@vpxa/aikit 0.1.74 → 0.1.75

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (134) hide show
  1. package/package.json +6 -1
  2. package/packages/cli/dist/index.js +2 -2
  3. package/packages/cli/dist/{init-DQkar6Es.js → init-CuRXmyD9.js} +1 -1
  4. package/packages/cli/dist/scaffold-WMQ2uQ48.js +2 -0
  5. package/packages/cli/dist/{user-CopNWxHP.js → user-vbJwa7x2.js} +1 -1
  6. package/scaffold/dist/adapters/claude-code.mjs +4 -0
  7. package/scaffold/dist/adapters/copilot.mjs +75 -0
  8. package/scaffold/dist/adapters/flows.mjs +1 -0
  9. package/scaffold/dist/adapters/skills.mjs +1 -0
  10. package/scaffold/{compiled → dist/compiled}/flows-data.mjs +304 -446
  11. package/scaffold/{compiled → dist/compiled}/skills-data.mjs +554 -2281
  12. package/scaffold/dist/definitions/agents.mjs +9 -0
  13. package/scaffold/{definitions → dist/definitions}/bodies.mjs +6 -229
  14. package/scaffold/dist/definitions/exclusions.mjs +1 -0
  15. package/scaffold/dist/definitions/hooks.mjs +1 -0
  16. package/scaffold/dist/definitions/models.mjs +1 -0
  17. package/scaffold/dist/definitions/plugins.mjs +1 -0
  18. package/scaffold/{definitions → dist/definitions}/prompts.mjs +9 -149
  19. package/scaffold/{definitions → dist/definitions}/protocols.mjs +9 -37
  20. package/scaffold/dist/definitions/tools.mjs +1 -0
  21. package/packages/cli/dist/scaffold-ukCDW3wQ.js +0 -2
  22. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Architect-Reviewer-Alpha.agent.md +0 -132
  23. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Architect-Reviewer-Beta.agent.md +0 -132
  24. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Code-Reviewer-Alpha.agent.md +0 -112
  25. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Code-Reviewer-Beta.agent.md +0 -112
  26. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Debugger.agent.md +0 -412
  27. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Documenter.agent.md +0 -468
  28. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Explorer.agent.md +0 -76
  29. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Frontend.agent.md +0 -440
  30. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Implementer.agent.md +0 -425
  31. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Orchestrator.agent.md +0 -452
  32. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Planner.agent.md +0 -481
  33. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/README.md +0 -57
  34. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Refactor.agent.md +0 -435
  35. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Researcher-Alpha.agent.md +0 -151
  36. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Researcher-Beta.agent.md +0 -152
  37. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Researcher-Delta.agent.md +0 -153
  38. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Researcher-Gamma.agent.md +0 -152
  39. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/Security.agent.md +0 -433
  40. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/_shared/architect-reviewer-base.md +0 -104
  41. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/_shared/code-agent-base.md +0 -366
  42. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/_shared/code-reviewer-base.md +0 -87
  43. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/_shared/decision-protocol.md +0 -27
  44. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/_shared/forge-protocol.md +0 -90
  45. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/_shared/researcher-base.md +0 -114
  46. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/templates/adr-template.md +0 -28
  47. package/scaffold/_preview/agents/templates/execution-state.md +0 -26
  48. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/_epilogue/steps/docs-sync/README.md +0 -120
  49. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-advanced/README.md +0 -70
  50. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-advanced/steps/design/README.md +0 -178
  51. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-advanced/steps/execute/README.md +0 -145
  52. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-advanced/steps/plan/README.md +0 -122
  53. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-advanced/steps/spec/README.md +0 -121
  54. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-advanced/steps/task/README.md +0 -119
  55. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-advanced/steps/verify/README.md +0 -145
  56. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-basic/README.md +0 -51
  57. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-basic/steps/assess/README.md +0 -109
  58. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-basic/steps/design/README.md +0 -116
  59. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-basic/steps/implement/README.md +0 -131
  60. package/scaffold/_preview/flows/aikit-basic/steps/verify/README.md +0 -123
  61. package/scaffold/_preview/prompts/aikit-ask.prompt.md +0 -13
  62. package/scaffold/_preview/prompts/aikit-debug.prompt.md +0 -15
  63. package/scaffold/_preview/prompts/aikit-design.prompt.md +0 -15
  64. package/scaffold/_preview/prompts/aikit-flow-add.prompt.md +0 -84
  65. package/scaffold/_preview/prompts/aikit-flow-create.prompt.md +0 -80
  66. package/scaffold/_preview/prompts/aikit-flow-manage.prompt.md +0 -24
  67. package/scaffold/_preview/prompts/aikit-implement.prompt.md +0 -17
  68. package/scaffold/_preview/prompts/aikit-plan.prompt.md +0 -15
  69. package/scaffold/_preview/prompts/aikit-review.prompt.md +0 -24
  70. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/SKILL.md +0 -335
  71. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/assets/templates/adr-madr.md +0 -89
  72. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/assets/templates/adr-readme.md +0 -20
  73. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/assets/templates/adr-simple.md +0 -46
  74. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/references/adr-conventions.md +0 -95
  75. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/references/examples.md +0 -193
  76. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/references/review-checklist.md +0 -77
  77. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/references/template-variants.md +0 -52
  78. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/scripts/bootstrap_adr.js +0 -259
  79. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/scripts/new_adr.js +0 -391
  80. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/adr-skill/scripts/set_adr_status.js +0 -169
  81. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/aikit/SKILL.md +0 -754
  82. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/brainstorming/SKILL.md +0 -265
  83. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/brainstorming/spec-document-reviewer-prompt.md +0 -49
  84. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/c4-architecture/SKILL.md +0 -389
  85. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/c4-architecture/references/advanced-patterns.md +0 -552
  86. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/c4-architecture/references/c4-syntax.md +0 -510
  87. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/c4-architecture/references/common-mistakes.md +0 -437
  88. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/c4-architecture/references/html-design-system.md +0 -337
  89. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/c4-architecture/references/html-template.html +0 -627
  90. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/SKILL.md +0 -553
  91. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/references/diataxis-anti-patterns.md +0 -147
  92. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/references/diataxis-compass.md +0 -123
  93. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/references/diataxis-quadrants.md +0 -192
  94. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/references/diataxis-quality.md +0 -76
  95. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/references/diataxis-templates.md +0 -120
  96. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/references/flow-artifacts-guide.md +0 -70
  97. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/references/project-knowledge-gotchas.md +0 -32
  98. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/references/project-knowledge-templates.md +0 -281
  99. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/docs/references/project-knowledge-workflow.md +0 -80
  100. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/frontend-design/SKILL.md +0 -237
  101. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/lesson-learned/SKILL.md +0 -113
  102. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/lesson-learned/references/anti-patterns.md +0 -55
  103. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/lesson-learned/references/se-principles.md +0 -109
  104. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/multi-agents-development/SKILL.md +0 -448
  105. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/multi-agents-development/architecture-review-prompt.md +0 -81
  106. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/multi-agents-development/code-quality-review-prompt.md +0 -91
  107. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/multi-agents-development/implementer-prompt.md +0 -93
  108. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/multi-agents-development/parallel-dispatch-example.md +0 -167
  109. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/multi-agents-development/spec-review-prompt.md +0 -81
  110. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/present/SKILL.md +0 -616
  111. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/react/SKILL.md +0 -309
  112. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/repo-access/SKILL.md +0 -178
  113. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/repo-access/references/error-patterns.md +0 -116
  114. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/repo-access/references/platform-matrix.md +0 -142
  115. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/requirements-clarity/SKILL.md +0 -333
  116. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/session-handoff/SKILL.md +0 -199
  117. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/session-handoff/references/handoff-template.md +0 -139
  118. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/session-handoff/references/resume-checklist.md +0 -80
  119. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/session-handoff/scripts/check_staleness.js +0 -269
  120. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/session-handoff/scripts/create_handoff.js +0 -299
  121. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/session-handoff/scripts/list_handoffs.js +0 -113
  122. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/session-handoff/scripts/validate_handoff.js +0 -241
  123. package/scaffold/_preview/skills/typescript/SKILL.md +0 -405
  124. package/scaffold/adapters/claude-code.mjs +0 -73
  125. package/scaffold/adapters/copilot.mjs +0 -292
  126. package/scaffold/adapters/flows.mjs +0 -27
  127. package/scaffold/adapters/skills.mjs +0 -25
  128. package/scaffold/definitions/agents.mjs +0 -266
  129. package/scaffold/definitions/exclusions.mjs +0 -58
  130. package/scaffold/definitions/hooks.mjs +0 -43
  131. package/scaffold/definitions/models.mjs +0 -84
  132. package/scaffold/definitions/plugins.mjs +0 -147
  133. package/scaffold/definitions/tools.mjs +0 -250
  134. package/scaffold/generate.mjs +0 -92
@@ -1,93 +0,0 @@
1
- # Implementer Dispatch Prompt Template
2
-
3
- Use this template when dispatching **Implementer**, **Frontend**, or **Refactor** agents.
4
-
5
- Fill in the bracketed sections with task-specific content. The Orchestrator provides ALL context — the subagent should NOT need to search/explore.
6
-
7
- ---
8
-
9
- ## Prompt Template
10
-
11
- ```markdown
12
- You are implementing a focused task. All context you need is provided below. Do NOT search for additional files or read the full plan — work only within the scope defined here.
13
-
14
- ## 1. Scope
15
- **Files to create/modify:**
16
- - [exact/path/to/file1.ts] — [create | modify]
17
- - [exact/path/to/file2.ts] — [create | modify]
18
-
19
- **Boundary — do NOT touch:**
20
- - [files/that/are/off/limits.ts]
21
- - [other/agents/territory/]
22
-
23
- ## 2. Goal
24
- [Clear description of what the code should do]
25
-
26
- **Acceptance criteria:**
27
- - [ ] [Specific, testable criterion 1]
28
- - [ ] [Specific, testable criterion 2]
29
- - [ ] [Specific, testable criterion 3]
30
-
31
- ## 3. Architectural Context
32
- [Relevant code snippets, patterns, conventions from compact/digest — paste actual code, don't reference files]
33
-
34
- Example existing pattern:
35
- \`\`\`typescript
36
- // From services/auth.service.ts — follow this pattern
37
- export class AuthService {
38
- constructor(private readonly repo: AuthRepository) {}
39
- async validate(token: string): Promise<User> { ... }
40
- }
41
- \`\`\`
42
-
43
- ## 4. Constraints
44
- - Follow [specific pattern/convention]
45
- - Use [specific library/approach]
46
- - Do NOT [specific anti-pattern to avoid]
47
- - [Any other boundaries]
48
-
49
- ## 5. FORGE Context
50
- **Tier:** [Floor | Standard | Critical]
51
- **Evidence requirements:** [What evidence to collect — test results, type coverage, etc.]
52
-
53
- ## 6. Self-Review Checklist
54
- Before declaring your status, verify ALL:
55
- - [ ] All acceptance criteria from §2 are met
56
- - [ ] No files outside §1 scope were modified
57
- - [ ] Code follows conventions from §3 and constraints from §4
58
- - [ ] Tests pass (run them if possible)
59
- - [ ] No TODO/FIXME/HACK left without justification
60
- - [ ] No hardcoded values that should be configurable
61
-
62
- ---
63
-
64
- **STATUS PROTOCOL — End your response with EXACTLY ONE:**
65
-
66
- ### DONE
67
- All tasks complete. Self-review checklist passed. Ready for review.
68
-
69
- ### DONE_WITH_CONCERNS
70
- All tasks complete, but I have concerns:
71
- - [Concern 1: description + suggested resolution]
72
- - [Concern 2: description + suggested resolution]
73
-
74
- ### NEEDS_CONTEXT
75
- Cannot proceed without the following:
76
- - [Specific question or missing information]
77
-
78
- ### BLOCKED
79
- Hit a wall and cannot proceed:
80
- - [Description of blocker]
81
- - [What I tried]
82
- - [Suggestion for resolution]
83
- ```
84
-
85
- ---
86
-
87
- ## Usage Notes
88
-
89
- - **Always paste actual code snippets** in §3 — use `compact()` or `digest()` to extract relevant context before crafting the prompt
90
- - **Keep scope tight** — 1-3 files maximum per dispatch
91
- - **Include failing test output** if dispatching a bug fix
92
- - **For Frontend agent**: add design requirements, responsive breakpoints, component hierarchy
93
- - **For Refactor agent**: include before/after expectations, what specifically to clean up
@@ -1,167 +0,0 @@
1
- # Parallel Dispatch Worked Example
2
-
3
- This example shows how the Orchestrator decomposes a feature into parallel tasks, crafts context for each subagent, and manages the batch through review.
4
-
5
- ---
6
-
7
- ## Scenario: Add User Notification Preferences
8
-
9
- **User request:** "Add a notification preferences page where users can toggle email, push, and in-app notifications per category (marketing, security, product updates)."
10
-
11
- ---
12
-
13
- ## Step 1: Scope Map & Decomposition
14
-
15
- Orchestrator runs `scope_map({ task: "notification preferences" })` and identifies:
16
-
17
- | Area | Files | Agent |
18
- |------|-------|-------|
19
- | Backend API | `services/notification-prefs.service.ts`, `routes/notification-prefs.route.ts` | Implementer |
20
- | Database | `migrations/add-notification-prefs.ts`, `models/notification-prefs.model.ts` | Implementer |
21
- | Frontend Page | `pages/settings/notifications.tsx`, `components/NotificationToggle.tsx` | Frontend |
22
- | Tests | `__tests__/notification-prefs.test.ts` | Implementer |
23
-
24
- ## Step 2: Independence Check (5-Question Checklist)
25
-
26
- | # | Question | Backend API + DB | Frontend Page |
27
- |---|----------|-----------------|---------------|
28
- | 1 | Same files? | `services/`, `routes/`, `migrations/`, `models/` | `pages/`, `components/` |
29
- | 2 | Shared state? | No — backend defines API contract | No — consumes API contract |
30
- | 3 | Execution order? | No — can define API while UI is built | No — can mock API response |
31
- | 4 | Shared new types? | Exports `NotificationPrefs` type | Imports same type |
32
- | 5 | Parallel-safe? | ✅ Yes — different directories | ✅ Yes — different directories |
33
-
34
- **Decision: PARALLEL** — But first define the shared type contract.
35
-
36
- ## Step 3: Shared Context Prep
37
-
38
- Before dispatching, Orchestrator creates the shared contract:
39
-
40
- ```typescript
41
- // Type contract — paste into BOTH agent prompts
42
- interface NotificationPrefs {
43
- userId: string;
44
- categories: {
45
- marketing: { email: boolean; push: boolean; inApp: boolean };
46
- security: { email: boolean; push: boolean; inApp: boolean };
47
- product: { email: boolean; push: boolean; inApp: boolean };
48
- };
49
- updatedAt: Date;
50
- }
51
-
52
- // API contract
53
- // GET /api/notifications/preferences → NotificationPrefs
54
- // PUT /api/notifications/preferences → NotificationPrefs (body: Partial<NotificationPrefs['categories']>)
55
- ```
56
-
57
- ## Step 4: Parallel Dispatch
58
-
59
- ### Dispatch A → Implementer (Backend + DB + Tests)
60
-
61
- ```markdown
62
- You are implementing a focused task. All context below.
63
-
64
- ## 1. Scope
65
- - services/notification-prefs.service.ts — create
66
- - routes/notification-prefs.route.ts — create
67
- - migrations/add-notification-prefs.ts — create
68
- - models/notification-prefs.model.ts — create
69
- - __tests__/notification-prefs.test.ts — create
70
-
71
- ## 2. Goal
72
- Create backend API for notification preferences CRUD.
73
- - GET endpoint returns current prefs (default all-true for new users)
74
- - PUT endpoint updates partial categories
75
- - Migration creates notification_preferences table
76
-
77
- ## 3. Architectural Context
78
- [Paste existing service pattern from compact()]
79
- [Paste existing route pattern from compact()]
80
- [Paste existing migration pattern from compact()]
81
- [Paste the shared type contract above]
82
-
83
- ## 4. Constraints
84
- - Follow existing repository pattern (see §3)
85
- - Use Zod for request validation
86
- - Include unit tests for service layer
87
-
88
- ## 5. FORGE Context
89
- Tier: Standard. Evidence: test pass, type coverage.
90
-
91
- ## 6. Self-Review Checklist
92
- [standard checklist]
93
-
94
- STATUS PROTOCOL: DONE / DONE_WITH_CONCERNS / NEEDS_CONTEXT / BLOCKED
95
- ```
96
-
97
- ### Dispatch B → Frontend (UI Page + Components)
98
-
99
- ```markdown
100
- You are implementing a focused task. All context below.
101
-
102
- ## 1. Scope
103
- - pages/settings/notifications.tsx — create
104
- - components/NotificationToggle.tsx — create
105
-
106
- ## 2. Goal
107
- Create notification preferences settings page.
108
- - Grid layout: rows = categories, columns = channels
109
- - Toggle switches for each cell
110
- - Auto-save on toggle (optimistic update with rollback)
111
- - Loading skeleton on initial fetch
112
-
113
- ## 3. Architectural Context
114
- [Paste existing settings page pattern from compact()]
115
- [Paste existing toggle component from compact()]
116
- [Paste the shared type contract + API contract above]
117
-
118
- ## 4. Constraints
119
- - Use existing Toggle component from design system
120
- - Follow settings page layout pattern
121
- - Mobile responsive (stack columns on small screens)
122
- - Mock API response for now: GET returns all-true defaults
123
-
124
- ## 5. FORGE Context
125
- Tier: Floor. Evidence: renders without error.
126
-
127
- ## 6. Self-Review Checklist
128
- [standard checklist]
129
-
130
- STATUS PROTOCOL: DONE / DONE_WITH_CONCERNS / NEEDS_CONTEXT / BLOCKED
131
- ```
132
-
133
- ## Step 5: Review Pipeline
134
-
135
- Both agents return DONE. Orchestrator runs review:
136
-
137
- 1. **Spec Review** (Code-Reviewer-Alpha as spec reviewer):
138
- - Backend: PASS — all acceptance criteria met
139
- - Frontend: PASS_WITH_NOTES — missing keyboard accessibility on toggles
140
-
141
- 2. **Code Quality Review** (Alpha + Beta in parallel):
142
- - Alpha: APPROVE_WITH_SUGGESTIONS — extract validation schema to shared file
143
- - Beta: APPROVE — clean implementation
144
-
145
- 3. **Architecture Review** (not triggered — no boundary changes)
146
-
147
- 4. **FORGE Gate**: `evidence_map({ action: "gate" })` → YIELD (all evidence collected)
148
-
149
- ## Step 6: Commit
150
-
151
- ```
152
- feat: add notification preferences page
153
-
154
- - Backend: CRUD API for notification preferences per category
155
- - Frontend: Settings page with toggle grid, auto-save
156
- - Migration: notification_preferences table
157
- ```
158
-
159
- ---
160
-
161
- ## Key Takeaways
162
-
163
- 1. **Define shared contracts FIRST** — paste into all agent prompts
164
- 2. **Independence check takes 30 seconds** — prevents hours of merge conflicts
165
- 3. **Each agent gets ONLY its files** — focused context = better output
166
- 4. **Review is sequential** — spec first, then quality, then architecture (conditional)
167
- 5. **FORGE gates at the end** — not between every step
@@ -1,81 +0,0 @@
1
- # Spec Compliance Review Prompt Template
2
-
3
- Use this template when dispatching **Code-Reviewer-Alpha** for adversarial spec compliance review. This review runs BEFORE code quality review.
4
-
5
- **Mindset: "Don't trust the report."** The implementer says it's done — verify independently.
6
-
7
- ---
8
-
9
- ## Prompt Template
10
-
11
- ```markdown
12
- You are performing an adversarial spec compliance review. Your job is to verify that the implementation matches what was requested — nothing more, nothing less.
13
-
14
- **Do NOT trust the implementer's self-assessment.** Verify independently.
15
-
16
- ## Task Specification
17
- [Paste the original task that was dispatched to the implementer — including all acceptance criteria]
18
-
19
- ## Implementation Output
20
- [Paste the implementer's response — code changes, self-review, status]
21
-
22
- ## Files Changed
23
- [List of files modified with brief description of changes]
24
-
25
- ---
26
-
27
- ## Review Dimensions
28
-
29
- ### 1. Acceptance Criteria Match
30
- For EACH acceptance criterion in the task spec:
31
- - [ ] **Met** / **Not Met** / **Partially Met**
32
- - Evidence: [specific code or test that proves it]
33
-
34
- ### 2. Over-Build Detection
35
- - Are there features, functions, or abstractions NOT requested in the spec?
36
- - Are there unnecessary generalizations?
37
- - Were files modified outside the stated scope?
38
- → Flag each over-build with: what was added, why it shouldn't be there
39
-
40
- ### 3. Under-Build Detection
41
- - Are any acceptance criteria unaddressed?
42
- - Are there edge cases implied by the spec but not handled?
43
- - Are there missing tests for stated requirements?
44
- → Flag each under-build with: what's missing, what should exist
45
-
46
- ### 4. Scope Compliance
47
- - List every file modified — does it match the scope in the original task?
48
- - Were any out-of-scope files touched? (this is a red flag)
49
-
50
- ### 5. Contract Adherence
51
- - Do new exports/interfaces match what other components expect?
52
- - Are function signatures compatible with existing callers?
53
- - Will this break anything downstream?
54
-
55
- ---
56
-
57
- ## Output Format
58
-
59
- ### Verdict: [PASS | PASS_WITH_NOTES | FAIL]
60
-
61
- **PASS** — Implementation matches spec completely.
62
- **PASS_WITH_NOTES** — Matches spec but has minor concerns that don't block.
63
- **FAIL** — Implementation does not match spec. List specific gaps.
64
-
65
- ### Findings:
66
- | # | Type | Severity | Description | Location |
67
- |---|------|----------|-------------|----------|
68
- | 1 | [Over/Under/Scope/Contract] | [Critical/Major/Minor] | [Description] | [file:line] |
69
-
70
- ### Recommendation:
71
- [What needs to change before this passes spec review]
72
- ```
73
-
74
- ---
75
-
76
- ## Usage Notes
77
-
78
- - Run this BEFORE code quality review — no point reviewing quality if spec is wrong
79
- - Paste the ORIGINAL task spec, not a summary — the reviewer needs exact acceptance criteria
80
- - If verdict is FAIL, bounce back to implementer with specific gaps before proceeding
81
- - PASS_WITH_NOTES can proceed to code quality review, but notes should be tracked