@pieai/pro-gov 0.3.3 → 0.3.5

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
package/README.md CHANGED
@@ -1,19 +1,31 @@
1
1
  # @pieai/pro-gov
2
2
 
3
- Project-level distribution kit for Project Governance System.
3
+ `@pieai/pro-gov` is the project-level setup kit for
4
+ [Project Governance System](https://github.com/PieAIStudio/ProjectGovernanceSystem).
5
+ It helps AI-assisted projects stay understandable after many plans, documents,
6
+ tools, and AI sessions have accumulated.
4
7
 
5
- `@pieai/doc-gov` remains the validator package. `@pieai/pro-gov` ships reusable
6
- project-governance assets and a conservative project-level CLI. It is the
7
- package that answers: "What starter/profile material does this project need,
8
- and what would change if we adopted it?"
8
+ Think of Project Governance System as a librarian, traffic desk, and inspection
9
+ station:
10
+
11
+ - `pro-gov` shows which reusable project-governance parts are present or missing;
12
+ - `@pieai/doc-gov` checks documents, routing, links, hooks, and CI;
13
+ - Superpowers may provide the engineering process;
14
+ - Ponytail may provide an optional simplicity review.
15
+
16
+ The current `pro-gov` release is conservative by design. Public init and sync
17
+ commands inspect and compare; they do not silently overwrite another project's
18
+ router or local truth.
9
19
 
10
20
  ## Install
11
21
 
22
+ Requires Node.js `22.12.0` or newer.
23
+
12
24
  ```bash
13
25
  pnpm add -D @pieai/pro-gov @pieai/doc-gov
14
26
  ```
15
27
 
16
- Add scripts in the target project:
28
+ Optional project scripts:
17
29
 
18
30
  ```json
19
31
  {
@@ -24,24 +36,77 @@ Add scripts in the target project:
24
36
  }
25
37
  ```
26
38
 
27
- ## Commands
39
+ ## Public Commands
28
40
 
29
41
  ```bash
30
42
  pro-gov assets list
43
+ pro-gov assets discover --target .
44
+ pro-gov assets recommend --target .
45
+ pro-gov lens inspect --target .
46
+ pro-gov lens report --target . --out .pro-gov/lens-report.md
31
47
  pro-gov init --profile engineering-runtime --dry-run
32
48
  pro-gov init --profile doc-only --dry-run
33
49
  pro-gov sync --check
34
50
  pro-gov doctor
35
51
  ```
36
52
 
37
- The first release is read-only by default. It reports what would change before
38
- any future write path is added.
53
+ What these commands do:
54
+
55
+ | Command group | Purpose | Writes project files? |
56
+ | --- | --- | --- |
57
+ | `assets list` | Shows packaged assets and public registry metadata. | No |
58
+ | `assets discover` | Detects local project signals. | No |
59
+ | `assets recommend` | Suggests relevant asset bundles with reasons. | No |
60
+ | `lens inspect` | Produces ProjectLens-style local evidence. | No |
61
+ | `lens report` | Writes the requested report file. | Only the explicit output |
62
+ | `init --dry-run` | Shows starter/profile files that would be needed. | No |
63
+ | `sync --check` | Compares local starter files with packaged assets. | No |
64
+ | `doctor` | Checks required packaged assets and whether `doc-gov` is available. | No |
65
+
66
+ ## Full Checkout Commands
67
+
68
+ A full Project Governance System checkout may also manage Yuanfei's local
69
+ agent-asset registry through reviewed plans:
70
+
71
+ ```bash
72
+ pro-gov assets plan --bundle base-governance --target . --out .pro-gov/asset-plan.json
73
+ pro-gov assets apply --plan .pro-gov/asset-plan.json
74
+ pro-gov assets check --target .
75
+ pro-gov assets npx update --plan
76
+ ```
77
+
78
+ The plan is the safety gate. `apply` may update managed targets described by the
79
+ plan; it must not overwrite an unrelated unmanaged file.
80
+
81
+ These checkout-only workflows depend on the upstream `agent-assets/` registry.
82
+ The public npm package intentionally excludes private and mirrored third-party
83
+ skill bodies.
39
84
 
40
85
  ## Package Boundary
41
86
 
42
- - `pro-gov` lists and compares starter/profile/integration assets.
43
- - `doc-gov` validates governed Markdown, router integrity, manifest freshness,
44
- links, local hooks, and CI wiring.
45
- - Project-local product truth stays in the target project.
46
- - Write-mode install or upgrade behavior is intentionally not enabled in the
47
- first release.
87
+ - `pro-gov` distributes starter, profile, integration, and adoption assets.
88
+ - `pro-gov assets discover|recommend` provides read-only project evidence and
89
+ deterministic recommendations.
90
+ - `pro-gov assets plan|apply|check` manages local assets only from an explicit,
91
+ reviewable plan in a full upstream checkout.
92
+ - `pro-gov lens inspect|report` provides read-only inspection and an explicit
93
+ report output.
94
+ - `doc-gov` remains the document, router, manifest, link, hook, CI, and migration
95
+ validator.
96
+ - Product truth stays in the target project.
97
+ - Write-mode `pro-gov init --apply` is not enabled in this release.
98
+ - Superpowers and Ponytail are external tools, not bundled runtime dependencies.
99
+
100
+ ## Recommended Companion Tools
101
+
102
+ Superpowers is recommended for engineering/runtime projects that need
103
+ brainstorming, plans, TDD, debugging, verification, and worktree discipline.
104
+
105
+ Ponytail can be installed as an optional complexity adviser. Keep its global mode
106
+ `off`; test `lite` in one isolated task before considering a stronger mode.
107
+ Ponytail must not remove requested scope, tests, safety, accessibility, or proof.
108
+
109
+ Read the
110
+ [full project introduction](https://github.com/PieAIStudio/ProjectGovernanceSystem#readme)
111
+ for beginner examples, profiles, adoption guidance, and exact integration
112
+ boundaries.
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ status: stable
6
6
  canonical: true
7
7
  owner: human
8
8
  created: 2026-05-06
9
- last_reviewed: 2026-06-13
9
+ last_reviewed: 2026-06-15
10
10
  domain: adoption
11
11
  tags:
12
12
  - adoption
@@ -22,16 +22,22 @@ related:
22
22
 
23
23
  Use this when a project wants to migrate into the Project Governance System.
24
24
 
25
+ Before choosing external AI workflow tools, read
26
+ `docs/reference/adoption/recommended-agent-tooling.md`. It explains which PGS
27
+ packages are required, when Superpowers is recommended, and why Ponytail should
28
+ remain globally `off` until it is tested in an isolated task.
29
+
25
30
  ## The Short Version
26
31
 
27
32
  1. Pick one profile.
28
33
  2. Inventory the project's current docs/rules.
29
34
  3. Install the governance packages.
30
- 4. Add starter `docs/governance/` and `docs/policy/` files.
31
- 5. Add the selected `docs/governance/agents-routing/` profile rule.
32
- 6. Move current truth into the governed layers.
33
- 7. Archive or delete old systems.
34
- 8. Run validation.
35
+ 4. Run project and agent-asset discovery.
36
+ 5. Add starter `docs/governance/` and `docs/policy/` files.
37
+ 6. Add the selected `docs/governance/agents-routing/` profile rule.
38
+ 7. Move current truth into the governed layers.
39
+ 8. Archive or delete old systems.
40
+ 9. Run validation.
35
41
 
36
42
  Do not migrate by slowly adding random files. Migrate by making one clear current work surface.
37
43
 
@@ -66,6 +72,11 @@ Current package-based method:
66
72
  the starter files that would be installed
67
73
  - run `pro-gov sync --check` to compare reusable starter files without changing
68
74
  the project
75
+ - run `pro-gov assets discover --target <path>` and
76
+ `pro-gov assets recommend --target <path>` to collect local project signals
77
+ and suggested agent-asset bundles without changing the project
78
+ - run `pro-gov lens inspect --target <path>` when the project needs a
79
+ ProjectLens-style local evidence packet
69
80
  - run `doc-gov migrate --profile <engineering-runtime|doc-only> --check` before
70
81
  changing files so profile mismatches fail early
71
82
  - run `doc-gov router-check` after the sync so stale router/profile paths fail
@@ -97,6 +108,27 @@ the private workspace package name is `pro-gov`. Target projects should use
97
108
  for public links, and refer to the source as the Project Governance System
98
109
  upstream repository.
99
110
 
111
+ ### Optional: Managed Agent Assets
112
+
113
+ Agent assets are skills, rules, and commands exposed to AI hosts. They are not
114
+ the same as governed project docs.
115
+
116
+ Use this flow only from a full Project Governance System checkout that contains
117
+ `agent-assets/`; the public npm package excludes Yuanfei's private and
118
+ third-party skill bodies by design:
119
+
120
+ ```bash
121
+ pro-gov assets discover --target /path/to/project --json
122
+ pro-gov assets recommend --target /path/to/project --json
123
+ pro-gov assets plan --target /path/to/project --bundle base-governance --host codex --out /tmp/pro-gov-asset-plan.json
124
+ pro-gov assets apply --plan /tmp/pro-gov-asset-plan.json
125
+ pro-gov assets check --target /path/to/project --json
126
+ ```
127
+
128
+ The plan file is the safety gate. Review it before applying. It creates managed
129
+ symlinks and `.pro-gov/assets.lock.json`; it should not overwrite unmanaged
130
+ project files.
131
+
100
132
  ## Step 4: Add Starter Structure
101
133
 
102
134
  Use `starter/` as the reference, but keep local facts local.
@@ -145,6 +177,10 @@ Add:
145
177
 
146
178
  Do not add Superpowers TDD or Directed Development by default.
147
179
 
180
+ Ponytail is also optional. If it is installed, keep its global mode `off` and
181
+ activate it only for a bounded task or review after reading
182
+ `integrations/ponytail.md`.
183
+
148
184
  ## Step 6: Create Current Work
149
185
 
150
186
  Create or update:
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ status: active
6
6
  canonical: true
7
7
  owner: human
8
8
  created: 2026-06-09
9
- last_reviewed: 2026-06-13
9
+ last_reviewed: 2026-06-14
10
10
  domain: adoption
11
11
  tags:
12
12
  - downstream
@@ -30,9 +30,12 @@ downstream projects.
30
30
  ## Registry Rules
31
31
 
32
32
  - Update this file when a project adopts, leaves, renames, or changes profile.
33
+ - Keep only projects that currently exist and are expected to receive future
34
+ governance updates. Remove deleted or superseded projects instead of keeping
35
+ stale health rows.
33
36
  - Treat package versions as the versions installed in the downstream project's
34
- `package.json`. Existing rows may list only `doc-gov` until that project is
35
- intentionally synced to `pro-gov`.
37
+ `package.json`. Record both packages when the project has completed
38
+ package-based adoption.
36
39
  - Treat health as a snapshot. A project can be on the latest version but still
37
40
  have local working-tree cleanup in progress.
38
41
  - Do not add a project-specific profile here unless at least two projects need
@@ -44,18 +47,21 @@ downstream projects.
44
47
 
45
48
  ## Current Downstream Projects
46
49
 
47
- Checked on 2026-06-09.
50
+ The current downstream set was checked on 2026-06-14.
48
51
 
49
- | Project | Local path | Profile | Installed doc-gov | Health snapshot | Notes |
50
- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
51
- | Non-Heroes | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/Non-Heroes` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.2` | Partial | Package and router are current; local doc migration work is in progress, so `doctor` currently fails on moved/archive reference docs until that project is cleaned up. |
52
- | Show | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/Show` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.2` | Healthy | `router-check` and `doctor` pass. |
53
- | PieFlow | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/PieFlow` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.2` | Healthy | `router-check` and `doctor` pass. |
54
- | story-creator | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/_NovelFrameworks/story-creator` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.2` | Healthy | Uses engineering routing because the repository contains a TypeScript CLI, tests, hooks, gates, and writing-system runtime. |
55
- | PieAIStudio-Site | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/PieAIStudio-Site` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.2` | Healthy | `router-check` and `doctor` pass. |
56
- | PieHQ | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/PieHQ` | `doc-only` | `0.3.2` | Healthy | `router-check` and `doctor` pass; unrelated FounderLogs work is present locally. |
57
- | PieIP | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/PieIP` | `doc-only` | `0.3.2` | Healthy | `router-check` and `doctor` pass. |
58
- | ProjectLens | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/ProjectLens` | `doc-only` | `0.3.2` | Healthy | `router-check` and `doctor` pass; ProjectLens is a project-level audit workspace, not a runtime product. |
52
+ | Project | Local path | Profile | Installed doc-gov | Installed pro-gov | Health snapshot | Notes |
53
+ | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
54
+ | Anvil | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/Anvil` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | `docs:check` passes with 0 warnings. Existing unrelated local writing work was preserved. |
55
+ | Collapse | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/Collapse` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | Adopted the thin placeholder-phase runtime profile. `docs:check` and the production build pass. |
56
+ | Non-Heroes | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/Non-Heroes` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | `docs:check` passes with 0 warnings. |
57
+ | PieAIStudio-Site | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/PieAIStudio-Site` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | `docs:check` passes with 0 warnings. Existing unrelated local skill links were preserved. |
58
+ | PieHQ | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/PieHQ` | `doc-only` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | `docs:check` passes with 0 warnings. |
59
+ | Sea | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/Sea` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | `docs:check` passes with 0 warnings across the large governed-doc set. |
60
+ | Show | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/Show` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | `docs:check` passes with 0 warnings. |
61
+ | SupaLuv | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/SupaLuv` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | Migrated from the vendored `doc-gov@0.2.0` copy. `docs:check` and `cloud:check` pass; unrelated local content work was preserved. |
62
+ | YaZu | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/YaZu` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | `docs:check` passes with 0 warnings. |
63
+ | TuringPact | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/TuringPact` | `engineering-runtime` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | Migrated the legacy `Docs/` system into current, completed, and archive layers. `docs:check` and `verify:web` pass. |
64
+ | ProjectLens | `/Users/yuanfei/PieAI/ProjectLens` | `doc-only` | `0.3.3` | `0.3.3` | Healthy | `docs:check` passes with 0 warnings. ProjectLens is a project-level audit workspace, not a runtime product. |
59
65
 
60
66
  ## Representative Examples
61
67
 
@@ -63,9 +69,6 @@ The `examples/` directory is not the full registry. It contains representative
63
69
  case studies:
64
70
 
65
71
  - `examples/non-heroes/example.md` for an engineering-runtime product.
66
- - `examples/pieflow/example.md` for a complex app/runtime product.
67
- - `examples/pieip/example.md` for a doc-only AI media / asset-governance
68
- project.
69
72
 
70
73
  Add a new example only when a project teaches a reusable adoption pattern that
71
74
  the existing examples do not cover.
@@ -74,5 +77,9 @@ the existing examples do not cover.
74
77
 
75
78
  - `Supa` is no longer tracked here because that project was renamed/replaced by
76
79
  `Non-Heroes`.
80
+ - `story-creator` is no longer tracked because the repository was renamed and
81
+ replaced by `Anvil`.
82
+ - `PieFlow` and `PieIP` were removed from the current registry on 2026-06-14
83
+ because those projects were deleted.
77
84
  - GitNexus is intentionally absent. It has been removed from the central system
78
85
  and should not be reintroduced through downstream policy links.
@@ -32,8 +32,8 @@ The central repo owns the **engine**. Each project owns its **local product cont
32
32
  | --- | --- |
33
33
  | Status lifecycle, document types, SSOT, agents routing, CLI checks, templates | Project Governance System upstream repository |
34
34
  | Non-Heroes product plans, runtime canon, product rules | Non-Heroes |
35
- | PieFlow product truth, connector rules, browser lanes | PieFlow |
36
- | PieIP character/script/asset governance | PieIP |
35
+ | TuringPact product truth, game runtime, commercial Gates | TuringPact |
36
+ | ProjectLens audit evidence and observer workflow | ProjectLens |
37
37
  | Current downstream adoption list and health snapshot | `docs/reference/adoption/downstream-project-registry.md` |
38
38
 
39
39
  ## Naming And Checkout Paths
@@ -62,10 +62,10 @@ Not yet automatically.
62
62
  Known downstream projects are listed in
63
63
  `docs/reference/adoption/downstream-project-registry.md`.
64
64
 
65
- Originally Non-Heroes, PieFlow, and PieIP had local working copies because the
66
- system was born inside active projects. This central repo is now the upstream
67
- source, and downstream projects should use `@pieai/doc-gov`, `@pieai/pro-gov`,
68
- and their selected profile instead of keeping private CLI or starter copies.
65
+ Early downstream projects had local working copies because the system was born
66
+ inside active projects. This central repo is now the upstream source, and
67
+ downstream projects should use `@pieai/doc-gov`, `@pieai/pro-gov`, and their
68
+ selected profile instead of keeping private CLI or starter copies.
69
69
 
70
70
  ## Why Not Auto-Symlink Everything?
71
71
 
@@ -79,7 +79,8 @@ The old `governance/` folder mixed both kinds. The clearer split is:
79
79
  - `docs/governance/` contains doc-system rules, SSOT, agents-routing, document types, templates, and manifest.
80
80
  - `docs/policy/` contains project-local AI development policy, lane wording, proof commands, and truth hierarchy.
81
81
 
82
- Symlinking or copying the whole policy layer would be wrong because Non-Heroes and PieFlow need different local lane profiles. The safe rule:
82
+ Symlinking or copying the whole policy layer would be wrong because different
83
+ projects need different local lane profiles. The safe rule:
83
84
 
84
85
  - shared rules may be symlinked
85
86
  - doc-gov core should become the installed validator package
@@ -104,7 +105,7 @@ Example:
104
105
  - The generic fix is a `completed` lifecycle state.
105
106
  - Therefore `completed` belongs in this repo's doc-gov core.
106
107
 
107
- ## How PieFlow And PieIP Upgrade
108
+ ## How Downstream Projects Upgrade
108
109
 
109
110
  Use an explicit migration task:
110
111
 
@@ -6,7 +6,7 @@ status: stable
6
6
  canonical: true
7
7
  owner: human
8
8
  created: 2026-06-04
9
- last_reviewed: 2026-06-13
9
+ last_reviewed: 2026-06-21
10
10
  domain: adoption
11
11
  tags:
12
12
  - release
@@ -69,28 +69,55 @@ Before publishing:
69
69
  - package dry-runs show only intended files
70
70
  - publish `@pieai/doc-gov` before `@pieai/pro-gov` when both package versions
71
71
  are new, because `pro-gov` depends on the matching validator release
72
- - maintainer is authenticated to npm
72
+ - npm Trusted Publisher is configured for both packages
73
73
  - registry is the official npm registry, not a mirror
74
74
  - scoped publish uses public access
75
75
 
76
- Recommended commands:
76
+ Recommended local verification:
77
77
 
78
78
  ```bash
79
- npm whoami --registry https://registry.npmjs.org/
80
-
81
79
  pnpm --filter @pieai/doc-gov pack --dry-run
82
80
  pnpm --filter @pieai/pro-gov pack --dry-run
81
+ ```
83
82
 
84
- pnpm --filter @pieai/doc-gov publish --access public --registry https://registry.npmjs.org/
85
- npm view @pieai/doc-gov version --registry https://registry.npmjs.org/
83
+ Recommended publish command:
86
84
 
87
- pnpm --filter @pieai/pro-gov publish --access public --registry https://registry.npmjs.org/
88
- npm view @pieai/pro-gov version --registry https://registry.npmjs.org/
85
+ ```bash
86
+ gh workflow run npm-publish.yml --ref main
89
87
  ```
90
88
 
91
89
  Important: do not claim an npm package is live until its `npm view <package>
92
90
  version` command resolves from the public registry.
93
91
 
92
+ ## Trusted Publishing Setup
93
+
94
+ npm publishing should use Trusted Publishing through GitHub Actions. This is the
95
+ smooth path: GitHub Actions proves to npm that a specific workflow in this
96
+ repository is publishing the package, so maintainers do not need to pass a
97
+ long-lived npm token around.
98
+
99
+ Set this once for each package on npmjs.com:
100
+
101
+ 1. Open the package settings for `@pieai/doc-gov`.
102
+ 2. Add a Trusted Publisher for GitHub Actions:
103
+ - owner: `PieAIStudio`
104
+ - repository: `ProjectGovernanceSystem`
105
+ - workflow file: `npm-publish.yml`
106
+ - allowed action: `npm publish`
107
+ 3. Repeat the same setup for `@pieai/pro-gov`.
108
+ 4. Keep the workflow as manual `workflow_dispatch` until several releases have
109
+ succeeded.
110
+
111
+ The workflow must keep:
112
+
113
+ - `permissions.id-token: write`
114
+ - a GitHub-hosted runner
115
+ - npm CLI `11.5.1` or newer
116
+ - package `repository` fields that match the public GitHub repository
117
+ - `pnpm pack` before publish, so workspace dependencies are converted in the
118
+ tarball
119
+ - `npm publish <tarball> --provenance --access public`
120
+
94
121
  ## After Release
95
122
 
96
123
  After GitHub and npm are live:
@@ -101,23 +128,3 @@ After GitHub and npm are live:
101
128
  - update downstream projects only through an explicit sync task
102
129
  - update public website copy from the current README and this checklist, not
103
130
  from stale chat history
104
-
105
- ## Future: Trusted Publishing
106
-
107
- The first release may be published from a logged-in maintainer machine. Future
108
- releases should move to npm Trusted Publishing through GitHub Actions.
109
-
110
- Recommended future setup:
111
-
112
- 1. On npmjs.com, open the package settings for `@pieai/doc-gov` and
113
- `@pieai/pro-gov`.
114
- 2. Add a Trusted Publisher for GitHub Actions to each package:
115
- - owner: `PieAIStudio`
116
- - repository: `ProjectGovernanceSystem` (GitHub slug)
117
- - workflow file: `npm-publish.yml`
118
- 3. Keep the workflow as manual `workflow_dispatch` until the first trusted
119
- publishing run succeeds.
120
- 4. After that, optionally add a release-tag trigger such as `v0.3.1`.
121
-
122
- Trusted Publishing gives npm a verifiable GitHub build origin and avoids
123
- long-lived npm tokens.
@@ -0,0 +1,106 @@
1
+ ---
2
+ id: REF-RECOMMENDED-AGENT-TOOLING
3
+ title: Recommended Agent Tooling
4
+ type: reference
5
+ status: stable
6
+ canonical: true
7
+ owner: human
8
+ created: 2026-06-21
9
+ last_reviewed: 2026-06-21
10
+ domain: adoption
11
+ tags:
12
+ - adoption
13
+ - tooling
14
+ - superpowers
15
+ - ponytail
16
+ pinned: false
17
+ related:
18
+ - REF-ADOPTION-PLAYBOOK
19
+ - POLICY-DESIGN-PRINCIPLES
20
+ - POLICY-SYNC-STRATEGY
21
+ ---
22
+
23
+ # Recommended Agent Tooling
24
+
25
+ This page separates what a project needs from what may help it.
26
+
27
+ ## The Beginner Version
28
+
29
+ Imagine a school workshop:
30
+
31
+ - PGS labels the shelves, routes each job, and checks that the record is complete.
32
+ - Superpowers gives the class a reliable build-and-test routine.
33
+ - Ponytail is the adviser who asks, "Can we make this with fewer unnecessary
34
+ parts?"
35
+
36
+ Installing every tool does not mean every tool should run all the time.
37
+
38
+ ## Recommendation Table
39
+
40
+ | Tool | Recommendation | Best fit | Default behavior |
41
+ | --- | --- | --- | --- |
42
+ | `@pieai/pro-gov` | Required for package-based PGS adoption | Projects adopting PGS starter/profile assets | Use its read-only discovery, init, sync, doctor, and Lens commands. |
43
+ | `@pieai/doc-gov` | Required for package-based PGS adoption | All governed PGS projects | Run document, router, manifest, link, hook, and CI checks. |
44
+ | Superpowers | Recommended for engineering/runtime projects | Apps, games, services, browser products, and other code-heavy work | Use the matching workflow when the selected PGS lane requires it. |
45
+ | Ponytail | Recommended as an installed, optional adviser | Projects that need help resisting unnecessary complexity | Keep the global mode `off`; activate it explicitly for a bounded task or review. |
46
+
47
+ ## Superpowers
48
+
49
+ Superpowers owns engineering workflow discipline:
50
+
51
+ - brainstorming before creative implementation;
52
+ - implementation plans;
53
+ - test-driven development;
54
+ - systematic debugging;
55
+ - verification before completion;
56
+ - isolated worktree usage.
57
+
58
+ PGS routes the task first. Superpowers then runs inside the selected lane.
59
+
60
+ Engineering/runtime projects usually benefit from Superpowers. Doc-only
61
+ projects should not inherit the full engineering ceremony unless their current
62
+ task actually involves runtime or code behavior.
63
+
64
+ Read `integrations/superpowers.md` for the exact boundary.
65
+
66
+ ## Ponytail
67
+
68
+ Ponytail advises the AI to prefer smaller, less speculative solutions. That can
69
+ reduce unnecessary code, files, dependencies, and abstractions.
70
+
71
+ Keep its global mode `off`. When a low-risk task needs a simplicity comparison,
72
+ test `lite` in an isolated session first. Use `full` only as an optional stress
73
+ test after checking that requirements, tests, verification, security,
74
+ accessibility, and durable evidence remain intact.
75
+
76
+ Ponytail is not a replacement for PGS or Superpowers. Shorter work is valuable
77
+ only when it is still the complete, proven work the project asked for.
78
+
79
+ Read `integrations/ponytail.md` for the mode policy and comparison protocol.
80
+
81
+ ## A Practical Default
82
+
83
+ For an engineering/runtime project:
84
+
85
+ ```text
86
+ install PGS packages
87
+ -> keep Superpowers available for engineering workflows
88
+ -> install Ponytail but keep global mode off
89
+ -> activate Ponytail only when a bounded simplicity review would help
90
+ ```
91
+
92
+ For a doc-only project:
93
+
94
+ ```text
95
+ install PGS packages
96
+ -> use doc-only routing and evidence rules
97
+ -> add engineering workflow tools only for a real engineering task
98
+ -> keep Ponytail optional and off by default
99
+ ```
100
+
101
+ ## What PGS Does Not Do
102
+
103
+ PGS does not automatically install, enable, update, or remove these external
104
+ plugins in another person's AI host. It documents the recommended boundary and
105
+ lets each project or user adopt tools deliberately.
106
+
@@ -25,19 +25,20 @@ System as a public project page.
25
25
 
26
26
  ## Public Positioning
27
27
 
28
- Project Governance System is an AI-native governance layer for projects that
29
- work with AI agents over time.
28
+ Project Governance System keeps long-running AI-assisted projects understandable
29
+ and governable.
30
30
 
31
31
  Beginner-friendly description:
32
32
 
33
- > Git remembers code history. AGENTS.md tells an AI how to enter a project.
34
- > Superpowers gives engineering workflows. Project Governance System is the
35
- > librarian and traffic desk: it decides where durable AI-created documents
36
- > belong, which ones are current truth, which route a task should take, and
37
- > when old documents should retire.
33
+ > AI can create plans, specifications, rules, and reports faster than people can
34
+ > organize them. Project Governance System is the librarian, traffic desk, and
35
+ > inspection machine: it keeps current truth easy to find, sends each task down
36
+ > the right route, and checks that important project evidence is still connected.
38
37
 
39
38
  ## What To Emphasize
40
39
 
40
+ - It reduces the cognitive load of returning to an AI-assisted project after
41
+ days, weeks, or many different AI sessions.
41
42
  - It keeps AI-generated specs, plans, decisions, references, and routing rules
42
43
  from becoming unmanaged clutter.
43
44
  - It separates central governance rules from project-local truth.
@@ -46,13 +47,18 @@ Beginner-friendly description:
46
47
  checks, router integrity, health checks, and read-only migration checks.
47
48
  - It provides `pro-gov` commands for packaged starter/profile assets,
48
49
  read-only init planning, read-only sync checks, and package health checks.
49
- - It is designed to work with external workflow systems instead of replacing
50
- them.
50
+ - It includes ProjectLens-style read-only inspection and a governed local agent
51
+ asset registry without publishing private or third-party skill bodies.
52
+ - It works with external workflow systems instead of replacing them:
53
+ Superpowers owns engineering process, while Ponytail may act as an optional
54
+ complexity adviser with global mode `off`.
51
55
 
52
56
  ## Do Not Overclaim
53
57
 
54
58
  - Do not say it replaces Git.
55
59
  - Do not say it replaces Superpowers.
60
+ - Do not say it requires or automatically enables Ponytail.
61
+ - Do not promise a fixed percentage reduction in code, tokens, time, or cost.
56
62
  - Do not say it automatically migrates every project.
57
63
  - Do not imply product prompts, generated media, or runtime assets must move
58
64
  under `docs/**`.
@@ -70,11 +76,13 @@ Use the central repo's README.md, packages/doc-gov/README.md,
70
76
  packages/pro-gov/README.md, docs/reference/adoption/public-release-checklist.md,
71
77
  and docs/reference/adoption/site-publication-brief.md as source material.
72
78
 
73
- Position it for normal readers as an AI-era documentation governance system:
74
- the librarian and traffic desk for AI-created project documents. Explain what
75
- problem it solves, why it matters, how doc-gov checks work, and how it fits next
76
- to Git, AGENTS.md, Superpowers, pro-gov starter/profile distribution, and
77
- project-local product truth.
79
+ Position it for normal readers as the system that keeps long-running AI-assisted
80
+ projects understandable and governable. Lead with the pain: AI creates useful
81
+ plans, specs, rules, and evidence faster than people can organize and retire
82
+ them. Use the librarian, traffic desk, and inspection-machine analogy before
83
+ technical package details. Explain how it fits next to Git, AGENTS.md,
84
+ Superpowers, optional Ponytail advice, pro-gov starter/profile distribution,
85
+ ProjectLens inspection, and project-local product truth.
78
86
 
79
87
  Keep the copy confident but accurate. Do not claim automatic migration or
80
88
  full replacement of existing workflow tools. npm publication is live, so include