@untangle-code/cli 0.0.0-stage → 0.1.1

package/src/commands/watch/README.md

@@ -0,0 +1,160 @@
+# `untangle watch` — complexity watcher (WP-128)
+
+> Achieving the same functionality with less structural, semantic, cyclomatic and cognitive
+> complexity is better code, subject to preserved behavior and interfaces. — `vision.md` §1b
+
+This directory contains the standalone complexity watcher. Its entry can be built with
+`pnpm --filter @untangle-code/cli run build:watch`; index-watch mode delegates to the complete
+CLI build.
+
+## 1. What it measures
+
+The running stream combines:
+
+| Package | Responsibility |
+|---|---|
+| `@untangle-code/scanner` | Baseline inclusion/exclusion and reasons. |
+| `@untangle-code/watcher` | Native events, debounce, reconciliation and ref lock. |
+| `@untangle-code/jobs` | BoundedQueue backpressure with visible byte budget. |
+| `@untangle-code/parser-registry` | Language adapters, syntax trees and facts. |
+| `@untangle-code/chunker` | Semantic load from `CodeChunkDraft.tokenEstimate`. |
+| `@untangle-code/complexity` | Three scope metrics and aggregation without double counting. |
+
+Each change reports metric deltas, direction and contributing scopes. Direction and
+contribution sites matter together; a bare number hides where responsibility changed.
+Human output is English. Legacy machine values `abgebaut`, `aufgebaut`, `unveraendert`
+remain stable in JSON and mean decreased, increased and unchanged respectively.
+
+## 2. Four measurements
+
+Three are scope measurements aggregated through `metrics_scope_id` using
+`execution_unit` from `packages/complexity/src/scope-aggregate.ts`: each outer execution
+unit once, including nested closures without adding them again. Every output names its
+reading.
+
+| Metric | Source | Specification |
+|---|---|---|
+| `cognitive` | IR `computeCognitive`, `untangle-cognitive-v1` | §16.4 |
+| `cyclomatic` | `computeCyclomatic(...).extended` | §16.3 |
+| `structural` | `parameter_count + return_count + exit_point_count` | §16.5 |
+
+Only structural counts can be summed/disjointly decomposed here. Parent SLOC includes child
+lines, while max nesting is a maximum; summing either would double count or lose meaning.
+
+The fourth deliberately is not a scope measurement:
+
+| Metric | Source | Reading |
+|---|---|---|
+| `semantic` | Sum of file chunk `tokenEstimate` | `file_chunks` |
+
+It estimates how much context must be loaded for the file. This Untangle-local reading is
+not a `spec.md` §16 metric; its provenance remains explicit and it is never reported as one.
+
+## 3. Evidence limits
+
+The vision's improvement claim also requires preserved public symbols/tests and no new
+dependency edges. Watch measures **complexity only**. A decrease is not proof that a change
+improved the product.
+
+The overall direction counts measurements, not magnitudes: tokens cannot be added to
+cognitive points. Ties are unchanged rather than a fabricated common score.
+
+## 4. E4 at the interface
+
+Unanalyzed files appear in the same stream as measured files, with reason/stage and details
+such as partial parse quality/error-node coverage. They contribute no unreliable complexity
+or misleading deltas; later retries can recover. Silent omission would look like no change.
+
+Ignore-rule exclusions are a deliberate exception: `.gitignore`/default-rule omissions are
+reported in baseline `filesExcludedByRules`, not one event per path. Ordinary repositories
+can have thousands; flooding the stream would hide actual E4 events. Non-rule exclusions
+such as binary content, size and unreadable input get individual events.
+
+Each measurement also reports limitations in `notes`: ambiguous adapter scope IDs, missing
+`SourceRange` on NodeKind facts and chunker degradation.
+
+## 5. Output
+
+```text
+--format text   Human-readable stream (default); color only on a TTY
+--format json   One JSON object per event (JSONL)
+--out PATH      Also retain the same stream without color
+```
+
+Text/JSON derive from identical `events.ts` values. Transcripts contain no terminal control
+codes.
+
+## 6. Shutdown
+
+SIGINT/SIGTERM triggers exactly one teardown sequence:
+
+1. Remove signal handlers so a second Ctrl-C can force termination.
+2. Stop RepoWatcher timers/watch loop and release its ref lock.
+3. Close/drain the queue.
+4. Inspect lock state rather than assert it was released.
+5. Write completion and close the transcript.
+
+The final event includes elapsed time, processed/unanalyzed counts, net measurement change,
+queue high-water count/bytes, budget exceptions and observed lock status.
+
+## 7. Decisions
+
+### Watch the search index
+
+`watch --index` is a separate mode. At startup and each reconciliation interval, the same
+scanner as query refresh checks hashes, index configuration and tokenizer contract. A stale,
+incompatible or missing index triggers one serialized indexing run followed by a fresh check.
+
+```bash
+untangle watch --index --reconcile=30000
+untangle watch --index --repo=backend --embedder=offline --format=json
+untangle watch --index --baseline-only
+```
+
+Multiple repositories require `--repo`; `--ref` must identify a physically checked-out ref.
+Auto uses the current index profile, or configured service if no index exists. Offline
+explicitly selects the network-free profile.
+
+JSONL events use `kind: index_watch`, repository/ref and freshness. Index reports/progress
+stay on stderr; `--out` additionally saves the event stream. Baseline-only performs one
+check and any necessary update. `--exit-after=N` ends after N updates; bounded execution
+succeeds only if the final check confirms freshness. Errors retain their CLI exits.
+SIGINT/SIGTERM propagates to indexing and exits 130 after cleanup. Direct standalone
+`dist/commands/watch/cli.js --index` delegates to the full build; `build:watch` remains usable.
+
+1. **BoundedQueue instead of IndexJobRunner.** Pure complexity watch needs neither embedding
+   nor storage stages. It uses job backpressure/byte-budget machinery without requiring
+   Ollama/Qdrant to reach completion (`architecture.md` §13.2).
+2. **A second scope key.** Byte-range metrics IDs correctly identify a measurement scope but
+   shift after inserted lines. Cross-state matching therefore uses `matchKey` from the
+   original adapter ID plus ordinal. Aggregation still uses `metrics_scope_id`.
+3. **Retain the last measurable value after a parse failure.** A partially saved file should
+   compare its next successful parse to its last measurable state, not to nothing. The
+   intermediate failure is explicit `unanalyzed` evidence.
+4. **Check invariants before totaling.** `aggregateScopeTree` throws on violations. Watch
+   checks tree invariants and all scope coverage per metric first, reporting an inconsistent
+   tree as unanalyzed with its first violations rather than crashing or producing totals.
+5. **Closed option parsing.** Unknown options are errors, never silently ignored; ignored
+   flags could change what is measured without telling the user.
+
+## 8. Known limits
+
+- Only the root `.gitignore` is installed in the watcher predicate; baseline scanning supports
+  nested layers. Reconciliation provides no file/directory distinction, so the predicate
+  asks IgnoreEngine both ways and ignores if either applies.
+- NodeKind facts have no SourceRange. With ambiguous adapter IDs, structural scope attribution
+  is approximate; notes/baseline counts expose this limitation.
+- Semantic load is file-wide, not scope-wide, so it has no scope contribution sites.
+- Baseline is nonincremental and remeasures each file at startup. A historical measurement
+  took approximately 36s for 648 files; this is an observation, not a performance guarantee.
+  Persisted baseline resumption remains future work.
+- Comparison is against startup measurement, not an arbitrary Git ref or HEAD.
+
+## 9. Reproduce
+
+```bash
+pnpm --filter @untangle-code/cli run build:watch
+node apps/cli/dist/commands/watch/cli.js --baseline-only
+node apps/cli/dist/commands/watch/cli.js --out watch.jsonl
+node apps/cli/dist/commands/watch/cli.js --format json | jq -c 'select(.kind=="change")'
+```