@pzy560117/opentest 0.1.12 → 0.1.14

package/assets/manifest.json

@@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
 {
-  "version": "0.1.12",
+  "version": "0.1.14",
   "languages": [
     {
       "id": "en",
@@ -70,6 +70,7 @@
       "opentest/references/matrix-format.md",
       "opentest/references/opentest-driven-development.md",
       "opentest/references/quality-gate.md",
+      "opentest/references/rules-precedence.md",
       "opentest/references/test-asset-layout.md",
       "opentest/references/test-surfaces.md",
       "opentest/references/web-browser-testing.md",

package/assets/skills/opentest/SKILL.md

@@ -1,17 +1,19 @@
 ---
 name: opentest
-description: "OpenTest router entry: detect .opentest.yaml, initialize lifecycle state, and route to plan/author/run/accept/verify/heal/archive."
+description: "OpenTest router."
 ---
 
 # OpenTest
 
-OpenTest turns change requirements into a test-evidence lifecycle before implementation work proceeds.
+OpenTest is the single user entry for phase and adapter routing.
 
 ## Required references
 
 - `opentest/references/command-routing.md`
 - `opentest/references/lifecycle.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
+- `opentest/references/test-surfaces.md`
 
 ## Bootstrap
 
@@ -22,12 +24,12 @@ OPENTEST_GUARD="${OPENTEST_GUARD:-$(find "${OPENTEST_SEARCH_ROOTS[@]}" -path '*/
 OPENTEST_DETECT="${OPENTEST_DETECT:-$(find "${OPENTEST_SEARCH_ROOTS[@]}" -path '*/opentest/scripts/opentest-detect.sh' -type f -print -quit 2>/dev/null)}"
 ```
 
-If any script is missing, stop and ask the user to install OpenTest.
+Stop if scripts are missing.
 
 ## Route
 
 1. If `.opentest.yaml` is missing, run `bash "$OPENTEST_STATE" init`.
 2. Run `bash "$OPENTEST_STATE" check` and `bash "$OPENTEST_DETECT" summary`.
-3. Read `phase` with `bash "$OPENTEST_STATE" get phase`.
-4. Dispatch to `opentest-plan`, `opentest-author`, `opentest-run`, `opentest-accept`, `opentest-verify`, `opentest-heal`, or `opentest-archive`.
-5. Keep generated user-facing artifacts in the installed skill language.
+3. Dispatch by `phase` to `opentest-plan`, `opentest-author`, `opentest-run`, `opentest-accept`, `opentest-verify`, `opentest-heal`, or `opentest-archive`.
+4. `plan/run/accept` choose adapters from matrix surface: `web-browser`, `android-app`, `desktop-gui`, or `api`.
+5. Ask only when surface cannot be inferred. Use installed skill language.

package/assets/skills/opentest/references/rules-precedence.md

@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
+# Rules Precedence
+
+OpenTest is a testing lifecycle skill. When a project invokes OpenTest or has an active `.opentest.yaml`, the selected execution surface defines the required evidence chain.
+
+Project or global rules that say not to create test-framework code by default are restraint rules for ad hoc acceptance. They prevent unnecessary scaffolding before a testing workflow is selected. They do not disable OpenTest evidence contracts.
+
+Once a matrix row selects an execution surface, its framework route is part of required evidence:
+
+- `android-app`: `pytest` is the user-facing orchestration entry. `android-midscene-pytest`, ADB, screenshots, logcat, and Midscene reports are evidence contracts, not optional scaffolding.
+- `web-browser`: `instant-acceptance` can use MCP or Playwright CLI; `durable-regression` uses the project E2E framework or `@playwright/test`.
+- `api`: project API commands are preferred; without them, use `pytest` with HTTP/schema/fixture evidence.
+- `desktop-gui`: use project GUI automation or `@midscene/computer` when visual desktop automation is required.
+
+Do not set `test_framework: none` to satisfy a generic framework-restraint rule while the matrix requires a framework-backed execution surface. If a project rule explicitly forbids the required framework, record the conflict as `blocked` or ask for a decision. Do not silently downgrade required evidence.
+
+`test_framework: none` is valid only when the matrix has no framework-backed execution surface and no required evidence that depends on pytest, Playwright, Midscene, or a project test harness.

package/assets/skills/opentest/scripts/opentest-guard.sh

@@ -52,6 +52,39 @@ check_result() {
   fi
 }
 
+matrix_path() {
+  yaml_field matrix
+}
+
+matrix_has() {
+  local pattern="$1"
+  local matrix
+  matrix=$(matrix_path)
+  file_nonempty "$matrix" && grep -Eqi "$pattern" "$matrix"
+}
+
+framework_matches_matrix() {
+  local framework
+  framework=$(yaml_field test_framework)
+  framework="${framework:-pytest}"
+
+  if matrix_has 'android-app|opentest-android-app|android-midscene-pytest'; then
+    if [ "$framework" != "pytest" ]; then
+      red "  [FAIL] android-app execution surface requires test_framework=pytest"
+      return 1
+    fi
+  fi
+
+  if [ "$framework" = "none" ]; then
+    if matrix_has 'python[[:space:]]+-m[[:space:]]+pytest|pytest report|pytest 报告|@playwright/test|npx[[:space:]]+playwright[[:space:]]+test|durable-regression|midscene|opentest-api|opentest-desktop-gui'; then
+      red "  [FAIL] test_framework=none conflicts with framework-backed matrix evidence"
+      return 1
+    fi
+  fi
+
+  return 0
+}
+
 result_is_archivable() {
   local result
   result=$(yaml_field verification_result)
@@ -61,6 +94,7 @@ result_is_archivable() {
 guard_plan() {
   check_path "plan exists" "$(yaml_field plan)"
   check_path "matrix exists" "$(yaml_field matrix)"
+  check_result "test_framework matches matrix execution surfaces" framework_matches_matrix
 }
 
 guard_author() {
@@ -73,10 +107,12 @@ guard_author() {
   else
     check_path "matrix exists for recorded gaps" "$matrix"
   fi
+  check_result "test_framework matches matrix execution surfaces" framework_matches_matrix
 }
 
 guard_run() {
   check_path "run report exists" "$(yaml_field run_report)"
+  check_result "test_framework matches matrix execution surfaces" framework_matches_matrix
 }
 
 guard_accept() {
@@ -89,6 +125,7 @@ guard_accept() {
   else
     check_path "run report exists for recorded no-acceptance path" "$run_report"
   fi
+  check_result "test_framework matches matrix execution surfaces" framework_matches_matrix
 }
 
 guard_verify() {

package/assets/skills/opentest-accept/SKILL.md

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 ---
 name: opentest-accept
-description: "OpenTest phase 4: execute acceptance and write back evidence."
+description: "OpenTest phase 4: execute acceptance and evidence."
 ---
 
 # OpenTest Accept
@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ Write PASS, FAIL, or blocked evidence to cases and matrix.
 
 - `opentest/references/acceptance-evidence.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-surfaces.md`
 - `opentest/references/android-app-testing.md`
 - `opentest/references/web-browser-testing.md`
@@ -25,10 +26,10 @@ Write PASS, FAIL, or blocked evidence to cases and matrix.
 
 1. Read the matrix, fixtures, and `docs/opentest/acceptance/`.
 2. Select the acceptance tool from the matrix execution surface.
-3. For `web-browser`, use `opentest-web-browser`: Playwright MCP/CLI, `@playwright/test` for durable regression, Midscene only for visual assist.
-4. For `android-app`, use `opentest-android-app` and `android-midscene-pytest`: `python -m pytest tests_py -v`, ADB smoke, Midscene HTML, logcat, and `midscene_run`; block missing prerequisites.
-5. For `desktop-gui`, use `opentest-desktop-gui`: project GUI automation or `@midscene/computer`, screenshot/recording, metadata, and read-back.
-6. For `api`, use `opentest-api`: project API command or `pytest` with `httpx`/`requests`, schema checks, fixtures, read-after-write, and cleanup/teardown.
+3. `web-browser`: Playwright MCP/CLI; `@playwright/test` for durable regression; Midscene only for visual assist.
+4. `android-app`: `opentest-android-app` plus `android-midscene-pytest`, `python -m pytest tests_py -v`, ADB smoke, Midscene HTML, logcat, and `midscene_run`; block missing prerequisites.
+5. `desktop-gui`: `opentest-desktop-gui`, project GUI automation or `@midscene/computer`, screenshot/recording, metadata, and read-back.
+6. `api`: `opentest-api`, project API command or `pytest` with `httpx`/`requests`, schema, fixtures, read-after-write, and cleanup/teardown.
 7. For CRUD/data changes, execute the full chain from the workflow reference.
 8. Record feedback location/shape, artifacts, blocked evidence, and matching ACC IDs.
 9. Update acceptance records and run `bash "$OPENTEST_GUARD" accept --apply`.

package/assets/skills/opentest-author/SKILL.md

@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ Turn the matrix into executable tests, fixtures, seed/teardown notes, and accept
 
 - `opentest/references/opentest-driven-development.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-asset-layout.md`
 - `opentest/templates/fixtures-template.md`
 - `opentest/templates/acceptance-template.md`
@@ -19,7 +20,7 @@ Turn the matrix into executable tests, fixtures, seed/teardown notes, and accept
 
 1. Read `matrix` and `fixtures` from `.opentest.yaml`.
 2. Preserve each row's requirement source and expected behavior. Do not rewrite acceptance cases around current implementation names, component internals, or existing test files.
-3. Place assets in the fixed layout from `test-asset-layout.md`; default to pytest under `tests/` when no project framework exists. Missing implementation means evidence stays pending.
+3. Place assets in the fixed layout from `test-asset-layout.md`; default to pytest under `tests/` when no project framework exists, and do not convert required framework evidence to `none`. Missing implementation means evidence stays pending.
 4. Create/update fixtures, seed, teardown, users, roles, entities, files/images, and assertion surfaces.
 5. For CRUD/data changes, author the full acceptance flow: create -> list -> detail -> update -> read back -> delete -> confirm absence -> teardown.
 6. Record any gap/blocker with reason and risk.

package/assets/skills/opentest-plan/SKILL.md

@@ -1,17 +1,16 @@
 ---
 name: opentest-plan
-description: "OpenTest phase 1: create test strategy and acceptance matrix."
+description: "OpenTest phase 1: create strategy and matrix."
 ---
 
 # OpenTest Plan
 
-Create plan, matrix, and fixtures before implementation.
-
 ## Required references
 
 - `opentest/references/codex-harness-coverage-heuristics.md`
 - `opentest/references/matrix-format.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-asset-layout.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-surfaces.md`
 - `opentest/references/android-app-testing.md`
@@ -21,14 +20,15 @@ Create plan, matrix, and fixtures before implementation.
 
 ## Steps
 
-1. Read rules, requirements/diff, commands, and detection output.
-2. Treat requirements and risks as sources; inspect current code only for project facts.
-3. Apply CRUD baseline and test data rules for data-writing/API/form/file/stateful changes.
-4. Classify execution surface and evidence layer separately: `web-browser`, `android-app`, `desktop-gui`, or `api`; use `opentest-android-app`, web modes, `opentest-desktop-gui`, and `opentest-api` where applicable.
-5. Produce a requirement-first matrix with source, behavior, surface, mode, evidence, command, gap/blocker, status, and fixed layout.
-6. Write `.opentest.yaml` fields: `plan`, `matrix`, `fixtures`.
-7. Update handoff if present, then run `bash "$OPENTEST_GUARD" plan --apply`.
+1. Read rules, req/diff, commands, detect output, and `rules-precedence.md`.
+2. Treat requirements and risks as sources; use current code only for project facts.
+3. Apply CRUD baseline and test data for data/API/form/file/state changes.
+4. Classify execution surface and evidence layer separately: `web-browser`, `android-app`, `desktop-gui`, or `api`.
+5. If rules restrain frameworks, decide whether OpenTest's surface is the explicit framework requirement; conflicts are blocker, not `test_framework: none`.
+6. Produce a requirement-first matrix with source, behavior, surface, mode, evidence, command, gap, status, and layout.
+7. Write `.opentest.yaml`: `plan`, `matrix`, `fixtures`, and surface-consistent `test_framework`.
+8. Update handoff if present, then run `bash "$OPENTEST_GUARD" plan --apply`.
 
 ## Gate
 
-Every behavior, failure path, boundary, and risk needs evidence or gap/blocker. Every row cites a source and includes surface plus evidence layer; web rows include acceptance mode. Do not use unit/component/integration/contract/smoke as the execution surface. Do not drop or narrow acceptance because current code has no matching file.
+Every behavior, failure path, boundary, and risk needs evidence or gap/blocker. Every row cites source, surface, and evidence layer; web rows include mode. `test_framework` must match routes; `android-app` uses `pytest`, never `none`. Do not use unit/component/integration/contract/smoke as surface. Do not drop or narrow acceptance because current code has no matching file.

package/assets/skills/opentest-run/SKILL.md

@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ Run matrix-driven commands and write reports under `docs/opentest/runs/`.
 
 - `opentest/references/command-routing.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-asset-layout.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-surfaces.md`
 - `opentest/references/android-app-testing.md`

package/assets/skills-zh/opentest/SKILL.md

@@ -1,17 +1,19 @@
 ---
 name: opentest
-description: "OpenTest 路由入口。自动检测 .opentest.yaml、初始化生命周期状态，并分发到 plan/author/run/accept/verify/heal/archive。"
+description: "OpenTest 路由：状态检测、阶段分发和执行面 adapter 选择。"
 ---
 
 # OpenTest
 
-OpenTest 在实现前把需求转成测试证据生命周期。
+OpenTest 把需求转成测试证据生命周期。用户只触发 OpenTest；AI 自动选择阶段 skill 和执行面 adapter。
 
 ## 必读引用
 
 - `opentest/references/command-routing.md`
 - `opentest/references/lifecycle.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
+- `opentest/references/test-surfaces.md`
 
 ## 启动
 
@@ -28,6 +30,6 @@ OPENTEST_DETECT="${OPENTEST_DETECT:-$(find "${OPENTEST_SEARCH_ROOTS[@]}" -path '
 
 1. 若 `.opentest.yaml` 不存在，运行 `bash "$OPENTEST_STATE" init`。
 2. 运行 `bash "$OPENTEST_STATE" check` 和 `bash "$OPENTEST_DETECT" summary`。
-3. 用 `bash "$OPENTEST_STATE" get phase` 读取阶段。
-4. 分发到 `opentest-plan`、`opentest-author`、`opentest-run`、`opentest-accept`、`opentest-verify`、`opentest-heal` 或 `opentest-archive`。
-5. 面向人的产物使用已安装的 skill 语言。
+3. 按 `phase` 分发到 `opentest-plan`、`opentest-author`、`opentest-run`、`opentest-accept`、`opentest-verify`、`opentest-heal` 或 `opentest-archive`。
+4. `plan/run/accept` 按矩阵执行面自动选择 adapter：`web-browser` -> `opentest-web-browser`，`android-app` -> `opentest-android-app`，`desktop-gui` -> `opentest-desktop-gui`，`api` -> `opentest-api`。
+5. 除非无法推断执行面，不要让用户手动选择 adapter。使用已安装的 skill 语言。

package/assets/skills-zh/opentest/references/rules-precedence.md

@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
+# 规则优先级
+
+OpenTest 是测试生命周期 skill。项目触发 OpenTest，或存在活跃的 `.opentest.yaml` 时，已选执行面决定必需证据链。
+
+全局或项目规则里的“不默认创建测试框架代码”是临时验收的克制规则。它用于避免在未选择测试流程前过早铺脚手架，不用于关闭 OpenTest 的证据契约。
+
+矩阵行一旦选择执行面，对应框架路线就是必需证据的一部分：
+
+- `android-app`：`pytest` 是面向用户的编排入口。`android-midscene-pytest`、ADB、截图、logcat 和 Midscene 报告是证据契约，不是可选脚手架。
+- `web-browser`：`instant-acceptance` 可以用 MCP 或 Playwright CLI；`durable-regression` 使用项目 E2E 框架或 `@playwright/test`。
+- `api`：优先项目 API 命令；没有项目命令时，用 `pytest` 搭配 HTTP、schema 和 fixture 证据。
+- `desktop-gui`：优先项目 GUI 自动化；需要视觉桌面自动化时使用 `@midscene/computer`。
+
+不得为了满足泛化的框架克制规则，把 `test_framework` 设为 `none`，同时又在矩阵里要求框架支撑的执行面。如果项目规则明确禁止必需框架，记录为 `blocked` 或请求裁决；不要静默降级必需证据。
+
+只有当矩阵没有框架支撑的执行面，也没有依赖 pytest、Playwright、Midscene 或项目测试 harness 的必需证据时，`test_framework: none` 才是有效声明。

package/assets/skills-zh/opentest-accept/SKILL.md

@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ description: "OpenTest 阶段 4：执行自然语言验收、MCP 验收或真实
 
 - `opentest/references/acceptance-evidence.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-surfaces.md`
 - `opentest/references/android-app-testing.md`
 - `opentest/references/web-browser-testing.md`

package/assets/skills-zh/opentest-author/SKILL.md

@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ description: "OpenTest 阶段 2：根据矩阵补齐测试资产、fixtures 和
 
 - `opentest/references/opentest-driven-development.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-asset-layout.md`
 - `opentest/templates/fixtures-template.md`
 - `opentest/templates/acceptance-template.md`
@@ -19,7 +20,7 @@ description: "OpenTest 阶段 2：根据矩阵补齐测试资产、fixtures 和
 
 1. 读取 `.opentest.yaml` 的 `matrix` 和 `fixtures`。
 2. 保留每条矩阵行的需求来源和期望行为。不要围绕当前实现命名、组件内部结构或已有测试文件重写验收用例。
-3. 资产必须放入 `test-asset-layout.md` 的固定目录；没有项目框架时默认使用 pytest + `tests/`。实现缺失只表示证据 pending。
+3. 资产必须放入 `test-asset-layout.md` 的固定目录；没有项目框架时默认使用 pytest + `tests/`，不得把必需框架证据降级为 `none`。实现缺失只表示证据 pending。
 4. 创建/更新 fixtures、seed、teardown、用户、角色、实体、文件/图片和断言界面。
 5. CRUD/数据变更必须补全链路：新增 -> 列表 -> 详情 -> 修改 -> 回读 -> 删除 -> 确认消失 -> 清理。
 6. 记录 gap/blocker 的原因和风险。

package/assets/skills-zh/opentest-plan/SKILL.md

@@ -12,6 +12,7 @@ description: "OpenTest 阶段 1：分析变更、风险和项目事实，生成
 - `opentest/references/codex-harness-coverage-heuristics.md`
 - `opentest/references/matrix-format.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-asset-layout.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-surfaces.md`
 - `opentest/references/android-app-testing.md`
@@ -21,14 +22,15 @@ description: "OpenTest 阶段 1：分析变更、风险和项目事实，生成
 
 ## 步骤
 
-1. 读取规则、需求/设计/请求/diff、现有命令和 detect 输出。
+1. 读取规则、需求/设计/请求/diff、现有命令、detect 输出和 `rules-precedence.md`。
 2. 把需求、流程、业务规则和风险当成验收来源；读取当前代码只用于发现项目事实，例如命令、路由、框架、fixtures 和 helper。
 3. 数据写入、API、表单、文件或有状态流程默认套用 CRUD 基线和测试数据要求。
 4. 分开判定执行面和证据层级。执行面只能是 `web-browser`、`android-app`、`desktop-gui` 或 `api`；Android 行用 `opentest-android-app`，Web 行必须写验收模式，原生桌面行用 `opentest-desktop-gui`，API 行用 `opentest-api`。
-5. 生成需求先行矩阵，包含来源、行为、执行面、验收模式、证据层级、命令/工具、证据、缺口/阻塞、状态和固定资产目录。
-6. 写入 `.opentest.yaml` 的 `plan`、`matrix`、`fixtures`。
-7. 如存在 handoff，同步 plan/matrix/fixtures 路径，然后运行 `bash "$OPENTEST_GUARD" plan --apply`。
+5. 若项目规则克制测试框架，判断 OpenTest 已选执行面是否构成明确框架要求；冲突写为 blocker，不得静默设为 `test_framework: none`。
+6. 生成需求先行矩阵，包含来源、行为、执行面、验收模式、证据层级、命令/工具、证据、缺口/阻塞、状态和固定资产目录。
+7. 写入 `.opentest.yaml` 的 `plan`、`matrix`、`fixtures` 和与执行面一致的 `test_framework`。
+8. 如存在 handoff，同步 plan/matrix/fixtures 路径，然后运行 `bash "$OPENTEST_GUARD" plan --apply`。
 
 ## 质量门
 
-每个行为、失败路径、边界和风险面都要有证据或 gap/blocker。每行必须引用需求来源，并包含执行面和证据层级；Web 行还要有验收模式。不得把 unit/component/integration/contract/smoke 当执行面。不得因为当前代码没有对应函数、组件、API 或测试文件就删除或缩小验收。CRUD 基线和测试数据默认必需；不适用时在矩阵写明原因。
+每个行为、失败路径、边界和风险面都要有证据或 gap/blocker。每行必须引用需求来源，并包含执行面和证据层级；Web 行还要有验收模式。`test_framework` 必须匹配执行面路线；`android-app` 使用 `pytest`，不得是 `none`。不得把 unit/component/integration/contract/smoke 当执行面。不得因为当前代码没有对应函数、组件、API 或测试文件就删除或缩小验收。CRUD 基线和测试数据默认必需；不适用时在矩阵写明原因。

package/assets/skills-zh/opentest-run/SKILL.md

@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ description: "OpenTest 阶段 3：按 targeted、fast、full、ci-like 或 pre-p
 
 - `opentest/references/command-routing.md`
 - `opentest/references/complete-testing-workflow.md`
+- `opentest/references/rules-precedence.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-asset-layout.md`
 - `opentest/references/test-surfaces.md`
 - `opentest/references/android-app-testing.md`

package/package.json

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 {
   "name": "@pzy560117/opentest",
-  "version": "0.1.12",
+  "version": "0.1.14",
   "description": "OpenTest quality evidence lifecycle skills for Codex",
   "keywords": [
     "opentest",

package/scripts/smoke-test.js

@@ -216,12 +216,35 @@ function assertRequirementFirstAcceptanceContracts() {
   assert(chineseMatrix.includes('需求来源') && chineseMatrix.includes('REQ-001'), '[REQFIRST] Chinese matrix template must include requirement source examples');
   assert(englishPlan.includes('current code only for project facts') && englishPlan.includes('Do not drop or narrow acceptance'), '[REQFIRST] English plan skill must prevent implementation-derived acceptance');
   assert(chinesePlan.includes('读取当前代码只用于发现项目事实') && chinesePlan.includes('不得因为当前代码没有对应函数'), '[REQFIRST] Chinese plan skill must prevent implementation-derived acceptance');
+  assert(englishPlan.includes('rules-precedence.md') && englishPlan.includes('test_framework') && englishPlan.includes('android-app') && englishPlan.includes('never `none`'), '[REQFIRST] English plan skill must gate framework precedence');
+  assert(chinesePlan.includes('rules-precedence.md') && chinesePlan.includes('test_framework') && chinesePlan.includes('android-app') && chinesePlan.includes('不得是 `none`'), '[REQFIRST] Chinese plan skill must gate framework precedence');
   assert(englishAuthor.includes('Missing implementation means evidence stays pending'), '[REQFIRST] English author skill must keep requirements when implementation is missing');
   assert(chineseAuthor.includes('实现缺失只表示证据 pending'), '[REQFIRST] Chinese author skill must keep requirements when implementation is missing');
 }
 
+function assertRulesPrecedenceContracts() {
+  const englishRules = readRequiredText('assets/skills/opentest/references/rules-precedence.md', '[PRECEDENCE] missing English rules-precedence');
+  const chineseRules = readRequiredText('assets/skills-zh/opentest/references/rules-precedence.md', '[PRECEDENCE] missing Chinese rules-precedence');
+  const guardScript = readFileSync('assets/skills/opentest/scripts/opentest-guard.sh', 'utf8');
+  const englishAuthor = readFileSync('assets/skills/opentest-author/SKILL.md', 'utf8');
+  const chineseAuthor = readFileSync('assets/skills-zh/opentest-author/SKILL.md', 'utf8');
+  const englishRun = readFileSync('assets/skills/opentest-run/SKILL.md', 'utf8');
+  const chineseRun = readFileSync('assets/skills-zh/opentest-run/SKILL.md', 'utf8');
+  const englishAccept = readFileSync('assets/skills/opentest-accept/SKILL.md', 'utf8');
+  const chineseAccept = readFileSync('assets/skills-zh/opentest-accept/SKILL.md', 'utf8');
+
+  assert(englishRules.includes('test_framework: none') && englishRules.includes('android-app') && englishRules.includes('blocked'), '[PRECEDENCE] English rules must define none conflict handling');
+  assert(chineseRules.includes('test_framework') && chineseRules.includes('android-app') && chineseRules.includes('blocked'), '[PRECEDENCE] Chinese rules must define none conflict handling');
+  assert(guardScript.includes('framework_matches_matrix') && guardScript.includes('android-app execution surface requires test_framework=pytest') && guardScript.includes('test_framework=none conflicts'), '[PRECEDENCE] guard must block framework/matrix conflicts');
+  assert(englishAuthor.includes('rules-precedence.md') && chineseAuthor.includes('rules-precedence.md'), '[PRECEDENCE] author skills must load rules precedence');
+  assert(englishRun.includes('rules-precedence.md') && chineseRun.includes('rules-precedence.md'), '[PRECEDENCE] run skills must load rules precedence');
+  assert(englishAccept.includes('rules-precedence.md') && chineseAccept.includes('rules-precedence.md'), '[PRECEDENCE] accept skills must load rules precedence');
+}
+
 function assertTestSurfaceContracts() {
   const manifestText = readFileSync('assets/manifest.json', 'utf8');
+  const englishRouter = readFileSync('assets/skills/opentest/SKILL.md', 'utf8');
+  const chineseRouter = readFileSync('assets/skills-zh/opentest/SKILL.md', 'utf8');
   const englishSurfaces = readRequiredText('assets/skills/opentest/references/test-surfaces.md', '[SURFACE] missing English test-surfaces reference');
   const chineseSurfaces = readRequiredText('assets/skills-zh/opentest/references/test-surfaces.md', '[SURFACE] missing Chinese test-surfaces reference');
   const englishMatrixFormat = readFileSync('assets/skills/opentest/references/matrix-format.md', 'utf8');
@@ -245,6 +268,11 @@ function assertTestSurfaceContracts() {
   const surfaces = ['web-browser', 'android-app', 'desktop-gui', 'api'];
 
   assert(manifestText.includes('opentest/references/test-surfaces.md'), '[SURFACE] manifest must ship test-surfaces reference');
+  assert(manifestText.includes('opentest/references/rules-precedence.md'), '[SURFACE] manifest must ship rules-precedence reference');
+  assert(englishRouter.includes('single user entry') && englishRouter.includes('matrix surface') && englishRouter.includes('Ask only when') && englishRouter.includes('surface cannot be inferred'), '[SURFACE] English router must keep single-entry automatic adapter routing');
+  assert(chineseRouter.includes('用户只触发 OpenTest') && chineseRouter.includes('按矩阵执行面自动选择 adapter') && chineseRouter.includes('不要让用户手动选择 adapter'), '[SURFACE] Chinese router must keep single-entry automatic adapter routing');
+  assert(englishRouter.includes('rules-precedence.md'), '[SURFACE] English router must load rules precedence');
+  assert(chineseRouter.includes('rules-precedence.md'), '[SURFACE] Chinese router must load rules precedence');
 
   for (const surface of surfaces) {
     assert(englishSurfaces.includes(surface), `[SURFACE] English test-surfaces missing ${surface}`);
@@ -253,6 +281,8 @@ function assertTestSurfaceContracts() {
     assert(chineseMatrixFormat.includes(surface), `[SURFACE] Chinese matrix-format missing ${surface}`);
     assert(englishMatrix.includes(surface), `[SURFACE] English matrix template missing ${surface}`);
     assert(chineseMatrix.includes(surface), `[SURFACE] Chinese matrix template missing ${surface}`);
+    assert(englishRouter.includes(surface), `[SURFACE] English router missing ${surface}`);
+    assert(chineseRouter.includes(surface), `[SURFACE] Chinese router missing ${surface}`);
   }
 
   assert(englishSurfaces.includes('Do not invent a fifth primary surface'), '[SURFACE] English reference must forbid fifth primary surface');
@@ -919,6 +949,7 @@ assertManifestStructure();
 assertPrepublishGateCoversManifestAssets();
 assertDefaultPytestContracts();
 assertRequirementFirstAcceptanceContracts();
+assertRulesPrecedenceContracts();
 assertTestSurfaceContracts();
 assertAndroidAppContracts();
 assertWebBrowserContracts();