@machinespirits/eval 0.2.0 → 0.3.0

package/config/tutor-agents.yaml

@@ -714,3 +714,2264 @@ profiles:
       enforce_mutual_recognition: true
       require_memory_integration: true
       assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # DIVERGENT SUPEREGO CELLS (22-27)
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # These cells test whether genuinely divergent internal agents produce the
+  # behavioral modulation predicted by the Drama Machine framework.
+  #
+  # The convergent superego (cells 3,4,7,8) shares the Ego's goal (good pedagogy)
+  # and acts as quality control — producing d=0.05 modulation.
+  #
+  # Divergent superegos have CONFLICTING objectives:
+  #   - Suspicious: Challenges authenticity of engagement (orthogonal to correctness)
+  #   - Adversary: Argues for the opposite pedagogical method (methodological tension)
+  #   - Advocate: Represents the learner's experience (experiential vs. expert view)
+  #
+  # Design: 3 superego types × 2 recognition levels = 6 cells
+  # All use unified learner (Factor C held constant) to isolate superego effect.
+  # Models: nemotron (ego) + kimi-k2.5 (superego), matching factorial conditions.
+  #
+  # Key parameter changes vs convergent (max_rounds=2, threshold=0.8):
+  #   - max_rounds: 3 (more room for genuine negotiation)
+  #   - convergence_threshold: 0.65/0.60 (lower bar for adversarial agreement)
+  #
+  # Comparisons:
+  #   Cell 3  (M=76.6) vs Cells 22,24,26 → Does divergence increase modulation?
+  #   Cell 7  (M=92.3) vs Cells 23,25,27 → Does divergence interact with recognition?
+
+  # Cell 22: Base × Suspicious Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_22_base_suspicious_unified:
+    description: "Divergent cell 22: base ego + suspicious superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: divergent_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 23: Recognition × Suspicious Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_23_recog_suspicious_unified:
+    description: "Divergent cell 23: recognition ego + suspicious superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: divergent_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 24: Base × Adversary Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_24_base_adversary_unified:
+    description: "Divergent cell 24: base ego + adversary superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: divergent_adversary
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: adversary
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-adversary.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 25: Recognition × Adversary Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_25_recog_adversary_unified:
+    description: "Divergent cell 25: recognition ego + adversary superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: divergent_adversary
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: adversary
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-adversary.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 26: Base × Advocate Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_26_base_advocate_unified:
+    description: "Divergent cell 26: base ego + advocate superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: divergent_advocate
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: advocate
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-advocate.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 27: Recognition × Advocate Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_27_recog_advocate_unified:
+    description: "Divergent cell 27: recognition ego + advocate superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: divergent_advocate
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: advocate
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-advocate.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # DIALECTICAL SYNTHESIS CELLS (28-33)
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # Same divergent superegos as cells 22-27, but paired with a DIALECTICAL ego
+  # that is trained to synthesize (Aufhebung) rather than capitulate.
+  #
+  # Cells 22-27 = divergent superego + standard ego → capitulation baseline
+  # Cells 28-33 = divergent superego + dialectical ego → synthesis test
+  #
+  # The dialectical ego follows: defend → extract what's valid → integrate.
+  # Hypothesis: divergent agents produce BOTH modulation AND quality gains
+  # when the Ego treats critique as material for synthesis, not as a veto.
+  #
+  # Comparisons:
+  #   Cells 22-27 vs 28-33 → Does Aufhebung training recover quality?
+  #   Cells 28-33 vs 3,7   → Does dialectical divergence beat convergent?
+  #   SD(28-33) vs SD(3,7) → Does modulation survive synthesis training?
+
+  # Cell 28: Base Dialectical × Suspicious Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_28_base_dialectical_suspicious_unified:
+    description: "Dialectical cell 28: base dialectical ego + suspicious superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 29: Recognition Dialectical × Suspicious Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_29_recog_dialectical_suspicious_unified:
+    description: "Dialectical cell 29: recognition dialectical ego + suspicious superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 30: Base Dialectical × Adversary Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_30_base_dialectical_adversary_unified:
+    description: "Dialectical cell 30: base dialectical ego + adversary superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_adversary
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: adversary
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-adversary.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 31: Recognition Dialectical × Adversary Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_31_recog_dialectical_adversary_unified:
+    description: "Dialectical cell 31: recognition dialectical ego + adversary superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_adversary
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: adversary
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-adversary.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 32: Base Dialectical × Advocate Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_32_base_dialectical_advocate_unified:
+    description: "Dialectical cell 32: base dialectical ego + advocate superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_advocate
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: advocate
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-advocate.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # Cell 33: Recognition Dialectical × Advocate Superego × Unified Learner
+  cell_33_recog_dialectical_advocate_unified:
+    description: "Dialectical cell 33: recognition dialectical ego + advocate superego, unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_advocate
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: advocate
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-advocate.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # FULL-FEATURE DIALECTICAL CELLS (34-39)
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # These cells enable ALL modulation features on top of the dialectical
+  # superego architecture:
+  #   - Writing Pad (persistent learner model across turns)
+  #   - Dialectical Negotiation (memory surfaces in prompts)
+  #   - Prompt Rewriting (LLM-synthesized between-turn directives)
+  #   - Cross-turn superego memory (prior feedback accumulation)
+  #   - Learner trajectory assessment (structured resistance signals)
+  #
+  # Without these features, the superego operates as a near-deterministic
+  # quality filter — it cannot adapt across turns, detect resistance patterns,
+  # or help the ego find breakthrough directions.
+  #
+  # Cells 34-39 test the hypothesis: with full modulation infrastructure,
+  # does dialectical superego negotiation produce measurable learning
+  # trajectories (vs the flat learnerGrowthIndex observed in cells 28-33)?
+  #
+  # Design: 2 (base/recog) × 3 (suspicious/adversary/advocate) = 6 cells
+  # ===========================================================================
+
+  # DEPRECATED: Cells 34-39 were designed for full-feature dialectical testing
+  # (cross-turn memory + prompt rewriting + learner signals) but were never run.
+  # The mechanisms they test were later explored through cells 40-65.
+
+  # Cell 34: Base Dialectical × Suspicious × Full Features
+  cell_34_base_dialectical_suspicious_unified_full:
+    description: "Full-feature dialectical cell 34: base ego + suspicious superego + writing pad + prompt rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: llm
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 35: Recognition Dialectical × Suspicious × Full Features
+  cell_35_recog_dialectical_suspicious_unified_full:
+    description: "Full-feature dialectical cell 35: recognition ego + suspicious superego + writing pad + prompt rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: llm
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 36: Base Dialectical × Adversary × Full Features
+  cell_36_base_dialectical_adversary_unified_full:
+    description: "Full-feature dialectical cell 36: base ego + adversary superego + writing pad + prompt rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_adversary
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: adversary
+      full_modulation: true
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: llm
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-adversary.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 37: Recognition Dialectical × Adversary × Full Features
+  cell_37_recog_dialectical_adversary_unified_full:
+    description: "Full-feature dialectical cell 37: recognition ego + adversary superego + writing pad + prompt rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_adversary
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: adversary
+      full_modulation: true
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: llm
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-adversary.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 38: Base Dialectical × Advocate × Full Features
+  cell_38_base_dialectical_advocate_unified_full:
+    description: "Full-feature dialectical cell 38: base ego + advocate superego + writing pad + prompt rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_advocate
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: advocate
+      full_modulation: true
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: llm
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-advocate.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 39: Recognition Dialectical × Advocate × Full Features
+  cell_39_recog_dialectical_advocate_unified_full:
+    description: "Full-feature dialectical cell 39: recognition ego + advocate superego + writing pad + prompt rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_advocate
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: advocate
+      full_modulation: true
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: llm
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 3
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-advocate.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # SUPEREGO DISPOSITION REWRITING CELLS (40-45)
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # Clone of cells 34-39 with superego_disposition_rewriting enabled.
+  # The superego's evaluation criteria evolve turn-by-turn based on whether
+  # its prior critiques actually improved learner engagement.
+
+  # Cell 40: Base Dialectical × Suspicious × Full + Superego Rewriting
+  cell_40_base_dialectical_suspicious_unified_superego:
+    description: "Superego disposition cell 40: base ego + suspicious superego + full features + superego rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 41: Recognition Dialectical × Suspicious × Full + Superego Rewriting
+  cell_41_recog_dialectical_suspicious_unified_superego:
+    description: "Superego disposition cell 41: recognition ego + suspicious superego + full features + superego rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 42: Base Dialectical × Adversary × Full + Superego Rewriting
+  cell_42_base_dialectical_adversary_unified_superego:
+    description: "Superego disposition cell 42: base ego + adversary superego + full features + superego rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_adversary
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: adversary
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-adversary.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 43: Recognition Dialectical × Adversary × Full + Superego Rewriting
+  cell_43_recog_dialectical_adversary_unified_superego:
+    description: "Superego disposition cell 43: recognition ego + adversary superego + full features + superego rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_adversary
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: adversary
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-adversary.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 44: Base Dialectical × Advocate × Full + Superego Rewriting
+  cell_44_base_dialectical_advocate_unified_superego:
+    description: "Superego disposition cell 44: base ego + advocate superego + full features + superego rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_advocate
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: advocate
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-advocate.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 45: Recognition Dialectical × Advocate × Full + Superego Rewriting
+  cell_45_recog_dialectical_advocate_unified_superego:
+    description: "Superego disposition cell 45: recognition ego + advocate superego + full features + superego rewriting"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_advocate
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: advocate
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-advocate.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # ============================================================================
+  # Cells 46-53: Insight-Action Gap Mechanisms
+  # ============================================================================
+  # These cells test 3 mechanisms to close the insight-action gap where superego
+  # reflections diagnose problems but don't change behavior. All use suspicious
+  # superego type for controlled comparison against cells 40-41.
+  #
+  # Also fixes foundational gap: superegoPromptExtension is now threaded to the
+  # dialectical engine, so superego self-reflections reach the critique prompt.
+
+  # Cell 46-47: Quantitative Disposition
+  # Superego self-reflection outputs parseable behavioral parameters (rejection_threshold,
+  # max_rejections, priority/deprioritized criteria) that are enforced by the dialectical engine.
+  cell_46_base_dialectical_suspicious_unified_quantitative:
+    description: "Insight-action cell 46: base ego + suspicious superego + quantitative disposition"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: quantitative_disposition
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      quantitative_disposition: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  cell_47_recog_dialectical_suspicious_unified_quantitative:
+    description: "Insight-action cell 47: recognition ego + suspicious superego + quantitative disposition"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: quantitative_disposition
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      quantitative_disposition: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 48-49: Progressive Prompt Erosion
+  # Each turn reduces base prompt authority and increases experiential reflection authority.
+  # Rate 0.2 means: turn 1 = 80/20 base/experience, turn 2 = 60/40, turn 3 = 40/60, etc.
+  cell_48_base_dialectical_suspicious_unified_erosion:
+    description: "Insight-action cell 48: base ego + suspicious superego + prompt erosion"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: prompt_erosion
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      prompt_erosion:
+        enabled: true
+        rate: 0.2
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  cell_49_recog_dialectical_suspicious_unified_erosion:
+    description: "Insight-action cell 49: recognition ego + suspicious superego + prompt erosion"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: prompt_erosion
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      prompt_erosion:
+        enabled: true
+        rate: 0.2
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 50-51: Intersubjective Recognition
+  # After both ego and superego reflect, ego reads superego's reflection and responds.
+  # Creates bidirectional awareness — reflections become dialogues, not monologues.
+  cell_50_base_dialectical_suspicious_unified_intersubjective:
+    description: "Insight-action cell 50: base ego + suspicious superego + intersubjective recognition"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: intersubjective
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      intersubjective: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  cell_51_recog_dialectical_suspicious_unified_intersubjective:
+    description: "Insight-action cell 51: recognition ego + suspicious superego + intersubjective recognition"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: intersubjective
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      intersubjective: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 52-53: Combined — All 3 Mechanisms
+  # Quantitative disposition + prompt erosion + intersubjective recognition
+  cell_52_base_dialectical_suspicious_unified_combined:
+    description: "Insight-action cell 52: base ego + suspicious superego + all 3 mechanisms combined"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: combined
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      quantitative_disposition: true
+      prompt_erosion:
+        enabled: true
+        rate: 0.2
+      intersubjective: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  cell_53_recog_dialectical_suspicious_unified_combined:
+    description: "Insight-action cell 53: recognition ego + suspicious superego + all 3 mechanisms combined"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: combined
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      quantitative_disposition: true
+      prompt_erosion:
+        enabled: true
+        rate: 0.2
+      intersubjective: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # ============================================================================
+  # Other-Ego Profiling Cells (54-59): Theory of Mind as Architecture
+  # ============================================================================
+  # All cells use nemotron ego + kimi-k2.5 superego, self-reflection strategy, unified learner.
+  # The other_ego_profiling config controls profile building and injection.
+  # Key comparisons:
+  #   54 vs 55: recognition effect with profiling
+  #   54 vs 56: bidirectionality value
+  #   57 vs 52/53: profiling vs existing combined mechanisms
+  #   57 vs 58: profiling + existing mechanisms synergy
+  #   57 vs 59: strategy planning benefit
+
+  cell_54_base_dialectical_profile_tutor:
+    description: "Other-ego cell 54: base ego + suspicious superego + tutor→learner profile only"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      other_ego: tutor_only
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: false
+      strategy_planning: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  cell_55_recog_dialectical_profile_tutor:
+    description: "Other-ego cell 55: recognition ego + suspicious superego + tutor→learner profile"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      other_ego: tutor_only
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: false
+      strategy_planning: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  cell_56_base_dialectical_profile_bidirectional:
+    description: "Other-ego cell 56: base ego + suspicious superego + bidirectional profiling"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      other_ego: bidirectional
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: true
+      strategy_planning: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  cell_57_recog_dialectical_profile_bidirectional:
+    description: "Other-ego cell 57: recognition ego + suspicious superego + bidirectional profiling"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      other_ego: bidirectional
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: true
+      strategy_planning: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  cell_58_recog_dialectical_profile_bidirectional_full:
+    description: "Other-ego cell 58: recognition ego + suspicious superego + bidirectional profiling + full mechanism suite"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      other_ego: bidirectional_full
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      quantitative_disposition: true
+      prompt_erosion:
+        enabled: true
+        rate: 0.2
+      intersubjective: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: true
+      strategy_planning: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  cell_59_recog_dialectical_profile_bidirectional_strategy:
+    description: "Other-ego cell 59: recognition ego + suspicious superego + bidirectional profiling + explicit strategy planning"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      other_ego: bidirectional_strategy
+    learner_architecture: unified_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: true
+      strategy_planning: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # ============================================================
+  # Multi-Agent Learner × Modulation Mechanisms (Cells 60-63)
+  # ============================================================
+  # 2×2 factorial: (base vs recognition) × (self_reflection vs profiling_bidirectional)
+  # All use ego_superego learner to test modulation with dynamic interlocutor
+  # Default models: nemotron ego + kimi-k2.5 superego (override with --model for Haiku)
+
+  # Cell 60: Base Dialectical × Self-Reflection × Ego/Superego Learner
+  cell_60_base_dialectical_selfreflect_psycho:
+    description: "Multi-agent learner cell 60: base ego + suspicious superego + self-reflection + ego/superego learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 61: Recognition Dialectical × Self-Reflection × Ego/Superego Learner
+  cell_61_recog_dialectical_selfreflect_psycho:
+    description: "Multi-agent learner cell 61: recognition ego + suspicious superego + self-reflection + ego/superego learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 62: Base Dialectical × Bidirectional Profiling × Ego/Superego Learner
+  cell_62_base_dialectical_profile_bidirectional_psycho:
+    description: "Multi-agent learner cell 62: base ego + suspicious superego + bidirectional profiling + ego/superego learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      other_ego: bidirectional
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: true
+      strategy_planning: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 63: Recognition Dialectical × Bidirectional Profiling × Ego/Superego Learner
+  cell_63_recog_dialectical_profile_bidirectional_psycho:
+    description: "Multi-agent learner cell 63: recognition ego + suspicious superego + bidirectional profiling + ego/superego learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      other_ego: bidirectional
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: true
+      strategy_planning: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 64: Recognition Dialectical × Intersubjective × Ego/Superego Learner
+  cell_64_recog_dialectical_intersubjective_psycho:
+    description: "Multi-agent learner cell 64: recognition ego + suspicious superego + intersubjective + ego/superego learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: intersubjective
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      intersubjective: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 65: Recognition Dialectical × Combined × Ego/Superego Learner
+  cell_65_recog_dialectical_combined_psycho:
+    description: "Multi-agent learner cell 65: recognition ego + suspicious superego + all mechanisms combined + ego/superego learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: combined
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      quantitative_disposition: true
+      prompt_erosion:
+        enabled: true
+        rate: 0.2
+      intersubjective: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # ========================================================================
+  # Cells 66-68: Cognitive Prosthesis — Superego-Routed Profiling
+  # ========================================================================
+  # Test whether routing profiling through the stronger superego model (kimi-k2.5)
+  # helps weaker ego models (nemotron) approximate stronger model quality.
+  # All cells use recognition + dynamic learner + bidirectional profiling.
+
+  # Cell 66: Superego-routed profiling (descriptive format)
+  cell_66_recog_dialectical_profile_prosthesis_descriptive:
+    description: "Cognitive prosthesis cell 66: superego-routed bidirectional profiling (descriptive), nemotron ego, recognition"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      mechanism: profile_bidirectional
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: true
+      use_superego_model: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 67: Superego-routed profiling (prescriptive DO/DON'T format)
+  cell_67_recog_dialectical_profile_prosthesis_prescriptive:
+    description: "Cognitive prosthesis cell 67: superego-routed bidirectional profiling (prescriptive), nemotron ego, recognition"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      mechanism: profile_bidirectional
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: true
+      use_superego_model: true
+      prescriptive: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 68: Superego-routed profiling (prescriptive) + adversary superego
+  cell_68_recog_dialectical_profile_prosthesis_adversary:
+    description: "Cognitive prosthesis cell 68: superego-routed prescriptive profiling + adversary superego, nemotron ego, recognition"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_adversary
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: adversary
+      mechanism: profile_bidirectional
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego_recognition
+    recognition_mode: true
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+    other_ego_profiling:
+      enabled: true
+      bidirectional: true
+      use_superego_model: true
+      prescriptive: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.60
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-recognition-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-adversary.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      enforce_mutual_recognition: true
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # ========================================================================
+  # Cells 69-70: Base Pairs for Dynamic Learner Intersubjective/Combined
+  # ========================================================================
+  # Base counterparts to cells 64-65 (recognition-only).
+  # Completes the 4×2 mechanism × recognition matrix with dynamic learners:
+  #   Self-reflect:     60 (base) / 61 (recog)
+  #   Profiling:        62 (base) / 63 (recog)
+  #   Intersubjective:  69 (base) / 64 (recog)  <-- NEW base pair
+  #   Combined:         70 (base) / 65 (recog)  <-- NEW base pair
+
+  # Cell 69: Base Dialectical × Intersubjective × Ego/Superego Learner
+  cell_69_base_dialectical_intersubjective_psycho:
+    description: "Multi-agent learner cell 69: base ego + suspicious superego + intersubjective + ego/superego learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: intersubjective
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      intersubjective: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # Cell 70: Base Dialectical × Combined × Ego/Superego Learner
+  cell_70_base_dialectical_combined_psycho:
+    description: "Multi-agent learner cell 70: base ego + suspicious superego + all mechanisms combined + ego/superego learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: dialectical_suspicious
+      multi_agent_tutor: true
+      multi_agent_learner: true
+      superego_type: suspicious
+      full_modulation: true
+      superego_rewriting: true
+      mechanism: combined
+    learner_architecture: ego_superego
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: true
+    writing_pad_enabled: true
+    dialectical_negotiation: true
+    prompt_rewriting:
+      enabled: true
+      strategy: self_reflection
+      quantitative_disposition: true
+      prompt_erosion:
+        enabled: true
+        rate: 0.2
+      intersubjective: true
+    superego_disposition_rewriting: true
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: true
+      max_rounds: 1
+      convergence_threshold: 0.65
+      rejection_budget: 6
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: nemotron
+      staging: front
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-dialectical.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: kimi-k2.5
+      staging: back
+      prompt_file: tutor-superego-suspicious.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.2
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    intervention_strategies:
+      require_memory_integration: true
+      assess_transformative_potential: true
+
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # PROMPT ELABORATION BASELINE (cells 71-72)
+  # ===========================================================================
+  # Tests contribution of pedagogical prompt elaboration.
+  # Cell 71 (naive) uses JSON-schema-only prompt (~35 lines).
+  # Compare against cell 1 (base, 344-line prompt) to measure elaboration effect.
+
+  # Cell 71: Naive × Single Agent × Unified Learner
+  cell_71_naive_single_unified:
+    description: "Prompt elaboration baseline: naive single-agent tutor (JSON schema only, no pedagogical guidance), unified learner"
+    factors:
+      prompt_type: naive
+      multi_agent_tutor: false
+      multi_agent_learner: false
+    learner_architecture: unified
+    recognition_mode: false
+    memory_enabled: false
+    dialogue:
+      enabled: false
+      max_rounds: 0
+    ego:
+      provider: openrouter
+      model: haiku
+      prompt_file: tutor-ego-naive.md
+      hyperparameters:
+        temperature: 0.6
+        max_tokens: 8000
+    superego: null