@mandujs/mcp 0.13.0 → 0.16.0

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (136) hide show
  1. package/README.md +6 -7
  2. package/package.json +3 -2
  3. package/src/adapters/index.ts +20 -20
  4. package/src/adapters/monitor-adapter.ts +100 -100
  5. package/src/adapters/tool-adapter.ts +88 -88
  6. package/src/executor/error-handler.ts +250 -250
  7. package/src/executor/index.ts +22 -22
  8. package/src/executor/tool-executor.ts +148 -148
  9. package/src/hooks/config-watcher.ts +174 -174
  10. package/src/hooks/index.ts +23 -23
  11. package/src/hooks/mcp-hooks.ts +227 -227
  12. package/src/logging/index.ts +15 -15
  13. package/src/logging/mcp-transport.ts +134 -134
  14. package/src/registry/index.ts +13 -13
  15. package/src/registry/mcp-tool-registry.ts +298 -298
  16. package/src/resources/skills/guides.ts +1136 -1136
  17. package/src/resources/skills/index.ts +12 -12
  18. package/src/resources/skills/loader.ts +218 -218
  19. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/SKILL.md +91 -91
  20. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/metadata.json +13 -13
  21. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/rules/_sections.md +26 -26
  22. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/rules/_template.md +77 -77
  23. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/rules/comp-arch-avoid-boolean-props.md +146 -146
  24. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/rules/comp-arch-compound-components.md +164 -164
  25. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/rules/comp-island-event.md +161 -161
  26. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/rules/comp-island-slot-split.md +167 -167
  27. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/rules/comp-pattern-children.md +149 -149
  28. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/rules/comp-state-context-interface.md +148 -148
  29. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-composition/rules/comp-state-lift-state.md +150 -150
  30. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/SKILL.md +92 -92
  31. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/_sections.md +41 -41
  32. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/_template.md +38 -38
  33. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/metadata.json +13 -13
  34. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/rules/deploy-build-bun.md +109 -109
  35. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/rules/deploy-build-output.md +115 -115
  36. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/rules/deploy-cicd-github.md +219 -219
  37. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/rules/deploy-docker-bun.md +150 -150
  38. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/rules/deploy-docker-compose.md +223 -223
  39. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/rules/deploy-platform-fly.md +152 -152
  40. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/rules/deploy-platform-render.md +179 -179
  41. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/rules/deploy-platform-supabase.md +323 -323
  42. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-deployment/rules/deploy-platform-vercel.md +140 -140
  43. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-fs-routes/SKILL.md +82 -82
  44. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-fs-routes/metadata.json +12 -12
  45. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-fs-routes/rules/_sections.md +36 -36
  46. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-fs-routes/rules/_template.md +69 -69
  47. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-fs-routes/rules/routes-api-methods.md +65 -65
  48. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-fs-routes/rules/routes-dynamic-param.md +93 -93
  49. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-fs-routes/rules/routes-naming-page.md +55 -55
  50. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-guard/SKILL.md +129 -129
  51. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-guard/metadata.json +12 -12
  52. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-guard/rules/_sections.md +36 -36
  53. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-guard/rules/_template.md +82 -82
  54. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-guard/rules/guard-config-rules.md +100 -100
  55. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-guard/rules/guard-layer-direction.md +76 -76
  56. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-guard/rules/guard-preset-mandu.md +81 -81
  57. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-guard/rules/guard-validate-import.md +80 -80
  58. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-hydration/SKILL.md +91 -91
  59. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-hydration/metadata.json +12 -12
  60. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-hydration/rules/_sections.md +31 -31
  61. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-hydration/rules/_template.md +72 -72
  62. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-hydration/rules/hydration-data-event.md +109 -109
  63. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-hydration/rules/hydration-directive-use-client.md +55 -55
  64. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-hydration/rules/hydration-island-setup.md +113 -113
  65. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-hydration/rules/hydration-priority-visible.md +68 -68
  66. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/SKILL.md +85 -85
  67. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/metadata.json +14 -14
  68. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/_sections.md +31 -31
  69. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/_template.md +64 -64
  70. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/perf-async-defer-await.md +103 -103
  71. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/perf-async-parallel.md +95 -95
  72. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/perf-bun-file.md +124 -124
  73. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/perf-bun-serve.md +125 -125
  74. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/perf-bundle-imports.md +80 -80
  75. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/perf-bundle-island-lazy.md +145 -145
  76. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/perf-cache-react.md +98 -98
  77. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-performance/rules/perf-render-transitions.md +154 -154
  78. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-security/SKILL.md +87 -87
  79. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-security/metadata.json +13 -13
  80. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-security/rules/_sections.md +31 -31
  81. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-security/rules/_template.md +74 -74
  82. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-security/rules/sec-auth-guard.md +127 -127
  83. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-security/rules/sec-env-management.md +133 -133
  84. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-security/rules/sec-input-validate.md +148 -148
  85. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-security/rules/sec-protect-csrf.md +146 -146
  86. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-security/rules/sec-protect-headers.md +138 -138
  87. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-slot/SKILL.md +85 -85
  88. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-slot/metadata.json +12 -12
  89. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-slot/rules/_sections.md +36 -36
  90. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-slot/rules/_template.md +63 -63
  91. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-slot/rules/slot-basic-structure.md +38 -38
  92. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-slot/rules/slot-ctx-response.md +56 -56
  93. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-slot/rules/slot-guard-auth.md +59 -59
  94. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-slot/rules/slot-http-methods.md +64 -64
  95. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/SKILL.md +154 -154
  96. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/_sections.md +43 -43
  97. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/_template.md +32 -32
  98. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/metadata.json +15 -15
  99. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-component-compound.md +235 -235
  100. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-component-slots.md +255 -255
  101. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-component-tokens.md +205 -205
  102. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-island-animations.md +272 -272
  103. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-island-scoping.md +167 -167
  104. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-island-variants.md +221 -221
  105. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-perf-critical.md +209 -209
  106. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-perf-purge.md +192 -192
  107. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-setup-modules.md +162 -162
  108. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-setup-panda.md +164 -164
  109. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-setup-tailwind.md +170 -170
  110. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-tailwind-v4-gotchas.md +179 -179
  111. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-styling/rules/style-theme-darkmode.md +229 -229
  112. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-testing/SKILL.md +99 -99
  113. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-testing/metadata.json +13 -13
  114. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-testing/rules/_sections.md +26 -26
  115. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-testing/rules/_template.md +65 -65
  116. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-testing/rules/test-component-island.md +195 -195
  117. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-testing/rules/test-e2e-playwright.md +196 -196
  118. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-testing/rules/test-mock-fetch.md +219 -219
  119. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-testing/rules/test-slot-unit.md +192 -192
  120. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/SKILL.md +117 -117
  121. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/_sections.md +23 -23
  122. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/_template.md +32 -32
  123. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/metadata.json +13 -13
  124. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/rules/ui-accessibility-aria.md +232 -232
  125. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/rules/ui-accessibility-focus.md +238 -238
  126. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/rules/ui-composition-patterns.md +259 -259
  127. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/rules/ui-island-integration.md +258 -258
  128. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/rules/ui-radix-patterns.md +213 -213
  129. package/src/resources/skills/mandu-ui/rules/ui-shadcn-setup.md +209 -209
  130. package/src/resources/skills/recipes.ts +932 -932
  131. package/src/tools/ate.ts +129 -0
  132. package/src/tools/index.ts +4 -1
  133. package/src/tools/project.ts +334 -334
  134. package/src/tools/runtime.ts +497 -497
  135. package/src/tools/seo.ts +417 -417
  136. package/src/utils/withWarnings.ts +83 -83
@@ -1,167 +1,167 @@
1
- ---
2
- title: Separate Server Logic (Slot) from Client (Island)
3
- impact: MEDIUM
4
- impactDescription: Clear server-client boundary
5
- tags: composition, island, slot, separation
6
- ---
7
-
8
- ## Separate Server Logic (Slot) from Client (Island)
9
-
10
- **Impact: MEDIUM (Clear server-client boundary)**
11
-
12
- 서버 로직(slot)과 클라이언트 로직(Island)을 명확히 분리하세요. slot은 데이터 페칭과 비즈니스 로직, Island는 인터랙션을 담당합니다.
13
-
14
- **Incorrect (혼합된 관심사):**
15
-
16
- ```tsx
17
- // ❌ 클라이언트 컴포넌트에서 데이터 페칭
18
- "use client";
19
-
20
- export function TodosIsland() {
21
- const [todos, setTodos] = useState([]);
22
-
23
- useEffect(() => {
24
- // 클라이언트에서 데이터 페칭 → 워터폴 발생
25
- fetch("/api/todos")
26
- .then(res => res.json())
27
- .then(setTodos);
28
- }, []);
29
-
30
- return <TodoList todos={todos} />;
31
- }
32
- ```
33
-
34
- **Correct (slot-client 분리):**
35
-
36
- ```typescript
37
- // spec/slots/todos.slot.ts - 서버 로직
38
- import { Mandu } from "@mandujs/core";
39
- import { db } from "@/lib/db";
40
-
41
- export default Mandu.filling()
42
- .guard((ctx) => {
43
- // 인증 체크 (서버에서)
44
- if (!ctx.get("user")) {
45
- return ctx.unauthorized("Login required");
46
- }
47
- })
48
- .get(async (ctx) => {
49
- // 데이터 페칭 (서버에서)
50
- const todos = await db.todo.findMany({
51
- where: { userId: ctx.get("user").id },
52
- orderBy: { createdAt: "desc" },
53
- });
54
-
55
- return ctx.ok({ todos });
56
- })
57
- .post(async (ctx) => {
58
- // 생성 로직 (서버에서)
59
- const body = await ctx.body<{ text: string }>();
60
- const todo = await db.todo.create({
61
- data: { text: body.text, userId: ctx.get("user").id },
62
- });
63
-
64
- return ctx.created({ todo });
65
- });
66
- ```
67
-
68
- ```tsx
69
- // app/todos/client.tsx - 클라이언트 인터랙션
70
- "use client";
71
-
72
- import { useState, useCallback } from "react";
73
-
74
- interface TodosIslandProps {
75
- initialTodos: Todo[]; // 서버에서 받은 초기 데이터
76
- }
77
-
78
- export function TodosIsland({ initialTodos }: TodosIslandProps) {
79
- const [todos, setTodos] = useState(initialTodos);
80
- const [input, setInput] = useState("");
81
-
82
- const addTodo = useCallback(async () => {
83
- // 낙관적 업데이트
84
- const optimisticTodo = { id: Date.now(), text: input, done: false };
85
- setTodos(prev => [optimisticTodo, ...prev]);
86
- setInput("");
87
-
88
- // 서버에 요청
89
- const res = await fetch("/api/todos", {
90
- method: "POST",
91
- body: JSON.stringify({ text: input }),
92
- });
93
- const { todo } = await res.json();
94
-
95
- // 실제 데이터로 교체
96
- setTodos(prev => prev.map(t =>
97
- t.id === optimisticTodo.id ? todo : t
98
- ));
99
- }, [input]);
100
-
101
- return (
102
- <div>
103
- <input
104
- value={input}
105
- onChange={(e) => setInput(e.target.value)}
106
- placeholder="New todo..."
107
- />
108
- <button onClick={addTodo}>Add</button>
109
- <ul>
110
- {todos.map(todo => (
111
- <TodoItem key={todo.id} todo={todo} />
112
- ))}
113
- </ul>
114
- </div>
115
- );
116
- }
117
- ```
118
-
119
- ```tsx
120
- // app/todos/page.tsx - 페이지 (서버 컴포넌트)
121
- import { TodosIsland } from "./client";
122
- import { loadTodos } from "./slot";
123
-
124
- export default async function TodosPage() {
125
- // 서버에서 데이터 로드 (워터폴 없음)
126
- const { todos } = await loadTodos();
127
-
128
- return (
129
- <div>
130
- <h1>My Todos</h1>
131
- {/* 초기 데이터를 Island에 전달 */}
132
- <TodosIsland initialTodos={todos} />
133
- </div>
134
- );
135
- }
136
- ```
137
-
138
- ## 분리 원칙
139
-
140
- | 관심사 | 위치 | 예시 |
141
- |--------|------|------|
142
- | 데이터 페칭 | Slot | DB 쿼리, API 호출 |
143
- | 인증/인가 | Slot Guard | 권한 체크 |
144
- | 비즈니스 로직 | Slot | 유효성 검사, 계산 |
145
- | 인터랙션 | Island | 클릭, 입력, 애니메이션 |
146
- | 클라이언트 상태 | Island | useState, useReducer |
147
- | 낙관적 업데이트 | Island | 즉시 UI 반영 |
148
-
149
- ## 데이터 흐름
150
-
151
- ```
152
- ┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
153
- │ Page (Server Component) │
154
- │ └─ loadTodos() from slot │
155
- │ └─ DB Query │
156
- │ │
157
- │ ↓ initialTodos prop │
158
- │ │
159
- │ ┌───────────────────────────────────┐ │
160
- │ │ TodosIsland (Client Component) │ │
161
- │ │ └─ useState(initialTodos) │ │
162
- │ │ └─ User interactions │ │
163
- │ │ └─ Optimistic updates │ │
164
- │ │ └─ POST to /api/todos │ │
165
- │ └───────────────────────────────────┘ │
166
- └─────────────────────────────────────────┘
167
- ```
1
+ ---
2
+ title: Separate Server Logic (Slot) from Client (Island)
3
+ impact: MEDIUM
4
+ impactDescription: Clear server-client boundary
5
+ tags: composition, island, slot, separation
6
+ ---
7
+
8
+ ## Separate Server Logic (Slot) from Client (Island)
9
+
10
+ **Impact: MEDIUM (Clear server-client boundary)**
11
+
12
+ 서버 로직(slot)과 클라이언트 로직(Island)을 명확히 분리하세요. slot은 데이터 페칭과 비즈니스 로직, Island는 인터랙션을 담당합니다.
13
+
14
+ **Incorrect (혼합된 관심사):**
15
+
16
+ ```tsx
17
+ // ❌ 클라이언트 컴포넌트에서 데이터 페칭
18
+ "use client";
19
+
20
+ export function TodosIsland() {
21
+ const [todos, setTodos] = useState([]);
22
+
23
+ useEffect(() => {
24
+ // 클라이언트에서 데이터 페칭 → 워터폴 발생
25
+ fetch("/api/todos")
26
+ .then(res => res.json())
27
+ .then(setTodos);
28
+ }, []);
29
+
30
+ return <TodoList todos={todos} />;
31
+ }
32
+ ```
33
+
34
+ **Correct (slot-client 분리):**
35
+
36
+ ```typescript
37
+ // spec/slots/todos.slot.ts - 서버 로직
38
+ import { Mandu } from "@mandujs/core";
39
+ import { db } from "@/lib/db";
40
+
41
+ export default Mandu.filling()
42
+ .guard((ctx) => {
43
+ // 인증 체크 (서버에서)
44
+ if (!ctx.get("user")) {
45
+ return ctx.unauthorized("Login required");
46
+ }
47
+ })
48
+ .get(async (ctx) => {
49
+ // 데이터 페칭 (서버에서)
50
+ const todos = await db.todo.findMany({
51
+ where: { userId: ctx.get("user").id },
52
+ orderBy: { createdAt: "desc" },
53
+ });
54
+
55
+ return ctx.ok({ todos });
56
+ })
57
+ .post(async (ctx) => {
58
+ // 생성 로직 (서버에서)
59
+ const body = await ctx.body<{ text: string }>();
60
+ const todo = await db.todo.create({
61
+ data: { text: body.text, userId: ctx.get("user").id },
62
+ });
63
+
64
+ return ctx.created({ todo });
65
+ });
66
+ ```
67
+
68
+ ```tsx
69
+ // app/todos/client.tsx - 클라이언트 인터랙션
70
+ "use client";
71
+
72
+ import { useState, useCallback } from "react";
73
+
74
+ interface TodosIslandProps {
75
+ initialTodos: Todo[]; // 서버에서 받은 초기 데이터
76
+ }
77
+
78
+ export function TodosIsland({ initialTodos }: TodosIslandProps) {
79
+ const [todos, setTodos] = useState(initialTodos);
80
+ const [input, setInput] = useState("");
81
+
82
+ const addTodo = useCallback(async () => {
83
+ // 낙관적 업데이트
84
+ const optimisticTodo = { id: Date.now(), text: input, done: false };
85
+ setTodos(prev => [optimisticTodo, ...prev]);
86
+ setInput("");
87
+
88
+ // 서버에 요청
89
+ const res = await fetch("/api/todos", {
90
+ method: "POST",
91
+ body: JSON.stringify({ text: input }),
92
+ });
93
+ const { todo } = await res.json();
94
+
95
+ // 실제 데이터로 교체
96
+ setTodos(prev => prev.map(t =>
97
+ t.id === optimisticTodo.id ? todo : t
98
+ ));
99
+ }, [input]);
100
+
101
+ return (
102
+ <div>
103
+ <input
104
+ value={input}
105
+ onChange={(e) => setInput(e.target.value)}
106
+ placeholder="New todo..."
107
+ />
108
+ <button onClick={addTodo}>Add</button>
109
+ <ul>
110
+ {todos.map(todo => (
111
+ <TodoItem key={todo.id} todo={todo} />
112
+ ))}
113
+ </ul>
114
+ </div>
115
+ );
116
+ }
117
+ ```
118
+
119
+ ```tsx
120
+ // app/todos/page.tsx - 페이지 (서버 컴포넌트)
121
+ import { TodosIsland } from "./client";
122
+ import { loadTodos } from "./slot";
123
+
124
+ export default async function TodosPage() {
125
+ // 서버에서 데이터 로드 (워터폴 없음)
126
+ const { todos } = await loadTodos();
127
+
128
+ return (
129
+ <div>
130
+ <h1>My Todos</h1>
131
+ {/* 초기 데이터를 Island에 전달 */}
132
+ <TodosIsland initialTodos={todos} />
133
+ </div>
134
+ );
135
+ }
136
+ ```
137
+
138
+ ## 분리 원칙
139
+
140
+ | 관심사 | 위치 | 예시 |
141
+ |--------|------|------|
142
+ | 데이터 페칭 | Slot | DB 쿼리, API 호출 |
143
+ | 인증/인가 | Slot Guard | 권한 체크 |
144
+ | 비즈니스 로직 | Slot | 유효성 검사, 계산 |
145
+ | 인터랙션 | Island | 클릭, 입력, 애니메이션 |
146
+ | 클라이언트 상태 | Island | useState, useReducer |
147
+ | 낙관적 업데이트 | Island | 즉시 UI 반영 |
148
+
149
+ ## 데이터 흐름
150
+
151
+ ```
152
+ ┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐
153
+ │ Page (Server Component) │
154
+ │ └─ loadTodos() from slot │
155
+ │ └─ DB Query │
156
+ │ │
157
+ │ ↓ initialTodos prop │
158
+ │ │
159
+ │ ┌───────────────────────────────────┐ │
160
+ │ │ TodosIsland (Client Component) │ │
161
+ │ │ └─ useState(initialTodos) │ │
162
+ │ │ └─ User interactions │ │
163
+ │ │ └─ Optimistic updates │ │
164
+ │ │ └─ POST to /api/todos │ │
165
+ │ └───────────────────────────────────┘ │
166
+ └─────────────────────────────────────────┘
167
+ ```
@@ -1,149 +1,149 @@
1
- ---
2
- title: Use Children for Composition Over Render Props
3
- impact: MEDIUM
4
- impactDescription: Simpler API, better composition
5
- tags: composition, children, render-props, pattern
6
- ---
7
-
8
- ## Use Children for Composition Over Render Props
9
-
10
- **Impact: MEDIUM (Simpler API, better composition)**
11
-
12
- `renderX` props 대신 `children`을 사용하여 컴포지션하세요. 더 선언적이고 유연합니다.
13
-
14
- **Incorrect (render props):**
15
-
16
- ```tsx
17
- // ❌ renderX props 패턴
18
- function Modal({
19
- renderHeader,
20
- renderBody,
21
- renderFooter,
22
- renderCloseButton,
23
- }: ModalProps) {
24
- return (
25
- <div className="modal">
26
- <div className="modal-header">
27
- {renderCloseButton?.()}
28
- {renderHeader?.()}
29
- </div>
30
- <div className="modal-body">
31
- {renderBody?.()}
32
- </div>
33
- <div className="modal-footer">
34
- {renderFooter?.()}
35
- </div>
36
- </div>
37
- );
38
- }
39
-
40
- // 사용 시 복잡함
41
- <Modal
42
- renderHeader={() => <h2>Title</h2>}
43
- renderBody={() => <p>Content</p>}
44
- renderFooter={() => (
45
- <>
46
- <Button>Cancel</Button>
47
- <Button>Save</Button>
48
- </>
49
- )}
50
- renderCloseButton={() => <CloseButton />}
51
- />
52
- ```
53
-
54
- **Correct (children + compound):**
55
-
56
- ```tsx
57
- // ✅ children과 컴파운드 패턴
58
- function Modal({ children }: { children: React.ReactNode }) {
59
- return <div className="modal">{children}</div>;
60
- }
61
-
62
- function ModalHeader({ children }: { children: React.ReactNode }) {
63
- return <div className="modal-header">{children}</div>;
64
- }
65
-
66
- function ModalBody({ children }: { children: React.ReactNode }) {
67
- return <div className="modal-body">{children}</div>;
68
- }
69
-
70
- function ModalFooter({ children }: { children: React.ReactNode }) {
71
- return <div className="modal-footer">{children}</div>;
72
- }
73
-
74
- function ModalClose({ onClose }: { onClose: () => void }) {
75
- return <button onClick={onClose} className="modal-close">×</button>;
76
- }
77
-
78
- export { Modal, ModalHeader, ModalBody, ModalFooter, ModalClose };
79
- ```
80
-
81
- **사용:**
82
-
83
- ```tsx
84
- // 선언적이고 명확함
85
- <Modal>
86
- <ModalHeader>
87
- <ModalClose onClose={handleClose} />
88
- <h2>Title</h2>
89
- </ModalHeader>
90
-
91
- <ModalBody>
92
- <p>Content goes here</p>
93
- </ModalBody>
94
-
95
- <ModalFooter>
96
- <Button onClick={handleClose}>Cancel</Button>
97
- <Button onClick={handleSave}>Save</Button>
98
- </ModalFooter>
99
- </Modal>
100
- ```
101
-
102
- ## 장점
103
-
104
- | render props | children |
105
- |--------------|----------|
106
- | 숨겨진 구조 | 명시적 구조 |
107
- | 함수 호출 문법 | JSX 문법 |
108
- | 순서가 props에 의존 | 순서를 소비자가 제어 |
109
- | 어떤 props가 있는지 봐야 함 | 자동완성 지원 |
110
-
111
- ## Mandu Island에서의 적용
112
-
113
- ```tsx
114
- // ❌ 피해야 할 패턴
115
- <FormIsland
116
- renderInput={(value, onChange) => <Input value={value} onChange={onChange} />}
117
- renderSubmit={(onSubmit) => <Button onClick={onSubmit}>Submit</Button>}
118
- renderError={(error) => <ErrorMessage error={error} />}
119
- />
120
-
121
- // ✅ 권장 패턴
122
- <Form.Provider>
123
- <Form.Frame>
124
- <Form.Input name="email" />
125
- <Form.Input name="password" type="password" />
126
- <Form.Error />
127
- <Form.Submit>Sign In</Form.Submit>
128
- </Form.Frame>
129
- </Form.Provider>
130
- ```
131
-
132
- ## 언제 Render Props를 사용하나?
133
-
134
- render props가 여전히 유용한 경우:
135
- - 부모가 데이터를 제공하고 자식이 렌더링 방법을 결정 (예: virtualized list)
136
- - 자식에게 상태를 노출해야 하는 headless 컴포넌트
137
-
138
- ```tsx
139
- // Render props가 적합한 예: Virtualized List
140
- <VirtualList
141
- items={items}
142
- itemHeight={50}
143
- renderItem={(item, index) => (
144
- <div key={item.id}>{item.name}</div>
145
- )}
146
- />
147
- ```
148
-
149
- Reference: [Compound Components](https://kentcdodds.com/blog/compound-components-with-react-hooks)
1
+ ---
2
+ title: Use Children for Composition Over Render Props
3
+ impact: MEDIUM
4
+ impactDescription: Simpler API, better composition
5
+ tags: composition, children, render-props, pattern
6
+ ---
7
+
8
+ ## Use Children for Composition Over Render Props
9
+
10
+ **Impact: MEDIUM (Simpler API, better composition)**
11
+
12
+ `renderX` props 대신 `children`을 사용하여 컴포지션하세요. 더 선언적이고 유연합니다.
13
+
14
+ **Incorrect (render props):**
15
+
16
+ ```tsx
17
+ // ❌ renderX props 패턴
18
+ function Modal({
19
+ renderHeader,
20
+ renderBody,
21
+ renderFooter,
22
+ renderCloseButton,
23
+ }: ModalProps) {
24
+ return (
25
+ <div className="modal">
26
+ <div className="modal-header">
27
+ {renderCloseButton?.()}
28
+ {renderHeader?.()}
29
+ </div>
30
+ <div className="modal-body">
31
+ {renderBody?.()}
32
+ </div>
33
+ <div className="modal-footer">
34
+ {renderFooter?.()}
35
+ </div>
36
+ </div>
37
+ );
38
+ }
39
+
40
+ // 사용 시 복잡함
41
+ <Modal
42
+ renderHeader={() => <h2>Title</h2>}
43
+ renderBody={() => <p>Content</p>}
44
+ renderFooter={() => (
45
+ <>
46
+ <Button>Cancel</Button>
47
+ <Button>Save</Button>
48
+ </>
49
+ )}
50
+ renderCloseButton={() => <CloseButton />}
51
+ />
52
+ ```
53
+
54
+ **Correct (children + compound):**
55
+
56
+ ```tsx
57
+ // ✅ children과 컴파운드 패턴
58
+ function Modal({ children }: { children: React.ReactNode }) {
59
+ return <div className="modal">{children}</div>;
60
+ }
61
+
62
+ function ModalHeader({ children }: { children: React.ReactNode }) {
63
+ return <div className="modal-header">{children}</div>;
64
+ }
65
+
66
+ function ModalBody({ children }: { children: React.ReactNode }) {
67
+ return <div className="modal-body">{children}</div>;
68
+ }
69
+
70
+ function ModalFooter({ children }: { children: React.ReactNode }) {
71
+ return <div className="modal-footer">{children}</div>;
72
+ }
73
+
74
+ function ModalClose({ onClose }: { onClose: () => void }) {
75
+ return <button onClick={onClose} className="modal-close">×</button>;
76
+ }
77
+
78
+ export { Modal, ModalHeader, ModalBody, ModalFooter, ModalClose };
79
+ ```
80
+
81
+ **사용:**
82
+
83
+ ```tsx
84
+ // 선언적이고 명확함
85
+ <Modal>
86
+ <ModalHeader>
87
+ <ModalClose onClose={handleClose} />
88
+ <h2>Title</h2>
89
+ </ModalHeader>
90
+
91
+ <ModalBody>
92
+ <p>Content goes here</p>
93
+ </ModalBody>
94
+
95
+ <ModalFooter>
96
+ <Button onClick={handleClose}>Cancel</Button>
97
+ <Button onClick={handleSave}>Save</Button>
98
+ </ModalFooter>
99
+ </Modal>
100
+ ```
101
+
102
+ ## 장점
103
+
104
+ | render props | children |
105
+ |--------------|----------|
106
+ | 숨겨진 구조 | 명시적 구조 |
107
+ | 함수 호출 문법 | JSX 문법 |
108
+ | 순서가 props에 의존 | 순서를 소비자가 제어 |
109
+ | 어떤 props가 있는지 봐야 함 | 자동완성 지원 |
110
+
111
+ ## Mandu Island에서의 적용
112
+
113
+ ```tsx
114
+ // ❌ 피해야 할 패턴
115
+ <FormIsland
116
+ renderInput={(value, onChange) => <Input value={value} onChange={onChange} />}
117
+ renderSubmit={(onSubmit) => <Button onClick={onSubmit}>Submit</Button>}
118
+ renderError={(error) => <ErrorMessage error={error} />}
119
+ />
120
+
121
+ // ✅ 권장 패턴
122
+ <Form.Provider>
123
+ <Form.Frame>
124
+ <Form.Input name="email" />
125
+ <Form.Input name="password" type="password" />
126
+ <Form.Error />
127
+ <Form.Submit>Sign In</Form.Submit>
128
+ </Form.Frame>
129
+ </Form.Provider>
130
+ ```
131
+
132
+ ## 언제 Render Props를 사용하나?
133
+
134
+ render props가 여전히 유용한 경우:
135
+ - 부모가 데이터를 제공하고 자식이 렌더링 방법을 결정 (예: virtualized list)
136
+ - 자식에게 상태를 노출해야 하는 headless 컴포넌트
137
+
138
+ ```tsx
139
+ // Render props가 적합한 예: Virtualized List
140
+ <VirtualList
141
+ items={items}
142
+ itemHeight={50}
143
+ renderItem={(item, index) => (
144
+ <div key={item.id}>{item.name}</div>
145
+ )}
146
+ />
147
+ ```
148
+
149
+ Reference: [Compound Components](https://kentcdodds.com/blog/compound-components-with-react-hooks)