@polymorphism-tech/morph-spec 8.28.0 → 8.31.0

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (185) hide show
  1. package/CLAUDE.md +6 -1
  2. package/README.md +13 -2
  3. package/bin/morph-spec.js +48 -0
  4. package/bin/validate.js +379 -379
  5. package/claude-plugin.json +1 -1
  6. package/docs/CHEATSHEET.md +1 -1
  7. package/docs/QUICKSTART.md +1 -1
  8. package/framework/CLAUDE.md +2 -0
  9. package/framework/MORPH.md +2 -1
  10. package/framework/agents.json +20 -9
  11. package/framework/commands/create-umbraco-lp.md +1 -1
  12. package/framework/commands/morph-status.md +1 -1
  13. package/framework/docs/CLI.md +18 -0
  14. package/framework/evals/rubrics/code-quality.md +17 -0
  15. package/framework/evals/rubrics/condensed.md +3 -1
  16. package/framework/hooks/claude-code/statusline.sh +11 -11
  17. package/framework/hooks/git/commit-msg/conventional-commits.sh +33 -33
  18. package/framework/hooks/git/pre-commit/agents.sh +25 -25
  19. package/framework/hooks/git/pre-commit/orchestrator.sh +64 -64
  20. package/framework/hooks/git/pre-commit/specs.sh +50 -50
  21. package/framework/hooks/git/pre-push/run-tests.sh +44 -44
  22. package/framework/hooks/shared/phase-utils.js +2 -0
  23. package/framework/hooks/shared/stdin-reader.js +26 -26
  24. package/framework/mcp/registry.json +97 -11
  25. package/framework/rubrics/backend.json +2 -2
  26. package/framework/rubrics/default.json +2 -2
  27. package/framework/rubrics/frontend.json +2 -2
  28. package/framework/schemas/tasks.schema.json +25 -0
  29. package/framework/skills/core/create-umbraco-lp/SKILL.md +13 -2
  30. package/framework/skills/core/create-umbraco-lp/references/umbraco-lp-patterns.md +598 -0
  31. package/framework/skills/core/migrate-lp-to-umbraco/SKILL.md +92 -7
  32. package/framework/skills/core/morph-apply/SKILL.md +12 -3
  33. package/framework/skills/core/morph-brainstorming/SKILL.md +1 -1
  34. package/framework/skills/core/morph-eval/SKILL.md +1 -1
  35. package/framework/skills/core/morph-hotfix/SKILL.md +1 -1
  36. package/framework/skills/core/morph-implement/SKILL.md +12 -2
  37. package/framework/skills/core/morph-plan/SKILL.md +45 -3
  38. package/framework/skills/core/morph-proposal/SKILL.md +1 -1
  39. package/framework/skills/core/morph-review/SKILL.md +11 -3
  40. package/framework/skills/core/morph-stack-scan/SKILL.md +13 -1
  41. package/framework/skills/core/morph-standards/SKILL.md +1 -1
  42. package/framework/skills/core/morph-uiux/SKILL.md +1 -1
  43. package/framework/standards/PROVENANCE.json +41 -0
  44. package/framework/standards/STANDARDS.json +218 -7
  45. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/agent-session.md +160 -160
  46. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/batching.md +193 -193
  47. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/context-providers.md +188 -188
  48. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/mcp-server.md +250 -250
  49. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/mcp-tools.md +197 -197
  50. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/middleware-patterns.md +207 -207
  51. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/modalities-image-gen.md +173 -173
  52. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/modalities-speech-to-text.md +171 -171
  53. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/modalities-text-to-speech.md +181 -181
  54. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/modalities-vision.md +201 -201
  55. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/multi-agent-patterns.md +155 -155
  56. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/production.md +231 -231
  57. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/prompts-in-db.md +214 -214
  58. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/providers/model-registry.md +158 -158
  59. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/service-tier-flex.md +135 -135
  60. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/structured-output.md +249 -249
  61. package/framework/standards/ai-agents/sweet-spot.md +109 -109
  62. package/framework/standards/frontend/design-system/ai-image-generation.md +43 -0
  63. package/framework/standards/frontend/design-system/ai-video-generation.md +113 -0
  64. package/framework/standards/frontend/design-system/premium-finish.md +160 -0
  65. package/framework/standards/frontend/gsap/gsap-core.md +1 -1
  66. package/framework/standards/frontend/gsap/gsap-plugins.md +1 -1
  67. package/framework/standards/frontend/gsap/gsap-scrolltrigger.md +3 -1
  68. package/framework/standards/frontend/nextjs/motion-patterns.md +3 -1
  69. package/framework/standards/frontend/scroll-driven/frame-scrub.md +287 -0
  70. package/framework/standards/frontend/scroll-driven/scroll-components.md +256 -0
  71. package/framework/standards/frontend/scroll-driven/smooth-scroll.md +148 -0
  72. package/framework/standards/frontend/seo/meta-schema-audit.md +134 -0
  73. package/framework/templates/.idea/morph-templates.xml +92 -0
  74. package/framework/templates/.vscode/morph-templates.code-snippets +186 -0
  75. package/framework/templates/IDE-SNIPPETS.md +262 -262
  76. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/abstractions/api-endpoint.cs +7 -7
  77. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/ai-agents/AgentBootstrap.cs.template +39 -39
  78. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/ai-agents/EmbeddingService.cs.template +68 -68
  79. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/ai-agents/ModelRegistry.cs.template +117 -117
  80. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/ai-agents/PromptRepository.cs.template +95 -95
  81. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/ai-agents/ResilientToolMiddleware.cs.template +61 -61
  82. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/ai-agents/VectorSearchTool.cs.template +107 -107
  83. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/ai-agents/model-registry.json.template +58 -58
  84. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/contracts/contracts-vsa.cs +281 -281
  85. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/database/migration.cs +83 -83
  86. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/feature/endpoint.cs.hbs +21 -21
  87. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/feature/request.cs.hbs +4 -4
  88. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/feature/response.cs.hbs +4 -4
  89. package/framework/templates/code/dotnet/feature/validator.cs.hbs +15 -15
  90. package/framework/templates/code/sql/ai-agents/agent-prompts-migration.sql.template +58 -58
  91. package/framework/templates/code/sql/ai-agents/pgvector-embeddings-migration.sql.template +91 -91
  92. package/framework/templates/code/typescript/contracts.ts +167 -167
  93. package/framework/templates/context/ARCHITECTURE.md +20 -0
  94. package/framework/templates/docs/clarifications.md +253 -253
  95. package/framework/templates/docs/schema-analysis.md +119 -119
  96. package/framework/templates/docs/ui-components.md +52 -52
  97. package/framework/templates/docs/ui-design-system.md +76 -76
  98. package/framework/templates/docs/ui-flows.md +167 -167
  99. package/framework/templates/docs/ui-mockups.md +98 -98
  100. package/framework/templates/feature/decisions.md +122 -122
  101. package/framework/templates/frontend/nextjs/Dockerfile.nextjs.hbs +43 -43
  102. package/framework/templates/frontend/nextjs/client-component.tsx.hbs +26 -26
  103. package/framework/templates/frontend/nextjs/env.mjs.hbs +32 -32
  104. package/framework/templates/frontend/nextjs/feature-form.tsx.hbs +56 -56
  105. package/framework/templates/frontend/nextjs/page.tsx.hbs +22 -22
  106. package/framework/templates/frontend/nextjs/tsconfig.json.hbs +26 -26
  107. package/framework/templates/frontend/nextjs/use-feature.ts.hbs +54 -54
  108. package/framework/templates/infrastructure/docker/Dockerfile.template +58 -58
  109. package/framework/templates/infrastructure/docker/dockerfile-api.dockerfile +38 -38
  110. package/framework/templates/infrastructure/docker/dockerfile-web.dockerfile +48 -48
  111. package/framework/templates/infrastructure/github/README.md +56 -56
  112. package/framework/templates/infrastructure/github/actions/docker-build-push/action.yml.hbs +45 -45
  113. package/framework/templates/infrastructure/github/actions/health-check/action.yml.hbs +27 -27
  114. package/framework/templates/infrastructure/github/workflows/docker-build-push.yml.hbs +59 -59
  115. package/framework/templates/infrastructure/github/workflows/dotnet-build.yml.hbs +39 -39
  116. package/framework/templates/integrations/asaas-client.cs +387 -387
  117. package/framework/templates/integrations/asaas-webhook.cs +351 -351
  118. package/framework/templates/meta-prompts/fusion/fusion-agent.md +76 -76
  119. package/framework/templates/meta-prompts/fusion/fusion-aggregator.md +100 -100
  120. package/framework/templates/meta-prompts/validators/pre-commit-validator.md +95 -95
  121. package/framework/templates/project/validate.js +120 -120
  122. package/framework/templates/state.template.json +17 -17
  123. package/framework/templates/ui/design-system.css +226 -226
  124. package/package.json +1 -1
  125. package/src/commands/dashboard/dashboard.js +53 -53
  126. package/src/commands/graph/affected.js +89 -0
  127. package/src/commands/graph/build.js +94 -0
  128. package/src/commands/graph/explain.js +96 -0
  129. package/src/commands/graph/status.js +93 -0
  130. package/src/commands/index.js +13 -13
  131. package/src/commands/project/checkpoint.js +209 -209
  132. package/src/commands/project/doctor.js +11 -0
  133. package/src/core/paths/output-schema.js +7 -0
  134. package/src/core/state/phase-state-machine.js +197 -197
  135. package/src/core/templates/template-renderer.js +477 -477
  136. package/src/dashboard/app/components/DetailPanel.jsx +11 -11
  137. package/src/dashboard/app/components/FlowGraph.jsx +17 -17
  138. package/src/dashboard/app/components/SearchFilter.jsx +22 -22
  139. package/src/dashboard/app/hooks/useDetailPanel.js +15 -15
  140. package/src/dashboard/app/main.jsx +13 -13
  141. package/src/dashboard/app/pages/AgentMap.jsx +370 -370
  142. package/src/dashboard/app/pages/HookInspector.jsx +418 -418
  143. package/src/dashboard/app/pages/PhasePipeline.jsx +408 -408
  144. package/src/dashboard/app/pages/RulesMap.jsx +273 -273
  145. package/src/dashboard/app/pages/SkillsLibrary.jsx +366 -366
  146. package/src/dashboard/app/pages/Standards.jsx +332 -332
  147. package/src/dashboard/app/styles/index.css +47 -47
  148. package/src/dashboard/index.html +12 -12
  149. package/src/dashboard/package.json +24 -24
  150. package/src/dashboard/scanner/phases-scanner.js +15 -15
  151. package/src/dashboard/scanner/rubrics-scanner.js +12 -12
  152. package/src/dashboard/scanner/rules-scanner.js +37 -37
  153. package/src/dashboard/scanner/skills-scanner.js +43 -43
  154. package/src/dashboard/scanner/squads-scanner.js +13 -13
  155. package/src/dashboard/vite-plugin-morph-data.js +17 -17
  156. package/src/dashboard/vite.config.js +24 -24
  157. package/src/lib/detectors/design-system-detector.js +188 -188
  158. package/src/lib/detectors/index.js +217 -217
  159. package/src/lib/generators/architecture-scanner.js +45 -4
  160. package/src/lib/generators/design-system-generator.js +508 -508
  161. package/src/lib/generators/settings-generator.js +209 -209
  162. package/src/lib/graph/god-nodes.js +75 -0
  163. package/src/lib/graph/graph-health.js +61 -0
  164. package/src/lib/graph/graph-loader.js +86 -0
  165. package/src/lib/graph/graphify-runtime.js +100 -0
  166. package/src/lib/graph/graphifyignore.js +86 -0
  167. package/src/lib/graph/sanitize.js +280 -0
  168. package/src/lib/hooks/hook-executor.js +167 -167
  169. package/src/lib/installers/mcp-installer.js +719 -719
  170. package/src/lib/tasks/task-classifier.js +30 -30
  171. package/src/lib/tasks/task-parser.js +209 -209
  172. package/src/lib/tasks/tasks-json-parser.js +26 -0
  173. package/src/lib/validators/checkpoint-persistence.js +39 -39
  174. package/src/lib/validators/css/css-validator.js +340 -340
  175. package/src/lib/validators/reuse/index.js +10 -0
  176. package/src/lib/validators/reuse/reuse-validator.js +324 -0
  177. package/src/lib/validators/reuse/symbol-scanner.js +144 -0
  178. package/src/lib/validators/shared/emit-validator-dispatch.js +14 -14
  179. package/src/lib/validators/shared/issue-counter.js +14 -14
  180. package/src/lib/validators/validation-runner.js +40 -1
  181. package/src/scripts/setup-infra.js +60 -1
  182. package/src/utils/agent-id-mapper.js +11 -11
  183. package/src/utils/claude-settings-manager.js +300 -300
  184. package/src/utils/file-copier.js +40 -0
  185. package/src/utils/skills-installer.js +187 -187
@@ -1,253 +1,253 @@
1
- # Clarifications - {{FEATURE_NAME_TITLE}}
2
-
3
- **Feature**: {{FEATURE_NAME}}
4
- **Date**: {{DATE}}
5
- **Phase**: CLARIFY (Phase 3)
6
- **Status**: {{#if status}}{{status}}{{else}}In Progress{{/if}}
7
-
8
- ---
9
-
10
- ## Purpose
11
-
12
- This document addresses ambiguities, edge cases, and questions identified during the design review. All clarifications should be incorporated back into `spec.md` after approval.
13
-
14
- ---
15
-
16
- ## Questions & Answers
17
-
18
- {{#each questions}}
19
- ### Q{{this.id}}: {{this.category}} - {{this.title}}
20
-
21
- **Question:**
22
- {{this.question}}
23
-
24
- **Context:**
25
- {{this.context}}
26
-
27
- **Answer:**
28
- {{this.answer}}
29
-
30
- **Impact:**
31
- {{this.impact}}
32
-
33
- **Spec Updates Required:**
34
- {{#each this.specUpdates}}
35
- - {{this}}
36
- {{/each}}
37
-
38
- **Priority:** {{this.priority}}
39
- **Resolved:** {{#if this.resolved}}✅ Yes{{else}}❌ No{{/if}}
40
- **Resolved By:** {{#if this.resolvedBy}}{{this.resolvedBy}}{{else}}_Pending_{{/if}}
41
-
42
- ---
43
- {{/each}}
44
-
45
- ## Edge Cases Identified
46
-
47
- {{#each edgeCases}}
48
- ### EC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
49
-
50
- **Scenario:**
51
- {{this.scenario}}
52
-
53
- **Current Behavior:**
54
- {{this.currentBehavior}}
55
-
56
- **Expected Behavior:**
57
- {{this.expectedBehavior}}
58
-
59
- **Proposed Solution:**
60
- {{this.proposedSolution}}
61
-
62
- **Acceptance Criteria:**
63
- {{#each this.acceptanceCriteria}}
64
- - [ ] {{this}}
65
- {{/each}}
66
-
67
- **Affected Components:**
68
- {{#each this.affectedComponents}}
69
- - {{this}}
70
- {{/each}}
71
-
72
- ---
73
- {{/each}}
74
-
75
- ## Assumptions Validated
76
-
77
- {{#each assumptions}}
78
- ### A{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
79
-
80
- **Assumption:**
81
- {{this.description}}
82
-
83
- **Validation:**
84
- {{#if this.validated}}✅ Confirmed{{else}}❌ Invalid{{/if}}
85
-
86
- **Notes:**
87
- {{this.notes}}
88
-
89
- **Action Required:**
90
- {{#if this.action}}{{this.action}}{{else}}_None_{{/if}}
91
-
92
- ---
93
- {{/each}}
94
-
95
- ## Business Rules Clarified
96
-
97
- {{#each businessRules}}
98
- ### BR{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
99
-
100
- **Rule:**
101
- {{this.rule}}
102
-
103
- **Rationale:**
104
- {{this.rationale}}
105
-
106
- **Examples:**
107
- {{#each this.examples}}
108
- - {{this}}
109
- {{/each}}
110
-
111
- **Exceptions:**
112
- {{#if this.exceptions}}
113
- {{#each this.exceptions}}
114
- - {{this}}
115
- {{/each}}
116
- {{else}}
117
- _None_
118
- {{/if}}
119
-
120
- ---
121
- {{/each}}
122
-
123
- ## Data Validation Rules
124
-
125
- {{#each dataValidations}}
126
- ### DV{{@index}}: {{this.field}} Validation
127
-
128
- **Field:** {{this.field}}
129
- **Entity:** {{this.entity}}
130
-
131
- **Validation Rules:**
132
- {{#each this.rules}}
133
- - {{this}}
134
- {{/each}}
135
-
136
- **Error Messages:**
137
- {{#each this.errorMessages}}
138
- - {{this.condition}}: "{{this.message}}"
139
- {{/each}}
140
-
141
- **Impact on UX:**
142
- {{this.uxImpact}}
143
-
144
- ---
145
- {{/each}}
146
-
147
- ## Performance & Scalability Clarifications
148
-
149
- {{#each performanceClarifications}}
150
- ### PC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
151
-
152
- **Concern:**
153
- {{this.concern}}
154
-
155
- **Clarification:**
156
- {{this.clarification}}
157
-
158
- **Solution:**
159
- {{this.solution}}
160
-
161
- **Performance Target:**
162
- {{this.target}}
163
-
164
- ---
165
- {{/each}}
166
-
167
- ## Security & Authorization Clarifications
168
-
169
- {{#each securityClarifications}}
170
- ### SC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
171
-
172
- **Security Concern:**
173
- {{this.concern}}
174
-
175
- **Clarification:**
176
- {{this.clarification}}
177
-
178
- **Implementation:**
179
- {{this.implementation}}
180
-
181
- **Affected Roles:**
182
- {{#each this.affectedRoles}}
183
- - {{this}}
184
- {{/each}}
185
-
186
- ---
187
- {{/each}}
188
-
189
- ## Integration & External Dependencies
190
-
191
- {{#each integrationClarifications}}
192
- ### IC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
193
-
194
- **External System:**
195
- {{this.externalSystem}}
196
-
197
- **Question:**
198
- {{this.question}}
199
-
200
- **Clarification:**
201
- {{this.clarification}}
202
-
203
- **API Endpoint/Method:**
204
- {{this.apiDetails}}
205
-
206
- **Error Handling:**
207
- {{this.errorHandling}}
208
-
209
- ---
210
- {{/each}}
211
-
212
- ## Summary
213
-
214
- **Total Questions:** {{#if totalQuestions}}{{totalQuestions}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
215
- **Resolved:** {{#if resolvedCount}}{{resolvedCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
216
- **Pending:** {{#if pendingCount}}{{pendingCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
217
-
218
- **Edge Cases Identified:** {{#if edgeCaseCount}}{{edgeCaseCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
219
- **Business Rules Documented:** {{#if businessRuleCount}}{{businessRuleCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
220
- **Assumptions Validated:** {{#if assumptionCount}}{{assumptionCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
221
-
222
- ---
223
-
224
- ## Next Steps
225
-
226
- 1. [ ] Resolve all pending questions
227
- 2. [ ] Update `spec.md` with all clarifications
228
- 3. [ ] Update `contracts.cs` if data model changes are needed
229
- 4. [ ] Document breaking changes in `decisions.md`
230
- 5. [ ] Get stakeholder approval on all clarifications
231
- 6. [ ] Advance to Phase 4 (Tasks)
232
-
233
- ---
234
-
235
- ## Spec Updates Log
236
-
237
- **Changes to be made to `spec.md`:**
238
-
239
- {{#each specUpdates}}
240
- ### Update {{@index}}
241
-
242
- **Section:** {{this.section}}
243
- **Type:** {{this.type}}
244
- **Description:** {{this.description}}
245
- **From Clarification:** {{this.clarificationId}}
246
-
247
- ---
248
- {{/each}}
249
-
250
- ---
251
-
252
- *Generated by MORPH-SPEC v{{FRAMEWORK_VERSION}}*
253
- *All clarifications must be incorporated into spec.md before advancing to Phase 4*
1
+ # Clarifications - {{FEATURE_NAME_TITLE}}
2
+
3
+ **Feature**: {{FEATURE_NAME}}
4
+ **Date**: {{DATE}}
5
+ **Phase**: CLARIFY (Phase 3)
6
+ **Status**: {{#if status}}{{status}}{{else}}In Progress{{/if}}
7
+
8
+ ---
9
+
10
+ ## Purpose
11
+
12
+ This document addresses ambiguities, edge cases, and questions identified during the design review. All clarifications should be incorporated back into `spec.md` after approval.
13
+
14
+ ---
15
+
16
+ ## Questions & Answers
17
+
18
+ {{#each questions}}
19
+ ### Q{{this.id}}: {{this.category}} - {{this.title}}
20
+
21
+ **Question:**
22
+ {{this.question}}
23
+
24
+ **Context:**
25
+ {{this.context}}
26
+
27
+ **Answer:**
28
+ {{this.answer}}
29
+
30
+ **Impact:**
31
+ {{this.impact}}
32
+
33
+ **Spec Updates Required:**
34
+ {{#each this.specUpdates}}
35
+ - {{this}}
36
+ {{/each}}
37
+
38
+ **Priority:** {{this.priority}}
39
+ **Resolved:** {{#if this.resolved}}✅ Yes{{else}}❌ No{{/if}}
40
+ **Resolved By:** {{#if this.resolvedBy}}{{this.resolvedBy}}{{else}}_Pending_{{/if}}
41
+
42
+ ---
43
+ {{/each}}
44
+
45
+ ## Edge Cases Identified
46
+
47
+ {{#each edgeCases}}
48
+ ### EC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
49
+
50
+ **Scenario:**
51
+ {{this.scenario}}
52
+
53
+ **Current Behavior:**
54
+ {{this.currentBehavior}}
55
+
56
+ **Expected Behavior:**
57
+ {{this.expectedBehavior}}
58
+
59
+ **Proposed Solution:**
60
+ {{this.proposedSolution}}
61
+
62
+ **Acceptance Criteria:**
63
+ {{#each this.acceptanceCriteria}}
64
+ - [ ] {{this}}
65
+ {{/each}}
66
+
67
+ **Affected Components:**
68
+ {{#each this.affectedComponents}}
69
+ - {{this}}
70
+ {{/each}}
71
+
72
+ ---
73
+ {{/each}}
74
+
75
+ ## Assumptions Validated
76
+
77
+ {{#each assumptions}}
78
+ ### A{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
79
+
80
+ **Assumption:**
81
+ {{this.description}}
82
+
83
+ **Validation:**
84
+ {{#if this.validated}}✅ Confirmed{{else}}❌ Invalid{{/if}}
85
+
86
+ **Notes:**
87
+ {{this.notes}}
88
+
89
+ **Action Required:**
90
+ {{#if this.action}}{{this.action}}{{else}}_None_{{/if}}
91
+
92
+ ---
93
+ {{/each}}
94
+
95
+ ## Business Rules Clarified
96
+
97
+ {{#each businessRules}}
98
+ ### BR{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
99
+
100
+ **Rule:**
101
+ {{this.rule}}
102
+
103
+ **Rationale:**
104
+ {{this.rationale}}
105
+
106
+ **Examples:**
107
+ {{#each this.examples}}
108
+ - {{this}}
109
+ {{/each}}
110
+
111
+ **Exceptions:**
112
+ {{#if this.exceptions}}
113
+ {{#each this.exceptions}}
114
+ - {{this}}
115
+ {{/each}}
116
+ {{else}}
117
+ _None_
118
+ {{/if}}
119
+
120
+ ---
121
+ {{/each}}
122
+
123
+ ## Data Validation Rules
124
+
125
+ {{#each dataValidations}}
126
+ ### DV{{@index}}: {{this.field}} Validation
127
+
128
+ **Field:** {{this.field}}
129
+ **Entity:** {{this.entity}}
130
+
131
+ **Validation Rules:**
132
+ {{#each this.rules}}
133
+ - {{this}}
134
+ {{/each}}
135
+
136
+ **Error Messages:**
137
+ {{#each this.errorMessages}}
138
+ - {{this.condition}}: "{{this.message}}"
139
+ {{/each}}
140
+
141
+ **Impact on UX:**
142
+ {{this.uxImpact}}
143
+
144
+ ---
145
+ {{/each}}
146
+
147
+ ## Performance & Scalability Clarifications
148
+
149
+ {{#each performanceClarifications}}
150
+ ### PC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
151
+
152
+ **Concern:**
153
+ {{this.concern}}
154
+
155
+ **Clarification:**
156
+ {{this.clarification}}
157
+
158
+ **Solution:**
159
+ {{this.solution}}
160
+
161
+ **Performance Target:**
162
+ {{this.target}}
163
+
164
+ ---
165
+ {{/each}}
166
+
167
+ ## Security & Authorization Clarifications
168
+
169
+ {{#each securityClarifications}}
170
+ ### SC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
171
+
172
+ **Security Concern:**
173
+ {{this.concern}}
174
+
175
+ **Clarification:**
176
+ {{this.clarification}}
177
+
178
+ **Implementation:**
179
+ {{this.implementation}}
180
+
181
+ **Affected Roles:**
182
+ {{#each this.affectedRoles}}
183
+ - {{this}}
184
+ {{/each}}
185
+
186
+ ---
187
+ {{/each}}
188
+
189
+ ## Integration & External Dependencies
190
+
191
+ {{#each integrationClarifications}}
192
+ ### IC{{@index}}: {{this.title}}
193
+
194
+ **External System:**
195
+ {{this.externalSystem}}
196
+
197
+ **Question:**
198
+ {{this.question}}
199
+
200
+ **Clarification:**
201
+ {{this.clarification}}
202
+
203
+ **API Endpoint/Method:**
204
+ {{this.apiDetails}}
205
+
206
+ **Error Handling:**
207
+ {{this.errorHandling}}
208
+
209
+ ---
210
+ {{/each}}
211
+
212
+ ## Summary
213
+
214
+ **Total Questions:** {{#if totalQuestions}}{{totalQuestions}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
215
+ **Resolved:** {{#if resolvedCount}}{{resolvedCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
216
+ **Pending:** {{#if pendingCount}}{{pendingCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
217
+
218
+ **Edge Cases Identified:** {{#if edgeCaseCount}}{{edgeCaseCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
219
+ **Business Rules Documented:** {{#if businessRuleCount}}{{businessRuleCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
220
+ **Assumptions Validated:** {{#if assumptionCount}}{{assumptionCount}}{{else}}0{{/if}}
221
+
222
+ ---
223
+
224
+ ## Next Steps
225
+
226
+ 1. [ ] Resolve all pending questions
227
+ 2. [ ] Update `spec.md` with all clarifications
228
+ 3. [ ] Update `contracts.cs` if data model changes are needed
229
+ 4. [ ] Document breaking changes in `decisions.md`
230
+ 5. [ ] Get stakeholder approval on all clarifications
231
+ 6. [ ] Advance to Phase 4 (Tasks)
232
+
233
+ ---
234
+
235
+ ## Spec Updates Log
236
+
237
+ **Changes to be made to `spec.md`:**
238
+
239
+ {{#each specUpdates}}
240
+ ### Update {{@index}}
241
+
242
+ **Section:** {{this.section}}
243
+ **Type:** {{this.type}}
244
+ **Description:** {{this.description}}
245
+ **From Clarification:** {{this.clarificationId}}
246
+
247
+ ---
248
+ {{/each}}
249
+
250
+ ---
251
+
252
+ *Generated by MORPH-SPEC v{{FRAMEWORK_VERSION}}*
253
+ *All clarifications must be incorporated into spec.md before advancing to Phase 4*