@nahisaho/shikigami 1.44.0 → 1.47.0

package/AGENTS.md

@@ -313,7 +313,7 @@ When user says "project created", "created project", or similar:
 4. **(Phase 2)** **Purpose Discovery** → Discover true purpose through 1Q1A dialogue
 5. **(Phase 3)** **Deep Research** → Think→Search→Report→Action cycle
 6. **(Phase 4)** **Framework Analysis** → Apply SWOT/3C/PEST etc.
-7. **(Phase 5)** **Report Generation** → Create structured report
+7. **(Phase 5)** **Report Generation** → Select template → Write report → Quality check → **WAIT for approval**
 8. **(Phase 6)** **Complete** → Update manifest.yaml, verify deliverables
 
 ### Case B: New research request (no project yet)
@@ -329,12 +329,13 @@ When receiving a new research request:
 7. **(Phase 2)** **Purpose Discovery** → Discover true purpose through 1Q1A dialogue
 8. **(Phase 3)** **Deep Research** → Think→Search→Report→Action cycle
 9. **(Phase 4)** **Framework Analysis** → Apply SWOT/3C/PEST etc.
-10. **(Phase 5)** **Report Generation** → Create structured report
+10. **(Phase 5)** **Report Generation** → Select template → Write report → Quality check → **WAIT for approval**
 11. **(Phase 6)** **Complete** → Update manifest.yaml, verify deliverables
 
 **MANDATORY APPROVAL POINTS** (must wait for user before proceeding):
 - Case B Step 1: Project name confirmation
 - Phase 1 (both cases): Structured prompt approval
+- Phase 5→6 (both cases): Quality check approval
 
 ---
 
@@ -545,16 +546,85 @@ OUTPUT: Completed report (under reports/), reference list
 ```
 
 **Template Selection Criteria**:
-| Report Type | Template | Use When |
-|-------------|----------|----------|
-| Research Report | research-report | General investigation, market research, technology assessment |
-| Proposal | proposal | Recommendations, action plans, business cases |
-| Qiita Article | qiita-article | Technical content for publication |
-| Executive Summary | executive-summary | Brief overview for decision makers |
-| Comparison Report | comparison-report | Product/service/technology comparisons |
-| Feasibility Study | feasibility-study | Viability assessment, go/no-go decisions |
-| Competitive Analysis | competitive-analysis | Competitor landscape, positioning |
-| Technical Report | technical-report | Deep technical investigation |
+
+**Category 1: Approval & Decision**
+| Purpose Keywords | Template | Use When |
+|------------------|----------|----------|
+| 予算承認、投資申請、コスト承認 | budget-approval | Budget/investment approval requests |
+| 即時承認、緊急承認、迅速決定 | immediate-approval | Time-sensitive approvals |
+| 段階承認、フェーズ承認、マイルストーン | staged-approval | Multi-phase approval processes |
+| パイロット、試験導入、PoC承認 | pilot-approval | Pilot/trial approvals |
+| 変更要求、変更管理、スコープ変更 | change-request | Change requests, scope changes |
+
+**Category 2: Analysis & Research**
+| Purpose Keywords | Template | Use When |
+|------------------|----------|----------|
+| 市場調査、市場分析、マーケット | market-analysis | Market research, industry analysis |
+| 競合分析、競合調査、ライバル | competitive-analysis | Competitor landscape analysis |
+| ユーザー調査、UXリサーチ、顧客理解 | user-research | User/customer research |
+| リスク評価、リスク分析、脆弱性 | risk-assessment | Risk assessment, vulnerability analysis |
+| デューデリジェンス、M&A、投資判断 | due-diligence | Due diligence, M&A evaluation |
+| ABテスト、実験結果、比較実験 | ab-test | A/B test results, experiment reports |
+
+**Category 3: Vendor & Procurement**
+| Purpose Keywords | Template | Use When |
+|------------------|----------|----------|
+| ベンダー評価、製品選定、ツール選定 | vendor-evaluation | Vendor/product evaluation |
+| RFI、情報提供依頼、事前調査 | rfi | Request for Information |
+| RFP、提案依頼、入札 | rfp | Request for Proposal |
+| SLA、サービスレベル、契約条件 | sla | SLA definition, service contracts |
+
+**Category 4: Technical & Security**
+| Purpose Keywords | Template | Use When |
+|------------------|----------|----------|
+| 技術調査、技術評価、アーキテクチャ | technical-report | Deep technical investigation |
+| セキュリティ評価、脆弱性診断、監査 | security-assessment | Security audits, assessments |
+| コンプライアンス、規制対応、法令遵守 | compliance | Compliance reports, regulatory |
+
+**Category 5: Business & Strategy**
+| Purpose Keywords | Template | Use When |
+|------------------|----------|----------|
+| ビジネスケース、投資対効果、ROI | business-case | Business case, ROI analysis |
+| エグゼクティブサマリー、経営報告 | executive-summary | Brief overview for executives |
+| ホワイトペーパー、技術解説、啓蒙 | white-paper | Thought leadership, technical papers |
+| 検討資料、比較検討、オプション分析 | consideration | Options analysis, consideration docs |
+
+**Category 6: Project & Operations**
+| Purpose Keywords | Template | Use When |
+|------------------|----------|----------|
+| プロジェクト状況、進捗報告、ステータス | project-status | Project status reports |
+| ポストモーテム、振り返り、障害報告 | post-mortem | Incident reviews, retrospectives |
+| ロードマップ、製品計画、開発計画 | product-roadmap | Product/development roadmaps |
+| QBR、四半期レビュー、業績報告 | qbr | Quarterly business reviews |
+
+**Category 7: Sales & Customer**
+| Purpose Keywords | Template | Use When |
+|------------------|----------|----------|
+| 営業資料、セールス、提案書 | sales-playbook | Sales enablement materials |
+| 顧客成功事例、ケーススタディ、導入事例 | customer-success | Customer success stories |
+
+**Category 8: Learning & Collaboration**
+| Purpose Keywords | Template | Use When |
+|------------------|----------|----------|
+| 研修資料、トレーニング、教育 | training-material | Training/education materials |
+| ワークショップ、ファシリテーション | workshop | Workshop design, facilitation |
+| インタビューガイド、ヒアリング | interview-guide | Interview/hearing guides |
+| 共同研究、産学連携、研究提案 | joint-research-proposal | Joint research proposals |
+| 思考フロー、分析過程、ロジック展開 | thinking-flow-report | Thinking process documentation |
+
+**Template Selection Flow**:
+```
+WHEN: Phase 5 starts
+DO:
+  1. Extract purpose keywords from user's original request
+  2. Match keywords against Template Selection Criteria tables
+  3. If multiple matches, prioritize by:
+     a. Exact keyword match
+     b. Category relevance
+     c. User's stated output format
+  4. If no match found, use 'consideration' as default
+  5. Confirm template selection with user before writing
+```
 
 **CRITICAL**: Always use `shikigami-report-template` skill to load the appropriate template BEFORE writing. Template provides:
 - Required sections and structure
@@ -611,6 +681,89 @@ OUTPUT: Completed report (under reports/), reference list
 | 4→5 | 1+ framework applied, numerical verification done | Not required |
 | 5→6 | Report exists, quality check passed, citations complete | **Required** |
 
+### Quality Checklist (Phase 5→6 Gate)
+
+```
+WHEN: Report draft completed, before Phase 6
+DO: Execute ALL checks below. Report CANNOT proceed to Phase 6 until all items pass.
+```
+
+**1. Numerical Consistency Check** ✅
+| Check Item | How to Verify | FAIL Condition |
+|------------|---------------|----------------|
+| Source attribution | Every number has [[n]] citation | Any number without citation |
+| Percentage totals | Sum of percentages = 100% (or explicitly explained) | Silent deviation from 100% |
+| Text-table match | Numbers in body text match tables/charts | Any discrepancy |
+| Unit correctness | 億/万/thousand/million used correctly | Unit mismatch or confusion |
+| Time series order | Chronological data in correct sequence | Year/date ordering errors |
+| Calculation accuracy | Derived numbers (growth rate, averages) are correct | Math errors |
+
+**2. Citation Completeness Check** 📚
+| Check Item | How to Verify | FAIL Condition |
+|------------|---------------|----------------|
+| Inline citations | All facts/claims have [[n]] format | Uncited factual statements |
+| References list | All [[n]] appear in References section | Missing reference entries |
+| URL validity | All URLs are accessible | 404 or dead links |
+| No vague sources | No "various sources", "it is said that" | Vague attributions |
+| Date recorded | All references include access date | Missing dates |
+
+**3. Content Consistency Check** 🔄
+| Check Item | How to Verify | FAIL Condition |
+|------------|---------------|----------------|
+| Executive summary sync | Summary numbers match body text | Any discrepancy |
+| Conclusion alignment | Conclusions supported by analysis | Unsupported claims |
+| Conflict markers handled | All (?), (⚡), (💭) items addressed | Unresolved conflicts |
+| MECE coverage | No gaps or overlaps in analysis | Logical gaps |
+
+**4. Format & Structure Check** 📋
+| Check Item | How to Verify | FAIL Condition |
+|------------|---------------|----------------|
+| Template compliance | All required sections present | Missing sections |
+| Heading hierarchy | Proper H1→H2→H3 structure | Broken hierarchy |
+| Table formatting | Tables render correctly | Malformed tables |
+| Link formatting | All links work correctly | Broken markdown links |
+
+**Quality Check Execution Flow**:
+```
+Phase 5 Complete
+    ↓
+[1] Run Numerical Consistency Check
+    ↓ (All pass?)
+[2] Run Citation Completeness Check  
+    ↓ (All pass?)
+[3] Run Content Consistency Check
+    ↓ (All pass?)
+[4] Run Format & Structure Check
+    ↓ (All pass?)
+Generate Quality Report Summary
+    ↓
+Request User Approval for Phase 6
+```
+
+**Quality Report Format**:
+```markdown
+## Quality Check Results
+
+| Category | Status | Issues Found |
+|----------|--------|-------------|
+| Numerical Consistency | ✅ PASS / ❌ FAIL | [count] issues |
+| Citation Completeness | ✅ PASS / ❌ FAIL | [count] issues |
+| Content Consistency | ✅ PASS / ❌ FAIL | [count] issues |
+| Format & Structure | ✅ PASS / ❌ FAIL | [count] issues |
+
+### Issues to Address (if any)
+1. [Issue description and location]
+2. [Issue description and location]
+```
+
+**Auto-Fix Rules**:
+| Issue Type | Auto-Fix Action |
+|------------|----------------|
+| Missing citation | Flag with ⚠️, request source |
+| Percentage ≠ 100% | Add "(その他: X%)" or note |
+| Unit confusion | Standardize to larger unit |
+| Dead URL | Attempt Wayback Machine recovery |
+
 ---
 
 ## File Saving Rules
@@ -871,4 +1024,4 @@ DO: Auto-detect Shift_JIS/EUC-JP/ISO-2022-JP and convert to UTF-8
 ---
 
 **Last Updated**: 2026-01-28  
-**Version**: 1.44.0
+**Version**: 1.47.0

package/CHANGELOG.md

@@ -5,6 +5,61 @@ All notable changes to SHIKIGAMI will be documented in this file.
 The format is based on [Keep a Changelog](https://keepachangelog.com/en/1.0.0/),
 and this project adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0.html).
 
+## [1.47.0] - 2026-01-28
+
+### Changed
+
+- **AGENTS.md: Integrate template selection & quality check into workflow overview**
+  - Case A Phase 5: "Create structured report" → "Select template → Write report → Quality check → **WAIT for approval**"
+  - Case B Phase 5: Same update
+  - Added Phase 5→6 to MANDATORY APPROVAL POINTS
+  - Quality check approval now required before Phase 6
+
+## [1.46.0] - 2026-01-28
+
+### Added
+
+- **AGENTS.md: Detailed Quality Checklist (Phase 5→6 Gate)**
+  - **Numerical Consistency Check**: 6 items
+    - Source attribution, percentage totals, text-table match
+    - Unit correctness, time series order, calculation accuracy
+  - **Citation Completeness Check**: 5 items
+    - Inline citations, references list, URL validity
+    - No vague sources, date recorded
+  - **Content Consistency Check**: 4 items
+    - Executive summary sync, conclusion alignment
+    - Conflict markers handled, MECE coverage
+  - **Format & Structure Check**: 4 items
+    - Template compliance, heading hierarchy
+    - Table formatting, link formatting
+  - Quality Check Execution Flow diagram
+  - Quality Report Format template
+  - Auto-Fix Rules for common issues
+
+## [1.45.0] - 2026-01-28
+
+### Added
+
+- **AGENTS.md: Complete Template Selection Criteria (33 templates)**
+  - Category 1: Approval & Decision (5 templates)
+    - budget-approval, immediate-approval, staged-approval, pilot-approval, change-request
+  - Category 2: Analysis & Research (6 templates)
+    - market-analysis, competitive-analysis, user-research, risk-assessment, due-diligence, ab-test
+  - Category 3: Vendor & Procurement (4 templates)
+    - vendor-evaluation, rfi, rfp, sla
+  - Category 4: Technical & Security (3 templates)
+    - technical-report, security-assessment, compliance
+  - Category 5: Business & Strategy (4 templates)
+    - business-case, executive-summary, white-paper, consideration
+  - Category 6: Project & Operations (4 templates)
+    - project-status, post-mortem, product-roadmap, qbr
+  - Category 7: Sales & Customer (2 templates)
+    - sales-playbook, customer-success
+  - Category 8: Learning & Collaboration (5 templates)
+    - training-material, workshop, interview-guide, joint-research-proposal, thinking-flow-report
+  - Japanese purpose keywords for each template
+  - Template Selection Flow with matching logic
+
 ## [1.44.0] - 2026-01-28
 
 ### Added

package/package.json

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 {
   "name": "@nahisaho/shikigami",
-  "version": "1.44.0",
+  "version": "1.47.0",
   "description": "GitHub Copilot Agent Skills for Deep Research & Consulting - AI-Powered Research Assistant with 50+ Consulting Frameworks",
   "keywords": [
     "github-copilot",