@mycodemap/mycodemap 0.4.0 → 0.4.2

package/scripts/validate-docs.js

@@ -4,6 +4,7 @@
 import { existsSync, readFileSync } from 'node:fs';
 import path from 'node:path';
 import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url';
+import { collectAnalyzeDocSyncFailures } from './sync-analyze-docs.js';
 
 const __dirname = path.dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url));
 const defaultRootDir = path.resolve(__dirname, '..');
@@ -45,6 +46,20 @@ function expectNotIncludes(text, snippet, label, failures) {
   }
 }
 
+function validateSnippets(text, label, requiredSnippets, outdatedSnippets, failures) {
+  if (!text) {
+    return;
+  }
+
+  for (const snippet of requiredSnippets) {
+    expectIncludes(text, snippet, label, failures);
+  }
+
+  for (const snippet of outdatedSnippets) {
+    expectNotIncludes(text, snippet, label, failures);
+  }
+}
+
 function validatePackageScripts(rootDir, failures) {
   const packageJsonText = readText(rootDir, 'package.json', failures);
   if (!packageJsonText) {
@@ -67,43 +82,553 @@ function validatePackageScripts(rootDir, failures) {
 
 function validateAnalyzeDocs(rootDir, failures) {
   const readme = readText(rootDir, 'README.md', failures);
-  const cliSource = readText(rootDir, 'src/cli/index.ts', failures);
-
-  if (!readme || !cliSource) {
+  const aiGuide = readText(rootDir, 'AI_GUIDE.md', failures);
+  const claudeGuide = readText(rootDir, 'CLAUDE.md', failures);
+  const commandsGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md', failures);
+  const outputGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/OUTPUT.md', failures);
+  const engineeringGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/rules/engineering-with-codex-openai.md', failures);
+  const analyzeOptionsSource = readText(rootDir, 'src/cli/commands/analyze-options.ts', failures);
+  const cliIndexSource = readText(rootDir, 'src/cli/index.ts', failures);
+
+  if (!analyzeOptionsSource || !cliIndexSource) {
     return;
   }
 
-  const requiredCliSnippets = [
-    ".option('-i, --intent <type>'",
-    ".option('-t, --targets <paths...>'",
-    ".option('-k, --keywords <words...>'",
-    ".option('--include-tests'"
+  const requiredAnalyzeOptionSnippets = [
+    'ANALYZE_OPTION_DEFINITIONS',
+    "flags: '-i, --intent <type>'",
+    "flags: '-t, --targets <paths...>'",
+    "flags: '-k, --keywords <words...>'",
+    "flags: '--include-tests'",
+    'docDescription:',
+    'docDefaultValue:',
+    'getAnalyzeHelpText'
   ];
 
-  for (const snippet of requiredCliSnippets) {
-    expectIncludes(cliSource, snippet, 'src/cli/index.ts', failures);
+  for (const snippet of requiredAnalyzeOptionSnippets) {
+    expectIncludes(
+      analyzeOptionsSource,
+      snippet,
+      'src/cli/commands/analyze-options.ts',
+      failures
+    );
   }
 
-  const requiredReadmeExamples = [
-    'mycodemap analyze -i overview -t src/orchestrator',
-    'mycodemap analyze -i impact -t src/cli/index.ts --include-tests',
-    'mycodemap analyze -i dependency -t src/cli/index.ts',
-    'mycodemap analyze -i search -k UnifiedResult'
-  ];
+  expectIncludes(cliIndexSource, 'configureAnalyzeCommand(', 'src/cli/index.ts', failures);
+
+  validateSnippets(
+    readme,
+    'README.md analyze examples',
+    [
+      'mycodemap analyze -i find -k SourceLocation',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i read -t src/cli/index.ts --include-tests --json',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i link -t src/cli/index.ts',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i show -t src/orchestrator',
+      '`refactor` 会返回 `E0001_INVALID_INTENT`'
+    ],
+    [
+      'mycodemap analyze -i overview -t src/orchestrator',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i impact -t src/cli/index.ts --include-tests',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i dependency -t src/cli/index.ts',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i search -k UnifiedResult',
+      'mycodemap analyze --intent impact --file src/cli/index.ts'
+    ],
+    failures
+  );
+
+  validateSnippets(
+    aiGuide,
+    'AI_GUIDE.md analyze baseline',
+    [
+      'analyze -i show -t "src/" --json',
+      'node dist/cli/index.js analyze -i read -t "{{FILE}}" --scope transitive --json',
+      'intent: "find" | "read" | "link" | "show";'
+    ],
+    [
+      'analyze -i overview -t "src/" --json',
+      'node dist/cli/index.js analyze -i impact -t "{{FILE}}" --transitive --json',
+      'analyze -i refactor'
+    ],
+    failures
+  );
+
+  validateSnippets(
+    commandsGuide,
+    'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md analyze baseline',
+    [
+      '### 当前公共契约：4 种分析意图',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i find -k "UnifiedResult"',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i read -t "src/index.ts" --scope transitive',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i link -t "src/orchestrator"',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i show -t "src/"',
+      '### legacy 兼容映射'
+    ],
+    [
+      '### 当前实现：8 种分析意图（过渡态）',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i impact -t "src/index.ts"',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i dependency -t "src/orchestrator"',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i complexity -t "src/domain"',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i search -k "UnifiedResult"',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i overview -t "src/"',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i refactor -t "src/cache"',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i reference -t "src/interface/types"',
+      'mycodemap analyze -i documentation -t "src/domain/services"'
+    ],
+    failures
+  );
+
+  validateSnippets(
+    outputGuide,
+    'docs/ai-guide/OUTPUT.md analyze schema',
+    [
+      '当前公共契约已固定为 `find` / `read` / `link` / `show`',
+      'type AnalyzeIntent = "find" | "read" | "link" | "show";',
+      'warnings?: AnalyzeWarning[];',
+      'analysis?: ReadAnalysis | LinkAnalysis | ShowAnalysis;',
+      '"intent": "read"',
+      '"code": "deprecated-intent"'
+    ],
+    [
+      '当前仍是 8 意图过渡态，本文件先记录真实 schema',
+      'intent: "impact" | "dependency" | "search" | "documentation" | "complexity" | "overview" | "refactor" | "reference";'
+    ],
+    failures
+  );
+
+  validateSnippets(
+    claudeGuide,
+    'CLAUDE.md analyze retrieval guidance',
+    [
+      'node dist/cli/index.js analyze -i <find|read|link|show>'
+    ],
+    [
+      'node dist/cli/index.js analyze <intent>'
+    ],
+    failures
+  );
+
+  validateSnippets(
+    engineeringGuide,
+    'docs/rules/engineering-with-codex-openai.md analyze guardrail',
+    [
+      'node dist/cli/index.js analyze --help',
+      '`find` / `read` / `link` / `show`',
+      '`warnings[]`',
+      '`--structured --json`'
+    ],
+    [
+      '`--output-mode machine --json`',
+      'analyze documentation'
+    ],
+    failures
+  );
+
+  failures.push(...collectAnalyzeDocSyncFailures(rootDir));
+}
+
+function validatePositioningBaselineDocs(rootDir, failures) {
+  const readme = readText(rootDir, 'README.md', failures);
+  const aiGuide = readText(rootDir, 'AI_GUIDE.md', failures);
+  const aiGuideIndex = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/README.md', failures);
+  const outputGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/OUTPUT.md', failures);
+  const architecture = readText(rootDir, 'ARCHITECTURE.md', failures);
+
+  if (readme) {
+    const requiredReadmeSnippets = [
+      'AI-first 代码地图工具',
+      'AI/Agent 是主要消费者',
+      '`server`、`watch`、`report`、`logs` 已从 public CLI 移除，并在调用时给出迁移提示。'
+    ];
+
+    for (const snippet of requiredReadmeSnippets) {
+      expectIncludes(readme, snippet, 'README.md positioning baseline', failures);
+    }
 
-  for (const example of requiredReadmeExamples) {
-    expectIncludes(readme, example, 'README.md analyze examples', failures);
+    expectNotIncludes(
+      readme,
+      '当前公共 CLI 仍包含 `workflow`、`ship`、`server`、`watch`、`report`、`logs` 等过渡能力',
+      'README.md positioning baseline',
+      failures
+    );
   }
 
-  const outdatedReadmeExamples = [
-    'mycodemap analyze "',
-    'mycodemap analyze --intent impact --file',
-    'mycodemap analyze --intent dependency --file',
-    'mycodemap analyze --intent search "'
-  ];
+  if (aiGuide) {
+    const requiredAiGuideSnippets = [
+      'CodeMap 是一个 AI-first 代码地图工具',
+      '当前 CLI 过渡现实',
+      '`Server Layer` 是内部架构层，不等于公共 `mycodemap server` 命令',
+      '后者已从 public CLI 移除'
+    ];
+
+    for (const snippet of requiredAiGuideSnippets) {
+      expectIncludes(aiGuide, snippet, 'AI_GUIDE.md positioning baseline', failures);
+    }
+  }
+
+  if (aiGuideIndex) {
+    const requiredIndexSnippets = [
+      'AI-first 代码地图工具',
+      'AI/Agent 是主要消费者',
+      '`server`、`watch`、`report`、`logs` 已从 public CLI 移除'
+    ];
+
+    for (const snippet of requiredIndexSnippets) {
+      expectIncludes(aiGuideIndex, snippet, 'docs/ai-guide/README.md positioning baseline', failures);
+    }
+  }
+
+  if (outputGuide) {
+    const requiredOutputSnippets = [
+      '目标态',
+      '当前 CLI 现实',
+      '机器可读优先'
+    ];
+
+    for (const snippet of requiredOutputSnippets) {
+      expectIncludes(outputGuide, snippet, 'docs/ai-guide/OUTPUT.md contract baseline', failures);
+    }
+  }
+
+  if (architecture) {
+    expectIncludes(
+      architecture,
+      '`Server Layer` 是内部架构层，不等于公共 `mycodemap server` 命令',
+      'ARCHITECTURE.md naming boundary',
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+}
+
+function validateCliSurfaceDocs(rootDir, failures) {
+  const readme = readText(rootDir, 'README.md', failures);
+  const aiGuide = readText(rootDir, 'AI_GUIDE.md', failures);
+  const aiGuideIndex = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/README.md', failures);
+  const commandsGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md', failures);
+  const setupGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/SETUP_GUIDE.md', failures);
+  const assistantGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/AI_ASSISTANT_SETUP.md', failures);
+  const quickstart = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/QUICKSTART.md', failures);
+  const integration = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/INTEGRATION.md', failures);
+
+  if (readme) {
+    expectIncludes(readme, '### 已移除的公共 CLI 命令', 'README.md cli surface', failures);
+
+    const outdatedReadmeSnippets = [
+      '### `mycodemap watch`',
+      '### `mycodemap report`（当前过渡能力）',
+      '### `mycodemap logs`（当前过渡能力）',
+      '### `mycodemap server`（当前过渡能力，且不等于 Server Layer）',
+    ];
+
+    for (const snippet of outdatedReadmeSnippets) {
+      expectNotIncludes(readme, snippet, 'README.md cli surface', failures);
+    }
+  }
+
+  if (aiGuide) {
+    expectNotIncludes(aiGuide, '后者当前仍公开', 'AI_GUIDE.md cli surface', failures);
+  }
+
+  if (aiGuideIndex) {
+    expectNotIncludes(
+      aiGuideIndex,
+      '`workflow`、`server`、`watch`、`report`、`logs`、`ship` 仍是当前公开的过渡能力',
+      'docs/ai-guide/README.md cli surface',
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (commandsGuide) {
+    expectIncludes(commandsGuide, '## 已移除的公共命令', 'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md cli surface', failures);
+
+    const outdatedCommandSnippets = [
+      '## server - HTTP 服务器（当前过渡能力）',
+      '### watch - 监听模式',
+      '### report - 生成报告',
+      '### logs - 日志管理',
+    ];
+
+    for (const snippet of outdatedCommandSnippets) {
+      expectNotIncludes(commandsGuide, snippet, 'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md cli surface', failures);
+    }
+  }
+
+  if (setupGuide) {
+    expectIncludes(setupGuide, '### 已移除的公共 CLI 命令', 'docs/SETUP_GUIDE.md cli surface', failures);
+    expectNotIncludes(setupGuide, '### 监听模式', 'docs/SETUP_GUIDE.md cli surface', failures);
+    expectNotIncludes(setupGuide, 'mycodemap watch', 'docs/SETUP_GUIDE.md cli surface', failures);
+  }
+
+  if (assistantGuide) {
+    expectIncludes(
+      assistantGuide,
+      '若文档或提示词仍把 `server`、`watch`、`report`、`logs` 当成当前 public CLI',
+      'docs/AI_ASSISTANT_SETUP.md cli surface',
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (quickstart) {
+    expectIncludes(
+      quickstart,
+      '公共 `mycodemap server` 命令已从 public CLI 移除',
+      'docs/ai-guide/QUICKSTART.md cli surface',
+      failures
+    );
+    expectNotIncludes(
+      quickstart,
+      '公共 `mycodemap server` 命令仍存在',
+      'docs/ai-guide/QUICKSTART.md cli surface',
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (integration) {
+    expectNotIncludes(integration, 'mycodemap watch', 'docs/ai-guide/INTEGRATION.md cli surface', failures);
+  }
+}
+
+function validateConfigDocs(rootDir, failures) {
+  const readme = readText(rootDir, 'README.md', failures);
+  const setupGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/SETUP_GUIDE.md', failures);
+  const assistantGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/AI_ASSISTANT_SETUP.md', failures);
 
-  for (const example of outdatedReadmeExamples) {
-    expectNotIncludes(readme, example, 'README.md analyze examples', failures);
+  if (readme) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      readme,
+      'README.md config contract',
+      [
+        '执行后会在项目根目录生成 `mycodemap.config.json` 配置文件。',
+        '通过 `mycodemap init` 生成的 `mycodemap.config.json` 配置文件支持以下选项：',
+        '"$schema": "https://mycodemap.dev/schema/config.json"',
+        '"mode": "hybrid"',
+        '"plugins": {',
+        '| `plugins.builtInPlugins` | `boolean` | 是否启用内置插件 | `true` |'
+      ],
+      [
+        '执行后会在项目根目录生成 `codemap.config.json` 配置文件。',
+        '通过 `codemap init` 生成的 `codemap.config.json` 配置文件支持以下选项：',
+        '"$schema": "https://codemap.dev/schema.json"',
+        '"mode": "fast"'
+      ],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (setupGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      setupGuide,
+      'docs/SETUP_GUIDE.md config contract',
+      [
+        '生成的配置文件 `mycodemap.config.json`：',
+        '"include": ["src/**/*.ts"]',
+        '"watch": false',
+        '"plugins": {',
+        '| `plugins.debug` | boolean | `false` | 是否输出插件调试日志 |'
+      ],
+      [
+        '"include": ["src/**/*"]'
+      ],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (assistantGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      assistantGuide,
+      'docs/AI_ASSISTANT_SETUP.md config contract',
+      [
+        '- `mycodemap.config.json` - CodeMap 配置文件'
+      ],
+      [
+        '- `codemap.config.json` - CodeMap 配置文件'
+      ],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+}
+
+function validatePluginRuntimeDocs(rootDir, failures) {
+  const readme = readText(rootDir, 'README.md', failures);
+  const aiGuide = readText(rootDir, 'AI_GUIDE.md', failures);
+  const commandsGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md', failures);
+  const outputGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/OUTPUT.md', failures);
+  const quickstartGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/QUICKSTART.md', failures);
+
+  if (readme) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      readme,
+      'README.md plugin runtime contract',
+      [
+        '只有**显式声明了** `plugins` 段时，`generate` 才会启用插件 runtime；没有该段的旧项目保持原有行为。',
+        '`AI_MAP.md` 的 `Plugin Summary` 与 `codemap.json` 的 `pluginReport`',
+        '已加载插件、插件生成文件数量与插件诊断摘要'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (aiGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      aiGuide,
+      'AI_GUIDE.md plugin runtime contract',
+      [
+        '`codemap.json.pluginReport`',
+        '`pluginReport.diagnostics[]` 用统一结构暴露 `load / initialize / analyze / generate` 四个阶段'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (commandsGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      commandsGuide,
+      'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md plugin runtime contract',
+      [
+        '`generate` 不提供独立 `--plugin` flags；插件通过 `mycodemap.config.json` 的 `plugins` 段声明。',
+        '`AI_MAP.md` 会增加 `Plugin Summary`，`codemap.json` 会增加 `pluginReport`'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (outputGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      outputGuide,
+      'docs/ai-guide/OUTPUT.md plugin runtime contract',
+      [
+        'interface PluginExecutionReport {',
+        'pluginReport?: PluginExecutionReport;',
+        'stage: "load" | "initialize" | "analyze" | "generate";'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (quickstartGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      quickstartGuide,
+      'docs/ai-guide/QUICKSTART.md plugin runtime contract',
+      [
+        '若显式配置了 plugins，也要看 Plugin Summary',
+        '解析 `.mycodemap/codemap.json` 的 `pluginReport`'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+}
+
+function validateGraphStorageDocs(rootDir, failures) {
+  const readme = readText(rootDir, 'README.md', failures);
+  const aiGuide = readText(rootDir, 'AI_GUIDE.md', failures);
+  const commandsGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md', failures);
+  const quickstartGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/QUICKSTART.md', failures);
+  const setupGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/SETUP_GUIDE.md', failures);
+  const validationRule = readText(rootDir, 'docs/rules/validation.md', failures);
+  const schema = readText(rootDir, 'mycodemap.config.schema.json', failures);
+
+  if (readme) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      readme,
+      'README.md graph storage contract',
+      [
+        '"storage": {',
+        '| `storage.type` | `"filesystem" \\| "kuzudb" \\| "memory" \\| "auto"` | 图存储后端类型 | `"filesystem"` |',
+        '`neo4j` 已不再是正式支持的 backend；旧配置会返回显式迁移错误，不会静默 fallback 到 `filesystem`。',
+        '图存储后端生产化不等于重新开放公共 HTTP API 产品面；`Server Layer` 仍是内部架构层。'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (aiGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      aiGuide,
+      'AI_GUIDE.md graph storage contract',
+      [
+        '| "需要切换/排查图存储后端" | 编辑 `mycodemap.config.json.storage` → 运行 `generate` / `export` |',
+        '`generate` 会写入配置的图存储后端；`export` 与内部 `Server Layer` handler 会读取同一份后端数据。',
+        '`neo4j` 已不再是正式支持的 backend；旧配置会暴露显式迁移错误，不会静默 fallback。'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (commandsGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      commandsGuide,
+      'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md graph storage contract',
+      [
+        '`generate` 会读取 `mycodemap.config.json.storage`，并把 CodeGraph 写入所选后端。',
+        '`export json|graphml|dot` 会从 `mycodemap.config.json.storage` 指定的后端读取 CodeGraph。',
+        '图存储后端收口不等于重新开放公共 `mycodemap server` 产品面；`Server Layer` 仍是内部层。'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (quickstartGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      quickstartGuide,
+      'docs/ai-guide/QUICKSTART.md graph storage contract',
+      [
+        'stdout 还会显示当前写入的 `MVP3 Storage (...)`',
+        '| "需要切换/排查图存储后端" | 编辑 `mycodemap.config.json.storage` 后运行 `generate` | `export json` 验证是否能从同一 backend 读回 | 文本 + 机器可读 |'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (setupGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      setupGuide,
+      'docs/SETUP_GUIDE.md graph storage contract',
+      [
+        '"storage": {',
+        '| `storage.type` | string | `"filesystem"` | 图存储后端类型：`filesystem` / `kuzudb` / `memory` / `auto` |',
+        '旧的 `neo4j` 配置已不再受支持，会返回显式迁移错误，不会静默 fallback 到 `filesystem`。'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (validationRule) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      validationRule,
+      'docs/rules/validation.md graph storage guardrail',
+      [
+        '若改动涉及 `mycodemap.config.json.storage` 或图数据库适配器',
+        'schema / README / AI 文档没同步',
+        '旧的 `neo4j` 配置已经不受支持，但文档还把它写成正式 backend'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (schema) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      schema,
+      'mycodemap.config.schema.json storage contract',
+      [
+        '"storage"',
+        '"enum": ["filesystem", "kuzudb", "memory", "auto"]',
+        '"outputPath"',
+        '"databasePath"',
+        '"autoThresholds"'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
   }
 }
 
@@ -133,6 +658,194 @@ function validateTestingDocs(rootDir, failures) {
   expectIncludes(testingRule, '`vitest.benchmark.config.ts`', 'docs/rules/testing.md', failures);
 }
 
+function validateWorkflowAndDiscoveryDocs(rootDir, failures) {
+  const readme = readText(rootDir, 'README.md', failures);
+  const aiGuide = readText(rootDir, 'AI_GUIDE.md', failures);
+  const commandsGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md', failures);
+  const outputGuide = readText(rootDir, 'docs/ai-guide/OUTPUT.md', failures);
+  const engineeringRule = readText(rootDir, 'docs/rules/engineering-with-codex-openai.md', failures);
+  const validationRule = readText(rootDir, 'docs/rules/validation.md', failures);
+
+  if (readme) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      readme,
+      'README.md workflow/discovery boundary',
+      [
+        '`workflow` 是公开的 analysis-only 工作流能力，只编排分析阶段：`find → read → link → show`。',
+        '共享同一套 `.gitignore` 感知排除规则',
+        '"coverage/**"',
+        '"**/*.test.ts"',
+        '"**/*.spec.ts"',
+        '"**/*.d.ts"',
+        '`mycodemap ship` 的 CHECK 阶段现在复用 `ci check-working-tree`、`ci check-branch`、`ci check-scripts`'
+      ],
+      [
+        '    "*.test.ts",',
+        '    "*.spec.ts",'
+      ],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (aiGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      aiGuide,
+      'AI_GUIDE.md discovery baseline',
+      [
+        '| 文件发现契约 | 扫描类命令共享 `.gitignore` 感知排除模块；无 `.gitignore` 时回退到默认 `exclude` |'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (commandsGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      commandsGuide,
+      'docs/ai-guide/COMMANDS.md workflow/ci boundary',
+      [
+        '`ship` 的 CHECK 阶段会复用 `ci check-working-tree`、`ci check-branch`、`ci check-scripts`',
+        '`ci check-branch --allow` 支持 `*` 通配',
+        '`ci check-headers -d` 与 `generate` / `analyze` 共享同一套 `.gitignore` 感知排除规则',
+        '`workflow` 只保留 `find → read → link → show` 四个分析阶段'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (outputGuide) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      outputGuide,
+      'docs/ai-guide/OUTPUT.md discovery contract',
+      [
+        '| 文件发现 | 扫描类命令共享一个文件发现模块 | 先尊重仓库 `.gitignore`，无 `.gitignore` 时回退到默认 `exclude` |',
+        'type DiscoveryFallbackExclude =',
+        '"coverage/**"',
+        '"**/*.test.ts"',
+        '"**/*.spec.ts"',
+        '"**/*.d.ts"',
+        'sharedBy: ["generate", "analyze", "ci check-headers -d"];'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (engineeringRule) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      engineeringRule,
+      'docs/rules/engineering-with-codex-openai.md workflow/ci boundary',
+      [
+        '`ci check-branch --allow` 支持 `*` 通配；在 CI / PR 环境中，分支识别会回退到 `GITHUB_HEAD_REF` / `GITHUB_REF_NAME`。',
+        '`generate`、`analyze` 与 `ci check-headers -d` 共享 `.gitignore` 感知文件发现模块；没有 `.gitignore` 时回退到统一默认 `exclude`。',
+        '`check-working-tree`、`check-branch`、`check-scripts` 作为共享发布前 gate checks，由本地 `ci` 命令提供，`ship` 的 CHECK 阶段直接复用它们。'
+      ],
+      [
+        '然后再通过 `node dist/cli/index.js ci ...` 执行 `check-working-tree`、`check-branch`、`check-scripts`'
+      ],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (validationRule) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      validationRule,
+      'docs/rules/validation.md workflow/discovery boundary',
+      [
+        '若改动涉及产品定位、输出契约、共享文件发现规则或 `Server Layer` / `mycodemap server` 边界',
+        '当前 CI Gateway 直接执行 `check-docs-sync`、commit 格式、文件头、risk、output contract；`ship` 的本地 CHECK 阶段复用 `check-working-tree`、`check-branch`、`check-scripts`',
+        '文档声称扫描类命令会尊重 `.gitignore`，但实现仍保留手写跳过规则',
+        '把 `workflow` 重新扩回非分析阶段，却没同步 README / AI 命令文档 / guardrail 脚本'
+      ],
+      [],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+}
+
+function validateProductSpecsDocs(rootDir, failures) {
+  const productSpecsReadme = readText(rootDir, 'docs/product-specs/README.md', failures);
+  const comparison = readText(rootDir, 'docs/product-specs/MVP3-ARCHITECTURE-COMPARISON.md', failures);
+  const prd = readText(rootDir, 'docs/product-specs/MVP3-ARCHITECTURE-REDESIGN-PRD.md', failures);
+  const techPrd = readText(rootDir, 'docs/product-specs/MVP3-ARCHITECTURE-REDESIGN-TECH-PRD.md', failures);
+
+  if (productSpecsReadme) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      productSpecsReadme,
+      'docs/product-specs/README.md active specs index',
+      [
+        '## 当前有效规格',
+        '`MVP3-ARCHITECTURE-COMPARISON.md`',
+        '`MVP3-ARCHITECTURE-REDESIGN-PRD.md`',
+        '`MVP3-ARCHITECTURE-REDESIGN-TECH-PRD.md`'
+      ],
+      [
+        '当前活跃产品规格暂为空'
+      ],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (comparison) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      comparison,
+      'docs/product-specs/MVP3-ARCHITECTURE-COMPARISON.md baseline',
+      [
+        '# MVP3 架构对比：历史设计目标 vs v1.3 已落地基线',
+        '`src/server/` 保留为**内部架构层**；公共 `server` 命令已移除',
+        '`filesystem` / `memory` / `kuzudb` / `auto` 为正式 surface；`neo4j` 已退出正式支持',
+        '当前公开能力仅保留 analysis-only：`find → read → link → show`',
+        'Java / Rust / C/C++ 等更多 parser 实现 | 接口预留，未作为当前 shipped reality |'
+      ],
+      [
+        '# MVP3 架构对比：Before vs After',
+        'cli/commands/viz.ts',
+        '支持 14 种语言'
+      ],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (prd) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      prd,
+      'docs/product-specs/MVP3-ARCHITECTURE-REDESIGN-PRD.md shipped baseline',
+      [
+        '# CodeMap MVP3 架构重构产品需求文档（PRD，v1.3 同步版）',
+        '公共 CLI 不再暴露 `server`、`watch`、`report`、`logs`',
+        '| `neo4j` | removed | 不再是正式支持 backend；旧配置返回显式迁移错误 |',
+        '`workflow` 是 **analysis-only** 能力，只编排 `find → read → link → show`',
+        '| 公共 HTTP API / `mycodemap server` 产品面 | Deferred |'
+      ],
+      [
+        '支持 14 种语言',
+        'neo4j | shipped'
+      ],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (techPrd) {
+    validateSnippets(
+      techPrd,
+      'docs/product-specs/MVP3-ARCHITECTURE-REDESIGN-TECH-PRD.md technical baseline',
+      [
+        '# CodeMap MVP3 架构重构技术需求文档（Tech-PRD，v1.3 同步版）',
+        '`neo4j` 已不再是正式支持 backend。',
+        '`auto` 是稳定配置面',
+        '但“按规模自动切到图数据库”的更强启发式仍是未来候选，而不是当前完成能力',
+        '| analyze / refresh / incremental update 作为公共能力 | 明确返回 `501` unsupported |',
+        '`workflow` 当前是 analysis-only 能力：'
+      ],
+      [
+        'TypeScriptParser, GoParser, PythonParser, ParserRegistry'
+      ],
+      failures
+    );
+  }
+}
+
 function validateGuardrailDocs(rootDir, failures) {
   const readme = readText(rootDir, 'README.md', failures);
   const engineeringRule = readText(rootDir, 'docs/rules/engineering-with-codex-openai.md', failures);
@@ -219,8 +932,15 @@ function validateDocs(rootDir) {
   const failures = [];
 
   validatePackageScripts(rootDir, failures);
+  validatePositioningBaselineDocs(rootDir, failures);
+  validateCliSurfaceDocs(rootDir, failures);
+  validateConfigDocs(rootDir, failures);
+  validatePluginRuntimeDocs(rootDir, failures);
+  validateGraphStorageDocs(rootDir, failures);
   validateAnalyzeDocs(rootDir, failures);
   validateTestingDocs(rootDir, failures);
+  validateWorkflowAndDiscoveryDocs(rootDir, failures);
+  validateProductSpecsDocs(rootDir, failures);
   validateGuardrailDocs(rootDir, failures);
   validateAssistantDocs(rootDir, failures);