@ydtb/specsmd 0.1.22

package/flows/fire/agents/builder/skills/run-execute/SKILL.md

@@ -0,0 +1,700 @@
+---
+name: run-execute
+description: Execute work items based on their assigned mode (autopilot, confirm, validate). Supports single-item and multi-item (batch/wide) runs.
+version: 1.0.0
+---
+
+<objective>
+Execute work items based on their assigned mode (autopilot, confirm, validate).
+Supports both single-item and multi-item (batch/wide) runs.
+</objective>
+
+<prerequisites>
+  Before executing scripts, ensure required dependencies are installed:
+
+  <step n="1" title="Check yaml Package">
+    <action>Run: npm list yaml --depth=0 2>/dev/null || echo "NOT_FOUND"</action>
+    <check if="output contains NOT_FOUND">
+      <output>Installing required dependency: yaml</output>
+      <action>Run: npm install yaml</action>
+    </check>
+  </step>
+
+  | Package | Purpose | Install Command |
+  |---------|---------|-----------------|
+  | `yaml` | Parse/stringify state.yaml | `npm install yaml` |
+
+</prerequisites>
+
+<triggers>
+  - Pending work item ready for execution
+  - Resumed from interrupted run
+  - Batch of work items passed from run-plan
+</triggers>
+
+<resume_detection critical="true">
+  Before starting execution, check if resuming an interrupted run:
+
+  <step n="0" title="Check for Active Run">
+    <action>Check state.yaml for runs.active[] array</action>
+
+    <check if="runs.active is empty">
+      <goto step="1">No active run, start fresh</goto>
+    </check>
+
+    <check if="runs.active has entries">
+      <action>Load run state from .specs-fire/runs/{runs.active[0].id}/run.md</action>
+      <action>Get current_item and its status from state.yaml</action>
+      <action>Check for existing artifacts and LOAD if present:</action>
+
+      <substep>design.md → if exists, LOAD from .specs-fire/intents/{intent}/work-items/{id}-design.md</substep>
+      <substep>plan.md → if exists, LOAD from .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/plan.md (skip plan generation)</substep>
+      <substep>test-report.md → if exists, tests already passed (skip to Step 6b)</substep>
+      <substep>review-report.md → if exists, review done (skip to Step 6c)</substep>
+
+      <determine_resume_point>
+        | Artifacts Present | Resume At |
+        |-------------------|-----------|
+        | None | Step 3 (Generate Plan) |
+        | plan.md only | Step 5 (Implementation) |
+        | plan.md + test-report.md | Step 6b (Code Review) |
+        | plan.md + test-report.md + review-report.md | Step 6c (Commit Changes) |
+        | plan.md + test-report.md + review-report.md + commit done | Step 7 (Complete Item) |
+      </determine_resume_point>
+
+      <output>
+        Resuming run {run-id} for work item {current_item}.
+        Mode: {mode}
+        Loaded existing artifacts: {artifact_list}
+        Resuming at: Step {step_number}
+      </output>
+    </check>
+  </step>
+</resume_detection>
+
+<degrees_of_freedom>
+  Varies by mode:
+
+- **Autopilot**: LOW — Execute standard patterns decisively
+- **Confirm**: MEDIUM — Present plan, adjust based on feedback
+- **Validate**: LOW — Follow approved design precisely
+</degrees_of_freedom>
+
+<llm critical="true">
+  <mandate>USE SCRIPTS — NEVER bypass init-run.cjs or complete-run.cjs</mandate>
+  <mandate>ALWAYS CREATE plan.md — Create plan BEFORE implementation starts (ALL modes)</mandate>
+  <mandate>ALWAYS CREATE test-report.md — Create test report AFTER tests complete</mandate>
+  <mandate>ALWAYS RUN code-review — Invoke code-review skill after tests pass</mandate>
+  <mandate>ALWAYS COMMIT AFTER EACH WORK ITEM — Atomic commits per work item for git traceability</mandate>
+  <mandate>TRACK ALL FILE OPERATIONS — Every create, modify MUST be recorded</mandate>
+  <mandate>NEVER skip tests — Tests are mandatory, not optional</mandate>
+  <mandate>FOLLOW BROWNFIELD RULES — Read before write, match existing patterns</mandate>
+</llm>
+
+<artifact_timing critical="true">
+  Artifacts MUST be created at these points:
+
+  | Artifact | When Created | Created By |
+  |----------|--------------|------------|
+  | run.md | Start of run | init-run.cjs script |
+  | plan.md | BEFORE implementation (Step 4) | Agent using template |
+  | test-report.md | AFTER tests pass (Step 6) | Agent using template |
+  | review-report.md | AFTER test report (Step 6b) | code-review skill |
+  | git commit | AFTER code review (Step 6c) - ONCE PER WORK ITEM | commit-changes skill |
+  | walkthrough.md | After run completes (Step 8) | walkthrough-generate skill |
+
+  For batch runs: Append each work item's section to plan.md and test-report.md.
+  <critical>Git commit is performed ONCE PER WORK ITEM for traceability (atomic commits).</critical>
+</artifact_timing>
+
+<flow>
+  <step n="1" title="Initialize Run">
+    <critical>MUST call init-run.cjs script. DO NOT use mkdir directly.</critical>
+    <note>The script creates BOTH the folder AND run.md file.</note>
+
+    <action>Prepare work items JSON array:</action>
+    <code>
+      # For single item:
+      node scripts/init-run.cjs {rootPath} {workItemId} {intentId} {mode}
+
+      # For batch/wide (multiple items):
+      node scripts/init-run.cjs {rootPath} --batch '[
+        {"id": "item-1", "intent": "intent-1", "mode": "autopilot"},
+        {"id": "item-2", "intent": "intent-1", "mode": "confirm"}
+      ]' --scope=batch
+    </code>
+
+    <action>Parse script output for runId and runPath</action>
+    <action>Verify run.md was created in .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/</action>
+
+    <check if="run.md not found">
+      <error>init-run.cjs failed to create run.md. Check script output.</error>
+    </check>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="2" title="Load Work Item Context">
+    <note>For batch runs, repeat steps 2-6c for each work item</note>
+
+    <action>Get current_item from state.yaml runs.active[0]</action>
+    <action>Load work item from .specs-fire/intents/{intent}/work-items/{id}.md</action>
+    <action>Read intent brief for broader context</action>
+    <action>Load project standards using hierarchical resolution:</action>
+
+    <standards_resolution critical="true">
+      <substep n="2a" title="Discover Standards Locations">
+        <action>Scan repository for: **/.specs-fire/standards/</action>
+        <action>Build list sorted by path depth (root = depth 0)</action>
+        <example>
+          depth 0: .specs-fire/standards/
+          depth 2: packages/api/.specs-fire/standards/
+          depth 2: apps/mobile/.specs-fire/standards/
+        </example>
+      </substep>
+
+      <substep n="2b" title="Load Constitution (Root Only)">
+        <action>Load .specs-fire/standards/constitution.md from ROOT</action>
+        <critical>IGNORE any constitution.md in nested directories</critical>
+        <critical>Constitution is ALWAYS inherited, NEVER overridden</critical>
+        <note>If constitution.md doesn't exist, skip gracefully</note>
+      </substep>
+
+      <substep n="2c" title="Resolve Module Standards">
+        <action>For each discovered standards location (excluding root):</action>
+
+        <resolution_algorithm>
+          FOR each standard_file IN [tech-stack.md, coding-standards.md,
+                                      testing-standards.md, system-architecture.md]:
+
+            IF {location}/standards/{standard_file} EXISTS:
+              → USE this file for scope {location.parent_path}/**
+            ELSE:
+              → Walk UP to find nearest ancestor with this file
+              → USE ancestor's file (ultimately root if none found)
+        </resolution_algorithm>
+      </substep>
+
+      <substep n="2d" title="Present Standards with Scoping">
+        <action>Present loaded standards with clear path-based scoping:</action>
+
+        <output_format>
+          ## Constitution (applies to ALL files)
+          [content of root constitution.md]
+
+          ## Standards for {module_path}/** files
+          When editing files under {module_path}/, apply:
+          - Tech Stack: [resolved tech-stack.md for this scope]
+          - Coding Standards: [resolved coding-standards.md for this scope]
+          - Testing Standards: [resolved testing-standards.md for this scope]
+
+          ## Default Standards (paths without specific scope)
+          For all other files, apply root standards.
+        </output_format>
+      </substep>
+    </standards_resolution>
+
+    <action>Determine execution mode from work item</action>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="3a" title="Autopilot Mode" if="mode == autopilot">
+    <output>
+      Executing in Autopilot mode (0 checkpoints).
+      Work item: {title}
+    </output>
+    <goto step="4"/>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="3b" title="Confirm Mode" if="mode == confirm">
+    <action>Generate implementation plan</action>
+    <action>Save plan IMMEDIATELY using template: templates/plan.md.hbs</action>
+    <action>Write to: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/plan.md</action>
+    <output>Plan saved to: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/plan.md</output>
+
+    <checkpoint>
+      <template_output section="plan">
+        ## Implementation Plan for "{title}"
+
+        ### Approach
+        {describe approach}
+
+        ### Files to Create
+        {list files}
+
+        ### Files to Modify
+        {list files}
+
+        ### Tests
+        {list test files}
+
+        ---
+        Approve plan? [Y/n/edit]
+      </template_output>
+    </checkpoint>
+
+    <check if="response == edit">
+      <ask>What changes to the plan?</ask>
+      <action>Adjust plan</action>
+      <action>Update plan.md with changes</action>
+      <goto step="3b"/>
+    </check>
+    <goto step="5"/>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="3c" title="Validate Mode" if="mode == validate">
+    <action>Load design doc from .specs-fire/intents/{intent}/work-items/{id}-design.md</action>
+    <action>Generate implementation plan based on design</action>
+    <action>Save plan IMMEDIATELY using template: templates/plan.md.hbs</action>
+    <action>Write to: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/plan.md</action>
+    <action>Include reference to design doc in plan</action>
+    <output>Plan saved to: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/plan.md</output>
+
+    <checkpoint>
+      <template_output section="plan">
+        ## Implementation Plan for "{title}"
+
+        Based on approved design document.
+
+        ### Implementation Checklist
+        {from design doc}
+
+        ### Files to Create
+        {list files}
+
+        ### Files to Modify
+        {list files}
+
+        ---
+        This is Checkpoint 2 of Validate mode.
+        Approve implementation plan? [Y/n/edit]
+      </template_output>
+    </checkpoint>
+
+    <check if="response == edit">
+      <ask>What changes to the plan?</ask>
+      <action>Adjust plan</action>
+      <action>Update plan.md with changes</action>
+      <goto step="3c"/>
+    </check>
+    <goto step="5"/>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="4" title="Generate Plan (Autopilot Only)" if="mode == autopilot">
+    <note>Confirm and Validate modes already saved plan in Step 3b/3c</note>
+
+    <batch_handling critical="true">
+      <check if="batch/wide run AND plan.md already exists">
+        <action>Read existing plan.md content</action>
+        <action>Append new section for current work item:</action>
+        <format>
+          ---
+
+          ## Work Item: {work_item_id}
+
+          ### Approach
+          {describe approach for this specific work item}
+
+          ### Files to Create
+          {list files}
+
+          ### Files to Modify
+          {list files}
+
+          ### Tests
+          {list test files}
+        </format>
+        <action>Write updated plan.md (preserving previous sections)</action>
+      </check>
+
+      <check if="plan.md does not exist OR single run">
+        <action>Generate implementation plan</action>
+        <action>Save plan using template: templates/plan.md.hbs</action>
+        <action>Write to: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/plan.md</action>
+      </check>
+    </batch_handling>
+
+    <output>
+      Plan saved to: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/plan.md
+      (Autopilot mode - continuing without checkpoint)
+    </output>
+    <note>No checkpoint in autopilot - human can review plan.md while agent works</note>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="5" title="Execute Implementation">
+    <action>Update phase to 'execute':</action>
+    <code>node scripts/update-phase.cjs {rootPath} {runId} execute</code>
+
+    <action>For each planned change:</action>
+    <substep n="5a">Implement the change</substep>
+    <substep n="5b">Track file operation (create/modify)</substep>
+    <substep n="5c">Record decisions made</substep>
+
+    <standards_application critical="true">
+      When editing a file at path X:
+      1. Find the LONGEST matching standards scope (most specific)
+      2. Apply those standards to the file
+      3. If no specific scope matches, apply root standards
+
+      <example>
+        Editing packages/api/src/handler.go
+        → Apply "Standards for packages/api/**"
+
+        Editing scripts/deploy.sh
+        → Apply "Default Standards" (root)
+      </example>
+    </standards_application>
+
+    <brownfield_rules>
+      <rule>READ existing code before modifying</rule>
+      <rule>MATCH existing naming conventions</rule>
+      <rule>FOLLOW existing patterns in the codebase</rule>
+      <rule>PRESERVE existing tests</rule>
+      <rule>USE module-specific standards when editing module files</rule>
+    </brownfield_rules>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="6" title="Run Tests">
+    <action>Update phase to 'test':</action>
+    <code>node scripts/update-phase.cjs {rootPath} {runId} test</code>
+
+    <action>Load testing standards from .specs-fire/standards/testing-standards.md</action>
+    <action>Write tests following testing standards:</action>
+    <substep>Unit tests for new/modified functions</substep>
+    <substep>Integration tests for API endpoints or workflows</substep>
+    <substep>Follow test naming and structure conventions</substep>
+
+    <action>Run test suite</action>
+    <check if="tests fail">
+      <output>Tests failed. Fixing issues...</output>
+      <action>Fix failing tests</action>
+      <action>Re-run tests</action>
+    </check>
+
+    <action>Validate acceptance criteria from work item</action>
+
+    <critical>Create test report AFTER tests pass</critical>
+
+    <batch_handling critical="true">
+      <check if="batch/wide run AND test-report.md already exists">
+        <action>Read existing test-report.md content</action>
+        <action>Append new section for current work item:</action>
+        <format>
+          ---
+
+          ## Work Item: {work_item_id}
+
+          ### Test Results
+          - Passed: {passed_count}
+          - Failed: {failed_count}
+          - Skipped: {skipped_count}
+
+          ### Acceptance Criteria Validation
+          {validation_results}
+        </format>
+        <action>Write updated test-report.md (preserving previous sections)</action>
+      </check>
+
+      <check if="test-report.md does not exist OR single run">
+        <action>Generate test report using template: templates/test-report.md.hbs</action>
+        <action>Write to: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/test-report.md</action>
+      </check>
+    </batch_handling>
+
+    <action>Include in test report:</action>
+    <substep>Test results summary (passed/failed/skipped)</substep>
+    <substep>Code coverage percentage</substep>
+    <substep>Acceptance criteria validation results</substep>
+    <substep>Any test warnings or notes</substep>
+    <output>Test report saved to: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/test-report.md</output>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="6b" title="Code Review">
+    <action>Update phase to 'review':</action>
+    <code>node scripts/update-phase.cjs {rootPath} {runId} review</code>
+
+    <critical>ALWAYS run code review after tests pass</critical>
+    <output>Running code review...</output>
+
+    <action>Invoke code-review skill with context:</action>
+    <code>
+      invoke-skill: code-review
+      context:
+        files_created: {files_created}
+        files_modified: {files_modified}
+        run_id: {run_id}
+        intent_id: {intent_id}
+    </code>
+
+    <invoke_skill>code-review</invoke_skill>
+
+    <note>
+      Code review skill will:
+      1. Review all files created/modified in this work item
+      2. Auto-fix no-brainer issues (unused imports, console.log, etc.)
+      3. Present suggestions requiring approval
+      4. Create review-report.md artifact
+    </note>
+
+    <check if="code-review returns suggestions">
+      <note>User interaction happens within code-review skill</note>
+      <action>Wait for code-review skill to complete</action>
+    </check>
+
+    <check if="code-review applied fixes">
+      <action>Re-run tests to verify fixes didn't break anything</action>
+      <check if="tests fail">
+        <output>Code review fixes caused test failure. Reverting...</output>
+        <action>Revert code review changes</action>
+        <action>Re-run tests to confirm passing</action>
+      </check>
+    </check>
+
+    <output>
+      Code review complete.
+      Review report: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/review-report.md
+    </output>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="6c" title="Commit Changes">
+    <critical>ALWAYS commit after each work item completes for git traceability.</critical>
+    <output>Committing changes for work item: {work_item_id}...</output>
+
+    <action>Invoke commit-changes skill with context:</action>
+    <code>
+      node ../commit-changes/scripts/commit-changes.cjs {rootPath} {runId} \
+        --files-created='{files_created_json}' \
+        --files-modified='{files_modified_json}' \
+        --work-item-id={work_item_id} \
+        --work-item-title="{work_item_title}" \
+        --intent-id={intent_id}
+    </code>
+
+    <check if="commit succeeds">
+      <output>
+        Changes committed successfully.
+        Commit: {commit_hash}
+      </output>
+      <action>Store commit_hash for walkthrough inclusion</action>
+    </check>
+
+    <check if="commit was skipped">
+      <check if="reason == git_not_initialized">
+        <output>
+          Git not initialized. Skipping commit.
+          To enable automatic commits, run: git init
+        </output>
+      </check>
+      <check if="reason == no_code_changes">
+        <output>No code changes to commit (only .specs-fire artifacts).</output>
+      </check>
+      <check if="reason == pre_commit_hook_failed">
+        <output>
+          Pre-commit hook failed. Commit skipped.
+          Fix issues and commit manually, or skip hooks with --no-verify
+        </output>
+      </check>
+      <note>Continue with workflow - commit failure is not fatal</note>
+    </check>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="7" title="Complete Current Work Item">
+    <llm critical="true">
+      <mandate>BATCH RUNS: You MUST loop until ALL items are done</mandate>
+      <mandate>NEVER call --complete-run until ALL items have artifacts</mandate>
+      <mandate>ALWAYS check pending count BEFORE deciding which flag to use</mandate>
+    </llm>
+
+    <substep n="7a" title="Check Batch Status">
+      <action>Read state.yaml runs.active[{runId}]</action>
+      <action>Get scope value: single, batch, or wide</action>
+      <action>Count work_items where status == "pending"</action>
+      <action>Store pending_count for decision</action>
+    </substep>
+
+    <substep n="7b" title="Route Based on Batch Status">
+      <check if="scope in [batch, wide] AND pending_count > 0">
+        <critical>DO NOT call --complete-run yet - more items remain!</critical>
+        <action>Call complete-run.cjs with --complete-item flag:</action>
+        <code>
+          node scripts/complete-run.cjs {rootPath} {runId} --complete-item
+        </code>
+        <action>Parse output JSON for nextItem and remainingItems</action>
+        <output>
+          Completed: {current_item}
+          Next item: {nextItem}
+          Remaining: {remainingItems} items
+        </output>
+        <goto step="2">MUST continue with next work item - loop back NOW</goto>
+      </check>
+
+      <check if="scope == single OR pending_count == 0">
+        <action>All items complete - finalize the run</action>
+        <action>Call complete-run.cjs with --complete-run flag:</action>
+        <code>
+          node scripts/complete-run.cjs {rootPath} {runId} --complete-run \
+            --files-created='[{"path":"...","purpose":"..."}]' \
+            --files-modified='[{"path":"...","changes":"..."}]' \
+            --tests=5 --coverage=85
+        </code>
+        <goto step="8"/>
+      </check>
+    </substep>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="8" title="Generate Walkthrough">
+    <invoke_skill>walkthrough-generate</invoke_skill>
+  </step>
+
+  <step n="9" title="Report Completion">
+    <output>
+      Run {run-id} completed.
+
+      Work items completed: {count}
+      Files created: {count}
+      Files modified: {count}
+      Tests added: {count}
+
+      Artifacts:
+      - Run Log: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/run.md
+      - Plan: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/plan.md
+      - Test Report: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/test-report.md
+      - Code Review: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/review-report.md
+      - Walkthrough: .specs-fire/runs/{run-id}/walkthrough.md
+    </output>
+  </step>
+</flow>
+
+<scripts>
+  | Script | Purpose | Usage |
+  |--------|---------|-------|
+  | `scripts/init-run.cjs` | Initialize run record and folder | Creates run.md with all work items |
+  | `scripts/update-phase.cjs` | Update current work item's phase | `node scripts/update-phase.cjs {rootPath} {runId} {phase}` |
+  | `scripts/complete-run.cjs` | Finalize run and update state | `--complete-item` or `--complete-run` |
+  | `../commit-changes/scripts/commit-changes.cjs` | Commit changes to git | `node ../commit-changes/scripts/commit-changes.cjs {rootPath} {runId} [options]` |
+
+  <script name="init-run.cjs">
+    ```bash
+    # Single work item
+    node scripts/init-run.cjs /project work-item-id intent-id autopilot
+
+    # Batch/wide (multiple items)
+    node scripts/init-run.cjs /project --batch '[
+      {"id": "wi-1", "intent": "int-1", "mode": "autopilot"},
+      {"id": "wi-2", "intent": "int-1", "mode": "confirm"}
+    ]' --scope=batch
+    ```
+
+    <output_format>
+      ```json
+      {
+        "success": true,
+        "runId": "run-001",
+        "runPath": "/project/.specs-fire/runs/run-001",
+        "scope": "batch",
+        "workItems": [...],
+        "currentItem": "wi-1"
+      }
+      ```
+    </output_format>
+  </script>
+
+  <script name="complete-run.cjs">
+    ```bash
+    # Complete current item (batch runs - moves to next item)
+    node scripts/complete-run.cjs /project run-001 --complete-item
+
+    # Complete entire run (single runs or final item in batch)
+    node scripts/complete-run.cjs /project run-001 --complete-run \
+      --files-created='[{"path":"src/new.ts","purpose":"New feature"}]' \
+      --files-modified='[{"path":"src/old.ts","changes":"Added import"}]' \
+      --tests=5 --coverage=85
+    ```
+
+    <complete_item_output>
+      ```json
+      {
+        "success": true,
+        "runId": "run-001",
+        "completedItem": "wi-1",
+        "nextItem": "wi-2",
+        "remainingItems": 1,
+        "allItemsCompleted": false
+      }
+      ```
+    </complete_item_output>
+
+    <complete_run_output>
+      ```json
+      {
+        "success": true,
+        "runId": "run-001",
+        "scope": "batch",
+        "workItemsCompleted": 2,
+        "completedAt": "2026-01-20T..."
+      }
+      ```
+    </complete_run_output>
+  </script>
+</scripts>
+
+<file_tracking_format>
+
+  ```yaml
+  files_created:
+    - path: src/auth/login.ts
+      purpose: Login endpoint handler
+
+  files_modified:
+    - path: src/routes/index.ts
+      changes: Added login route
+
+  decisions:
+    - decision: Use JWT for tokens
+      rationale: Stateless, works with load balancer
+  ```
+
+</file_tracking_format>
+
+<run_folder_structure>
+  After init-run.cjs creates a run:
+
+  ```
+  .specs-fire/runs/run-001/
+  ├── run.md           # Created by init-run.cjs, updated by complete-run.cjs
+  ├── plan.md          # Created BEFORE implementation (ALL modes - required)
+  ├── test-report.md   # Created AFTER tests pass (required)
+  ├── review-report.md # Created by code-review skill (Step 6b)
+  └── walkthrough.md   # Created by walkthrough-generate skill
+  ```
+
+  <timeline>
+    1. `run.md` — Created at run start by init-run.cjs
+    2. `plan.md` — Created BEFORE implementation begins (Step 4)
+    3. `test-report.md` — Created AFTER tests pass (Step 6)
+    4. `review-report.md` — Created by code-review skill (Step 6b)
+    5. `walkthrough.md` — Created after run completes (Step 8)
+  </timeline>
+
+  The run.md contains:
+
+- All work items with their statuses
+- Current item being executed
+- Files created/modified (after completion)
+- Decisions made (after completion)
+- Commit hash (if commit was successful)
+- Summary (after completion)
+</run_folder_structure>
+
+<success_criteria>
+  <criterion>Run initialized via init-run.cjs script</criterion>
+  <criterion>Standards loaded with hierarchical resolution</criterion>
+  <criterion>Constitution loaded from root (if exists)</criterion>
+  <criterion>Module-specific standards applied to module files</criterion>
+  <criterion>plan.md created BEFORE implementation</criterion>
+  <criterion>All work items implemented</criterion>
+  <criterion>All tests pass</criterion>
+  <criterion>test-report.md created AFTER tests pass</criterion>
+  <criterion>code-review skill invoked and completed</criterion>
+  <criterion>review-report.md created</criterion>
+  <criterion>commit-changes skill invoked (skipped gracefully if git unavailable)</criterion>
+  <criterion>Run completed via complete-run.cjs script</criterion>
+  <criterion>walkthrough.md generated</criterion>
+</success_criteria>