@mnstry/atelier 0.2.0-alpha.5 → 0.2.0-alpha.8

package/src/projection/obsidian/edits/object-store.mjs

@@ -0,0 +1,517 @@
+import { randomBytes as cryptoRandomBytes, randomUUID } from 'node:crypto'
+import fs from 'node:fs'
+import path from 'node:path'
+import { isPendingPrivateWrite } from '../../../project/durable-state.mjs'
+import { checkManagedRoots } from '../../../project/file-class.mjs'
+import { atomicReplacePrivateText, ensureContainedPrivateDirectory, openRegularFileNoFollow, syncPrivateDirectory } from '../../../project/private-state.mjs'
+import { canonicalJson, isoTime } from '../../../runtime/obsidian/documents.mjs'
+import { createAbandonmentProof, machineDigest } from '../../../runtime/obsidian/private-lock.mjs'
+import { OBSIDIAN_EXT_KEY, validateObsidianContract } from '../contracts.mjs'
+import { sha256Digest } from '../materialize/byte-lens.mjs'
+import { ARBITRATION_RULES, EditArbitrationRefusal, OBJECT_EVENT_SCHEMA, REFUSED_DISPOSITIONS, arbitrateEvents, isObjectEvent, recordableOperation, refuseArbitration, sameOrigin } from './arbitrate.mjs'
+import { decodeIdentitySegment, encodeIdentitySegment, isIdentifier, isIdentitySegment } from './object-identity.mjs'
+import { editIdempotencyKey } from './observe.mjs'
+
+// Durable arbitration of edits, shared by every view of one workspace.
+//
+//   <stateRoot>/state/objects/<repo>/<node>/000000000001.json   the events of one object
+//   <stateRoot>/state/object-index/<repo>/<node>.json           a derived summary, a cache
+//
+// <repo> and <node> are encoded identifiers (object-identity.mjs); the
+// repository is part of the key, so equal node ids of two repositories never
+// meet. The state root is private workspace state, outside every repository
+// and vault.
+//
+// The events of an object are its only truth. An event is one complete,
+// canonical JSON file named by its sequence number, published with a
+// non-overwriting hard link and never rewritten or removed. Every event names
+// the digest of the one before it. An appender reads the log through N,
+// decides, and publishes N+1; of two appenders exactly one gets the name, and
+// the other reads again and decides again against what it lost to. So every
+// event was decided against exactly the events before it, the log is a
+// serialization of everything any process did, and there is no last writer to
+// win: what an operation becomes is a function of the whole log
+// (arbitrate.mjs), not of who wrote last.
+//
+// The compare/apply lease of an object is two of those events. Holding it
+// means the last `lease-acquired` is not followed by its `lease-released`.
+// It is taken from a holder only with proof that the holder is gone: its
+// process does not exist on this machine (the proof rules of the engine lock,
+// runtime/obsidian/private-lock.mjs). No amount of elapsed time is proof. A
+// holder on another machine, or a live process that no longer knows it holds
+// the lease, needs a person; so does an object whose log cannot be read,
+// which refuses every operation and is never repaired by guessing.
+//
+// Only what the log cannot derive is asked of the caller; what it can derive
+// is also written down, as `conflict-declared`, `superseded` and
+// `siblings-stale` events that follow the event that caused them. A crash
+// between the two loses nothing: the state is derived from the cause, and the
+// next writer or `recoverObject` appends the declaration that is missing.
+//
+// Bounds. An event is at most 16 KiB (an observation is about 1.5 KiB). An
+// object holds at most 4096 events, about 500 edits taken through a full
+// apply; the last 64 are kept for settling what is in flight (intent,
+// outcome, declarations, release), so an observation or a new lease refuses
+// `object-log-full` first. Nothing is rotated, compacted or dropped: a full
+// object refuses, and what becomes of it is a person's decision.
+//
+// Nothing here writes to a source file or to a vault, and no event, index or
+// error holds note or source text: identifiers, digests, store references,
+// codes, numbers and timestamps only.
+
+export const OBJECTS_DIRECTORY = path.join('state', 'objects')
+export const OBJECT_INDEX_DIRECTORY = path.join('state', 'object-index')
+export const OBJECT_INDEX_SCHEMA = 'atelier-obsidian-object-index/v1'
+export const EDIT_ACKNOWLEDGEMENT_SCHEMA = 'atelier-obsidian-edit-acknowledgement/v1'
+export const OBJECT_STORE_LIMITS = Object.freeze({ maxEventBytes: 16 * 1024, maxEventsPerObject: 4096, reservedForSettlement: 64, maxAppendAttempts: 256 })
+export const OBJECT_STORE_CRASH_STEPS = Object.freeze(['event-linked', 'event-published', 'index-updated'])
+
+const EVENT_NAME = /^(\d{12})\.json$/
+const eventName = (sequence) => `${String(sequence).padStart(12, '0')}.json`
+const NEEDS_PERSON = new Set(['held-on-another-machine'])
+
+export const OBJECT_STORE_PRIMITIVES = Object.freeze({
+  rules: ARBITRATION_RULES,
+  limits: OBJECT_STORE_LIMITS,
+  // Proof that the holder of a lease is gone: its process does not exist on
+  // this machine. There is no maximum age.
+  proveAbandoned: createAbandonmentProof(),
+  // An index is used only when it was derived from exactly the events present.
+  indexIsCurrent: ({ index, eventCount, headDigest }) => index.sequence === eventCount && index.headDigest === headDigest,
+})
+
+// The members of `values` that were given: an absent optional member is absent from the event, never null.
+const optional = (values) => Object.fromEntries(Object.entries(values).filter(([, value]) => value !== undefined && value !== null))
+
+function readBytesNoFollow(file) {
+  const descriptor = openRegularFileNoFollow(file)
+  try { return fs.readFileSync(descriptor) } finally { fs.closeSync(descriptor) }
+}
+
+export function createObjectStoreForOracleTests(primitives = OBJECT_STORE_PRIMITIVES) {
+  const { rules, limits, proveAbandoned, indexIsCurrent } = primitives
+
+  return function openObjectStore({ stateRoot, workspaceId, repositoryRoots, clock, crash = () => {}, randomBytes = cryptoRandomBytes } = {}) {
+    if (typeof stateRoot !== 'string' || !path.isAbsolute(stateRoot)) throw new TypeError('stateRoot must be an absolute path')
+    if (!isIdentifier(workspaceId)) throw new TypeError('workspaceId must be a contract identifier')
+    if (typeof clock !== 'function') throw new TypeError('a clock must be injected')
+    if (!Array.isArray(repositoryRoots) || repositoryRoots.some((item) => typeof item !== 'string' || !path.isAbsolute(item))) {
+      throw new TypeError('repositoryRoots must list the absolute root of every enrolled repository; pass an explicit empty list when there is none')
+    }
+    const guard = checkManagedRoots({ managedRoots: [stateRoot], repositoryRoots })
+    if (!guard.ok) refuseArbitration('state-root-overlaps-repository', 'the arbitration state may not overlap an enrolled repository', { codes: guard.refusals.map((item) => item.code) })
+    fs.mkdirSync(stateRoot, { recursive: true, mode: 0o700 })
+    const root = fs.realpathSync.native(stateRoot)
+    // Two processes may create the same directory at once; the one that loses
+    // the mkdir finds it made, and checks it like any other.
+    const privateDir = (...parts) => {
+      for (let attempt = 0; ; attempt += 1) {
+        try { return ensureContainedPrivateDirectory({ workspaceRoot: root, directory: path.join(root, ...parts), label: 'edit arbitration state' }) } catch (error) {
+          if (error.code !== 'EEXIST' || attempt >= 8) throw error
+        }
+      }
+    }
+    const objectsRoot = privateDir(OBJECTS_DIRECTORY)
+    const indexRoot = privateDir(OBJECT_INDEX_DIRECTORY)
+    // Verified prefixes of logs this store has read. Events are immutable and
+    // chained, so a verified prefix stays verified; recoverObject reads afresh.
+    const verified = new Map()
+
+    function identityOf(value) {
+      const identity = { workspaceId, repoId: value?.repoId, nodeId: value?.nodeId }
+      if (!isIdentifier(identity.repoId) || !isIdentifier(identity.nodeId)) refuseArbitration('invalid-identity', 'an object is named by a repository identifier and a node identifier')
+      if (value.workspaceId !== undefined && value.workspaceId !== workspaceId) refuseArbitration('foreign-workspace', 'the object belongs to another workspace')
+      return identity
+    }
+    const segmentsOf = (identity) => [encodeIdentitySegment(identity.repoId), encodeIdentitySegment(identity.nodeId)]
+    const pointerOf = (identity) => ({ repoId: identity.repoId, nodeId: identity.nodeId })
+
+    // ---- reading ---------------------------------------------------------
+
+    function listEventNames(directory, identity) {
+      let names
+      try { names = fs.readdirSync(directory) } catch (error) {
+        if (error.code === 'ENOENT') return 0
+        if (error.code === 'ENOTDIR') refuseArbitration('foreign-object-file', 'something that is not a directory stands where the object is kept', pointerOf(identity))
+        throw error
+      }
+      let highest = 0
+      for (const name of names) {
+        if (isPendingPrivateWrite(name)) continue
+        const match = EVENT_NAME.exec(name)
+        if (!match || Number(match[1]) < 1) refuseArbitration('foreign-object-file', 'the object directory holds a file that is not an event; nothing is decided until a person has looked', pointerOf(identity))
+        highest = Math.max(highest, Number(match[1]))
+      }
+      return highest
+    }
+
+    function readEvent(directory, identity, sequence, previous) {
+      const corrupt = (code, message) => refuseArbitration(code, message, { ...pointerOf(identity), sequence })
+      let bytes
+      try {
+        const file = path.join(directory, eventName(sequence))
+        if (fs.lstatSync(file).size > limits.maxEventBytes) corrupt('object-event-too-large', 'an event is larger than an event can be')
+        bytes = readBytesNoFollow(file)
+      } catch (error) {
+        if (error instanceof EditArbitrationRefusal) throw error
+        // Events are published in order and never removed, so a name that is
+        // listed has every lower name beside it.
+        return corrupt(error.code === 'ENOENT' ? 'object-log-gap' : 'object-event-unreadable', 'an event of the object cannot be read')
+      }
+      let document
+      try { document = JSON.parse(bytes.toString('utf8')) } catch { return corrupt('object-event-malformed', 'an event of the object is not a document') }
+      if (!isObjectEvent(document) || canonicalJson(document) !== bytes.toString('utf8')) corrupt('object-event-malformed', 'an event of the object is not a valid canonical event')
+      if (document.workspaceId !== identity.workspaceId || document.repoId !== identity.repoId || document.nodeId !== identity.nodeId) corrupt('object-event-foreign', 'an event names another object')
+      if (document.sequence !== sequence || document.previous !== previous) corrupt('object-log-chain-broken', 'an event does not follow the one before it')
+      return { document, digest: sha256Digest(bytes) }
+    }
+
+    // { directory, events, digests, derived }. Refuses a log that cannot be trusted.
+    function readLog(identity, { fresh = false } = {}) {
+      const directory = path.join(objectsRoot, ...segmentsOf(identity))
+      const highest = listEventNames(directory, identity)
+      const cached = fresh ? undefined : verified.get(directory)
+      const events = cached ? [...cached.events] : []
+      const digests = cached ? [...cached.digests] : []
+      if (highest < events.length) refuseArbitration('object-log-shortened', 'events of the object have disappeared', pointerOf(identity))
+      for (let sequence = events.length + 1; sequence <= highest; sequence += 1) {
+        const { document, digest } = readEvent(directory, identity, sequence, digests.at(-1) ?? null)
+        events.push(document)
+        digests.push(digest)
+      }
+      verified.set(directory, { events, digests })
+      const derived = arbitrateEvents(events, rules)
+      if (derived.violations.length > 0) {
+        refuseArbitration('object-log-inconsistent', 'the events of the object are not a history this store could have written', { ...pointerOf(identity), violations: derived.violations })
+      }
+      return { directory, events, digests, derived: { ...derived, identity } }
+    }
+
+    // ---- writing ---------------------------------------------------------
+
+    // 'published' or 'taken'. A crash leaves a complete event or none, and at
+    // most a private staging file that no reader takes for an event.
+    function publishEvent(directory, document) {
+      const text = canonicalJson(document)
+      const bytes = Buffer.from(text, 'utf8')
+      if (bytes.length > limits.maxEventBytes) refuseArbitration('object-event-too-large', 'the event is larger than an event can be', { sequence: document.sequence, bytes: bytes.length })
+      const file = path.join(directory, eventName(document.sequence))
+      const pending = path.join(directory, `.atelier-write-${randomUUID()}.tmp`)
+      const context = { type: document.type, sequence: document.sequence, repoId: document.repoId, nodeId: document.nodeId }
+      let descriptor
+      let crashed = false
+      const seam = (step) => { try { crash(step, context) } catch (error) { crashed = true; throw error } }
+      try {
+        descriptor = openRegularFileNoFollow(pending, fs.constants.O_WRONLY | fs.constants.O_CREAT | fs.constants.O_EXCL, 0o600)
+        fs.writeFileSync(descriptor, bytes); fs.fsyncSync(descriptor); fs.closeSync(descriptor); descriptor = undefined
+        try { fs.linkSync(pending, file) } catch (error) {
+          if (error.code !== 'EEXIST') throw error
+          // The same bytes under the name: the same decision, made twice.
+          if (!readBytesNoFollow(file).equals(bytes)) return 'taken'
+        }
+        seam('event-linked')
+        syncPrivateDirectory(directory)
+        if (!readBytesNoFollow(file).equals(bytes)) throw new Error('published event readback mismatch')
+        seam('event-published')
+        return 'published'
+      } finally {
+        if (descriptor !== undefined) fs.closeSync(descriptor)
+        // A crashed process removes nothing.
+        if (!crashed) try { fs.unlinkSync(pending) } catch (error) { if (error.code !== 'ENOENT') throw error }
+      }
+    }
+
+    function objectDirectory(identity) {
+      const [repo, node] = segmentsOf(identity)
+      const existed = fs.existsSync(path.join(objectsRoot, repo, node))
+      const directory = privateDir(OBJECTS_DIRECTORY, repo, node)
+      if (!existed) { syncPrivateDirectory(path.join(objectsRoot, repo)); syncPrivateDirectory(objectsRoot) }
+      return directory
+    }
+
+    // Appends the event `build(derived)` describes, decided against exactly
+    // the events before it. `build` returns { type, body }, or { done } when
+    // nothing is to be appended. The reducer is the judge: an event it would
+    // list as a violation is refused with that code and never written.
+    function append(identity, build, { settling = false } = {}) {
+      for (let attempt = 0; attempt < limits.maxAppendAttempts; attempt += 1) {
+        const log = readLog(identity)
+        const decided = build(log.derived, log)
+        if (Object.hasOwn(decided, 'done')) return { appended: false, log, value: decided.done }
+        const ceiling = limits.maxEventsPerObject - (settling ? 0 : limits.reservedForSettlement)
+        if (log.events.length >= ceiling) refuseArbitration('object-log-full', 'the object holds as many events as an object may; nothing is rotated or dropped', { ...pointerOf(identity), events: log.events.length, limit: limits.maxEventsPerObject })
+        const event = { schema: OBJECT_EVENT_SCHEMA, ...identity, sequence: log.events.length + 1, previous: log.digests.at(-1) ?? null, type: decided.type, recordedAt: isoTime(clock), body: decided.body }
+        if (!isObjectEvent(event)) refuseArbitration('invalid-event', 'the event is not one this store records', { type: decided.type })
+        const after = arbitrateEvents([...log.events, event], rules)
+        if (after.violations.length > 0) refuseArbitration(after.violations[0].code, 'the events of the object do not allow this', { ...pointerOf(identity), type: decided.type })
+        if (publishEvent(objectDirectory(identity), event) === 'taken') continue
+        return { appended: true, event, log: readLog(identity) }
+      }
+      return refuseArbitration('append-contention', 'the object was appended to by others on every attempt', pointerOf(identity))
+    }
+
+    // What the log can derive and has not yet written down, oldest cause first.
+    function declare(identity) {
+      for (;;) {
+        const { appended } = append(identity, ({ undeclared }) => {
+          if (undeclared.siblingsStale !== null) return { type: 'siblings-stale', body: undeclared.siblingsStale }
+          if (undeclared.superseded.length > 0) return { type: 'superseded', body: { operations: undeclared.superseded } }
+          if (undeclared.conflicted.length > 0) return { type: 'conflict-declared', body: { operations: undeclared.conflicted } }
+          return { done: true }
+        }, { settling: true })
+        if (!appended) return
+      }
+    }
+
+    // ---- the index, a cache ---------------------------------------------
+
+    const indexFile = (identity) => { const [repo, node] = segmentsOf(identity); return path.join(indexRoot, repo, `${node}.json`) }
+
+    function indexDocument({ derived, digests }) {
+      const scopes = new Set()
+      const operations = derived.operations.map((entry) => {
+        const own = [...new Set(entry.origins.map((origin) => origin.scopeId))].sort()
+        for (const scopeId of own) scopes.add(scopeId)
+        return { idempotencyKey: entry.idempotencyKey, kind: entry.kind, state: entry.state, reason: entry.reason, scopes: own }
+      })
+      return {
+        schema: OBJECT_INDEX_SCHEMA, ...derived.identity, sequence: derived.sequence, headDigest: digests.at(-1) ?? null,
+        state: derived.state, sourceDigest: derived.sourceDigest, operations, scopes: [...scopes].sort(),
+        leaseHeld: derived.lease !== null, intentOutcomeUnknown: derived.intent !== null,
+      }
+    }
+
+    function writeIndex(log) {
+      if (log.events.length === 0) return
+      const [repo] = segmentsOf(log.derived.identity)
+      privateDir(OBJECT_INDEX_DIRECTORY, repo)
+      const text = canonicalJson(indexDocument(log))
+      const file = indexFile(log.derived.identity)
+      try { if (readBytesNoFollow(file).toString('utf8') === text) return } catch { /* absent or unreadable: written below */ }
+      atomicReplacePrivateText(file, text)
+    }
+
+    function settle(identity) {
+      declare(identity)
+      const log = readLog(identity)
+      // The index is a cache: when it cannot be written, every reader derives
+      // what it needs from the events, and says so here.
+      let indexed = true
+      try { writeIndex(log) } catch { indexed = false }
+      crash('index-updated', { type: null, sequence: log.events.length, ...pointerOf(identity) })
+      return { log, indexed }
+    }
+
+    function readIndex(identity) {
+      try {
+        const document = JSON.parse(readBytesNoFollow(indexFile(identity)).toString('utf8'))
+        return document?.schema === OBJECT_INDEX_SCHEMA && document.workspaceId === workspaceId && document.repoId === identity.repoId && document.nodeId === identity.nodeId && Array.isArray(document.operations) && Array.isArray(document.scopes) ? document : null
+      } catch { return null }
+    }
+
+    // ---- objects on disk -------------------------------------------------
+
+    const directoriesOf = (directory) => {
+      let entries
+      try { entries = fs.readdirSync(directory, { withFileTypes: true }) } catch (error) { if (error.code === 'ENOENT') return { names: [], foreign: 0 }; throw error }
+      const names = entries.filter((entry) => entry.isDirectory() && isIdentitySegment(entry.name)).map((entry) => entry.name).sort()
+      return { names, foreign: entries.length - names.length }
+    }
+
+    // The identity of the object in <repo>/<node>: decoded from the names, or
+    // read from the first event when a name is hashed.
+    function identityAt(repo, node) {
+      let repoId = decodeIdentitySegment(repo)
+      let nodeId = decodeIdentitySegment(node)
+      if (repoId === null || nodeId === null) {
+        try {
+          const first = JSON.parse(readBytesNoFollow(path.join(objectsRoot, repo, node, eventName(1))).toString('utf8'))
+          if (isObjectEvent(first)) { repoId = first.repoId; nodeId = first.nodeId }
+        } catch { /* reported below */ }
+      }
+      if (!isIdentifier(repoId) || !isIdentifier(nodeId) || encodeIdentitySegment(repoId) !== repo || encodeIdentitySegment(nodeId) !== node) return null
+      return { workspaceId, repoId, nodeId }
+    }
+
+    function walkObjects(visit) {
+      let foreign = 0
+      const repos = directoriesOf(objectsRoot)
+      foreign += repos.foreign
+      for (const repo of repos.names) {
+        const nodes = directoriesOf(path.join(objectsRoot, repo))
+        foreign += nodes.foreign
+        for (const node of nodes.names) visit(identityAt(repo, node), path.join(objectsRoot, repo, node))
+      }
+      return foreign
+    }
+
+    // ---- the lease --------------------------------------------------------
+
+    function leaseOf(lease) {
+      if (lease === null || typeof lease !== 'object' || typeof lease.nonce !== 'string') refuseArbitration('lease-required', 'this is recorded only under the lease of the object')
+      return { identity: identityOf(lease), nonce: lease.nonce }
+    }
+
+    function underLease(lease, type, body) {
+      const { identity, nonce } = leaseOf(lease)
+      const { event } = append(identity, () => ({ type, body: { nonce, ...body } }), { settling: true })
+      const { log, indexed } = settle(identity)
+      return { sequence: event.sequence, state: log.derived, indexed }
+    }
+
+    return {
+      workspaceId,
+      stateRoot: root,
+
+      // Records one edit operation document. Returns { acknowledgement,
+      // appended, operation, object }. The acknowledgement depends only on the
+      // event that recorded this origin, so offering the same document again
+      // (a lost acknowledgement, a second tick, another process) appends
+      // nothing and answers the same.
+      observe(operation, { presentSourceDigest, resolves = [] } = {}) {
+        if (validateObsidianContract('edit-operation', operation).length > 0) refuseArbitration('invalid-operation', 'the document is not an edit operation')
+        const identity = identityOf(operation)
+        const recorded = recordableOperation(operation)
+        const expectedKey = editIdempotencyKey({ ...identity, baseSourceDigest: operation.baseSourceDigest, observedDigest: operation.observed.digest })
+        if (recorded === null || operation.idempotencyKey !== expectedKey) refuseArbitration('invalid-operation', 'the edit operation cannot be recorded as it is', { editId: operation.editId })
+        if (recorded.state === 'pending' && (recorded.kind !== 'body-replacement' || recorded.ext?.[OBSIDIAN_EXT_KEY]?.newSourceDigest === undefined)) {
+          refuseArbitration('invalid-operation', 'a pending operation is a body replacement that names its result', { editId: operation.editId })
+        }
+        const present = presentSourceDigest === undefined ? (recorded.ext?.[OBSIDIAN_EXT_KEY]?.currentSourceDigest ?? null) : presentSourceDigest
+        const body = { operation: recorded, presentSourceDigest: present, resolves: [...new Set(resolves)].sort() }
+        const origin = { scopeId: recorded.origin.scopeId, generationId: recorded.origin.generationId, editId: recorded.editId, resolves: body.resolves }
+        const recordedAt = (derived) => derived.operations.find((entry) => entry.idempotencyKey === recorded.idempotencyKey)?.origins.find((known) => sameOrigin(known, origin))?.sequence
+        const result = append(identity, (derived) => {
+          const sequence = recordedAt(derived)
+          if (sequence !== undefined) return { done: sequence }
+          return { type: derived.operations.some((entry) => entry.idempotencyKey === recorded.idempotencyKey) ? 'coalesced' : 'observed', body }
+        })
+        const { log, indexed } = settle(identity)
+        const sequence = result.appended ? result.event.sequence : result.value
+        return {
+          acknowledgement: { schema: EDIT_ACKNOWLEDGEMENT_SCHEMA, ...identity, idempotencyKey: recorded.idempotencyKey, editId: recorded.editId, sequence, eventDigest: log.digests[sequence - 1] },
+          appended: result.appended,
+          operation: log.derived.operations.find((entry) => entry.idempotencyKey === recorded.idempotencyKey) ?? null,
+          object: log.derived,
+          indexed,
+        }
+      },
+
+      stateOf(identity) {
+        return readLog(identityOf(identity)).derived
+      },
+
+      // Every object on disk, from the index where it is current and from the
+      // events where it is not. An object that cannot be read is listed as
+      // such and hides nothing else. { objects, foreign }
+      list({ state, scopeId } = {}) {
+        const objects = []
+        const foreign = walkObjects((identity, directory) => {
+          if (identity === null) { objects.push({ repoId: null, nodeId: null, state: 'unreadable', code: 'object-identity-unknown' }); return }
+          try {
+            const eventCount = listEventNames(directory, identity)
+            if (eventCount === 0) return
+            let index = readIndex(identity)
+            const headDigest = index === null ? null : sha256Digest(readBytesNoFollow(path.join(directory, eventName(eventCount))))
+            if (index === null || !indexIsCurrent({ index, eventCount, headDigest })) {
+              const log = readLog(identity)
+              index = indexDocument(log)
+              try { writeIndex(log) } catch { /* still a cache */ }
+            }
+            objects.push({ repoId: index.repoId, nodeId: index.nodeId, state: index.state, sequence: index.sequence, sourceDigest: index.sourceDigest, scopes: index.scopes, operations: index.operations, leaseHeld: index.leaseHeld, intentOutcomeUnknown: index.intentOutcomeUnknown })
+          } catch (error) {
+            if (!(error instanceof EditArbitrationRefusal)) throw error
+            objects.push({ ...pointerOf(identity), state: 'unreadable', code: error.code })
+          }
+        })
+        return {
+          objects: objects.filter((item) => (state === undefined || item.state === state) && (scopeId === undefined || item.scopes?.includes(scopeId))),
+          foreign,
+        }
+      },
+
+      // { acquired: true, lease } or { acquired: false, code: 'lease-held',
+      // reason, needsPerson, holder }. Never waits.
+      async acquireLease(identityInput, { pid = process.pid, runtimeId = null } = {}) {
+        const identity = identityOf(identityInput)
+        for (let attempt = 0; attempt < limits.maxAppendAttempts; attempt += 1) {
+          const before = readLog(identity).derived
+          let takeover = null
+          if (before.lease !== null) {
+            const held = before.lease
+            const proof = await proveAbandoned({ machine: held.machine, pid: held.pid, service: null, acquiredAt: held.acquiredAt }, { nowMs: Date.parse(isoTime(clock)) })
+            if (!proof.abandoned) {
+              return { acquired: false, code: 'lease-held', reason: proof.reason, needsPerson: NEEDS_PERSON.has(proof.reason), holder: { pid: held.pid, runtimeId: held.runtimeId, acquiredAt: held.acquiredAt, sequence: held.sequence } }
+            }
+            takeover = { nonce: held.nonce, reason: proof.reason }
+          }
+          const nonce = randomBytes(16).toString('hex')
+          let lost = false
+          const { event } = append(identity, (derived) => {
+            // The holder changed while it was being examined: examine again.
+            if ((derived.lease?.nonce ?? null) !== (takeover?.nonce ?? null)) { lost = true; return { done: null } }
+            return { type: 'lease-acquired', body: { lease: { nonce, pid, machine: machineDigest(), runtimeId, acquiredAt: isoTime(clock) }, takeover } }
+          })
+          if (lost) continue
+          const { log } = settle(identity)
+          return { acquired: true, lease: { ...identity, nonce, sequence: event.sequence }, takeover, object: log.derived }
+        }
+        return refuseArbitration('append-contention', 'the lease of the object changed hands on every attempt', pointerOf(identity))
+      },
+
+      // false when the lease is no longer this one (it was taken over after a
+      // proof that this holder was gone).
+      releaseLease(lease) {
+        const { identity, nonce } = leaseOf(lease)
+        const { appended } = append(identity, (derived) => (derived.lease?.nonce === nonce ? { type: 'lease-released', body: { nonce } } : { done: false }), { settling: true })
+        settle(identity)
+        return appended
+      },
+
+      // Write-ahead: recorded before the source is touched.
+      recordIntent(lease, { idempotencyKey, expectedSourceDigest, newSourceDigest, actor, policy, applyId }) {
+        return underLease(lease, 'apply-intent', { idempotencyKey, expectedSourceDigest, newSourceDigest, actor, policy, ...optional({ applyId }) })
+      },
+
+      // The source was written: old and new digests, who, and under what.
+      recordApplied(lease, { idempotencyKey, oldSourceDigest, newSourceDigest, actor, policy, applyId, backupRef }) {
+        return underLease(lease, 'applied', { idempotencyKey, oldSourceDigest, newSourceDigest, actor, policy, ...optional({ applyId, backupRef }) })
+      },
+
+      // The source was not written. `presentSourceDigest` is what the source
+      // was read to be, when it was read. `disposition` is what becomes of a
+      // pending operation: 'retained' (try again later), 'conflicted', 'refused'.
+      recordRefused(lease, { idempotencyKey, code, presentSourceDigest = null, disposition = 'retained', applyId, policy, recoveryRefs }) {
+        if (!REFUSED_DISPOSITIONS.includes(disposition)) refuseArbitration('invalid-event', 'the disposition is not one this store records', { type: 'apply-refused' })
+        return underLease(lease, 'apply-refused', { idempotencyKey, code, presentSourceDigest, disposition, ...optional({ applyId, policy, recoveryRefs }) })
+      },
+
+      // Reads every event of the object again, from the files, writes down
+      // whatever declaration a crash left unwritten, and rebuilds its index.
+      recoverObject(identityInput) {
+        const identity = identityOf(identityInput)
+        readLog(identity, { fresh: true })
+        const { log, indexed } = settle(identity)
+        return { ...log.derived, indexed }
+      },
+
+      // Deletes every index and derives it again from the events. Equal events
+      // give equal bytes.
+      rebuildIndexes() {
+        fs.rmSync(indexRoot, { recursive: true, force: true })
+        privateDir(OBJECT_INDEX_DIRECTORY)
+        const result = { rebuilt: 0, unreadable: [], foreign: 0 }
+        result.foreign = walkObjects((identity) => {
+          if (identity === null) { result.unreadable.push({ repoId: null, nodeId: null, code: 'object-identity-unknown' }); return }
+          try { writeIndex(readLog(identity, { fresh: true })); result.rebuilt += 1 } catch (error) {
+            if (!(error instanceof EditArbitrationRefusal)) throw error
+            result.unreadable.push({ ...pointerOf(identity), code: error.code })
+          }
+        })
+        return result
+      },
+    }
+  }
+}
+
+export const openObjectStore = createObjectStoreForOracleTests()

package/src/projection/obsidian/edits/observe.mjs

@@ -0,0 +1,123 @@
+import { createHash } from 'node:crypto'
+import { OBSIDIAN_EXT_KEY, assertObsidianContract } from '../contracts.mjs'
+import { sha256Digest } from '../materialize/byte-lens.mjs'
+import { applyEditLens } from './regions.mjs'
+
+// Observation: one pending edit record of the maintenance engine becomes one
+// edit operation document.
+//
+// The order is fixed. First the immutable bytes: the edited note must already
+// be retained in the recovery object store under its digest (the engine put it
+// there before it queued the record), and the published note and the base
+// source the edit is judged against are retained beside it. Only then is the
+// edit classified. A crash between the two leaves every byte needed to
+// classify again and no half-made operation. The live note in the vault is
+// never read here: bytes that were not preserved cannot be replaced by
+// whatever the note holds now.
+//
+// Nothing here writes to a source file or to a vault, and the document holds
+// identities, digests, byte offsets, codes and store references only.
+
+const EXT = OBSIDIAN_EXT_KEY
+export const EDIT_LENS_VERSION = '1.0.0'
+
+// The same edited bytes over the same base source of the same object are the
+// same operation, from whichever view or generation they were observed.
+export function editIdempotencyKey({ workspaceId, repoId, nodeId, baseSourceDigest, observedDigest }) {
+  return `op-${createHash('sha256').update([workspaceId, repoId, nodeId, baseSourceDigest, observedDigest].join('\u0000')).digest('hex')}`
+}
+
+// How a lens outcome is carried by the closed operation contract. A change to
+// front matter or to the link structure is content for a proposal, which a
+// later step builds from the preserved bytes; a base that moved is a conflict;
+// everything else the lens refuses is refused.
+function classify(outcome) {
+  if (outcome.kind === 'body-replacement') return { kind: 'body-replacement', state: 'pending' }
+  if (outcome.code === 'unsupported-structural-edit' || outcome.code === 'unsupported-frontmatter-edit') return { kind: 'semantic-proposal', state: 'proposed' }
+  if (outcome.code === 'stale-base') return { kind: 'body-replacement', state: 'conflicted' }
+  return { kind: 'body-replacement', state: 'refused' }
+}
+
+function refusal(code, detail = {}) {
+  return { kind: 'refusal', code, detail }
+}
+
+function readRetained(store, digest) {
+  try {
+    const bytes = store.readObject(digest)
+    return sha256Digest(bytes) === digest ? bytes : null
+  } catch (error) {
+    if (error?.code === 'ENOENT' || error?.code === 'recovery-object-corrupt') return null
+    throw error
+  }
+}
+
+export const EDIT_OBSERVATION_STEPS = Object.freeze({
+  // Returns { edited, publishedRef, baseRef }; throws nothing for missing bytes.
+  preserve({ store, edit, publishedNoteBytes, baseSourceBytes }) {
+    const edited = readRetained(store, edit.observedDigest)
+    if (edited === null) return { edited: null }
+    return { edited, publishedRef: store.retainObject(publishedNoteBytes).ref, baseRef: store.retainObject(baseSourceBytes).ref }
+  },
+  classify: (input) => applyEditLens(input),
+})
+
+// `edit` is a pending edit record; `store` is the recovery store of its view;
+// `manifest` is the generation manifest the record names. `publishedNoteBytes`
+// is the publisher's retained baseline of the note and `baseSourceBytes` the
+// source as it is now. `afterPreserved` is a seam between the two halves.
+//
+// Returns { operation, outcome }: the validated document and the lens result
+// (the new source bytes stay in memory; this phase applies nothing).
+export function createEditObserverForOracleTests(steps = EDIT_OBSERVATION_STEPS) {
+  return function observeEdit({ edit, store, manifest, publishedNoteBytes, baseSourceBytes, afterPreserved = () => {} }) {
+    for (const bytes of [publishedNoteBytes, baseSourceBytes]) if (!Buffer.isBuffer(bytes)) throw new TypeError('observation reads Buffers only')
+    const { workspaceId, repoId, nodeId } = edit.identity
+    const noteEntry = manifest.generationId === edit.generationId && manifest.scopeId === edit.scopeId
+      ? manifest.notes.find((note) => note.repoId === repoId && note.nodeId === nodeId && note.path === edit.path)
+      : undefined
+
+    const preserved = steps.preserve({ store, edit, publishedNoteBytes, baseSourceBytes })
+    afterPreserved()
+    let outcome
+    if (!preserved.edited) outcome = refusal('edit-bytes-missing', { observedDigest: edit.observedDigest })
+    else if (!noteEntry) outcome = refusal('unknown-note')
+    else outcome = steps.classify({ manifest, repoId, nodeId, publishedNoteBytes, editedNoteBytes: preserved.edited, baseSourceBytes })
+
+    const baseSourceDigest = noteEntry?.ext?.[EXT]?.source?.rawDigest ?? sha256Digest(baseSourceBytes)
+    const { kind, state } = classify(outcome)
+    const operation = {
+      schema: 'atelier-obsidian-edit-operation/v1',
+      contractVersion: '1.0.0',
+      editId: edit.editId,
+      workspaceId,
+      repoId,
+      nodeId,
+      origin: {
+        scopeId: edit.scopeId,
+        generationId: edit.generationId,
+        ext: { [EXT]: { notePath: edit.path, baseNoteDigest: edit.baseNoteDigest, publishedNoteDigest: noteEntry?.noteDigest ?? null } },
+      },
+      kind,
+      baseSourceDigest,
+      observed: { digest: edit.observedDigest, byteLength: preserved.edited ? preserved.edited.length : 0, recoveryRef: edit.objectRef },
+      idempotencyKey: editIdempotencyKey({ workspaceId, repoId, nodeId, baseSourceDigest, observedDigest: edit.observedDigest }),
+      state,
+      observedAt: edit.observedAt,
+      ext: {
+        [EXT]: {
+          lensVersion: EDIT_LENS_VERSION,
+          ...(preserved.edited ? { publishedNoteRef: preserved.publishedRef, baseSourceRef: preserved.baseRef } : {}),
+          currentSourceDigest: sha256Digest(baseSourceBytes),
+          ...(outcome.kind === 'body-replacement'
+            ? { result: { newSourceDigest: outcome.newSourceDigest, newByteLength: outcome.newSourceBytes.length, changedRanges: outcome.changedRanges, unchanged: outcome.unchanged, generated: outcome.generated } }
+            : { refusal: { code: outcome.code, detail: outcome.detail } }),
+        },
+      },
+    }
+    assertObsidianContract('edit-operation', operation)
+    return { operation, outcome }
+  }
+}
+
+export const observeEdit = createEditObserverForOracleTests()