@sdd-method/sdd-cli 1.23.1 → 1.25.0

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
@@ -1,22 +1,17 @@
1
1
  # GENERATED — DO NOT EDIT. This file is a projection of the authored model (M-ADR 0210 §4.6, flip 1):
2
2
  # docs/method/foundations/schemas/catalogue-schema.tql (the type system; header carries the bump log)
3
3
  # docs/method/foundations/schemas/catalogue-schema-meta.tql (what a type system cannot say)
4
- # Regenerate: python3 orchestration/scripts/check-catalogue-schema-roundtrip.py --write
5
- # Guard: python3 orchestration/scripts/check-catalogue-schema-roundtrip.py (any difference fails the build)
4
+ # Regenerate: sdd-cli metamodel roundtrip --write
5
+ # Guard: sdd-cli metamodel roundtrip (any difference fails the build)
6
6
  # Direction of truth: authored .tql -> this projection (round-trip gate) -> vendored copies (digest hook).
7
- # Emitted with PyYAML safe_dump(sort_keys=False, allow_unicode=True, width=1000000); the three header scalars
8
- # are quoted for the textual readers downstream. The one deliberate
9
- # difference from the authored form is schema_status: the authored form says canonical; a projection never does.
10
- schema_version: "3.10.0"
7
+ # Emitted by sdd-cli's YAML emitter with no line folding; the three header scalars are quoted for the
8
+ # textual readers downstream. The one deliberate difference from the authored form is schema_status:
9
+ # the authored form says canonical; a projection never does.
10
+ schema_version: "3.11.0"
11
11
  schema_owner: "sdd-method"
12
12
  schema_status: "generated"
13
13
  enums:
14
14
  quality_gate:
15
- description: 'Gate verdict a rubric assessment records for a target, in `quality_scores.gate` (per M-ADR 0205 §4.5). The vocabulary all fifteen method-side gate registries declare.
16
-
17
- DELIBERATELY NOT BOUND via `column_enums`, and the reason is measured rather than assumed — do not "fix" this by binding it. These values come from hand-authored score registries written by scoring runs, not from a method-mandated authoring surface, and one estate''s `domain-architecture-scores.yaml` declared `pass-with-waiver` before the method did, and uses it — the extension was RULED INTO this vocabulary (2026-08-07); the next estate extension would meet the same choice, and binding would hard-fail a build over a deliberate, self-documented row. This follows the `products.synthesis_band` precedent — the other column fed from a rubric registry — where an out-of-vocabulary value is reported as a convention finding and the cell left EMPTY, rather than emitting a value no consumer can interpret. The builder names the file, the entry, the value and the remedy, which is better diagnosis than a generic enum violation could give. Contrast `service_type`, which IS bound: it comes from repo-config, an authoring surface the method mandates.
18
-
19
- '
20
15
  values:
21
16
  - value: pass
22
17
  description: Meets the rubric's pass threshold with no hard gate triggered.
@@ -27,11 +22,11 @@ enums:
27
22
  - value: fail
28
23
  description: Below the fail threshold, or a hard gate triggered.
29
24
  - value: unscored
30
- description: 'The entry exists but carries no assessment. Distinct from absent: an unscored row asserts that nothing has been judged, which is exactly the silence M-ADR 0205 §4.5''s coverage instrument exists to make loud.'
25
+ description: "The entry exists but carries no assessment. Distinct from absent: an unscored row asserts that nothing has been judged, which is exactly the silence M-ADR 0205 §4.5's coverage instrument exists to make loud."
26
+ description: |
27
+ Gate verdict a rubric assessment records for a target, in `quality_scores.gate` (per M-ADR 0205 §4.5). The vocabulary all fifteen method-side gate registries declare.
28
+ DELIBERATELY NOT BOUND via `column_enums`, and the reason is measured rather than assumed — do not "fix" this by binding it. These values come from hand-authored score registries written by scoring runs, not from a method-mandated authoring surface, and one estate's `domain-architecture-scores.yaml` declared `pass-with-waiver` before the method did, and uses it — the extension was RULED INTO this vocabulary (2026-08-07); the next estate extension would meet the same choice, and binding would hard-fail a build over a deliberate, self-documented row. This follows the `products.synthesis_band` precedent — the other column fed from a rubric registry — where an out-of-vocabulary value is reported as a convention finding and the cell left EMPTY, rather than emitting a value no consumer can interpret. The builder names the file, the entry, the value and the remedy, which is better diagnosis than a generic enum violation could give. Contrast `service_type`, which IS bound: it comes from repo-config, an authoring surface the method mandates.
31
29
  score_selection_method:
32
- description: 'How the effective review was chosen from a target''s review history, in `quality_scores.selection_method` — the `selection_policy.method` field every gate registry carries. The catalogue models only the EFFECTIVE score (one row per target/rubric); this column makes the row say WHICH review it is rather than implying there was only one. Not bound, for the same registry-authored reason as `quality_gate`.
33
-
34
- '
35
30
  values:
36
31
  - value: latest
37
32
  description: Most recent review by scored_at. The default and, at 2026-08-06, the only value in use across either estate.
@@ -41,10 +36,9 @@ enums:
41
36
  description: Effective score reconciled across several reviews.
42
37
  - value: highest-severity
43
38
  description: The most severe review wins — the conservative policy for gate-blocking rubrics.
39
+ description: |
40
+ How the effective review was chosen from a target's review history, in `quality_scores.selection_method` — the `selection_policy.method` field every gate registry carries. The catalogue models only the EFFECTIVE score (one row per target/rubric); this column makes the row say WHICH review it is rather than implying there was only one. Not bound, for the same registry-authored reason as `quality_gate`.
44
41
  staleness_basis:
45
- description: 'Which anchor a `quality_scores` row''s staleness verdict can be computed from, in `quality_scores.staleness_basis`. This column exists because a staleness verdict whose basis is unstated is not a measurement — the basis-error class that produced six wrong figures in a single day of this method''s own arc. The coverage predicate MUST NOT be able to emit a staleness claim without naming which of these it used.
46
-
47
- '
48
42
  values:
49
43
  - value: corpus_ref
50
44
  description: The row carries the commit the assessment read — the precise anchor. Authored; introduced by the M-ADR 0205 §4.5 change-set, so absent from every score written before it.
@@ -52,23 +46,19 @@ enums:
52
46
  description: No corpus_ref; staleness computed from the assessment date against the target's last content change, resolved through target_path. Correct but coarser — it cannot distinguish a re-commit that changed nothing from a real edit.
53
47
  - value: none
54
48
  description: Neither anchor available (no corpus_ref and no resolvable target_path). Staleness is UNKNOWN for this row and must be reported as unknown, never as fresh.
49
+ description: |
50
+ Which anchor a `quality_scores` row's staleness verdict can be computed from, in `quality_scores.staleness_basis`. This column exists because a staleness verdict whose basis is unstated is not a measurement — the basis-error class that produced six wrong figures in a single day of this method's own arc. The coverage predicate MUST NOT be able to emit a staleness claim without naming which of these it used.
55
51
  scoring_form:
56
- description: 'The scoring shape a rubric uses, in `quality_scores.scoring_form`. Reserved by M-ADR 0205 §4.5 so the banded reverse family can arrive additively without reshaping rows.
57
-
58
- Both forms are now declared. `banded` was added in 3.3.0 once the reverse family was modelled; before that it was deliberately absent so a premature banded row would fail loudly rather than pass against an unemitted value.
59
-
60
- The two forms are NOT interchangeable and must not be averaged together — which is why they never share a score column. A weighted row carries `weighted_score` (1-5) and leaves `band`/`band_total` empty; a banded row carries `band` + `band_total` and leaves `weighted_score` empty. Any aggregate over `weighted_score` is therefore correct by construction rather than by the caller remembering to filter.
61
-
62
- '
63
52
  values:
64
53
  - value: weighted
65
54
  description: Weighted 1-5 dimensions rolled into a weighted_score against a pass threshold, with flags and hard gates. The forward house form; all fifteen method-side registries use it.
66
55
  - value: banded
67
56
  description: Dimensions summed to an integer total and mapped to a named band. The reverse family's form. Added in 3.3.0. The band vocabulary is PER-RUBRIC and deliberately unbound — see the band column.
57
+ description: |
58
+ The scoring shape a rubric uses, in `quality_scores.scoring_form`. Reserved by M-ADR 0205 §4.5 so the banded reverse family can arrive additively without reshaping rows.
59
+ Both forms are now declared. `banded` was added in 3.3.0 once the reverse family was modelled; before that it was deliberately absent so a premature banded row would fail loudly rather than pass against an unemitted value.
60
+ The two forms are NOT interchangeable and must not be averaged together — which is why they never share a score column. A weighted row carries `weighted_score` (1-5) and leaves `band`/`band_total` empty; a banded row carries `band` + `band_total` and leaves `weighted_score` empty. Any aggregate over `weighted_score` is therefore correct by construction rather than by the caller remembering to filter.
68
61
  capability_service_role:
69
- description: 'The part a service plays in delivering ONE capability. A property of the capability↔service RELATIONSHIP, never of the service: the same service is legitimately `primary` for capabilities in its own domain and `backend-gateway` for capabilities elsewhere. Authored in the capability traceability manifest services[].role (see the capability-traceability-manifest-template). Bound in 3.8.0; the values and their meanings are the template''s, unchanged. Consumers deriving "which repos realise this capability" MUST read this column or use repo_capability, which excludes `dependency` (M-ADR 0157 §4.3 as amended) — a repo_capability row is a contribution claim.
70
-
71
- '
72
62
  values:
73
63
  - value: primary
74
64
  description: Realises this capability.
@@ -78,8 +68,9 @@ enums:
78
68
  description: This capability DEPENDS ON the service — the inverse direction of contribution. The relationship is real and catalogued here; it does NOT produce a repo_capability row.
79
69
  - value: backend-gateway
80
70
  description: Owned by ANOTHER domain and the sanctioned entry point into that domain's data for this capability — not merely a dependency, the door in. Expect it on cross-domain rows only. Contributes; kept in repo_capability.
71
+ description: |
72
+ The part a service plays in delivering ONE capability. A property of the capability↔service RELATIONSHIP, never of the service: the same service is legitimately `primary` for capabilities in its own domain and `backend-gateway` for capabilities elsewhere. Authored in the capability traceability manifest services[].role (see the capability-traceability-manifest-template). Bound in 3.8.0; the values and their meanings are the template's, unchanged. Consumers deriving "which repos realise this capability" MUST read this column or use repo_capability, which excludes `dependency` (M-ADR 0157 §4.3 as amended) — a repo_capability row is a contribution claim.
81
73
  c4_system_kind:
82
- description: "Architectural kind of a C4 system. Derived 1:1 from the originating SDD manifest's category — every architectural product (the only ones that get a c4_systems row) maps to exactly one of these four kinds. Non-architectural categories (integration-umbrella, support-repo) emit no c4_systems row — and the builder MUST say so with a coverage finding, never silently (M-ADR 0133 §4.2c). Mapping table:\n platform-root → platform\n platform-subsystem → subsystem\n application-product → application\n integration-provider → integration\n"
83
74
  values:
84
75
  - value: platform
85
76
  description: A platform-root system — the one system that identifies a platform (M-ADR 0208 §4.1; 'platform-ecosystem' is the long form, 1:1 with the root). Exactly one per PLATFORM; an organisation-tier aggregate legitimately carries one per constituent platform, keyed by platform_sdd_id (0208 §4.2). An invariant `subsystem` exists to protect — do not reuse `platform` for subsystem rows.
@@ -89,21 +80,22 @@ enums:
89
80
  description: An application-product system, consumes platform services and contracts.
90
81
  - value: integration
91
82
  description: An integration-provider system, bridges an external provider into the platform.
83
+ description: |
84
+ Architectural kind of a C4 system. Derived 1:1 from the originating SDD manifest's category — every architectural product (the only ones that get a c4_systems row) maps to exactly one of these four kinds. Non-architectural categories (integration-umbrella, support-repo) emit no c4_systems row — and the builder MUST say so with a coverage finding, never silently (M-ADR 0133 §4.2c). Mapping table:
85
+ platform-root → platform
86
+ platform-subsystem → subsystem
87
+ application-product → application
88
+ integration-provider → integration
92
89
  c4_container_type:
93
- description: 'Canonical C4 container kind for `c4_containers.type`, aligned with c4model.com/abstractions (per M-ADR 0155). A C4 container is something that must be running for the system to work — an application or a data store.
94
-
95
- BOUND via `c4_containers.column_enums` since 3.0.0 (M-ADR 0203 §4.1, completing 0155''s staged enforcement): a non-member value hard-fails build and validate. The 2.x-era legacy values are removed; their migration rule (0155''s own): `External System` boxes belong in `c4_external_systems` (C4 L1 peer systems, not L2 containers); running infrastructure (broker, gateway, cache) retypes to Application or Data Store; pure deployment infrastructure (load balancer, DNS) leaves the container catalogue (it belongs in a C4 deployment diagram, which is not catalogued).
96
-
97
- '
98
90
  values:
99
91
  - value: Application
100
92
  description: A separately deployable/runnable application — a service, BFF, UI, consumer, worker, etc.
101
93
  - value: Data Store
102
94
  description: A database or persistence layer (also covers running stores like a message broker when modelled as a container).
95
+ description: |
96
+ Canonical C4 container kind for `c4_containers.type`, aligned with c4model.com/abstractions (per M-ADR 0155). A C4 container is something that must be running for the system to work — an application or a data store.
97
+ BOUND via `c4_containers.column_enums` since 3.0.0 (M-ADR 0203 §4.1, completing 0155's staged enforcement): a non-member value hard-fails build and validate. The 2.x-era legacy values are removed; their migration rule (0155's own): `External System` boxes belong in `c4_external_systems` (C4 L1 peer systems, not L2 containers); running infrastructure (broker, gateway, cache) retypes to Application or Data Store; pure deployment infrastructure (load balancer, DNS) leaves the container catalogue (it belongs in a C4 deployment diagram, which is not catalogued).
103
98
  service_type:
104
- description: 'Type of repository, declared in `orchestration/repo-config/*.yaml` as `service_type` and surfaced in `repositories.component_type` and `services.component_type`. The canonical builder uses this to decide which repos are runtime services (api_service, worker, gateway, frontend, mobile) and which are non-runtime (library, infrastructure, documentation). Whether a repo is a vertical-domain application is conveyed by its SDD manifest''s `profile: application-product`, not by a service_type tag — this enum is strictly about runtime artefact shape (per resolution of adopt-canonical-catalogue-builder.md §7.1).
105
-
106
- '
107
99
  values:
108
100
  - value: api_service
109
101
  description: REST/GraphQL/RPC service exposing an API.
@@ -137,12 +129,9 @@ enums:
137
129
  description: Docs-only repo.
138
130
  runtime: false
139
131
  emits_service_row: false
132
+ description: |
133
+ Type of repository, declared in `orchestration/repo-config/*.yaml` as `service_type` and surfaced in `repositories.component_type` and `services.component_type`. The canonical builder uses this to decide which repos are runtime services (api_service, worker, gateway, frontend, mobile) and which are non-runtime (library, infrastructure, documentation). Whether a repo is a vertical-domain application is conveyed by its SDD manifest's `profile: application-product`, not by a service_type tag — this enum is strictly about runtime artefact shape (per resolution of adopt-canonical-catalogue-builder.md §7.1).
140
134
  capability_exemption_reason:
141
- description: 'Why a catalogued repository deliberately bears no capability, per M-ADR 0188 §4.2. Closed vocabulary: reason codes make exemptions countable and trendable (a growing `prototype` or `archived` population is itself an estate signal), where free text would bury them. Extensions are method-owned and proceed by ADR amendment, so that adopters cannot locally widen the exemption surface to silence findings.
142
-
143
- ENFORCED, not advisory. The builder drops a `repo_capability_exemption` row whose reason is outside this vocabulary and emits a `convention` finding. The repository then resolves to nothing and is reported as an orphan — which is the point. If an unrecognised reason still exempted the repo, `reason: whatever` would be a universal silencer.
144
-
145
- '
146
135
  values:
147
136
  - value: infrastructure
148
137
  description: Provisions or operates the estate; realises no product capability.
@@ -156,23 +145,19 @@ enums:
156
145
  description: Exploratory; not part of the product model.
157
146
  - value: archived
158
147
  description: Retained for reference; no longer live.
148
+ description: |
149
+ Why a catalogued repository deliberately bears no capability, per M-ADR 0188 §4.2. Closed vocabulary: reason codes make exemptions countable and trendable (a growing `prototype` or `archived` population is itself an estate signal), where free text would bury them. Extensions are method-owned and proceed by ADR amendment, so that adopters cannot locally widen the exemption surface to silence findings.
150
+ ENFORCED, not advisory. The builder drops a `repo_capability_exemption` row whose reason is outside this vocabulary and emits a `convention` finding. The repository then resolves to nothing and is reported as an orphan — which is the point. If an unrecognised reason still exempted the repo, `reason: whatever` would be a universal silencer.
159
151
  service_capability_exemption_reason:
160
- description: 'Why a catalogued service deliberately bears no capability, per M-ADR 0133 §4.2b. Closed vocabulary — narrower than `capability_exemption_reason` by design: a repository can be exempt for six reasons (packaging, tooling, provenance), but a SERVICE, by definition, already runs something — the repository-tier distinctions that don''t reproduce at the service tier (pure IaC, build tooling, test scaffolding, vendored code) fold into `platform-internal`, since a service that exists at all is doing platform-internal work if it isn''t product-facing.
161
-
162
- ENFORCED, not advisory. The builder drops a `service_capability_exemption` row whose reason is outside this vocabulary and emits a `convention` finding. The service then resolves to nothing and is reported per the coverage predicate''s tier-scoped verdict set — which is the point.
163
-
164
- '
165
152
  values:
166
153
  - value: platform-internal
167
154
  description: Runs, but serves the platform's own operation rather than a product capability (e.g. an internal control-plane or ops service).
168
155
  - value: deprecated
169
156
  description: No longer live; retained for reference or wind-down.
157
+ description: |
158
+ Why a catalogued service deliberately bears no capability, per M-ADR 0133 §4.2b. Closed vocabulary — narrower than `capability_exemption_reason` by design: a repository can be exempt for six reasons (packaging, tooling, provenance), but a SERVICE, by definition, already runs something — the repository-tier distinctions that don't reproduce at the service tier (pure IaC, build tooling, test scaffolding, vendored code) fold into `platform-internal`, since a service that exists at all is doing platform-internal work if it isn't product-facing.
159
+ ENFORCED, not advisory. The builder drops a `service_capability_exemption` row whose reason is outside this vocabulary and emits a `convention` finding. The service then resolves to nothing and is reported per the coverage predicate's tier-scoped verdict set — which is the point.
170
160
  external_system_exemption_reason:
171
- description: 'Why an external-system candidate is ACCOUNTED FOR at the estate boundary, per M-ADR 0189 §4.6 (WS15; wording corrected by F16, 2.32.0): five values assert another party owns the system, and two assert the estate/organisation owns it but it has no model home yet — forcing the latter through the former would demand a false reason, and a false reason is worse than silence. The adjudicator can prove a candidate internal; it cannot prove one accounted-for — that is an assertion the author is accountable for, in the shape M-ADR 0188 ratified for repositories. Closed vocabulary, method-owned, extended only by ADR amendment, so adopters cannot locally widen the exemption surface to silence the unverified-candidate coverage finding.
172
-
173
- ENFORCED, not advisory: the builder drops a row whose reason is outside this vocabulary (convention finding) and the candidate stays unverified — which is the point. An unrecognised reason must not succeed at the one thing an exemption does.
174
-
175
- '
176
161
  values:
177
162
  - value: third-party-saas
178
163
  description: An operated vendor service the estate consumes (billing, auth, maps, email…).
@@ -185,22 +170,21 @@ enums:
185
170
  - value: public-infrastructure
186
171
  description: Public networks, registries, or services no party in the estate operates.
187
172
  - value: estate-owned-unmodelled
188
- description: 'Operated by this estate but with no SDD or container home yet — the row is an accounted-for stand-in, and this population is the estate''s modelling backlog, countable (F16, 2.32.0). Not an assertion of externality: an assertion of accountability for a boundary row.'
173
+ description: "Operated by this estate but with no SDD or container home yet — the row is an accounted-for stand-in, and this population is the estate's modelling backlog, countable (F16, 2.32.0). Not an assertion of externality: an assertion of accountability for a boundary row."
189
174
  - value: organisation-internal
190
175
  description: Owned elsewhere in the same organisation, outside this estate's modelling boundary (F16, 2.32.0).
176
+ description: |
177
+ Why an external-system candidate is ACCOUNTED FOR at the estate boundary, per M-ADR 0189 §4.6 (WS15; wording corrected by F16, 2.32.0): five values assert another party owns the system, and two assert the estate/organisation owns it but it has no model home yet — forcing the latter through the former would demand a false reason, and a false reason is worse than silence. The adjudicator can prove a candidate internal; it cannot prove one accounted-for — that is an assertion the author is accountable for, in the shape M-ADR 0188 ratified for repositories. Closed vocabulary, method-owned, extended only by ADR amendment, so adopters cannot locally widen the exemption surface to silence the unverified-candidate coverage finding.
178
+ ENFORCED, not advisory: the builder drops a row whose reason is outside this vocabulary (convention finding) and the candidate stays unverified — which is the point. An unrecognised reason must not succeed at the one thing an exemption does.
191
179
  scaffold_status:
192
- description: 'Lifecycle of a scaffold declaration, in `scaffolds.status`. AUTHORED in the manifest, copied by the builder: closing a scaffold is a recorded act of the unit of work finishing (M-ADR 0207 §4.3), not a computed consequence — the delta instrument reports a closed scaffold whose delta is not zero as a finding, it never closes one itself.
193
-
194
- '
195
180
  values:
196
181
  - value: open
197
182
  description: The unit of work is in flight. `declared` items are a state, not a defect (M-ADR 0207 §4.2).
198
183
  - value: closed
199
184
  description: The author has recorded the unit of work as done. A `declared` item under a closed scaffold presumes the scaffold right — the work is incomplete — and is reported (M-ADR 0207 §4.3).
185
+ description: |
186
+ Lifecycle of a scaffold declaration, in `scaffolds.status`. AUTHORED in the manifest, copied by the builder: closing a scaffold is a recorded act of the unit of work finishing (M-ADR 0207 §4.3), not a computed consequence — the delta instrument reports a closed scaffold whose delta is not zero as a finding, it never closes one itself.
200
187
  scaffold_item_kind:
201
- description: 'The grain of a scaffold declaration item, in `scaffold_items.item_kind`. Declares which family of catalogue surface the item promises; `target_kind` names the specific catalogue.
202
-
203
- '
204
188
  values:
205
189
  - value: entity
206
190
  description: A node catalogue row the work will add (a service, capability, feature, screen, …). target_ref is the declared id in that catalogue's vocabulary.
@@ -208,17 +192,17 @@ enums:
208
192
  description: An edge catalogue row the work will add. Endpoints are declared in edge_source_ref/edge_target_ref, mapped to the edge catalogue's FK columns in schema declaration order.
209
193
  - value: contract
210
194
  description: A contract artefact the work will introduce or amend. target_ref is the repo-relative spec path, matching `contracts.spec_path`.
195
+ description: |
196
+ The grain of a scaffold declaration item, in `scaffold_items.item_kind`. Declares which family of catalogue surface the item promises; `target_kind` names the specific catalogue.
211
197
  scaffold_item_state:
212
- description: 'Realisation state of a scaffold item, in `scaffold_items.state`. DERIVED by the builder''s resolution pass against the same build''s catalogue rows — never authored. The manifest declares intent; this column records whether the intent is realised in the corpus the build read. Staleness is deliberately NOT a value here: it is a coverage-time verdict against `scaffolds.corpus_ref` (M-ADR 0207 §4.6), because a git-derived value in a derived row would break rebuild determinism against unchanged authored inputs.
213
-
214
- '
215
198
  values:
216
199
  - value: declared
217
200
  description: The target does not (yet) resolve in the built catalogues. Under an open scaffold this is the computable backlog; under a closed one it is a reported finding (M-ADR 0207 §4.2/§4.3).
218
201
  - value: realised
219
202
  description: The target resolves in the built catalogues. The declaration is met for this item.
203
+ description: |
204
+ Realisation state of a scaffold item, in `scaffold_items.state`. DERIVED by the builder's resolution pass against the same build's catalogue rows — never authored. The manifest declares intent; this column records whether the intent is realised in the corpus the build read. Staleness is deliberately NOT a value here: it is a coverage-time verdict against `scaffolds.corpus_ref` (M-ADR 0207 §4.6), because a git-derived value in a derived row would break rebuild determinism against unchanged authored inputs.
220
205
  interaction_pattern:
221
- description: 'How a capability''s declared dependency on a service is coupled at RUNTIME — M-ADR 0171''s closed interaction-pattern vocabulary (the union of its ingestion and invocation sets), reused on `capability_service.interaction_pattern` per M-ADR 0211 §4.1 and not widened. BOUND because the value comes from the traceability manifest, a method-mandated authoring surface (M-ADR 0210 §4.5). A NON-RUNTIME coupling — build-time code generation, a load-time singleton, packaging, an authoring sequence — leaves the column EMPTY and states its kind in the manifest''s dependency_notes; that is T4''s excluded-by-class case and reaches no band 5. An entry declares ONE coupling: two tokens in one entry is two entries. Measured at two estates before binding: 17 of 18 runtime couplings mapped onto exactly one token; none needed a token the vocabulary lacks.'
222
206
  values:
223
207
  - value: event-stream-consume
224
208
  description: Subscribe to and drain a broker / stream / feed the provider produces; the consumer drains a durable, ordered channel (Event-Driven / Polling Consumer over a Message Channel).
@@ -234,27 +218,27 @@ enums:
234
218
  description: Submit a request; the result returns later via a separate channel, correlated by identifier (Request-Reply, asynchronous + Correlation Identifier).
235
219
  - value: publish
236
220
  description: Fire-and-forget write to a broker / queue / endpoint with no awaited response (Publish-Subscribe / fire-and-forget Message).
221
+ description: "How a capability's declared dependency on a service is coupled at RUNTIME — M-ADR 0171's closed interaction-pattern vocabulary (the union of its ingestion and invocation sets), reused on `capability_service.interaction_pattern` per M-ADR 0211 §4.1 and not widened. BOUND because the value comes from the traceability manifest, a method-mandated authoring surface (M-ADR 0210 §4.5). A NON-RUNTIME coupling — build-time code generation, a load-time singleton, packaging, an authoring sequence — leaves the column EMPTY and states its kind in the manifest's dependency_notes; that is T4's excluded-by-class case and reaches no band 5. An entry declares ONE coupling: two tokens in one entry is two entries. Measured at two estates before binding: 17 of 18 runtime couplings mapped onto exactly one token; none needed a token the vocabulary lacks."
237
222
  event_participation:
238
- description: 'The part a service, capability or feature plays toward an event, in `service_event.role`, `capability_event.role` and `feature_event.role`. `service_event.role` is also M-ADR 0206 §4.2''s role-conditional impact flow (publishes → toward-target, consumes → toward-source). Bound at 3.9.0 (M-ADR 0210 §4.5): the values come from repo-config and derived edges, method-mandated surfaces; every row at both adopter estates'' committed aggregates was in-vocabulary when bound.'
239
223
  values:
240
224
  - value: publishes
241
225
  description: The participant emits the event.
242
226
  - value: consumes
243
227
  description: The participant receives the event.
228
+ description: "The part a service, capability or feature plays toward an event, in `service_event.role`, `capability_event.role` and `feature_event.role`. `service_event.role` is also M-ADR 0206 §4.2's role-conditional impact flow (publishes → toward-target, consumes → toward-source). Bound at 3.9.0 (M-ADR 0210 §4.5): the values come from repo-config and derived edges, method-mandated surfaces; every row at both adopter estates' committed aggregates was in-vocabulary when bound."
244
229
  contract_participation:
245
- description: The part a service plays toward a contract, in `service_contract.role`. Bound at 3.9.0 (M-ADR 0210 §4.5); one estate's rows were all `exposes`, the other's all `consumes` — the union is the vocabulary, and each estate's usage was in it.
246
230
  values:
247
231
  - value: exposes
248
232
  description: The service publishes the contract as its own surface.
249
233
  - value: consumes
250
234
  description: The service depends on a contract another service exposes.
235
+ description: The part a service plays toward a contract, in `service_contract.role`. Bound at 3.9.0 (M-ADR 0210 §4.5); one estate's rows were all `exposes`, the other's all `consumes` — the union is the vocabulary, and each estate's usage was in it.
251
236
  consumption_role:
252
- description: 'The part a product plays toward a capability or service it depends on, in `product_capability.role` and `product_service.role`. EXACTLY ONE VALUE, deliberately: every row at both estates carries `consumes`, and a column with one value is a population of one (M-ADR 0200 §4.10). Bound so the constant is DECLARED rather than accidental — a second value arriving is then a vocabulary decision with a finding, not a silent widening.'
253
237
  values:
254
238
  - value: consumes
255
239
  description: The product depends on / consumes the target.
240
+ description: "The part a product plays toward a capability or service it depends on, in `product_capability.role` and `product_service.role`. EXACTLY ONE VALUE, deliberately: every row at both estates carries `consumes`, and a column with one value is a population of one (M-ADR 0200 §4.10). Bound so the constant is DECLARED rather than accidental — a second value arriving is then a vocabulary decision with a finding, not a silent widening."
256
241
  journey_participation:
257
- description: 'The kind of participation a persona has in a user journey, in `persona_journey.role` — the ADR 0210 worked example''s `participation`. Bound at 3.9.0 (M-ADR 0210 §4.5): parsed from the persona spec''s declared `Roles:` line, a method template surface; every row at both estates was in-vocabulary when bound.'
258
242
  values:
259
243
  - value: primary
260
244
  description: The persona the journey is designed around.
@@ -262,6 +246,14 @@ enums:
262
246
  description: A persona the journey passes to or from.
263
247
  - value: supporting
264
248
  description: A persona present in the journey without owning it.
249
+ description: "The kind of participation a persona has in a user journey, in `persona_journey.role` — the ADR 0210 worked example's `participation`. Bound at 3.9.0 (M-ADR 0210 §4.5): parsed from the persona spec's declared `Roles:` line, a method template surface; every row at both estates was in-vocabulary when bound."
250
+ model_notation:
251
+ values:
252
+ - value: mermaid-erd
253
+ description: M-ADR 0042's diagram grammar (data-model.mermaid.md) — the pre-Decision-1 form; migrates at the model's next requirements pass.
254
+ - value: typeql
255
+ description: The documented TypeQL subset of M-ADR 0210 §4.2 (data-model.tql) — the canonical form of every model authored from 2026-09-17 and of every migrated model.
256
+ description: "The notation a domain-model artefact is written in. Bound at 3.11.0 as the instrument of M-ADR 0210 §4.6 Decision 2: the builder derives it from the file, the metric line counts it, and a mermaid-erd row becomes an error at the first rebuild after the sunset 2027-03-31."
265
257
  catalogues:
266
258
  domains:
267
259
  primary_key: id
@@ -320,7 +312,7 @@ catalogues:
320
312
  - name: category
321
313
  type: string
322
314
  nullable: true
323
- description: 'Architectural classification per docs/method/methods/standards/product-category-taxonomy.md. Values: platform-root | platform-subsystem | application-product | integration-provider | integration-umbrella | support-repo. Determines whether the Product gets a c4_systems row.'
315
+ description: "Architectural classification per docs/method/methods/standards/product-category-taxonomy.md. Values: platform-root | platform-subsystem | application-product | integration-provider | integration-umbrella | support-repo. Determines whether the Product gets a c4_systems row."
324
316
  - name: doc_path
325
317
  type: string
326
318
  nullable: false
@@ -328,7 +320,7 @@ catalogues:
328
320
  - name: lifecycle
329
321
  type: string
330
322
  nullable: true
331
- description: 'planned | active | deprecated (default active when empty). Owner-declared product lifecycle from the SDD manifest''s lifecycle: field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.1.0; `planned` added 1.9.0 / catalogue 2.47.0). `planned` = the product is real and intended but does not exist yet, which is the normal opening state of a forward-authored product — so a forward estate that has generated nothing should read `planned`, not the `active` the empty default implies. Distinct from status (documentation maturity): lifecycle is a fact about the PRODUCT, status about the DOCUMENT, and both can hold at once — a product can be reviewed AND deprecated, or planned AND thinly documented. Added in 2.22.0.'
323
+ description: "planned | active | deprecated (default active when empty). Owner-declared product lifecycle from the SDD manifest's lifecycle: field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.1.0; `planned` added 1.9.0 / catalogue 2.47.0). `planned` = the product is real and intended but does not exist yet, which is the normal opening state of a forward-authored product — so a forward estate that has generated nothing should read `planned`, not the `active` the empty default implies. Distinct from status (documentation maturity): lifecycle is a fact about the PRODUCT, status about the DOCUMENT, and both can hold at once — a product can be reviewed AND deprecated, or planned AND thinly documented. Added in 2.22.0."
332
324
  - name: deprecated_date
333
325
  type: date
334
326
  nullable: true
@@ -336,31 +328,31 @@ catalogues:
336
328
  - name: successor_sdd_id
337
329
  type: string
338
330
  nullable: true
339
- description: 'For deprecated products: sdd_id of the superseding SDD. Same vocabulary as sdd_id/source_sdd_id (NOT products.id). Soft reference — the aggregator orphan-checks it against contributing sdd_ids ([finding] orphan when unresolved), never a hard FK: the successor may live outside the aggregation scope. Added in 2.22.0.'
331
+ description: "For deprecated products: sdd_id of the superseding SDD. Same vocabulary as sdd_id/source_sdd_id (NOT products.id). Soft reference — the aggregator orphan-checks it against contributing sdd_ids ([finding] orphan when unresolved), never a hard FK: the successor may live outside the aggregation scope. Added in 2.22.0."
340
332
  - name: exemplar
341
333
  type: string
342
334
  nullable: true
343
- description: '`true` when this SDD is a reference exemplar — it demonstrates a profile shape rather than modelling a real product or provider relationship. Empty otherwise, which is the unmarked norm (absent in the manifest = a real SDD, no finding). From the manifest''s `exemplar:` field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.8.0). PROFILE-AGNOSTIC, unlike surface/packaging/application_archetype which are application-product-only — the first exemplar cohort found was integration-products. DERIVED, not authorable: this column and `integrations.exemplar` both come from the one manifest field, so they cannot disagree; two independently authored copies could, which is the failure mode the trait exists to remove. No builder branches on it — it is emitted to be filterable and nothing consumes it, because an implicit exclusion inside a rollup is much harder to remove than to add. Added in 2.46.0.'
335
+ description: "`true` when this SDD is a reference exemplar — it demonstrates a profile shape rather than modelling a real product or provider relationship. Empty otherwise, which is the unmarked norm (absent in the manifest = a real SDD, no finding). From the manifest's `exemplar:` field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.8.0). PROFILE-AGNOSTIC, unlike surface/packaging/application_archetype which are application-product-only — the first exemplar cohort found was integration-products. DERIVED, not authorable: this column and `integrations.exemplar` both come from the one manifest field, so they cannot disagree; two independently authored copies could, which is the failure mode the trait exists to remove. No builder branches on it — it is emitted to be filterable and nothing consumes it, because an implicit exclusion inside a rollup is much harder to remove than to add. Added in 2.46.0."
344
336
  - name: surface
345
337
  type: string
346
338
  nullable: true
347
- description: 'ui | api (empty for non-application-product). Application-product surface trait from the manifest''s surface: field (M-ADR 0167, sdd-manifest-schema 1.2.0). Empty on non-application products. Added in 2.35.0.'
339
+ description: "ui | api (empty for non-application-product). Application-product surface trait from the manifest's surface: field (M-ADR 0167, sdd-manifest-schema 1.2.0). Empty on non-application products. Added in 2.35.0."
348
340
  - name: packaging
349
341
  type: string
350
342
  nullable: true
351
- description: 'vendor-saas | self-operated (empty for non-application-product). Application-product packaging trait from the manifest''s packaging: field (M-ADR 0175, sdd-manifest-schema 1.7.0). `vendor-saas` marks a packaged-SaaS product — vendor-operated runtime (no own deployment evidence) and a vendor-versioned base capability set. Absent in the manifest resolves to `self-operated`, the unmarked norm. Per M-ADR 0175 §4 no builder may branch on this trait beyond evidence/deployment handling. Column position follows the M-ADR 0194 §3.1 canonical axis order (surface, packaging, application_archetype). Added in 2.41.0.'
343
+ description: "vendor-saas | self-operated (empty for non-application-product). Application-product packaging trait from the manifest's packaging: field (M-ADR 0175, sdd-manifest-schema 1.7.0). `vendor-saas` marks a packaged-SaaS product — vendor-operated runtime (no own deployment evidence) and a vendor-versioned base capability set. Absent in the manifest resolves to `self-operated`, the unmarked norm. Per M-ADR 0175 §4 no builder may branch on this trait beyond evidence/deployment handling. Column position follows the M-ADR 0194 §3.1 canonical axis order (surface, packaging, application_archetype). Added in 2.41.0."
352
344
  - name: application_archetype
353
345
  type: string
354
346
  nullable: true
355
- description: 'Application-product shape classification from the manifest''s application_archetype: field (M-ADR 0191, sdd-manifest-schema 1.2.0). Resolved-enum over a tiered vocabulary (method: unclassified; reference-architecture bundle; adopter). Defaults to ''unclassified'' for application-product (with a coverage finding), empty for other profiles. Distinct from the M-ADR 0173 domain archetype and M-ADR 0169 openui archetype. Added in 2.35.0.'
347
+ description: "Application-product shape classification from the manifest's application_archetype: field (M-ADR 0191, sdd-manifest-schema 1.2.0). Resolved-enum over a tiered vocabulary (method: unclassified; reference-architecture bundle; adopter). Defaults to 'unclassified' for application-product (with a coverage finding), empty for other profiles. Distinct from the M-ADR 0173 domain archetype and M-ADR 0169 openui archetype. Added in 2.35.0."
356
348
  - name: synthesis_quality
357
349
  type: int
358
350
  nullable: true
359
- description: 'DEPRECATED at 3.3.0, for removal at 4.0.0 — superseded by `quality_scores` (rubric_id `reverse-product-quality.product_synthesis_quality`). Score 0-10 from the product-synthesis rubric (reverse method only). WIRED in 2.47.0 from `orchestration/gate-registry/reverse-product-quality-scores.yaml` — the registry family at product granularity — via the SELF-PRODUCT rule: the unit whose `product_path` is ''.'' AND whose key equals the SDD''s sdd_id. Both conditions are required; product_path alone admits synthetic gate fixtures, key-matching alone admits covered sub-products. Backfill only: it fills an empty cell and never overwrites an emitted value. Empty on a forward estate by design — a forward-authored product has no reverse rubric score, and residue-based authoring signals deliberately do NOT write here (see status).'
351
+ description: "DEPRECATED at 3.3.0, for removal at 4.0.0 — superseded by `quality_scores` (rubric_id `reverse-product-quality.product_synthesis_quality`). Score 0-10 from the product-synthesis rubric (reverse method only). WIRED in 2.47.0 from `orchestration/gate-registry/reverse-product-quality-scores.yaml` — the registry family at product granularity — via the SELF-PRODUCT rule: the unit whose `product_path` is '.' AND whose key equals the SDD's sdd_id. Both conditions are required; product_path alone admits synthetic gate fixtures, key-matching alone admits covered sub-products. Backfill only: it fills an empty cell and never overwrites an emitted value. Empty on a forward estate by design — a forward-authored product has no reverse rubric score, and residue-based authoring signals deliberately do NOT write here (see status)."
360
352
  - name: synthesis_band
361
353
  type: string
362
354
  nullable: true
363
- description: 'DEPRECATED at 3.3.0, for removal at 4.0.0 — superseded by `quality_scores.band`, which is UNBOUND because the vocabulary is per-rubric. This column''s closed set accepts only three of the SEVEN band values the reverse estate actually authors (measured 3.3.0: strong, working, weak, moderate, easy, hard, very-hard), silently emptying the rest. developing | working | strong — a CLOSED vocabulary; a band outside it is reported as a convention finding and the cell left empty rather than emitting a value no consumer can interpret. Wired in 2.47.0 alongside synthesis_quality.'
355
+ description: "DEPRECATED at 3.3.0, for removal at 4.0.0 — superseded by `quality_scores.band`, which is UNBOUND because the vocabulary is per-rubric. This column's closed set accepts only three of the SEVEN band values the reverse estate actually authors (measured 3.3.0: strong, working, weak, moderate, easy, hard, very-hard), silently emptying the rest. developing | working | strong — a CLOSED vocabulary; a band outside it is reported as a convention finding and the cell left empty rather than emitting a value no consumer can interpret. Wired in 2.47.0 alongside synthesis_quality."
364
356
  - name: last_assessed
365
357
  type: date
366
358
  nullable: true
@@ -385,7 +377,6 @@ catalogues:
385
377
  nullable: true
386
378
  applications:
387
379
  primary_key: id
388
- description: Filtered view of products where profile = application-product.
389
380
  columns:
390
381
  - name: id
391
382
  type: string
@@ -405,7 +396,7 @@ catalogues:
405
396
  - name: category
406
397
  type: string
407
398
  nullable: true
408
- description: 'Architectural classification per docs/method/methods/standards/product-category-taxonomy.md. Values: platform-root | platform-subsystem | application-product | integration-provider | integration-umbrella | support-repo. Determines whether the Product gets a c4_systems row.'
399
+ description: "Architectural classification per docs/method/methods/standards/product-category-taxonomy.md. Values: platform-root | platform-subsystem | application-product | integration-provider | integration-umbrella | support-repo. Determines whether the Product gets a c4_systems row."
409
400
  - name: doc_path
410
401
  type: string
411
402
  nullable: false
@@ -413,7 +404,7 @@ catalogues:
413
404
  - name: lifecycle
414
405
  type: string
415
406
  nullable: true
416
- description: 'planned | active | deprecated (default active when empty). Owner-declared product lifecycle from the SDD manifest''s lifecycle: field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.1.0; `planned` added 1.9.0 / catalogue 2.47.0). `planned` = the product is real and intended but does not exist yet, which is the normal opening state of a forward-authored product — so a forward estate that has generated nothing should read `planned`, not the `active` the empty default implies. Distinct from status (documentation maturity): lifecycle is a fact about the PRODUCT, status about the DOCUMENT, and both can hold at once — a product can be reviewed AND deprecated, or planned AND thinly documented. Added in 2.22.0.'
407
+ description: "planned | active | deprecated (default active when empty). Owner-declared product lifecycle from the SDD manifest's lifecycle: field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.1.0; `planned` added 1.9.0 / catalogue 2.47.0). `planned` = the product is real and intended but does not exist yet, which is the normal opening state of a forward-authored product — so a forward estate that has generated nothing should read `planned`, not the `active` the empty default implies. Distinct from status (documentation maturity): lifecycle is a fact about the PRODUCT, status about the DOCUMENT, and both can hold at once — a product can be reviewed AND deprecated, or planned AND thinly documented. Added in 2.22.0."
417
408
  - name: deprecated_date
418
409
  type: date
419
410
  nullable: true
@@ -421,31 +412,31 @@ catalogues:
421
412
  - name: successor_sdd_id
422
413
  type: string
423
414
  nullable: true
424
- description: 'For deprecated products: sdd_id of the superseding SDD. Same vocabulary as sdd_id/source_sdd_id (NOT products.id). Soft reference — the aggregator orphan-checks it against contributing sdd_ids ([finding] orphan when unresolved), never a hard FK: the successor may live outside the aggregation scope. Added in 2.22.0.'
415
+ description: "For deprecated products: sdd_id of the superseding SDD. Same vocabulary as sdd_id/source_sdd_id (NOT products.id). Soft reference — the aggregator orphan-checks it against contributing sdd_ids ([finding] orphan when unresolved), never a hard FK: the successor may live outside the aggregation scope. Added in 2.22.0."
425
416
  - name: exemplar
426
417
  type: string
427
418
  nullable: true
428
- description: '`true` when this SDD is a reference exemplar — it demonstrates a profile shape rather than modelling a real product or provider relationship. Empty otherwise, which is the unmarked norm (absent in the manifest = a real SDD, no finding). From the manifest''s `exemplar:` field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.8.0). PROFILE-AGNOSTIC, unlike surface/packaging/application_archetype which are application-product-only — the first exemplar cohort found was integration-products. DERIVED, not authorable: this column and `integrations.exemplar` both come from the one manifest field, so they cannot disagree; two independently authored copies could, which is the failure mode the trait exists to remove. No builder branches on it — it is emitted to be filterable and nothing consumes it, because an implicit exclusion inside a rollup is much harder to remove than to add. Added in 2.46.0.'
419
+ description: "`true` when this SDD is a reference exemplar — it demonstrates a profile shape rather than modelling a real product or provider relationship. Empty otherwise, which is the unmarked norm (absent in the manifest = a real SDD, no finding). From the manifest's `exemplar:` field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.8.0). PROFILE-AGNOSTIC, unlike surface/packaging/application_archetype which are application-product-only — the first exemplar cohort found was integration-products. DERIVED, not authorable: this column and `integrations.exemplar` both come from the one manifest field, so they cannot disagree; two independently authored copies could, which is the failure mode the trait exists to remove. No builder branches on it — it is emitted to be filterable and nothing consumes it, because an implicit exclusion inside a rollup is much harder to remove than to add. Added in 2.46.0."
429
420
  - name: surface
430
421
  type: string
431
422
  nullable: true
432
- description: 'ui | api (empty for non-application-product). Application-product surface trait from the manifest''s surface: field (M-ADR 0167, sdd-manifest-schema 1.2.0). Empty on non-application products. Added in 2.35.0.'
423
+ description: "ui | api (empty for non-application-product). Application-product surface trait from the manifest's surface: field (M-ADR 0167, sdd-manifest-schema 1.2.0). Empty on non-application products. Added in 2.35.0."
433
424
  - name: packaging
434
425
  type: string
435
426
  nullable: true
436
- description: 'vendor-saas | self-operated (empty for non-application-product). Application-product packaging trait from the manifest''s packaging: field (M-ADR 0175, sdd-manifest-schema 1.7.0). `vendor-saas` marks a packaged-SaaS product — vendor-operated runtime (no own deployment evidence) and a vendor-versioned base capability set. Absent in the manifest resolves to `self-operated`, the unmarked norm. Per M-ADR 0175 §4 no builder may branch on this trait beyond evidence/deployment handling. Column position follows the M-ADR 0194 §3.1 canonical axis order (surface, packaging, application_archetype). Added in 2.41.0.'
427
+ description: "vendor-saas | self-operated (empty for non-application-product). Application-product packaging trait from the manifest's packaging: field (M-ADR 0175, sdd-manifest-schema 1.7.0). `vendor-saas` marks a packaged-SaaS product — vendor-operated runtime (no own deployment evidence) and a vendor-versioned base capability set. Absent in the manifest resolves to `self-operated`, the unmarked norm. Per M-ADR 0175 §4 no builder may branch on this trait beyond evidence/deployment handling. Column position follows the M-ADR 0194 §3.1 canonical axis order (surface, packaging, application_archetype). Added in 2.41.0."
437
428
  - name: application_archetype
438
429
  type: string
439
430
  nullable: true
440
- description: 'Application-product shape classification from the manifest''s application_archetype: field (M-ADR 0191, sdd-manifest-schema 1.2.0). Resolved-enum over a tiered vocabulary (method: unclassified; reference-architecture bundle; adopter). Defaults to ''unclassified'' for application-product (with a coverage finding), empty for other profiles. Distinct from the M-ADR 0173 domain archetype and M-ADR 0169 openui archetype. Added in 2.35.0.'
431
+ description: "Application-product shape classification from the manifest's application_archetype: field (M-ADR 0191, sdd-manifest-schema 1.2.0). Resolved-enum over a tiered vocabulary (method: unclassified; reference-architecture bundle; adopter). Defaults to 'unclassified' for application-product (with a coverage finding), empty for other profiles. Distinct from the M-ADR 0173 domain archetype and M-ADR 0169 openui archetype. Added in 2.35.0."
441
432
  - name: synthesis_quality
442
433
  type: int
443
434
  nullable: true
444
- description: 'DEPRECATED at 3.3.0, for removal at 4.0.0 — superseded by `quality_scores` (rubric_id `reverse-product-quality.product_synthesis_quality`). Score 0-10 from the product-synthesis rubric (reverse method only). WIRED in 2.47.0 from `orchestration/gate-registry/reverse-product-quality-scores.yaml` — the registry family at product granularity — via the SELF-PRODUCT rule: the unit whose `product_path` is ''.'' AND whose key equals the SDD''s sdd_id. Both conditions are required; product_path alone admits synthetic gate fixtures, key-matching alone admits covered sub-products. Backfill only: it fills an empty cell and never overwrites an emitted value. Empty on a forward estate by design — a forward-authored product has no reverse rubric score, and residue-based authoring signals deliberately do NOT write here (see status).'
435
+ description: "DEPRECATED at 3.3.0, for removal at 4.0.0 — superseded by `quality_scores` (rubric_id `reverse-product-quality.product_synthesis_quality`). Score 0-10 from the product-synthesis rubric (reverse method only). WIRED in 2.47.0 from `orchestration/gate-registry/reverse-product-quality-scores.yaml` — the registry family at product granularity — via the SELF-PRODUCT rule: the unit whose `product_path` is '.' AND whose key equals the SDD's sdd_id. Both conditions are required; product_path alone admits synthetic gate fixtures, key-matching alone admits covered sub-products. Backfill only: it fills an empty cell and never overwrites an emitted value. Empty on a forward estate by design — a forward-authored product has no reverse rubric score, and residue-based authoring signals deliberately do NOT write here (see status)."
445
436
  - name: synthesis_band
446
437
  type: string
447
438
  nullable: true
448
- description: 'DEPRECATED at 3.3.0, for removal at 4.0.0 — superseded by `quality_scores.band`, which is UNBOUND because the vocabulary is per-rubric. This column''s closed set accepts only three of the SEVEN band values the reverse estate actually authors (measured 3.3.0: strong, working, weak, moderate, easy, hard, very-hard), silently emptying the rest. developing | working | strong — a CLOSED vocabulary; a band outside it is reported as a convention finding and the cell left empty rather than emitting a value no consumer can interpret. Wired in 2.47.0 alongside synthesis_quality.'
439
+ description: "DEPRECATED at 3.3.0, for removal at 4.0.0 — superseded by `quality_scores.band`, which is UNBOUND because the vocabulary is per-rubric. This column's closed set accepts only three of the SEVEN band values the reverse estate actually authors (measured 3.3.0: strong, working, weak, moderate, easy, hard, very-hard), silently emptying the rest. developing | working | strong — a CLOSED vocabulary; a band outside it is reported as a convention finding and the cell left empty rather than emitting a value no consumer can interpret. Wired in 2.47.0 alongside synthesis_quality."
449
440
  - name: last_assessed
450
441
  type: date
451
442
  nullable: true
@@ -464,13 +455,13 @@ catalogues:
464
455
  type: string
465
456
  nullable: true
466
457
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
458
+ description: Filtered view of products where profile = application-product.
467
459
  foreign_keys:
468
460
  - column: domain_id
469
461
  references: domains.id
470
462
  nullable: true
471
463
  integrations:
472
464
  primary_key: id
473
- description: Granular provider adapters. Each row is either (a) an integration-product SDD's own row (one per SDD; parent_product_id empty), or (b) a manifest-declared sub-integration of a multi-provider monolith (parent_product_id = umbrella SDD's id). Per M-ADR 0144 (schema 2.6.0), sub-integrations are declared via the optional `sub_integrations:` array in `integration-manifest.yaml`.
474
465
  columns:
475
466
  - name: id
476
467
  type: string
@@ -500,7 +491,7 @@ catalogues:
500
491
  - name: ingestion_pattern
501
492
  type: string
502
493
  nullable: true
503
- description: 'Closed method-tier enum (event-stream-consume | webhook | socket-listen | poll) from the manifest''s SDD-level `ingestionPattern` — HOW the integration acquires data (M-ADR 0171 §4.2). SCALAR: §9.3''s multi-valued allowance was withdrawn in §10.5. Empty when undeclared or on an outbound-only integration. Empty on `sub_integrations` rows — the patterns are declared once at SDD level and are not per-provider. Added in 2.45.0.'
494
+ description: "Closed method-tier enum (event-stream-consume | webhook | socket-listen | poll) from the manifest's SDD-level `ingestionPattern` — HOW the integration acquires data (M-ADR 0171 §4.2). SCALAR: §9.3's multi-valued allowance was withdrawn in §10.5. Empty when undeclared or on an outbound-only integration. Empty on `sub_integrations` rows — the patterns are declared once at SDD level and are not per-provider. Added in 2.45.0."
504
495
  - name: invocation_pattern
505
496
  type: string
506
497
  nullable: true
@@ -512,7 +503,7 @@ catalogues:
512
503
  - name: exemplar
513
504
  type: string
514
505
  nullable: true
515
- description: '`true` when the emitting SDD is a reference exemplar (demonstrates a profile shape rather than modelling a real provider relationship); empty otherwise. Derived from the SDD manifest''s `exemplar:` field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.8.0), same source as `products.exemplar` — neither column is independently authorable. Carried on `sub_integrations` rows too, INHERITED from the emitting SDD. That deliberately differs from `ingestion_pattern`/`invocation_pattern`, which are empty on sub rows, and the difference is the point: a pattern is a MECHANISM (how this integration acquires data), genuinely one per SDD, whereas `exemplar` is a REALITY STATUS that propagates to everything the SDD emits — if the SDD is a demonstration then every provider relationship it declares is a demonstration. Leaving sub rows empty would flag the umbrella and count its demonstration sub-providers as real, reproducing the rollup overcount this column exists to fix one level down. Do not normalise it to match the pattern columns. The trade accepted: a real SDD with one demonstration sub-provider is unexpressible — a state that should not exist. Added in 2.46.0.'
506
+ description: "`true` when the emitting SDD is a reference exemplar (demonstrates a profile shape rather than modelling a real provider relationship); empty otherwise. Derived from the SDD manifest's `exemplar:` field (sdd-manifest-schema 1.8.0), same source as `products.exemplar` — neither column is independently authorable. Carried on `sub_integrations` rows too, INHERITED from the emitting SDD. That deliberately differs from `ingestion_pattern`/`invocation_pattern`, which are empty on sub rows, and the difference is the point: a pattern is a MECHANISM (how this integration acquires data), genuinely one per SDD, whereas `exemplar` is a REALITY STATUS that propagates to everything the SDD emits — if the SDD is a demonstration then every provider relationship it declares is a demonstration. Leaving sub rows empty would flag the umbrella and count its demonstration sub-providers as real, reproducing the rollup overcount this column exists to fix one level down. Do not normalise it to match the pattern columns. The trade accepted: a real SDD with one demonstration sub-provider is unexpressible — a state that should not exist. Added in 2.46.0."
516
507
  - name: source_sdd_id
517
508
  type: string
518
509
  nullable: true
@@ -521,6 +512,7 @@ catalogues:
521
512
  type: string
522
513
  nullable: true
523
514
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
515
+ description: Granular provider adapters. Each row is either (a) an integration-product SDD's own row (one per SDD; parent_product_id empty), or (b) a manifest-declared sub-integration of a multi-provider monolith (parent_product_id = umbrella SDD's id). Per M-ADR 0144 (schema 2.6.0), sub-integrations are declared via the optional `sub_integrations:` array in `integration-manifest.yaml`.
524
516
  foreign_keys:
525
517
  - column: domain_id
526
518
  references: domains.id
@@ -530,18 +522,11 @@ catalogues:
530
522
  nullable: true
531
523
  integration_component:
532
524
  primary_key: id
533
- description: 'Integration-product edge (M-ADR 0171 §9, catalogued per §10.1): one row per component declared in the SDD''s `integration-manifest.yaml` `components:` array. A component is one of the integration''s component code repos (M-ADR 0106) — an integration SDD is a one-to-many spec→code unit — and the tier is the source of truth for the interaction pattern, with the SDD-level `ingestionPattern`/`invocationPattern` as its aggregate (§9.3).
534
-
535
- Built per-SDD, integration-product only (other profiles emit headers-only). A component id is unique within its manifest and names an **interaction surface** — commonly one provider feed — which is NOT necessarily a deployable (§10.2). The optional `component_repo` carries an explicit code linkage; when declared it MUST resolve to a `repositories.id` or `services.id` of the same SDD, and a declared-but-unresolvable linkage is a **coverage finding, not a load failure**. `resolution` records the outcome inline, including `undeclared` for the normal feed-level case, so a consumer filters on it rather than inferring from a join miss.
536
-
537
- The method deliberately does NOT enumerate `component_type` — that is the adopter''s own framework-role label (§9.1/§9.5), carried so an adopter''s role→pattern mapping stays machine-traceable. `transport`/`format`/`auth` are open strings for the same reason: they describe the wire, and the portable semantic is the pattern. Added in schema 2.43.0.
538
-
539
- '
540
525
  columns:
541
526
  - name: id
542
527
  type: string
543
528
  nullable: false
544
- description: '{integration_id}__{component_id}. A duplicate emits a divergence finding and is dropped — two components of one integration cannot share an id.'
529
+ description: "{integration_id}__{component_id}. A duplicate emits a divergence finding and is dropped — two components of one integration cannot share an id."
545
530
  - name: integration_id
546
531
  type: string
547
532
  nullable: false
@@ -553,7 +538,7 @@ catalogues:
553
538
  - name: component_repo
554
539
  type: string
555
540
  nullable: true
556
- description: 'OPTIONAL explicit code linkage from `components[].componentRepo` — the deployable (repositories.id / services.id) that realises this component. Empty is the normal case for a feed-level component: the tier is at interaction-surface granularity, not deployable granularity, and the method does not require a component to name a deployable (M-ADR 0171 §10.2). When declared it MUST resolve, since a declared link is a positive assertion the method can check. Added in 2.44.0.'
541
+ description: "OPTIONAL explicit code linkage from `components[].componentRepo` — the deployable (repositories.id / services.id) that realises this component. Empty is the normal case for a feed-level component: the tier is at interaction-surface granularity, not deployable granularity, and the method does not require a component to name a deployable (M-ADR 0171 §10.2). When declared it MUST resolve, since a declared link is a positive assertion the method can check. Added in 2.44.0."
557
542
  - name: resolution
558
543
  type: string
559
544
  nullable: false
@@ -565,7 +550,7 @@ catalogues:
565
550
  - name: direction
566
551
  type: string
567
552
  nullable: true
568
- description: 'inbound | outbound | bidirectional, from `dataFlow.direction`. Determines which pattern field is meaningful: inbound → ingestion_pattern, outbound → invocation_pattern, internal components declare neither (M-ADR 0171 §9.1).'
553
+ description: "inbound | outbound | bidirectional, from `dataFlow.direction`. Determines which pattern field is meaningful: inbound → ingestion_pattern, outbound → invocation_pattern, internal components declare neither (M-ADR 0171 §9.1)."
569
554
  - name: frequency
570
555
  type: string
571
556
  nullable: true
@@ -601,7 +586,7 @@ catalogues:
601
586
  - name: declared_in
602
587
  type: string
603
588
  nullable: false
604
- description: 'components-array | component-manifest — WHICH of M-ADR 0171 §9.1''s two homes declared this component. Added in 2.49.0, when the second home became catalogued. Required because §10.1 states that any coverage reasoning MUST say which form it counts, and once one table holds both, a consumer cannot tell them apart: merging them without this recreates the reference-exemplar problem — well-formed rows that do not mean what a consumer assumes. Measured at the time of wiring: the array form was 15 components across 5 SDDs, the per-component form 86 across 21, and the two are DISJOINT (no id collision, no SDD using both). `resolution` also reads differently by form — for the array form `componentRepo` is an optional declaration (0 of 15 declared it); for the per-component form the containing `repos/<component>/` directory IS the repo, so linkage is structural rather than declared.'
589
+ description: "components-array | component-manifest — WHICH of M-ADR 0171 §9.1's two homes declared this component. Added in 2.49.0, when the second home became catalogued. Required because §10.1 states that any coverage reasoning MUST say which form it counts, and once one table holds both, a consumer cannot tell them apart: merging them without this recreates the reference-exemplar problem — well-formed rows that do not mean what a consumer assumes. Measured at the time of wiring: the array form was 15 components across 5 SDDs, the per-component form 86 across 21, and the two are DISJOINT (no id collision, no SDD using both). `resolution` also reads differently by form — for the array form `componentRepo` is an optional declaration (0 of 15 declared it); for the per-component form the containing `repos/<component>/` directory IS the repo, so linkage is structural rather than declared."
605
590
  - name: source_sdd_id
606
591
  type: string
607
592
  nullable: true
@@ -610,6 +595,10 @@ catalogues:
610
595
  type: string
611
596
  nullable: true
612
597
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
598
+ description: |
599
+ Integration-product edge (M-ADR 0171 §9, catalogued per §10.1): one row per component declared in the SDD's `integration-manifest.yaml` `components:` array. A component is one of the integration's component code repos (M-ADR 0106) — an integration SDD is a one-to-many spec→code unit — and the tier is the source of truth for the interaction pattern, with the SDD-level `ingestionPattern`/`invocationPattern` as its aggregate (§9.3).
600
+ Built per-SDD, integration-product only (other profiles emit headers-only). A component id is unique within its manifest and names an **interaction surface** — commonly one provider feed — which is NOT necessarily a deployable (§10.2). The optional `component_repo` carries an explicit code linkage; when declared it MUST resolve to a `repositories.id` or `services.id` of the same SDD, and a declared-but-unresolvable linkage is a **coverage finding, not a load failure**. `resolution` records the outcome inline, including `undeclared` for the normal feed-level case, so a consumer filters on it rather than inferring from a join miss.
601
+ The method deliberately does NOT enumerate `component_type` — that is the adopter's own framework-role label (§9.1/§9.5), carried so an adopter's role→pattern mapping stays machine-traceable. `transport`/`format`/`auth` are open strings for the same reason: they describe the wire, and the portable semantic is the pattern. Added in schema 2.43.0.
613
602
  foreign_keys:
614
603
  - column: integration_id
615
604
  references: integrations.id
@@ -631,7 +620,7 @@ catalogues:
631
620
  - name: domain_id
632
621
  type: string
633
622
  nullable: true
634
- description: 'Domain slug for a domain-scoped ADR (docs/domains/<slug>/…); ''platform'' for a platform-scoped ADR (docs/platform/adr/), whose owner has that domain by construction; EMPTY for a method-scoped ADR (docs/method/adr/, docs/method/platform-adr/) — method ADRs are cross-cutting governance and belong to no domain. Nullable since 3.10.0 (M-ADR 0136 §4.3 amendment): before it, method ADRs were pinned to ''platform'' and dangled in every platform-root without a domain of that name.'
623
+ description: "Domain slug for a domain-scoped ADR (docs/domains/<slug>/…); 'platform' for a platform-scoped ADR (docs/platform/adr/), whose owner has that domain by construction; EMPTY for a method-scoped ADR (docs/method/adr/, docs/method/platform-adr/) — method ADRs are cross-cutting governance and belong to no domain. Nullable since 3.10.0 (M-ADR 0136 §4.3 amendment): before it, method ADRs were pinned to 'platform' and dangled in every platform-root without a domain of that name."
635
624
  - name: decision_date
636
625
  type: date
637
626
  nullable: true
@@ -670,7 +659,7 @@ catalogues:
670
659
  - name: id
671
660
  type: string
672
661
  nullable: false
673
- description: 'Slug: {domain}-{term-slug} for uniqueness.'
662
+ description: "Slug: {domain}-{term-slug} for uniqueness."
674
663
  - name: term
675
664
  type: string
676
665
  nullable: false
@@ -688,7 +677,7 @@ catalogues:
688
677
  - name: aliases
689
678
  type: string
690
679
  nullable: true
691
- description: ''';''-separated list.'
680
+ description: "';'-separated list."
692
681
  - name: evidence
693
682
  type: string
694
683
  nullable: true
@@ -712,12 +701,11 @@ catalogues:
712
701
  nullable: true
713
702
  glossary_xref:
714
703
  primary_key: id
715
- description: 'Edge: cross-domain glossary relationships from glossary-alignment-manifest.yaml. Per M-ADR 0158, four walkers ingest into this catalogue: (a) forward declared pair-form {source, target} entries under aliases/conflicts, (b) reverse-method cross_domain_terms (emits references edges per referencer→owner), (c) reverse-method multi-domain conflicts (pair-wise expansion across domains[]), (d) forward-method supersedes (status: superseded entries with superseded_by back-link).'
716
704
  columns:
717
705
  - name: id
718
706
  type: string
719
707
  nullable: false
720
- description: 'Composite: {source_id}__{relation}__{target_id}.'
708
+ description: "Composite: {source_id}__{relation}__{target_id}."
721
709
  - name: source_id
722
710
  type: string
723
711
  nullable: false
@@ -728,6 +716,7 @@ catalogues:
728
716
  type: string
729
717
  nullable: false
730
718
  description: alias-of | conflicts-with | references | supersedes (extended in schema 2.12.0 per M-ADR 0158).
719
+ description: "Edge: cross-domain glossary relationships from glossary-alignment-manifest.yaml. Per M-ADR 0158, four walkers ingest into this catalogue: (a) forward declared pair-form {source, target} entries under aliases/conflicts, (b) reverse-method cross_domain_terms (emits references edges per referencer→owner), (c) reverse-method multi-domain conflicts (pair-wise expansion across domains[]), (d) forward-method supersedes (status: superseded entries with superseded_by back-link)."
731
720
  foreign_keys:
732
721
  - column: source_id
733
722
  references: glossary_items.id
@@ -737,12 +726,11 @@ catalogues:
737
726
  nullable: false
738
727
  entity_glossary:
739
728
  primary_key: id
740
- description: 'Edge: data-model entity → canonical glossary term. Added in schema 2.12.0 per M-ADR 0158. Source: glossary-alignment-manifest.yaml `models[].entities[]` with status ∈ {aligned, matched_direct} and non-empty glossary_term. PK derives from (domain, entity_name, glossary_item) so same-domain multi-diagram entries collapse to one row; cross-domain entries (e.g. platform-wide conceptual model + domain-specific model) emit one row per domain — legitimate cross-level cataloguing.'
741
729
  columns:
742
730
  - name: id
743
731
  type: string
744
732
  nullable: false
745
- description: 'Composite: {domain_id}__{entity_name_slug}__{glossary_item_id}.'
733
+ description: "Composite: {domain_id}__{entity_name_slug}__{glossary_item_id}."
746
734
  - name: domain_id
747
735
  type: string
748
736
  nullable: false
@@ -768,6 +756,7 @@ catalogues:
768
756
  type: string
769
757
  nullable: true
770
758
  description: The data-model entity this glossary mapping is about — an entities.id. The edge was always emitted per (domain, entity, glossary_term) and this end was missing from its keys (found at M-ADR 0210 flip 2; added at 3.9.0). Nullable until every builder populates it.
759
+ description: "Edge: data-model entity → canonical glossary term. Added in schema 2.12.0 per M-ADR 0158. Source: glossary-alignment-manifest.yaml `models[].entities[]` with status ∈ {aligned, matched_direct} and non-empty glossary_term. PK derives from (domain, entity_name, glossary_item) so same-domain multi-diagram entries collapse to one row; cross-domain entries (e.g. platform-wide conceptual model + domain-specific model) emit one row per domain — legitimate cross-level cataloguing."
771
760
  foreign_keys:
772
761
  - column: domain_id
773
762
  references: domains.id
@@ -879,7 +868,7 @@ catalogues:
879
868
  - name: status
880
869
  type: string
881
870
  nullable: false
882
- description: 'Capability LIFECYCLE phase — this column carries ONE axis and the reader may rely on that. active | planned | exploration | deprecated. Default ''active''. History, because the shape of the mistake is the useful part: the prior three-member set (active|planned|deprecated) could not express what estates authored, so 3.5.0 widened it to six on measured evidence — 44 of one estate''s 78 manifests were outside it (exploration 26, placeholder 11, detailed-pre-lock 6, first-draft 1), each recurring value varying WITHIN a domain, which is the ruled discriminator for a genuine phase over an authoring convention. But 3.6.0 RETRACTED `placeholder` and `detailed-pre-lock`: per M-ADR 0201 §1 those are rungs on the SPEC-AUTHORING ladder (`placeholder | first-draft | detailed-pre-lock`, plus §4.1''s `reverse-derived`), declared in each spec''s own `**Status:**` header and gated there by the spec-lifecycle gate. Admitting them here made one column carry two orthogonal axes, so a reader could not tell whether `placeholder` described the capability or its document. **Where the other axis lives: the spec header. Do not re-import it here.** `exploration` stays and is NOT authoring vocabulary — it is absent from 0201''s ladder, has M-ADR 0089''s workflow and named gates behind it, and describes the capability rather than its spec; a capability declaring it must carry a populated `traceability.exploration` block, and one that does not is a loud contradiction (validate-traceability enforces this; measured 0 of 26 violations). ⚠ A rule this column deliberately does NOT carry: `placeholder`''s. The obvious one (no authored features) was MEASURED FALSE — 4 of 11 carried features, one of them 9 — and the deeper reason no rule fit is that `placeholder` was never making a claim about the capability at all. That unwritable rule was the first symptom of the axis error, before anyone had named it. ⚠ DELIBERATELY NOT BOUND via column_enums, and this is staged rather than permanent: binding carries hard-fail teeth, and at 3.5.0 one out-of-vocabulary row remains (forward estate, `first-draft`, n=1, referred to that estate; the reverse estate measures ZERO across 180 manifests). An out-of-vocabulary value is CARRIED, not emptied and not rejected, and is reported as a convention finding by validate-traceability — nullable stays false and no cell is ever emptied, so the empty-means-unauthored-or-rejected ambiguity of the products.synthesis_band / quality_scores.gate precedents does not arise here. Bind only once that count is ZERO at both estates; binding a set not proven to cover what estates author is how synthesis_band earned its deprecation. On drift and enforcement, stated with its confound rather than as a slogan: the enforced sibling `contracts.status` drifted 1.2% (2 of 172) while this unenforced field drifted 56% (44 of 78) at the SAME estate — but the other estate''s copy of this same unenforced field drifted 0% of 180, so enforcement is not the only variable. The difference is authoring shape: the forward estate hand-authors per capability across 13 domains and explores vocabulary doing it, while the reverse estate''s manifests come from one largely uniform extraction process. That uniformity is itself the phase-vs-convention discriminator firing — a value uniform across a whole estate is tracking the process that wrote it.'
871
+ description: "Capability LIFECYCLE phase — this column carries ONE axis and the reader may rely on that. active | planned | exploration | deprecated. Default 'active'. History, because the shape of the mistake is the useful part: the prior three-member set (active|planned|deprecated) could not express what estates authored, so 3.5.0 widened it to six on measured evidence — 44 of one estate's 78 manifests were outside it (exploration 26, placeholder 11, detailed-pre-lock 6, first-draft 1), each recurring value varying WITHIN a domain, which is the ruled discriminator for a genuine phase over an authoring convention. But 3.6.0 RETRACTED `placeholder` and `detailed-pre-lock`: per M-ADR 0201 §1 those are rungs on the SPEC-AUTHORING ladder (`placeholder | first-draft | detailed-pre-lock`, plus §4.1's `reverse-derived`), declared in each spec's own `**Status:**` header and gated there by the spec-lifecycle gate. Admitting them here made one column carry two orthogonal axes, so a reader could not tell whether `placeholder` described the capability or its document. **Where the other axis lives: the spec header. Do not re-import it here.** `exploration` stays and is NOT authoring vocabulary — it is absent from 0201's ladder, has M-ADR 0089's workflow and named gates behind it, and describes the capability rather than its spec; a capability declaring it must carry a populated `traceability.exploration` block, and one that does not is a loud contradiction (validate-traceability enforces this; measured 0 of 26 violations). ⚠ A rule this column deliberately does NOT carry: `placeholder`'s. The obvious one (no authored features) was MEASURED FALSE — 4 of 11 carried features, one of them 9 — and the deeper reason no rule fit is that `placeholder` was never making a claim about the capability at all. That unwritable rule was the first symptom of the axis error, before anyone had named it. ⚠ DELIBERATELY NOT BOUND via column_enums, and this is staged rather than permanent: binding carries hard-fail teeth, and at 3.5.0 one out-of-vocabulary row remains (forward estate, `first-draft`, n=1, referred to that estate; the reverse estate measures ZERO across 180 manifests). An out-of-vocabulary value is CARRIED, not emptied and not rejected, and is reported as a convention finding by validate-traceability — nullable stays false and no cell is ever emptied, so the empty-means-unauthored-or-rejected ambiguity of the products.synthesis_band / quality_scores.gate precedents does not arise here. Bind only once that count is ZERO at both estates; binding a set not proven to cover what estates author is how synthesis_band earned its deprecation. On drift and enforcement, stated with its confound rather than as a slogan: the enforced sibling `contracts.status` drifted 1.2% (2 of 172) while this unenforced field drifted 56% (44 of 78) at the SAME estate — but the other estate's copy of this same unenforced field drifted 0% of 180, so enforcement is not the only variable. The difference is authoring shape: the forward estate hand-authors per capability across 13 domains and explores vocabulary doing it, while the reverse estate's manifests come from one largely uniform extraction process. That uniformity is itself the phase-vs-convention discriminator firing — a value uniform across a whole estate is tracking the process that wrote it."
883
872
  - name: spec_path
884
873
  type: string
885
874
  nullable: true
@@ -887,7 +876,7 @@ catalogues:
887
876
  - name: contract_provenance
888
877
  type: string
889
878
  nullable: true
890
- description: 'How this capability''s declared contract SET was produced, from `traceability.contracts.provenance`. hand-authored | reverse-extracted | generated — the vocabulary the method already ships for `authoring-mode`, reused deliberately so provenance has one vocabulary and not two. Empty means undeclared, and undeclared reads as `hand-authored` by convention. Added at 3.5.0. ⚠ STRICTLY ORTHOGONAL to the contract-set maturity ladder (`traceability.contracts.status`: planned | provisional | partial | complete | locked | none): provenance never constrains status and status never constrains provenance, and `reverse-extracted` + `complete` is the legitimate pair that motivated the field. Evidence: 2 reverse-estate manifests had written `reverse-extracted` INTO contracts.status, where it is invalid, because a complete reverse-derived contract surface had no way to say both true things at once and the author picked the provenance one. A rule here that constrained maturity would re-create exactly that defect. ⚠ Note the asymmetry this column exposes and does not fix: the maturity ladder it is orthogonal to has NO catalogue column at all — `traceability.contracts.status` is validator-enforced but uncatalogued, so it is queryable by no consumer. That is the authored-but-uncatalogued class (a block with no column has no automated reader, so nothing can notice when it is absent or wrong); this column is given one precisely so the provenance half does not join it. Giving the ladder a column is a candidate follow-on, not done here.'
879
+ description: "How this capability's declared contract SET was produced, from `traceability.contracts.provenance`. hand-authored | reverse-extracted | generated — the vocabulary the method already ships for `authoring-mode`, reused deliberately so provenance has one vocabulary and not two. Empty means undeclared, and undeclared reads as `hand-authored` by convention. Added at 3.5.0. ⚠ STRICTLY ORTHOGONAL to the contract-set maturity ladder (`traceability.contracts.status`: planned | provisional | partial | complete | locked | none): provenance never constrains status and status never constrains provenance, and `reverse-extracted` + `complete` is the legitimate pair that motivated the field. Evidence: 2 reverse-estate manifests had written `reverse-extracted` INTO contracts.status, where it is invalid, because a complete reverse-derived contract surface had no way to say both true things at once and the author picked the provenance one. A rule here that constrained maturity would re-create exactly that defect. ⚠ Note the asymmetry this column exposes and does not fix: the maturity ladder it is orthogonal to has NO catalogue column at all — `traceability.contracts.status` is validator-enforced but uncatalogued, so it is queryable by no consumer. That is the authored-but-uncatalogued class (a block with no column has no automated reader, so nothing can notice when it is absent or wrong); this column is given one precisely so the provenance half does not join it. Giving the ladder a column is a candidate follow-on, not done here."
891
880
  - name: source
892
881
  type: string
893
882
  nullable: false
@@ -903,7 +892,7 @@ catalogues:
903
892
  - name: slice_scope
904
893
  type: string
905
894
  nullable: true
906
- description: 'Per-slice marker when one capability legitimately covers multiple app groups or data subsets (e.g. a compliance capability spanning several regulated-fleet sub-groups). Same capability_id may appear across multiple rows when sliced; row identity is then `(id, slice_scope)`. Empty when the capability is not sliced. Per-slice AC numbering convention: AC1-ACN unsuffixed for the first slice; subsequent slices use AC numbering suffixed by slice. See `docs/method/methods/reverse/rubrics/reverse-platform-evidence-quality.md` §`slice_scope:` and `docs/method/methods/capability-spec-template.md` Guideline 9. Added in schema 2.9.0.'
895
+ description: "Per-slice marker when one capability legitimately covers multiple app groups or data subsets (e.g. a compliance capability spanning several regulated-fleet sub-groups). Same capability_id may appear across multiple rows when sliced; row identity is then `(id, slice_scope)`. Empty when the capability is not sliced. Per-slice AC numbering convention: AC1-ACN unsuffixed for the first slice; subsequent slices use AC numbering suffixed by slice. See `docs/method/methods/reverse/rubrics/reverse-platform-evidence-quality.md` §`slice_scope:` and `docs/method/methods/capability-spec-template.md` Guideline 9. Added in schema 2.9.0."
907
896
  - name: source_sdd_id
908
897
  type: string
909
898
  nullable: true
@@ -924,14 +913,11 @@ catalogues:
924
913
  nullable: true
925
914
  feature_groups:
926
915
  primary_key: id
927
- description: 'Hierarchical grouping for features. First-class entity per resolution of adopt-canonical-catalogue-builder.md §7.2 — replaces the previous reverse-only synthetic `feature-tree-group` rows in features.csv. Both forward and reverse can use feature_groups: forward application-product SDDs whose `feature-tree.md` has H2/H3 structure, reverse SDDs whose extracted feature trees are inherently hierarchical, and any SDD that promotes groups to first-class with authored metadata. Groups can nest via `parent_group_id`.
928
-
929
- '
930
916
  columns:
931
917
  - name: id
932
918
  type: string
933
919
  nullable: false
934
- description: '{product_id|capability_id}-group-{slug}[-{nested-slug}].'
920
+ description: "{product_id|capability_id}-group-{slug}[-{nested-slug}]."
935
921
  - name: name
936
922
  type: string
937
923
  nullable: false
@@ -964,6 +950,8 @@ catalogues:
964
950
  type: string
965
951
  nullable: true
966
952
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
953
+ description: |
954
+ Hierarchical grouping for features. First-class entity per resolution of adopt-canonical-catalogue-builder.md §7.2 — replaces the previous reverse-only synthetic `feature-tree-group` rows in features.csv. Both forward and reverse can use feature_groups: forward application-product SDDs whose `feature-tree.md` has H2/H3 structure, reverse SDDs whose extracted feature trees are inherently hierarchical, and any SDD that promotes groups to first-class with authored metadata. Groups can nest via `parent_group_id`.
967
955
  foreign_keys:
968
956
  - column: product_id
969
957
  references: products.id
@@ -980,7 +968,7 @@ catalogues:
980
968
  - name: id
981
969
  type: string
982
970
  nullable: false
983
- description: '{product_id|capability_id}-{feature-slug}.'
971
+ description: "{product_id|capability_id}-{feature-slug}."
984
972
  - name: name
985
973
  type: string
986
974
  nullable: false
@@ -1005,7 +993,7 @@ catalogues:
1005
993
  - name: maturity
1006
994
  type: string
1007
995
  nullable: true
1008
- description: 'Standard: working | provisional | unknown | absent. Ecosystem-specific values may be added with parser awareness.'
996
+ description: "Standard: working | provisional | unknown | absent. Ecosystem-specific values may be added with parser awareness."
1009
997
  - name: status
1010
998
  type: string
1011
999
  nullable: false
@@ -1013,7 +1001,7 @@ catalogues:
1013
1001
  - name: source
1014
1002
  type: string
1015
1003
  nullable: false
1016
- description: 'feature-tree | feature-set | capability-spec | feature-spec | feature-grounding. NOTE: feature-tree-group source removed in 1.3.0 — groups are now first-class in feature_groups.csv. As of schema 2.2.0, source: feature-tree is emitted by the canonical builder for rows derived from feature-tree.md bullets. As of schema 2.5.0, source: feature-grounding is emitted for rows derived from `docs/domains/<dom>/design/<capability>/feature-grounding.md` markdown tables (per M-ADR 0143). As of schema 2.7.0, source: capability-spec is emitted by the canonical builder for rows derived from `## Feature Grounding (code-path trace)` tables in `docs/domains/<dom>/product/<capability>.md` capability spec markdown (per M-ADR 0145). Feature-grounding and capability-spec rows are both capability-owned: product_id is empty; capability_id resolves from the file path.'
1004
+ description: "feature-tree | feature-set | capability-spec | feature-spec | feature-grounding. NOTE: feature-tree-group source removed in 1.3.0 — groups are now first-class in feature_groups.csv. As of schema 2.2.0, source: feature-tree is emitted by the canonical builder for rows derived from feature-tree.md bullets. As of schema 2.5.0, source: feature-grounding is emitted for rows derived from `docs/domains/<dom>/design/<capability>/feature-grounding.md` markdown tables (per M-ADR 0143). As of schema 2.7.0, source: capability-spec is emitted by the canonical builder for rows derived from `## Feature Grounding (code-path trace)` tables in `docs/domains/<dom>/product/<capability>.md` capability spec markdown (per M-ADR 0145). Feature-grounding and capability-spec rows are both capability-owned: product_id is empty; capability_id resolves from the file path."
1017
1005
  - name: runway
1018
1006
  type: string
1019
1007
  nullable: true
@@ -1045,7 +1033,7 @@ catalogues:
1045
1033
  - name: id
1046
1034
  type: string
1047
1035
  nullable: false
1048
- description: '{product_id}-{persona-slug}.'
1036
+ description: "{product_id}-{persona-slug}."
1049
1037
  - name: name
1050
1038
  type: string
1051
1039
  nullable: false
@@ -1076,7 +1064,7 @@ catalogues:
1076
1064
  - name: id
1077
1065
  type: string
1078
1066
  nullable: false
1079
- description: '{product_id}-{journey-slug}.'
1067
+ description: "{product_id}-{journey-slug}."
1080
1068
  - name: name
1081
1069
  type: string
1082
1070
  nullable: false
@@ -1114,7 +1102,7 @@ catalogues:
1114
1102
  - name: id
1115
1103
  type: string
1116
1104
  nullable: false
1117
- description: '{domain}-{stem}-{kind} — the kind component joined the id at schema 3.0.0 (M-ADR 0203 §4.4), ending the kindless collision class where one service published as two contract families (openapi + proto) minted one id (measured cost: 1 row + 2 edges permanently unrepresentable, plus legitimate shared-contract citation flagged as divergence). Mechanical migration: new id = old id + ''-'' + kind; `sdd-cli catalogue migration-map` emits the pairs, and authored alias targets (M-ADR 0147) re-key automatically during the cut window.'
1105
+ description: "{domain}-{stem}-{kind} — the kind component joined the id at schema 3.0.0 (M-ADR 0203 §4.4), ending the kindless collision class where one service published as two contract families (openapi + proto) minted one id (measured cost: 1 row + 2 edges permanently unrepresentable, plus legitimate shared-contract citation flagged as divergence). Mechanical migration: new id = old id + '-' + kind; `sdd-cli catalogue migration-map` emits the pairs, and authored alias targets (M-ADR 0147) re-key automatically during the cut window."
1118
1106
  - name: name
1119
1107
  type: string
1120
1108
  nullable: false
@@ -1177,7 +1165,6 @@ catalogues:
1177
1165
  nullable: true
1178
1166
  events:
1179
1167
  primary_key: id
1180
- description: 'Asynchronous messages. Cross-domain events (e.g. shared envelopes) leave domain_id empty. Per M-ADR 0156 (multi-source ingestion, schema 2.12.0): forward-method canonical source is `contracts/avro/*.avsc` files; reverse-method canonical source is `docs/domains/{domain}/contracts/events/event-catalog.yaml`. YAML wins on name/domain/publisher/transport/consumers; avsc augments schema_path/version. Both paths run and merge by id slug.'
1181
1168
  columns:
1182
1169
  - name: id
1183
1170
  type: string
@@ -1194,11 +1181,11 @@ catalogues:
1194
1181
  - name: transport
1195
1182
  type: string
1196
1183
  nullable: true
1197
- description: 'Open string per M-ADR 0156. Recommended values: kafka | sns | sqs | kinesis | eventbridge | mongodb-change-stream | nats | activemq | rabbitmq | jms | other. Values outside the recommended set emit [finding] convention.'
1184
+ description: "Open string per M-ADR 0156. Recommended values: kafka | sns | sqs | kinesis | eventbridge | mongodb-change-stream | nats | activemq | rabbitmq | jms | other. Values outside the recommended set emit [finding] convention."
1198
1185
  - name: schema_path
1199
1186
  type: string
1200
1187
  nullable: true
1201
- description: 'Path to event schema (Avro .avsc or JSON-Schema .json/.schema.json). Nullable — leave empty for loosely-typed events (e.g. ActiveMQ JMS, NATS with payload_schema: {type: object}). Per M-ADR 0156.'
1188
+ description: "Path to event schema (Avro .avsc or JSON-Schema .json/.schema.json). Nullable — leave empty for loosely-typed events (e.g. ActiveMQ JMS, NATS with payload_schema: {type: object}). Per M-ADR 0156."
1202
1189
  - name: version
1203
1190
  type: string
1204
1191
  nullable: true
@@ -1214,6 +1201,7 @@ catalogues:
1214
1201
  type: string
1215
1202
  nullable: true
1216
1203
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
1204
+ description: "Asynchronous messages. Cross-domain events (e.g. shared envelopes) leave domain_id empty. Per M-ADR 0156 (multi-source ingestion, schema 2.12.0): forward-method canonical source is `contracts/avro/*.avsc` files; reverse-method canonical source is `docs/domains/{domain}/contracts/events/event-catalog.yaml`. YAML wins on name/domain/publisher/transport/consumers; avsc augments schema_path/version. Both paths run and merge by id slug."
1217
1205
  foreign_keys:
1218
1206
  - column: publisher_service_id
1219
1207
  references: services.id
@@ -1234,7 +1222,7 @@ catalogues:
1234
1222
  - name: product_id
1235
1223
  type: string
1236
1224
  nullable: true
1237
- description: 'Owning product, when the system corresponds to one. Nullable: every product is a system, but not every system is a product (external/SaaS systems have no owning product). Architectural products only (per category taxonomy). Relaxed to nullable in schema 2.11.0.'
1225
+ description: "Owning product, when the system corresponds to one. Nullable: every product is a system, but not every system is a product (external/SaaS systems have no owning product). Architectural products only (per category taxonomy). Relaxed to nullable in schema 2.11.0."
1238
1226
  - name: kind
1239
1227
  type: string
1240
1228
  nullable: false
@@ -1262,14 +1250,11 @@ catalogues:
1262
1250
  kind: enums.c4_system_kind
1263
1251
  c4_containers:
1264
1252
  primary_key: id
1265
- description: 'C4 L2. Each container belongs to exactly one C4 system. `domain_id` is a denormalised organisational tag, not a C4-structural attribute — multi-domain ecosystems use it for filtering/reporting. `service_id` is the optional "may represent" link to a runtime service when the container is a deployable application.
1266
-
1267
- '
1268
1253
  columns:
1269
1254
  - name: id
1270
1255
  type: string
1271
1256
  nullable: false
1272
- description: '{system_id}-{container-slug}.'
1257
+ description: "{system_id}-{container-slug}."
1273
1258
  - name: name
1274
1259
  type: string
1275
1260
  nullable: false
@@ -1288,7 +1273,7 @@ catalogues:
1288
1273
  - name: type
1289
1274
  type: string
1290
1275
  nullable: true
1291
- description: 'Canonical C4 container kind — bound to enums.c4_container_type (Application | Data Store) since 3.0.0, hard-fail (M-ADR 0203 §4.1 completing M-ADR 0155). The 2.x legacy values are removed: External System boxes belong in c4_external_systems; running infrastructure retypes; deployment infrastructure leaves the catalogue.'
1276
+ description: "Canonical C4 container kind — bound to enums.c4_container_type (Application | Data Store) since 3.0.0, hard-fail (M-ADR 0203 §4.1 completing M-ADR 0155). The 2.x legacy values are removed: External System boxes belong in c4_external_systems; running infrastructure retypes; deployment infrastructure leaves the catalogue."
1292
1277
  - name: technology
1293
1278
  type: string
1294
1279
  nullable: true
@@ -1303,6 +1288,8 @@ catalogues:
1303
1288
  type: string
1304
1289
  nullable: true
1305
1290
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
1291
+ description: |
1292
+ C4 L2. Each container belongs to exactly one C4 system. `domain_id` is a denormalised organisational tag, not a C4-structural attribute — multi-domain ecosystems use it for filtering/reporting. `service_id` is the optional "may represent" link to a runtime service when the container is a deployable application.
1306
1293
  foreign_keys:
1307
1294
  - column: system_id
1308
1295
  references: c4_systems.id
@@ -1317,14 +1304,11 @@ catalogues:
1317
1304
  type: enums.c4_container_type
1318
1305
  c4_components:
1319
1306
  primary_key: id
1320
- description: 'C4 L3. Each component belongs to exactly one C4 container. `service_id` is denormalised from `c4_containers.service_id` for query convenience — populated when the parent container represents a runtime service.
1321
-
1322
- '
1323
1307
  columns:
1324
1308
  - name: id
1325
1309
  type: string
1326
1310
  nullable: false
1327
- description: '{container_id}-{component-slug}.'
1311
+ description: "{container_id}-{component-slug}."
1328
1312
  - name: name
1329
1313
  type: string
1330
1314
  nullable: false
@@ -1335,7 +1319,7 @@ catalogues:
1335
1319
  - name: service_id
1336
1320
  type: string
1337
1321
  nullable: true
1338
- description: 'Denormalised: the service the parent container represents, when applicable.'
1322
+ description: "Denormalised: the service the parent container represents, when applicable."
1339
1323
  - name: path
1340
1324
  type: string
1341
1325
  nullable: true
@@ -1350,6 +1334,8 @@ catalogues:
1350
1334
  type: string
1351
1335
  nullable: true
1352
1336
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
1337
+ description: |
1338
+ C4 L3. Each component belongs to exactly one C4 container. `service_id` is denormalised from `c4_containers.service_id` for query convenience — populated when the parent container represents a runtime service.
1353
1339
  foreign_keys:
1354
1340
  - column: container_id
1355
1341
  references: c4_containers.id
@@ -1359,9 +1345,6 @@ catalogues:
1359
1345
  nullable: true
1360
1346
  c4_external_systems:
1361
1347
  primary_key: id
1362
- description: 'C4 external software systems — peer systems at the L1 context level that the ecosystem integrates with but does not own (per M-ADR 0155). Rendered `System_Ext(...)` on L1/L2 diagrams. NOT a c4_container (external systems are not inside your system) and NOT a c4_system (they have no owning Product). External systems are inherently shared references: the same external system may be declared by multiple SDDs, so the aggregator dedups identical rows by PK rather than failing on duplicate (the one narrowly-scoped exception to M-ADR 0134''s duplicate-PK rule); conflicting attributes on the same id surface as a `convention` finding.
1363
-
1364
- '
1365
1348
  columns:
1366
1349
  - name: id
1367
1350
  type: string
@@ -1386,7 +1369,7 @@ catalogues:
1386
1369
  - name: source_scope
1387
1370
  type: string
1388
1371
  nullable: true
1389
- description: 'Scope of the first-seen declaration: l1 (context diagram) or l2 (container diagram — scope-relative per M-ADR 0189 §4.1). Added 2.30.0.'
1372
+ description: "Scope of the first-seen declaration: l1 (context diagram) or l2 (container diagram — scope-relative per M-ADR 0189 §4.1). Added 2.30.0."
1390
1373
  - name: source_sdd_id
1391
1374
  type: string
1392
1375
  nullable: true
@@ -1395,6 +1378,8 @@ catalogues:
1395
1378
  type: string
1396
1379
  nullable: true
1397
1380
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
1381
+ description: |
1382
+ C4 external software systems — peer systems at the L1 context level that the ecosystem integrates with but does not own (per M-ADR 0155). Rendered `System_Ext(...)` on L1/L2 diagrams. NOT a c4_container (external systems are not inside your system) and NOT a c4_system (they have no owning Product). External systems are inherently shared references: the same external system may be declared by multiple SDDs, so the aggregator dedups identical rows by PK rather than failing on duplicate (the one narrowly-scoped exception to M-ADR 0134's duplicate-PK rule); conflicting attributes on the same id surface as a `convention` finding.
1398
1383
  repositories:
1399
1384
  primary_key: id
1400
1385
  columns:
@@ -1446,7 +1431,7 @@ catalogues:
1446
1431
  - name: languages
1447
1432
  type: string
1448
1433
  nullable: true
1449
- description: ''';''-separated.'
1434
+ description: "';'-separated."
1450
1435
  - name: doc_path
1451
1436
  type: string
1452
1437
  nullable: false
@@ -1469,12 +1454,11 @@ catalogues:
1469
1454
  component_type: enums.service_type
1470
1455
  domain_models:
1471
1456
  primary_key: id
1472
- description: 'Per-domain ER diagram modelling the domain''s aggregates, entities, and domain events. Platform-profile only — application and integration profiles emit headers-only. Forward source: `traceability.domain_model.path` in capability traceability manifests. Reverse source: file-system scan of `docs/domains/*/architecture/data-model.mermaid.md`. Added in schema 2.4.0; see M-ADR 0142.'
1473
1457
  columns:
1474
1458
  - name: id
1475
1459
  type: string
1476
1460
  nullable: false
1477
- description: '{domain_id}-data-model.'
1461
+ description: "{domain_id}-data-model."
1478
1462
  - name: name
1479
1463
  type: string
1480
1464
  nullable: false
@@ -1501,18 +1485,24 @@ catalogues:
1501
1485
  type: string
1502
1486
  nullable: true
1503
1487
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
1488
+ - name: notation
1489
+ type: string
1490
+ nullable: true
1491
+ description: "The notation the model artefact is written in — one of enums.model_notation (mermaid-erd | typeql), DERIVED by the builder from the file (data-model.mermaid.md → mermaid-erd; data-model.tql → typeql), never authored. The compliance instrument of M-ADR 0210 §4.6 Decision 2 (as amended): a mermaid-erd row is advisory until the sunset 2027-03-31 and an error after it. Added in 3.11.0."
1492
+ description: "Per-domain ER diagram modelling the domain's aggregates, entities, and domain events. Platform-profile only — application and integration profiles emit headers-only. Forward source: `traceability.domain_model.path` in capability traceability manifests. Reverse source: file-system scan of `docs/domains/*/architecture/data-model.mermaid.md`. Added in schema 2.4.0; see M-ADR 0142."
1504
1493
  foreign_keys:
1505
1494
  - column: domain_id
1506
1495
  references: domains.id
1507
1496
  nullable: false
1497
+ column_enums:
1498
+ notation: enums.model_notation
1508
1499
  entities:
1509
1500
  primary_key: id
1510
- description: 'Data-model entity (a structural realisation of a concept inside a domain''s data model). Distinct from glossary_items (vocabulary-level) and from domain_models (file-level). Added in schema 2.13.0 per M-ADR 0159. Forward source: `models[].entities[]` in glossary-alignment-manifest.yaml. Reverse source: `EntityName { ... }` declarations inside `erDiagram` fences in `docs/domains/{domain}/architecture/data-model.mermaid.md`. PK uses an entity-aware slug that normalises across UPPER_SNAKE and PascalCase authoring styles.'
1511
1501
  columns:
1512
1502
  - name: id
1513
1503
  type: string
1514
1504
  nullable: false
1515
- description: 'Slugged PK: {domain_id}-{entitySlug(name)}. For manifest-sourced rows with domain=platform-wide, the leading domain segment is empty (`-{entitySlug(name)}`) and the row carries a [finding] convention.'
1505
+ description: "Slugged PK: {domain_id}-{entitySlug(name)}. For manifest-sourced rows with domain=platform-wide, the leading domain segment is empty (`-{entitySlug(name)}`) and the row carries a [finding] convention."
1516
1506
  - name: name
1517
1507
  type: string
1518
1508
  nullable: false
@@ -1528,7 +1518,7 @@ catalogues:
1528
1518
  - name: persistence_kind
1529
1519
  type: string
1530
1520
  nullable: true
1531
- description: 'Open string; recommended values: relational-table | document-collection | event-payload | dto | view | other. Values outside the recommended set fire `[finding] convention`.'
1521
+ description: "Open string; recommended values: relational-table | document-collection | event-payload | dto | view | other. Values outside the recommended set fire `[finding] convention`."
1532
1522
  - name: context
1533
1523
  type: string
1534
1524
  nullable: true
@@ -1553,6 +1543,7 @@ catalogues:
1553
1543
  type: string
1554
1544
  nullable: true
1555
1545
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
1546
+ description: "Data-model entity (a structural realisation of a concept inside a domain's data model). Distinct from glossary_items (vocabulary-level) and from domain_models (file-level). Added in schema 2.13.0 per M-ADR 0159. Forward source: `models[].entities[]` in glossary-alignment-manifest.yaml. Reverse source: `EntityName { ... }` declarations inside `erDiagram` fences in `docs/domains/{domain}/architecture/data-model.mermaid.md`. PK uses an entity-aware slug that normalises across UPPER_SNAKE and PascalCase authoring styles."
1556
1547
  foreign_keys:
1557
1548
  - column: domain_id
1558
1549
  references: domains.id
@@ -1565,7 +1556,6 @@ catalogues:
1565
1556
  nullable: true
1566
1557
  repo_capability:
1567
1558
  primary_key: id
1568
- description: 'Edge: repo contributes to capability. Forward-declared via repo-config `capabilities[]` (M-ADR 0188 §6.1) or the legacy multi-purpose `additional_context[]`; reverse-derived via capability_service ⋈ services.primary_repo_id and capability_feature ⋈ feature_repo.'
1569
1559
  columns:
1570
1560
  - name: id
1571
1561
  type: string
@@ -1576,6 +1566,7 @@ catalogues:
1576
1566
  - name: capability_id
1577
1567
  type: string
1578
1568
  nullable: false
1569
+ description: "Edge: repo contributes to capability. Forward-declared via repo-config `capabilities[]` (M-ADR 0188 §6.1) or the legacy multi-purpose `additional_context[]`; reverse-derived via capability_service ⋈ services.primary_repo_id and capability_feature ⋈ feature_repo."
1579
1570
  foreign_keys:
1580
1571
  - column: repo_id
1581
1572
  references: repositories.id
@@ -1585,13 +1576,6 @@ catalogues:
1585
1576
  nullable: false
1586
1577
  repo_capability_exemption:
1587
1578
  primary_key: id
1588
- description: 'A repository''s declared, reasoned statement that it bears no product capability (M-ADR 0188 §4.3). Emitted from the repo-config `capability_exemption:` block.
1589
-
1590
- This is deliberately a catalogue row rather than an inert YAML aside. An exemption is a modelling assertion and belongs in the model: it is then queryable at the aggregate tier, reviewable in the same surface as the capabilities it stands in for, and countable — so that a reviewer watching the exemption population grow can see it happen. Never net exemptions off against orphans in a metric.
1591
-
1592
- The invariant it participates in (M-ADR 0188 §4.1): every `repositories` row must resolve, either by carrying a `repo_capability` edge or by declaring an exemption here. A row satisfying both is a declaration conflict, reported as a `divergence` finding.
1593
-
1594
- '
1595
1579
  columns:
1596
1580
  - name: id
1597
1581
  type: string
@@ -1606,6 +1590,10 @@ catalogues:
1606
1590
  type: string
1607
1591
  nullable: false
1608
1592
  description: Mandatory, non-empty. The reason code makes exemptions countable; the note makes them reviewable. A row with an empty note is dropped with a `convention` finding.
1593
+ description: |
1594
+ A repository's declared, reasoned statement that it bears no product capability (M-ADR 0188 §4.3). Emitted from the repo-config `capability_exemption:` block.
1595
+ This is deliberately a catalogue row rather than an inert YAML aside. An exemption is a modelling assertion and belongs in the model: it is then queryable at the aggregate tier, reviewable in the same surface as the capabilities it stands in for, and countable — so that a reviewer watching the exemption population grow can see it happen. Never net exemptions off against orphans in a metric.
1596
+ The invariant it participates in (M-ADR 0188 §4.1): every `repositories` row must resolve, either by carrying a `repo_capability` edge or by declaring an exemption here. A row satisfying both is a declaration conflict, reported as a `divergence` finding.
1609
1597
  foreign_keys:
1610
1598
  - column: repo_id
1611
1599
  references: repositories.id
@@ -1614,13 +1602,6 @@ catalogues:
1614
1602
  reason: enums.capability_exemption_reason
1615
1603
  service_capability_exemption:
1616
1604
  primary_key: id
1617
- description: 'A service''s declared, reasoned statement that it bears no product capability (M-ADR 0133 §4.2b). The services-tier equivalent of `repo_capability_exemption`, one tier down: `repo_capability_exemption` exists because M-ADR 0197 gave a repository a `services:` block, so a repository resolving under M-ADR 0188 no longer implies its services do. Emitted from the repo-config `service_capability_exemption:` block, keyed to the repo''s own default/primary service id — a declared, non-primary `services:` entry has no per-entry authoring surface yet (M-ADR 0197 §4.7, design-only) and cannot be exempted through this block.
1618
-
1619
- Two reasons only (`enums.service_capability_exemption_reason`): `platform-internal` and `deprecated`. Narrower than the repository vocabulary by design — a service, by definition, already runs something, so the repository-tier packaging/tooling/provenance distinctions don''t reproduce here.
1620
-
1621
- The invariant it participates in: every catalogued `services` row must resolve, either by carrying a `capability_service` edge or by declaring an exemption here — checked by a coverage predicate whose verdict set is tier-scoped (member tier cannot assert an unclaimed service is genuinely orphaned, only that it is unresolved locally; a cross-SDD claim on the service may exist in a sibling SDD''s own capability_service.csv, invisible to this SDD''s own build).
1622
-
1623
- '
1624
1605
  columns:
1625
1606
  - name: id
1626
1607
  type: string
@@ -1635,6 +1616,10 @@ catalogues:
1635
1616
  type: string
1636
1617
  nullable: false
1637
1618
  description: Mandatory, non-empty. The reason code makes exemptions countable; the note makes them reviewable. A row with an empty note is dropped with a `convention` finding.
1619
+ description: |
1620
+ A service's declared, reasoned statement that it bears no product capability (M-ADR 0133 §4.2b). The services-tier equivalent of `repo_capability_exemption`, one tier down: `repo_capability_exemption` exists because M-ADR 0197 gave a repository a `services:` block, so a repository resolving under M-ADR 0188 no longer implies its services do. Emitted from the repo-config `service_capability_exemption:` block, keyed to the repo's own default/primary service id — a declared, non-primary `services:` entry has no per-entry authoring surface yet (M-ADR 0197 §4.7, design-only) and cannot be exempted through this block.
1621
+ Two reasons only (`enums.service_capability_exemption_reason`): `platform-internal` and `deprecated`. Narrower than the repository vocabulary by design — a service, by definition, already runs something, so the repository-tier packaging/tooling/provenance distinctions don't reproduce here.
1622
+ The invariant it participates in: every catalogued `services` row must resolve, either by carrying a `capability_service` edge or by declaring an exemption here — checked by a coverage predicate whose verdict set is tier-scoped (member tier cannot assert an unclaimed service is genuinely orphaned, only that it is unresolved locally; a cross-SDD claim on the service may exist in a sibling SDD's own capability_service.csv, invisible to this SDD's own build).
1638
1623
  foreign_keys:
1639
1624
  - column: service_id
1640
1625
  references: services.id
@@ -1643,11 +1628,6 @@ catalogues:
1643
1628
  reason: enums.service_capability_exemption_reason
1644
1629
  external_system_exemption:
1645
1630
  primary_key: id
1646
- description: 'A declared, reasoned assertion that an external-system candidate is GENUINELY external (M-ADR 0189 §4.6 / WS15). Annotation catalogue (M-ADR 0133 §4.2b): one FK, declared never derived, closed reason enum. Sourced from `orchestration/external-system-exemptions.yaml`.
1647
-
1648
- The invariant it completes: c4_external_systems was the one catalogue family with no coverage predicate — a candidate producing no adjudication outcome was silent, and that silence hid a 28% dependency -graph distortion (ledger L4). Every candidate now either resolves at adjudication, or carries an exemption here, or is reported unverified. An exemption retires only the unverified finding — never an adjudication outcome (a converted candidate''s exemption is a contradiction, reported and dropped). Shared entities may be exempted by multiple SDDs: identical rows dedup at aggregation (same exception class as c4_external_systems); conflicting rows keep first-seen with a convention finding.
1649
-
1650
- '
1651
1631
  columns:
1652
1632
  - name: id
1653
1633
  type: string
@@ -1663,6 +1643,9 @@ catalogues:
1663
1643
  type: string
1664
1644
  nullable: false
1665
1645
  description: Mandatory, non-empty. The reason makes exemptions countable; the note makes them reviewable (M-ADR 0188 §4.2 pattern).
1646
+ description: |
1647
+ A declared, reasoned assertion that an external-system candidate is GENUINELY external (M-ADR 0189 §4.6 / WS15). Annotation catalogue (M-ADR 0133 §4.2b): one FK, declared never derived, closed reason enum. Sourced from `orchestration/external-system-exemptions.yaml`.
1648
+ The invariant it completes: c4_external_systems was the one catalogue family with no coverage predicate — a candidate producing no adjudication outcome was silent, and that silence hid a 28% dependency -graph distortion (ledger L4). Every candidate now either resolves at adjudication, or carries an exemption here, or is reported unverified. An exemption retires only the unverified finding — never an adjudication outcome (a converted candidate's exemption is a contradiction, reported and dropped). Shared entities may be exempted by multiple SDDs: identical rows dedup at aggregation (same exception class as c4_external_systems); conflicting rows keep first-seen with a convention finding.
1666
1649
  foreign_keys:
1667
1650
  - column: external_system_id
1668
1651
  references: c4_external_systems.id
@@ -1671,7 +1654,6 @@ catalogues:
1671
1654
  reason: enums.external_system_exemption_reason
1672
1655
  repo_contract:
1673
1656
  primary_key: id
1674
- description: 'Edge: repo is bound to a contract — implements or consumes; the source (contributes_to.artifact_type=contract-surface) does not distinguish, so this description asserts no direction (M-ADR 0211 §1). From contributes_to.artifact_type=contract-surface. Per M-ADR 0147 service-architecture external interfaces are a contract-consumes source; contract_id is external_for_profiles app/integration because their repos reference platform-resident (or platform-held BFF) contracts — resolved at aggregation, staying internal for platform-profile.'
1675
1657
  columns:
1676
1658
  - name: id
1677
1659
  type: string
@@ -1682,6 +1664,7 @@ catalogues:
1682
1664
  - name: contract_id
1683
1665
  type: string
1684
1666
  nullable: false
1667
+ description: "Edge: repo is bound to a contract — implements or consumes; the source (contributes_to.artifact_type=contract-surface) does not distinguish, so this description asserts no direction (M-ADR 0211 §1). From contributes_to.artifact_type=contract-surface. Per M-ADR 0147 service-architecture external interfaces are a contract-consumes source; contract_id is external_for_profiles app/integration because their repos reference platform-resident (or platform-held BFF) contracts — resolved at aggregation, staying internal for platform-profile."
1685
1668
  foreign_keys:
1686
1669
  - column: repo_id
1687
1670
  references: repositories.id
@@ -1694,7 +1677,6 @@ catalogues:
1694
1677
  - integration-product
1695
1678
  product_capability:
1696
1679
  primary_key: id
1697
- description: 'Edge: product depends on / consumes capability. Forward sources from app-platform-dependencies.yaml. capability_id is external because the consuming product (an application-product SDD) references a capability owned by the platform SDD.'
1698
1680
  columns:
1699
1681
  - name: id
1700
1682
  type: string
@@ -1712,6 +1694,7 @@ catalogues:
1712
1694
  - name: notes
1713
1695
  type: string
1714
1696
  nullable: true
1697
+ description: "Edge: product depends on / consumes capability. Forward sources from app-platform-dependencies.yaml. capability_id is external because the consuming product (an application-product SDD) references a capability owned by the platform SDD."
1715
1698
  foreign_keys:
1716
1699
  - column: product_id
1717
1700
  references: products.id
@@ -1724,7 +1707,6 @@ catalogues:
1724
1707
  role: enums.consumption_role
1725
1708
  product_service:
1726
1709
  primary_key: id
1727
- description: 'Edge: product depends on / consumes service. Forward sources from app-platform-dependencies.yaml. service_id is external because the consuming product (an application-product SDD) references a service owned by the platform SDD.'
1728
1710
  columns:
1729
1711
  - name: id
1730
1712
  type: string
@@ -1742,7 +1724,8 @@ catalogues:
1742
1724
  - name: required_stability
1743
1725
  type: string
1744
1726
  nullable: true
1745
- description: 'provisional | locked | unknown. The consuming SDD''s expectation of contract stability, carried verbatim from app-platform-dependencies.yaml. Not a bound enum: an out-of-vocabulary value is carried, not rejected, and is reported by validate-app-dependencies.sh.'
1727
+ description: "provisional | locked | unknown. The consuming SDD's expectation of contract stability, carried verbatim from app-platform-dependencies.yaml. Not a bound enum: an out-of-vocabulary value is carried, not rejected, and is reported by validate-app-dependencies.sh."
1728
+ description: "Edge: product depends on / consumes service. Forward sources from app-platform-dependencies.yaml. service_id is external because the consuming product (an application-product SDD) references a service owned by the platform SDD."
1746
1729
  foreign_keys:
1747
1730
  - column: product_id
1748
1731
  references: products.id
@@ -1755,12 +1738,11 @@ catalogues:
1755
1738
  role: enums.consumption_role
1756
1739
  service_contract:
1757
1740
  primary_key: id
1758
- description: 'Edge: service exposes or consumes contract. Both FKs are external (per M-ADR 0147): federated SDDs that walk per-repo service-architecture tables emit consumes rows where service_id resolves to the platform-root catalogue''s services.csv (post-aggregation) and contract_id resolves to the platform-root contracts.csv. Internal builds (e.g. connect-mono) still optimistically validate locally. Schema 2.8.0.'
1759
1741
  columns:
1760
1742
  - name: id
1761
1743
  type: string
1762
1744
  nullable: false
1763
- description: '{service_id}__{contract_id}__{role}.'
1745
+ description: "{service_id}__{contract_id}__{role}."
1764
1746
  - name: service_id
1765
1747
  type: string
1766
1748
  nullable: false
@@ -1771,6 +1753,7 @@ catalogues:
1771
1753
  type: string
1772
1754
  nullable: false
1773
1755
  description: exposes | consumes.
1756
+ description: "Edge: service exposes or consumes contract. Both FKs are external (per M-ADR 0147): federated SDDs that walk per-repo service-architecture tables emit consumes rows where service_id resolves to the platform-root catalogue's services.csv (post-aggregation) and contract_id resolves to the platform-root contracts.csv. Internal builds (e.g. connect-mono) still optimistically validate locally. Schema 2.8.0."
1774
1757
  foreign_keys:
1775
1758
  - column: service_id
1776
1759
  references: services.id
@@ -1784,12 +1767,11 @@ catalogues:
1784
1767
  role: enums.contract_participation
1785
1768
  service_event:
1786
1769
  primary_key: id
1787
- description: 'Edge: service publishes or consumes event.'
1788
1770
  columns:
1789
1771
  - name: id
1790
1772
  type: string
1791
1773
  nullable: false
1792
- description: '{service_id}__{event_id}__{role}.'
1774
+ description: "{service_id}__{event_id}__{role}."
1793
1775
  - name: service_id
1794
1776
  type: string
1795
1777
  nullable: false
@@ -1800,6 +1782,7 @@ catalogues:
1800
1782
  type: string
1801
1783
  nullable: false
1802
1784
  description: publishes | consumes.
1785
+ description: "Edge: service publishes or consumes event."
1803
1786
  foreign_keys:
1804
1787
  - column: service_id
1805
1788
  references: services.id
@@ -1811,12 +1794,11 @@ catalogues:
1811
1794
  role: enums.event_participation
1812
1795
  service_entity:
1813
1796
  primary_key: id
1814
- description: 'Edge: service touches data-model entity. Added in schema 2.13.0 per M-ADR 0159. Primary source: per-domain `## Data Store Mapping` markdown table in `docs/domains/{domain}/architecture/data-model.mermaid.md` (relation=owns). Optional forward source (Phase 5 deferred): `entities:` block in `orchestration/repo-config/<repo>.yaml`. Service names resolve via heuristic (slug-of-name; trailing-id-segment) with optional adopter-authored alias map at `docs/platform/reference/service-name-aliases.yaml`.'
1815
1797
  columns:
1816
1798
  - name: id
1817
1799
  type: string
1818
1800
  nullable: false
1819
- description: 'Composite PK: {service_id}__{entity_id}__{relation}.'
1801
+ description: "Composite PK: {service_id}__{entity_id}__{relation}."
1820
1802
  - name: service_id
1821
1803
  type: string
1822
1804
  nullable: false
@@ -1826,7 +1808,7 @@ catalogues:
1826
1808
  - name: relation
1827
1809
  type: string
1828
1810
  nullable: false
1829
- description: 'Open string; recommended values: owns | reads | writes | references. Data Store Mapping table source emits `owns`. Values outside the recommended set fire `[finding] convention`.'
1811
+ description: "Open string; recommended values: owns | reads | writes | references. Data Store Mapping table source emits `owns`. Values outside the recommended set fire `[finding] convention`."
1830
1812
  - name: evidence_path
1831
1813
  type: string
1832
1814
  nullable: true
@@ -1839,6 +1821,7 @@ catalogues:
1839
1821
  type: string
1840
1822
  nullable: true
1841
1823
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
1824
+ description: "Edge: service touches data-model entity. Added in schema 2.13.0 per M-ADR 0159. Primary source: per-domain `## Data Store Mapping` markdown table in `docs/domains/{domain}/architecture/data-model.mermaid.md` (relation=owns). Optional forward source (Phase 5 deferred): `entities:` block in `orchestration/repo-config/<repo>.yaml`. Service names resolve via heuristic (slug-of-name; trailing-id-segment) with optional adopter-authored alias map at `docs/platform/reference/service-name-aliases.yaml`."
1842
1825
  foreign_keys:
1843
1826
  - column: service_id
1844
1827
  references: services.id
@@ -1848,7 +1831,6 @@ catalogues:
1848
1831
  nullable: false
1849
1832
  capability_feature:
1850
1833
  primary_key: id
1851
- description: 'Edge: capability decomposes into features. Forward: traceability.runway.enables. Reverse: parsed from spec Feature Grounding.'
1852
1834
  columns:
1853
1835
  - name: id
1854
1836
  type: string
@@ -1859,6 +1841,7 @@ catalogues:
1859
1841
  - name: feature_id
1860
1842
  type: string
1861
1843
  nullable: false
1844
+ description: "Edge: capability decomposes into features. Forward: traceability.runway.enables. Reverse: parsed from spec Feature Grounding."
1862
1845
  foreign_keys:
1863
1846
  - column: capability_id
1864
1847
  references: capabilities.id
@@ -1868,9 +1851,6 @@ catalogues:
1868
1851
  nullable: false
1869
1852
  capability_service:
1870
1853
  primary_key: id
1871
- description: 'Edge: capability is realised by services. Sourced from the capability traceability manifest services[] block. service_id is an external FK (schema 2.29.0, F4): a traceability entry marked `owner_sdd:` declares a cross-SDD reference (e.g. the service moved to a sibling SDD at an M-ADR 0170 §4.2 carve) — the per-SDD builder emits the edge, logs it `[finding] external`, and aggregation validates it hard against the owning sibling''s rows. An UNMARKED id that does not resolve locally is NOT emitted — it stays a member-tier orphan finding (or convention, when it names a known external system).
1872
-
1873
- '
1874
1854
  columns:
1875
1855
  - name: id
1876
1856
  type: string
@@ -1884,11 +1864,11 @@ catalogues:
1884
1864
  - name: role
1885
1865
  type: string
1886
1866
  nullable: true
1887
- description: 'The part the service plays in delivering THIS capability — a property of the relationship, not of the service (capability-traceability-manifest-template). Closed enum, see enums.capability_service_role. Nullable: legacy rows may carry no role; the enum validator checks values, not presence. `dependency` rows are excluded from repo_capability Path X (M-ADR 0157 §4.3 as amended). Enum bound in 3.8.0.'
1867
+ description: "The part the service plays in delivering THIS capability — a property of the relationship, not of the service (capability-traceability-manifest-template). Closed enum, see enums.capability_service_role. Nullable: legacy rows may carry no role; the enum validator checks values, not presence. `dependency` rows are excluded from repo_capability Path X (M-ADR 0157 §4.3 as amended). Enum bound in 3.8.0."
1888
1868
  - name: contract_id
1889
1869
  type: string
1890
1870
  nullable: true
1891
- description: 'The contract this dependency is against — a contracts.id declared as `contract:` on the services[] entry (M-ADR 0211 §4.1). External FK on the pattern of feature_contract: resolved at aggregation. Empty when the entry declares none; a `dependency`-role entry that reaches T4 band 5 carries it.'
1871
+ description: "The contract this dependency is against — a contracts.id declared as `contract:` on the services[] entry (M-ADR 0211 §4.1). External FK on the pattern of feature_contract: resolved at aggregation. Empty when the entry declares none; a `dependency`-role entry that reaches T4 band 5 carries it."
1892
1872
  - name: interaction_pattern
1893
1873
  type: string
1894
1874
  nullable: true
@@ -1901,6 +1881,8 @@ catalogues:
1901
1881
  type: string
1902
1882
  nullable: true
1903
1883
  description: Where the coupling is evidenced — a path or anchor in the SDD, from `evidence:` on the services[] entry. Prose about the coupling stays in dependency_notes; this is the pointer a reviewer follows.
1884
+ description: |
1885
+ Edge: capability is realised by services. Sourced from the capability traceability manifest services[] block. service_id is an external FK (schema 2.29.0, F4): a traceability entry marked `owner_sdd:` declares a cross-SDD reference (e.g. the service moved to a sibling SDD at an M-ADR 0170 §4.2 carve) — the per-SDD builder emits the edge, logs it `[finding] external`, and aggregation validates it hard against the owning sibling's rows. An UNMARKED id that does not resolve locally is NOT emitted — it stays a member-tier orphan finding (or convention, when it names a known external system).
1904
1886
  foreign_keys:
1905
1887
  - column: capability_id
1906
1888
  references: capabilities.id
@@ -1918,7 +1900,6 @@ catalogues:
1918
1900
  interaction_pattern: enums.interaction_pattern
1919
1901
  capability_event:
1920
1902
  primary_key: id
1921
- description: 'Edge: capability publishes or consumes event. Schema 2.14.0 (per M-ADR 0160) multi-source ingestion: (1) forward shape A — `traceability.events[{id, role}]` (legacy aspirational shape, unauthored across observed adopters); (2) forward shape B — `traceability.contracts.published_events[]` / `consumed_events[]` with `{event, status, notes}` (the observed forward-method shape; event name slug-resolves against events.csv); (3) derived — `capability_service ⋈ service_event` join (zero authoring; associative not authoritative). Authored rows win on PK conflict with derived. The `source` column distinguishes the two so governance queries can filter to authoritative ownership. The earlier `## Related Events` capability-spec heading is retired (no adopter authored it; the template never carried the section).'
1922
1903
  columns:
1923
1904
  - name: id
1924
1905
  type: string
@@ -1937,6 +1918,7 @@ catalogues:
1937
1918
  type: string
1938
1919
  nullable: false
1939
1920
  description: authored | derived. `authored` rows come from a traceability declaration (shape A or shape B); `derived` rows come from `capability_service ⋈ service_event` and represent associative coupling, not ownership. Schema 2.14.0 per M-ADR 0160.
1921
+ description: "Edge: capability publishes or consumes event. Schema 2.14.0 (per M-ADR 0160) multi-source ingestion: (1) forward shape A — `traceability.events[{id, role}]` (legacy aspirational shape, unauthored across observed adopters); (2) forward shape B — `traceability.contracts.published_events[]` / `consumed_events[]` with `{event, status, notes}` (the observed forward-method shape; event name slug-resolves against events.csv); (3) derived — `capability_service ⋈ service_event` join (zero authoring; associative not authoritative). Authored rows win on PK conflict with derived. The `source` column distinguishes the two so governance queries can filter to authoritative ownership. The earlier `## Related Events` capability-spec heading is retired (no adopter authored it; the template never carried the section)."
1940
1922
  foreign_keys:
1941
1923
  - column: capability_id
1942
1924
  references: capabilities.id
@@ -1948,7 +1930,6 @@ catalogues:
1948
1930
  role: enums.event_participation
1949
1931
  capability_contract:
1950
1932
  primary_key: id
1951
- description: 'Edge: capability is bound to a contract. Whether the capability exposes or depends on it is not stated by the source (traceability.contracts), so this description asserts no direction (M-ADR 0211 §1). Forward-declared only. Forward-declared only (traceability.contracts). The reverse derivation this description long claimed (service_contract ⋈ capability_service) was measured nonexistent — 0 `source: derived` rows across 105 units, builder references neither catalogue — and the CLAIM was corrected at 3.0.0 (M-ADR 0203 §4.5 / F2, gap class absent-derivation per M-ADR 0196 §4.1). The edge is forward-one-directional until a decision builds a reverse source.'
1952
1933
  columns:
1953
1934
  - name: id
1954
1935
  type: string
@@ -1962,7 +1943,8 @@ catalogues:
1962
1943
  - name: source
1963
1944
  type: string
1964
1945
  nullable: false
1965
- description: 'declared — the only emitted value. `derived` is reserved vocabulary: the reverse derivation it anticipated was never built (0 rows across 105 measured units) and the claim was corrected at 3.0.0 (M-ADR 0203 §4.5 / F2); the value re-enters if a decision builds a reverse source.'
1946
+ description: "declared — the only emitted value. `derived` is reserved vocabulary: the reverse derivation it anticipated was never built (0 rows across 105 measured units) and the claim was corrected at 3.0.0 (M-ADR 0203 §4.5 / F2); the value re-enters if a decision builds a reverse source."
1947
+ description: "Edge: capability is bound to a contract. Whether the capability exposes or depends on it is not stated by the source (traceability.contracts), so this description asserts no direction (M-ADR 0211 §1). Forward-declared only. Forward-declared only (traceability.contracts). The reverse derivation this description long claimed (service_contract ⋈ capability_service) was measured nonexistent — 0 `source: derived` rows across 105 units, builder references neither catalogue — and the CLAIM was corrected at 3.0.0 (M-ADR 0203 §4.5 / F2, gap class absent-derivation per M-ADR 0196 §4.1). The edge is forward-one-directional until a decision builds a reverse source."
1966
1948
  foreign_keys:
1967
1949
  - column: capability_id
1968
1950
  references: capabilities.id
@@ -1972,7 +1954,6 @@ catalogues:
1972
1954
  nullable: false
1973
1955
  journey_feature:
1974
1956
  primary_key: id
1975
- description: 'Edge: journey touches features. Parsed from Related features bullet.'
1976
1957
  columns:
1977
1958
  - name: id
1978
1959
  type: string
@@ -1983,6 +1964,7 @@ catalogues:
1983
1964
  - name: feature_id
1984
1965
  type: string
1985
1966
  nullable: false
1967
+ description: "Edge: journey touches features. Parsed from Related features bullet."
1986
1968
  foreign_keys:
1987
1969
  - column: journey_id
1988
1970
  references: user_journeys.id
@@ -1992,7 +1974,6 @@ catalogues:
1992
1974
  nullable: false
1993
1975
  persona_feature:
1994
1976
  primary_key: id
1995
- description: 'Edge: persona uses features. Parsed from Related features bullet.'
1996
1977
  columns:
1997
1978
  - name: id
1998
1979
  type: string
@@ -2003,6 +1984,7 @@ catalogues:
2003
1984
  - name: feature_id
2004
1985
  type: string
2005
1986
  nullable: false
1987
+ description: "Edge: persona uses features. Parsed from Related features bullet."
2006
1988
  foreign_keys:
2007
1989
  - column: persona_id
2008
1990
  references: personas.id
@@ -2012,7 +1994,6 @@ catalogues:
2012
1994
  nullable: false
2013
1995
  feature_service:
2014
1996
  primary_key: id
2015
- description: 'Edge: feature is implemented by service. Parsed from Feature Services table in feature-tree.md.'
2016
1997
  columns:
2017
1998
  - name: id
2018
1999
  type: string
@@ -2023,6 +2004,7 @@ catalogues:
2023
2004
  - name: service_id
2024
2005
  type: string
2025
2006
  nullable: false
2007
+ description: "Edge: feature is implemented by service. Parsed from Feature Services table in feature-tree.md."
2026
2008
  foreign_keys:
2027
2009
  - column: feature_id
2028
2010
  references: features.id
@@ -2032,7 +2014,6 @@ catalogues:
2032
2014
  nullable: false
2033
2015
  feature_event:
2034
2016
  primary_key: id
2035
- description: 'Edge: feature publishes or consumes event. Derived only — emitted from the `feature_service ⋈ service_event` join, mirroring M-ADR 0160''s capability_event derived path one rung lower in the capability/feature/service hierarchy. Every row carries `source=derived`; there is no authored shape (the authored signal lives at the service level via `service_event`, which the feature inherits through `feature_service`). PK is `{feature_id}__{event_id}__{role}` so the same feature can carry both publishes + consumes rows for the same event without collision. Schema 2.15.0 per M-ADR 0161.'
2036
2017
  columns:
2037
2018
  - name: id
2038
2019
  type: string
@@ -2051,6 +2032,7 @@ catalogues:
2051
2032
  type: string
2052
2033
  nullable: false
2053
2034
  description: Always `derived` (schema 2.15.0). The column is retained for symmetry with `capability_event.source` and to keep the door open for an authored shape if one surfaces; today every row is derived.
2035
+ description: "Edge: feature publishes or consumes event. Derived only — emitted from the `feature_service ⋈ service_event` join, mirroring M-ADR 0160's capability_event derived path one rung lower in the capability/feature/service hierarchy. Every row carries `source=derived`; there is no authored shape (the authored signal lives at the service level via `service_event`, which the feature inherits through `feature_service`). PK is `{feature_id}__{event_id}__{role}` so the same feature can carry both publishes + consumes rows for the same event without collision. Schema 2.15.0 per M-ADR 0161."
2054
2036
  foreign_keys:
2055
2037
  - column: feature_id
2056
2038
  references: features.id
@@ -2062,7 +2044,6 @@ catalogues:
2062
2044
  role: enums.event_participation
2063
2045
  feature_repo:
2064
2046
  primary_key: id
2065
- description: 'Edge: feature is implemented in repo. From contributes_to.artifact_type=feature-set.'
2066
2047
  columns:
2067
2048
  - name: id
2068
2049
  type: string
@@ -2073,6 +2054,7 @@ catalogues:
2073
2054
  - name: repo_id
2074
2055
  type: string
2075
2056
  nullable: false
2057
+ description: "Edge: feature is implemented in repo. From contributes_to.artifact_type=feature-set."
2076
2058
  foreign_keys:
2077
2059
  - column: feature_id
2078
2060
  references: features.id
@@ -2082,12 +2064,11 @@ catalogues:
2082
2064
  nullable: false
2083
2065
  feature_contract:
2084
2066
  primary_key: id
2085
- description: 'Edge: feature is exposed via contract. Derived — forward: capability_feature ⋈ capability_contract (on capability_id); reverse: feature_service ⋈ service_contract (on service_id). Both join paths are run and merged; duplicate (feature_id, contract_id) pairs are deduplicated. contract_id is external for app/integration profiles where contracts live in the platform SDD. Added in schema 2.3.0.'
2086
2067
  columns:
2087
2068
  - name: id
2088
2069
  type: string
2089
2070
  nullable: false
2090
- description: '{feature_id}__{contract_id}.'
2071
+ description: "{feature_id}__{contract_id}."
2091
2072
  - name: feature_id
2092
2073
  type: string
2093
2074
  nullable: false
@@ -2098,6 +2079,7 @@ catalogues:
2098
2079
  type: string
2099
2080
  nullable: true
2100
2081
  description: cap-feature-cap-contract | feature-service-service-contract. Diagnostic only — records which join path produced the row.
2082
+ description: "Edge: feature is exposed via contract. Derived — forward: capability_feature ⋈ capability_contract (on capability_id); reverse: feature_service ⋈ service_contract (on service_id). Both join paths are run and merged; duplicate (feature_id, contract_id) pairs are deduplicated. contract_id is external for app/integration profiles where contracts live in the platform SDD. Added in schema 2.3.0."
2101
2083
  foreign_keys:
2102
2084
  - column: feature_id
2103
2085
  references: features.id
@@ -2108,12 +2090,11 @@ catalogues:
2108
2090
  external: true
2109
2091
  feature_subscription_channels:
2110
2092
  primary_key: id
2111
- description: 'Edge: feature delivers async push via a named channel/topic. Peer of `graphql_operations:` in the per-feature evidence shape — `graphql_operations:` carries the GraphQL operation names declared in the schema (Queries / Mutations / Subscriptions); `feature_subscription_channels` rows carry the channel/topic layer that physically delivers the push events (AppSync WebSocket endpoints, Pekko WS channels, MQTT topics, server-sent-event streams). Per resolved decision §1 of `content/plans/v0-9-0-cohort-sweep-derived-bundle.md`: a single GraphQL Subscription operation may listen on multiple channels; one channel may be consumed by multiple operations — modelling as a separate edge catalogue (not as a feature column) accommodates the many-to-many. Built per-SDD from `reverse-evidence/feature-grounding-evidence.yaml` `subscription_channels:` entries on each feature. Added in schema 2.9.0.'
2112
2093
  columns:
2113
2094
  - name: id
2114
2095
  type: string
2115
2096
  nullable: false
2116
- description: '{feature_id}__{channel_name}.'
2097
+ description: "{feature_id}__{channel_name}."
2117
2098
  - name: feature_id
2118
2099
  type: string
2119
2100
  nullable: false
@@ -2124,7 +2105,7 @@ catalogues:
2124
2105
  - name: transport
2125
2106
  type: string
2126
2107
  nullable: false
2127
- description: 'Delivery protocol: `appsync-websocket | pekko-ws | mqtt | sse | webhook-push | other`. The `other` value is escape-valve; adopters using it SHOULD record the actual transport in evidence.'
2108
+ description: "Delivery protocol: `appsync-websocket | pekko-ws | mqtt | sse | webhook-push | other`. The `other` value is escape-valve; adopters using it SHOULD record the actual transport in evidence."
2128
2109
  - name: evidence
2129
2110
  type: string
2130
2111
  nullable: true
@@ -2141,18 +2122,18 @@ catalogues:
2141
2122
  type: string
2142
2123
  nullable: true
2143
2124
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2125
+ description: "Edge: feature delivers async push via a named channel/topic. Peer of `graphql_operations:` in the per-feature evidence shape — `graphql_operations:` carries the GraphQL operation names declared in the schema (Queries / Mutations / Subscriptions); `feature_subscription_channels` rows carry the channel/topic layer that physically delivers the push events (AppSync WebSocket endpoints, Pekko WS channels, MQTT topics, server-sent-event streams). Per resolved decision §1 of `content/plans/v0-9-0-cohort-sweep-derived-bundle.md`: a single GraphQL Subscription operation may listen on multiple channels; one channel may be consumed by multiple operations — modelling as a separate edge catalogue (not as a feature column) accommodates the many-to-many. Built per-SDD from `reverse-evidence/feature-grounding-evidence.yaml` `subscription_channels:` entries on each feature. Added in schema 2.9.0."
2144
2126
  foreign_keys:
2145
2127
  - column: feature_id
2146
2128
  references: features.id
2147
2129
  nullable: false
2148
2130
  capability_domain_model:
2149
2131
  primary_key: id
2150
- description: 'Edge: capability references a domain model. Forward: declared in `traceability.domain_model` field of the capability traceability manifest. Reverse: inferred via capability → domain → domain_model. Platform-profile only. Added in schema 2.4.0; see M-ADR 0142.'
2151
2132
  columns:
2152
2133
  - name: id
2153
2134
  type: string
2154
2135
  nullable: false
2155
- description: '{capability_id}__{domain_model_id}.'
2136
+ description: "{capability_id}__{domain_model_id}."
2156
2137
  - name: capability_id
2157
2138
  type: string
2158
2139
  nullable: false
@@ -2163,6 +2144,7 @@ catalogues:
2163
2144
  type: string
2164
2145
  nullable: false
2165
2146
  description: traceability-manifest | inferred.
2147
+ description: "Edge: capability references a domain model. Forward: declared in `traceability.domain_model` field of the capability traceability manifest. Reverse: inferred via capability → domain → domain_model. Platform-profile only. Added in schema 2.4.0; see M-ADR 0142."
2166
2148
  foreign_keys:
2167
2149
  - column: capability_id
2168
2150
  references: capabilities.id
@@ -2172,12 +2154,11 @@ catalogues:
2172
2154
  nullable: false
2173
2155
  feature_domain_model:
2174
2156
  primary_key: id
2175
- description: 'Edge: feature operates on a domain model. Derived from capability_feature ⋈ capability_domain_model (on capability_id). Platform-profile only. Orphan features (no capability link) get no row. Added in schema 2.4.0; see M-ADR 0142.'
2176
2157
  columns:
2177
2158
  - name: id
2178
2159
  type: string
2179
2160
  nullable: false
2180
- description: '{feature_id}__{domain_model_id}.'
2161
+ description: "{feature_id}__{domain_model_id}."
2181
2162
  - name: feature_id
2182
2163
  type: string
2183
2164
  nullable: false
@@ -2188,6 +2169,7 @@ catalogues:
2188
2169
  type: string
2189
2170
  nullable: true
2190
2171
  description: cap-feature-cap-domain-model. Diagnostic only.
2172
+ description: "Edge: feature operates on a domain model. Derived from capability_feature ⋈ capability_domain_model (on capability_id). Platform-profile only. Orphan features (no capability link) get no row. Added in schema 2.4.0; see M-ADR 0142."
2191
2173
  foreign_keys:
2192
2174
  - column: feature_id
2193
2175
  references: features.id
@@ -2197,7 +2179,6 @@ catalogues:
2197
2179
  nullable: false
2198
2180
  persona_journey:
2199
2181
  primary_key: id
2200
- description: 'Edge: persona participates in journey. Roles: primary | handoff | supporting.'
2201
2182
  columns:
2202
2183
  - name: id
2203
2184
  type: string
@@ -2212,6 +2193,7 @@ catalogues:
2212
2193
  type: string
2213
2194
  nullable: false
2214
2195
  description: primary | handoff | supporting.
2196
+ description: "Edge: persona participates in journey. Roles: primary | handoff | supporting."
2215
2197
  foreign_keys:
2216
2198
  - column: persona_id
2217
2199
  references: personas.id
@@ -2223,12 +2205,11 @@ catalogues:
2223
2205
  role: enums.journey_participation
2224
2206
  persona_c4system:
2225
2207
  primary_key: id
2226
- description: 'Edge: persona (C4 Person) uses a C4 system. Captures the L1 context ''Person uses System'' relationship, extracted from Person(...) macros on the L1 context diagram and matched to personas rows. Per M-ADR 0155. Added in schema 2.10.0.'
2227
2208
  columns:
2228
2209
  - name: id
2229
2210
  type: string
2230
2211
  nullable: false
2231
- description: '{persona_id}__{c4_system_id}.'
2212
+ description: "{persona_id}__{c4_system_id}."
2232
2213
  - name: persona_id
2233
2214
  type: string
2234
2215
  nullable: false
@@ -2239,6 +2220,7 @@ catalogues:
2239
2220
  type: string
2240
2221
  nullable: true
2241
2222
  description: Optional interaction label from the Rel(...) line, e.g. 'Web browser' / 'Mobile app'.
2223
+ description: "Edge: persona (C4 Person) uses a C4 system. Captures the L1 context 'Person uses System' relationship, extracted from Person(...) macros on the L1 context diagram and matched to personas rows. Per M-ADR 0155. Added in schema 2.10.0."
2242
2224
  foreign_keys:
2243
2225
  - column: persona_id
2244
2226
  references: personas.id
@@ -2248,14 +2230,11 @@ catalogues:
2248
2230
  nullable: false
2249
2231
  persona_container:
2250
2232
  primary_key: id
2251
- description: 'Edge: a persona uses a C4 container — the L2-granularity companion to persona_c4system (M-ADR 0189 F26 §3, ratified 2026-07-10). Eleven of one estate''s L2 diagrams and the bulk of another''s 81 unroutable Rels drew Person→Container relationships that had no catalogue and, until F26, no finding. Harvested at member tier from Rel(...) lines whose endpoints resolve to a file-local Person and a local container (either direction; the row is normalised persona→container). A Person that matches no persona row is a coverage finding, never a silent skip. Both authoring directions feed from the same diagram surface (M-ADR 0157 parity). Added in schema 2.34.0.
2252
-
2253
- '
2254
2233
  columns:
2255
2234
  - name: id
2256
2235
  type: string
2257
2236
  nullable: false
2258
- description: '{persona_id}__{container_id}.'
2237
+ description: "{persona_id}__{container_id}."
2259
2238
  - name: persona_id
2260
2239
  type: string
2261
2240
  nullable: false
@@ -2266,6 +2245,8 @@ catalogues:
2266
2245
  type: string
2267
2246
  nullable: true
2268
2247
  description: Optional interaction label from the Rel(...) line. May hold multiple '; '-joined labels (F25).
2248
+ description: |
2249
+ Edge: a persona uses a C4 container — the L2-granularity companion to persona_c4system (M-ADR 0189 F26 §3, ratified 2026-07-10). Eleven of one estate's L2 diagrams and the bulk of another's 81 unroutable Rels drew Person→Container relationships that had no catalogue and, until F26, no finding. Harvested at member tier from Rel(...) lines whose endpoints resolve to a file-local Person and a local container (either direction; the row is normalised persona→container). A Person that matches no persona row is a coverage finding, never a silent skip. Both authoring directions feed from the same diagram surface (M-ADR 0157 parity). Added in schema 2.34.0.
2269
2250
  foreign_keys:
2270
2251
  - column: persona_id
2271
2252
  references: personas.id
@@ -2275,12 +2256,11 @@ catalogues:
2275
2256
  nullable: false
2276
2257
  system_external_dependency:
2277
2258
  primary_key: id
2278
- description: 'Edge: a C4 system integrates with an external software system. Captures the L1 context ''System integrates with External System'' relationship, extracted from System_Ext(...) + Rel(...) on L1/L2 diagrams. Per M-ADR 0155. Container-level external dependencies are out of scope (system-level only). Added in schema 2.10.0. From 2.30.0 (M-ADR 0189 §4.4): edges whose external endpoint the aggregator adjudicates as an INTERNAL system are rewritten onto system_system_dependency and removed from this catalogue.'
2279
2259
  columns:
2280
2260
  - name: id
2281
2261
  type: string
2282
2262
  nullable: false
2283
- description: '{c4_system_id}__{external_system_id}.'
2263
+ description: "{c4_system_id}__{external_system_id}."
2284
2264
  - name: c4_system_id
2285
2265
  type: string
2286
2266
  nullable: false
@@ -2295,6 +2275,7 @@ catalogues:
2295
2275
  type: string
2296
2276
  nullable: true
2297
2277
  description: The Rel's non-external endpoint resolved to a local container at member tier, when it is one (F17, 2.33.0) — the datum that lets adjudication rewrite this edge onto container_dependency instead of destroying it. Empty when the endpoint is the system itself or unresolvable.
2278
+ description: "Edge: a C4 system integrates with an external software system. Captures the L1 context 'System integrates with External System' relationship, extracted from System_Ext(...) + Rel(...) on L1/L2 diagrams. Per M-ADR 0155. Container-level external dependencies are out of scope (system-level only). Added in schema 2.10.0. From 2.30.0 (M-ADR 0189 §4.4): edges whose external endpoint the aggregator adjudicates as an INTERNAL system are rewritten onto system_system_dependency and removed from this catalogue."
2298
2279
  foreign_keys:
2299
2280
  - column: c4_system_id
2300
2281
  references: c4_systems.id
@@ -2307,14 +2288,11 @@ catalogues:
2307
2288
  nullable: true
2308
2289
  container_dependency:
2309
2290
  primary_key: id
2310
- description: 'Edge: a C4 container depends on another INTERNAL container (adopter finding F17 — F6 exactly one tier down: "no edge for internal" at L2). Derived by the aggregator at adjudication: an external-system candidate that resolves to an internal container was never external — each of its dependency edges whose member-resolved `from_container_id` is known is rewritten here, and a candidate with no remaining edges is dropped (it was a phantom duplicate of the container). A candidate with unconvertible edges is kept with the tier-contradiction finding, so no edge is ever destroyed to make a build quieter — the measured cost that stopped an adopter remediating 22 contradictions was eight real edges. ALSO emitted at member tier (F19, 2.33.1): the C4-correct authoring — Rel(container_a, container_b) between two Container(...) nodes — emits its edge directly; adjudication merges into a catalogue that already has content rather than being its only source, so the metamodel no longer rewards mis-declaration over correct authoring. Added in schema 2.33.0.
2311
-
2312
- '
2313
2291
  columns:
2314
2292
  - name: id
2315
2293
  type: string
2316
2294
  nullable: false
2317
- description: '{from_container_id}__{to_container_id}.'
2295
+ description: "{from_container_id}__{to_container_id}."
2318
2296
  - name: from_container_id
2319
2297
  type: string
2320
2298
  nullable: false
@@ -2333,6 +2311,8 @@ catalogues:
2333
2311
  type: string
2334
2312
  nullable: true
2335
2313
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2314
+ description: |
2315
+ Edge: a C4 container depends on another INTERNAL container (adopter finding F17 — F6 exactly one tier down: "no edge for internal" at L2). Derived by the aggregator at adjudication: an external-system candidate that resolves to an internal container was never external — each of its dependency edges whose member-resolved `from_container_id` is known is rewritten here, and a candidate with no remaining edges is dropped (it was a phantom duplicate of the container). A candidate with unconvertible edges is kept with the tier-contradiction finding, so no edge is ever destroyed to make a build quieter — the measured cost that stopped an adopter remediating 22 contradictions was eight real edges. ALSO emitted at member tier (F19, 2.33.1): the C4-correct authoring — Rel(container_a, container_b) between two Container(...) nodes — emits its edge directly; adjudication merges into a catalogue that already has content rather than being its only source, so the metamodel no longer rewards mis-declaration over correct authoring. Added in schema 2.33.0.
2336
2316
  foreign_keys:
2337
2317
  - column: from_container_id
2338
2318
  references: c4_containers.id
@@ -2342,14 +2322,11 @@ catalogues:
2342
2322
  nullable: false
2343
2323
  system_system_dependency:
2344
2324
  primary_key: id
2345
- description: 'Edge: a C4 system depends on another INTERNAL system (M-ADR 0189 §4.3). Derived by the aggregator at adjudication (§4.4): an external-system candidate whose declared identity resolves to an internal system was never external — its Rel(...) dependency edges are rewritten onto this catalogue and the candidate row is dropped. Not emitted at member tier (a member cannot see sibling systems); headers-only there, like cross_sdd_platform_capability. Both authoring directions feed it from the same diagram surface (M-ADR 0157 parity). Added in schema 2.30.0.
2346
-
2347
- '
2348
2325
  columns:
2349
2326
  - name: id
2350
2327
  type: string
2351
2328
  nullable: false
2352
- description: '{from_system_id}__{to_system_id}.'
2329
+ description: "{from_system_id}__{to_system_id}."
2353
2330
  - name: from_system_id
2354
2331
  type: string
2355
2332
  nullable: false
@@ -2368,6 +2345,8 @@ catalogues:
2368
2345
  type: string
2369
2346
  nullable: true
2370
2347
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2348
+ description: |
2349
+ Edge: a C4 system depends on another INTERNAL system (M-ADR 0189 §4.3). Derived by the aggregator at adjudication (§4.4): an external-system candidate whose declared identity resolves to an internal system was never external — its Rel(...) dependency edges are rewritten onto this catalogue and the candidate row is dropped. Not emitted at member tier (a member cannot see sibling systems); headers-only there, like cross_sdd_platform_capability. Both authoring directions feed it from the same diagram surface (M-ADR 0157 parity). Added in schema 2.30.0.
2371
2350
  foreign_keys:
2372
2351
  - column: from_system_id
2373
2352
  references: c4_systems.id
@@ -2377,12 +2356,11 @@ catalogues:
2377
2356
  nullable: false
2378
2357
  c4_container_entity:
2379
2358
  primary_key: id
2380
- description: 'Derived edge: C4 container is responsible for data-model entity. Added in schema 2.13.0 per M-ADR 0159 §4.8. Pure transitive derivation: `service_entity ⋈ c4_containers.service_id`. Only the subset of containers with `service_id` populated contribute edges (per M-ADR 0155 the container ↔ service cardinality is o-or-1; data-store containers and infra-umbrella containers without a service mapping legitimately emit no rows).'
2381
2359
  columns:
2382
2360
  - name: id
2383
2361
  type: string
2384
2362
  nullable: false
2385
- description: 'Composite PK: {container_id}__{entity_id}.'
2363
+ description: "Composite PK: {container_id}__{entity_id}."
2386
2364
  - name: container_id
2387
2365
  type: string
2388
2366
  nullable: false
@@ -2400,6 +2378,7 @@ catalogues:
2400
2378
  type: string
2401
2379
  nullable: true
2402
2380
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2381
+ description: "Derived edge: C4 container is responsible for data-model entity. Added in schema 2.13.0 per M-ADR 0159 §4.8. Pure transitive derivation: `service_entity ⋈ c4_containers.service_id`. Only the subset of containers with `service_id` populated contribute edges (per M-ADR 0155 the container ↔ service cardinality is o-or-1; data-store containers and infra-umbrella containers without a service mapping legitimately emit no rows)."
2403
2382
  foreign_keys:
2404
2383
  - column: container_id
2405
2384
  references: c4_containers.id
@@ -2409,12 +2388,11 @@ catalogues:
2409
2388
  nullable: false
2410
2389
  c4_system_entity:
2411
2390
  primary_key: id
2412
- description: 'Derived edge: C4 system is responsible for data-model entity. Added in schema 2.13.0 per M-ADR 0159 §4.8. Pure aggregation roll-up: `c4_container_entity ⋈ c4_containers.system_id`, with container_count recording how many of the system''s containers touch the entity (governance signal for cross-container concerns).'
2413
2391
  columns:
2414
2392
  - name: id
2415
2393
  type: string
2416
2394
  nullable: false
2417
- description: 'Composite PK: {system_id}__{entity_id}.'
2395
+ description: "Composite PK: {system_id}__{entity_id}."
2418
2396
  - name: system_id
2419
2397
  type: string
2420
2398
  nullable: false
@@ -2432,6 +2410,7 @@ catalogues:
2432
2410
  type: string
2433
2411
  nullable: true
2434
2412
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2413
+ description: "Derived edge: C4 system is responsible for data-model entity. Added in schema 2.13.0 per M-ADR 0159 §4.8. Pure aggregation roll-up: `c4_container_entity ⋈ c4_containers.system_id`, with container_count recording how many of the system's containers touch the entity (governance signal for cross-container concerns)."
2435
2414
  foreign_keys:
2436
2415
  - column: system_id
2437
2416
  references: c4_systems.id
@@ -2441,7 +2420,6 @@ catalogues:
2441
2420
  nullable: false
2442
2421
  capability_adr:
2443
2422
  primary_key: id
2444
- description: 'Edge: ADR informs capability. Forward: declared in capability spec Architecture Decisions. Reverse: same plus heuristic match supplements with confidence.'
2445
2423
  columns:
2446
2424
  - name: id
2447
2425
  type: string
@@ -2456,6 +2434,7 @@ catalogues:
2456
2434
  type: string
2457
2435
  nullable: false
2458
2436
  description: spec | high | medium.
2437
+ description: "Edge: ADR informs capability. Forward: declared in capability spec Architecture Decisions. Reverse: same plus heuristic match supplements with confidence."
2459
2438
  foreign_keys:
2460
2439
  - column: capability_id
2461
2440
  references: capabilities.id
@@ -2465,7 +2444,6 @@ catalogues:
2465
2444
  nullable: false
2466
2445
  adr_supersedes:
2467
2446
  primary_key: id
2468
- description: 'Edge: superseding ADR → superseded ADR. Parsed from Supersedes bullets where prose references a known ADR id.'
2469
2447
  columns:
2470
2448
  - name: id
2471
2449
  type: string
@@ -2476,6 +2454,7 @@ catalogues:
2476
2454
  - name: superseded_adr_id
2477
2455
  type: string
2478
2456
  nullable: false
2457
+ description: "Edge: superseding ADR → superseded ADR. Parsed from Supersedes bullets where prose references a known ADR id."
2479
2458
  foreign_keys:
2480
2459
  - column: superseding_adr_id
2481
2460
  references: adrs.id
@@ -2485,14 +2464,11 @@ catalogues:
2485
2464
  nullable: false
2486
2465
  product_platform_dependencies:
2487
2466
  primary_key: id
2488
- description: 'Per-SDD edge: an application-side or integration-side SDD declares that its product depends on a platform-side capability + service pair. Built from `reverse-evidence/feature-grounding-evidence.yaml` `platform_dependencies:` block (product-level — the cohort source shape carries product-scoped dependency rows with a `consumed_by:` list naming which services within the consuming product depend on the target). Each row records one (consuming product, target capability, target service) triple. The aggregator then joins these rows against platform-side `capability_service` to emit `cross_sdd_platform_capability` edges at aggregation time. Cross- SDD references (target_capability_id, target_service_id) are external — they''re not expected to resolve in the per-SDD build, only at aggregation. Added in schema 2.9.0; see `content/plans/v0-9-0-cohort-sweep-derived-bundle.md` §"Cross-SDD platform-capability-edge".
2489
-
2490
- '
2491
2467
  columns:
2492
2468
  - name: id
2493
2469
  type: string
2494
2470
  nullable: false
2495
- description: '{product_id}__{target_capability_id}__{target_service_id}, EXCEPT for async shared-stream rows (M-ADR 0192) where there is no realiser service: the third component falls back to the stream contract_path, i.e. {product_id}__{target_capability_id}__{contract_path}. For OFF-PLATFORM rows (M-ADR 0204, target_locus external|legacy) there is no platform capability either: id = {product_id}__{target_locus}__{target_external_system_id}, falling back to contract_path as the third component when no external-system id is named. This keeps the PK stable and collision-free when a product depends on the same capability via two distinct streams.'
2471
+ description: "{product_id}__{target_capability_id}__{target_service_id}, EXCEPT for async shared-stream rows (M-ADR 0192) where there is no realiser service: the third component falls back to the stream contract_path, i.e. {product_id}__{target_capability_id}__{contract_path}. For OFF-PLATFORM rows (M-ADR 0204, target_locus external|legacy) there is no platform capability either: id = {product_id}__{target_locus}__{target_external_system_id}, falling back to contract_path as the third component when no external-system id is named. This keeps the PK stable and collision-free when a product depends on the same capability via two distinct streams."
2496
2472
  - name: product_id
2497
2473
  type: string
2498
2474
  nullable: false
@@ -2500,7 +2476,7 @@ catalogues:
2500
2476
  - name: target_capability_id
2501
2477
  type: string
2502
2478
  nullable: true
2503
- description: 'Capability the consuming product depends on. Resolves at aggregation against a sibling SDD''s capabilities.id; external by definition. Conditionally nullable (M-ADR 0204 §4.3): EMPTY when target_locus is external|legacy — there is no platform capability to name on an off-platform row, and demanding a value is what put a product''s own feature slug in this column. A platform-locus row still requires it.'
2479
+ description: "Capability the consuming product depends on. Resolves at aggregation against a sibling SDD's capabilities.id; external by definition. Conditionally nullable (M-ADR 0204 §4.3): EMPTY when target_locus is external|legacy — there is no platform capability to name on an off-platform row, and demanding a value is what put a product's own feature slug in this column. A platform-locus row still requires it."
2504
2480
  - name: target_locus
2505
2481
  type: string
2506
2482
  nullable: true
@@ -2508,11 +2484,11 @@ catalogues:
2508
2484
  - name: target_external_system_id
2509
2485
  type: string
2510
2486
  nullable: true
2511
- description: 'For target_locus external|legacy rows only: the M-ADR 0189 external-system entry id the dependency targets (authored in the source file''s service_id slot; the builder routes it here so the FK columns stay clean). Deliberately NOT a declared FK: corroboration against c4_external_systems is WARNING-severity at aggregation (M-ADR 0204 §4.2), because the C4 surface may legitimately lag discovery, and a declared FK can only fail.'
2487
+ description: "For target_locus external|legacy rows only: the M-ADR 0189 external-system entry id the dependency targets (authored in the source file's service_id slot; the builder routes it here so the FK columns stay clean). Deliberately NOT a declared FK: corroboration against c4_external_systems is WARNING-severity at aggregation (M-ADR 0204 §4.2), because the C4 surface may legitimately lag discovery, and a declared FK can only fail."
2512
2488
  - name: target_service_id
2513
2489
  type: string
2514
2490
  nullable: true
2515
- description: 'Service identifier the consuming product depends on. Resolves at aggregation against a sibling SDD''s services.id; external by definition. The join key the aggregator uses to derive cross_sdd_platform_capability for SYNCHRONOUS dependencies. Conditionally nullable (M-ADR 0192): for an async shared-stream dependency (contract_type in the async set — `event`/`event-stream`/`stream`) there is no single realiser service, so this is empty and the dependency binds to the stream contract_path + target_capability_id instead. A synchronous contract_type still requires it. Made nullable in schema 2.36.0.'
2491
+ description: "Service identifier the consuming product depends on. Resolves at aggregation against a sibling SDD's services.id; external by definition. The join key the aggregator uses to derive cross_sdd_platform_capability for SYNCHRONOUS dependencies. Conditionally nullable (M-ADR 0192): for an async shared-stream dependency (contract_type in the async set — `event`/`event-stream`/`stream`) there is no single realiser service, so this is empty and the dependency binds to the stream contract_path + target_capability_id instead. A synchronous contract_type still requires it. Made nullable in schema 2.36.0."
2516
2492
  - name: target_domain
2517
2493
  type: string
2518
2494
  nullable: true
@@ -2524,7 +2500,7 @@ catalogues:
2524
2500
  - name: required_stability
2525
2501
  type: string
2526
2502
  nullable: true
2527
- description: 'provisional | locked | unknown. Optional; the consuming SDD''s expectation of contract stability — and only that: where the target lives and what lifecycle its implementation is in are separate concerns that do not belong in this field. Not a bound enum: an out-of-vocabulary value is carried, not rejected, and is reported by validate-app-dependencies.sh.'
2503
+ description: "provisional | locked | unknown. Optional; the consuming SDD's expectation of contract stability — and only that: where the target lives and what lifecycle its implementation is in are separate concerns that do not belong in this field. Not a bound enum: an out-of-vocabulary value is carried, not rejected, and is reported by validate-app-dependencies.sh."
2528
2504
  - name: contract_path
2529
2505
  type: string
2530
2506
  nullable: true
@@ -2541,6 +2517,8 @@ catalogues:
2541
2517
  type: string
2542
2518
  nullable: true
2543
2519
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2520
+ description: |
2521
+ Per-SDD edge: an application-side or integration-side SDD declares that its product depends on a platform-side capability + service pair. Built from `reverse-evidence/feature-grounding-evidence.yaml` `platform_dependencies:` block (product-level — the cohort source shape carries product-scoped dependency rows with a `consumed_by:` list naming which services within the consuming product depend on the target). Each row records one (consuming product, target capability, target service) triple. The aggregator then joins these rows against platform-side `capability_service` to emit `cross_sdd_platform_capability` edges at aggregation time. Cross- SDD references (target_capability_id, target_service_id) are external — they're not expected to resolve in the per-SDD build, only at aggregation. Added in schema 2.9.0; see `content/plans/v0-9-0-cohort-sweep-derived-bundle.md` §"Cross-SDD platform-capability-edge".
2544
2522
  foreign_keys:
2545
2523
  - column: product_id
2546
2524
  references: products.id
@@ -2555,14 +2533,11 @@ catalogues:
2555
2533
  external: true
2556
2534
  cross_sdd_platform_capability:
2557
2535
  primary_key: id
2558
- description: 'Federated edge: an application-side or integration-side SDD''s `product_platform_dependencies` reference resolves against a platform-side SDD''s capability spec via the platform capability''s `capability_service` roster. Surfaces ecosystem-wide platform- consumer relationships at product → capability granularity. Built **only at aggregation time** — `sdd-cli catalogue aggregate` joins each consuming SDD''s `product_platform_dependencies` rows against every other SDD''s `capability_service` rows on `target_service_id == service_id`, emitting one row per resolved (consuming-product, platform-capability) pair. Per-SDD builders emit nothing for this catalogue; the aggregator owns it entirely. A platform-dependency whose target_service_id doesn''t resolve to any platform-side capability_service row is logged as an `orphan` finding and produces no row. Cross-SDD references are external by definition. Added in schema 2.9.0; see `content/plans/v0-9-0-cohort-sweep-derived-bundle.md` §"Cross-SDD platform-capability-edge" and M-ADR 0134.
2559
-
2560
- '
2561
2536
  columns:
2562
2537
  - name: id
2563
2538
  type: string
2564
2539
  nullable: false
2565
- description: '{consuming_sdd_id}__{consuming_product_id}__{platform_sdd_id}__{platform_capability_id}__{service_id}. Composite encoding so the same (consuming product, platform capability) pair can appear once per resolving service when a product depends on multiple services owned by the same capability.'
2540
+ description: "{consuming_sdd_id}__{consuming_product_id}__{platform_sdd_id}__{platform_capability_id}__{service_id}. Composite encoding so the same (consuming product, platform capability) pair can appear once per resolving service when a product depends on multiple services owned by the same capability."
2566
2541
  - name: consuming_sdd_id
2567
2542
  type: string
2568
2543
  nullable: false
@@ -2583,6 +2558,8 @@ catalogues:
2583
2558
  type: string
2584
2559
  nullable: false
2585
2560
  description: Service identifier the consuming SDD references and the platform SDD owns. The join key.
2561
+ description: |
2562
+ Federated edge: an application-side or integration-side SDD's `product_platform_dependencies` reference resolves against a platform-side SDD's capability spec via the platform capability's `capability_service` roster. Surfaces ecosystem-wide platform- consumer relationships at product → capability granularity. Built **only at aggregation time** — `sdd-cli catalogue aggregate` joins each consuming SDD's `product_platform_dependencies` rows against every other SDD's `capability_service` rows on `target_service_id == service_id`, emitting one row per resolved (consuming-product, platform-capability) pair. Per-SDD builders emit nothing for this catalogue; the aggregator owns it entirely. A platform-dependency whose target_service_id doesn't resolve to any platform-side capability_service row is logged as an `orphan` finding and produces no row. Cross-SDD references are external by definition. Added in schema 2.9.0; see `content/plans/v0-9-0-cohort-sweep-derived-bundle.md` §"Cross-SDD platform-capability-edge" and M-ADR 0134.
2586
2563
  foreign_keys:
2587
2564
  - column: consuming_product_id
2588
2565
  references: products.id
@@ -2598,14 +2575,11 @@ catalogues:
2598
2575
  external: true
2599
2576
  application_data_plane_bindings:
2600
2577
  primary_key: id
2601
- description: 'Application-product edge (M-ADR 0193): one row per declared data-plane binding — a typed way the service sources, holds, produces or exposes data. The data-plane is a COMPOSITION of these bindings, a second axis orthogonal to `application_archetype` (0191). Built per-SDD from the manifest''s `data_plane.bindings` block (application-product only; other profiles emit headers-only). The `pattern` vocabulary splits by DIRECTION (§4.7): an INBOUND data-sourcing sub-set (retrieve | own-store | stream-ingest | project) and an OUTPUT-side sub-set (generate | publish), materialised as the derived `direction` column. An INBOUND binding whose `target` is a platform capability/service reconciles with `product_platform_dependencies` — a `retrieve@internal` binding is a synchronous platform dependency and a `stream-ingest@internal` binding is the M-ADR 0192 `contract_type: event` async dependency; the genuinely new inbound rows are `own-store` (a self-binding) and any `external-vendor` binding. OUTPUT-side rows do NOT participate in that reconciliation (§4.7 rule 1): `publish` is a contract the service PROVIDES, not one it consumes, so it has no inbound counterpart to cross-check — consumers must filter on `direction` before reconciling, which is what the column is for. The archetype-default-vs-declared WARN keys on the bare `pattern` token and so spans both directions (§4.7 rule 2). Added in schema 2.37.0; `direction` added in 2.40.0.
2602
-
2603
- '
2604
2578
  columns:
2605
2579
  - name: id
2606
2580
  type: string
2607
2581
  nullable: false
2608
- description: '{product_id}__{pattern}__{locality}__{target} (empty components collapse to blanks). A duplicate emits a divergence finding and is dropped. `direction` is NOT a component — it is derived from `pattern`, so it adds nothing to identity.'
2582
+ description: "{product_id}__{pattern}__{locality}__{target} (empty components collapse to blanks). A duplicate emits a divergence finding and is dropped. `direction` is NOT a component — it is derived from `pattern`, so it adds nothing to identity."
2609
2583
  - name: product_id
2610
2584
  type: string
2611
2585
  nullable: false
@@ -2613,15 +2587,15 @@ catalogues:
2613
2587
  - name: pattern
2614
2588
  type: string
2615
2589
  nullable: false
2616
- description: 'Closed method-tier enum: retrieve | own-store | stream-ingest | project (inbound, data-sourcing) | generate | publish (output-side, per M-ADR 0193 §4.7). How the data relates to the service (§4.1).'
2590
+ description: "Closed method-tier enum: retrieve | own-store | stream-ingest | project (inbound, data-sourcing) | generate | publish (output-side, per M-ADR 0193 §4.7). How the data relates to the service (§4.1)."
2617
2591
  - name: direction
2618
2592
  type: string
2619
2593
  nullable: false
2620
- description: 'inbound | output. DERIVED from `pattern` by a single method-tier mapping — not authored, and not a manifest field, so it cannot disagree with `pattern`. Materialises the output-side sub-set §4.7 declares (generate/publish => output; everything else => inbound). Exists because three §4.7 rules branch on direction: platform-dep reconciliation is inbound-only, the archetype WARN must compare like with like, and the M-ADR 0187 convergence reasoning differs by direction. Added in 2.40.0.'
2594
+ description: "inbound | output. DERIVED from `pattern` by a single method-tier mapping — not authored, and not a manifest field, so it cannot disagree with `pattern`. Materialises the output-side sub-set §4.7 declares (generate/publish => output; everything else => inbound). Exists because three §4.7 rules branch on direction: platform-dep reconciliation is inbound-only, the archetype WARN must compare like with like, and the M-ADR 0187 convergence reasoning differs by direction. Added in 2.40.0."
2621
2595
  - name: locality
2622
2596
  type: string
2623
2597
  nullable: true
2624
- description: 'Closed enum: internal-platform | internal-domain | external-vendor. Where the other end sits. REQUIRED on the inbound data-sourcing patterns (retrieve/stream-ingest/project); may be empty for own-store (a self-binding with no other end) and for the output-side patterns (generate/publish), which may carry one but do not require it (M-ADR 0193 §4.7).'
2598
+ description: "Closed enum: internal-platform | internal-domain | external-vendor. Where the other end sits. REQUIRED on the inbound data-sourcing patterns (retrieve/stream-ingest/project); may be empty for own-store (a self-binding with no other end) and for the output-side patterns (generate/publish), which may carry one but do not require it (M-ADR 0193 §4.7)."
2625
2599
  - name: transport
2626
2600
  type: string
2627
2601
  nullable: true
@@ -2646,20 +2620,19 @@ catalogues:
2646
2620
  type: string
2647
2621
  nullable: true
2648
2622
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2623
+ description: |
2624
+ Application-product edge (M-ADR 0193): one row per declared data-plane binding — a typed way the service sources, holds, produces or exposes data. The data-plane is a COMPOSITION of these bindings, a second axis orthogonal to `application_archetype` (0191). Built per-SDD from the manifest's `data_plane.bindings` block (application-product only; other profiles emit headers-only). The `pattern` vocabulary splits by DIRECTION (§4.7): an INBOUND data-sourcing sub-set (retrieve | own-store | stream-ingest | project) and an OUTPUT-side sub-set (generate | publish), materialised as the derived `direction` column. An INBOUND binding whose `target` is a platform capability/service reconciles with `product_platform_dependencies` — a `retrieve@internal` binding is a synchronous platform dependency and a `stream-ingest@internal` binding is the M-ADR 0192 `contract_type: event` async dependency; the genuinely new inbound rows are `own-store` (a self-binding) and any `external-vendor` binding. OUTPUT-side rows do NOT participate in that reconciliation (§4.7 rule 1): `publish` is a contract the service PROVIDES, not one it consumes, so it has no inbound counterpart to cross-check — consumers must filter on `direction` before reconciling, which is what the column is for. The archetype-default-vs-declared WARN keys on the bare `pattern` token and so spans both directions (§4.7 rule 2). Added in schema 2.37.0; `direction` added in 2.40.0.
2649
2625
  foreign_keys:
2650
2626
  - column: product_id
2651
2627
  references: products.id
2652
2628
  nullable: false
2653
2629
  application_data_plane_deviations:
2654
2630
  primary_key: id
2655
- description: 'Application-product annotation (M-ADR 0191 §4.3 overlay): one row per declared departure from the archetype''s default data-plane composition. Built per-SDD from the manifest''s `data_plane.deviations` block so the overlay WARN — which runs at AGGREGATION tier, where the reference- architecture bundle (and its `expected_bindings`) resolves — can suppress a mismatch it is told is sanctioned variance. The `expectation` value is the **bare pattern token** (`retrieve` | `own-store` | `stream-ingest` | `project` | `generate` | `publish`) that the product knowingly diverges from; it must match the pattern the WARN keys on. The token set spans both directions — the WARN keys on the bare pattern, so an output-side expectation is deviated exactly like an inbound one (M-ADR 0193 §4.7 rule 2). Added in schema 2.38.0; output-side tokens documented in 2.40.0.
2656
-
2657
- '
2658
2631
  columns:
2659
2632
  - name: id
2660
2633
  type: string
2661
2634
  nullable: false
2662
- description: '{product_id}__{expectation}. A duplicate emits a divergence finding and is dropped.'
2635
+ description: "{product_id}__{expectation}. A duplicate emits a divergence finding and is dropped."
2663
2636
  - name: product_id
2664
2637
  type: string
2665
2638
  nullable: false
@@ -2680,20 +2653,19 @@ catalogues:
2680
2653
  type: string
2681
2654
  nullable: true
2682
2655
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2656
+ description: |
2657
+ Application-product annotation (M-ADR 0191 §4.3 overlay): one row per declared departure from the archetype's default data-plane composition. Built per-SDD from the manifest's `data_plane.deviations` block so the overlay WARN — which runs at AGGREGATION tier, where the reference- architecture bundle (and its `expected_bindings`) resolves — can suppress a mismatch it is told is sanctioned variance. The `expectation` value is the **bare pattern token** (`retrieve` | `own-store` | `stream-ingest` | `project` | `generate` | `publish`) that the product knowingly diverges from; it must match the pattern the WARN keys on. The token set spans both directions — the WARN keys on the bare pattern, so an output-side expectation is deviated exactly like an inbound one (M-ADR 0193 §4.7 rule 2). Added in schema 2.38.0; output-side tokens documented in 2.40.0.
2683
2658
  foreign_keys:
2684
2659
  - column: product_id
2685
2660
  references: products.id
2686
2661
  nullable: false
2687
2662
  application_conformance_coverage:
2688
2663
  primary_key: id
2689
- description: 'Application-product annotation (M-ADR 0191 §4.3 overlay, second element — WS4): one row per conformance tag the product asserts about its archetype''s conformance expectations. Built per-SDD from the manifest''s `conformance` block so the AGGREGATION-tier conformance GATE can read it. `status=covered` means the product''s own conformance suite exercises the tag; `status=deviated` means the product declares (with a rationale) that it deliberately does not. At aggregation, an archetype-expected conformance tag that is neither covered nor deviated raises a deviation-visible WARN. The method gates the DECLARATION — it does not run the adopter''s conformance suite. Added in schema 2.39.0.
2690
-
2691
- '
2692
2664
  columns:
2693
2665
  - name: id
2694
2666
  type: string
2695
2667
  nullable: false
2696
- description: '{product_id}__{tag}. A duplicate emits a divergence finding and is dropped.'
2668
+ description: "{product_id}__{tag}. A duplicate emits a divergence finding and is dropped."
2697
2669
  - name: product_id
2698
2670
  type: string
2699
2671
  nullable: false
@@ -2718,18 +2690,19 @@ catalogues:
2718
2690
  type: string
2719
2691
  nullable: true
2720
2692
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2693
+ description: |
2694
+ Application-product annotation (M-ADR 0191 §4.3 overlay, second element — WS4): one row per conformance tag the product asserts about its archetype's conformance expectations. Built per-SDD from the manifest's `conformance` block so the AGGREGATION-tier conformance GATE can read it. `status=covered` means the product's own conformance suite exercises the tag; `status=deviated` means the product declares (with a rationale) that it deliberately does not. At aggregation, an archetype-expected conformance tag that is neither covered nor deviated raises a deviation-visible WARN. The method gates the DECLARATION — it does not run the adopter's conformance suite. Added in schema 2.39.0.
2721
2695
  foreign_keys:
2722
2696
  - column: product_id
2723
2697
  references: products.id
2724
2698
  nullable: false
2725
2699
  screens:
2726
2700
  primary_key: id
2727
- description: 'UI screen specified in the OpenUI Lang grammar (per M-ADR 0166). One row per screen / coherent screen group. Application-product profile (other profiles emit headers-only). Source: authored `screens/*.md` (frontmatter + ```openui-lang block); the reverse toolkit produces these from a router + component-tree projection.'
2728
2701
  columns:
2729
2702
  - name: id
2730
2703
  type: string
2731
2704
  nullable: false
2732
- description: 'Slugged PK: {product_id}-{screen-slug}.'
2705
+ description: "Slugged PK: {product_id}-{screen-slug}."
2733
2706
  - name: name
2734
2707
  type: string
2735
2708
  nullable: false
@@ -2765,7 +2738,7 @@ catalogues:
2765
2738
  - name: evidence_class
2766
2739
  type: string
2767
2740
  nullable: true
2768
- description: 'Evidence class of the screen''s claims, from frontmatter `evidence_class:` (alias `evidence-class:`). Free-form; conventional values code-reverse | vendor-doc | operational (M-ADR 0175). Empty when undeclared. Completes the evidence-class dimension for the packaged-SaaS case: a packaged-SaaS SDD catalogues the vendor''s STANDARD screens (documentation-reversed from vendor publications, `vendor-doc`) alongside the organisation''s CUSTOMISED screens (code-reversed, `code-reverse`) per M-ADR 0175 §3.1 — without this column the two are indistinguishable, and doc-derived UI claims masquerade as code-verified. Orthogonal to `source` (`screen-spec` | `screen-extraction`), which records the authoring DIRECTION, not the evidence''s strength: a `screen-extraction` screen can be either class, since a vendor''s documented UI is extracted-but-not-code-verified. Added in schema 2.42.0.'
2741
+ description: "Evidence class of the screen's claims, from frontmatter `evidence_class:` (alias `evidence-class:`). Free-form; conventional values code-reverse | vendor-doc | operational (M-ADR 0175). Empty when undeclared. Completes the evidence-class dimension for the packaged-SaaS case: a packaged-SaaS SDD catalogues the vendor's STANDARD screens (documentation-reversed from vendor publications, `vendor-doc`) alongside the organisation's CUSTOMISED screens (code-reversed, `code-reverse`) per M-ADR 0175 §3.1 — without this column the two are indistinguishable, and doc-derived UI claims masquerade as code-verified. Orthogonal to `source` (`screen-spec` | `screen-extraction`), which records the authoring DIRECTION, not the evidence's strength: a `screen-extraction` screen can be either class, since a vendor's documented UI is extracted-but-not-code-verified. Added in schema 2.42.0."
2769
2742
  - name: source_sdd_id
2770
2743
  type: string
2771
2744
  nullable: true
@@ -2774,18 +2747,18 @@ catalogues:
2774
2747
  type: string
2775
2748
  nullable: true
2776
2749
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2750
+ description: "UI screen specified in the OpenUI Lang grammar (per M-ADR 0166). One row per screen / coherent screen group. Application-product profile (other profiles emit headers-only). Source: authored `screens/*.md` (frontmatter + ```openui-lang block); the reverse toolkit produces these from a router + component-tree projection."
2777
2751
  foreign_keys:
2778
2752
  - column: product_id
2779
2753
  references: products.id
2780
2754
  nullable: false
2781
2755
  ui_components:
2782
2756
  primary_key: id
2783
- description: 'An entry in the adopter-owned component registry that screens compose against (per M-ADR 0166) — the UI-structure contract. A screen composes registry components but never defines one. Application-product profile. Source: components referenced across the SDD''s screen-spec ```openui-lang blocks (registry projection); the reverse toolkit discovers the authoritative registry from the design-system import surface.'
2784
2757
  columns:
2785
2758
  - name: id
2786
2759
  type: string
2787
2760
  nullable: false
2788
- description: 'Slugged PK: {product_id}-{component-slug}.'
2761
+ description: "Slugged PK: {product_id}-{component-slug}."
2789
2762
  - name: name
2790
2763
  type: string
2791
2764
  nullable: false
@@ -2797,7 +2770,7 @@ catalogues:
2797
2770
  - name: kind
2798
2771
  type: string
2799
2772
  nullable: true
2800
- description: 'Optional classification: layout | display | input | chart | element | composite | remote | remote-iframe | remote-webcomponent. A `remote*` kind marks a micro-frontend federation seam (M-ADR 0166 §4.7).'
2773
+ description: "Optional classification: layout | display | input | chart | element | composite | remote | remote-iframe | remote-webcomponent. A `remote*` kind marks a micro-frontend federation seam (M-ADR 0166 §4.7)."
2801
2774
  - name: source
2802
2775
  type: string
2803
2776
  nullable: false
@@ -2810,18 +2783,18 @@ catalogues:
2810
2783
  type: string
2811
2784
  nullable: true
2812
2785
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2786
+ description: "An entry in the adopter-owned component registry that screens compose against (per M-ADR 0166) — the UI-structure contract. A screen composes registry components but never defines one. Application-product profile. Source: components referenced across the SDD's screen-spec ```openui-lang blocks (registry projection); the reverse toolkit discovers the authoritative registry from the design-system import surface."
2813
2787
  foreign_keys:
2814
2788
  - column: product_id
2815
2789
  references: products.id
2816
2790
  nullable: false
2817
2791
  screen_component:
2818
2792
  primary_key: id
2819
- description: 'Edge: screen composes a UI component. Parsed from the screen-spec ```openui-lang block''s component references (per M-ADR 0166).'
2820
2793
  columns:
2821
2794
  - name: id
2822
2795
  type: string
2823
2796
  nullable: false
2824
- description: 'Composite PK: {screen_id}__{component_id}.'
2797
+ description: "Composite PK: {screen_id}__{component_id}."
2825
2798
  - name: screen_id
2826
2799
  type: string
2827
2800
  nullable: false
@@ -2836,6 +2809,7 @@ catalogues:
2836
2809
  type: string
2837
2810
  nullable: true
2838
2811
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2812
+ description: "Edge: screen composes a UI component. Parsed from the screen-spec ```openui-lang block's component references (per M-ADR 0166)."
2839
2813
  foreign_keys:
2840
2814
  - column: screen_id
2841
2815
  references: screens.id
@@ -2845,12 +2819,11 @@ catalogues:
2845
2819
  nullable: false
2846
2820
  screen_feature:
2847
2821
  primary_key: id
2848
- description: 'Edge: screen realises a feature (traceability). Forward: `realises:` frontmatter on the screen-spec. Reverse: route → feature mapping. Per M-ADR 0166.'
2849
2822
  columns:
2850
2823
  - name: id
2851
2824
  type: string
2852
2825
  nullable: false
2853
- description: 'Composite PK: {screen_id}__{feature_id}. For app/integration builds the feature_id may be a bare realises slug until the aggregator resolves it to the platform feature id (then the PK is regenerated).'
2826
+ description: "Composite PK: {screen_id}__{feature_id}. For app/integration builds the feature_id may be a bare realises slug until the aggregator resolves it to the platform feature id (then the PK is regenerated)."
2854
2827
  - name: screen_id
2855
2828
  type: string
2856
2829
  nullable: false
@@ -2865,6 +2838,7 @@ catalogues:
2865
2838
  type: string
2866
2839
  nullable: true
2867
2840
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2841
+ description: "Edge: screen realises a feature (traceability). Forward: `realises:` frontmatter on the screen-spec. Reverse: route → feature mapping. Per M-ADR 0166."
2868
2842
  foreign_keys:
2869
2843
  - column: screen_id
2870
2844
  references: screens.id
@@ -2877,12 +2851,11 @@ catalogues:
2877
2851
  - integration-product
2878
2852
  persona_screen:
2879
2853
  primary_key: id
2880
- description: 'Edge: persona can access a screen. Forward: `persona_access:` frontmatter. Reverse: route persona-access guards, permission/feature-flag config, or a host shell''s per-persona menu (where the backend pre-filters visible screens). Per M-ADR 0166.'
2881
2854
  columns:
2882
2855
  - name: id
2883
2856
  type: string
2884
2857
  nullable: false
2885
- description: 'Composite PK: {persona_id}__{screen_id}.'
2858
+ description: "Composite PK: {persona_id}__{screen_id}."
2886
2859
  - name: persona_id
2887
2860
  type: string
2888
2861
  nullable: false
@@ -2897,6 +2870,7 @@ catalogues:
2897
2870
  type: string
2898
2871
  nullable: true
2899
2872
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2873
+ description: "Edge: persona can access a screen. Forward: `persona_access:` frontmatter. Reverse: route persona-access guards, permission/feature-flag config, or a host shell's per-persona menu (where the backend pre-filters visible screens). Per M-ADR 0166."
2900
2874
  foreign_keys:
2901
2875
  - column: persona_id
2902
2876
  references: personas.id
@@ -2906,12 +2880,11 @@ catalogues:
2906
2880
  nullable: false
2907
2881
  screen_action:
2908
2882
  primary_key: id
2909
- description: 'Edge: screen emits an action, optionally resolved to a catalogued event. The behavioural MFE seam — inter-bundle communication as a catalogued contract, not an ad-hoc string. Forward: `action=` declarations in the ```openui-lang block. Reverse: emitted custom-event / event-bus wiring. event_id is external-capable (the event may live in the platform SDD). Per M-ADR 0166 + M-ADR 0156.'
2910
2883
  columns:
2911
2884
  - name: id
2912
2885
  type: string
2913
2886
  nullable: false
2914
- description: 'Composite PK: {screen_id}__{action-slug}.'
2887
+ description: "Composite PK: {screen_id}__{action-slug}."
2915
2888
  - name: screen_id
2916
2889
  type: string
2917
2890
  nullable: false
@@ -2931,6 +2904,7 @@ catalogues:
2931
2904
  type: string
2932
2905
  nullable: true
2933
2906
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2907
+ description: "Edge: screen emits an action, optionally resolved to a catalogued event. The behavioural MFE seam — inter-bundle communication as a catalogued contract, not an ad-hoc string. Forward: `action=` declarations in the ```openui-lang block. Reverse: emitted custom-event / event-bus wiring. event_id is external-capable (the event may live in the platform SDD). Per M-ADR 0166 + M-ADR 0156."
2934
2908
  foreign_keys:
2935
2909
  - column: screen_id
2936
2910
  references: screens.id
@@ -2941,7 +2915,6 @@ catalogues:
2941
2915
  external: true
2942
2916
  conformance_finding:
2943
2917
  primary_key: id
2944
- description: 'Conformance-reverse drift summary, one row per check (method M-ADR 0180). NOT produced by `catalogue build` (it reads the spec repo) — produced by `sdd-cli conformance --emit-finding` (which has the code repo) and federated here by the aggregator. Each row is a run-dated snapshot of declared-vs-observed drift for an implementation member (M-ADR 0181 role/lifecycle), so estate-wide conformance is queryable (aggregate union) and trendable (snapshot diff across runs/commits). Verdicts are PROVISIONAL — disposition (code-defect | spec-stale | divergence) is triage, recorded elsewhere. No enforced FK on implementation_repo: the code repo is frequently cross-repo and not in this SDD''s repositories.csv. Added in schema 2.25.0.'
2945
2918
  columns:
2946
2919
  - name: id
2947
2920
  type: string
@@ -2984,11 +2957,11 @@ catalogues:
2984
2957
  - name: declared_not_observed
2985
2958
  type: number
2986
2959
  nullable: false
2987
- description: 'Count declared but not observed (candidate: spec-stale / unimplemented / dangling).'
2960
+ description: "Count declared but not observed (candidate: spec-stale / unimplemented / dangling)."
2988
2961
  - name: observed_not_declared
2989
2962
  type: number
2990
2963
  nullable: false
2991
- description: 'Count observed but not declared (candidate: binding-stale / code-defect).'
2964
+ description: "Count observed but not declared (candidate: binding-stale / code-defect)."
2992
2965
  - name: needs_triage
2993
2966
  type: boolean
2994
2967
  nullable: false
@@ -3005,24 +2978,14 @@ catalogues:
3005
2978
  type: string
3006
2979
  nullable: true
3007
2980
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
2981
+ description: "Conformance-reverse drift summary, one row per check (method M-ADR 0180). NOT produced by `catalogue build` (it reads the spec repo) — produced by `sdd-cli conformance --emit-finding` (which has the code repo) and federated here by the aggregator. Each row is a run-dated snapshot of declared-vs-observed drift for an implementation member (M-ADR 0181 role/lifecycle), so estate-wide conformance is queryable (aggregate union) and trendable (snapshot diff across runs/commits). Verdicts are PROVISIONAL — disposition (code-defect | spec-stale | divergence) is triage, recorded elsewhere. No enforced FK on implementation_repo: the code repo is frequently cross-repo and not in this SDD's repositories.csv. Added in schema 2.25.0."
3008
2982
  quality_scores:
3009
2983
  primary_key: id
3010
- description: 'Rubric assessment of a target artefact, one row per (target, rubric), per M-ADR 0205 §4.5. Source: `orchestration/gate-registry/<rubric>-scores.yaml` — the authored surface stays YAML because a score is a judgment, authored where it asserts intent; these rows are DERIVED and never edited.
3011
-
3012
- Models the EFFECTIVE score only — `current`, as chosen by the registry''s `selection_policy`. The authored `reviews[]` history is deliberately not catalogued: variable-length history in a fixed-grain catalogue would give two answers to "what is the score". `review_run_id` and `selection_method` make each row name which review it is.
3013
-
3014
- THE BUILDER MUST READ TWO AUTHORED DIALECTS. All fifteen method-side templates specify a nested shape (`selection_policy` / `current` / `reviews`), but the live forward-estate data is overwhelmingly FLAT — `gate`/`weighted_score`/`scored_at`/`scored_by`/`scores`/`flags` directly on the entry. Measured 2026-08-06: reading only the template shape would catalogue 6 entries out of 204. The templates were modernised; the data was not migrated, and both are legitimate.
3015
-
3016
- `rubric_id` comes from the file''s `registry_type` when declared, else the filename stem minus `-scores` — NEVER the container key, which is unreliable (4 of 10 forward registries drift from the method template) and non-unique (`domains` names both domain-architecture and intent-quality; `capabilities` names both feature-grounding and traceability-manifest).
3017
-
3018
- Scope: the weighted house form only. The banded reverse family is additive later via `scoring_form` (see that enum).
3019
-
3020
- '
3021
2984
  columns:
3022
2985
  - name: id
3023
2986
  type: string
3024
2987
  nullable: false
3025
- description: 'PK: {rubric_id}__{target_kind}__{target_ref}. Composite in one slug because the natural key is a triple and the rest of this schema keys on a single `id`.'
2988
+ description: "PK: {rubric_id}__{target_kind}__{target_ref}. Composite in one slug because the natural key is a triple and the rest of this schema keys on a single `id`."
3026
2989
  - name: rubric_id
3027
2990
  type: string
3028
2991
  nullable: false
@@ -3034,7 +2997,7 @@ catalogues:
3034
2997
  - name: target_kind
3035
2998
  type: string
3036
2999
  nullable: false
3037
- description: 'What kind of thing was scored: adr | contract | c4_diagram | capability | domain | feature | product | repository | persona | screen | glossary | integration | user_story | work_order | strategic_doc. Polymorphic because scored units span catalogue entities and non-catalogued artefacts (M-ADR 0205 §4.5).'
3000
+ description: "What kind of thing was scored: adr | contract | c4_diagram | capability | domain | feature | product | repository | persona | screen | glossary | integration | user_story | work_order | strategic_doc. Polymorphic because scored units span catalogue entities and non-catalogued artefacts (M-ADR 0205 §4.5)."
3038
3001
  - name: target_ref
3039
3002
  type: string
3040
3003
  nullable: false
@@ -3058,19 +3021,19 @@ catalogues:
3058
3021
  - name: band
3059
3022
  type: string
3060
3023
  nullable: true
3061
- description: 'Named band for a `banded` row; empty for a weighted one. DELIBERATELY UNBOUND, and for the same reason `dimension_key` is not normalised: the vocabulary belongs to the rubric, not to the method. Measured across the reverse estate at 3.3.0 — `reverseability` uses easy | moderate | hard | very-hard (a DIFFICULTY scale, where a higher band is worse), while `repo_doc_quality`, `product_synthesis_quality`, `reverse_platform_evidence_quality` and `artifact_quality` use strong | working (a QUALITY scale). One closed enum over both would assert that `hard` and `working` are comparable, which they are not. A consumer comparing bands must therefore group by rubric_id first.'
3024
+ description: "Named band for a `banded` row; empty for a weighted one. DELIBERATELY UNBOUND, and for the same reason `dimension_key` is not normalised: the vocabulary belongs to the rubric, not to the method. Measured across the reverse estate at 3.3.0 — `reverseability` uses easy | moderate | hard | very-hard (a DIFFICULTY scale, where a higher band is worse), while `repo_doc_quality`, `product_synthesis_quality`, `reverse_platform_evidence_quality` and `artifact_quality` use strong | working (a QUALITY scale). One closed enum over both would assert that `hard` and `working` are comparable, which they are not. A consumer comparing bands must therefore group by rubric_id first."
3062
3025
  - name: band_total
3063
3026
  type: int
3064
3027
  nullable: true
3065
- description: 'Integer total a `banded` rubric summed its dimensions to, before mapping to `band`; empty for a weighted row. Kept SEPARATE from weighted_score rather than sharing it: the scales are incompatible (a banded total ranges 0-13 against a weighted 1-5), and a single column holding both would make any average over it silently wrong. Separation makes an aggregate over weighted_score correct by construction rather than by the caller remembering to filter on scoring_form.'
3028
+ description: "Integer total a `banded` rubric summed its dimensions to, before mapping to `band`; empty for a weighted row. Kept SEPARATE from weighted_score rather than sharing it: the scales are incompatible (a banded total ranges 0-13 against a weighted 1-5), and a single column holding both would make any average over it silently wrong. Separation makes an aggregate over weighted_score correct by construction rather than by the caller remembering to filter on scoring_form."
3066
3029
  - name: scored_at
3067
3030
  type: date
3068
3031
  nullable: true
3069
- description: 'Date of the effective assessment, from `scored_at` (the forward house form''s field name — NOT `assessed_at`, which is the reverse family''s file-level field). Date-typed: per the M-ADR 0205 §4.1 engine''s TRY_CAST semantics, a prose value here is reported as a type nonconformance rather than aborting the load or being smoothed away — the `adrs.decision_date` case, which reverse practice already exercises.'
3032
+ description: "Date of the effective assessment, from `scored_at` (the forward house form's field name — NOT `assessed_at`, which is the reverse family's file-level field). Date-typed: per the M-ADR 0205 §4.1 engine's TRY_CAST semantics, a prose value here is reported as a type nonconformance rather than aborting the load or being smoothed away — the `adrs.decision_date` case, which reverse practice already exercises."
3070
3033
  - name: corpus_ref
3071
3034
  type: string
3072
3035
  nullable: true
3073
- description: 'The commit the assessment read — the precise staleness anchor. NEW AUTHORING introduced by this change-set: no score written before it carries one, so this column is empty across both estates at introduction and fills forward as registries are rewritten. The reverse family already has the idea under a different name (`snapshot.source_revision`).'
3036
+ description: "The commit the assessment read — the precise staleness anchor. NEW AUTHORING introduced by this change-set: no score written before it carries one, so this column is empty across both estates at introduction and fills forward as registries are rewritten. The reverse family already has the idea under a different name (`snapshot.source_revision`)."
3074
3037
  - name: staleness_basis
3075
3038
  type: string
3076
3039
  nullable: false
@@ -3082,7 +3045,7 @@ catalogues:
3082
3045
  - name: selection_method
3083
3046
  type: string
3084
3047
  nullable: true
3085
- description: 'How the effective review was chosen — see the score_selection_method enum. Empty in the flat dialect, which carries no selection_policy: absence means ''the only review'', not ''policy unknown''.'
3048
+ description: "How the effective review was chosen — see the score_selection_method enum. Empty in the flat dialect, which carries no selection_policy: absence means 'the only review', not 'policy unknown'."
3086
3049
  - name: scorer_provider
3087
3050
  type: string
3088
3051
  nullable: true
@@ -3106,11 +3069,11 @@ catalogues:
3106
3069
  - name: flag_count
3107
3070
  type: int
3108
3071
  nullable: false
3109
- description: 'Number of heuristic flags raised. Normalises two authored dialects: `flags: {name: bool}` (count the true ones) and `flags_raised: [names]` (count the list). A per-flag child catalogue is deliberately NOT built — it arrives when a named query needs to filter by flag name, not by accretion.'
3072
+ description: "Number of heuristic flags raised. Normalises two authored dialects: `flags: {name: bool}` (count the true ones) and `flags_raised: [names]` (count the list). A per-flag child catalogue is deliberately NOT built — it arrives when a named query needs to filter by flag name, not by accretion."
3110
3073
  - name: hard_gate_triggered
3111
3074
  type: boolean
3112
3075
  nullable: false
3113
- description: 'Whether any hard gate fired. Normalises `hard_gates: {triggered, reasons}` and `hard_gates_triggered: [reasons]`.'
3076
+ description: "Whether any hard gate fired. Normalises `hard_gates: {triggered, reasons}` and `hard_gates_triggered: [reasons]`."
3114
3077
  - name: required_actions_count
3115
3078
  type: int
3116
3079
  nullable: false
@@ -3127,22 +3090,23 @@ catalogues:
3127
3090
  type: string
3128
3091
  nullable: true
3129
3092
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
3093
+ description: |
3094
+ Rubric assessment of a target artefact, one row per (target, rubric), per M-ADR 0205 §4.5. Source: `orchestration/gate-registry/<rubric>-scores.yaml` — the authored surface stays YAML because a score is a judgment, authored where it asserts intent; these rows are DERIVED and never edited.
3095
+ Models the EFFECTIVE score only — `current`, as chosen by the registry's `selection_policy`. The authored `reviews[]` history is deliberately not catalogued: variable-length history in a fixed-grain catalogue would give two answers to "what is the score". `review_run_id` and `selection_method` make each row name which review it is.
3096
+ THE BUILDER MUST READ TWO AUTHORED DIALECTS. All fifteen method-side templates specify a nested shape (`selection_policy` / `current` / `reviews`), but the live forward-estate data is overwhelmingly FLAT — `gate`/`weighted_score`/`scored_at`/`scored_by`/`scores`/`flags` directly on the entry. Measured 2026-08-06: reading only the template shape would catalogue 6 entries out of 204. The templates were modernised; the data was not migrated, and both are legitimate.
3097
+ `rubric_id` comes from the file's `registry_type` when declared, else the filename stem minus `-scores` — NEVER the container key, which is unreliable (4 of 10 forward registries drift from the method template) and non-unique (`domains` names both domain-architecture and intent-quality; `capabilities` names both feature-grounding and traceability-manifest).
3098
+ Scope: the weighted house form only. The banded reverse family is additive later via `scoring_form` (see that enum).
3130
3099
  foreign_keys:
3131
3100
  - column: sdd_id
3132
3101
  references: products.id
3133
3102
  nullable: true
3134
3103
  quality_score_dimensions:
3135
3104
  primary_key: id
3136
- description: 'One row per (target, rubric, dimension) — the per-dimension detail behind a `quality_scores` row, per M-ADR 0205 §4.5.
3137
-
3138
- A child catalogue rather than columns, and this is forced rather than stylistic: the fifteen rubrics carry FIFTEEN DISJOINT dimension vocabularies (`A1`-`A8`, `C1`-`C8`, `G1`-`G7`, `T1`-`T7`, `D1`-`D6`, `S1`-`S6`, `I1`-`I6`, plus five fully-named sets such as `definition_precision` and `intent_fidelity`) — 45 distinct keys measured in one estate alone. No fixed column set can hold them; serialised JSON in a cell would be unjoinable and break the relational metamodel; generic `d1..d8` columns would be lossy and re-create the positional-index failure class. A child table is what this metamodel already does for every one-to-many, and it joins natively on the M-ADR 0205 §4.1 engine.
3139
-
3140
- '
3141
3105
  columns:
3142
3106
  - name: id
3143
3107
  type: string
3144
3108
  nullable: false
3145
- description: 'PK: {quality_score_id}__{dimension_key}.'
3109
+ description: "PK: {quality_score_id}__{dimension_key}."
3146
3110
  - name: quality_score_id
3147
3111
  type: string
3148
3112
  nullable: false
@@ -3162,7 +3126,7 @@ catalogues:
3162
3126
  - name: dimension_key
3163
3127
  type: string
3164
3128
  nullable: false
3165
- description: 'The rubric''s own dimension identifier, verbatim — `A1` where the rubric uses codes, `definition_precision` where it uses names. NOT normalised into a method-wide vocabulary: the key is how the rubric and its registry refer to the dimension, and rewriting it here would make the row untraceable to the rubric that produced it.'
3129
+ description: "The rubric's own dimension identifier, verbatim — `A1` where the rubric uses codes, `definition_precision` where it uses names. NOT normalised into a method-wide vocabulary: the key is how the rubric and its registry refer to the dimension, and rewriting it here would make the row untraceable to the rubric that produced it."
3166
3130
  - name: dimension_score
3167
3131
  type: number
3168
3132
  nullable: true
@@ -3170,7 +3134,7 @@ catalogues:
3170
3134
  - name: dimension_weight
3171
3135
  type: number
3172
3136
  nullable: true
3173
- description: 'Weight the rubric assigns the dimension, where discoverable. Usually EMPTY: weights live in the rubric document and the registry header comment, not per entry — so this column is honest about the fact that a weighted_score cannot currently be recomputed from these rows alone.'
3137
+ description: "Weight the rubric assigns the dimension, where discoverable. Usually EMPTY: weights live in the rubric document and the registry header comment, not per entry — so this column is honest about the fact that a weighted_score cannot currently be recomputed from these rows alone."
3174
3138
  - name: source_sdd_id
3175
3139
  type: string
3176
3140
  nullable: true
@@ -3179,24 +3143,20 @@ catalogues:
3179
3143
  type: string
3180
3144
  nullable: true
3181
3145
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
3146
+ description: |
3147
+ One row per (target, rubric, dimension) — the per-dimension detail behind a `quality_scores` row, per M-ADR 0205 §4.5.
3148
+ A child catalogue rather than columns, and this is forced rather than stylistic: the fifteen rubrics carry FIFTEEN DISJOINT dimension vocabularies (`A1`-`A8`, `C1`-`C8`, `G1`-`G7`, `T1`-`T7`, `D1`-`D6`, `S1`-`S6`, `I1`-`I6`, plus five fully-named sets such as `definition_precision` and `intent_fidelity`) — 45 distinct keys measured in one estate alone. No fixed column set can hold them; serialised JSON in a cell would be unjoinable and break the relational metamodel; generic `d1..d8` columns would be lossy and re-create the positional-index failure class. A child table is what this metamodel already does for every one-to-many, and it joins natively on the M-ADR 0205 §4.1 engine.
3182
3149
  foreign_keys:
3183
3150
  - column: quality_score_id
3184
3151
  references: quality_scores.id
3185
3152
  nullable: false
3186
3153
  scaffolds:
3187
3154
  primary_key: id
3188
- description: 'Forward scaffold declaration, one row per unit of work, per M-ADR 0207 §4.1. Source: `orchestration/scaffolds/*.yaml` — the authored surface stays YAML because a scaffold is a declaration of intent, authored where the work is scoped; these rows are DERIVED and never edited (M-ADR 0205 §4.0 governs unchanged).
3189
-
3190
- The scaffold states the catalogue shape a unit of work will comprise — its items are `scaffold_items` rows — and the declared-vs-derived delta against the built catalogues is the unit''s definition of done: delta zero (structural) AND every realised artefact score-current (content, via `quality_scores`), per M-ADR 0207 §4.5. The unit is the change-set''s declared delta; estate-level scaffold totality is an explicit non-goal (M-ADR 0207 §4.4), so an estate region no scaffold covers produces no finding.
3191
-
3192
- `corpus_ref` is REQUIRED — a scaffold without an anchor cannot carry a staleness verdict, and M-ADR 0207 §4.6 makes the anchor part of the declaration, not an optional refinement. Staleness itself is computed at coverage time (the scores idiom), never stored here.
3193
-
3194
- '
3195
3155
  columns:
3196
3156
  - name: id
3197
3157
  type: string
3198
3158
  nullable: false
3199
- description: 'PK: the manifest''s declared unit id (kebab-case slug). Unique per SDD; the aggregator namespaces cross-SDD ids exactly as for every other catalogue.'
3159
+ description: "PK: the manifest's declared unit id (kebab-case slug). Unique per SDD; the aggregator namespaces cross-SDD ids exactly as for every other catalogue."
3200
3160
  - name: name
3201
3161
  type: string
3202
3162
  nullable: false
@@ -3212,7 +3172,7 @@ catalogues:
3212
3172
  - name: corpus_ref
3213
3173
  type: string
3214
3174
  nullable: false
3215
- description: 'The commit the scaffold was declared against — the staleness anchor, mirroring quality_scores.corpus_ref (M-ADR 0207 §4.6: one staleness idiom, not two). Required: a manifest without one fails validation rather than emitting an unanchorable row.'
3175
+ description: "The commit the scaffold was declared against — the staleness anchor, mirroring quality_scores.corpus_ref (M-ADR 0207 §4.6: one staleness idiom, not two). Required: a manifest without one fails validation rather than emitting an unanchorable row."
3216
3176
  - name: manifest_schema
3217
3177
  type: string
3218
3178
  nullable: false
@@ -3229,6 +3189,10 @@ catalogues:
3229
3189
  type: string
3230
3190
  nullable: true
3231
3191
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
3192
+ description: |
3193
+ Forward scaffold declaration, one row per unit of work, per M-ADR 0207 §4.1. Source: `orchestration/scaffolds/*.yaml` — the authored surface stays YAML because a scaffold is a declaration of intent, authored where the work is scoped; these rows are DERIVED and never edited (M-ADR 0205 §4.0 governs unchanged).
3194
+ The scaffold states the catalogue shape a unit of work will comprise — its items are `scaffold_items` rows — and the declared-vs-derived delta against the built catalogues is the unit's definition of done: delta zero (structural) AND every realised artefact score-current (content, via `quality_scores`), per M-ADR 0207 §4.5. The unit is the change-set's declared delta; estate-level scaffold totality is an explicit non-goal (M-ADR 0207 §4.4), so an estate region no scaffold covers produces no finding.
3195
+ `corpus_ref` is REQUIRED — a scaffold without an anchor cannot carry a staleness verdict, and M-ADR 0207 §4.6 makes the anchor part of the declaration, not an optional refinement. Staleness itself is computed at coverage time (the scores idiom), never stored here.
3232
3196
  foreign_keys:
3233
3197
  - column: sdd_id
3234
3198
  references: products.id
@@ -3237,18 +3201,11 @@ catalogues:
3237
3201
  status: enums.scaffold_status
3238
3202
  scaffold_items:
3239
3203
  primary_key: id
3240
- description: 'One declared item of a scaffold — an entity, edge, or contract the unit of work promises — per M-ADR 0207 §4.1. Derived from the manifest''s item list; `state` is the builder''s resolution verdict against the same build''s catalogue rows.
3241
-
3242
- THE POLYMORPHIC TARGET DECLARES NO FOREIGN KEY, by design (the quality_scores.target_ref precedent, taken further): a scaffold exists to reference targets BEFORE they exist. FK truth here is CONDITIONAL ON STATE — a `declared` item''s (target_kind, target_ref) MUST NOT resolve in the built catalogues, a `realised` item''s MUST — and the builder''s resolution pass is what enforces it: it computes `state` FROM resolution, so a disagreement between state and resolution cannot be emitted by a conforming builder. The M-ADR 0207 §4.8 delta instrument re-derives the same verdict on the engine as its self-check.
3243
-
3244
- `target_kind` is the CATALOGUE NAME the target should appear in (services, capabilities, repo_contract, contracts, …) — bound to the schema''s own catalogue list by the builder: an unknown target_kind is a loud convention finding, never a silently-dropped item (M-ADR 0207 §4.1). For `edge` items the endpoints are declared in edge_source_ref/edge_target_ref, mapped to the edge catalogue''s FK columns in schema declaration order; target_ref then carries the builder-computed endpoint slug so the PK stays single-column.
3245
-
3246
- '
3247
3204
  columns:
3248
3205
  - name: id
3249
3206
  type: string
3250
3207
  nullable: false
3251
- description: 'PK: {scaffold_id}__{item_kind}__{target_kind}__{target_ref}. Composite in one slug because the natural key is a quadruple and the rest of this schema keys on a single `id`.'
3208
+ description: "PK: {scaffold_id}__{item_kind}__{target_kind}__{target_ref}. Composite in one slug because the natural key is a quadruple and the rest of this schema keys on a single `id`."
3252
3209
  - name: scaffold_id
3253
3210
  type: string
3254
3211
  nullable: false
@@ -3264,15 +3221,15 @@ catalogues:
3264
3221
  - name: target_ref
3265
3222
  type: string
3266
3223
  nullable: false
3267
- description: 'Identifier of the declared target in the vocabulary of its catalogue: the declared id for entity items, the repo-relative spec path for contract items (matching contracts.spec_path), the builder-computed {source}__{target} endpoint slug for edge items.'
3224
+ description: "Identifier of the declared target in the vocabulary of its catalogue: the declared id for entity items, the repo-relative spec path for contract items (matching contracts.spec_path), the builder-computed {source}__{target} endpoint slug for edge items."
3268
3225
  - name: edge_source_ref
3269
3226
  type: string
3270
3227
  nullable: true
3271
- description: 'For edge items: the declared source endpoint, in the vocabulary of the edge catalogue''s first FK column (schema declaration order). Empty for entity and contract items.'
3228
+ description: "For edge items: the declared source endpoint, in the vocabulary of the edge catalogue's first FK column (schema declaration order). Empty for entity and contract items."
3272
3229
  - name: edge_target_ref
3273
3230
  type: string
3274
3231
  nullable: true
3275
- description: 'For edge items: the declared target endpoint, second FK column. Empty for entity and contract items.'
3232
+ description: "For edge items: the declared target endpoint, second FK column. Empty for entity and contract items."
3276
3233
  - name: state
3277
3234
  type: string
3278
3235
  nullable: false
@@ -3285,6 +3242,10 @@ catalogues:
3285
3242
  type: string
3286
3243
  nullable: true
3287
3244
  description: The platform this row belongs to — sdd_id of its platform-root. Stamped by the aggregator per M-ADR 0208 §4.4 (preserve-if-set, fill rule by pull path); left empty by per-SDD builders. Added in 3.7.0.
3245
+ description: |
3246
+ One declared item of a scaffold — an entity, edge, or contract the unit of work promises — per M-ADR 0207 §4.1. Derived from the manifest's item list; `state` is the builder's resolution verdict against the same build's catalogue rows.
3247
+ THE POLYMORPHIC TARGET DECLARES NO FOREIGN KEY, by design (the quality_scores.target_ref precedent, taken further): a scaffold exists to reference targets BEFORE they exist. FK truth here is CONDITIONAL ON STATE — a `declared` item's (target_kind, target_ref) MUST NOT resolve in the built catalogues, a `realised` item's MUST — and the builder's resolution pass is what enforces it: it computes `state` FROM resolution, so a disagreement between state and resolution cannot be emitted by a conforming builder. The M-ADR 0207 §4.8 delta instrument re-derives the same verdict on the engine as its self-check.
3248
+ `target_kind` is the CATALOGUE NAME the target should appear in (services, capabilities, repo_contract, contracts, …) — bound to the schema's own catalogue list by the builder: an unknown target_kind is a loud convention finding, never a silently-dropped item (M-ADR 0207 §4.1). For `edge` items the endpoints are declared in edge_source_ref/edge_target_ref, mapped to the edge catalogue's FK columns in schema declaration order; target_ref then carries the builder-computed endpoint slug so the PK stays single-column.
3288
3249
  foreign_keys:
3289
3250
  - column: scaffold_id
3290
3251
  references: scaffolds.id