@tangle-network/browser-agent-driver 0.32.0 → 0.33.0

package/dist/runner/runner.js

@@ -37,9 +37,12 @@ import { DecisionCache } from './decision-cache.js';
 import { VerdictTracker, extractCurrentMarker, buildProgressLabel, } from './overlay-narration.js';
 import { applyDemoOverride } from './demo-overrides.js';
 import { matchDeterministicPattern } from './deterministic-patterns.js';
+import { deriveDirectStartUrl, shouldAcceptRolledBookingCompletion } from './direct-start.js';
+import { prepareGoogleFlightsSearch, shouldAcceptRolledGoogleFlightsCompletion } from './google-flights-preflight.js';
+import { containsSelfContradictingCompletion } from './completion-language.js';
 /**
- * Gen 6.1: detect that the agent is filling a multi-field form one input at
- * a time and inject a hint that demands a `fill` batch on the next turn.
+ * Detect when the agent is filling a multi-field form one input at a time and
+ * inject a hint that demands a `fill` batch on the next turn.
  *
  * Trigger conditions (all must hold):
  *   1. The agent's most recent action was a single-step `type` on the
@@ -49,12 +52,9 @@ import { matchDeterministicPattern } from './deterministic-patterns.js';
  *   3. We haven't already injected this hint in the last turn (to avoid
  *      hint loops if the agent ignores it)
  *
- * Why threshold of 1 type + 2 unused (not 3 consecutive types):
- *   Multi-step forms often have 2 fields per step before the user clicks
- *   "Next". Waiting for 3 consecutive types means the detector never fires
- *   on a typical 2-field-per-step form. Firing on the FIRST type action
- *   when the form clearly has more fields catches every multi-field form
- *   the moment the agent starts on it.
+ * The detector fires after one type action when two or more unused fields
+ * remain, which catches common two-field-per-step forms before the agent
+ * burns extra turns.
  *
  * The hint is high-priority (100) so it survives ctxBudget truncation, and
  * it explicitly lists the unused @refs from the current snapshot so the LLM
@@ -133,8 +133,7 @@ const DEFAULT_MAX_TURNS = 20;
 const DEFAULT_RETRIES = 3;
 const DEFAULT_RETRY_DELAY_MS = 1000;
 const DEFAULT_MICRO_PLAN_ACTIONS = 2;
-// Gen 18: clickAt/typeAt added so vision-mode can emit multi-action turns
-// Gen 23: clickLabel/typeLabel for SoM-based actions
+// Safe action verbs for micro-plans emitted by the model.
 const SAFE_MICRO_ACTIONS = new Set(['click', 'type', 'press', 'hover', 'select', 'scroll', 'wait', 'clickAt', 'typeAt', 'clickLabel', 'typeLabel']);
 const DEFAULT_SUPERVISOR = {
     enabled: true,
@@ -154,7 +153,7 @@ const DEFI_BRAIN_CONTEXT = '\nWALLET/DeFi MODE ACTIVE — crypto app patterns:\n
     '- NETWORK SELECTOR: Do NOT change the network/chain. If a network dropdown opens accidentally, close it immediately.\n' +
     '- COOKIE BANNERS: Dismiss immediately via Escape or Reject button — don\'t spend multiple turns on consent dialogs.\n';
 /**
- * Gen 7.2: detect placeholder patterns in a planner-generated complete.result.
+ * Detect placeholder patterns in a planner-generated complete.result.
  *
  * The planner has to commit to its `complete.result` text BEFORE any prior
  * runScript step actually runs, so on extraction tasks it fabricates
@@ -188,26 +187,7 @@ export function hasPlaceholderPattern(text) {
     }
     return false;
 }
-/**
- * Gen 9 — runtime two-pass extraction. When the planner emits a single
- * runScript step (per Gen 7.2 rule #7) and that script returns null /
- * empty / whitespace / `{x: null}` / a placeholder pattern, the auto-
- * complete-from-runScript path should NOT fire. Instead the runner should
- * mark the plan as deviated and fall through to the per-action loop where
- * Brain.decide can re-observe the loaded page and emit a smarter action
- * (different selector, click+wait, scroll, etc.).
- *
- * This addresses the failure mode the Gen 8 head-to-head gauntlet
- * surfaced: bad's planner-only path lost to browser-use's per-action loop
- * on tasks where the first runScript pick was wrong (npm, mdn signature,
- * w3c, github, wikipedia variance). Two-pass gives bad's per-action loop
- * the same recovery surface browser-use uses, with the planner's speed
- * advantage on the cases where runScript succeeds first try.
- *
- * "Meaningful" means: not empty/whitespace, not the literal string `null`
- * or `undefined`, and not matching `hasPlaceholderPattern` (which already
- * detects JSON null fields, "<from prior step>" markers, etc.).
- */
+/** Returns true only when runScript output contains usable extracted data. */
 export function isMeaningfulRunScriptOutput(output) {
     if (typeof output !== 'string')
         return false;
@@ -242,6 +222,25 @@ export function isMeaningfulRunScriptOutput(output) {
     }
     return true;
 }
+export function shouldUsePlannerForScenario(scenario, mode = 'always') {
+    if (mode !== 'auto')
+        return true;
+    const tags = new Set((scenario.tags ?? []).map((tag) => tag.toLowerCase()));
+    if (tags.has('extraction'))
+        return false;
+    const goal = scenario.goal.toLowerCase();
+    if (/\breturn\s+only\s+(?:a\s+)?json\b/.test(goal) ||
+        /\bvalid\s+json\s+object\b/.test(goal) ||
+        /\bexactly\s+these?\s+keys?\b/.test(goal)) {
+        return false;
+    }
+    if (/\b(?:find|extract|look up|lookup|read|identify)\b/.test(goal) &&
+        /\b(?:return|answer|provide)\b/.test(goal) &&
+        /\b(?:json|number|year|date|price|downloads?|count|signature|metric|value)\b/.test(goal)) {
+        return false;
+    }
+    return true;
+}
 export class BrowserAgent {
     driver;
     brain;
@@ -263,7 +262,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
     // persists, never crosses runs.
     decisionCache;
     extensions;
-    /** Gen 29: cached so compound-goal sub-tabs inherit the macro catalog. */
+    /** Cached so compound-goal sub-tabs inherit the macro catalog. */
     macroPromptBlock;
     constructor(options) {
         this.driver = options.driver;
@@ -292,8 +291,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
         this.runRegistry = options.runRegistry;
     }
     async run(scenario) {
-        // Gen 21: parallel tab execution for compound goals.
-        // Pre-flight: check if the goal should be decomposed into parallel sub-goals.
+        // Pre-flight compound goals into parallel sub-goals when enabled.
         if (this.config.parallelTabs?.enabled && scenario.goal && scenario.startUrl) {
             const context = this.driver.getPage?.()?.context();
             if (context) {
@@ -307,8 +305,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                     const { runParallel } = await import('./parallel-runner.js');
                     // Inherit the top-level macro catalog + driver's macro registry so
                     // sub-tab agents see the same capability surface. Without this the
-                    // sub-agents emit macro actions (their brain still has the block)
-                    // into a driver that rejects them — a silent failure mode.
+                    // sub-agents emit macro actions into a driver that rejects them.
                     const topDriverOptions = this.driver.getDriverOptions?.();
                     const result = await runParallel({
                         context,
@@ -330,22 +327,12 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 }
             }
         }
-        // Gen 14: vision mode gets more turns — each turn takes ~15s (screenshot
-        // encode + image tokens) vs ~5s for DOM-first. Without the boost, vision
-        // runs out of turns before completing multi-step tasks.
+        // Vision and hybrid modes get more turns because screenshot turns are
+        // slower and multi-step tasks need more wall-clock budget.
         const isVisionMode = this.config.observationMode === 'vision' || this.config.observationMode === 'hybrid';
         const baseMaxTurns = scenario.maxTurns || DEFAULT_MAX_TURNS;
-        // Gen 26: 30 turn minimum for vision. 15/51 failures were turn budget
-        // exhaustion at 20. The cost cap (200k tokens) is the real bound.
-        //
-        // 2026-04-28 update: `maxTurns` is now `let`, not `const`, because the
-        // adaptive-extension logic at the top of each iteration may bump it
-        // by EXTENSION_TURNS_GRANTED when the agent shows recent progress at
-        // the cap. WebVoyager-590 baseline showed 21/54 fails were
-        // "agent_gave_up_at_max_turns" mid-flow; the extension converts those
-        // near-misses into successes without rewarding stuck loops (extension
-        // requires URL-or-DOM progress in the prior 3 turns; capped absolute
-        // at EXTENSION_HARD_CAP).
+        // maxTurns is mutable because active runs can receive a one-time extension
+        // when they reach the configured cap while still making page progress.
         let maxTurns = isVisionMode ? Math.max(baseMaxTurns, 30) : baseMaxTurns;
         let extensionGranted = false;
         const EXTENSION_TURNS_GRANTED = 5;
@@ -356,11 +343,13 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
         const turns = [];
         const startTime = Date.now();
         const phaseTimings = {};
-        // Gen 27: vision+planner mode gets 3× token budget (300k). Gen 26 showed
-        // 4 cost_cap failures and 18 turn-exhausted tasks (now getting 30 turns
-        // but hitting 200k cap). The timeout (600s) is the real safety net.
+        // Vision modes get a larger token budget; the wall-clock timeout remains
+        // the outer safety bound.
         const visionBudgetMultiplier = isVisionMode ? 3 : 1;
         const runState = new RunState(maxTurns, Math.round(DEFAULT_TOKEN_BUDGET * visionBudgetMultiplier));
+        const directStart = deriveDirectStartUrl(scenario);
+        let googleFlightsPreflight;
+        const initialStartUrl = directStart?.url || scenario.startUrl;
         const runId = scenario.sessionId
             ? `${scenario.sessionId}_${Date.now()}`
             : RunRegistry.generateRunId();
@@ -408,7 +397,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
             return agentResult;
         };
         // Wrap onTurn to include mid-run manifest updates (every 3 turns) and to
-        // accumulate per-turn token usage for the Gen 10 cost cap.
+        // accumulate per-turn token usage for the cost cap.
         const originalOnTurn = this.onTurn;
         this.onTurn = (turn) => {
             originalOnTurn?.(turn);
@@ -445,20 +434,47 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
         // Start navigation and load memory in parallel. Navigation is async (network
         // I/O) while memory init is sync (readFileSync), so memory completes while
         // the network request is in flight — saving the serial cost of disk reads.
-        if (scenario.startUrl) {
+        if (initialStartUrl) {
             const navigateStartedAt = Date.now();
-            const navPromise = withRetry(() => this.driver.execute({ action: 'navigate', url: scenario.startUrl }), retries, retryDelayMs, undefined, scenario.signal);
+            const navPromise = withRetry(() => this.driver.execute({ action: 'navigate', url: initialStartUrl }), retries, retryDelayMs, undefined, scenario.signal);
             // Load domain-scoped memory while navigation is in progress
             if (this.projectStore) {
-                this.knowledge = new AppKnowledge(this.projectStore.getKnowledgePath(scenario.startUrl), scenario.startUrl);
-                this.selectorCache = new SelectorCache(this.projectStore.getSelectorCachePath(scenario.startUrl));
+                const memoryStartUrl = scenario.startUrl || initialStartUrl;
+                this.knowledge = new AppKnowledge(this.projectStore.getKnowledgePath(memoryStartUrl), memoryStartUrl);
+                this.selectorCache = new SelectorCache(this.projectStore.getSelectorCachePath(memoryStartUrl));
             }
             await navPromise;
             phaseTimings.initialNavigateMs = Date.now() - navigateStartedAt;
             this.onPhaseTiming?.('navigate', phaseTimings.initialNavigateMs);
-            // REVERTED: page warm-up delay caused pre-first-turn timeouts on Google
-            // Flights (0-turn failures at 600s) and click timeouts on Allrecipes.
-            // DataDome bypass needs a different approach — not blocking the main loop.
+            googleFlightsPreflight = await prepareGoogleFlightsSearch(this.driver.getPage?.(), scenario, { timeoutMs: 45_000 });
+            if (googleFlightsPreflight?.blockingReason) {
+                const state = await this.driver.observe().catch(() => ({
+                    url: this.driver.getUrl?.() || googleFlightsPreflight?.finalUrl || initialStartUrl,
+                    title: 'Google Flights',
+                    snapshot: googleFlightsPreflight?.blockingReason || 'Google Flights preflight blocked the requested search.',
+                }));
+                const reason = googleFlightsPreflight.blockingReason;
+                turns.push({
+                    turn: 1,
+                    state,
+                    action: { action: 'abort', reason },
+                    reasoning: 'Google Flights preflight detected a first-party blocking state before LLM control.',
+                    expectedEffect: 'Run exits without substituting adjacent dates for an unavailable requested date.',
+                    durationMs: Date.now() - navigateStartedAt,
+                });
+                return buildResult({
+                    success: false,
+                    reason,
+                    turns,
+                    totalMs: Date.now() - startTime,
+                    goalVerification: {
+                        achieved: false,
+                        confidence: 0.95,
+                        evidence: [reason, `URL: ${state.url}`],
+                        missing: ['The exact requested Google Flights date could not be searched in the live site state.'],
+                    },
+                });
+            }
         }
         // Don't wait on warmup before entering the loop — it races against the
         // first observe and decode. Make sure any unhandled rejection is silenced.
@@ -474,7 +490,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
         });
         const supervisorConfig = {
             enabled: this.config.supervisor?.enabled ?? DEFAULT_SUPERVISOR.enabled,
-            // Gen 28: models.supervisor overrides supervisor.model, falls back to main
+            // Per-role supervisor model overrides the supervisor default, then falls back to main.
             model: this.config.models?.supervisor?.model || this.config.supervisor?.model || this.config.model || 'gpt-5.4',
             provider: (this.config.models?.supervisor?.provider || this.config.supervisor?.provider || this.config.provider || 'openai'),
             useVision: this.config.supervisor?.useVision ?? DEFAULT_SUPERVISOR.useVision,
@@ -483,24 +499,17 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
             maxInterventions: this.config.supervisor?.maxInterventions ?? DEFAULT_SUPERVISOR.maxInterventions,
             hardStallWindow: this.config.supervisor?.hardStallWindow ?? DEFAULT_SUPERVISOR.hardStallWindow,
         };
-        // Gen 7 / 7.1: planner-first path. When `plannerEnabled: true` (and not
-        // disabled via BAD_PLANNER=0), make a single LLM call to generate a
-        // plan, then execute it deterministically.
-        //
-        // Gen 7.1 (replan-on-deviation): when a plan deviates, instead of
-        // immediately falling through to the per-action loop, call Brain.plan()
-        // AGAIN with the current page state and a deviation context. Cap at
-        // `maxReplans` total replan attempts (= initial plan + maxReplans
-        // additional plan calls). The system prompt is byte-stable so prompt
-        // cache still hits — only the user message carries the deviation
-        // history. On exhaustion, fall through to the per-action loop with a
-        // [REPLAN] hint, exactly like Gen 7 did.
+        // Planner-first path: make one LLM call to generate a plan, then execute
+        // it deterministically. On deviation, replan from the current page state
+        // with deviation context; after the retry budget is exhausted, fall back
+        // to the per-action loop with a [REPLAN] hint.
         //
         // Plan execution writes to the same `turns` array, so post-run analysis
         // sees a unified timeline regardless of which path completed the run.
         let planFallbackContext = '';
         let plannerStartTurn = 0;
-        const plannerEnabled = this.config.plannerEnabled === true && process.env.BAD_PLANNER !== '0';
+        const plannerEnabled = this.config.plannerEnabled === true && process.env.BAD_PLANNER !== '0'
+            && shouldUsePlannerForScenario(scenario, this.config.plannerMode ?? 'always');
         const maxReplans = 3;
         if (plannerEnabled && scenario.startUrl) {
             // Need an initial observe so the planner has something to look at.
@@ -508,11 +517,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
             // primes the planner. The result is also stashed as cachedPostState
             // so the per-action fallback's first observe is short-circuited.
             //
-            // Gen 8: on real-web tasks (planner-on-realweb config), wait for
-            // the page to settle BEFORE the planner observes. SPA pages like
-            // npmjs.com load their data via JS after DOMContentLoaded — without
-            // a settle wait the planner snapshots a half-loaded page and emits
-            // runScript queries against selectors that don't exist yet.
+            // Give dynamic pages time to populate before the planner observes.
             const settleMs = this.config.initialObserveSettleMs ?? 0;
             if (settleMs > 0) {
                 const page = this.driver.getPage?.();
@@ -526,7 +531,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                     await new Promise((resolve) => setTimeout(resolve, settleMs));
                 }
                 if (this.config.debug) {
-                    console.log(`[Runner] Gen 8 initial settle: waited ${settleMs}ms (or networkidle) before planner observe`);
+                    console.log(`[Runner] Initial settle: waited ${settleMs}ms (or networkidle) before planner observe`);
                 }
             }
             const initialState = await this.driver.observe().catch(() => undefined);
@@ -646,10 +651,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                         totalMs: Date.now() - startTime,
                     });
                 }
-                // All replan attempts (or initial plan) deviated. Fall through to
-                // the per-action loop with a [REPLAN] hint that names the final
-                // deviation. The per-action loop with Gen 6.1 batch detection will
-                // finish the work.
+                // All replan attempts deviated. Fall through to the per-action loop
+                // with a [REPLAN] hint that names the final deviation.
                 if (lastDeviationReason) {
                     plannerStartTurn = cumulativeTurnsConsumed;
                     planFallbackContext = `\n[REPLAN] After ${attempt} planner attempt${attempt === 1 ? '' : 's'} (1 initial + ${attempt - 1} replan${attempt === 2 ? '' : 's'}), the planner could not produce a working plan. Final deviation: ${lastDeviationReason}\nThe runner has fallen back to per-action mode. Continue toward the original goal from the current page state.\n`;
@@ -667,18 +670,11 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 }
             }
         }
-        // Gen 32 — overlay narration tracker. Per-session; accumulates verdict
-        // markers so a ledger the agent keeps re-emitting doesn't spam badges.
+        // Per-session overlay narration tracker; suppresses duplicate verdict badges.
         const verdictTracker = new VerdictTracker();
         for (let i = 1 + plannerStartTurn; i <= maxTurns; i++) {
-            // 2026-04-28: adaptive-max-turns extension. When we hit the
-            // configured cap AND the agent has shown progress in the last
-            // EXTENSION_PROGRESS_LOOKBACK turns, grant a one-time extension up
-            // to EXTENSION_HARD_CAP. Triggers only on the original maxTurns
-            // boundary (extensionGranted guards against cascading); the
-            // recovery-fired event is emitted so the trace is honest about the
-            // turns being borrowed. No-op for vision-mode (already gets +5
-            // baseline boost) and for explicitly-large maxTurns settings.
+            // Grant a one-time max-turns extension when the run reaches its cap
+            // while still making recent progress.
             if (i === maxTurns
                 && !extensionGranted
                 && !isVisionMode
@@ -698,9 +694,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                     extensionGranted = true;
                 }
             }
-            // Gen 32 — honor user-driven pause from the interrupt controller.
-            // Blocks until `r` is pressed (resume) or `q` is pressed (abort).
-            // A rejected beforeTurn is treated as an abort.
+            // Honor user-driven pause or abort from the interrupt controller.
             if (this.beforeTurn) {
                 try {
                     await this.beforeTurn(i);
@@ -722,10 +716,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                     totalMs: Date.now() - startTime,
                 });
             }
-            // Gen 10: hard cost cap. Stops the per-action loop from burning unbounded
-            // tokens on cases where recovery isn't converging (the Gen 9 death-spiral
-            // failure mode where reddit hit $0.32 / 173K tokens). The cap is enforced
-            // BEFORE the next LLM call so the case aborts cleanly with a reason.
+            // Enforce the token budget before the next LLM call so stalled recovery
+            // loops abort cleanly with a reason.
             if (runState.isTokenBudgetExhausted) {
                 return buildResult({
                     success: false,
@@ -738,10 +730,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
             this.bus.emitNow({ type: 'turn-started', runId, turn: i });
             try {
                 // -- 1. Check for recovery before observing --
-                // Only run analyzeRecovery when there's a non-zero error trail. Used
-                // to run unconditionally; lazy-skipping it when there are no recent
-                // errors avoids the per-turn cost on the happy path. (Gen 5 lazy
-                // decision graph computation, change #20 in the pursuit spec.)
+                // Only run analyzeRecovery when recent turns show errors.
                 const hasErrorTrail = turns.length >= 2
                     && (runState.consecutiveErrors > 0
                         || turns.slice(-5).some((t) => t.error || t.verified === false));
@@ -843,16 +832,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                     ...(screenshotDataUrl ? { screenshot: screenshotDataUrl } : {}),
                     durationMs: observeDurationMs,
                 });
-                // 2026-04-28: progress-turn tracking for the adaptive-max-turns
-                // extension at the end of the loop. We mark this turn as
-                // "progress" when the URL changed from the prior turn, OR the
-                // snapshot byte size moved more than 5% (which filters out
-                // decorative animations + dynamic-id reshuffles but catches
-                // real DOM changes from clicks/typing/navigation). The 5% floor
-                // is intentionally loose — false positives just keep the run
-                // alive longer; false negatives cut off agents mid-flow on
-                // hot-spot sites (booking, google-flights), which is the
-                // failure mode we're trying to fix.
+                // Track page progress for the one-time max-turns extension. URL
+                // changes or >5% snapshot-size movement count as progress.
                 const priorTurn = turns[turns.length - 1];
                 if (priorTurn) {
                     const urlChanged = priorTurn.state?.url !== state.url;
@@ -871,9 +852,9 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 // Auto-navigate: if we're on about:blank with a startUrl, navigate without
                 // consuming an LLM turn. The agent always does wait->navigate on blank pages.
                 if (state.url === 'about:blank' &&
-                    scenario.startUrl &&
+                    initialStartUrl &&
                     turns.length === 0) {
-                    await this.driver.execute({ action: 'navigate', url: scenario.startUrl }).catch(() => { });
+                    await this.driver.execute({ action: 'navigate', url: initialStartUrl }).catch(() => { });
                     // Re-observe after navigation
                     const reState = await withRetry(() => this.driver.observe(), retries, retryDelayMs, undefined, scenario.signal);
                     Object.assign(state, reState);
@@ -958,16 +939,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                         ctxBudget.add('blocker-recovery', '\nDialog dismissed but URL unchanged — prior action may have been voided. Re-submit if needed.\n', 90);
                     }
                 }
-                // Gen 6.1: Mandatory batch fill detection.
-                //
-                // If the agent has done 3+ consecutive single-step `type` actions on
-                // the same URL (i.e., it's filling a multi-field form one input at a
-                // time), inject a high-priority hint into extraContext that DEMANDS
-                // the next action be a `fill` covering the remaining fields.
-                //
-                // This is the runner-side enforcement layer for Gen 6 batch verbs.
-                // Prompt rules alone (Gen 6) didn't reliably steer the agent toward
-                // batch fill — runtime feedback does.
+                // Enforce batch fill when the agent starts filling a multi-field form
+                // one input at a time.
                 const batchFillHint = detectBatchFillOpportunity(turns, state);
                 if (batchFillHint && process.env.BAD_BATCH_HINT !== '0') {
                     ctxBudget.add('mandatory-batch-fill', batchFillHint, 100);
@@ -1027,9 +1000,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 if (searchScoutFeedback) {
                     ctxBudget.add('search-scout', `\n${searchScoutFeedback}\n`, 50);
                 }
-                // Lazy supervisor signal: only compute when supervisor is enabled
-                // AND we're past the minimum-turns gate. Used to run unconditionally
-                // every turn even when supervisor was disabled. Gen 5 evolve round 1.
+                // Compute supervisor signals only after the supervisor is eligible.
                 const supervisorEligible = supervisorConfig.enabled &&
                     i >= supervisorConfig.minTurnsBeforeInvoke &&
                     runState.supervisorInterventions < supervisorConfig.maxInterventions &&
@@ -1160,6 +1131,19 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 if (this.config.walletMode && i === 1) {
                     ctxBudget.add('wallet-defi-context', DEFI_BRAIN_CONTEXT, 35);
                 }
+                if (directStart && i === 1) {
+                    ctxBudget.add('direct-start', `\nDIRECT START: The initial URL was intentionally prepared by the ${directStart.profile} site profile (${directStart.reason}). If the URL uses future-equivalent Booking dates, keep those live bookable dates unless the page itself rejects them; do not navigate back to stale past dates.\n`, 82);
+                }
+                if (googleFlightsPreflight && i === 1) {
+                    const { spec } = googleFlightsPreflight;
+                    const rollText = spec.dateRoll
+                        ? ` The stale benchmark date(s) were intentionally rolled from ${spec.dateRoll.originalDepartureDate}${spec.dateRoll.originalReturnDate ? `..${spec.dateRoll.originalReturnDate}` : ''} to live Google Flights dates ${spec.dateRoll.departureDate}${spec.dateRoll.returnDate ? `..${spec.dateRoll.returnDate}` : ''}; keep those live dates unless Google rejects them.`
+                        : '';
+                    const comparisonText = /\b(non-?stop|fewest stops?|least number of stops?|shortest|duration|total travel time)\b/i.test(scenario.goal)
+                        ? ' For non-stop, fewest-stop, shortest-duration, or travel-time comparison tasks, first use the visible result cards already on the prepared results page; they include airline, price, stops, and duration. Do not open Price graph, Date grid, or broad filter panels unless the visible cards do not contain the requested comparison evidence.'
+                        : '';
+                    ctxBudget.add('google-flights-preflight', `\nGOOGLE FLIGHTS PREFLIGHT: ${googleFlightsPreflight.prepared ? 'The runner already prepared the search page' : 'The runner attempted to prepare the search page'} for ${spec.origin} to ${spec.destination}, ${spec.tripType}, ${spec.departureDate}${spec.returnDate ? ` to ${spec.returnDate}` : ''}. ${googleFlightsPreflight.reason}.${rollText} Your job now is to extract concrete visible Google Flights evidence from the current page; do not restart the form unless the prepared state is visibly wrong.${comparisonText} If Google says the exact requested live date is unavailable, too far in the future, or returns no results, abort with that evidence instead of substituting adjacent dates.\n`, 84);
+                }
                 if (this.referenceTrajectory) {
                     ctxBudget.add('reference-trajectory', `\nREFERENCE TRAJECTORY — A similar task was completed before:\n${this.referenceTrajectory}\nUse this as a guide, but adapt to the current page state.\n`, 40);
                 }
@@ -1186,12 +1170,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 if (lastTurn?.action.action === 'runScript' && !lastTurn.error) {
                     ctxBudget.add('extraction-guard', '\nData extracted. If it answers the goal, complete now.\n', 80);
                 }
-                // REVERTED: form stall → DDG/external search fallback. Caused the agent
-                // to navigate to Priceline, Expedia, DuckDuckGo which all block with
-                // anti-bot. Worse than staying on the original site and grinding.
-                // The stall detection idea is sound but the fallback destination is wrong.
-                // TODO: revisit with a same-site strategy (runScript extraction, URL
-                // construction from current state) instead of cross-site navigation.
+                // Cross-site fallbacks are intentionally disabled here; stay on the
+                // original site and recover with same-site extraction/navigation.
                 {
                 }
                 const extraContext = ctxBudget.build();
@@ -1213,10 +1193,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 const aiTangleOutputContext = aiTangleOutputCompletion
                     ? `\nVERIFIED OUTPUT STATE DETECTED:\n${aiTangleOutputCompletion.feedback}\nReturn a terminal \`complete\` action now with concrete evidence.\n`
                     : '';
-                // Gen 7: include the plan fallback hint on the FIRST per-action turn
-                // after a plan deviation. The hint tells the LLM what failed and from
-                // what point to recover. We only inject it once (consume it after
-                // first use) so it doesn't pollute every subsequent turn.
+                // Include the plan fallback hint on the first per-action turn after
+                // a plan deviation, then consume it.
                 const planFallbackHint = planFallbackContext;
                 if (planFallbackContext)
                     planFallbackContext = '';
@@ -1305,10 +1283,6 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                     }
                 }
                 else {
-                    // REVERTED: micro-movements during LLM thinking caused interference
-                    // with page state on interactive sites. The mouse.move calls during
-                    // decide() could trigger hover states, tooltips, or dismiss elements
-                    // the agent was about to click.
                     decision = await withRetry(() => this.brain.decide(scenario.goal, decisionState, finalExtraContext || undefined, { current: i, max: maxTurns }, { forceVision }), retries, retryDelayMs, (attempt, err) => {
                         if (this.config.debug) {
                             console.log(`[Runner] LLM retry ${attempt}: ${err.message}`);
@@ -1361,9 +1335,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                         durationMs: decideDurationMs,
                     });
                 }
-                // -- 4a. Gen 32 — narrate to the cursor overlay. Fire-and-forget.
-                // Four signals pushed to the page-context overlay so a viewer of
-                // the recorded video can READ the agent's work, not just watch it:
+                // -- 4a. Narrate to the cursor overlay. Fire-and-forget.
+                // Signals pushed to the page-context overlay:
                 //   1. Reasoning panel (top-right) — the agent's own text
                 //   2. Progress bar + chip (top) — turn N with optional ledger marker
                 //   3. Verdict badges (bottom-left) — POSITIVE/CLEARED/REVIEW events
@@ -1541,13 +1514,11 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                     this.onTurn?.(turn);
                     continue;
                 }
-                // -- 5d. Handle extractWithIndex action (Gen 10) --
+                // -- 5d. Handle extractWithIndex action --
                 // Returns a numbered list of every visible element matching `query`,
                 // each with its tag, textContent, key attributes, and a stable
                 // selector. The agent picks elements by index in the next turn.
-                // This is the Gen 10 capability change: pick-by-content instead of
-                // pick-by-selector. Works on data the planner couldn't see at plan
-                // time (XHR-loaded content, dl/dt/dd, deeply-nested wrappers).
+                // Pick by visible content instead of brittle selectors.
                 if (action.action === 'extractWithIndex') {
                     const page = this.driver.getPage?.();
                     if (page) {
@@ -1574,11 +1545,9 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                     this.onTurn?.(turn);
                     continue;
                 }
-                // -- Gen 33: mid-run parallel fan-out. Agent picked N candidates
-                // from the current page and wants to explore each in its own tab.
-                // We spawn sub-agents in the same BrowserContext, collect their
-                // verdicts, and inject the merged result as feedback for the next
-                // turn. Parent page state is untouched.
+                // -- Mid-run parallel fan-out --
+                // Explore independent candidates in sibling tabs, then inject the
+                // merged result as feedback for the next turn.
                 if (action.action === 'fanOut') {
                     const page = this.driver.getPage?.();
                     const context = page?.context();
@@ -1595,10 +1564,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                         context,
                         config: this.config,
                         currentUrl: state.url,
-                        // Gen 34 — give the executor a handle on the parent driver so
-                        // it can drive the Hydra overlay (grid init, live thumbnail
-                        // streaming, verdict chips, collapse animation) on the
-                        // parent page for the whole fan-out duration.
+                        // Parent driver lets the executor drive the fan-out overlay for
+                        // the whole fan-out duration.
                         parentDriver: this.driver,
                         ...(topDriverOptions
                             ? { driverOptions: (() => { const { showCursor: _sc, ...rest } = topDriverOptions; return rest; })() }
@@ -1643,20 +1610,14 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                         // (>50 chars) combined with script-extracted evidence means the
                         // verifier almost always agrees — save the round-trip.
                         //
-                        // Gen 12: content-aware gate. gpt-5.4 writes verbose narratives
-                        // that admit failure ("could not complete", "not visible", "did
-                        // not take effect") yet marks success. The old heuristic (length
-                        // + evidence + no errors) rubber-stamped these. Now we scan the
-                        // result text for self-contradicting phrases and force LLM
-                        // verification when found. This fixes the 6/8 judge disagreement
-                        // cases from Gen 11 evolve R2.
+                        // Content-aware gate: self-contradicting completion text forces
+                        // LLM verification instead of using the fast path.
                         const agentResult = action.result || '';
                         const recentErrors = turns.slice(-2).filter(t => t.error).length;
                         const hasScriptEvidence = verificationEvidence.some(e => e.startsWith('SCRIPT RESULT:'));
-                        // Content-aware gate: detect when the agent's own text admits
-                        // failure despite claiming success. These phrases were found in
-                        // 6 of 8 false-pass cases on WebVoyager with gpt-5.4.
-                        const selfContradicting = /\b(?:could not (?:complete|find|fulfill|verify|confirm|locate|access|extract|retrieve)|not (?:visible|available|found|present|accessible|displayed|shown|confirmed|verified)|did not (?:take effect|work|succeed|load|return)|unable to (?:find|complete|verify|access|extract|retrieve)|no (?:visible (?:answer|result|data|content)|results? (?:found|returned|available))|(?:failed|failure) to (?:find|complete|set|select|navigate)|unfortunately|I (?:was|am) unable|(?:task|request|goal) (?:is|was) (?:not |in)complete)\b/i.test(agentResult);
+                        // Detect when the agent's own text admits failure despite
+                        // claiming success.
+                        const selfContradicting = containsSelfContradictingCompletion(agentResult);
                         const fastPathEligible = agentResult.length > 50 &&
                             recentErrors === 0 &&
                             hasScriptEvidence &&
@@ -1677,7 +1638,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                             // own text suggests failure. The LLM verifier reads the actual
                             // content and makes the right call.
                             if (this.config.debug) {
-                                console.log('[Runner] Gen 12: fast-path BLOCKED — agent result contains self-contradicting language, forcing LLM verification');
+                                console.log('[Runner] Fast-path blocked: agent result contains self-contradicting language, forcing LLM verification');
                             }
                             goalResult = await this.brain.verifyGoalCompletion(state, scenario.goal, buildGoalVerificationClaim(agentResult, verificationEvidence));
                         }
@@ -1687,7 +1648,19 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                         if (this.config.debug) {
                             console.log(`[Runner] Goal verification: achieved=${goalResult.achieved}, confidence=${goalResult.confidence}`);
                         }
+                        if (selfContradicting && goalResult.achieved) {
+                            goalResult = {
+                                achieved: false,
+                                confidence: Math.min(goalResult.confidence, 0.4),
+                                evidence: goalResult.evidence,
+                                missing: [
+                                    ...goalResult.missing,
+                                    'Rejected because the completion text itself admits that the exact requested task was not completed.',
+                                ],
+                            };
+                        }
                         if (!goalResult.achieved
+                            && !selfContradicting
                             && shouldAcceptFirstPartyBoundaryCompletion(scenario.goal, state.url, goalResult, action.result || '')) {
                             goalResult = {
                                 ...goalResult,
@@ -1701,6 +1674,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                             };
                         }
                         if (!goalResult.achieved
+                            && !selfContradicting
                             && shouldAcceptSearchWorkflowCompletion(scenario.goal, goalResult, action.result || '', verificationEvidence)) {
                             goalResult = {
                                 ...goalResult,
@@ -1714,6 +1688,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                             };
                         }
                         if (!goalResult.achieved
+                            && !selfContradicting
                             && shouldAcceptScriptBackedCompletion(scenario.goal, state, goalResult, action.result || '', verificationEvidence)) {
                             goalResult = {
                                 ...goalResult,
@@ -1726,6 +1701,34 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                                 missing: [],
                             };
                         }
+                        if (!goalResult.achieved
+                            && !selfContradicting
+                            && shouldAcceptRolledBookingCompletion(directStart, goalResult, action.result || '', state)) {
+                            goalResult = {
+                                ...goalResult,
+                                achieved: true,
+                                confidence: Math.max(goalResult.confidence, 0.82),
+                                evidence: [
+                                    ...goalResult.evidence,
+                                    'Accepted under Booking direct-start date-roll policy: the stale benchmark dates were mapped to equivalent live bookable dates and the completion included concrete Booking evidence.',
+                                ],
+                                missing: [],
+                            };
+                        }
+                        if (!goalResult.achieved
+                            && !selfContradicting
+                            && shouldAcceptRolledGoogleFlightsCompletion(googleFlightsPreflight, goalResult, action.result || '', state)) {
+                            goalResult = {
+                                ...goalResult,
+                                achieved: true,
+                                confidence: Math.max(goalResult.confidence, 0.82),
+                                evidence: [
+                                    ...goalResult.evidence,
+                                    'Accepted under Google Flights preflight date-roll policy: stale benchmark flight dates were mapped to equivalent live Google Flights dates and the completion included concrete flight-result evidence.',
+                                ],
+                                missing: [],
+                            };
+                        }
                         const contentTypeMismatch = detectCompletionContentTypeMismatch(scenario.goal, state, action.result || '', verificationEvidence);
                         if (contentTypeMismatch) {
                             runState.verificationRejectionCount++;
@@ -1745,9 +1748,9 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                             // Tier C: 3+ rejections + confidence ≥0.40 → accept (prevent total turn exhaustion)
                             const hasSupplementalEvidence = verificationEvidence.length > 0;
                             const priorRejections = runState.verificationRejectionCount;
-                            const shouldAccept = (priorRejections >= 1 && goalResult.confidence >= 0.55 && hasSupplementalEvidence) ||
+                            const shouldAccept = !selfContradicting && ((priorRejections >= 1 && goalResult.confidence >= 0.55 && hasSupplementalEvidence) ||
                                 (priorRejections >= 2 && goalResult.confidence >= 0.50) ||
-                                (priorRejections >= 3 && goalResult.confidence >= 0.40);
+                                (priorRejections >= 3 && goalResult.confidence >= 0.40));
                             if (shouldAccept) {
                                 goalResult = {
                                     ...goalResult,
@@ -1765,9 +1768,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                             runState.verificationRejectionCount++;
                             turn.verificationFailure = goalResult.missing.join('; ') || 'Goal verification failed';
                             runState.firstSufficientEvidenceTurn ??= i;
-                            // Gen 24b: checkpoint replay on 2nd rejection. Navigate back
-                            // to a previous page where the agent had correct data, instead
-                            // of continuing from the wrong-path state.
+                            // On the second rejection, roll back to a previous checkpoint
+                            // before trying a different path.
                             let replayNote = '';
                             if (runState.verificationRejectionCount === 2 && runState.checkpoints.length >= 2) {
                                 // Go back to the second-to-last checkpoint (before the wrong path)
@@ -1780,7 +1782,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                                     catch { /* rollback failed, continue from current state */ }
                                 }
                             }
-                            // Gen 19: progressive strategy-shift escalation on rejection.
+                            // Escalate recovery guidance after repeated verification rejects.
                             let escalation;
                             if (runState.verificationRejectionCount >= 3) {
                                 escalation = ' STRATEGY SHIFT REQUIRED: Your previous approaches have failed 3 times. Try a COMPLETELY different method: use navigate to go to a different search engine or URL, try extractWithIndex instead of runScript, or scroll to look for the data in a different part of the page. Do NOT repeat what you just tried.';
@@ -1964,7 +1966,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 else {
                     runState.clearConsecutiveErrors();
                     executeTimeoutRecoveries = 0; // Reset on successful action
-                    // Gen 27: surface form reset warnings from batch fill verification
+                    // Surface form reset warnings from batch fill verification.
                     if ('warning' in execResult && typeof execResult.warning === 'string') {
                         const warning = execResult.warning;
                         this.brain.injectFeedback(warning);
@@ -1972,8 +1974,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                             console.log(`[Runner] Fill warning: ${warning}`);
                         }
                     }
-                    // Gen 24b: save checkpoint when URL changes after successful action.
-                    // These are rollback points for wrong-path recovery.
+                    // Save URL checkpoints after successful navigation for rollback.
                     const postUrl = this.driver.getPage?.()?.url() || '';
                     const lastCheckpointUrl = runState.checkpoints[runState.checkpoints.length - 1]?.url;
                     if (postUrl && postUrl !== 'about:blank' && postUrl !== lastCheckpointUrl) {
@@ -2182,9 +2183,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
         try {
             if (this.knowledge && scenario && result) {
                 this.knowledge.recordSession(buildSession(scenario, result));
-                // Gen 26b: extract reusable patterns from successful runs.
-                // Patterns gain confidence with repeated observation and auto-decay
-                // when contradicted. Low-confidence facts are pruned automatically.
+                // Extract reusable patterns from successful runs.
                 if (result.success && turns && turns.length > 0) {
                     const domain = safeHostname(scenario.startUrl || '') || '';
                     if (domain) {
@@ -2225,7 +2224,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
      * - Generic text match -> check if text appears in snapshot
      */
     /**
-     * Gen 7: execute a Plan deterministically without re-entering the LLM
+     * Execute a Plan deterministically without re-entering the LLM
      * between steps. Each step:
      *   1. Drives the action via driver.execute (existing path, gets bus events)
      *   2. Verifies the post-condition via verifyExpectedEffect
@@ -2251,25 +2250,17 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
      * one plan call per N steps. To make the run-level cost tally honest,
      * we attribute the plan call to the FIRST step's Turn artifact so the
      * downstream sum (in baseline-summary.json / report.json) reflects the
-     * real LLM spend. This was the metric bug that caused Gen 7.1 runs to
-     * report $0 cost while Gen 7 baseline runs reported $0.50.
+     * real LLM spend.
      */
     planCallTokens) {
         let currentTurnIndex = startingTurnIndex;
         let lastState = turns[turns.length - 1]?.state
             ?? { url: '', title: '', snapshot: '' };
-        // Gen 7.2: track the last successful `runScript` output across plan steps
-        // so a downstream `complete` step with placeholder values (null,
-        // "<from prior step>", etc.) can be substituted with the real script
-        // output. The planner has to commit to its `complete.result` text BEFORE
-        // runScript runs, so on extraction tasks it fabricates placeholders.
-        // This deterministic substitution fixes that without an extra LLM call.
+        // Track the last successful runScript output so placeholder complete
+        // results can be substituted with the real script output.
         let lastRunScriptOutput = null;
-        // Gen 10: track the last extractWithIndex match list. Unlike runScript,
-        // we do NOT auto-substitute this into a placeholder complete — the LLM
-        // must read the formatted match list and pick by index. When the plan
-        // ends with extractWithIndex (or runs out of valid steps), we fall
-        // through to the per-action loop with the match list as feedback.
+        // Track extractWithIndex matches for per-action fallback; the LLM must
+        // read the list and pick by index.
         let lastExtractOutput = null;
         for (let stepIdx = 0; stepIdx < plan.steps.length; stepIdx++) {
             if (scenario.signal?.aborted) {
@@ -2296,10 +2287,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
             // timeline regardless of whether the runner used the planner or the
             // per-action loop.
             //
-            // Token attribution: the FIRST step of each plan carries the
-            // Brain.plan() LLM call's token usage. Without this, runs that stay
-            // in plan-mode (Gen 7.1) report $0 cost while their Brain.plan()
-            // calls actually spent real tokens.
+            // Token attribution: the first step carries the Brain.plan() LLM call's
+            // token usage so run-level cost includes planning.
             const isFirstStep = stepIdx === 0;
             const turn = {
                 turn: turnNumber,
@@ -2319,21 +2308,16 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
             // Terminal actions: complete and abort don't go through driver.execute
             // — the runner handles them as the end of the plan.
             if (step.action.action === 'complete') {
-                // Gen 7.2 placeholder substitution: if the planner emitted a complete
-                // with placeholder values AND we have a real runScript output from
-                // earlier in the plan, use the runScript output as the final result.
-                // Detection is conservative: only substitute when the planner clearly
-                // didn't know real values at planning time (null literals, "<from
-                // prior step>", "{{...}}" templates, "<placeholder>", etc.).
+                // Substitute placeholder complete results with prior runScript output.
                 let resolvedResult = step.action.result;
                 if (lastRunScriptOutput
                     && typeof resolvedResult === 'string'
                     && hasPlaceholderPattern(resolvedResult)) {
                     if (this.config.debug) {
-                        console.log(`[Runner] Gen 7.2: substituting placeholder complete.result with runScript output (${lastRunScriptOutput.length} chars)`);
+                        console.log(`[Runner] Substituting placeholder complete.result with runScript output (${lastRunScriptOutput.length} chars)`);
                     }
                     resolvedResult = lastRunScriptOutput;
-                    turn.reasoning = `${turn.reasoning ?? ''} [Gen 7.2 substituted runScript output]`.trim();
+                    turn.reasoning = `${turn.reasoning ?? ''} [substituted runScript output]`.trim();
                 }
                 turn.durationMs = Date.now() - stepStartedAt;
                 turns.push(turn);
@@ -2380,12 +2364,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
             // execute-started / execute-completed events on the bus exactly
             // like the per-action loop does.
             //
-            // CRITICAL: each plan step gets a 10s wall-clock cap (vs the driver's
-            // default 30s). Plan steps assume every selector was just observed in
-            // the snapshot at planning time — a missing element should fail
-            // FAST and trigger fallback to per-action mode, NOT block the run for
-            // 30s. Batch verbs already enforce a 5s per-field cap internally,
-            // but single-step type/click/press/select use the full 30s default.
+            // Cap each plan step at 10s so missing selectors fail quickly and hand
+            // control back to per-action mode.
             this.bus.emitNow({ type: 'execute-started', runId, turn: turnNumber, action: step.action });
             const execStartedAt = Date.now();
             const planStepTimeoutMs = 10_000;
@@ -2450,18 +2430,14 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
             runState.clearConsecutiveErrors();
             if (execResult.bounds)
                 turn.actionBounds = execResult.bounds;
-            // Gen 7.2: capture runScript output so a downstream complete step
-            // with placeholder values can be substituted with the real output.
-            // This is the supply side of the placeholder-substitution fix above.
+            // Capture runScript output for placeholder substitution and evidence.
             if (step.action.action === 'runScript' && typeof execResult.data === 'string' && execResult.data.length > 0) {
                 lastRunScriptOutput = execResult.data;
                 if (execResult.data.length > 10) {
                     runState.recordEvidence(`EXTRACTED (turn ${currentTurnIndex}): ${execResult.data.slice(0, 500)}`);
                 }
             }
-            // Gen 10: capture extractWithIndex match list for fall-through to the
-            // per-action loop. The LLM must read the list and pick by index — we
-            // do not auto-complete with the raw match list.
+            // Capture extractWithIndex output for per-action fallback.
             if (step.action.action === 'extractWithIndex' && typeof execResult.data === 'string' && execResult.data.length > 0) {
                 lastExtractOutput = execResult.data;
                 // Also push as goal verification evidence so the verifier sees what
@@ -2475,8 +2451,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
             // Verify the post-condition. We re-observe to get the post-action
             // state, then run the same verifyExpectedEffect helper the per-action
             // loop uses. The fresh observe is also stashed in cachedPostState so
-            // the next step's pre-step observe is short-circuited (Gen 4 lazy
-            // observe optimization).
+            // the next step's pre-step observe can reuse it.
             this.bus.emitNow({
                 type: 'verify-started',
                 runId,
@@ -2600,18 +2575,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 };
             }
         }
-        // Gen 7.2 auto-complete-from-runScript: if the plan ended without an
-        // explicit complete BUT the last successful step was a runScript with
-        // non-empty output, treat the runScript output as the final result and
-        // synthesize a complete turn. This handles the planner-prompt path where
-        // the planner correctly emits ONLY runScript on extraction tasks (per
-        // rule #7) — without this, we'd fall through to a 4-5 turn per-action
-        // loop that's much slower than necessary.
-        //
-        // Detection: the LAST step in the plan was a `runScript` AND we captured
-        // a non-empty output for it. We don't check intermediate steps because
-        // a plan like [navigate, click, runScript] where runScript is last is
-        // exactly the extraction-task shape we want to short-circuit.
+        // Auto-complete when the plan ends with meaningful runScript output.
         const lastStep = plan.steps[plan.steps.length - 1];
         if (lastStep
             && lastStep.action.action === 'runScript'
@@ -2621,7 +2585,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 turn: synthTurnNumber,
                 state: lastState,
                 action: { action: 'complete', result: lastRunScriptOutput },
-                reasoning: 'Gen 7.2 auto-complete: plan ended after runScript, runner emitted complete with the runScript output',
+                reasoning: 'Auto-complete: plan ended after runScript, runner emitted complete with the runScript output',
                 durationMs: 0,
             };
             turns.push(synthTurn);
@@ -2638,7 +2602,7 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 durationMs: 0,
             });
             if (this.config.debug) {
-                console.log(`[Runner] Gen 7.2: auto-emitted complete with runScript output (${lastRunScriptOutput.length} chars) after plan exhausted`);
+                console.log(`[Runner] Auto-emitted complete with runScript output (${lastRunScriptOutput.length} chars) after plan exhausted`);
             }
             return {
                 kind: 'completed',
@@ -2647,12 +2611,8 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 turnsConsumed: plan.steps.length + 1,
             };
         }
-        // Gen 10: if the plan ended with extractWithIndex, fall through to the
-        // per-action loop with the match list as feedback. The LLM must read
-        // the matches and pick by index — we do NOT auto-complete with the raw
-        // match list. This is the planner-emits-extract path for extraction
-        // tasks like npm/mdn/python-docs where the planner used the new
-        // extractWithIndex action.
+        // If the plan produced extractWithIndex matches, fall through with the
+        // match list so the LLM can choose the correct index.
         if (lastExtractOutput) {
             return {
                 kind: 'deviated',
@@ -2662,20 +2622,13 @@ export class BrowserAgent {
                 turnsConsumed: plan.steps.length,
             };
         }
-        // Gen 9 (cherry-picked into Gen 10): if the last step WAS a runScript
-        // but the output was NOT meaningful (null, empty, placeholder), DO NOT
-        // auto-complete with garbage. Fall through to the per-action loop with
-        // a deviation reason that names the empty output. In Gen 10 the per-
-        // action loop has TWO new tools that make this recovery actually work:
-        //   1. extractWithIndex (the wide-query content-match action) — see
-        //      data-extraction rule #25
-        //   2. cost cap (100k tokens) — bounds any death-spiral if the LLM
-        //      can't recover, preventing the Gen 9.1 reddit failure mode
+        // If the plan ends with runScript but output is empty or placeholder-like,
+        // fall through to per-action mode instead of completing with bad data.
         if (lastStep
             && lastStep.action.action === 'runScript'
             && !isMeaningfulRunScriptOutput(lastRunScriptOutput)) {
             if (this.config.debug) {
-                console.log(`[Runner] Gen 9: runScript returned no meaningful output (${JSON.stringify(lastRunScriptOutput).slice(0, 100)}); falling through to per-action loop for two-pass extraction`);
+                console.log(`[Runner] runScript returned no meaningful output (${JSON.stringify(lastRunScriptOutput).slice(0, 100)}); falling through to per-action loop for two-pass extraction`);
             }
             return {
                 kind: 'deviated',