@yielded/auth-persistence 0.1.0-beta.25 → 0.1.0-beta.27

package/src/internal/totp-native.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,701 @@
+import type { LifecycleHooks } from "@yielded/auth/Hooks";
+import { AuthenticationRequirement, SecurityRevision } from "@yielded/auth/Sessions";
+import {
+  TotpUnavailable,
+  TotpMutation,
+  TotpPolicy,
+  TotpRecord,
+  TotpSnapshot,
+  type TotpDecision,
+  type TotpPersistence,
+} from "@yielded/auth/Totp";
+import { Crypto, DateTime, Effect, Option, Schema } from "effect";
+import { SqlClient } from "effect/sql/SqlClient";
+import type { Fragment } from "effect/sql/Statement";
+
+import { digest, randomId } from "./crypto";
+import { sqlBatchAssertion } from "./d1-planning";
+import { PersistenceMappingError } from "./mapping-error";
+import type { TotpMapping } from "./models/totp-model";
+import type { NativeSqlTables, SqlTable } from "./native-sql-table";
+import { makeNativeSessionPending, prepareNativeSession } from "./session-native-pending";
+import { makeConditionalSqlInsert } from "./session-native-record";
+import { assessSessionAt, sameSessionRevision } from "./session-native-state";
+import { exactSqlText, executeSqlChange } from "./sql-change";
+import {
+  CurrentSqlCommit,
+  makeSqlCommitExecutor,
+  SqlBatchCommit,
+  appendSqlBatchStatement,
+  registerSqlBatchPostcondition,
+  registerSqlPostcondition,
+} from "./sql-commit";
+import type { AnyTableModel } from "./table-model";
+
+export type NativeTotpMapping = TotpMapping<
+  AnyTableModel,
+  AnyTableModel,
+  AnyTableModel,
+  unknown,
+  AnyTableModel
+>;
+
+const unavailable = () => TotpUnavailable.make({});
+
+const invariant: (value: unknown) => asserts value = (value) => {
+  if (!value)
+    throw PersistenceMappingError.make({ operation: "decode", cause: "Invalid TOTP authority" });
+};
+
+const codec = Schema.fromJsonString(TotpRecord);
+const encodeTotpRecord = Schema.encodeSync(codec);
+const reject: TotpDecision = { _tag: "Rejected" };
+
+export const makeNativeTotpServices = Effect.fnUntraced(function* (
+  tables: NativeSqlTables,
+  mapping: NativeTotpMapping,
+): Effect.fn.Return<
+  { readonly totpPersistence: TotpPersistence["Service"] },
+  never,
+  SqlClient | LifecycleHooks | Crypto.Crypto | SqlBatchCommit
+> {
+  const batch = yield* SqlBatchCommit;
+  const conditionalInsert = yield* makeConditionalSqlInsert();
+
+  const sql = (yield* SqlClient).withoutTransforms(),
+    crypto = yield* Crypto.Crypto,
+    executor = yield* makeSqlCommitExecutor(unavailable),
+    external = yield* Effect.serviceOption(CurrentSqlCommit);
+
+  const s = mapping.subject,
+    f = mapping.factor,
+    c = mapping.credential,
+    subject = tables(s.table),
+    factor = tables(f.table),
+    credential = tables(c.table),
+    engineNow = tables.expression(mapping.engineNowMillis);
+
+  const active = tables.expression(s.activeCondition),
+    activeCredential = tables.expression(c.activeCondition);
+
+  const lock = sql.onDialectOrElse({ sqlite: () => sql``, orElse: () => sql`for update` });
+
+  const nativeLocks =
+    batch === undefined && sql.onDialectOrElse({ sqlite: () => false, orElse: () => true });
+
+  const exact = (table: SqlTable, key: string, value: unknown) =>
+    exactSqlText(sql, table.column(key), table.value(key, value));
+
+  const id = (table: SqlTable, key: string, value: unknown) =>
+    sql`${table.column(key)} = ${table.value(key, value)}`;
+
+  const pending =
+    mapping.pending === undefined
+      ? undefined
+      : yield* makeNativeSessionPending(
+          tables,
+          {
+            ...mapping.pending,
+            subjectId: {
+              toNative: (id) => Effect.sync(() => mapping.subjectIds.toNative(id)),
+              toSubject: (id) => Effect.sync(() => mapping.subjectIds.toSubject(id)),
+              equals: Object.is,
+            },
+          },
+          batch !== undefined,
+        );
+
+  const provide = <A, E, R>(work: Effect.Effect<A, E, R>) =>
+    work.pipe(Effect.provideService(Crypto.Crypto, crypto));
+
+  const run = <A, E, R>(work: Effect.Effect<A, E, R>) =>
+    batch === undefined
+      ? executor.run(provide(work))
+      : executor.batch(provide(work)).pipe(Effect.provideService(SqlBatchCommit, batch));
+
+  const stage = Effect.fnUntraced(function* (statement: Fragment, expected = 1) {
+    if (batch !== undefined) {
+      yield* appendSqlBatchStatement(sql`${statement}`);
+      yield* appendSqlBatchStatement(sqlBatchAssertion(sql, sql`changes() = ${expected}`));
+    } else invariant((yield* executeSqlChange(sql, statement)) === expected);
+  });
+
+  const capture = Effect.fnUntraced(function* (
+    subjectId: TotpRecord["subjectId"],
+    locking = false,
+  ) {
+    const nativeId = mapping.subjectIds.toNative(subjectId);
+
+    invariant(mapping.subjectIds.toSubject(nativeId) === subjectId);
+
+    const scope = yield* digest(
+      `effect-auth/totp/scope/v1/${mapping.moduleId.length}:${mapping.moduleId}/${subjectId}`,
+    );
+
+    if (locking && nativeLocks) {
+      const owners =
+        yield* sql`select ${subject.column(s.id)} from ${subject.name} where ${id(subject, s.id, nativeId)} and ${active} limit 2 ${lock}`;
+
+      invariant(owners.length <= 1);
+      if (owners[0] === undefined) return undefined;
+    }
+    // The distinct subject lock always precedes the ordered authority locks.
+    // Advisory snapshots use this same bounded join without transaction control.
+    const currentCredentials = sql`select ${credential.fields("c_")} from ${credential.name} where ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)} and ${activeCredential} order by ${credential.column(c.id)} limit 65 ${locking && nativeLocks ? lock : sql``}`;
+
+    const rows =
+      yield* sql`with current_credentials as ${sql.onDialectOrElse({ pg: () => sql`materialized`, orElse: () => sql`` })} (${currentCredentials})
+      select ${subject.fields("s_")}, ${factor.fields("f_")}, current_credentials.*, ${engineNow} as engine_now
+      from ${subject.name} left join ${factor.name} on ${exact(factor, f.scope, scope)} left join current_credentials on 1 = 1
+      where ${id(subject, s.id, nativeId)} and ${active} limit 65`;
+
+    invariant(rows.length <= 64);
+    if (rows[0] === undefined) return undefined;
+
+    const subjectRow = subject.decode(rows[0], "s_"),
+      decoded = factor.decode(rows[0], "f_");
+
+    const factorRow =
+      decoded[f.scope] === null || decoded[f.scope] === undefined ? undefined : decoded;
+
+    const now = Number(rows[0].engine_now);
+    const credentials: { credentialId: unknown; revision: unknown }[] = [];
+
+    for (const row of rows) {
+      const value = credential.decode(row, "c_");
+
+      if (value[c.id] === null || value[c.id] === undefined) continue;
+      invariant(mapping.subjectIds.toSubject(value[c.subjectId]) === subjectId);
+      invariant(!credentials.some((entry) => entry.credentialId === value[c.id]));
+      credentials.push({ credentialId: value[c.id], revision: value[c.revision] });
+    }
+
+    const revision = yield* Schema.decodeUnknownEffect(TotpSnapshot.fields.revision)({
+      subjectId,
+      securityRevision: subjectRow[s.securityRevision],
+      credentials,
+    });
+
+    const ordered = {
+      ...revision,
+      credentials: [...revision.credentials].sort((left, right) =>
+        left.credentialId.localeCompare(right.credentialId),
+      ),
+    };
+
+    invariant(
+      mapping.subjectIds.toSubject(subjectRow[s.id]) === subjectId && Number.isSafeInteger(now),
+    );
+
+    const record =
+      factorRow === undefined ? null : yield* Schema.decodeUnknownEffect(codec)(factorRow[f.state]);
+
+    invariant(
+      record === null ||
+        (record.moduleId === mapping.moduleId &&
+          record.subjectId === subjectId &&
+          record.version === factorRow?.[f.version] &&
+          (record.secret === null || record.secret.revision === record.revision) &&
+          (record.pending === null || record.pending.secret.revision === record.pending.revision)),
+    );
+
+    invariant(
+      record === null ||
+        record.secret === null ||
+        ordered.credentials.some(
+          (entry) =>
+            entry.credentialId === record.credentialId && entry.revision === record.revision,
+        ),
+    );
+
+    const snapshot = yield* Schema.decodeEffect(Schema.toType(TotpSnapshot))({
+      revision: ordered,
+      requirement: mapping.subject.decodeRequirement(subjectRow),
+      record,
+    });
+
+    return { nativeId, subjectRow, factorRow, scope, snapshot, now };
+  });
+
+  const mutate = Effect.fnUntraced(function* (input: TotpMutation) {
+    invariant(
+      input.moduleId === mapping.moduleId &&
+        Schema.encodeSync(Schema.fromJsonString(TotpPolicy))(input.policy) ===
+          Schema.encodeSync(Schema.fromJsonString(TotpPolicy))(mapping.policy),
+    );
+    const captured = yield* capture(input.subjectId, true);
+
+    if (captured === undefined) return reject;
+
+    const { snapshot, subjectRow, factorRow, scope, nativeId, now } = captured,
+      current = snapshot.record,
+      policy = input.policy,
+      action = input.action;
+
+    if (
+      snapshot.revision.securityRevision !== input.snapshot.revision.securityRevision ||
+      (current?.version ?? null) !== (input.snapshot.record?.version ?? null) ||
+      (current === null) !== (input.snapshot.record === null) ||
+      (current !== null && encodeTotpRecord(current) !== encodeTotpRecord(input.snapshot.record!))
+    )
+      return reject;
+
+    let expectedCount: number | undefined,
+      countGuardIndex = -1;
+
+    const guards: Fragment[] = [],
+      timeGuards: Fragment[] = [],
+      credentialGuards: { credentialId: string; condition: Fragment }[] = [];
+
+    const timeBound = (start: number, end: number) => {
+      timeGuards.push(sql`${engineNow} >= ${start} and ${engineNow} < ${end}`);
+    };
+
+    if (
+      action._tag === "Enroll" ||
+      action._tag === "Confirm" ||
+      action._tag === "Disable" ||
+      action._tag === "Regenerate"
+    ) {
+      const authorization = input.authorization;
+
+      if (authorization === undefined) return reject;
+      const { challenge, evidence } = authorization;
+
+      const expectedAction = {
+        Enroll: "enroll",
+        Confirm: "confirm",
+        Disable: "disable",
+        Regenerate: "regenerate",
+      }[action._tag];
+
+      if (
+        challenge.action !== expectedAction ||
+        challenge.moduleId !== mapping.moduleId ||
+        challenge.revision.subjectId !== input.subjectId ||
+        challenge.revision.securityRevision !== snapshot.revision.securityRevision ||
+        evidence.flowId !== challenge.flowId ||
+        evidence.bindingDigest !== challenge.bindingDigest ||
+        evidence.revision.subjectId !== input.subjectId ||
+        evidence.revision.securityRevision !== snapshot.revision.securityRevision
+      )
+        return reject;
+      for (const revision of evidence.revision.credentials)
+        credentialGuards.push({
+          credentialId: revision.credentialId,
+          condition: sql`exists(select 1 from ${credential.name} where ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)} and ${exact(credential, c.id, revision.credentialId)} and ${exact(credential, c.revision, revision.revision)} and ${activeCredential})`,
+        });
+      expectedCount = evidence.revision.credentials.length;
+      countGuardIndex = guards.length;
+      guards.push(
+        sql`(select count(*) from ${credential.name} where ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)} and ${activeCredential}) = ${evidence.revision.credentials.length}`,
+      );
+
+      const requirements = [authorization.requirement, snapshot.requirement],
+        maximumAge = Math.min(
+          policy.maximumEvidenceAgeMillis,
+          ...requirements.map((r) => r.maximumAgeMillis),
+        );
+
+      for (const requirement of requirements) {
+        const assessed = yield* assessSessionAt(
+          evidence,
+          { ...requirement, maximumAgeMillis: maximumAge },
+          now,
+        ).pipe(Effect.result);
+
+        if (assessed._tag === "Failure" || !assessed.success.satisfied) return reject;
+      }
+      for (const proof of evidence.proofs) {
+        const verified = DateTime.toEpochMillis(proof.verifiedAt);
+
+        if (verified > now || now - verified >= maximumAge) return reject;
+        timeBound(verified, verified + maximumAge);
+      }
+      if (
+        (current !== null && current.secret !== null) ||
+        action._tag === "Disable" ||
+        action._tag === "Regenerate"
+      ) {
+        const factors = new Set(evidence.proofs.flatMap((p) => p.factors));
+
+        if (
+          !(
+            evidence.proofs.some(
+              (p) => p.userVerified && p.phishingResistant && p.factors.includes("possession"),
+            ) ||
+            (factors.has("knowledge") &&
+              factors.has("possession") &&
+              new Set(evidence.proofs.map((p) => p.credentialId)).size >= 2)
+          )
+        )
+          return reject;
+      }
+    }
+    if (action._tag === "Recovery" && action.reset) {
+      const target = action.pending;
+
+      if (
+        target === undefined ||
+        pending === undefined ||
+        mapping.pending === undefined ||
+        target.revision.subjectId !== input.subjectId ||
+        target.revision.securityRevision !== snapshot.revision.securityRevision ||
+        target.expiresAtMillis <= now
+      )
+        return reject;
+      const selected = yield* pending.read("Login", target.digest);
+
+      if (selected === undefined) return reject;
+      const original = yield* mapping.pending.login.decode(selected.record.snapshot);
+
+      if (
+        selected.record.flowId !== target.flowId ||
+        selected.record.bindingDigest !== target.bindingDigest ||
+        selected.record.subjectId !== input.subjectId ||
+        selected.record.expiresAtMillis !== target.expiresAtMillis ||
+        original.digest !== target.digest ||
+        !sameSessionRevision(original.evidence.revision, target.revision)
+      )
+        return reject;
+      guards.push(
+        sql`exists(select 1 from ${pending.table.name} where ${pending.predicate(pending.table, "Login", target.digest)} and ${exact(pending.table, pending.p.snapshot, selected.record.snapshot)} and ${exact(pending.table, pending.p.version, original.version)})`,
+      );
+      for (const revision of target.revision.credentials)
+        credentialGuards.push({
+          credentialId: revision.credentialId,
+          condition: sql`exists(select 1 from ${credential.name} where ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)} and ${exact(credential, c.id, revision.credentialId)} and ${exact(credential, c.revision, revision.revision)} and ${activeCredential})`,
+        });
+      timeBound(0, target.expiresAtMillis);
+    }
+
+    let next: TotpRecord,
+      semantic = false,
+      accepted = true;
+
+    if (action._tag === "Enroll") {
+      const candidate = action.record;
+
+      if (
+        candidate.subjectId !== input.subjectId ||
+        candidate.moduleId !== input.moduleId ||
+        candidate.pending === null ||
+        candidate.pending.expiresAtMillis <= now ||
+        candidate.pending.expiresAtMillis > now + policy.enrollmentLifetimeMillis ||
+        candidate.pending.failedAttempts !== 0 ||
+        candidate.pending.secret.revision !== candidate.pending.revision
+      )
+        return reject;
+      // Reissuing cannot erase the confirmation budget during its current enrollment lifetime.
+      if (current !== null && current.pending !== null && current.pending.expiresAtMillis > now)
+        return reject;
+      if (
+        current !== null &&
+        (candidate.credentialId !== current.credentialId ||
+          encodeTotpRecord({ ...candidate, pending: current.pending }) !==
+            encodeTotpRecord(current))
+      )
+        return reject;
+      if (
+        current === null &&
+        (candidate.secret !== null ||
+          candidate.recoveryDigests.length !== 0 ||
+          candidate.acceptedStep !== -1 ||
+          candidate.failedAttempts !== 0)
+      )
+        return reject;
+      next = candidate;
+      timeBound(0, candidate.pending.expiresAtMillis);
+    } else {
+      if (current === null) return reject;
+      next = { ...current };
+      if (action._tag === "Confirm") {
+        const pending = current.pending;
+
+        if (
+          pending === null ||
+          pending.enrollmentId !== action.enrollmentId ||
+          pending.expiresAtMillis <= now ||
+          pending.failedAttempts >= policy.attemptLimit
+        )
+          return reject;
+        timeBound(0, pending.expiresAtMillis);
+        if (
+          action.matchedStep === null ||
+          Math.abs(Math.floor(now / 30000) - action.matchedStep) > policy.clockSkewSteps
+        ) {
+          next = {
+            ...current,
+            pending: { ...pending, failedAttempts: pending.failedAttempts + 1 },
+          };
+          accepted = false;
+        } else {
+          if (new Set(action.recoveryDigests).size !== 10) return reject;
+          next = {
+            ...current,
+            secret: pending.secret,
+            revision: pending.secret.revision,
+            pending: null,
+            recoveryDigests: action.recoveryDigests,
+            acceptedStep: action.matchedStep,
+            attemptWindow: now,
+            failedAttempts: 0,
+          };
+          semantic = true;
+          timeBound(
+            Math.max(0, (action.matchedStep - policy.clockSkewSteps) * 30000),
+            (action.matchedStep + policy.clockSkewSteps + 1) * 30000,
+          );
+        }
+      } else if (action._tag === "Verify" || action._tag === "Recovery") {
+        if (current.secret === null) return reject;
+
+        const expired = now >= current.attemptWindow + policy.attemptWindowMillis,
+          attempts = expired ? 0 : current.failedAttempts,
+          start = expired ? now : current.attemptWindow;
+
+        if (attempts >= policy.attemptLimit) return reject;
+        next = { ...current, attemptWindow: start, failedAttempts: attempts + 1 };
+        if (action._tag === "Verify") {
+          if (
+            action.matchedStep === null ||
+            action.matchedStep <= current.acceptedStep ||
+            Math.abs(Math.floor(now / 30000) - action.matchedStep) > policy.clockSkewSteps
+          )
+            accepted = false;
+          else {
+            next = { ...next, acceptedStep: action.matchedStep, failedAttempts: 0 };
+            timeBound(
+              Math.max(0, (action.matchedStep - policy.clockSkewSteps) * 30000),
+              (action.matchedStep + policy.clockSkewSteps + 1) * 30000,
+            );
+          }
+        } else {
+          if (
+            (action.reset
+              ? policy.lostFactorRecovery !== "reset-with-recovery-code"
+              : !policy.allowRecoveryCodeForPending) ||
+            !current.recoveryDigests.includes(action.digest)
+          )
+            accepted = false;
+          else {
+            next = {
+              ...next,
+              recoveryDigests: current.recoveryDigests.filter((value) => value !== action.digest),
+              failedAttempts: 0,
+            };
+            if (action.reset) {
+              next = {
+                ...next,
+                secret: null,
+                pending: null,
+                recoveryDigests: [],
+                revision: yield* randomId,
+              };
+              semantic = true;
+            }
+          }
+        }
+      } else {
+        if (current.secret === null) return reject;
+        semantic = action._tag === "Disable";
+        if (action._tag === "Disable")
+          next = {
+            ...current,
+            secret: null,
+            pending: null,
+            recoveryDigests: [],
+            revision: yield* randomId,
+          };
+        else {
+          if (new Set(action.recoveryDigests).size !== 10) return reject;
+          next = { ...current, recoveryDigests: action.recoveryDigests };
+        }
+      }
+    }
+    next = { ...next, version: yield* randomId };
+
+    const ownerKey = id(subject, s.id, nativeId);
+    const initialAuthority = sql`exists(select 1 from ${subject.name} where ${ownerKey} and ${exact(subject, s.securityRevision, snapshot.revision.securityRevision)} and ${active})`;
+
+    const initialFactor =
+      factorRow === undefined
+        ? sql`not exists(select 1 from ${factor.name} where ${exact(factor, f.scope, scope)})`
+        : sql`exists(select 1 from ${factor.name} where ${exact(factor, f.scope, scope)} and ${exact(factor, f.version, current!.version)})`;
+
+    const policyGuard = sql.and(
+      (s.requirementColumns ?? []).map((key) =>
+        subjectRow[key] === null
+          ? sql`${subject.column(key)} is null`
+          : sql`${subject.column(key)} = ${subject.value(key, subjectRow[key])}`,
+      ),
+    );
+
+    const policyCondition = sql`exists(select 1 from ${subject.name} where ${ownerKey} and ${policyGuard})`;
+    const fresh = sql.and([...timeGuards, sql`${engineNow} >= ${now}`]);
+
+    // A factor UPDATE pins scope and version itself, and MySQL rejects a subquery
+    // on the table being updated (error 1093), so only inserts add initialFactor.
+    const unchangedFactor = sql.and([
+      initialAuthority,
+      policyCondition,
+      fresh,
+      ...guards,
+      ...credentialGuards.map((g) => g.condition),
+    ]);
+
+    let nextRevision = snapshot.revision.securityRevision;
+
+    if (semantic) {
+      nextRevision = SecurityRevision.make(yield* randomId);
+      // Subject is the first lock and first graph mutation. The conditional write
+      // validates original evidence before changing the TOTP authority vector.
+      yield* stage(
+        sql`${subject.update({ [s.securityRevision]: nextRevision, [s.factorEnabled]: s.encodeEnabled(next.secret !== null) })} where ${ownerKey} and ${exact(subject, s.securityRevision, snapshot.revision.securityRevision)} and ${active} and ${fresh} and ${initialFactor} and ${policyGuard} and ${sql.and([...guards, ...credentialGuards.map((g) => g.condition)])}`,
+      );
+
+      const values = {
+        ...c.encodeInsert({
+          credentialId: next.credentialId,
+          subjectId: nativeId,
+          revision: next.revision,
+          active: next.secret !== null,
+        }),
+        [c.id]: next.credentialId,
+        [c.subjectId]: nativeId,
+        [c.revision]: next.revision,
+        [c.status]: c.encodeStatus(next.secret !== null),
+      };
+
+      const insert = credential.insert(values);
+
+      const changes = {
+        [c.revision]: next.revision,
+        [c.status]: c.encodeStatus(next.secret !== null),
+      };
+
+      const upsert = sql.onDialectOrElse({
+        mysql: () =>
+          sql`${insert} on duplicate key update ${credential.columnName(c.revision)} = case when ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)} then ${credential.value(c.revision, next.revision)} else ${credential.column(c.revision)} end, ${credential.columnName(c.status)} = case when ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)} then ${credential.value(c.status, c.encodeStatus(next.secret !== null))} else ${credential.column(c.status)} end`,
+        orElse: () =>
+          sql`${insert} on conflict (${credential.columnName(c.id)}) do update set ${sql.join(", ", false)(Object.entries(changes).map(([key, value]) => sql`${credential.columnName(key)} = ${credential.value(key, value)}`))} where ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)}`,
+      });
+
+      if (sql.onDialectOrElse({ mysql: () => true, orElse: () => false }) && batch === undefined) {
+        yield* sql`${upsert}`;
+        invariant(
+          (yield* sql`select 1 from ${credential.name} where ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)} and ${exact(credential, c.id, next.credentialId)} and ${exact(credential, c.revision, next.revision)} and ${id(credential, c.status, c.encodeStatus(next.secret !== null))}`)
+            .length === 1,
+        );
+      } else yield* stage(upsert);
+    }
+
+    const encoded = encodeTotpRecord(next),
+      values = { [f.state]: encoded, [f.version]: next.version };
+
+    const afterAuthority = sql`exists(select 1 from ${subject.name} where ${ownerKey} and ${exact(subject, s.securityRevision, nextRevision)} and ${active})`;
+    const writeGuard = semantic ? sql`${afterAuthority} and ${fresh}` : unchangedFactor;
+
+    if (factorRow === undefined) {
+      const insert = {
+        ...f.encodeInsert({ scope, state: encoded, version: next.version }),
+        [f.scope]: scope,
+        ...values,
+      };
+
+      yield* stage(
+        conditionalInsert(
+          factor,
+          insert,
+          semantic ? writeGuard : sql.and([writeGuard, initialFactor]),
+        ),
+      );
+    } else
+      yield* stage(
+        sql`${factor.update(values)} where ${exact(factor, f.scope, scope)} and ${exact(factor, f.version, current!.version)} and ${writeGuard}`,
+      );
+
+    const expectedPolicy = semantic
+      ? { ...subjectRow, [s.factorEnabled]: s.encodeEnabled(next.secret !== null) }
+      : subjectRow;
+
+    const finalPolicy = sql`exists(select 1 from ${subject.name} where ${ownerKey} and ${sql.and((s.requirementColumns ?? []).map((key) => (expectedPolicy[key] === null ? sql`${subject.column(key)} is null` : sql`${subject.column(key)} = ${subject.value(key, expectedPolicy[key])}`)))})`;
+
+    const finalCondition = sql.and([
+      afterAuthority,
+      finalPolicy,
+      fresh,
+      sql`exists(select 1 from ${factor.name} where ${exact(factor, f.scope, scope)} and ${exact(factor, f.version, next.version)} and ${exact(factor, f.state, encoded)})`,
+      ...guards.filter((_, index) => expectedCount === undefined || index !== countGuardIndex),
+      ...credentialGuards
+        .filter((g) => !semantic || g.credentialId !== next.credentialId)
+        .map((g) => g.condition),
+      ...(semantic
+        ? [
+            sql`exists(select 1 from ${credential.name} where ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)} and ${exact(credential, c.id, next.credentialId)} and ${exact(credential, c.revision, next.revision)} and ${id(credential, c.status, c.encodeStatus(next.secret !== null))})`,
+          ]
+        : []),
+      ...(expectedCount === undefined
+        ? []
+        : [
+            sql`(select count(*) from ${credential.name} where ${id(credential, c.subjectId, nativeId)} and ${activeCredential}) = ${expectedCount + (semantic ? (next.secret === null ? 0 : 1) - (current?.secret === null || current === null ? 0 : 1) : 0)}`,
+          ]),
+    ]);
+
+    if (batch !== undefined)
+      yield* registerSqlBatchPostcondition({
+        name: "totp-factor-and-authority",
+        statement: sqlBatchAssertion(sql, finalCondition),
+      });
+    else if (Option.isSome(external))
+      yield* registerSqlPostcondition({
+        name: "totp-factor-and-authority",
+        check: Effect.gen(function* () {
+          invariant((yield* sql`select 1 where ${finalCondition}`).length === 1);
+          if (input.authorization !== undefined) {
+            const final = yield* capture(input.subjectId);
+
+            invariant(final !== undefined && final.now >= now);
+            const expected = mapping.subject.decodeRequirement(expectedPolicy);
+
+            const encodedRequirement = Schema.encodeSync(
+              Schema.fromJsonString(AuthenticationRequirement),
+            );
+
+            invariant(
+              encodedRequirement(final.snapshot.requirement) === encodedRequirement(expected),
+            );
+          }
+        }).pipe(
+          Effect.provideService(Crypto.Crypto, crypto),
+          Effect.mapError((cause) => PersistenceMappingError.make({ operation: "decode", cause })),
+        ),
+      });
+
+    return accepted ? { _tag: "Accepted" as const, record: next } : reject;
+  });
+
+  const totpPersistence: TotpPersistence["Service"] = {
+    snapshot: (input) =>
+      executor.read(
+        provide(
+          Effect.gen(function* () {
+            invariant(input.moduleId === mapping.moduleId);
+
+            return (yield* capture(input.subjectId))?.snapshot;
+          }),
+        ),
+      ),
+    mutate: (original, project) =>
+      run(
+        Effect.gen(function* () {
+          const input = yield* Schema.decodeEffect(Schema.toType(TotpMutation))(original);
+          const decision = yield* mutate(input);
+
+          return yield* prepareNativeSession(decision, project);
+        }),
+      ),
+  };
+
+  return { totpPersistence };
+});