@tekyzinc/gsd-t 4.6.11 → 4.7.10

package/templates/workflows/gsd-t-execute.workflow.js

@@ -13,6 +13,25 @@
 // context-brief, file-disjointness, verify-gate — all invoked from inside
 // stages via templates/workflows/_lib.js helpers.
 //
+// M89: Stated-Claims→classify→research wiring (auto-research-contract v1.2.0 §6.5/§1/§2/§3/§4/§7).
+// Domain workers embed the Stated-Claims snippet (§6.5) so agents tag load-bearing claims
+// KNOWN|GUESSED. After domain workers, the Research phase iterates GUESSED entries through
+// bin/gsd-t-research-gate.cjs: external → write §7 marker (status=uncited) → research agent
+// (model:"fable") → cite → flip marker (status=cited). Internal → grep/Read; grep-empty →
+// escalate to external research + cite + marker (§5.1 ambiguous escalation). Idempotent per §4.1
+// (exact normalized claim-key match only). Wave is a pure composer and does NOT embed this wiring
+// (M85 zero-model: invariant; research reaches wave via its execute sub-workflow).
+//
+// M90 §2 D4-T4: Architectural-trigger wiring (protocol-class path, R-ARCH-2 "everywhere" feed).
+// After domain workers, compute the extend-existing-code signal from each domain's filesTouched:
+// any file that already existed on disk before this execute run is extend-class (the task EXTENDED
+// existing code rather than creating net-new). For each such domain, fire the arch trigger (R-ARCH-2)
+// via the inline runCli helper. This is the NAMED PRODUCER: the signal is computed from real
+// runtime inputs (filesTouched vs. on-disk existence), never from a seeded injection.
+// Result is logged + stored in domainArchTriggerResults for verify gate (R-FAIL-2: if the trigger
+// fires with provenByAdversaryOnly=true and the flag is unresolved, verify FAILS).
+// Contract: unproven-assumption-doctrine-contract.md §2 (R-ARCH-2, protocol-class path).
+//
 // Invocation contract:
 //   The Workflow tool reads this file's `meta` block and runs the script
 //   body. `args` is the JSON object passed in via Workflow({args}). Expected
@@ -26,11 +45,12 @@
 export const meta = {
   name: "gsd-t-execute",
   description:
-    "Run a GSD-T execute phase: preflight → brief → parallel domain workers → integrate barrier → verify-gate",
+    "Run a GSD-T execute phase: preflight → brief → parallel domain workers → research (Stated-Claims) → integrate barrier → verify-gate",
   phases: [
     { title: "Preflight",    detail: "gsd-t preflight + brief generation" },
     { title: "Disjointness", detail: "prove tasks are file-disjoint" },
     { title: "Domains",      detail: "parallel domain workers" },
+    { title: "Research",     detail: "classify GUESSED claims + cite external via web research (§6.5/§1/§2/§7)" },
     { title: "Integrate",    detail: "cross-domain wire-up" },
     { title: "Verify-Gate",  detail: "two-track verify-gate" },
   ],
@@ -49,9 +69,107 @@ const DOMAIN_RESULT_SCHEMA = {
     tasksDone:    { type: "array", items: { type: "string" } },
     tasksBlocked: { type: "array", items: { type: "string" } },
     notes:        { type: "string" },
+    // M89 §6.5 — Stated Claims: raw [GUESSED:*] lines emitted by the worker (§6.5 DETECT seam).
+    // Each entry is the full bullet text e.g. "[GUESSED:assumed] the create call returns a `url`".
+    // The Research phase iterates these through bin/gsd-t-research-gate.cjs.
+    statedClaims: { type: "array", items: { type: "string" } },
+    // Primary artifact path written by this worker (used by Research phase to write/flip §7 markers).
+    artifactPath: { type: "string" },
+  },
+};
+
+// M89 §7 — ENFORCE marker format helpers (normalize claim-key per §4.1)
+// Normalize: lowercase, then collapse EVERY non-word run to a single space (cycle-2
+// finding #1) so the key is marker-syntax-safe (no "="/"<"/">"/"-"); byte-identical
+// across all 4 workflows (enforced by m89-normalize-claim-key-parity).
+function normalizeClaimKey(claim) {
+  return claim.toLowerCase().replace(/[^\w]+/g, " ").trim();
+}
+
+// M89 §7 — marker templates
+function uncitedMarker(key) {
+  return `<!-- auto-research-claim: class=external key=${key} status=uncited -->`;
+}
+function citedMarker(key) {
+  return `<!-- auto-research-claim: class=external key=${key} status=cited -->`;
+}
+
+// M89 §2 — research stage schema (StructuredOutput from research-subagent)
+const RESEARCH_RESULT_SCHEMA = {
+  type: "object",
+  required: ["ok", "gapKey"],
+  additionalProperties: true,
+  properties: {
+    ok:         { type: "boolean" },
+    gapKey:     { type: "string" },
+    citedBlock: { type: "string" },
+    sourceUrls: { type: "array", items: { type: "string" } },
+    fetchDates: { type: "array", items: { type: "string" } },
+    reason:     { type: "string" },
   },
 };
 
+// M89 §1 — classify a guessed claim via bin/gsd-t-research-gate.cjs (D1 envelope)
+async function classifyClaim(projectDir, claimText, phaseName) {
+  return runCli(projectDir, "research-gate", ["classify", claimText, "--json"], "gsd-t-research-gate.cjs", "classify-claim", true, phaseName);
+}
+
+// M89 §4.1 — check if a cited marker already exists in artifact text (exact key match)
+function isAlreadyCited(artifactText, claimKey) {
+  const needle = `auto-research-claim: class=external key=${claimKey} status=cited`;
+  return artifactText.includes(needle);
+}
+
+// M89 §5.1 — grep the repo for an internal claim via an agent Bash call
+async function grepForClaim(projectDir, claimText, phaseName) {
+  const escaped = claimText.replace(/'/g, "'\\''").slice(0, 200);
+  const prompt = [
+    `Decide whether THIS repo's own code/contracts/tests CONFIRM the SPECIFIC claim — not merely`,
+    `share vocabulary with it (Red Team MEDIUM). Project: \`${projectDir}\`. Claim: "${escaped}"`,
+    `Run: \`grep -r --include="*.js" --include="*.ts" --include="*.md" --include="*.cjs" -l "${escaped.slice(0, 60)}" "${projectDir}" 2>/dev/null | head -5\``,
+    `Also try: \`grep -r -l "${escaped.slice(0, 40)}" "${projectDir}" 2>/dev/null | head -5\``,
+    `Then Read the candidates and judge: set found=true ONLY IF the repo content actually CONFIRMS`,
+    `the value/shape/behavior the claim asserts. Coincidental keyword overlap = found=false.`,
+    `If the claim is about an EXTERNAL system's behavior (3rd-party API, library, browser, protocol),`,
+    `grep CANNOT confirm it → found=false so it escalates to web research.`,
+    `Return JSON: { "found": <boolean>, "matches": ["<file>", ...] }. Do ONLY this. No other work.`,
+  ].join("\n");
+  const schema = { type: "object", required: ["found"], additionalProperties: true, properties: { found: { type: "boolean" }, matches: { type: "array", items: { type: "string" } } } };
+  const r = await agent(prompt, { label: "grep-internal-claim", model: "haiku", schema, phase: phaseName })
+    .catch(() => ({ found: false, matches: [] }));
+  return r || { found: false, matches: [] };
+}
+
+// M89 §1.1 — the AMBIGUOUS → LLM JUDGE. When the mechanical classifier finds no string
+// fact (class:ambiguous), the LLM decides internal/external/uncertain in natural language.
+// Bare model:"fable" (the research tier — NOT the ?? override form; "judge" is not a
+// designated stage). Returns the verdict string; on any error → "uncertain" (fail toward
+// research — never guess-internal). The caller treats external/uncertain as research.
+const CLASSIFY_JUDGE_SCHEMA = {
+  type: "object", required: ["verdict"], additionalProperties: true,
+  properties: { verdict: { type: "string", enum: ["internal", "external", "uncertain"] }, reason: { type: "string" } },
+};
+async function judgeAmbiguous(claimText, phaseName) {
+  const prompt = [
+    `You are the M89 ambiguous-claim JUDGE (auto-research-contract §1.1). The mechanical`,
+    `string-fact classifier could not decide this GUESSED claim, so decide it in natural language.`,
+    ``,
+    `Claim: "${claimText}"`,
+    ``,
+    `- "internal"  = about THIS repo's OWN code / contracts / schema / tests — grep/Read can confirm.`,
+    `- "external"  = asserts an OUTSIDE system's behavior/shape/limit (3rd-party API, library, browser,`,
+    `                protocol, spec) and is unverified — needs web research.`,
+    `- "uncertain" = you cannot CONFIDENTLY place it as internal. Use freely — per M89 doctrine an`,
+    `                unverified claim is RESEARCHED, never guessed.`,
+    ``,
+    `Return JSON: { "verdict": "internal"|"external"|"uncertain", "reason": "<one line>" }.`,
+    `Do NOT modify files. Do NOT run web searches in THIS step — only decide the verdict.`,
+  ].join("\n");
+  const r = await agent(prompt, { label: "classify-judge", model: "fable", schema: CLASSIFY_JUDGE_SCHEMA, phase: phaseName })
+    .catch((e) => ({ verdict: "uncertain", reason: `judge error: ${e && e.message}` }));
+  return (r && r.verdict) || "uncertain";
+}
+
 const INTEGRATE_RESULT_SCHEMA = {
   type: "object",
   required: ["status", "crossDomainEdits"],
@@ -163,6 +281,14 @@ const domainResults = await parallel(
       `- Update affected docs (progress.md Decision Log, architecture.md, contracts/, requirements.md, README.md) per the Document Ripple Completion Gate in CLAUDE.md — in the SAME commits as the code changes.`,
       `- If a task is blocked (dependency not met), record it in tasksBlocked and continue with the next.`,
       `- Return a JSON object matching the StructuredOutput schema. The "status" field is the OVERALL domain status: "complete" if all tasks done, "partial" if some done and some blocked, "blocked" if you couldn't start, "failed" on error.`,
+      ``,
+      `**M89 STATED CLAIMS — REQUIRED (auto-research-contract §6.5):**`,
+      `Read \`${projectDir}/templates/prompts/stated-claims-snippet.md\` for the full DETECT protocol.`,
+      `Before returning your StructuredOutput, emit a \`## Stated Claims\` section listing every`,
+      `load-bearing claim you relied on, tagged [KNOWN] or [GUESSED:assumed|unknown|stale].`,
+      `In your StructuredOutput JSON, include a "statedClaims" array: one entry per [GUESSED:*] line`,
+      `(the full bullet text). Also include "artifactPath" if you wrote a primary output artifact`,
+      `(the markdown or file path the Research phase should write §7 markers into).`,
     ].join("\n");
 
     try {
@@ -189,6 +315,243 @@ if (blocking.length) {
   return { status: "failed", reason: "domain-failed", domainResults };
 }
 
+// ── M89 Research Phase — Stated-Claims→classify→cite (§6.5/§1/§2/§3/§4/§7) ──
+phase("Research");
+
+// Collect all GUESSED claims from all domain workers (§6.5 DETECT seam)
+const allGuessedClaims = [];
+for (const dr of domainResults.filter(Boolean)) {
+  if (Array.isArray(dr.statedClaims) && dr.statedClaims.length > 0) {
+    for (const claimLine of dr.statedClaims) {
+      // Parse "[GUESSED:type] claim text" → extract the claim text
+      const m = claimLine.match(/^\[GUESSED:[^\]]+\]\s*(.+)$/);
+      if (m) {
+        allGuessedClaims.push({ claimText: m[1].trim(), domain: dr.domain, artifactPath: dr.artifactPath || null, rawLine: claimLine });
+      }
+    }
+  }
+}
+
+if (allGuessedClaims.length === 0) {
+  log("Research: no GUESSED claims found — skipping classify+research loop");
+} else {
+  log(`Research: ${allGuessedClaims.length} GUESSED claim(s) to classify`);
+
+  // Read artifact text for idempotency check (§4.1 — exact key match)
+  // Artifacts are read once per unique path via an agent Bash call
+  const artifactCache = {};
+  async function readArtifact(artifactPath) {
+    if (!artifactPath) return "";
+    if (artifactCache[artifactPath] !== undefined) return artifactCache[artifactPath];
+    const r = await agent(
+      `Read the file at \`${artifactPath}\` and return its full text content in a JSON object: { "text": "<file content>" }. If the file does not exist, return { "text": "" }.`,
+      { label: "read-artifact", model: "haiku", schema: { type: "object", required: ["text"], properties: { text: { type: "string" } }, additionalProperties: false }, phase: "Research" }
+    ).catch(() => ({ text: "" }));
+    const t = (r && r.text) || "";
+    artifactCache[artifactPath] = t;
+    return t;
+  }
+
+  // Write §7 marker and cited block to artifact via agent Bash (§7 marker lifecycle)
+  async function writeMarkerAndCite(artifactPath, claimKey, citedBlock) {
+    if (!artifactPath) return;
+    const marker = uncitedMarker(claimKey);
+    const flipped = citedMarker(claimKey);
+    const prompt = [
+      `You are performing a precise file edit. Path: \`${artifactPath}\`.`,
+      `Do the following in order:`,
+      `0. Ensure the parent directory exists (Bash: \`mkdir -p "$(dirname '${artifactPath.replace(/'/g, "'\\''")}')"\`) — the path may be a deterministic fallback artifact that does not exist yet.`,
+      `1. Read the file (use the Read tool). If it does not exist, treat its content as empty.`,
+      `2. If the file does not contain the line \`${marker}\`, APPEND this block to the end of the file:`,
+      `   \`\`\``,
+      `   ${marker}`,
+      `   ${citedBlock}`,
+      `   \`\`\``,
+      `3. If the file already contains \`${marker}\`, replace it with \`${flipped}\` and also append the cited block if not already present.`,
+      `4. If the file already contains \`${flipped}\`, do nothing (already cited — idempotent per §4.1).`,
+      `Use the Edit or Write tool to apply the change. Return JSON: { "done": true, "action": "appended|replaced|noop" }.`,
+    ].join("\n");
+    await agent(prompt, { label: "write-marker-cite", model: "haiku", schema: { type: "object", required: ["done"], properties: { done: { type: "boolean" }, action: { type: "string" } }, additionalProperties: true }, phase: "Research" })
+      .catch((e) => log(`write-marker-cite error: ${e && e.message}`));
+    // Invalidate cache so subsequent reads see the updated file
+    delete artifactCache[artifactPath];
+  }
+
+  async function writeUncitedMarker(artifactPath, claimKey) {
+    if (!artifactPath) return;
+    const marker = uncitedMarker(claimKey);
+    const safePath = artifactPath.replace(/'/g, "'\\''");
+    const prompt = [
+      `Ensure the parent directory exists, then append this line to the file \`${artifactPath}\` (only if not already present — exact string match):`,
+      `\`${marker}\``,
+      `Use Bash: \`mkdir -p "$(dirname '${safePath}')" && { grep -qF '${marker.replace(/'/g, "'\\''")}' '${safePath}' 2>/dev/null || echo '${marker.replace(/'/g, "'\\''")}' >> '${safePath}'; }\``,
+      `Return JSON: { "done": true }.`,
+    ].join("\n");
+    await agent(prompt, { label: "write-uncited-marker", model: "haiku", schema: { type: "object", required: ["done"], properties: { done: { type: "boolean" } }, additionalProperties: true }, phase: "Research" })
+      .catch((e) => log(`write-uncited-marker error: ${e && e.message}`));
+    delete artifactCache[artifactPath];
+  }
+
+  // Process each GUESSED claim sequentially (classify → route)
+  for (const { claimText, domain, artifactPath, rawLine } of allGuessedClaims) {
+    const claimKey = normalizeClaimKey(claimText);
+    log(`Research: classifying claim "${claimText.slice(0, 60)}" [domain=${domain}]`);
+
+    // FAIL-CLOSED (Red Team HIGH): artifactPath is worker-self-reported + optional. An EXTERNAL
+    // (or ambiguous→escalated-external) guess MUST still get its §7 uncited marker written
+    // SOMEWHERE, or the §7 ENFORCE gate finds nothing and the guess ships uncited+unresearched.
+    // So the external/escalation path writes to a DETERMINISTIC FALLBACK ARTIFACT when the worker
+    // reported no path. Internal/grep can still no-op safely.
+    const claimSlug = claimKey.replace(/\s+/g, "-").slice(0, 80) || "claim";
+    const externalArtifact = artifactPath || `${projectDir}/.gsd-t/research/${(domain || "domain")}-${claimSlug}.md`;
+
+    // §4.1 idempotency — skip if already cited (exact key match). Read the path actually
+    // WRITTEN (externalArtifact = real path OR the deterministic fallback) so a re-run does
+    // NOT re-research a claim already cited in the fallback artifact (Red Team MEDIUM).
+    const artifactText = await readArtifact(externalArtifact);
+    if (isAlreadyCited(artifactText, claimKey)) {
+      log(`Research: skip "${claimKey.slice(0, 50)}" — already cited (§4.1 idempotent)`);
+      continue;
+    }
+
+    // Classify the claim (D1 envelope)
+    const cls = await classifyClaim(projectDir, claimText, "Research");
+    const envelope = cls.envelope;
+    if (!envelope || !envelope.ok) {
+      log(`Research: classify error for "${claimText.slice(0, 50)}" — ${cls.stderr || JSON.stringify(envelope)}`);
+      continue;
+    }
+
+    // External-claim handler (§7 marker → research(fable) → cite → flip). Closure so the
+    // ambiguous→judge path reuses it for an "external"/"uncertain" verdict.
+    const doExternal = async () => {
+      log(`Research: external claim → write §7 marker + fable research for "${claimKey.slice(0, 50)}"${artifactPath ? "" : " (FALLBACK artifact — worker reported no path)"}`);
+      // §7: write uncited marker at classify time (to the real OR fallback artifact — fail-CLOSED)
+      await writeUncitedMarker(externalArtifact, claimKey);
+
+      // §2: research agent — bare "fable" tier literal (NOT the ??-override form; contract §2)
+      const researchPrompt = [
+        `Read \`${projectDir}/templates/prompts/research-subagent.md\` for the full research protocol.`,
+        `Your task: verify this external guessed claim via live web sources.`,
+        `Claim: "${claimText}"`,
+        `Gap-key (normalized): "${claimKey}"`,
+        `Emit a ## Verified Facts (auto-research) block with source URL + fetch date per the protocol. Append the trailer \`key: ${claimKey}\` on every fact line so the §7 gate matches by claim-key (Red Team MEDIUM #2).`,
+        `Return StructuredOutput JSON per the schema.`,
+      ].join("\n");
+      const researchResult = await agent(researchPrompt, {
+        label: "research",
+        model: "fable",
+        schema: RESEARCH_RESULT_SCHEMA,
+        phase: "Research",
+      }).catch((e) => ({ ok: false, gapKey: claimKey, reason: `research agent error: ${e && e.message}` }));
+
+      if (researchResult && researchResult.ok && researchResult.citedBlock) {
+        // §7: flip marker to cited + write cited block (real OR fallback artifact)
+        await writeMarkerAndCite(externalArtifact, claimKey, researchResult.citedBlock);
+        log(`Research: cited "${claimKey.slice(0, 50)}" — marker flipped to status=cited`);
+      } else {
+        log(`Research: research FAILED for "${claimKey.slice(0, 50)}" — marker stays uncited. Reason: ${(researchResult && researchResult.reason) || "unknown"}`);
+      }
+    };
+
+    // Internal-claim handler — grep/Read (A3); grep-empty → escalate to external (§5.1).
+    const doInternal = async () => {
+      log(`Research: internal claim → grep/Read for "${claimText.slice(0, 50)}"`);
+      const grepResult = await grepForClaim(projectDir, claimText, "Research");
+      if (grepResult.found) {
+        log(`Research: internal claim resolved by grep (${(grepResult.matches || []).join(", ").slice(0, 80)}) — no research needed`);
+        // No marker, no research stage (A3 — internal class never enters research)
+      } else {
+        // §5.1 escalation: grep-empty → escalate to external. Reuse doExternal() (same
+        // marker→research→cite→flip path, incl. the key: trailer) instead of duplicating it.
+        log(`Research: grep returned nothing — escalating ambiguous claim to external (§5.1): "${claimText.slice(0, 50)}"`);
+        await doExternal();
+      }
+    };
+
+    // ── Dispatch by the 3-result classifier verdict (v1.3.0) ──────────────────
+    if (envelope.class === "external") {
+      await doExternal();
+    } else if (envelope.class === "internal") {
+      await doInternal();
+    } else {
+      // class:AMBIGUOUS — no string fact; the LLM judge decides (NOT regex). internal→grep;
+      // external→research; UNCERTAIN→research (uncertain = verify, NEVER guess-internal).
+      log(`Research: ambiguous claim → LLM judge for "${claimText.slice(0, 50)}" (no string fact; when unsure, research)`);
+      const verdict = await judgeAmbiguous(claimText, "Research");
+      log(`Research: ambiguous claim "${claimKey.slice(0, 50)}" → judge verdict: ${verdict}`);
+      if (verdict === "internal") {
+        await doInternal();
+      } else {
+        if (verdict === "uncertain") log(`Research: judge UNCERTAIN → treating "${claimKey.slice(0, 50)}" as external → research (no silent guess)`);
+        await doExternal();
+      }
+    }
+  }
+}
+
+// ── M90 §2 D4-T4 — Arch-Trigger (protocol-class, extend-existing-code signal) ──
+// For each domain, compute the extend-existing-code signal: any file in filesTouched that
+// already existed on disk before this execute run → extend-class → fire the arch trigger.
+// PRODUCER: signal is computed from real runtime inputs (filesTouched vs. on-disk check).
+// The trigger is best-effort (non-blocking): log results for verify gate; don't halt execute.
+const domainArchTriggerResults = [];
+for (const dr of domainResults.filter(Boolean)) {
+  if (!Array.isArray(dr.filesTouched) || dr.filesTouched.length === 0) continue;
+  // Check which files existed on disk before this run (extend-class signal).
+  // agent()-Bash: check existence via `test -f <file>` for each touched file.
+  const touchedFiles = dr.filesTouched.slice(0, 10); // cap at 10 per domain
+  const checkResult = await agent(
+    [
+      `For the project at \`${projectDir}\`, check which of these files existed on disk BEFORE the current execute run.`,
+      `Files to check: ${JSON.stringify(touchedFiles)}`,
+      `For each file, run: \`test -f '${projectDir}/<file>' && echo EXISTS || echo ABSENT\` (substitute <file> with the actual path).`,
+      `Return JSON: { "existingFiles": ["<file>", ...] } — list ONLY files that exist (exit 0 from test -f).`,
+      `Do NOT modify any files. Read-only existence check.`,
+    ].join("\n"),
+    {
+      label: `arch-trigger-exist-check:${dr.domain}`,
+      phase: "Research",
+      model: "haiku",
+      schema: {
+        type: "object", required: ["existingFiles"],
+        properties: { existingFiles: { type: "array", items: { type: "string" } } },
+        additionalProperties: true,
+      },
+    }
+  ).catch(() => ({ existingFiles: [] }));
+
+  const existingFiles = Array.isArray(checkResult && checkResult.existingFiles) ? checkResult.existingFiles : [];
+  if (existingFiles.length === 0) continue; // no extend-class signal for this domain
+
+  // Signal confirmed: domain extended existing code → fire arch trigger (R-ARCH-2)
+  const triggerInput = JSON.stringify({
+    type: "extend-existing-code",
+    context: `domain:${dr.domain} extended existing files: ${existingFiles.slice(0, 3).join(", ")}`,
+    basis: `Execute domain ${dr.domain} edited existing file(s): ${existingFiles.slice(0, 3).join(", ")}`,
+  });
+  const triggerResult = await runCli(
+    projectDir,
+    "architectural-trigger",
+    ["trigger", triggerInput],
+    "gsd-t-architectural-trigger.cjs",
+    `arch-trigger:${dr.domain}`,
+    true,
+    "Research"
+  );
+  const triggerEnv = triggerResult.envelope || {};
+  log(`M90 arch-trigger ${dr.domain}: fired=${triggerEnv.fired} reason=${triggerEnv.reason || "?"} provenByAdversaryOnly=${triggerEnv.provenByAdversaryOnly || false}`);
+  domainArchTriggerResults.push({
+    domain: dr.domain,
+    existingFiles,
+    fired: triggerEnv.fired || false,
+    reason: triggerEnv.reason || null,
+    provenByAdversaryOnly: triggerEnv.provenByAdversaryOnly || false,
+    stopDirective: triggerEnv.stopDirective || false,
+  });
+}
+log(`M90 arch-trigger: ${domainArchTriggerResults.length} domain(s) fired extend-existing-code signal`);
+
 phase("Integrate");
 const integratePrompt = [
   `You are the integration agent. ${domainResults.length} domain workers have completed.`,
@@ -228,4 +591,6 @@ return {
   domainResults,
   integrate,
   verifyGate: vg.envelope,
+  // M90 §2: arch-trigger results (surfaced for verify gate R-FAIL-2 check)
+  archTriggerResults: domainArchTriggerResults,
 };