@tenphi/tasty 0.10.1 → 0.11.0

package/docs/methodology.md

@@ -0,0 +1,501 @@
+# Methodology
+
+Tasty has opinions about how components should be structured. The patterns described here are not mandatory — Tasty works without them — but following them gets the most out of the engine: better state resolution, cleaner component APIs, simpler overrides, and fewer surprises as the system grows.
+
+---
+
+## Component architecture: root + sub-elements
+
+### The model
+
+Every Tasty component has a **root element** and zero or more **sub-elements**. The root owns the state context. Sub-elements participate in the same context by default.
+
+```tsx
+const Alert = tasty({
+  styles: {
+    padding: '3x',
+    fill: { '': '#surface', 'type=danger': '#danger.10' },
+    border: { '': '1bw solid #border', 'type=danger': '1bw solid #danger' },
+    radius: '1r',
+
+    Icon: {
+      color: { '': '#text-secondary', 'type=danger': '#danger' },
+      width: '3x',
+      height: '3x',
+    },
+    Message: {
+      preset: 't2',
+      color: '#text',
+    },
+  },
+  elements: { Icon: 'span', Message: 'div' },
+});
+```
+
+When `<Alert mods={{ type: 'danger' }}>` is rendered, the root gets `data-type="danger"` and **all** sub-elements react to it through their state maps. The `Icon` turns `#danger`, the border changes — from a single modifier on the root.
+
+### How this differs from BEM
+
+BEM organizes CSS around blocks, elements, and modifiers. Each element applies its own modifier classes independently:
+
+```html
+<!-- BEM: each element carries its own modifier -->
+<div class="alert alert--danger">
+  <span class="alert__icon alert__icon--danger">!</span>
+  <div class="alert__message">Something went wrong</div>
+</div>
+```
+
+In BEM, `alert__icon--danger` is a separate class that must be applied to the icon element explicitly. The block modifier `alert--danger` does not automatically propagate to elements — each element needs its own modifier class, and the CSS for each element+modifier combination is written separately.
+
+In Tasty, sub-elements inherit the root's state context automatically:
+
+```tsx
+<Alert mods={{ type: 'danger' }}>
+  <Alert.Icon>!</Alert.Icon>
+  <Alert.Message>Something went wrong</Alert.Message>
+</Alert>
+```
+
+One `mods` prop on the root. No modifier classes on sub-elements. The CSS for `type=danger` is declared once per property, and every sub-element that references that state key reacts to it.
+
+This is the fundamental design choice: **state flows from root to sub-elements**, not from each element independently.
+
+### When sub-elements need their own state
+
+Use `@own(...)` when a sub-element should react to its own state rather than the root's:
+
+```tsx
+const Nav = tasty({
+  styles: {
+    NavItem: {
+      color: {
+        '': '#text',
+        '@own(:hover)': '#primary',
+        '@own(:focus-visible)': '#primary',
+        'selected': '#primary',
+      },
+    },
+  },
+  elements: { NavItem: 'a' },
+});
+```
+
+Here, `:hover` and `:focus-visible` belong to the individual `NavItem` being hovered, not the root `Nav`. But `selected` is still a root-level modifier — a parent component controls which item is selected.
+
+The default (root state context) is the right choice most of the time. Use `@own()` only when the sub-element has interactive states that are independent of the root.
+
+---
+
+## styleProps as the public API
+
+`styleProps` define which CSS properties a component exposes as typed React props. They are the primary mechanism for product engineers to customize a component without breaking its design constraints.
+
+```tsx
+const Space = tasty({
+  as: 'div',
+  styles: { display: 'flex', flow: 'column', gap: '1x' },
+  styleProps: ['flow', 'gap', 'padding', 'fill', 'placeItems', 'placeContent'],
+});
+
+// Product engineer uses it:
+<Space flow="row" gap="2x" padding="4x" placeItems="center">
+```
+
+Style props accept state maps, so responsive values work through the same API:
+
+```tsx
+<Space
+  flow={{ '': 'column', '@tablet': 'row' }}
+  gap={{ '': '2x', '@tablet': '4x' }}
+>
+```
+
+### Choosing what to expose
+
+Tasty exports predefined style prop lists that group properties by role. Use them instead of hand-picking arrays:
+
+| Preset | Properties | Typical use |
+|--------|-----------|-------------|
+| `FLOW_STYLES` | flow, gap, columnGap, rowGap, align, justify, placeItems, placeContent, alignItems, alignContent, justifyItems, justifyContent, gridColumns, gridRows, gridTemplate, gridAreas | Layout containers (`Space`, `Grid`) |
+| `POSITION_STYLES` | gridArea, gridColumn, gridRow, order, placeSelf, alignSelf, justifySelf, zIndex, margin, inset, position | Positioned elements (`Button`, `Badge`) |
+| `DIMENSION_STYLES` | width, height, flexBasis, flexGrow, flexShrink, flex | Sized elements |
+| `COLOR_STYLES` | color, fill, fade, image | Color-customizable elements |
+| `BLOCK_STYLES` | padding, paddingInline, paddingBlock, overflow, scrollbar, textAlign, border, radius, shadow, outline | Block-level containers |
+| `CONTAINER_STYLES` | All of the above combined (+ BASE_STYLES) | Fully flexible containers |
+| `OUTER_STYLES` | POSITION_STYLES + DIMENSION_STYLES + block outer (border, radius, shadow, outline) | Components whose outer shell is customizable |
+| `INNER_STYLES` | BASE_STYLES + COLOR_STYLES + block inner (padding, overflow, scrollbar) + FLOW_STYLES | Components whose inner layout is customizable |
+
+```tsx
+import { tasty, FLOW_STYLES, POSITION_STYLES } from '@tenphi/tasty';
+
+const Space = tasty({
+  as: 'div',
+  styles: { display: 'flex', flow: 'column', gap: '1x' },
+  styleProps: FLOW_STYLES,
+});
+
+const Button = tasty({
+  as: 'button',
+  styles: { padding: '1.5x 3x', fill: '#primary', radius: true },
+  styleProps: POSITION_STYLES,
+});
+```
+
+You can also combine presets or mix them with individual properties:
+
+```tsx
+styleProps: [...FLOW_STYLES, ...DIMENSION_STYLES, 'fill'],
+```
+
+Match the preset to the component's role:
+
+- **Layout containers** (`Space`, `Box`, `Grid`) — `FLOW_STYLES`, optionally with `DIMENSION_STYLES`
+- **Positioned elements** (`Button`, `Badge`) — `POSITION_STYLES`
+- **Text elements** — custom: `['preset', 'color']`
+- **Compound components** — typically none; styling happens via sub-elements and extension
+
+### The governance trade-off
+
+Exposing every CSS property as a prop defeats the purpose of a design system. The more props a component exposes, the more ways product engineers can deviate from the intended design. A good rule of thumb: expose props that product engineers *need* to adjust for layout and composition, and keep visual identity (colors, borders, typography) controlled through the component definition, variants, or styled wrappers.
+
+---
+
+## tokens prop for dynamic values
+
+Every Tasty component accepts a `tokens` prop that renders as inline CSS custom properties on the element. This is the mechanism for per-instance dynamic values.
+
+```tsx
+const ProgressBar = tasty({
+  styles: {
+    width: '100%',
+    height: '1x',
+    fill: '#surface',
+    Bar: {
+      width: '$progress',
+      height: '100%',
+      fill: '#primary',
+      transition: 'width 0.3s',
+    },
+  },
+  elements: { Bar: 'div' },
+});
+
+// Usage: the progress value comes from a prop, not from styles
+<ProgressBar tokens={{ '$progress': `${percent}%` }} />
+```
+
+The `tokens` prop sets `style="--progress: 75%"` on the DOM element. The `$progress` reference in styles maps to `var(--progress)`, so the bar width updates without regenerating any CSS.
+
+### When to use tokens vs other mechanisms
+
+| Need | Use |
+|------|-----|
+| Value changes per instance at render time (progress, user color, avatar size) | `tokens` prop (on component) |
+| Value is constant across all instances (card padding, border radius) | `configure({ tokens })` for `:root` CSS custom properties |
+| Value should be inlined at parse time (alias for another token) | `configure({ replaceTokens })` |
+| Value changes based on component state (hover, disabled, breakpoint) | State map in `styles` |
+| Value changes based on a variant (primary, danger, outline) | `variants` option |
+
+Design tokens (via `configure({ tokens })`) are injected as CSS custom properties on `:root`. Replace tokens (via `configure({ replaceTokens })`) are resolved at parse time and baked into the generated CSS. The `tokens` prop on components is resolved at render time via inline CSS custom properties. Use design tokens for design-system constants, replace tokens for value aliases, and the `tokens` prop for truly dynamic per-instance values.
+
+---
+
+## styles prop vs style prop
+
+Tasty components accept both `styles` and `style`, but they serve very different purposes.
+
+### styles — Tasty extension mechanism
+
+The `styles` prop is processed through the full Tasty pipeline. Tokens, custom units, state maps, sub-element keys — everything works:
+
+```tsx
+<Card styles={{ padding: '6x', Title: { color: '#danger' } }} />
+```
+
+However, **using `styles` directly is discouraged in design-system code.** The recommended pattern is to create a styled wrapper instead:
+
+```tsx
+// Preferred: create a styled wrapper
+const LargeCard = tasty(Card, {
+  styles: { padding: '6x', Title: { color: '#danger' } },
+});
+
+<LargeCard />
+```
+
+Why? Styled wrappers are:
+
+- **Faster** — styles are parsed and injected once at definition time, not on every render
+- **Stable** — the style object is defined once, not recreated on every render
+- **Composable** — another engineer can extend `LargeCard` further
+- **Inspectable** — the component has a name in React DevTools
+- **Lint-friendly** — the ESLint plugin's `no-styles-prop` rule flags direct usage
+
+The `styles` prop exists as an escape hatch — for prototyping, one-off overrides during development, or cases where wrapping is impractical. It should not be the default way product engineers customize components.
+
+### style — React inline styles (escape hatch)
+
+The `style` prop is standard React `CSSProperties`. It bypasses Tasty entirely — no tokens, no units, no state maps:
+
+```tsx
+<Card style={{ marginTop: 16 }} />
+```
+
+Reserve `style` for third-party library integration where you need to set CSS properties that Tasty does not control (e.g. a library that reads inline `style` for positioning). Never use `style` as a styling mechanism for your own components.
+
+See [Best practices](#best-practices) below for the full list of do's and don'ts.
+
+---
+
+## Wrapping and extension
+
+`tasty(Base, { styles })` is the primary extension mechanism. It creates a new component whose styles are merged with the base component's styles.
+
+```tsx
+import { Button } from 'my-ds';
+
+const DangerButton = tasty(Button, {
+  styles: {
+    fill: { '': '#danger', ':hover': '#danger-hover' },
+    color: '#danger-text',
+  },
+});
+```
+
+### Extend mode vs replace mode
+
+Merge behavior depends on whether the child provides a `''` (default) key in a state map:
+
+- **No `''` key** — extend mode: parent states are preserved, child adds or overrides specific states
+- **Has `''` key** — replace mode: child defines everything from scratch for that property
+
+```tsx
+// Extend: adds `loading` state, overrides `disabled`, keeps parent's '' and ':hover'
+tasty(Button, {
+  styles: {
+    fill: {
+      loading: '#yellow',
+      disabled: '#gray.20',
+    },
+  },
+});
+
+// Replace: provides '' key, so parent's fill states are dropped entirely
+tasty(Button, {
+  styles: {
+    fill: {
+      '': '#danger',
+      ':hover': '#danger-hover',
+    },
+  },
+});
+```
+
+For full details on merge semantics, `@inherit`, `null`, and `false` tombstones, see [Style DSL — Extending vs. Replacing State Maps](dsl.md#extending-vs-replacing-state-maps).
+
+### When to use styleProps vs wrapping
+
+If the component exposes the properties you need as `styleProps`, use them directly — that is what they are for:
+
+```tsx
+// Card exposes padding and gap as styleProps — just use them
+<Card padding="2x" gap="1x">
+```
+
+Wrapping is for changes that go beyond what `styleProps` expose — overriding colors, adding state mappings, restyling sub-elements:
+
+```tsx
+const DangerCard = tasty(Card, {
+  styles: {
+    border: '1bw solid #danger',
+    Title: { color: '#danger' },
+  },
+});
+```
+
+This is preferred over `<Card styles={{ border: '1bw solid #danger' }}>` because:
+
+1. Styles are parsed and injected once, not on every render
+2. `DangerCard` can be extended further by others
+3. It has a meaningful name in DevTools and code search
+4. The ESLint `no-styles-prop` rule encourages this pattern
+
+---
+
+## How configuration simplifies components
+
+Tasty's `configure()` is not just setup — it directly reduces the complexity of every component in the system.
+
+### State aliases eliminate repetition
+
+Without aliases, every component inlines the full query:
+
+```tsx
+// Without aliases
+padding: { '': '4x', '@media(w < 768px)': '2x' },
+flow: { '': 'row', '@media(w < 768px)': 'column' },
+```
+
+With aliases:
+
+```tsx
+// With aliases
+padding: { '': '4x', '@mobile': '2x' },
+flow: { '': 'row', '@mobile': 'column' },
+```
+
+The alias is defined once. If the breakpoint changes from `768px` to `640px`, you update one line in `configure()` and every component adjusts.
+
+### Recipes extract repeated patterns
+
+Without recipes, every card-like component repeats the same base styles:
+
+```tsx
+// Without recipes — repeated in Card, ProfileCard, SettingsPanel, ...
+styles: {
+  padding: '4x',
+  fill: '#surface',
+  radius: '1r',
+  border: true,
+  // ...component-specific styles
+}
+```
+
+With recipes:
+
+```tsx
+// With recipes
+styles: {
+  recipe: 'card',
+  // ...component-specific styles only
+}
+```
+
+The recipe encapsulates the shared pattern. Change `card`'s radius from `1r` to `2r` and every component using it updates.
+
+### Design tokens enforce consistency
+
+```tsx
+configure({
+  tokens: {
+    '$card-padding': '4x',
+    '$input-height': '5x',
+  },
+});
+```
+
+Components use `$card-padding` instead of hardcoding `4x`. If the DS team decides to change card padding, the token is the single source of truth. Tokens support state maps for theme-aware values. Token values are parsed through the Tasty DSL, so you can use units (`4x`), color syntax (`#purple`), and other DSL features in token definitions.
+
+See [Configuration](configuration.md) for the full `configure()` API.
+
+---
+
+## Best practices
+
+### Do
+
+- **Create styled wrappers** instead of passing `styles` directly — faster, composable, inspectable
+- **Use design tokens and custom units** (`#text`, `2x`, `1r`) instead of raw CSS values
+- **Use semantic transition names** (`transition: 'theme 0.3s'`) instead of listing CSS properties
+- **Use `elements` prop** to declare typed sub-components for compound components
+- **Use `styleProps`** to define what product engineers can customize
+- **Use `tokens` prop** for per-instance dynamic values (progress, user color)
+- **Use modifiers** (`mods`) for state-driven style changes instead of runtime `styles` prop changes
+
+### Avoid
+
+### Using raw CSS values when tokens exist
+
+```tsx
+// Bad: hardcoded color
+fill: 'oklch(55% 0.25 265)',
+
+// Good: token reference
+fill: '#primary',
+```
+
+Tokens ensure consistency across components and make theme changes a one-line update.
+
+### Using CSS property names when Tasty alternatives exist
+
+```tsx
+// Bad: raw CSS properties
+backgroundColor: '#fff',
+borderRadius: '4px',
+flexDirection: 'column',
+
+// Good: Tasty shorthands
+fill: '#surface',
+radius: '1r',
+flow: 'column',
+```
+
+Tasty's enhanced properties provide concise syntax, better composability, and simpler overrides. See [recommended props](styles.md#recommended-props) for the full mapping.
+
+### Changing styles prop at runtime
+
+```tsx
+// Bad: styles object changes every render
+<Card styles={{ padding: isCompact ? '2x' : '4x' }} />
+
+// Good: use modifiers
+<Card mods={{ compact: isCompact }} />
+
+// In the component definition:
+padding: { '': '4x', compact: '2x' },
+```
+
+Modifiers are compiled into exclusive selectors once. Changing `styles` at runtime forces Tasty to regenerate and re-inject CSS.
+
+### Overusing style prop
+
+```tsx
+// Bad: bypassing Tasty for custom styling
+<Button style={{ backgroundColor: 'red', padding: '12px 24px' }} />
+
+// Good: create a styled wrapper
+const DangerButton = tasty(Button, {
+  styles: { fill: '#danger', padding: '1.5x 3x' },
+});
+```
+
+The `style` prop bypasses tokens, units, and state maps. It should only be used for third-party library integration.
+
+### Skipping elements for compound components
+
+```tsx
+// Less ideal: manual data-element attributes
+<Card>
+  <div data-element="Title">Card Title</div>
+  <div data-element="Content">Card content</div>
+</Card>
+
+// Better: declare elements for typed sub-components
+const Card = tasty({
+  styles: {
+    Title: { preset: 'h3', color: '#primary' },
+    Content: { preset: 't2', color: '#text' },
+  },
+  elements: { Title: 'h2', Content: 'div' },
+});
+
+<Card>
+  <Card.Title>Card Title</Card.Title>
+  <Card.Content>Card content</Card.Content>
+</Card>
+```
+
+The `elements` prop gives you typed sub-components with automatic `data-element` attributes, `mods` support, and better discoverability.
+
+---
+
+## Learn more
+
+- **[Getting Started](getting-started.md)** — Installation, first component, tooling setup
+- **[Building a Design System](design-system.md)** — Practical guide to building a DS layer with Tasty
+- **[Style DSL](dsl.md)** — State maps, tokens, units, extending semantics, keyframes, @property
+- **[Runtime API](runtime.md)** — `tasty()` factory, component props, variants, sub-elements, hooks
+- **[Configuration](configuration.md)** — Full `configure()` API: tokens, recipes, custom units, style handlers
+- **[Style Properties](styles.md)** — Complete reference for all enhanced style properties
+- **[Adoption Guide](adoption.md)** — Who should adopt Tasty, incremental phases, what changes for product engineers