@ngocsangairvds/vsaf 3.2.15 → 4.0.0

package/tools/skills/bmad-technical-research/technical-steps/step-06-research-synthesis.md

@@ -1,487 +0,0 @@
-# Technical Research Step 6: Technical Synthesis and Completion
-
-## MANDATORY EXECUTION RULES (READ FIRST):
-
-- 🛑 NEVER generate content without web search verification
-
-- 📖 CRITICAL: ALWAYS read the complete step file before taking any action - partial understanding leads to incomplete decisions
-- 🔄 CRITICAL: When loading next step with 'C', ensure the entire file is read and understood before proceeding
-- ✅ Search the web to verify and supplement your knowledge with current facts
-- 📋 YOU ARE A TECHNICAL RESEARCH STRATEGIST, not content generator
-- 💬 FOCUS on comprehensive technical synthesis and authoritative conclusions
-- 🔍 WEB SEARCH REQUIRED - verify current facts against live sources
-- 📄 PRODUCE COMPREHENSIVE DOCUMENT with narrative intro, TOC, and summary
-- ✅ YOU MUST ALWAYS SPEAK OUTPUT In your Agent communication style with the config `{communication_language}`
-
-## EXECUTION PROTOCOLS:
-
-- 🎯 Show web search analysis before presenting findings
-- ⚠️ Present [C] complete option after synthesis content generation
-- 💾 ONLY save when user chooses C (Complete)
-- 📖 Update frontmatter `stepsCompleted: [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]` before completing workflow
-- 🚫 FORBIDDEN to complete workflow until C is selected
-- 📚 GENERATE COMPLETE DOCUMENT STRUCTURE with intro, TOC, and summary
-
-## CONTEXT BOUNDARIES:
-
-- Current document and frontmatter from previous steps are available
-- **Research topic = "{{research_topic}}"** - comprehensive technical analysis
-- **Research goals = "{{research_goals}}"** - achieved through exhaustive technical research
-- All technical research sections have been completed (overview, architecture, implementation)
-- Web search capabilities with source verification are enabled
-- This is the final synthesis step producing the complete technical research document
-
-## YOUR TASK:
-
-Produce a comprehensive, authoritative technical research document on **{{research_topic}}** with compelling narrative introduction, detailed TOC, and executive summary based on exhaustive technical research.
-
-## COMPREHENSIVE TECHNICAL DOCUMENT SYNTHESIS:
-
-### 1. Technical Document Structure Planning
-
-**Complete Technical Research Document Structure:**
-
-```markdown
-# [Compelling Technical Title]: Comprehensive {{research_topic}} Technical Research
-
-## Executive Summary
-
-[Brief compelling overview of key technical findings and strategic implications]
-
-## Table of Contents
-
-- Technical Research Introduction and Methodology
-- Technical Landscape and Architecture Analysis
-- Implementation Approaches and Best Practices
-- Technology Stack Evolution and Trends
-- Integration and Interoperability Patterns
-- Performance and Scalability Analysis
-- Security and Compliance Considerations
-- Strategic Technical Recommendations
-- Implementation Roadmap and Risk Assessment
-- Future Technical Outlook and Innovation Opportunities
-- Technical Research Methodology and Source Documentation
-- Technical Appendices and Reference Materials
-```
-
-### 2. Generate Compelling Technical Introduction
-
-**Technical Introduction Requirements:**
-
-- Hook reader with compelling technical opening about {{research_topic}}
-- Establish technical research significance and current relevance
-- Outline comprehensive technical research methodology
-- Preview key technical findings and strategic implications
-- Set authoritative, technical expert tone
-
-**Web Search for Technical Introduction Context:**
-Search the web: "{{research_topic}} technical significance importance"
-
-### 3. Synthesize All Technical Research Sections
-
-**Technical Section-by-Section Integration:**
-
-- Combine technical overview from step-02
-- Integrate architectural patterns from step-03
-- Incorporate implementation research from step-04
-- Add cross-technical insights and connections
-- Ensure comprehensive technical coverage with no gaps
-
-### 4. Generate Complete Technical Document Content
-
-#### Final Technical Document Structure:
-
-```markdown
-# [Compelling Title]: Comprehensive {{research_topic}} Technical Research
-
-## Executive Summary
-
-[2-3 paragraph compelling summary of the most critical technical findings and strategic implications for {{research_topic}} based on comprehensive current technical research]
-
-**Key Technical Findings:**
-
-- [Most significant architectural insights]
-- [Critical implementation considerations]
-- [Important technology trends]
-- [Strategic technical implications]
-
-**Technical Recommendations:**
-
-- [Top 3-5 actionable technical recommendations based on research]
-
-## Table of Contents
-
-1. Technical Research Introduction and Methodology
-2. {{research_topic}} Technical Landscape and Architecture Analysis
-3. Implementation Approaches and Best Practices
-4. Technology Stack Evolution and Current Trends
-5. Integration and Interoperability Patterns
-6. Performance and Scalability Analysis
-7. Security and Compliance Considerations
-8. Strategic Technical Recommendations
-9. Implementation Roadmap and Risk Assessment
-10. Future Technical Outlook and Innovation Opportunities
-11. Technical Research Methodology and Source Verification
-12. Technical Appendices and Reference Materials
-
-## 1. Technical Research Introduction and Methodology
-
-### Technical Research Significance
-
-[Compelling technical narrative about why {{research_topic}} research is critical right now]
-_Technical Importance: [Strategic technical significance with current context]_
-_Business Impact: [Business implications of technical research]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### Technical Research Methodology
-
-[Comprehensive description of technical research approach including:]
-
-- **Technical Scope**: [Comprehensive technical coverage areas]
-- **Data Sources**: [Authoritative technical sources and verification approach]
-- **Analysis Framework**: [Structured technical analysis methodology]
-- **Time Period**: [current focus and technical evolution context]
-- **Technical Depth**: [Level of technical detail and analysis]
-
-### Technical Research Goals and Objectives
-
-**Original Technical Goals:** {{research_goals}}
-
-**Achieved Technical Objectives:**
-
-- [Technical Goal 1 achievement with supporting evidence]
-- [Technical Goal 2 achievement with supporting evidence]
-- [Additional technical insights discovered during research]
-
-## 2. {{research_topic}} Technical Landscape and Architecture Analysis
-
-### Current Technical Architecture Patterns
-
-[Comprehensive architectural analysis synthesized from step-03 with current context]
-_Dominant Patterns: [Current architectural approaches]_
-_Architectural Evolution: [Historical and current evolution patterns]_
-_Architectural Trade-offs: [Key architectural decisions and implications]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### System Design Principles and Best Practices
-
-[Complete system design analysis]
-_Design Principles: [Core principles guiding {{research_topic}} implementations]_
-_Best Practice Patterns: [Industry-standard approaches and methodologies]_
-_Architectural Quality Attributes: [Performance, scalability, maintainability considerations]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-## 3. Implementation Approaches and Best Practices
-
-### Current Implementation Methodologies
-
-[Implementation analysis from step-04 with current context]
-_Development Approaches: [Current development methodologies and approaches]_
-_Code Organization Patterns: [Structural patterns and organization strategies]_
-_Quality Assurance Practices: [Testing, validation, and quality approaches]_
-_Deployment Strategies: [Current deployment and operations practices]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### Implementation Framework and Tooling
-
-[Comprehensive implementation framework analysis]
-_Development Frameworks: [Popular frameworks and their characteristics]_
-_Tool Ecosystem: [Development tools and platform considerations]_
-_Build and Deployment Systems: [CI/CD and automation approaches]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-## 4. Technology Stack Evolution and Current Trends
-
-### Current Technology Stack Landscape
-
-[Technology stack analysis from step-02 with current updates]
-_Programming Languages: [Current language trends and adoption patterns]_
-_Frameworks and Libraries: [Popular frameworks and their use cases]_
-_Database and Storage Technologies: [Current data storage and management trends]_
-_API and Communication Technologies: [Integration and communication patterns]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### Technology Adoption Patterns
-
-[Comprehensive technology adoption analysis]
-_Adoption Trends: [Technology adoption rates and patterns]_
-_Migration Patterns: [Technology migration and evolution trends]_
-_Emerging Technologies: [New technologies and their potential impact]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-## 5. Integration and Interoperability Patterns
-
-### Current Integration Approaches
-
-[Integration patterns analysis with current context]
-_API Design Patterns: [Current API design and implementation patterns]_
-_Service Integration: [Microservices and service integration approaches]_
-_Data Integration: [Data exchange and integration patterns]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### Interoperability Standards and Protocols
-
-[Comprehensive interoperability analysis]
-_Standards Compliance: [Industry standards and compliance requirements]_
-_Protocol Selection: [Communication protocols and selection criteria]_
-_Integration Challenges: [Common integration challenges and solutions]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-## 6. Performance and Scalability Analysis
-
-### Performance Characteristics and Optimization
-
-[Performance analysis based on research findings]
-_Performance Benchmarks: [Current performance characteristics and benchmarks]_
-_Optimization Strategies: [Performance optimization approaches and techniques]_
-_Monitoring and Measurement: [Performance monitoring and measurement practices]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### Scalability Patterns and Approaches
-
-[Comprehensive scalability analysis]
-_Scalability Patterns: [Architectural and design patterns for scalability]_
-_Capacity Planning: [Capacity planning and resource management approaches]_
-_Elasticity and Auto-scaling: [Dynamic scaling approaches and implementations]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-## 7. Security and Compliance Considerations
-
-### Security Best Practices and Frameworks
-
-[Security analysis with current context]
-_Security Frameworks: [Current security frameworks and best practices]_
-_Threat Landscape: [Current security threats and mitigation approaches]_
-_Secure Development Practices: [Secure coding and development lifecycle]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### Compliance and Regulatory Considerations
-
-[Comprehensive compliance analysis]
-_Industry Standards: [Relevant industry standards and compliance requirements]_
-_Regulatory Compliance: [Legal and regulatory considerations for {{research_topic}}]_
-_Audit and Governance: [Technical audit and governance practices]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-## 8. Strategic Technical Recommendations
-
-### Technical Strategy and Decision Framework
-
-[Strategic technical recommendations based on comprehensive research]
-_Architecture Recommendations: [Recommended architectural approaches and patterns]_
-_Technology Selection: [Recommended technology stack and selection criteria]_
-_Implementation Strategy: [Recommended implementation approaches and methodologies]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### Competitive Technical Advantage
-
-[Analysis of technical competitive positioning]
-_Technology Differentiation: [Technical approaches that provide competitive advantage]_
-_Innovation Opportunities: [Areas for technical innovation and differentiation]_
-_Strategic Technology Investments: [Recommended technology investments and priorities]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-## 9. Implementation Roadmap and Risk Assessment
-
-### Technical Implementation Framework
-
-[Comprehensive implementation guidance based on research findings]
-_Implementation Phases: [Recommended phased implementation approach]_
-_Technology Migration Strategy: [Approach for technology adoption and migration]_
-_Resource Planning: [Technical resources and capabilities planning]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### Technical Risk Management
-
-[Comprehensive technical risk assessment]
-_Technical Risks: [Major technical risks and mitigation strategies]_
-_Implementation Risks: [Risks associated with implementation and deployment]_
-_Business Impact Risks: [Technical risks and their business implications]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-## 10. Future Technical Outlook and Innovation Opportunities
-
-### Emerging Technology Trends
-
-[Forward-looking technical analysis based on comprehensive research]
-_Near-term Technical Evolution: [1-2 year technical development expectations]_
-_Medium-term Technology Trends: [3-5 year expected technical developments]_
-_Long-term Technical Vision: [5+ year technical outlook for {{research_topic}}]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-### Innovation and Research Opportunities
-
-[Technical innovation analysis and recommendations]
-_Research Opportunities: [Areas for technical research and innovation]_
-_Emerging Technology Adoption: [Potential new technologies and adoption timelines]_
-_Innovation Framework: [Approach for fostering technical innovation]_
-_Source: [URL]_
-
-## 11. Technical Research Methodology and Source Verification
-
-### Comprehensive Technical Source Documentation
-
-[Complete documentation of all technical research sources]
-_Primary Technical Sources: [Key authoritative technical sources used]_
-_Secondary Technical Sources: [Supporting technical research and analysis]_
-_Technical Web Search Queries: [Complete list of technical search queries used]_
-
-### Technical Research Quality Assurance
-
-[Technical quality assurance and validation approach]
-_Technical Source Verification: [All technical claims verified with multiple sources]_
-_Technical Confidence Levels: [Confidence assessments for uncertain technical data]_
-_Technical Limitations: [Technical research limitations and areas for further investigation]_
-_Methodology Transparency: [Complete transparency about technical research approach]_
-
-## 12. Technical Appendices and Reference Materials
-
-### Detailed Technical Data Tables
-
-[Comprehensive technical data tables supporting research findings]
-_Architectural Pattern Tables: [Detailed architectural pattern comparisons]_
-_Technology Stack Analysis: [Detailed technology evaluation and comparison data]_
-_Performance Benchmark Data: [Comprehensive performance measurement data]_
-
-### Technical Resources and References
-
-[Valuable technical resources for continued research and implementation]
-_Technical Standards: [Relevant technical standards and specifications]_
-_Open Source Projects: [Key open source projects and communities]_
-_Research Papers and Publications: [Academic and industry research sources]_
-_Technical Communities: [Professional networks and technical communities]_
-
----
-
-## Technical Research Conclusion
-
-### Summary of Key Technical Findings
-
-[Comprehensive summary of the most important technical research findings]
-
-### Strategic Technical Impact Assessment
-
-[Assessment of technical implications for {{research_topic}}]
-
-### Next Steps Technical Recommendations
-
-[Specific next steps for leveraging this technical research]
-
----
-
-**Technical Research Completion Date:** {{date}}
-**Research Period:** current comprehensive technical analysis
-**Document Length:** As needed for comprehensive technical coverage
-**Source Verification:** All technical facts cited with current sources
-**Technical Confidence Level:** High - based on multiple authoritative technical sources
-
-_This comprehensive technical research document serves as an authoritative technical reference on {{research_topic}} and provides strategic technical insights for informed decision-making and implementation._
-```
-
-### 5. Present Complete Technical Document and Final Option
-
-**Technical Document Completion Presentation:**
-
-"I've completed the **comprehensive technical research document synthesis** for **{{research_topic}}**, producing an authoritative technical research document with:
-
-**Technical Document Features:**
-
-- **Compelling Technical Introduction**: Engaging technical opening that establishes research significance
-- **Comprehensive Technical TOC**: Complete navigation structure for technical reference
-- **Exhaustive Technical Research Coverage**: All technical aspects of {{research_topic}} thoroughly analyzed
-- **Executive Technical Summary**: Key technical findings and strategic implications highlighted
-- **Strategic Technical Recommendations**: Actionable technical insights based on comprehensive research
-- **Complete Technical Source Citations**: Every technical claim verified with current sources
-
-**Technical Research Completeness:**
-
-- Technical landscape and architecture analysis fully documented
-- Implementation approaches and best practices comprehensively covered
-- Technology stack evolution and trends detailed
-- Integration, performance, and security analysis complete
-- Strategic technical insights and implementation guidance provided
-
-**Technical Document Standards Met:**
-
-- Exhaustive technical research with no critical gaps
-- Professional technical structure and compelling narrative
-- As long as needed for comprehensive technical coverage
-- Multiple independent technical sources for all claims
-- current technical data throughout with proper citations
-
-**Ready to complete this comprehensive technical research document?**
-[C] Complete Research - Save final comprehensive technical document
-
-### 6. Handle Final Technical Completion
-
-#### If 'C' (Complete Research):
-
-- **Replace** the template placeholder `[Research overview and methodology will be appended here]` in the `## Research Overview` section near the top of the document with a concise 2-3 paragraph overview summarizing the research scope, key findings, and a pointer to the full executive summary in the Research Synthesis section
-- Append the complete technical document to the research file
-- Update frontmatter: `stepsCompleted: [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]`
-- Complete the technical research workflow
-- Provide final technical document delivery confirmation
-
-## APPEND TO DOCUMENT:
-
-When user selects 'C', append the complete comprehensive technical research document using the full structure above. Also replace the `[Research overview and methodology will be appended here]` placeholder in the Research Overview section at the top of the document.
-
-## SUCCESS METRICS:
-
-✅ Compelling technical introduction with research significance
-✅ Comprehensive technical table of contents with complete document structure
-✅ Exhaustive technical research coverage across all technical aspects
-✅ Executive technical summary with key findings and strategic implications
-✅ Strategic technical recommendations grounded in comprehensive research
-✅ Complete technical source verification with current citations
-✅ Professional technical document structure and compelling narrative
-✅ [C] complete option presented and handled correctly
-✅ Technical research workflow completed with comprehensive document
-
-## FAILURE MODES:
-
-❌ Not producing compelling technical introduction
-❌ Missing comprehensive technical table of contents
-❌ Incomplete technical research coverage across technical aspects
-❌ Not providing executive technical summary with key findings
-❌ Missing strategic technical recommendations based on research
-❌ Relying solely on training data without web verification for current facts
-❌ Producing technical document without professional structure
-❌ Not presenting completion option for final technical document
-
-❌ **CRITICAL**: Reading only partial step file - leads to incomplete understanding and poor decisions
-❌ **CRITICAL**: Proceeding with 'C' without fully reading and understanding the next step file
-❌ **CRITICAL**: Making decisions without complete understanding of step requirements and protocols
-
-## COMPREHENSIVE TECHNICAL DOCUMENT STANDARDS:
-
-This step ensures the final technical research document:
-
-- Serves as an authoritative technical reference on {{research_topic}}
-- Provides strategic technical insights for informed decision-making
-- Includes comprehensive technical coverage with no gaps
-- Maintains rigorous technical source verification standards
-- Delivers strategic technical insights and actionable recommendations
-- Meets professional technical research document quality standards
-
-## TECHNICAL RESEARCH WORKFLOW COMPLETION:
-
-When 'C' is selected:
-
-- All technical research steps completed (1-5)
-- Comprehensive technical research document generated
-- Professional technical document structure with intro, TOC, and summary
-- All technical sections appended with source citations
-- Technical research workflow status updated to complete
-- Final comprehensive technical research document delivered to user
-
-## FINAL TECHNICAL DELIVERABLE:
-
-Complete authoritative technical research document on {{research_topic}} that:
-
-- Establishes technical credibility through comprehensive research
-- Provides strategic technical insights for informed decision-making
-- Serves as technical reference document for continued use
-- Maintains highest technical research quality standards with current verification
-
-Congratulations on completing comprehensive technical research with professional documentation! 🎉

package/tools/skills/bmad-technical-research/workflow.md

@@ -1,52 +0,0 @@
-
-# Technical Research Workflow
-
-**Goal:** Conduct comprehensive technical research using current web data and verified sources to produce complete research documents with compelling narratives and proper citations.
-
-**Your Role:** You are a technical research facilitator working with an expert partner. This is a collaboration where you bring research methodology and web search capabilities, while your partner brings domain knowledge and research direction.
-
-## PREREQUISITE
-
-**⛔ Web search required.** If unavailable, abort and tell the user.
-
-## Activation
-
-1. Load config from `{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/config.yaml` and resolve::
-   - Use `{user_name}` for greeting
-   - Use `{communication_language}` for all communications
-   - Use `{document_output_language}` for output documents
-   - Use `{planning_artifacts}` for output location and artifact scanning
-   - Use `{project_knowledge}` for additional context scanning
-
-## QUICK TOPIC DISCOVERY
-
-"Welcome {{user_name}}! Let's get started with your **technical research**.
-
-**What technology, tool, or technical area do you want to research?**
-
-For example:
-- 'React vs Vue for large-scale applications'
-- 'GraphQL vs REST API architectures'
-- 'Serverless deployment options for Node.js'
-- 'Or any other technical topic you have in mind...'"
-
-### Topic Clarification
-
-Based on the user's topic, briefly clarify:
-1. **Core Technology**: "What specific aspect of [technology] are you most interested in?"
-2. **Research Goals**: "What do you hope to achieve with this research?"
-3. **Scope**: "Should we focus broadly or dive deep into specific aspects?"
-
-## ROUTE TO TECHNICAL RESEARCH STEPS
-
-After gathering the topic and goals:
-
-1. Set `research_type = "technical"`
-2. Set `research_topic = [discovered topic from discussion]`
-3. Set `research_goals = [discovered goals from discussion]`
-4. Create the starter output file: `{planning_artifacts}/research/technical-{{research_topic}}-research-{{date}}.md` with exact copy of the `./research.template.md` contents
-5. Load: `./technical-steps/step-01-init.md` with topic context
-
-**Note:** The discovered topic from the discussion should be passed to the initialization step, so it doesn't need to ask "What do you want to research?" again - it can focus on refining the scope for technical research.
-
-**✅ YOU MUST ALWAYS SPEAK OUTPUT In your Agent communication style with the config `{communication_language}`**