@longtable/cli 0.1.25 → 0.1.26

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
package/README.md CHANGED
@@ -20,8 +20,7 @@ npm install -g @longtable/cli
20
20
  ```
21
21
 
22
22
  The npm install only installs the CLI. It does not write Codex skills, MCP
23
- config, hooks, tmux state, or provider runtime files without explicit setup
24
- approval.
23
+ config, hooks, or provider runtime files without explicit setup approval.
25
24
 
26
25
  ## Primary Flow
27
26
 
@@ -91,9 +90,7 @@ longtable roles
91
90
  longtable ask --cwd "<project-path>" --prompt "..."
92
91
  longtable panel --prompt "..."
93
92
  longtable sentinel --prompt "Should I define a new measurement construct?"
94
- longtable hud --watch
95
93
  longtable team --prompt "Review this measurement plan." --role editor,measurement_auditor --json
96
- longtable team --tmux --prompt "Review this measurement plan."
97
94
  longtable team --debate --prompt "Review this measurement plan." --role editor,measurement_auditor --json
98
95
  longtable codex install-skills
99
96
  longtable claude install-skills
@@ -111,6 +108,16 @@ longtable ask --prompt "lt panel: show the disagreement before I commit" --json
111
108
 
112
109
  Natural language should be the default.
113
110
 
111
+ Codex UI Researcher Checkpoints are a core LongTable feature when enabled:
112
+
113
+ ```bash
114
+ longtable setup --provider codex --surfaces skills_mcp --checkpoint-ui strong
115
+ ```
116
+
117
+ That setup writes the MCP configuration and Codex elicitation approval needed
118
+ for form-style checkpoint prompts. Without it, LongTable keeps the same
119
+ `QuestionRecord` pending and falls back to numbered text.
120
+
114
121
  Explicit short forms are available when needed:
115
122
 
116
123
  ```text
@@ -152,10 +159,6 @@ Inside a LongTable project workspace, panel planning also appends an
152
159
  `InvocationRecord` to `.longtable/state.json`, creates a pending follow-up
153
160
  `QuestionRecord`, and refreshes `CURRENT.md`.
154
161
 
155
- ```bash
156
- longtable decide --answer evidence --rationale "Need citation support before continuing."
157
- ```
158
-
159
162
  Default panel roles include:
160
163
 
161
164
  - `reviewer`
@@ -165,32 +168,25 @@ Default panel roles include:
165
168
 
166
169
  Use `--role` to constrain the panel when the research problem is already clear.
167
170
 
168
- ## Sentinel, HUD, And Agent Team
171
+ ## Sentinel And Agent Team
169
172
 
170
173
  `longtable sentinel` is an explicit gap/tacit check for prompts that may contain
171
174
  measurement, theory, method, evidence, authorship, or tacit-assumption risks.
172
175
  Use `--record` inside a LongTable workspace to store the finding as an
173
176
  unconfirmed inferred hypothesis.
174
177
 
175
- `longtable hud --watch` renders a compact view of the current project goal,
176
- blocker, pending checkpoints, recent decisions, and invocation counts.
177
- `longtable hud --tmux` opens that view in a tmux pane.
178
-
179
178
  `longtable team` creates a file-backed agent-team review under
180
179
  `.longtable/team/<id>/`: independent review, cross-review, and
181
180
  synthesis/checkpoint. Use it when roles should inspect each other's concerns
182
181
  before LongTable proposes a researcher decision.
183
182
 
184
- `longtable team --tmux` opens role-specific panes for live discussion. The panes
185
- can add logs, but the file-backed team artifact remains the source of truth.
186
-
187
183
  `longtable team --debate` creates a fixed five-round debate record under
188
184
  `.longtable/team/<id>/`: independent review, cross-review, rebuttal,
189
- convergence, and synthesis/checkpoint. Tmux can show live role panes, but the
190
- file-backed artifact directory is the source of truth.
185
+ convergence, and synthesis/checkpoint. The file-backed artifact directory is
186
+ the source of truth.
191
187
 
192
188
  See `docs/AGENT-TEAM-README.md` in the repository for a user-facing guide to
193
- panel, team, debate, and tmux surfaces.
189
+ panel, team, and debate surfaces.
194
190
 
195
191
  ## Evidence And Search Direction
196
192
 
package/dist/cli.js CHANGED
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
1
1
  #!/usr/bin/env node
2
2
  import { existsSync, readFileSync, statSync } from "node:fs";
3
3
  import { mkdir, mkdtemp, readFile, rm, writeFile } from "node:fs/promises";
4
- import { execFileSync, execSync } from "node:child_process";
4
+ import { execSync } from "node:child_process";
5
5
  import { emitKeypressEvents } from "node:readline";
6
6
  import { createInterface } from "node:readline/promises";
7
7
  import { stdin as input, stdout as output, cwd, exit } from "node:process";
@@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ import { installCodexPromptAliases, listInstalledCodexPromptAliases, removeCodex
15
15
  import { buildPersonaGuidance, parseInvocationDirective } from "./persona-router.js";
16
16
  import { PERSONA_DEFINITIONS, listRoleDefinitions } from "./personas.js";
17
17
  import { buildPanelFallback, renderPanelSummary } from "./panel.js";
18
- import { appendInvocationRecordToWorkspace, assertWorkspaceNotBlocked, answerWorkspaceQuestion, createWorkspaceClarificationCard, createWorkspaceQuestion, createOrUpdateProjectWorkspace, inspectProjectWorkspace, loadWorkspaceState, loadProjectContextFromDirectory, renderProjectWorkspaceSummary, syncCurrentWorkspaceView } from "./project-session.js";
18
+ import { appendInvocationRecordToWorkspace, assertWorkspaceNotBlocked, answerWorkspaceQuestion, createWorkspaceFollowUpQuestions, createWorkspaceQuestion, createOrUpdateProjectWorkspace, inspectProjectWorkspace, loadWorkspaceState, loadProjectContextFromDirectory, renderProjectWorkspaceSummary, syncCurrentWorkspaceView } from "./project-session.js";
19
19
  import { buildTeamDebate, buildTeamReview, renderTeamDebateSummary } from "./debate.js";
20
20
  const VALID_MODES = new Set([
21
21
  "explore",
@@ -42,7 +42,7 @@ const ANSI = {
42
42
  green: "\u001B[32m"
43
43
  };
44
44
  const LONGTABLE_MCP_SERVER_NAME = "longtable-state";
45
- const LONGTABLE_MCP_PACKAGE_VERSION = "0.1.25";
45
+ const LONGTABLE_MCP_PACKAGE_VERSION = "0.1.26";
46
46
  const LONGTABLE_MCP_MARKER_START = "# LongTable state MCP START";
47
47
  const LONGTABLE_MCP_MARKER_END = "# LongTable state MCP END";
48
48
  function style(text, prefix) {
@@ -89,7 +89,7 @@ function usage() {
89
89
  " longtable install [--json] [--path <file>] [--runtime-path <file>]",
90
90
  " longtable mcp install [--provider codex|claude|all] [--write] [--checkpoint-ui off|interactive|strong] [--json] [--codex-config <path>] [--claude-settings <path>] [--package <spec>]",
91
91
  " longtable sentinel --prompt <text> [--cwd <path>] [--json] [--record]",
92
- " longtable team --prompt <text> [--role <role[,role]>] [--tmux] [--debate] [--rounds 3|5] [--cwd <path>] [--json]",
92
+ " longtable team --prompt <text> [--role <role[,role]>] [--debate] [--rounds 3|5] [--cwd <path>] [--json]",
93
93
  " longtable ask [--prompt <text>] [--print] [--json] [--setup <path>] [--cwd <path>]",
94
94
  " longtable clarify --prompt <task-context> [--provider codex|claude] [--required|--advisory] [--print] [--cwd <path>] [--json] [--force]",
95
95
  " longtable question --prompt <decision-context> [--title <text>] [--text <question>] [--provider codex|claude] [--required|--advisory] [--print] [--cwd <path>] [--json]",
@@ -622,12 +622,12 @@ function buildPermissionSetupChoices() {
622
622
  {
623
623
  id: "strong",
624
624
  label: "Strong Researcher Checkpoint UI",
625
- description: "Why: uses Codex MCP elicitation for high-responsibility research decisions. What you get: clickable checkpoints with other/rationale. Tradeoff: requires Codex MCP elicitation approval."
625
+ description: "Why: makes Codex UI checkpoints the default for high-responsibility research decisions. What you get: MCP form checkpoints with a single decision field. Tradeoff: requires Codex MCP elicitation approval."
626
626
  },
627
627
  {
628
628
  id: "interactive",
629
629
  label: "Interactive checkpoint UI",
630
- description: "Why: keeps UI prompts available for required checkpoints. What you get: MCP form checkpoints when supported. Tradeoff: requires Codex MCP elicitation approval."
630
+ description: "Why: keeps Codex UI prompts available for required checkpoints. What you get: MCP form checkpoints when supported. Tradeoff: requires Codex MCP elicitation approval."
631
631
  },
632
632
  {
633
633
  id: "off",
@@ -768,7 +768,6 @@ async function runSetup(args) {
768
768
  interventionPosture: effectiveIntervention,
769
769
  checkpointUiMode: checkpointUi,
770
770
  workspaceCreationPreference: workspacePreference,
771
- tmuxMode: "standard",
772
771
  teamMode: "panel"
773
772
  };
774
773
  if (surfaces === "skills_mcp_sentinel") {
@@ -1769,6 +1768,38 @@ function inferModeFromPrompt(prompt) {
1769
1768
  }
1770
1769
  return "explore";
1771
1770
  }
1771
+ function inferCollaborationRoute(prompt) {
1772
+ const normalized = prompt.toLowerCase();
1773
+ const explicitDebate = /\bdebate\b|\bdebated\b|\brebuttal\b|\bconvergence\b|\bargue both sides\b/i.test(prompt) ||
1774
+ /토론|논쟁|반박|재반박|수렴/.test(prompt);
1775
+ if (explicitDebate) {
1776
+ return "debate";
1777
+ }
1778
+ const explicitTeam = /\bagent team\b|\bresearch team\b|\bteam review\b|\bteam-style\b|\buse a team\b/i.test(prompt) ||
1779
+ /에이전트\s*팀|연구\s*팀|팀\s*(리뷰|검토)|팀으로/.test(prompt);
1780
+ if (explicitTeam) {
1781
+ return "team";
1782
+ }
1783
+ const panelCue = /\bpanel\b|\bmulti[- ]?role\b|\bmultiple perspectives\b|\brole disagreement\b|\bdisagreement\b|\bconflict\b/i.test(prompt) ||
1784
+ /패널|여러\s*관점|복수\s*관점|역할.*불일치|불일치|충돌/.test(prompt);
1785
+ const multiPerspectiveCue = panelCue ||
1786
+ /\bperspectives?\b|\broles?\b|\breviewer and editor\b|\beditor and reviewer\b|\bmethods and measurement\b/i.test(prompt) ||
1787
+ /관점|역할|리뷰어.*에디터|에디터.*리뷰어|방법.*측정|측정.*방법/.test(prompt);
1788
+ if (!multiPerspectiveCue) {
1789
+ return null;
1790
+ }
1791
+ const trigger = classifyCheckpointTrigger(prompt, {});
1792
+ const highStakes = trigger.signal.artifactStakes === "external_submission" ||
1793
+ trigger.signal.artifactStakes === "study_protocol" ||
1794
+ trigger.requiresQuestionBeforeClosure;
1795
+ if (panelCue && trigger.signal.artifactStakes === "external_submission") {
1796
+ return "debate";
1797
+ }
1798
+ if (highStakes) {
1799
+ return "team";
1800
+ }
1801
+ return "panel";
1802
+ }
1772
1803
  function parsePanelVisibility(value) {
1773
1804
  if (value === "synthesis_only" ||
1774
1805
  value === "show_on_conflict" ||
@@ -1820,6 +1851,9 @@ async function runModeCommand(mode, args) {
1820
1851
  }
1821
1852
  const setup = await loadOptionalSetup(typeof args.setup === "string" ? args.setup : undefined);
1822
1853
  const projectContext = await loadProjectContextFromDirectory(workingDirectory);
1854
+ if (projectContext) {
1855
+ await assertWorkspaceNotBlocked(projectContext);
1856
+ }
1823
1857
  const projectAware = await buildProjectAwarePrompt(prompt, workingDirectory);
1824
1858
  const panelPreference = setup?.profileSeed.panelPreference;
1825
1859
  const panelRequested = args.panel === true ||
@@ -2019,9 +2053,9 @@ function questionRecordToChoices(record) {
2019
2053
  : [])
2020
2054
  ];
2021
2055
  }
2022
- function renderClarificationCard(questions) {
2056
+ function renderFollowUpQuestions(questions) {
2023
2057
  if (questions.length === 0) {
2024
- return "No new clarification questions are pending for this prompt.";
2058
+ return "No new follow-up questions are pending for this prompt.";
2025
2059
  }
2026
2060
  const width = 44;
2027
2061
  const boxLine = (text = "") => `│ ${text.padEnd(width, " ")} │`;
@@ -2072,13 +2106,13 @@ function renderClarificationCard(questions) {
2072
2106
  lines.push("Answer in a terminal with `longtable clarify --prompt ...`, or record choices with `longtable decide --question <id> --answer <value>`.");
2073
2107
  return lines.join("\n");
2074
2108
  }
2075
- async function answerClarificationCardInTerminal(context, questions, provider) {
2109
+ async function answerFollowUpQuestionsInTerminal(context, questions, provider) {
2076
2110
  if (questions.length === 0) {
2077
2111
  return;
2078
2112
  }
2079
2113
  const rl = createInterface({ input, output });
2080
2114
  try {
2081
- console.log(renderBrandBanner("LongTable", "Clarification Card"));
2115
+ console.log(renderBrandBanner("LongTable", "Follow-up Questions"));
2082
2116
  console.log("");
2083
2117
  for (let index = 0; index < questions.length; index += 1) {
2084
2118
  const question = questions[index];
@@ -2109,7 +2143,7 @@ async function runClarify(args) {
2109
2143
  }
2110
2144
  const provider = args.provider === "claude" ? "claude" : args.provider === "codex" ? "codex" : undefined;
2111
2145
  const required = args.required === true ? true : args.advisory === true ? false : undefined;
2112
- const result = await createWorkspaceClarificationCard({
2146
+ const result = await createWorkspaceFollowUpQuestions({
2113
2147
  context,
2114
2148
  prompt,
2115
2149
  provider,
@@ -2129,17 +2163,17 @@ async function runClarify(args) {
2129
2163
  return;
2130
2164
  }
2131
2165
  if (args.print === true || !isInteractiveTerminal()) {
2132
- console.log(renderClarificationCard(result.questions));
2166
+ console.log(renderFollowUpQuestions(result.questions));
2133
2167
  return;
2134
2168
  }
2135
- await answerClarificationCardInTerminal(context, result.questions, provider);
2169
+ await answerFollowUpQuestionsInTerminal(context, result.questions, provider);
2136
2170
  console.log("");
2137
- console.log("LongTable clarification decisions recorded");
2171
+ console.log("LongTable follow-up decisions recorded");
2138
2172
  console.log(`- answered: ${result.questions.length}`);
2139
2173
  console.log(`- state: ${context.stateFilePath}`);
2140
2174
  console.log(`- current: ${context.currentFilePath}`);
2141
2175
  }
2142
- async function runAutomaticClarificationIfNeeded(prompt, args) {
2176
+ async function runAutomaticFollowUpIfNeeded(prompt, args) {
2143
2177
  if (args["no-clarify"] === true || args.print === true || args.json === true) {
2144
2178
  return false;
2145
2179
  }
@@ -2149,7 +2183,7 @@ async function runAutomaticClarificationIfNeeded(prompt, args) {
2149
2183
  return false;
2150
2184
  }
2151
2185
  const provider = args.provider === "claude" ? "claude" : args.provider === "codex" ? "codex" : undefined;
2152
- const result = await createWorkspaceClarificationCard({
2186
+ const result = await createWorkspaceFollowUpQuestions({
2153
2187
  context,
2154
2188
  prompt,
2155
2189
  provider,
@@ -2159,17 +2193,22 @@ async function runAutomaticClarificationIfNeeded(prompt, args) {
2159
2193
  return false;
2160
2194
  }
2161
2195
  if (!isInteractiveTerminal()) {
2162
- console.log(renderClarificationCard(result.questions));
2196
+ console.log(renderFollowUpQuestions(result.questions));
2163
2197
  return true;
2164
2198
  }
2165
- await answerClarificationCardInTerminal(context, result.questions, provider);
2199
+ await answerFollowUpQuestionsInTerminal(context, result.questions, provider);
2166
2200
  return false;
2167
2201
  }
2168
2202
  async function runAsk(args) {
2203
+ const workingDirectory = typeof args.cwd === "string" ? args.cwd : cwd();
2169
2204
  const prompt = await resolvePrompt(typeof args.prompt === "string" ? args.prompt : undefined);
2170
2205
  if (!prompt) {
2171
2206
  throw new Error("A prompt is required.");
2172
2207
  }
2208
+ const projectContext = await loadProjectContextFromDirectory(workingDirectory);
2209
+ if (projectContext) {
2210
+ await assertWorkspaceNotBlocked(projectContext);
2211
+ }
2173
2212
  const directive = parseInvocationDirective(prompt);
2174
2213
  const effectivePrompt = directive.cleanedPrompt;
2175
2214
  const inferred = directive.mode ?? inferModeFromPrompt(effectivePrompt);
@@ -2178,7 +2217,7 @@ async function runAsk(args) {
2178
2217
  return;
2179
2218
  }
2180
2219
  const mode = inferred === "panel" ? "review" : inferred;
2181
- if (await runAutomaticClarificationIfNeeded(effectivePrompt, args)) {
2220
+ if (await runAutomaticFollowUpIfNeeded(effectivePrompt, args)) {
2182
2221
  return;
2183
2222
  }
2184
2223
  const delegatedArgs = {
@@ -2188,7 +2227,18 @@ async function runAsk(args) {
2188
2227
  if (directive.roles.length > 0 && typeof delegatedArgs.role !== "string") {
2189
2228
  delegatedArgs.role = directive.roles.join(",");
2190
2229
  }
2191
- if (inferred === "panel" || directive.panel || delegatedArgs.panel === true) {
2230
+ const collaborationRoute = directive.collaboration ??
2231
+ (directive.panel || delegatedArgs.panel === true
2232
+ ? "panel"
2233
+ : inferCollaborationRoute(effectivePrompt) ?? (inferred === "panel" ? "panel" : null));
2234
+ if (collaborationRoute === "team" || collaborationRoute === "debate") {
2235
+ await runTeam({
2236
+ ...delegatedArgs,
2237
+ debate: collaborationRoute === "debate"
2238
+ });
2239
+ return;
2240
+ }
2241
+ if (collaborationRoute === "panel") {
2192
2242
  await runPanelCommand({
2193
2243
  ...delegatedArgs,
2194
2244
  visibility: "always_visible"
@@ -2200,9 +2250,6 @@ async function runAsk(args) {
2200
2250
  function localId(prefix) {
2201
2251
  return `${prefix}_${Date.now().toString(36)}_${Math.random().toString(36).slice(2, 8)}`;
2202
2252
  }
2203
- function shellEscape(value) {
2204
- return `'${value.replaceAll("'", "'\\''")}'`;
2205
- }
2206
2253
  async function writeJsonFile(path, value) {
2207
2254
  await writeFile(path, `${JSON.stringify(value, null, 2)}\n`, "utf8");
2208
2255
  }
@@ -2329,8 +2376,7 @@ async function runTeam(args) {
2329
2376
  roleFlag: typeof args.role === "string" ? args.role : undefined,
2330
2377
  provider: setup?.providerSelection.provider,
2331
2378
  visibility: "always_visible",
2332
- roundCount: rounds,
2333
- tmux: args.tmux === true
2379
+ roundCount: rounds
2334
2380
  });
2335
2381
  await writeTeamDebateArtifacts(debate, teamDir, prompt);
2336
2382
  const canRecordWorkspace = projectAware.projectContextFound && projectContext && existsSync(projectContext.stateFilePath);
@@ -2354,40 +2400,6 @@ async function runTeam(args) {
2354
2400
  }, null, 2));
2355
2401
  return;
2356
2402
  }
2357
- if (args.tmux === true) {
2358
- const sessionName = `longtable-${teamId.replaceAll("_", "-")}`;
2359
- const shell = process.env.SHELL || "/bin/sh";
2360
- const launcher = process.argv[1] ?? "longtable";
2361
- const leaderCommand = [
2362
- `echo ${shellEscape(`LongTable debate ${teamId}`)}`,
2363
- `echo ${shellEscape(`Artifacts: ${teamDir}`)}`,
2364
- `echo ${shellEscape("Fixed rounds are recorded. Role panes can add live review logs.")}`,
2365
- `echo ${shellEscape(`Checkpoint: ${debate.questionRecord.id}`)}`,
2366
- `exec ${shellEscape(shell)}`
2367
- ].join("; ");
2368
- execFileSync("tmux", ["new-session", "-d", "-s", sessionName, "-c", workingDirectory, leaderCommand], { stdio: "inherit" });
2369
- for (const member of debate.plan.members) {
2370
- const rolePrompt = [
2371
- `LongTable autonomous debate role: ${member.label} (${member.role}).`,
2372
- "Use the fixed debate artifacts as the shared record. Add live notes only; do not answer the researcher checkpoint.",
2373
- `Artifacts: ${teamDir}`,
2374
- "",
2375
- projectAware.prompt
2376
- ].join("\n");
2377
- const logPath = join(teamDir, `${member.role}.debate.log`);
2378
- const command = [
2379
- `node ${shellEscape(launcher)} review --role ${shellEscape(member.role)} --prompt ${shellEscape(rolePrompt)} --cwd ${shellEscape(workingDirectory)} 2>&1 | tee ${shellEscape(logPath)}`,
2380
- `echo ${shellEscape(`Debate role log written to ${logPath}`)}`,
2381
- `exec ${shellEscape(shell)}`
2382
- ].join("; ");
2383
- execFileSync("tmux", ["split-window", "-t", sessionName, "-c", workingDirectory, command], { stdio: "inherit" });
2384
- execFileSync("tmux", ["select-layout", "-t", sessionName, "tiled"], { stdio: "ignore" });
2385
- }
2386
- console.log(`LongTable tmux debate launched: ${sessionName}`);
2387
- console.log(`Attach with: tmux attach -t ${sessionName}`);
2388
- console.log(`Artifacts: ${teamDir}`);
2389
- return;
2390
- }
2391
2403
  console.log(renderTeamDebateSummary(debate.run));
2392
2404
  console.log(`- checkpoint: ${debate.questionRecord.id}`);
2393
2405
  return;
@@ -2399,8 +2411,7 @@ async function runTeam(args) {
2399
2411
  roleFlag: typeof args.role === "string" ? args.role : undefined,
2400
2412
  provider: setup?.providerSelection.provider,
2401
2413
  visibility: "always_visible",
2402
- roundCount: rounds,
2403
- tmux: args.tmux === true
2414
+ roundCount: rounds
2404
2415
  });
2405
2416
  await writeTeamDebateArtifacts(team, teamDir, prompt);
2406
2417
  const canRecordWorkspace = projectAware.projectContextFound && projectContext && existsSync(projectContext.stateFilePath);
@@ -2425,41 +2436,8 @@ async function runTeam(args) {
2425
2436
  }, null, 2));
2426
2437
  return;
2427
2438
  }
2428
- if (args.tmux !== true) {
2429
- console.log(renderTeamDebateSummary(team.run));
2430
- console.log(`- checkpoint: ${team.questionRecord.id}`);
2431
- return;
2432
- }
2433
- const sessionName = `longtable-${teamId.replaceAll("_", "-")}`;
2434
- const shell = process.env.SHELL || "/bin/sh";
2435
- const launcher = process.argv[1] ?? "longtable";
2436
- const leaderCommand = [
2437
- `echo ${shellEscape(`LongTable team ${teamId}`)}`,
2438
- `echo ${shellEscape(`Artifacts: ${teamDir}`)}`,
2439
- `echo ${shellEscape("Cross-review artifacts are recorded. Role panes can add live review logs.")}`,
2440
- `echo ${shellEscape(`Checkpoint: ${team.questionRecord.id}`)}`,
2441
- `exec ${shellEscape(shell)}`
2442
- ].join("; ");
2443
- execFileSync("tmux", ["new-session", "-d", "-s", sessionName, "-c", workingDirectory, leaderCommand], { stdio: "inherit" });
2444
- for (const member of team.plan.members) {
2445
- const rolePrompt = [
2446
- `LongTable team discussion role: ${member.label} (${member.role}).`,
2447
- "Give claims, objections, open questions, and evidence needs. Address likely disagreement with other roles.",
2448
- "",
2449
- prompt
2450
- ].join("\n");
2451
- const logPath = join(teamDir, `${member.role}.log`);
2452
- const command = [
2453
- `node ${shellEscape(launcher)} review --role ${shellEscape(member.role)} --prompt ${shellEscape(rolePrompt)} --cwd ${shellEscape(workingDirectory)} 2>&1 | tee ${shellEscape(logPath)}`,
2454
- `echo ${shellEscape(`Role log written to ${logPath}`)}`,
2455
- `exec ${shellEscape(shell)}`
2456
- ].join("; ");
2457
- execFileSync("tmux", ["split-window", "-t", sessionName, "-c", workingDirectory, command], { stdio: "inherit" });
2458
- execFileSync("tmux", ["select-layout", "-t", sessionName, "tiled"], { stdio: "ignore" });
2459
- }
2460
- console.log(`LongTable tmux team launched: ${sessionName}`);
2461
- console.log(`Attach with: tmux attach -t ${sessionName}`);
2462
- console.log(`Logs: ${teamDir}`);
2439
+ console.log(renderTeamDebateSummary(team.run));
2440
+ console.log(`- checkpoint: ${team.questionRecord.id}`);
2463
2441
  }
2464
2442
  async function runDecide(args) {
2465
2443
  const workingDirectory = typeof args.cwd === "string" ? args.cwd : cwd();
package/dist/debate.d.ts CHANGED
@@ -7,7 +7,6 @@ export interface BuildTeamDebateOptions {
7
7
  provider?: ProviderKind;
8
8
  visibility?: PanelVisibility;
9
9
  roundCount?: number;
10
- tmux?: boolean;
11
10
  }
12
11
  export interface TeamDebateBundle {
13
12
  plan: PanelPlan;
package/dist/debate.js CHANGED
@@ -322,7 +322,7 @@ function buildTeamBundle(options, kind) {
322
322
  prompt: options.prompt,
323
323
  roles: plan.members,
324
324
  status: "completed",
325
- surface: options.tmux ? "tmux_console" : "file_backed_debate",
325
+ surface: "file_backed_debate",
326
326
  interactionDepth: kind === "debate" ? "debated" : "cross_reviewed",
327
327
  roundPolicy: kind === "debate" ? "fixed" : "team_cross_review",
328
328
  roundCount,
@@ -371,9 +371,7 @@ function buildTeamBundle(options, kind) {
371
371
  interactionDepth: run.interactionDepth,
372
372
  panelPlan: plan,
373
373
  teamDebateRun: run,
374
- degradationReason: options.tmux
375
- ? undefined
376
- : "Tmux was not requested; file-backed debate artifacts are the canonical execution record."
374
+ degradationReason: "File-backed team artifacts are the canonical execution record."
377
375
  };
378
376
  return {
379
377
  plan,
@@ -12,6 +12,7 @@ export interface LongTableInvocationDirective {
12
12
  explicit: boolean;
13
13
  cleanedPrompt: string;
14
14
  mode?: InteractionMode | "panel" | "status";
15
+ collaboration?: "panel" | "team" | "debate";
15
16
  roles: CanonicalPersona[];
16
17
  panel: boolean;
17
18
  showConflicts: boolean;
@@ -7,7 +7,9 @@ const DIRECTIVE_MAP = [
7
7
  { key: "critique", mode: "critique" },
8
8
  { key: "draft", mode: "draft" },
9
9
  { key: "commit", mode: "commit" },
10
- { key: "panel", mode: "panel", panel: true, showConflicts: true },
10
+ { key: "panel", mode: "panel", collaboration: "panel", panel: true, showConflicts: true },
11
+ { key: "team", mode: "review", collaboration: "team", panel: true, showConflicts: true },
12
+ { key: "debate", mode: "review", collaboration: "debate", panel: true, showConflicts: true },
11
13
  { key: "status", mode: "status" },
12
14
  { key: "editor", mode: "review", roles: ["editor"] },
13
15
  { key: "reviewer", mode: "review", roles: ["reviewer"] },
@@ -72,6 +74,7 @@ export function parseInvocationDirective(prompt) {
72
74
  explicit: true,
73
75
  cleanedPrompt: body || prompt,
74
76
  mode: directive.mode,
77
+ collaboration: directive.collaboration,
75
78
  roles: directive.roles ?? [],
76
79
  panel: directive.panel === true,
77
80
  showConflicts: directive.showConflicts === true
@@ -113,7 +113,7 @@ export declare function syncCurrentWorkspaceView(context: LongTableProjectContex
113
113
  export declare function appendInvocationRecordToWorkspace(context: LongTableProjectContext, invocation: InvocationRecord, questions?: QuestionRecord[]): Promise<ResearchState>;
114
114
  export declare function listBlockingWorkspaceQuestions(context: LongTableProjectContext): Promise<QuestionRecord[]>;
115
115
  export declare function assertWorkspaceNotBlocked(context: LongTableProjectContext): Promise<void>;
116
- export declare function createWorkspaceClarificationCard(options: {
116
+ export declare function createWorkspaceFollowUpQuestions(options: {
117
117
  context: LongTableProjectContext;
118
118
  prompt: string;
119
119
  provider?: ProviderKind;
@@ -647,10 +647,10 @@ function optionsForCheckpointTrigger(family, checkpointKey) {
647
647
  function includesAny(prompt, patterns) {
648
648
  return patterns.some((pattern) => pattern.test(prompt));
649
649
  }
650
- function clarificationOptions(first, second, third, fourth) {
650
+ function followUpQuestionOptions(first, second, third, fourth) {
651
651
  return [first, second, third, ...(fourth ? [fourth] : [])];
652
652
  }
653
- function buildClarificationQuestionSpecs(prompt) {
653
+ function buildFollowUpQuestionSpecs(prompt) {
654
654
  const normalized = prompt.toLowerCase();
655
655
  const specs = [];
656
656
  function push(spec) {
@@ -664,7 +664,7 @@ function buildClarificationQuestionSpecs(prompt) {
664
664
  title: "Rubric update basis",
665
665
  question: "How should LongTable use the available materials to update the rubric?",
666
666
  whyNow: "Rubric updates can silently change grading criteria if LongTable guesses the calibration basis.",
667
- options: clarificationOptions({ value: "calibrate_to_exemplars", label: "Calibrate criteria to exemplars", description: "Use strong submissions to refine what each criterion means.", recommended: true }, { value: "polish_existing", label: "Polish existing rubric only", description: "Keep criteria stable and improve wording or consistency." }, { value: "rewrite_structure", label: "Restructure the rubric", description: "Change categories or levels where the materials suggest a better structure." })
667
+ options: followUpQuestionOptions({ value: "calibrate_to_exemplars", label: "Calibrate criteria to exemplars", description: "Use strong submissions to refine what each criterion means.", recommended: true }, { value: "polish_existing", label: "Polish existing rubric only", description: "Keep criteria stable and improve wording or consistency." }, { value: "rewrite_structure", label: "Restructure the rubric", description: "Change categories or levels where the materials suggest a better structure." })
668
668
  });
669
669
  }
670
670
  if (includesAny(normalized, [/\bexemplar\b/, /\bbest submission\b/, /\bselected submission\b/, /\bTA\b/i, /우수\s*답안|예시|선정|조교/])) {
@@ -673,7 +673,7 @@ function buildClarificationQuestionSpecs(prompt) {
673
673
  title: "Exemplar use",
674
674
  question: "How should LongTable use selected exemplars or TA guidance?",
675
675
  whyNow: "Exemplars can either calibrate criteria privately or become visible evidence inside the output.",
676
- options: clarificationOptions({ value: "calibrate_only", label: "Use as private calibration", description: "Adjust criteria using exemplars without quoting them.", recommended: true }, { value: "include_deidentified_excerpts", label: "Include de-identified excerpts", description: "Add short anonymized examples where they clarify quality." }, { value: "separate_notes", label: "Keep examples in separate notes", description: "Use exemplars outside the main artifact." })
676
+ options: followUpQuestionOptions({ value: "calibrate_only", label: "Use as private calibration", description: "Adjust criteria using exemplars without quoting them.", recommended: true }, { value: "include_deidentified_excerpts", label: "Include de-identified excerpts", description: "Add short anonymized examples where they clarify quality." }, { value: "separate_notes", label: "Keep examples in separate notes", description: "Use exemplars outside the main artifact." })
677
677
  });
678
678
  }
679
679
  if (includesAny(normalized, [/\binstruction/, /\bguidance\b/, /\bsource\b/, /\bfile\b/, /\bdocx?\b/, /지침|가이드|문서|파일|자료/])) {
@@ -682,7 +682,7 @@ function buildClarificationQuestionSpecs(prompt) {
682
682
  title: "Source authority",
683
683
  question: "If sources conflict or leave gaps, which source should LongTable privilege?",
684
684
  whyNow: "Without an authority rule, LongTable may resolve conflicts by convenience rather than researcher intent.",
685
- options: clarificationOptions({ value: "explicit_user_instruction", label: "Your explicit instruction", description: "Use the researcher's current instruction as the highest authority.", recommended: true }, { value: "project_files", label: "Project files", description: "Treat supplied files or existing artifacts as authoritative." }, { value: "external_guidance", label: "TA or external guidance", description: "Prioritize instructor, TA, venue, or policy guidance." })
685
+ options: followUpQuestionOptions({ value: "explicit_user_instruction", label: "Your explicit instruction", description: "Use the researcher's current instruction as the highest authority.", recommended: true }, { value: "project_files", label: "Project files", description: "Treat supplied files or existing artifacts as authoritative." }, { value: "external_guidance", label: "TA or external guidance", description: "Prioritize instructor, TA, venue, or policy guidance." })
686
686
  });
687
687
  }
688
688
  if (includesAny(normalized, [/\bdeliver\b/, /\boutput\b/, /\btracked?[- ]?change/, /\bdocx?\b/, /\bmarkdown\b/, /\btable\b/, /전달|산출물|결과물|수정\s*표시|트랙|형식|포맷/])) {
@@ -691,7 +691,7 @@ function buildClarificationQuestionSpecs(prompt) {
691
691
  title: "Delivery format",
692
692
  question: "How should LongTable deliver the clarified output?",
693
693
  whyNow: "Format and change-tracking choices affect whether the result is usable for review or handoff.",
694
- options: clarificationOptions({ value: "tracked_changes", label: "Tracked-change artifact", description: "Produce a reviewable changed version where possible.", recommended: true }, { value: "clean_final", label: "Clean final artifact", description: "Deliver the final version without change markup." }, { value: "summary_plus_artifact", label: "Summary plus artifact", description: "Include a concise change summary with the output." })
694
+ options: followUpQuestionOptions({ value: "tracked_changes", label: "Tracked-change artifact", description: "Produce a reviewable changed version where possible.", recommended: true }, { value: "clean_final", label: "Clean final artifact", description: "Deliver the final version without change markup." }, { value: "summary_plus_artifact", label: "Summary plus artifact", description: "Include a concise change summary with the output." })
695
695
  });
696
696
  }
697
697
  if (includesAny(normalized, [/\bupdate\b/, /\bchange\b/, /\bedit\b/, /\bfix\b/, /\bimplement\b/, /\bbuild\b/, /\bcreate\b/, /업데이트|수정|변경|구현|만들|고쳐/])) {
@@ -700,7 +700,7 @@ function buildClarificationQuestionSpecs(prompt) {
700
700
  title: "Autonomy boundary",
701
701
  question: "How much should LongTable do before checking back with you?",
702
702
  whyNow: "Execution requests can move from advice to authorship or artifact ownership unless the boundary is explicit.",
703
- options: clarificationOptions({ value: "ask_then_act", label: "Clarify first, then act", description: "Ask needed questions before changing the artifact.", recommended: true }, { value: "act_with_defaults", label: "Act with visible defaults", description: "Proceed using recommended defaults and record them." }, { value: "recommend_only", label: "Recommend only", description: "Describe changes but do not alter artifacts." })
703
+ options: followUpQuestionOptions({ value: "ask_then_act", label: "Clarify first, then act", description: "Ask needed questions before changing the artifact.", recommended: true }, { value: "act_with_defaults", label: "Act with visible defaults", description: "Proceed using recommended defaults and record them." }, { value: "recommend_only", label: "Recommend only", description: "Describe changes but do not alter artifacts." })
704
704
  });
705
705
  }
706
706
  if (includesAny(normalized, [/\bperformance\b/, /\btest\b/, /\bevaluate\b/, /\bcheck\b/, /\bbenchmark\b/, /성능|테스트|평가|체크|검증/])) {
@@ -709,7 +709,7 @@ function buildClarificationQuestionSpecs(prompt) {
709
709
  title: "Evaluation target",
710
710
  question: "What should LongTable treat as the main performance target?",
711
711
  whyNow: "Performance checks can optimize for UX, correctness, trigger sensitivity, or delivery reliability.",
712
- options: clarificationOptions({ value: "question_sensitivity", label: "Question sensitivity", description: "Check whether LongTable asks at the right knowledge-gap moments.", recommended: true }, { value: "renderer_convenience", label: "Renderer convenience", description: "Check whether the most convenient question UI is used." }, { value: "state_reliability", label: "State reliability", description: "Check whether questions and answers persist correctly." })
712
+ options: followUpQuestionOptions({ value: "question_sensitivity", label: "Question sensitivity", description: "Check whether LongTable asks at the right knowledge-gap moments.", recommended: true }, { value: "renderer_convenience", label: "Renderer convenience", description: "Check whether the most convenient question UI is used." }, { value: "state_reliability", label: "State reliability", description: "Check whether questions and answers persist correctly." })
713
713
  });
714
714
  }
715
715
  if (specs.length === 0) {
@@ -718,19 +718,19 @@ function buildClarificationQuestionSpecs(prompt) {
718
718
  title: "Missing context",
719
719
  question: "What should LongTable clarify before proceeding?",
720
720
  whyNow: "The request can be answered in multiple ways, and choosing silently would hide a researcher judgment.",
721
- options: clarificationOptions({ value: "scope", label: "Clarify scope first", description: "Ask what is included and excluded before acting.", recommended: true }, { value: "criteria", label: "Clarify success criteria", description: "Ask what would count as a good result." }, { value: "proceed", label: "Proceed with visible assumptions", description: "Continue, but make assumptions explicit." })
721
+ options: followUpQuestionOptions({ value: "scope", label: "Clarify scope first", description: "Ask what is included and excluded before acting.", recommended: true }, { value: "criteria", label: "Clarify success criteria", description: "Ask what would count as a good result." }, { value: "proceed", label: "Proceed with visible assumptions", description: "Continue, but make assumptions explicit." })
722
722
  });
723
723
  }
724
724
  return specs;
725
725
  }
726
- const CLARIFICATION_PROMPT_PREFIX = "Clarification prompt:";
727
- function hasClarificationPrompt(record, prompt) {
728
- return record.prompt.rationale.includes(`${CLARIFICATION_PROMPT_PREFIX} ${prompt}`);
726
+ const FOLLOW_UP_PROMPT_PREFIX = "Follow-up prompt:";
727
+ function hasFollowUpPrompt(record, prompt) {
728
+ return record.prompt.rationale.includes(`${FOLLOW_UP_PROMPT_PREFIX} ${prompt}`);
729
729
  }
730
- export async function createWorkspaceClarificationCard(options) {
730
+ export async function createWorkspaceFollowUpQuestions(options) {
731
731
  const state = await loadResearchState(options.context.stateFilePath);
732
732
  if (!options.force) {
733
- const existing = (state.questionLog ?? []).filter((record) => hasClarificationPrompt(record, options.prompt));
733
+ const existing = (state.questionLog ?? []).filter((record) => hasFollowUpPrompt(record, options.prompt));
734
734
  const pending = existing.filter((record) => record.status === "pending");
735
735
  if (pending.length > 0) {
736
736
  return { questions: pending, state, created: false, alreadyAnswered: false };
@@ -743,14 +743,14 @@ export async function createWorkspaceClarificationCard(options) {
743
743
  const preferredSurfaces = options.provider === "claude"
744
744
  ? ["native_structured", "terminal_selector", "numbered"]
745
745
  : ["mcp_elicitation", "terminal_selector", "numbered"];
746
- const questions = buildClarificationQuestionSpecs(options.prompt).map((spec) => ({
746
+ const questions = buildFollowUpQuestionSpecs(options.prompt).map((spec) => ({
747
747
  id: createId("question_record"),
748
748
  createdAt,
749
749
  updatedAt: createdAt,
750
750
  status: "pending",
751
751
  prompt: {
752
752
  id: createId("question_prompt"),
753
- checkpointKey: `clarification_${spec.key}`,
753
+ checkpointKey: `follow_up_${spec.key}`,
754
754
  title: spec.title,
755
755
  question: spec.question,
756
756
  type: "single_choice",
@@ -761,7 +761,7 @@ export async function createWorkspaceClarificationCard(options) {
761
761
  source: "runtime_guidance",
762
762
  rationale: [
763
763
  spec.whyNow,
764
- `${CLARIFICATION_PROMPT_PREFIX} ${options.prompt}`
764
+ `${FOLLOW_UP_PROMPT_PREFIX} ${options.prompt}`
765
765
  ],
766
766
  preferredSurfaces: preferredSurfaces
767
767
  }
package/package.json CHANGED
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
1
1
  {
2
2
  "name": "@longtable/cli",
3
- "version": "0.1.25",
3
+ "version": "0.1.26",
4
4
  "private": false,
5
5
  "description": "Researcher-facing LongTable CLI",
6
6
  "type": "module",
@@ -28,12 +28,12 @@
28
28
  "typecheck": "tsc -p tsconfig.json --noEmit"
29
29
  },
30
30
  "dependencies": {
31
- "@longtable/checkpoints": "0.1.25",
32
- "@longtable/core": "0.1.25",
33
- "@longtable/memory": "0.1.25",
34
- "@longtable/provider-claude": "0.1.25",
35
- "@longtable/provider-codex": "0.1.25",
36
- "@longtable/setup": "0.1.25"
31
+ "@longtable/checkpoints": "0.1.26",
32
+ "@longtable/core": "0.1.26",
33
+ "@longtable/memory": "0.1.26",
34
+ "@longtable/provider-claude": "0.1.26",
35
+ "@longtable/provider-codex": "0.1.26",
36
+ "@longtable/setup": "0.1.26"
37
37
  },
38
38
  "devDependencies": {
39
39
  "@types/node": "^22.10.1",