@torka/claude-workflows 0.2.0 → 0.3.0

package/bmad-workflows/bmm/workflows/4-implementation/implement-epic-with-subagents/workflow-plan-implement-epic-with-subagents.md

@@ -0,0 +1,758 @@
+---
+stepsCompleted: [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9]
+planApproved: true
+outputFormatDesigned: true
+structureDesigned: true
+buildComplete: true
+status: COMPLETE
+completionDate: 2026-01-04
+---
+
+# Workflow Creation Plan: implement-epic-with-subagents
+
+## Initial Project Context
+
+- **Module:** bmm (BMAD Method Module)
+- **Phase:** 4-implementation
+- **Target Location:** `_bmad/bmm/workflows/4-implementation/implement-epic-with-subagents/`
+- **Created:** 2026-01-03
+
+## Workflow Overview
+
+**Name:** implement-epic-with-subagents
+**Purpose:** Automate entire epic execution by orchestrating sub-agents to execute all stories sequentially, with minimal human intervention.
+
+## Problem Statement
+
+Epic execution currently requires:
+- Significant time investment
+- Constant human-in-the-loop to manage agent session changes
+- Manual coordination between different workflow phases
+
+## Target Users
+
+- Entrepreneurs
+- Full stack developers
+- Semi-tech Builders
+
+---
+
+## Key Requirements
+
+### Workflow Type Classification
+
+- **Primary Type:** Meta-Workflow (coordinates other workflows/agents)
+- **Secondary Type:** Autonomous Workflow (runs with minimal human input)
+- **Execution Model:** Fully autonomous with critical checkpoint pauses
+
+### Core Workflow Flow
+
+**Pattern: Sequential Epic Executor (Enhanced)**
+
+```
+Load Epic
+  → Parse all stories from epic file
+  → For each story (in sequence):
+      → Create-story (story-prep-master agent)
+      → Execute dev-story (specialist/dev agent)
+      → Quality-gate (quality-gate-verifier agent)    ← Independent verification
+      → Code-review (principal-code-reviewer agent)
+      → Git commit
+      → Update sprint-status.yaml
+  → Generate Epic Completion Report
+  → Epic Complete
+```
+
+### Agent Orchestration
+
+| Step | Agent | Invocation Pattern | Source |
+|------|-------|-------------------|--------|
+| Create Story | story-prep-master | "Create story N.M" | `.claude/agents/story-prep-master.md` |
+| Implement | **Dynamic Selection** | "Develop story N.M" | See Agent Selection Logic below |
+| Quality Gate | quality-gate-verifier | "Verify story N.M" | `.claude/agents/quality-gate-verifier.md` |
+| Review | principal-code-reviewer | "Review story N.M" | `.claude/agents/principal-code-reviewer.md` |
+
+**Agent Context Rules:**
+- Each agent starts with fresh context
+- Agents receive explicit task instructions
+- No accumulated context between agent invocations
+
+### Development Agent Selection Logic
+
+**Primary Source:** `.claude/agents/vt-bmad-dev-agents/`
+
+The workflow should automatically determine the correct specialist dev agent based on:
+- Story title and description
+- Task types within the story
+- Technology stack involved (e.g., frontend, backend, database, API)
+
+**Selection Algorithm:**
+1. Parse story content (title, tasks, dev notes)
+2. Scan `.claude/agents/vt-bmad-dev-agents/` for available specialist agents
+3. Match story requirements to agent specializations (based on agent descriptions)
+4. If match found → invoke specialist agent
+5. If no match found → fallback to `dev` (Amelia) agent at `_bmad/bmm/agents/dev.md`
+
+**Example Specialist Agents (to be created):**
+- `frontend-specialist.md` - React, Next.js, UI components
+- `backend-specialist.md` - API routes, server logic
+- `database-specialist.md` - Schema, migrations, queries
+- `integration-specialist.md` - External APIs, third-party services
+
+### Specialist Agent Format
+
+Each specialist agent in `.claude/agents/vt-bmad-dev-agents/` must follow this structure:
+
+```markdown
+---
+name: frontend-specialist
+specialty: React/Next.js UI components and frontend architecture
+description: Specialist dev agent for frontend implementation...
+model: sonnet
+---
+
+## Specialty Context
+
+**Domain:** Frontend Development
+**Technologies:** React, Next.js, TypeScript, Tailwind CSS, Shadcn/UI
+**Story Types:** UI components, pages, client-side logic, styling
+**Keywords:** component, page, UI, form, button, modal, layout, responsive
+
+## Matching Criteria
+- Story title contains: "UI", "component", "page", "frontend"
+- Tasks involve: React components, CSS, client-side state
+- Dev Notes reference: src/components/*, src/app/*
+```
+
+The orchestrator scans:
+1. `specialty` field (one-liner in frontmatter)
+2. `Specialty Context` section for detailed matching
+
+### Agent Handoff Contract
+
+**Dual Communication Model:**
+
+**PRIMARY: File Artifacts**
+- `story-{N.M}.md` - created/updated by agents
+- `sprint-status.yaml` - status field updated atomically
+- `completion-report-{N.M}.md` - optional detailed log
+
+**SECONDARY: Structured Handoff Message**
+
+Each agent outputs a parseable handoff block at completion:
+
+```
+=== AGENT HANDOFF ===
+agent: dev | story-prep-master | principal-code-reviewer
+story: N.M
+status: completed | failed | blocked
+files_changed:
+  - path/to/file1.tsx
+  - path/to/file2.test.tsx
+tests_passed: true | false
+tests_run: 12
+tests_failed: 0
+coverage: 92%
+blockers: none | ["db_migration_required", "architecture_decision"]
+next_action: proceed | escalate | retry
+error_summary: null | "Brief description of failure"
+=== END HANDOFF ===
+```
+
+**Orchestrator Validation:**
+1. Parse structured handoff message
+2. Verify against sprint-status.yaml
+3. Double-check = reliable status determination
+
+### Quality Gate Agent
+
+**Agent:** `quality-gate-verifier`
+**Location:** `.claude/agents/quality-gate-verifier.md`
+**Purpose:** Independent verification of implementation quality before code review
+
+**Why Separate Agent:**
+- Fresh context for objective verification
+- Preserves orchestrator's context window
+- Independent verification (doesn't trust dev agent's self-reporting)
+
+**Agent Responsibilities:**
+1. Run test suite independently (`npm test` or equivalent)
+2. Generate and parse coverage report
+3. Compare actual results with dev agent's handoff message
+4. Detect discrepancies (if dev agent misreported)
+5. Check for test quality indicators (not just pass/fail)
+6. Validate no skipped or pending tests
+
+**Checks:**
+- All tests pass (independently verified)
+- Coverage meets threshold (configurable, default 80%)
+- No skipped/pending tests
+- Handoff message matches actual results
+- No unresolved blockers in code (TODO/FIXME checks)
+
+**Handoff Output:**
+```
+=== QUALITY GATE HANDOFF ===
+agent: quality-gate-verifier
+story: N.M
+verification_status: passed | failed | suspicious
+tests_run: 12
+tests_passed: 12
+tests_failed: 0
+tests_skipped: 0
+coverage: 92%
+dev_handoff_match: true | false
+issues_found:
+  - none | [list of issues]
+recommendation: proceed | retry | escalate
+notes: "Optional verification notes"
+=== END HANDOFF ===
+```
+
+**Actions:**
+- Pass → proceed to code-review
+- Fail (simple) → retry dev-story (up to 3 attempts)
+- Fail (complex) → escalate to human
+- Suspicious (handoff mismatch) → escalate with warning
+
+### Input Requirements
+
+| Input | Format | Source |
+|-------|--------|--------|
+| Epic File | BMAD epics-template format | `_bmad/bmm/workflows/3-solutioning/create-epics-and-stories/templates/epics-template.md` |
+| Sprint Status | YAML status tracking | `_bmad/bmm/workflows/4-implementation/sprint-planning/sprint-status-template.yaml` |
+| Project Context | Markdown (optional) | `**/project-context.md` |
+
+**Story Format Reference:** `_bmad/bmm/workflows/4-implementation/create-story/template.md`
+
+### Output Specifications
+
+| Output | Description |
+|--------|-------------|
+| Updated sprint-status.yaml | Status updated after each story phase |
+| Story files | Created by story-prep-master for each story |
+| Epic Completion Report | Simple summary of execution (stories completed, failed, time, issues) |
+
+### Autonomy & Human Checkpoint Rules
+
+**Fully Autonomous Unless:**
+- Database migration required
+- New architecture decision needed (rare)
+- Critical blocker encountered
+- Complex failure that cannot be auto-resolved
+
+**Human has pre-reviewed epic** - no need for approval checkpoints during normal execution.
+
+### Failure Handling Strategy
+
+| Failure Type | Action |
+|--------------|--------|
+| Simple (lint, type errors, fixable test failures) | Auto-retry up to 3 attempts |
+| Moderate (test failures requiring code changes) | Agent attempts fix, escalate after 2 failed attempts |
+| Complex (architectural issues, missing dependencies) | Stop immediately, escalate with full context |
+
+**Escalation Information:**
+- Error logs and stack traces
+- What was attempted
+- Suggested fixes (if identifiable)
+- Full context of the story being executed
+
+### Progress Tracking
+
+- Use existing BMAD sprint-status.yaml format
+- Update status after each phase:
+  - `backlog` → `ready-for-dev` (after story creation)
+  - `ready-for-dev` → `in-progress` (during dev)
+  - `in-progress` → `review` (after dev complete)
+  - `review` → `done` (after code review passes)
+
+### Story Execution Order
+
+- **Linear execution** - stories processed in order as they appear in epic
+- No complex dependency handling required
+- If a story fails and escalates, workflow pauses at that story
+
+### Instruction Style
+
+- **Intent-Based** for orchestration logic (flexible, adaptive)
+- **Prescriptive** for agent invocation (exact commands)
+
+### Success Criteria
+
+1. All stories in epic reach `done` status
+2. All code reviews pass
+3. Sprint-status.yaml accurately reflects completion
+4. Completion report generated
+5. No unhandled failures or silent errors
+
+---
+
+## Tools Configuration
+
+### Core LLM Features (Required)
+
+| Tool | Status | Purpose |
+|------|--------|---------|
+| **Sub-Agents** | ✅ Required | Core orchestration - spawn story-prep-master, dev agents, principal-code-reviewer |
+| **File I/O** | ✅ Required | Read epic files, update sprint-status.yaml, create/update story files |
+| **Web-Browsing** | ✅ Included | Research documentation, troubleshoot issues, access current information |
+
+### Memory Systems
+
+| Tool | Status | Purpose |
+|------|--------|---------|
+| **Sidecar File** | ✅ Included | Persist epic execution state across session boundaries, track progress, enable resume |
+
+**Sidecar File Schema:**
+```yaml
+epic_execution_state:
+  epic_file: "path/to/epic.md"
+  current_story: "2.3"
+  stories_completed: ["2.1", "2.2"]
+  stories_pending: ["2.3", "2.4", "2.5"]
+  last_action: "dev-story"
+  last_status: "in-progress"
+  started_at: "2026-01-03T10:00:00Z"
+  last_updated: "2026-01-03T14:30:00Z"
+```
+
+### Core BMAD Tools
+
+| Tool | Status | Reason |
+|------|--------|--------|
+| **Party-Mode** | ❌ Excluded | Not needed for autonomous execution |
+| **Advanced Elicitation** | ❌ Excluded | Not needed for autonomous execution |
+| **Brainstorming** | ❌ Excluded | Not a creative workflow |
+
+### External Integrations
+
+| Tool | Status | Implementation | Purpose |
+|------|--------|----------------|---------|
+| **Git Auto-Commit** | ✅ Included | Bash tool (`git add . && git commit`) | Commit after each story completion |
+| **Context-7 MCP** | ✅ Required | MCP server | Access up-to-date API docs and library references |
+| **Playwright MCP** | ⚪ Optional | MCP server (if installed) | E2E testing automation |
+
+### Git Auto-Commit Integration
+
+After each story reaches `done` status:
+```bash
+git add .
+git commit -m "feat(story-N.M): [story title]
+
+Implemented via implement-epic-with-subagents workflow.
+Agent: [dev-agent-name]
+Coverage: [X]%
+Tests: [passed/total]
+
+Co-Authored-By: [agent-name] <noreply@anthropic.com>"
+```
+
+**Commit Timing:**
+- After code-review passes
+- Before moving to next story
+- Include structured commit message with story context
+
+### Installation Requirements
+
+| Tool | Requires Install | Status |
+|------|------------------|--------|
+| Context-7 MCP | Yes | Required - must be configured |
+| Playwright MCP | Yes | Optional - use if available |
+| All other tools | No | Built-in LLM capabilities |
+
+---
+
+## Output Format Design
+
+### Output Documents Summary
+
+| Output | Format Type | Template Source |
+|--------|-------------|-----------------|
+| Story files | Strict | Existing BMAD template (`create-story/template.md`) |
+| Sidecar state file | Strict | YAML schema (defined in Tools Configuration) |
+| Epic Completion Report | Structured | New template (below) |
+
+### Epic Completion Report Template
+
+**Format Type:** Structured (required sections, flexible content)
+**File Format:** Markdown
+**Location:** `{output_folder}/epic-reports/epic-completion-{epic-name}-{date}.md`
+
+```markdown
+# Epic Completion Report: {epic_name}
+
+## Execution Summary
+
+| Field | Value |
+|-------|-------|
+| **Epic File** | {epic_file_path} |
+| **Started** | {start_timestamp} |
+| **Completed** | {end_timestamp} |
+| **Duration** | {total_duration} |
+| **Status** | Completed | Partial | Failed |
+
+## Stories Execution
+
+| Story | Title | Status | Agent | Coverage | Tests | Duration |
+|-------|-------|--------|-------|----------|-------|----------|
+| N.M | {title} | done/failed | {agent_name} | X% | P/T | Xm |
+
+### Stories Completed: {completed_count}/{total_count}
+
+## Quality Metrics
+
+- **Average Coverage:** {avg_coverage}%
+- **Total Tests Run:** {total_tests}
+- **Tests Passed:** {passed_tests}
+- **Tests Failed:** {failed_tests}
+- **Git Commits Created:** {commit_count}
+
+## Agent Selection Summary
+
+| Agent | Stories Handled | Selection Reason |
+|-------|-----------------|------------------|
+| {agent_name} | [N.M, N.M] | {matching_criteria} |
+
+## Issues & Escalations
+
+### Retries
+- {story}: {retry_reason} - {outcome}
+
+### Escalations
+- {story}: {escalation_reason} - {resolution}
+
+### Blockers Encountered
+- {blocker_description}
+
+## Session Information
+
+- **Orchestrator Sessions:** {session_count}
+- **Resume Points:** {resume_count}
+- **Sidecar File:** {sidecar_path}
+```
+
+### Template Placeholders
+
+| Placeholder | Source |
+|-------------|--------|
+| `{epic_name}` | Parsed from epic file |
+| `{start_timestamp}` | Workflow initialization |
+| `{end_timestamp}` | Final story completion |
+| `{agent_name}` | Dynamic agent selection |
+| `{coverage}` | Quality gate handoff |
+
+---
+
+## Workflow Structure Design
+
+### Step Architecture Overview
+
+```
+step-01-init.md ─────→ step-02-orchestrate.md ─────→ step-03-complete.md
+       │                        ↑
+       ↓                        │
+step-01b-continue.md ───────────┘
+```
+
+### Step Definitions
+
+#### Step 1: Initialization (`step-01-init.md`)
+
+**Purpose:** Load epic, validate prerequisites, initialize execution state
+
+**Sequence:**
+1. Load epic file (prompt user for path or auto-detect)
+2. Parse all stories from epic (N.1, N.2, N.3...)
+3. Validate prerequisites:
+   - story-prep-master agent exists
+   - quality-gate-verifier agent exists
+   - principal-code-reviewer agent exists
+   - Specialist agents folder exists (or fallback dev agent)
+   - Context-7 MCP available
+4. Load sprint-status.yaml
+5. Check for existing sidecar file:
+   - If exists → route to step-01b-continue
+   - If not → create new sidecar file
+6. Present execution plan summary
+7. Menu: [C] Start Epic Execution
+
+**Outputs:**
+- Initialized sidecar state file
+- Parsed story list in memory
+
+---
+
+#### Step 1b: Continuation (`step-01b-continue.md`)
+
+**Purpose:** Resume epic execution from previous session
+
+**Sequence:**
+1. Load sidecar state file
+2. Determine resume point:
+   - Current story (N.M)
+   - Current phase (create/dev/quality/review)
+   - Stories completed vs pending
+3. Display progress summary
+4. Confirm with user
+5. Menu: [C] Continue from Story N.M | [R] Restart Epic
+
+**Outputs:**
+- Updated sidecar with resume timestamp
+
+---
+
+#### Step 2: Orchestration Loop (`step-02-orchestrate.md`)
+
+**Purpose:** Execute all stories autonomously with sub-agents
+
+**Sequence:**
+For each pending story in epic:
+
+```
+┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
+│ STORY EXECUTION LOOP                                        │
+├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
+│                                                             │
+│  PHASE A: Create Story                                      │
+│  ├── Update sidecar: current_phase = "create"               │
+│  ├── Spawn: story-prep-master agent                         │
+│  ├── Instruction: "Create story N.M from epic"              │
+│  ├── Parse handoff message                                  │
+│  ├── Update sprint-status: story → ready-for-dev            │
+│  └── If failed → handle failure                             │
+│                                                             │
+│  PHASE B: Develop Story                                     │
+│  ├── Update sidecar: current_phase = "dev"                  │
+│  ├── Select specialist agent (or fallback to dev)           │
+│  ├── Spawn: selected dev agent                              │
+│  ├── Instruction: "Develop story N.M"                       │
+│  ├── Parse handoff message                                  │
+│  ├── Update sprint-status: story → in-progress              │
+│  └── If failed → handle failure                             │
+│                                                             │
+│  PHASE C: Quality Gate                                      │
+│  ├── Update sidecar: current_phase = "quality"              │
+│  ├── Spawn: quality-gate-verifier agent                     │
+│  ├── Instruction: "Verify story N.M"                        │
+│  ├── Parse handoff message                                  │
+│  ├── If failed → retry dev (up to 3x) or escalate           │
+│  └── If passed → proceed                                    │
+│                                                             │
+│  PHASE D: Code Review                                       │
+│  ├── Update sidecar: current_phase = "review"               │
+│  ├── Spawn: principal-code-reviewer agent                   │
+│  ├── Instruction: "Review story N.M"                        │
+│  ├── Parse handoff message                                  │
+│  ├── Update sprint-status: story → review                   │
+│  └── If failed → handle failure                             │
+│                                                             │
+│  PHASE E: Git Commit                                        │
+│  ├── Update sidecar: current_phase = "commit"               │
+│  ├── Execute: git add . && git commit                       │
+│  └── Commit message with story context                      │
+│                                                             │
+│  PHASE F: Finalize Story                                    │
+│  ├── Update sprint-status: story → done                     │
+│  ├── Update sidecar: add to stories_completed               │
+│  ├── Output brief status to user                            │
+│  └── Proceed to next story                                  │
+│                                                             │
+└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
+```
+
+**Failure Handling:**
+
+```
+On failure (after retries exhausted):
+  1. Determine failure type (simple/moderate/complex)
+  2. If simple: auto-retry (already handled)
+  3. If requires human input:
+     a. Display failure context
+     b. Present options: [S] Skip this story | [X] Stop execution
+     c. Wait for user decision
+     d. If Skip: mark story as skipped, continue
+     e. If Stop: save state, proceed to step-03 (partial)
+```
+
+**Progress Reporting:**
+
+After each story completion:
+```
+✅ Story N.M: [title]
+   Agent: [agent-name] | Coverage: X% | Tests: P/T | Duration: Xm
+```
+
+**Outputs:**
+- Created story files
+- Git commits
+- Updated sprint-status.yaml
+- Updated sidecar state
+
+---
+
+#### Step 3: Completion (`step-03-complete.md`)
+
+**Purpose:** Generate completion report, finalize epic
+
+**Sequence:**
+1. Gather all execution data from sidecar
+2. Generate Epic Completion Report (using template)
+3. Save report to output folder
+4. Update sprint-status: epic → done (or partial)
+5. Optionally archive/delete sidecar file
+6. Present summary to user
+
+**Outputs:**
+- Epic Completion Report (markdown)
+- Final sprint-status.yaml update
+
+---
+
+### Design Decisions
+
+| Decision | Choice | Rationale |
+|----------|--------|-----------|
+| **Escalation Handling** | Pause in same session | User can resolve immediately without context loss |
+| **Progress Reporting** | Brief status per story | Keeps user informed without verbose output |
+| **Story Failure** | Ask user to skip or stop | User decides based on epic context and dependencies |
+
+### Interaction Patterns
+
+| Phase | User Interaction Level |
+|-------|------------------------|
+| Init | Interactive (confirm epic, start) |
+| Continue | Interactive (confirm resume) |
+| Orchestration | Autonomous (interrupt only on blocker) |
+| Failure | Interactive (skip/stop decision) |
+| Complete | Interactive (review summary) |
+
+### File Structure
+
+```
+implement-epic-with-subagents/
+├── workflow.yaml           # Workflow configuration
+├── workflow.md             # Main workflow entry (optional)
+├── steps/
+│   ├── step-01-init.md
+│   ├── step-01b-continue.md
+│   ├── step-02-orchestrate.md
+│   └── step-03-complete.md
+├── templates/
+│   └── epic-completion-report.md
+└── validation/
+    └── checklist.md        # Pre-execution validation
+```
+
+### State Management
+
+**Sidecar File Updates:**
+- On init: Create with epic info + story list
+- On each phase start: Update current_story, current_phase
+- On story complete: Add to stories_completed
+- On failure: Record failure details
+- On resume: Add resume timestamp
+
+### Agent Spawning Pattern
+
+```
+Task tool invocation:
+{
+  subagent_type: "general-purpose",
+  prompt: "[Agent instructions with story context]",
+  description: "[Phase] story N.M"
+}
+```
+
+Each agent receives:
+- Story file path
+- Sprint status path
+- Project context path (if exists)
+- Specific task instructions
+
+---
+
+## Build Summary
+
+### Files Generated
+
+**Workflow Files:**
+| File | Path | Size |
+|------|------|------|
+| workflow.yaml | `_bmad-output/bmb-creations/workflows/implement-epic-with-subagents/workflow.yaml` | Main config |
+| step-01-init.md | `_bmad-output/bmb-creations/workflows/implement-epic-with-subagents/steps/step-01-init.md` | Initialization |
+| step-01b-continue.md | `_bmad-output/bmb-creations/workflows/implement-epic-with-subagents/steps/step-01b-continue.md` | Continuation |
+| step-02-orchestrate.md | `_bmad-output/bmb-creations/workflows/implement-epic-with-subagents/steps/step-02-orchestrate.md` | Main loop |
+| step-03-complete.md | `_bmad-output/bmb-creations/workflows/implement-epic-with-subagents/steps/step-03-complete.md` | Completion |
+
+**Templates:**
+| File | Path |
+|------|------|
+| epic-completion-report.md | `_bmad-output/bmb-creations/workflows/implement-epic-with-subagents/templates/epic-completion-report.md` |
+
+**Validation:**
+| File | Path |
+|------|------|
+| checklist.md | `_bmad-output/bmb-creations/workflows/implement-epic-with-subagents/validation/checklist.md` |
+
+**New Agents Created:**
+| Agent | Path |
+|-------|------|
+| quality-gate-verifier | `.claude/agents/quality-gate-verifier.md` |
+
+**Folders Created:**
+| Folder | Purpose |
+|--------|---------|
+| `.claude/agents/vt-bmad-dev-agents/` | Specialist dev agents (empty, ready for population) |
+
+### Installation Notes
+
+To install workflow to bmm module:
+```bash
+cp -r _bmad-output/bmb-creations/workflows/implement-epic-with-subagents _bmad/bmm/workflows/4-implementation/
+```
+
+### Next Steps
+
+1. **Review generated files** - Verify content matches requirements
+2. **Create specialist agents** - Populate `.claude/agents/vt-bmad-dev-agents/` with specialists
+3. **Test workflow** - Run with a small epic to validate
+4. **Install to bmm** - Copy to final location when ready
+
+### Build Timestamp
+
+Generated: 2026-01-04
+
+---
+
+## Fresh-Eyes Review (2026-01-04)
+
+### Validation Results
+
+| Category | Result |
+|----------|--------|
+| Configuration validation | ⚠️ PASSED with notes |
+| Step compliance | ✅ PASSED |
+| Cross-file consistency | ⚠️ PASSED with notes |
+| Requirements verification | ✅ PASSED |
+
+### Issues Found
+
+**Warnings (2):**
+1. **Config Path Assumption** - workflow.yaml references `_bmad/bmm/config.yaml`. Verify bmm config exists with `implementation_artifacts` before first run.
+2. **Template Placeholder Syntax** - epic-completion-report.md uses `{{placeholder}}` while steps use `{variable}`. Minor inconsistency.
+
+**Suggestions (2):**
+1. Consider adding `validation/pre-flight.sh` script for automated checks
+2. Include example specialist agent template in package
+
+### Review Outcome
+
+All critical checks passed. Workflow is ready for deployment and testing. Minor warnings are documented for awareness but do not block usage.
+
+### Reviewer Notes
+
+- All original requirements from plan are implemented
+- Step files follow BMAD template structure
+- Agent orchestration pattern is well-designed
+- Failure handling is comprehensive
+- Resume capability via sidecar is robust