@qqbrowser/openclaw-qbot 0.0.127 → 0.0.129

package/extensions/openclaw-telemetry-galileo-embedded/index.ts

@@ -1,663 +0,0 @@
-/**
- * openclaw-telemetry-galileo-embedded 插件入口
- *
- * 开发者内嵌版本：配置从 galileo.config.json 文件读取，不依赖 configSchema / pluginConfig。
- * 与用户版 openclaw-telemetry-galileo 使用不同的插件 ID，可同时加载、互不冲突。
- *
- * Trace 链路关系（伽利略协议）：
- *   invoke_agent {agentName} (root span, per before_agent_start → agent_end)
- *     ├── chat {model}       （llm_input → llm_output，包含完整 prompt/response）
- *     ├── execute_tool {name} （before_tool_call → after_tool_call，包含 params/result）
- *     └── invoke_agent {id}   （subagent_spawned → subagent_ended）
- *
- * Metrics 监控项：
- *   LLMClient — Chat 类型指标（llm_output 时上报）
- *   GenAIExecuteTool — Tool 类型指标（after_tool_call 时上报）
- */
-
-import type { OpenClawPluginApi } from "openclaw/plugin-sdk/diagnostics-otel";
-import {
-  createTraceLoggerService,
-  getTracer,
-  getGalileoConfig,
-  spanKey,
-  setActiveSpan,
-  getActiveSpanEntry,
-  removeActiveSpan,
-  findActiveSpanByAgentId,
-  nextLlmSeq,
-  getLlmSeq,
-  clearLlmSeq,
-  cleanupOrphanedLlmSeqs,
-  safeAttr,
-  stripPromptMetadata,
-  reportChatMetrics,
-  reportToolMetrics,
-  reportAgentMetrics,
-  registerCleanupCallback,
-  setUserId,
-  getUserId,
-  setCustomAttributes,
-  getCustomAttributes,
-  ROOT_CONTEXT,
-  SpanStatusCode,
-  SpanKind,
-} from "./src/service.js";
-
-// ============================================================================
-// 插件内自行统计的数据结构
-// ============================================================================
-
-const llmStartTimeMap = new Map<string, number>();
-
-interface AccumulatedUsage {
-  inputTokens: number;
-  outputTokens: number;
-}
-const agentUsageMap = new Map<string, AccumulatedUsage>();
-
-interface PendingAgentEnd {
-  span: any;
-  event: any;
-  ctx: any;
-  timestamp: number;
-}
-const pendingAgentEndMap = new Map<string, PendingAgentEnd>();
-const pendingAgentEndTimers = new Map<string, ReturnType<typeof setTimeout>>();
-const PENDING_AGENT_END_TIMEOUT_MS = 30_000;
-
-/**
- * 解析用户 ID，优先级：运行时设置的 userId > 配置文件中的 userId > 从 sessionKey 提取
- */
-function resolveUserId(sessionKey?: string): string {
-  const runtimeUserId = getUserId();
-  if (runtimeUserId) return runtimeUserId;
-  return extractUserIdFromSessionKey(sessionKey) || "";
-}
-
-/**
- * 获取自定义属性，给 key 加上 "custom." 前缀后返回，用于注入 span attributes
- */
-function resolveCustomAttributes(): Record<string, string | number | boolean> {
-  const raw = getCustomAttributes();
-  const result: Record<string, string | number | boolean> = {};
-  for (const [key, value] of Object.entries(raw)) {
-    result[`custom.${key}`] = value;
-  }
-  return result;
-}
-
-// ============================================================================
-// 辅助函数
-// ============================================================================
-
-function extractAgentIdFromSessionKey(sessionKey: string | undefined | null): string {
-  const raw = (sessionKey ?? "").trim();
-  if (!raw) return "";
-  const parts = raw.split(":");
-  if (parts.length >= 2 && parts[0] === "agent") {
-    return parts[1];
-  }
-  return "";
-}
-
-function extractUserIdFromSessionKey(sessionKey: string | undefined | null): string {
-  const raw = (sessionKey ?? "").trim().toLowerCase();
-  if (!raw) return "";
-  const parts = raw.split(":");
-  for (let i = parts.length - 2; i >= 0; i--) {
-    if (parts[i] === "direct" || parts[i] === "group" || parts[i] === "channel") {
-      const peerId = parts.slice(i + 1).join(":");
-      return peerId || "";
-    }
-  }
-  return "";
-}
-
-function extractAssistantTextContent(msg: unknown): string | null {
-  if (!msg || typeof msg !== "object") return null;
-  const m = msg as Record<string, unknown>;
-  if (typeof m.content === "string") return m.content;
-  if (Array.isArray(m.content)) {
-    const texts = m.content
-      .filter((block: unknown) => {
-        if (!block || typeof block !== "object") return false;
-        return (block as Record<string, unknown>).type === "text";
-      })
-      .map((block: unknown) => String((block as Record<string, unknown>).text ?? ""))
-      .filter(Boolean);
-    return texts.length > 0 ? texts.join("\n") : null;
-  }
-  return null;
-}
-
-function extractLastAssistantOutput(messages: unknown): string {
-  if (!Array.isArray(messages) || messages.length === 0) return "";
-  const lastAssistant = messages
-    .slice()
-    .reverse()
-    .find((m: unknown) => {
-      if (!m || typeof m !== "object") return false;
-      return (m as Record<string, unknown>).role === "assistant";
-    });
-  return extractAssistantTextContent(lastAssistant) ?? "";
-}
-
-function finalizeAgentSpan(
-  pending: PendingAgentEnd,
-  agentOutput: string,
-  accumulatedUsage: AccumulatedUsage,
-): void {
-  const { span, event, ctx } = pending;
-  const agentKey = spanKey("agent", ctx.sessionKey || ctx.sessionId);
-
-  agentUsageMap.delete(agentKey);
-
-  span.addEvent("gen_ai.invoke_agent_response", {
-    "message.detail": agentOutput,
-  });
-
-  span.setAttributes({
-    "openclaw.duration_ms": event.durationMs ?? 0,
-    "gen_ai.usage.input_tokens": accumulatedUsage.inputTokens,
-    "gen_ai.usage.output_tokens": accumulatedUsage.outputTokens,
-  });
-
-  if (!event.success && event.error) {
-    span.setStatus({ code: SpanStatusCode.ERROR, message: String(event.error) });
-    span.setAttribute("error.type", String(event.error));
-  }
-  span.end();
-
-  const galileoCfg = getGalileoConfig();
-  if (galileoCfg?.metrics.enabled) {
-    const genAi = galileoCfg.genAi;
-    const durationMs = event.durationMs ?? 0;
-    const durationSec = durationMs / 1000;
-
-    reportAgentMetrics({
-      provider: genAi.system,
-      userId: resolveUserId(ctx.sessionKey),
-      agentName: genAi.agentName,
-      agentId: genAi.agentId,
-      appName: genAi.appName,
-      isStream: true,
-      promptTokens: accumulatedUsage.inputTokens,
-      completionTokens: accumulatedUsage.outputTokens,
-      firstTokenLatency: 0,
-      operationDuration: durationSec,
-      errorType: event.error ? String(event.error) : undefined,
-    });
-  }
-}
-
-const plugin = {
-  id: "openclaw-telemetry-galileo-embedded",
-  name: "OpenClaw Telemetry Galileo (Embedded)",
-  description:
-    "开发者内部版：将 OpenClaw 所有调用链路（LLM / Tool / Subagent）串联为完整 OTLP trace，" +
-    "按伽利略 Agent 协议上报 trace 和 metrics。配置从 galileo.config.json 读取。",
-
-  register(api: OpenClawPluginApi) {
-    // 注册 OTLP Provider 生命周期服务（不传 pluginConfig，从配置文件读取）
-    api.registerService(createTraceLoggerService());
-
-    // ================================================================
-    // 1. before_agent_start
-    // ================================================================
-    api.on("before_agent_start", (event: any, ctx: any) => {
-      const tracer = getTracer();
-      if (!tracer) return;
-
-      const galileoCfg = getGalileoConfig();
-      const genAi = galileoCfg?.genAi;
-
-      const agentName = genAi?.agentName || ctx.agentId || "openclaw-agent";
-      const agentKey = spanKey("agent", ctx.sessionKey || ctx.sessionId);
-
-      const span = tracer.startSpan(
-        `invoke_agent ${agentName}`,
-        {
-          kind: SpanKind.CLIENT,
-          attributes: {
-            "gen_ai.operation.name": "invoke_agent",
-            "gen_ai.system": genAi?.system || "openclaw",
-            "gen_ai.agent.name": agentName,
-            "gen_ai.agent.id": genAi?.agentId || ctx.agentId || "",
-            "gen_ai.app.name": genAi?.appName || "openclaw",
-            "gen_ai.conversation.id": ctx.sessionId || "",
-            "gen_ai.user.id": resolveUserId(ctx.sessionKey),
-            "gen_ai.is_stream": true,
-            "openclaw.session_key": ctx.sessionKey ?? "",
-            "openclaw.session_id": ctx.sessionId ?? "",
-            "openclaw.trigger": ctx.trigger ?? "",
-            "openclaw.channel_id": ctx.channelId ?? "",
-            ...resolveCustomAttributes(),
-          },
-        },
-        ROOT_CONTEXT,
-      );
-
-      span.addEvent("gen_ai.invoke_agent_request", {
-        "message.detail": stripPromptMetadata(event.prompt ?? ""),
-      });
-
-      setActiveSpan(agentKey, span, ROOT_CONTEXT);
-    });
-
-    // ================================================================
-    // 2. llm_input
-    // ================================================================
-    api.on("llm_input", (event: any, ctx: any) => {
-      const tracer = getTracer();
-      if (!tracer) return;
-
-      const galileoCfg = getGalileoConfig();
-      const genAi = galileoCfg?.genAi;
-
-      const runId = event.runId || ctx.sessionId || "unknown";
-      const agentKey = spanKey("agent", ctx.sessionKey || ctx.sessionId);
-      const seq = nextLlmSeq(runId);
-      const llmKey = spanKey("llm", runId, String(seq));
-      const model = event.model || "unknown";
-
-      const parentEntry = getActiveSpanEntry(agentKey);
-      const parentCtx = parentEntry?.ctx ?? ROOT_CONTEXT;
-
-      const span = tracer.startSpan(
-        `chat ${model}`,
-        {
-          kind: SpanKind.CLIENT,
-          attributes: {
-            "gen_ai.operation.name": "chat",
-            "gen_ai.system": event.provider || genAi?.system || "openclaw",
-            "gen_ai.request.model": model,
-            "gen_ai.app.name": genAi?.appName || "openclaw",
-            "gen_ai.conversation.id": ctx.sessionId || "",
-            "gen_ai.user.id": resolveUserId(ctx.sessionKey),
-            "gen_ai.is_stream": true,
-            "openclaw.run_id": runId,
-            "openclaw.session_id": ctx.sessionId ?? "",
-            "openclaw.provider": event.provider ?? "",
-            "openclaw.model": model,
-            "openclaw.llm.seq": seq,
-            ...resolveCustomAttributes(),
-          },
-        },
-        parentCtx,
-      );
-
-      if (event.systemPrompt) {
-        span.addEvent("gen_ai.system.message", {
-          "message.detail": safeAttr({
-            content: event.systemPrompt,
-            role: "system",
-          }),
-        });
-      }
-
-      span.addEvent("gen_ai.user.message", {
-        "message.detail": safeAttr({
-          content: stripPromptMetadata(event.prompt ?? ""),
-          role: "user",
-        }),
-      });
-
-      const startTime = Date.now();
-      span.setAttribute("openclaw.start_time_ms", startTime);
-      llmStartTimeMap.set(llmKey, startTime);
-
-      setActiveSpan(llmKey, span, parentCtx);
-    });
-
-    // ================================================================
-    // 3. llm_output
-    // ================================================================
-    api.on("llm_output", (event: any, ctx: any) => {
-      const runId = event.runId || ctx.sessionId || "unknown";
-      // 直接从 llmSeqByRun 获取当前 seq，避免从 100 倒序遍历
-      const currentSeq = getLlmSeq(runId);
-
-      if (currentSeq === 0) {
-        // 收集需要删除的 key，避免在 forEach 中直接删除
-        const prefix = `llm:${runId}:`;
-        const keysToDelete: string[] = [];
-        llmStartTimeMap.forEach((_v, key) => {
-          if (key.startsWith(prefix)) {
-            keysToDelete.push(key);
-          }
-        });
-        for (const key of keysToDelete) {
-          llmStartTimeMap.delete(key);
-        }
-        return;
-      }
-
-      const llmKey = spanKey("llm", runId, String(currentSeq));
-      const entry = removeActiveSpan(llmKey);
-      if (!entry) return;
-
-      const { span } = entry;
-      const inputTokens = event.usage?.input ?? 0;
-      const outputTokens = event.usage?.output ?? 0;
-
-      const startTimeMs = llmStartTimeMap.get(llmKey) ?? 0;
-      llmStartTimeMap.delete(llmKey);
-      const computedDurationMs = startTimeMs > 0 ? Date.now() - startTimeMs : 0;
-
-      const agentKey = spanKey("agent", ctx.sessionKey || ctx.sessionId);
-      const accumulated = agentUsageMap.get(agentKey) ?? { inputTokens: 0, outputTokens: 0 };
-      accumulated.inputTokens += inputTokens;
-      accumulated.outputTokens += outputTokens;
-      agentUsageMap.set(agentKey, accumulated);
-
-      span.setAttributes({
-        "gen_ai.response.model": event.model || "",
-        "gen_ai.usage.input_tokens": inputTokens,
-        "gen_ai.usage.output_tokens": outputTokens,
-        "gen_ai.response.finish_reasons": "stop",
-        "openclaw.tokens.input": inputTokens,
-        "openclaw.tokens.output": outputTokens,
-        "openclaw.tokens.cache_read": event.usage?.cacheRead ?? 0,
-        "openclaw.tokens.cache_write": event.usage?.cacheWrite ?? 0,
-        "openclaw.tokens.total": event.usage?.total ?? 0,
-      });
-
-      const outputContent =
-        (event.assistantTexts?.length ? event.assistantTexts.join("\n") : null) ??
-        extractAssistantTextContent(event.lastAssistant) ??
-        "";
-      span.addEvent("gen_ai.choice", {
-        "message.detail": safeAttr({
-          index: 0,
-          finish_reason: "stop",
-          message: { content: outputContent, role: "assistant" },
-        }),
-      });
-
-      if (computedDurationMs > 0) {
-        span.setAttribute("gen_ai.client.operation.duration", computedDurationMs / 1000);
-      }
-
-      span.end();
-
-      const computedDurationSec = computedDurationMs / 1000;
-
-      const pending = pendingAgentEndMap.get(agentKey);
-      if (pending) {
-        pendingAgentEndMap.delete(agentKey);
-        const timer = pendingAgentEndTimers.get(agentKey);
-        if (timer) {
-          clearTimeout(timer);
-          pendingAgentEndTimers.delete(agentKey);
-        }
-        const agentOutput =
-          (event.assistantTexts?.length ? event.assistantTexts.join("\n") : null) ??
-          extractAssistantTextContent(event.lastAssistant) ??
-          "";
-        finalizeAgentSpan(pending, agentOutput, accumulated);
-        clearLlmSeq(runId);
-      }
-
-      const galileoCfg = getGalileoConfig();
-      if (galileoCfg?.metrics.enabled) {
-        const genAi = galileoCfg.genAi;
-        const firstTokenLatency = computedDurationSec;
-
-        reportChatMetrics({
-          provider: event.provider || genAi.system,
-          requestModel: event.model || "",
-          responseModel: event.model || "",
-          isStream: false,
-          userId: resolveUserId(ctx.sessionKey),
-          agentName: genAi.agentName,
-          agentId: genAi.agentId,
-          appName: genAi.appName,
-          promptTokens: inputTokens,
-          completionTokens: outputTokens,
-          firstTokenLatency,
-          operationDuration: computedDurationSec,
-        });
-      }
-    });
-
-    // ================================================================
-    // 4. before_tool_call
-    // ================================================================
-    api.on("before_tool_call", (event: any, ctx: any) => {
-      const tracer = getTracer();
-      if (!tracer) return;
-
-      const galileoCfg = getGalileoConfig();
-      const genAi = galileoCfg?.genAi;
-
-      const toolCallId = event.toolCallId || event.toolName;
-      const runId = event.runId || ctx.runId || "unknown";
-      const toolKey = spanKey("tool", runId, toolCallId);
-      const agentKey = spanKey("agent", ctx.sessionKey || ctx.sessionId);
-
-      const parentEntry = getActiveSpanEntry(agentKey);
-      const parentCtx = parentEntry?.ctx ?? ROOT_CONTEXT;
-
-      const span = tracer.startSpan(
-        `execute_tool ${event.toolName}`,
-        {
-          kind: SpanKind.CLIENT,
-          attributes: {
-            "gen_ai.operation.name": "execute_tool",
-            "gen_ai.tool.name": event.toolName ?? "",
-            "gen_ai.tool.call.id": event.toolCallId ?? "",
-            "gen_ai.app.name": genAi?.appName || "openclaw",
-            "gen_ai.conversation.id": ctx.sessionId || "",
-            "gen_ai.user.id": resolveUserId(ctx.sessionKey),
-            "openclaw.run_id": runId,
-            "openclaw.session_id": ctx.sessionId ?? "",
-            ...resolveCustomAttributes(),
-          },
-        },
-        parentCtx,
-      );
-
-      span.addEvent("gen_ai.tool_call_args", {
-        "message.detail": safeAttr(event.params),
-      });
-
-      span.setAttribute("openclaw.start_time_ms", Date.now());
-
-      setActiveSpan(toolKey, span, parentCtx);
-    });
-
-    // ================================================================
-    // 5. after_tool_call
-    // ================================================================
-    api.on("after_tool_call", (event: any, ctx: any) => {
-      const toolCallId = event.toolCallId || event.toolName;
-      const runId = event.runId || ctx.runId || "unknown";
-      const toolKey = spanKey("tool", runId, toolCallId);
-
-      const entry = removeActiveSpan(toolKey);
-      if (!entry) return;
-
-      const { span } = entry;
-
-      span.addEvent("gen_ai.tool_response", {
-        "message.detail": safeAttr(event.result),
-      });
-
-      span.setAttributes({
-        "openclaw.duration_ms": event.durationMs ?? 0,
-      });
-
-      if (event.error) {
-        span.setStatus({ code: SpanStatusCode.ERROR, message: String(event.error) });
-        span.setAttribute("error.type", String(event.error));
-      }
-      span.end();
-
-      const galileoCfg = getGalileoConfig();
-      if (galileoCfg?.metrics.enabled) {
-        const genAi = galileoCfg.genAi;
-        const durationMs = event.durationMs ?? 0;
-        const durationSec = durationMs / 1000;
-
-        reportToolMetrics({
-          provider: genAi.system,
-          toolName: event.toolName || "",
-          userId: resolveUserId(ctx.sessionKey),
-          agentName: genAi.agentName,
-          agentId: genAi.agentId,
-          appName: genAi.appName,
-          operationDuration: durationSec,
-          codeType: event.error ? "exception" : "success",
-          errorType: event.error ? String(event.error) : undefined,
-        });
-      }
-    });
-
-    // ================================================================
-    // 6. subagent_spawned
-    // ================================================================
-    api.on("subagent_spawned", (event: any, ctx: any) => {
-      const tracer = getTracer();
-      if (!tracer) return;
-
-      const galileoCfg = getGalileoConfig();
-      const genAi = galileoCfg?.genAi;
-
-      const subagentKey = spanKey("subagent", event.childSessionKey);
-      const agentKey = spanKey("agent", ctx.requesterSessionKey || ctx.childSessionKey);
-      const requesterAgentId = extractAgentIdFromSessionKey(ctx.requesterSessionKey);
-      const parentEntry =
-        getActiveSpanEntry(agentKey) ??
-        (requesterAgentId ? findActiveSpanByAgentId(requesterAgentId) : undefined);
-      const parentCtx = parentEntry?.ctx ?? ROOT_CONTEXT;
-
-      const span = tracer.startSpan(
-        `invoke_agent ${event.agentId}`,
-        {
-          kind: SpanKind.CLIENT,
-          attributes: {
-            "gen_ai.operation.name": "invoke_agent",
-            "gen_ai.system": genAi?.system || "openclaw",
-            "gen_ai.agent.name": event.agentId ?? "",
-            "gen_ai.agent.id": event.agentId ?? "",
-            "gen_ai.app.name": genAi?.appName || "openclaw",
-            "gen_ai.conversation.id": ctx.sessionId || event.childSessionKey || "",
-            "openclaw.subagent.run_id": event.runId ?? "",
-            "openclaw.subagent.mode": event.mode ?? "",
-            "openclaw.subagent.label": event.label ?? "",
-            ...resolveCustomAttributes(),
-          },
-        },
-        parentCtx,
-      );
-
-      span.addEvent("gen_ai.invoke_agent_request", {
-        "message.detail": safeAttr({
-          agentId: event.agentId,
-          mode: event.mode,
-          label: event.label,
-        }),
-      });
-
-      setActiveSpan(subagentKey, span, parentCtx);
-    });
-
-    // ================================================================
-    // 7. subagent_ended
-    // ================================================================
-    api.on("subagent_ended", (event: any, ctx: any) => {
-      const subagentKey = spanKey("subagent", event.targetSessionKey);
-      const entry = removeActiveSpan(subagentKey);
-      if (!entry) return;
-
-      const { span } = entry;
-
-      span.addEvent("gen_ai.invoke_agent_response", {
-        "message.detail": safeAttr({
-          reason: event.reason,
-          outcome: event.outcome,
-        }),
-      });
-
-      if (event.outcome === "error" || event.outcome === "timeout") {
-        const errorMessage = event.error ? String(event.error) : event.outcome;
-        span.setStatus({
-          code: SpanStatusCode.ERROR,
-          message: errorMessage,
-        });
-        span.setAttribute("error.type", errorMessage);
-      }
-      span.end();
-    });
-
-    // ================================================================
-    // 8. agent_end
-    // ================================================================
-    api.on("agent_end", (event: any, ctx: any) => {
-      const agentKey = spanKey("agent", ctx.sessionKey || ctx.sessionId);
-      const entry = removeActiveSpan(agentKey);
-      if (!entry) return;
-
-      const { span } = entry;
-
-      pendingAgentEndMap.set(agentKey, {
-        span,
-        event,
-        ctx,
-        timestamp: Date.now(),
-      });
-
-      const timer = setTimeout(() => {
-        pendingAgentEndTimers.delete(agentKey);
-        if (!pendingAgentEndMap.has(agentKey)) return;
-        const p = pendingAgentEndMap.get(agentKey)!;
-        pendingAgentEndMap.delete(agentKey);
-        console.warn(
-          `[openclaw-telemetry-galileo-embedded][warn] llm_output 超时未到达，兜底关闭 agent span`,
-        );
-        const fallbackOutput = extractLastAssistantOutput(p.event.messages);
-        const fallbackUsage = agentUsageMap.get(agentKey) ?? { inputTokens: 0, outputTokens: 0 };
-        finalizeAgentSpan(p, fallbackOutput, fallbackUsage);
-        cleanupOrphanedLlmSeqs();
-      }, PENDING_AGENT_END_TIMEOUT_MS);
-      // 不阻止进程正常退出
-      if (timer && typeof timer.unref === "function") {
-        timer.unref();
-      }
-      pendingAgentEndTimers.set(agentKey, timer);
-    });
-
-    registerCleanupCallback(() => {
-      llmStartTimeMap.clear();
-      agentUsageMap.clear();
-      pendingAgentEndTimers.forEach((t) => clearTimeout(t));
-      pendingAgentEndTimers.clear();
-      pendingAgentEndMap.clear();
-    });
-
-    api.logger.info(
-      "[openclaw-telemetry-galileo-embedded] 已注册所有 typed hook（伽利略协议模式）: " +
-        "before_agent_start, llm_input, llm_output, " +
-        "before_tool_call, after_tool_call, " +
-        "subagent_spawned, subagent_ended, agent_end",
-    );
-
-    const q36 = process.env.OPENCLAW_TELEMETRY_GALIELO_QIEMI36;
-    const guid = process.env.OPENCLAW_TELEMETRY_GALIELO_GUID;
-    if (q36 && guid) {
-      setUserId(q36);
-      setCustomAttributes({ qimei36: q36, guid });
-    } else {
-      api.logger.warn(
-        "[openclaw-telemetry-galileo-embedded] 未设置 OPENCLAW_TELEMETRY_GALIELO_QIEMI36 和 OPENCLAW_TELEMETRY_GALIELO_GUID 环境变量，" +
-          "将无法上报到伽利略",
-      );
-    }
-  },
-};
-
-export default plugin;
-
-// 导出运行时设置接口，供外部代码动态设置用户 ID 和自定义属性
-export { setUserId, getUserId, setCustomAttributes, getCustomAttributes };