@kontourai/flow-agents 3.6.0 → 3.7.0

package/kits/builder/skills/gate-review/SKILL.md

@@ -1,234 +1,83 @@
 ---
 name: "gate-review"
-description: "Enumerate gate fires and suspected misses from the session's Hachure trust.bundle, classify each as correct/false_block/missed_block using Surface's resolveInquiry to produce canonical InquiryRecords, route findings to learning-review, and propose advisory-only gate/flow fixes. Use mid-session after a goal-fit block or at closeout. Requires ADR 0010 Phase 1 (trust.bundle dual-write) to be present."
+description: "Explicit advisory extension for reviewing apparent workflow gate blocks or misses from a completed trust bundle."
 ---
 
 # Gate Review
 
-Classify gate fires and suspected misses from the session's `trust.bundle` by calling Surface's `resolveInquiry` to produce canonical `InquiryRecord` outputs. Every finding is advisory — proposes a fix, never applies one.
+## Role and Boundary
 
-## Contract
+**Role:** explicit advisory extension outside generic routing.
 
-- **Advisory-only**: proposes fixes, never applies them. No finding may instruct auto-application of any fix.
-- Never writes to `scripts/hooks/` or any flow file.
-- Reads the local `trust.bundle` file only. Does NOT fall back to `command-log.jsonl`, `.goal-fit-block-streak.json`, or `evidence.json` direct reads as primary inputs.
-- If no `trust.bundle` is present at `.kontourai/flow-agents/<slug>/trust.bundle`, reports `NOT_VERIFIED` and stops. Does not silently degrade to bespoke sidecar reads.
-- Routes all telemetry, `learning.json` writes, and correction routing through `learning-review`. Gate-review never calls `record-learning` directly.
-- Reads `state.json` for lifecycle context only (phase, status). `state.json` is NOT a trust claim per ADR 0010.
-- Reads `context/gate-awareness.md` for vocabulary alignment when available.
-- Classification vocabulary (`correct`, `false_block`, `missed_block`) aligns with `context/gate-awareness.md` sections "Judge Gate Correctness" and "Missed-Block Diagnostic".
-- Uses `@kontourai/surface`'s `resolveInquiry(bundle, inquiry)` to produce canonical `InquiryRecord` outputs per ADR 0003.
-- If `@kontourai/surface` is unavailable, logs a warning and skips output. No bespoke fork fallback.
-- **Builder Kit build flow**: gate-review operates on sessions created by `deliver` or `plan-work` with `--flow-id builder.build`. The session's trust.bundle contains both declared builder.* claims (e.g. `builder.verify.tests`) and legacy workflow.* shadow claims. Gate-review classifies all claims present in the bundle regardless of claimType prefix.
+Use only when the user explicitly asks to assess a suspected gate false block,
+missed block, or gate behavior at closeout. This extension does not select a
+flow, advance a run, apply a fix, or replace review, verification, or
+learning-review.
+
+It owns **no step-gate evidence**. It consumes existing trust data and produces
+advisory review output only. Any remediation enters the normal planning and
+delivery process after human selection.
 
 ## Inputs
 
-- `trust.bundle` at `.kontourai/flow-agents/<slug>/trust.bundle` (produced by ADR 0010 Phase 1 dual-write in `workflow-sidecar`).
-
-  **Dependency**: this file is NOT present at `origin/main @ a9b8fd6`; it requires ADR 0010 Phase 1 to be built and merged (owned by `arch/goal-fit-gate-trust-bundle`). Do not begin execution until Phase 1 has landed or a fixture is agreed with that owner.
-
-  The bundle shape produced by `workflow-sidecar` (schemaVersion 3, source `"flow-agents/workflow-sidecar;statusFunctionVersion=1"`):
-  ```json
-  {
-    "schemaVersion": 3,
-    "source": "flow-agents/workflow-sidecar;statusFunctionVersion=1",
-    "claims": [
-      {
-        "id": "<slug>-<checkId>.<surface>.<fieldOrBehavior>",
-        "subjectType": "workflow-check",
-        "subjectId": "<slug>/<checkId>",
-        "surface": "flow-agents.workflow",
-        "claimType": "workflow.check.test",
-        "fieldOrBehavior": "<check summary>",
-        "value": "pass|fail|skip",
-        "createdAt": "<ISO-8601>",
-        "updatedAt": "<ISO-8601>",
-        "status": "verified|disputed|assumed|proposed|rejected|stale|unknown"
-      }
-    ],
-    "evidence": [...],
-    "events": [...],
-    "policies": []
-  }
-  ```
-
-  The claim `status` field is the canonically derived status (computed by `@kontourai/surface.deriveClaimStatus`). Status values and their meaning for gate-review:
-
-  | `status` | Meaning |
-  | --- | --- |
-  | `verified` | Claim confirmed by matching evidence; a pass. |
-  | `disputed` | Claim contradicted by evidence; a genuine failure. |
-  | `assumed` | Claim accepted without direct evidence (e.g. `accepted_gap` criterion, `skip` check). |
-  | `proposed` | Claim written but not yet evaluated. |
-  | `rejected` | Claim explicitly rejected. |
-  | `stale` | Claim data is outdated; gate had stale input. |
-  | `unknown` | No event found; claim was never evaluated. |
-
-- `state.json` at `.kontourai/flow-agents/<slug>/state.json` (lifecycle context; not a trust input).
-- Optional: seeded fixture `trust.bundle` path for testing before Phase 1 produces real bundles.
-
-## Artifact Contract
-
-Write the following artifacts under `.kontourai/flow-agents/<slug>/`:
-
-### `<slug>--gate-review.md`
-
-Human-readable summary. Sections:
-
-- `## Session` — slug, state.json phase/status at review time, trust.bundle schemaVersion
-- `## Gate Fires` — one entry per classified InquiryRecord
-- `## Suspected Misses` — missed_block InquiryRecords; expected criteria absent from the bundle
-- `## Advisory Fixes` — proposed (NOT applied) fixes per InquiryRecord (from `answer.value.advisoryFix`)
-- `## NOT_VERIFIED Gaps` — any classification that could not be completed (e.g. trust.bundle absent, Surface unavailable)
-- `## Routed To` — `learning-review` invocation record
-
-### `gate-review.inquiries.json`
-
-Machine-readable array of canonical `InquiryRecord` objects validated against the hachure schema at `node_modules/hachure/schemas/inquiry-record.schema.json` (canonical `$id`: `https://kontourai.io/schemas/surface/inquiry-record.schema.json`).
-
-Required fields per schema: `id`, `inquiry`, `outcome`, `resolutionPath`, `inputSnapshot`, `statusFunctionVersion`, `resolvedAt`.
-
-The `outcome` field is the canonical Surface value: `"matched"` (claim found and resolved), `"derived"` (rule-based resolution), or `"unsupported"` (no matching claim — absent criterion).
-
-The `answer` field carries gate-review's value-add:
-- `answer.status` — canonical `TrustStatus` of the resolved claim (`"unknown"` when absent).
-- `answer.value` — gate-review advisory object:
-  ```json
-  {
-    "calibration": "correct | false_block | missed_block",
-    "advisoryFix": "<non-empty advisory string>",
-    "gateFired": true,
-    "sessionSlug": "<slug>"
-  }
-  ```
-
-The `calibration` field in `answer.value` is derived from `(outcome, answer.status, blockSignal.blocked)`:
-- `"matched"` + `"disputed"|"rejected"` + `blocked=true` → `"correct"`
-- `"matched"` + `"verified"|"assumed"` + `blocked=true` → `"false_block"`
-- `"matched"` + `"stale"|"unknown"|"proposed"` + `blocked=false` → `"missed_block"`
-- `"unsupported"` (absent claim) → `"missed_block"`
-
-The `advisoryFix` in `answer.value` must be non-empty for every record. No record may have `auto_applied: true` or instruct automatic changes.
-
-Example record:
-```json
-{
-  "id": "my-session-gr-1",
-  "inquiry": {
-    "id": "my-session-gr-1",
-    "question": "Was gate action on claim my-session/unit-tests... (status: verified) justified?",
-    "askedBy": "gate-review",
-    "askedAt": "2026-06-24T00:00:00Z",
-    "target": { "subjectType": "workflow-check", "subjectId": "my-session/unit-tests", "fieldOrBehavior": "unit tests pass" }
-  },
-  "outcome": "matched",
-  "resolutionPath": { "claimIds": ["my-session/unit-tests.flow-agents.workflow.unit tests pass"] },
-  "answer": {
-    "status": "verified",
-    "value": {
-      "calibration": "false_block",
-      "advisoryFix": "Investigate why the gate blocked when claim ... has status verified ...",
-      "gateFired": true,
-      "sessionSlug": "my-session"
-    }
-  },
-  "inputSnapshot": [{ "claimId": "my-session/unit-tests.flow-agents.workflow.unit tests pass", "status": "verified" }],
-  "statusFunctionVersion": "1",
-  "resolvedAt": "2026-06-24T00:00:00Z"
-}
-```
-
-Invariants:
-- Every record must have a non-empty `answer.value.advisoryFix`.
-- No record may have `auto_applied: true`.
-- `answer.value.calibration` must be one of `"correct"`, `"false_block"`, or `"missed_block"`.
-
-After writing `gate-review.inquiries.json`, invoke `learning-review` passing the inquiries artifact path as an additional reviewer-notes input. Learning-review writes `learning.json` via `npm run workflow:sidecar -- record-learning`. Do NOT call `record-learning` from gate-review directly.
-
-## Bundle-Claim to InquiryRecord Mapping
-
-| Bundle claim condition | outcome | calibration | Rationale |
-| --- | --- | --- | --- |
-| Gate blocked AND claim has `status: "disputed"` or `"rejected"` | `matched` | `correct` | Gate saw a genuine failure; block was warranted. |
-| Gate blocked AND claim has `status: "verified"` or `"assumed"` | `matched` | `false_block` | Gate blocked despite passing claims — acted on stale or incorrect data. |
-| An expected claim is absent from the bundle entirely | `unsupported` | `missed_block` | Gate had no claim to evaluate. |
-| A claim has `status: "stale"` and the gate did NOT block | `matched` | `missed_block` | Stale claim was present but gate did not fire on it. |
-| A claim has `status: "unknown"` with no evidence trace | `matched` | `missed_block` | Claim was never evaluated; gate had no resolved evidence. |
-
-Cross-reference with `state.json` phase at the time of the block to confirm the block was in an active workflow phase (not planning or archived).
-
-## Workflow
+Require an existing session directory with a `trust.bundle`; read `state.json`
+only for lifecycle context. Use `flow-agents workflow status --session-dir
+<session-dir>` to confirm the public run identity and current state when a run
+is active.
+
+The extension may also use expected criteria from the selected Work Item and
+its adapters:
+
+- **Work Item adapter:** acceptance criteria and expected workflow outcomes.
+- **Repository adapter:** local policy and source context.
+- **Change adapter:** review, verification, or release state associated with
+  the suspected block.
+
+These adapters are provider-neutral. A GitHub issue or pull request is an
+optional labeled example, not a required source of truth.
+
+## Extension Behavior
 
-### Step 1 — Locate trust.bundle
+This extension is observational: it may inspect a `builder.build` session but
+does not select, start, resume, advance, pause, release, or cancel its flow.
+It classifies existing information and returns advisory output for a human to
+route through normal planning, delivery, or learning work.
 
-Resolve `.kontourai/flow-agents/<slug>/trust.bundle`. The slug is the most recent active session (by `current.json` or `state.json` newest-mtime). If absent, surface the blocker:
+## Classification Method
 
-```
-[gate-review] trust.bundle absent — NOT_VERIFIED. Build ADR 0010 Phase 1 first.
-```
+Use `@kontourai/surface`'s `resolveInquiry(bundle, inquiry)` to produce
+canonical `InquiryRecord` objects. Do not invent a bespoke substitute when the
+Surface dependency is unavailable.
 
-Stop and surface the blocker to the user.
+For each observed gate fire and each expected-but-absent criterion, classify:
 
-### Step 2 — Load Surface and resolve inquiries
+| Condition | Calibration |
+| --- | --- |
+| A blocked claim is `disputed` or `rejected` | `correct` |
+| A blocked claim is `verified` or `assumed` | `false_block` |
+| An expected claim is absent, stale, unknown, or unresolved without a block | `missed_block` |
 
-Run `npm run workflow:sidecar -- gate-review <dir>`.
-
-The sidecar writer:
-1. Loads `@kontourai/surface` (ESM, fail-open dynamic import).
-2. For each claim in the bundle: builds a `SurfaceInquiry` with a canonical `target` and calls `resolveInquiry(bundle, inquiry)`.
-3. For each absent expected criterion (from `acceptance.json`): builds a `SurfaceInquiry` targeting the missing claim; `resolveInquiry` returns `"unsupported"`.
-4. Derives `calibration` from `(outcome, answer.status, blockSignal.blocked)` using `deriveGateCalibration`.
-5. Composes advisory `advisoryFix` string using `gateAdvisoryFix`.
-6. Sets `answer.value = { calibration, advisoryFix, gateFired, sessionSlug }`.
-7. Strips Surface-internal fields (`identityLinkIds`, `transitiveRuleIds`) to conform to the hachure schema.
-8. Validates each record against `inquiry-record.schema.json` (fail-open).
-9. Writes `gate-review.inquiries.json`.
-
-### Step 3 — Classify each InquiryRecord
-
-Apply the InquiryRecord calibration mapping:
-
-**`correct`** — `outcome: "matched"`, claim `status: "disputed"` or `"rejected"`, `blocked=true`:
-> Gate saw a genuine failure. Block was warranted. Advisory fix: close the gap and re-run.
-
-**`false_block`** — `outcome: "matched"`, claim `status: "verified"` or `"assumed"`, `blocked=true`:
-> Gate blocked despite passing claims. Advisory fix: investigate the block trigger; add freshness check.
-
-**`missed_block`** — `outcome: "unsupported"` (absent) OR `status: "stale"|"unknown"|"proposed"`, `blocked=false`:
-> Gate had no claim to evaluate or claim was unresolved. Advisory fix: ensure record-evidence writes the claim.
-
-### Step 4 — Write human-readable summary
-
-Write `<slug>--gate-review.md` with sections for Session, Gate Fires, Suspected Misses, Advisory Fixes, NOT_VERIFIED Gaps, and Routed To.
-
-Optionally use `buildTrustReport(bundle)` + `formatTrustReportSummary(report)` from `@kontourai/surface` for the trust-state summary section.
-
-### Step 5 — Invoke learning-review
-
-Pass the `gate-review.inquiries.json` path as additional reviewer notes to `learning-review`. Do not call `record-learning` directly. Learning-review owns the `learning.json` write and correction routing.
+Every record must include a non-empty, advisory-only recommendation. Never
+auto-apply or direct an automatic change. Preserve `InquiryRecord` schema
+requirements, including identity, inquiry, outcome, resolution path, input
+snapshot, status-function version, and resolution time.
 
-Example invocation note:
-```
-gate-review InquiryRecords at .kontourai/flow-agents/<slug>/gate-review.inquiries.json:
-- <N> record(s): calibration counts
-- gate fired: <true/false>
-- calibration: correct=<n>, false_block=<n>, missed_block=<n>
-Use these as reviewer notes for the learning-review correction record.
-```
+## Output Responsibility
 
-## Gates
+Produce these advisory artifacts in the existing session directory:
 
-- **Advisory gate**: every InquiryRecord must have a non-empty `answer.value.advisoryFix`. Gate-review must not complete without one per record.
-- **No-auto-apply gate**: no record's advisory fix may instruct auto-application of any fix. Any proposed fix that starts with "Apply" or "Change" must be rephrased as "Propose" or "Investigate".
-- **Phase-1 dependency gate**: if `trust.bundle` is absent, surface the blocker to the user rather than degrading silently to bespoke sidecars.
-- **Surface gate**: if `@kontourai/surface` is unavailable, log and skip (no fork fallback).
+- `<slug>--gate-review.md`: session context, gate fires, suspected misses,
+  advisory recommendations, and unresolved gaps.
+- `gate-review.inquiries.json`: canonical `InquiryRecord` array.
 
-## NOT_VERIFIED Gaps
+Pass those outputs to `learning-review` as reviewer notes when learning review
+is requested. Do not write learning output, modify flow definitions, or attach
+step evidence on behalf of another primitive.
 
-| Gap | Description | Resolution trigger |
-| --- | --- | --- |
-| NV1 | trust.bundle absent at `origin/main @ a9b8fd6` — ADR 0010 Phase 1 not yet built | Phase 1 merged to main by `arch/goal-fit-gate-trust-bundle` owner |
-| NV2 | AC1 seeded-session test fixture cannot be validated against real bundle shape | Phase 1 lands; coordinate with Phase 1 owner on exact bundle file path and claim array shape |
-| NV3 | AC2 false_block / missed_block fixture depends on exact Phase 1 bundle structure | Same as NV2 |
+## Standalone and No-Active-Run Behavior
 
-AC1 and AC2 are `not_verified` pending ADR 0010 Phase 1. The classification logic is spec-complete against the real bundle shape (confirmed by `workflow-sidecar ensure-session` + `record-evidence` probe). Re-run seeded-session tests after Phase 1 lands.
+This extension may analyze a completed session without an active run. If there
+is no active run but the session and trust bundle exist, perform the advisory
+review without creating or resuming a workflow. If the session or trust bundle
+is absent, report `NOT_VERIFIED` and produce no new session, evidence, or
+workflow run.