@ryuenn3123/agentic-senior-core 3.0.15 → 3.0.16

package/lib/cli/architect.mjs

@@ -7,109 +7,14 @@ import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url';
 import { BLUEPRINT_RECOMMENDATIONS } from './constants.mjs';
 import { ensureDirectory, pathExists, toTitleCase } from './utils.mjs';
 
-export const ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_TOKEN_BUDGET = 900;
-export const ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_TIMEOUT_MS = 1500;
-export const ARCHITECT_MIN_TOKEN_BUDGET = 200;
-export const ARCHITECT_MAX_TOKEN_BUDGET = 4000;
-export const ARCHITECT_MIN_TIMEOUT_MS = 200;
-export const ARCHITECT_MAX_TIMEOUT_MS = 10000;
-export const ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_RESEARCH_MODE = 'snapshot';
-
-const ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_RESEARCH_MODES = new Set(['snapshot', 'realtime']);
-const ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_REALTIME_SIGNAL_ENV_KEY = 'AGENTIC_ARCHITECT_REALTIME_SIGNAL_JSON';
-const ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_REALTIME_SIGNAL_PATH_ENV_KEY = 'AGENTIC_ARCHITECT_REALTIME_SIGNAL_PATH';
-const ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_PALETTE_ROLES = ['base', 'surface', 'accent', 'success', 'danger'];
-const ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_TYPOGRAPHY_SCALES = ['compact', 'balanced', 'expressive'];
-const ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_SPACING_PATTERNS = ['compact-grid', 'balanced-grid', 'airy-grid'];
-const ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_MOTION_CHARACTERISTICS = [
-  'subtle-enter',
-  'staggered-reveal',
-  'state-feedback',
-  'conversion-focus',
-  'calm-transition',
-];
-
 const ARCHITECT_MODULE_FILE_PATH = fileURLToPath(import.meta.url);
 const ARCHITECT_PACKAGE_ROOT = path.resolve(path.dirname(ARCHITECT_MODULE_FILE_PATH), '..', '..');
-const ARCHITECT_RESEARCH_SNAPSHOT_FILE_PATH = path.join(
-  ARCHITECT_PACKAGE_ROOT,
-  '.agent-context',
-  'state',
-  'stack-research-snapshot.json'
-);
-
-const FALLBACK_STACK_RESEARCH_SNAPSHOT = {
-  schemaVersion: '1.0.0',
-  snapshotId: 'ecosystem-signals-fallback',
-  generatedAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-  deterministic: true,
-  sourceName: 'Agentic-Senior-Core internal fallback snapshot',
-  sourceUrl: 'state://stack-research-snapshot/fallback',
-  trustedRealtimeSources: [
-    {
-      sourceId: 'awwwards-trend-feed',
-      sourceName: 'Awwwards Trend Feed',
-      sourceUrl: 'https://www.awwwards.com',
-    },
-  ],
-  stackSignals: [
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'typescript.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.91, talentAvailability: 0.9, deliveryVelocity: 0.89 },
-    },
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'python.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.92, talentAvailability: 0.88, deliveryVelocity: 0.9 },
-    },
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'java.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.89, talentAvailability: 0.83, deliveryVelocity: 0.8 },
-    },
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'php.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.79, talentAvailability: 0.75, deliveryVelocity: 0.84 },
-    },
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'go.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.84, talentAvailability: 0.78, deliveryVelocity: 0.82 },
-    },
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'csharp.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.86, talentAvailability: 0.8, deliveryVelocity: 0.79 },
-    },
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'rust.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.74, talentAvailability: 0.63, deliveryVelocity: 0.67 },
-    },
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'ruby.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.7, talentAvailability: 0.62, deliveryVelocity: 0.72 },
-    },
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'react-native.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.72, talentAvailability: 0.67, deliveryVelocity: 0.74 },
-    },
-    {
-      stackFileName: 'flutter.md',
-      measuredAt: '2026-04-18T00:00:00.000Z',
-      metrics: { ecosystemMaturity: 0.75, talentAvailability: 0.69, deliveryVelocity: 0.76 },
-    },
-  ],
-};
 
 const ARCHITECT_PREFERENCE_FILE_PATH = process.env.AGENTIC_ARCHITECT_PREF_FILE
   ? path.resolve(process.env.AGENTIC_ARCHITECT_PREF_FILE)
   : path.join(os.homedir(), '.agentic-senior-core', 'architect-preferences.json');
 
+// Keyword hints — low-confidence bias only, not authoritative research.
 const STACK_SIGNAL_WEIGHTS = {
   'typescript.md': [
     { term: 'typescript', weight: 0.9 },
@@ -205,14 +110,6 @@ const STACK_TRADEOFF_SUMMARIES = {
   'flutter.md': 'consistent UI across mobile platforms, but ecosystem fit should be checked per package.',
 };
 
-function clampNumericValue(value, minimumValue, maximumValue) {
-  return Math.min(Math.max(value, minimumValue), maximumValue);
-}
-
-function estimateTokenUsage(textValue) {
-  return Math.ceil(String(textValue || '').length / 4);
-}
-
 function resolveConfidenceLabel(confidenceScore) {
   if (confidenceScore >= 0.85) {
     return 'high';
@@ -234,481 +131,23 @@ function resolveRecommendedBlueprintFileName(stackFileName, blueprintFileNames)
   return blueprintFileNames[0] || null;
 }
 
-function normalizeArchitectResearchMode(rawMode) {
-  const normalizedMode = String(rawMode || ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_RESEARCH_MODE).trim().toLowerCase();
-  if (ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_RESEARCH_MODES.has(normalizedMode)) {
-    return normalizedMode;
-  }
-
-  return ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_RESEARCH_MODE;
-}
-
-function isValidIsoTimestamp(value) {
-  if (typeof value !== 'string' || value.trim().length === 0) {
-    return false;
-  }
-
-  return !Number.isNaN(Date.parse(value));
-}
-
-function toIsoTimestamp(value, fallbackValue = new Date().toISOString()) {
-  return isValidIsoTimestamp(value) ? new Date(value).toISOString() : fallbackValue;
-}
-
-function loadStackResearchSnapshot() {
-  try {
-    if (!existsSync(ARCHITECT_RESEARCH_SNAPSHOT_FILE_PATH)) {
-      return {
-        snapshot: FALLBACK_STACK_RESEARCH_SNAPSHOT,
-        sourcePath: 'fallback://embedded-snapshot',
-      };
-    }
-
-    const snapshotContent = readFileSync(ARCHITECT_RESEARCH_SNAPSHOT_FILE_PATH, 'utf8');
-    const parsedSnapshot = JSON.parse(snapshotContent);
-
-    if (!Array.isArray(parsedSnapshot?.stackSignals) || parsedSnapshot.stackSignals.length === 0) {
-      return {
-        snapshot: FALLBACK_STACK_RESEARCH_SNAPSHOT,
-        sourcePath: 'fallback://embedded-snapshot',
-      };
-    }
-
-    return {
-      snapshot: parsedSnapshot,
-      sourcePath: ARCHITECT_RESEARCH_SNAPSHOT_FILE_PATH,
-    };
-  } catch {
-    return {
-      snapshot: FALLBACK_STACK_RESEARCH_SNAPSHOT,
-      sourcePath: 'fallback://embedded-snapshot',
-    };
-  }
-}
-
-function normalizeMetricValue(value, fallbackValue = 0) {
-  const parsedValue = Number(value);
-  if (!Number.isFinite(parsedValue)) {
-    return fallbackValue;
-  }
-
-  return clampNumericValue(parsedValue, 0, 1);
-}
-
-function calculateSnapshotSignalScore(snapshotSignalEntry) {
-  const metrics = snapshotSignalEntry?.metrics || {};
-  const ecosystemMaturity = normalizeMetricValue(metrics.ecosystemMaturity, 0.65);
-  const talentAvailability = normalizeMetricValue(metrics.talentAvailability, 0.65);
-  const deliveryVelocity = normalizeMetricValue(metrics.deliveryVelocity, 0.65);
-  const aggregateScore = (ecosystemMaturity + talentAvailability + deliveryVelocity) / 3;
-
-  return {
-    aggregateScore,
-    metrics: {
-      ecosystemMaturity,
-      talentAvailability,
-      deliveryVelocity,
-    },
-  };
-}
-
-function parseRealtimeSignalPayloadFromJson(rawJsonContent) {
-  try {
-    const parsedPayload = JSON.parse(rawJsonContent);
-    if (!Array.isArray(parsedPayload?.stackSignals)) {
-      return null;
-    }
-
-    return parsedPayload;
-  } catch {
-    return null;
-  }
-}
-
-function loadRealtimeSignalPayload(realtimeSignalFilePath) {
-  const normalizedRealtimeSignalFilePath = String(realtimeSignalFilePath || '').trim();
-  if (normalizedRealtimeSignalFilePath) {
-    try {
-      const absoluteRealtimeSignalPath = path.resolve(normalizedRealtimeSignalFilePath);
-      if (existsSync(absoluteRealtimeSignalPath)) {
-        const filePayload = parseRealtimeSignalPayloadFromJson(readFileSync(absoluteRealtimeSignalPath, 'utf8'));
-        if (filePayload) {
-          return {
-            payload: filePayload,
-            sourcePath: absoluteRealtimeSignalPath,
-          };
-        }
-      }
-    } catch {
-      // Ignore file loading errors and continue to environment fallback.
-    }
-  }
-
-  const signalPathFromEnvironment = String(process.env[ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_REALTIME_SIGNAL_PATH_ENV_KEY] || '').trim();
-  if (signalPathFromEnvironment) {
-    try {
-      const absoluteRealtimeSignalPath = path.resolve(signalPathFromEnvironment);
-      if (existsSync(absoluteRealtimeSignalPath)) {
-        const filePayload = parseRealtimeSignalPayloadFromJson(readFileSync(absoluteRealtimeSignalPath, 'utf8'));
-        if (filePayload) {
-          return {
-            payload: filePayload,
-            sourcePath: absoluteRealtimeSignalPath,
-          };
-        }
-      }
-    } catch {
-      // Ignore file loading errors and continue to environment JSON fallback.
-    }
-  }
-
-  const signalJsonFromEnvironment = String(process.env[ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_REALTIME_SIGNAL_ENV_KEY] || '').trim();
-  if (signalJsonFromEnvironment) {
-    const payloadFromEnvironment = parseRealtimeSignalPayloadFromJson(signalJsonFromEnvironment);
-    if (payloadFromEnvironment) {
-      return {
-        payload: payloadFromEnvironment,
-        sourcePath: `env://${ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_REALTIME_SIGNAL_ENV_KEY}`,
-      };
-    }
-  }
-
-  return {
-    payload: null,
-    sourcePath: null,
-  };
-}
-
-function normalizeStackSignalBoost(value) {
-  const normalizedSignal = normalizeMetricValue(value, 0);
-  return Number((normalizedSignal * 0.35).toFixed(4));
-}
-
-function normalizePaletteRoles(rawPaletteRoles) {
-  if (!Array.isArray(rawPaletteRoles) || rawPaletteRoles.length === 0) {
-    return ['base', 'surface', 'accent'];
-  }
-
-  const sanitizedRoles = rawPaletteRoles
-    .map((paletteRole) => String(paletteRole || '').trim().toLowerCase())
-    .filter((paletteRole) => ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_PALETTE_ROLES.includes(paletteRole));
-
-  if (sanitizedRoles.length === 0) {
-    return ['base', 'surface', 'accent'];
-  }
-
-  return Array.from(new Set(sanitizedRoles));
-}
-
-function normalizeTypographyScale(rawTypographyScale) {
-  const normalizedScale = String(rawTypographyScale || '').trim().toLowerCase();
-  if (ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_TYPOGRAPHY_SCALES.includes(normalizedScale)) {
-    return normalizedScale;
-  }
-
-  return 'balanced';
-}
-
-function normalizeSpacingPattern(rawSpacingPattern) {
-  const normalizedPattern = String(rawSpacingPattern || '').trim().toLowerCase();
-  if (ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_SPACING_PATTERNS.includes(normalizedPattern)) {
-    return normalizedPattern;
-  }
-
-  return 'balanced-grid';
-}
-
-function normalizeMotionCharacteristics(rawMotionCharacteristics) {
-  if (!Array.isArray(rawMotionCharacteristics) || rawMotionCharacteristics.length === 0) {
-    return ['subtle-enter', 'state-feedback'];
-  }
-
-  const sanitizedCharacteristics = rawMotionCharacteristics
-    .map((motionCharacteristic) => String(motionCharacteristic || '').trim().toLowerCase())
-    .filter((motionCharacteristic) => ARCHITECT_ALLOWED_MOTION_CHARACTERISTICS.includes(motionCharacteristic));
-
-  if (sanitizedCharacteristics.length === 0) {
-    return ['subtle-enter', 'state-feedback'];
-  }
-
-  return Array.from(new Set(sanitizedCharacteristics));
-}
-
-function synthesizeDesignSignals({
-  normalizedProjectDescription,
-  recommendedStackFileName,
-  realtimePayload,
-  snapshotGeneratedAt,
-}) {
-  const descriptionText = String(normalizedProjectDescription || '');
-  const looksLikeFinancialSurface = /fraud|bank|payment|regulated|security/.test(descriptionText);
-  const looksLikeGrowthSurface = /marketing|landing|conversion|sales|campaign/.test(descriptionText);
-  const looksLikeDataProduct = /analytics|dashboard|report|insight|data/.test(descriptionText);
-
-  let paletteRoles = ['base', 'surface', 'accent'];
-  let typographyScale = 'balanced';
-  let spacingPattern = 'balanced-grid';
-  let motionCharacteristics = ['subtle-enter', 'state-feedback'];
-
-  if (looksLikeFinancialSurface) {
-    paletteRoles = ['base', 'surface', 'accent', 'danger', 'success'];
-    motionCharacteristics = ['calm-transition', 'state-feedback'];
-  } else if (looksLikeGrowthSurface) {
-    paletteRoles = ['base', 'surface', 'accent', 'success'];
-    typographyScale = 'expressive';
-    motionCharacteristics = ['staggered-reveal', 'conversion-focus', 'state-feedback'];
-  }
-
-  if (looksLikeDataProduct || recommendedStackFileName === 'python.md') {
-    spacingPattern = 'compact-grid';
-  }
-
-  const realtimeDesignSignals = realtimePayload?.designSignals || null;
-  if (realtimeDesignSignals) {
-    paletteRoles = normalizePaletteRoles(realtimeDesignSignals.paletteRoles || paletteRoles);
-    typographyScale = normalizeTypographyScale(realtimeDesignSignals.typographyScale || typographyScale);
-    spacingPattern = normalizeSpacingPattern(realtimeDesignSignals.spacingPattern || spacingPattern);
-    motionCharacteristics = normalizeMotionCharacteristics(
-      realtimeDesignSignals.motionCharacteristics || motionCharacteristics
-    );
-  }
-
-  return {
-    generatedAt: snapshotGeneratedAt,
-    normalizedSignals: {
-      paletteRoles,
-      typographyScale,
-      spacingPattern,
-      motionCharacteristics,
-    },
-    sourcePolicy: {
-      normalizedSignalsOnly: true,
-      copiedExternalProse: false,
-      blockedInputPacks: ['DESIGN.md'],
-    },
-  };
-}
-
-function buildEvidenceCitation({
-  citationId,
-  sourceType,
-  sourceName,
-  sourceUrl,
-  measuredAt,
-  stackFileName,
-  metrics,
-  note,
-}) {
-  return {
-    citationId,
-    sourceType,
-    sourceName,
-    sourceUrl,
-    measuredAt: toIsoTimestamp(measuredAt),
-    stackFileName,
-    metrics,
-    note,
-  };
-}
-
-function buildFallbackRecommendation({
-  stackFileNames,
-  blueprintFileNames,
-  tokenBudget,
-  timeoutMs,
-  usedTokens,
-  elapsedMs,
-  timeoutTriggered,
-  requestedResearchMode,
-  effectiveResearchMode,
-  snapshot,
-  snapshotSourcePath,
-  realtimeGateEnabled,
-  realtimeSignalsLoaded,
-  realtimeSignalSourcePath,
-  normalizedProjectDescription,
-}) {
-  const fallbackStackFileName = stackFileNames.includes('typescript.md')
-    ? 'typescript.md'
-    : stackFileNames[0] || 'typescript.md';
-  const fallbackBlueprintFileName = resolveRecommendedBlueprintFileName(fallbackStackFileName, blueprintFileNames);
-  const fallbackSnapshotSignal = Array.isArray(snapshot?.stackSignals)
-    ? snapshot.stackSignals.find((stackSignal) => stackSignal.stackFileName === fallbackStackFileName) || null
-    : null;
-  const fallbackSnapshotMetrics = calculateSnapshotSignalScore(fallbackSnapshotSignal);
-  const fallbackEvidenceCitations = [
-    buildEvidenceCitation({
-      citationId: `snapshot:${snapshot?.snapshotId || 'fallback'}:${fallbackStackFileName}`,
-      sourceType: 'snapshot',
-      sourceName: snapshot?.sourceName || 'Stack research snapshot',
-      sourceUrl: snapshot?.sourceUrl || snapshotSourcePath,
-      measuredAt: fallbackSnapshotSignal?.measuredAt || snapshot?.generatedAt,
-      stackFileName: fallbackStackFileName,
-      metrics: fallbackSnapshotMetrics.metrics,
-      note: 'Deterministic snapshot baseline used for fallback recommendation.',
-    }),
-  ];
-
-  const fallbackDesignGuidance = synthesizeDesignSignals({
-    normalizedProjectDescription,
-    recommendedStackFileName: fallbackStackFileName,
-    realtimePayload: null,
-    snapshotGeneratedAt: toIsoTimestamp(snapshot?.generatedAt),
-  });
-
-  return {
-    projectDescription: String(normalizedProjectDescription || '').trim(),
-    recommendedStackFileName: fallbackStackFileName,
-    recommendedBlueprintFileName: fallbackBlueprintFileName,
-    confidenceLabel: 'low',
-    confidenceScore: 0.45,
-    rationaleSentences: [
-      `I recommend ${toTitleCase(fallbackStackFileName)} with ${toTitleCase(fallbackBlueprintFileName)} as a safe fallback path.`,
-      'The architecture recommendation budget was constrained before a stronger stack signal could be computed.',
-      `Main trade-off: ${STACK_TRADEOFF_SUMMARIES[fallbackStackFileName] || 'validate ecosystem fit before production rollout.'}`,
-    ],
-    alternatives: [],
-    uncertaintyNotes: [
-      timeoutTriggered
-        ? 'Timeout guardrail triggered before recommendation analysis completed.'
-        : 'Input signals were not strong enough for a high-confidence architecture recommendation.',
-    ],
-    signalSummary: 'fallback mode',
-    failureModes: {
-      lowConfidence: true,
-      dataConflict: false,
-      repeatedOverride: false,
-      realtimeGated: requestedResearchMode === 'realtime' && !realtimeGateEnabled,
-      realtimeUnavailable: requestedResearchMode === 'realtime' && realtimeGateEnabled && !realtimeSignalsLoaded,
-    },
-    research: {
-      requestedMode: requestedResearchMode,
-      effectiveMode: effectiveResearchMode,
-      deterministic: effectiveResearchMode === 'snapshot',
-      snapshotId: snapshot?.snapshotId || 'fallback',
-      snapshotGeneratedAt: toIsoTimestamp(snapshot?.generatedAt),
-      snapshotSourcePath,
-      realtimeGateEnabled,
-      realtimeSignalsLoaded,
-      realtimeSignalSourcePath,
-      trustedRealtimeSources: Array.isArray(snapshot?.trustedRealtimeSources)
-        ? snapshot.trustedRealtimeSources
-        : [],
-    },
-    evidenceCitations: fallbackEvidenceCitations,
-    designGuidance: fallbackDesignGuidance,
-    researchBudget: {
-      tokenBudget,
-      timeoutMs,
-      usedTokens: Math.min(usedTokens, tokenBudget),
-      elapsedMs: Math.min(elapsedMs, timeoutMs),
-      tokenBudgetCapped: usedTokens >= tokenBudget,
-      timeoutTriggered,
-    },
-  };
-}
-
+/**
+ * Generates a repo-grounded architecture brief based on project description
+ * keywords and repository marker detection. This is an offline brief —
+ * for ecosystem-level research, the consuming agent should perform live
+ * web research rather than relying on stale local snapshots.
+ */
 export function recommendArchitecture({
   projectDescription,
   projectDetection,
   stackFileNames,
   blueprintFileNames,
-  tokenBudget = ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_TOKEN_BUDGET,
-  timeoutMs = ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_TIMEOUT_MS,
-  researchMode = ARCHITECT_DEFAULT_RESEARCH_MODE,
-  enableRealtimeResearch = false,
-  realtimeSignalFilePath = null,
 }) {
-  const startedAt = Date.now();
-  const boundedTokenBudget = clampNumericValue(tokenBudget, ARCHITECT_MIN_TOKEN_BUDGET, ARCHITECT_MAX_TOKEN_BUDGET);
-  const boundedTimeoutMs = clampNumericValue(timeoutMs, ARCHITECT_MIN_TIMEOUT_MS, ARCHITECT_MAX_TIMEOUT_MS);
-  const requestedResearchMode = normalizeArchitectResearchMode(researchMode);
-  const { snapshot: stackResearchSnapshot, sourcePath: snapshotSourcePath } = loadStackResearchSnapshot();
-  const snapshotGeneratedAt = toIsoTimestamp(stackResearchSnapshot.generatedAt);
-  const realtimeGateEnabled = requestedResearchMode === 'realtime' && enableRealtimeResearch === true;
-  const realtimeSignalPayloadResult = realtimeGateEnabled
-    ? loadRealtimeSignalPayload(realtimeSignalFilePath)
-    : { payload: null, sourcePath: null };
-  const realtimeSignalPayload = realtimeSignalPayloadResult.payload;
-  const realtimeSignalsLoaded = Array.isArray(realtimeSignalPayload?.stackSignals)
-    && realtimeSignalPayload.stackSignals.length > 0;
-  const effectiveResearchMode = realtimeGateEnabled && realtimeSignalsLoaded
-    ? 'realtime'
-    : 'snapshot';
   const normalizedDescription = String(projectDescription || '').trim().toLowerCase();
-  const effectiveDescriptionSeed = normalizedDescription || 'general software project';
-  let effectiveDescription = effectiveDescriptionSeed;
-  let usedTokens = estimateTokenUsage(effectiveDescription) + 120;
+  const effectiveDescription = normalizedDescription || 'general software project';
   const uncertaintyNotes = [];
 
-  if (requestedResearchMode === 'realtime' && !realtimeGateEnabled) {
-    uncertaintyNotes.push('Realtime research mode requested but gate is off. Using deterministic snapshot baseline.');
-  }
-
-  if (requestedResearchMode === 'realtime' && realtimeGateEnabled && !realtimeSignalsLoaded) {
-    uncertaintyNotes.push('Realtime research gate is on, but no trusted realtime payload was available. Using deterministic snapshot baseline.');
-  }
-
-  if (usedTokens > boundedTokenBudget) {
-    effectiveDescription = effectiveDescription.slice(0, Math.max(120, boundedTokenBudget * 4));
-    usedTokens = boundedTokenBudget;
-    uncertaintyNotes.push('Token budget guardrail trimmed input context before recommendation.');
-  }
-
-  if ((Date.now() - startedAt) > boundedTimeoutMs) {
-    return buildFallbackRecommendation({
-      stackFileNames,
-      blueprintFileNames,
-      tokenBudget: boundedTokenBudget,
-      timeoutMs: boundedTimeoutMs,
-      usedTokens,
-      elapsedMs: Date.now() - startedAt,
-      timeoutTriggered: true,
-      requestedResearchMode,
-      effectiveResearchMode,
-      snapshot: stackResearchSnapshot,
-      snapshotSourcePath,
-      realtimeGateEnabled,
-      realtimeSignalsLoaded,
-      realtimeSignalSourcePath: realtimeSignalPayloadResult.sourcePath,
-      normalizedProjectDescription: normalizedDescription,
-    });
-  }
-
-  const snapshotSignalByStackFileName = new Map();
-  for (const snapshotSignalEntry of stackResearchSnapshot?.stackSignals || []) {
-    if (!snapshotSignalEntry?.stackFileName) {
-      continue;
-    }
-
-    snapshotSignalByStackFileName.set(snapshotSignalEntry.stackFileName, snapshotSignalEntry);
-  }
-
-  const realtimeSignalByStackFileName = new Map();
-  if (realtimeSignalsLoaded) {
-    for (const realtimeSignalEntry of realtimeSignalPayload.stackSignals) {
-      const stackFileName = realtimeSignalEntry?.stackFileName;
-      if (!stackFileName || !stackFileNames.includes(stackFileName)) {
-        continue;
-      }
-
-      const rawRealtimeSignalStrength = realtimeSignalEntry.signalStrength
-        ?? realtimeSignalEntry.metrics?.signalStrength
-        ?? 0;
-      const normalizedRealtimeSignalStrength = normalizeMetricValue(rawRealtimeSignalStrength, 0);
-      realtimeSignalByStackFileName.set(stackFileName, {
-        signalBoost: normalizeStackSignalBoost(normalizedRealtimeSignalStrength),
-        measuredAt: realtimeSignalEntry.measuredAt || realtimeSignalPayload.generatedAt || snapshotGeneratedAt,
-        sourceName: realtimeSignalEntry.sourceName || realtimeSignalPayload.sourceName || 'Trusted realtime source',
-        sourceUrl: realtimeSignalEntry.sourceUrl || realtimeSignalPayload.sourceUrl || realtimeSignalPayloadResult.sourcePath,
-        metrics: {
-          signalStrength: normalizedRealtimeSignalStrength,
-          freshnessHours: Number(realtimeSignalEntry.metrics?.freshnessHours) || 0,
-        },
-      });
-    }
-  }
-
+  // Repo marker detection scoring (grounded in actual project files).
   const detectionScoreByStackFileName = new Map();
   for (const rankedCandidate of projectDetection?.rankedCandidates || []) {
     const confidenceScore = Number(rankedCandidate.confidenceScore) || 0;
@@ -722,63 +161,64 @@ export function recommendArchitecture({
     );
   }
 
+  // Keyword hint scoring (low-confidence bias, not research).
   const scoredStackCandidates = stackFileNames.map((stackFileName) => {
     const configuredSignals = STACK_SIGNAL_WEIGHTS[stackFileName] || [];
-    const matchedSignals = [];
-    let keywordSignalScore = 0;
+    const matchedKeywords = [];
+    let keywordScore = 0;
 
     for (const configuredSignal of configuredSignals) {
       if (!effectiveDescription.includes(configuredSignal.term)) {
         continue;
       }
 
-      keywordSignalScore += configuredSignal.weight;
-      matchedSignals.push(configuredSignal.term);
+      keywordScore += configuredSignal.weight;
+      matchedKeywords.push(configuredSignal.term);
     }
 
-    const detectionSignalScore = detectionScoreByStackFileName.get(stackFileName) || 0;
-    const snapshotSignalEntry = snapshotSignalByStackFileName.get(stackFileName) || null;
-    const snapshotSignalScorePayload = calculateSnapshotSignalScore(snapshotSignalEntry);
-    const snapshotSignalScore = normalizeStackSignalBoost(snapshotSignalScorePayload.aggregateScore);
-    const realtimeSignalPayloadEntry = realtimeSignalByStackFileName.get(stackFileName) || null;
-    const realtimeSignalScore = realtimeSignalPayloadEntry?.signalBoost || 0;
-    const totalScore = 0.2 + keywordSignalScore + detectionSignalScore + snapshotSignalScore + realtimeSignalScore;
+    const detectionScore = detectionScoreByStackFileName.get(stackFileName) || 0;
+    const totalScore = 0.2 + keywordScore + detectionScore;
 
     return {
       stackFileName,
       totalScore,
-      keywordSignalScore,
-      detectionSignalScore,
-      snapshotSignalScore,
-      snapshotMetrics: snapshotSignalScorePayload.metrics,
-      realtimeSignalScore,
-      realtimeMetrics: realtimeSignalPayloadEntry?.metrics || null,
-      snapshotMeasuredAt: snapshotSignalEntry?.measuredAt || stackResearchSnapshot.generatedAt,
-      realtimeMeasuredAt: realtimeSignalPayloadEntry?.measuredAt || null,
-      realtimeSourceName: realtimeSignalPayloadEntry?.sourceName || null,
-      realtimeSourceUrl: realtimeSignalPayloadEntry?.sourceUrl || null,
-      matchedSignals,
+      keywordScore,
+      detectionScore,
+      matchedKeywords,
     };
   }).sort((leftCandidate, rightCandidate) => rightCandidate.totalScore - leftCandidate.totalScore);
 
+  // Fallback when no candidates can be scored.
   if (scoredStackCandidates.length === 0) {
-    return buildFallbackRecommendation({
-      stackFileNames,
-      blueprintFileNames,
-      tokenBudget: boundedTokenBudget,
-      timeoutMs: boundedTimeoutMs,
-      usedTokens,
-      elapsedMs: Date.now() - startedAt,
-      timeoutTriggered: false,
-      requestedResearchMode,
-      effectiveResearchMode,
-      snapshot: stackResearchSnapshot,
-      snapshotSourcePath,
-      realtimeGateEnabled,
-      realtimeSignalsLoaded,
-      realtimeSignalSourcePath: realtimeSignalPayloadResult.sourcePath,
-      normalizedProjectDescription: normalizedDescription,
-    });
+    const fallbackStackFileName = stackFileNames.includes('typescript.md')
+      ? 'typescript.md'
+      : stackFileNames[0] || 'typescript.md';
+    const fallbackBlueprintFileName = resolveRecommendedBlueprintFileName(fallbackStackFileName, blueprintFileNames);
+
+    return {
+      briefType: 'offline',
+      projectDescription: String(projectDescription || '').trim(),
+      recommendedStackFileName: fallbackStackFileName,
+      recommendedBlueprintFileName: fallbackBlueprintFileName,
+      confidenceLabel: 'low',
+      confidenceScore: 0.35,
+      rationaleSentences: [
+        `Defaulting to ${toTitleCase(fallbackStackFileName)} with ${toTitleCase(fallbackBlueprintFileName)} as a safe fallback.`,
+        'No keyword or detection signals were strong enough for a grounded recommendation.',
+        'For ecosystem-level validation, perform live web research before committing to this stack.',
+      ],
+      alternatives: [],
+      uncertaintyNotes: [
+        'This is an offline brief based on keyword hints and repo markers only.',
+        'Ecosystem fitness was not verified — the agent should research before finalizing.',
+      ],
+      signalSummary: 'fallback (no strong signals)',
+      failureModes: {
+        lowConfidence: true,
+        dataConflict: false,
+        repeatedOverride: false,
+      },
+    };
   }
 
   const strongestCandidate = scoredStackCandidates[0];
@@ -791,7 +231,7 @@ export function recommendArchitecture({
     + Math.min(strongestCandidate.totalScore / 8, 0.25)
     + Math.min(Math.max(scoreGap, 0) / 3, 0.18);
 
-  if (strongestCandidate.matchedSignals.length === 0) {
+  if (strongestCandidate.matchedKeywords.length === 0) {
     confidenceScore -= 0.2;
   }
 
@@ -799,7 +239,7 @@ export function recommendArchitecture({
     confidenceScore -= 0.1;
   }
 
-  confidenceScore = clampNumericValue(confidenceScore, 0.35, 0.97);
+  confidenceScore = Math.min(Math.max(confidenceScore, 0.35), 0.97);
 
   const confidenceLabel = resolveConfidenceLabel(confidenceScore);
   const lowConfidence = confidenceScore < 0.7;
@@ -813,114 +253,36 @@ export function recommendArchitecture({
     uncertaintyNotes.push('Data conflict: top stack candidates are close, so trade-offs need manual confirmation.');
   }
 
+  // Offline briefs should always be transparent about their grounding source.
+  uncertaintyNotes.push(
+    'This brief is grounded in repo markers and keyword hints only. '
+    + 'For ecosystem-level validation, the agent should perform live web research.'
+  );
+
   const recommendedStackFileName = strongestCandidate.stackFileName;
   const recommendedBlueprintFileName = resolveRecommendedBlueprintFileName(recommendedStackFileName, blueprintFileNames);
+
   const signalSummaryParts = [];
-  if (strongestCandidate.matchedSignals.length > 0) {
-    signalSummaryParts.push(strongestCandidate.matchedSignals.slice(0, 4).join(', '));
+  if (strongestCandidate.matchedKeywords.length > 0) {
+    signalSummaryParts.push(`keywords: ${strongestCandidate.matchedKeywords.slice(0, 4).join(', ')}`);
   }
-  signalSummaryParts.push(`snapshot ${strongestCandidate.snapshotSignalScore.toFixed(2)}`);
-  if (strongestCandidate.realtimeSignalScore > 0) {
-    signalSummaryParts.push(`realtime ${strongestCandidate.realtimeSignalScore.toFixed(2)}`);
+  if (strongestCandidate.detectionScore > 0) {
+    signalSummaryParts.push(`repo detection: ${strongestCandidate.detectionScore.toFixed(2)}`);
   }
-  const signalSummary = signalSummaryParts.join(', ');
+  const signalSummary = signalSummaryParts.length > 0
+    ? signalSummaryParts.join('; ')
+    : 'weak signals only';
 
   const rationaleSentences = [
-    `I recommend ${toTitleCase(recommendedStackFileName)} with ${toTitleCase(recommendedBlueprintFileName)} for this project.`,
-    `The strongest evidence in your description is ${signalSummary}, combined with available repository signals.`,
+    `Stack brief: ${toTitleCase(recommendedStackFileName)} with ${toTitleCase(recommendedBlueprintFileName)}.`,
+    `Grounding signals: ${signalSummary}.`,
     `Main trade-off: ${STACK_TRADEOFF_SUMMARIES[recommendedStackFileName] || 'validate ecosystem fit before production rollout.'}`,
   ];
 
   if (lowConfidence) {
-    rationaleSentences.push('Confidence is low, so review alternatives before finalizing architecture.');
+    rationaleSentences.push('Confidence is low — review alternatives and perform live research before finalizing.');
   }
 
-  const evidenceCitations = [
-    buildEvidenceCitation({
-      citationId: `snapshot:${stackResearchSnapshot.snapshotId || 'snapshot'}:${recommendedStackFileName}`,
-      sourceType: 'snapshot',
-      sourceName: stackResearchSnapshot.sourceName || 'Stack research snapshot',
-      sourceUrl: stackResearchSnapshot.sourceUrl || snapshotSourcePath,
-      measuredAt: strongestCandidate.snapshotMeasuredAt || snapshotGeneratedAt,
-      stackFileName: recommendedStackFileName,
-      metrics: strongestCandidate.snapshotMetrics,
-      note: 'Deterministic stack research snapshot signal.',
-    }),
-  ];
-
-  if (projectDetection?.recommendedStackFileName) {
-    evidenceCitations.push(
-      buildEvidenceCitation({
-        citationId: `detector:${projectDetection.recommendedStackFileName}`,
-        sourceType: 'detection',
-        sourceName: 'Existing project marker detector',
-        sourceUrl: 'state://project-detection',
-        measuredAt: snapshotGeneratedAt,
-        stackFileName: projectDetection.recommendedStackFileName,
-        metrics: {
-          confidenceScore: Number(projectDetection.confidenceScore || 0),
-          confidenceGap: Number(projectDetection.confidenceGap || 0),
-        },
-        note: 'Repository marker detection signal used for stack recommendation bias.',
-      })
-    );
-  }
-
-  if (effectiveResearchMode === 'realtime') {
-    const realtimeCitationCandidate = strongestCandidate.realtimeSignalScore > 0
-      ? strongestCandidate
-      : scoredStackCandidates.find((stackCandidate) => stackCandidate.realtimeSignalScore > 0) || null;
-
-    if (realtimeCitationCandidate) {
-      const realtimeCitationOnRecommendedStack = realtimeCitationCandidate.stackFileName === recommendedStackFileName;
-      evidenceCitations.push(
-        buildEvidenceCitation({
-          citationId: `realtime:${realtimeCitationCandidate.stackFileName}`,
-          sourceType: 'realtime',
-          sourceName: realtimeCitationCandidate.realtimeSourceName || 'Trusted realtime source',
-          sourceUrl: realtimeCitationCandidate.realtimeSourceUrl || realtimeSignalPayloadResult.sourcePath,
-          measuredAt: realtimeCitationCandidate.realtimeMeasuredAt || snapshotGeneratedAt,
-          stackFileName: realtimeCitationCandidate.stackFileName,
-          metrics: realtimeCitationCandidate.realtimeMetrics
-            || { signalStrength: realtimeCitationCandidate.realtimeSignalScore },
-          note: realtimeCitationOnRecommendedStack
-            ? 'Optional realtime signal, loaded only when realtime research is explicitly gated on.'
-            : 'Optional realtime signal loaded for an alternative stack signal; used as supporting evidence in realtime mode.',
-        })
-      );
-    } else if (realtimeSignalsLoaded && Array.isArray(realtimeSignalPayload?.stackSignals) && realtimeSignalPayload.stackSignals.length > 0) {
-      const fallbackRealtimeSignal = realtimeSignalPayload.stackSignals[0];
-      const fallbackRealtimeSignalStrength = normalizeMetricValue(
-        fallbackRealtimeSignal?.signalStrength
-          ?? fallbackRealtimeSignal?.metrics?.signalStrength
-          ?? 0,
-        0
-      );
-
-      evidenceCitations.push(
-        buildEvidenceCitation({
-          citationId: 'realtime:payload-fallback',
-          sourceType: 'realtime',
-          sourceName: fallbackRealtimeSignal?.sourceName || realtimeSignalPayload.sourceName || 'Trusted realtime source',
-          sourceUrl: fallbackRealtimeSignal?.sourceUrl || realtimeSignalPayload.sourceUrl || realtimeSignalPayloadResult.sourcePath,
-          measuredAt: fallbackRealtimeSignal?.measuredAt || realtimeSignalPayload.generatedAt || snapshotGeneratedAt,
-          stackFileName: recommendedStackFileName,
-          metrics: {
-            signalStrength: fallbackRealtimeSignalStrength,
-          },
-          note: 'Optional realtime payload loaded, but stack mapping did not match current candidate set. Stored as trace citation.',
-        })
-      );
-    }
-  }
-
-  const designGuidance = synthesizeDesignSignals({
-    normalizedProjectDescription: normalizedDescription,
-    recommendedStackFileName,
-    realtimePayload: effectiveResearchMode === 'realtime' ? realtimeSignalPayload : null,
-    snapshotGeneratedAt,
-  });
-
   const alternatives = scoredStackCandidates
     .slice(1, 3)
     .map((stackCandidate) => {
@@ -930,32 +292,12 @@ export function recommendArchitecture({
         blueprintFileName: alternativeBlueprintFileName,
         oneLineTradeoff: STACK_TRADEOFF_SUMMARIES[stackCandidate.stackFileName]
           || 'validate fit with your runtime and team constraints.',
-        evidenceSummary: `keyword=${stackCandidate.keywordSignalScore.toFixed(2)}, detection=${stackCandidate.detectionSignalScore.toFixed(2)}, snapshot=${stackCandidate.snapshotSignalScore.toFixed(2)}, realtime=${stackCandidate.realtimeSignalScore.toFixed(2)}`,
+        evidenceSummary: `keyword=${stackCandidate.keywordScore.toFixed(2)}, detection=${stackCandidate.detectionScore.toFixed(2)}`,
       };
     });
 
-  const elapsedMs = Date.now() - startedAt;
-  if (elapsedMs > boundedTimeoutMs) {
-    return buildFallbackRecommendation({
-      stackFileNames,
-      blueprintFileNames,
-      tokenBudget: boundedTokenBudget,
-      timeoutMs: boundedTimeoutMs,
-      usedTokens,
-      elapsedMs,
-      timeoutTriggered: true,
-      requestedResearchMode,
-      effectiveResearchMode,
-      snapshot: stackResearchSnapshot,
-      snapshotSourcePath,
-      realtimeGateEnabled,
-      realtimeSignalsLoaded,
-      realtimeSignalSourcePath: realtimeSignalPayloadResult.sourcePath,
-      normalizedProjectDescription: normalizedDescription,
-    });
-  }
-
   return {
+    briefType: 'offline',
     projectDescription: String(projectDescription || '').trim(),
     recommendedStackFileName,
     recommendedBlueprintFileName,
@@ -969,46 +311,16 @@ export function recommendArchitecture({
       lowConfidence,
       dataConflict,
       repeatedOverride: false,
-      realtimeGated: requestedResearchMode === 'realtime' && !realtimeGateEnabled,
-      realtimeUnavailable: requestedResearchMode === 'realtime' && realtimeGateEnabled && !realtimeSignalsLoaded,
-    },
-    research: {
-      requestedMode: requestedResearchMode,
-      effectiveMode: effectiveResearchMode,
-      deterministic: effectiveResearchMode === 'snapshot',
-      snapshotId: stackResearchSnapshot.snapshotId || 'snapshot',
-      snapshotGeneratedAt,
-      snapshotSourcePath,
-      realtimeGateEnabled,
-      realtimeSignalsLoaded,
-      realtimeSignalSourcePath: realtimeSignalPayloadResult.sourcePath,
-      trustedRealtimeSources: Array.isArray(stackResearchSnapshot.trustedRealtimeSources)
-        ? stackResearchSnapshot.trustedRealtimeSources
-        : [],
-    },
-    evidenceCitations,
-    designGuidance,
-    researchBudget: {
-      tokenBudget: boundedTokenBudget,
-      timeoutMs: boundedTimeoutMs,
-      usedTokens: Math.min(usedTokens, boundedTokenBudget),
-      elapsedMs,
-      tokenBudgetCapped: usedTokens >= boundedTokenBudget,
-      timeoutTriggered: false,
     },
   };
 }
 
 export function formatArchitectureRecommendation(architectureRecommendation) {
-  const researchModeSummary = architectureRecommendation.research
-    ? `${architectureRecommendation.research.requestedMode} -> ${architectureRecommendation.research.effectiveMode}`
-    : 'snapshot';
   const outputLines = [
-    '\nArchitecture recommendation (project-description-first):',
+    '\nArchitecture brief (offline, repo-grounded):',
     `- Stack: ${toTitleCase(architectureRecommendation.recommendedStackFileName)}`,
     `- Blueprint: ${toTitleCase(architectureRecommendation.recommendedBlueprintFileName)}`,
     `- Confidence: ${architectureRecommendation.confidenceLabel} (${architectureRecommendation.confidenceScore})`,
-    `- Research mode: ${researchModeSummary}`,
     '- Rationale:',
     ...architectureRecommendation.rationaleSentences.map((sentence, sentenceIndex) => `  ${sentenceIndex + 1}. ${sentence}`),
     '- Alternatives:',
@@ -1048,31 +360,6 @@ export function formatArchitectureRecommendation(architectureRecommendation) {
     outputLines.push(`- Caution labels: ${cautionLabels.join(', ')}`);
   }
 
-  if (Array.isArray(architectureRecommendation.evidenceCitations) && architectureRecommendation.evidenceCitations.length > 0) {
-    outputLines.push('- Evidence citations (measurable source + timestamp):');
-    outputLines.push(
-      ...architectureRecommendation.evidenceCitations.map((citationEntry, citationIndex) => {
-        const metricsSummary = Object.entries(citationEntry.metrics || {})
-          .map(([metricKey, metricValue]) => `${metricKey}=${metricValue}`)
-          .join(', ');
-        return `  ${citationIndex + 1}. [${citationEntry.sourceType}] ${citationEntry.sourceName} @ ${citationEntry.measuredAt} (${metricsSummary || 'no metrics'})`;
-      })
-    );
-  }
-
-  if (architectureRecommendation.designGuidance?.normalizedSignals) {
-    const normalizedSignals = architectureRecommendation.designGuidance.normalizedSignals;
-    outputLines.push('- Design signal synthesis (normalized, no copied external prose):');
-    outputLines.push(`  1. Palette roles: ${normalizedSignals.paletteRoles.join(', ')}`);
-    outputLines.push(`  2. Typography scale: ${normalizedSignals.typographyScale}`);
-    outputLines.push(`  3. Spacing pattern: ${normalizedSignals.spacingPattern}`);
-    outputLines.push(`  4. Motion characteristics: ${normalizedSignals.motionCharacteristics.join(', ')}`);
-  }
-
-  outputLines.push(
-    `- Research guardrails: ${architectureRecommendation.researchBudget.usedTokens}/${architectureRecommendation.researchBudget.tokenBudget} tokens, ${architectureRecommendation.researchBudget.elapsedMs}ms/${architectureRecommendation.researchBudget.timeoutMs}ms`
-  );
-
   return outputLines.join('\n');
 }