@jphutchins/code-review 0.1.0-alpha.55 → 0.1.0-alpha.57

package/package.json

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 {
   "name": "@jphutchins/code-review",
-  "version": "0.1.0-alpha.55",
+  "version": "0.1.0-alpha.57",
   "description": "Deterministic commenter for agentic PR review — gather, render, inline, post, adapt, extract, cost, validate, print-schema",
   "type": "module",
   "license": "MIT",

package/templates/comment.eta

@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@
 <%~ it.findingsPointer %>
 <% } -%>
 
-### <%= it.verdictBadge(it.findings.verdict) %>
+## <%= it.verdictBadge(it.findings.verdict) %>
 
 <% const meta = [] %><% if (it.postedAt) { meta.push('**Reviewed** `' + it.reviewedSha.slice(0, 7) + '` at ' + it.postedAt) } %><% if (it.route) { meta.push('**route:** ' + it.route) } %><% if (it.effort) { meta.push('**effort:** ' + it.effort) } %><% if (it.hasUsage) { meta.push('**turns:** ' + it.envelope.turns); meta.push('**wall:** ' + it.formatDuration(it.envelope.duration_ms)); meta.push('**models:** ' + it.modelNames); meta.push('**cost:** ' + it.formatCost(it.costReport.totalCostUSD)) } else { meta.push('_usage unavailable_') } %><sub><%~ meta.join(' · ') %></sub>
 <% if (!it.incomplete) { -%>
@@ -45,15 +45,22 @@
 
 <% if (!it.incomplete && it.systemic.length > 0) { -%>
 
-### 🔗 Systemic problems
+## 🔗 Systemic problems
 
 <% it.systemic.forEach(function(s) { -%>
-#### <%= it.severityEmoji(s.severity) %> (<%= s.severity %>) <%= s.title %><% if (s.id) { %> (<% if (s.code_url) { %>[`<%= s.id %>`](<%~ s.code_url %>)<% } else { %>`<%= s.id %>`<% } %>)<% } %> · confidence <%= it.formatConfidence(s.confidence) %>
+### <%= it.severityEmoji(s.severity) %> (<%= s.severity %>) <%= s.title %>
+<sub>confidence <%= it.formatConfidence(s.confidence) %><% if (s.id) { %> · id <% if (s.code_url) { %>[`<%~ s.id %>`](<%~ s.code_url %>)<% } else { %>`<%~ s.id %>`<% } %><% } %></sub>
 <% const meta = [] %><% if (s.paths && s.paths.length > 0) { meta.push('Affects: ' + s.paths.map(function(p) { return '`' + p + '`' }).join(', ')) } %><% if (s.finding_ids && s.finding_ids.length > 0) { meta.push('Ties together: ' + s.finding_ids.map(function(c) { return '`' + c + '`' }).join(', ')) } %><% if (meta.length > 0) { %>_<%~ meta.join(' · ') %>_<% } %>
 
 <%~ s.description %>
+<% if (s.discussionHtml) { -%>
+
+<details><summary>💬 Discussion</summary>
+
+<%~ s.discussionHtml %>
+</details>
+<% } -%>
 
-> [!TIP]
 > <details><summary>Reasoning</summary>
 >
 <% s.reasoning.split("\n").forEach(function(rl) { -%>
@@ -71,7 +78,8 @@
 > [!WARNING]
 > **Unverified — no failing-job logs were available.** This route reads the failing CI job's log to
 > name the failure; none could be staged for this run, so every finding below was reasoned from the
-> diff alone. Treat them as hypotheses until the log is checked.
+> diff or from local reproduction of the checks. Treat them as hypotheses until the failing log is
+> checked.
 
 <% } %>
 
@@ -93,7 +101,7 @@
 <% } %>
 
 <% if (it.strays.length > 0) { %>
-### <% if (it.inlineDisposition && (it.inlineDisposition.kind === 'disabled' || it.inlineDisposition.kind === 'whole-document')) { %>Findings<% } else if (it.inlineDisposition && it.inlineDisposition.kind === 'no-envelope') { %>Findings (no inline review — result envelope lost)<% } else { %><%= (it.unanchoredCount && it.unanchoredCount > 0) ? 'Findings' : 'Findings outside the diff' %><% } %>
+## <% if (it.inlineDisposition && (it.inlineDisposition.kind === 'disabled' || it.inlineDisposition.kind === 'whole-document')) { %>Findings<% } else if (it.inlineDisposition && it.inlineDisposition.kind === 'no-envelope') { %>Findings (no inline review — result envelope lost)<% } else { %><%= (it.unanchoredCount && it.unanchoredCount > 0) ? 'Findings' : 'Findings outside the diff' %><% } %>
 <% if (it.inlineDisposition && it.inlineDisposition.kind === 'no-envelope') { %>
 _Every finding is listed below — the inline review could not be built because the result envelope was missing._
 <% } else if (it.inlineDisposition && it.inlineDisposition.kind === 'whole-document') { %>
@@ -103,7 +111,8 @@ _<%= it.unanchoredCount %> finding<%= it.unanchoredCount === 1 ? '' : 's' %> bel
 <% } %>
 
 <% it.strays.forEach(function(f) { -%>
-#### <%= it.severityEmoji(f.severity) %> (<%= f.severity %>) `<%= f.path %>:<%= f.rangeLabel %><% if (f.side) { %> (<%= f.side %>)<% } %>` — <%= f.title %><% if (f.id) { %> (<% if (f.code_url) { %>[`<%= f.id %>`](<%~ f.code_url %>)<% } else { %>`<%= f.id %>`<% } %>)<% } %> · confidence <%= it.formatConfidence(f.confidence) %> · likelihood <%= it.formatConfidence(f.likelihood) %>
+### <%= it.severityEmoji(f.severity) %> (<%= f.severity %>) `<%= f.path %>:<%= f.rangeLabel %><% if (f.side) { %> (<%= f.side %>)<% } %>` — <%= f.title %>
+<sub>confidence <%= it.formatConfidence(f.confidence) %> · likelihood <%= it.formatConfidence(f.likelihood) %><% if (f.id) { %> · id <% if (f.code_url) { %>[`<%~ f.id %>`](<%~ f.code_url %>)<% } else { %>`<%~ f.id %>`<% } %><% } %></sub>
 <% if (f.permalink) { -%>
 
 <%~ f.permalink %><% if (f.permalinkAnchored) { %> · _agent-reported location_<% } %>
@@ -133,9 +142,15 @@ _<%= it.unanchoredCount %> finding<%= it.unanchoredCount === 1 ? '' : 's' %> bel
 <%~ f.patchProjection.raw %>
 ```
 <% } -%>
+<% if (f.discussionHtml) { -%>
+
+<details><summary>💬 Discussion</summary>
+
+<%~ f.discussionHtml %>
+</details>
+<% } -%>
 
-> [!TIP]
-> <details><summary>Reasoning (<%= it.formatConfidence(f.confidence) %> confidence · <%= it.formatConfidence(f.likelihood) %> likelihood)</summary>
+> <details><summary>Reasoning</summary>
 >
 <% f.reasoning.split("\n").forEach(function(rl) { -%>
 > <%= rl %>
@@ -145,12 +160,33 @@ _<%= it.unanchoredCount %> finding<%= it.unanchoredCount === 1 ? '' : 's' %> bel
 <% }) %>
 <% } %>
 
+<% if (it.discussionDropped > 0) { %>
+_<%= it.discussionDropped %> discussion thread<%= it.discussionDropped === 1 ? '' : 's' %> not listed<% if ((it.discussionDroppedIds && it.discussionDroppedIds.length > 0) || (it.discussionDroppedSystemicIds && it.discussionDroppedSystemicIds.length > 0) || (it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds && it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds.length > 0)) { %> (<% if (it.discussionDroppedIds && it.discussionDroppedIds.length > 0) { %>finding<%= it.discussionDroppedIds.length === 1 ? '' : 's' %> <% it.discussionDroppedIds.forEach(function(id) { %>`<%~ id %>` <% }) %><% if ((it.discussionDroppedSystemicIds && it.discussionDroppedSystemicIds.length > 0) || (it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds && it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds.length > 0)) { %>· <% } %><% } %><% if (it.discussionDroppedSystemicIds && it.discussionDroppedSystemicIds.length > 0) { %>systemic<%= it.discussionDroppedSystemicIds.length === 1 ? '' : 's' %> <% it.discussionDroppedSystemicIds.forEach(function(id) { %>`<%~ id %>` <% }) %><% if (it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds && it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds.length > 0) { %>· <% } %><% } %><% if (it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds && it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds.length > 0) { %>earlier-round<% if (it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds.length > 1) { %> (×<%= it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds.length %>)<% } %> <% it.discussionDroppedOrphanedIds.forEach(function(id) { %>`<%~ id %>` <% }) %><% } %>)<% } %><% if (it.discussionDroppedExtra > 0) { %> +<%= it.discussionDroppedExtra %> more<% } %> — the links live on the comment thread._
+<% } %>
+
+<% if ((it.orphanedLines && it.orphanedLines.length > 0) || it.orphanedUnresolvable) { %>
+## 💬 Discussions on findings from earlier rounds
+
+<% if (it.orphanedUnresolvable && (!it.orphanedLines || it.orphanedLines.length === 0)) { %>
+_Comments naming tokens outside this round's report could not be matched against the prior findings — the prior findings artifact could not be resolved, so whether they name departed findings is unknown._
+<% } else { %>
+<details><summary>Comments naming findings this round no longer reports (fixed or re-id'd) — the conversation stays discoverable.<% if (it.orphanedTotal > it.orphanedLines.length) { %> (showing <%= it.orphanedLines.length %> of <%= it.orphanedTotal %>)<% } %></summary>
+
+<% it.orphanedLines.forEach(function(line) { -%>
+<%~ line %>
+<% }) -%>
+
+</details>
+<% } %>
+<% } %>
+
 <% if (it.suppressedNits && it.suppressedNits.length > 0) { %>
 > [!NOTE]
 > <details><summary>🔇 <%= it.suppressedNits.length %> nit<%= it.suppressedNits.length === 1 ? '' : 's' %> below the visibility floor (confidence × likelihood < <%= it.nitVisibilityFloor %>) — hidden</summary>
 >
 <% it.suppressedNits.forEach(function(n) { -%>
-> - `<%= n.path %>:<%= n.startLine %>` — <%= n.title %><% if (n.id) { %> (<% if (n.codeUrl) { %>[`<%= n.id %>`](<%~ n.codeUrl %>)<% } else { %>`<%= n.id %>`<% } %>)<% } %> _(m = <%= n.m %>)_
+> - `<%= n.path %>:<%= n.startLine %>` — <%= n.title %><% if (n.id) { %> (<% if (n.codeUrl) { %>[`<%~ n.id %>`](<%~ n.codeUrl %>)<% } else { %>`<%~ n.id %>`<% } %>)<% } %> _(m = <%= n.m %>)_
+<% if (n.discussionHtml) { %><%~ n.discussionHtml %><% } %>
 > <%~ '<!-- code-review:suppressed-nit' %>
 > <%~ 'severity: ' + n.severity %>
 > <%~ 'location: ' + n.path + ':' + n.startLine + '-' + n.endLine + (n.side ? ' (' + n.side + ')' : '') %>