使用 CR 的三个一级部分。`generation-gate` 按顺序输出：
 
 1. 中文场景名、匹配级别和能力组合
 2. 目标项目与版本门禁结果
 3. Sisyphus MCP 组件/API/demo 证据
 4. `ComponentDecision` 摘要和全部 Ant Design fallback
 5. 生成文件树与完整代码
-6. 实际执行的检查及结果
-7. 未解决项和按优先级排列的 TODO
+6. 门卫审查结论、自动修复轮次和最终问题清单
+7. 实际执行的检查及结果
+8. 未解决项和按优先级排列的 TODO；门卫未通过时明确标记“阻断交付”
 
 ## 资源路由
 
@@ -189,6 +226,8 @@ node scripts/validate-scaffold.mjs \
 - 场景与能力模型：`references/scene-model.md`
 - 数据和项目适配契约：`references/integration-contracts.md`
 - 生成后校验规则：`references/validation-rules.md`
+- 只读规范门卫与自动修复闭环：`references/review-guard.md`
+- Sisyphus CR 完整审查基线：`references/review-standard.md`
 - 可引用的团队批准样例：`references/approved-examples.yaml`
 - 结构模板注册表：`assets/templates/scene-registry.json`
 - 同版本 MCP/Scene 机器契约：`assets/ai-contract.json`

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/agents/openai.yaml

@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
 interface:
-  display_name: 'Sisyphus 业务场景生成'
-  short_description: '从截图或需求生成可验证的保险业务页面脚手架'
-  default_prompt: 'Use $sisyphus-scene to match this requirement to a business scene and generate a verified React scaffold.'
+  display_name: 'Sisyphus 场景生成与审查'
+  short_description: '生成保险业务页面脚手架，或按指定路径执行只读规范审查'
+  default_prompt: 'Use $sisyphus-scene to route this request to verified scene generation or read-only path review.'
 
 policy:
   allow_implicit_invocation: true

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/assets/ai-contract.json

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 {
-  "version": "4.6.3-beta.2",
+  "version": "4.6.3",
   "schemaVersion": 2,
   "tools": [
     "sisyphus-get-meta-status",

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/components/DetailPanel/index.tsx

@@ -0,0 +1,11 @@
+interface DetailPanelProps {
+  detail: Record<string, unknown>;
+  loading: boolean;
+  onLoad: (id: string) => void;
+}
+
+export const DetailPanel = ({ detail, loading, onLoad }: DetailPanelProps) => (
+  <button disabled={loading} onClick={() => onLoad('next')} type="button">
+    {String(detail.name || '加载')}
+  </button>
+);

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/config/index.tsx

@@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
+import { Button } from 'antd';
+
+interface CreateColumnsOptions {
+  loading: boolean;
+  onEdit: (id: string) => void;
+}
+
+export const createTableColumns = ({ loading, onEdit }: CreateColumnsOptions) => [
+  { dataIndex: 'name', title: '名称' },
+  {
+    title: '操作',
+    render: (_: unknown, record: { id: string }) => (
+      <Button loading={loading} onClick={() => onEdit(record.id)}>
+        编辑
+      </Button>
+    ),
+  },
+];

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/constants/index.ts

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+export const STATUS_OPTIONS = [{ label: '生效', value: 'active' }];

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/index.tsx

@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
+import { useRequest } from 'ahooks';
+import { Form, message } from 'antd';
+import { ProForm, ProSpin } from '@zat-design/sisyphus-react';
+import { useRef, useState } from 'react';
+
+import { DetailPanel } from './components/DetailPanel';
+import { getEntity } from './services';
+
+export const InvalidReviewPage = () => {
+  const [form] = Form.useForm();
+  const [loading, setLoading] = useState(false);
+  const [detail, setDetail] = useState<Record<string, unknown>>({});
+  const currentId = useRef('');
+  const { loading: requestLoading, runAsync } = useRequest(getEntity, { manual: true });
+
+  const handleLoad = async (id: string) => {
+    currentId.current = id;
+    setLoading(true);
+    try {
+      const response = await runAsync(id);
+      setDetail(response.data);
+    } catch {
+      message.error('加载详情失败');
+    } finally {
+      setLoading(false);
+    }
+  };
+
+  return (
+    <>
+      <ProSpin spinning={requestLoading} />
+      <DetailPanel loading={loading} detail={detail} onLoad={handleLoad} />
+      <ProForm form={form} columns={[]} />
+    </>
+  );
+};

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/services/index.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+import { request } from '../utils/request';
+
+/** GET /api/entities */ export const getEntities = () => request('/api/entities'); /** GET /api/entities/:id */ export const getEntity = (id: string) => request(`/api/entities/${id}`);

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/utils/request.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
+import { message } from 'antd';
+
+export const request = async (url: string) => {
+  try {
+    throw new Error(`接口失败：${url}`);
+  } catch (error) {
+    message.error(error instanceof Error ? error.message : '接口失败');
+    throw error;
+  }
+};

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/components/DetailPanel/index.tsx

@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+import { Form, type FormInstance } from 'antd';
+
+interface DetailPanelProps {
+  antdForm: FormInstance;
+  dataSource: { rowOperationLoading: boolean };
+  onLoad: () => void;
+  onToggleRow: () => void;
+}
+
+export const DetailPanel = ({
+  antdForm,
+  dataSource,
+  onLoad,
+  onToggleRow,
+}: DetailPanelProps) => (
+  <Form form={antdForm}>
+    <button disabled={dataSource.rowOperationLoading} onClick={onToggleRow} type="button">
+      行操作
+    </button>
+    <button onClick={onLoad} type="button">
+      加载
+    </button>
+  </Form>
+);

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/index.tsx

@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
+import { useRequest } from 'ahooks';
+import { Form, message } from 'antd';
+import { ProForm, ProSpin } from '@zat-design/sisyphus-react';
+import { useState } from 'react';
+
+import { DetailPanel } from './components/DetailPanel';
+import { requestWithoutGlobalErrorFeedback } from './services';
+
+export const ValidReviewPage = () => {
+  const [proForm] = ProForm.useForm();
+  const [antdForm] = Form.useForm();
+  const [rowOperationLoading, setRowOperationLoading] = useState(false);
+  const { loading, runAsync } = useRequest(requestWithoutGlobalErrorFeedback, { manual: true });
+
+  const handleLoad = async () => {
+    try {
+      await runAsync();
+    } catch (error) {
+      message.error(error instanceof Error ? error.message : '请求失败');
+    }
+  };
+
+  return (
+    <>
+      <ProSpin spinning={loading} />
+      <DetailPanel
+        antdForm={antdForm}
+        dataSource={{ rowOperationLoading }}
+        onLoad={handleLoad}
+        onToggleRow={() => setRowOperationLoading((value) => !value)}
+      />
+      <ProForm form={proForm} columns={[]} />
+    </>
+  );
+};

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/services/index.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+export const requestWithoutGlobalErrorFeedback = async () => {
+  throw new Error('接口返回的真实失败信息');
+};

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/shared/constants.ts

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+export const SHARED_STATUS_OPTIONS = [{ label: '生效', value: 'active' }];

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/shared/consumer-a.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+import { SHARED_STATUS_OPTIONS } from './constants';
+
+export const firstStatus = SHARED_STATUS_OPTIONS[0];

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/shared/consumer-b.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+import { SHARED_STATUS_OPTIONS } from './constants';
+
+export const statusCount = SHARED_STATUS_OPTIONS.length;

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/invalid/config/formColumns.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
+export const formColumns = [
+  {
+    type: 'ProInput',
+    name: 'policyName',
+    label: '保单名称',
+    required: true,
+    rules: [{ required: true, message: '请输入保单名称' }],
+    fieldProps: {
+      placeholder: '请输入保单名称',
+      onChange: (value: unknown) => value,
+    },
+  },
+];

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/invalid/flowHelper.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+export const cloneHistory = <T>(value: T): T => JSON.parse(JSON.stringify(value));
+
+export const calculateLayoutWidth = (columns: number) => columns * 160;

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/invalid/package.json

@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+{
+  "dependencies": {
+    "@zat-design/sisyphus-react": "4.6.3-beta.2",
+    "antd": "6.3.4",
+    "react": "19.1.0"
+  }
+}

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/components/DirectControl.tsx

@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+interface DirectControlProps {
+  onChange: (value: string) => void;
+}
+
+export const DirectControl = ({ onChange }: DirectControlProps) => (
+  <input onChange={(event) => onChange(event.target.value)} placeholder="例如 P12345678" />
+);

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/config/formColumns.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+export const formColumns = [
+  {
+    type: 'ProInput',
+    name: 'policyName',
+    label: '保单名称',
+    required: true,
+    fieldProps: {
+      onFieldChange: (value: unknown) => value,
+    },
+  },
+  {
+    type: 'ProInput',
+    name: 'policyCode',
+    label: '保单号',
+    rules: [{ pattern: /^P\d{8}$/, message: '保单号格式为 P 加 8 位数字' }],
+    fieldProps: {
+      placeholder: '例如 P12345678',
+    },
+  },
+];

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/context/BusinessContext.tsx

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+import { createContext } from 'react';
+
+export const BusinessContext = createContext({ readonly: true });

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/hooks/useBusinessState.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+import { useState } from 'react';
+
+export const useBusinessState = () => useState<'idle' | 'saving'>('idle');

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/package.json

@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+{
+  "dependencies": {
+    "@zat-design/sisyphus-react": "4.6.3-beta.2",
+    "antd": "6.3.4",
+    "react": "19.1.0"
+  }
+}

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/protocol.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
+export interface PolicyProtocol {
+  id: string;
+  name: string;
+}

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/services/index.ts

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+export const getPolicy = async (id: string) => ({ id, name: '测试保单' });

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/utils/flowHelper.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+export const cloneHistory = <T>(value: T): T => JSON.parse(JSON.stringify(value));
+
+export const calculateLayoutWidth = (columns: number) => columns * 160;

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/fixtures/valid-decisions.json

@@ -8,13 +8,13 @@
     "apiEvidence": {
       "tool": "sisyphus-get-component-api",
       "target": "ProForm",
-      "libraryVersion": "4.6.3-beta.2",
+      "libraryVersion": "4.6.3",
       "schemaVersion": 2
     },
     "demoEvidence": {
       "tool": "sisyphus-get-example",
       "target": "ProForm/demos/base.tsx",
-      "libraryVersion": "4.6.3-beta.2",
+      "libraryVersion": "4.6.3",
       "schemaVersion": 2,
       "exampleId": "ProForm/demos/base.tsx"
     }
@@ -28,13 +28,13 @@
     "apiEvidence": {
       "tool": "sisyphus-get-component-api",
       "target": "ProTable",
-      "libraryVersion": "4.6.3-beta.2",
+      "libraryVersion": "4.6.3",
       "schemaVersion": 2
     },
     "demoEvidence": {
       "tool": "sisyphus-get-example",
       "target": "ProTable/demos/base.tsx",
-      "libraryVersion": "4.6.3-beta.2",
+      "libraryVersion": "4.6.3",
       "schemaVersion": 2,
       "exampleId": "ProTable/demos/base.tsx"
     }

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/review-gate-cases.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,140 @@
+schema_version: 1
+policy:
+  reviewer: independent-read-only-subagent
+  max_repair_rounds: 2
+  blocking_priorities:
+    - P0
+    - P1
+    - P2
+cases:
+  - id: private-constants
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/constants/index.ts
+    evidence: ordinary-page-private-constants-directory
+    expected_rule: directory-responsibility
+  - id: mirrored-request-loading
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/index.tsx
+    evidence: useRequest-loading-copied-to-local-state
+    expected_rule: request-loading-source
+  - id: flat-custom-component-loading
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/index.tsx
+    evidence: request-loading-passed-as-flat-prop-to-project-component
+    expected_rule: custom-component-data-source
+  - id: dynamic-column-in-config
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/config/index.tsx
+    evidence: config-column-contains-jsx-permission-callback-and-runtime-loading
+    expected_rule: table-column-responsibility
+  - id: wrong-sisyphus-form-instance
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/index.tsx
+    evidence: form-use-form-instance-consumed-by-pro-form
+    expected_rule: sisyphus-form-instance
+  - id: duplicate-request-error-message
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/index.tsx
+    evidence: global-request-message-plus-local-fixed-error
+    expected_rule: duplicate-error-feedback
+  - id: service-formatting
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/services/index.ts
+    evidence: jsdoc-export-and-adjacent-services-packed-on-one-line
+    expected_rule: service-layout
+  - id: stale-async-response
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/invalid/index.tsx
+    evidence: earlier-detail-request-can-overwrite-new-record
+    expected_rule: async-race-safety
+  - id: third-party-loading-is-valid
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/index.tsx
+    evidence: request-loading-passed-directly-to-sisyphus-public-api
+    expected_result: review-passed
+  - id: antd-form-instance-is-valid
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/components/DetailPanel/index.tsx
+    evidence: form-use-form-instance-consumed-only-by-antd-form
+    expected_result: review-passed
+  - id: business-loading-is-valid
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/index.tsx
+    evidence: non-request-row-operation-lock
+    expected_result: review-passed
+  - id: shared-constants-is-valid
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/shared/constants.ts
+    evidence: constants-module-used-by-multiple-business-modules
+    expected_result: review-passed
+  - id: local-error-message-is-valid-without-global-handler
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate/valid/index.tsx
+    evidence: request-layer-does-not-display-api-message
+    expected_result: review-passed
+  - id: first-review-pass
+    kind: workflow
+    review_results:
+      - passed
+    expected_repair_rounds: 0
+    expected_result: delivery-allowed
+  - id: repair-then-pass
+    kind: workflow
+    review_results:
+      - failed-p1
+      - passed
+    expected_repair_rounds: 1
+    expected_result: delivery-allowed
+  - id: two-rounds-still-failing
+    kind: workflow
+    review_results:
+      - failed-p1
+      - failed-p2
+      - failed-p2
+    expected_repair_rounds: 2
+    expected_result: blocked
+  - id: flat-root-utility
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/invalid/flowHelper.ts
+    evidence: pure-helper-flattened-in-page-root
+    expected_rule: root-source-responsibility
+  - id: sisyphus-columns-on-change
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/invalid/config/formColumns.ts
+    evidence: sisyphus-column-field-props-on-change
+    expected_rule: sisyphus-on-field-change
+  - id: duplicate-simple-required-rule
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/invalid/config/formColumns.ts
+    evidence: required-true-plus-simple-required-rule
+    expected_rule: duplicate-required-validation
+  - id: redundant-default-placeholder
+    kind: invalid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/invalid/config/formColumns.ts
+    evidence: placeholder-repeats-label-default
+    expected_rule: default-placeholder
+  - id: utils-directory-is-valid
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/utils/flowHelper.ts
+    evidence: pure-helper-under-utils-directory
+    expected_result: review-passed
+  - id: direct-control-on-change-is-valid
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/components/DirectControl.tsx
+    evidence: directly-rendered-react-input-public-on-change
+    expected_result: review-passed
+  - id: complex-validation-rules-are-valid
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/config/formColumns.ts
+    evidence: regex-validation-without-duplicate-required-rule
+    expected_result: review-passed
+  - id: special-placeholder-is-valid
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/config/formColumns.ts
+    evidence: placeholder-explains-required-business-format
+    expected_result: review-passed
+  - id: responsibility-layer-exceptions-are-valid
+    kind: valid
+    fixture: evals/fixtures/review-gate-v1.5/valid/protocol.ts
+    evidence: component-hook-service-context-and-protocol-remain-in-own-layers
+    expected_result: review-passed

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/review-routing-cases.yaml

@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
+schema_version: 1
+cases:
+  - id: relative-review-path
+    prompt: '审查 src/pages/Policy'
+    expected_mode: path-review
+    expected_path: src/pages/Policy
+  - id: absolute-review-path
+    prompt: '规范检查 /workspace/src/pages/Policy/index.tsx'
+    expected_mode: path-review
+    expected_path: /workspace/src/pages/Policy/index.tsx
+  - id: backtick-review-path
+    prompt: 'review `src/pages/Claim`'
+    expected_mode: path-review
+    expected_path: src/pages/Claim
+  - id: reference-path-stays-generation
+    prompt: '参考 src/pages/Policy 生成一个理赔列表页'
+    expected_mode: generation-gate
+  - id: review-without-path-unresolved
+    prompt: '审查一下这个页面'
+    expected_mode: path-review-unresolved
+    expected_result: unable-to-determine
+  - id: missing-review-path-unresolved
+    prompt: '审查 src/pages/Missing'
+    expected_mode: path-review-unresolved
+    expected_result: unable-to-determine
+  - id: non-sisyphus-review-path-undetermined
+    prompt: '审查 src/plain-react'
+    expected_mode: path-review
+    expected_result: unable-to-determine
+  - id: review-and-fix-remains-read-only
+    prompt: '审查并修复 src/pages/Policy'
+    expected_mode: path-review
+    mutation_allowed: false

package/skills/sisyphus-scene/evals/trigger-cases.yaml

@@ -5,8 +5,11 @@ should_trigger:
   - '参考 claim 应用实现一个多 Tab 详情编辑页'
   - '这个布局不在已有场景里，请根据 Sisyphus demo 组合'
   - '做一个右侧步骤锚点、统一校验的长表单'
+  - '使用 sisyphus-scene 审查 src/pages/Policy'
+  - '规范检查 `/workspace/src/pages/Claim/index.tsx`'
 should_not_trigger:
   - '解释一下 React useEffect'
   - '修复这个现有组件的业务 bug'
   - '给 antd4 项目生成 CRUD 页面'
   - '给 Sisyphus v3 项目兼容一个旧页面'
+  - '审查一下 React 的最佳实践'