@nerviq/cli 1.18.0 → 1.20.0

package/src/techniques/quality.js

@@ -1,318 +1,318 @@
-/**
- * Quality technique fragments.
- * Generated mechanically from the legacy techniques.js monolith during HR-09.
- */
-
-const {
-  getClaudeInstructionBundle,
-  getRepoInstructionBundle,
-  hasDocumentedVerificationGuidance,
-  hasDocumentedTestCommand,
-  hasDocumentedLintCommand,
-  hasDocumentedBuildCommand,
-  hasFrontendSignals,
-} = require('./shared');
-
-module.exports = {
-  verificationLoop: {
-      id: 93,
-      name: 'Claude instruction surfaces include verification criteria',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        const docs = getRepoInstructionBundle(ctx);
-        return hasDocumentedVerificationGuidance(docs);
-      },
-      impact: 'critical',
-      rating: 5,
-      category: 'quality',
-      fix: 'Add canonical test/lint/build commands to your Claude instruction surfaces (CLAUDE.md, imported docs, or .claude/commands) so Claude can verify its own work.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  testCommand: {
-      id: 93001,
-      name: 'Claude instruction surfaces include a test command',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        return hasDocumentedTestCommand(getRepoInstructionBundle(ctx));
-      },
-      impact: 'high',
-      rating: 5,
-      category: 'quality',
-      fix: 'Add an explicit test command to your Claude instruction surfaces (for example "Run `npm test` before committing").',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  lintCommand: {
-      id: 93002,
-      name: 'Claude instruction surfaces include a lint command',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        return hasDocumentedLintCommand(getRepoInstructionBundle(ctx));
-      },
-      impact: 'high',
-      rating: 4,
-      category: 'quality',
-      fix: 'Add a lint command to your Claude instruction surfaces so Claude can check style and static quality automatically.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  buildCommand: {
-      id: 93003,
-      name: 'Claude instruction surfaces include a build command',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        return hasDocumentedBuildCommand(getRepoInstructionBundle(ctx));
-      },
-      impact: 'medium',
-      rating: 4,
-      category: 'quality',
-      fix: 'Add a build command to your Claude instruction surfaces so Claude can verify compilation before committing.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  frontendDesignSkill: {
-      id: 1025,
-      name: 'Frontend design skill for anti-AI-slop',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        if (!hasFrontendSignals(ctx)) return null;
-        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
-        return md.includes('frontend_aesthetics') || md.includes('anti-AI-slop') || md.includes('frontend-design');
-      },
-      impact: 'medium',
-      rating: 5,
-      category: 'design',
-      fix: 'Install the official frontend-design skill for better UI output quality.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  tailwindMention: {
-      id: 102501,
-      name: 'Tailwind CSS configured',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        if (!hasFrontendSignals(ctx)) return null;
-        const pkg = ctx.fileContent('package.json') || '';
-        return pkg.includes('tailwind') ||
-          ctx.files.some(f => /tailwind\.config/.test(f));
-      },
-      impact: 'low',
-      rating: 3,
-      category: 'design',
-      fix: 'Consider adding Tailwind CSS for rapid, consistent UI styling with Claude.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  claudeMdFreshness: {
-      id: 2001,
-      name: 'CLAUDE.md mentions current Claude features',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
-        if (md.length < 50) return false; // too short to evaluate
-        // Check for awareness of features from 2025+
-        const modernFeatures = ['hook', 'skill', 'agent', 'subagent', 'mcp', 'compact', '/clear', 'extended thinking', 'tool_use', 'worktree'];
-        const found = modernFeatures.filter(f => md.toLowerCase().includes(f));
-        return found.length >= 2; // knows at least 2 modern features
-      },
-      impact: 'medium',
-      rating: 4,
-      category: 'quality-deep',
-      fix: 'Your CLAUDE.md may be outdated. Modern Claude Code supports hooks, skills, agents, MCP, worktrees, and extended thinking. Mention the ones you use.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  claudeMdNoContradictions: {
-      id: 2003,
-      name: 'CLAUDE.md has no obvious contradictions',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent();
-        if (!md || md.length < 50) return false; // no CLAUDE.md or too short = not passing
-        // Check for common contradictions
-        // Check for contradictions on the SAME topic (same line or adjacent sentence)
-        const lines = md.split('\n');
-        let hasContradiction = false;
-        for (const line of lines) {
-          if (/\balways\b.*\bnever\b|\bnever\b.*\balways\b/i.test(line)) {
-            hasContradiction = true;
-            break;
-          }
-        }
-        const hasBothStyles = /\buse tabs\b/i.test(md) && /\buse spaces\b/i.test(md);
-        return !hasContradiction && !hasBothStyles;
-      },
-      impact: 'high',
-      rating: 4,
-      category: 'quality-deep',
-      fix: 'CLAUDE.md may contain contradictory instructions. Review for conflicting rules (e.g., "always X" and "never X" about the same topic).',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  hooksAreSpecific: {
-      id: 2004,
-      name: 'Hooks use specific matchers (not catch-all)',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        const settings = ctx.jsonFile('.claude/settings.local.json') || ctx.jsonFile('.claude/settings.json');
-        if (!settings || !settings.hooks) return null; // no hooks = not applicable
-        const hookStr = JSON.stringify(settings.hooks);
-        // Check that hooks have matchers, not just catch-all
-        return hookStr.includes('matcher');
-      },
-      impact: 'medium',
-      rating: 3,
-      category: 'quality-deep',
-      fix: 'Hooks without matchers run on every tool call. Use matchers like "Write|Edit" or "Bash" to target specific tools.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  commandsUseArguments: {
-      id: 2006,
-      name: 'Commands use $ARGUMENTS for flexibility',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        if (!ctx.hasDir('.claude/commands')) return null; // not applicable
-        const files = ctx.dirFiles('.claude/commands');
-        if (files.length === 0) return null;
-        // Check if at least one command uses $ARGUMENTS
-        for (const f of files) {
-          const content = ctx.fileContent(`.claude/commands/${f}`) || '';
-          if (content.includes('$ARGUMENTS') || content.includes('$arguments')) return true;
-        }
-        return false;
-      },
-      impact: 'medium',
-      rating: 3,
-      category: 'quality-deep',
-      fix: 'Commands without $ARGUMENTS are static. Use $ARGUMENTS to make them flexible: "Fix the issue: $ARGUMENTS"',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  agentsHaveMaxTurns: {
-      id: 2007,
-      name: 'Subagents have max-turns limit',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        if (!ctx.hasDir('.claude/agents')) return null;
-        const files = ctx.dirFiles('.claude/agents');
-        if (files.length === 0) return null;
-        for (const f of files) {
-          const content = ctx.fileContent(`.claude/agents/${f}`) || '';
-          // Current frontmatter uses kebab-case: max-turns (also accept legacy maxTurns)
-          if (!content.includes('max-turns') && !content.includes('maxTurns')) return false;
-        }
-        return true;
-      },
-      impact: 'medium',
-      rating: 3,
-      category: 'quality-deep',
-      fix: 'Subagents without max-turns can run indefinitely. Add "max-turns: 50" to subagent YAML frontmatter.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  securityReviewInWorkflow: {
-      id: 2008,
-      name: '/security-review command or workflow',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        const hasCommand = ctx.hasDir('.claude/commands') &&
-          (ctx.dirFiles('.claude/commands') || []).some(f => f.includes('security') || f.includes('review'));
-        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
-        const hasExplicitRef = /\/security-review|security review command|security workflow/i.test(md);
-        return hasCommand || hasExplicitRef;
-      },
-      impact: 'medium',
-      rating: 4,
-      category: 'quality-deep',
-      fix: 'Claude Code has built-in /security-review (OWASP Top 10). Add it to your workflow or create a /security command.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  testCoverage: {
-      id: 2010,
-      name: 'Test coverage or strategy mentioned',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
-        return /coverage|test.*strateg|e2e|integration test|unit test|##\s*test|writing.*tests|modifying.*tests|run.*test|test.*command/i.test(md);
-      },
-      impact: 'medium', rating: 3, category: 'quality',
-      fix: 'Mention your testing strategy in CLAUDE.md (unit, integration, E2E, coverage targets).',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  typeCheckingConfigured: {
-      id: 2031,
-      name: 'Type checking configured (TypeScript or similar)',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        return !!(ctx.fileContent('tsconfig.json') || ctx.fileContent('jsconfig.json') ||
-          ctx.fileContent('pyrightconfig.json') || ctx.fileContent('mypy.ini'));
-      },
-      impact: 'medium', rating: 3, category: 'quality',
-      fix: 'Add type checking configuration. Type-safe code produces fewer Claude errors.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  noDeprecatedPatterns: {
-      id: 2009,
-      name: 'No deprecated patterns detected',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent();
-        if (!md) return false;
-        // Only flag truly deprecated patterns, not valid aliases
-        const deprecatedPatterns = [
-          /\bhuman_prompt\b/i, /\bassistant_prompt\b/i, // old completions API format (not Messages API)
-          /\buse model claude-3-opus\b/i, // explicit recommendation to use old name as --model
-          /\buse model claude-3-sonnet\b/i,
-        ];
-        return !deprecatedPatterns.some(p => p.test(md));
-      },
-      impact: 'medium',
-      rating: 3,
-      category: 'quality-deep',
-      fix: 'CLAUDE.md references deprecated API patterns (human_prompt/assistant_prompt). Update to current Messages API conventions.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  claudeMdQuality: {
-      id: 102502,
-      name: 'CLAUDE.md has substantive content',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent();
-        if (!md) return null;
-        const lines = md.split('\n').filter(l => l.trim());
-        const sections = (md.match(/^##\s/gm) || []).length;
-        const hasCommand = /\b(npm|yarn|pnpm|pytest|go |make |ruff |cargo |dotnet )\b/i.test(md);
-        return lines.length >= 15 && sections >= 2 && hasCommand;
-      },
-      impact: 'medium',
-      rating: 4,
-      category: 'quality-deep',
-      fix: 'CLAUDE.md exists but lacks substance. Add at least 2 sections (## headings) and include your test/build/lint commands.',
-      template: null
-    },
-
-  consistencyPassAtK: {
-      id: 110005,
-      name: 'Consistency/pass@k evaluation mentioned',
-      check: (ctx) => {
-        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
-        const configPaths = [
-          'package.json',
-          'jest.config.js',
-          'jest.config.cjs',
-          'jest.config.mjs',
-          'vitest.config.js',
-          'vitest.config.ts',
-          'playwright.config.js',
-          'playwright.config.ts',
-          'pytest.ini',
-          'pyproject.toml',
-          'tox.ini',
-          '.github/workflows/ci.yml',
-          '.github/workflows/ci.yaml',
-          '.github/workflows/test.yml',
-          '.github/workflows/test.yaml',
-        ];
-        const configContent = configPaths
-          .map(file => ctx.fileContent(file) || '')
-          .filter(Boolean)
-          .join('\n');
-  
-        return /pass@k|consistency|multiple runs?|reproducib/i.test(`${md}\n${configContent}`);
-      },
-      impact: 'low', rating: 3, category: 'quality',
-      fix: 'Mention pass@k or consistency testing in CLAUDE.md or test configuration so repeated-run quality evaluation is explicit.',
-      template: null,
-      confidence: 0.7,
-    },
-};
+/**
+ * Quality technique fragments.
+ * Generated mechanically from the legacy techniques.js monolith during HR-09.
+ */
+
+const {
+  getClaudeInstructionBundle,
+  getRepoInstructionBundle,
+  hasDocumentedVerificationGuidance,
+  hasDocumentedTestCommand,
+  hasDocumentedLintCommand,
+  hasDocumentedBuildCommand,
+  hasFrontendSignals,
+} = require('./shared');
+
+module.exports = {
+  verificationLoop: {
+      id: 93,
+      name: 'Claude instruction surfaces include verification criteria',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        const docs = getRepoInstructionBundle(ctx);
+        return hasDocumentedVerificationGuidance(docs);
+      },
+      impact: 'critical',
+      rating: 5,
+      category: 'quality',
+      fix: 'Add canonical test/lint/build commands to your Claude instruction surfaces (CLAUDE.md, imported docs, or .claude/commands) so Claude can verify its own work.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  testCommand: {
+      id: 93001,
+      name: 'Claude instruction surfaces include a test command',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        return hasDocumentedTestCommand(getRepoInstructionBundle(ctx));
+      },
+      impact: 'high',
+      rating: 5,
+      category: 'quality',
+      fix: 'Add an explicit test command to your Claude instruction surfaces (for example "Run `npm test` before committing").',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  lintCommand: {
+      id: 93002,
+      name: 'Claude instruction surfaces include a lint command',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        return hasDocumentedLintCommand(getRepoInstructionBundle(ctx));
+      },
+      impact: 'high',
+      rating: 4,
+      category: 'quality',
+      fix: 'Add a lint command to your Claude instruction surfaces so Claude can check style and static quality automatically.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  buildCommand: {
+      id: 93003,
+      name: 'Claude instruction surfaces include a build command',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        return hasDocumentedBuildCommand(getRepoInstructionBundle(ctx));
+      },
+      impact: 'medium',
+      rating: 4,
+      category: 'quality',
+      fix: 'Add a build command to your Claude instruction surfaces so Claude can verify compilation before committing.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  frontendDesignSkill: {
+      id: 1025,
+      name: 'Frontend design skill for anti-AI-slop',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        if (!hasFrontendSignals(ctx)) return null;
+        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
+        return md.includes('frontend_aesthetics') || md.includes('anti-AI-slop') || md.includes('frontend-design');
+      },
+      impact: 'medium',
+      rating: 5,
+      category: 'design',
+      fix: 'Install the official frontend-design skill for better UI output quality.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  tailwindMention: {
+      id: 102501,
+      name: 'Tailwind CSS configured',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        if (!hasFrontendSignals(ctx)) return null;
+        const pkg = ctx.fileContent('package.json') || '';
+        return pkg.includes('tailwind') ||
+          ctx.files.some(f => /tailwind\.config/.test(f));
+      },
+      impact: 'low',
+      rating: 3,
+      category: 'design',
+      fix: 'Consider adding Tailwind CSS for rapid, consistent UI styling with Claude.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  claudeMdFreshness: {
+      id: 2001,
+      name: 'CLAUDE.md mentions current Claude features',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
+        if (md.length < 50) return false; // too short to evaluate
+        // Check for awareness of features from 2025+
+        const modernFeatures = ['hook', 'skill', 'agent', 'subagent', 'mcp', 'compact', '/clear', 'extended thinking', 'tool_use', 'worktree'];
+        const found = modernFeatures.filter(f => md.toLowerCase().includes(f));
+        return found.length >= 2; // knows at least 2 modern features
+      },
+      impact: 'medium',
+      rating: 4,
+      category: 'quality-deep',
+      fix: 'Your CLAUDE.md may be outdated. Modern Claude Code supports hooks, skills, agents, MCP, worktrees, and extended thinking. Mention the ones you use.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  claudeMdNoContradictions: {
+      id: 2003,
+      name: 'CLAUDE.md has no obvious contradictions',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent();
+        if (!md || md.length < 50) return false; // no CLAUDE.md or too short = not passing
+        // Check for common contradictions
+        // Check for contradictions on the SAME topic (same line or adjacent sentence)
+        const lines = md.split('\n');
+        let hasContradiction = false;
+        for (const line of lines) {
+          if (/\balways\b.*\bnever\b|\bnever\b.*\balways\b/i.test(line)) {
+            hasContradiction = true;
+            break;
+          }
+        }
+        const hasBothStyles = /\buse tabs\b/i.test(md) && /\buse spaces\b/i.test(md);
+        return !hasContradiction && !hasBothStyles;
+      },
+      impact: 'high',
+      rating: 4,
+      category: 'quality-deep',
+      fix: 'CLAUDE.md may contain contradictory instructions. Review for conflicting rules (e.g., "always X" and "never X" about the same topic).',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  hooksAreSpecific: {
+      id: 2004,
+      name: 'Hooks use specific matchers (not catch-all)',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        const settings = ctx.jsonFile('.claude/settings.local.json') || ctx.jsonFile('.claude/settings.json');
+        if (!settings || !settings.hooks) return null; // no hooks = not applicable
+        const hookStr = JSON.stringify(settings.hooks);
+        // Check that hooks have matchers, not just catch-all
+        return hookStr.includes('matcher');
+      },
+      impact: 'medium',
+      rating: 3,
+      category: 'quality-deep',
+      fix: 'Hooks without matchers run on every tool call. Use matchers like "Write|Edit" or "Bash" to target specific tools.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  commandsUseArguments: {
+      id: 2006,
+      name: 'Commands use $ARGUMENTS for flexibility',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        if (!ctx.hasDir('.claude/commands')) return null; // not applicable
+        const files = ctx.dirFiles('.claude/commands');
+        if (files.length === 0) return null;
+        // Check if at least one command uses $ARGUMENTS
+        for (const f of files) {
+          const content = ctx.fileContent(`.claude/commands/${f}`) || '';
+          if (content.includes('$ARGUMENTS') || content.includes('$arguments')) return true;
+        }
+        return false;
+      },
+      impact: 'medium',
+      rating: 3,
+      category: 'quality-deep',
+      fix: 'Commands without $ARGUMENTS are static. Use $ARGUMENTS to make them flexible: "Fix the issue: $ARGUMENTS"',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  agentsHaveMaxTurns: {
+      id: 2007,
+      name: 'Subagents have max-turns limit',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        if (!ctx.hasDir('.claude/agents')) return null;
+        const files = ctx.dirFiles('.claude/agents');
+        if (files.length === 0) return null;
+        for (const f of files) {
+          const content = ctx.fileContent(`.claude/agents/${f}`) || '';
+          // Current frontmatter uses kebab-case: max-turns (also accept legacy maxTurns)
+          if (!content.includes('max-turns') && !content.includes('maxTurns')) return false;
+        }
+        return true;
+      },
+      impact: 'medium',
+      rating: 3,
+      category: 'quality-deep',
+      fix: 'Subagents without max-turns can run indefinitely. Add "max-turns: 50" to subagent YAML frontmatter.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  securityReviewInWorkflow: {
+      id: 2008,
+      name: '/security-review command or workflow',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        const hasCommand = ctx.hasDir('.claude/commands') &&
+          (ctx.dirFiles('.claude/commands') || []).some(f => f.includes('security') || f.includes('review'));
+        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
+        const hasExplicitRef = /\/security-review|security review command|security workflow/i.test(md);
+        return hasCommand || hasExplicitRef;
+      },
+      impact: 'medium',
+      rating: 4,
+      category: 'quality-deep',
+      fix: 'Claude Code has built-in /security-review (OWASP Top 10). Add it to your workflow or create a /security command.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  testCoverage: {
+      id: 2010,
+      name: 'Test coverage or strategy mentioned',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
+        return /coverage|test.*strateg|e2e|integration test|unit test|##\s*test|writing.*tests|modifying.*tests|run.*test|test.*command/i.test(md);
+      },
+      impact: 'medium', rating: 3, category: 'quality',
+      fix: 'Mention your testing strategy in CLAUDE.md (unit, integration, E2E, coverage targets).',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  typeCheckingConfigured: {
+      id: 2031,
+      name: 'Type checking configured (TypeScript or similar)',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        return !!(ctx.fileContent('tsconfig.json') || ctx.fileContent('jsconfig.json') ||
+          ctx.fileContent('pyrightconfig.json') || ctx.fileContent('mypy.ini'));
+      },
+      impact: 'medium', rating: 3, category: 'quality',
+      fix: 'Add type checking configuration. Type-safe code produces fewer Claude errors.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  noDeprecatedPatterns: {
+      id: 2009,
+      name: 'No deprecated patterns detected',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent();
+        if (!md) return false;
+        // Only flag truly deprecated patterns, not valid aliases
+        const deprecatedPatterns = [
+          /\bhuman_prompt\b/i, /\bassistant_prompt\b/i, // old completions API format (not Messages API)
+          /\buse model claude-3-opus\b/i, // explicit recommendation to use old name as --model
+          /\buse model claude-3-sonnet\b/i,
+        ];
+        return !deprecatedPatterns.some(p => p.test(md));
+      },
+      impact: 'medium',
+      rating: 3,
+      category: 'quality-deep',
+      fix: 'CLAUDE.md references deprecated API patterns (human_prompt/assistant_prompt). Update to current Messages API conventions.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  claudeMdQuality: {
+      id: 102502,
+      name: 'CLAUDE.md has substantive content',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent();
+        if (!md) return null;
+        const lines = md.split('\n').filter(l => l.trim());
+        const sections = (md.match(/^##\s/gm) || []).length;
+        const hasCommand = /\b(npm|yarn|pnpm|pytest|go |make |ruff |cargo |dotnet )\b/i.test(md);
+        return lines.length >= 15 && sections >= 2 && hasCommand;
+      },
+      impact: 'medium',
+      rating: 4,
+      category: 'quality-deep',
+      fix: 'CLAUDE.md exists but lacks substance. Add at least 2 sections (## headings) and include your test/build/lint commands.',
+      template: null
+    },
+
+  consistencyPassAtK: {
+      id: 110005,
+      name: 'Consistency/pass@k evaluation mentioned',
+      check: (ctx) => {
+        const md = ctx.claudeMdContent() || '';
+        const configPaths = [
+          'package.json',
+          'jest.config.js',
+          'jest.config.cjs',
+          'jest.config.mjs',
+          'vitest.config.js',
+          'vitest.config.ts',
+          'playwright.config.js',
+          'playwright.config.ts',
+          'pytest.ini',
+          'pyproject.toml',
+          'tox.ini',
+          '.github/workflows/ci.yml',
+          '.github/workflows/ci.yaml',
+          '.github/workflows/test.yml',
+          '.github/workflows/test.yaml',
+        ];
+        const configContent = configPaths
+          .map(file => ctx.fileContent(file) || '')
+          .filter(Boolean)
+          .join('\n');
+  
+        return /pass@k|consistency|multiple runs?|reproducib/i.test(`${md}\n${configContent}`);
+      },
+      impact: 'low', rating: 3, category: 'quality',
+      fix: 'Mention pass@k or consistency testing in CLAUDE.md or test configuration so repeated-run quality evaluation is explicit.',
+      template: null,
+      confidence: 0.7,
+    },
+};